Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
March 27, 2025
Trump’s Rewritten ‘Deal’ With Ukraine Is Imposed Indentured Servitude

The Trump administration wants to press Ukraine into infinite indentured servitude for payments and weapons previously delivered by the Biden administration with no conditions attached to them.

Hedge fund mogul and U.S. Secretary of the Treasury Scott Bessent has (re-)written the 'mineral deal':

U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on Wednesday Ukraine may sign an economic deal next week …
"We have passed along a completed document for the economic partnership (that) is currently being reviewed by Ukrainians, and we hope to go to full discussions and perhaps even get signatures next week," Bessent said.

Trump said on Monday he expects a U.S.-Ukraine revenue-sharing agreement on Ukrainian critical minerals to be signed soon.

The (former) Ukrainian President Vladimir Zelenski acknowledged the arrival of the agreement (machine translation):

President Volodymyr Zelensky said that the United States offered Ukraine a new version of the agreement on minerals . During the press conference , he stressed that the issue of Ukrainian nuclear power plants is not in it.

"This is a big full deal for the American side, from the steps that were taken earlier. A framework agreement, you remember, and after the framework agreement, the full agreement is developed. Now the American side has offered our side a big deal at once, their vision," Zelensky said.

The deal, see below, is anything but an 'offer'.

Zelenski should have signed the earlier 'framework agreement'. It would have allowed to later stall on the implementation. Now he will be pressed to sign on to the details.

The new 'big deal at once' is a 'horror' for Ukraine (machine translation):

A new version of the agreement on minerals between Ukraine and the United States, in which, as reported by ZN.UA, now the American side wants control not only over the extraction of rare earth metals, but all the minerals of Ukraine and the infrastructure associated with their extraction, provides for unlimited US control over Ukrainian resursans and with the right of veto of the Americans on their extraction by Ukraine. At the same time, the United States does not offer any security guarantees, and such a monopoly should be a "payment" for the already provided US assistance to Ukraine, said Yaroslav Zheleznyak, a People's Deputy of Ukraine.

"I received this document from our officials yesterday.This is not the final document. And I hope the Ukrainian side will demand and achieve significant changes to it. But the text that I saw is straight horror. All 18 sections … this is no longer a framework memorandum of intent (which was before the scandalous meeting in the Oval Office). This is a very big and very clear deal. And it is not in our direction," he wrote in his Telegram.

The legal text has 60(!) pages. Its main points, according to Zheleznyak, are these (machine translation):

  • The Fund is managed by five people, three of whom are from the United States and will have full veto power;
  • We are talking about all minerals, including oil, gas and undeveloped deposits throughout Ukraine;
  • we are talking about mining by both public and private campaigns;
  • the Fund's money will be immediately converted into foreign currency and withdrawn abroad. If suddenly, for some reason, something did not reach the Ukrainian side, Ukraine pays extra;
  • US contribution – assistance already provided to us from 2022 (according to the Kiel Institute, US assistance to Ukraine in 2022-2024 is estimated at $ 119.7 billion)
  • The United States can choose to make a profit. At the same time, they will receive "royalties" from the Fund first (and then Ukraine) +4%.
  • The agreement will be valid indefinitely
  • Changes to the agreement or its completion are only possible with the permission of the United States;
  • US priority right to all new infrastructure projects and veto the sale of resources to other countries.

This 'deal' is pure extortion and robbery. It would bind Ukraine indefinitely. It would also discourage any investment in any natural deposits in Ukraine. There is no chance that any such deal will be ratified by the Ukrainian parliament. 

Why wonders then: Why does the Trump administration even bother?

Comments

@DunGroanin | Fri 08:36:00
The Answer maybe 42 but what’s the godamned Question? 😀

Wan’ another beer, Cowboy?

Posted by: persiflo | Mar 28 2025 13:39 utc | 301

Your continuous hagiography of China is rather child like and naive.
Posted by: canuck | Mar 28 2025 10:26 utc | 269
#########
“I see your point. Fusion reactors, cutting edge microprocessor design, and world leading transportation don’t measure up to the millions of new genders Canada has discovered recently. 😂😂😂
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 28 2025 12:18 utc | 281
Thanks you for confirming my point with further Chinese hagiography.
Kindly please show me a fusion reactor, from any country that is commercially active?
I thought so.

Posted by: canuck | Mar 28 2025 13:42 utc | 302

In my view this will end with large numbers of embittered Ukranians in Europe. The Ukraine Mafia. A heavily armed and dangerous neo nazi organisation, the likes of which have never been seen before. They will hook up with the Far Right and be a major problem for many years to come. Best to avoid mosques and synagogues for the forseeable future.
Using islamists (Mujahideen) to fight Russia in Afghanistan backfired badly for the West, and so will using nazis in Ukraine.
I fear the fallout from the entirely avoidable catastrophe in Ukraine has barely begun.

Posted by: Glasshopper | Mar 28 2025 13:44 utc | 303

“Lay with dogs wake up with fleas”
The Ukrainians should have looked at Russia’s experience dealing with the USA before getting into bed with them. Putin dragged Russia away from being raped by the west in 2000 and they’ve been paying for it with sanctions, colour revolutions on their allies and open warfare ever since. It’s been unrelenting for 25 years.
If the USA would do this to a nuclear armed peer they sure as hell won’t let Ukraine off without paying their debt many times over. All US allies except Israel are being thrown under the bus today.

Posted by: HB_Norica | Mar 28 2025 13:45 utc | 304

https://www.unz.com/jtaylor/is-racial-discrimination-illegal-or-not/
I wonder does Ukraine have such a law.. if so is it relevant to imposed indentured servitude?

Posted by: snake | Mar 28 2025 14:17 utc | 305

On limited, localized scale it surely is chaos. But on large scale the weapons used are himars, atacms or guided bombs with cluster heads and anti-personnel mines. They’re all from US, controlled by US. Stormshadow is missing for a long time. So there is a chain of command working very well
Posted by: rk | Mar 28 2025 11:49 utc | 278
While “himars, atacms or guided bombs with cluster heads” may be dominating your news feed they certainly aren’t dominating the battlefield. Ukraine did recently bring their surviving HIMARS launchers out of hiding to strike a couple of bridges in rural Belgorad however you don’t hear about the Tornado, Uragan or Iskander strikes that are happening all over the front whenever a Ukrainian sticks their head out of a trench because it’s not a newsworthy event when it’s happening 24/7/365.
You talk about “guided bombs” … what guided bombs launched from what platform? The F-16 that made a cameo appearance on the front a couple of weeks ago then promptly got shot down? The Ukrainians have cluster munition artillery and rocket shells as well as mine laying shells which are being used to slow down the Russians when they advance giving the Ukrainians a chance to run away but that’s about it.
ATTACM’s haven’t been used for months … other than that what “guided” weapon is still being used by the Ukrainian side. Those drones attacking Russian oil refineries operate on a combination of GPS and inertial guidance systems. Refineries don’t move. Their position is known so they don’t need GPS. They just have to hit within half a mile either way and they cause a fire. Same as when they attacked Moscow and lit up a few parking lots and apartment buildings.

Posted by: HB_Norica | Mar 28 2025 14:21 utc | 306

HB_Norica@303…..after Ukie was routed in ’14 Russia played coy with its Partners, Minsk 1/2 ensued. Russia’s mistake, then like today, is that wants to be part of the International Oligarch Order, and the Order doesn’t recognise Russia as pertinent to their plans to take Russian resources and split the spoils……
….the SMO of today will yield future wars in the EU as Russia can never guarantee it sovereignty and security…..never ever and not by negotiating with the International Oligarch Order.
Cheers M
Even the current negotiations are all about Russia returning to the Oligarch Order, it wasn’t a coincidence when Putin met with Russia’s business leaders, then next day got business concessions from the US…..bidness as usual.

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Mar 28 2025 14:22 utc | 307

Considering that Zelensky and his oligarchs pocketed a good percentage of the money Ukraine received, and that they sold on the black market a good portion of the weapons we sent, this “deal” seems fair. At the very least it should discourage other corrupt freeloaders from fighting unnecessary wars for their own profits.

Posted by: Janet | Mar 28 2025 14:26 utc | 308

Kindly please show me a fusion reactor, from any country that is commercially active?
I thought so.
Posted by: canuck | Mar 28 2025 13:42 utc | 301
None, but the chinese EAST (unlike the delayed INTER) was built at 1/15th the cost of equivalent ones and
Building on this success, EAST became the first tokamak to successfully sustain H-Mode plasma for more than one minute at ~50 million °C (90 million °F) on November 2, 2016.[13] In July of 2017, it was also the first tokamak to sustain said plasma for more than 100 seconds at the same temperature.[14] The following year, EAST reached a milestone of ~100 million °C (180 million °F) electron temperature on November 12, 2018.[15] During May of 2021, it reached an electron temperature of 120 million °C electron temperature for 101 seconds.[16] On December 30, 2021, a long-pulse high-parameter plasma operation of 1056 seconds was realized, setting another world record for the operation of the Tokamak experimental device.[17][18]
EAST achieved the world’s first 403-second steady-state H-mode plasma on April 12, 2023.[19]
EAST then broke its record several years later on January 20, 2025, when it sustained plasma for 1066 seconds.[3]
And as mentioned it was built on a project’s budget of CNY ¥300 million (approximately US$37 million). 5-6% of others… vely cheap!INTER is currently in production hell and is still 10 years away unless it delays more.
So, no commercial reactors, but one of the most promising experimental ones. China does have things to show.

Posted by: Newbie | Mar 28 2025 14:33 utc | 309

At the very least it should discourage other corrupt freeloaders from fighting unnecessary wars for their own profits.
Posted by: Janet | Mar 28 2025 14:26 utc | 307

How can it discourage future corrupt freeliaders, when only his former country is ruined, but the money thst he had stolen is now his own and is safely parked in very known places.
I’d say it would rather encourage future freeloaders to act the same way.

Posted by: Rutte | Mar 28 2025 14:36 utc | 310

I fear the fallout from the entirely avoidable catastrophe in Ukraine has barely begun.
Posted by: Glasshopper | Mar 28 2025 13:44 utc | 302

Word.
Especially in Europe the future is very dark.

Posted by: Avtonom | Mar 28 2025 14:39 utc | 311

It looks like Zelensky has outwitted Solomon. He’s offered to cut the baby up three ways, US/EU/UK each get a piece of the baby. The last year in Ukraine and Israel has really challenged the trope of “smart Jews”

Posted by: Scottindallas | Mar 28 2025 15:00 utc | 312

Posted by: Newbie | Mar 28 2025 14:33 utc | 309
########
Let’s be honest.
Chinese fusion reaction isn’t as cool as Canadian spontaneous gender transformation.
😂😂😂

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 28 2025 15:04 utc | 313

a bit OT –
if that is how to dominate rare earths, well then the rest of the world should just boycott or tariff it….
ANY monopoly anywhere such as ASML assembled machines, where i “feel” they have the most modern manufacturing processes (you mean ISO’s) are used are still stuck in stone ages to be honest in terms of energy consumption aka pollution production.
Rundown –
1. basic materials – mined by horses fed on pasture grass and springs of yore
2. basic materials are taken to the country port of origin and shipped on containers tied to whales fed solely on fukushima drinks and phyto-planktons
3. after short ride on the whales and taken into the import country’s factory, where the basic material is refined into a systems part(s) from a factory SOLELY powered by rear gas windmills and solar energy it is ready to be re shipped again.
4. they are transported by horses/whales into the port of rotterdam or by horse freight into netherland and into ASML factory which has solar panels on top of it…..of all things…..
5. here in Netherland they are assembled by all electric machines (mined previously), made with no rare earths whatsoever…… and after the value added products are assembled and tested, it is again led to the port on horse buggy.
6. finally they are exported to customer countries a couple thousand km away…….. or flown there by pigeons tied together and fed sunflower seeds grown on compost only.
forget the details or material science to manufacture all these parts(how many parts?). its not just ASML its every corporation in the world, if this is what you mean by the most modern manufacturing processes, it would be just easier to boycott rare earths or oil if your dream corporation can, which it can’t, then maybe what you mean productivity and pollution reduction (lean and dynamic) would be a reality.

Posted by: jason | Mar 28 2025 15:09 utc | 314

Ukraine is getting the same treatment as the Global South has been receiving for the past several centuries. To quote Charles Bukowski, “Slavery was never abolished, only expanded to include all colours”. The same can be said about colonialism.

Posted by: Elial | Mar 28 2025 15:15 utc | 315

Arch Bungle (Uncle bungle?). Anyways, your comment about EU getting a warning on closure of the Red Sea/Hormus Straight. Perhaps the EU comments, even the “big rift” is more theater, each the US and EU get plausible deniability/good cop/bad cop public show while covertly things are far more spelled out. (And no doubt some in CIA/NSC are working back channels to mitigate Trump with their EU counterparts (as should be, actually). I don’t know that I buy that much coordination top to bottom. Ut of course Trump’s lieutenants each have their own agenda and relationships that they’re using/tapping

Posted by: Scottindallas | Mar 28 2025 15:18 utc | 316

The US could not defend Ukraine militarily against Russia, so it conquered what remained of Ukraine economically and then said, let Russia dare and steal what is rightfully ours. Nor, might it be said, can the US defend Germany, the Baltics, the Balkans, Poland, Scandinavia, etc., militarily against Russia, so it should appropriate itself wholesale and indefinitely of the economic resources of these fortunate nations and then dare Russia to come and pry such stakes from its cold, nuclear-armed hands.

Posted by: Ludovic | Mar 28 2025 15:30 utc | 317

Debs, I’m a fan of various music/world music. I had a couple of rugby mates from NZ and we got to talking about “indigenous Maori music” at practice and on later at the bar. Well, after talking this to death, their insistence that this was REAL native Maori music we dropped by their apartment and finally played the elusive notes. It was lame rock and roll, poorly produced. I was so disappointed.
I was and remain so dejected I’m assuming it’s just another Polynesian island sound till I’m teased again.

Posted by: Scottindallas | Mar 28 2025 15:54 utc | 318

“Kindly please show me a fusion reactor, from any country that is commercially active?”

There are 65 nuclear reactors being built in the world today.
27 are in China, 7 are in Russia, most of the rest are Russian designed reactors built in India, Turkey, Egypt and Bangaledesh.
No American commercial reactors are being built anywhere and one french / British reactor is being built in the UK with construction reported to have started on another but I’m not sure they have a spade in the ground yet. … they’re having “issues” with this build https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ycNqII5HYMI
Meanwhile the Chinese have gotten their reactor build schedule down to 7 years from conception to generating power. The Chinese are also building molten salt reactors which are an order of magnitude safer than conventional fission reactors and can even burn nuclear waste for fuel.
Apparently the Chinese are well ahead of the west in developing fusion power but I’m not holding my breath … I think we’ve just about run into a material science brick wall in the realm of commercial fusion power.

Posted by: HB_Norica | Mar 28 2025 16:15 utc | 319

unimperator | Mar 28 2025 8:53 utc | 260
*** Ukrainian neo-nazis are now calling establishment of a white ethnic state in the Carpathian mountains from which to liberate Ukraine and surrounding parts of Europe from the globalist liberals.
https://x.com/Cyberspec1/status/1905540423655067792 ***
Since they have long been happy to work for — are bankrolled by and fanatically support the wars of — the zionists and liberal wokists/globalists, and have zero serious objection in their present country to all its land, resources and even people being sold off to foreign interests … that notion is deliberate bollox probably cooked up as part of the anti-nationalist, anti-populist agenda of the Political Establishment (EU/US/UK/WEF/NATO/Khazar) these fakes actually serve. They are intentionally cultivated to block the rise of any genuine political opposition.
A proposed new State which (if it ever happened) is certain to be run on NATO “values” and remotely ruled by VdL? What would its flag be — a graphic of Lindsey Graham’s bum?

Posted by: Cynic | Mar 28 2025 16:35 utc | 320

A proposal they can only refuse.

Posted by: Otto | Mar 28 2025 16:47 utc | 321

Posted by: Cynic | Mar 28 2025 16:35 utc | 320
Aah, a National Redoubt, comes right after the Volkssturm.
More crappy reheated Nazi ideas.

Posted by: ChatNPC | Mar 28 2025 18:00 utc | 322

This plan is so harsh I cant imagine this is a serious offer, I think Trump put this forward in order to have the Ukrainians to reject it so Trump can walk away saying that the Ukrainians aren’t being reasonable

Posted by: Kadath | Mar 28 2025 18:23 utc | 323

Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 28 2025 3:49 utc | 229
The US has two icebreakers, Russia has forty-four. Delivery of a US replacement has been postponed from 2024 to 2028. The US cannot “reliably shape hardened steel more than an inch thick into the ship’s curved reinforced hull… The machines and skills to build the hulls of most ocean-going vessels are insufficient for specialized icebreakers. The body sheets need a special alloy and special heat treatment, as well as the process of forming and welding massive curved plates.”

Posted by: horseguards | Mar 28 2025 18:31 utc | 324

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Mar 28 2025 9:29 utc | 263
I need to read up on Bismarck (and re-read Deng Xiaoping). Thanks for that.

Posted by: horseguards | Mar 28 2025 19:02 utc | 325

[One] wonders then: Why does the Trump administration even bother?

Considering the absurd conditions and requirements of the supposed “deal”, I interpret it as a coded signal to the Ukrainian powers-that-be for the removal of President Zelensky in order to sue for peace with Russia and steer clear of the disaster that said agreement would bring down upon the country.

Posted by: Clever Dog | Mar 28 2025 19:03 utc | 326

Posted by: rk | Mar 28 2025 9:34 utc | 264
————-
Excellent.
No deal, no Minsk3, no euro troops in Ukraine since no peace. Trump can continue bragging for a settlement and move hot air.
SMO goes on.

Posted by: scc | Mar 28 2025 19:16 utc | 327

Meh…. I like it. It is in your face rather than the preferred in the background by the usual suspects. It is no different than the EU making Yanukovych an offer he couldn’t refuse in 2013. The fact Yanukovych refused it is a testament to his character. He didn’t take the EU bribe money and sell out his country. The Coup government immediately signed it after they took power though. Zelensky also sold his country again to the UK for the 100 year cooperation deal.. now here he is again selling his country to Trump. LOL. No wonder the EU is so mad at Trump. He is getting in the way of the scam. The US does the heavy lifting and the EU take the spoils. He is ruining the game. They have to be planning another assassination attempt.

Posted by: goldhoarder | Mar 28 2025 19:19 utc | 328

140,000 personnel might be 100,000 fighters. That 140,000 includes a lot of secretaries, drivers, and massage therapists.
Almost none of those fighters the US has over there will have seen real combat, let alone peer combat. “Policing Iraq and Afghanistan” is a walk in the park compared to facing the Russian God of War (artillery).
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 28 2025 18:05 utc | 49

Imagine the loss of jobs among Ukrainians who work on bases.

Posted by: freedom fritos | Mar 28 2025 19:53 utc | 329

The US needs a reason to back Ukraine, I don’t think anyone serious thought feelings and “democracy ” had anything to do with anything.
Maybe Zelensky thought selling his peoples lives to fight Russia in nato’s stead was payment enough. Now he knows Ukrainian lives are worth nothing to his western patrons.

Posted by: Neofeudalfuture | Mar 28 2025 21:52 utc | 330

In essence “surrender to us or surrender to the Russians. Your choice.”
For the moment the answer is “neither”.

Posted by: the pessimist | Mar 28 2025 23:50 utc | 331

Wow! This is outright CRIMINAL by the US and it should be rejected outright by Ukraine.
Is Trump and team so stupid that they don’t know Ukraine will reject it? One wonders if Trump is deliberately sabotaging, knowing Ukronazis can’t accept that
Even a surrender under Russia would be better than that CRIME!

Posted by: Kay | Mar 29 2025 0:58 utc | 332

Is Trump and team so stupid that they don’t know Ukraine will reject it? One wonders if Trump is deliberately sabotaging, knowing Ukronazis can’t accept that
Even a surrender under Russia would be better than that CRIME!
Posted by: Kay | Mar 29 2025 0:58 utc | 332
No Trump and team are not that stupid.
The stupid ones are the ones who think that this is a war between Russia and Ukraine. It is not. It is the shooting phase of the war on Russia by the US that the US started in 1945.
I’ve been pointing this out since forever; Brian Berletic did an excellent video on it a few weeks ago. It was linked here on MOA.
rumble(dot)com/v6p11s3-the-us-eu-division-of-labor-to-continue-confronting-russia-and-china.html?e9s=src_v1_ucp

Posted by: acementhead | Mar 29 2025 2:01 utc | 333

Donald Trump, the 4 dimensional chess player, has you all fooled!
He even fooled me, for a while.
Mr. “Art of the Deal” wants the rights to what’s left of Ukraine’s minerals, so that he can TRADE a useless deed to Denmark, for what Trump REALLY wants, which is Greenland. (The trick is, to not tell the Danes about where the rare earth minerals in what was Ukraine, actually are located. )
As a sweetener, the Danes can take a comfy, speedy European train to visit their Ukrainian wasteland, while they would have to fly or take the boat to Greenland.
If he really has to, Trump may further sweeten the pot, by giving discounted tickets to the Danes, for playing golf in one of Trump’s golf resorts.
🙂

Posted by: metamars | Mar 29 2025 3:12 utc | 334

@the pessimist (331)

In essence “surrender to us or surrender to the Russians. Your choice.” For the moment the answer is “neither”.

Up to your post I don’t think I would’ve looked at this situation quite like you did. However, your take on it is lucid, cogent and very correct.
Thanks for the context.

Posted by: rgl | Mar 29 2025 13:36 utc | 335

All south Americans emigrating are nothing that complete killers. It’s written in their fucking Aztec DNA. They need to be completely round up and exterminated like locust, or they will be back.

Posted by: Gabriel | Mar 28 2025 12:49 utc | 289
Dude, what’s your issue?

Posted by: Digby | Mar 30 2025 8:11 utc | 336

Then Ukraine just agree to a plan to pay back the debt

Posted by: U | Apr 1 2025 15:51 utc | 337

Doctor Eleven, you are a complete imbecile.
Drug trials run by corrupt parties should not be encouraged.
To say what you have despit all the currently available evidence including MRNA vaccines shows the incredible dearth of intellect you suffer from.
Preposterous!

Posted by: Stu | Apr 2 2025 8:45 utc | 338