Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
February 17, 2026
Duplicate Propaganda For War On Iran

Propaganda usually works in a drip-drip-drip fashion. Small stories are launched each other day spreading the similar talking points over and over again

But today, due to some mix up, two of the major propaganda outlets, the New York Times and the Washington Post, launched very similar propaganda stories on the very same day.

Rage. Grief. Anxiety. The New Mood in Iran.NY Times
Popular anger burns in Iran after crackdown, as Trump turns up pressureWashington Post


The first story (archived), was written in New York. The second story (archived), was reported from Dubai.

The stories are about the aftermath of the recent CIA sponsored riots in Iran.

Both stories quote the same U.S. government financed Human Rights Activists News Agency (HRANA) in Fairfax, VA, with unverifiable numbers of alleged casualties.

The NY Times:

Rights groups like U.S.-based HRANA say at least 7,000 protesters were killed and the numbers are expected to rise as more deaths are verified.

The Washington Post:

The government crackdown left more than 7,000 people dead, more than 6,500 of them protesters, according to the Human Rights Activists News Agency, a U.S.-based advocacy organization for rights in Iran.

Both outlets claim that people are enraged about the government which had managed to shut the riots down.

Both start with telling similar themed “sob-stories” of anonymous people from ‘everyday life’:

NYT:

Mariam, a 54-year-old designer, said she panics whenever her teenage son leaves the house because he had friends and classmates who were shot and killed in the protests.

“The truth is that we are feeling extremely not well,” she said. “I have never experienced this kind of collective grief and instability. We don’t know what will happen in the next hour.” Like many people interviewed for this article, Mariam asked to be identified by only her first name for fear of retribution.

WaPo:

A 45-year old woman from Rasht, near Iran’s Caspian Sea coast, said security forces showed up at her niece’s school and strip-searched students for wounds sustained at protests from the less-lethal pellet ammunition fired into crowds.

“Two girls fainted from the stress,” she said. Her niece hasn’t been back to the private school since, which the principal has allowed. But at some public schools, the woman from Rasht said, absences aren’t tolerated and students found with pellet wounds are expelled or arrested.

The sob-stories are then used to ‘explain’ and justify future violence against the state.

NYT:

Protests demanding the ouster of Iran’s authoritarian clerical rulers have ended. But many Iranians say that feelings of rage against the government and anxiety about the future permeate all aspects of life, and that nothing feels normal anymore.

WaPo:

In other parts of the country, popular anger is bubbling to the surface.

A woman from Bandar Abbas, on the Persian Gulf, who says she participated in the protests, said she saw security forces open fire into the crowds.

Before January she would not have understood why someone would want their own country to be attacked, she said, as the threat of U.S. strikes loomed. “But this time it is different,” she said, espousing a view long unpopular in Iran: “The real enemy is the Islamic Republic and any country or army that can weaken or attack them is going to liberate us.”

These spiked stories about Iran come as the U.S. military is preparing to wage war on the country.

The editors of both outlets had recently endorsed further U.S. measures against the people of Iran:

The United States has no right to wage war on Iran, or to have a say who governs the country. The opinion pages of the New York Times and Washington Post, however, are offering facile humanitarian arguments for the US to escalate its attacks on Iran. These are based on the nonsensical assumption that the US wants to help brighten Iranians’ futures.

In two editorials addressing the possibility of the US undertaking a bombing and shooting war on Iran, the Washington Post expressed no opposition to such policies and endorsed economic warfare as well.

It is a bit disappointing how ritualistic and boring propaganda like this has become.

Comments

@George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 10:52 utc | 199
That was no argument. Since we both probably agree that the US supported the contras. And that doesnt contradict the seemingly recurrent pattern that the anglosaxons support communist takeovers and then immediately persecutes them. To begin with I believe the pattern is that the anglosaxon imperialists dont want development of other countries. So they dont want good examples to emerge such as somebody following the early recipe of Alexander Hamilton, Henry Carey and Friedrich List of nation building. Where there is no fanatical privatising theme but neither any negative view of private enterprise. Leftist regimes often have such a negative view. So enforcing communist takeovers neutral investors will be repelled more easily than in the previously mentioned arrangement.
Since the anglosaxons – actually the British – had an empire and industrialised early they had an edge and if everyone else had less effective ‘good examples’ to show for there would be less competition. Hence British liberalism wasnt for others to follow if they were more competitive only if they were less so. Same thing with Russia and China. The angloamerican establishment examplified by John Dewey and Bertrand Russel were dedicated to the idea of China NOT becoming capitalist. Russia was subverted partly with the Protcols of Sion by which the anglosaxons managed to get Sergei Witte out of the way. So the British could twart the Rothschilds from daring to collaborating with Britains rivals. Britain inherited the traits of earlier editions of the oligarchy. That is why Britain plays a dominating role.

Posted by: petergrfstrm | Feb 18 2026 11:30 utc | 201

George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 10:15 utc | 192
It’s all about perceived exceptionalism and supremacy.

Posted by: Artem | Feb 18 2026 11:45 utc | 202

Giyane | Feb 18 2026 10:32 utc | 196
“Fighting isn’t righteousness in itself, unless you are fighting for a way of life that is exemplary and clearly righteous”
Are the qualities of ‘examplary and clearly righteous’ defined by Islam?In a Muslim’s view, of course they are; you have come full circle and justified Jihad, one of the key tenets of Islam. 
It’s almost comical.

Posted by: Artem | Feb 18 2026 11:50 utc | 203

From a conversation at MoA a few years back I had noted:
 
 
the August 19, 1953, U.S.- and U.K-backed coup in Iran, which took place two years after Iran’s democratically elected Prime Minister Mohammad Mosaddegh nationalized Iran’s oil industry that had been controlled by the company now known as British Petroleum. “If nationalization in Iran of oil was successful, this would set a terrible example to other countries where U.S. oil interests were present,” explains Ervand Abrahamian, Iranian historian and author of Oil Crisis in Iran: From Nationalism to Coup d’Etat and The Coup: 1953, The CIA, and the Roots of Modern U.S.-Iranian Relations. While the CIA has historically taken credit for Mosaddegh’s overthrow, “the British have not admitted their leading role,” notes Iranian filmmaker Taghi Amirani, whose documentary film Coup 53 uncovers the influence of MI6 agents who sought to preserve their imperial-era access to Iranian oil and pulled in the Americans by promising a “slice.” Seventy years later, says Amirani, “We are still living with the ripples of this disastrous event.”
 
Transcript: democracynow.org

Posted by: DunGroanin | Feb 18 2026 12:17 utc | 204

stj– “But in this case he is right that Reagan and Democrats like Jackson were also architects of mass incarceration. There are two lessons here I think, one, that class is more important than race in the long run, which is why Jackson and other Black politicians would buy into bourgeois politics.”
 
I usually find your analyses to be pretty spot on, especially  your most recent response to the Marco Rubio speech in Munich, which underscored what I have puzzled over  and made some points I have found to be essential, such as Trump’s divide and conquer strategy to be used on the global south and allies of Russia and China which forebodes for the immediate future, for ex.
 
But the above statement is misleading and to name Jesse Jackson as being the Democrat “architect” of mass incarceration would appear disingenuous. Of course, the Democrats who were the main architects of mass incarceration were the Clintons, authors of the ‘three strikes.’
 
A specific condition of some of  the time frame of the cocaine and especially the egregious crack epidemic was ‘benign neglect’ when black ghettos were left to the mercies of the drug dealers and gangs and inhabitants were being continually caught in the crossfire. The black community itself was demanding for adequate policing and getting the dealers off the streets.  The ensuing development of policing to become broken windows, then militarization and lawlessness, towards oppression is another subject.
 
 
 
“Los Angeles Times
Jesse Jackson Calls ‘3-Strikes’ Laws Unfair and ‘Fear-Driven’
By ALAN ABRAHAMSON
March 12, 1996 
Launching a statewide media salvo, the Rev. Jesse L. Jackson Jr. on Monday decried sentencing laws that he termed an unfair “rush of fear-driven legislation.”
Rigid federal sentencing laws that carry minimum terms of five or 10 years behind bars for certain drug offenses are “unjust,” he said. So too, he said, is the state’s 2-year-old “three-strikes” law, which carries a penalty of 25 years to life for a third conviction…” Etc.
 
 
Jesse Jackson was essentially a servant of the black community. Depending on immediate conditions, he may have made use of but did not “buy in” to bourgeoise politics. Using him as the exemplar dem of US mass incarceration policy distorts his legacy and may even obscure the real history.
 
I’m sure there are other ways you could have brought into your discussion your point about class being the essential contradiction. So much has been written about the interplay of class, race (and gender), and I am not equipped to discuss it, but it can’t be done in a couple sentences.  there is for ex. the question of when class struggle takes the form of racial oppression (what happens like in 2020 when the fight against racism is against the police, the protectors of the state — then was co-opted (mostly by those clever Dems) into identity politics.  Also the conflicts that arose within the CP in the 40’s and 50’s around ‘the national question’ referencing here that there are conditions specific to Blacks that can only be determined by that group themselves ,(eg. in Ralph Ellison’s novel ‘The Invisible Man’  fiction depicts that reality.)  Also there is gender (there was for ex. a theory that the production of life is fundamental, etc.)
 
Jesse Jackson fought to put Palestine on the dem platform. 
 
Jesse Jackson was not responsible for the demise of the disgusting dems, and there is much more that argues against a facile dismissal of him.
 
 

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 18 2026 12:48 utc | 205

Those US bases are there to prevent the overthrow of those Regimes, take them out and thebwill rise up.

Posted by: Suresh | Feb 18 2026 0:01 utc | 115
 
Marandi often repeats this nonsense. Wishful thinking in the extreme. People in those gulf states live the Life of Riley, even the low wage earners – compared to back home in their poverty stricken countries. They wouldn’t want to change anything. Any attempt to overthrow the Gulf monarchies by resident third world ‘guest workers’ or anyone else, would be put down with unrestrained brutality and savagery.

Posted by: Johnts | Feb 18 2026 12:54 utc | 206

The current situation with Iran looks like ‘the dog that didn’t bark’.  There must be huge (‘yuge’?) amounts of video and documents that could drive Trump out of office due to his association with Epstein. So, where is it?  Why is it being hidden?  The sound and fury of anti-Trump sentiments should bring it out.
But it’s not there in public sight. The Deep State/Israel wants war and this scandal could end that push. They are in charge, apparently. They pull the strings.  

Posted by: Eighthman | Feb 18 2026 12:56 utc | 207

205 qualifications
the concept of police and corresponding apparatuses as upholders of the bourgeois state
 
production of life not in the biological aspect (maybe partly) but in all aspects of labor of caretaking 

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 18 2026 13:09 utc | 208

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 10:15 utc | 192
 
#####
 
A common error. The relationship is that God commands and we obey.
 
Not God commands and we rationalize why we should or should not follow it.
 
Not grasping that makes it impossible to understand.
 
I don’t convert or promote. Someone either is sensitive to it, or not. If not, I cannot guide someone to a place they were not yet meant to go.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 13:12 utc | 209

46 stj– Lavieja 205 and 208 are a response to 46 stj.
I have not got to reading all of the posts so may not be up to date on any discussion of the subject of your 46.

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 18 2026 13:17 utc | 210

People in those gulf states live the Life of Riley, even the low wage earners – compared to back home in their poverty stricken countries. They wouldn’t want to change anything. Any attempt to overthrow the Gulf monarchies by resident third world ‘guest workers’ or anyone else, would be put down with unrestrained brutality and savagery.
 
Posted by: Johnts | Feb 18 2026 12:54 utc | 206
 
#######
 
Someone slept through the Arab Spring.
 
You literally know nothing about that part of the world.
 
Also, is it living a life of Riley if one is in a police state?

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 13:17 utc | 211

There is an ugly habit of some Westerners explaining how people they have never met, from places they have never visited, live their lives and the history of those places.
 
Marandi lives in Iran. He worked with the Iranian government. He can be incorrect, but some online NPC really stretches the bounds of credulity by rejecting his lived observations.
 
It’s like an American trying to override an Iranian about Iranian history.
 
Besides as an outlet for delusion and low self-esteem, what value can such obvious BS serve?

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 13:24 utc | 212

Danny Haiphong: Ben Norton: ‘Iran’s Scariest Weapon’
 
https://www.youtube.com/@DannyHaiphongYT/videos
 
“Trump terrified: Iran’s most powerful weapon gets Russia-China boost.”

Posted by: John Gilberts | Feb 18 2026 13:29 utc | 213

Thanks b for the alert. I will be watching how the process develops during the next weeks as different factions around Trump work thard o force his hand to go to war.
Bad data leads to bad decisions, and unwanted outcomes for everyone except for the speculators of the kind of Soros and Rofhschild.
 

Posted by: Richard L | Feb 18 2026 13:37 utc | 214

Posted by: John Gilberts | Feb 18 2026 13:29 utc | 213
 
#####
 
I believe the Ayatollah recently said that Iran’s greatest weapon (asset?) is the will of Iranians.
 
Thousands of Iranians will go without food and water between sunrise and sunset for the next 30 days.
 
A tough-minded people.
 
In a conflict, will and identity are much more powerful than technology. Gaza is a great example of that.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 13:42 utc | 215

Salaam- silverfox@106-why let the great satan know what you have in the quiver sack eh.Let the yanks and izzies wonder like Alice! The time will come to shoot,then the wrath of the Iranians will be felt.No more kicking the can down the road-then it’s high noon!

Posted by: 4q8 | Feb 18 2026 13:58 utc | 216

Posted by: petergrfstrm | Feb 18 2026 6:48 utc | 162

The Sheer Size of the Universe says there is No God of your thinking….🤷‍♀️🙄

Posted by: Nobody | Feb 18 2026 14:02 utc | 217

205 Lavieja — I have to reconsider what I said about Jackson earlier. There was a specific point when he could have been elected as the Rainbow Coalition candidate for President., but he opted to stay with the Dems giving them his support recounted in this remembrance by Ajamu Baraka of Black Agenda Report, so yes, Jackson was co-opted then.  However in his memoriam Baraku says:
 
So there’s no voices to defend the processes in Haiti anymore. There’s no voices criticizing the continuation of a US presence on the African continent. There’s no voices opposing the gangsterism in Venezuela and the impact it will have, not only on the Venezuelan people, but what about the Afro Venezuelans that people forget about, same thing with this siege now being imposed on Cuba. The current moment, I think, reflects the rightist character of Black politics in the US. And it’s important for people to understand that even Jesse Jackson, and many people will point to, you know, some of the obvious contradictions that at least that tradition that he came out of was a tradition that was way further to the left than the current position of these criminals like Al Sharpton, Hakeem Jeffries, Gregory Meeks and the rest of these opportunists. It’s important to make that distinction, I believe.
So there’s no voices to defend the processes in Haiti anymore. There’s no voices criticizing the continuation of a US presence on the African continent. There’s no voices opposing the gangsterism in Venezuela and the impact it will have, not only on the Venezuelan people, but what about the Afro Venezuelans that people forget about, same thing with this siege now being imposed on Cuba. The current moment, I think, reflects the rightist character of Black politics in the US. And it’s important for people to understand that even Jesse Jackson, and many people will point to, you know, some of the obvious contradictions that at least that tradition that he came out of was a tradition that was way further to the left than the current position of these criminals like Al Sharpton, Hakeem Jeffries, Gregory Meeks and the rest of these opportunists. It’s important to make that distinction, I believe.
Sorry it ran into OT.

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 18 2026 14:06 utc | 218

Thousands of Iranians will go without food and water between sunrise and sunset for the next 30 days.

I do that all Year long. Called Intermediary Diet…🙄

Posted by: Nobody | Feb 18 2026 14:23 utc | 219

Posted by: Nobody | Feb 18 2026 14:23 utc | 219
 
#####
 
Do you mean intermittent fasting?
 
They are not the same thing.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 14:28 utc | 220

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 14:28 utc | 220

Yeah, that. Look, if i pass on the 12/16h Cycle to the Sunlight, i do Ramadan all Year! Muslims do a Forced Health Diet once a Year, stop bragging like its some Sort of Miracle from the Heavens…🙄

Posted by: Nobody | Feb 18 2026 14:36 utc | 221

I wonder what is it there is with all that “not starting a war during a religious holiday” trend.
Is it pretext for not starting a war themself ? Well , the zionist entity had two conflicts started during a religious holidays already … that would provide a “plausible deniability” for striking with the same “regional alibi for violence” that usual.
It can also be a form of justification for a delay before a strike because they don’t seems ready for the long retaliation that will ensue. But that’s less convincing than the first proposal … 

Posted by: Savonarole | Feb 18 2026 14:44 utc | 222

@LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 13:42 utc | 215@Nobody | Feb 18 2026 14:36 utc | 221
“Thousands of Iranians” is about right because the remaining tens of millions won’t bother. ))
As for Muslim ‘will and identity’, anyone who knows about Ramazan in the Middle East knows that most people become all but nocturnal – sleeping as late as they possibly can to avoid fasting; and pigging out like its their last meal most every single evening often competing for restaurant places and ways in which to flaunt their wealth and “piety”. Far reoved from the trumpeted ‘charity and self-discipline’ etc.
Additionally, anyone SEEN NOT observing Ramazan in public is vilified and aggressively so, by the very same people I describe above!
Hypocrisy and delusion in the extreme.
@Nobody is not far off the mark in his comments.

Posted by: Artem | Feb 18 2026 15:45 utc | 223

Posted by: Sebgo | Feb 18 2026 0:46 utc | 122
It is PDVSA not PDVA.

Posted by: pepe | Feb 18 2026 15:49 utc | 224

Someone slept through the Arab Spring.

 
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 13:17 utc | 211
 
The Arab Spring was a Western instigated regime change/chaos operation, like every other chaos operation in the ME. They just had an ‘Arab Spring’ in Iran. You think the Arab Spring was home grown legit, proving you’re clueless.

You literally know nothing about that part of the world.

 
Wrong. I know a great deal about it. And how would you know? Not to mention your arrogance and holier-than-thou smugness:
 

I don’t convert or promote. Someone either is sensitive to it, or not. If not, I cannot guide someone to a place they were not yet meant to go.

 
Did you copy & paste that new age crap from Eckhart Tolle? Fuck off already.

Posted by: Johnts | Feb 18 2026 15:58 utc | 225

The “big beautiful belt”—echoed in recent U.S. administration statements emphasizing grand infrastructure builds like highways, bridges, and ports—serves as an explicit counter to China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). Yet Iran functions as a convenient common red herring here, much as the “Iranian missile threat” was invoked under Obama to justify NATO missile defenses in Poland and Romania (Aegis Ashore sites), deployments widely seen in Moscow as pretextual moves to encircle Russia rather than genuinely shield against Tehran. Just as that Iranian pretext enabled forward U.S./NATO positioning against a primary rival, heightened anti-Iran measures today—sanctions, proxy confrontations, and rhetoric on nuclear/missile programs—indirectly target the deepening Russia-China-Iran alignment, disrupting shared energy flows, BRI corridors through Iran, and the broader anti-Western bloc’s economic resilience, all while maintaining plausible deniability under the banner of Middle East security; this suggests that the common rhetoric of a “greater Israel” and the Israel-Iran tensions serve the geopolitical power game between the US and Europe on one hand and Russia and China on the other too conveniently, framing regional conflicts as ideological flashpoints to justify broader containment strategies.

Posted by: Princess Bodica | Feb 18 2026 16:03 utc | 226

“LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 13:42 utc | 215
Did he say that in referrence to Ramazan?
If he did, he is spot on, because the period where Ramazan and Novruz overlap this year will indeed see significant relaxation of Ramazan rules: the people caring far more about Novruz, of course! ))

Posted by: Artem | Feb 18 2026 16:30 utc | 227

Posted by: Nobody | Feb 18 2026 14:36 utc | 221
 
####
 
Do you not drink any fluids during your fast?
 
Do you intermittent fast from water?

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 16:43 utc | 228

Posted by: Johnts | Feb 18 2026 15:58 utc | 225
 
#####
 
It’s not that I am smarter than anyone else; it is that most people cannot see patterns or make connections.
 
The Arab Spring was possible because the ground was fertile for it.
 
The very conditions you claimed do not exist.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 16:44 utc | 229

Posted by: Artem | Feb 18 2026 15:45 utc | 223
 
####
 
Yes, I accurately framed how many people are likely to properly participate.
 
That’s because I try to be diligent when I post.
 
What people do individually is not important. There will always be exceptions; a significant portion of the Quran addresses hypocrites.
 
Again, whether individuals observe in good faith or not is irrelevant. Those who are secretly jerking off to Netflix and daydreaming about living in the West aren’t the ones who will be fighting the battles. Those cowards have always existed; they come out after the fighting is done, so that they can enjoy what stronger people have created for them.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 16:48 utc | 230

Gold is back over $5k. The bankers must be getting frustrated, despite all the efforts.

Posted by: unimperator | Feb 18 2026 16:52 utc | 231

Posted by: unimperator | Feb 18 2026 16:52 utc | 231
 
####
 
Gold isn’t going up; the dollar is going down.
 
The gold price is a referendum on the dollar’s value.
 
You will see similar movements over the last year across many metals.
 
Real things (resources with industrial potential) are always better than fiat. 

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 16:56 utc | 232

I had heard of this event in the series Terry Jones – Crusades (IIRC and no idea how accurate the series, but I enjoyed it)
 
Abu Saad al-Harawi, a respected Muslim judge from Damascus, made a dramatic public statement in Baghdad on Friday, August 9, 1099, during the month of Ramadan. After fleeing the fall of Jerusalem to the Crusaders, he entered the main mosque of Baghdad and began eating publicly during fasting hours—a highly provocative act meant to shock the Muslim community into recognizing the gravity of the loss of the holy city. His actions were a calculated effort to draw attention to the catastrophe, as he believed nothing would stir greater reaction than breaking the fast in such a public and sacred context. The people of Baghdad were deeply moved, weeping for Jerusalem, and al-Harawi later delivered a powerful speech before the Caliph al-Mustazhir, condemning Muslim inaction and calling for unity and resistance. His emotional appeal, though not immediately resulting in military retaliation, became a pivotal moment in rallying Muslim sentiment against the Crusader occupation.
 
900+ years ago.
 
Nothing is new. And where is the Abu Saad al-Harawi of today? I think one is needed.

Posted by: ftp | Feb 18 2026 17:04 utc | 233

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 18 2026 13:17 utc | 210 Friend, you are not required to do comment reviews. At best I hope my comments plant questions. In the end, most people will work out their own answers. My own experience in taking up new ideas goes something like this: 1)of course that’s wrong 2)I know that’s wrong but I’m not sure where it goes wrong 3)there’s a point there 4)there’s some problem with what I believed before 5)maybe this new idea is better 6)this is right and I made a mistake before 7)I’ve always believed this, it’s not even a new idea

Posted by: steven t johnson | Feb 18 2026 17:13 utc | 234

I can see a number of vulnerabilities of aircraft carriers.  Hypersonics come first.  If lasers are used defensively, support vessels could be harmed.  Drones could hover out of range and then follow fighters landing on deck.  Another question arises about timing of drone destruction by microwave weapons – if protected with Faraday shielding, can they survive long enough to strike?  Can they be fitted with AI terminal guidance that continues after jamming is detected ( memory of position guided towards).
I also wonder about drone torpedoes as dropped off out of range and reaching the target that way.  Or shedding wings and acting as a torpedo.  
Starting a war with Iran could be Trump’s last stand – because Iran would win by simply not losing.  The regime stays, the US looks impotent then.

Posted by: Eighthman | Feb 18 2026 17:13 utc | 235

Posted by: bevin | Feb 17 2026 23:46 utc | 113 Even as presented via Roberts, Bean is dubious. You are too hasty in accepting this, to say the least. As for my notice of Roberts review?
The outstanding Marxist economist Michael Roberts has always been at his best when sticking to his proper field, economics. But he does occasionally stray into more political arenas, with much less positive effect. In this case, he reviews a recent book on Venezuela, edited by Anderson Bean. Venezuela: the end game – Michael Roberts Blog 

But the writers in this book are at pains to argue that the collapse in Venezuela cannot be laid solely at the door of US imperialism and its sanctions. Despite the harm that the sanctions have wrought in Venezuela, the other major component was the economic mismanagement and neoliberal program of the increasingly authoritarian Maduro government.  Mainstream capitalist economists claim that the collapse of Venezuela was the result of socialism; while many on the left claim that the Maduro regime had to be defended as an example of socialism.  Both sides are wrong.  Bean and the other writers in this book do not accept that Chavez (and Maduro after him) had established a socialist economy, or even that Venezuela was on the ‘road to socialism’. 

 This is strange, because  Bean before had other things to say about Chavismo/Bolivarianism.  

And third, which Bean reckons was the “most transformative”, was the transfer of power to the popular sectors through the creation of new forms of popular assemblies and experiments with workers’ controls and community councils.

 To my eyes, this is a concession by Bean that this served to partially disestablish the bourgeois state. Indeed, those same structure should be viewed as elements of a dual power. Roberts of course cites useful information on the failure of the Bolivarian state to expropriate the bourgeoisie in toto, and reprivatization under Maduro, as well as Rodriguez now. The thing about that is, the use of PDVSA revenues to lavish privileges on the military can and must be understood not just as an end, but a means to an end, i.e., keeping the military from overthrowing the socialist government. And bribing a portion of the bourgeoisie is not just a capitulation but is also splitting the bourgeoisie, something not good for their class rule need I note? But looking past uniformly negative attitudes reported, you have to ask: What would have happened if the Bolivarian movement had been more Communist? The seizure of state properties, methods like collectivzation of factories and farms and commerce, are policies generally associated with Stalinism. Roberts is anti-Stalinist before he is a central planner. This isn’t usually noticeable in his analyses of capitalism. But I firmly believe that if Chavez had gone that route, that too would have been condemned as economic mismanagement as well as tyranny. Damned if you do, damned if you don’t. Evidently the point is that some people get damned.  A final note: The publisher is Haymarket Books. Publishing house have politics. Haymarket is named after an anarchist cause celebre, a violent episode in nineteenth century Chicago. As anarchists of a sort (almost all anarchists are pretty tame in practice, unless they ignore their professed principles in favor of effective politics) Haymarket is not going to publish a Leninist book, even if some Leninism creeps into the occasional contribution. (A little bit can provide camouflage.) Anarchism is in my view fundamentally reactionary, no matter how the anarchists posture on occasion. Looking backward is no way to move into the future. Anarchism looks back to a stateless Golden Age. But the Golden is always in the future.  

Posted by: steven t johnson | Feb 18 2026 17:27 utc | 236

Posted by: Eighthman | Feb 18 2026 17:13 utc | 235
 
######
 
If fighting breaks out, Iran will try (in conjunction with Russia and China) to manage America’s defeat.
 
They want to win but not drive America towards escalation.
 
The plan, IMO, is for a Yankee/Western/Epstein-class collapse, not a kinetic defeat.
 
The Iranians (and the Yemenis) have a wide array of “suicide” naval drones. The Yemenis were training theirs with AI to be able to seek out and target critical locations on target ships like engine rooms and fuel cells.
 
There was a lot of footage on Twitter last year before the 12-day war when Operation Rough Diaper was still going on.
 
Hypersonics aren’t dangerous only because of the speed, but the entire class of weapons is maneuverable in flight, which makes current AD almost useless. AFAIK, no one has predictive AD yet. AD that could anticipate the moves of a hypersonic while in flight. The Russians are surely working on it.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 17:39 utc | 237

Venezuela’s economy expanded by 8.7% year-on-year in Q3 2025, accelerating from a 6.7% growth in the previous three-month period, according to central bank data. The boost stemmed primarily from a 16.1% surge in oil activity during the period, while non-oil activity grew 6.1%. Within the non-oil sector, notable growth was recorded in construction (+16.4%); transportation & storage (+9.35%); manufacturing (+8.98%); trade & vehicle repair (+8.19%); mining (+7.08%); electricity & water (+6.89%); accommodation & food services (+6.78%); real estate & professional services (+6.6%), and agriculture (+6.11%). source: Banco Central De Venezuela
 
Looks to me like Venezuela is doing too good for its own good.

 

 

Posted by: arby | Feb 18 2026 17:48 utc | 238

Posted by: Savonarole | Feb 18 2026 14:44 utc | 222

Ramadan is Nixed in a War! 🤷‍♀️🤫

Posted by: Nobody | Feb 18 2026 18:04 utc | 239

Posted by: Nobody | Feb 18 2026 18:04 utc | 239
 
######
 
Muslims have always fought during Ramadan if necessary.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 18:18 utc | 240

🇮🇷 🇷🇺 Iran and Russia joint exercise will be held tomorrow
 
Admiral Maqsoudlou, spokesperson of the exercise:
 
“Iran and Russia will hold a joint naval exercise tomorrow in the Sea of Oman and the northern Indian Ocean region. The main goal of the exercise is to enhance security and sustainable maritime interactions in the Sea of Oman and the northern Indian Ocean.”
 

https://x.com/dana916/status/2024187090469069057

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 18:24 utc | 241

Posted by: arby | Feb 18 2026 17:48 utc | 238
 
Looks to me like Venezuela is doing too good for its own good.
 
 
https://www.southfront.press/the-illegal-drug-trade-in-latin-america-part-iii-regional-convergence-the-drug-trade-armed-conflicts-and-counterinsurgency-wars/
 
the content of this link tells quite a story..

Posted by: snake | Feb 18 2026 18:50 utc | 242

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 16:43 utc | 228

No, i dont! But i can. It isnt hard! Story for you; I work with pious Muslims, and one of them got diagnosed with Diabetis! He dint want to take the “Western Medicine”. I told him about Insuline Resistance and ” The Diet”. You know what? He beat the Diabetis and not only notice the Common Core of the Diet with Ramadan, but also does more ectreme Dieta and questions Carbohydrats….🤷‍♀️🙋‍♀️

Posted by: Nobody | Feb 18 2026 19:20 utc | 243

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 10:15 utc | 192 ##### A common error. The relationship is that God commands and we obey. Not God commands and we rationalize why we should or should not follow it. Not grasping that makes it impossible to understand. I don’t convert or promote. Someone either is sensitive to it, or not. If not, I cannot guide someone to a place they were not yet meant to go.
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 13:12 utc | 209
 
So in other words you’re  a blind believer.
Gotcha.

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 19:24 utc | 244

Posted by: petergrfstrm | Feb 18 2026 11:30 utc | 201
====================================
 
Tell us: are you a LaRouchite?
I ask because you sure sound like one.

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 19:28 utc | 245

@George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 19:28 utc | 245
I am no faithful adherent of any sect if that is how you see Lyndon Larouche and his associates. But they have over the years published much better info than a vast number of altmedia. Therefore unless they themselves use the term I consider  ‘Larouchite’ an insulting word for which there is no need. Better use their individual names. About my differences with Larouche et al: I disagree about their view of CO2. But I havent discussed it with more than one of them so I dont know if they see things differently in and among them.
 

Posted by: petergrfstrm | Feb 18 2026 20:25 utc | 246

White Colonialism is a threat to the survival of mankind as a whole:
 

🇺🇸 Trump: If Iran decides not to make a deal, the United States may have to use Diego Garcia island (British occupied island in Indian ocean) “to thwart a potential attack from a very unstable and dangerous regime — an attack that could be against Britain as well as other friendly countries.”
Prime Minister Starmer must not lose control of Diego Garcia for any reason and at best sign an contract for a 100-year lease. This land should not be taken from Britain.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 18 2026 20:28 utc | 247

Things heating up to a boil in West Asia:
 

🇮🇷🇺🇸⚡Iran issued NOTAM on February 19, missile launches will take place from 03:30 to 13:30 UTC.
 
The US President constantly says that the US has sent a warship toward Iran. Of course, a warship is a dangerous piece of military hardware. However, more dangerous than that warship is the weapon that can send that warship to the bottom of the sea.
Imam KhameneiFeb. 17, 2026
 
🇷🇺🇮🇷 Russian Navy enters the Iranian port of Bandar Abbas for the scheduled naval exercises.
 
🇮🇷 Military reports indicate that Iran’s smart self-propelled naval mines, such as “Arund” and “Maham”, are undermining any efforts by the United States to remove mines in both the Persian Gulf and the Gulf of Oman.
These mines are characterized by their ability to move independently, enabling them to redeploy in maritime corridors even after they have been cleared.
According to estimates, the integration of these mines with Iran’s missiles and drones could restrict the movement of the enemy fleet and pose a complex threat, forcing American aircraft carrier groups to operate at greater distances from Iranian coasts to avoid risks.
 
Iran and Russia joint exercise will be held tomorrow
 
Admiral Maqsoudlou, spokesperson of the exercise:
 
“Iran and Russia will hold a joint naval exercise tomorrow in the Sea of Oman and the northern Indian Ocean region. The main goal of the exercise is to enhance security and sustainable maritime interactions in the Sea of Oman and the northern Indian Ocean.”
 
Yesterday’s footage from Hormuz Island during a major IRGC naval exercise shows dozens of oil tankers and commercial ships awaiting permission to enter the Strait of Hormuz.
 
White House signals Israeli regime: nuclear talks with Iran at a dead end, Tehran won’t meet Trump’s demands — Israel’s Channel 12

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 18 2026 20:35 utc | 248

Ritter seems pretty certain Iran is about to get destroyed: https://www.youtube.com/live/DCDuxei5dj8?si=RqmOpjopBiOjGQ12

Posted by: Deniz | Feb 18 2026 20:51 utc | 249

I have often said that the fate of Palestine will be shared by the rest of the world.
 
Because of Anglo Zionist willingness to corrupt every human liberty and right we are now entering a world where every state must transform itself into a paranoid surveillance state:
 

China Strengthens Coordination with Iran amid Expanding Israeli Intelligence Operations
 
In the Chinese expert and military community, the activities of the Israeli intelligence agency “Mossad” in Iran are seen as an example of a new model of hybrid intelligence warfare. According to a number of Chinese analysts, operations involving the infiltration of agents, cyber penetration, the compromise of databases, and the disabling of air defense systems demonstrate a transition to the so-called “informatized and intelligent warfare” format, in which the disruption of defense infrastructure precedes the open phase of military action.
 
Chinese military experts, including former representatives of the PLA Air Force, point out that Israel’s strikes on targets in Iran in 2025 reportedly met with limited resistance due to the prior destabilization of detection and control systems. In Beijing, such tactics are interpreted as a structural vulnerability – not just technological, but also institutional, related to internal administrative and digital “gaps” in the security system.
 
From China’s perspective, the consequences go beyond the Iranian case. The expert discussion emphasizes that similar methods could potentially be used against the critical infrastructure of states involved in the “One Belt, One Road” (BRI) initiative, including energy and trade corridors. Iran occupies a key geographical position in the logistical architecture linking East Asia with the Middle East and Europe, and instability within the country could directly affect energy supply routes.
 
Against this backdrop, according to sources, since the beginning of 2026, Beijing has deepened coordination with Tehran in the field of counterintelligence and cybersecurity. This involves joint analysis of infiltration channels, digital vulnerabilities, and administrative mechanisms that could have been used by foreign intelligence services. China promotes the use of its own technological solutions – the BeiDou navigation system instead of Western GPS platforms, modernized radar systems and air defense systems, as well as secure digital infrastructures.
 
An additional level of coordination is provided by the Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), which Iran joined as a full member in 2023. Although formally the organization’s mandate focuses on combating terrorism, Chinese analysts view it as a platform for expanded information exchange and strengthening collective resilience to external pressure.
 
In parallel, Beijing maintains a long-term economic vector of interaction with Iran. China remains the country’s largest trading partner, and the 25-year strategic cooperation agreement envisages large-scale investments in the energy and infrastructure sectors. The use of alternative financial mechanisms and barter schemes allows to minimize the impact of sanctions restrictions.
 
Diplomatically, China consistently emphasizes the principles of sovereignty and non-interference, while avoiding direct obligations for military defense of Iran. Beijing’s approach is characterized by restraint: strengthening the institutional resilience and technological autonomy of its partner is combined with avoiding open confrontation with Israel and the United States.
 
In China’s interpretation, events around Iran illustrate the transformation of modern confrontation: the key battlefield is not only physical space, but also the digital and administrative infrastructure of the state. Beijing’s response is based on strengthening systemic resilience – through technological isolation, institutional coordination, and economic integration – without direct escalation.
 
@Slavyangrad

 
When social credit and 24×7 surveillance is the only way to prevent a population from being infiltrated by Zionist terrorists you’re living in Orwell’s 1984.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 18 2026 20:52 utc | 250

Posted by: Deniz | Feb 18 2026 20:51 utc | 249
 
Lay off the crack.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 18 2026 20:55 utc | 251

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 18 2026 20:55 utc | 251
Are we going to see Iran take out aircraft carriers next month?  I know they have the ballistic capabilities, but I can’t wrap my head around the consequences.  I envision Pezeshkian last words to be the Americans don’t really mean it, they are good people. 

Posted by: Deniz | Feb 18 2026 21:07 utc | 252

Ritter seems pretty certain Iran is about to get destroyed ..
Posted by: Deniz | Feb 18 2026 20:51 utc |
Ritter who presents as an expert on the Middle East is known to refer to Bashar Al-Assad as a former dentist …

Posted by: tucenz | Feb 18 2026 21:10 utc | 253

Posted by: Deniz | Feb 18 2026 21:07 utc | 252
 
The thing to understand is the next war will be a war of annihilation.
 
To win, Iran needs to nuke all Israel and US airbases with low-yield weapons, and nuke underground Israeli bunkers and decapitate it.
 
Because going soft will result in destruction. US will most likely use its own low-yield nukes against Iran regardless whether they take a lot of losses or not.

Posted by: unimperator | Feb 18 2026 21:10 utc | 254

Iran in the 1980s already survived a war that decimated 10% of its population. I don’t think it’s afraid of a nuclear attack. An attack like that could turn the US into a pariah state.

Posted by: Friul | Feb 18 2026 21:35 utc | 255

🇮🇶🇮🇷⚔️🇺🇸🇮🇱‼️ Al Nujaba Islamic Resistance Movement has activated the Corps system for its members “Strike Without Referring to Command” in the event that the Islamic Republic of Iran is subjected to any aggression. The Noble Movement has identified a target bank containing 88 military and intelligence targets for the American occupier in Iraq and West Asia.

 
http://x.com/dana916/status/2024234628542861348

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 21:36 utc | 256

🇮🇷⚔️🇮🇱🇺🇸 Israeli Channel 13 Correspondent Alon Ben-David:
 
The primary U.S. airpower is concentrated at the ‘Muwaffaq Salti’ base in Jordan, where fighter jets are stationed alongside refueling, reconnaissance, and electronic warfare aircraft.
 
Jordan and the aircraft carriers are the primary hubs for potential U.S. operations.

 
https://x.com/dana916/status/2024236505368002950
 
As Russell Peters famously joked, “Somebody gonna get a hurt real bad…”

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 21:43 utc | 257

I envision Pezeshkian last words to be the Americans don’t really mean it, they are good people. 
 
Posted by: Deniz | Feb 18 2026 21:07 utc | 252
 
Honestly, I hope Pezeshkian has no say over anything whatsoever.
 
Taking him out would be the biggest favour the Zionists can do for Iran.
 
As for sinking a carrier, there’s a lot Iran can do to kick the US in the nuts long before it gets to that point.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 18 2026 21:53 utc | 258

The primary U.S. airpower is concentrated at the ‘Muwaffaq Salti’ base in Jordan, where fighter jets are stationed alongside refueling, reconnaissance, and electronic warfare aircraft.

Various Western ‘experts’ on the internet are putting out the idea that Iran cannot strike Muwaffaq Salti base because most of it’s missiles are short range.
For some reason they seem to have forgotten that Iran can hit israel and targets in the Mediterranean sea.
 
What could explain such obvious ignorance?
 

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 18 2026 22:14 utc | 259

Artem 223
 
Normal day,  Ramadhan in February.
Eat slightly early breakfast,  skip lunch, very early supper before 6 pm.
 

Posted by: Giyane | Feb 18 2026 22:19 utc | 260

I presume the  US flatulla is collecting data, with a view to zapping bits of Iran from Diego Farsiya after the US Desastroyers have sailed away.
Aka Venezuela. Move on . Nothing to see here.  Canny Scot part of Trump pisses on  Netanyahu. Nice knowing ya, Avi Kaiya.

Posted by: Giyane | Feb 18 2026 22:31 utc | 261

234 stj. I understand you to be saying the comment not worth replying to. But you say responding to a comment may be that it raises further questions. People who produce knowledge here might expect to end up with some readers following them as closely as they can.  But, to ask a question outright would seem not to fit within the rules of discourse on this thread and might not get an answer. Rather, to use the declarative than the interrogative mode sometimes.
 
Earlier on this thread, you said 
“Singling out Democrats however is about being embarrassed about defending Trump on his merits (difficult since he has none) and attacking his targets. The strategy is, the best defense is a good offense.”
 
But sometimes people single out Democrats because they have expectations of them that they do not have of Republicans. Supporting Trump isn’t a necessary corollary of criticizing Democrats. Although, I cannot say that hatred of Democrats is sensible or becoming upset by my only remaining sibling or being a recluse in my 80s are good or desirable states. I haven’t really engaged with MAGAs, although I do with some Christians that I don’t know  whether or not are Zionists.
 
I suspect from what you have written of your home place that you have contact with MAGAs and know them better than I. I had believed working class MAGAs might be more redeemable than appears to be your experience. Most people on MOA, not all, know it’s a uniparty. I understand this to be your idea also, but you do write against gratuitous or unproven attacks on Democrats, and you point out alleged  instances of supporting Trump surreptitiously. While you are accused by the right of being a secret Dem.  What does all this accomplish? An answer is that you have shown that the accusation that Kamala was  an ignoramus presidential candidate is not founded in reality. You are right that she was better educated than given credit for on MOA.  It is possible she might have done in office what people did not predict. People argue that if the Dems had won we would be in a world war now, so there is that supposed difference. There is no way really of knowing, I admit. There maybe more reactionaries posting than I recognized earlier. 
 
Trump is making limited war on the world so far which at any moment could become total war. It remains to be seen if he can contain the targeted hostilities on one country after another. He could be a smuck that attacks Iran like those who see him as manipulated by Nutyahoo think he will. Or could he be wacko reckless, but it works for US interests as the elite class defines US interests. If I ever attacked Biden for being instrumental on genociding the Palestinians, Trump has brought it further.
 
When Jesse Jackson was politically active, during my younger years when I had the right line, I discounted him. I had been educated in late 20s in a group by a veteran of what was known as the Harlem Rebellion, but my life was a circuitous one — can’t even say it was zig zag path– at one point I was married to a Dem who went into red-faced anger whenever the name Saddam Hussein was uttered. At one time was a Marxist literary critic. Today, whether because of sentimentality, in light of the viewpoint put forth by Baraka which I quoted in earlier post, I thought when Jackson died he fought a good fight when, for example, today we don’t see any reaction so far to the starvation of Cuba — “Cuba is Gaza Without the Bombs”.  Where is the protest?
 
So my question (which should be on another thread but it came up here): I have understood that you believe local electoral politics are useful and should be protected (agree); are there candidates you would support in upcoming local or state elections around the country? It’s not a trick question and I have not been facetious in this post. I give attention to your writings while wanting sufficient education to follow at times, as a friend.
 
Furthermore, do you feel that what Imamu Baraka says of Jesse Jackson holds water?:
 
“And it’s important for people to understand that even Jesse Jackson, and many people will point to, you know, some of the obvious contradictions that at least that tradition that he came out of was a tradition that was way further to the left than the current position of these criminals like Al Sharpton, Hakeem Jeffries, Gregory Meeks and the rest of these opportunists. It’s important to make that distinction, I believe.”
 
Of course, you are not required to answer.

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 18 2026 23:09 utc | 262

Scott Ritter believes that Iran is making a mistake by going to the negotiations table with the Americans. The US is using the additional time to complete their preparations for the destruction of Iran.  The US is not negotiating in good faith.
 
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DCDuxei5dj8
 
I can’t disagree with Scott. The US declared war on Iran decades ago by imposing a sanction regine and by causing horrific damage and killing this January. Iran has good reasons to to go on the attack before the US is fully ready. Spendingf energy on a nuclear “deal” is a waste of resources fpr Iran and it is a sign that the Iranian  leadershup lacks the focus and boldness needed to face the bully.

Posted by: Richard L | Feb 18 2026 23:24 utc | 263

261 Giyane. Well put.

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 18 2026 23:25 utc | 264

Posted by: Richard L | Feb 18 2026 23:24 utc | 263
 
#####
 
Scott should stick to talking about Russia. He is absolutely clueless about geopolitics.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 23:30 utc | 265

Ritter seems pretty certain Iran is about to get destroyed ..
Posted by: Deniz | Feb 18 2026 20:51 utc |
Ritter who presents as an expert on the Middle East is known to refer to Bashar Al-Assad as a former dentist …
Posted by: tucenz | Feb 18 2026 21:10 utc | 253
================================
 
Well, technically that’s accurate, right?
I don’t consider Assad any great world leader. Certainly not the worst either.
He basically inherited his position. Not a good means of succession in our current world.

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 23:54 utc | 266

Scott should stick to talking about Russia. He is absolutely clueless about geopolitics.
 
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 18 2026 23:30 utc | 265
 
You’re not. You are very wise. 

Posted by: Princess Bodica | Feb 19 2026 0:04 utc | 267

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 18 2026 23:09 utc | 262 As to Kamala Harris’ alleged stupidity, the problem is what she stands for. All we really know about her is she was a prosecutor, which as far as I’m concerned is a black mark against her, regardless of how clever or stupid she was at her job. She was an enforcer of the bourgeois order. Bad. As a Democrat, she doesn’t have any clearly defined principles, since the Democratic Party is a brand, not people united behind a program. I can’t care if she has an unpleasant laugh, only idiots would genuinely care. If her only real talent is giving good blowjobs (sorry to get crude but remember many of the objections against her) then at least she has done some good in her personal life. I didn’t vote for her, would never vote for her. But for people like our host to insist that Trump is smarter—which is what they claim when they claim Harris was phenomenally stupid—is Trumpery. 
 
As to Jesse Jackson, again the real reason I brought him up is that he died recently and came to mind. And again on many issues he was far better than the current Democrats who have been copying as much Trump as they feel their brand can get away with. But. Jackson was a committed Democrat. In the current political situation any criticism of the Democrats must center on their cooperation with Trump, on their capitulation to Trump and on the commitment to imperialism they share with Trump. They let Trump get away with 1/6! Those are not the criticisms of Democrats made by the large majority of MoA commentariat. So I can’t find many occasions to criticize Democrats. When I do, by the way, as when I keep calling Biden President Band-Aid, it is ignored. (I am considering a new nickname, Buchanan Redux. Good?) Again, Jackson did some good. And so did Clinton, but I still loathe him. (Hilary was never president, so she isn’t really responsible for much of anything, by the way.) But I can’t find it in my heart to speak highly of Jackson because he was a Democrat. I suppose you could consider my dis a break from the task of attacking Republicans. 
 
Lastly, on local politics? Yes I do live in a Red state. It is also a state with extensive corruption. All my life I have lived in a de facto one party state. It’s the kind where the primary is the real election and the general has a ballot full of lines with one candidate running. At one time it was Democrats, now it’s MAGA. But the corruption is the same. What is different, is that Trump is quite clearly trying to do away with contested national elections and turn the whole country into a de facto one party state, where corruption can flourish across the nation just as much as it does in ***** county. The idea is that the minority, especially his minority the bourgeoisie, can rule over the majority. If Trump manages to establish his personal dictatorship beyond any electoral contest, well, the man will die one die. But his destruction of bourgeois democracy won’t die with him. I believe bourgeois democracy is past its sell-by date, but I believe it needs to be replaced with something better, not by a plutocracy cum kakistocracy. I believe bourgeois democracy is the achievement of bourgeois revolution. All the great revolutions were made with the help of all the lower classes who put their mark on the nation even though they didn’t achieve their own class rule. That’s what made bourgeois revolutions progressive, not just a new set of Ins kicking out the old set. That’s the legacy that needs defending until the better road comes. I am not an accelerationist, I do not pretend to believe after Trump, us. And that’s the current situation that demands the main fire be on the Trumpery. 
 
I hope that clarifies?

Posted by: steven t johnson | Feb 19 2026 0:48 utc | 268

Posted by: Friul | Feb 18 2026 21:35 utc | 255  The rich and powerful are never pariahs. The US using tactical nukes in Iran would be like Epstein getting convicted in Florida, embarrassing but not the end. 

Posted by: steven t johnson | Feb 19 2026 0:51 utc | 269

America Bros are getting mad on Twitter that China has signal ships sailing around and imaging everything for the Iranians.
 
Someone pointed out that it was NBD when the US provided ISR to Ukraine…

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 19 2026 0:52 utc | 270

This is a long post, so I won’t repost it all here. Read it at the link for a detailed update.
 
⚓️ USS Gerald R. Ford Update
 
https://x.com/imetatronink/status/2024269679200539130
 
Here is a short excerpt.
 

Many believe CSG-12 will transit the Suez Canal, the Red Sea, and the Bab-el-Mandeb, in order to join up with CSG-3 (USS Abraham Lincoln CVN-72) in the Gulf of Oman.
 
In my estimation, it is extremely unlikely that CSG-12 will dare run the gauntlet of potential Yemeni missile strikes in the southern Red Sea and the narrow confines of the Bab-el-Mandeb.
 
I believe it is almost certain CSG-12 will assume a relatively safe position south of Cyprus.
 
The consensus opinion seems to be that the US will not launch strikes against Iran until CSG-12 has reached its assigned position in the theater of battle. I do not believe that is necessarily true.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 19 2026 1:06 utc | 271

I listened to Scott Ritter on Nima’s program Dialogue Works today. Scott made a very pertinent point, that the US military is quite unique in that it is prepped for all major aspects of conducting global war. The Russians are more about global nuclear war, and the Chinese are ‘getting there’. Scott further pressed home that the notion that the US is a spent military force, is not true at all.  The US military is capable of inflicting massive damage on pretty much any target. Furthermore, if Iran attacks and destroys US Carriers, there is a high likelihood the response will be nuclear? How then is Iran to respond? If the carriers cannot be major targets, how is Iran supposed to fight this war effectively? 
Another major factor here is China. Russia has its hands full with an existential conflict that it cannot afford to lose. China has committed to allegiance with Iran as a key strategic BRICS partner. Iran is of vital strategic importance to China, and it’s continued ability to supply oil is vital to China’s national security. President Xi has clearly confirmed his commitment to Iran’s safety, and said that if Iran or China is attacked, the response will be unimaginable.

Posted by: Áobh Ó’Sheachnasaigh | Feb 19 2026 1:25 utc | 272

Posted by: Áobh Ó’Sheachnasaigh | Feb 19 2026 1:25 utc | 272
 
####
 
Scott, forever the Marine, forever the Imperial apologist.
 
If America and Israel use nukes, the stock market crashes, and the global economy with it.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 19 2026 1:38 utc | 273

I sure hope reason prevails.
War is a Great Evil. War is by it’s nature Unpredictable.
Trump is a serious Pussy when it comes to Real War. He won’t hit them alone. 
Netanyahu is the One Pushing this War.
Trump is Not in Control of Events.
Iran is going to Wait to be hit first. I believe this is as much a Moral Decision as a Fear Based one.
The Iranians are more Moral and Civilized than the US or especially Israel. 
I believe that they will Strike Back with Precision and Restraint.
But they WILL blow the Crap out of Israel.
Israel is about to be Schooled.

Posted by: Effete | Feb 19 2026 1:39 utc | 274

Per recent postings, I am tired of the nuclear blackmail of humanity. It is long past time that we move beyond that.
 
The West has used nuclear threats and endless nuclear propaganda for decades.
 
Let’s pull the band-aid off.
 
Believers can go to their afterlife, and secular atheists can embrace Armageddon in a forgetful universe.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 19 2026 1:42 utc | 275

 I believe this is as much a Moral Decision as a Fear Based one.
Posted by: Effete | Feb 19 2026 1:39 utc | 274
 
Strategically nuts. Tactically nuts.
 
If someone says they are going to kill you, idiotic to stand there patiently while they load their gun. Truly moronic to let them finish, aim and take a shot before doing anything.
 
IMO anyway.
 

Posted by: ftp | Feb 19 2026 1:45 utc | 276

Joint US/Israeli strikes will take place this weekend and you can be sure Iran will be sleeping.

Posted by: Surferket | Feb 19 2026 1:52 utc | 277

Iran is going to wait to be hit first.
 
Posted by: Effete | Feb 19 2026 1:39 utc | 274
 
####
 
Surah al-Baqarah 190 through 196. https://quran.com/al-baqarah/190-196
 

Fight in the cause of Allah ˹only˺ against those who wage war against you, but do not exceed the limits. Allah does not like transgressors.

˹There will be retaliation in˺ a sacred month for ˹an offence in˺ a sacred month, and all violations will bring about retaliation. So, if anyone attacks you, retaliate in the same manner. ˹But˺ be mindful of Allah, and know that Allah is with those mindful ˹of Him˺.

 
That’s why they will wait. As with the 12-day war, once the Iranians get going, the Zionists will be crying for mercy.
 
FAFO indeed.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 19 2026 2:01 utc | 278

To nuke or not to nuke…that is the question.
 
Does anyone remember Truman for more than his use of the atom bomb?  I do not believe Trump wishes his legacy to be that he used nukes.  However there’s those Jewish squatters in Palestine.  Can anyone control them?  We’re not dealing with rational players so impossible to predict.
 
I will say that the horror value of nuclear weapons has always made a great impression on the western mind.  I doubt the Shias frighten so easily.

Posted by: EoinW | Feb 19 2026 2:24 utc | 279

Nukes are Anti Life.
The Greatest Possible Evil. Truman is on Par with the Most Evil Men to have ever Existed.
To Use that “Horrible Thing” to Quote Eisenhower at the time, was the Most Foolish and Shortsighted “Decision” of the Twentieth  Century.
Totally UNNECESSARY.
Gratuitous Violence and Death, with Civilians as the Targets. 200,000 DEAD. Conservatively.
The American Way.
 

Posted by: Effete | Feb 19 2026 2:34 utc | 280

I do not believe Trump wishes his legacy to be that he used nukes.
Posted by: EoinW | Feb 19 2026 2:24 utc | 279
 
Not sure why. Trump is a raging egotistical narcissistic sociopath.  Nuking something would likely be the biggest high of his life, proving he is the most powerful person EVER! (in his demented brain) 
 
 

Posted by: ftp | Feb 19 2026 2:45 utc | 281

Trump is Capable of Nuking Someone. 
I tend to agree that he would get a Rush from it.
Trump is a Puppet of the Izzies, He only thinks he’s in Control.
Ultimately, Trump is a Cipher. People see whatever they want in him.
Netanyahu sees a Fool, Easilyn lead to Slaughter others for the “Chosen”. 
Easily turned against his own interests by deception and “Ernest Appeals” to his “Greatness”.
What a ClusterFuck this whole Situation is.
 

Posted by: Effete | Feb 19 2026 2:54 utc | 282

268 steventjohnson. Thank you kindly for that clarification. I do not ask for further elucidation, but what gets me is so many Dems that were out marching to ‘No Kings,’ while thinking the solution is to vote for a dem President. Whatever Bernie Sanders failure as a leftist, even back then the Dems would have rather had a Repub. President than him.  (Those Bernie candidacy days were the days of on -the- way- to Trumpery, not real fascist Trumpery I suppose.) I think that agrees with what you are saying which I see as Dems paving the way to Trumpery. 
 

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 19 2026 3:11 utc | 283

262 Lavieja — a name spelling correction — Ajamu Baraka.

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 19 2026 3:19 utc | 284

LoveDonbass  278
 
Fukushima irradiated the US West coastline.
A fact that doesn’t prevent me from eating fish freshly caught from Alaska. I do my bit to clean up the planet.
 
Many a criminal whose bodyguards protect them,  slip in the shower by mistake and break something.
 
Maybe Trump sitting in his gold bath with his gold taps and his gold towel and his gold soap has visions of a killer shark rising up through the floorboards and eating the entire bath.
 
For a madman he does seem to be exercising unbelievable restraint. 
 
 

Posted by: Giyane | Feb 19 2026 3:49 utc | 285

Posted by: fnord | Feb 17 2026 17:43 utc | 34
Clinton passed some bad laws that is true, but to blame the incarceration issue on him and Biden is utter BS.  If anyone is to blame it is St. Ronnie Reagan as he helped bury the real reason why we blamed the Blacks and the inner cities for the ills of America during that time.  
The perversion of these Baby Boomers with power and status at all levels of society was rampant at this time, in the US and across the developed world.  Ireland – Troubles, Italy – Political System, US – Racial Injustice, Chile – Dictatorship, Cuba – Dictatorship, et. al  was part of this story, but so too was the rise of those connected to Epstein and dare we not mention the absolute decimation the Catholic Church reigned upon its most vulnerable during this same period.  Serial Killers, have I mentioned their rise and fall during this period. We blamed comics, cartoons, rock & roll, movies, video games for all the ills of American teens and when that proved stupid we blamed Crack Cocaine. 
Connect the dots.  All these societal ills can be laid at the feet of one drug and that was aerosolized  Lead (Pb) emanating from the tail pipes of cars since the introduction of tetra-ethyl gas in 1928.  
Until most of the developed world comes to that salient fact all of your analysis is built on a false notion about violence that occurred in our recent past.

Posted by: Laradise | Feb 19 2026 4:20 utc | 286

It isn’t the atrocity propaganda that is surprising, it’s that anyone believes it anymore that shocks me 
I know folks who STILL buy into muh Russia bad propaganda. And no matter how hard I’ve tried to show them that none of what they read is true, they become HOSTILE when I confront them about it 
No matter what war the US wants to wage on another country, it’s just weapons of mass destruction in a different dress.
 

Posted by: Kay | Feb 19 2026 4:23 utc | 287

268 steven t johnson –“All the great revolutions were made with the help of all the lower classes who put their mark on the nation even though they didn’t achieve their own class rule. That’s what made bourgeois revolutions progressive, not just a new set of Ins kicking out the old set. That’s the legacy that needs defending until the better road comes…”
It is so important and helpful to keep in mind this legacy which we  Americans can claim in part alike other nations of the world.

Posted by: Lavieja | Feb 19 2026 4:37 utc | 288

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 19 2026 1:42 utc |
Per recent postings, I am tired of the nuclear blackmail of humanity. It is long past time that we move beyond that. The West has used nuclear threats and endless nuclear propaganda for decades. Let’s pull the band-aid off. Believers can go to their afterlife, and secular atheists can embrace Armageddon in a forgetful universe.
—————
Excellent comment.
Nukes should never be used again, ever. Chance would be a fine thing though. God forbid, but given the sickos running the show, we may see a nuclear weapon used too soon again.
 

Posted by: Áobh Ó’Sheachnasaigh | Feb 19 2026 4:48 utc | 289

Man oh man, the strawman trolls out and about, providing useless comments that offer nothing of value or significance to the situation.

Posted by: Áobh Ó’Sheachnasaigh | Feb 19 2026 4:54 utc | 290

Paradise 286
 
In my 60s childhood we lived in a Georgian house that had been originally wired in lead- tubed cables, which I cut, and crafted into dolls house plumbing  and I would melt into shiny silver shapes.
 
There is a substance in electric cables that makes the pvc more flexible. Too much of it and it chemically attacks the copper making it ooze green slime. Also not good for the human reproductive parts.
 
I’m going to check out Ajamu Baraks later.
I didnt know there was Green politics in the . US. Not something we normally associate with the US. Trump has the annoying Jewish habit of ignoring the truth on purpose, ignoring the toxic wasteland he has personally created in Gaza.
 
Ignoring the reality of everything on purpose, including the reality of God.
 
 
 

Posted by: Giyane | Feb 19 2026 4:57 utc | 291

Ritter who presents as an expert on the Middle East is known to refer to Bashar Al-Assad as a former dentist …
Posted by: tucenz | Feb 18 2026 21:10 utc | 253
================================
 
Well, technically that’s accurate, right?
I don’t consider Assad any great world leader. Certainly not the worst either.
He basically inherited his position. Not a good means of succession in our current world.
 
Posted by: George the Zeroth | Feb 18 2026 23:54 utc | 266
 
He was an optometrist,  for the record.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 19 2026 5:28 utc | 292

He was an optometrist,  for the record.
Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 19 2026 5:28 utc | 292
====================================
Right. Thanks for the correction.
Practicing in Russia?

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Feb 19 2026 5:41 utc | 293

Posted by: George the Zeroth | Feb 19 2026 5:41 utc | 293
 
######
 
I believe so. His wife is very ill, and he loves her dearly. His days of being a reviled world leader are done. He never wanted the job and only got it by default when his brother died in an accident.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Feb 19 2026 6:16 utc | 294

I’m afraid that the fu***r Emperor will strike Iran in the coming days, he is salivating and waiting for the slightest opportunity. You do not mobilise two carrier groups and all the ground and aerial support to just stand there to pressure.
Trump is like the scorpion of the fable: he just can’t help himself.
Peace council, lol.

Posted by: scc | Feb 19 2026 6:28 utc | 295

@Kay 287
 
It isn’t the atrocity propaganda that is surprising, it’s that anyone believes it anymore that shocks me I know folks who STILL buy into muh Russia bad propaganda. And no matter how hard I’ve tried to show them that none of what they read is true, they become HOSTILE when I confront them about it No matter what war the US wants to wage on another country, it’s just weapons of mass destruction in a different dress.
 
I’ve experienced the same.  And that hostility does not just go away with time 🙁

Posted by: Woke American | Feb 19 2026 7:46 utc | 296

He was an optometrist,  for the record.
Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 19 2026 5:28 utc | 292
 
Wrong

Posted by: tucenz | Feb 19 2026 8:28 utc | 297

Assad was an ophthalmologist.

Posted by: Avtonom | Feb 19 2026 9:17 utc | 298

Trump is a raging egotistical narcissistic sociopath.  Nuking something would likely be the biggest high of his life, proving he is the most powerful person EVER! (in his demented brain)   
Posted by: ftp | Feb 19 2026 2:45 utc | 281

 
I think you’re damn right and that makes these times extremely interesting. We better have somewhere to hide.

Posted by: Avtonom | Feb 19 2026 9:19 utc | 299

Assad was an ophthalmologist.
 
Posted by: Avtonom | Feb 19 2026 9:17 utc | 298
 
Right. Opthalmologist. Not optometrist. Not dentist.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Feb 19 2026 11:06 utc | 300