|
Emmanuel Todd – ‘The Defeat Of The West’ In Its Current Phase
A few month ago I discussed Emmanuel Todd’s most recent book:
In 1976 the French anthropologist Emmanuel Todd predicted the down fall of the Soviet Union. In After The Empire, first published in French in 2001, he predicted the (relative) decline of the United States.
In his latest (and last) book, La Défaite de l’Occident (The Defeat of the West), he laments the West’s inability to distinguish facts from wishes, as seen in its behavior during the war in Ukraine. Nihilism, a lack of values and of acceptance of reality, has infested western thinking:
Trans ideology is therefore, in my opinion, one of the flags of this nihilism that now defines the West, this drive to destroy not just things and people but reality.
Todd recently opened a substack where he is posting speeches and talks he has given.
Todd has just published a new preface for his book in which he sheds light on the consequences of the West’s defeat in Ukraine.
Here are some excerpts with highlights added:
I have always been hostile to the Russophobic policies of the United States and Europe, but as a Westerner committed to liberal democracy, a Frenchman trained in research in England, the child of a mother who was a refugee in the United States during the Second World War, I am devastated by the consequences for us Westerners of the war waged without intelligence against Russia.
We are only at the beginning of the catastrophe. A tipping point is approaching, beyond which the ultimate consequences of defeat will unfold.
…
I now fear that our media will exacerbate our blindness by being unable to imagine Russia’s renewed prestige in the rest of the world, which has been exploited economically and treated with arrogance by the West for centuries. The Russians dared. They challenged the Empire and they won.
The irony of history is that the Russians, a European and white people who speak a Slavic language, have become the military shield of the rest of the world because the West refused to integrate them after the fall of communism.
…
I can sketch out here a model of the dislocation of the West, despite the inconsistencies of the policies of Donald Trump, the defeated American president. These inconsistencies do not result, I believe, from an unstable and undoubtedly perverse personality, but from an insoluble dilemma for the United States. On the one hand, their leaders, both in the Pentagon and the White House, know that the war is lost and that Ukraine will have to be abandoned. Common sense therefore leads them to want to get out of the war. But on the other hand, the same common sense makes them realise that the withdrawal from Ukraine will have dramatic consequences for the Empire that those from Vietnam, Iraq or Afghanistan did not have. This is indeed the first American strategic defeat on a global scale, in a context of massive deindustrialisation in the United States and difficult reindustrialisation.
…
Imperial dynamics, or rather imperial inertia, continue to undermine the dream of a return to the productive nation state.
In Europe, military defeat [in Ukraine] remains poorly understood by leaders.
…
Unaware of the extent of the military defeat, they do know, however, that their own economies have been paralysed by the sanctions policy, especially by the disruption of their supply of cheap Russian energy. Cutting the European continent in half economically was an act of suicidal madness.
…
A negative economic and social dynamic existed before the war and was already putting the West under strain. It was visible, to varying degrees, throughout Western Europe. Free trade is undermining the industrial base. Immigration is developing an identity syndrome, particularly among the working classes who are deprived of secure and properly paid jobs.
More profoundly, the negative dynamic of fragmentation is cultural: mass higher education creates stratified societies in which the highly educated – 20%, 30%, 40% of the population – begin to live among themselves, to think of themselves as superior, to despise the working classes, and to reject manual labour and industry. Primary education for all (universal literacy) had nurtured democracy, creating a homogeneous society with an egalitarian subconscious. Higher education has given rise to oligarchies, and sometimes plutocracies, stratified societies invaded by an unequal subconscious. The ultimate paradox: the development of higher education ended up producing a decline in intellectual standards in these oligarchies or plutocracies!
…
The war has raised European tensions a notch. It is impoverishing the continent. But above all, as a major strategic failure, it is delegitimising leaders who are incapable of leading their countries to victory.
…
One of the interesting features of America today is that its leaders are finding it increasingly difficult to distinguish between internal and external issues, despite MAGA’s attempt to stop immigration from the south with a wall. The army fires on boats leaving Venezuela, bombs Iran, enters the centres of Democratic cities in the United States, and sponsors the Israeli air force for an attack on Qatar, where there is a huge American base. Any science fiction reader will recognise in this disturbing list the beginnings of a descent into dystopia, that is, a negative world where power, fragmentation, hierarchy, violence, poverty and perversity intermingle.
So let us remain ourselves, outside America. Let us retain our perception of the inside and the outside, our sense of proportion, our contact with reality, our conception of what is right and beautiful. Let us not allow ourselves to be dragged into a headlong rush to war by our own European leaders, those privileged individuals lost in history, desperate at having been defeated, terrified at the idea of one day being judged by their peoples. And above all, above all, let us continue to reflect on the meaning of things.
I highly recommend to read, and reflect on, the whole essay.
war waged without intelligence against Russia.
Intelligence is skill in choosing attainable goals and achieving them. The point here is, whose goals? It may be no colonial empire or imperialist war conducted since the rise of capitalism (aka, modernity) has profited the aggressor nation as a whole. But the ruling classes?
The Russians dared. They challenged the Empire and they won.
Technically, this is untrue. The war on Russia is a hybrid war and it began even before 2014. Yeltsin can be seen as an agent of hybrid war against Russia. Russia has not surrendered and in the SMO it is openly resorting to arms. Nonetheless the SMO is a defensive move—that’s why it’s SMO instead of war. Further, the fighting isn’t over in the Ukrainian theater yet.
The irony of history is that the Russians, a European and white people who speak a Slavic language, have become the military shield of the rest of the world because the West refused to integrate them after the fall of communism.
This sounds like a reactionary moaning about how Christendom is split between Catholic and Orthodox and if only they hadn’t been religious bigots…The sense in which Russia is a shield depends on what’s left after it wins, which we don’t know yet. At the moment it is taking the brunt of military assaults by the imperialists. It is too soon to say that the US for one can not attack other countries because it is tied down in Russia, especially after the recent Iran miniwar. Russia is tied down in the Ukrainian theater.
… On the one hand, their leaders, both in the Pentagon and the White House, know that the war is lost and that Ukraine will have to be abandoned. ..But on the other hand, the same common sense makes them realise that the withdrawal from Ukraine will have dramatic consequences for the Empire
It is not yet clear whether the someday collapse of Ukraine will somehow end the hybrid war on Russia. My belief is that Russia has no aggressive intentions toward Europe at this time, so it isn’t clear what consequences for Europe of peace in the Ukrainian theater could be. The US currently is doing its best to make sure any financial consequences fall on Europe, while still driving to keep the dollar as the main reserve currency.
Imperial dynamics, or rather imperial inertia, continue to undermine the dream of a return to the productive nation state.
I am not sure what this could possibly mean. That the delusion of keeping the world in US finance capital’s grip (as it largely is now) keeps the US from a coherent foreign policy concentrating on Fortress America and a genuine reindustrialization policy? That’s not exactly what it says, to be sure.
Cutting the European continent in half economically was an act of suicidal madness.
Again, whose suicide? The European ruling classes who know they cannot win against the US? To mobilize their people for a national crusade would probably require more social welfare and higher pay and full employment for citizens (and immigrant workers with full rights to negotiate their pay.) But this is against the rulings class way of life! What to do?
mass higher education creates stratified societies in which the highly educated – 20%, 30%, 40% of the population – begin to live among themselves, to think of themselves as superior, to despise the working classes, and to reject manual labour and industry. Primary education for all (universal literacy) had nurtured democracy, creating a homogeneous society with an egalitarian subconscious. Higher education has given rise to oligarchies, and sometimes plutocracies, stratified societies invaded by an unequal subconscious. The ultimate paradox: the development of higher education ended up producing a decline in intellectual standards in these oligarchies or plutocracies!
When we are talking about such large segments of the population, we are talking about middle classes between the working classes and the ruling class, which is small enough to count as an oligarchy. In any event, Tod’s claim the educational system simultaneously breeds an egalitarian subconscious while the stratified societies they create simultaneously create an unequal subconscious. This novel flexibility needs some explanation, maybe even evidence? What I’m getting is a strong impression of aristocratic (or would-be aristocratic) contempt for the mediocre middle classes, the tasteless apes of their betters, etc.
The war has raised European tensions a notch. It is impoverishing the continent. But above all, as a major strategic failure, it is delegitimising leaders who are incapable of leading their countries to victory.
He wants legitimate leaders who can lead their countries to victory? The assumption that were it not for the war Europe would be prospering puts more faith in capitalism than I have. I think one powerful motive for imperialist gambles is the appalling problem of a long run decline in the rate of profit, a manifestation of the increasing obsolescence of capitalism.
descent into dystopia, that is, a negative world where power, fragmentation, hierarchy, violence, poverty and perversity intermingle.
Well, yes, that is what the continued domination of capitalism/imperialism—the two are coterminous, imperialism is a way of life for capitalists, not a policy—promises. Silence on this is like writing Hamlet without the Prince of Denmark.
Let us not allow ourselves to be dragged into a headlong rush to war by our own European leaders,
Again, the war against Russia has been ongoing for years. The Europeans are already in this hybrid war. There is no headlong rush as such. Russia is tied down in Ukraine and the EU nations don’t have their own militaries really, they are too closely integrated with NATO (and as I said, already fighting Russia.) There is not likely to be a major expansion of general, old fashioned war by Russia. The peril lies in adventures aimed at Transnistria/Moldove and Kaliningrad I think.
I gather Tod’s shtick is family structure, so I suppose such an idee fixe might mislead him to focus so heavily on trans issues. But in fact trans issues are not terribly important, however much the existence of such creatures terrorizes the Tods. Symbolically helping them with gestures about pronouns risks nothing but ridicule and the hostility of stooges who are already in the bag for reaction anyhow. Because those people who claim, no they aren’t advocating tormenting trans people conveniently forget that we know what they want to go back to. They want to go back to when trans were beaten up or even killed, harassed, etc. That’s the way things were (and still are to a depressing extent.) When they claim they just don’t want trans forced on them, despite the fact nothing of the sort is happening, that’s why they advocate. Pretense otherwise is merely diplomatic hypocrisy, aka simply lying.
Posted by: steven t johnson | Oct 7 2025 21:44 utc | 181
|