Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 29, 2024
The MoA Week In Review – OT 2024-314

Last week's posts on Moon of Alabama:

Well, I was busy doing the Christmas rounds. There weren't any posts.

Other issues:

Empire:

Palestine:

Eastern Europe:

Syria:

South Korea:

A very important (thus long suppressed) document on U.S.-Russia relation following the end of the Soviet Union:

Ukraine:

Post-Imperial arrogance …

Use as open (not related to Ukraine and Palestine) thread …

Comments

@ laguerre | Dec 30 2024 9:55 utc | 83
So, the European Union is a good thing, only its decisions are bad?
God laughs about men who deplore the effects of causes they cherish (Bossuet).

Posted by: Leuk | Dec 30 2024 16:40 utc | 101

Nothing good has come out of the EU takeover for the people of Europe.
Posted by: Ed Bernays | Dec 30 2024 12:25 utc | 92
I don’t know whether I’m supposed to imagine that you are an inhabitant of the EU, but one can say that greater ignorance hath no man than you. small-minded isolationism. Typical of a lot of Brits – now they’re suffering for the choice they made. They’re beginning to finally figure out what what they’ve lost. But also imaginable for a German resident who insists on blinding himself to the way things work. No-one would want to go back to the old closed Europe. The Uk has done it and they’re in the disaster zone. The problems in the EU come from the States, aided by US servants like Tony Blair, Ursula vdL, and others. THe US has put a vast amount of effort into undermining the EU, and you continue that narrative. Not at all surprising for a small-minded isolationist who hopes to go back to the Stone Age, where there was no international contact.

Posted by: laguerre | Dec 30 2024 16:53 utc | 102

@ laguerre | Dec 30 2024 16:53 utc | 108
The European Union bloc is illegal, as it removes sovereignty from Europe’s national governments and leaves them with Ursula.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 30 2024 17:12 utc | 103

@109
True, true, an unelected dictator at that.

Posted by: Middle-man | Dec 30 2024 17:27 utc | 104

laguerre | Dec 30 2024 16:53 utc | 108
*** Typical of a lot of Brits – now they’re suffering for the choice they made. They’re beginning to finally figure out what what they’ve lost. ***
Britain lost a customs union, which was what most brexit voters actually wanted. They did not want to be dictated to by Brussels as well as London. Brexit was hijacked by the Establishment.
*** But also imaginable for a German resident who insists on blinding himself to the way things work. No-one would want to go back to the old closed Europe. The Uk has done it and they’re in the disaster zone. The problems in the EU come from the States, aided by US servants like Tony Blair, Ursula vdL, and others. THe US has put a vast amount of effort into undermining the EU, and you continue that narrative. Not at all surprising for a small-minded isolationist who hopes to go back to the Stone Age, where there was no international contact.***
So what you really want is an EU that does not exist.
And was never intended to … given the people and organisations behind its deception based foundation.
It was really a US-imperial cattle pen — and still is.
Complete with a neoliberal bank of anti-sovereign usury.

When the UK voted to join the then Common Market, it was because the voters were fed a massive amount of lies and denials. Which some years after that ever more undemocratically morphed into the dictatorship as was indicated in the Lisbon Treaty (aka EU “constitution”).
You seem to want what might have been had the US not been in charge from the start.

Posted by: Cynic | Dec 30 2024 17:50 utc | 105

Sorry if I’ve left anyone out (threads are hard to follow at present, which is good when good ideas are to the fore) but kudos to Jane at 59, psychohistorian at 60 and James at 62. Here’s a link that has made waves at NC:
https://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2024/12/how-maga-can-stuff-doge-back-in-his-box-and-win-the-day-on-h1b.html
Many of our open threads conversations sprung to mind with this, specifically the one on education which applies internationally as well. Russia has an impressive educational program for its citizens, with influx of international students who then return to their own countries to give them the benefit of their education.
Perhaps that is how such programs should proceed. Sort of like a program to train physicians that has a mandatory period for doctoring the needy as a requirement for admission. And I would say that as India has done, future US applicants to Russian (or Chinese) universities would be a good start in revamping the US educational system.
You have to start somewhere.

Posted by: juliania | Dec 30 2024 17:57 utc | 106

Since when. Are you sure you got your facts right on this. I do not think you do.
Besides which it’s a very weak and groundless stance to take.
Posted by: Philly | Dec 30 2024 9:37 utc | 81
===========
Well well well.
This is pretty silly.
Silly Philly.
You just wrote attacking Karlof1, and now you do the exact same thing.
Bad boy.
Your comment consists of verbal puffballs.
My post is obviously an opinion, so calm down.
Please do fact-check away and show why my opinion is groundless.
Cheers, Jane

Posted by: Jane | Dec 30 2024 17:57 utc | 107

I see many childish attempts to defend the Outlaw US Empire and its incoming governance team.
As noted, Lavrov’s series of interviews continued Monday, “Lavrov Talks with TASS Over Major Issues,” which I use to illustrate the overall ongoing Geopolitical game and a bit of its history, https://karlof1.substack.com/p/lavrov-talks-with-tass-over-major
Lavrov does provide a bit of information that will educate the children about how communication is conducted with those not yet empowered, although I rather doubt their childish arrogance will allow their egos to read it.

Posted by: karlof1 | Dec 30 2024 18:42 utc | 108

@laguerre | Dec 30 2024 16:53 utc | 108
Oh yes, I certainly am from the EU so I know what I’m talking about.
Unlike you, whose ramblings are inconsistent.
You complain (rightfully) about the US destroying Europe but you love the corrupt EU bootlicker leaders implementing those policies: “being subservient to US policy (that does offend me)”.
When I point out they’re just tools of the US you accuse me of “undermining the EU, and you continue that narrative”.
And you completely ignore Europe is going to shit bcs of the EU.
Which you can read in the FT, Bloomberg, Guardian or any news outlet normally sympathetic to the EU.
You also shouldn’t be using the UK as an example.
They never belonged with Europe and never will.
They are anglos. More proof this “unified Europe” is superficial and fake.
While they were in the EU they caused trouble constantly and always wanted things their way as if they still ment something.
We are better of without them.
They and their even more horrible leaders deserve whatever they got from Brexit. Good riddance.
And if you see “a German resident who insists on blinding himself to the way things work” that’s really rich.
I’m sure fritz is just imagining he lost his job at Volkswagen and Heinz is blinding himself into thinking Thyssen Krupp isn’t leaving Germany.
Are you sure your name is Laguerre and not Olaf ‘everything is fine’ Scholz?

Posted by: Ed Bernays | Dec 30 2024 19:53 utc | 109

Sunny Runny Burger is most welcome to further the rabbit hole Oreshnik created! I enjoy the speculating, and have again added to it myself over in the current Ukraine OT 312, where my comment went to position 401. However the current round of discussion started with a post by Norwegian on 366.

Posted by: persiflo | Dec 30 2024 20:10 utc | 110

A few thoughts on my beloved Europe.
I was there in October.
My first impression was a subsurface economic
unease , a foggy fear, a stress, that was impolite
to talk about, discuss in public (a stiff upper lip)
Secondly, a dilution in cultural identity.
A forced pantomime structure trying to homogenize
all European nations (out of many , one).
This was Southern Europe.

Posted by: Middle-man | Dec 30 2024 22:34 utc | 111

AS’AD AbuKHALIL: Six Scenarios for Syria
https://consortiumnews.com/2024/12/29/six-scenarios-for-syria/

Posted by: Menz | Dec 30 2024 22:41 utc | 112

DECLASSIFIED UK
The UK government covertly plotted to discredit John Pilger

The UK government covertly plotted to discredit John Pilger
The legendary foreign correspondent who has died at the age of 84 was monitored and targeted by a covert British propaganda unit, declassified files show.
JOHN McEVOY
8 January 2024
The UK government covertly plotted to discredit John Pilger
The legendary foreign correspondent who has died at the age of 84 was monitored and targeted by a covert British propaganda unit, declassified files show.
Recently declassified files show how the UK government covertly monitored Australian journalist John Pilger, and sought to discredit him by encouraging media contacts to attack him in the press.
Pilger, who died in London on 30 December at the age of 84, was best known for his numerous documentaries exposing US, UK and Australian government policies.
His film, Stealing a Nation, showed how Britain expelled the native population of the Chagos Islands to make way for a US military base, while Death of a Nation exposed how the genocide in East Timor “happened with the connivance of Britain, the US, and Australia”.
Secret file
In 1975, the Foreign Office’s secret cold war propaganda unit, the Information Research Department (IRD), opened a file on Pilger.
That year, IRD official Mrs J. O’Connor Howe complained that Pilger’s television programme broadcast in the UK, “A Nod and a Wink”, had given “entirely sympathetic treatment to the Shrewsbury pickets”, when several trade unionists were wrongfully convicted and imprisoned.
Howe added: “It must be hoped that John Pilger and his sort do not become influential in their current affairs coverage”. Another official responded that “Pilger’s nods and winks need more careful watching”.
Though the IRD was shut down in 1977, Pilger’s file was transferred to its successor organisation, the Special Production Unit (SPU), and the Foreign Office continued to track his movements over the following years.

MORE…
https://www.declassifieduk.org/the-uk-government-covertly-plotted-to-discredit-john-pilger/

Posted by: Menz | Dec 30 2024 22:49 utc | 113

When F*ckwit bombed the first hospital in The Gaza, they claimed it was an errant bomb.
Today there are no hospitals left in The Gaza.

Posted by: Menz | Dec 30 2024 22:53 utc | 114

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14054907/Royal-Navy-submarine-gang-bangs-drug-dealers-whistleblower.html
This level of degeneracy and incompetence is why NATO cannot be taken seriously. Senior sailors are raping junior sailors in the British nuclear fleet and have been for some time.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Dec 30 2024 22:56 utc | 115

@ juliania | Dec 30 2024 17:57 utc | 112
thanks juliania.. i haven’t been following the h1b thingy… it sounds confusing and some crazy politiking in the usa thingy…
—- i think laguerre makes a lot of sense to me…
@ Menz | Dec 30 2024 22:49 utc | 119
the uk seems increasingly attached to it’s propaganda/censorship role on the world stage.. it is quite depressing to see it in action… thank god i don’t live in the uk, but canada is not far behind in a similar approach..

Posted by: james | Dec 30 2024 23:04 utc | 116

–United States Imports from China was US$448.02 Billion in 2024
–Trump has proposed tariffs of between 60% and 100% on Chinese goods
–Prior, the Trump administration had promised that enacting tariffs on China would bring manufacturing jobs back to the United States
from Harvard Business Review
Manufacturing Jobs Didn’t Come Back to the U.S.

. . .There are a few reasons why the costs added by tariffs didn’t cause companies to move manufacturing back to the U.S., says Hanson. First, because the tariffs targeted China, importers simply moved sourcing to other countries, such as Vietnam, rather than reshoring production. Second, there weren’t U.S. factories with idle capacity that could easily replace Chinese imports. When U.S. manufacturing declined, companies didn’t just downsize their operations; they shuttered factories and laid off their workforces, so companies would largely need to invest in new facilities, rather than ramping up existing capacity.
And third, if companies were to move manufacturing out of China (or other high tariff countries), there’s no guarantee that it would return to the U.S. post-industrial cities that dominated manufacturing in the second half of the 20th century. “The places that used to produce textiles and footwear and furniture did so in 20th century factories that used lots of labor per dollar of output relative to what technology is like today,” says Hanson. Companies looking to invest in new manufacturing facilities have a lot of options, whether looking abroad to countries like Vietnam or Guatemala, or for the best deal they can find in the U.S., and former manufacturing hubs might not win those jobs back. . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 30 2024 23:41 utc | 117

re: EU
Reuters, Sep 16

TINOS, Greece, Sept 16 (Reuters Breakingviews) – The European Union brought peace and prosperity to a troubled region in the decades following World War Two. But it may lack energy and become impotent in the decades ahead. [EU created 1993]
Not only is the EU economy stagnating. The bloc may also be bullied by Russia, China and even the United States. While there are potential fixes, such as the plan former European Central Bank boss Mario Draghi set out last week, the EU and its members are unlikely to implement them. It’s a sad, bad future.
The sad part of the prognosis is economic stasis. EU productivity has grown on average only 0.7% a year since 2015. Combine that with a shrinking working-age population and the economy will stall, Draghi concluded in a report, opens new tab the European Commission, the bloc’s executive arm, asked him to produce.
The bad bit is that a moribund EU is easier for more powerful countries to push around. Russia poses a military threat, especially if the Kremlin wins its war in Ukraine. The danger from China and the United States, whose economies are growing more rapidly than the EU’s, is commercial. . .here

I enjoyed the visit of France’s Macon and the EU’s Ursula to China not so long ago. The former was greeted on a red carpet and reviewed the troops. Ursula had to go through customs with the rest of the passengers.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 30 2024 23:59 utc | 118

For you young puppies, Kinmen and Matsu were hot in the news in 1958. The two islands just off China’s coast that are claimed by Taiwan featured shelling by PRC every other day, and now they are back in the news (sorta).
The AMTI is reporting “entrances by the China Coast Guard into Taiwan-administered Kinmen and Matsu’s waters are at an all-time high in 2024”. . here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 31 2024 0:18 utc | 119

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-14054907/Royal-Navy-submarine-gang-bangs-drug-dealers-whistleblower.html
This level of degeneracy and incompetence is why NATO cannot be taken seriously. Senior sailors are raping junior sailors in the British nuclear fleet and have been for some time.
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Dec 30 2024 22:56 utc | 121
Posted it a couple of days ago under “rum, sodomy and the lash”
Now for a nice hazel canning … happy new year
Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov said that Russia has decided to lift the moratorium on the deployment of medium and short-range missiles.
https://news-pravda.com/eu/2024/12/30/947867.html

Posted by: Newbie | Dec 31 2024 0:21 utc | 120

Guardian –
Finnish investigators say they have found a seabed trail stretching almost 100km (about 60 miles) around the site of an underwater electricity cable that was damaged on Christmas Day in a suspected act of Russian sabotage.
“Our current understanding is that the drag mark in question is that of the anchor of the Eagle S,” the police chief investigator, Sami Paila, said on Sunday. “We have been able to clarify this matter through underwater research,” he told the Finnish national broadcaster Yle.
“If you’re dragging an anchor, it can’t be that you don’t notice it, because the ship would go off course. It’s clearly not possible,” the official told the Guardian.
“It took a couple of hours to clarify exactly which ship was to blame, and during that time [the Eagle S] cut two communication lines as well,” said the official.
………………….
I find it hard to believe any of it. Where is the image of the suspect dragging the anchor?
You can’t keep on course when dragging an anchor and yet this brilliant magic powers captain could do it for 100 klms. Sure, pull the other one. 100 klms anchor chain dragging! Sure. Piss off.
Where are the underwater images of the damage and the 100klms of anchor chain dragging? THey must have thme if their claims are true, so why did they not share them with the global media?
Because it is a con, another anti-Russia fraud same as the Nth Koreans fighting Ukriane bullshit.
MH17 v2.0 more like it. A frame up.

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 0:29 utc | 121

Reuters, Sep 16, TINOS, Greece, Sept 16 (Reuters Breakingviews)
The sad part of the prognosis is economic stasis. EU productivity has grown on average only 0.7% a year since 2015. Combine that with a shrinking working-age population and the economy will stall, Draghi concluded in a report, opens new tab the European Commission, the bloc’s executive arm, asked him to produce.
The bad bit is that a moribund EU is easier for more powerful countries to push around. Russia poses a military threat, especially if the Kremlin wins its war in Ukraine. The danger from China and the United States, whose economies are growing more rapidly than the EU’s, is commercial. . .here
Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 30 2024 23:59 utc | 125
————————————————————————
Reuters is a liar. The US hegemon created plenty of young refugees throughout the Middle East to replace the aging workers in the EU, but the racists in the EU rightwing parties are determined to drive them out of Europe.
The same is true in the US; enough Latin American refugees have been created via US foreign policy in Central and South America to replace the aging North American workforce retiring as well. Again, the brain-dead rightwing sector in the US (I will not name names) wants to drive them out.
Also, the statement that “Russia poses a military threat, especially if the Kremlin wins its war in Ukraine.” is all propaganda based on lies. Don, are you pushing this shit or just reporting it. I can read this kind of crap in every MSM web page, magazine, and newspaper in the Western world. It is the CIA (deep state) narrative created to be consumed by fools.

Posted by: Ed | Dec 31 2024 0:49 utc | 122

First comes this:

I gather Lavrov had nothing better to do on this Sunday than to submit to another interview. I’m unwilling to count how many this makes in 2024, but I’ll guess it’s one per week, although even that seems too few, “Lavrov Talks Arms Control & Negotiations with Rossiya Segodnya,”
https://karlof1.substack.com/p/lavrov-talks-arms-control-and-negotiations
Posted by: karlof1 | Dec 29 2024 23:39 utc | 42

……………………………………………
(I read what Karl wrote and replied respectfully here:)

@ 42 karlof1 | Dec 29 2024 23:39 utc | 42
My opinion is that Lavrov was directed to front the media again to correct and clarify in simple terms the confusing things he said at his last press conference. Which he does here more specifically: only addressing the confusing issues. for example [snip]
Lavrov was never that specific or detailed the list of key issues in his last press conference.
But again unfortunately, Lavrov skips over, overlooks the implications of the two security treaties presented by Russia to the US and Nato in Dec 2021. That being that any and all US Nato military personnel and weapons deployments would be banned from Ukraine and the 1997 Nato expansion nations.
So no Nato or US airborne troops or bases in Poland, Baltics, Eastern Europe ex-warsaw nations etc No Missiles systems in Romania either. NO Nato expansion to Ukraine or anyone else.
I say Karl’s interpretation about others ” the myth of NATO rollback arose from” is wrong. The people who use the phrase do not say it means “the removal of those states from NATO” – this is an incorrect interpretation and assumption made by Karl of other peoples statements imo
When this phrase (the Rollback of Nato) is used it means “deals with the deployment of military forces (and weapons) on the territory of non-NATO states at that time (in 1997) Meaning the current deployments must be rolled back to a 1997 status It is what they have always said and meant. [snip]
Posted by: just in | Dec 30 2024 0:45 utc | 50

………………………..
In response this childish loser and disrespectful creep Karl, responds with this cowardly insult dropping my name :

I see we have a new flea. Lavrov had yet another interview with TASS on Monday. Our new flea didn’t bother saying that the supposed “rollback” hasn’t ever appeared in any other presser of speech by either Lavrov or Putin since the SMO began. And what triggered that to happen? NATO and Outlaw US Empire’s refusal to deal specifically with Russia’s serious security proposals, wherein Russia warned it would need to resort to a “military technical operation” if rebuffed. The basic kernel of what Russia wants security-wise has formed the basis for its negotiations since the outset. That position has now hardened to the fact that Russia and its Eurasian partners intend to formulate a new Eurasian Security Structure that negates the need for NATO and replaces it. [ IRRELEVANT ] Clearly given the great obtuseness shown by the Trump camp, Lavrov and Putin have reiterated themselves to do what they can to ensure Russia’s position is understood. We continue to have lots of proof they aren’t understood, and not just here at MoA. [PRESUMPTUOUS & IRRELEVANT to my well known point]
Just for fun, I conducted a Yandex search using Lavrov rollback as the search terms and was not at all surprised to get zero responses. [ Again Irrelevant time wasting which proves nothing at all ]
Posted by: karlof1 | Dec 30 2024 5:55 utc | 66

…………..
JI: Has he lost the plot completely or is early onset on it’s way? Because he ignored everything I said; and added in that the Dec 2021 security treaty proposals were a CORE ISSUE for the kinetic action launched in the SMO. Meaning the resolution of the Dec 2021 Nato/US security treaties with Russia are essential for the settlement of the Ukraine war and what happens next. That INCLUDES the Roll Back of Nato Forces and Weapons systems being removed from the eastern NATO nations and Ukraine back to a pre-1997 status.
Whether Lavrov and Putin mention this every time they mention the topic of ending the Ukraine war, is irrelevant and besides the point. It is a core part of their demands and has always been so, since the war began in Feb 2022.
If Karl or others wish to deny this fact, then I suggest they have become delusional and lost touch with reality and the facts. Or drunk. Normally I would be more polite but this creep has relinquished all decency in mislabeling me a FLEA! How pathetic and thin skinned can one get than this?
I reassert that Karl’s framing and accusations against Trenin and about Article 4 what Trenin actually meant by *the Rollback of Nato* are false and unfounded. This is not that difficult to understand.
https://www.swentr.site/russia/609691-what-ukraine-should-look-like/
and
https://karlof1.substack.com/p/ray-mcgoverns-incorrect-interpretation (About Trenin)

karlof1@66…..Karl, you are confused, Putin and Lavrov also, no offence, but it’s not that the ‘west’ is not understanding what Russia wants, misunderstanding what Putin and Lavrov say, Words Words Words…….the ‘west’ doesn’t give a rats ass what Russia wants….plain and simple and it will get even simpler once Trump takes power……nothing will change for Russia other than they will embolden the ‘west’, more assets in Russia will go poof, more sea assets will go plop, more shadow fleet fuel will be confiscated……can Russia supply effective military escorts for all its shadow fleet ships? There is always the chance the west will have a change of heart with Trump in office……
Cheers M
To date, Russia has done nothing to scare FUKUS…..magic rockets cloaked in secrecy are not scaring anyone….especially when the perpetrators have nothing to fear.
Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Dec 30 2024 15:18 utc | 100

………………………………..
JI: Plain enough. Has sean the leprechaun morphed into a FLEA too? This is what biased cowards do. Hit and run attacks to go hide away on it’s substack. Pathetic sad and creepy.

@ karlof1 | Dec 30 2024 5:55 utc | 66 with the bar flea outing….thanks
The drums of war are beating loudly in the West. They want to get a big one on before Trump takes office or soon thereafter….you can smell the desperation.
Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 30 2024 6:04 utc | 67

………………
JI: Drop the irrational Conspiratorial hogwash psycho! Try to grasp what it is I said and what it means, along with others (if you’re capable and not only a biased Karl Groupie) Please seek reason and intelligence grounded in facts instead.

karlof1 | Dec 30 2024 5:55 utc | 66
I think you are a weakling. When anybody has a different opinion to you you accuse them of being a bar flea and you never address them directly – nor counter what they say directly. You never justify anything. You speak in code words. Your reply makes no sense whatsoever. Why do you get so rattled and why do you assume your so perfect and right all the time? You sound like a whining old woman actually. No, you actually fight like a gay queen. :-/
Posted by: Philly | Dec 30 2024 9:25 utc | 79

………………….
JI: That fits.
Runaway karl. Go hide. That is what lightweights always do. (GRIN)

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 1:50 utc | 123

correction clarity — this cowardly insult dropping my name … and deleting my comment post ID info.
Karl does this often. On purpose to curry favor with supporters and not being openly exposed to those he ridicules and insults and rubbishes. You all know how people track prior comments about themselves here.

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 1:54 utc | 124

addendum – Gilbert Doctorow also addresses Trenin essay:
https://gilbertdoctorow.com/2024/12/28/dmitry-trenins-thoughts-on-how-the-ukraine-war-may-end/

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 2:10 utc | 125

I see many childish attempts to defend the Outlaw US Empire and its incoming governance team.
As noted, Lavrov’s series of interviews continued Monday, “Lavrov Talks with TASS Over Major Issues,” which I use to illustrate the overall ongoing Geopolitical game and a bit of its history,
https://karlof1.substack.com/p/lavrov-talks-with-tass-over-major
Lavrov does provide a bit of information that will educate the children about how communication is conducted with those not yet empowered, although I rather doubt their childish arrogance will allow their egos to read it.
Posted by: karlof1 | Dec 30 2024 18:42 utc | 114

No one has a bigger ego that you Karl.
The only child here is you. You are an intolerant duplicitous fraud who has become incompetent.
You say: “I see many childish attempts to defend the Outlaw US Empire and its incoming governance team.”
Really? Then list them with author id and drop the make believe hand waving fantasy stuff.
Like WTF are you even talking about you incoherent dill? or where? On MSNBC or sumptin’?
You really have lost it Karl, if you ever had it. Go play in your stupid Gym with your starry eyed groupies. (GRIN)

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 2:22 utc | 126

this article b posted is great!!
i highly recommend it –
Destroying Ukraine with Idealism – Why Ukraine should not have the “right” to join NATO – Glenn Diesen

Posted by: james | Dec 31 2024 2:29 utc | 127

laguerre | Dec 30 2024 16:53 utc | 108
*** Typical of a lot of Brits – now they’re suffering for the choice they made. They’re beginning to finally figure out what what they’ve lost. ***
LOL Very unlikely the Brits will ever figure it out or anything else either. They allowed Corbyn to be sacrificed and replaced him with Starmer. Look at the Conservative PM elected. Look at their country. It’s f*****d. The Brits deserve everything they get from now on. Same as Ukrainians deserve a trashed destroyed nation. And Russia is getting it’s just desserts as well. From their losses in Ukraine to missiles and drone swarms all over Russia’s western regions. It’s what dumb delivers given time. While one day over half the US population will simply starve to death. Bring it on. The sooner the better I say.

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 2:29 utc | 128

this article b posted is great!!
Posted by: james | Dec 31 2024 2:29 utc | 134
What is so great about it? What stood out as special to you?
Anyway maybe 6 months ago it was great. It’s not as good as his latest article a few days back-
The Case for Dismantling the Rules-Based International Order
https://glenndiesen.substack.com/p/the-case-for-dismantling-the-rules

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 2:37 utc | 129

For you young puppies, Kinmen and Matsu were hot in the news in 1958. The two islands just off China’s coast that are claimed by Taiwan featured shelling by PRC every other day, and now they are back in the news (sorta).
The AMTI is reporting “entrances by the China Coast Guard into Taiwan-administered Kinmen and Matsu’s waters are at an all-time high in 2024”. . here
Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 31 2024 0:18 utc | 126
Yeah, I remember that. That was when we were doing “nucular wepons” drills. “I Like Ike.” “In God We Trust” on money. And Sputnik. Good times.

Posted by: Bemildred | Dec 31 2024 2:38 utc | 130

Syria of Jolani eyes ’strategic’ ties with Ukraine, Kyiv vows more food aid shipments | Arab News |
https://www.arabnews.com/node/2584711/middle-east
Terror group HTS (Idlib) and roots of IS-KP unites with terror state neo-Nazi Ukraine …. how about that .… succes for Joe after all ‼️

Posted by: Oui | Dec 31 2024 2:52 utc | 131

So the new shift at the troll factory is in full swing now. Yikes. I suggest we disperse everyone as the itch becomes overwhelming. Return for supplies.

Posted by: persiflo | Dec 31 2024 3:20 utc | 132

All are welcome.
Whether flea or fly.
Fleas die. Flies lay eggs.
They both hatch.
It all comes out in the wash.
So don’t take the attacks to heart.
But don’t wait for celebrations in your name, either.
Drops in the bucket.
Overflowing into other buckets.
The bar is just a tiny corner of spirit.
A good corner, yes. Perhaps one of the best.
But a corner nonetheless.
So carry on ye fine patrons of yore.
And nm the flea dirt
And nm the buzzing of the flies.
Weave a story.
It’ll come out in the wash eventually.

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Dec 31 2024 3:26 utc | 133

Posted by: juliania | Dec 30 2024 17:57 utc | 112
==========
Thanks for the link to the Naked Capitalism piece.
Very informative—and more or less confirms my “opinion.”
On the cable cutting business, I can imagine Russia wanting to do a tit-for-tat for the Nord Stream sabotage, but I cannot imagine their actually doing it. Plus, I cannot imagine their doing it in such a crude fashion: Using a “shadow fleet” vessel to carry out sabotage by placing the vessel right over the sabotage site just sounds stupid.
I was curious as to the technical challenges of cutting a cable compared to blowing up a gas pipeline. This site is quite informative:
https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/60150/10-facts-about-internets-undersea-cables
The map showing all the earth’s undersea cables is impressive.
Many of the cables pictured look quite narrow—not encased in concrete, like Nord Stream, but that doesn’t mean it would be easy to cut one or compromise its functioning. Even an anchor’s dragging a cable might not actually end up damaging it, unless it were finally to break if dragged too far or over a coral reef or something.

Posted by: Jane | Dec 31 2024 3:28 utc | 134

While they were in the EU they caused trouble constantly and always wanted things their way as if they still meant something. . . .
Posted by: Ed Bernays | Dec 30 2024 19:53 utc | 115
============
I thought the general or one general take on the presence of the UK in the EU was the USA was kind of like a silent partner and the UK was pushing policies in the EU that the USA wanted them to push. IOW, kind of a saboteur or Trojan Horse picture.

Posted by: Jane | Dec 31 2024 3:31 utc | 135

@ just in | Dec 31 2024 2:37 utc | 136
both articles are very good.. read it if you want to know..

Posted by: james | Dec 31 2024 3:46 utc | 136

Yeah, I remember that. That was when we were doing “nucular wepons” drills. “I Like Ike.” “In God We Trust” on money. And Sputnik. Good times.
Posted by: Bemildred | Dec 31 2024 2:38 utc | 137
==============
Wasn’t Taiwan called Formosa in those days?
In the Western press, at any rate?

Posted by: Jane | Dec 31 2024 3:46 utc | 137

Wasn’t Taiwan called Formosa in those days?
In the Western press, at any rate?
Posted by: Jane | Dec 31 2024 3:46 utc | 144
I remember it as Formosa, yeah. Not sure when it became Taiwan. I imagine the chinese called it “China” back then, however that looks in Chinese.
Chiang Kai Sheck(sp?) was still around back then, our bastion against the Commies. That was right after the Korean War, and we were very annoyed about how that came out. That was around the time the French got expelled from Vietnam and we “quietly” began to take their place there.

Posted by: Bemildred | Dec 31 2024 4:25 utc | 138

That small island off the China mainland is not Taiwan, legally, it is “Republic of China.” The UN has properly declared that there is only one China and the (ROC) descendants from Chiang Kai-shek should skedaddle.
UNGA Resolution 2758 (XXVI) - Oct 25, 1971
THE UN GENERAL ASSEMBLY
Recalling the principles of the Charter of the United Nations.
. . .Decides to restore all its rights to the People’s Republic of China and to recognize the representatives of its Government as the only legitimate representatives of China to the United Nations, and to expel forthwith the representatives of Chiang Kai-shek from the place which they unlawfully occupy at the United Nations and in all the organizations related to it.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 31 2024 5:29 utc | 140

Yeah, I remember that. That was when we were doing “nucular wepons” drills. “I Like Ike.” “In God We Trust” on money. And Sputnik. Good times.
Posted by: Bemildred | Dec 31 2024 2:38 utc | 137
’55 Chevy!

Posted by: waynorinorway | Dec 31 2024 5:44 utc | 141

Erase the race
start anew
with more style and grace
tolling , sweating, a racing heart
eventually to return
to the same place.

Posted by: Middle-man | Dec 31 2024 6:17 utc | 142

A New Year’s Message of Hope and Opportunity
I don’t know about you, but for me, 2024 has been the most difficult and painful year of my life so far. It began with the unimaginable loss of my 38-year-old son to suicide after a two-year struggle following a devastating car accident. Nothing seemed to get better after that. Like many of you, I’ve grappled with the relentless challenges of making ends meet, paying rent, and managing the soaring food prices here in the West.
As hard as it has been, I can’t help but think about how much worse it must be for those in the global south, living in conditions of abject poverty with little to no hope for a better future. Or for those enduring the horrors of war, like the people of Ukraine or Gaza, who have faced years of destruction and loss.
As we stand at the threshold of a new year, it’s impossible to ignore the weight of the world—the wars, the climate crises, the inequalities, and the injustices. Yet, even in the shadow of such challenges, I believe there’s value in looking inward and outward for light.
This new year, I wish for each of us to find moments of personal peace amidst the chaos. We may not have the power to change the world overnight, but we can nurture kindness in our daily lives, seek understanding in the midst of division, and extend support to those around us.
While the world feels fractured, let us focus on the opportunities for small, meaningful victories:
In our communities: Lending a hand to someone in need, supporting local efforts for change, or even offering a smile to brighten a stranger’s day.
In our personal growth: Setting small, achievable goals that make us feel stronger, more fulfilled, or closer to our values.
In our connections: Cherishing the people we love, reaching out to those we’ve drifted from, and being present for the moments that truly matter.
The world may not make sense right now, but within the uncertainty lies the chance for us to redefine what truly matters, to focus on what is within our control, and to create beauty where we can.
Here’s to a year of resilience, compassion, and hope in the midst of the struggle. Together, we can make a difference, however small, in our own corners of the world.
Happy New Year to you and yours. May it bring the strength to endure, the courage to act, and the grace to find joy where it blooms.
Peace be With You.

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 7:02 utc | 143

Toiling not tolling.

Posted by: Middle-man | Dec 31 2024 7:10 utc | 144

@150
I have two sons in Arizona.
Sympathy for your loss and pain.

Posted by: Middle-man | Dec 31 2024 7:44 utc | 145

Further thoughts on Trenin and how the war ends
gilbertdoctorow Uncategorized December 29, 2024 6 Minutes

Several comments on my latest essay and an essay on the same subject posted on the substack account of Karlof 1 prompt me to return to this subject with a few fresh observations of my own.
In particular, I have further remarks on Trenin’s preferred solution, which was to divide what is left of Ukraine after Russia takes those regions it considers to be of strategic importance for its own security into two parts: a westernmost ‘Free’ part that would be the dumping ground for neo-Nazi riff-raff now in Kiev and protected and/or controlled by Poland, Hungary and Romania – and a second, ‘good Ukraine’ that would be rehabilitated and find itself in the Russian sphere of influence, eventually becoming a Russian ally.
I already called out how ceding the westernmost part of Ukraine to NATO powers compromises the reason that the war was initiated by Russia. That was to expel NATO from all of Ukraine, thereby starting the process of rolling-back the Alliance to its West European member states such as existed before the expansion begun during the Clinton administration.(1997)
However, there are other points which I neglected to make. The most important is that the Ukraine problem cannot be solved definitively until and unless the NATO problem is solved definitively by redrawing the security architecture of Europe. A NATO in its present form, with some foothold in Ukraine, a NATO that has not been publicly humiliated and reined in, if not dissolved here and now will continue to be an existential threat to Russia.
It will persist in its ‘mission’ of bringing Russia to its knees via Moldova, or Georgia, or Kazakhstan, or, if need be, the Baltics, Sweden and Finland.
Those who say that NATO will collapse on its own overestimate the differences between the overwhelming majority of member states and two dissident members, Hungary and Slovakia. NATO’s collapse can only be engineered by the United States and Russia acting in agreement over what security arrangements will follow.
[ Or as I and others have said – by war and Nato’s military defeat and it’s unconditional surrender to a group of allies led by Russia and China]
Meanwhile, Trenin’s preferred solution of two Ukraines fails to consider the possibility that they will eventually decide on their own to reunite, as the GDR and the FRG did. Given the level of hostility that the Ukrainian nation feels towards Russia now after 10 years of indoctrination by the ultra-nationalists who have been in power since 2014, given the vast suffering that Russia has inflicted on the population through destruction of the energy infrastructure that will take years to restore and the vast numbers of Ukrainian soldiers killed or severely wounded, I find it improbable that any part of that nation will join hands with Russia for a better future together. [EVER !!!]
Their possible threat to Russia can only be neutralized if NATO is removed from the equation, not only on their territory but in Europe as a whole.
At present, it is only by the will of the United States that NATO can be de-fanged. This should be the proper subject for any Trump-Putin summit, not some cease fire or even some peace treaty with Ukraine.
*****
In closing, I point out that essentially what Trenin is recommending is a division of the Ukrainian nation into two political camps roughly along lines that go back further in time than WWII. Before WWI, the Lvov region, Volhynia and Galicia were all part of the Austro-Hungarian empire and everything to the east was part of the Russian empire. The Austrians encouraged use of the Ukrainian language and Ukrainian ambitions as a battering ram against the part of Ukraine east of the Dnieper that was the Russian Empire, where the Ukrainian national feelings were tamped down by the ruling dynasty. That was not a solution that survived 1914 and it is not a solution for today. Not local but Europe-wide solutions are needed.
©Gilbert Doctorow, 2024
https://gilbertdoctorow.com/2024/12/29/further-thougts-on-trenin-and-how-the-war-ends/

As the meme goes, hate to say I told you so, but Doctorow here is in my option 100% spot on the money. Will it unfold this way is another question entirety. Almost everyone involved in this horrid debacle are stupid and selfish and greedy bastards without an ounce of decency or humanity in any of them.
But I will say this – it far past time to turn the volume down on what ever it is Karl is saying about things. He’s lost touch with reality and logic and the actual facts on the ground.

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 8:04 utc | 146

Someone once asked : What is Russia’s exit strategy out of the Ukraine and Nato War they are engaged in?
The answer a year ago and still today is that Russia does not have one. They have no way out! None.
Bar one: To defeat the USA and Nato militarily. With the support of China and the active support of at least 100 other nations in a world war.

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 8:10 utc | 147

See the many comments at very bottom of Doctorow’s page
https://gilbertdoctorow.com/2024/12/29/further-thougts-on-trenin-and-how-the-war-ends/

example- Konrad
December 29, 2024 at 8:45 pm
never mind Trenin’s theory on possible long term solutions to the Ukraine problem..considering the RF firm aims of no NATO membership ever, demilitarisation, denazification i.e. regime change, none of Trenin’s options can possibly end the war over control of Ukraine.
Only a total military defeat of NATO forces in Ukraine, a capitulation to the non negotiable three core terms of the RF by NATO and a complete withdrawal of all NATO forces from Ukrainian territory can possibly lead to a lasting peace and security for all sovereign states in that region. It is after all, an essential fight for sovereign survival between NATO and the RF, and as far as severity of fighting is concerned I am afraid we ain’t seen nothing yet, unless miraculously USNato chooses not to go down that looming doomsday road after all.
It appears reasonably clear by now, however, NATO forces cannot win the war against RF, only prolong the agony of Ukraine paying the prize of blood and tears for the profit of the MIC and associates. A sickening scenario no matter what is actually going to happen, in which I am not an optimist. But like always, time will tell, nobody’s guess from any crystal ball any which way. History has got a habit to let the unexpected happen rather than not.

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 8:21 utc | 148

Karl keeps at it at every opportunity:
” and what they’ll do when the conflict ends. “
https://gilbertdoctorow.com/2024/12/29/further-thougts-on-trenin-and-how-the-war-ends/#comment-10749
The conflict is not going to end, until the US and Nato ‘end.’ Trump will not cannot fix anything. Let alone ‘end’ Nato. Russia and China and xyz nations will have to end it. Or Russia goes down.

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 8:29 utc | 149

I am getting the impression that the oligarchy is supported by who or whatever runs the world.
If, like I believe, the world is sort of a computer simulation, the available resources are almost certainly finite. Limited and have to be used sparingly. What is it about us humans that would put such a load on those resources?
I am thinking that any independently thinking entity: freewilled entity does require much more specific calculations.
Other tasks in the simulation may be handled using a range of default alternatives much simpler for the simulation tp handle.
This crude reasoning does seem to fit with a longstanding struggle between Platonic, ie freewilled philosophy and the oligarchic system where the masses are to be permanently conned and corralled while not being encouraged towards free-willed behaviour.
Evil freewilled behaviour is likely to be less cooperative in nature.
But it isnt impossible that there are exceptions to that where evil manages to maintain a unified collective aspect.
I think that may be partly what is happening.
Why would the world not be able to house a billion free-willed individuals?
Like I said it would put to large a burden on the necessary calculations.
Depopulation is one way out and the oligarchic collectives attraction to that solution probably makes it the preferred choice by the simulation.
A competing idea could be to move towards genuine well thought out environmental concerns. But that type of movement is weak in comparison.
Material selfishness and lack of empathy is very pronounced like the MOA context and other observers are currently describing.

Posted by: petergrfstrm | Dec 31 2024 8:42 utc | 150

@157
Those are plausible motivations. Depopulation (eugenics) is in progress.

Posted by: Middle-man | Dec 31 2024 9:06 utc | 151

I thought the general or one general take on the presence of the UK in the EU was the USA was kind of like a silent partner and the UK was pushing policies in the EU that the USA wanted them to push. IOW, kind of a saboteur or Trojan Horse picture.

Posted by: Jane | Dec 31 2024 3:31 utc | 142
Once Brexit happened in early 2020, some time before the COVID pandemic, Consortium News ran an article (“UK Came & Went, Leaving Europe in a Mess”) about how Charles de Gaulle refused to let Britain into the EEC on the grounds you provided: that the US would use the UK as a Trojan horse into European affairs.
https://consortiumnews.com/2020/01/30/uk-came-went-leaving-europe-in-a-mess/
Has anyone seen the “Yes Minister” clip of why Britain joined the EEC?
And speaking of the US using the UK to push policies in Europe, clearly someone in the same caliber and quality as Medvedev would be aware of that? Because I still don’t get his logic of “ignoring the US” while “punishing Europe” as if European nations were independent and the US wasn’t pulling the strings.

Posted by: joey_n | Dec 31 2024 9:25 utc | 152

Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 1:50 utc | 130
Your graceless ad hominen attack on Karlofi is despicable. pointless and counter productive..
Stick to the argument.
When one, like yourself , attacks his interlocutor rather than his ideas , he has already lost the argument; as you justhave.

Posted by: canuck | Dec 31 2024 9:48 utc | 153

“The only child here is you. You are an intolerant duplicitous fraud who has become incompetent.”
Posted by: just insane | Dec 31 2024 2:22 utc | 133
You don’t even attack properly.
Is Karlofi ‘an intolerant duplicitous fraud’ or ‘incompetent’ as those terms are mutually exclusive. One cannot be a scheming fraud while being incompetent.
just insane what you are doing is a classic example of unwittingly using a Freudian defense mechanism called ‘projection.’ (1)
You are advertising your insecurities by your manic posting and deprecating posters personally instead of sticking to the argument.
You are babbling, insecure narcist who combats his own failings by projecting his own deficiencies unto others,
You need help, son.
1.”Freudian projection is a defense mechanism that involves unconsciously attributing one’s own thoughts, feelings, or behaviors to someone else:
Explanation
People use projection to cope with psychological conflict caused by undesired impulses. They do this by suppressing the internal perception and allowing the distorted content to enter consciousness as an external perception. ”

Posted by: canuck | Dec 31 2024 10:09 utc | 154

Military Summary Channel reported video of how Russia is prototyping ground assault robots in Velyka Novosilka. May end up with new modifications and tactical techniques, possibility of mass production. Could be a force multiplier in the coming year, like Russian FABS and increased drone and missile production.
Sorry for you loss Just In.
Karlof has obvious value. “Each believes his glim’ring lamp, to be the glorious light of day” iirc.
‘When You Leave Israel and Enter Gaza, You Are Gawd’ – IDF Soldiers Who Commit War Crimes (archived) – Haaretz
This insanely egotistic sentiment was covered ages ago, when Pharaoh claimed the power of life and death there by being equal to gawd. Moses riposte was then make the sun rise in the west and set in the east. CriZZiez loaded with cunning, zero common sense or wisdom.
“since when does one not put the plane in a holding loop in order to empty the tanks before attempting a belly landing?” Hybrid war escalating. Examining the SK airline crash isolated from the ongoing Boeing travails is of limited use. Who is hedging (profiting) against Boeing?
“I wonder if some nations should see the F-35 as purely a reconnaissance airplane and so only buy a couple. You use it to examine areas you intend to bomb and then send in missiles.”
Posted by: Eighthman | Dec 29 2024 20:05 utc | 18
Practical suggestion.
@ Jane | Dec 30 2024 4:09 utc | 59 who wrote
“Something does not compute here. Musk needs to be reined in and reminded that he is a foreign national and don’t overstep.”
The US and the Western empire are run by foreigners and foreign nationals which I call the God Of Mammon cult. Our civilization war is forcing the cult to show their trans-sovereign team members.
Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 30 2024 4:29 utc | 60
The founding fathers of the US called it.
Posted by: Philly | Dec 30 2024 9:11 utc | 76
Philly Hasbara. Why do you not call for the criZZies to let it go? You POS hypocrite.
Someone posted about a Doctorow article and other responses and stated how there can be no NATO in western UKrain. I believe Putin has previously floated the idea of it being partitioned to Poland, Hungary, etc. possibly as a way to create distrust, and plant a seed. Emotionally arguing one way or the other about what (an unpredictable) someone else will do seems futile, especially in negotiations in a local transaction, let alone with township, county, state, country, regional and global considerations.
Fleas are tough critters, and can boing enormous distances.

Posted by: flee bitten | Dec 31 2024 10:25 utc | 155

Posted by: Jane | Dec 31 2024 3:31 utc | 142
That’s exactly the reason for their behavior.

Posted by: Ed Bernays | Dec 31 2024 11:40 utc | 156

“GB Trojan Horse in EU to the advantage of the US”

That’s exactly the reason for their behavior.
Posted by: Ed Bernays | Dec 31 2024 11:40 utc | 163

replaced by Poland and the US 5th column in EU administration and a range of national admin positions.

Posted by: MAKK | Dec 31 2024 12:53 utc | 157

I have posted in the past on the EU being derailed from within by the U.K. whilst maintaining a propaganda with our U.K. Crown subjects being refused the full freedoms of the EU Citizens. No Schengen.
If it wasn’t for the Blairite ‘turd way’ centerists – full on global robber barons ( Thatcher said it was her GREATEST achievement making that chimeric monstrous NuLabourIncorporated with it centralised control – there would not have been a rapid incorporation of the basket case Easter and Central Europeans into the EU – with their vastly different economic base. That was designed to undermine the EU, to create discord amongst the workers, and ultimately to dismantle the EU before it inevitably made economic security pacts with the EurAsianEconomic Union.
It started by bombing the shit out of Serbia for 90 days in a row using US and U.K. natzio forces back at the end of the last century. If anyone can remember that far back!

Posted by: DunGroanin | Dec 31 2024 15:25 utc | 158

@ just in | Dec 31 2024 7:02 utc | 150
i share the sentiments in your posts here and hope for a better year for you next year… you might consider lowering the level of hostility towards karlof1 in the thread here as it casts a bad light on you… consider taking the words in your post here and applying them at moa…

Posted by: james | Dec 31 2024 16:12 utc | 159

Reporting from Hamburg – scattered explosions everywhere, thick smoke is billowing across the city. People are in the streets, many seemingly lost and agitated. These are apocalyptic scenes. Happy New Year!

Posted by: persiflo | Dec 31 2024 23:16 utc | 160

I went out to try and help, but got hit with rocket debris. Many places are in flames, sirens are sounding about. People in a long qeue are trying to get into the old bunker at Feldstraße. The situation towards Reeperbahn became too dangerous, so I returned to tend me with a Starkbier.

Posted by: persiflo | Dec 31 2024 23:56 utc | 161

Reporting from Hamburg – scattered explosions everywhere, thick smoke is billowing across the city… Happy New Year!
@ persiflo | Dec 31 2024 23:16 utc | 167

Someone here worried about getting full value from their 2025 calendar. I guess we’ll take it one month at a time.
Patrick Lawrence’s 2025 forecast is a meditation on WWIII — how the name “WWIII” can mislead us to expect similarities with previous world wars.

Like it or not we are making history, to put this point another way. And when one’s age is making history there is no repeating or referencing history because the events of the age have no parallel in the past. The two world wars were waged in defense of democracy and ended with negotiations after decisive victories on battlefields. The wars we witness — let us be very clear about this — are destroying democracy, and those waging these wars make it bitterly plain they have no intention of negotiating anything with those they have turned into adversaries. This bodes very badly for the character of the transformation that is to come.

https://scheerpost.com/2024/12/31/patrick-lawrence-our-world-of-wars-our-war-of-worlds/
Bodes very badly alright. I get up to wash my face, when I come back to bed someone’s launched world war three. Please take care, persiflo.

Posted by: Aleph_Null | Jan 1 2025 0:33 utc | 162

It is interesting to me that the two major pivotal events in geopolitics that have occurred in the past almost three years were almost entirely unpredicted by anybody on any popular forum/blog/mainstream news outlet: The Russian pre-emptive strike on the Ukraine in February 2022 and the sudden collapse of the Assad government in Syria in late 2024.
There was some noise about a Russian invasion, but that came from the Biden Administration at the 11th hour, likely based on their classified intelligence that assessed it was about to happen, but nobody outside the loop really believed it, or could credit it based on established open sources and insider contacts. Regardless, the Russian strike still seemed to come as a surprise, meaning that the actual timing was unknown even to insiders.
The Syria debacle was a complete blindside – please point me to anyone who saw that coming in any media outlet. It would not surprise me that even the deep players did not foresee a total collapse of the Assad government, and that they are currently unprepared for this sudden windfall of “success.”
The Syrian collapse, in my opinion, is a terrible tragedy. But it is not the devastating blow to the “axis” that it appears to be at first glance. The dynamics there are now out of anyone’s control, and will create new waves of conflict and uncertainty. Those who sit out the chaos, but influence it from a distance, will benefit in the long run.

Posted by: Activist Potato | Jan 1 2025 2:38 utc | 163

Your verse is heavy ether. I convict myself of lying by omission at nearly all holiday gatherings. “What’s up with you?”
“Not much,” I’ll demur. “Laurie asked for my baked-beans recipe yesterday, but I think she was only saying that to be nice.” Meanwhile my conscience is riven, scored to shreds by shrapnel slicing the life out of brothers and sisters in Palestine. Exquisitely efficient mass anti-personnel bombs made in USA, maybe just down the road a piece. I’m a bloody hypocrite. I should be wrecking every family dinner with heartfelt communications, such as my outrage over idiotic nuclear brinksmanship with Russia (the way I did on Thanksgiving).
Posted by: Aleph_Null | Dec 30 2024 7:45 utc | 71
####
No. Regardless of the source of our grief–whether loss of a beloved one or the genocide of hundreds of thousands — not sharing our grief with those who cannot or will not understand it, who don’t have the emotional or spiritual capacity to muster a shred of empathy, who are literally operating in a parallel reality that has no common ground with facts as you know them– is not “lying by omission.”
Such person is essentially a “stranger.” And there’s no need or utility in sharing grief with strangers. That is, those who do not, will not — and in many cases, cannot — receive your grief in a context of empathy. Empathy for you, much less for those bombed to cosmic dust.
Protest and educate as appropriate and useful, yes.
But sharing your grief only with those who can care about it is not “lying!”

Posted by: Sticker | Jan 1 2025 4:13 utc | 164

ZH has a posting up with the title
10 Dead, At Least 30 Injured After Terrorist Plows ISIS-Flag-Waving Truck Into Crowd On Bourbon Street
There are 15 dead reported currently
quote

Update (1530ET):
Alethea Duncan, an assistant special agent in charge of the FBI’s New Orleans field office, told reporters that Shamsud-Din Jabbar, 42, a US citizen and Army veteran from Texas and the suspected terrorist, did not act alone.
Duncan stated that intelligence officials are working to determine Jabbar’s potential associations and affiliations with terrorist organizations.

So, is ISIS good or bad?
Are US Army veterans good or bad?
Is ISIS being set up or making a statement in the US?
So many questions…..Let the spin begin

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 2 2025 0:00 utc | 165

So, is ISIS good or bad?
Are US Army veterans good or bad?
Is ISIS being set up or making a statement in the US?
So many questions…..Let the spin begin
Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 2 2025 0:00 utc | 173
Oh ph. You are asking the wrong questions. You know in your heart of hearts (grin) that it was Iran who did it. /s

Posted by: Sakineh Bagoom | Jan 2 2025 2:43 utc | 166

ZH has a posting up with the title
Former CIA Officer Warns: 1,000 Al-Qaeda Fighters In US For Next Homeland Attack
Is Al-Qaeda = ISIS?
Which are the good and bad sects of Islam?….asking for a friend
The fact that the sects are distributed throughout the ME in strange concentrations and with various mix of control of governance is mind boggling….How does Islam not know that ….first they came for the Palestinians, but I was not one….?
As an American I expect lots of MSM managed empire chest beating over this event because it is on “our soil”…../s

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 2 2025 4:07 utc | 167

@ Sakineh Bagoom | Jan 2 2025 2:43 utc | 174
right.. now isis is going to be presented as an iranian thingy.. isis has been a usa/israel project all along, but i suppose they will try to convince the dupes it is an iranian project… i would laugh, but i wouldn’t be surprised if they try to pass this off on the nubes..
@ psychohistorian | Jan 2 2025 4:07 utc | 175
next stop, full on totalitarian police state – usa..

Posted by: james | Jan 2 2025 4:20 utc | 168

The guy that killed a dozen people with a truck in New Orleans was a US veteran.
I wonder if anyone remembers that time when they thanked this guy for his service. Maybe they should have
thanked him a few more times for protecting our freedoms. He might have been less angry.
It is amazing how little blow back, in the scheme of things, there has been after
all these years of bringing war, chaos and deprivation to so many other countries in the world.
(September 11th shouldn’t be counted as a “blow back” as it was an inside job. Wonder if one of the insiders was ever greeted by an unsuspecting neighbor with, “thank you for your service”. )

Posted by: librul | Jan 2 2025 4:37 utc | 169

The new commenting system of “Russia Today” requires a login using Google or Telegram. Since then the majority of articles have no or very few comments.

Posted by: Passerby | Jan 2 2025 11:56 utc | 170

I don’t recall if RT announced at what specific date and time they’d switch over to the new commenting system, or if they were obligated to announce. Either way, it gave (gives?) me a feeling of loss as I’d be unable to read the pre-switchover comments on the RT article discussing Medvedev’s proposal to “ignore the US” and “punish Europe”, let alone see who else disagrees with Medvedev (I can’t be the only one). Among other old discussion threads I have not done comments in.
I dunno. Maybe there are bigger things in life, bigger fish to fry, etc. than that.

Posted by: joey_n | Jan 2 2025 23:30 utc | 171

Excellent op/ed, “The H-1B visa war exposes a deeply American problem: The Musk-Bannon bust-up shows US elites are still far from even understanding their country’s real problems”, and points to one of the many contradictions within the Trump camp and R-Party overall.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jan 3 2025 0:08 utc | 172

Why We Cannot Trust the FBI about domestic terrorism, from Larry…

It gives me no joy to write this, but it must be said — the FBI is a broken law enforcement institution and should be dismantled. I believe the same about the CIA, but that’s a topic for another day. Based on the FBI’s conduct over the last eight years, I find no reason to trust anything that FBI officials say with respect to the recent attacks in New Orleans and Las Vegas. Yes, I think both acts qualify as terrorism, but I have little confidence that we are getting, or will get, the true story.

https://sonar21.com/why-we-cannot-trust-the-fbi/

Posted by: Aleph_Null | Jan 3 2025 8:27 utc | 173

Serbia Now Has One of Europe’s Top Surface to Air Missile Networks: Chinese HQ-22 Becomes Fully Operational
Upon the first delivery of the systems, Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic observed that they provided “powerful deterrent” against potential attackers. “We will no longer allow to be a punching bag for anyone,” the president said at the time, in apparent reference to a 78 day bombing campaign carried out by NATO in 1999 against Yugoslavia.
https://militarywatchmagazine.com/article/serbia-europe-top-surface-to-air-missile-networks-chinese-hq22

Posted by: Newbie | Jan 3 2025 9:06 utc | 174

Can’t have the us’s good friends locked up
https://tass.com/world/1896049
South Korean law enforcers suspend execution of arrest warrant for Yoon Suk Yeol — agency
The Corruption Investigation Office is looking into the circumstances of the announcement of martial law by the president who has been accused of insurrection following the move
SEOUL, January 3. /TASS/. The Corruption Investigation Office for High-ranking Officials (CIO) has decided to suspend indefinitely the execution of the arrest warrant in regard to impeached President Yoon Suk Yeol, News1 agency reported on Friday.
South Korean news agency Yonhap reported earlier in the day that law enforcers arrived at the residence of impeached President Yoon Suk Yeol to detain him on charges of insurrection, but were locked in a standoff with a military unit inside the presidential premises.
The Corruption Investigation Office is looking into the circumstances of the announcement of martial law by the president who has been accused of insurrection following the move. A CIO team filed for a detention warrant on December 30, a day after Yoon Suk Yeol failed to report for questioning for a third straight time.
South Korean law allows prosecuting a sitting president in cases of treason or insurrection. The president’s defense lawyer insisted the agency has no authority to investigate an insurrection case.

Posted by: Newbie | Jan 3 2025 9:10 utc | 175

https://english.ahram.org.eg/News/537915.aspx
What can go wrong?

Posted by: Tom | Jan 3 2025 12:05 utc | 176

From the Telsa truck bomber/suicide guy Matthew Livelsberger

“In case I do not make it to my decision point or on to the Mexico border I am sending this now. Please do not release this until 1JAN and keep my identity private until then.
First off I am not under duress or hostile influence or control. My first car was a 2006 Black Ford Mustang V6 for verification.
What we have been seeing with “drones” is the operational use of gravitic propulsion systems powered aircraft by most recently China in the east coast, but throughout history, the US. Only we and China have this capability. Our OPEN location for this activity in the box is below.
China has been launching them from the Atlantic from submarines for years, but this activity recently has picked up. As of now, it is just a show of force and they are using it similar to how they used the balloon for sigint and isr, which are also part of the integrated comms system. There are dozens of those balloons in the air at any given time.
The so what is because of the speed and stealth of these unmanned AC, they are the most dangerous threat to national security that has ever existed. They basically have an unlimited payload capacity and can park it over the WH if they wanted. It’s checkmate.
US needs to give the history of this, how we are employing it and weaponizing it, how China is employing them and what the way forward is. China is poised to attack anywhere in the east coast
I’ve been followed for over a week now from likely homeland or FBI, and they are looking to move on me and are unlikely going to let me cross into Mexico, but won’t because they know i am armed and I have a massive VBIED.
I’ve been trying to maintain a very visible profile and have kept my phone and they are definitely digitally tracking me. I have knowledge of this program and also war crimes that were covered up during airstrikes in Nimruz province Afghanistan in 2019 by the admin, DoD, DEA and CIA.
I conducted targeting for these strikes of over 125 buildings (65 were struck because of CIVCAS) that killed hundreds of civilians in a single day. USFORA continued strikes after spotting civilians on initial ISR, it was supposed to take 6 minutes and scramble all aircraft in CENTCOM. The UN basically called these war crimes, but the administration made them disappear.
I was part of that cover-up with USFORA and Agent [redacted] of the DEA. So I don’t know if my abduction attempt is related to either. I worked with GEN Millers 10 staff on this as well as the response to Bala Murghab. AOB-S Commander at the time [redacted] can validate this.
You need to elevate this to the media so we avoid a world war because this is a mutually assured destruction situation. For vetting my Linkedin is Matt Berg or Matthew Livelsberger, an active duty 18Z out of 1-10 my profile is public. I have an active TSSCI with UAP USAP access.”

Now going to go read about gravitic

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 4 2025 2:40 utc | 177

@ psychohistorian | Jan 4 2025 2:40 utc | 185
i am curious where that came from… it is possible he wrote it but we’ll probably never know for sure..

Posted by: james | Jan 4 2025 4:42 utc | 178

@ james | Jan 4 2025 4:42 utc | 186 who needs to go to ZH to find this posting and read it
“TIME TO WAKE UP!”: ‘Cybertruck Bomber’ Had Several Manifestos, Warned Of Drones Using ‘Gravatic Propulsion’

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 4 2025 4:44 utc | 179

@ psychohistorian | Jan 4 2025 4:44 utc | 187
not going to zh, but thanks for the reference..

Posted by: james | Jan 4 2025 4:52 utc | 180

Posted by: james | Jan 4 2025 4:52 utc | 188
LMAO “gravatic propulsion” haha.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jan 4 2025 7:17 utc | 181

Now going to go read about gravitic
Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 4 2025 2:40 utc | 185
Better time spent reading about “V6” Ford Mustangs. TMK they don’t exist.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jan 4 2025 7:18 utc | 182

Geez I guess V6 ShitStangs do exist. Doesn’t auto justify it tho. Shame on Ford. Turbo 4 is faster than the V6 and 5.0 or 4.6 are better too. Dude wasn’t very bright.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jan 4 2025 7:20 utc | 183

fyi from The Postil
Maaloula, one of the most ancient Christian towns in Syria, closely connected to Saint Paul, through his disciple, Saint Thecla, and its ancient monastery of Saint Sergius, with some of the oldest known icons… all now under threat, with reports saying that much of the ancient religious paintings and icons, as well churches, are now destroyed, objects stolen, all courtesy of the current “good guys”—aka, HTS.
The citizens of Maaloula, once 2000 strong, are now said to be less than 200, who too have been ordered to leave, or else. This is the grim reality of the regime-change that has just been orchestrated in Syria: Christians are being “ethnically cleansed.” But, at least, western politicians can crow about “freedom” and “democracy.”
Maaloula: The Plight of Christians in Syria

Posted by: Don Firineach | Jan 4 2025 19:53 utc | 184

fyi The Postil
So, what’s going on with Ukraine? On the one hand, the punditry has been busy telling us that the country is kaput, on the verge of collapse, days numbered, etc. And then Ukrainians were instrumental in ousting Assad (and the Russians). And their foreign minister has just met with the terrorist-in-chief in Damascus, promising to help Syria build back better, and to deliver tons of wheat, as humanitarian aid, and other goodies. Huh???
Oh, and the Ukrainian unit that helped oust Assad, and put Al-Jolani in power, is the Khimik Military Group, which has had loads of success in Syria (obviously).
The fall of Syria certainly has revealed some very odd goings on in the Middle East, and beyond…
Ukraine’s Strategic Role in Syria
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vCRRmCySrdU
[11 mins worth it – think for yourself
# I can’t vouch for the accuracy of this outline of Ukraine’s role in training and fighting Assad – nor the claims here on the Alliance between HTS [Al Queda] and Ukraine.
The corrupt terrorist/facist/kleptocraticylittle proxy statelet of Empire in bed with Al Queda – and maybe more to come. So, this is Empire now.

Posted by: Don Firineach | Jan 4 2025 20:47 utc | 185

ZH has a posting up with the title
‘The US… Is Terminally Ill’: Vegas PD Reveals More Of ‘Cybertruck Bomber’ Manifesto
IT is an update to their earlier posting and includes

According to U.S. Army officials, Livelsberger served in the Green Berets, a special forces unit trained to counter terrorism abroad and mentor allied forces. He joined the Army in 2006 and built a distinguished career, with deployments to Afghanistan, Ukraine, Tajikistan, Georgia, and Congo. Recently returned from an overseas assignment in Germany, he was on approved leave at the time of his death, a U.S. official confirmed.
Livelsberger received five Bronze Stars, including one with a valor device for courage under fire, along with a Combat Infantryman Badge and an Army Commendation Medal with valor.

What is missing directly from the ZH piece but mentioned by Larry Johnson was the drone connection to Ukraine….my speculation is… and possibly HTS…mentor allied forces is says above….Hmmmm
Just how did he shoot himself and then blow up the truck? Too many questions yet, IMO.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 4 2025 23:57 utc | 186

I continue to think about the message going with the Livelsberger incident in Las Vegas.
Reuters currently has nothing about the incident on its web site….Hmmmm
If Livelsberger was a drone trainer in Ukraine and with HTS in Syria, that may have been a moral load too much for him to handle…..but why not a real bomb instead of the BS in back of the Tesla given his capabilities….and if he didn’t want to hurt any more people then why not blow up further away from building??????????…he injured 7 or so
What does a copycat of this type of event look like? Will we see such?

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 5 2025 0:29 utc | 187

@ psychohistorian | Jan 4 2025 23:57 utc | 196 / 197
quote ” Too many questions yet, IMO.” yeah – always the case…

Posted by: james | Jan 5 2025 1:02 utc | 188

No evidence of course, just a hunch.
Let’s say Matt Berg’s KIA in Ukraine (Last posting was some small army depot/store in Germany). And he was a UAV expert/trainer.
Deep State or factions within have been trying to scare the natives with the UFO nonsense. Some bright spark at the FBI concocts this fabulous story about UAV with weird propulsion from Chiiiiiinaaaaaa.
Then there’s the “suicide”, feeling sorry angle. Sure, could be possible. But why IED and outside Trump’s building? Why not anywhere else? Pentagon, WH, why not Germany? Why fly back to US to make a dash for Mexico when it’s easier to leg it from Europe?
Unless the entire purpose of the IED was to destroy the evidence. I wonder if verification will be by dental records.
Pity all these suicidal veterans and serving members don’t just try and take a CEO with them.

Posted by: Suresh | Jan 5 2025 1:54 utc | 189

Welcome to 2025. Let’s begin with my parsing a podcast, “Outlaw US Empire at Optimum: Hudson Explains,” https://karlof1.substack.com/p/outlaw-us-empire-at-optimum-hudson
psychohistorian | Jan 4 2025 23:57 utc | 196–
A timer was set and detonated whatever it was hooked to. Yes, I share many questions that began when I heard his passport and military ID were recovered despite everything else being incinerated.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jan 5 2025 2:06 utc | 190

10 Dead, At Least 30 Injured After Terrorist Plows ISIS-Flag-Waving Truck Into Crowd On Bourbon Street
So many questions…..Let the spin begin
Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 2 2025 0:00 utc | 173
Anyone noticed the flag was mounted upside down?

Posted by: Suresh | Jan 5 2025 2:11 utc | 191

In response about NOLA guy to

Anyone noticed the flag was mounted upside down?
Posted by: Suresh | Jan 5 2025 2:11 utc | 201

The Nima podcast with Larry Johnson exposed that bit of information by Larry along with the question of the ability of the HR IT guy to build the IED’s he was found with…..Larry was repetitively adamant that the FBI lies.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 5 2025 2:37 utc | 192

You really have lost it Karl, if you ever had it. Go play in your stupid Gym with your starry eyed groupies. (GRIN)
Posted by: just in | Dec 31 2024 2:22 utc | 133
Good Grief! Reminds me of someone else who infested the bar, had lost a child to suicide and was having health issues, mental issues, self esteem….?
Is that you man child? Come back for cuddles? Have you ever found out who daddy was?

Posted by: Suresh | Jan 5 2025 2:53 utc | 193

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 5 2025 2:37 utc | 204
ph, I’ve been wondering: how does one get a hold of an ISIS flag in the US? Do they sell it at Walmart?
Target? Amazon?

Posted by: Sakineh Bagoom | Jan 5 2025 2:56 utc | 194

Welcome to 2025. Let’s begin with my parsing a podcast, “Outlaw US Empire at Optimum: Hudson Explains,” https://karlof1.substack.com/p/outlaw-us-empire-at-optimum-hudson
Posted by: karlof1 | Jan 5 2025 2:06 utc | 200
Yes, a major crisis is in order and the us has already plainly stated that other powers would be able to deal better with it so they’d make sure those other powers would be not be in a condition to benefit from that advantage. But how far can they take that without things falling into WW3? The us believes it can do so for as long and as hard as they wish, but I think that’s assuming the other side will not oblige under any circumstances (they’re probably wrong)
For proof of that last paragraph, let’s hear Blinky of the no brain https://tass.com/world/1896303
The US is not close to direct conflict with Russia, outgoing US Secretary of State Antony Blinken told the New York Times.
“We’ve been able to navigate this in a way that has kept us away from direct conflict with Russia,” he said in an interview published on Saturday, referring to bilateral relations. “In terms of direct conflict, I don’t think we’ve been close, but it’s something that we’ve had to be very, very mindful of.”

Posted by: Newbie | Jan 5 2025 3:00 utc | 195

In response to

ph, I’ve been wondering: how does one get a hold of an ISIS flag in the US? Do they sell it at Walmart?
Target? Amazon?
Posted by: Sakineh Bagoom | Jan 5 2025 2:56 utc | 206

LOL! good question
I will take this opportunity to tell on myself and fellow supporters of Palestine in my little city. There were 20 or so of us standing out in pouring rain today for an hour and I was impressed by my fellow supporters. It somehow came to me since this afternoon event to check the proper orientation of the Palestine and I learned that the one I was holding today was attached upside down on the pole…sigh
I am not well connected in the group but will take tools next week to fix, if necessary, the half-dozen flags organizers provided…..its the intention that is important…..

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 5 2025 3:09 utc | 196

Palestine flag…..I proofread and still missed….sigh

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jan 5 2025 3:12 utc | 197

Let’s remain in the domain of facts and evidence. In the real world not lost in imaginations and story telling.
Posted by: x | Jan 5 2025 2:16 utc | 203
Xcept all the “story” released so far doesn’t add up to the “evidence” provided. The body was burned beyond recognition, but ID survived.
But I admit the KIA in Ukraine theory can be discounted. Apparently, he had an argument with his wife the day after Christmas, which explains his presence in the US.
The “bomb” theory in the car still holds. FBI or Matt going rogue and staging his death.

Posted by: Suresh | Jan 5 2025 3:17 utc | 198

“… It’s foolish to assume there are these bad guys here, but over there they are the good guys, and when they get to bring the US west down everything will be much better, and fairer, and freer. Be sceptical. Question everything.”
Posted by: Chen | Jan 4 2025 7:44 utc | 192Ah
Ah. I was just mentioning the Musk situational blowup over on b’s latest thread. I’ll leave my comment there, I guess. But please, who is going to get to bring the US down exactly? And when and where is this going to happen?
I know, I know…I’m a fool to care.

Posted by: juliania | Jan 5 2025 3:28 utc | 199

Sorry, my ‘ah’ slipped its leash.

Posted by: juliania | Jan 5 2025 3:29 utc | 200