Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
March 11, 2025
The Pipeline Raid Of Sudzha

Throughout the war in Ukraine natural gas was still pumped through the Brotherhood (Druzhba) pipeline system from Russia via Ukraine to Hungary and Slovakia.


bigger

At the beginning of the year the government of Ukraine decided to close the connection. It shut off the valves on Ukrainian ground. That event will be marked the end of the Ukrainian incursion into the Kursk region of Russia.

The map shows the Ukrainian held ground in Russia as of January 1 2025. It includes the city of Sudzha and some 20 Russian hamlets and villages.

Situation on January 1 2025

bigger via LiveUAmap

The Brotherhood pipeline system consists of five parallel tubes with a diameter of 1.4 meters (4'8"). These run roughly parallel to the 34k-004 road (H-07 in Ukraine) from Kursk southwest-wards passing north of Sudzah on towards Sumy in Ukraine.

The pipes are buried in the ground. Due to vegetation disturbances the buried pipelines are visible in satellite pictures.

Pipeline bundle (from upper right to lower left) near the exit point of the raid

bigger

Sometime after January 1 the Russian command responsible for the area developed a plan to use the pipeline system to attack the Ukrainian enemy from behind.

Natural gas was drained from one of the pipes of the Brotherhood pipeline system. Oxygen was pumped into it. Some 15 kilometer (~10 miles) north-east of Sudzha, near Bol'shoye Soldatskoye, an access hole was cut into the pipeline. Soldiers were sent into the pipeline to reconnaissance it. But there was still some natural gas and too little oxygen in the pipeline. The first soldiers fainted and had to be rescued. After weeks of work the pipeline was usable as a covered passageway towards Sudzha.

Drawn from five different military units a force of 800 men was assembled and prepared for the mission.

During the first two month of the year the Ukrainian forces had already lost ground on the western side of their incursion area. The general situation had gotten worse after the Russian forces gained fire control via drones over the only larger supply route from Sumy to Sudzha. Videos from that road showed dozens of wreaked and burned out vehicles. But the Ukrainian lines, and Sudzha, were still holding.

Situation on March 1 2025

bigger

In early March Russia commandos entered the pipeline (along the arrow above). They used it to get to the north of the industrial zone of Sudzha, started to cut exit-holes and dug through the ground covering the pipeline. Some 800 soldiers followed and settled down within the pipeline.

On March 8, when the command was given, the Russian commandos exited the pipeline and entered nearby woods. They moved on to blockade the 34k-004 road, crossed it and entered the northern part of the industrial zone of Sudzha. There they could dug in. No larger Ukrainian units were in the immediate area. No one could stop the move.

Exit point and attack route

bigger

Hearing reports on their radios of enemies in their back the Ukrainian soldiers panicked. Every unit north-east and east of Sudzha was cut off from supplies. There was no way to retreat. At the same time the Russian army attacked in the west and north of the Ukrainian held area. Resistance soon collapsed. Those who could retreated to Sudzha did so. From there they tried to move back to Ukraine.

Situation on March 11 2025

bigger

Within one day the Ukrainian held area had shrunk by half. The Russian re-captured and cleared a total of 12 settlements. Current reports say that the Ukrainian forces within Russia are in full retreat along roads under permanent fire. Some will survive.

Meanwhile Russian forces are entering Sudzha.

This operation is a wonderful demonstration of what the Russians call 'Operational Art'. It connects the details of tactics with the goals of the strategy.

The move through the pipeline, behind Ukrainian lines and the cut through major Ukrainian supply lines achieved within days more than months of bloody fighting. The commander of this operation has surely earned some high honors.

Dima of the Military Summary Channel discussed some of the above in yesterday's summary.

A Russian news channel provided an excellent five minute video (with English subtitles) which shows the operation. It includes takes from within the pipeline.

This operation is one for the books.

Comments

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Mar 11 2025 21:56 utc | 152
That have reliability problems and have to be towed to port, all the time being recorded acoustically and photographed by the US. The other thing about pumping out ships and boats is the problem manning them, the Soviets went for extreme automation to cut down crew numbers, the Chinese do not seem to have gone down that route.
They also seem to have problems maintaining the technology they stole from the West, so what with the US Navy still suffering from 12 years of progressive policies and the Chinese Navy suffering from too-rapid an expansion all bets are off if those two fought it out. My money’s on the US, but it would probably be a very unfunny comedy of errors.

Posted by: Milites | Mar 11 2025 23:08 utc | 201

Innuendo @ 192

I don’t think Stalin would be proud of this after 7 months of occupation.

Stalin needed to sacrifice the lives of 30 million Russians to drive the Germans back to Berlin, Putin isn’t there yet, hopefully he will never need to be, different times, different war. If Putin does get were Stalin got you won’t be so snarky, this time the Russians will make the west pay 10 times the price they pay.

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Mar 11 2025 23:08 utc | 202

Seven months of blood and steel trying to hold Kursk.
And they come away with nothing but corpses and ashes.
A defeat that would not sting so bad if the failed attempt to hold Kursk lasted seven days.
The difference between a one night stand and finding out youve been cheated on half your marriage.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 11 2025 23:08 utc | 203

Manufacturing consent requires a low level, demonization campaign that appeals to left and right audiences, and that simply is not happening.
Posted by: UWDude | Mar 11 2025 22:30 utc | 174
______
I agree that there’s no great effort (which — you’re correct — would take years) to manufacture such consent right now, and that others, such as illegal immigrants, are higher on the list. Still, the memory of the president who demonized the country of “Kung Flu” may give a little bit of extra incentive to those Chinese residing here who were thinking of moving back anyway for whatever reason (family, economic opportunity, whatever). Why not relocate at a leisurely pace than at the last panicked moment, even if that moment never comes?

Posted by: malenkov | Mar 11 2025 23:11 utc | 204

“OK, so let’s have a catchy name for the “ceasefire” and the deployment of “peacekeepers”…
How does “Operation Warp Speed” sound?…
Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Mar 11 2025 20:29 utc | 86”
You got it! got to improve the “optics”.
Trump just capitulated to the MIC. Lindsey was the tell. You always no which way the wind is blowing from him. The z ungratful was not big enough to overcome “brutal Russia bad”. What three days? You need both heros and villains and subplots in the WWF.

Posted by: Npins | Mar 11 2025 23:11 utc | 205

Posted by: Fool Me Twice | Mar 11 2025 23:02 utc | 196
and lots of people who came here for opportunity will leave, meaning housing prices will stabilize if not drop.
Anyways, i know a guy, (a tad slow), irl who thinks Trump is going to make the economy better, and I have explained to him a few times that Trump did nothing to correct it his first term, and that the implosion is decades in the making, and that Trump might be left holding the hot potato.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 11 2025 23:11 utc | 206

LightYearsFromHome | Mar 11 2025 22:46 utc | 182–
Thanks for your reply. Well, basic grenades aren’t so bad. It’s those larger loads where the shock wave might knock you out. Maybe some sort of reactive armor. Lots of different FPV drones armed with a wide variety of ordinance. As I’ve written before, I’m very happy not to be there.
Trump’s pre-election boast of solving the war in 24 hours is smelling really bad. And evert stunt makes it smell even worse. Trump: We’re gonna end forever wars. Trump: We’re gonna resume the Ukraine forever war. Trump: If Hamas doesn’t behave, I’ll cry.

Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 11 2025 23:15 utc | 207

Posted by: Milites | Mar 11 2025 23:08 utc | 201
I once told someone that if China went to war, the common Chinese soldiers curse would be “Cheap Chinese Shit!’
Was surprised, and laughed in Wandering Earth, when the Chinese poked fun at themselves for thos, with a scrne where some part catastrophically fails, and a piece flies towards the camera with “Made in China” printed on it, (in English).

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 11 2025 23:16 utc | 208

I don’t think Stalin would be proud of this after 7 months of occupation.
Posted by: Innuendo | Mar 11 2025 22:59 utc | 192
______
Would that be the Stalin who fought the Nazis all the way to Stalingrad, or the Stalin who played for time by signing a pact with the Nazis?
And how’s the weather in “franconia”?

Posted by: malenkov | Mar 11 2025 23:19 utc | 209

“If the Russians say no,” Sec Rubio stated in regard to the 30-day ceasefire—“we will know what the impediment is here.“
Uttered scoldingly, as if the U.S.—a co-belligerent on the *losing* side of this war—has *cards* to play.
Russia has been and should always remain “an impediment” to the weaponization of Ukraine, by the U.S.-led NATO, to weaken Russia, to destroy Russia, to maintain a constant terroristic force on Russia’s borders for launching attacks like we saw in Domododevo today.
If DJT’s team has empowered the Kiev Regime, it has thrown-down on the wrong side, allowing an illegitimate government to have a leg to stand on.
Russia has won the war. The war is over.
It is only a question as to how much Russia wants to apportion the spoils.
Russia is *an impediment* in the U.S.’s plans, by hook or crook, to wrest a ‘W’ here. The U.S. cannot concede defeat, but Ukraine can’t win. Welp.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Mar 11 2025 23:20 utc | 210

“Not many of you understand negotiating or mediating a case.
Posted by: CullenBaker | Mar 11 2025 20:48 utc | 99”
I understand not agreeing to a deal that totally ignores my interests and I think Putin does too. A insulting lowball offer is the quickest way to understand the counter party is not serious. Back to work Russia.
If Trumo doesnt get one of these wars ended he is as useless as night of the living dead Biden. Almost.
You cant like one side of a coin and hate the other. There is only one coin. Trump just paves the way for a new neoliberal goon in four. What is needed is a true populist that breaks all the stereotypes that everyone understands where he or she is coming from.
Signed
Trumtard deelux

Posted by: Npins | Mar 11 2025 23:21 utc | 211

Refinnejenna | Mar 11 2025 20:09 utc | 73
*** I’ve read somewhere online that the commander of this pipeline operation was Apti Alauddinov. He is from Chechnya. ***
General Alaudinov is commander of the Achmat special force (which is not only Chechen) plus other Russian military forces. As may be ascertained from reading his Telegram channel, superior in every way — military or otherwise — compared to the West’s top officers. But too modest to think so.

Posted by: Cynic | Mar 11 2025 23:23 utc | 212

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Mar 11 2025 22:18 utc | 167
Agree, the official, version does not hold water. Too many people talking about a recently conducted operation suggests misdirection and misinformation are all part of the Russian plan. My guess is an elite advance guard secures, by way of the pipe, then a battalion conventionally consolidates and launches the next phase, perhaps taking advantage of the pre-arranged ISR pause to move.

Posted by: Milites | Mar 11 2025 23:23 utc | 213

How does “Operation Warp Speed” sound?…
Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Mar 11 2025 20:29 utc | 86
Operation postnatal depression

Posted by: Tannenhouser | Mar 11 2025 23:24 utc | 214

They also seem to have problems maintaining the technology they stole from the West
Posted by: Milites | Mar 11 2025 23:08 utc | 201
#####################
Thanks for the laugh. America Firsters are always good for a chuckle.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 11 2025 23:26 utc | 215

As a negotiator myself during my long years in various situations, if I were advising Mr Putin and Russia, I would advise developing a counter ceasefire proposal asap to prevent Kiev from claiming in the media that “there, we told you so, Putin doesn’t want peace” in the evnt of Putin rejecting Kievs 30-day ceasefire plan.
Its as much a PR war as a military/political war.

Posted by: HERMIUS | Mar 11 2025 23:29 utc | 216

“Seven months of blood and steel trying to hold Kursk.
And they come away with nothing but corpses and ashes.
A defeat that would not sting so bad if the failed attempt to hold Kursk lasted seven days.
The difference between a one night stand and finding out youve been cheated on half your marriage.
Posted by: UWDude | Mar 11 2025 23:08 utc | 203”
Someone said (Wilkerson?) that Kursk was Milleys brain child.

Posted by: Npins | Mar 11 2025 23:29 utc | 217

Gabriel | Mar 11 2025 20:10 utc | 74
*** I wrote a previous comment about the pipeline method. It’s not quite sure if they marched 16km completely blinded and not knowing what lies aheas. I personally think than only Superman can go 16 km with head bent down and 20-30kg of backpack. Let’s not fool ouserlf. They probably advanced 1km, then drilled some hole above to allow air to enter. It was much smarter to use carts and electric scoters with small seats to advance. next time, maybe the generals will read this comment.***
You’ll be suggesting next they should have used Tesla cars or chartered a Ryanair flight.
And only “little green men” could march in a tunnel that diameter anyway.

Posted by: Cynic | Mar 11 2025 23:29 utc | 218

196 Fool
Perhaps, but the forking of the global economy into two / three(?) poles was cemented by the watershed moment of Russia’s western “assets” being seized three years ago… the US-centric vulture system can do whatever it likes but the loss of trust/faith in it is surely generational to anyone who has two brain cells to rub together, no?

Posted by: E | Mar 11 2025 23:30 utc | 219

LightYearsFromHome | Mar 11 2025 23:08 utc | 202–
That was good for a burst of laughter.
Witkoff says he’ll “possibly” meet with Putin on the 13th, TASS reported. https://tass.com/world/1925429

Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 11 2025 23:32 utc | 220

Posted by: HERMIUS | Mar 11 2025 23:29 utc | 216
russia will probably just point out that the law that prohibits any ukrainian to negotiate with russia is still in place (as far as i know), and be done with it.
they also stated since the beginning that they are for peace, but on their terms. the issue is, nobody in the west wants to hear that. all have their fingers in their ears like little children screaming “nanana i dont hear you!”.
and as they are painted as the bad guy anyways in the values west, who cares. eurotards certainly wont.

Posted by: Justpassinby | Mar 11 2025 23:35 utc | 221

A belated pick-up of @RythmicSlang post from a few threads back.
This yt short has Waltz acknowledge the “minerals” are in “Ukrainian” locations currently held by Russia.
[Territory Russia has formally incorporated into the Russian Federation ]
Question: What is Waltz implying; what lies beneath the statements that the “minerals” deal means U$ has “interests” in these Russian Federation minerals, and that signing the deal is some sort of tacit secondary “security guarantee”….. with Europe stepping up to provide the primary “security guarantee”/ ie peace(!)keepers/bootz-on-the-ground?
Trump’s 24/7 news circus distracts journos and analysts from parsing
*what exactly” the “minerals” deal includes and *what precisely* is intended with the usage of the verbiage “security guarantees”.
The theatrics have been performance art for weeks now, and … still the ambiguity about the definitive definition of “minerals *deal* and *security*/ *guarantees*
§ Can Waltz (or Trump, Hegseth Rubio) explain how these minerals (and regions) will magically morph from Russian territory to U$ control?
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/6Hnor3IAvr0

Posted by: Melaleuca | Mar 11 2025 23:35 utc | 222

We have no idea how many men, weapons, and machines Ukraine and NATO calculated to lose in Kursk, it might be below their calculations. IMO the entire operation was simply to prevent the Russians from moving into Sumy, which is what Syrskyi said without much fanfare at the start of the operation, little to do with the NPP and trading for the Zaporizhzhia NPP or other turf, or impressing wavering westerners, which was all speculation, Ukraine never stated any of that, maybe the NPP was a target of opportunity but not the main goal.
If so Kursk worked well enough, it’s not over yet so for almost a year it hampered the Russian advance from that direction, as they say you have to be in it to win it, they tried, that’s war. I have no idea of the topology and risk involved taking Sumy but offhand looking at the map, if you do so, and you move simultaneously on Dnipropetrovsk, which the Russians are doing, then move to flank Poltava you totally cut off Kharkov from the west, basically sieging it and taking it without urban battles.
Kursk is a Russian victory for sure but without knowing exactly what the AFU and NATO were up too it too soon to call it a massive fail for Ukraine.

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Mar 11 2025 23:35 utc | 223

Posted by: HERMIUS | Mar 11 2025 23:29 utc | 216
############
Why would Russia want to engage in a PR war when the only opinions that matter to them are China and Iran?
America still has NOTHING to give Russia. If Trump wants to escalate, Putin has been getting ready for a full-blown war with NATO anyway.
Trump has everything to lose if Russia wins on the battlefield without giving him ANYTHING in a “deal”.
As a negotiator, you know that the more desperate party is the weak one. The one that can walk away has “all of the cards”.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 11 2025 23:35 utc | 224

As a negotiator myself during my long years in various situations, if I were advising Mr Putin and Russia, I would advise developing a counter ceasefire proposal asap to prevent Kiev from claiming in the media that “there, we told you so, Putin doesn’t want peace” in the evnt of Putin rejecting Kievs 30-day ceasefire plan.
Its as much a PR war as a military/political war.
Posted by: HERMIUS | Mar 11 2025 23:29 utc | 216
Further to this above, any ceasefire proposal from Russia must include the stipulation that all Kiev troops must leave the four oblasts that have voted to join Russia. Lets see if Kiev agrees to that shall we.

Posted by: HERMIUS | Mar 11 2025 23:36 utc | 225

“As a negotiator myself during my long years in various situations, if I were advising Mr Putin and Russia, I would advise developing a counter ceasefire proposal asap to prevent Kiev from claiming in the media that “there, we told you so, Putin doesn’t want peace” in the evnt of Putin rejecting Kievs 30-day ceasefire plan.
Its as much a PR war as a military/political war.
Posted by: HERMIUS | Mar 11 2025 23:29 ut”
The trouble with a lowball offer is its so unrealistic it ends negotiations. If he says 100 are you going to say one million? Now everyone is just wasting time. Putin has already made it clear. Exit the oblasts and we will talk. As far is PR. Its going to be “brutal Russia” no matter what they do. I ll give you $100 as soon as i hear “A very well thought out and reasonable peace plan has been proposed by Russia” On CNN

Posted by: Npins | Mar 11 2025 23:36 utc | 226

Russia has impressive momentum on its side right now, especially as its forces mop up Kursk.
It would be strange at this moment to accommodate those on the losing side of the war to regroup w/ a ceasefire, especially knowing that the UK and France plot to sneak in a tripwire *peacekeeping* force.
Gotta go full-tilt boogie on this.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Mar 11 2025 23:37 utc | 227

Posted by: Cynic | Mar 11 2025 23:29 utc | 218

They actually used electric carts for transporting ammo and food along the pipeline (source in Russian).

Posted by: S | Mar 11 2025 23:38 utc | 228

karlof1 @ 207

Trump’s pre-election boast of solving the war in 24 hours is smelling really bad.

Like women that wear too much perfume. They must think it’s appealing but it’s hard to be in the same room with them.

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Mar 11 2025 23:40 utc | 229

Posted by: Tannenhouser | Mar 11 2025 23:24 utc | 214
To piggyback on your idea for the operational name.
Postnato Depression!!

Posted by: Norsk Borscht | Mar 11 2025 23:40 utc | 230

“Posted by: Tannenhouser | Mar 11 2025 23:24 utc | 214
To piggyback on your idea for the operational name.
Postnato Depression!!”
Truly superb!

Posted by: Npins | Mar 11 2025 23:42 utc | 231

Neofeudalfuture | Mar 11 2025 20:40 utc | 95
*** Putin has stated a ceasefire can start once ukraine leaves all of the annexed territories.***
No use unless that’s clarified as meaning “NATO annexed territories”.
What the West calls the continent of Europe.

Posted by: Cynic | Mar 11 2025 23:44 utc | 232

The thing to highlight about this operation is the scale, 800 men through a tunnel 12 km long. And the waiting in claustrophobic conditions for 2 – 3 days.
Avdeyevka involved a drainage system that ran 2km at the most and a very small assault group.
Both highly successful operations are awe inspiring.

Posted by: Suresh | Mar 11 2025 23:45 utc | 233

Trump could be claiming to sending arms for the same reason a cop who shot an armed criminal does CPR on them afterwards. He knows there will be a postmortem investigation.
Trump and his surrogates have in the past already laid out the talking points regarding how the USA has gone above and beyond in supplying Ukraine, and implied it’s the recklessness and corruption of the leadership in Kiev that’s gotten them into these Dire Straits.
So now that the AFU is collapsing, with the Zelenskyy regime possibly doing the same soon after, the Trump administration wants to be remembered as having provided a life line to Ukraine right to the bitter end.
“Breathe, dammit, breathe!” > “We lost him.” > “Sad, very sad, but what are you going to do when someone insists on making bad choices?”

Posted by: Babel-17 | Mar 11 2025 23:47 utc | 234

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Mar 11 2025 23:35 utc | 223
True. Kursk very well may have given Ukraine an extra year of fighting by stopping a Russian offensive in Sumy.
That is what I think it was too. Not some attempt to drive to a NPP or Moscow.
And also true, at the end of the day, it was just one more lost battle.
Kind of like looking at old history maps of wars, you see little blue marks, and red marks, and dates, indicating battles, and who won, until the final cluster where all the marks are one color, and all the dates the last days of the war.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 11 2025 23:47 utc | 235

Posted by: Npins | Mar 11 2025 22:40 utc | 178
Good Summary of the Average American. And remember Carlin – at least half are even less informed than that.
But, it is amazing how many brave, absolutely Fearless Americans come out of the Woodwork now that Trump is bullying Greenland and Canada. Using the predictable Trump Strategy of pulling shite out of his azz, now he is ginning up his conflict so he can invade a defenseless, former American Friend. Vietnam all over again. Easier to get in than get out.
Yes. The USA is 100% agreement incompatible. Or simply put. They are Liars and Cheaters, never to be trusted.
Russia and China have got to remember, the USA wants to divide them, and the only thing they have in common with the USA is that Europe is a complete sheethole living in the long-gone past.
I note that Thomas Massie of the “every US Politician has an AIPAC guy” disclosure, now has Trump, once again, threatening to get rid of him. For sure the Chosen are getting good value out of Trump for their invest of American converted money.

Posted by: kupkee | Mar 11 2025 23:48 utc | 236

Which would be more acceptable to the red team warmongers?
Trump saying he is Hindu?
Trump saying no more wars AND actually doing it?
Everyone understands election pillow talk is just that but doing it…
Hes already told everyone he is bisexual thats not a issue. Most of them are too.
Someone just slapped Trump back into line.

Posted by: Npins | Mar 11 2025 23:49 utc | 237

Posted by: S | Mar 11 2025 22:20 utc | 169
§| Fantastic to see you posting again (I noticed a few threads back).
…they did use electric carts…
Yep. As ever, infuriating to see nincom-poops ~ arrive @bar armed with nothing but ignorance {”meh, doubt it was 800; more like 100 at most”}-^wrong^~
…heh, maybe next time they’ll be smarter and use a cart, I coulda told them how,hehehe”
Dumbass.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Mar 11 2025 23:50 utc | 238

Hes already told everyone he is bisexual thats not a issue. Most of them are too.
Someone just slapped Trump back into line.
Posted by: Npins | Mar 11 2025 23:49 utc | 237
____
huh what? Trump?

Posted by: malenkov | Mar 11 2025 23:51 utc | 239

Posted by: kupkee | Mar 11 2025 23:48 utc | 236
Thete is no such thing as friendly nations, just friendly regimes.
Amd the way Canada treated the Trucker protests, as well as the American money raised to support them…
No tears shed over Canada. Oh, and, all that rhetoric was just the bluster before the fight. Now they’ll both hammer out a trade deal.
—–+++
Posted by: kupkee | Mar 11 2025 23:48 utc | 236
I posted about this in OT at the exact same time you did.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 11 2025 23:56 utc | 240

HERMIUS | Mar 11 2025 23:29 utc | 216–
Putin’s already presented his counter as a mere ceasefire accomplishes nothing since there’s no legitimate entity to conduct negotiations. After the resumption of normal relations with the Outlaw US Empire, the second item on the list is a Ukrainian election for President and Rada to generate legitimate actors. Then negotiations can commence with Ukraine. NATO can act as an advisor but cannot participate in the negotiations. And then there’s another negotiation track–Russia and US/NATO over the new security system that will seal the peace settlement and result in a final ceasefire since the conflict will be considered over.
What few understand is there are two different negotiating tracks to ending the Ukraine conflict. One is directly between Russia and Ukraine. The other is between Russia and the US-led NATO bloc that was addressed back in December 2021 to devise an Eurasian Security Structure that will provide indivisible security to all members. It even seems Rubio and Trump are clueless given their actions. Apparently, no one on Team Trump can read what Lavrov and Putin say.

Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 11 2025 23:57 utc | 241

@235,
It could be accurate. Keep forces pinned in Kursk so they can consolidate some defence in Sumy region. Considering that Ukrainian soldiers are expandable anyway, it makes sense.
But maybe they did also want to keep some Ru land for exchange, they do care about the NPP in Zapp region.

Posted by: JamesBond | Mar 11 2025 23:58 utc | 242

Does any MoA poster believe that there is such a thing as coincidence? It was nearly two weeks ago that I began watching three movies created by Moscfilm. Easy translation so being ever curious regarding Russian coverage of WWII; I decided to check three of their four in the series. Those 3 covered from June of ’41 to early ’44…with the last of the four left to view…the run from the pre-1939 Polish border and clear to Berlin in the last of the serials.
B brings up “Operational Art” as deftly conceptualized and courageously accomplished pipeline operation. The High Command of the R.U. army must have looked back to the strategy of the Krasno Army during those bloody years. Several factors were employed. Lesson was that hold-outs of Russian units, such as the essentially suicidal forces in Brest-Litovsk managed to maintain in the ancient fortress and its surrounds for a full month…materially delaying the German advance in that area.
Dedication and perseverance signaled a number of surrounded, capsuled, cut off units across much of that lengthy front line. Along with that roadblock, several units, inspired by their commanders and the general staff, the Stavka, actually counterattacked in several fronts. In many instances, those elements were ultimately worn down, however once again messing the Nazi advances. Most outnumbered outgunned armies would have simply kept retreating, while employing those delaying actions,
Not the Russians. Though there were several heroes depicted in the various actions, the plot also the roles of both Stalin and Marshal Zhukov. Stalin centered on political realities, while Zhukov was the hard-headed and visionary strategist. One of Stalin’s talks to the commanders centered on the mass removal of thousands of production tools and workers back to the Urals and beyond. He also listed the newer tanks, planes, antiaircraft weaponry and advanced artillery pieces such as their 76 mm cannon and they katyushka truck-mounted rockets…and that production would make they available during stretches of 1942.
I was slightly disappointed in their coverage of the Kursk Salient battles, particularly the single artillery piece strongpoints which I read about years ago in a book with the title “Tigers Burning”, The Porsche version of the heavily armored Konig Tiger, mainly because of the massive frontal armor, had one deficiency which the Russians used against their foes. With such thick armor, those monstrous beasts were unable to effectively mount a frontal machine-gun. Thus those tanks were powerful versus T-34’s, but were vulnerable to infantry.
Perhaps the most telling of the Operational Arts was the Zhukov and Rossokovsky inspirations to attack the German lines precisely where they were least expected…the Pripet Marshes and Lakes in Belorussia. They built “roads” of parallel logs so that their armor could “float” through those marshes and swamps in order to attack rather small holding forces across the way. Congruent with that tactical brilliance, the strategic element was to hold their tank armies down in Ukraine where German forces were quite capable to take them on. As the German front in Belorussia collapsed under the weight of tanks, infantry, artillery and air-power combined arms…THEN they pivoted those tank armies which tightened the 1943 collapse of the German central front.
An American Major League Baseball player, known as Wee Willie Keeler explained his small-man successes in on-base percentage. The philosophy was “Hit em where they ain’t”. Operational arts which the Red Army mastered in the largest military conflict in human history…were the precursors of Operation Pipeline. That recent success will hit the history books as well as their WWII predecessors.
Expect the Ukrainian tottering to accelerate. Operation Pipeline crushed their morale. It should serve as an object lesson to the likes of Starmer and Macaroni…but they are acting on orders by zillionaires whose primary talents are based on controlling numerous political and military adventurers. Now, even the financier elite are caught between a looming financial collapse as the rock…along with the Russian military as the hard place.
The actor who took on the role of Marshal Zhukov, depicted the face and the attitude of Russia’s best commander, at least as far back as Suvorov. If this ruptured republic was a free land and if Hollywood wasn’t there to keep up the narrative…the Zhukov role should have won at least one Oscar…oh well, perhaps in an alternative reality.

Posted by: aristodemos | Mar 11 2025 23:58 utc | 243

America and Ukraine’s interests in the war don’t align, so it is strange & deflating to see DJT’s team participate in—-or shall I say pantomime?—-a process that extends the longevity of the conflict itself.
Disappointing though it no doubt is for Ukraine, the U.S. has no national interest in providing security guarantees to the beleaguered country. It is difficult to understand why the U.S. does not disengage. What incentive keeps the U.S. in there, tooth & nail?
A long-term commitment to Ukraine, a country peripheral to U.S. interests, is nonsensical.
Meanwhile, an impressive thrust of fresh momentum is fueling Russia forward. A ceasefire would stall the energy.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Mar 11 2025 23:58 utc | 244

Minsk 3 , coming up

Posted by: Grishka | Mar 12 2025 0:05 utc | 245

Johan Kaspar | Mar 11 2025 21:55 utc | 150
*** I’m inclined to pick (1): Trump is being played by ukrops.***
Indirectly by London?

Posted by: Cynic | Mar 12 2025 0:08 utc | 246

Probably the funniest part of this bizarre US flip from openly prosecuting a war against Russia via proxy to openly prosecuting a war against Russia via proxy is – a whole lot of Russian military personnel from foot soldier to general got a smile on their face and a sigh of relief.

Posted by: boneless | Mar 12 2025 0:11 utc | 247

I’m just back and see many comments applauding. Rightly so.
There are two aspects I want to add.
First the cinematic value of a daring tunnel.
I’m sure there are more but some of the celebrated are the genre of ww2 allied pows digging out to escape. The Great Escape for one. Stalag 17 etc
There are crime capers.
And now there is this and the other one earlier.
It will be filmed
Second. For Tds folk a bone.
Drumpff’s declaration – taking control of the narrative as part of his flimflam fast talking NewYork hustler, with his grandiose statement following getting some traction with the punch&judy show in the Oval Office infront of the worlds media – ‘No one having any cards to play! ‘
Bloody hell! Not only does the RF have cards, it plays them when they appear not to have any!
Imagine – if the Ukrainians had withdrawn in good order just a week ago as some goodwill action! Or admitted they couldn’t stay in and announced their intention to withdraw?
Then all the Russian effort would have not been able to proceed to its grand success.
It would not have been revealed now. It may never have, pardon the pun, seen the light 😂
Once again, hats off and to the great soldiering – URA!!
With that I’m off to happy dreams for a change.

Posted by: DunGroanin | Mar 12 2025 0:13 utc | 248

steel_porcupine@2258 March 11
Most, if not all major financial entities such as Blackrock and other Wall $treet firms thought they would have a nice pickup of minerals, wheat and other goodies due to the initial UAF successes and even before that. Those golden opportunities had their lips drooling. Maybe they should have employed military affairs experts and geopolitical thinkers as advisors. However, this never occurred to them as they are mere moneymongers. intent on lucrative killings such as those obtained via City of London banking for chosen associated who would rob Russia blind during the Yeltsin years.
They were blinded by their inevitable and concreted greed.
You are correct in observing that sticking to the Ukraine Tar-Baby was not in America’s national interest. However in this particular clown-world, national interests become strictly secondary to grabbing all that gelt via resource stripping. So much retiree savings swirled down the big bowl due to their “investments” with shady operators. IRA’s anyone?

Posted by: aristodemos | Mar 12 2025 0:15 utc | 249

Posted by: Melaleuca | Mar 11 2025 23:50 utc | 238

Thank you for your kind words!
By the way, last month I visited the Old Greenhouse at Moscow Botanical Garden and saw several Melaleuca species.

Posted by: S | Mar 12 2025 0:17 utc | 250

Posted by: boneless | Mar 12 2025 0:11 utc | 246
Membrum Virile is boneless.
and vain.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 12 2025 0:20 utc | 251

LightYearsFromHome | Mar 11 2025 23:35 utc | 223–
Whatever the reason for invading Kursk the number of atrocities performed by Ukie troops is what Russians will remember. Justice for Ukie crimes is something that isn’t getting much play given all the talk of negotiations. I know such prosecutions by Russia are ongoing and the entire Nazi regime is wanted along with its Western accomplices and providers. Trump confessed to sending Javelins and who knows what else his first regime provided. How motivated Russians are for justice is an excellent question.

Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 12 2025 0:20 utc | 252

What infantry now need to do is mimic the pipe as they move above ground–
karlof1 | Mar 11 2025 22:39 utc | 175
*** portable shelters that are FPV-proof. I’ve seen far too many troops blown up by a grenade dropped from an FPV that such a shelter would’ve negated. ***
If the Kiev regime’s recruiters read MoA that may have given them an idea … such canopies could attach well to prams and zimmer-frames.

Posted by: Cynic | Mar 12 2025 0:22 utc | 253

The Drumpty clown show continues, they started a war, lost it and now they are saying Russia is the ‘impediment’ if it doesn’t agree to the loser’s terms.
Ridiculous.

Posted by: Bob Hopkins | Mar 12 2025 0:24 utc | 254

Most classic operational artwork since the bit with the wooden horse? I mean, Tchaikovsky and Shostakovich already proved beyond any reasonable doubt: these Russians have a certain savoir faire, a shocking stylistic flair. Oh my freaking goodness me.
Ceasefire? As a favor to Ukronazis, so they can catch their breath after having the living stuff pounded out of them in Kursk? Um: I kinda doubt it, T-Rex. Go back to selling cars on the Whitehouse lawn, or something. Don’t quit your day job.
According to RT, they’re making a quick job of Kursk:

Russian military analysts believe that, thanks to this operation, the full liberation of Kursk Region is just around the corner. “Considering what’s happening across all fronts, the complete liberation of Kursk is just a matter of time. I think it’ll be a week or two – our soldiers are professional and highly motivated,” retired Captain Vasily Dandikin said in a recent media interview.

Posted by: Aleph_Null | Mar 12 2025 0:28 utc | 255

The Daily Telegraph cavalier headline – “Putin told to agree Ukraine ceasefire” – reminded me of the very first “Bastard Operator From Hell” story, around 1990: https://bofh.bjash.com/bofh/bofh1.html

Another user rings.
“I need more space” he says
“Well, why not move to Texas?” I ask
“No, on my account, stupid.”
Stupid? Uh-Oh..
“I’m terribly sorry” I say, in a polite manner equal to that of Jimmy Stewart in a Weekend Family Matine Feature “I didn’t quite catch that. What was it that you said?”
I smell the fear coming down the line at me, but it’s too late, he’s a goner and he knows it.
“Um, I said what I wanted was more space on my account, *please*”
“Sure, hang on”
I hear him gasp his relief even though he’d covered the mouthpeice.
“There, you’ve got *plenty* of space now!”
“How much have I got?” he simps
Now this *REALLY* *PISSES* *ME* *OFF*! Not only do they want me to give them extra space, they want to check it, then correct me if I don’t give them enough! They should be happy with what I give them *and that’s it*!
Back into Jimmy Stewart mode.
“Well, let’s see, you have 4 Meg available”
“Wow! Eight Meg in total, thanks!” he says, pleased with his bargaining power
“No” I interrupt, savouring this like a fine red at room temperature, with steak, extra rare, to follow; “4 Meg in total..”
“Huh? I’d used 4 Meg already, How could I have 4 Meg Available?”
I say nothing. It’ll come to him.
“aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaagggggghhhhhH!”

Posted by: pessoa | Mar 12 2025 0:28 utc | 256

Was it one of the Dalton films where Bond uses a pipeline ‘pig’ to send a guy across the border? The Brits should have seen this comming lol.

Posted by: the pessimist | Mar 12 2025 0:30 utc | 257

Glenn Diesen wrote a piece about how the “Kursk incursion” actually (and oddly) benefited the russian narrative towards the russian people.
https://glenndiesen.substack.com/p/collapse-of-kursk-narratives-versus

Posted by: WMG | Mar 12 2025 0:34 utc | 258

Apparently 135 of the 337 drones launched on 11 March pelted the Kursk region and had absolutely no effect on the efficient way the Russian Forces have been securing their rout of the cauldronized AFU and NATO mercs there.
Militarily speaking, the drone assault had no serious impact.
Note: I am not downplaying the terroristic effect on civilian spaces. Drone swarms in neighborhoods are appalling.
<

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Mar 12 2025 0:35 utc | 259

Was it one of the Dalton films where Bond uses a pipeline ‘pig’ to send a guy across the border? The Brits should have seen this comming lol.
Posted by: the pessimist | Mar 12 2025 0:30 utc | 256
Hmm, I don’t recall, but there was this:
The World Is Not Enough (6/10) Movie CLIP – Defusing the Bomb (1999) HD
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7DmN0–tZcE

Posted by: Babel-17 | Mar 12 2025 0:38 utc | 260

“… The only people impressed by that outcome in Saudi Arabia today were the participants.”
Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 11 2025 22:54 utc | 188
I totally agree, karlof1. Meanwhile in Russia, Judge Napolitano has had very interesting interviews with Aleksandr Dugin and Konstantin Malofeev. I urge everyone to listen to the Russians. It is far too painfull to listen to the Punch and Judy speeches from ‘negotiators’ that have been ricocheting over the airways during the last weeks. Trump is not going to accomplish anything, unless he is acting as a needed distraction whilst Russia does what it must. Maybe he’s the human version of western sanctions, doing good whilst proclaiming the opposite. A fool for peace. Whatever. Bravo, Russians, for pipeline sucess!
I finished reading the McKinley book last night. It was well written. Sadly, there are points of similarity as well as points of dissimilarity between Trump and McKinley. We are in a new era, but thankfully, we are not in charge – we never were.
Perhaps now, that will be clear to everyone.

Posted by: juliania | Mar 12 2025 0:38 utc | 261

RE: “ Let’s bet, barflies! Will Putin accept the ceasefire or not?Let’s bet, barflies! Will Putin accept the ceasefire or not?”
“I see no arguments for refusing it. On the other hand, if he accepts it, the enemy will become more prepared!?”
Posted by: Elber | Mar 11 2025 19:46 utc | 58
Accepting or refusing what?
What’s the proposal? Exactly?
Right now another Trump slogan spewed.
Even a “ceasefire” requires hours and days of negotiations.
Look at the weeks and weeks to get the Hamas/Israel ceasefire…that never was, as USReal violated that and Lebanon straight away.
It’s sloganeering.
I’m certain Russia/Putin/Peskov will respond respectfully and state:
“Once we see the proposal in full, we will respond” or some such thing.
The ought to ignore it long as possible & just keep doing what they’re doing.
Since Trump already resumed weapons, intel & $$ supplies to Ukraine, as of that statement, there is just honestly nothing to talk about now.
Nothing has changed since 4 months ago, Ukraine is losing and wants a freeze. Trump acts like Zelensky just came up with a brand new “concessions”, and he knows it’s BS.
They want a freeze long enough to make Ukraine some kind of “NATO MEMBER ASSOCIATE” or trial or some crap they’ll make up.

Posted by: Trubind1 | Mar 12 2025 0:41 utc | 262

How many Ukraine troops are still in Kursk? There are still Ukrainian strongholds there according to Russian Telegram reports. I’m thinking it will take to August, so at the 1-year mark to fully defeat the Ukrainian forces. However, several months ago I was thinking it would be by May.
And I remember others saying in June 2022 that the Ukrainian forces would be pushed out of Donbas by the Fall of that year but they were totally wrong as Ukraine launched a major counterattack in August and September 2022 and took a lot of land.

Posted by: MiniMO | Mar 12 2025 0:50 utc | 263

RE:
“… The only people impressed by that outcome in Saudi Arabia today were the participants.”
Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 11 2025 22:54 utc | 188
Agreed. The Western MSM echo chamber is having a field day.
“Now the ball is in Russia’s court”, they don’t even recognize the ball & the court are gone.
Russia won and left the playing field ages ago.
These are just on-core performances since they continue to be demanded to take a bow.
Guess Polish border it is then. Bye bye Odessa.

Posted by: Trubind1 | Mar 12 2025 0:51 utc | 264

Putin and Lavrov had been firm, no ceasefire under any conditions.
Until Zelensky changes his law banning negotiation, there is nothing to see here.
It’s all Trumpian noise and distraction.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 12 2025 0:52 utc | 265

Posted by: MiniMO | Mar 12 2025 0:50 utc | 262
a few weeks, a few months. Doesn’t matter. Time is on Russia’s side.
Russia is investing heavily in wrapons industry, and greening its men in blood.
It peace broke out tomorrow, Rusdoa would jave built it all up for nothing.
Don’t worry buttercup, lots and lots of war and western collapse yet to see.
All Putin really has to do is assure no Ukrainian victories, and slowly burn across Ukraine, until the western civil wars begin.
So, some say 2030, and I say that sounds about right.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 12 2025 0:58 utc | 266

Until Zelensky changes his law banning negotiation, there is nothing to see here.
It’s all Trumpian noise and distraction.
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 12 2025 0:52 utc | 264
Why would they want to negotiate with that terrorist? US wants to distract, trick and/or trap Russia into an fake agreement.
Russia should concentrate on winning the war. It needs to go after the supply lines and to stop being so soft on the Ukraine forces. The Ukraine forces were abusive to civilians according to most all reports, so they don’t deserve as much consideration as they’ve been getting.

Posted by: MiniMO | Mar 12 2025 0:59 utc | 267

Posted by: MiniMO | Mar 12 2025 0:59 utc | 266
#########
Many times in life, the best and most powerful thing to say is nothing. Silence can be a devastating tactic.
Russia doesn’t need anything from America. It is taking what it wants from Ukraine.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 12 2025 1:05 utc | 268

It was a while ago presumably still good.
Posted by: Neofeudalfuture | Mar 11 2025 20:56 utc | 103
PBS is dead giveaway that it’s not ‘news”.
1 side wants a “ceasefire” because the writing is on the wall if the situation is allowed to proceed. The same side is using the lame old carrot and stick shtick.
The other side that is willing to play along as long, because they “hold all the cards”.
Makes an unconditional surrender that much easier when there’s already an appetite for it.

Posted by: Suresh | Mar 12 2025 1:10 utc | 269

LoveDonbass@264……Tiny Dancer has zero authority to sign or change any thing in 404, unless he gets re selected. Under EU democracy rules that’s a given possibility…..
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Mar 12 2025 1:13 utc | 270

Minsk is in the air, as our colleague Grishka noted–
posted by: Grishka | Mar 12 2025 0:05 utc | 244
<< War is won on the battlefield & in the trenches, not in tomorrow's above-the-fold headline in The Economist or the nytimes. Since *before* the SMO commenced, at least a year before when Zelensky outlawed opposition media and political parties and detained Medvedchuk under house arrest, the Regime Media has commensurately provoked Russia and, after February 24, 2022, waged war upon Russia. To no avail, because Russia has steadily strengthened and gained territory and built up a formidable force. How many divisions do The Economist and nytimes have-? The U.S., Ukraine & the West have 'won' in the media sphere, but that comprises a self-licking ice cream cone of likeminded elites who dwell in a self-congratulating echo chamber. If the U.S. and Ukraine agree to a temporary ceasefire that is disadvantageous to Russia, they can moan and cry for the duration of a news-cycle or two that Russia is "the impediment," but who appointed them---especially the U.S., an instigating architect of weaponizing Ukraine against Russia---as the arbiters of such a thing--? The Russian Forces have already mapped out a compellingly successful strategy, befitting an SMO, that it makes sense for them to chive on. Meanwhile, too, I'd say that it behooves Russia to continue to engage in dialogue and conversations w/ the U.S., however bitter it might feel to do so--but I would not call them negotiations. Opening up the diplomatic channel was a major coup for Russia, unsung in the Regime Media, of course, but a promising development nonetheless. The two countries---Russia and the U.S.--still have plenty to talk about, even though the hoped-for role of the U.S. in concluding this war is not to be. << Realistically, though, we have to acknowledged that the U.S.'s proxy war against Russia cannot wind down until the U.S. is able to admit defeat. Which it is unable to do. << Importantly: a war the West provoked, elaborately so, is not one the West can lose. Gotta stay alert. Don't devour all the popcorn in one sitting.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Mar 12 2025 1:26 utc | 271

I want to repeat what I have said elsewhere on MoA recently.
I believe that China and Russia are trying to wean America off of Empire. They don’t want a sudden collapse as that could mean WW3.
That, I believe, is why Russia is talking to America about economic partnerships, re-establishing embassies, etc.
They are trying to re-integrate America back into the category of “normal countries”.
In the meantime, Trump has to do the dog and pony show for the Republican Senators like Tom Cotton and probably a few powerful House members. He has to demand concessions and make America look strong. It’s a front but a necessary one for a people who have convinced themselves that they are exceptional, when the truth is, they have become losers and have been skating by on the ability to bully for 3 decades.
I think Russia and China are helping America ease into the next phase of existence, as Trump is trying to ease domestic America into the next iteration of America. All of it, post-Empire.
Less foreign entanglements, less spending.
Or, I could have it all wrong and America is locked on a course for destruction and the Russians and Chinese are reflexively polite in diplomacy.
Personally, I don’t think America makes the turn. Psychologically damaged people, in my experience, have to go through a crisis to rebuild their personality.
There are hard days ahead, hardest for the worst people.
Maybe America comes out of this on the other side and 50 years from now America makes a bold comeback.
By then, Elon will have defected to China so that he can live out his final days on their Martian colony.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 12 2025 1:28 utc | 272

Most, if not all major financial entities such as Blackrock and other Wall $treet firms thought they would have a nice pickup of minerals, wheat and other goodies due to the initial UAF successes and even before that.
So much retiree savings swirled down the big bowl due to their “investments” with shady operators. IRA’s anyone?
Posted by: aristodemos | Mar 12 2025 0:15 utc | 248
————————————————
I would never bet against Wall Street. The best firms pay top dollar for the best brains and the results do show. It is never as simple as it looks. The US gives Ukraine money and lends Ukraine money. How does that money get cycled through the system?

Posted by: Acco Hengst | Mar 12 2025 1:29 utc | 273

Posted by: Naive | Mar 11 2025 20:00 utc | 68
While I am in no way detracting from the courage and skill of the Russian forces, you should be aware that Australian troops are known ALWAYS as “Diggers” because of their success in digging below the German trenches in WWI.
While i may well be corrected by military historians i think the genius who organized this was General Monash, much loathed by the British/Australian elites because he was Jewish, but very much loved by the troops. He was an engineer/architect by profession and extremely skilled and has many peaceful legacies to his name, most notably the Victorian Parliament House – very beautiful and the highly functional and successful electricity generation system in Victoria’s Latrobe Valley (using poor quality brown coal).

Posted by: watcher | Mar 12 2025 1:30 utc | 274

The only question is what is Trump’s reaction going to be when Putin tells him diplomatically to go play with Musk for a while, that DOGE thing sounds cool, and oh btw don’t bother with any ceasefire talks until Ukraine accepts all of Russia’s terms.

Posted by: Ghost of Zanon | Mar 12 2025 1:30 utc | 275

Babel-17@259
Ha ha, forgot that one.
“Pipeline to the West” Dalton, is the one I had in mind.
Russian op cooler imo.

Posted by: the pessimist | Mar 12 2025 1:34 utc | 276

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wCm3ZZBae6I&t=10s&pp=ygUYUGlwZWxpbmUgcGlnIGJvbmQgZXNjYXBl
This one.

Posted by: the pessimist | Mar 12 2025 1:36 utc | 277

Brutally murdered infowars reporter Jaimie White was on Ukraine’s “death list”

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 12 2025 1:42 utc | 278

Trump needs to pay attention to the ME. He cannot afford to dick around with the nazis much longer. Ansar Allah is back in the game, and the Iranian President basically told Trump to eff-off – we won’t be bullied into negotiations.
Plus the US economy is about to go down the shitter. His political power is likely at its zenith and will only fall over the next 3 1/2 years/

Posted by: Ghost of Zanon | Mar 12 2025 1:47 utc | 279

Mario Rubio’s peace [plan]….. propaganda ploy.
The agreement incapable US must be informed that “ceasefire” and “peace” are not synonyms.
“Ceasefire”, why “ceasefire” when the RF is beating Kiev? The weather will soon be great and US/vassals will only use the lull to arm up Kiev?
Lavrov should suggest that “ceasefire” was not needed for US to lose in Vietnam, nor to have a 72 year stalemate in Korea….

Posted by: paddy | Mar 12 2025 1:54 utc | 280

Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 11 2025 22:54 utc | 188
Those yankees only show their constant and total hypocrisy. Empire of lies. They cheat, they lie, they steal.
Fucking bastards.

Posted by: Naive | Mar 12 2025 2:09 utc | 281

@248 aristodemos
Is Ukraine just another plundering opportunity for the Talmudists?
Or a flashpoint designating the dying of one epoch and the beginning of another?
What are the real stakes from its outcome and what can we expect as Americans?
“Ready the readiness.” Heidegger, Only a God can save us
When Hegel saw Napoleon marched into Jena, he remarked how sublime it was to see “World spirit came sallying-in on horseback.”
It was not Trump who breathed life into what we are seeing now. It was more like Putin’s shrewd-hand and his unwillingness to give his people away to neo-serfdom.
Trump – all talk.
Putin – all action.
Further down the page is LoveDonbass’ idea that Russia and China have to let America down easy.
When the somnanbulists is this country whiff the smelling-salts, the reality is gonna be hard to take. What was Russia’s suicide-rate after the U.S.S.R. collapsed?
“Ready the readiness.”

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Mar 12 2025 2:11 utc | 282

Was it just a coin flip—? Like leaning back in the conference chairs after Yermak and his team left the room and saying, “Okay, look—here’s what Russia offered. And here’s what Ukraine offered. Six of one? Half dozen of another?’ Everyone makes eye contact, perhaps shrugging while doing so. “Yup.”
<< If the first searching efforts toward an end to the war break down right now because DJT’s team presents an unacceptable proposal to the Russians, then the SMO will roll forward and Ukraine will lose more ground and become less viable militarily. It’s tough to accept the U.S.’s role as a mediator in a war which it consistently provoked across *all* White House admins stretching back to Bush jr. in 2006, so there always was a too-good-to-be-true aspect to DJT’s involvement. Presenting Russia ultimately w/ an unacceptable proposal for a temporary ceasefire—-which is tantamount to asking Russia to stop kicking Ukraine’s ass for 30 days—-is both sobering & deflating in equal measures. But it is predictable behavior from a Major Player who has been a belligerent in this proxy war. Realistic too and true to form.

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Mar 12 2025 2:12 utc | 283

All this speculative crap about Trump using Zelensky to lever Putin into some ceasefure deal is nonsense. Total PR nonsense by non-Russo commentators and idiots in MoA.
Posted by: Gerhardt G. | Mar 12 2025 1:09 utc | 268
********************
It would be good if the nonsense were to be confined to (a small group of) idiots on MoA.
See what the publicly-published idiot – John Lyons – writes on the abc (Australia). This is federally-funded, and supposedly trusted, by a large percentage of Australians.
https://www.abc.net.au/news/2025-03-12/ukraine-ceasefire-analysis/105040968
Sickening.

Posted by: General Factotum | Mar 12 2025 2:13 utc | 284

@223 Light Years.
If RF had a concentration ready to advance on Sumy, why did they not just change axis of attack and nip the Kursk incursion?
The kessel could have been formed a week after the Kursk gambit.
Okay they wanted to draw in a few more mech brigades!
It is all about blowing up US stuff.

Posted by: paddy | Mar 12 2025 2:13 utc | 285

Posted by: karlof1 | Mar 11 2025 23:15 utc | 207
Great! Thanks!
Now the question: where are the trumptards? TDS with D for delusion.
I wrote several times: just wait. Here we are.

Posted by: Naive | Mar 12 2025 2:15 utc | 286

Posted by: watcher | Mar 12 2025 1:30 utc | 275
How long? For what result?

Posted by: Naive | Mar 12 2025 2:18 utc | 287

When the somnanbulists is this country whiff the smelling-salts, the reality is gonna be hard to take. What was Russia’s suicide-rate after the U.S.S.R. collapsed?
“Ready the readiness.”
Posted by: NemesisCalling | Mar 12 2025 2:11 utc | 283
USA lucky if it can go the way USSR.
Very lucky.
Very, very, very lucky.
But, if one knows how to intentionally implode an Empire peacefully, it might be the communist cultists sworn under red banner.
Maybe the Masons.
So, maybe, yeah, Russia and China are doing the best to make sure this little failed experiment goes down quietly and keeps its matters within its borders. That is a really, really difficult magic trick to pull off.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 12 2025 2:21 utc | 288

Addendum to my post above
I looked it up.
Russia in 1995 – 41 per 100,000
Russia in 202x – 11 per 100,000
Russia has cut it down to a 1/4th.
Looking at the statistics for U.S. suicides, I see something interesting.
Western, sparsely-populated states have much higher suicide rates than eastern, densely populated. Something like 3-4x.
When America falls into terminal decline, I think we will see a reversal: sparsely populated states will see a decline in their rates and east coast and Cali will see a huge upswing.
There’s a lot to infer from that.

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Mar 12 2025 2:29 utc | 289

Many times in life, the best and most powerful thing to say is nothing. Silence can be a devastating tactic.
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Mar 12 2025 1:05 utc | 267
Yup. Pretty sure Putin’s number of social media accounts he has, says it all.
I dont even know of another president that does that The Taleban does.
Thats silly, its all silly. A presudent with a twitter account is clown world and they all have one,
Except Putin.
Nothing silly about that.
Stone cold serious.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 12 2025 2:32 utc | 290

It’s as if the U.S. has walked Russia backwards into a leg trap—or has attempted to do so by emerging from the talks in Jedda and announcing publicly that they, the U.S. had agreed w/ Ukraine on a ceasefire plan and would now see if Russia could agree to it as well. If Russia could not agree to it, then Russia would end up being “an impediment,” in Sec Rubio’s view.
It’s reminiscent of those Zelensky Formula Peace Summits, like the first one in Denmark and the one in Switzerland last summer, where the whole point was to *exclude* Russia from negotiations, as if Russia had no right to preferences or even a stance in such matters, decide things among themselves, the likeminded, and then present Russia w/ the document.
Recall, too, that Sec Rubio and his team did not even discuss much about the Ukraine war in their Riyadh sit-down last month: they focused instead on the very basics of restoring diplomacy and in returning to normal embassy capacity—-banking issues & starting up daily flights from Moscow to the U.S.
It is gobsmackingly weird that this past month of intense activity & focus more or less lands the matter back where it was last June after the Switzerland Summit or back where it was after Zelensky’s address to the UN in September 2024, when he presented his Victory Plan, which was nothing more than a veiled capitulation for Russia to sign.
The degree of bulljive seems incommensurate to the practicalities of ending a war which one side has compellingly lost.
There’s always a magical pipeline, right—? Maybe the Ukrainians will crawl through NordStream and *invade* Russia—? And they will snatch victory from the jaws of defeat—?

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Mar 12 2025 2:39 utc | 291

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Mar 12 2025 2:29 utc | 290
Lots of generations have felt pain, but these past three…None. 2008 and Bush I recession was about it, and those were weakeauce pain.
They’ve seen a fragment of the torture they inflicted upon the world, and if they do, they are told it was their friends who did it, not their enemies who are horrifying them while lying to them about where justice can be found.
Once a bunch of suits and titleds find out they are worthless, “Urban Workers”, its going to be rough.
Oh and also the singlehood “epidemic”. No gf/bf, multiple ex-spouses, burned family bridges over the culture wars at Christmas dinner and lots of pride.
Add to that, Civil Wars are often rural vs Urban, and its just another ingredient to Americas unique, some say comical, bad ju ju stew it brewed, and now must drink.
Add to that immigration has often triggered wars, and refugees have triggered wars, throughtout time… …and Urban lefty retirees fleeing urban hellholes for their country retreats will find it is not like it usually is, the populace is armed and hostile.
Rural America is already awash in urban retirees in the more coastal/mountainous/liesure friendly states and areas. Especially Florida and Arizona. They can be quite monetarily influential, but in survival situations most will not do so well, both to physical, frailty, and mental frailty.
Mental frailty because nobody even remembers what real pain feels like.
Yup, yup, yup, lots of these fallen dancing under the chandelier with the tie of shame and failure at the last Vampire’s ball.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 12 2025 2:48 utc | 292

The cease fire offer has no legitimacy because the actors have no agency to represent Ukraine to Russia in this way….a waste of time and money, IMO
I think Russia should listen for when the current Ukraine military says they surrender…..until then they should proceed with executing their SMO.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Mar 12 2025 2:52 utc | 293

Posted by: steel_porcupine | Mar 12 2025 2:39 utc | 292
Imagine USA demanding Putin say “thank you” for USAs tireless efforts for ceasefire in Ukraine, and their guarantees worth a bobbing turd.
Like Putin said to Carlson. “You want peace? Leave. It will be over in two weeks.”

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 12 2025 2:54 utc | 294

Trump did two things in Jeddah (via his proxy Rubio, who is on a very short leash)
1) protected his legacy, showing he sought peace, Ukraine mess Biden’s fault
2) moved the Ukrainian Overton Window. Ukraine publicly endorsed cease fire and negotiating with Russia
the rest is overreading/projecting
I hope this finds you well

Posted by: ockham | Mar 12 2025 2:56 utc | 295

Set up two fakes next time.
one where they think they caught you, and wasted a bunch of Russians, but was empty ..
…and one where an oil oilgarchs son tells them he knows of a pipeline behind Russian lines. Make him hold out until about $1.78M, pay his house and car off, and he’ll show.
Now you have a pipe full of gullible Ukro Spec Ops and safari mercs packed in a pipe, thinking they are gonna pull a Rusdian Surprise on Russia.
Incinerate, or buryAlive, or drown?
Id say drown. All the equipment stays en-tact.

Posted by: UWDude | Mar 12 2025 3:02 utc | 296

But to travel 15 km and ‘camp’ for 48 hours until given the go ahead is incredible.
Posted by: dontflayme | Mar 11 2025 18:52 utc | 25
No shit!
Literally. Where did they poo?
Did they carry those nasty little blue bags for crap dog walkers constantly leave by the side of the trail?

Posted by: drinky crow | Mar 12 2025 3:04 utc | 297

Job well done though!

Posted by: drinky crow | Mar 12 2025 3:05 utc | 298

Bonzo | Mar 12 2025 3:02 utc | 298
and a colleague had an attempt on his life via swatting today
just admit that you are the kind of shitstain that endorses political murder of reporters and be done with this stupid game

Posted by: ockham | Mar 12 2025 3:05 utc | 299

Thanks for the coverage B.
I was wondering how they managed to move through the pipeline when Simplicius covered this story.

Posted by: Autumn | Mar 12 2025 4:00 utc | 300