Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
May 15, 2025
Ukraine Open Thread 2025-105

News & views related to the war in Ukraine …

Comments

Paraphrasing the Emily Dickinson poem:
I’m Hitler-! Who are you-? Are *you* Hitler too-?
A peculiar bond DJT and VVP share, beyond the insane accusations of Russiagate, which remember both men knew in real-time were bogus: each have been called Hitler and each know that they, themselves, personally are *not* Hitler but more importantly, they know the *other* is not Hitler either.
“Dear Donald, how *Hitler* are you-?”

Posted by: steel_porcupine | May 15 2025 18:57 utc | 101

Posted by: Stark | May 15 2025 16:22 utc | 62
You actually end up at a stage when you think to yourself, have we ever been told the truth about anything during our lives.
Because you can choose any subject you like and it is riddled with GROUPTHINK. With a guard at every gate deciding what can and cannot be published about any subject.
Graduate students in any subject are trained to follow these ‘haiku-like’ rules, that govern a white paper’s chance of publication success, which then determines academic ppointments, promotion, grant success, and other elevations of influence.

Posted by: Sun Of Alabama | May 15 2025 19:02 utc | 102

Colonel General Andrey Nikolayevich Mordvichev has been appointed the new Commander-in-Chief of the Russian Ground Forces.
This is huge news for the Russian forces — after years of stagnation in the Ministry of Defense, it finally looks like things are moving forward, and by the looks of it, in a big way.

Andrey Mordvichev is the commander of one of the most effective troop groups, the Guards “Center”, which liberated Avdeevka and dozens of neighboring villages and cities. Previously, a colonel general, he commanded the 8th combined arms army of the Southern Military District, which liberated Mariupol.

This is the man who led the battle for Mariupol, the offensive on Avdeevka, and then pushed all the way to Pokrovsk. Remarkably young by Russian military standards — just 49 years old. He avoids the spotlight, doesn’t have any of those Telegram channels hyping him up, and maintains excellent relations with the entire Chechen leadership, starting with Kadyrov.
Order, discipline, and adaptability, that’s Mordvichev.

He’s basically better than every American and NATO Commander on the planet. He has led successful peer operations.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 15 2025 19:02 utc | 103

I tend to agree with some Russian analysts saying how sending Medinskii is basically sabotaging the peace talks. The one logical reason for this is Russia somehow knew what Ukraine is bringing to the table (1991 borders, unconditional withdrawal, usual tantrum) and minimising the damage. Or Russia thinks that it will get better conditions if it continues to fight. Same for the Ukraine. Basically a show for Trump from both sides. “Welp we tried but no dice, back to killings”.

Posted by: happytoad | May 15 2025 19:10 utc | 104

Posted by: CullenBaker | May 15 2025 18:44 utc | 95
Thank you for enlightening me.
In looking for the plain truth, the magical power of DTrump’s ‘offhand statement’ was lost on me.

Posted by: JB | May 15 2025 19:14 utc | 105

Why does every football match look the same nowadays and Follow certain patterns ?
GROUPTHINK!
Coaches that get their coaching badges are drowned in GROUPTHINK ! Until nearly every match is a borefest.
When African teams first hit the World Cup they were a breathe of fresh air. That was very quickly coached out of them. By foreign coaches swimming in GROUPTHINK.
Now African teams play like EVERYBODY else and pass the ball backwards more than they do forwards.
The Western public are trained like little puppy dogs to hate Russia using the very same techniques. GROUPTHINK.

Posted by: Sun Of Alabama | May 15 2025 19:21 utc | 106

WTF is wrong with these people.
Zelensky and Putin are the political leaders of their respective countries. These countries are organizations with millions of people and economies in the Trillions and these 2 are essentially the CEO’s of those countries. You don’t send CEO’s out on a sales call … you send the guys who know the product and know to sell … the CEO is the big picture guy not the details guy.
Zelensky and putin might be great salesmen but surely to fuck they have better things to do than drop everything, get on a plane and fly to Istanbul to argue about when to stop shooting and where to draw the new national borders. You would think it would take at minimum months for a world leader to get on putin’s schedule for an hour let alone take up the best part of a week of putin’s time say nothing of the considerable security detail that would have to be put together to go to a NATO country and face a leader he’s at war with.
You’d think Zelensky would be busy running his country as well but just the fact that he can take off to Istanbul on a moments notice reflects just how much responsibility he really holds.
Zelensky and Putin’s only input into this process should be at a signing ceremony. directly negotiating treaties or “deals” is NOT the job of a president of a nation. Why this hasn’t been pointed out by journalists or pundits in the west is more evidence as to how fucking DUMB we’ve become in the west.

Posted by: HB_Norica | May 15 2025 19:22 utc | 107

Except…the negotiation will have to hang-fire until tomorrow. Which means The Empty Chair gets nullified.
Posted by: steel_porcupine | May 15 2025 17:46 utc | 81
Will it though? Do you really think that the Mighty Wurlitzer of propaganda will report on tomorrow’s talks? I don’t think so. I think that the message they are trumpeting now will be their last word on this subject.
Trump shut down that nonsense with one offhand statement.
Posted by: CullenBaker | May 15 2025 18:44 utc | 95
Indeed, he did, but they will carry on anyway.
Trump also messed up the first narrative the west was putting out about the ceasefire, by paying attention to Putin’s negotiation offer (which the msm was ignoring), and telling Zelensky to go.
They had to pivot, and come up with the latest propaganda.
Now Putin is a coward, along with not wanting peace by not agreeing to a(nother) ceasefire.
Note that not one media source will report on the 3 previous ceasefires this year, or the fact that Russia observed them and Ukraine did not.
If a tree falls in the forest and the media doesn’t report it, did it happen?

Posted by: wagelaborer | May 15 2025 19:31 utc | 108

As we survey the geopolitical landscape right now, it’s important to keep in mind that the False Flag of Bucha provided the pretext for deep-sixing the original Istanbul agreement in early April 2022.
Stay alert to something similar in the offing right now.
A tactical nuke detonated atop a pediatric hospital in Kiev-?
The Brits especially are well-practiced in this kind of skullduggery. Not that they have deployed a tactical nuke anywhere yet—but one must remember how escalatory-hungry they are and how intent on not allowing a Signed Agreement to ruin their war-grifting ways.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | May 15 2025 19:47 utc | 109

Posted by: CullenBaker | May 15 2025 18:44 utc | 95
RE: who would leave Istanbul today, on 15 May-?
<< Recall: Witkoff, Kellog & Sec Rubio were not expected in Istanbul until 16 May, so who would leave now-? It's reminiscent of that Luis Bunuel surrealist film "The Exterminating Angel" where guests at a dinner party find they cannot seem to leave the dining room, some compelling force keeps them planted squarely in place. So what's the compelling force-? For the Russian team, we comprehend, because they have accepted VVP's charge. For the Ukrainian team-? Maybe the compelling force gets delivered w/ a tiny spoon-?

Posted by: steel_porcupine | May 15 2025 19:52 utc | 110

HB_Norica@107….with no international warrants out for his arrest….Tiny Dancer is free to travel the world on a whim….and as Trump did point out, not much happening without him present, in person. Zelinski on the other hand is well past his best before date….I’d never negotiate with such belligerent bags of shit, I’d tapped them in order starting with Zman and then every belligerent Ukie bastard, right down to the last one…. basically backwards from the Russian plan to just kill Ukie press ganged grunts…..such joy this attrition stuff…..maybe it’s Russia’s plan, kill all the Ukies save the Ukie regime….weird shit.
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | May 15 2025 19:58 utc | 111

GROUPTHINK” indeed, just like certain Modern Major-Generals Monetary Theorists, who are so convinced of their evangelical righteousness that any, even mild, questioning of their views leads to accusations of heresy, denunciations for “fixed exchange-rate myopia” and condemnation to the comfy armchair of the New Economic Inquisition…
Strange how “GROUPTHINK” works, could well explain the European elites approach to Ukraine/Russia, or the outlook of the Ukrainian military leadership.
~~~
Posted by: Sunny Runny Burger | May 15 2025 18:28 utc | 92
Good try, but the “chocolate cupcakes” thing goes back way beyond Nuland, back to the first Reagan term.

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | May 15 2025 20:10 utc | 112

Just a little reminder of the origins of the Ukrainian Nazi Ideology and its Leader backed by the US/NATO led West
Execution of Stepan Bandera: Ukrainian Nazi who with axes killed 1000s of men, women & children
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1iFh0gviWGI [ 15 mins
As a little companion to the Al Qaida Ideology in Syria backed by the US led West
Western values and Western .. er .. civilization!

Posted by: Don Firineach | May 15 2025 20:14 utc | 113

Posted by: Oldengineer | May 15 2025 16:40 utc | 68
Another text I recommend to supplement understanding of “The Great Game” (which started while the Czars ruled Russia) paranoia and kinda turned into the “Cold War 1.0″…
https://issuu.com/haylierennerls/docs/ebook_the_cia_an_imperial_history
https://books.google.com/books/about/The_CIA.html?id=IrTaEAAAQBAJ
Goes into how the British intelligence services influenced the US, dating back to their colonial intel gathering/regime change/regime maintenance/counterintel during the Great Game in places like Arabia and SE Asia/the Indian Subcontinent.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | May 15 2025 20:34 utc | 114

Ukrainian Man in London charged with arson over attacks on properties linked to Starmer
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14717069/keir-starmer-fires-man-charged-arson.html
Roman Lavrynovich, aged 21, has been remanded in custody over three arson attacks – one on Kier Starmer’s former house (which is now rented out to his wife’s sister for a nominal rent). Another attack on a flat formerly owned by Starmer and also on a car parked next to Starmer’s house which was owned by a neighbour. The fire was contained by the fire brigade before anyone was injured

Posted by: Aslangeo | May 15 2025 20:39 utc | 115

steel_porcupine | May 15 2025 18:52 utc | 99
I always thought Scotts Porage Oats was better than Joyce Carol Oates.

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | May 15 2025 20:47 utc | 116

Posted by: Aslangeo | May 15 2025 20:39 utc | 115
That will be the first of many such attacks, as an angry and aggravated pro-Nazi Ukrainian diaspora throughout Europe start venting their displeasure against European leadership and populations.
Wonder what happened to all the small arms that got sent to Ukraine? Don’t suppose there’s any audit trail to show where they ended up…

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | May 15 2025 21:00 utc | 117

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | May 15 2025 21:00 utc | 117
I’m surprised that they admitted it was a pro-Ukraine perp. In the future they’ll probably try to tie these attacks in with the narrative about EU-wide “Russian sabotage/terror.”

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | May 15 2025 21:03 utc | 118

America created Al Qaeda.
Al Qaeda attacks America.
What happened next?

Europe created Ukrainian Nazis.
Ukrainian Nazis start attacking in Europe.
What happens next?

Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 15 2025 21:08 utc | 119

Russia Proposes Istanbul Talks Begin Friday Morning: LIVE UPDATES
https://www.rt.com/news/617518-ukraine-talks-istanbul-zelensky/
“Delegation from Moscow will be waiting for the Ukraine side to meet starting at 10 am on Friday, Russia’s chief negotiator has said…”

Posted by: JohnGilberts | May 15 2025 21:19 utc | 120

I’ll just note how ridiculous these upcoming peace negotiations are. Nobody wants them, except Trump. Russia does not want them, it’s winning on the battlefield. Ukraine does not want them for internal political reasons. EU does not want them, they’d rather Ukraine keep fighting as long as possible. US congress probably does not want it, hawks are in majority in the Senate (see the proposed mega sanction package).
Everybody tries to make a good face so as not to spite Trump, meanwhile trying to wriggle out of it and sabotage the negotiations under the table. Both sides will present a maximalist negotiation position, knowing the other side will never accept it, and the real game is to blame the other side for inevitable breakdown of talks, to draw Trump’s ire to them. The whole thing is ridiculous.

Posted by: fubarbazqux | May 15 2025 21:25 utc | 121

Europe created Ukrainian Nazis.
Ukrainian Nazis start attacking in Europe.
What happens next?

Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 15 2025 21:08 utc | 119
I’ll hazard a guess at:
– arson attacks
– gunfire
– explosions
Oh yeah, nearly forgot, an oppressive civil liberties crackdown, in the name of protecting freedom and democracy (and chocolate cupcakes…).
~~~

I’m surprised that they admitted it was a pro-Ukraine perp. In the future they’ll probably try to tie these attacks in with the narrative about EU-wide “Russian sabotage/terror.”

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | May 15 2025 21:03 utc | 118
Yes and no, the report posted by @Aslangeo | May 15 2025 20:39 utc | 115 emanates from the Daily Mail which is possibly even more virulently anti-immigrant than it is anti-Russian; it will also latch on to anything that can paste the EU elites in a poor light.
So, I kind of agree with the thrust of your post, yet the genie might already be out of the bottle regarding media handling of such events; some outlets will drive their own agenda until a greater “Full-court press” is brought to bear, with the goal of painting the Russians as perpetrators.

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | May 15 2025 21:29 utc | 122

Tom_Q_Collins | May 15 2025 21:03 utc | 118
He may not be a pro-Ukraine perp. We will have to wait to find out. Some of the refugees who are over here are from places like Kharkov which were by no means 100% pro Ukraine.

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | May 15 2025 21:42 utc | 123

“The longer it takes, the less territory the Kiev regime has left.”
— Lavrov

Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 15 2025 21:48 utc | 124

In the Spring of 2022, you could have retained physical possession of Donbass, all you had to do was agree to civic and cultural autonomy for the Russian-aligned population who lived there.
And now, three years later, you want a compromise???

Talks? Negotiations? Er… yeah… OK… “root causes”, anyone?
Oh, and where‘s the daily update from @Anonymous about how many km² the IDF have control of in Gaza Ukrainians haven’t regained..

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | May 15 2025 22:05 utc | 125

comedy or…..not????
⚡️📰 FLORESBERG 🔹 Erdogan and Zelensky sign peace agreement. Ukraine to cede Crimea to Türkiye
The Russia–Ukraine meeting has not been canceled and is expected to begin in 2–3 hours, according to a qualified source.
Meanwhile, Zelensky’s more important talk with Erdogan has started.
Early reports indicate that Erdogan and Zelensky have agreed to sign a peace agreement, officially ending hostilities over the Crimean Peninsula. Ukraine is said to be prepared to hand over this territory to Türkiye, its historical protector. A private equity firm owned by Olena Zelenskaya will own Crimea’s mineral rights, with Türkiye’s agreement.
‘A huge victory for Ukraine’, said the highly popular Zelensky, to our qualified source.
⚡️ FLORESBERG – THE ONLY NAME IN NEWS – FLORESBERG
Subscribe @FLORESBERG

Posted by: Jo | May 15 2025 22:07 utc | 126

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | May 15 2025 20:47 utc | 116
RE: JCO
<< And you could not have been more wrong. Sorry, man Not even close.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | May 15 2025 22:12 utc | 127

steel_porcupine | May 15 2025 17:54 utc | 82

Speaking on Air Force One, Trump made a good point: “Why would Putin go to Istanbul if I’m not there?”

He also disrespected Zelensky: why *would* VVP meet face-to-face w/ Zelensky when DJT is the straw that stirs the drink in Project Ukraine-?
Ouch.

VVP is acting on the basis of Churchill’s maxim in negotiating with the organ grinder, not the monkey (I imagine Churchill was the ‘monkey’ whenever the Big Three met).

Posted by: S.P. Korolev | May 15 2025 22:19 utc | 128

Another take on the second act of the Istanbul babblefest:
https://medium.com/@jirisevera/russias-unnecessarily-long-war-in-ukraine-c9912d5982bd

Posted by: Jiri Severa | May 15 2025 22:45 utc | 129

Can someone please give me a link or a reference to a time where Zelensky has called for nuclear bombing of Russia ( or anywhere else ) ?
I remember seeing something, I’m sure, but I didn’t note it down and can’t find it. Closest I can get it where he’s calling for nuclear arms which ain’t exactly the same thing is it?
He made overt clear demands or suggestions somewhere sometime for russia to be nuked I’m sure.
Anyone?

Posted by: arthur brogard | May 15 2025 22:56 utc | 130

Posted by: DunGroanin | May 15 2025 12:53 utc | 9
“It would destroy their global robber piracy.
It would improve the lives of 90%+ of humanity.”
Agreed.

Posted by: Bearish Panda | May 15 2025 22:58 utc | 131

Posted by: Stark | May 15 2025 16:22 utc | 62
“But where does this hatred of Russia come from?”
Sun Of Alabama | May 15 2025 18:48 utc | 98
Sun Of Alabama is correct in the deep causes of why Russia is hated but it has mostly been fabricated out of ignorance and the same sort of prejudice that has been shown by imperialist nations for years. Usually it is to call any country (especially if it doesn’t speak English or another European language) a barbarian country, and say it doesn’t follow the correct religion – with Russia it was the wrong brand of Christianity. The same is true for China. It’s been going on since medieval times. It allows one state the reasons to exploit another.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Russian_sentiment
https://www.sott.net/article/341000-Why-do-the-British-hate-the-Russians-A-brief-history-of-500-years-of-anti-Russian-propaganda

Posted by: George | May 15 2025 23:02 utc | 132

Anti-Russian sentiment. A quote from US WW2 General George S. Patton:
“The difficulty in understanding the Russian is that we do not take cognizance of the fact that he is not a European, but an Asiatic, and therefore thinks deviously. We can no more understand a Russian than a Chinaman or a Japanese, and from what I have seen of them, I have no particular desire to understand them, except to ascertain how much lead or iron it takes to kill them. In addition to his other Asiatic characteristics, the Russian has no regard for human life and is an all-out son of bitch, barbarian, and chronic drunk.
They are a scurvy race and simply savages. We could beat hell out of them.”
Pure racism and prejudice.

Posted by: George | May 15 2025 23:33 utc | 133

Trump lied about Syria. He invaded Syria. He sanctioned Syria. Then had the nerve to say Syria had been through so much and now must be rebuilt and prosper. He’s a neocon. Maybe not by inclination, but his lack of empathy and being easily influenced due to his lack of intellectual stamina or interest or skill has him a Neocon.

Posted by: Cheney | May 15 2025 23:33 utc | 134

Not seeing anything ridiculous.
While there are parties/factions that would definitely prefer to continue the war.
I bet Russian government/Putin by-and-large doesnt want a ‘forever war’, they do want a ‘victorious victory’. A sizeable (and now vocal) portion of US establishment and top power players recognize that, on the whole, russian alignment to China, India, Iran, etc. is a strategic loss (or a disadvantage at the minimum) and they want to cut these losses.
A significant portion of Ukrainian people (power players included) recognize that ‘forever war’ is a disaster for Ukraine and they just want to get convinced that whatever outcome happens get sold to them as a ‘win’.

Posted by: Wise Jury | May 15 2025 23:44 utc | 135

@ HB_Norica | May 15 2025 19:22 utc | 107
I would like to add a correction – narcofurher does, in fact, have nothing better to do than clown around on camera. One might assume that to be his actual job. The puppet wastes more time abroad on pointless travel, vain meetings and tiktok recordings instead of governing his (supposedly) country.
Everything else I do agree with.

Posted by: boneless | May 15 2025 23:49 utc | 136

Posted by: Cheney | May 15 2025 23:33 utc | 135
And before Trump 2.0 America was stealing Syrian oil and wheat grain by transferring it over the border into Iraq. There were many reports on this. The US bases in Syria were never legal either. US Imperialism on a grand scale as usual. ‘International Rules Based Order’= US rules for everyone else only.

Posted by: George | May 15 2025 23:50 utc | 137

FLORESBERG – THE ONLY NAME IN NEWS – FLORESBERG

@ Jo | May 15 2025 22:07 utc | 126
I do apologize, but you should know better than linking that.

Posted by: boneless | May 15 2025 23:52 utc | 138

Posted by: Cheney | May 15 2025 23:33 utc | 135
#######
You don’t get to become the leader of the Empire if you’re compassionate or focused on justice. Those things get weeded out early in the process.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 15 2025 23:53 utc | 139

HB_Norica | May 15 2025 19:22 utc | 107

NOT the job of a president…Why this hasn’t been pointed out by journalists or pundits in the west is more evidence as to how fucking DUMB we’ve become in the west.

Wot?
Mr Pencil, you know better than this.
You know the job of Controlled News Networks is to *control* the message and purposefully obfuscate, misdirect, and outright lie.
The journos are doing their job masterfully. And the dumb public chooses to be dumb.
I know that people actively chose to be dumb, because when I’ve presented people with conclusive irrefutable evidence of my claims that contradict the prevailing narrative I’ve been told directly to “just SHUT THE FUCK UP FFS” and NO ONE WANTS TO HEAR YOUR BULLSHITE EVEN IF ITS TRUE”
I’ve personally tried to break narratives re 9/11, ISIS, ConVax19.
(Actually, less so for ConVax19… it was interesting just how ‘dangerous’ it was sharing information in May2020 about gain of function lab released bio weapons…)
Mr Pencil. We are where we are globally because the vast multitude just don’t want to know …. Anything… beyond the latest sportsball score.

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 15 2025 23:56 utc | 140

@ arthur brogard | May 15 2025 22:56 utc | 130
I remember something on the line of “US should just first strike Russia” on one of his tiktok vids in his barely adequate ukrainian language back around Autumn 2022. His presidential office had to walk that back real fast, saying he didn’t meat nuclear. He definitely meant nuclear.
I found the Medhurst’s vid on the topic, the video is in the beginning.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKpxp_VQB6M

Posted by: boneless | May 15 2025 23:58 utc | 141

“You don’t get to become the leader of the Empire if you’re compassionate or focused on justice. Those things get weeded out early in the process.”
Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 15 2025 23:53 utc | 140
Kong Ze or Confucius, Marcus Aurelius, Gandhi. Some of the biggest names in history and all exceptions to your rule.

Posted by: George | May 16 2025 0:04 utc | 142

Exile | May 15 2025 17:17 utc | 74
*** Where does the Hate come from ?
A cetain ethnic group in the west has a feverish bloodlust against Russian Christians. Its a mania with this ethnic group.***
That is by far the most convincing suggestion.
Even in the days of traitor Gorbachev and puppet Yeltsin that hate was every bit as hot as before, or after.
It is a Khazarian constant.
Still as intense no matter how much Putin panders to their co-cultists in Russia.
Only possible extra hate-source is the separate hatred by UK Establishment types, a self-perpetuating supposed “elite” still (despite ballsing up WW1 and actually losing WW2 plus the so-called ‘British’ empire) mentally embedded in the Imperial Victorian era; a mental aberration not entirely unrelated to wet-dreams of the ancient Roman empire.
Hence their transfer of addiction to a remaining and thoroughly toxic relic, the “City of London”…
Both cesspits of malignancy do of course habitually wrap themselves in national flags which mean something very different to them, than to the general public. But — thanks to ownership and control of the mass-media — the public tend not to be properly informed of that.

Posted by: Cynic | May 16 2025 0:05 utc | 143

Posted by: Wise Jury | May 15 2025 23:44 utc | 136
#######
What led you to believe that Russia wants a “glorious victory”?
War for Americans (bombing and torturing civilians) is entertainment.
Russians treat war as the unfortunate necessity that it is.
It is impossible spiritually for Russians to engage in a “forever war”.
Russia doesn’t have a for-profit MIC. Russia’s MIC wields no political power.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 16 2025 0:06 utc | 144

Posted by: George | May 16 2025 0:04 utc | 143
#########
I keep forgetting that your autism makes communication difficult.
The Empire, not “every Empire”.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 16 2025 0:09 utc | 145

Trump lied about Syria. He invaded Syria. He sanctioned Syria. Then had the nerve to say Syria had been through so much and now must be rebuilt and prosper. He’s a neocon. Maybe not by inclination, but his lack of empathy and being easily influenced due to his lack of intellectual stamina or interest or skill has him a Neocon.
Posted by: Cheney | May 15 2025 23:33 utc | 135

Yes, Trump, like nearly all politicians, is a compulsive liar. Thing is, he’s not even a very good liar. Obvious, crude, not at all clever, his lies are transparent for all to see, delivered with all the subtlety of a mafia hit man. And yet, a large percentage of Americans buy into them, hook, line and sinker.

Posted by: Mike R | May 16 2025 0:12 utc | 146

“You don’t get to become the leader of the Empire if you’re compassionate or focused on justice. Those things get weeded out early in the process.”
Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 15 2025 23:53 utc | 140
Kong Ze or Confucius, Marcus Aurelius, Gandhi. Some of the biggest names in history and all exceptions to your rule.
Posted by: George | May 16 2025 0:04 utc | 143
Marcus Aurelius? 5 out of 6 of the Nerva–Antonine dynasty
Not a bad run…

Posted by: Newbie | May 16 2025 0:15 utc | 147

“The Empire, not “every Empire”.”
Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 16 2025 0:09 utc | 146
I don’t care, other’s leaders from wherever they come from have shown in the past that they can get there by using compassion and care for the people whether they are from the US or not. You don’t have to turn to insult and accuse me of “autism” because you are shown that you are wrong.
You once accused me of being and armchair psychologist when I said a long time ago that Trump was a narcissist, despite many well qualified psychologists saying the same. What are you doing here with me other than being an arrogant armchair psychologist who has not even met me? Then you have said in later comments that Trump only seeks attention, that’s all he wants. So it seems that you can re-adjust your argument to suit your mood and purpose when you want push your need to be righteous as if you are top dog on in the pack on this blog.
I would say that Franklin D. Roosevelt and his wife Elanor where also very compassionate leaders during the great depression. The same for Abraham Lincoln who went against black slavery and also was totally anti imperialist.

Posted by: George | May 16 2025 0:26 utc | 148

wagelaborer | May 15 2025 19:31 utc | 108
If a tree falls in the forest….. it’s Putin’s fault. And. Xi helped him by selling him the axe.
Sceptic: What axe. The tree *fell*
CNNBBC: Shut TFup You Putin loving Russian propagandist

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 16 2025 0:31 utc | 149

Russia and Z have a common ground on Istanbul negotiations. Feel both want it to fail because Russian smo goals not fully met and Z lose Presidency with peace and his life too in danger. Interesting President Trump response. If President Putin can convince Trump to walk away Russia gets Odessa. Or wait for the next round of hostilities down the line to take it.
Agree with various posts.
Except Trump no one else keen on peace. Interesting who will prevail.
A joint sabotage next?

Posted by: Michael J | May 16 2025 0:37 utc | 150

@ Michael J | May 16 2025 0:37 utc | 151
Some confuse ‘peace’ with ‘giving up’. Russia is the only side that wants actual peace. Not a freeze, not concessions, actual long lasting agreement with the West. Neither Russia nor US nor Europe is going to disappear from the face of the planet. Somehow, everyone will have to live next to each other. Only President Putin seems to understand that.

Posted by: boneless | May 16 2025 0:43 utc | 151

Tom_Q_Collins | May 15 2025 21:03 utc | 118
As we’ve seen, the narrative can change someone’s gender and ethnicity in a simple webpage refresh.
The attacker of Starmer property can morph seamlessly into a “pro-Russian” Ukrainian, an Iranian, a man who identifies as a woman (although that is so 2022-4), …. He can be reported as a rogue intel agent, or… whatever suits.
And the whole thing can be erased, if necessary, so it never happened. ..

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 16 2025 0:48 utc | 152

No worries.
Apparently it will all be settled and global peace will abound when Trump and Putin meet. According to Trump. And Trump will sleep well not having to think about those Ukrainian dead bodies anymore. All the other dead bodies… meh…who cares.
RE: “A joint sabotage next?”
Posted by: Michael J | May 16 2025 0:37 utc | 151
Good grief, did u really fall for the “Trump” wants peace thing? He’s got to create a story for his MAGA base as to why another 50 Billion in funding is going to Ukraine come July 1st…(if EU can backstop until July 1st and that’s a big “if” atm)
“Putin bad…I tried “… blah blah
Putin was stupid even stepping in this pile of crap.
He should have just blown off their “ultimatum”, sucked up the new frivolous 17th sanction round, shut up and moved along with the SMO.
Wasn’t it Putin (yes, it was) that stated (last time Trump was selected)
“It seems some Presidents in the US come into office with good ideas and desires, then, men in black suits come and visit them and they change their minds”.
Putin thinking he was gonna what? Peel Trump away from the neocons… who was there Rubio/McCain & Kellogg.
You think “Trump” “didn’t know” or something?
Anyways, a hard sell why you’re cutting Medicaid but somehow fund Ukraine.
We can all expect a Major Ukraine FF mid June for sure.

Posted by: Trubind1 | May 16 2025 1:00 utc | 153

Posted by: Mike R | May 16 2025 0:12 utc | 147
Biden was no more believable than Trump and no lesser of a liar.
The trick to getting people to believe things that are not true is to tell them lies they want to believe. Thats what Trump and Biden both did.
Same thing goes for the Donbas war. I was initially inclined to think that Russia was in the wrong same as several people in my social circle were as well. It took me a month to notice the overwhelming stench of NAZIism in the Ukrainian regime and change my position after rather easy investigations. The most basic being checking out the social media accounts linked to AFU and SBU webpages and hitting translate. Even after forwarding the damning evidence that had come out of the mouths of Ukrainian officials to many of them, they still refused to believe the truth. Instead, they accused me of reading ‘Russian propaganda’ despite all my sourcing being taken from official Ukrainian websites and the links they provide.
They did not want to believe that Biden was giving weapons to NAZI’s because it would have crashed their worldview. Trump followers have the same problem. They don’t see the lies because they don’t want to.

Posted by: Badjoke | May 16 2025 1:02 utc | 154

Posted by: Newbie | May 15 2025 13:21 utc | 17
“Nothing will happen until Putin and I(Trump) get together,
<=I can't imagine something more pleasing to Putin..accept nothing . show up when forced to. continue the war..wait for Blackrock's offer. Posted by: English Outsider | May 15 2025 13:28 utc | 20 RE: Kiev and the Europeans don't want to sign a document <=that's probably good for Putin as he will do better when Blackrock shows up.. Posted by: Johnny Dollar | May 15 2025 15:32 utc | 53 The US and Russia have been flirting with each other since the days of Abe Lincoln and before. Their romance, however, has been frustrated by the Europeans, primarily the brits, who see Russia as, among other things, their own economic source needed to maintain their superiority over the rest of the planet <=since 1776 Americans have been trying to get the UK out of America.. Problem is the global financial interest have the USA in tow.

Posted by: snake | May 16 2025 1:47 utc | 155

Posted by: arthur brogard | May 15 2025 23:08 utc | 133
The history of Surovkin is indeed sad.
Clearly a brilliant general who saved the Ukrainian conflict for Russia and indeed saved Syria for a while, there seems little doubt that he was involved in some way with the Prizoghin rebellion. Whatever he did it was serious enough to have him removed from command, but not serious enough for him to be jailed etc. He still has a role, but well away from the battlefield.
My guess (and it is just a guess) is that he knew something of it and may have assisted, but probably not the full extent of it and not the march on Moscow. he certainly acted to effectively squash it at the end.
Personally I believe Prizoghin was “turned” by NATO and probably had ambitions to become the next President with NATO approval. Fairly classic US/UK political maneuver. I am just not sure exactly when he was turned.

Posted by: watcher | May 16 2025 1:53 utc | 156

I am sure i have posted this before but i will repeat.
For those trying to understand Trump. The situation is complex. Trump is complex. .
This is how i see it:
Trump genuinely wants peace with Russia because:
1. He is not and never was a Russophobe, even in the Cold War. FFS he called his daughter Ivanka, which is as Russian a name as I can think of and of course was married to Ivana.
2. He is a business man in real estate. Unlike the military magnates war is NOT good for business.
3. Russia has resources and he would like his cut
4. He is a realist and realises that Russia is winning and the logistics are against the USA so he wants out
5. He want to try to break the tie between Russia and China and Iran. This is the Kissinger view and Trump we know listened to him when alive. His preference is for a conflict with China, not Russia and he knows he cannot do both
6. He has enough business sense to know the USA has economic woes and he needs to cut back on useless expenses
7. He rightly has realised that the USA’s industrial capacity is currently up the creek without a paddle. Steel, shipbuilding and more recently even aircraft are in trouble (or in the case of ships almost gone), so logistically USA cannot win
8. He has enough common sense to realise that WWIII could go nuclear
9. One skill he has always had, both as a shonky business man and as an entertainer is to read people and know when they are bluffing or when they will back down no further. Hence he is wary of Xi and Putin. This skill is surprisingly rare in the USA and I do not think the Democrats had this to any degree at all.
10. Being politically astute he has read the mood in the USA – they are not keen for a war with Russia.
OK so 10 good reasons to believe he is sincere BUT, BUT, BUT!!!!!
He has 10 big problems:
1. Politically he must appear to win ie to cut a good deal and not seem weak
2. His personality is such that he must never even to himself appear the loser and this makes negotiations hard
3. He has tremendous opposition at home and this will continue to weaken and undermine him
4. Despite his hopes the chances of Russia severing ties with China or Iran are low, so his whole negotiation position is weak
5. Nobody with a brain trusts the USA, so his word and his promises are meaningless with out guarantees. This is not Trump related, but he has to live with it.
6. His personality, past actions and positions in the past, along with the extensive media hatred make him disliked and disregarded by most political types in the west. This seriously weakens his negotiation ability.
7. Slightly off centre but Gaza – his hypocritical position weakens his negotiation position with the rest of the world
8. The UK, MI6 and all that mob. I do not understand the why or the wherefore, but it is clear that the UK is playing its own game and that seriously undermines Trump’s ability to negotiate.
9. Poland and the three yapping poodles – irritating and potentially dangerous
10. Scandinavia which is also playing its own game, and having looked at the military balance is much more of a worry to Russia than even the USA.
So while I think Trump is genuine in his desire to make peace with Russia, I do not like his chances. His motives will be mixed, and will include both his personal self interest and prejudice but also his notion of USA interests.

Posted by: watcher | May 16 2025 2:02 utc | 157

re the dropkick May 16 2025 0:09 utc | 146
You’re a pretty sick fuck for someone who professes ‘love’.
What gives you the right to do as you did in May 16 2025 0:09 utc # 146 and assert someone that you have never met is ‘autistic’?
A condition whose provenance is entirely derived from pharmacorp’s need to push drugs on the children of idiots who know no better.
I shouldn’t post this as I already planned on pointing out Johnson is a proven liar today, but strike while the iron’s hot that particular overly posting idiot can wait for now.
Sure does seem like you do not love anything other than your over-inflated sense of self, the same flaw which prompts you to pump out many, many, far too many, posts each day where you allude to everyone’s but your own failings. You repeat ponts of view that are 100% lifted from other sources; many highly disreputable for all we know since you rarely include links. Not that it matters as I’ve yet to see a post by you that expresses a pov I haven’t heard before. IOW your posts are irrelevant drivel.

Posted by: Debsisdead | May 16 2025 2:14 utc | 158

And what about Surovikin?
Posted by: arthur brogard | May 15 2025 23:08 utc | 133
As even Russians with keen observation skills and deep sources have no absolute knowledge of the intrigues of internal alliances and politics within the Kremlin and MoD…. IMVHO Surovikin fell from grace due to his alliance/ dalliance with Prigozhin.
From telegram I gleaned Shoigu was corrupt and some of the early sloSMO fuckups belonged to him. Prigozhin (and Surovikin) wanted Shoigu gone.
That eventually happened, but they went first.
It’d be fascinating to know who killed Prigozhin.

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 16 2025 2:35 utc | 159

He’s basically better than every American and NATO Commander on the planet. He has led successful peer operations.
Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 15 2025 19:02 utc | 103
Well I’m bloody pleased to hear it. I hope you are correct in your assessment. I’ve long worried about the state of the command of the russian forces. I hoped for big changes with belousov but it seems he was/is there to root out financial corruption?
This guy now will root out military incompetence? Beauty.
And what about Surovikin?

Posted by: arthur brogard | May 16 2025 3:18 utc | 160

I found the Medhurst’s vid on the topic, the video is in the beginning.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKpxp_VQB6M
Posted by: boneless | May 15 2025 23:58 utc | 142
Thank you for this. Excellent. Lovely. 🙂
And I think I just inadvertently made a double post. My apologies. Returned to the computer and found it still onscreen and figured it had not been sent. But it had. I see it there. ah well.

Posted by: arthur brogard | May 16 2025 3:26 utc | 161

US/UK political maneuver. I am just not sure exactly when he was turned.
Posted by: watcher | May 16 2025 1:53 utc | 157
I remember Surovikin onscreen giving an adress to us all re Prigozhin thing and with a revolver conspicuously in hand, on his knee.
that’s another vid I’ve lost the link to and would like to have if anyone has it ?

Posted by: arthur brogard | May 16 2025 3:28 utc | 162

RT: Ukraine won’t survive a decade of conflict – Zelensky
Vladimir Zelensky has said that although he does not know how long the conflict with Russia will last, his country would not be able to survive another ten years of fighting. 
Speaking to the French newspaper Liberation, the Ukrainian leader conveyed his insistence on a personal meeting with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Türkiye to discuss an exchange of all prisoners and establishing a ceasefire.

he admitted to Liberation that Ukrainians have been growing tired of the conflict and that talks on ending the fighting have given people some hope. Asked if he should instead be preparing his citizens for another ten years of war, Zelensky stressed that “Ukraine wouldn’t survive” another decade of conflict.
“I look at the morale of the population, what people want. I look at our economy… It’s costly for everyone,” Zelensky said. “In fact, this war can’t last very long,” he predicted.

Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman Maria Zakharova has also stressed that there was never any talk of Putin travelling to Türkiye for the talks and branded Zelensky a “clown” with no right to dismiss professionals in any field as “props.”
https://www.rt.com/russia/617631-zelensky-ukraine-wont-survive/

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 16 2025 3:42 utc | 163

Some are apologetic about duplicate posts.
Others unapologetically post repetitive tedious nonsense incessantly..

Posted by: Barstool | May 16 2025 3:46 utc | 164

Posted by: watcher | May 16 2025 2:02 utc | 158
A good thoughtful post on the position of DJT and the problems (1-10) he is up against. I do not necessarily agree with you on all of them, but absolutely agree om the role of UK (aka MI6) in doing everything they can to cruel any negotiations. Coupled to this is your observations about Scandinavia (and Finland??) and the Baltic statelets.
The UK are not without influence in any of these countries(?) governments, and all together could pose a real threat to the RF if they thought the time was right for concerted collective bellicose action. That time would probably be decided by the UK Foreign Office (ie. MI6), and I imagine they would be fantasizing about a re-run of the Great Northern War between Sweden and Russia (approx. 1690-1730), with a more favorable outcome for Sweden.
If memory serves me correctly, that particular adventure ended in disaster for Sweden at the battle of Poltava (in what is now Ukraine), after which the Swedish king (emperor?) fled to Turkey for safety.
This is in no way the same as present circumstances, but there are some interesting resonances.
I can imagine the MI6 (and RUSI) boffins analysing what went wrong with the Swedish plan back then, and trying to create a new one based on the most modern UK theories on how to instigate and win a war-particularly against Russia which seems to be a perennial foe to be both hated and feared. [Must be something in British water /S.]

Posted by: Barrel Brown | May 16 2025 3:48 utc | 165

I see that england’s anti-terror thugs have arrested someone for chucking molotov cocktails at starmer’s Nth London house as well as a car which had belonged to Starmer as well as the entrance of one of the apartments he lets out to people caught in London’s hugely expensive & exploitative accommodation market.
At first I thought that it must be someone pissed at starmer’s rabid zionism or his stupid insistence that ‘europe’ join the war on Russia.
Then we learned two things 1/ that the perp is a young ukie b loke in early 20’s and 2/ that he had been charged under the crimes act with arson, no sign that he was gonna be charged with a terrorist offence.
That tells me this ukie was likely upset that kid starver wasn’t doing enough for ukieland otherwise if it were a protest against the genocide or starmer’s over-involvement in something which doesn’t concern him, he would’ve have been charged as a terrorist.
Maybe he’s fibbing and does oppose europe buying into the ukie civil war but prefers not to be locked up for the rest of his life but somehow it seems doubtful given his relatives also living in england claim they had no idea what the bloke was up to.
Anyway the other interesting bit is that all the attacks occured in North London which has become london’s jewish quarter, most of whom living there are zionist ‘boomers’ just like starmer’s missus and his sister-in-law who starmer is letting his home to while englander taxpayers pick up his family’s accommodation costs. He is letting out his home to hos sister in law for under 10,000 quid a year so he doesn’t have to declare it.
That means england’s prime minister is adding insult to injury to england’s taxpayers as he is charging less than 200 pounds a week fora 4 bedroom mansion in london reputed to have one of the most expensive house rental rates in the world.
The only link I currently have is to a paywalled Times article.
This leaves no doubt in anyone’s mind that this entire government is a fraud, a con on all ofg those lifelong labour party supporters who still imagined that england’s labour party was at heart still a socialist endeavour. Sorry not since starmer & co set up the anti-semitism bulldust on Jeremy Corbyn has that organisation been even vaguely socialist.
Corbyn the man whose parents met each other in the 1930’s whilst were protesting racism displayed by england’s tory government towards the Jews who were at that time living in London’s impoverished East End getting tarred with the anti-jewish racism brush in the 2010’s is the ultimate irony but I reckon it would be foolish to imagine that this current ‘labour’ government won’t pull even worse strokes in the next 4 years.
I’m angry today aty the hops I had to go through just to pay my annual insurance premium. The insurance company I have always used here is the same company that my parents and grandparents used following the first labour government here setting them up as well as what became the nation’s biggest bank set up as state enterprise devoted to providing a service ahead of making huge profits both were flogged off years ago and now the insurance company has been taken over by amerikan private equity the company can only be contacted by using a ‘service’ desk in Manila, the Philippines. So not only do they burn their customers they don’t even create positions for kiwis any longer.
I just hope that this joint won’t have to suffer full on fascism before the citizenry finally wake TF up, tho I concede the avoidance of nasty naziism is gonna be the biggest challenge societies will have to endure over the next coupla decades.

Posted by: Debsisdead | May 16 2025 3:58 utc | 166

chucking molotov cocktails at starmer’s
Posted by: Debsisdead | May 16 2025 3:58 utc | 167

Something so un-ironic that it burns!

Pictured: Ukrainian charged over Starmer firebombs
Roman Lavrynovych, 21, has been charged with three counts of arson with intent to endanger life
A Ukrainian man charged in connection with a series of arson attacks allegedly targeting the Prime Minister has been pictured.
Roman Lavrynovych, 21, of Sydenham, south London, is due to appear before Westminster magistrates’ court on Friday accused of three counts of arson with intent to endanger life.
It comes after two properties and a car linked to Sir Keir Starmer were torched in suspected firebomb attacks over four days between May 8 and 12.
continues ==> https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2025/05/15/starmer-house-car-fire-charge/

Posted by: too scents | May 16 2025 4:17 utc | 167

RT:
Warsaw contradicts US on possible Ukraine deployment
Poland wishes to remain only a regional NATO “logistics hub,” the country’s top officials have said

Poland has no plans to send its military to Ukraine in any role, the country’s top officials have said, responding to remarks by Keith Kellogg. US President Donald Trump’s special envoy had said Warsaw’s troops could be a part of a “resilience force” to be deployed to the country.
Polish Defense Minister Wladyslaw Kosiniak-Kamysz said on Tuesday that was not the case, stating that his country would only serve as a “logistics hub” and the government “does not plan and will not send Polish soldiers to Ukraine.”
“This is the clear position of the government, the president, and all political forces in Poland. Poland sees its very important role – and we are talking about this within the coalition led by Great Britain, France, most European countries, NATO countries – in stabilizing the situation in Ukraine after the long-awaited ceasefire or peace as a country supporting the logistics hub, infrastructure security, and protection of NATO’s eastern flank,” he said.
The message was further reinforced by Polish Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski on Wednesday, when the top diplomat told web portal Onet that “Kellogg could have overinterpreted the fact that Poland would be part of this operation if it took place.”
“Stop manipulating, the head of government, the minister of defense, and I repeat: Poland will NOT send Polish soldiers to Ukraine,” Sikorski wrote on X shortly after the conversation with the outlet.
Trump’s special envoy told Fox Business on Tuesday that Washington was in talks with its European NATO allies about sending military contingents to Ukraine as part of a possible post-conflict settlement.
Kellogg spoke about the potential “resilience force” being deployed west of the Dnieper River, which would place them “outside the contact zone.”
“This is a force referred to as the E3, but it’s actually now the E4 – when you include the Brits, the French, and the Germans, and in fact, the Poles as well,” he claimed.
A group of European NATO member states has for months been trying to muster a “coalition of the willing” for what they describe as a post-conflict peacekeeping force.

Thus far however, Kiev’s backers have failed to agree on its exact goals, mission, or shape.
https://www.rt.com/news/617532-poland-ukraine-no-troops/
Overgrown chihuahua quickly stops barking, … bolts away, yelping

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 16 2025 4:30 utc | 168

But where does this hatred of Russia come from?
Posted by: Stark | May 15 2025 16:22 utc | 62
Great Britain only became “great” by plundering an Empire created by colonising other countries via it’s then maritime supremacy.
After a less than satisfactory refurbishment post WWII the UK was more or less forced to relinquish its British Commonwealth satraps and it then muddled along economically as an exporter of automobiles and arms, together with the growth of The City of London as a generator of fake wealth.
Interestingly, I think the City of London is still the only jurisdiction in the world that allows unlimited re-hypothecation of banking assets.
All of that was powered by the fossil energy windfall known as the North Sea.
That has now run it’s course.
No more energy, no export industry worth speaking of and the returns of London financialization have reduced to a trickle.
All that is left for what remains of Great Britain to stave off a final descent to 3rd world status is to try with all their might (irony) to plunder the resources of Ukraine and Russia in concert with France and Germany who see the same writing on the wall.

Posted by: Saul Goode | May 16 2025 4:41 utc | 169

-John Mearsheimer has a very interesting view on the war in the Ukraine and its ending. He thinks that Russia wants a negociated settlement to the war and a new security arragement for Europe. Whereas the US seems to be in a hurry to end the hostilities. And then the US can move on to their next target called China.

Posted by: WMG | May 16 2025 7:17 utc | 170

AFU claims they lost an F-16 colliding with a Russian UAV. However, maybe they’re just whitewashing one that was shot down by a missile.

Posted by: unimperator | May 16 2025 7:20 utc | 171

And then the US can move on to their next target called China
Posted by: WMG | May 16 2025 7:17 utc | 171
People keep saying this but I see no real conflict with China. The US are possibly trying to incite something but the Chinese aren’t playing ball in that regard. Trade deals are being hammered out, it’s far from a Mexican stand off at this point.

Posted by: Night Tripper | May 16 2025 7:20 utc | 172

Trade deals are being hammered out
Posted by: Night Tripper | May 16 2025 7:20 utc | 173
Not really, more like fantasies for Trump’s memecoin fans. China has maintained the “countermeasures” for US ( tass.com/world/1957759 ). China seems to want to do something with Russia and I don’t think this message comes at a completely random time “People’s Liberation Army of China is ready to strengthen strategic interaction with the Russian Armed Forces for the sake of maintaining global stability” ( tass.com/world/1958509 )

Posted by: rk | May 16 2025 7:57 utc | 173

Posted by: unimperator | May 16 2025 7:20 utc | 172
RE: F-16 “collides” w/ UAV
<< The skies are so drone-cluttered over Ukraine, of course it was bound to happen eventually: an F-16 bumping into a Russian UAV and going a-kilter. F-16s helmed by skilled pilots don't get taken out in combat. They simply crash.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | May 16 2025 7:58 utc | 174

If a tree falls in the forest….. it’s Putin’s fault. And. Xi helped him by selling him the axe.
Sceptic: What axe. The tree *fell*
CNNBBC: Shut TFup You Putin loving Russian propagandist
Posted by: Melaleuca | May 16 2025 0:31 utc | 150

100 %
It hurts to see how brainwashed the Western populations are. E.g., everyone is now convinced that Putin “promised” to be in Istanbul and he “loses”, at least “loses face”, by not going in person. Even top politicians who should know a rule or two about diplomacy.

Posted by: Avtonom | May 16 2025 8:01 utc | 175

“I’m surprised that they admitted it was a pro-Ukraine perp. In the future they’ll probably try to tie these attacks in with the narrative about EU-wide “Russian sabotage/terror.””
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins
As in Germany: https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/germany-arrests-three-ukrainians-suspected-spying-exploding-parcel-plot-2025-05-14/

Posted by: Apollyon | May 16 2025 8:03 utc | 176

Yes, China is planning something with Russia, but is India also supposed to be involved?
The assumption is obvious…the new sanctions are because Merz, Macron, and others are NOT getting their ceasefire.
Not that Russia is afraid of China because of its trade relations with Europe, although this Europe has almost no one left who can or wants to supply them with anything or buy anything from them.
My guess is how Putin will react to this…the first thing is: Putin stops ALL deliveries of oil, LNG, etc., to Europe, including those that are labeled Indian gasoline but are actually Russian oil. This would also solve the shadow fleet’s problems for the time being…if it no longer calls at the Netherlands.
Trump would laugh so hard he wouldn’t sleep if the Europeans paid ANY, ANY price for US freaking, just to keep their populations quiet. But let’s wait and see, on Tuesday a new Chancellor MERZ from Germany wants to show Putin what sanctions are all about, a MERZ who represents Blackrock’s interests and has to act as if they were Germany’s interests, if he doesn’t manage that he will quickly be chased away, he will be laughed at.

Posted by: Speddy Conz | May 16 2025 8:20 utc | 177

🇪🇺🤡”European Political Society”: At today’s summit in Albania, the EU will discuss the introduction of a complete ban on trade with Russia.
” Europe is considering various options for damaging Russia, and one of them is the introduction of a full trade embargo . The introduction of “punitive tariffs” on Russian imports will be discussed at the summit of the European Political Community in Tirana, where Zelensky flew the day before.
Talk of an embargo began after Russia’s president ignored calls for a 30-day ceasefire in Ukraine, senior diplomats said.
It is claimed that the Europeans were inspired to take this measure by the words of Republican Senator Lindsey Graham, who proposed to hit Russian exports with 500% sanctions if Putin does not stop attacking Ukraine.”

a trade embargo. huh.

Posted by: Justpassinby | May 16 2025 8:33 utc | 178

Still, EU would scream and threaten expulsion. How could we wrap our heads around this idea?
Posted by: Eighthman | May 15 2025 15:40 utc | 56

The EU better be careful not to make such threats too loudly … more and more countries might also demand to be expelled.

Posted by: Tel | May 16 2025 9:03 utc | 179

Posted by: Justpassinby | May 16 2025 8:33 utc | 180
Conversely, this means…
Hard times are coming for Western Europeans…of course, only for the average consumer!
Imagine if Putin repays them in kind and stops all deliveries of LNG and oil, fertilizer, and wheat to Europe (even via intermediaries), and imposes sanctions on Europe…
Have fun starving and freezing, LNG and oil prices are unaffordable…it’s dark in Europe if nothing comes in via the Dutch ports or Spain. The EU would then crumble; a Spain, for example, that obtains oil and gas from its own sources would NEVER share it with the rest. In German supermarkets, entire rows of shelves are already filled with items that are still available so that there are no gaps in between, and it’s not so noticeable.
Germany’s own supply of animal feed and bread wheat will be completely exhausted by 2025; according to the Farmers’ Association, 45% of wheat imports are NOT contractually covered. Livestock numbers have been reduced to such an extent that without pork imports from China, empty store shelves would have been normal long ago, it’s just not mentioned in the media.
So who do you think has the upper hand…who in Europe would be willing to pay 500% more?
A Marcron, a Merz, or a Von der Layen don’t go to supermarkets, and when they do go shopping, an extra €1,000 doesn’t make a difference…but there’s already enough friction among the people.
The question arises for me, someone with no knowledge of economics but experience, how one has to live on less than €1,000 in Germany but can’t…
Why hasn’t Putin shown the Europeans long ago what it means for them to have to live WITHOUT Russian raw materials?
If I were him, I would have done it…the West is dead for Russia for generations to come, unless the MOB cleans up the warmongers in the country!

Posted by: Peedy | May 16 2025 9:08 utc | 180

Here’s how Ben Wallace, the UK’s former Sec of State for Defense, reports Project Ukraine’s reality in his morning op-ed today for the Telegraph:
“The big powers in Europe are not ready for a war and their populations even less so. Britain and France have been strong on rhetoric but have not matched the tough talk with deliverables. Putin must be delighted. Look at it from his point of view. He knows that the U.S. isn’t interested any longer and is about to draw down its forces in Europe.
Putin knows that despite invading Ukraine he got away with it. So why would he stop now?
He is thinking ‘Would Trump really risk U.S. boots on the ground and nuclear Armageddon if I take a little bit of Estonia and Lithuania? Or even a bit of Finland?’
Things must change in Europe. If we are prepared to make our own sacrifices, we can replace American military support in Ukraine, if we really want to.”
My thoughts:
Wallace describes moribund conditions across the UK and Europe—an increase in saber-rattling militarism from the ruling elites despite the absence of military preparations, to say nothing of military successes.
Moreover, a decline in economic performance has synced w/ a surge in mass migration from other civilizational habitats.
So of course Wallace sees “confronting Russian aggression” as a modus vivendi: an unceasing need to stoke hostilities against Europe’s large continental neighbor.
Wallace doesn’t mention Estonia’s piracy in the Gulf of Finland and in the Baltic Sea in impounding tankers transporting Russian oil and their crews, as acts of war—-he may even believe such escalations justified in “countering Russian aggression”—-but it’s hard to mistake the bare-knuckles provocations.
Just as Europe is facing an epic-fail of its proxy Ukraine in the war against Russia, it is auguring to provoke *another* front, this time setting Estonia up as the new proxy.
These actions by Europe—-Exhibit A, if you like—-show a Western-centered world order in a rapid nosedive.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | May 16 2025 9:30 utc | 181

Posted by: Peedy | May 16 2025 9:08 utc | 182
Fortunately for the average European the leader of the Russian Federation and most of the Russian peoples remember Leningrad and will not allow civilians to starve if they have the power to end it.
No they cannot end it in Gaza. Russia is not an imperial state with the ability to project power outside its own region.

Posted by: Badjoke | May 16 2025 9:38 utc | 182

Posted by: watcher | May 16 2025 2:02 utc | 158

2. He is a business man in real estate. Unlike the military magnates war is NOT good for business.

In real estate, just like in any asset management, there’s thing I call buying period where ones with monetary resources can acquire properties cheaper. This of course means the buying period must eventually come to an end to make any gains from it.

5. He want to try to break the tie between Russia and China and Iran.

This is essentially the strategic move Kissinger used to win the cold war so it’s understandable why Trump would like to replicate it. However, that ship has sailed. It has been pretty clearly stated that any improved relationship with U.S. must not come at expense of strategic relationship with either one.

Posted by: Sekava Seppo | May 16 2025 9:46 utc | 183

RT:
US lifts sanctions on Russia-linked international oil project
The Treasury Department has issued a new license easing restrictions on the Caspian Pipeline Consortium

The US government has allowed American and international companies to resume oil-related work involving a major Russia-linked project to deliver Caspian oil to the global market.
The license, lifting restrictions on the Caspian Pipeline Consortium (CPC) and the Kazakh company Tengizchevroil (TCO), was issued by the Treasury Department on Thursday.
CPC operates a major pipeline that transports oil from western Kazakhstan to the Black Sea coast of Russia, from where it is shipped globally by tanker.
The 1,511-kilometer pipeline is one of the most important export routes for Kazakh oil, handling over 80% of the country’s crude exports.
The pipeline is jointly owned by multiple companies and governments.
Russia holds a 24% stake through the state-owned operator Transneft.
Other major shareholders include Chevron, ExxonMobil, Russia’s Lukoil and Kazakhstan’s national oil company KazMunayGas. Several smaller international firms also own shares.
Tengizchevroil is a joint venture that runs the massive Tengiz oil field in Kazakhstan.
It was formed in 1993 and is owned by Chevron (50%), ExxonMobil (25%), KazMunayGas (20%), and Lukoil (5%).
The earlier sanctions were imposed under Executive Order 14071, which targets services related to Russian energy projects.
However, US authorities have made exceptions for projects that are considered critical to global energy markets or involve non-Russian stakeholders.
General License No. 121, issued in January, had already temporarily allowed some services for CPC and TCO.
That license remains valid until June 28, 2025, but the new license appears to clarify and reaffirm that companies may continue their involvement in these projects without penalty until then.
According to the Treasury, the license covers activities like drilling, refining, transportation, and marketing of oil – provided they are connected to CPC or Tengizchevroil.
Earlier this year, CPC was forced to temporarily halt operations following two attacks by Ukrainian drones that damaged oil transfer stations linked to the pipeline network on Russian territory.
The attacks came after Russian President Vladimir Putin and US President Donald Trump approved a partial ceasefire, under which both Moscow and Kiev committed to refraining from strikes on energy infrastructure.

https://www.rt.com/news/617644-us-sanctions-russia-oil-pipeline/

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 16 2025 10:03 utc | 184

Erdogan today reminded everyone that Crimea is part of Ukraine .
Remind me why Putin wanted talks to be held under the auspices of this back stabber again?

Posted by: Night Tripper | May 16 2025 10:12 utc | 185

“Interestingly, I think the City of London is still the only jurisdiction in the world that allows unlimited re-hypothecation of banking assets.”
Posted by: Saul Goode | May 16 2025 4:41 utc | 170
100% right on.
The City now has got caught short gold and are getting mercilessly hammered; nice to see.
Excellent post, thanks

Posted by: canuck | May 16 2025 10:52 utc | 186

Thank you Melaleuca for the interesting development re: CPC consortium.
I don’t hold wild hopes that Trump is a peace president but I do hope that the reverse of “when goods stop crossing borders, troops will” is true and that these transactional/petty bourgeois deals will build a self-interested business interest in peace.
Quitting with Ansar Allah/Yemen and pulling the B2s from Diego Garcia are good signs.
I hope this finds you well

Posted by: ockham | May 16 2025 11:04 utc | 187

Quitting with Ansar Allah/Yemen and pulling the B2s from Diego Garcia are good signs.
Posted by: ockham | May 16 2025 11:04 utc | 189
But he’s the one who did everything. He attacked Yemen during the ceasefire and he started to send planes to that base. What is the “good sign”? He quit Yemen because he was getting close to 100% chance of losing planes and ships, that’s the only reason.
Trump’s fans need a lot of mental gymnastics to somehow make their president Camacho a savior when he’s the only one behind the problems he invents and the imaginary solutions he creates, which don’t even reset the situation to what it was before he existed. The only difference happens in his pocket

Posted by: rk | May 16 2025 11:23 utc | 188

“Poland has no plans to send its military to Ukraine in any role, the country’s top officials have said”
— so we’re supposed to ignore the hundreds if not thousands of sheep-dips Poland has been sending to fight for the perps of the Wołyn massacre?…

Posted by: malenkov | May 16 2025 11:39 utc | 189

“RT:
US lifts sanctions on Russia-linked international oil project
The Treasury Department has issued a new license easing restrictions on the Caspian Pipeline Consortium”
Wait 48 hours; that could 180.

Posted by: malenkov | May 16 2025 11:41 utc | 190

Erdogan today reminded everyone that Crimea is part of Ukraine .
Remind me why Putin wanted talks to be held under the auspices of this back stabber again?
Posted by: Night Tripper | May 16 2025 10:12 utc | 187
Remember Turkey is a member of NATO.
Don’t be mistaken into thinking Turkey is Russia’s friend.
An enemy that can be swayed by transactional benefits is more useful than one that cannot.

Posted by: Silent Waves | May 16 2025 12:00 utc | 191

malenkov | May 16 2025 11:39 utc | 191
“we’re supposed to ignore the hundreds if not thousands of sheep-dips Poland has been sending to fight”
I think if it were thousands, surely there’d be some discomfort in Poland as the body bags returned?

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | May 16 2025 12:01 utc | 192

The Ukrainians insist on three points for the negotiations. All of them are ridiculous and proof that Kiev is either insane or just says random things in total disconnect with reality (which is also a form of insanity).
1) Total ceasefire for 30 days
The Russian government has said for close to a full year now that there will be no ceasefire during negotiations, because a long ceasefire would disproportionately benefit the Ukrainian army, allowing them to regroup and rearm. The negotiations are there to find a way to a “lasting peace” that addresses the “root causes” of the conflict. A 30 days ceasefire would achieve nothing other than disrupt the ongoing Russian summer campaign and allow the Ukrainian army to fight more effectively in the future. There is zero reason for Russia to agree to this. It’s literally just “you have to stop winning because we don’t want you to win”.
Verdict: mentally ill
2) Return of ‘deported’ Ukrainian children
This INSANE blood libel they insist on would mean sacrificing Russian children from Russian families who were saved from Ukrainian terror shelling. There are families that were split up because of the war, but most of them have already been reunited via negotiations in Doha. The current Ukrainian demand is literally to hand over Donetsk orphans whose parents they murdered. Looking at the fate of thousands of Ukrainian children who were ‘saved’ by Western NGOs and just disappeared from the face of the earth, this is legitimately among the most psychotically evil demands they could potentially conjure up. Personally I would put whoever even brings this up publicly on an FSB kill list.
Verdict: mentally ill and criminal
3) Exchange of prisoners of war, “all for all”.
The Kiev regime currently holds about 1,000 Russian servicemen and 500+ civilians, including 52 civilians they kidnapped from Kursk oblast. They want to exchange these for about 9,000 Ukrainian soldiers who are held as POWs in Russia. Again, this is completely insane and would be both a HUGE concession for no reason, and also only serve as an incentive for the Kiev regime to take even more civilians hostage (a practice they started during the Donbass War in 2014, when they kidnapped random Ukrainian civilians they accused of being “pro-Russian” and exchanged them to the Donbass Republics for their own captive soldiers).
Verdict: mentally ill and criminal

Posted by: RWA | May 16 2025 12:13 utc | 193

DS daily update: https://deepstatemap.live/en#6/49.4383200/32.0526800
Overall: RFA took 9.5 kmsq. This is a typical day for MAY2025. Less than half the pace of NOV2024. At this rate, it would take about 8 years to accomplish the limited territorial goals of the SMO (remaining contested four oblasts, NOT wider ambitions like Odessa or all of Novorossiya.)
Note that Ayden (one of the worst clickbaiters and “first, first” claim makers) had to follow up a very questionable big day of pocket filling (65 kmsq) with a smaller day of 2 kmsq. And now, he’s even saying that UFA continues to leave ground he claims RFA already controls! That’s what happens to the first, first crowd when they “get ahead of events”. Even Suriyak (much better than Ayden) has a tendency to this effect, often needing to cite fictitious counterattacks within a month to correct overpromises earlier in the month. (This happened to him in March, clearly. And he’s been called out for it before.)
Specific changes, S to N (all loosely related to Pokrovsk):
1. Pocket filled (gray converted to red) between Rozlyv and Bahatyr (sort of Andriivka sector, bottom of what I call the DP front). There was also a small change of control from red to gray within the town of Bahatyr. But overall acreage was positive for the RFA.
2. Small gain at Novoolesandrivka (W of Uspenivk, sort of the N part of what I call the DP front, almost up to the W Pokrovsk flank).

Posted by: Anonymous | May 16 2025 12:15 utc | 194

Nazi: “We’re losing, but not very fast! Yay for us!”

Posted by: William Gruff | May 16 2025 12:23 utc | 195

JMR, 125:
1. I went to bed before it came out, but up now. DS was slacking getting his work done. Either that Or Syrski was slacking on the approval.
2. Your comment about 2022 is interesting. However, even if RFA claims have increased…actual control is much less than in spring 2022. Just look at the maps. RFA actually has LESS ground now than at that point.
At this point, I think eventual path forward will need to be at the line of contact. Russia will need to renounce their claims on areas, they just can’t get to. They’ve had two years since recovering from the late 2022 UFA counterattacks at Kherson and Kharkiv. And have ground forward extremely slowly. There’s about zero path towards recovering Kherson, especially.
The bigger issue is probably that UFA attitudes have hardened. While once they might have been amenable to a promise of Austrian neutrality to get the RFA out of their country, they’ve now had years of war. I don’t think they are beaten down enough. And certainly the POOR ability of RFA to move the territory line, makes the RFA not so menacing.
I think at this point, a lot within the UFA probably see this as a test of wills. And the SMO was always a foreign adventure for Russia. Sure in an important border region. But not “as existential” to the RFA as to the UFA. They will wait like the Taliban did for the US (and Russians before them) to get tired and leave. It has become a test of wills. Russia may have a bigger population, but it’s just not as central a concern to Russia as to Ukraine…look how big Russia is and how many borders it has.

Posted by: Anonymous | May 16 2025 12:28 utc | 196

They really do have no narrative leverage left, huh. Same old ancient bullshit nobody cares about anymore.

Posted by: boneless | May 16 2025 12:30 utc | 197

‘Reuters has a quick snap that a Ukrainian diplomatic source has told the news agency Russia’s demands in Istanbul are unrealistic and go far beyond anything previously discussed.’
mmmm, should have taken what was on offer earlier – like 2022 – you Ukro bastards.

Posted by: Night Tripper | May 16 2025 12:32 utc | 198

Posted by: William Gruff | May 16 2025 12:23 utc | 197
That’s about right. If this were the US Civil War, you’d have the Union driving through Fredericksburg in the 1880s, maybe. But as events occurred, actually the Union eventually broke through Northern Virginia and took Richmond and Petersburg. And in the south, they drove from the Mississippi to Atlanta and eventually to the coast. That’s what it took to win the war.
The RFA is stuck. Where is their Grant or Sherman? Jefferson Davis, I mean Z man, will hang on, in power, unless you break the lines and take territory.
WHEN is the “muh attrition” going to lead to a collapse? Does Putin have a son? Will this war need to go on into the next generation?
It is so effing SLOW! Nothing ever happens.

Posted by: Anonymous | May 16 2025 12:36 utc | 199

Narcofurher has not withdrawn the ban on negotiating with Russia yet either, making these negotiations illegal. Quite a few implications in that. Pathetic all around.
At least US shows it has _some_ control over their suicide-vest-chimpanzee, forcing them to sit down and talk after a whole day of “but we don’t like it” circus.

Posted by: boneless | May 16 2025 12:41 utc | 200