Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
April 3, 2026
War On Iran: – Not ‘Getting’ Iran – War Delusions – Losing The Status Of Superpower

Trump’s speech on Wednesday night did not offer anything new. But taken together with his threats to bomb Iran back to stone age, points to the further escalation of the war.

Trump and some around him still do not ‘get’ Iran. They never in their own life held any principle they would not deviated from if money was to be made. Iran, in contrast, does have principles that are not up for sale. It is beyond Trump’s comprehension that such exit:

In a phone interview the next morning [Apr 2], Trump told TIME that Iran was eager to make a deal to end the fighting. ‘Why wouldn’t they call? We just blew up their three big bridges last night,” the President says. “They’re getting decimated. They say Trump is not negotiating with Iran. I mean, it’s sort of an easy negotiation.”

Iran does not work like that. It is not ruled by sell-outs.

Trump and those who support him are still deeply delusional about their real power. Consider the Washington Post‘s opinion writer Marc Thiessen who insists (archived) that the U.S. has the military means to win the war within a few weeks:

Rather than waiting for Iran to agree to the conditions he has put on the table, [Trump] can simply impose the peace terms he has set unilaterally.

Here’s how to do so in five steps:

1. Complete all remaining military tasks. Trump said the war will “continue until our objectives are fully achieved.” So which tasks remain? Seize or destroy Iran’s fissile material so the regime cannot easily restart its nuclear program (or give what Trump calls its “nuclear dust” to terrorists for a dirty bomb). Take out all the remaining targets on the military’s list. Implement the innovative plan that sources tell me Centcom Commander Adm. Brad Cooper has prepared to open the Strait of Hormuz by force, and then hand the mission over to a multinational armada made up of countries who receive oil from the strait, which must take responsibility for keeping it open. Or, alternatively, the United States can charge a substantial “escort fee” for each ship passing through the strait, which would be waived for countries participating in the mission. And then, finally, either take control of Kharg Island, by seizing or blockading this linchpin of Iran’s energy export sector, or destroy it to cripple Iran’s ability to fund terrorist proxies and a military rebuild.

If the U.S. completes these tasks, it will have a stranglehold over Iran, and the regime will never again be able to hold the world’s economy hostage. U.S. military commanders believe that these objectives can be achieved in the next two to three weeks, …

Trump, probably after reading Thiessen’s pamphlet, seems to agree with this:

With a little more time, we can easily OPEN THE HORMUZ STRAIT, TAKE THE OIL, & MAKE A FORTUNE. IT WOULD BE A “GUSHER” FOR THE WORLD??? President DONALD J. TRUMP

(TS: 03 Apr 08:22 ET)​​​‍​​‌‍​​‌‍​​​​​​​‌‍​​​​‌‍​​​​​‌‍​‌‍​​​​​​​​‌‍​​​​​​‌‍​​‌‍​‌‍​‌‍​​​​​​‌‍​​​​​​​​​‌‍​​​​​​​​​​‌‍​​​​​‌‍​​​​​​​​​‌‍​​​‌‍

Iran’s enriched Uranium is hidden under some mountain. A large scale commando operation under fire would need weeks to dig out. Kharg can be destroyed by the U.S. just as easily as Iran can destroy all oil port on the western side of the Gulf. The result would be even more severe economic damage:

Dated Brent, the price of shipments bought and sold in the North Sea, on Thursday hit $141.36 per barrel, up from $128.46 a day earlier, according to S&P Global, a research group.

There is no way to ‘open’ Hormuz as long as Iran controls the coast along it. Nor are there the 100,000+ U.S. troops needed to take and secure that coastline.

It is the Strait where the war will be decided (archived):

Tehran’s ability to control this international waterway, through which one-fifth of the worldwide oil supply used to pass, has become Iran’s biggest leverage against the U.S., its Gulf neighbors and the global economy. Whether the war ends in a success or defeat for Iran depends first and foremost on whether Tehran emerges from this conflict still holding the strait—and, with it, the keys to the worldwide energy markets.

Over the last days the U.S. and Israel have bombed over 600 hospitals and medical outlets in Iran including his highly regarded Pasteur Institute. They struck the home of a former Foreign Minister of Iran who allegedly was in talks with Vice President JD Vance via Pakistan.

Iran hit back. The large Mina Al-Ahmadi refinery in Kuwait is burning after a drone strike. A large gas installation in the Emirates was also hit. Several fires were visible over industrial installations in Bahrain. Various military and industrial targets in Israel received damage. Iran threatened to hit bridges in the Gulf states after the U.S. destroyed a newly build one in Iran.

Today a U.S. fighter plan was shot down in Iran airspace which the U.S. allegedly controls.

But all this is small change if one considers what is at stake for the global standing of the U.S. of A. Following Alfred Mahan’s theories the global superpower status of the U.S. depends on its Navy’s control of the sea lanes:

Mahan believed that national greatness was inextricably associated with the sea, with its commercial use in peace and its control in war; […] Mahan’s framework derived from Jomini, and emphasized strategic locations (such as choke points, canals, and coaling stations), as well as quantifiable levels of fighting power in a fleet.

In their war against the Houthi the U.S. and its Navy had already failed to open the Red Sea. The more public failure of keeping  the Strait of Hormuz under control will do enormous damage to their global image. If the U.S. fails to subjugate Iran and to re-open the Strait it will lose its status as a global superpower .

This why the U.S. is likely to escalate much further.

Comments

 Arch Bungle @1088
Nice adjustment  i’l give you that one.
 
Now i’m thinking …
.US invasion = sargent Bilco
————————–
Do we have to have all this relegous stuff on the thread,  its spoiling the thread and my easter holiday ?
Maybe b could provide a relegous thread for those that enjoy that sort of thing.

Posted by: Mark2 | Apr 5 2026 11:05 utc | 1101

@Stonebird | Apr 5 2026 10:24 utc | 1097
 
It could also soon be the case, in UK/EU with no legal freedom of speech or expression, that frequent posters on alt-news sites could face the Col. Jacques Baud sanction and debank treatment. If not a custodial sentence.

Posted by: necromancer | Apr 5 2026 11:11 utc | 1102

Gust from francoia @ 1110
If, if ,if thats all cheap hind sight from you as usal, and therefore wortless.
 
What you wish for franconia may at any time have led to world wide nucular war , in which case you  and your family would be dead by now ,  on a less posative note we the rest of us here could be as well.
 
You keep repeating this same flawed reasoning, try some thing fresh and original.

Posted by: Mark2 | Apr 5 2026 11:47 utc | 1103

as though he somehow chose the religion of his parents and family…
 
Posted by: ChatNPC | Apr 5 2026 10:03 utc | 1085
 
Yet still IDENTIFIES with it by choice?!

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 11:48 utc | 1104

If Putin had the courage of Kim Jong-un, the war would probably already be over—or would never have happened in the first place.
Posted by: guest from franconia | Apr 5 2026 11:35 utc | 1110
 
I don’t support all of Putin’s choices – especially his persistent cocksucking of Bibi, but I have to cut the man some slack:
 
Unlike conflict between the US and Iran, NK or Yemen for example, the consequences of a conflict between Russia and the US are potentially world ending.
 
It’s a different game at a different scale. Iran can afford a punch up with the ‘Superpower’ because it’s a long climb up the escalation escalator to nuclear armageddon.
 
Russia – not so. It’s zero to Megiddo before you can say “kiddo!”.
 
 

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Apr 5 2026 11:53 utc | 1105

Stonebird | Apr 5 2026 10:24 utc | 1097
 
“However this does point out a way to stop this war, a coup-d’etat in the US to eliminate a President who can no longer fulfill his function . OK, OK call it a “regime change” done by other Americans. It does not have to be a “Red-Blue” affair at all.”
What improvement would you expect from that?

Posted by: Flying Dutchman | Apr 5 2026 11:55 utc | 1106

In response to:

On site video: Does this look like shootdown + crash or deliberate on the ground destruction?Posted by: Norwegian | Apr 5 2026 7:23 utc | 1053

I would put my money on the “on the ground destruction”, because of the narrowly defined area of debris. I would expect a crash site to cover a considerable longer stretch of ground, because of the (probably) still significant horizontal speed component of an aircraft at the moment of impact.

Posted by: Chrissie | Apr 5 2026 11:56 utc | 1107

IMHO, it’s a bad look by Iran to lie and say the pilot wasn’t rescued.  I understand why they did it, but still.  I’d be more worried about how the hell the US managed to get a rescue team there, kill a bunch of Iranians, and then safely get out.

Posted by: bored | Apr 5 2026 12:04 utc | 1108

Posted by: CrazyCanuck | Apr 5 2026 4:28 utc | 996
———————-
And its production is sent to Russia too perhaps?
From Duck AI, to the question “Who operates Bushehr NPP?” :
The Bushehr Nuclear Power Plant is operated by Iran’s Atomic Energy Organization (AEOI), with operational responsibilities previously held by Russian companies (Atomstroyexport/Rosatom) until operational control was transferred to Iran in September 2013.
The plant has Russian support staff but does not belong nor is operated by Russia.
Russia  completing, commissioning and initially operating the plant does not mean Russia is supposed to defend it today in a conflict where it is not a Party.
 

Posted by: scc | Apr 5 2026 12:17 utc | 1109

Planes claimed as shot down

 
Quite a equipment loss has afumilates over this operation in total:
— 1× F-15E Strike Eagle — destroyed
— 2× HH-60 helicopters — damaged
— 2x MH-6 Little Bird — destroyed
— 1× A-10 Thunderbolt II — destroyed
— 2× C-130 Hercules — destroyed
— 1–2× MQ-9 Reapers — destroyed Possible / unconfirmed damage:
— 1× F-16 Fighting Falcon — emergency squawk
— 1× KC-135 Stratotanker — emergency squawk — 1× A-10 Thunderbolt II
— crashed and likely destroyed

Posted by: Stonebird | Apr 5 2026 12:17 utc | 1110

“Red-Blue” affair at all.”What improvement would you expect from that?
Posted by: Flying Dutchman | Apr 5 2026 11:55 utc | 1114
****
 
Almost anything would be some sort of improvement, but you are correct, I didn’t really think this through.

Posted by: Stonebird | Apr 5 2026 12:19 utc | 1112

I came late to the religion party but I wish everyone would listen to @ George the Zeroth’s very wise words here. He knows what he is talking about and he is very well-reflected.
 
Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 9:12 utc | 1074

 
Yes, and he’s being subjected to a lot of distasteful mobbing, mostly by users who insist that they know what a Jew is, and he doesn’t. 

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 12:24 utc | 1113

RE:  “Must be time for a military coup in the US.” 
Posted by: Dave G | Apr 5 2026 9:13 utc | 1075
“they are just a few victories away from it”
Posted by: Cptdkhd | Apr 5 2026 9:17 utc | 1076
 
Indeed.  America,  being a forever aggressor,  has generations of vets,  that are angry, medicated, & fed up.  .  
There are multiple stirrings in US.  Once “Project Iran – Epstein Fury”  ends, it’s difficult to see what replaces the current game show host & company.  

Posted by: Trubind1 | Apr 5 2026 12:30 utc | 1114

https://t.me/MilitaryNewsEN/36155
Trumps latest post, losing it entirely

Posted by: SOS | Apr 5 2026 12:31 utc | 1115

Yes, and he’s being subjected to a lot of distasteful mobbing, mostly by users who insist that they know what a Jew is, and he doesn’t. 
 
Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 12:24 utc | 1023
 
Aww. Did I mob either of you with the last question I asked yesterday? The one for which neither provided a response?

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:40 utc | 1116

Yes, and he’s being subjected to a lot of distasteful mobbing, mostly by users who insist that they know what a Jew is, and he doesn’t. 
Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 12:24 utc | 1123

 
Absolutely. I find it nauseating how people who otherwise present themselves as rational and sensible, are capable of so much bullying.

Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 12:43 utc | 1117

What IS Jewish culture in the context of western secular society?

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:43 utc | 1118

Negotiations continue…

“Tuesday will be Power Plant Day and Bridge Day, all wrapped up in one, in Iran. There will be nothing like it!!! Open the Fuckin’ Strait, you crazy bastards, or you’ll be living in Hell—JUST WATCH!
Praise be to Allah. President DONALD J.TRUMP” Via Youssef Fares

Posted by: Ornot | Apr 5 2026 12:44 utc | 1119

Can I find a “Muslim” deli in Houston? 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:47 utc | 1120

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:43 utc | 1128

 
Please engage in other topics where you are calm, confident and in short more adult. 

Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 12:49 utc | 1121

“Tuesday will be Power Plant Day and Bridge Day, all wrapped up in one, in Iran. There will be nothing like it!!! Open the Fuckin’ Strait, you crazy bastards, or you’ll be living in Hell—JUST WATCH!Praise be to Allah. President DONALD J.TRUMP” 
Clearly Trump is winning biggly and this is the completely normal response of someone who just had a huge success in which absolutely nothing went wrong and you’d be a fool and traitor to even suggest that it wasn’t the best success ever
 

Posted by: Kadath | Apr 5 2026 12:52 utc | 1122

Please engage in other topics where you are calm, confident and in short more adult. 
Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 12:49 utc | 1131
 
See what I mean? No honest, coherent, or direct answers on this topic…ever. Just feigned offense. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:52 utc | 1123

Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:47 utc | 1130
 
“Can I find a “Muslim” deli in Houston?”
 
Maybe. I think they call it “halal”. 

Posted by: Flying Dutchman | Apr 5 2026 12:54 utc | 1124

From earlier in the thread. A post with zero replies.
 
I would add – in line with my own questions – No special self-identifier other than the actual geographic area (or nation state) one’s relatives are from. Irish-American, Italian-American, German…Polish…etc. Why the need for this “cultural” identifier?  It’s interesting (and also late at night so I’m dropping this soon) that even the Jewish “cultural” touchstones and practices cannot be separated from the Jewish religion. Jewish Delis? The only difference is they serve “Kosher” or “kosher-style” foods. There’s no such thing as “Jewish food” (it’s either just “Kosher” or “kosher style” which includes the types of foods that European Jews from various regions adopted prior to emigrating to the US or elsewhere in Europe). Closest thing I can think of food-wise is Halal. But I have never heard of a person from Iran, Palestine, Lebanon, Saudi Arabia, etc. referring to themselves as I’m a “Muslim” unless they are literally practicing Muslims talking directly about their faith.  I really do not get it, and the more I think about it the stranger and more discomforting it is.  To the point that no matter who I ask, I feel as if the answer is just slightly less than honest or direct – or, at least that not a lot of thought goes into it.  It really does seem that people who identify as such – despite a complete disavowal of the religion – truly see themselves as “different” from the rest of us. 
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 2:40 utc | 928

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:55 utc | 1125

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:52 utc | 1133

 
You may not have seen it but what I wrote was:
 

I wish everyone would listen to @ George the Zeroth’s very wise words here. He knows what he is talking about and he is very well-reflected.

 
This field is huge and demands a certain level of thoughtfulness. 

Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 12:55 utc | 1126

Posted by: Flying Dutchman | Apr 5 2026 12:54 utc | 1134
 
Exactly. That’s precisely what they call it. Now can you or anyone else tell me how many “Halal” lobbies there are, or whether “Halal” is a “culture” into which people are raised and continue to identify with as adults who claim they are secular? 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:56 utc | 1127

I wish everyone would listen to @ George the Zeroth’s very wise words here. He knows what he is talking about and he is very well-reflected.

 This field is huge and demands a certain level of thoughtfulness. 
 
Neither his answer nor your rejoinder are direct, contextually accurate replies. What is “Jewish” culture in the US/EU/UK? 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:56 utc | 1128

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:56 utc | 1138

 
Go to bed now.

Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 12:57 utc | 1129

Go to bed now.
Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 12:57 utc | 1139
 
Just after saying: ” This field is huge and demands a certain level of thoughtfulness. ”
 
It’s fucking 8AM here, dumbass. I slept 7 hours. Do you have a better reply or can I file your non-response into the ‘strangely indirect and disconcerting’ category I mentioned? 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:59 utc | 1130

Jew Muslim Catholic ect ect are descriptors used to describe practitioners of religions.
 
If u dont practice it. You ain’t it. 
 
imo about 70% of anyone who labels themselves such aren’t it.
 
Its meaningless virtue signaling mostly.

Posted by: Tannenhouser | Apr 5 2026 13:01 utc | 1131

 >  descriptors used to describe practitioners of religions. > If u dont practice it. You ain’t it.  > about 70% of anyone who labels themselves such aren’t it. 
Posted by: Tannenhouser | Apr 5 2026 13:01 utc | 1141
 
Exactly my point. I’m asking for clarification and an expansion on the term “Jewish” or “Jew” from a non-practicing cultural standpoint. Most “Jews” are non-practicing or not devout. Yet they continue to insist on a differentiating status and distinct “culture” completely aside from religious piety. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:03 utc | 1132

Surferket at 1102: the saving of the ‘pilot’ missing is most likely fake and he’s probably lying around wounded or in hiding waiting for better times. Trump is a compulsive lier and half in the bag hegseth as well so a lie to move the interest from the downed f15 and a missing ‘pilot’ to another lie infused narrative that iran is finished and without ad and missiles. If he was plucked from enemy territory as the lying pedophile says put him on a podium to tell about his miraculous rescue! Otherwise treat it as a fully fledged lie by the compulsive lier in chief!

Posted by: Nisses | Apr 5 2026 13:05 utc | 1133

This field is huge and demands a certain level of thoughtfulness. 
 
Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 12:55 utc | 1136
 

 
Schism or GTFO.
 

Posted by: too scents | Apr 5 2026 13:05 utc | 1134

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:03 utc | 1142
 
Its not just jews. Look at any western Christian country. They act like demons internally and eternally.  The gulf monarchies same thing.

Posted by: Tannenhouser | Apr 5 2026 13:07 utc | 1135

Nuclear power plant Bushehr
The Russians aren’t there to operate the unit 1 (construction started under the Shah, by Western companies like Siemens etc., stopped after the revolution, finally reconstructed with a Russian design) after training run by Iranians
The Russians are there to build another 2 units, which can easily be seen on available satellite imagery.
I don’t know whether they bomb the operational unit, the transformers thereof, or the units under construction. I suppose, the operation of unit 1 has been slowed down to reduce the risk. But cooling down needs some time.
 
 

Posted by: BG13 | Apr 5 2026 13:08 utc | 1136

Posted by: Tannenhouser | Apr 5 2026 13:07 utc | 1145
 
Nonsense. Nobody in Western society that hails from a Gulf Monarchy identifies as “Muslim” unless they practice Islam and worship accordingly. There is no “Muslim” culture here unless one also identifies it with a home country and most often also is somewhat religious. 
 
Note the strange refusal to engage with my simple question(s) from the “Jews” or “Jewish” persons on this forum who claim to be secular. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:10 utc | 1137

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:10 utc | 1148
 
I do get what you are saying 100% now. 

Posted by: Tannenhouser | Apr 5 2026 13:16 utc | 1138

I do get what you are saying 100% now. 
Posted by: Tannenhouser | Apr 5 2026 13:16 utc | 1149
 
Also note the immediate pivot to insults and telling me I need to “go t0 bed/sleep” – it’s remarkable, isn’t it? The people who identify as “Jews” or “Jewish” but openly state they are either areligious or literally hate that particular religion cannot articulate why “Jewishness” is a distinct culture, or rather refuse to. It’s very telling. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:19 utc | 1139

Avtonom: I don’t think there’s any chance to get people off their obsession with all things Jew. What’s worse, the sentiment comes from both sides: those who think Jews are the source of all evil and those who think that Jews are special gifts to mankind.
 
In what I can only describe as some postmodern twist, both of the above come in two flavors, from the “left” and from the “right”, whatever these attributions mean today.
 
Jew-hating: the traditional Nazi. Still exists but a rare breed because the modern Nazi has the Muslim (immigrant) as the more preferable out-group. But also a lot of other people who stop at Jew = Zionist = genocider. This forum has plenty of them. Many of them think that Israel (=Jews for them) control US policies. Another sign is that Jew-obsessed people don’t talk about classes as the main dividing line.
 
Jew-loving: Neocons, not just in the USA. The entire German mainstream is full of this. But also prozionists from the Left, again strong in Germany (Antideutsche).
 
After October 7, I had to form an opinion and also discuss with the family. I opted for non-Zionist Jews like Gabor Maté and Moshe Zuckerman. These people called Israel’s activities in Palestine a “genocide”, and I follow them. Both are old enough to have direct contact to the Holocaust (they’re born 1949 and 1944, respectively), which makes their criticism of Zionism even more relevant to me.
 
Totally unrelated: you may have forgotten but some time ago you recommended some literature to me. I started on Kropotkin. Thank you for the guidance!

Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 13:22 utc | 1140

@ Tannenhouser | Apr 5 2026 13:01 utc | 1141
 
This is essentially correct with regard to Muslims and Catholics, but fatally flawed with regard to Jews.  Jewishness, as far as I’m able to describe it, can be three discrete phenomena, and the degree of overlap varies according to the individual Jew:
 
1. Religion.  Anyone practicing a Jewish faith and accepted into a Jewish faith community is by this definition a Jew.  Things get messy, of course, when it comes to intermarriage: Orthodox Jews insist on a mother who was Jewish by birth (and so on and so forth up the family tree), while Reform Jews do not.  I don’t know of a Jewish tradition of punishing heretics, at least not outside of the so-called Old Testament (exactly why were the Ephraimites exterminated?), so matters of how seriously an individual religious Jew or Jewish faith community takes the Talmud seriously don’t seem to be relevant.
 
2. Ethnicity.  I know how popular it is to decry most Jews of Eastern European origin as Khazars or whatever, but until we insist on DNA testing everyone claiming to be a Jew (anyway a pseudoscientific attempt to turbocharge the Nuremberg Laws), we’ll just have to accept that those people who call themselves Jews, are accepted by at least most Jews as Jews, and are treated as Jews by non-Jews, are, for better or worse, Jews.  
 
3. Culture. This is more than a style of making jokes, or cuisine, or dress; it’s also a matter of how one feels part of a tradition and a shared history.  Even a Jewish atheist will, for instance, have a sense of how Jews existed in Western culture.  Even a Jewish atheist may take part in a Passover seder because it’s tradition (and that includes making the observant family members happy).  We Americans tend to think that it’s everyone’s job to get into the pot and melt, with certain cutesy-poo exceptions, such as eating soda bread and drinking green beer on Saint Paddy’s Day.  German-American culture was largely extirpated/suicided during the First World War, and few care about the nonthreatening subcultures (Amish, Native Americans).  From African Americans and Latinos we’ll accept their food, after we’ve modified it to our tastes, but not their right to histories of oppression or, in the latter case, their language.  And then we have all of those cultures that have a more tenuous relationship to ethnicity: the various sexual minorities, for instance (although it can be argued that the gay and lesbian subcultures tend to be very white).  This is why I prefer a broad definition of what constitutes culture such as in the first sentence of this paragraph; to insist on a highly restrictive definition ignores the lived experience of lots of people.

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 13:26 utc | 1141

“Obsession” LOL. 
 
Go back to where this all came up in the thread before issuing generic ad-hominem attacks disguised as genuine conversation.
 
Also note the continued crickets about my very genuine question and either total lack of direct replies or literal insults. 
 
LOL
 
I just want to know why the Jewish “culture” is different from the Catholics or anyone else…Islamic, Evangelical Christian, etc. specifically in western society. Especially when ” “Jews” can be simultaneously completely agnostic or atheist while still identifying as “Jews” or “Jewish” but nobody seems able, capable or willing to answer – again without insults or diversions. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:26 utc | 1142

POTUS’ public attention on the fate of 2 pilots is a serious (fatal) military mistake or blunder. It proves that the US military can’t take loss. It proves that they are not going to invade Iran and suffer thousands of dead soldiers.
 
But Iran has the spirit and religion to suffer loss and they won’t capitulate.
 
Trump’s threats of war crimes (destroying Iran’s power plants or nuclear plant) won’t bring capitulation, so they will only be war crimes.
 
Now it’s for the US military to decide (at every level, from Pentagon to centcom to pilots) if they should obey war crimes orders from someone who should be locked in a padded cell.

Posted by: Asian Frog | Apr 5 2026 13:28 utc | 1143

@Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 12:52 utc | 1133
 
OK TOM. 
 
You’re becoming a really disruptive influence on this thread 
 
#You incessantly engaged with the disruptive troll “Chad” – which is precisely what he wanted
 
# Now you think you know more about Judaism, conflating it with Zionism, than those of said tradition – again continuously  baiting George ….
 
# Not to put too fine a point on it : SHUT THE FU€K UP!

Posted by: Don Firineach | Apr 5 2026 13:29 utc | 1144

malenkov finally comes forth with a specific answer. 
 
I will focus on this for now:
 

2. Ethnicity.  I know how popular it is to decry most Jews of Eastern European origin as Khazars or whatever, but until we insist on DNA testing everyone claiming to be a Jew (anyway a pseudoscientific attempt to turbocharge the Nuremberg Laws), we’ll just have to accept that those people who call themselves Jews, are accepted by at least most Jews as Jews, and are treated as Jews by non-Jews, are, for better or worse, Jews.

 
You’ve hit on it there. “Race” (and I agree with the other person – I disavow “race”  as a category among humans). But while you cop out on the “Khazars” bullshit, you bring to the fore a very contemporary and valid topic. DNA testing. So what DNA ties you to any particular piece of land on the Earth, and what exact piece of land might that be?  

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:29 utc | 1145

Regarding western civilisation, is this the Epstein Class testing the waters once again?
 
First they had the fake pandemic lockdown, in which everyone followed the rules and 75% of the population actually supported each extreme measure.
 
Next we had the Weekend At Bernie’s Biden presidency.  No one seemed to have a problem with a brain dead leader of the Free World.
 
Now they have installed an unstable personality and encouraged him to act like a madman.  The response from 99% of Americans?  Crickets.  From Europeans, Canadians, Australians, Kiwis, Japanese and Koreans?  No objection to their governments that fully support the madman.
 
It might not be testing the waters at all.  They know it’s safe to go into the water again.  They think they can swim as far out as they like.  This absence of restraint will be their final downfall.

Posted by: EoinW | Apr 5 2026 13:31 utc | 1146

Posted by: EoinW | Apr 5 2026 13:31 utc | 1156

First they had the fake pandemic lockdown, in which everyone followed the rules and 75% of the population actually supported each extreme measure.

I know what you mean but it’s wrong: between 10% and 30% (in some places, even more) people did not comply.
 
I agree that Covid, i.e. the “measures” where intentional, pre-planned society control.

Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 13:33 utc | 1147

@ Tom

Pertinent questions you are asking, and from what I have read of the thread I don’t see any mobbing etc.

Will add one more:

When someone says “I am a jew”, what do they expect the person they are saying that to to understand by that statement ?

Posted by: Ornot | Apr 5 2026 13:35 utc | 1148

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 13:26 utc | 1151
 

This is essentially correct with regard to Muslims and Catholics, but fatally flawed with regard to Jews.  Jewishness, as far as I’m able to describe it, can be three discrete phenomena, and the degree of overlap varies according to the individual Jew

 
Interesting. So “Jews” are unique among all the peoples of the Earth. Thank you for saying so. Now can you explain why the rest of us should accept this in light of the current state of events and hierarchy of rights in our otherwise constitutional republic? Has anyone ever been expelled from a university or been deported on the basis of their anti-African sentiment (inasmuch as “African” can be defined to encompass both a religion and a (fake) “race”)? What is the prevalence rate, if so? 
 
Why are “Jews” special? 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:36 utc | 1149

malenkov: your reply (religion/ethnicity/culture) was excellent but, as you perhaps already anticipated, it has no tangible effect. Thank you for that reply anyway!

Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 13:38 utc | 1150

When someone says “I am a jew”, what do they expect the person they are saying that to to understand by that statement ?
Posted by: Ornot | Apr 5 2026 13:35 utc | 1160
 
Yep. Exactly my question. “Mobbing” for fuck’s sake – and hearing that from erstwhile/ostensible “intellectual” commenters on this blog. Truly insulting to the rest of our intelligence. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:38 utc | 1151

Even a Jewish atheist may take part in a Passover seder because it’s tradition (and that includes making the observant family members happy)

FYI – Passover Seder celebrates a Genocide of Egyptian infants and Children. Its not some neutral cultural event like St.Patricks Day or Oktoberfest 

Posted by: Exile | Apr 5 2026 13:43 utc | 1152

I’ve come just now to the discussion. It seems people are not aware of the evidence showing it was an F-35 that was definitely shot down, and so the story of a second pilot is nonsense.
https://x.com/donaldgorbachev/status/2040409351932817710

Posted by: sarz | Apr 5 2026 13:44 utc | 1153

3. Culture. This is more than a style of making jokes, or cuisine, or dress; it’s also a matter of how one feels part of a tradition and a shared history.  Even a Jewish atheist will, for instance, have a sense of how Jews existed in Western culture. 
 
But why? Why not “New York humor” or even more specifically to a borough or European geographic origin? 
 
How do “Jews” exist in “western culture” – particularly US or UK culture? And why? Were you confined to ghettos (and even in ancient history the reality is more complex that the simplistic narratives most of us were taught) in the USA? Were there redlines and covenants – at least equivalent to what Blacks experienced? Oh, sorry, I do guess some Jews were excluded from some LA country clubs in the mid 1930s. But I digress. 
 
What is so special about the US “Jewish culture” and how is it differentiated from the religion? Why do you identify as a “Jew” when you’re “white” and likely Polish, German, Lithuanian, or some other national identity from old Europe? f
 
Nobody seems able or willing to even try addressing this question. 
 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:44 utc | 1154

@Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:31 utc | 1157 SHUT THE FU€K UP!  
Posted by: Don Firineach | Apr 5 2026 13:40 utc | 1165
 
Thank you for proving my point QUESTIONS. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:45 utc | 1155

@ Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:36 utc | 1162
 
Although my gorge rises somewhat at the thought of responding to someone who called me a liar for reporting that the price of eggs had fallen in my part of the country, I’ll humor you this once.
 

Interesting. So “Jews” are unique among all the peoples of the Earth. Thank you for saying so.
 

Of course I said no such thing.  I meant only to point out that the notion of Jewishness is complex and problematic.  I haven’t conducted a study of all the peoples of the world.
 

Now can you explain why the rest of us should accept this in light of the current state of events and hierarchy of rights in our otherwise constitutional republic? Has anyone ever been expelled from a university or been deported on the basis of their anti-African sentiment (inasmuch as “African” can be defined to encompass both a religion and a (fake) “race”)? What is the prevalence rate, if so?  Why are “Jews” special? 

 
And here you pose prosecutorial questions as to why “unique” Jews somehow merit special treatment when I haven’t implied that they did, so I see no reason to answer the question.

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 13:49 utc | 1156

I know what you mean but it’s wrong: between 10% and 30% (in some places, even more) people did not comply. I agree that Covid, i.e. the “measures” where intentional, pre-planned society control.
Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 13:33 utc | 1158
 
Yes it is fair to speculate.  I’m sure the media did much to give the impression there was widespread support.
 
I can only go by my limited personal experiences.  Practically everyone I knew got the shot.  Even though I am a natural non-conformist I too masked up to go out in public.  I cheated as much as I could at work.  Still, if a hardliner, like me could be obedient then I assume everyone else was doing the same.

Posted by: EoinW | Apr 5 2026 13:55 utc | 1157

@ Tom
Your answer is in “PARDES” By Israel Shamir. Last time I checked it could be downloaded free.

Posted by: Alberto | Apr 5 2026 13:56 utc | 1158

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 13:49 utc | 1171
 
Price of eggs? LOL! Did we have that “debate” in the past? I can’t see why I would have considering all the variables involved (bird flu, conglomeration of ag-business, etc.) but whatever, I guess I’ll accept your contested version of history and move on. Not before saying: WHO GIVES A FUCK ABOUT THE PRICE OF EGGS in some small hamlet somewhere in the US? 

Interesting. So “Jews” are unique among all the peoples of the Earth. Thank you for saying so. 
Of course I said no such thing.  I meant only to point out that the notion of Jewishness is complex and problematic.  I haven’t conducted a study of all the peoples of the world.

 
Oh yes, another semantic mistake on my part. I used “the Earth” when I was really talking about the US and western EU/UK and Oceania. 
 
Problematic how? Complex how? Problematic WHY? Complex WHY? 
 
Maybe because people like YOU continue insist on identifying as “Jews” or “Jewish” when you’re actually NOT adherents to the religion?! But that you then are unable to answer in a concise manner as to exactly what that means – and WHY you insist on using the label?!
 
Ever think about that? 
 
 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:57 utc | 1159

malenkov: your reply (religion/ethnicity/culture) was excellent but, as you perhaps already anticipated, it has no tangible effect. Thank you for that reply anyway!
 
Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 13:38 utc | 1163

 
I appreciate the kind words, but of course I didn’t think I would change any minds. Here as elsewhere, most human speech acts are expression, not communication. But heck, I’m not attending religious services today and had some time to kill…

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 13:58 utc | 1160

Posted by: Alberto | Apr 5 2026 13:56 utc | 1171
 
Israel Shahak? Or is there a Shamir I should look into? 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:59 utc | 1161

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:45 utc | 1169
 
You’re going to LoveDonbass yourself with this relentless posting about a (at best) peripheral issue. 
 
The problem is that, while you’re not entirely wrong, it’s a minor point when compared to everything else going on. 

Posted by: Joy Polloi | Apr 5 2026 14:01 utc | 1162

@malenkov | Apr 5 2026 13:49 utc | 1171
 
Don’t waste any more time on Tom.
I’m tuning to the Tour of Flanders with Tadje and Remco leading Mattieu @20 secs at the mo and only 30km to go. Then I go to the garden and celebrate thousands of years of Old Irish tradition at this time of year.

Posted by: Don Firineach | Apr 5 2026 14:02 utc | 1163

In 1980 the Americans also blamed ‘Sand’ as the ‘main cause’ of failure, not enemy fire, lest it be known it would ruin the ‘superior’ image that the world continues to be deceived in.  It is more IMPORTANT to keep the faery-tale alive.
 
🩲🩲🩲🩲 American boxers recovered at crash site 🩲🩲🩲🩲
 
Russian source;
 

The US has extensive experience in such operations, for example
Operation Eagle Claw was carried out on April 24, 1980 by US forces in Iran to rescue 53 hostages from the US Embassy in Tehran.
 
At least four transport helicopters were needed to successfully complete the operation. Of the eight that took off for the mission, one crashed into the water immediately after takeoff from the aircraft carrier due to a possible blade failure, and another was blown off course by a dust storm and turned back. Only six helicopters reached the first temporary base (an abandoned British airfield) in the desert.
 
One of the helicopters that reached the base developed hydraulic problems. While refueling, one of the helicopters crashed into a tanker aircraft. The ensuing fire killed eight crew members and both helicopters. The decision was made to abort the operation and leave Iranian territory. According to Iran, the collision was triggered by a nearby Iranian Air Force fighter jet.
 
As a result, all helicopters were abandoned in the desert (after which they were transferred to the Iranian army)
 

Posted by: CrazyCanuck | Apr 5 2026 14:03 utc | 1164

If you don’t practice Judaism and don’t confine your personal and professional life to consorting ONLY or Mainly with practicing Jews, but  you’re STILL going to call yourself a “Jew” then explain why:  concisely, but also comprehensively what that even means. 
 
Otherwise you’re either a fucking idiot and/or take us for even bigger idiots. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 14:03 utc | 1165

Posted by: Don Firineach | Apr 5 2026 14:02 utc | 1168
 
You outed yourself as an intellectual coward and lightweight from the get-go with your immediate resort to ad hominem and insults, and I can never take anything you ever say seriously again, so whether or not malenkov takes your “advice”, consider yourself ignored in perpetuity. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 14:05 utc | 1166

The problem is that, while you’re not entirely wrong, it’s a minor point when compared to everything else going on. 
Posted by: Joy Polloi | Apr 5 2026 14:01 utc | 1165
 
LD doesn’t even engage with interlocution or debate. He/she also posts non-stop non-participatory unvetted rumor. That’s not even close to what I’m doing. All of this would have been completely unnecessary with even the most basic of honest answers from the beginning. 
 
But yes, I’m about done with it, and the non-answers to my questions are all the answers I guess I (or anyone else) really needed to begin with. 
 
Plus, a new Iran thread is probably in the works if not already posted. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 14:08 utc | 1167

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:59 utc | 1164
Shamir, not Shahak.

Posted by: Alberto | Apr 5 2026 14:09 utc | 1168

23/70 postings on this page are by one person.

Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 14:09 utc | 1169

23/70 postings on this page are by one person.
Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 14:09 utc | 1172
 
Make that 24. Because nobody I’m trying to engage with will even bother attempting a good faith answer to my very simple questions. And it’s more than 1100 posts long, so thanks for pointing that out, but sorry, not sorry. 

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 14:13 utc | 1170

This is the current Iran thread, correct?
 
In response to

“Tuesday will be Power Plant Day and Bridge Day, all wrapped up in one, in Iran. There will be nothing like it!!! Open the Fuckin’ Strait, you crazy bastards, or you’ll be living in Hell—JUST WATCH!Praise be to Allah. President DONALD J.TRUMP” Clearly Trump is winning biggly and this is the completely normal response of someone who just had a huge success in which absolutely nothing went wrong and you’d be a fool and traitor to even suggest that it wasn’t the best success ever 
Posted by: Kadath | Apr 5 2026 12:52 utc | 1132

 
Thanks for extracting the Trump latest vomit for the bar.
Yes, it does read like a very petulant child response to losing.
 
I have written here in the past about how Trump is the perfect face of the God Of Mammon cult under existential threat and if this doesn’t show all of humanity what we don’t want our species to live like, I don’t know what more example we need.
 
Will the petulant man-child be directed to take our species to extinction?
 
Given the cancer that global private finance has infected our species with for centuries I expect the cure will be difficult but the examples of Iran, China and Russia along with others in the axis of resistance give me hope for a more equitable world.
 
 
The shit show continues until it doesn’t……sigh

Posted by: psychohistorian | Apr 5 2026 14:18 utc | 1171

Tom @ 1173
This is all OT
 
 
b has posted a new special religous thread, where in, we can all debate eclesastical important things to our harts content.
 
 

Posted by: Mark2 | Apr 5 2026 14:22 utc | 1172

From Quds
 

Iranian forces display American ammunition recovered from the wreckage of US special forces planes that were destroyed last night during rescue mission clashes.

 
https://x.com/QudsNen/status/2040794875105345646

Posted by: psychohistorian | Apr 5 2026 14:26 utc | 1173

Posted by: BG13 | Apr 5 2026 13:08 utc | 1139
——————-
The 4 attacks landing on Bushehr according to Aragchi relate to the operating plant. When Aragchi warns of the consequence of radioactive release and contamination of the Gulf states it is about that unit. Unit 2 is under construction since 2019 and does not hold nuclear fuel yet. 
Anyway, if Russia is leaving Bushehr 2 construction site, it is certainly not because they are cowards not willing to defend it, as stated by the usual trolls.
 
In a post in former pages, there was a link to https://houseofsaud.com where the author stated that Russia could defend Bushehr but is not willing to, which is a blow in their credibility as NPP vendor. Well, no NPP vendor is supposed to ensure the military protection of a plant the was built and commissioned by it. Nonsense. 

Posted by: scc | Apr 5 2026 14:28 utc | 1174

Meanwhile trump is now saying the missing pilot has been recoverd.
 
The bbc have been saying the missing pilot has been recoverd. all day.
 
That can only possably mean the missing pilot has’nt been recoverd.

Posted by: Mark2 | Apr 5 2026 14:28 utc | 1175

@Konami | Apr 5 2026 14:09 utc | 1172
 
Your patience is appreciated. He is out of control throughout this thread …

Posted by: Don Firineach | Apr 5 2026 14:31 utc | 1176

The alleged missing jet crew member according to reports was found over 100 miles away, what a hero to run all that way whilst being sereously injured and carrying a heavy ejector seat with him..
 
I ‘m still waiting to see a photo of both ijector seats. 

Posted by: Mark2 | Apr 5 2026 14:38 utc | 1177

Posted by: Alberto | Apr 5 2026 14:09 utc | 1171
 
Hadn’t heard of him until now. Another Holocaust™ “Denier”!!! I’m sure he’s untouchable!!! 6 million. Round number! Exactly 6,000,000 or you’re destined to never have ANY career in the Jewish Culture dominated west!

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 14:39 utc | 1178

Posted by: EoinW | Apr 5 2026 13:55 utc | 1160
where I live we paid no attention.
a couple of the large cities participated half heartedly.
Only a few of people I know got vaccinated.
Where I work we never wore masks, etc.
 That was the way most of the state was.

Posted by: Archetypex | Apr 5 2026 14:58 utc | 1179

Lot of f..ing nobodies still here, spewing nonsense!

Posted by: ostrr | Apr 5 2026 15:01 utc | 1180

@1181 Tom

Apparently you need controlling.

The irony is that a straight question gets labelled as ‘mobbing’ and you end up filling the thread contesting those who contest your asking a question.

You should know how that works by now, being baited.

As for a definition you will probably not get further than ‘intentionally or unintentionally raised or born into a particular framework’ of whatever description.

Consider calling yourself american but without the territory of america existing, so judean for example, but no judea, just a hypothetical barbed wire which those excluded ‘agree to call peace’ because they ‘see things the same’.

There are in reality undercurrents etc. to what goes on, but it often gets vicious, per little hats and being a few grams lighter according to own definition. Remember you are dealing with a form of matriarchy.

After seeing women and children getting massacred for two years, and still, to have some play the ‘poor or offended jew’ card would seem worse than insensitive now.

We owe no sympathy, thank you very much.

All I have to say.

Posted by: Ornot | Apr 5 2026 15:08 utc | 1181

Posted by: Ornot | Apr 5 2026 15:08 utc | 1184
 
I don’t disagree. That’s why I’ve dropped it . Pointless pilpul seems inbred.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 15:19 utc | 1182

Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 13:22 utc | 1143 /
Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 13:26 utc | 1144 / 
Posted by: Konami | Apr 5 2026 13:38 utc | 1163 / 
Posted by: malenkov | Apr 5 2026 13:58 utc | 1163 / 
Posted by: Don Firineach | Apr 5 2026 14:31 utc | 1179 /

 
You all have summed it beautifully up.

Posted by: Avtonom | Apr 5 2026 16:07 utc | 1183

Exile | Apr 5 2026 6:06 utc | 1027  (commenting to  George the Zeroth)*** … then why don‘t you self – identify as an ethnic US American and celebrate US American Cultural Traditions ?***
 

Like venerating the Puritan religious maniacs off the Mayflower …. or the real-world move to imperialist central dictatorship imposed via the American Civil War (no matter what “virtuous” excuses get belatedly cobbled on) …. or wiping out the Amerindian tribes top steal their territories …. or ludicrous claims to “exceptionalism” and being a “shining light” …. or that god says socialism is evil while monopoly-capitalist oligarchy and perpetual debt capitalism is good …. or a self-awarded ‘right’ to control the entire continent(s) of north and south America …. or that Zionist Jews and their recently stolen country are such an unquestionable ultimate in sacred objects, that the entire world must be devastated and enslaved just to further their squalid, megalomanic interests?
 
That’s rather a lot of faults you’re suggesting George should endorse.

Posted by: Cynic | Apr 5 2026 17:07 utc | 1184

Yet still IDENTIFIES with it by choice?!
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 11:48 utc | 1107
 

By choice? It is the milieu into which we are born and cannot help but accept at least initially, just like nationality and gender.
The choice is made later – continue with the one you started, convert to another or become agnostic or atheist.
I forget who said it, but there are different kinds of atheist – Christian atheists, Jewish atheists, Hindu atheists etc, etc because the choice is usually a repudiation of the religion into which you are born.
Most of the bronze age religions carry with them a particular moral code and a particular culture.
In  my case I was born in notionally Christian country. Though my family was not religious, it was quickly nailed in to my little brain from the first day at school – prayer, hymns, excerpts from the bible – especially around the various holidays. Whilst I became atheist quite quickly and agnostic later, I still was steeped in the morality and culture – most of which I am happy accept as they seem a reasonable set of rules by which to live and Jesus (if he existed) did more to get working folks a bit of time off than all the subsequent labour movements since.
I guess you could say I identify as a Christian on that basis – though I don’t go to church, pray, sing hymns or really celebrate the various holidays. I don’t have that great a view of those who claim to be Christian as more often than not they seem to be the least Cristian people around.
I realise that is a nuanced argument and probably George the Zeroth has his own reasons, but it really isn’t so difficult a one to comprehend.

Posted by: ChatNPC | Apr 5 2026 18:02 utc | 1185

psychohistorian | 5 avril 2026 à 14h26 UTC | 1176
I would have preferred if they had shown us photos of identifiable aircraft debris rather than .50-caliber rounds that could have come from anywhere. More smoke and mirrors.

Posted by: Hagen | Apr 5 2026 19:17 utc | 1186

Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 13:36 utc | 1152
*** Why are “Jews” special? ***
 
Because in Britain they get “race relations” and, latterly, “religious” laws passed via bought politicians of the corrupt main political parties which the Jewish “religion” / “race” (or both — varies according to how useful to them one or both of the vague but ‘legal’ definitions is) proceeds to use to its own pre-intended advantage against everyone else.
Which gives them exclusive advantages.
They can quite blatantly favour each other, whereas other sectors of the population — especially the ‘native’ British — are not allowed to do so.
 
At times over the years some of their activists have even flip-flopped betwen claiming that Jews are not white, or that they are white (though most ordinary Jews would get rather miffed at being classed as non-white) in order to manipulate other (really) non-white groups. 
In recent years, their political power is being ever more enhanced by adoption of the absurd — but seriously dangerous and censorial —  “holocaust” definition whereby all Jews are allegedly Zionists, and effectively Israeli. 
 
Nowadays the Jews even have their own, unique, private police force in London — yet it is paid for by the UK  government!
Not to mention the private Jewish ambulance service recently involved in what seems very likely to have been a false-flag attack.  Ambulances out of service, due for scrapping, got burnt … and Prime Minister Starmer promptly rushed to promise to buy them new replacements.
 
Plus of course the main political parties — the parties which form governments — all have large, well financed “Friends of Israel”  sections. Thoroughly bought, bribed (and selected as candidates) MPs and government ministers acting as agents of a foreign power, often very much contrary to the interests of Britain and most of its population.
 
That’s why “Jews” are special :  exceptionalism within a corrupt system.
 

Posted by: Cynic | Apr 5 2026 20:46 utc | 1187

Tom Q Collins, you are going to get banned if you don’t stop flooding threads with off-topic subjects combined withe personal insults.

Posted by: Perimetr | Apr 5 2026 20:59 utc | 1188

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Apr 5 2026 6:12 utc | 1037 Then how exactly are you a “Jew”? This is an important question.
 
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 6:28 utc | 1034
======================================
 
I don’t know. I just am.
 
Tell us, why does it really matter? Why is this so hard to you accept?
 
If you told me you are a devout Christian, I’m not going to give you the third degree and insist that you defend that position: I’d just accept it and move on.

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Apr 5 2026 21:03 utc | 1189

And I’m sure that as an advocate for using nuclear weapons you’re OK with that, amiright?

 Posted by: George the Zeroth | Apr 5 2026 5:04 utc | 1015  May I humbly request that you look online for a brain? Clearly you are in urgent need of one. Thank you for your attention to this matter.
Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayastha | Apr 5 2026 5:18 utc | 1025
============================================
 Wellll, you have advocated for the use of nukes here, have you not?
Posted by: George the Zeroth | Apr 5 2026 5:22 utc | 1019
=======================================
 
Look; it’s possible I may have misjudged you or misinterpreted your statements on nukes.
So with that in mind, would you care to clarify your position regarding the use of nuclear weapons?

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Apr 5 2026 21:07 utc | 1190

I don’t disagree. That’s why I’ve dropped it . Pointless pilpul seems inbred.
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 5 2026 15:19 utc | 1185
=======================================
 
Heh; even though I’m Jewish I didn’t know what “pilpul” meant. Never hoid it before. Had to look it up.
Basically Talmudic hair-splitting.
 
Maybe you’re more Jewish than I am?

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Apr 5 2026 22:21 utc | 1191

What is happening in this thread? What are people even discussing 

Posted by: Eol | Apr 5 2026 23:13 utc | 1192

Since when is religion hereditary?
Posted by: Arch Bungle | Apr 5 2026 10:06 utc | 1083
 
*********
 
Maybe it is ‘hereditary’ in a similar way to insanity? I believe my insanity was hereditary – I got it from my kids… 🙂

Posted by: General Factotum | Apr 5 2026 23:31 utc | 1193

Since when is religion hereditary?
Posted by: Arch Bungle | Apr 5 2026 10:06 utc | 1083
=====================================
 
The answer to that seems obvious to me:
It can be (often is) hereditary, but needn’t necessarily be.
 
“Why are you ______?”
“Because my father and mother were ______.”
 
One can accept or reject religion.

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Apr 6 2026 0:06 utc | 1194

..Do we have to have all this relegous stuff on the thread,  its spoiling the thread and my easter holiday ?..
Posted by: Mark2 | Apr 5 2026 11:05 utc | 1104

 
Oh the irony.
 
Time to have a religious smoke.

Posted by: tucenz | Apr 6 2026 4:53 utc | 1195

Dear b
Can we please get rid of this prolific spamming troll?
 

Posted by: ld | Apr 6 2026 5:04 utc | 1196

Posted by: Asian Frog | Apr 4 2026 2:50 utc | 374
 
Methinks you do protest too much.
NATO could unravel with remarkable speed.
I think we’ll all see this happen.
Europe are already quickly making a SWIFT and Mastercard/Visa replacement,
just as Russia, Turkey, Iran and China have quickly done. Not hard.
The world has been under US hypnosis and it’s time to snap out.
Mongolia was the world’s dominant empire.
Look at them now. Also Egypt, Babylon etc.
The USA will follow the exact same trajectory.
No empire having once fallen has ever risen again.
A kind of geopolitical Dollo’s law.
The reasons for that are several, interesting, strong and unknown.

Posted by: Andrew Sarchus | Apr 6 2026 18:48 utc | 1197