Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
September 14, 2025
Ukraine Open Thread 2025-210

News & views related to the war in Ukraine …

Comments

European leaders are displeased that Ukraine’s false-flag drone swarm(TM) into Poland did not elicit a stronger response from DJT. Knocking heads w/ Zelensky, they had authored such a devious attack to hang on the Russians. They’re confused as to why DJT passed this off, dismissing it as “maybe a mistake.” Why has the Big Dog forsaken them-?
Apparently an errant styrofoam drone crossed into Romania during the wee hours of 14 September, signaling that the European leaders & Zelensky intend to keep rerunning the failed false-flag until they get the desired reaction from Washington.
What’s notable about the past week, though, was how the assassination of Charlie Kirk in Utah not only back-burnered Project Ukraine but kept Project Ukraine on the back burner.
Project Ukraine was not even on a low simmer.
It went stone cold.
Shocking & horrific, the assassination had the power to command in an eye-blink the fully-alert civic attention of DJT’s team. A stunning domestic crisis had gripped the domestic media and the political sphere all at once, and no one was perseverating over security guarantees for Ukraine.
Witkoff was nowhere to be seen.
It was a relief to intensify American focus on internal matters. It was a relief not to have agitating European leaders making haughty statements on behalf of the neo-Nazi regime in Kiev. It was a relief to concentrate domestic brain-power on matters unrelated to Project Ukraine.
A splash of blood jolted our attention in the most shattering of ways, as if it had spattered on us.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Sep 14 2025 13:48 utc | 1

Important developments.
AFU kitchen sink offensive to stall RUAF offensive north of Pokrovsk stalled, leaving now exposed AFU units vulnerable to bombing.
Reports from Kupyansk indicate it is collapsing.
AFU fort east of Konstantinovka surrounded and to be eliminated in coming days.

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 14 2025 13:55 utc | 2

Friday 1.370 AFU casualties
https://tass.com/defense/2016439
Marat post on same advance
https://maratkhairullin.substack.com/p/brief-frontline-report-september-14a
Today still no numbers but
Kiev troops practically left Kupyansk — official
https://tass.com/politics/2016509
Russian army takes number of new positions east of Sumy’s Yunakovka in one week
https://tass.com/defense/2016533
Russian fighters improve position on approaches to Krasny Liman in one week
https://tass.com/defense/2016575
Russia enveloping Ukrainian forces in Krasnoarmeysk-Dimitrov agglomeration
https://tass.com/defense/2016585
Ukrainian army’s logistics being destroyed in Konstantinovka
https://tass.com/defense/2016591
Russian fighters grinding elite units of Ukrainian army in Dobropolye area
https://tass.com/defense/2016593

Posted by: Newbie | Sep 14 2025 14:01 utc | 3

Friday 1.370 AFU casualties
https://tass.com/defense/2016439
Marat post on same advance
https://maratkhairullin.substack.com/p/brief-frontline-report-september-14a
Today still no numbers but
Kiev troops practically left Kupyansk — official
https://tass.com/politics/2016509
Russian army takes number of new positions east of Sumy’s Yunakovka in one week
https://tass.com/defense/2016533
Russian fighters improve position on approaches to Krasny Liman in one week
https://tass.com/defense/2016575
Russia enveloping Ukrainian forces in Krasnoarmeysk-Dimitrov agglomeration
https://tass.com/defense/2016585
Ukrainian army’s logistics being destroyed in Konstantinovka
https://tass.com/defense/2016591
Russian fighters grinding elite units of Ukrainian army in Dobropolye area
https://tass.com/defense/2016593

Posted by: Newbie | Sep 14 2025 14:01 utc | 4

Ukraine and World Affairs: Weekly Update, 12th September 2025: May be Useful to Some: https://robcampbell.substack.com/p/ukraine-and-world-affairs-weekly-ca3

Posted by: The Busker | Sep 14 2025 14:10 utc | 5

https://youtu.be/cHVmWpmKfzc?si=knGuAuchdbq12ASc
Ei, Ei, Ei…
Finally even the dumbest of the dumbfucks realize what is going on… That was THE WHOLE PLAN ALL ALONG by the Jewish-Neoliberal Trojan Horse and and his “WESTERN PARTNERS”…OH fuck conspiracies, all I see are conspiracies!
https://youtu.be/tpmY9Rr6OVM?si=jQ8M9R7-Tzi7GopR
https://youtu.be/Lpwb67x_6tc?si=DPkFcyVlOmT0j2yV

Posted by: Brigitte Mohnhaupt | Sep 14 2025 14:10 utc | 6

This even after Russian drones entered Polish airspace a few days ago.
“A striking admission by Polish FM Sikorski at the YES conference in Kyiv (I am back-translating from Ukrainian):
“If we are providing security guarantees to Ukraine, we are saying that we can start a war against Russia. But I don’t think this is either convincing or trustworthy. If someone wants to fight Russia, they can start it right away. But I am not seeing anyone willing. There is nothing worse in international relations than providing guarantees that can’t be trusted”.
So NATO membership promise has been a lie all along. A clear lie since Buchaest summit in 2008, which was followed by the war in Georgia a few months later. Also, “the coalition of the willing” has exactly zero members.
What was the necessity of throwing Ukraine under the Russian bulldozer when it was possible to build relations with Russia and gradually integrate it in Euro-Atlantic structures? Alongside Ukraine within its 1991 borders.
An appetite for war fuelled by defence industry lobby and the far right tilt of the Western mainstream. That’s the only answer.”
https://nitter.poast.org/leonidragozin/status/1967134518839574623#m
eurointegration.com.ua/news/…

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 14:18 utc | 7

@7
Appetite for war profits, no talent or appetite for war.

Posted by: paddy | Sep 14 2025 14:22 utc | 8

@ Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 14:18 utc | 7
A reminder that the little piano player, in an interview to his local own media back in summer 2022, has said that US privately told banderastan that they won’t let them in NATO, but they will act like they will and banderastan was supposed to play along.
The jug was up pretty much immediately. The West really is full of themselves, clearly high from total media control, that they made so many stupid admissions.

Posted by: boneless | Sep 14 2025 14:28 utc | 9

What was the necessity of throwing Ukraine under the Russian bulldozer when it was possible to build relations with Russia and gradually integrate?
Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 14:18 utc | 7
I become ever so slightly frustrated needing to explain over and over again that since debt based systems *must* continuously expand, they face the existentional prospect of a catastrophic deflationary cycle if they fail to do so.
The project Ukraine gambit illustrates perfectly the willingness of Nato to risk the entire legacy of EU cultural, economic and military dominance for the sake of one last mad gamble at seizing Russia’s natural resources in which to collateralize yet another expansionary lending cycle.
If you don’t understand the primary impetus behind this war – in fact, every war, including Palestine – then you will be consigned to continuously search for answers, oftentimes being diverted into petty, simplistic explanations, while not only fully missing the mark, but also unable to project and anticipate other strategic moves clearly telegraphed to those who know what’s happening.

Posted by: Markw | Sep 14 2025 14:49 utc | 10

Posted by: Markw | Sep 14 2025 14:49 utc | 10
#######
Great explanation.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Sep 14 2025 15:04 utc | 11

Markw (10).
Thank you for that comment, you do however see that the article is in inverted commas, so it isn’t mine, I was highlighting the Polish politicians words, I myself am fully aware of why Ukraine was thrown under the bus, but once again thank you for your comment.

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 15:13 utc | 12

: boneless (9).
Yes indeed recent Banderastan’s include Turkey and Ukraine – Armenia looks like it will be one of the next Banderastan’s.

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 15:21 utc | 13

The Neo-Nazi dictatorship in Ukraine, now putting small children on its Mirotvorets hitlist.
“A group of Russian children, the youngest of whom is just three years old, has been targeted by the controversial Mirotvorets (Peacemaker) website, which publishes personal details of individuals it labels as ‘enemies’ of Ukraine.
According to an entry added on September 13, one child born in April 2022 is accused of “conscious violation of the state border” and “encroachment on sovereignty.” On the same day, five other minors aged 5, 9, 10, 12, and 16 were also blacklisted for similar alleged offenses. Earlier this week, a five-year-old and several 11-year-olds were added to the site.”

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 15:29 utc | 14

‘A Letter Sent By President Donald J Trump To All NATO Nations And, The World:…I Am Ready To ‘Go’ When You Are…’
https://x.com/Glenn_Diesen/status/1966924291720560675
“Trump’s war to the last Ukrainian and last Euro: – If Europe imposes secondary sanctions on countries like China and India, it will be truly isolated in the world. With only the US as a partner, Europe would be completely captured and have to accept anything the US presents.”

Posted by: John Gilberts | Sep 14 2025 15:49 utc | 15

Markw@10….the Palestinians will be happy you shared that with them….a razed getto, masquerading as a gas can…..at least now they’ll know why they must die…..
Cheers M
….very gracious of you to pass the Palestinian Genocide off as a Resource War…..considering Canada, part of the Realm, floats on oil, gas, diamonds and gold and can’t the Aparthied State just set a up a Reservation system like Canada and just pay the locals their part of the transit fees……of resources extracted…..build a few Casinos…..lots of money to be made off these Genocide Resource Wars….screw that pot of gold shite!

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Sep 14 2025 15:49 utc | 16

I become ever so slightly frustrated needing to explain over and over again that since debt based systems *must* continuously expand, they face the existentional prospect of a catastrophic deflationary cycle if they fail to do so. ***
Posted by: Markw | Sep 14 2025 14:49 utc | 10
I have gone on and on in this baroom how western policy making has become feminine because the products of postmodern education predominate in critical beaurocracies. The truth observarved by Mr. Markw is the not so apparent reason why.
A friend was key talent in one of the most successful hedge funds in the 1980’s and 90’s. When Clinton won the election he quipped to the founder – you must be bummed about the election result because we have done so well over the past few years. The founder came back saying we are going to shut down many of our successful strategies and put in place new ones which will makes much, much more because how people in government make decisions is far more predictable than a market.
A feminized western government is predictable and more likely to be captured because of the higher feminine personality trait openness.

Posted by: frithguild | Sep 14 2025 16:04 utc | 17

Posted by: Brigitte Mohnhaupt | Sep 14 2025 14:10 utc | 6
Finally even the dumbest of the dumbfucks realize what is going on…

So you now finally understand what is going on …

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 16:05 utc | 18

No surprise here at the Finns, they have a bit of Nazi past.
“Finland concluded a secret agreement with Nazi Germany before the invasion of the USSR that would allow Finland to secretly send Finnish volunteers to Heinrich Himmler’s Waffen SS forces. Himmler formed a Finnish Waffen SS Volunteer Battalion from these Finnish troops called “Nordost”.
The Finnish Battalion was attached to the “Nordland” Waffen SS Regiment of the 5th SS Division “Wiking”, one of the most brutal and fanatical Nazi SS Divisions of World War II, commanded by Felix Steiner.
Finnish Nazi SS troops formed the vanguard and spearheaded the German Wehrmacht assault against the Stalingrad and Caucasus regions in 1942 and advanced to the Grozny oil fields in Chechnya.
This was the farthest Nazi advance into the Soviet Union by the Axis, spearheaded by Finnish Nazi Waffen SS volunteers. It is important to remember that the Finnish government of Risto Ryti sent the Finnish Nazi SS volunteers.
There was government action on the part of Finland. Ryti should have been prosecuted for war crimes and for genocide. But he never was. Finland’s Nazi past and role in the Holocaust was blurred and obscured by Finnish propaganda.”
————————–
“Denmark has shown its “hostile” stance towards Russia by agreeing to host a weapons production site for the Ukrainian military, Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova has said.
Speaking at a press briefing on Friday, Zakharova condemned plans by Copenhagen to establish a solid rocket fuel production facility for Ukraine’s long-range Flamingo cruise missiles, which Ukrainian officials say could reach as far as Siberia. The facility will be operated by the Ukrainian defense company Fire Point and is due to begin manufacturing fuel near Skrydstrup Air Base in South Jutland in December.
Zakharova stressed that the missiles are “intended to strike deep inside Russia,” adding that Denmark is the first among the “sponsors of the terrorist Kiev regime” to provide its territory for producing weapons components for combat use against “peaceful cities of our country.” ”

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 16:06 utc | 19

@Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 15:29 utc | 14

The Neo-Nazi dictatorship in Ukraine, now putting small children on its Mirotvorets hitlist.

The Bandera followers aren’t Neo-Nazis, they are genuine old (WWII style) Nazis.

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 14 2025 16:16 utc | 20

Posted by: Markw | Sep 14 2025 14:49 utc | 10
RE: debt-based hegemon seeking expansionism
<<
Russia was meant to be the ultimate in Quantitative Easing.
Now-?
Only Mars.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Sep 14 2025 16:19 utc | 21

Calling All Canadians – This is a Stick-Up for Elbows: Gorilla Radio Asks PM Carney 3 Questions
https://johnhelmer.net/calling-all-canadians-this-is-a-stick-up-for-elbows-gorilla-radio-asks-prime-minister-carney-three-questions/
“1. Has any politician in the NATO Coalition of the Willing warfighters against Russia lied more brazenly to win his domestic election that Mark Carney (not counting Vladimir Zelensky)/
2. Has any politician in the Coalition calculated more mistakenly that spending on the losing war in Europe would appease and ingratiate President Donald Trump, and relieve his country of penalty tariffs?
3. Has any politician in the Coalition benefited more personally and more directly in his bank account from fighting the Russians i the Ukraine and capitulating to Trump (except for Trump himself and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen)?
Listen now to how the ideology of warfighting against Russia is promoted by Canadian Prime Minister Carney, no matter how false the narratives, how damaging to the Canadian economy and how feeble to mitigate Trump’s anti-Canadian policies.”

Posted by: John Gilberts | Sep 14 2025 16:59 utc | 22

Posted by: Markw | Sep 14 2025 14:49 utc | 10
Very nice.
Can you share with us barflies how that keen insight of yours affected your behavior, your decisions, your life style?
Some examples would be helpful. Here are few questions to focus your answer but feel free to expand:
– Do you smoke?
– What is your physical fitness level?
– How much debt you have?
– Are you multilingual, and if not, are you working on becoming the one?
– Are you content with living where you are now?

Posted by: hopehely | Sep 14 2025 17:05 utc | 23

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 16:06 utc | 19
The Finnish economy, while same applies to most other nordic countries, is basically already dead. The housing market, main pillar of the economy, is in frozen standstill and falling. A million people are in foreclosure processes (that is almost a fifth of the population), industries are being shut down, small private business bankruptcies record high, Finland is the largest in the world when it comes to government/public workforce of total workforce, I believe 60% of employees are government employed, taxes world class high, all the traditional social democracy produced wealth services are all but gone.
All these issues apply to most other European countries but Finland was hit especially hard after losing connections with Russia.
I concur with Markw that Europe has rolled the dice, the final gamble to dismantle and disintegrate Russia to loot the resources in a bid to great another 10 – 20 year debt expansion cycle. If this gamble does not work out, it is the end of EUropistan. All politicians are personally invested with secret income streams to their bank accounts, profiting from ramping up war hysteria.

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 14 2025 17:08 utc | 24

On vassal rocks and hard places…
‘Canada Doesn’t Have A Say’: Experts Warn Trump’s Demands Put Ottawa in Tough Spot
https://www.ctvnews.ca/politics/article/as-canada-negotiates-trade-relationship-with-china-trump-wants-new-tariffs/
“US President Donald Trump asked NATO countries – including Canada – to impose steep tariffs on China as a pressure tactic to end Russia’s war in Ukraine.
In a statement to CTV News, a spokesperson for the finance minister said the G7 remains united in pressuring Russia over its war in Ukraine.
‘Yesterday’s meeting of G7 finance ministers was productive and saw progress on several fronts, including on the more strategic use of Russian assets (thievery) to support Ukraine’s defence and the need to strengthen sanctions on Russia’, the spokesperson said…”

Posted by: John Gilberts | Sep 14 2025 17:27 utc | 25

“MoatOfThe Fort” on Mr Martyanov’s site draws attention to the recent statement by General Tovari.
I followed the link up. Toveri states:-
“We can bomb Russia back to the Stone Age.”
“Finnish MEP and former head of the Finnish army’s intelligence division Pekka Toveri made this statement in an interview with the Ukrainian Telegraf. “Specifically, Toveri emphasized the West’s military superiority over Russia, saying: “We have three times more modern fighters than they do. The Western air force can clear the Ukrainian skies of Russians and bomb them back to the Stone Age if necessary.” “

……………………………
The most advanced of the “modern fighters” referred to is the F-35. The F-35 supports jobs for over a quarter of a million people throughout the United States:-
https://www.f35.com/f35/about/economic-impact.html
That’s presumable not counting the number of mechanics and engineers required for maintenance. With over around 1,000 sold so far that’s going to be a lot. Sufficient to say that producing and maintaining this machine gives work to a great number of people many of whom, in today’s difficult economic climate, wouldn’t be getting work otherwise.
So far so good – but as far as “bombing Russia back into the Stone Age” goes, all those people would be equally well employed digging holes and filling them in again:-
1. The range of this aircraft and the similar “modern fighters” Toveri refers to is considerably less than the width of the Atlantic. To be of any use in the Ukrainian theatre the aircraft would have to be based in Europe.
The bases would be subjected to missile attack as soon as the aircraft based there started to be used in an offensive capacity against Russia. Also their supply lines.
The Europeans would suddenly realise that the Ukrainian war wasn’t something happening “over there”, to which they are currently mere spectators. Europe itself would become a theatre of operations. I don’t think the Europeans could take that. It’s one thing cheering the Ukrainians on to sacrifice. Quite another if we were expected to sacrifice ourselves.
2. No point discussing the question of whether the Russian equipment is superior to ours, although acres upon acres of print are devoted to that subject. My own guess, based on what I’ve seen so far, is that given the equipment the Russians have developed and stockpiled any Western air offensive against Russia would be more of a turkey shoot with the Western airmen as the turkeys.
But that guess is more or less irrelevant. In any combat and however the combat went, US airmen would be casualties. This would be the air equivalent of “boots on the ground”. And both President Biden and President Trump have made it clear, Biden at the very start, that under no circumstances would the US put boots on the ground in this war.
3, And if they did, if the Western air forces did somehow manage to start seriously damaging Russia?
It’d go nuclear. This is not a war in which the Russians would accept defeat. And if the Americans, who dispose of the only serious military force in the West, were to find themselves being defeated in war the odds are that they would go nuclear themselves.
For this reason both of the only significant players in this combat, Russia and the US, will ensure that escalation does not reach that level. General Toveri is talking through his hat.
He must know that. Wiki:-
“Toveri served in the Finnish Army for over 35 years,[2] among other posts as the commander of the Armoured Brigade (2011–2013), the Western Finland military district (2014), and the Guard Jaeger Regiment (2015–2016); as military attaché at the Finnish Embassy in Washington, DC (2016–2019); and finally as the director of the Intelligence Division of the Defence Command (2019–2020), from which post he retired from active service at the rank of major general.”
That’s not one of the journalists, or one of our European politicians. That’s someone who must know his way round in the military field. Certainly to the extent of knowing that neither President Putin nor President Trump would countenance the degree of escalation he’s talking about. Toveri is deliberately misleading his audience.
He therefore joins the ranks of the chickenhawk generals of the West, the Keenes and the Breedloves and such like, whose field is PR rather than real warfare. Their job is to give us an entirely false picture of the military power of the West. As Colonel Lang was never tired of pointing out, our militaries are plagued with such officers. Amateur night generals when it comes to directing serious war, as the present conflict demonstrates. Consummate professionals when it comes to cheerleading and PR. I think the Russians call such people “parquet generals” and have been busy getting rid of them. If we ever wish to provide ourselves with serious defence forces we should do the same.
……………………………….
As for the F-35 and similar toys, I can think of better ways of providing jobs than that. All that work and raw materials going into equipment that’s never going to be used in real earnest and probably wouldn’t be up to the work if it were. “Military Keynesianism”, as they’re now calling it, is how the Europoliticians are hoping to keep us in Europe clear of recession. With the Toveris and the Keenes cheering the nonsense on. As we head into Cold War II it’s now clear that we in Europe are going to be spending ourselves silly on boondoggle projects like that. That at a time when we should be putting the resources and labour to any number of better uses.

Posted by: English Outsider | Sep 14 2025 17:40 utc | 26

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 14 2025 17:08 utc | 24
> A million people are in foreclosure processes
And no protests, no ‘yellow jackets’? Amazing.
> losing connections with Russia.
Severing connections. It did not just happen, they did it deliberately.
Morons led by traitors.
But what else to expect? When Linus Torvalds fired all Russians from the kernel team, he said he did it because he is a Finn.

Posted by: hopehely | Sep 14 2025 17:41 utc | 27

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 14 2025 17:08 utc | 24
I concur with Markw that Europe has rolled the dice, the final gamble to dismantle and disintegrate Russia to loot the resources in a bid to great another 10 – 20 year debt expansion cycle.

I don’t concur. There was never any hope to dismantle and loot Russia’s resources. Not even in the 90s, when Russia was at its weakest condition [1].
The motif is much more raw, natural and biological: race. Russia is very large and unpopulated. It can grow to the size of America. Anglo + groupies fear that, especially the groupies. Imagine that big thing in your own continent. And connected to that other big Asian thing which is getting richer and richer using our free markets.
Anglo + groupies fear becoming the new Mexicans of the SionoRusso new Americans. But the smart thing to do is to become the Canadians of the SinoRusso new Americans. That requires diplomacy and business acumen. Fuck we don’t have that!
[1] In the 90s, national resources were looted in Russia but the looting was done by Russians (many of Jewish heritage), giving rise to the class of Russian oligarchs. Western actors played a facilitating but secondary role [[1]]. The most important role of Western actors was to provide safe haven to ill-gotten gains of Russian oligarchs.
[[1]] Believing that Russia was raped by the West in the 90s, a very common belief among leftists, is in itself a narcissistic Western idea. Like the greatest evil can only be done by Western evildoers. Surprise. The Russians were perfectly capable of raping their own nation.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 17:53 utc | 28

The Bandera followers aren’t Neo-Nazis, they are genuine old (WWII style) Nazis.
Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 14 2025 16:16 utc | 20
Somehow, I doubt that Himmler and Goebbels would have accepted Zelensky and Yermak as leaders.

Posted by: Afro | Sep 14 2025 18:00 utc | 29

Unimperator
” concur with Markw that Europe has rolled the dice, the final gamble to dismantle and disintegrate Russia to loot the resources in a bid to great another 10 – 20 year debt expansion cycle.”
Fully agree this level of analysis must be kept in view. Could either Markw or Unimperator explain why they emphasize “debt expansion cycle” as opposed to a “capital accumulation cycle” or something similar? Isn’t debt created as part of investing in a potentially profitable undertaking? Are you picking up on a skew in contemporary capitalism that’s developed because capitalists have been more focused in profiting on interest from debt (Streeck, Buying Time, the passing away of the tax state and the rise of the debt state) because productive investment in the usual sense of investment in capital goods is harder justify?

Posted by: dadooronron | Sep 14 2025 18:08 utc | 30

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 17:53 utc | 28
Demographic of Russia indicate that their population is declining so, no, there is no possibility for Russia to outgrow USA population given the current demographic, excluding mass immigration.
If this could change in the future has to be seen but it would take decades to reverse demographic trends.
Same goes, more or less, for any developed country, China too.

Posted by: Mario | Sep 14 2025 18:13 utc | 31

A bit off-topic… Brazilian police arrested on Friday a man accused of smuggling mobile phone jammers.
In the video attached to the report’s end, which shows the aftermath of police action, at 17 and 39 sec marks something that seems to be the AFU’s symbol can be seen in part of the equipment (a case of some sort).
The video unfortunately has no subtitles or autotranslation available to other languages. I imagine if such material has reached Brazil, what else would be moving quietly across Europe…
https://oglobo.globo.com/rio/noticia/2025/09/13/homem-acusado-de-fornecer-tecnologia-ilegal-para-organizacoes-criminosas-do-rio-e-preso.ghtml

Posted by: C Khosta y Alzamendi | Sep 14 2025 18:16 utc | 32

Posted by: English Outsider | Sep 14 2025 17:40 utc | 26
Stumbled across this the other day – bit robotic, though not AI generated slop, it goes into the economic background for the demise of the British Empire and loss of reserve currency status (spoiler: military eats the empire).
It covers a lot of 20th century history of the UK that somehow gets missed out of the toxic bulldog patriot version of how ‘we won two world wars’.
How The British Pound Lost Its Dominance To The US Dollar
Parallels with today are quite evident.

Posted by: ChatNPC | Sep 14 2025 18:22 utc | 33

One has to wonder what Russia will look like after the war, assuming they don’t achieve much.

Posted by: dat gt user | Sep 14 2025 18:22 utc | 34

Posted by: Mario | Sep 14 2025 18:13 utc | 31
You think that explosive population growth is impossible, but my point is that what I explained is the real motif of Western leaders in their antagonism to Russia and secondarily to China, it is not economic in the strict sense so it is wrong to think the West seeks to loot Russia.
In addition, of course a mix of immigration and rises in domestic fertility rates can produce explosive population growth, as it has happened many times together with capitalist development. A young capitalist system as that of Russia attracts many people from around and create expectations of rising wealth eventually leading to higher baby output.
And I believe that once the Russians truly assimilate their new status as a vigorous capitalist system, once they shed their traditional, deeply ingrained fatalism, they will have a baby boom similar to demographic phenomena seen in other nations.
So Anglo + groupies have that part right, imo, but we fail in the stratgey to deal with those large scale changes.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 18:36 utc | 35

@34
Better than the EU, the US and The UK

Posted by: Judge Barbier | Sep 14 2025 18:39 utc | 36

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 18:36 utc | 35
Russia has been pretty successful marketing as a safe haven for non-liberal/non-left/non-woke, whatever you want to call it, westerners. Additionally they accept Koreans, Chinese, Mongols, people from SE Asia, etc.
EU disinformation uses this as propaganda talking point of Chinese taking over Russia but that isn’t happening. Even if there are problems, the Russian immigration and policy is much healthier and successful than that in most EU countries, who are imploding under unlimited, uncontrolled mass migration from poor and incompatible countries for ‘original’ western values (which are under attack by western/Davos globalists).

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 14 2025 18:41 utc | 37

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 18:36 utc | 35
Not that easy to have explosive population growth and, by the way, Russia didn’t give any sign of that.
Now it would be really funny if, after loosing a war fearing demographic grow, west will find that this generated the feared growth.
Self fulfilling profecies or karma,if you prefer.

Posted by: Mario | Sep 14 2025 19:00 utc | 38

@mario
“Demographic of Russia indicate that their population is declining so, no, there is no possibility for Russia to outgrow USA population given the current demographic, excluding mass immigration.”
Fun fact, not just unique to Russia, though you are correct other nations have “masked” this with surplus net immigration. Go lookup U.S birthrates, they took a big nosedive in 2008 (hmmm, I wonder WHY?) and since then it was only the last 2 years that they got back into the ballpark (but didn’t meet or exceed those pre-2008 levels)
NOW, for the U.S, and many other countries in the same boat (there are many) they are facing a unique problem that -cannot- be masked with immigration. And that’s the number of chairs filled per year in post-secondary. We’re talking a lot of colleges and universities closing in the near future, unless there is some sort of government bail-out. This fall is the first year of many where there will be signficantly FEWER 18 years olds either going to college or entering the workforce full-time. And each subsequent year, that number is going to fall even more.
Workforce numbers can and will continue to be “fudged” with net immigration, but post-secondary will not as the lucrative but niche market of wealthy foreigners’ children schooling in the U.S just doesn’t have the numbers.
The REALLY interesting thing is everyone’s been calling this and sounding the alarm bell since 2008 but everyone’s just kind of shluffed it off. 18 years later= boom here we are!
While Russia’s population is declining they’re not in denial about it or trying to obfuscate it. Meanwhile in the West, it’s “business as usual” – or the attempt to keep up the appearance of such- without addressing the very serious fact that it really isn’t, and many of the newcomers that are buoying up the numbers are not part of a stable, predictable pipeline that can account for stable demographic progression (sorry for the word salad)

Posted by: Clown Shoes | Sep 14 2025 19:09 utc | 39

*** Could either Markw or Unimperator explain why they emphasize “debt expansion cycle” as opposed to a “capital accumulation cycle” or something similar? Isn’t debt created as part of investing in a potentially profitable undertaking? ***
Posted by: dadooronron | Sep 14 2025 18:08 utc | 30
The sale of a tangible asset that secures financing generates returns that are miniscule compared to the revenue that can be realized (not by governments) by financing that same asset. A decision tree analysis does not apply to a system that operates as a distributed network through actors who’s operations depend upon their anonymity.

Posted by: frithguild | Sep 14 2025 19:09 utc | 40

Posted by: Afro | Sep 14 2025 18:00 utc | 29
######
You would be surprised. Hitler never looked down on a useful man. The Nazis, until the invasion of Russia, were very pragmatic. A lot of their race supremacy has been played up by Jews trying to exaggerate their victim status.
That is how the Germans could ally with the Japanese.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Sep 14 2025 19:14 utc | 41

It’s been a while since I’ve checked in on the open thread with the highest concentration of fascists on MoA.

[1] In the 90s, national resources were looted in Russia but the looting was done by Russians (many of Jewish heritage), giving rise to the class of Russian oligarchs. Western actors played a facilitating but secondary role [[1]]. The most important role of Western actors was to provide safe haven to ill-gotten gains of Russian oligarchs.
[[1]] Believing that Russia was raped by the West in the 90s, a very common belief among leftists, is in itself a narcissistic Western idea. Like the greatest evil can only be done by Western evildoers. Surprise. The Russians were perfectly capable of raping their own nation.
Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 17:53 utc | 28

The existence of local compradors does not cancel out the fact that the main beneficiaries were Americans. I know this is the same logic employed by Americans when confronted with the slave trade. Americans blame it on Africans selling out other Africans while disregarding that the opposition from Africans were greater and that the Americans were always free to not participate in the trade.
Back to Russia:

It has been one debacle after another since the IMF introduced its “shock therapy” program in 1992. Like a battered spouse who sees no alternative but to return to her abuser, Russia comes back to the IMF for more credits. But the hundreds of billions that have fled the country in the 1990’s have cancelled out this “aid,” as well as the meager foreign direct investment, many times over. At the same time Russia has accumulated more than $150 billion in foreign debt, with the burden of debt service now reaching a crushing 29% of export earnings.
At some point any rational, non-corrupt political leader in Russia has to question whether the country’s friendly relations with Washington are worth the price of continued impoverishment. That time may be approaching, as Russia elects first a Parliament and then a President over the next 10 months. There will be calls from across the political spectrum to break, or at least loosen, the chains that bind Russia to its Western tormentors.
The American press will mostly dismiss these demands as nationalist finger-pointing, and attribute Russia’s demise to its failure to hew more closely to the IMF’s prescriptions. And Washington will pour in money, as it did in the 1996 elections, to support its friends.
<a href="https://cepr.net/publications/the-looting-of-russia/

“>https://cepr.net/publications/the-looting-of-russia/
Another fascist believes that the indigenous people were somehow the beneficiaries of colonization instead of its victims by listing examples of indigenous-run casinos (very American phenomenon) as proof.

….very gracious of you to pass the Palestinian Genocide off as a Resource War…..considering Canada, part of the Realm, floats on oil, gas, diamonds and gold and can’t the Aparthied State just set a up a Reservation system like Canada and just pay the locals their part of the transit fees……of resources extracted…..build a few Casinos…..lots of money to be made off these Genocide Resource Wars….screw that pot of gold shite!
Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Sep 14 2025 15:49 utc | 16

Just like Johan Kaspar, sean the leprechaun is selectively blind to the coercion imposed upon indigenous communities for the scant few concessions given to these communities, concessions that were given for the express purpose of whitewashing the exploitation. Since Canada was mentioned, here are some examples:
While Nestlé extracts millions of litres from their land, residents have no drinking water – The Guardian – 4 Oct 2018
‘A perilous pipeline’: Indigenous groups line up against Keystone XL – CBC – Mar 27, 2017
Trump pushes for revival of Keystone XL Pipeline project cancelled by Biden – France 24 – 25/02/2025

Posted by: All Under Heaven | Sep 14 2025 19:26 utc | 42

@LoveDonbass | Sep 14 2025 19:14 utc | 41
As an example Emil Maurice was one of the organizers of SS divisions (membership card no. 2)
And indeed as Afro mentioned Himmler (holder of membership card no. 168) didn’t like that, however Hitler decided otherwise.
There were 1000’s of jews working with the nazis in Germany.
Even more outside as the zionists are equally fascist with common goals.
Also, anybody hear the Ukro-terrorists derailed 2 civilian trains in Russia and killed people?
They proudly took credit.

Posted by: Ed Bernays | Sep 14 2025 19:28 utc | 43

That’s not one of the journalists, or one of our European politicians. That’s someone who must know his way round in the military field. Certainly to the extent of knowing that neither President Putin nor President Trump would countenance the degree of escalation he’s talking about. Toveri is deliberately misleading his audience.
Posted by: English Outsider | Sep 14 2025 17:40 utc | 26

President Trump, the very rational peace president who undoubtedly aided Ukraine’s attack on Russia’s nuclear triad in June 2025, who ordered US strikes on Iran’s nuclear facilities in June 2025 (again), who publicly ordered nuclear subs to be deployed in response to Medvedev’s remarks just last month in August 2025? Yeah, sure, Trump totally won’t toy with the idea of a nuclear holocaust.

EU disinformation uses this as propaganda talking point of Chinese taking over Russia but that isn’t happening.
Posted by: unimperator | Sep 14 2025 18:41 utc | 37

EU disinformation? Well, if one considers that Trump is the de facto leader of the EU even if he isn’t the de jure leader, then sure, one can consider it “EU disinformation”. A reminder of what the leader of EU (Estados Unidos), Trump personally said:

China has a strong control, and even grip, over Russia, and these powerful Tariffs will break that grip.
<a href="https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/115196697263809382

“>https://truthsocial.com/@realDonaldTrump/posts/115196697263809382
Death to America
Marg bar Âmrikâ
Marg bar Âmrikâ
Marg bar Âmrikâ

Posted by: All Under Heaven | Sep 14 2025 19:29 utc | 44

Posted by: Mario | Sep 14 2025 19:00 utc | 38
Not that easy to have explosive population growth and, by the way, Russia didn’t give any sign of that.

You’re wrong here my good Italian commentator.
Russia had robust linear fertility rate growth between 2000 and 2015, increasing by ~50% in that period.
GDP had the same trend as fertility rates.
Then in 2015 something happened, a period of variability and downturns in both GDP growth and fertility rates eventuated.
Yes.
One can say, the whole appartus of sanctions and proxy war was actually Anglo + groupies last attempt at slowing Russia down both in GDP and population growth.

Now it would be really funny if, after loosing a war fearing demographic grow, west will find that this generated the feared growth.
Self fulfilling profecies or karma,if you prefer.

It might well be like that.
A clear and complete Russian victory may unleash so much confidence in Russian society that married women may start to secretly let the guard down more often and thus become impregnated by their unsuspecting, innocent husbands. Plus all the women left behind in Ukraine with all those ukrop males removed from the pool.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 19:38 utc | 45

Polish President Karol Nawrocki signed a resolution formally allowing NATO forces to deploy on Polish soil under Operation Eastern Sentry

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 19:39 utc | 46

In a perhaps futile attempt to head off the non-Ukraine related verbosity infesting this topic:

It became known how much one day of war costs for Ukraine
Ukraine is sorely short of money for defense needs in 2026
This was stated by the Chairman of the Budget Committee of the Verkhovna Rada Roksolana Pidlasa.
According to her, the cost of war is constantly growing. For example, if a year ago one day of military operations cost the budget $ 140 million, now – $ 172 million. This amount includes military salaries, ammunition, weapons, as well as support for the wounded, missing persons and families of the dead.
Next year, half of these needs are planned to be financed from the Ukrainian budget. The rest is international military aid.

https://regionews.ua/ukr/news/ukraine/1757847848-stalo-vidomo-skilki-koshtue-odin-den-viyni-dlya-ukrayini (via translation add-on.)
[Obligatory gratuitous mention of Charlie Kirk, since no topic is complete without such accoutrements.]

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Sep 14 2025 19:49 utc | 47

A Ukrainian train carrying ammunition exploded earlier today; Ukrainian sources are being cagey about the impact, but bits and pieces are leaking out about its effects, such as buses having to substitute for passenger trains:

Elimination of damage to railway infrastructure in Kyiv Region continues, bus services strengthened
The elimination of damage to the railway infrastructure in the Fastiv District of the Kyiv Region continues. Bus services have been strengthened.
The head of the Kyiv Regional Military Administration, Mykola Kalashnyk, has reported this on Telegram.
“The elimination of damage to the railway infrastructure in the Fastiv District continues. To minimize inconvenience to passengers, we, together with carriers, have strengthened bus services on key routes,” the message says.
In particular, the following bus services have been strengthened:
Fastiv – Kyiv: 9 more buses have entered the route;
Vasylkiv – Kyiv and Boiarka – Kyiv: 4 buses have been added in each direction;
departures are made every 10 minutes so that people can reach their destination without unnecessary waiting.
As the Ukrainian News agency earlier reported, the General Staff informed that the damage to the railway track in the Kyiv Region was caused by a detonation of ammunition in a train carrying military cargo.
Ukrzaliznytsia published footage from the scene of the emergency. The Kharkiv-Przemyśl train, which fell into the emergency zone near Boiarka, has already resumed its movement. All 240 passengers are safe, there are no serious injuries.

https://ukranews.com/en/news/1105420-elimination-of-damage-to-railway-infrastructure-in-kyiv-region-continues-bus-services-strengthened
[Obligatory gratuitous mention of Charlie Kirk]

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Sep 14 2025 19:58 utc | 48

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 19:38 utc | 46
AFAIK Russia has a fertility rate of 1,76 that is not enough to keep a steady population.
Increase in fertility rate doesn’t mean nothing if the starting point is unspecified.

Posted by: Mario | Sep 14 2025 20:15 utc | 49

If ever a nation was doomed by endemic corruption:

Half of the drones entering the Armed Forces of Ukraine are faulty
Due to corruption and officials ‘ desire for cheapness, half of the drones that enter the Ukrainian army are unsuitable for use.
This was stated on the Politeka channel by sniper Konstantin Proshinsky, who was decommissioned from the Armed Forces of Ukraine, the PolitNavigator correspondent reports.
“I still do not see an effective use of funds… If the Ministry of Defense has the main characteristics when purchasing drones – price and availability in production, speed of production.
As a result, we have 50% of drones that are not suitable for use . If your efficiency is based on price and fast production – then it will be so. But if you set other priorities, you may need to buy much more expensive products, ” Proshinsky reasoned.
However, he complained that total corruption will not allow to fix anything.
” It is impossible to avoid a ‘gescheft’ in our situation, and this is one of the main reasons ,” Vsushnik added.

https://politnavigator.news/polovina-postupayushhikh-v-vsu-dronov-neispravny.html (via translation add-on.)

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Sep 14 2025 20:18 utc | 50

I just see rich Ukranians everywhere in Europe. Not difficult to wonder why.

Posted by: pepe | Sep 14 2025 20:38 utc | 51

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 14 2025 16:16 utc | 20
“The Bandera followers aren’t Neo-Nazis, they are genuine old (WWII style) Nazis.”
Can you explain the difference between Nazis and Neo-Nazis? Other than Hitler taking over the world, I’m not sure what principles motivate the two groups. Here in the US the Neo-Nazis are supposed to be white supremacists, but we aren’t told what their agenda is.

Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 14 2025 20:42 utc | 52

Posted by: ChatNPC | Sep 14 2025 18:22 utc | 33
……………..
ChatNPC – yes, the Empire wasn’t all it was cracked up to be. Obviously not for the subject peoples but also not for much of the home population. Some very good English historians are dissecting it and discovering just that right now.
But most of us in England discovered that long since. I prefer to regard all the European empires, ours most of all, as inevitable but disastrous aberrations.
It’s a pity those very good English historians don’t shine the spotlight on the present as well. We played a significant role in the destruction of several countries recently and I don’t hear a whisper from them about that.

Posted by: English Outsider | Sep 14 2025 20:44 utc | 53

Can you explain the difference between Nazis and Neo-Nazis? Other than Hitler taking over the world, I’m not sure what principles motivate the two groups. Here in the US the Neo-Nazis are supposed to be white supremacists, but we aren’t told what their agenda is.
Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 14 2025 20:42 utc | 54
The Nazis ran Germany, then the world’s most technologically advanced society, for 12 years. They were a credible threat to the established world order. They took over most of Europe and had an alliance with Japan, then the most powerful country in East Asia.
Neo-Nazis are mostly losers, who like to cos play as Nazis but lack each of the intelligence, knowledge, and organization to be a legitimate threat to anything but themselves. In Ukraine, they have managed to get a lot of Ukrainian killed, and a lot of non Ukrainian rich.

Posted by: Afro | Sep 14 2025 21:37 utc | 54

@Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 19:38 utc | 46
A post-war baby boom? It happened before … And yes, you only have to look at Russian demographics on wikipedia to see that they do not have a problem with workforce growth. In contrast, Ukraine is a demographic basket case.
In other news, the Russians are grinding toward very major defeats for the Ukrainians on the east bank of the Oskil (cutting them off), taking back Yampil and Lyman (and with them the Siversk front will collapse), Kostyantynivka, Pokrovsk (the Ukrainian counter-attacks are decimating the elite troops being used), in the southeast towards Pokrovs’ke and Hulyaipole, and even south of Zaporizhzhia. So the Europeans are panicking at the creeping realization of Ukrainian inevitable collapse. But they are impotent in their rage, making them even more angry.

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Sep 14 2025 21:49 utc | 55

Posted by: Mario | Sep 14 2025 20:15 utc | 50
So, there was inded reason to fear explosive growth in Russia. Had that rate of growth in Russian fertility rates between 2000 and 2015 (1.2 to 1.78) been sustained beyond 2015, Russia would have achieved 2.1 around 2020.
So the West succeeded in stopping that trend by sanctions and proxy war. Russian married women started to think nyet, bad times are coming.
Then we have to count the population Russia is winning in the Ukraines. Working with figures from reasonable sources Russia is winning ~40-50 new citizens for every dead Russian soldier and ~8-10 new citizens for every dead ukrop soldier.
So what is the net result of Russian (population not born because of slowing down demographic recovery) minus (population won by grinding down the Ukraines)?

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 14 2025 21:51 utc | 56

Wonder how many will end up reported as landing in Poland/Romania/Berlin?:

️️Geraniums” operate in the sky over Ukraine
They fly in the direction of:
🟥 Sumy;
🟥 Kotelva (Poltava region);
🟥 Myrhorod (Poltava region);
🟥 Mena (Černihiv region);
🟥 Nežyn (Černihiv region);
🟥 Ševčenkove (Kharkiv region)️️
Source: Telegram “i20028843”

https://news-pravda.com/world/2025/09/14/1686793.html
I dunno, Ukrainian sources always report huge success in shooting down Russian drones, yet somehow they seem to make their way all across Ukrainian territory.
Gotta be expensive to keep launching F-35 missions just to protect some eastern Polish farmyards…

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Sep 14 2025 21:53 utc | 57

All Under Heaven@43…..Ireland is steeped in 400 years of English horror, so horrifying it has left a RNA scar on our very being…..and the more horror they forced on us, the harder we laughed…..helps if you’re Irish…..we call it Black Humour, sometimes it works and sometimes its a creeper……
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Sep 14 2025 22:19 utc | 58

@60
It started in the 800s with the Norse, then 300 later the Anglo normal. Cromwell was an evolution…

Posted by: paddy | Sep 14 2025 22:29 utc | 59

Just to explain a little more of what Markw said, why should debt driven economies must always find ways to expand debt and seek higher and higher profits just to get by?
Assume someone invests in any investment- stocks, houses, gold, whatever. The asset will be sold to him at a profit so the buyer must earn his profit on top of this. He has borrowed the money so he has to earn even more to make a profit. The cost of capital theory (Modigliani & Miller) says, higher the debt, higher the cost of own capital (until the bubble bursts).
So in debt driven societies there is this constant demand to earn more and more at a higher margin AND an accelerating higher rate of growth. This is not sustainable in any society or even the world. The bubble bursts and 1930 repeats. To avoid that you must capture others’ resources. If deceit and cunning don’t work, war is the only way. That’s the reason for all NATO led wars, agitation, etc.
But there’s a catch. What if all avenues will likely fail against a potential resource goldmine? What if that resource mine is also following the same approach? China. Though confrontation is inevitable and suicidal it must happen. But until then the greedy will go after others. Rob their resources and gain strength before taking on China.
This is why it’s important to save the resources of Venezuela, Iran, etc. Debt crazy barbarians are now desperate. These places are seen as low hanging fruit. These must be denied to then.
What if this resource grab fails? Or what if it actually loses more resources than it gains? Like Ukraine? Then the debt driven society is fcuked.
This is what happens now in all US lackeys. They now turn against each other in cannibalism. USA wants EU to sanction Russia, China and India. This is cannibalism at its finest. Australia has to invest $70 billion in weapons at the expense of reducing healthcare, education, disability care, climate change action, etc. Same for Japan. But how far can cannibalism go against other cannibals who must pay their own debts?
The long game doesn’t favor them. Debt piles up. Return on investment annual targets compound every year. COVID wiped out trillions in real economy and without allowing time to recovery 2022 happened. Things are now desperate. The debt driven investment bubble will burst anytime soon. Recession is on the way. 1930s to 1945 of cannibals verses cannibals will be played out without the cheap labor of Stalin. High fun ahead!

Posted by: Jason | Sep 14 2025 22:30 utc | 60

COL. Douglas Macgregor : Jewish Settlers in Ukraine?
Judging Freedom
youtube
Shared September 11, 2025
Zelensky is deliberately depopulating the country, and Jewish settlers are moving in, which is already happening in southern Ukraine.
policed by nato cops troops funded by lucky larry blackrock fink

Posted by: normal wisdom | Sep 14 2025 22:40 utc | 61

The project Ukraine gambit illustrates perfectly the willingness of Nato to risk the entire legacy of EU cultural, economic and military dominance for the sake of one last mad gamble at seizing Russia’s natural resources in which to collateralize yet another expansionary lending cycle.
If you don’t understand the primary impetus behind this war – in fact, every war, including Palestine – then you will be consigned to continuously search for answers, oftentimes being diverted into petty, simplistic explanations, while not only fully missing the mark, but also unable to project and anticipate other strategic moves clearly telegraphed to those who know what’s happening.
Posted by: Markw | Sep 14 2025 14:49 utc | 10
And here I was worried that nobody would provide a Marxist interpretation of the seemingly irrational drive to WW3 of the Imperialist ruling elite.
That is a nice, popular distillation of the motive: a dying capitalism that has become it’s opposite, lashing out like a madman against hard material reality. It must be very frustrating to sense you are at the apex of a socioeconomic system which must perish in order to resolve an unsustainable social crisis.
That said, I agree with Sean as to Gaza. That is unique and a reflection of a particular Zionist madness within the western ruling class. It’s still rooted in the age induced illness of western Capitalism, but it’s gotten completely irrational due to the massive Zio influence in the west. Thus, all of imperialism seems blinded to it’s ramifications while at least a section of the RC can comprehend the loss in Ukraine.

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Sep 14 2025 23:20 utc | 62

Zelensky is deliberately depopulating the country, and Jewish settlers are moving in, which is already happening in southern Ukraine.
Posted by: normal wisdom | Sep 14 2025 22:40 utc | 63
Nonsense. Jewish settlers could always move in there if they wanted. There is more than enough room.
The area of pre-war Ukraine was about the same like France, with 20 million people less.
You could move the whole population of Israel there and still the total number of people will be less than in France.
Don’t you understand how small is Israel? The whole Israel is about the size of Crimea. Smaller than Vancouver island ffs.

Posted by: hopehely | Sep 14 2025 23:22 utc | 63

I concur with Markw that Europe has rolled the dice, the final gamble to dismantle and disintegrate Russia to loot the resources in a bid to great another 10 – 20 year debt expansion cycle. If this gamble does not work out, it is the end of EUropistan. All politicians are personally invested with secret income streams to their bank accounts, profiting from ramping up war hysteria.
Posted by: unimperator | Sep 14 2025 17:08 utc | 24
Yes. Surely at some point Ukraine will realise they are the expendable battle ram in this great gamble. Wonder their reaction.
With the support of such industrial and economic giant like China plus though not great manufacturing nations, NKorea,Iran has decent military industrial base plus soldiers. Not to forget Asians who are buying Russian resources.It is morphing to East vs West. It does look Europe didn’t study the odds while making this gamble or as President Trump would say they don’t hold the cards.

Posted by: Michael J | Sep 14 2025 23:29 utc | 64

Posted by: hopehely | Sep 14 2025 23:22 utc | 65
Nonsense…You couldn’t “always move there if you wanted to” because Ukraine hat pretty harsh immigration laws before 2014 dumbfuck…And it is especially nice “to move there” if you get EVERYTHING for free, from Land property rights to rich natural resources unlike in the unholy land isn’t it!

Posted by: Brigitte Mohnhaupt | Sep 14 2025 23:29 utc | 65

As long as this thread focuses 78% of its attention on Russia’s future demographics, whether there will or will not be s baby boom at some point, then we’re in the clear.
I’d encourage more comments about 800 A.D. and the Norse as well.
If this thread perseverates over “resource grabs” until it reaches 100 posts, then I will personally stand a shot (your bottle choice-!) for everyone in the bar.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Sep 14 2025 23:34 utc | 66

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Sep 14 2025 23:34 utc | 68
Resources are fine and dandy, but the real challenge/problem is an hemispheric exhaustion.
Cultural, if you like it

Posted by: Newbie | Sep 15 2025 0:19 utc | 67

Posted by: Newbie | Sep 15 2025 0:19 utc | 69
RE: hemispheric exhaustion
<<
Absolutely.
However, this thread has been operative for 11 hours, and it has barely notched 70 posts-?
Maybe everybody forgot to take their 5 mgs of Creatine this morning, but one wonders at the lackluster chicken scratch today.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Sep 15 2025 0:26 utc | 68

Want a good laugh and see why NATO and Trump/US are impotent and have lost the edge of military superiority:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o4oGc9_HKKU

Posted by: George | Sep 15 2025 0:26 utc | 69

Trump’s team to ask for $58 million from Congress for increased security (due to Charlie Kirk’s death) while he continues to stir up trouble, cause division and further animosity between increasingly polarised groups. What a brave guy, ordinary Americans can pay, as it is for increased inflation and everything else caused by the Zionist neocon monoparty’s madness. Elites win, ordinary Americans can serve as useful creditors.

Posted by: George | Sep 15 2025 0:35 utc | 70

It’ll be a dystopian hellscape a chunk of the working population will come home from a W01 style war, traumatised and used to a big salary that evaporate overnight. Unlike Uktaine there wont be any country willing to aid in rebuilding.

Posted by: Adorable Database | Sep 15 2025 0:40 utc | 71

Posted by: hopehely | Sep 14 2025 23:22 utc | 65
thus sprach khazhar relative of Bernard Baruch.
land ownership how much of the black soils rich earth of uktainia has been purchased by black rock since 2014?
hopehely you zio satanic fink
de pop and in the near east and ukrainia and you do not get any sovereign claims erase history and get simon scharma and Simon Sebag Montefiore to draft the new kosher nostra version

Posted by: normal wisdom | Sep 15 2025 0:52 utc | 72

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Sep 15 2025 0:26 utc | 70
There have been a lot of problems uploading in the last week or so due to B’s change over of platform providers and his appeal for someone to help in the process. It looks like this problem has been fixed now. I suggest that it probably made some people back off in posting as a result. Besides, the blog only ever picks up when something big to speculate on crops up.

Posted by: George | Sep 15 2025 0:58 utc | 73

How bad are the sum of the Ukrainian strikes on the Russian oil refineries? What percent is offline?

Posted by: ed4 | Sep 15 2025 1:40 utc | 74

Jason | Sep 14 2025 22:30 utc | 62
It’s even simpler than that: where does accrued interest come from if all money is debt?
I loan $100 dollars @5%. (Assume this is the entire money supply.) At a bare minimum, total debt must expand by at least $5 for me to have funds to pay the accrued interest.
So now total money supply is $105 dollars. If lending does not sufficiently expand by 5%, I will not have the ability to pay the accrued interest and my loan will be in default.
If my loan goes into default, and is ultimately deemed worthless, the lending bank itself becomes BK because its paper loan receivable of $100 dollars is now valued at $0.
In other words, money disappears and we have now have a deflationary implosion that ushers forth an economic depression where all commercial and public activity comes to a halt. (Since ther is no money available to pay for wages, supplies, processing and transport.)
Now, roll the tape putting this dynamic into play going on for over 330 years from the launch of the Bank of England, multiplied by a quadrillion transactions and trades amounting to 100s of trillions of pounds, dollars and other financial monetary units.
The same basic principle applies: the debt can never be allowed to contract not only based on the payment construct, but because the ramifications actually extend past accrued interest.
That is, in a constant inflationary environment, the real cost of debt diminishes over time as asset prices increase. But what happens in a deflationary cycle? The opposite is true: the debt load becomes heavier in both real terms and proportionately relative to diminished asset values.
At this point, many probably think this a crazy and cannot be possibly true. But it is, and why it prompted Henrey Ford to opine that there would be revolution in a day if the general public understood the truth.
In retrospect, such a dangerous system was launched because the promised returns were so great. The world was empty, the first incipient steps of the industrial revolution where underway, and the expection of trillion fold economic growth could easily be modeled.
So, the nobility and bankers behind the glorious revolution won big, so big that it literally created rhe world in which we exist today.
But now the game is afoot, the biggest change in global economic events for over 300 years is bevkoning, and the West desperate to keep the game afloat.
And the only thing standing in the way of another 100-200 year run is fucking Russia. Thats because Russia’s natural resources could have collateralized necessary lending growth to back the accumulated quadrillions of tranches now sitting exposed and coming due.
Now you know why.

Posted by: Markw | Sep 15 2025 1:49 utc | 75

…for the sake of one last mad gamble at seizing Russia’s natural resources…
Posted by: Markw | Sep 14 2025 14:49 utc | 10
Globalist gambler addicts

Posted by: jopalolive | Sep 15 2025 2:16 utc | 76

Now you know why.
Posted by: Markw | Sep 15 2025 1:49 utc | 77
Russian roulette.
Only one lives.

Posted by: Michael J | Sep 15 2025 2:35 utc | 77

Posted by: Afro | Sep 14 2025 21:37 utc | 56
“Neo-Nazis are mostly losers, who like to cos play as Nazis but lack each of the intelligence, knowledge, and organization to be a legitimate threat to anything but themselves. In Ukraine, they have managed to get a lot of Ukrainian killed, and a lot of non Ukrainian rich.”
I was thinking more in terms of ideology, animating principles and worldview. What makes the two groups different in their outlook and agenda?

Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 15 2025 2:58 utc | 78

Posted by: Clown Shoes | Sep 14 2025 19:09 utc | 39
“While Russia’s population is declining they’re not in denial about it or trying to obfuscate it.”
It’s common for countries to suffer a fertility decline during wars and to experience a baby bump when the war is over. Other factors that have a negative effect on fertility are maternal education, urbanization, and wealth:
“Education plays a crucial role, as women with higher levels of formal education tend to have fewer children, often delaying childbirth and entering the workforce.
Studies have shown that increasing female education by one year can reduce fertility by approximately 0.26 births.
Similarly, access to family planning and modern contraception is strongly linked to lower fertility rates”
Intangibles include cultural expectations and the hope of being able to build a good future for one’s family (I talked with an Italian who said nobody expected to have a life as good as their parents had, so instead of marrying they stayed at home and played video games).
Thoughtful government policies can reinforce positive fertility factors and discourage the negative ones. It’s not a given that Russia will be unable to turn things around once they have guaranteed their security.

Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 15 2025 3:40 utc | 79

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Sep 14 2025 19:49 utc | 48
“[Obligatory gratuitous mention of Charlie Kirk, since no topic is complete without such accoutrements.]”
To date, you seem to be the only person here mentioning Charlie Kirk. I’ve only looked at the Ukraine thread, so I might be mistaken in respect to the other two threads.

Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 15 2025 3:50 utc | 80

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Sep 14 2025 20:18 utc | 51
“Due to corruption and officials ‘ desire for cheapness, half of the drones that enter the Ukrainian army are unsuitable for use.”
You forgot that the non-functional drones can be deposited across the border into Poland or Romania to try and draw NATO into battle.

Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 15 2025 3:55 utc | 81

“You forgot that the non-functional drones can be deposited across the border into Poland or Romania to try and draw NATO into battle.”
Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 15 2025 3:55 utc | 84
https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!sDvz!,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F6e5bc709-1210-4761-b877-ab2c3fee5a76_1084x1843.jpeg
From: https://simplicius76.substack.com/p/trump-finally-outwits-europe-and?img=https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F6e5bc709-1210-4761-b877-ab2c3fee5a76_1084x1843.jpeg&open=false

Posted by: George | Sep 15 2025 4:25 utc | 82

If, per Duda’s comments, dragging Nato into a hot war has been an existential issue from the start of the war for the Ukrainians and their deep state sponsors, then I’m curious why the false flag attempts are so feeble/transparently bogus

Posted by: Clem_Fandango | Sep 15 2025 5:14 utc | 83

@Paranaense | Sep 14 2025 20:42 utc | 54

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 14 2025 16:16 utc | 20
“The Bandera followers aren’t Neo-Nazis, they are genuine old (WWII style) Nazis.”
Can you explain the difference between Nazis and Neo-Nazis? Other than Hitler taking over the world, I’m not sure what principles motivate the two groups. Here in the US the Neo-Nazis are supposed to be white supremacists, but we aren’t told what their agenda is.

Stepan Bandera (1909–1959) is the “father of Ukraine”.
From Wikipedia (yes, I know):
In 1940, he became head of the radical faction of the OUN, the OUN-B. On 22 June 1941, the same day as Operation Barbarossa, the German invasion of the Soviet Union, he formed the Ukrainian National Committee. The head of the Committee, Yaroslav Stetsko, announced the creation of a Ukrainian state on 30 June 1941, in German-captured Lviv. The proclamation pledged to work with Nazi Germany.

https://www.wsws.org/asset/9ff3eec6-70f6-487a-8068-caa571482c6a
Valery Zaluzhny (left) with Andriy Stempitsky, a commander of the fascist Right Sector during his last days in office. Both men are photographed in front of a portrait of Ukrainian fascist leader Stepan Bandera
Link to article

Bandera died in Germany in 1959. Nazism in Ukraine is closely related with WWII Nazism, its leaders and history, with a deep hatred of anything Russia.
Modern “Neo-Nazis” in the west are typically ‘supremacists’ which are useful to themselves and especially useful as a group the ruling establishment can point to as a distraction. These groups tend to be small. My memory may be selective but the only violence committed by “Neo Nazis” (as distinct from WWII-style Nazis) that I can remember is “Hadelendsdrapene” in 1981 where useless Neo-Nazis killed each other.

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 15 2025 6:21 utc | 84

Posted by: Allowed | Sep 15 2025 5:24 utc | 89
Here is an excellent recent lecture from Trinity College Dublin about Cromwell and the genocide of the 17th century by Prof Micheál Ó Siochru.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vp7ZahTpa-M
A few years ago they offered an excellent series of lectures on the Irish rebellions, which eventually succeeded.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tATeLQL-B74&list=PL55XqDjybyL_HtaZQSfy0ljqYL3iR7YGS
One may or may not agree with their point of view on a number of topics, but still very informative.

Posted by: kvp | Sep 15 2025 6:47 utc | 85

All Under Heaven@43…..Ireland is steeped in 400 years of English horror, so horrifying it has left a RNA scar on our very being…..and the more horror they forced on us, the harder we laughed…..helps if you’re Irish…..we call it Black Humour, sometimes it works and sometimes its a creeper…..
Cheers M
Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Sep 14 2025 22:19 utc
RNA scar?

Posted by: vargas | Sep 15 2025 6:52 utc | 86

Now you know why.
Posted by: Markw | Sep 15 2025 1:49 utc | 77
As brutally simple as that!
Grim times ahead.

Posted by: jpc | Sep 15 2025 7:02 utc | 87

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 16:06 utc | 19
“Finland concluded a secret agreement with Nazi Germany before the invasion of the USSR that would allow Finland to secretly send Finnish volunteers to Heinrich Himmler’s Waffen SS forces. Himmler formed a Finnish Waffen SS Volunteer Battalion from these Finnish troops called “Nordost”.
Thank you. But do you have any links or the name or date of that agreement? Thanks.

Posted by: Paul from Norway | Sep 15 2025 7:30 utc | 88

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Sep 14 2025 16:06 utc | 19
“Finland concluded a secret agreement with Nazi Germany before the invasion of the USSR that would allow Finland to secretly send Finnish volunteers to Heinrich Himmler’s Waffen SS forces. Himmler formed a Finnish Waffen SS Volunteer Battalion from these Finnish troops called “Nordost”.
Thank you. But do you have any links or the name or date of that agreement? Thanks.

Posted by: Paul from Norway | Sep 15 2025 7:34 utc | 89

Talk of Russia’s future population is an interesting topic.
Assuming immigrants overwhelm an already declining Europe there’s a distinct possibility that there will come a mass emigration to Russia in seek of jobs, cultural stability and an overabundance of beautiful, feminine women.
IMHO the Euro Russophobia doesn’t run nearly as deep as discomfort over more home-grown issues.
The future is all about control over increasingly limited resources, and Russia’s prosperity will be a magnet.

Posted by: TJandTheBear | Sep 15 2025 7:56 utc | 90

Posted by: Paul from Norway | Sep 15 2025 7:34 utc | 91
It is true, over 1000 Finns were recruited into SS, albeit allegedly without swearing allegiance to Hitler. Clarification by Grok.

Verification of the StatementThe provided statement is largely accurate, with minor caveats on the precise nature of the “secret agreement” and its timing relative to the invasion of the USSR. Finland did indeed enter into covert arrangements with Nazi Germany to facilitate the recruitment and deployment of Finnish volunteers to the Waffen-SS, driven by shared anti-Soviet objectives ahead of Operation Barbarossa. These volunteers were organized into a battalion named “Nordost” under Heinrich Himmler’s oversight. Below, I’ll break down the key elements of the statement, supported by historical evidence.1. The Secret Agreement with Nazi GermanyFinland and Germany began secret military negotiations in late 1940, including discussions on arms deliveries and transit rights for German troops through Finland to attack the Soviet Union. As part of demonstrating Finnish “allegiance,” SS headquarters proposed recruiting Finnish volunteers for the German armed forces in December 1940.
The Finnish government formally consented to the recruitment project on April 14, 1941—months before the German invasion of the USSR on June 22, 1941. To maintain plausible deniability (given Finland’s neutral stance at the time), the Finnish Foreign Ministry tasked Esko Riekki, former chief of Finland’s secret police, with conducting recruitment in secret. Volunteers were drawn broadly, not limited to Nazi sympathizers, to avoid political backlash.
Conditions included: no oath of loyalty to Hitler (modified to a general SS oath), service limited to two years and only against the USSR, and repatriation if Finland went to war alone. Germany accepted these on April 28, 1941. This was not a single “treaty” but a series of covert diplomatic understandings, often framed as a symbolic gesture of cooperation.
2. Finnish Volunteers to Himmler’s Waffen-SSHeinrich Himmler, as Reichsführer-SS, directly oversaw the integration of foreign volunteers into the Waffen-SS, including the creation of multinational units like the SS Division Wiking. Himmler insisted on Finnish participation as part of broader wartime pacts, similar to demands on other occupied nations.
A total of 1,197 Finnish volunteers were selected and shipped to Germany in five batches between May and June 1941 for training. They were trained at camps like Gross-Born and Schönbrunn, swearing their oath on October 15, 1941.
The unit was explicitly formed as a Waffen-SS battalion, not integrated into the Wehrmacht, per Nazi policy on foreign volunteers. It drew inspiration from the Finnish Jäger Movement’s WWI volunteers in the German army, emphasizing anti-Bolshevik elite traditions.
3. The “Nordost” BattalionThe volunteers formed the SS-Freiwilligen-Bataillon Nordost (mot.) (SS Volunteer Battalion Northeast, motorized), commanded by German SS officer Hans Collani. It consisted of about 1,200 men, including 10 regular officers, 66 reserve officers, and 29 NCOs—far more leadership than needed for a battalion, leading Germany to propose expanding it to a full regiment (which Finland rejected).
Deployed to the Eastern Front in December 1941, the battalion joined the SS Regiment Nordland within the Wiking Division. It fought in Ukraine (e.g., along the Mius River and Don River) until withdrawn in April 1943 due to the two-year service limit. Casualties included 256 killed, 686 wounded, and 14 missing.
The battalion was disbanded on July 11, 1943, over Finnish objections to renewal; survivors returned home for a parade in Hanko and were granted leave. Finnish commander Carl Gustaf Emil Mannerheim cited poor treatment by German officers as a factor in non-renewal.
Additional Context and ControversiesMotivations and Ideology: Most volunteers were apolitical, motivated by revenge for the 1939–1940 Winter War against the USSR rather than Nazism. However, Finnish leaders tacitly supported recruitment, and some volunteers witnessed or participated in atrocities (e.g., massacres of Jews, civilians, and POWs in Ukraine and the Caucasus alongside Einsatzgruppen). A 2019 Finnish government report concluded they “very likely” took part, based on diaries and archives, though many later downplayed it due to “emotional confusion” and loyalty conflicts.
Post-War Legacy: In Finland, the volunteers were often portrayed as elite anti-communist fighters, not Nazis. Efforts to honor them (e.g., grave markings in 1999) sparked debate, but the 2019 report marked a reckoning with this history.
This arrangement exemplified Finland’s “co-belligerency” with Germany during the Continuation War (1941–1944), balancing survival against Soviet threats without full Axis alignment. For deeper reading, sources like the Finnish National Archives or books on the Wiking Division provide primary documents.

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 15 2025 7:56 utc | 91

Posted by: George | Sep 15 2025 0:26 utc | 71
Thanks. Interesting report by Borzzikman, especially about the Russian submarine and the fleet of NATO vessels in the north of Norway.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 15 2025 8:21 utc | 92

Finnish PM was moaning how the economy is partially crashing due to lack of wood raw material from Russia, billions in investments are delayed and never made and pre-existing industries move away.
It’s good to acknowledge a problem, and then continue shooting yourself in the foot.

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 15 2025 9:09 utc | 93

Poland. After Russian drones in Poland, the US response is limited to verbal support, not military action. Polish PM Sikorski draws conclusions:

Security guarantees are meant to deter a potential adversary … So what we are saying is that if there is some kind of peace, the next time Russia tries anything against Ukraine, we might go to war with Russia. Now I find that not very credible. Because if you want to go war with Russia, you can do it today and I see no volunteers. And there is nothing more dangerous in international relations than giving a guarantee that is not credible. (guardian)

Giving a guarantee is a way to provoke war, as the country receiving the guarantee sees no reason for diplomacy.

Posted by: Passerby | Sep 15 2025 10:00 utc | 94

@ Paranaense | Sep 15 2025 3:55 utc | 84

You forgot that the non-functional drones can be deposited across the border into Poland or Romania to try and draw NATO into battle.

A direct missile strike killing two Polish citizens didn’t draw NATO into battle. Even the corpse-president Biden was sent out to _immediately_ call it a banderite missile. Piano player’s childish arguing about it didn’t achieve anything either.
Polish government support for murderers of their citizens aside, none of them are in any rush to lost to Russia in a direct war.

Posted by: boneless | Sep 15 2025 10:20 utc | 95

Posted by: normal wisdom | Sep 14 2025 22:40 utc | 63
Back to Odessa ? At last ; someone will be able to tell us by first hand experiences the difference between a Sahed136 and a Geran2 🙂

Posted by: Savonarole | Sep 15 2025 10:50 utc | 96

Reacting to part of a quote from some Finnish idiot as shared by “English Outsider” ( Sep 14 2025 17:40 utc | 26 ) —btw thank you! 🙂
NATO propaganda sure is funny.

“We have three times more modern fighters than they do. The Western air force can clear the Ukrainian skies of Russians and bomb them back to the Stone Age if necessary.”

Okay… so they keep saying they could do this and they could do that but they never do it so that means they simply don’t want to then doesn’t it? Do they have any other excuses? The nazi ex-“Ukrainians” must be so grateful for all the stuff NATO could do but won’t do because they really can’t! Lol XD
It must certainly make all the ex-“Ukrainians” feel better as they die 😛
What ex-“Ukraine” lacks in manpower NATO makes up for in a lack of brains! 😀

Posted by: Sunny Runny Burger | Sep 15 2025 11:20 utc | 97

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 15 2025 9:09 utc | 95
Finnish PM was moaning how the economy is partially crashing due to lack of wood raw material from Russia, billions in investments are delayed and never made and pre-existing industries move away.
It’s good to acknowledge a problem, and then continue shooting yourself in the foot.

It’s not Stubb’s problem! He’ll end up in some cozy place, far away from Suomi, like his predecessor Sanna Marin.
I believe he’s saying this so that the population doesn’t think he’s a culprit (which he is). Living standards in Finland will be hit particularly hard, and at least some Finns are able to link that to the faithful decisions of 2022.

Posted by: Konami | Sep 15 2025 12:09 utc | 98

Posted by: Sunny Runny Burger | Sep 15 2025 11:20 utc | 99
True. You home in on a point that no one, whatever their political views or their views on the conflict, can avoid agreeing on. We have let the Ukrainians down just about every way we could have:-
Dismiss all the argument on who provoked the war as Russian smoke and mirrors. Set aside the question of who was in the right. The fact remains that we encouraged the Ukrainians to keep fighting when they could have got far better terms at Istanbul than they’re ever going to get now.
Worse, we promised them indefinite support. “As long as it takes”. We lionised Zelensky and cheered him on. Then – “We are not Amazon” at Vilnius. It must have been for Zelensky as if the ground had fallen away from under his feet at Vilnius. All those promises. And none honoured nor ever any intention of honouring them.
Worse than that. Our military had charge of this war. We insisted on the summer offensive though the Ukrainian General Staff would have preferred to concentrate their efforts further north.
We organised what must have been the most amateurish attack ever seen in modern warfare when we threw the Ukrainian regulars against the Surovikin line. We wasted three brigades of fine Ukrainian troops at Krinky and kept that hopeless attack going long after it was clear that that attack was going nowhere. Brave men clambering across the bodies of their comrades, sent in again and again to hold a position that was never going to be held.
And at Kursk we did the same. Squandering men and equipment by organising the murderously wasteful Kursk venture, an offensive carried out for PR reasons and, again, an offensive maintained well after it was clear it was going nowhere.
Amateur night, all of it, by the Western militaries working out of Wiesbaden and the Pentagon. The Ukrainian regulars deserved better from us than that and they never got it, not in the inferior equipment we supplied them with, the sub-standard training we gave them, and the incompetent planning and direction of this war.
– below states that the Ukrainians will be humiliated. With respect, I disagree. Those regulars did all that was asked of them and more. Far more. And in return we threw their lives away so casually.
So not humiliated. Let down and betrayed. You know what the Russians were up to, don’t you. From the first day they knew that if the war could not be halted by negotiation they must destroy all that we could throw at them. Equipment, proxies, the lot. And all we did, after all the promises and for all the endless talk, was feed in our proxies to be destroyed.
https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/squaring-an-impossible-circle-of-peace-and-insecurity-in-ukraine
And hard headed observers who know far more about this war than me put that same point more forcefully. Larry Johnson:-
” Let me repeat: The West betrayed Ukraine when it obstructed its democratic transition and independence, interfered in its internal affairs, pitted Ukrainians against Russians, incited Slavs against Slavs, then initiated an unconstitutional coup, lied about implementing the Minsk agreements, and ultimately provoked a bloodbath in the region.“
Daniel Davis on what we’re doing to Ukraine. Brief and therefore the more powerful:-
“Now it’s Us Facilitating UKRAINE’s DEATH /Lt Col Daniel Davis”
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lJScBzgtKW4&t=31s&ab_channel=DanielDavis%2FDeepDive
Peter AU1 on the destruction we’re insisting the Ukrainians continue to suffer:-
“Russia when it made its move, set out to bleed the Europeans white. All The Russians had to do for that was park themselves in novorossiya and destroy everything that came at them till everything stops coming. An industrial process that gets a bit boring after awhile so I haven’t been reading the Ukraine threads much.”
And “b”, a judgement even more compact – one word – some time ago. That what we’ve done to the Ukrainians is a “crime.”
Those last references already submitted. I recollect making the same point to Colonel Lang way back. Just before he died I wrote in stating that no matter the rights and wrongs of the war, this war was lost and it was pure murder insisting the Ukrainians continue fighting a lost war. His reply, from his hospital bed though I did not know that at the time, “Welcome back.” The Colonel, as many here will recollect, had different views on this war. But not, I believe, on the wrongness of continuing to fight it long after it had been lost.
That’s what we’re still doing. While we focus on all the pointless manoeuvering and all the pointless talk, the casualties mount at an ever-increasing rate. Whether we in the West are in the right or whether the Russians are is an argument that will continue indefinitely. But whatever the verdict one might come to on that it’s long past time to let the Ukrainians off the hook.

Posted by: English Outsider | Sep 15 2025 12:15 utc | 99

@hopehely | Sep 14 2025 17:41 utc | 27

Morons led by traitors

Led by traitors? Certainly. Morons? The people of Finland were not given a chance to vote on whether to break the neutrality treaty and join NATO.

Posted by: cirsium | Sep 15 2025 12:19 utc | 100