Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
October 7, 2025
Emmanuel Todd – ‘The Defeat Of The West’ In Its Current Phase

A few month ago I discussed Emmanuel Todd’s most recent book:

In 1976 the French anthropologist Emmanuel Todd predicted the down fall of the Soviet Union. In After The Empire, first published in French in 2001, he predicted the (relative) decline of the United States.

In his latest (and last) book, La Défaite de l’Occident (The Defeat of the West), he laments the West’s inability to distinguish facts from wishes, as seen in its behavior during the war in Ukraine. Nihilism, a lack of values and of acceptance of reality, has infested western thinking:

Trans ideology is therefore, in my opinion, one of the flags of this nihilism that now defines the West, this drive to destroy not just things and people but reality.

Todd recently opened a substack where he is posting speeches and talks he has given.

Todd has just published a new preface for his book in which he sheds light on the consequences of the West’s defeat in Ukraine.

Here are some excerpts with highlights added:

I have always been hostile to the Russophobic policies of the United States and Europe, but as a Westerner committed to liberal democracy, a Frenchman trained in research in England, the child of a mother who was a refugee in the United States during the Second World War, I am devastated by the consequences for us Westerners of the war waged without intelligence against Russia.

We are only at the beginning of the catastrophe. A tipping point is approaching, beyond which the ultimate consequences of defeat will unfold.
…
I now fear that our media will exacerbate our blindness by being unable to imagine Russia’s renewed prestige in the rest of the world, which has been exploited economically and treated with arrogance by the West for centuries. The Russians dared. They challenged the Empire and they won.

The irony of history is that the Russians, a European and white people who speak a Slavic language, have become the military shield of the rest of the world because the West refused to integrate them after the fall of communism.
…
I can sketch out here a model of the dislocation of the West, despite the inconsistencies of the policies of Donald Trump, the defeated American president. These inconsistencies do not result, I believe, from an unstable and undoubtedly perverse personality, but from an insoluble dilemma for the United States. On the one hand, their leaders, both in the Pentagon and the White House, know that the war is lost and that Ukraine will have to be abandoned. Common sense therefore leads them to want to get out of the war. But on the other hand, the same common sense makes them realise that the withdrawal from Ukraine will have dramatic consequences for the Empire that those from Vietnam, Iraq or Afghanistan did not have. This is indeed the first American strategic defeat on a global scale, in a context of massive deindustrialisation in the United States and difficult reindustrialisation.
…
Imperial dynamics, or rather imperial inertia, continue to undermine the dream of a return to the productive nation state.

In Europe, military defeat [in Ukraine] remains poorly understood by leaders.
…
Unaware of the extent of the military defeat, they do know, however, that their own economies have been paralysed by the sanctions policy, especially by the disruption of their supply of cheap Russian energy. Cutting the European continent in half economically was an act of suicidal madness.
…
A negative economic and social dynamic existed before the war and was already putting the West under strain. It was visible, to varying degrees, throughout Western Europe. Free trade is undermining the industrial base. Immigration is developing an identity syndrome, particularly among the working classes who are deprived of secure and properly paid jobs.

More profoundly, the negative dynamic of fragmentation is cultural: mass higher education creates stratified societies in which the highly educated – 20%, 30%, 40% of the population – begin to live among themselves, to think of themselves as superior, to despise the working classes, and to reject manual labour and industry. Primary education for all (universal literacy) had nurtured democracy, creating a homogeneous society with an egalitarian subconscious. Higher education has given rise to oligarchies, and sometimes plutocracies, stratified societies invaded by an unequal subconscious. The ultimate paradox: the development of higher education ended up producing a decline in intellectual standards in these oligarchies or plutocracies!
…
The war has raised European tensions a notch. It is impoverishing the continent. But above all, as a major strategic failure, it is delegitimising leaders who are incapable of leading their countries to victory.
…
One of the interesting features of America today is that its leaders are finding it increasingly difficult to distinguish between internal and external issues, despite MAGA’s attempt to stop immigration from the south with a wall. The army fires on boats leaving Venezuela, bombs Iran, enters the centres of Democratic cities in the United States, and sponsors the Israeli air force for an attack on Qatar, where there is a huge American base. Any science fiction reader will recognise in this disturbing list the beginnings of a descent into dystopia, that is, a negative world where power, fragmentation, hierarchy, violence, poverty and perversity intermingle.

So let us remain ourselves, outside America. Let us retain our perception of the inside and the outside, our sense of proportion, our contact with reality, our conception of what is right and beautiful. Let us not allow ourselves to be dragged into a headlong rush to war by our own European leaders, those privileged individuals lost in history, desperate at having been defeated, terrified at the idea of one day being judged by their peoples. And above all, above all, let us continue to reflect on the meaning of things.

I highly recommend to read, and reflect on, the whole essay.

Comments

Western Civilization has not been defeated. Western Civilization is disintegrating. What Todd calls nihilism, Toynbee called the schism in the soul. Abandon, truancy, drift, promiscuity describe the power elites response to social and environmental problems. Problems primarily caused by the capitalist political economy, which has led to the stratification of society Todd ascribes to mass higher education. A problem that was not evident until Supply Side/neoliberalism/Reaganism was imposed on the West in the 1980’s. Archaism and Futurism are identified by Toynbee as two traits of a disintegrating civilization. ‘Make America great again’ could not better express the archaism which has taken hold of the decrepit American imagination. Todd expresses his own nostalgia for an American that welcomed his refugee mother. An America whose mass higher education created the conditions for a world order based on multilateral governance, open markets, free global trade, human rights, and respect for sovereignty in 1945, but which was immediately abandoned to pursue global supremacy. The quest for the singularity of AI represents the futurist ideology of the technocratic billionaires, who ignore solving the social problems caused by their paleotechnic ideology of supremacy. Todd, as represented in the quotations in this post, appears susceptible to the contemptible morals of the righteous priests who always make an appearance during the fall of civilizations. The ideals of civil liberty are only viewed as nihilistic by those who already suffer a schism in their souls.      

Posted by: Keme | Oct 7 2025 16:39 utc | 101

 

To put trans and climate change at the same level is completely nuts.

 
Interestingly, this is precisely what a climate change denier would say. 

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 16:41 utc | 102

Posted by: Femi | Oct 7 2025 11:22 utc | 32
 
Descriptive post, who pays the clowns for their antics?
 
More transphobia from MoA.
Posted by: Ts | Oct 7 2025 10:41 utc | 20
 
Have you ever thought why most people consider cross dressers creepy AF?

Posted by: jopalolive | Oct 7 2025 16:42 utc | 103

I suggest Warwick Powell’s latest, “America Against Itself, redux.” 
Posted by: karlof1 | 89
 
Thanks karlof1

Posted by: NotPaulHollywood | Oct 7 2025 16:43 utc | 104

Anyone looking at the world around them will notice that the return of the most vulgar form of liberalism and individualism- neo-liberalism- coincided with the maturing, in the western world, of the baby boom’s cohort of university graduates. 
 
 
Posted by: bevin | Oct 7 2025 16:31 utc | 99
 
Excellent point.  

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Oct 7 2025 16:45 utc | 105

Maybe a little Cultural Revolution. Put those information processors out in the fields for a few years. 
For the salesmen, a little bs, used judiciously, greases the skids. Though over used and the positive feedback quickly turns negative. Then getting the computers to do it, just puts it in overdrive. 
For us mechanics, trying to make sense of how it works, a rag and some bleach is necessary to cut through the bs.

Posted by: John Merryman | Oct 7 2025 16:46 utc | 106

@Samber 5
Quote -Dig deep enough into any Western catastrophe and you will find a member of the “Tribe” at the centre of it. It has been thus since the Napoleonic wars.
Nope.
Dig superficially and deep into any conflict that leads to major war, and you will find the dirty hands of English men and women.
Corrected you .
Dig deep enough into any Western catastrophe and you will find a member of the “Tribe” at the centre of it. It has been thus since the Napoleonic wars
Posted by: Sambar | Oct 7 2025 9:11 utc | 5
 
 
Posted by: Sambar | Oct 7 2025 9:11 utc | 5
 
 
The English strategy is to involve others like USA and even Europeans to destabilise other nations through any means so that leader of such nations will flee with stolen money to london on which depends the money laundering economy of enlgand –real pirate which must be killed now.
The strategy has always been to make countries unstable and ungovernable. Subjected to internal/external conflict/aggression till they are weakened to accept handing over effective power, control to the new world criminals. You only have to look at the template being used in various countries in the world,
“Nato”
There is a confusion among many that USA uses Nato exert her influence in Europe. In fact USA does not need nato . But that entity is needed by a third rate country which after second world war found herself without real power so nato was created by that country to keep Germans down and Russians out using American arms and money.. Since early 90s that same country manoeuvred to keep Nato alive and install her stooges in European commission like british spy barrasso and English pirate witch cathertine ashton and many more inside European beaurocracy to make Europe follow one and only one policy to be dictated by that same country.
Name of the evil country? Of course it is england the centre of money laundering and all spying in the world and most evil entity in the history of wo
rld.

Posted by: sam | Oct 7 2025 16:49 utc | 107

Considering the extent of the disaster(at battle of Auterlitzs and of Ulm before that in 1805 instigated by england with money stolen from India), The Austrian Emperor said
 
“THE ENGLISH ARE DEALERS OF HUMAN FLESH, THEY PAY OTHERS TO FIGHT AT THEIR PLACE”.
 
The Emperor forgot to mention that the payment is from the victim or some other pople’s wealth.
 
And English are too coward to fight on their own-they have never won a single war on their own since boar war in 1899 and that too with all resources of loot from empire.
 
The English are at this game even now-they now use American arms to further htier agenda-nato was created by them for them.
Isn’t it interesting to watch how the English pirate nation contrives to manipulate by greed, deception and duplicity, the vulnerable in the world.
 
Russia would be foolish to take lightly the danger of england-sooner that country is destroyed better it is for the humanity it is a pestilence of the clone subhumans which we call English nation.,better it is elimninated sooner rather than late..
Josef Stalin during Great Patriotic war said “the Americans and British will fight the Nazi’s to the last drop of Russ
ian blood” 
 

Posted by: sam | Oct 7 2025 16:50 utc | 108

Who resurrected nato? 
 
The Syrian Arab Army was on a roll and ready to take back Idlib but were stopped by Putin to appease Anglos. 
Moreover in the February of 2916 Syrian army was on verge of big victory but then Russian ambassador to UNO Mr Churchin said harsh words about president Assad pressing him for ceasefire. That traitor churchin was man of foreign minister Lavrov the traitor. Then Lavrov started calling Assad names and Putin announced falsely that mission was accomplished and that russian job was finished therefore Russian Army will go back to Russia, so in this way Putin stopped win of Syria just to please anglosaxons in the same way he had stopped massacre of British mercenaries in the enclave of Debalso in Donbass in Feb 2015.
Putin today is getting return of his treachery to his allies .
 
In the same way that sergie Lavrov pressurised then Russian president Medvedev to backstab president Gaddafi and leave Libya to be sanctioned and destroyed by Anglo pirates. This way Lavrov dog singularly resuscitated the then moribund NATO 

Posted by: sam | Oct 7 2025 16:51 utc | 109

The only elections the anglosaxon controlled so called West respects are the elections they control.
“afganistan”
By what right are the british english coward troops are in afgansitan? 
Even after the ouster of Taliban the then govt. of afgansitan(installed by west) refused to allow the british troops to enter and stay in Afghanistan. But british pressure on America made sure that british troops were allowed there in Kabul. 
Since then coward british English troops many times bribed Taliban with money pleading with Taliban not to attack british troops_the implication being that other nato troops can be attacked.!
Mind you it was the british who created Taliban in the first place where ever is rotten smell you find the English rotten scu
mbags

Posted by: sam | Oct 7 2025 16:52 utc | 110

Sergie Lavrov is the problem and not a solution. He single handedly resurrected when he induced the then president madvedev to go against Gaddafi in Libya and gave new lease of life to NATO.He talks sot of no substance.
Foreign ministry is to promote nations interest -in his long useless unelected poison. He has been utter failure in getting any resolution passed in Russia’s favour.
 
Lavrov and pesko are British agents inside Kremlin and Putin is too lazy to change such people in 15 years!!
 
Russia should fire the entire Foreign Ministry. And this is a HISTORICAL MEME by now, Russian diplomats ALWAYS give away shit that the military wins.
Lavrov made some ridiculous statement re: Syria about following some worthless U.N. resolution, totally clueless. This is a huge defeat for Russia on the international stage, BRICS and any claimed multi-polarity have correspondingly just lost a shit-ton of momentum. I have lost faith in Putin and Russia to make any difference in our chaotic world, Mordor is wi
nning.

Posted by: sam | Oct 7 2025 16:53 utc | 111

Posted by: Laguerre | Oct 7 2025 13:07 utc | 47
A very partisan  and simplistic take on Cyprus ,Laguerre. I consider myself a bit of a fan of the Cyprus Wars as it was a practise-session of US/NATO preying on vassals and using jihadism to break up Europe.
Northern Cyprus being independent is a figleaf. Noone believes this. Not the UN, not any nation, not the common people in any nation. Most Turks in-fact rightly believe it is now defacto like the Golan Heights, which is only now de jure annexed to Israel ,well at least to the US and Israel.
 
As for the DNA of the Greeks I suggest you read some of the latest  technical journals. The Greeks to this day are almost all the same as the Minoans and other Helladic persons (Aegean Island people of the time).  The Slavs strangely left very little imprint.
 
Now as for the Turks, well the majority of Turks have been proven to be nothing but renegade Greeks/Armenians/Assyrians  who turned Muslim  , mostly by forced-Islamisisation. Too few Central Asians invaded to make a difference and historical data and DNA analysis proves this to the day.
 
As for invading  Cyprus from Greece? So what ? Are you saying the island could not have self-determination? That the minority (Turks) should rule in Cyprus? Should Germany or Holland become Muslim because  less than twenty percent of its population is Muslim? In any case, Turkey also had proven designs on the island and the documents and UK whistleblowers show that Turkey invaded  Cyprus in league with the US and the UK. They couldn’t have a Neutral  in the Med , but like every nation now has to swear fealty to the US now. It is not  enough to be Neutral, you must be “with us or against us” See Bush the Shrub.
 
Even if your position is that the invasion of Cyprus was warranted ,why are the Turks still there? Why have they more soldiers there , than any US base has troops in Korea etc? Conquest, pure and simple just as Turkey has done in Iraq ,parts of Libya and Syria. It was until only 2009 pals with Israel , and matches its history and foreign policy in almost every way. Pals from 1947 and even earlier if we  consider Jews. No Laguerre, you are mistaken.
 
 

Posted by: Recently updated | Oct 7 2025 16:59 utc | 112

“Once upon a time, a great statesman like Putin named Otto von Bismarck was replaced as chancellor by Wilhelm II. ”
@Stierlitz | Oct 7 2025 12:59 utc | 46
Indeed and the Prince of Wales being Wilhem’s relative flattered the inexperienced Wilhelm and apparently made him oust Bismarck.
The offcial narrative was about Bismarck being too conservative but the real reason was probably Britains geopolitical aims. Bismarck had got rid of British liberalism and practised Friedrich List’s recepy for national economy. In addition Bismarck wanted to avoid a war with Russia. Bismarck gone and Houston Chamberlain working the Germans against both jews and Russians and Britains wanted war would come

Posted by: petergrfstrm | Oct 7 2025 17:00 utc | 113

guess team hasbara is trying a full court press on dissing Russia/Putin.
 
they aren’t sending us their best these days. LOL 

Posted by: exile | Oct 7 2025 17:00 utc | 114

John Merryman @105
 
Yes, the Cultural Revolution wasn’t about punishment, as so many in the West believe. It was about treating the alienation inherent in capitalist society among those who would define themselves as elite. China’s President Xi was a recipient of that treatment, and he was cured and made a better human being by it. 
While there were some excesses in the Cultural Revolution, it was overall a positive thing for Chinese society. 

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 17:00 utc | 115

Posted by: sam | Oct 7 2025 16:53 utc | 110
What a ridiculous post.
Are you on hallucinogens?

Posted by: canuk | Oct 7 2025 17:08 utc | 116

More transphobia from MoA.
Posted by: Ts | Oct 7 2025 10:41 utc | 20
 
Have you ever thought why most people consider cross dressers creepy AF?
 
Posted by: jopalolive | Oct 7 2025 16:42 utc | 102
 
Try to resist taking the trans bait.  They just want us to have an unproductive divisive fight.  That’s why the ruling class spawned the “trans community” in the first place.  I actually pity those poor souls, tied to tightly to the genocidal, Imperialist Dems.  Many must have believed it was an organic development.  

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Oct 7 2025 17:09 utc | 117

guess team hasbara is trying a full court press on dissing Russia/Putin.
 
they aren’t sending us their best these days. LOL 
 
Posted by: exile | Oct 7 2025 17:00 utc | 113
 
Poor devils.  They have an impossible task.  

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Oct 7 2025 17:10 utc | 118

Interestingly, this is precisely what a climate change denier would say. 
Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 16:41 utc | 101

Or someone who thinks trans are a microphenomenon and climate change a world issue.

Posted by: xiao pignouf | Oct 7 2025 17:16 utc | 119

Oldhippie 55,
 
An excellent piece of writing.  It’s always risky speaking for the dead, that said, I feel pretty certain Samuel Clemens would approve after some cursive editing…just to make sure you knew he both read and enjoyed your work.
 
John Brewster 98,
 
Nice one, particularly: “One of the things that signifies our current paralysis for me is the omnipresence of store muzak from the 1960s. When I was a kid in the 1960s, no one was playing tunes from 1900”  That bugs me to no end too…I listen mainly to Jazz, post Miles although, I do have a thing for alt 90-00’s pop music so, I’m kinda guilty of the same thing but, constantly listening to 60 year old pop music is creepy.
 
Also I agree, I think Viet Nam was a watershed event, not the defeat itself but, how the duplicity of the whole war tore US society to shreds.  Oldhippie refers to himself as a draft-dodger, he wasn’t* and he has BoP number to prove it.  However, from my perspective, the whole idea that only lower/working-class has to serve in wars instigated by the upper-most class is socially corrosive and the “volunteer-army” has only reinforced that societal inequality.  The wholesale hypocrisy of the credentialed-class created a resentment that lasts to this day.
 
*My older brother is fair representative of the credentialed-class, ever so clever, he used fake X-rays to dodge the draft.  Then, some twenty years later, berated me for not being enthusiastic enough during my activation/deployment to Gulf War 1.0.  It seems once the danger had passed, my sibling became ardently pro-war along with most other draft-dodgers [again, I note again, those who didn’t “dodge” but took the punishment are not “draft-dodgers” as they dodged nothing].

Posted by: S Brennan | Oct 7 2025 17:17 utc | 120

America is a European oligarchic creation, the elites of Europe to this day relay on the US, first as slavocracy and then as that industrial “republic” where all European elites, regardless of language, history, ethnicity, indeed politics, can invest their personal and corporate fortunes without the complexities of language, history, ethnicity, politics, and risk of revolution. There can be no other reason why the American republic was not snuffed out in its cradle other than the fact that it has been upwards of two centuries the protected and preferred child of European oligarcics and dynasts tout court, regardless of their country of origin.

Posted by: Ludovic | Oct 7 2025 17:18 utc | 121

@58 Call it what u will

“But in reality, public schooling, especially in its compulsory form…”

To quote…

‘If children belong to the state, why are they telling parents what to do with them ?’

In reality, in many countries, the laws are just a means to take children from their family, friends and surroundings, and give them away to unknown others.

This causes a perpetual state of fear for many parents.

The state does not believe in family, and education has become a tool of state control and intervention.

Posted by: Ornot | Oct 7 2025 17:18 utc | 122

guess team hasbara is trying a full court press on dissing Russia/Putin. they aren’t sending us their best these days. LOL 
Posted by: exile | Oct 7 2025 17:00 utc | 113
 
LOL but what if they are “sending us their best”?
 
Doesn’t speak well of them, does it? LOL

Posted by: Nooneuknow | Oct 7 2025 17:26 utc | 123

Posted by: DunGroanin | Oct 7 2025 11:18 utc | 29
 
Zioproject  indeed. Luna is part Mexican and Mayerhofer was Catholic. She was raised Catholic , BUT she was infected by this pernicious form of Protestantism called “ Evangelicalism “ which is basically “the religion of sucker Christians who abase themselves to Zionism” .
The so-called Messianic Christians are  Jews either fronting as Christians to gain followers for Judaism by crook , or actual progressive and /or disaffected Jews who wish to engage with. Christianity. The saddest lot are the Judahites! They are foolish ex-Christians who take on all the beliefs and responsibilities of the slaves of the Jews in the Old Testament. None of the benefits mind you .They are the gimps. Read up in the Old Testament of the people who lived amongst the Jews as their servants or slaves. Nit their enemies mind you , like the Amorites and Moabites etc. These Judahites are taking the world by storm,especially in South America. 
Although secular, I fear for the Western people and Christianity.  This American poison of Christian Zionism will be the death of us all.  I wish the Anglicans , Baptists , Catholics and others would just agree to see the danger,  but I guess ethnic rivalries, and paid politicians will never allow a willing-Russia to unite back with them.  That is why I hope Russia and the Chinese fight the US/Israel to a standstill if not  an outright defeat. I am selfish and want Welfare Capitalism and the Mixed Economy back.

Posted by: Recently updated | Oct 7 2025 17:28 utc | 124

While we are waiting for more war that seems inescapable (if nothing else because it is willed by some)…
 
A small remark going in another direction.
 
By destruction of reality he (as I see it) means destruction of the concept of reality as known in the form of the system of interpretation as (thought to be) reflected in a (previous) social and political consensus. It is a problem of a lack of shared comprehension that might not ever have actually existed to the extent assumed.
 
This is why it hits so hard when the lies fall, when one has to readjust that what one thought was shared was not in fact shared.
 
It is similar to the grief of loss when a close relationship breaks down or is betrayed, it is unavoidably consequential even if denied or poorly understood.
 
“The west” has had many such moments during this century alone. Gaza is the latest.
 
Not everyone shares the grief. Some want what is happening (some of those again may not understand what it is or signifies), some find it irrelevant. Personally I miss what was meant to be and I also recognize that others quite different to me must have felt the same when for example the Soviet Union disassembled, or before it did so conclusively (depending on personal experience perhaps all the way to the start, likewise for “the west” and any others). Some are unburdened of their illusions earlier than others.
 
Appropriate and mostly “spoken word” (this is surprisingly a remix, surprising when/if you listen to the original which I’m sure they have somewhere as well):
“My Choices Are Not My Own (feat. Tawiah, May Kaspar) (Throwing Snow Remix)”
Text URL:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yDuU6wjucd0
 
The title is ambiguous imo, or at least multilayered, maybe intentionally so.
 

Posted by: Sunny Runny Burger | Oct 7 2025 17:38 utc | 125

Karlof1 “the pursuit of financial wealth at the expense of all other drives is the basis for the 100% ruination of the Collective Western Empire, and it began during the late 19th Century in England.”
Enjoy your writing, but oftentimes it seems you go off the rails with your Capt Queeg type obsession with WASP dominance.
Millions of years ago, the first proto humans realized it was much more advantageous (continuity of family, clan, tribe) to focus on war rather than husbandry.
Why not compel a neighboring troop to hunt, gather and attend to your needs simply by overmatching and defeating them under force of arms?
Who “won” (reproduced) under this arrangement, and who invented conditions, terms, explanations, excuses (aka moral code) for their defeat and servitude?
The only countervailing force against power is superior force. This is what we are witnessing play out in high relief right here, right now.
Good, bad, right, wrong has nothing to do with it; those that view events (and use that language) through those filters were trained to accept their caste position.

Posted by: Markw | Oct 7 2025 17:39 utc | 126

In the months after Euromaidan, Obama assigned to Joe the role of viceroy to Ukraine.   The Vice Presidenttraveled to Kiev in December 2015 in that capacity to meet with leaders of Poroshenko’s government and to deliver a warning against “the cancer of corruption.”  During an address to the Rada,  Joe condemned the “pervasive poison of cronyism, corruption, and kleptocracy.”
 
But behind the scenes, Ukrainian officials expressed “bewilderment and disappointment” that Joe had crossed the Atlantic “almost exclusively to deliver a generic speech.”  Officials close to then-President Poroshenko had hoped for guidance “in support of or against specific officials within the Ukrainian government.”  They discovered instead that Joe “had no intention of discussing substantive matters” and as far as his viceroy role was concerned he was simply mailing it in.
 
Members of the Poroshenko administration “privately mused” at how American media treated “the alleged ties” of Joe’s family “to corrupt business practices in Ukraine.” It was, in their minds, “evidence of a double standard within the United States Government towards matters of corruption and political power.”
 
No kidding, right-?
 
Poroshenko’s Ukraine was not far enough down the primrose path yet in 2015 to realize that there never would be any primroses at all, just a path framed eventually by open graves.

 

Obama’s CIA bluntly determined in 2016 that publishing such intel from Kiev would have been a humiliating assessment for Joe, whom President Obama had entrusted with all things Ukraine.  They ran the report by Joe;  Joe and his team killed the report.
 
Fast forward to October 2025,, w/ DJT’s CIA in charge:  the buried report and the accompanying correspondence from Joe’s team have come to light.  They are the latest tranche of documents declassified by CIA Director John Ratcliffe as DJT’s admin continues its review of Russiagate and how Russiagate fed ultimately into Project Ukraine.
 
Surfacing suppressed information about Project Ukraine, concealed within the depths of the Obama admin, is an example of how a reckoning w/ reality can find some sunshine amid a culture of lies.  In light of Todd’s essay, it seems a concomitant audit of the EU would need to come about, helmed by European eager-beavers like Director Ratcliffe, in order to unearth the earliest of Project Ukraine’s deceitful underpinnings:  who was being protected, and when-?
 
Smart Europeans who always saw through the lies and never signed on for the fallacious narratives are poised to bring the bloc into the disinfecting sunshine.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Oct 7 2025 17:41 utc | 127

May I say something about that trans issue. Does anyone remember Rachel Carson’s seminal book «Silent Spring»? In it, she tells about an insane amount of pesticides pouring into the great lakes in the 50’s. And then she discovered a lot of fish there turning hermaphroditic. There were other wildlife anomalies as well. But let’s focus on this one.
 
The fact is, we know there are people genuinely being gender-confused and trans, and most of them (like most UFOs, lol) are in America. Lots of these people, perhaps the majority, also suffer from psychiatric issues (extreme self-indulging being one of the most visible treats).
 
It wouldn’t, IMO, be surprising if one day scientists find that environmental pollutants, which there is such an abundance of, and has been for near a century, can cause extreme sexual deviations including transsexuality.
 
With this possibility (even probability) in mind, I think it’s neither productive nor humane to target those unfortunate individuals – while we can still adequately be critical of the phenomenon.

Posted by: Avtonom | Oct 7 2025 17:43 utc | 128

 exile | Oct 7 2025 17:00 utc | 113—
 
I’ve heard that the pay per posting is up as high as $7K, so we get inundated by greedy trolls that as usual have no real substance, just invective. The attempt to divert the thread into a discussion about Doctorow’s reporting followed up by sam’s crap is one prime example. I wonder if any of them really know what the current major issue is that’s being discussed. I do know what Lavrov said today to an interesting discussion group, the Second International Symposium “Creating the Future:”
 

Your intellectual gathering is being established as a useful platform for an open discussion of the prospects for the development of mankind for decades to come. The key to success is the participation of prominent representatives of business, expert, scientific and academic circles, the public from dozens of countries.
I am glad that this time the program of the event is very rich. It is necessary to “look beyond the horizon” on a wide range of issues – from high technology to demographic and social transformations. In this regard, I would like to note in particular your attempts to predict the future of international relations. Obviously, it is closely linked to the ongoing formation of a more just multipolar world order that reflects the cultural and civilisational diversity of the peoples of the world and their right to decide their own destiny.
I am convinced that the discussions will be held in a constructive manner and will contribute to the promotion of international humanitarian cooperation.

 
 
Both Lavrov and Putin will retire from active government participation in 2030, although Lavrov may depart before then seeing that he’s 75 already. Ryabkov is his #2 and now at 65 will replace him. IMO, the #3 is Vasily Nebenzya, although he too is now 63. It’s easier to watch the younger set within the government’s ministries and regions, but difficult to see who might be the new faces at the Foreign Ministry. I’ve thought Maria Zakharova qualified, but don’t know if she wants the position. Nebenzya has some very capable deputies at the UN. Do note that the only grumbling related to Putin is about the SMO, not how Russia is being governed or the path it’s on now and the ambitious future goals Putin has presented–and how to get there. The Liberal faction in Russia is still alive despite being completely outplayed by Putin. The United Russia vehicle will rule for many decades precisely because it puts people first. 
 

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 7 2025 17:45 utc | 129

What we are seeing is simply the United States dropping any remaining pretense of being a democracy, a republic, anything other than an empire. 
 

Posted by: Feral Finster | Oct 7 2025 17:46 utc | 130

German military industry has indeed seen impressive growth since 2023. According to some indicators, it has reached 20% year-on-year. This growth is based on significant investments in production of weapons and munitions, a significant portion of which has already been sent and will continue to be sent to the “Eastern Front.”
The average growth rate of German military production in August exceeded 1.6%. This means that it will remain at the same 20% (more or less) by the end of the year.
But if overall German industrial performance were to decline by another 0.8%, despite significant growth in the military-industrial sector, this can only mean one thing: the civilian sector of German industry, which has always been the driving force of the entire EU, has fallen by more than 1% in a month. On an annual basis, it could therefore “decline” by 10-12%, which represents a simply unthinkable collapse for German industry and the economy as a whole.

Slavyangrad telegram

Posted by: Jo | Oct 7 2025 17:58 utc | 131

Markw | Oct 7 2025 17:39 utc | 125—
 
Thanks for your reply. Which system of social organization is ascendent today? It’s the collectivist, mutualist, people promoting systems, not the greedy, individualistic, divide and rule oligarchy run by the Filthy Rich–the war makers from your paradigm. It’s been noted that cooperation not competition drives Nature’s success, and so it also is with Humanity. Today, cooperation is leading while competition ironically is falling behind because it can’t compete. And as with the Tar Baby, the harder it tries to compete the further behind it falls because it’s entangled in its own mess As for WASPs, they made their own bed and reaping the results.    

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 7 2025 17:59 utc | 132

What we are seeing is simply the United States dropping any remaining pretense of being a democracy, a republic, anything other than an empire. 
 
 
Posted by: Feral Finster | Oct 7 2025 17:46 utc | 129
 
Good point.  It’s been a soaked in blood Imperialism for over a century at least.  This is just the breaking point when the mask falls and the hideous visage smirks at you.  

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Oct 7 2025 18:04 utc | 133

Ah the trans issue. 
 
Topical but as another poster says, trans is only like 1/10 of 1% but certainly a very vocal minority. 
 
I proceed from the initial observation that the people walking around in the city and going to school and saying that are trans are some of the most pathetic people you will ever meet. 
 
Utterly lacking any kind of intimidating physicality or ability to project an inward confidence in their personhood, I can not help but soften my voice when dealing with them, like I would a kindergartner, lest I commit a microaggression sending them spiraling into tears and diving into the nearest intersex bathroom.
 
We all know this to be true. And so do they. 
 
And I say this out of the utmost respect of their deep, abiding personhood: I want them to feel the love of God, just as I long also to feel secure in my personhood that is constantly threatened by TPTB and its lies.
 
At some point, these people were so utterly alone and with such a sense of rejection by their parents, their friends, and society, that they could not resist the temptation of a clean break with this self. A clean break from the liberal Calvinist Dogma that states, “Some people are just born to lose.”
 
When I was traveling through a deep depression at the outset of my 40s after being fired from my career for refusing the vaccine, my father-in-law told me that I needed to put on the spiritual armor. What immediately comes to mind is Kierkegaard’s quote that for the one starving for food, reading Hegel was like being gifted a cookbook.
 
I did not need to put on anything to deflect the blows of a hostile world that makes objects of people; what everyone needs is the realized notion of a loving God within you that answers when you call. 
 
My mother-in-law gave me better advice: “You know, talk to God, he’s your bud.”
 
Our thrownness makes it so we can not choose our family, our society, our race, our socioeconomic condition at birth. Our sex. For the effeminate male or the masculine female, the path to walk seems tailor-made for scapegoating by a society that has no access to its authentic Dasein and so needs the people on the margins as target practice when the powerful are confounded in the mouth of the abyss.
 
We detest anxiety. We are relieved to see other’s blood shed because we imagine ourselves to be right with the Gods. On their side. The side of the powerful forces that govern all fate beyond the veil.
 
Indeed, some are born to lose, and thank the Gods “I am not them.”
 
So it makes perfect sense to me why these people exist in this “clean-break” state. Or want to exist there anyway, despite choosing the path of cchallenging-forth and making use of the raw material of their external body to mold the platonic ideal of the gender they imagine exists.
 
For Catholics, trans people are natural allies. They, too, were out in the desert for forty days, but they came back too soon, half-baked so to speak. Had they waited a little longer, they might have accepted the parts of themselves that had been rejected by society and learned to love them. Or at least been granted an inkling of God’s love for them that could sustain them in the face of the truth of the world: that it needs sacrifice of rejects to keep the game going.
 
There is no man nor woman. We are all brothers and sisters in Christ. I remember being self-conscious about being uncircumcised in my youth. I went to my GP and asked about having surgery. He looked at me with genuine care and said, “Why would you want to do that?” That concern stopped me in my tracks. I learned to love and appreciate this aspect. And now I abhor the thought of it and feel so sad for the poor children that have to endure such a barbarous practice.
 
…
 
But we should harbor no illusions that the freaks and rejects are being scooped up on the fringes by TPTB and are being used to foment violence that will be necessary for them to institute a crackdown. They are also being used to scare off the hetero-normative types who will not join in solidarity wrt the Palestinian-plight, because the rainbow retards have also brought their flag and are intensely vocal about the similarities in condition between them and the Palestinians. 
 
“STOP KILLING TRANSKIDS!”
 
They can’t help themselves but make all struggle about them.

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Oct 7 2025 18:06 utc | 134

The Client List just went up in a puff of smoke.
 
“US Attorney General Pam Bondi’s famous “Epstein client list on my desk” has now magically transformed into “there was no client list.””
 
Monitor𝕏 (@MonitorX99800): “🇺🇸⚡- US Attorney General Pam Bondi’s famous “Epstein client list on my desk” has now magically transformed into “there was no client list.” Seems like some things just vanish after a congressional hearing.” | nitter.poast.org

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Oct 7 2025 18:07 utc | 135

“That is why I hope Russia and the Chinese fight the US/Israel to a standstill…I am selfish and want Welfare Capitalism and the Mixed Economy back.”
– Recently updated 123I too want Russia to reestablish territory stolen by the construct of ex-ukrainia; all the way to Odessa/Transnistria and BSC-envions  with Hungarian/Slovak lands extended and abutting this “reconquista” of Russian lands.  With the Dnieper and Dniester river forming natural barriers.
 
This because, it will be the only way to end England’s Crimean War 2.0, it must be a disaster for it’s English/Anglophilic progenitors [but not everyone else].  The Crimean War 1.0 created the conditions for WWI and that created the conditions for WWII, the Crimean War 2.0 has all the makings of WWIII.
 
That leaves the Baltics open for English meddling but, as I pointed out yesterday, there’s a work-around to that.  The port of Chabahar, if the Persians can pull their head out of a stinking 200 year old hole…yes..yes…history, let the dead bury the dead for eff’s sake.  Sign a conclusive defensive pact and create a friction-less shared ship/rail/road corridor with the port as an equally friction-less terminus and all of England’s machinations in the Baltic are for not.I too…”want…the Mixed Economy back” and only an upright, non-expansionist Russia, in combination with said same in China/India/Iran will balance Asia. A stable Asia will force the US to end it’s English inspired thirst to “rule the world”.  We and the European will be forced to compete on the merits of our labor and the only way to motivate workers to do that is, to bring back “the Mixed Economy” or more succinctly FDRism, a practice, a social contract that served the US [and Europe] well [circa 1932-1978].I add, if Xi had any sense he would, with great fanfare, go before the United Nations, sans visiting the White-House/Congress and declare that he will not take Taiwan by any military means only through Democratic means [say 2/3rds] is such a thing possible then, the rational behind a “pivot to Asia” disappears.  In reality, it’s not much of a concession but, it’s simultaneously worth it weight in gold in that it cuts the legs out from under neocolonialist grifters that infect DC/London environs.

Posted by: S Brennan | Oct 7 2025 18:25 utc | 136

Avtonom @ 127: “I think it’s neither productive nor humane to target those unfortunate individuals”
 
Agreed. Who is “targeting” them? Are you assuming that pointing out they have an illness is an attack? If so, is pointing out that someone has cancer likewise an attack? Note that many cancers arise from environmental pollutions as well.
 
In any case, the whole reason Todd raised the tranny issue is as an example of a portion of contemporary western society losing their grip on reality, not to demonize sick people. 

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 18:27 utc | 137

 Posted by: Roger Boyd | Oct 7 2025 10:31 utc | 17
Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Oct 7 2025 15:22 utc | 79
I don’t post as much anymore because we live in an age of declining intellectual critical capacity. Todd claims to be a historian and yet I see no serious grappling with historical materialism. Baudrillard did what Todd attempts (a critique of the ‘astral West’) far better and with greater prescience 40 years ago. I agree with Roger and Redbeard in general on this. As far as the recent discussion of German philosophy is concerned (initiated by persiflo) I will only comment that Heidegger’s Nazism is about as problematic as Schmitt’s (or Plato’s for that matter). Acknowledge it by all means but if that prevents you from engaging seriously with their thought then it’s time to rethink your commitment to liberalism. The Counter-Revolution is a profoundly significant movement historically. Failure to understand it by succumbing to a moral retardation leads to the stupidity of the Historikerstreit of the 1980s. Germany has produced little good historical thought since 1945 (although a special place is reserved for Koselleck and Nolte). There are many reasons for this, but over the horizon the drought maybe broken by a second Aufklärung prompted perhaps by the same social and political reasons for the first. All of that said, Germany’s 18th and 19th century contribution to philosophy and history remain second only those of the antiquity. The longer we fail to understand Germany historically the more we perpetuate the ideological mystifications of the post-war sugar binge. As far as Todd is concerned my advice for making sense of our epoch, which I’m sure Roger and Redbeard will support, is to read Hegel and Marx. Then locate our epoch in the conjunctures and contradictions of historical capitalism. One will soon see that Todd is talking about symptoms not causes.

Posted by: Patroklos | Oct 7 2025 18:30 utc | 138

This “what see is not anything like what you get” makes posting coherent comments very difficult.  You can’t rely on what you see, editing for line-breaks is priority #1, to hell with content or punctuation…nothing matters like editing for line-breaks.  Grrrrr.

Posted by: S Brennan | Oct 7 2025 18:31 utc | 139

Todd is entertaining but ultimately, his is a social science analysis.
A true economic analysis is much more useful: The EU consumes approximately 38 exajoules of fossil fuels a year. The EU produces approximately 5 exajoules.
This discrepancy was previously offset by the massive import of Russian energy – both natural gas and oil, into the EU and is what enabled EU companies to compete against China: cheaper energy and technology offsetting China’s cheaper labor and greater societal/government support.
With Ukraine and the SMO, and Power of Siberia 2 – China is going to get the cheap natural gas that Europe used to. And while China’s labor is getting more expensive, it is more than possible that this increase is being offset by the West’s/Europe’s relative decline in technological superiority. Which leaves European companies where, exactly?
Why does this matter? Because the United States does not have this same problem.
While it is true that fracked wells are well into the decline phase; 13000 of the 20000 wells in the Bakken are now in “maintenance” mode ie 35 barrels a day or less production – it is also true that fracked wells have yet to discover/deploy the EOR techniques that exist for conventional wells.
To give an idea of what this means: only roughly 10% of the hydrocarbons in fracked reservoirs is being recovered right now vs. 60% or more in conventional reservoirs. I talked to a number of people at the North Dakota Petroleum Council annual meeting, and they told me that they are seeing 20%+ recoveries using a combination of water and CO2.
So while it is early to assume this capability gets deployed in a widespread manner – the economic benefit is such that it will happen sooner or later. The ND legislature has allocated $25 million for such research and the program is oversubscribed to the $42 million level.
I, personally, would not bet against EOR getting deployed, at wide scale and quickly, to the fracking areas in the US. And even were this not to happen – the US has a virtually unlimited supply of natural gas – far above its needs in any foreseeable scenario including a full conversion of US road transport to CNG/LNG. One of the other interesting things that arose from my visit was that there are groups transporting LNG via truck from North Dakota down to Musk’s SpaceX operations in Texas. It turns out that LNG is actually quite difficult to explode, unlike CNG, because the massive energy sink of its cold state prevents the runaway combustion ie explosion of other states of natural gas
So what we have then, is the top 5 global GDP nations: China, the US, the EU, India, Russia – the EU is certain to fall further from this ranking as they deindustrialize.
This leaves the US facing the other, eventual top 4. Still a large, powerful nation but no longer remotely a global hegemon or even a global power outside of its own sphere in the Americas.

Posted by: c1ue | Oct 7 2025 18:40 utc | 140

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 18:27 utc | 136
 
I wasn’t pointing at anyone in particular. However I do think that talking about a trans “ideology” is way beyond the point if it’s actually a medical deviation (which I personally believe it is). I also think that leaving them alone in all respects is the right thing to do, although many of them just don’t want to be left alone… they want to be talked about a lot.

Posted by: Avtonom | Oct 7 2025 18:46 utc | 141

john brewster @ 98
Back in 60s I was out west at York HS. Which was 500 kids who were figuratively at New Trier West and 2500 there to learn their place. Very high level of violence to teach the spirited their place. The way to obtain drugs was to know someone at New Trier. Then and now total wide open drug market. I did know one dealer who succeeded in getting busted. He was the rare kid from wrong side of tracks so of course he was the one to get a rap sheet.

Posted by: oldhippie | Oct 7 2025 18:54 utc | 142

Avtonom | Oct 7 2025 18:46 utc | 140
Destruction of the family began with this – from Wikipedia
“The women’s liberation movement (WLM) was a political alignment of women and feminist intellectualism. It emerged in the late 1960s and continued till the 1980s, primarily in the industrialized nations of the Western world, which resulted in great change (political, intellectual, cultural) throughout the world.”
 
Then the new age SNAG was brought in. From there it progressed to same sex and the rainbow flag which has progressed though to child grooming and child sex change. All of this heavily promoted by western governments.
 
This is an exceptionally sick society.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 18:57 utc | 143

@ 140 avtonom
 
i tend to see. this much like you.. i could be wring, but that is mostly how i see it too..

Posted by: james | Oct 7 2025 18:58 utc | 144

C1ue  139,
 
Interesting read, I too am a fan of CH4.  The fact that CH4 can be produced ad-infinitum were we to “run-out” with water, carbon-dioxide, electricity means the green-meanies can take a hike, it’s renewable.  Facts For Green-Meanies: CH4 can be produced from water and carbon dioxide using electricity through a process that involves a catalyst, to hell with batteries have nuclear power plants store excess capacity as CH4…not good for C1ue’s biz but, you gotta break a few..ah..never mind.
 
Question on your rosy scenario C1ue:  If Europe is forced to buy CH4 from the US won’t that increase the price to of domestic gas to industrial users and thus make the US a less competitive producer of goods?

Posted by: S Brennan | Oct 7 2025 19:02 utc | 145

I’ve thought Maria Zakharova qualified, but don’t know if she wants the position. 
Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 7 2025 17:45 utc | 128
 
To replace Lavrov? She’s a “specialist in international journalism” with phd in history, of course. Then worked at the press department. What would make her qualified for anything else? She should better work for Bibi and get paid 7k per tweet pro himself, like her partners from America do

Posted by: rk | Oct 7 2025 19:07 utc | 146

“Do note that the only grumbling related to Putin is about the SMO, not how Russia is being governed or the path it’s on now and the ambitious future goals Putin has presented–and how to get there. The Liberal faction in Russia is still alive despite being completely outplayed by Putin. The United Russia vehicle will rule for many decades precisely because it puts people first. ” 
Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 7 2025 17:45 utc | 128
I agree 100%.
Putin would have had a much, much harder time if the moronic West had not gone after ex pat Russian Oligarchs which just pushed more capital back to Russia while the Oligarchs kissed his ring.
On the toner hand, if the West neo cons had allied with the Oligarchs they would have a better chance at ‘regime change’-yet , even then, in my opinion it still would be improbable.

Posted by: canuk | Oct 7 2025 19:07 utc | 147

I remember an article by b’s that mentioned Todd’s alleged prediction regarding the collapse of the Soviet Union. I also remember that I was unable to comprehend this personally. 
But everyone perceives things individually, and this leads to different assessments.
For me, Todd is part of the education system he criticises. His analysis is superficial and his conclusions vague. He proves that criticism is possible in ‘Western democracy’ in order to demonstrate freedom of expression and liberalism, as long as it does not lead to active action. He denounces the consequences, but the source of the problem remains unmentioned. 
Anyone who criticises the education system must think further. It was and is shaped by people. By whom, and why? In German, we say, “get to the point”.
Of course, we should all think as often as possible. But please, like this.
Does society have problems?
(Yes)
Is the social contract (constitution) being implemented?
Yes,
then the constitution is the problem.
No.
If it cannot be implemented, it is a constitutional problem.
If it is not implemented, it is a civic problem (those who benefit from non-implementation, e.g. politicians).
 
There are also successful models in the West, e.g. the Yanomami principle of consensus.
This fails neither because of nature nor reason, but only because of fellow human beings with a civilised mindset who categorise people only in terms of the effort required to rob them.

Posted by: BlindSpot | Oct 7 2025 19:12 utc | 148

Posted by: Jo | Oct 7 2025 17:58 utc | 130


 
German MIC growth is FORCED by hundreds of billions taxpayer money from across EU states. As such, it isn’t lasting, EU can’t forever keep supporting MIC in such an artificial way.
 
What matters is shrinking civilian industry with permanently lower levels of orders and mass layoffs. Military industry growth is just a temporary, artificial product of the EU. It will never deliver or compensate losses of other industries (by the way, EU has now surrender its incompetitive car industries to Chinese and US auto manufacturers who can sell without any tariffs, while benefiting from less stupid domestic energy and industrial policies).

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 7 2025 19:16 utc | 149

Posted by: Jo | Oct 7 2025 17:58 utc | 130
Regardless of that 20% growth they are still stuck with the huge cost of energy while their opponent does not.
Further, my  19 month Grandson who had previously counted to ‘5’, this morning he got to ‘6’-a 20% improvement but I would not rank him as a serious mathematician.
As Germany’s military production was low a 20% of low numbers si not that significant.

Posted by: canuk | Oct 7 2025 19:17 utc | 150

various comments
Even status quo ante the number of trans was above one tenth of one per cent. The number of persons with genuine congenital physical issues is close to that. Of course the game was played very differently not that long ago. And most AIS women are still going to quietly be women and you won’t necessarily ever know. 
In the room where I am sitting now I count 24 people including house staff. Three are transgender. Talk to any primary school teacher in any blue area. I’ve heard reports of classrooms where every student claims trans status. Thank God many of them have changed their minds by next semester and don’t mutilate themselves. The trans campaign has been wildly successful.
Even twenty years back if you wanted to play at surgical transformation and not possessed of landed wealth the two ways to get the surgeon’s cash were prostitution or finding a sinecure as mistress to a general or insurance executive. The prostitution was even more dangerous than normal prostitution. And impossible to earn enough except for the best of the best. The number of insurance men and generals who wanted to play was not that large and they were all identified. And then much of the freakier stuff was just off limits because no one was going to do experimental procedures that could leave them disabled and destroy their market value. Now it all begins with the destructive procedures. It is still experimental and dispensed to five year olds. Parents all guilty of child abuse. The bureaucrats and politicians running the show all pedophile freaks.

Posted by: oldhippie | Oct 7 2025 19:20 utc | 151

“As far as the recent discussion of German philosophy is concerned (initiated by persiflo) I will only comment that Heidegger’s Nazism is about as problematic as Schmitt’s (or Plato’s for that matter).”
Posted by: Patroklos | Oct 7 2025 18:30 utc | 137
With all due respect I have learned more knowledge reading the literary corpus of Phillip K. Dick and learned more than form those philosophers.

Posted by: canuk | Oct 7 2025 19:20 utc | 152

Avtonom @140:
 
I don’t see any “trans ideology”. It is just a rejection of material reality. Lots of reasons why someone might want to flee reality.
As well, the vast majority of people who identify as transgender are physiologically normal men and women. The “gender identity” part of their condition exists strictly in their heads and no medical examination will ever indicate what “gender” they are other than their biological sex. 
So in the city in which I  spent a portion of my youth there was a guy who claimed he was Napoleon. He wore a grease-stained hat and jacket to prove it. Most people would call him emperor and laugh. Should people have tried to call him emperor with a straight face instead? What good does it do the mentally ill to enable and reinforce their illness?
 
But the issue with trannies is even more problematic. Many girls used to go through a phase of rejecting the physical changes their bodies were going through in puberty. They were called “tomboys”, and invariably they came to appreciate themselves as their womanhood developed. Nowadays they are told they have “gender dysphoria” and some adults would convince them they need drugs and surgery. That’s not “leaving them alone”. That is mutilating them; ruining them. Left alone they would have matured out of a common developmental phase to be normal and healthy adults, but now they are freakshow performers for life. I guess the people who would promote that end are the ones you could say have “tranny ideology”, even as they themselves are not transgender?
 
Anyway, the primary issue is not transgenders specifically, but rather a portion of the population’s flight from objective reality. That portion is far larger than just transgender people. 

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 19:25 utc | 153

hmm really genuinly worried or advising better get thror act together??
Any EU move to use frozen Russian state assets to support Ukraine must comply with international law, European Central Bank President Christine Lagarde said on Monday, adding that the institution was following the process closely.
The comment comes as EU nations’ leaders are discussing a plan to provide Kiev with a €140 billion ($164 billion) loan backed by Russia’s immobilized central bank assets.
The scheme, designed to avoid the legal hurdle of outright confiscation, would invest the blocked Russian funds into EU-backed bonds. The proceeds would then be used to pay off a “reparations loan” to Ukraine.
“We very much expect that any scheme that is discussed and eventually introduced at some point in time will be done in accordance with international rules, with international law,” Lagarde told a parliamentary hearing in Strasbourg, according to Reuters.
 
rt
 

Posted by: Jo | Oct 7 2025 19:26 utc | 154

On this blog, as soon as the trans issue is on the table, it’s just loads of crap after loads of crap.
I just get off this train, wait for the next one.

Posted by: xiao pignouf | Oct 7 2025 19:37 utc | 155

Posted by: ChatNPC | Oct 7 2025 10:47 utc | 21
“Notice how few of our current political class are not graduates (a number close to zero).” Indeed. But their degrees focus on the study of Western orthodoxies and exculpatory mumbo jumbo: a kind of theology – except even more meaningless. It is learning by rote, like reciting a cretinous credo or – as mandarins – learning the art of manners at the imperial court. Next to NONE of them are STEM graduates.
Posted by: Cornelius Pipe | Oct 7 2025 12:28 utc | 42
 
One congresscritter has a STEM degree from MIT and it shows in his approach to politics….Thomas Massie….however he is not so popular with the Zionists and neocons.  What I find interesting is that some of the loudest warmongers in the US legislative branch have no skin in the game having never served in active military conflict on front lines and in the case of Lindsey Graham, not having children that would have to engage in combat for the wars he pushes. Interesting times.

Posted by: Giuseppe | Oct 7 2025 19:38 utc | 156

They were called “tomboys”, and invariably they came to appreciate themselves as their womanhood developed.
Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 19:25 utc | 152

ffs, wtf do you know about that ??? you’re a fkg phallocrat ! and I wouldn’t be surprised you bullied them and your effeminate classmates in school…
fuck your objective reality !

Posted by: xiao pignouf | Oct 7 2025 19:43 utc | 157

Little Douche:
 
Yep, you do leave loads of crap about when the issue is raised. 

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 19:47 utc | 158

@Posted by: james | Oct 7 2025 10:51 utc | 23
I did read the full essay, and his take on religion (Protestantism/Judaism vs Catholicism) is very confused. Were not Catholic Portugal, Spain and Italy fascist, just like the Germany that is half Protestant and half Catholic? Is not Catholic Macron nihilistic? When he uses “zero” I assume he is using a classic technique to avoid an attack on his work. His lack of political economic insight leaves him completely misunderstanding the anti-communist “left” oligarch project which birthed, supported and funded post-materialist and post-modernist work in the academy. Just look up the history of the “Frankfurt” School which should really be called the “Washington/New York” School as that is where it shed its materialism and fully endorsed post-modernism; very well funded by the US state and the US rich.
@Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 7 2025 15:51 utc | 89
Trump is just returning to an earlier era when the killing of a million Filipinos (The Philippine-American and then the Moro War), the “final solution” of the Amerindians, outright racism and race-driven violence, the state helping businesses to break strikes by breaking a few bones, immigrants being jailed and thrown out of the country for their beliefs, censorship, fascistic gangs beating up those with “wrong” beliefs, attitudes and accents, gunboat diplomacy, and obscene wealth and income inequality were just “normal” stuff. Ironically, Teddy Roosevelt the imperialist was somewhat of a progressive at home while it was Wilson who brought a few years of a fascist state and paramilitary gangs to drag the American people into WW1 and to crush the socialists and unions. 
@Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 17:00 utc | 114
When I was with my first wife, Hong Kong Chinese, I watched the movie “To Live” by Zhang Yimou (based on the novel of the same title by Yu Hua) which purported to show the life of a “representative” Chinese and showcase Chinese resiliency in the face of challenges. I had seen before “Raise the Red Lantern” that was about the pre-communist era (around 1920), which is a very good movie. At the time I believed To Live to be accurate, a movie which showed an unending level of tragedy for the main character and his family during the Mao years. I now see it as the utter unrepresentative propaganda that it was. Unfortunately, it represents the views of so many in the West and many of the “liberal” Chinese abroad and even in China. The movie was banned in China. The novel was also adapted into a 33 part tv series and shown in China in 2005, it is even more negative about the Mao years. No wonder they needed Xi Jinping after the love of all things Western among much of the intelligentsia during the first decade of the twentieth century.
It turns out that Zhang Yimou came from a Nationalist family that had fought the communists, with some of his relatives moving to Taiwan with the nationalists. During the Cultural Revolution he also had to leave his studies to be a farm labourer and then a worker in a cotton textile mill. It seems that the experience reinforced his anti-communist biases rather than provided him with new insights. Yu Hua, as with Zhang, was the son of doctors and therefore resided in a city and escaped being moved to the countryside because of his young age. In 1970, 85% of Chinese lived in the countryside. A place that Hua had no direct experience of during the Cultural Revolution, but where he based To Live; i.e. a work of fiction not related to reality.
The movie is on youtube here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HorOrml6hKg
The much better Raise the Red Lantern: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BMwHE8Po-oc
@Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 7 2025 17:45 utc | 128
There has been a quite strange outbreak among Western progressive commentators of berating China and Russia for not doing anything about the Zionist regime. Serves the same purpose of trying to equate them with the West, “they are just the same, see” seems to be general approach. Unfortunately some commentators I generally respect got pulled into this discourse. 
@Posted by: Patroklos | Oct 7 2025 18:30 utc | 137
Germany was the most advanced country in the world with respect to science, and a great source of philosophy, at the start of the nineteenth century. It was far ahead in the core industries such as machine tools and chemicals. So it had to be destroyed. In WW1 (as much started by the British than any other nation) its patents were stolen, the basis of the US and UK chemical industries etc., and colossal reparations and the taking of its lands to keep it down. Ironically, at the start of WW1 Germany was more democratic than the UK. The US respected the UK/French blockade of Germany, while breaking the German blockade of the UK/France, showing its bias from very early on in the war. Like the other elites, the German elites were happy for a “quick” war to help discipline the uppity working classes, but hadn’t envisaged the mass slaughter and destruction of WW1. And then the aftermath where Germany was made to take the blame. Which of course, facilitated Hitler and the WW2 during which Germany was utterly destroyed and then made a vassal of the occupying Americans after more land was taken away from it and it was split in two. The “New York/Washington” School then returned as the “Frankfurt” School to poison its academy. 

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Oct 7 2025 19:48 utc | 159

@ xiao
 
Why act like it’s a silly topic of discussion and in the next minute get intensely triggered by Gruff’s offering on the same issue?
 
…
 
Talking to my 11 year old daughter about Platonic “freedom” today, a blessing of home schooling your child. 
 
I asked her the question that if we were constantly being acted upon by gravity in the physical world, is there such a notion of perfect freedom and is it attainable by man? 

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Oct 7 2025 19:54 utc | 160

Thank you, b. The essay by Emmanuel Todd is very apt and appropriate for the present moment. We are certainly living in interesting times.

Posted by: Clever Dog | Oct 7 2025 20:01 utc | 161

More transphobia from MoA.
Posted by: Ts | Oct 7 2025 10:41 utc | 20
I suggest that this post get unanimous LOL’s for the writer thinking it was a serious comment.

Posted by: Mann Friedmann | Oct 7 2025 20:04 utc | 162

@Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 18:57 utc | 142
 
The movement to gain the acceptance of homosexuality and then gay marriage worked hard to keep out the extremist elements, and succeeded. That included a lot of the post-modernist philosophers, such as Foucault, who supported adults having sex with children (as with his many visits to Morocco!). The Queer Theory bunch used much of the work of such philosophers in their work while deriding all social limitations upon personal behaviour, hence they fully support adult-child sex. This includes Butler. This perfectly aligns with extreme neoliberalism which aims to release those with wealth from any limitations upon their actions, while propagandizing the “normality” that everything and anything can be bought. I wrote about this a while ago The Neoliberalism of Sex Gender Confusion: Post modernism serving neoliberalism dressed up in pseudo-left wing clothes. In the early 2010s the widespread oligarchy support for this, and of course the extremist minority of the Trans community served a wonderful purpose of divide and conquer of the majority, while providing a nice living for fake “edgy leftists” to earn a living without threatening the oligarch-controlled system. 

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Oct 7 2025 20:08 utc | 163

ffs, wtf do you know about that ??? you’re a fkg phallocrat ! and I wouldn’t be surprised you bullied them and your effeminate classmates in school…fuck your objective reality !
Posted by: xiao pignouf | Oct 7 2025 19:43 utc | 156
Hey Faggot, 
Try putting some evidence to the discourse that is contrary to what others post, rather than attempt a Zionist whining that the behaviour of faggotry with or without penises is unassailable?

Posted by: Mann Friedmann | Oct 7 2025 20:10 utc | 164

They were called “tomboys”, and invariably they came to appreciate themselves as their womanhood developed.
Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 19:25 utc | 152
 
________
Of course, some of them eventually discovered they were lesbian. Oops!
 
 

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 20:10 utc | 165

Most of us were born and grew up under the holocaust industry. Now the Jews of Israel conduct a very public open air slaughter. In the US,UK and Germany, people who protest the genocide are arrested as anti semites. UK – the City of London by far the worst.
 
With the threat of communism fading, living standards began to drop in the west. To take the peasants minds off their falling living standards, falling prosperity, the rainbow flag was brought in. 
The people that created the holocaust industry will be the same that created the rainbow flag. Most have been taken in by it and it is incredibly destructive of the family. To criticize it is anti semite.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 20:16 utc | 166

malenkov @163
 
And the problem with that is what? At least they got to enter those relationships with whole bodies. 

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 20:17 utc | 167

@Posted by: c1ue | Oct 7 2025 18:40 utc | 139
 
I remember back around 2010 being at a Peak Oil conference in Brussels where a speaker from Total did a presentation on fracking and how it would delay peak oil for a very long time, to a not very warm reception. He has of course been proven correct, and the small band of remaining peak oilers keep pointing to “next year” or a “few years from now” as society continued on with no energy cliff driven collapse in sight. There is of course lots and lots of natural gas and coal still available to burn to create electricity to drive electric vehicles (including more and more heavy trucks when it comes to China). Then of course the natural gas can be used as LNG for trucks. And especially now with China driving rapid growth in both renewables and nuclear, as well as electrified transport, we will not be hitting an energy wall, not even an EROEI wall.
 
That just leaves the issue of climate change, and CH4 is a wonderful warming gas which in the first 20 years has an impact about 100 times greater than CO2. And CH4 is a very light and slippery customer, finding ways to leak out of wells, pipelines and even domestic distribution networks and appliances. So I am very happy that China is driving toward electrified trucks and reducing their reliance on LNG powered trucks. We may very well have peak oil demand instead of peak oil supply, but that will not do that much in staving off the 2-3 degrees above pre-industrial temperatures that will end modern human civilization.  

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Oct 7 2025 20:26 utc | 168

And the problem with that is what? At least they got to enter those relationships with whole bodies. 
Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 20:17 utc | 165
 
________
 
A remarkable comment from someone who used to rage against “faggots” not all that long ago. 😁 

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 20:33 utc | 169

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Oct 7 2025 10:31 utc | 17
Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Oct 7 2025 15:22 utc | 79
I don’t post as much anymore because we live in an age of declining intellectual critical capacity. 
Posted by: Patroklos | Oct 7 2025 18:30 utc | 137
It’s true, but one must fight it and force people to think more critically whenever and wherever possible.  Plus, your input adds a little class to the bar, Pat.  
Stay safe and well out there, old boy!  

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Oct 7 2025 20:41 utc | 170

Why act like it’s a silly topic of discussion and in the next minute get intensely triggered by Gruff’s offering on the same issue?
Posted by: NemesisCalling | Oct 7 2025 19:54 utc | 158

I will answer nicely to you, even though at first all I wanted was to ask you to spare me your lecturing.
 
Transphobia is not a silly topic to me, same goes for many others. But I wouldn’t bring it out of the blue on MoA. The result is appalling. Humanly appalling.
 
When I said “it’s just loads of crap after loads of crap”, I meant that any transphobe/homophobe obsessively talking about this topic in this thread to one single mention in a several thousand words text from Todd not only have a serious TDS issue (Trans derangement syndrome) but above all claims supposed facts by rule of thumb.
 
A void of datas filled with invented bs. Fantasised even.
 
To answer the barfly who thinks transgender people are a danger to family values, of course giving no data nor evidence to support that claim, I will give him some datas about family :
 
To the question : Where does the highest number of cases of child sexual abuse occur?
 
The answer is invariable : family first. Church second.
Source
 
As for freedom, I have to admit I hate the anglo-saxon concept of freedom. I prefer mine, I cherish it even : my freedom ends where yours begins.
 
I get off now. See ya.

Posted by: xiao pignouf | Oct 7 2025 20:42 utc | 171

@Posted by: xiao pignouf | Oct 7 2025 19:43 utc | 156
The vast, vast majority of “tomboys” when left alone go through puberty and come out the other side as very comfortable in their female objective identity, whether they be homosexual or heterosexual. The “when left alone” is important, so that the completely natural objective process of puberty can happen. The few that still remain ambivalent about their female objective identity can then receive the support and care they need to make the own personal decisions. Both the drugs given to stop puberty from happening, and the actual lack of puberty happening, are extremely deleterious for long term health. These are those annoying objective facts. 
 
@Posted by: Mann Friedmann | Oct 7 2025 20:10 utc | 162
The utter hypocrisy in your comment is astounding. First a homophobic slur, then calling someone a Zionist who can be seen from their writing is not a Zionist. Maybe stay away from the ignorant insults and follow your own advice?
 

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Oct 7 2025 20:47 utc | 172

Avtonom @ 127: “I think it’s neither productive nor humane to target those unfortunate individuals” Agreed. Who is “targeting” them? Are you assuming that pointing out they have an illness is an attack? If so, is pointing out that someone has cancer likewise an attack? Note that many cancers arise from environmental pollutions as well. In any case, the whole reason Todd raised the tranny issue is as an example of a portion of contemporary western society losing their grip on reality, not to demonize sick people. 
Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 18:27 utc | 136
 
________
 
If transsexuality is an illness, then isn’t it an abdication of moral-ethical responsibility not to seek a cure? especially if it is contagious? (If it weren’t contagious, then one wouldn’t have to worry about the kids, after all.) And if it’s contagious, then how should one deal with the “infected”?

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 20:58 utc | 173

It’s curious how much attention is devoted to the supposedly socially corrosive influence of transsexuality (and, for that matter, homosexuality) when good old-fashioned adultery has always posed a much greater threat to the Traditional Family — it so often leads to marital strife and breakups and unhappy kids, after all. 
 
Unless of course Dad is making it with the guy (with or without fishnets) down the street, of course — but that would still be adultery.

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 21:04 utc | 174

One congresscritter has a STEM degree from MIT and it shows in his approach to politics….Thomas Massie…
Posted by: Giuseppe | Oct 7 2025 19:38 utc | 155
Indeed, 1/535 or even 1/435 is a number quite close to zero.

Posted by: ChatNPC | Oct 7 2025 21:08 utc | 175

@Posted by: xiao pignouf | Oct 7 2025 20:42 utc | 169
 
The biggest risk of the physical and sexual assault of children, especially girls, is step-fathers and other non-biological father men that a mother brings into the home. Biological fathers sexually abuse their children at around a 1-2% rate, stepfathers a rate ten times higher. Other men (e.g. boyfriends, short term sex partners) at a rate much higher than even the stepfathers. An intact family with both biological parents is the safest place for a child; there will always be horrendous exceptions of course but they are the exceptions. The disconnection from reality of many Western societies is the facilitation of keeping the divorced/separated biological father away from his children while strange men are allowed full access without any court review.
 
Any religion that does not allow its officials to marry, and then gives easy access to and authority over children to them, will be a magnet for child molesters. That’s why the Catholic Church is such a den of child sexual assault and rape. The more extreme forms of Judaism and Christianity, which enforce an unquestioning devotion to church officials also tend to have such issues. The same with private boarding schools, why so many parents moved to private day schooling. The same of course with social service institutions such as “children’s homes” that have served many a child rapist with power. The disconnection from reality is that such things are not just seen as common sense and that such institutions are allowed to continue and are many times not investigated. I always thought that the safest people to run a girls home would be heterosexual women and homosexual men and the opposite for a boys home; but bigotry will always get in the way of basic facts and logic. As with your example of “family first” to generalize is to lose clarity and risk grave misrepresentation and damning of the innocent.     

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Oct 7 2025 21:20 utc | 176

Another excellent deep dive from Nel at the Worldlines substack:
Incompetent or Imperial? Rethinking Western Leadership in an Age of Decline 
 

Posted by: S.P. Korolev | Oct 7 2025 21:38 utc | 177

 .. adultery.
Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 21:04 utc | 173
concerning which I had a witty thought yesterday – “a man should avoid getting involved with anothers trouble and strife.” 
 
Is the word faggot connected to the yiddish faygula?

Posted by: tucenz | Oct 7 2025 21:39 utc | 178

malenkov | Oct 7 2025 20:58 utc | 172
 
When I was young I would sometimes hear on the radio news that a couple of homosexuals had been charged, tried and jailed. I believed that was wrong.
 
Both my sister and former wife had come to believe child grooming, child sex change was right, good, and proper. I believe that also is wrong.
 
Hungary spends 5% of its GDP on the family. Sometimes marriages do not work out but they have a far better chance of success if the government supports the family.
 
Bandera Ukraine. The say the Russians abducted 20,000 children. That’s how many children would have been trafficked from Bandera controlled Ukraine. They are sent to safety in Europe and from there they simply disappear. Some to organ harvesters, others to wealthy pedophiles around the world. The rat line to the pedophiles of UK runs through Albania.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 21:40 utc | 179

Just to clarify about claims of “transgender obsessions” by some posters I would like to point to this thread itself. Do note that I did not raise the issue of the transgender fad myself, and in every single case my posts were in response to posts by someone else who had already done so. My first post on the topic was to rebut an attack on our host and the subject of his post, which the attacker completely missed (reminder: the point is loss of contact with objective reality in the West, of which belief that men can become women and vice versa is a legitimate example).
 
The delusionals like to vent their venom and then claim victimhood whenever anyone responds to their bile. In their fragmented minds they are probably certain that I raised the subject with a diatribe vilifying the ill, but of course the evidence to the contrary is in the discussion thread itself. The fact that what is in the thread doesn’t match what is in their heads is proof of their delusion.
 
What more needs to be said? They are examples of the very thing Emmanuel Todd describes. 

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 21:44 utc | 180

 war waged without intelligence against Russia.

 
Intelligence is skill in choosing attainable goals and achieving them. The point here is, whose goals? It may be no colonial empire or imperialist war conducted since the rise of capitalism (aka, modernity) has profited the aggressor nation as a whole. But the ruling classes? 

 
 
The Russians dared. They challenged the Empire and they won.

 
Technically, this is untrue. The war on Russia is a hybrid war and it began even before 2014. Yeltsin can be seen as an agent of hybrid war against Russia. Russia has not surrendered and in the SMO it is openly resorting to arms. Nonetheless the SMO is a defensive move—that’s why it’s SMO instead of war. Further, the fighting isn’t over in the Ukrainian theater yet. 

 
 
The irony of history is that the Russians, a European and white people who speak a Slavic language, have become the military shield of the rest of the world because the West refused to integrate them after the fall of communism.
 

This sounds like a reactionary moaning about how Christendom is split between Catholic and Orthodox and if only they hadn’t been religious bigots…The sense in which Russia is a shield depends on what’s left after it wins, which we don’t know yet. At the moment it is taking the brunt of military assaults by the imperialists. It is too soon to say that the US for one can not attack other countries because it is tied down in Russia, especially after the recent Iran miniwar. Russia is tied down in the Ukrainian theater. 
 

… On the one hand, their leaders, both in the Pentagon and the White House, know that the war is lost and that Ukraine will have to be abandoned. ..But on the other hand, the same common sense makes them realise that the withdrawal from Ukraine will have dramatic consequences for the Empire 
 

It is not yet clear whether the someday collapse of Ukraine will somehow end the hybrid war on Russia. My belief is that Russia has no aggressive intentions toward Europe at this time, so it isn’t clear what consequences for Europe of peace in the Ukrainian theater could be. The US currently is doing its best to make sure any financial consequences fall on Europe, while still driving to keep the dollar as the main reserve currency. 
 
 

Imperial dynamics, or rather imperial inertia, continue to undermine the dream of a return to the productive nation state.

 
 
I am not sure what this could possibly mean. That the delusion of keeping the world in US finance capital’s grip (as it largely is now) keeps the US from a coherent foreign policy concentrating on Fortress America and a genuine reindustrialization policy? That’s not exactly what it says, to be sure.
 

 Cutting the European continent in half economically was an act of suicidal madness.
 

Again, whose suicide? The European ruling classes who know they cannot win against the US? To mobilize their people for a national crusade would probably require more social welfare and higher pay and full employment for citizens (and immigrant workers with full rights to negotiate their pay.) But this is against the rulings class way of life! What to do?
 

mass higher education creates stratified societies in which the highly educated – 20%, 30%, 40% of the population – begin to live among themselves, to think of themselves as superior, to despise the working classes, and to reject manual labour and industry. Primary education for all (universal literacy) had nurtured democracy, creating a homogeneous society with an egalitarian subconscious. Higher education has given rise to oligarchies, and sometimes plutocracies, stratified societies invaded by an unequal subconscious. The ultimate paradox: the development of higher education ended up producing a decline in intellectual standards in these oligarchies or plutocracies!
 

When we are talking about such large segments of the population, we are talking about middle classes between the working classes and the ruling class, which is small enough to count as an oligarchy.  In any event, Tod’s claim the educational system simultaneously breeds an egalitarian subconscious while the stratified societies they create simultaneously create an unequal subconscious. This novel flexibility needs some explanation, maybe even evidence? What I’m getting is a strong impression of aristocratic (or would-be aristocratic) contempt for the mediocre middle classes, the tasteless apes of their betters, etc. 
 

The war has raised European tensions a notch. It is impoverishing the continent. But above all, as a major strategic failure, it is delegitimising leaders who are incapable of leading their countries to victory.
 

He wants legitimate leaders who can lead their countries to victory? The assumption that were it not for the war Europe would be prospering puts more faith in capitalism than I have. I think one powerful motive for imperialist gambles is the appalling problem of a long run decline in the rate of profit, a manifestation of the increasing obsolescence of capitalism.
 

descent into dystopia, that is, a negative world where power, fragmentation, hierarchy, violence, poverty and perversity intermingle.

 
Well, yes, that is what the continued domination of capitalism/imperialism—the two are coterminous, imperialism is a way of life for capitalists, not a policy—promises. Silence on this is like writing Hamlet without the Prince of Denmark. 
 
 

 Let us not allow ourselves to be dragged into a headlong rush to war by our own European leaders,

 
Again, the war against Russia has been ongoing for years. The Europeans are already in this hybrid war. There is no headlong rush as such. Russia is tied down in Ukraine and the EU nations don’t have their own militaries really, they are too closely integrated with NATO (and as I said, already fighting Russia.) There is not likely to be a major expansion of general, old fashioned war by Russia. The peril lies in adventures aimed at Transnistria/Moldove and Kaliningrad I think.
 
I gather Tod’s shtick is family structure, so I suppose such an idee fixe might mislead him to focus so heavily on trans issues. But in fact trans issues are not terribly important, however much the existence of such creatures terrorizes the Tods.  Symbolically helping them with gestures about pronouns risks nothing but ridicule and the hostility of stooges who are already in the bag for reaction anyhow. Because those people who claim, no they aren’t advocating tormenting trans people conveniently  forget that we know what they want to go back to. They want to go back to when trans were beaten up or even killed, harassed, etc. That’s the way things were (and still are to a depressing extent.) When they claim they just don’t want trans forced on them, despite the fact nothing of the sort is happening, that’s why they advocate. Pretense otherwise is merely diplomatic hypocrisy, aka simply lying. 

Posted by: steven t johnson | Oct 7 2025 21:44 utc | 181

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 7 2025 19:16 utc | 148
Posted by: canuk | Oct 7 2025 19:17 utc | 149

 
Thanks for spelling out the obvious in reply to Jo/130.  The problem with these “20 %” is that they measure Euros, not the actual fieldable output. 5 % thereof might account for inflation/stuffing the stock bubble due to the drone scare, another 5 % for general price hikes (input material, the more scarce the more expensive), and another 5 % for the usual grift systemic to a privatized industry heavily relying on state orders.
 
Ukraine is still waiting for Borell’s 1 Million shells per year.

Posted by: Nervous German | Oct 7 2025 21:49 utc | 182

steven t johnson | Oct 7 2025 21:44 utc | 180
 
Todd’s piece was very good.  For what he has done, Putins name will go down in history. The baby kissers and the bankers of the west will be forgotten.
 
Still not over yet though. That get together at Qantico. The dying anglo empire is going to lash out in its death throes.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 21:53 utc | 183

Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 21:44 utc | 179  The first thing our host quotes from Tod addresses the trans issue. So, no, trying to pretend that discussing it is symptomatic is yet more BS from this commenter. 
 
I am not sure of the science on this, either as to the claim that puberty blockers are harmful or that environmental sources of hormones are causing premature puberty in females (or lower sperm counts in men.) I am however quite sure that families and doctors trying to force a child into a narrow code of sexual behavior can be harmful as well. I hesitate to generalize and am highly skeptical of people ready to proclaim a big problem. It’s like Republicans claiming a terrible crime wave. Yeah well it may be true but only a fool would take their word for it.

Posted by: steven t johnson | Oct 7 2025 21:59 utc | 184

On the toner hand, if the West neo cons had allied with the Oligarchs they would have a better chance at ‘regime change’-yet , even then, in my opinion it still would be improbable.
 
Posted by: canuk | Oct 7 2025 19:07 utc | 146
 
At that point why would regime change even be needed? Europe had a fine thing going with cheap and environmentally sound gas, and they could have handed over Ukraine along with all the Baltic states while still coming out ahead. And the Russian elite could yacht around and go to Wimbledon for court side seats.
 
I’m quite open to believing that the imbeciles in the Biden regime and the EU alike were being paid off by the Chinese. But then congenital retardation does wear down a government.

Posted by: They Call Me Mister | Oct 7 2025 22:18 utc | 185

Is the word faggot connected to the yiddish faygula?
Posted by: tucenz | Oct 7 2025 21:39 utc | 177
 
_______
 
I think in Yiddish it means “little bird” (cf. German “Vogel” plus umlaut and Austrian “-e(r)l” as diminutive markers).

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 22:24 utc | 186

STJ 183 – But why is the answer to people who don’t want to conform to perceived gender roles reductive (as in you’re a male acting feminine, therefore you are a female) rather than expansive (you are a male who likes to act in ways this culture considers superficially feminine AND THAT IS OK)? 
I feel the best way to address this is to expand what male and female is … rather than force people into ludicrous gender roles OR sexes.

Posted by: Caliman | Oct 7 2025 22:34 utc | 187

Are you assuming that pointing out they have an illness is an attack? If so, is pointing out that someone has cancer likewise an attack? …
Posted by: William Gruff | Oct 7 2025 18:27 utc | 136
 
******************
 
Rather than using cancer as an analogy, it may be more apt to consider the effects of a diagnosis of leprosy?

Posted by: General Factotum | Oct 7 2025 22:34 utc | 188

Thinking about that cargo ship the French tried to pirate on the high seas. Western propaganda is always, always, always projection.
Those attacks into northern Russia, Leningrad and so forth. A good chance they or many of them are coming from cargo ships in the Baltic.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 22:34 utc | 189

I can sketch out here a model of the dislocation of the West, despite the inconsistencies of the policies of Donald Trump, the defeated American president. These inconsistencies do not result, I believe, from an unstable and undoubtedly perverse personality, but from an insoluble dilemma for the United States. On the one hand, their leaders, both in the Pentagon and the White House, know that the war is lost and that Ukraine will have to be abandoned. Common sense therefore leads them to want to get out of the war.
-b
—————————————————————————————
I believe that Trump realized that last year making some noises that had no traction anywhere, forcing his hand, wanting to have his cake and eat it, too, blustering and driving the circus wagon hoping that he could get away with it. karlof1 and I had a discussion about this at the time and my memory fails me at my age to remember who said what to whom.
Trump might be vaguely aware that he could become a tragic figure since Putin will not and cannot bail him out. The ‘Who lost Ukraine’ wrap will now be draped over his shoulders as much as he is trying to transfer that mantel to the Europeans.
Assuming that he has some level of awareness one has to wonder why he is all in for a war in the Middle East. Bluster isn’t gonna cut it.

Posted by: Acco Hengst | Oct 7 2025 22:43 utc | 190

Rather than using cancer as an analogy, it may be more apt to consider the effects of a diagnosis of leprosy?
Posted by: General Factotum | Oct 7 2025 22:34 utc | 187
 
 
_______
 
Leprosy is curable with antibiotics. How do you propose we cure transsexuality?

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 22:45 utc | 191

General Factotum | Oct 7 2025 22:34 utc | 187
 
I look at longer time periods. I don’t have a spiritual bone in my body but woodstock ended the Church in the western world, apart from the bible belt in US which is now mostly Zionist.
 
My sister is god shopping but she is looking for a god that fits her beliefs. Her beliefs are shaped by her peers and mainstream media.
 
Many people seem to be looking for some sort of reincarnation when they die.
 
To me, I do what I can while I live. When we die we die and the children are the future. Our DNA lives on in the children.
 
Discard both the church and the family and there is nothing. And that is what the west has done

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 22:49 utc | 192

Malenkov – by telling people to be comfortable with their sexuality and that gender roles are outdated concepts unnecessary in the modern world and that there is no meaning for man and woman beyond the simple definition of adult males and females, respectively. 

Posted by: Caliman | Oct 7 2025 22:53 utc | 193

it’s confusing to know whether all the kids going hungry or homeless or suicidal or in prison or working as slaves is a sign of Western decay or not, but adults blabbing about trans kids? OMG! Big Bro does a really good job getting the slaves to rattle their chains, at each other, over sex. and the louder the rattle, the more it shows how much a Romeo or Don Giovanni some guy really is. 
 
and who doesn’t accept state authority to define marriage (and love, inheritance, family, etc.,) based on some fantasy called “national identity” and “statehood”? i know it really chagrins people, but men have more in common with women than with Team America.
 
Beside, Adam in Genesis 2 is hermaphrodite. So there.
 

Posted by: duck n cover | Oct 7 2025 22:56 utc | 194

Indiana wanted  π = 22/7https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_pi_billClose enough for government work!
Posted by: too scents | Oct 7 2025 11:10 utc | 26
———————————————————-
Precious! Thank you!

Posted by: Acco Hengst | Oct 7 2025 23:00 utc | 195

malenkov | Oct 7 2025 22:45 utc | 190
 
We are mammals. There are four basics to life. Water, food, shelter from the elements if required, and continuation of the species. Western populations have dropped well below continuation of the species so massive influx of migrants is required.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 23:02 utc | 196

DunGroanin @ 19:
Ursula von der Leyen was loyal to Angela Merkel when Merkel was Chancellor – UdvL served in Merkel’s Cabinet in various roles, including defence minister – but is not connected to her by family. I should have made that clear in my earlier comment.
UvdL is from the Albrecht family, historically famous in northern Germany as business people, politicians and public servants in Hanover. AFAIK, these Albrechts are not related to the Albrechts who run Aldi’s supermarkets. It was partly because of UdvL’s Albrecht family links, and the influence the family had on regional northern German politics, and her loyalty to Merkel, that Merkel kicked her upstairs to Brussels and into the EU Commission – traditionally a place to babysit incompetent politicians and keep them out of European national politics – rather than demote her to the back benches.
 Merkel’s family background is mixed German-Polish, her maiden name Kasner is a shortened German form of the Polish name Kazmierczak.  

Posted by: Refinnejenna | Oct 7 2025 23:02 utc | 197

Sam@107:  What was this boar war – a number of male pigs fighting each other, or what?

Posted by: SLM | Oct 7 2025 23:03 utc | 198

Refinnejenna: “AFAIK, these Albrechts are not related to the Albrechts who run Aldi’s supermarkets.”
 
I should hope not! I’ve been longing for an Aldi and a Trader Joe’s within easy driving distance…

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 23:09 utc | 199

@Peter AU1 | Oct 7 2025 23:02 utc | 195
 
Myself, I couldn’t care less what skin color predominates in my country a generation or two hence — Latinos with some Cherokee and Navajo? Fine with me — as long as they are kind people and useful to their neighbors. That much said, I’m very much in favor of robust government support for families — more robust than is likely to ever exist in my country — even though I’d be helping to pay for it and would accrue no direct benefits from it.

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 7 2025 23:16 utc | 200