Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 15, 2024
The MoA Week In Review – OT 2024-299

Last week's posts on Moon of Alabama:


Other issues:

Gaza:

War on Iran:

China:

Europe:

Miscellaneous:

Use as open (not related to the wars in Ukraine and Palestine) thread …

Comments

Will Israel overreach?
Almost certainly, if we look at the historical record and the Yinon plan.

Posted by: Biochar | Dec 15 2024 14:25 utc | 1

firms, nations, blocs colliding and grinding against one another… yet these entities are essentially imaginary. we the living are left to live as best we can in the tiny gaps remaining to us.
counterfeit ideologies imposed upon us have confused and disoriented us. manipulation and coercion have trapped us into these monstruous combines, and have set us against ourselves, against life itself.

Posted by: bongholder | Dec 15 2024 14:45 utc | 2

What’s the situation in Latakia? Do Alwaite militias and the remnants of the Syrian Arab Army hold control over the city or has it been given up to the rebels?

Posted by: alawites | Dec 15 2024 14:49 utc | 3

John Helmer writes
“. . . on December 2, when Iran’s President, Masoud Pezeshkian, made an urgent telephone call to Putin. In principle, the Kremlin announced, Putin and Pezeshkian agreed on “unconditional support for the efforts of Syria’s legitimate authorities to restore constitutional order and maintain the country’s territorial integrity.”
In practice, there was a Russian condition. Putin told Pezeshkian that Russian anti-aircraft units in Syria would not operate against Israeli attack and defend the Iranian air bridge to Khmeimim for the troops and arms which Assad had been requesting urgently, and which the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps was ready to send. Putin also told the Iranian President that Russian ground forces and artillery would not engage Turkish forces moving southward, and would not bomb them from the air.
By the time Putin and Pezeshkian were speaking, after days of the closed-door debate with the General Staff, Putin believed he had the word of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that Russia’s principal military bases at Tartus and Khmeimim would not be attacked and Russian forces not threatened. Their pre-condition was that Putin would not encourage or defend Iranian reinforcements.”
Note that Assad had urgently requested that Iran airlift forces into Syria. This doesn’t exactly match the current narrative that Assad had simply walked away from Syria.

Posted by: Perimetr | Dec 15 2024 15:09 utc | 4

As I’ve said here and elsewhere for a while now, Trump will start a war with Iran in his 2nd term. Said it in 2020 if he was re-elected and I would bet the mortgage on it now. Will be a disaster potentially on a global scale. Russia and/or China likely will not stand by idle and Ansar Allah will have a say in the matter as well.
Re: China’s banning export of those materials to the US, I would assume that in addition to covert subterfuge, Uncle S(c)am simply pays more for them through a middle man if and until they develop their own mining and processing capacity/capability.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Dec 15 2024 15:25 utc | 5

I should have added that the General Staff opposed Putin’s actions in Syria.
Helmer wrote that “The General Staff and GRU warned Putin that Erdogan and Netanyahu could not be trusted, and that without Russian military force to deter them, plus Iranian troops, they would take over Syrian territory – the Turks down the coast to the Lebanese border and to Damascus; the Israelis across the Golan and the Quneitra buffer zone into the southern outskirts of Damascus.”
Putin chose to side with Israel and Turkey. He did so based on the promises of Netanyahu and Erdogan that Russia could keep the Russian naval and air base in Syria. Reports are that Russia has begun removing its S-400 system from the Khmeimim air base . . . that doesn’t sound like Russia will be keeping the bases.

Posted by: Perimetr | Dec 15 2024 15:25 utc | 6

thanks b for all your work… are you ever going to do a fundraiser again?
@ Tom_Q_Collins | Dec 15 2024 15:25 utc | 5
i will admit, it looks like it is going in that direction, doesn’t it? i wonder if trump thinks it will look good for his pompous image??

Posted by: james | Dec 15 2024 16:02 utc | 7

At this moment all is right with the world.
The front page of Reuters has a picture of a Syrian father helping his child place
a lit candle in a cathedral.
Main Headline is: Syrian Christians attend services, schools reopen a week after Assad’s overthrow

Posted by: librul | Dec 15 2024 16:31 utc | 8

Posted by: james | Dec 15 2024 16:02 utc | 7
I think we’re in for a continuation and possibly (or likely?) amplification of the current shitshow.
Leaving Biden’s (or his evil Zionist/anti-Russian handlers) poison pills (plural) aside, I still think Trump will take a maximalist stance against Iran. Especially now with the fall of Syria and the apparent neutering of Hizballah, he and his Zionist aides will attempt to finally subjugate Iran. They are hopefully not stupid enough to think any form of land war is feasible, but I don’t rule out all manner of covert action (assassinations, bribes, sabotage of utilities/cyber attacks, color revolution) or military air/missile strikes against crucial Iranian military (and alleged nuclear) infrastructure and armaments/AD.
Get your popcorn ready? Bibi seems to be made of teflon for now and his regime is lusting for blood and a “final solution” – Trump will almost assuredly oblige in one way or another.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Dec 15 2024 16:42 utc | 9

Here’s Antiwar dot com’s take on the Times of Israhell article b posted in the Week in Review:
https://news.antiwar.com/2024/12/12/report-israel-sees-opportunity-to-bomb-iran-after-downfall-of-assad/
I have no idea what the *actual* timing will be; do they wait for Trump to be inaugurated or take advantage of the “lame duck” Biden regime’s winnowing grasp on power? If I had to bet, I’d probably pick the former, perhaps immediately upon his being sworn in. But I can no longer predict the savagery and lack of regard for human life and regional stability of Bibi’s troubled tenure. I guess since I’m speculating, Israeli/American strikes on Iran could also coincide with legal events and outcomes in “Israel.”

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Dec 15 2024 16:51 utc | 10

Dec. 14, 2011
US: Assad’s Syria a ‘dead man walking’
The State Department official, Frederic Hof, told Congress on Wednesday that Assad’s repression may allow him to hang on to power but only for a short time.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 16:51 utc | 11

re Don Bacon
Assad is reportedly in Moscow, I don’t see what power he is hanging on to.

Posted by: Perimetr | Dec 15 2024 16:54 utc | 12

I don’t understand why you included that New York Times article “The End Game in Ukraine.” It’s chock full of lies and nonsense as per usual. It opens up with saying the war will come to an end soon because both Russia and Ukraine are running out of troops, than goes on to talk about whether or not US should let Russia keep the territories it has seized, as if they have a choice. Also talks about how Trump could concede that Ukraine could have some economic integration with Europe, even though Putin won’t like that. Putin has never made any objection to economic integration, it was the prospect of joining the military alliance NATO.. I guess the article is informative in the sense that it shows that the US media is admitting Ukraine cannot win, but it’s still just the usual worthless coping through misinformation that we’d expect from US MSM.

Posted by: James C | Dec 15 2024 17:01 utc | 13

We now live in a nation where
doctors destroy health,
lawyers destroy justice,
universities destroy knowledge,
governments destroy freedom,
the press destroys information,
religion destroys morals,
and our banks destroy the economy.

-Chris Hedges

Posted by: librul | Dec 15 2024 17:16 utc | 14

New leadership for Syria was job one for Hillary as Sec State:
.. .from a dozen years ago–
They’ve been trying to “advance a political transition in Syria” for five years, w/o success.
H. Clinton worked on the “Syria National Council” until about 2012, with meetings in Egypt and Qatar, and then when that bombed they came up with the “Syria National Coalition”.
My favorite prospective Syria PM from that era (from many) was a guy from Texas. Ghassan Hitto was elected prime minister on 18 March 2013 by a narrow margin over former Syrian Arab Republic agricultural minister Assad Mustafa. Hitto resigned on 8 July 2013. A Texas-based businessman [Murphy, TX] Hitto had lived in the US for over 30 years.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 17:16 utc | 15

The US attacking Iran (finally!) would bring a big decision to Tehran. Should Iran then destroy forty thousand US troops, some with dependents, also some civilian workers, and two major headquarters (Navy and Air Force), all arrayed around the Persian Gulf, plus ships at sea?

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 17:28 utc | 16

yeah, the whole thing could get very messy real fast… sounds like a job for the usa which excels at that sort of thingy..

Posted by: james | Dec 15 2024 17:37 utc | 17

Topic: US & South and North Korea
This is from june 2003: “Are We Headed for War with North Korea?”
https://www.cato.org/commentary/are-we-headed-war-north-korea
======================================================================
And I post this video again & as well:
“The coming war with china” (autor: John Pilger)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V42KtSeo3uI (if you have 1 hour and 54 minutes of spare time)

Posted by: WMG | Dec 15 2024 17:41 utc | 18

Blinken says US has made ‘direct contact’ with Syria’s victorious HTS – The United States and other Western governments classify HTS as a terrorist group due to its roots in Al-Qaeda’s Syria branch.
BLINKEN: . . .yes, we’ve been in contact with HTS and with other parties. We have impressed upon everyone we’ve been in contact with the importance of helping find Austin Tice and bringing him home. And we’ve also shared the principles that I just laid out for our ongoing support – principles, again, that have now been adopted by countries throughout the region and well beyond. And we’ve communicated those.
QUESTION: That’s direct contact?
BLINKEN: That’s direct contact, yes. . .here
The US would never talk to Assad.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 17:54 utc | 19

re: coming war with China @ 18
This idea has been supported by false news about terrible China.
. . .the fake news —
1. The UNCLOS tribunal was against China building on islands.
wrong- UNCLOS is “laws of the Sea” not land, and UNCLOS has agreed with that.
2. The “nine dash line” governs China’s claims on most of the South China Sea
wrong – This claim is a repeated statement in every criticism of China which has made no such claim, and which is ridiculous on its face. The only water that any state owns is territorial water around terrain.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 18:12 utc | 20

Alastair Crooke:
Turkey & israel coordinated their military moves in Syria.

Posted by: WMG | Dec 15 2024 18:27 utc | 21

Reports are that Russia has begun removing its S-400 system from the Khmeimim air base . . . that doesn’t sound like Russia will be keeping the bases.
Posted by: Perimetr | Dec 15 2024 15:25 utc | 6
There goes the early warning for iran…
The fact that RF didn’t shoot IDF planes does not mean they didn’t track and flag them (or even paint them)

Posted by: Newbie | Dec 15 2024 18:28 utc | 22

“There goes the early warning for iran…”
My impression was that Iran got “material help” from
Russia in that domain. ( Leading to the abortive IDF Attack.)

Posted by: MAKK | Dec 15 2024 18:57 utc | 23

According to Wash Post, indicted war criminal Gallant is in USA and telling Trump that Iran’s air defences were effectively destroyed back in October and so best opportunity exists for decapitation strike on nuke facilities and leadership. Trump is trying to decide whether to destroy Iran through bombs or via new sanctions. Biden admin says it may assume the authority to initiate the destruction before Trump sworn in.
Is all of this merely the bluster it sounds like? David Ignatius, the foreign policy courtier of the Post, penned recent stories focussed on the “humiliation” suffered this past week by Assad and Putin and their respective countries. Celebrating another’s supposed “humiliation” is not psychologically sound, or expression of confidence.
Re: blame game in Moscow. Doctorow is adamant that Helmer is reporting only the views and opinions of a minority faction in Russia’s security bureaucracy.

Posted by: jayc | Dec 15 2024 19:08 utc | 24

MoA and like-minded sources are falling for the MSM pipe-dreams of western victory in Syria.
But please consider these facts and their implications:
-the new regime in Syria is led by a man with a U.S. government price on his head;
-despite crowing about beating Assad, Netanyahoo immediately felt the need to launch a bombing campaign and land-grab to create a secure zone (against their friends Al Sham??);
-during the transition, Russia bombed certain jihadist forces (possibly ISIS elements?), but not enough to stop the run on Damascus, and Al Sham promptly announced that Russian bases were not going to be bothered (and has held to it);
-promptly after the removal of Assad, the SNA drove the SDF (U.S.-backed Kurds) out of Manbij;
-during the removal of Assad it was reported that one SNA brigade (who are fairly direct proxies of Turkey “defected” to Al Sham without apparently any consequences or repercussions;
-during the removal of Assad, Turkey, Russia, Iran and several other countries made a calm joint statement about a pleasant future for Syria;
-the SAA who had successfully driven jihadists out of Syria stood down without putting up any fight;
-Al Sham has recently made an international appeal against Israeli aggression.
Given these observations and some others I don’t recall off hand, my view is that the replacement of Assad was not a plan by or a victory for USrael, but rather a process coordinated between Russia and Turkey (possibly with the knowledge of Iran).

Posted by: Figleaf23 | Dec 15 2024 19:15 utc | 25

Re: blame game in Moscow. Doctorow is adamant that Helmer is reporting only the views and opinions of a minority faction in Russia’s security bureaucracy.
Posted by: jayc | Dec 15 2024 19:08 utc | 24
I have to agree with Doctorow for once, I never read Helmer when he starts babbling about the “stavka” and Putin.

Posted by: Bemildred | Dec 15 2024 19:22 utc | 26

re: jayc | Dec 15 2024 19:08 utc | 24
You wrote:
Doctorow is adamant that Helmer is reporting only the views and opinions of a minority faction in Russia’s security bureaucracy.
Do you consider the Russian General Staff to be a “tiny minority faction”?
This is what Helmer wrote in his first installment of THE KREMLIN’S OPRICHNIKI VERSUS THE GENERAL STAFF’S PRIGOZHNIKI IN THE NEW TIME OF TROUBLES:
“It is the conclusion of the Kremlin and of the General Staff, therefore, that they should either hang together or if not, they will hang each other.
Having opposed but obeyed Putin’s orders forbidding them to fire on Israeli aircraft attacking Syria, or on Turkish ground operations in and around Idlib, Moscow sources believe the General Staff have now told Putin much more than the refrain, he’s heard many times before, “We told you so”. This time the General Staff assessment of the invasion of Syria, refusal of the Syrian Arab Army (SAA) to fight, and the replacement of the Assad regime in Damascus is that grave damage has been done to the protective alliances which Russia has been promoting in Africa, the Americas, China, and North Korea.
“We just have to accept that Iran and Russia have been comprehensively defeated in their non-fight, “a well-informed Moscow source says. “It is the worst defeat of Russia by the Turks in history. If Putin goes on now to make significant concessions in an Istanbul II negotiation with [President Donald] Trump, that will be the cherry on top of the Turkish halva. We are thinking this; no one is saying it. In the end, a defeat in Ukraine is all we care about. If Putin fails to deliver that, then he has a much bigger problem than the one he has just retreated from. Yes, this is a huge dishonour for us, but nothing is served by talking of it. Still, the situation can be redeemed in the Ukraine. This means the complete and comprehensive defeat of the enemy there.”
A following Helmer post, THE NEW TIME OF TROUBLES, PART II — PUTIN OVERRULED THE GENERAL STAFF, stated:
Military sources in Moscow have told a tale of President Vladimir Putin’s decision not to defend the Syrian Arab Army and the Damascus government of Bashar al-Assad. That decision, the sources claim, was taken at least two weeks before the Turkish break-out from Idlib began on November 27, and was conveyed to Assad personally by December 6.
It had been hinted at four days earlier, on December 2, when Iran’s President, Masoud Pezeshkian, made an urgent telephone call to Putin. In principle, the Kremlin announced, Putin and Pezeshkian agreed on “unconditional support for the efforts of Syria’s legitimate authorities to restore constitutional order and maintain the country’s territorial integrity.”
In practice, there was a Russian condition. Putin told Pezeshkian that Russian anti-aircraft units in Syria would not operate against Israeli attack and defend the Iranian air bridge to Khmeimim for the troops and arms which Assad had been requesting urgently, and which the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps was ready to send. Putin also told the Iranian President that Russian ground forces and artillery would not engage Turkish forces moving southward, and would not bomb them from the air.
By the time Putin and Pezeshkian were speaking, after days of the closed-door debate with the General Staff, Putin believed he had the word of Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that Russia’s principal military bases at Tartus and Khmeimim would not be attacked and Russian forces not threatened. Their pre-condition was that Putin would not encourage or defend Iranian reinforcements . . .
“Russia does not betray friends in difficult situations,” was the line the Kremlin told the Foreign Ministry to instruct its diplomats to announce after Assad had landed in Moscow on December 8, adding the footnote that “a deal has been done to ensure the safety of Russian military bases.”
Reuters reports that Russia is dismantling its S-400 system at Latakia; the Russian naval vessels have left their base in Tartus. In other words, the “deal” that Putin made appears to have the same value as did the Minsk Accords.
The question now is, what happens to Iran now that Israel dominates Syrian airspace and Iran has apparently lost the protection previously afforded by the Russian S-400 air defense system in Syria?

Posted by: Perimetr | Dec 15 2024 19:46 utc | 27

> My impression was that Iran got “material help” from
Russia in that domain. ( Leading to the abortive IDF Attack.)
Posted by: MAKK | Dec 15 2024 18:57 utc | 23
Another theory is that it might have been a dry run to test and degrade Iranian AD in preparation for an all out attack.

Posted by: Pudding | Dec 15 2024 20:35 utc | 28

Yoon and Zelensky—brothers by another mother

Posted by: nwwoods | Dec 15 2024 20:54 utc | 29

i will admit, it looks like it is going in that direction, doesn’t it? i wonder if trump thinks it will look good for his pompous image??
Posted by: james | Dec 15 2024 16:02 utc | 7
I would strongly suggest, james, that you take time to listen to the Dialogue Works interview by Nima with Alex Krainer from a couple of days back. I only did so last night. The outline he gives is well worth considering, going back as he does to the early years of the 20th century. Much as the downfall of Syria came as a surprise to us lowly bloggers, it was not a surprise to people who matter. Alex’s presentation is a simply put analysis, very powerful.
Further surprises are in store for those who still rely on what I now will call sewagestream media (‘Monk’ openings to episodes will remind one of what that looks like and who dwells therein. Sometimes it is necessary to descend to their depths, but hopefully less and less often.)

Posted by: juliania | Dec 15 2024 21:01 utc | 30

@ juliania | Dec 15 2024 21:01 utc | 30
thanks juliania.. i subscribe to his substack and did read the transcript that came with the video the day he released it.. my general point is, i agree with tom collins @ 5 and think the level of fealty towards israel as demonstrated by usa politicians is off the charts.. and trump is a perfect example of this slavish behaviour… i don’t really care what the rationale is for it, it’s a fact… you might want to check out the common dreams link to jeffrey sachs article – – How the US and Israel Destroyed Syria and Called it Peace…. lots of good articles at moa week in review this week..
here is krainers post that juliania mentions for others to consider..
Syria: will it prove to be the empire’s final quagmire?

Posted by: james | Dec 15 2024 21:24 utc | 31

@ Posted by: Perimetr | Dec 15 2024 19:46 utc | 27
“Reuters reports …”?
You can’t be serious posting that.

Posted by: Figleaf23 | Dec 15 2024 21:38 utc | 32

Posted by: james | Dec 15 2024 21:24 utc | 31
Thank you, james, for the substack article. Bravo to you for supporting it. I will presently read it. My own tracking down of the Dialogue Works interview was a hard slog as it didn’t appear where I had previously found it,not even on Dialogue Works home site. However, after seeing a five days ago earlier interview with Alex I came across the word ‘trap’, which then enabled me to find the interview I’d previously viewed, so here that interview is:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Q0FQeGjPSc0
I did not, as you know, vote for Trump. At the time of the election there were too many unknowables for me, but while those still exist, I’m prepared to become a supporter if the current signs and deflections are overcome. We in the US have little else to hope for and I like to remain hopeful, not caring if my hopes are not fulfilled. In this I am not deluded as I was by Obama back in the day. I simply realize we wo’t know what is in his heart until he takes office. You see the negative statements of intent, and perhaps you are wiser to ‘trumpet’ them. We shall see.

Posted by: juliania | Dec 15 2024 22:05 utc | 33

b, thank you for another week of your posts, and for the week in review, which I have yet to get into. I just checked in with the X account of Canada’s satirical news site, The Beaverton. They have two articles about the Canada Post strike which appear to me (due to repeated under-linked use of the word ‘labour’) to be about the UK somehow.
So! A month long strike by Crown corporation, Canada Post, continues to make it challenging to ship online orders, among other things. This could be added to the suspicion around Jeff Bezos that’s appeared to crop up in a few news bits/leaks now and again.
For those across the Atlantic, for your consideration, if you wish:
“Local man hoping for Christmas miracle of Canada Post employees surrendering collective bargaining rights”
https://x.com/TheBeaverton/status/1868023215483998584
“Trudeau orders end to Canada Post strike after learning Santa Claus not real”
https://x.com/TheBeaverton/status/1868356095074291886

Posted by: Bruised Northerner | Dec 15 2024 22:34 utc | 34

In support of my comment above at 35, after reading the transcript posted by james | Dec 15 2024 21:24 utc | 31, I would suggest that my link at 35, being more a conversation than a condensed compilation, is an enlargement of the substack article. ( I was unable to open the video above james’s link.) For me, Nima’s video gives the most understandable reasons for what was, and is, taking place.

Posted by: juliania | Dec 15 2024 22:35 utc | 35

re: The “Rules-Based International Order,” illustrated
. . .from the files. . .
>Mar 2, 2012 · Atlantic national correspondent Jeffrey Goldberg writes that Obama will ask Netanyahu not to launch any attacks on Iran’s suspected nuclear facilities in coming months
>Aug 10, 2012 . On Iran, Obama Says ‘I Don’t Bluff’ And ‘All Options Are On The Table
>Jun 3, 2015 · As the June 30 deadline for the Iran nuclear deal approaches, President Obama is putting all his cards on the table — by announcing he is keeping no cards in his hand.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 23:21 utc | 36

@ Philly | Dec 15 2024 22:01 utc | 34
On Syria
re: They played everyone, on all sides, like fiddles.
That includes making up some sides, like Assad was gassing his people.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 23:26 utc | 37

Figleaf23 | Dec 15 2024 19:15 utc | 25–
Your POV is shared by others. Follow the money as Krainer suggests.

Posted by: karlof1 | Dec 15 2024 23:41 utc | 38

@ james | Dec 15 2024 21:24 utc | 31
re Putin’s remark: . . .I repeat: we are not discussing freezing the conflict, but its definitive resolution.”
Resolving the Ukraine conflict is not a desired US option, it prefers freezing the conflict as per Korea, a situation which has not been resolved in twenty-five years, and has proven to be a forever golden situation for the US rules-based international order. So Ukraine, if the US has its way, would be another Korea calling for many military bases, military exercises without end with unlimited financial expenditures on military junk. . .”War is a racket.” . .unfortunately a situation that would outlive Putin.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 23:46 utc | 39

Devil’s Bargain: U.S. Covered-up Japan’s Ethnic-Racial Bioweapons Experiments on U.S. POWs – Jeff Kaye
is a rather good account of Imperial Japan’s Nazi-style medical experiments on US POWs during WW 2. Note that the city of Mukden often mentioned is present-day Shenyang. Also, if business or whatever takes you to Harbin, the Unit 731 Museum in Ping Fang on the outskirts of Harbin is well worth a visit. The present-day Japanese government funds the museum, so they cannot deny the story it tells!

Posted by: lester | Dec 16 2024 0:18 utc | 40

Resolving the Ukraine conflict is not a desired US option, it prefers freezing the conflict as per Korea, a situation which has not been resolved in twenty-five years, and has proven to be a forever golden situation for the US rules-based international order. So Ukraine, if the US has its way, would be another Korea calling for many military bases, military exercises without end with unlimited financial expenditures on military junk. . .”War is a racket.” . .unfortunately a situation that would outlive Putin.
Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 23:46 utc | 42
Although I have mentioned a 12 year truce I would expect minimum terms would be a win for RF and no weapons in ukraine (maybe even romania/moldova)
The racket can continue in poland and the sub-par western european armies

Posted by: Newbie | Dec 16 2024 0:20 utc | 41

US sanctions on PR China, Russia, and other countires looks as if it will end wallingth US off from the rest of the world. Imperial China did this during the Ming and Quing dynastries. It didn’t work out well in the end!

Posted by: lester | Dec 16 2024 0:24 utc | 42

from X, on a speech from NATO supporting the US, from Zero Hedge…
Nato boss Mark Rutte calls on European members of Nato to spend less on pensions, health and social security and more on defence “to preserve our way of life”. So the poor must pay for endless Nato wars?

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 16 2024 0:27 utc | 43

Will Israel overreach?
Almost certainly, if we look at the historical record and the Yinon plan.
Posted by: Biochar | Dec 15 2024 14:25 utc | 1
Oh definitely and not merely based on the particular character of their state, but also, and in my view, primarily because their ideology demands constant over reach.
This year has seen the Zionazis openly state their ideology and it is almost indistinguishable from that of their forebears, the actual Nazis. Both see the world in terms of a racial struggle, both share a messianism that they believe virtually guarantees their success in conflicts with the untermenchen, and none of their core beliefs correspond to material reality.
This irrationalist philosophy of magic blood and racial supremacy, imposed from on high, dooms its adherents to foolish overreach every time.
Take for example, operation Barbarossa. It certainly would have made better sense to completely subdue the west while maintaining the treaty with Stalin. Once western Europe, including the UK had been subdued and Germany had time to incorporate and shore up its gains it would then have had a more realistic chance at defeating the Soviets.
That course was not taken, because Hitler believed his own irrational ideology. He sincerely believed that the mystery of the blood and Germany’s racial superiority virtually guaranteed victory over the subhumans regardless of the hard realities and context.
To think the Zionazis are any less crazy than their stepfather Hitler is to just ignore everything they say and do over the last year.

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 0:39 utc | 44

Syria: will it prove to be the empire’s final quagmire?
No. Many more quagmires to go yet. Besides which Syria was not a quagmire for the US empire, it was a walk in the park. They played everyone, on all sides, like fiddles.
Posted by: Philly | Dec 15 2024 22:01 utc | 34
Master of the accomplished fact. Way to go, Philly. There’s a lot more to go, tiger.

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 0:48 utc | 45

At this point the US/Israel/NATO gang looks unbeatable. They wage war on all fronts and domains 24/7. Its a long war and they have staying power. Another country down, more to follow. More ominous is the populations of the Evil Empire no longer have a moral base that in the past served as a leash on the political/military leaders. They know they can get away with anything now, even genocide. Not looking good

Posted by: Pete Lincoln | Dec 16 2024 0:52 utc | 46

Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 0:39 utc | 47
The book by Victor Suvorov is telling a slightly different story – that Hitler pre-empted Stalin’s attack. Germany were absolutely not prepared to wage war on two fronts. Hitler was aware of Stalin’s intent to attack Germany’s main oil supply in Romania (Ploesti). According to Suvorov Stalin was preparing for offensive war, not defensive. Just saying.

Posted by: fanto | Dec 16 2024 1:05 utc | 47

China vs Blinky in South America
Need a break? Relax! Kick back! Get out some popcorn, crack open a beer. China is openening a mega mega mega port in Peru. Cosco (a China company) hammered out a deal to build this port a couple of years ago with a Peruvian company and, since the local aristocrats were busy conspiring with the Yanks to take out Pedro Castillo nobody read the fine print which gave Cosco a huge advantage in operating and profiting from the port. Current fake president Dina Boluarte finally realized they gave up too much… too late. Meanwhile, little Blinky was given a bright idea from dim whit pretty boy Gavin Newsome: California just swapped out a bunch of dirty diesel communter trains for way faster maybe cleaner electric ones. Botta bing! Blinky appears in Peru like Santa Claus and gives– ok, sells– them to Peru in a desperate attempt to change the narrative from the big opening of the port.
bottom line, China is very solid, Russia is getting there, I believe Iran will too. US is way outplayed. Not even close.
full disclosure, I’m a hick. I heat mostly with wood.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b0jXWPDj-xg
https://www.thecentersquare.com/california/article_600c0d70-a69c-11ef-8f38-4f8c75866d49.html

Posted by: migueljose | Dec 16 2024 1:06 utc | 48

correction
The port treaty in Peru was negotiated in 2019 during Martin Vizcarra’s presidency.

Posted by: migueljose | Dec 16 2024 1:30 utc | 49

@ juliania | Dec 15 2024 22:05 utc | 35
thanks.. i have watched 40 minutes of the nima and alex video.. he has mostly gone over the same stuff in the substack link – maybe a bit more.. i will try to see it thru.. i watched the video b shared – you tube in german – Harald Kujat General a.D. Vortrag zum Ukraine-Krieg… it was worthwhile from the point of view of understanding some of the thinking in germany… there are some parallels with ukraine conflict and the middle east syria and etc conflict..
i am not sure how trump is going to process all of this, but if i am correct that the usa empire is a fading empire, they have less choices to make.. they have thrived on creating chaos and destruction in faraway places, but the returns are less and less here as i see it.. it is a game that has mostly been played with very little return coming in at present.. i think the internal tension is increasing in the usa as well.. take the issue of the medical care complex and this fellow luigi mangione.. the fact many younger people are propping him up as a folk hero says something about where the younger folks of the usa are today… the whole system seems to be imploding, with the elon musks vying to grab more power any way they can… it is quite unsavoury actually… i guess this is what money and chasing after money does to a country and a culture steeped in this type of thinking… sorry juliania, but i don’t want to take away your hope.. sometimes it is darkest before the dawn… things aren’t all light and happiness.. the world is going thru a change of order.. the way i see it the usa is going to have to adjust to a more secondary role and it seems very ill suited to such a role, given that the usa is the greatest, exceptional nation and all the rest of the jargon and talk that doesn’t cut it in the world today..
i guess in this sense, i share my hick friend migueljoses perspective here, lol!! i heat with wood too, lol..
@ Don Bacon | Dec 15 2024 23:46 utc | 42
right, in other words what trump is saying and what the usa wants are sort of related?? it’s not really the end of a war so much as a fake peace.. it seems russia has caught onto the idea that the usa is completely untrustworthy and non negotiable… maybe little donnie can have a temper tantrum when it doesn’t work out where he goes down in history as preventing ww3, lol…. it’s got a nice ring to it, but i heard he went thru a lot of bankruptcies to get where he is today! maybe he learned something along the way…
the best thing trump could do would be to exit nato, but i doubt very much the military-banking-energy complex would let him do such a thing.. so, it will be war, preparation for more war, while at the same time selling the plebs back home you are a man of peace!! time magazine 2025 cover, peace nobel prize winner little donnie.. i can see it now with his MAGA hat on, lol.. a true man of peace for the world!! i better be careful here or william gruff or c1ue are going to scold me!!

Posted by: james | Dec 16 2024 1:36 utc | 50

@ james | Dec 16 2024 1:36 utc | 53 with the empire ramble…thanks
I tried to post the real manifest by luigi mangione here but it went into typepad purgatory and it may come out tomorrow when b sees it…though it is not an issue he included in Weekly Review.
I think it is going to be a big deal in the US because “everybody knows” the health system is really sick and effecting them, or someone they know, personally.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 16 2024 1:46 utc | 51

thanks psychohistorian… i too think the luigi mangione event and dynamic is a big issue with a lot of implications.. i hope you are doing well..
let me try to share it and see if it goes thru..
𝗟𝘂𝗶𝗴𝗶 𝗠𝗮𝗻𝗴𝗶𝗼𝗻𝗲‘𝘀 𝗹𝗮𝘀𝘁 𝘄𝗼𝗿𝗱𝘀…
The Allopathic Complex and Its Consequences
The second amendment means I am my own chief executive and commander in chief of my own military. I authorize my own act of self-defense in response to a hostile entity making war on me and my family.
Nelson Mandela says no form of viooence can be excused. Camus says it’s all the same, whether you live or die or have a cup of coffee. MLK says violence never brings permanent peace. Gandhi says that non-violence is the mightiest power available to mankind.
That’s who they tell you are heroes. That’s who our revolutionaries are.
Yet is that not capitalistic? Non-violence keeps the system working at full speed ahead.
What did it get us. Look in the mirror.
They want us to be non-violent, so that they can grow fat off the blood they take from us.
The only way out is through. Not all of us will make it. Each of us is our own chief executive. You have to decide what you will tolerate.
In Gladiator 1 Maximus cuts into the military tattoo that identifies him as part of the roman legion. His friend asks “Is that the sign of your god?” As Maximus carves deeper into his own flesh, as his own blood drips down his skin, Maximus smiles and nods yes. The tattoo represents the emperor, who is god. The god emperor has made himself part of Maximus’s own flesh. The only way to destroy the emperor is to destroy himself. Maximus smiles through the pain because he knows it is worth it.
These might be my last words. I don’t know when they will come for me. I will resist them at any cost. That’s why I smile through the pain.
They diagnosed my mother with severe neuropathy when she was forty-one years old. She said it started ten years before that with burning sensations in her feet and occasional sharp stabbing pains. At first the pain would last a few moments, then fade to tingling, then numbness, then fade to nothing a few days later.
The first time the pain came she ignored it. Then it came a couple times a year and she ignored it. Then every couple months. Then a couple times a month. Then a couple times a week. At that point by the time the tingling faded to numbness, the pain would start, and the discomfort was constant. At that point even going from the couch to the kitchen to make her own lunch became a major endeavor.
She started with ibuprofen, until the stomach aches and acid reflux made her switch to acetaminophen. Then the headaches and barely sleeping made her switch back to ibuprofen.
The first doctor said it was psychosomatic. Nothing was wrong. She needed to relax, destress, sleep more.
The second doctor said it was a compressed nerve in her spine. She needed back surgery. It would cost $180,000. Recovery would be six months minimum before walking again. Twelve months for full potential recovery, and she would never lift more than ten pounds of weight again.
The third doctor performed a Nerve Conduction Study, Electromyography, MRI, and blood tests. Each test cost $800 to $1200. She hit the $6000 deductible of her UnitedHealthcare plan in October. Then the doctor went on vacation, and my mother wasn’t able to resume tests until January when her deductible reset.
The tests showed severe neuropathy. The $180,000 surgery would have had no effect.
They prescribed opioids for the pain. At first the pain relief was worth the price of constant mental fog and constipation. She didn’t tell me about that until later. All I remember is we took a trip for the first time in years, when she drove me to Monterey to go to the aquarium. I saw an otter in real life, swimming on its back. We left at 7am and listened to Green Day on the four-hour car ride. Over time, the opioids stopped working. They made her MORE sensitive to pain, and she felt withdrawal symptoms after just two or three hours.
Then gabapentin. By now the pain was so bad she couldn’t exercise, which compounded the weight gain from the slowed metabolic rate and hormonal shifts. And it barely helped the pain, and made her so fatigued she would go an entire day without getting out of bed.
Then Corticosteroids. Which didn’t even work.
The pain was so bad I would hear my mother wake up in the night screaming in pain. I would run into her room, asking if she’s OK. Eventually I stopped getting up. She’d yell out anguished shrieks of wordless pain or the word “fuck” stretched and distended to its limits. I’d turn over and go back to sleep.
All of this while they bled us dry with follow-up appointment after follow-up appointment, specialist consultations, and more imagine scans. Each appointment was promised to be fully covered, until the insurance claims were delayed and denied. Allopathic medicine did nothing to help my mother’s suffering. Yet it is the foundation of our entire society.
My mother told me that on a good day the nerve pain was like her legs were immersed in ice water. On a bad day it felt like her legs were clamped in a machine shop vice, screwed down to where the cranks stopped turning, then crushed further until her ankle bones sprintered and cracked to accommodate the tightening clamp. She had more bad days than good.
My mother crawled to the bathroom on her hands and knees. I slept in the living room to create more distance from her cries in the night. I still woke up, and still went back to sleep.
Back then I thought there was nothing I could do.
The high copays made consistent treatment impossible. New treatments were denied as “not medically necessary.” Old treatments didn’t work, and still put us out for thousands of dollars.
UnitedHealthcare limited specialist consultations to twice a year.
Then they refused to cover advanced imaging, which the specialists required for an appointment.
Prior authorizations took weeks, then months.
UnitedHealthcare constantly changed their claim filing procedure. They said my mother’s doctor needed to fax his notes. Then UnitedHealthcare said they did not save faxed patient correspondence, and required a hardcopy of the doctor’s typed notes to be mailed. Then they said they never received the notes. They were unable to approve the claim until they had received and filed the notes.
They promised coverage, and broke their word to my mother.
With every delay, my anger surged. With every denial, I wanted to throw the doctor through the glass wall of their hospital waiting room.
But it wasn’t them. It wasn’t the doctors, the receptionists, administrators, pharmacists, imaging technicians, or anyone we ever met. It was UnitedHealthcare.
People are dying. Evil has become institutionalized. Corporations make billions of dollars off the pain, suffering, death, and anguished cries in the night of millions of Americans.
We entered into an agreement for healthcare with a legally binding contract that promised care commensurate with our insurance payments and medical needs. Then UnitedHealthcare changes the rules to suit their own profits. They think they make the rules, and think that because it’s legal that no one can punish them.
They think there’s no one out there who will stop them.
Now my own chronic back pain wakes me in the night, screaming in pain. I sought out another type of healing that showed me the real antidote to what ails us.
I bide my time, saving the last of my strength to strike my final blows. All extractors must be forced to swallow the bitter pain they deal out to millions.
As our own chief executives, it’s our obligation to make our own lives better. First and foremost, we must seek to improve our own circumstances and defend ourselves. As we do so, our actions have ripple effects that can improve the lives of others.
Rules exist between two individuals, in a network that covers the entire earth. Some of these rules are written down. Some of these rules emerge from natural respect between two individuals. Some of these rules are defined in physical laws, like the properties of gravity, magnetism or the potential energy stored in the chemical bonds of potassium nitrate.
No single document better encapsulates the belief that all people are equal in fundamental worth and moral status and the frameworks for fostering collective well-being than the US constitution.
Writing a rule down makes it into a law. I don’t give a fuck about the law. Law means nothing. What does matter is following the guidance of our own logic and what we learn from those before us to maximize our own well-being, which will then maximize the well-being of our loved ones and community.
That’s where UnitedHealthcare went wrong. They violated their contract with my mother, with me, and tens of millions of other Americans. This threat to my own health, my family’s health, and the health of our country’s people requires me to respond with an act of war.
END

Posted by: james | Dec 16 2024 1:59 utc | 52

thanks psycho.. i tried to post it and it didn’t go thru either.. i hope you are well..
it might work broken up in 3 or 4 parts though.. you could try that..

Posted by: james | Dec 16 2024 2:00 utc | 53

Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 0:39 utc | 47
The book by Victor Suvorov is telling a slightly different story – that Hitler pre-empted Stalin’s attack. Germany were absolutely not prepared to wage war on two fronts. Hitler was aware of Stalin’s intent to attack Germany’s main oil supply in Romania (Ploesti). According to Suvorov Stalin was preparing for offensive war, not defensive. Just saying.
Posted by: fanto | Dec 16 2024 1:05 utc | 50
I don’t have a good link, but it’s unquestionable that it was Stalin who was in fact surprised by Germany’s attack which corresponds to the Nazis initial gains deep into Russia. Stalin felt he could work with Hitler and, he could have, had Hitler not subscribed to a fatal ideology of racial destiny…just like the Zionazis. The Soviet Union was in absolute disarray the first year of Barbarossa.
I don’t know Suvorov, but his take seems to complement the recent historical revisionism that Timothy Snyder perfected in Bloodlands, which served as a sort of historical justification for the Ukronazis open adoration of Bandera, the cat killer.

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 2:33 utc | 54

Looks like Suvorov defected to UK in 78. As expected, historians dispute his read on the conflict.
“A number of historians, such as Gabriel Gorodetsky and David Glantz disputed or rejected this claim.”
The reality is Stalin was the counterrevolutionary. He just wanted a peaceful national utopia, very much like Hitler. The comintern was shuttered by him and all attempts to aid revolutionary movements abroad ceased definitely prior to WW2. This of course led to increased economic isolation in an increasingly globalized world and the end of the Soviet.
The idea he wanted to take Germany prior to WW2 is just ludicrous.

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 2:44 utc | 55

Reuters has a posting up with the title
Bitcoin surges above $106,000 on strategic reserve hopes
So here we have another private money like the US dollar that is being promised US taxpayer backing on loses just like the private bankers.
On the other side we have sovereign nations that are considering alternatives to the current global private finance system and have been threatened by Trump with 100% tariffs if they create an alternative to the US dollar
How are private crypto currencies not a challenge to the US dollar but a sovereign backed currency would be?
Lies, damn lies and outright hypocrisy/obfuscation.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 16 2024 3:20 utc | 56

@ james | Dec 16 2024 1:36 utc | 53
re: now with his MAGA hat on, lol.. a true man of peace for the world!!
In a “democracy” we have presidents who (1) have an autocratic power but (2) that power is governed so they must do what they’re told to avoid another Dealey Plaza assassination.
Trump did order to get out of Iraq and Syria, but it wasn’t done. He blasted NATO, which influenced NATO to talk about getting more responsible. He eliminated the commerce agreement with Asia, the basis of any military agreement. He arrived at an agreement with DPRK’s Kim, which wasn’t allowed to happen because it required removing sanctions, a no-no in a rules-based international order. . . . What more could he do?

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 16 2024 3:26 utc | 57

Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 2:33 utc | 56
Thank you Ahenobarbus for you reply. Sorry for the omission on my part of the title of Suvorov’ s book – it is “The Chief Culprit – Stalin’s Grand Design to Start World War II”. (Naval Institute Press 2013).
It is a surprise to me that Timothy Snyder is possibly telling similar story, if that is the case – I will stop believing Suvorov, because Snyder is not a credible person (despite being Yale professor, or maybe because of it – sarcastically speaking).

Posted by: fanto | Dec 16 2024 3:28 utc | 58

# my 58
Also Trump came up with a plan to withdraw from Afghanistan, which Biden did.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 16 2024 3:28 utc | 59

Damn, another comment in typepad purgatory, this time for being about crypto…sigh

Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 16 2024 3:52 utc | 60

All the prez men,
Incoming ambassador shit stirrer to China,

Trump nominates China hawk David Perdue to become …
BBC
https://www.bbc.com › news › articles
6 Dec 2024 — A Chinese think tank had labelled David Perdue as “anti-China” during his time in the US Senate.
Trump taps hawkish former Senator David Perdue as …
Al Jazeera
https://www.aljazeera.com › news › 2024/12 › trump-ta…

Perdue

Han audacity shocks me !
They follow the Confucius edict
One sky cant have two suns‘.
They had four thousands years of hegemony.
They want it back, now !

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 3:59 utc | 61

Ex-Trump official calls for Seoul to raise defense spending …
KoreaTimes
https://www.koreatimes.co.kr › www › nation › 2024/12
27 Sept 2024 — A former U.S. national security advisor stressed the need Thursday for South Korea to increase its defense spending to 3 percent or 3.5
(News Focus) New S. Korea-U.S. defense cost deal adds …
Yonhap News Agency
https://en.yna.co.kr › All News
5 Oct 2024 — Seoul and Washington struck the five-year deal, called the Special Measures Agreement (SMA), on Wednesday (Korea time) following eight rounds of …
South Korea agrees to pay 8.3% more to host U.S. forces
Nikkei Asia
https://asia.nikkei.com › Politics › Defense › South-Kor…
5 Oct 2024 — SEOUL — South Korea will pay more for stationing American military personnel in the country under an agreement announced Friday.
U.S., South Korea agree on five-year plan to share defence …
Reuters
https://www.reuters.com › world › asia-pacific › us-sout…
4 Oct 2024 — The United States and South Korea on Friday agreed on a new five-year plan on sharing the cost of keeping American troops in South Korea, …
Track II dialogue reveals South Korean concerns over …
Asia New Zealand Foundation
https://www.asianz.org.nz › track-ii-dialogue-reveals-sou…
2 Dec 2024 — A key focus of the discussions was the re-election of Donald Trump as the next U.S. president and its potential impact on South Korea, New …
Trump says ‘money machine’ Korea should pay $10 billion …
조선일보
https://www.chosun.com › national-en › 2024/10/17
17 Oct 2024 — Former US President Donald Trump called South Korea a “money machine” and said the long-time US ally would be paying $10 billion every year for US troops …
Why Donald Trump’s win could mean a defence budget …
South China Morning Post
https://www.scmp.com › News › China › Politics
13 Nov 2024 — Taiwan might face impossible expectations from US president-elect who has called for island to drastically increase military spending.
South Korea shocked by Trump’s ‘money machine’ plan
DW
https://www.dw.com › south-korea-shocked-by-trumps-…
22 Oct 2024 — North Korea is keen to find cracks in the alliance between the US and South Korea, and Republican candidate Donald Trump’s recent comments …
Trump demands NATO allies spend at least 3 percent of …
KoreaTimes
https://www.koreatimes.co.kr › www › nation › 2024/08
27 Aug 2024 — Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump on Monday called on member countries of the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) to …

Some barfly says Trump is ‘anti Nato’, LOL
He is anti ‘NATO parasites who want a free ride on US defense budget’ !
People ask ‘what to make of the west’s leadership ?’
Its a gigantic protection racket !
When Trump talk about ‘NATO interoperability’ , it means …
‘Pay up ,…or else’
IOW, a mob shakedown !

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 4:42 utc | 62

thats all folks !

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 4:43 utc | 63

@ Don Bacon | Dec 16 2024 3:26 utc | 58
thanks don… it sounds like he is just a figurehead mostly then.. i am going to wait and see what he does, but it sounds like he might not do much of anything.. we’ll see..

Posted by: james | Dec 16 2024 5:09 utc | 64

My take on how all of the possible candidates that the Canadian public will be allowed to vote for in the next general election, that has to take place by October 2025 but may be much sooner, are fully oligarch-compliant. There is little or no real choice available to the Canadian citizenry, with policy differences being more on cultural issues than political economic ones. Including some background political history.
Canada’s Choice of Oligarch Acceptable Candidates

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Dec 16 2024 6:40 utc | 65

@Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 2:44 utc | 57

The reality is Stalin was the counterrevolutionary. He just wanted a peaceful national utopia, very much like Hitler. The comintern was shuttered by him and all attempts to aid revolutionary movements abroad ceased definitely prior to WW2. This of course led to increased economic isolation in an increasingly globalized world and the end of the Soviet. The idea he wanted to take Germany prior to WW2 is just ludicrous.

Stalin was a committed communist, who built the industrial economy required to defeat the Nazi menace. That was his main focus throughout the 1930s, as detailed in speech after speech. I agree that the stories of Russia planning to attack Germany are utter garbage, pathetic cold war propaganda. But after WW2 Stalin did place Eastern Europe under communism (as a buffer zone) and provided much needed aid to the Chinese communists. The fall of the Soviet Union was due to the real counter-revolutionaries – Khrushchev and then Brezhnev, who were much more into centralized bureaucratic power. Then of course the wrecker of the undermined system, Gorbachev. Stalin had railed against such bureaucratic concentration, and had twice pushed for much greater party democracy to offset the growth of the bureaucracy.

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Dec 16 2024 6:53 utc | 66

Says Ahenobarbus,

I don’t have a good link, but it’s unquestionable that it was Stalin who was in fact surprised by Germany’s attack which corresponds to the Nazis initial gains deep into Russia.

Yes, and yes to that. However, there is an argument in which the above observation actually supports the claim Suvorov and others (notably Bernd Schwipper) are making. It presents the Red Army as prepared to attack westwards, and the move being preempted by the Wehrmacht by mere weeks in the summer of 1941.
I am no military historian, but here is what I learned about this idea.
Suvorov’s book “Icebreaker” is not the only account where Stalin is an aggressor, too. Please note that it does not follow that Stalin is the only original aggressor in this unfortunate chapter of history; and as a German, I feel compelled to say that I have no excuse for the Drang nach Osten rhetoric which claimed a need for Lebensraum at the expense of Slav Untermenschen. Indeed the communist ideology is inclusive of all human beings, while that of the Nazis is not, and this point alone tells clearly that the Soviet Union won the good fight in the end. To add, I sincerely hoped that no man in their right mind would ever entertain the idea of waging anything remotely reminiscent of this war ever again; a dear belief likewise held by me and every Russian I have ever met in my live. The West Germany of today is an abberration of this history which puts me to shame almost beyond words.
From a purely military perspective there are strong indications that the Red Army was well set up to roll, and caught out in an offensive posture by German forces. They had forward airfields and tanks designed to wheel on paved roads; all diaries by Ostfront soldiers report endless columns lined up at the border; and the initial German success is against an enemy in the worst state of readiness to repel an attacking opponent. The last point is very important, so I shall encourage the surely present experts on battlegroup maneouvering to please chime in with their knowledge, to either corroborate or disprove this pivotal argument.
When it was over, a few things remained to be cleared. The Bundeswehr (official FRG) Institute of military history went through the records of Barbarossa, which took them till the mid-seventies; at last, just one question remained: who had actually started this war? The answer was left to a political decision.

Posted by: persiflo | Dec 16 2024 6:55 utc | 67

Try n link to what psychohistorian & James couldn’t which prolly wont get through as url says it like it is.

Posted by: Debsisdead | Dec 16 2024 9:10 utc | 68

james @53: “…the best thing trump could do would be to exit nato, but i doubt very much the military-banking-energy complex would let him do such a thing…”
You are absolutely correct, but while Trump may not be a super-genius, he realizes that too. That is why Trump is going to dismantle NATO in a backhanded and roundabout way.
Yes, Trump is going to “outwit” the Establishment, as he did when getting America out of Afghanistan. Of course, if he succeeds, it will only be because the Establishment is run by hysterical TDS chimps who are so brain damaged they make Trump look like a genius in comparison.
Take a look a some of the headlines denk posted @63:

South Korea to increase its defense spending to 3 percent or 3.5
Taiwan might face impossible expectations from US president-elect who has called for island to drastically increase military spending.
Trump demands NATO allies spend at least 3 percent of …

“…impossible expectations…”
Korea and Taiwan are not NATO, but Trump’s approach to disentanglement is the same: Keep upping the demands on the “partners” until they are forced to run away.
There are some other “tricks” Trump is setting up as well, but this gives you an idea how he could succeed in pulling American resources back to focus on America despite full-throated opposition from the neolibcons.
Sure, it doesn’t seem so clever when spelled out, but it could likely work because the Establishment is remarkably stupid, but considers itself brilliant. This leaves huge blind spots that Trump can exploit.

Posted by: William Gruff | Dec 16 2024 11:18 utc | 69

Posted by: William Gruff | Dec 16 2024 11:18 utc | 71
There are some other “tricks” Trump is setting up as well
I kinda like this one.

Posted by: john | Dec 16 2024 12:26 utc | 70

@Don Bacon, 46

Nato boss Mark Rutte calls on European members of Nato to spend less on pensions, health and social security and more on defence “to preserve our way of life”.

That sounds like the US Vietnam War doctrine of destroying a village to save a village.

Posted by: cirsium | Dec 16 2024 13:24 utc | 71

What is happening (or about to happen) in Myanmar?
Front-page article in the NYT this morning (Monday) about the terrible economic conditions there. The focus is on highly educated women (doctors and nurses) driven to prostitution just to make ends meet. We don’t usually see much propaganda about Myanmar beyond the occasional story about the ‘rag-tag army of plucky rebels trying to bring democracy to their country’.
Of course, we never hear anything about who is providing money, weapons, ammunition and logistic support to these rebels (could it be, CIA?) or why the economy is in the toilet (could it be, US sanctions?). Funding and supplying an army is not cheap.
One thing is clear from the geography: Myanmar is strategically placed on the southeast border of China and has a long coastline on the Bay of Bengal. Now, what country (or empire) might wish to stir up trouble along China’s border? And introduce a puppet regime with a fake democracy? Let me guess…
And why would NYT be increasing coverage of the humanitarian crisis, unless to soften our hearts and lead us toward a desire to intervene? — purely for the sake of the people, of course!

Posted by: Clever Dog | Dec 16 2024 14:01 utc | 72

Mark Rutte is a frontman who doesn’t write the song he’s singing. All of NATO can jump up and down as much as they like, if the US announces it’s going to pull out they will, and the rest of the ‘west’ is reduced to humming along for the chorus. Just like the cheesy lines from Rutte above, the noise we’re getting from Korea, or the hollow echoes of Scholzen’s Bundesregierung breakdown as soon as there is a change in beat.
Gruff has it right with the picture of upcoming rhetoric, but I believe it is already mostly without meaning. The big decisions are made, of have been made backstage; the rest is thunder and fury signifying nothing. I just hope the fireworks going off on stage now don’t cause any harmful accidents.

Posted by: persiflo | Dec 16 2024 14:07 utc | 73

@Posted by: persiflo | Dec 16 2024 6:55 utc | 68
You are spreading Nazi and Cold War propaganda which has been very widely debunked and the opposite very well supported. Including by the opening of the Kremlin archives to historians. This opening also helped debunk the nonsense numbers thrown around for “The Terror” (less than a million died over he 1930s) and the invented rubbish called “The Holodomor”, a natural disaster made worse by class war not any intentional attempt to starve the population of 404.
Stalin stated that others would attempt to destroy his legacy through lies, as with the West, Trotsky, Khrushchev, Brezhnev, Gorbachev etc. And now with a new Cold War we get a new crop of black propagandists.

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Dec 16 2024 14:21 utc | 74

Perdue

Han audacity shocks me !
They follow the Confucius edict
‘One sky cant have two suns’.
They had four thousands years of hegemony.
They want it back, now !

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 3:59 utc | 62
———–
What crock!
The Han spent five thousands years of history fending off invaders.
Xiongnu, Huns, Jin, Manchu, Mongols, Tibetans, Anglo, Euro, Jap,, Indians…
You name it !
Practically the entire who’s who of
the global genocidaire
Their latest iteration being none other than the G7
Mind you, they’ve been trying to rope in the Mongols , who ‘share many values‘ !

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 14:22 utc | 75

@ Posted by: Philly | Dec 16 2024 8:08 utc | 69
Yes, I was also struck by the odd writing in that article. But I think the problem is not that it is bad journalism. Rather, as you note in your last paragraph, it is just another piece of anti-China propaganda. The best way to read NYT, in my opinion, is to treat every article as propaganda and then ask myself, Why is NYT publishing this article today, in this position on the page? I take it as a given that the article is intended to shape my opinion rather than to provide me with objective facts (though I can glean some facts out of it).
In this case, part of the message is that BRICS is actually a real threat to the US empire, so it’s time to ratchet up fear and anger against those who support it, China in particular. Up until now, the BRICS idea has generally been downplayed in NYT articles, or completely ignored by not publishing anything about it. Paul Krugman and other prominent NYT pundits, when they do mention BRICS, just pooh-pooh it as a wild fantasy. Maybe the wheel is turning a bit, now.

Posted by: Clever Dog | Dec 16 2024 14:23 utc | 76

@Posted by: Philly | Dec 16 2024 8:08 utc | 69
Most of those policy “experts” and “journalists” cannot even speak or read Mandarin and have a very superficial understanding of Chinese history. That is why they keep failing again and again and again. In contrast, China has studied the West in great detail.

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Dec 16 2024 14:24 utc | 77

@Posted by: Roger Boyd | Dec 16 2024 14:21 utc | 76
Same with Solzhenitsyn, who has been proven to be an utter liar and fabricator. His major works were the product of a fantasist. Even his wife described Gulag Archipelago as “folklore”. A more detailed debunking: https://www.idcommunism.com/2018/01/gulag-archipelago-exposing.html
Such people were highly motivated to lie about the Soviet Union in the worst ways, as it greatly increased their receptivity in the West. At the very same time we have people like Conquest etc. being lauded for writing utter fabrications about the Soviet Union. Anything that could be used to denigrate socialism and communism was heavily marketed. As we see in the present with respect to Russia and China.

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Dec 16 2024 14:31 utc | 78

, but Trump’s approach to disentanglement is the same: Keep upping the demands on the “partners” until they are forced to run away.
Posted by: William Gruff | Dec 16 2024 11:18 utc | 71
—————–
When uncle sham hollers, everybody jumps !

Nato boss say Donald Trump is ‘right’ on need to boost …
London Evening Standard
https://www.standard.co.uk › News › Politics
3 days ago — Mark Rutte said US president-elect Donald Trump was ‘right’ that there should be more spending on defence.

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 14:31 utc | 79

From Vanessa Beeley:
Translation of President Assad’s alleged first statement since leaving Syria, published by the Syrian Presidency channel:
Translation in English
‘With the expansion of terrorism in Syria, and its arrival in the capital Damascus on the evening of Saturday, December 7, 2024, questions began to be raised about the fate and location of the president, amidst a torrent of confusion and stories far from the truth, which constituted support for the process of installing international terrorism concealed as a Syrian liberation revolution.
At a critical historical moment in the life of the nation, when truth should have a place, there is something that needs to be clarified through a brief statement. These circumstances and the subsequent complete cessation of communication for security reasons did not allow for it to be made, and its brief points do not replace the narration of the details of everything that happened later, when the opportunity arises.
First of all, I did not leave the country in a planned manner as was rumored, nor did I leave it during the last hours of the battles, but rather I remained in Damascus following up on my responsibilities until the early morning hours of Sunday, December 8, 2024. With the expansion of terrorism inside Damascus, I moved in coordination with my Russian friends to Latakia to follow up on the combat operations from there. Upon arriving at the Hmeimim base in the morning, it became clear that the forces had withdrawn from all the battle lines and that the last army positions had fallen, with the deterioration of the field situation in that area increasing, and the attack on the Russian military base itself being escalated by drones. In light of the impossibility of leaving the base in any direction, Moscow asked the base leadership to work on securing immediate evacuation to Russia on the evening of Sunday, December 8, the day after the fall of Damascus, and after the fall of the last military positions and the subsequent paralysis of the rest of the state institutions.
During those events, the issue of asylum or resignation was not raised by me or by any person or party, and the only option presented was to continue fighting in defense of the terrorist attack.
In this context, I emphasize that whoever, since the first day of the war, refused to trade his country’s salvation for personal salvation, or to bargain with his people with various offers and temptations, is the same person who stood with the officers and soldiers of his army on the front lines, dozens of meters away from the terrorists in the hottest and most dangerous hotbeds of conflict, and is the same person who did not leave during the most difficult years of the war and remained with his family and people to face terrorism under bombardment and the danger of terrorists storming the capital more than once during fourteen years of war. And whoever did not abandon the non-Syrian resistance in Palestine and Lebanon, and did not betray his allies who stood with him, cannot be the same person who abandons his people to whom he belongs, or betrays them and his army.
I have never been a person who seeks positions on a personal level, but rather I considered myself the owner of a national project that derived its support from a people who believed in it. I carried the certainty of the will of that people and their ability to preserve their state and defend its institutions and choices until the last moment. With the fall of the state into the hands of terrorism, and the loss of the ability to provide anything, the position becomes empty and meaningless, and there is no meaning to remaining responsible in it. This does not mean in any way abandoning the authentic national affiliation to Syria and its people, a fixed affiliation that is not changed by position or circumstance, a affiliation filled with hope that Syria will return free and independent.’

Posted by: JB | Dec 16 2024 14:32 utc | 80

gringo have been trying to nail the Myanmar junta for ages,
Trump did his part in term one,…

While he was threatening People’s Korea, Iran and Venezuela in his United Nations speech, U.S. President Donald Trump also demanded that the U.N. Security Council take “strong and swift action” to end violence against Myanmar’s Rohingya population.
U.S. government officials, including U.S. Ambassador to the U.N. Nikki Haley, Secretary of State Rex Tillerson and Vice President Mike Pence, have called for immediate action and delivery of humanitarian aid to the rohingya.’

OMFGawd, genocides in Myanmar !
http://www.gearoidocolmain.org/rohingya-psyops-us-covert-war-myanmar/
There are many unfinished biz Trump wanna pick up where he left off, such as Myanmar, Fentanyl, wuflu, Trade war.

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 14:55 utc | 81

shit !
Should’ve checked that link first …
https://tinyurl.com/nkse34ne

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 15:10 utc | 82

Should’ve checked that link first !
https://tinyurl.com/nkse34ne

Posted by: denk | Dec 16 2024 15:13 utc | 83

Monroe Doctrine:
The Monroe Doctrine is a U.S. foreign policy that opposes European colonialism in the Americas.
It’s working! China is taking over.
from Foreign Policy
What China Got Right in Latin America

To compete in the region, a second Trump administration needs to do more than saber-rattle.
China’s President Xi Jinping (L) and Peru’s President Dina Boluarte applaud during the virtual inauguration ceremony of the Chancay “megaport” at the government palace in Lima on Nov. 14.
It was one of those photos that says so much—how Washington’s diplomatic and economic presence has declined in Latin America, a region that the United States has long considered to be its unique zone of influence. In the group shot for November’s Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) summit in Lima, Peru, Chinese President Xi Jinping stood in the front row next to the host president, Dina Boluarte of Peru. Xi was beaming while in the back row, U.S. President Joe Biden cut a distant figure.
Xi had reason to beam. The summit was the unofficial ribbon cutting of a $3.6 billion Chinese-backed mega port in Chancay that will transport Peruvian and many other South American exports to Asia’s hungry markets. The massive infrastructure project marked not only a new stage in China’s decades long attempt to win over the Western Hemisphere, but also came at a moment when the United States has failed to match diplomatic and economic rhetoric with action and investment.
Since coming to power in 2013, the Chinese president has visited Latin America six different times across 11 countries. That’s more than the last three U.S. presidents combined made over the same period. Beyond the visits, though, China has brought real resources to address development opportunities that have long been lacking in the region—and that the United States has failed to recognize for decades. . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 16 2024 15:24 utc | 84

@ Debsisdead | Dec 16 2024 9:10 utc | 70 with the link to the NOT Luigi manifesto
That is not what I have and what should come out if it is true fairly soon.
Ping me if you want a copy. B has not released my nor james’s copies and it may still be too hot……I want to see it out there so we can find out if true or not….family and Luigi is still alive and can confirm/deny

Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 16 2024 15:29 utc | 85

Head of Southern Command warns of China’s growing technological grip in region
Gen. Laura Richardson is concerned about Beijing’s infrastructure investments in Latin America.

U.S. Southern Command is working deliberately via conferences, exercises and other engagements to inform international military partners in the region of China’s escalating presence and influence within their communications and technological infrastructure — and help them counter it, Gen. Laura Richardson said on Friday.
“I think that we have to truly appreciate what this region brings and the security challenges that these countries face,” the Southcom commander urged at a virtual event hosted by the Center for Strategic and International Studies.
For the Pentagon, China is “at the top of the list … as a pacing challenge or an adversary,” she noted. . . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 16 2024 15:30 utc | 86

Great news from the frozen hockey rink. The Dominatrix High Priestess of all thing Ukraine, has resigned.
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Dec 16 2024 16:18 utc | 87

Thanks for the feedback, gents.
Fanto: provides an unfamiliar author, which was interesting.
Boyd: recognizes the Soviets were not the aggressor in WW2, but spends too much time trying to defend Stalin who introduced something alien to Marxism: nationalist utopianism, which ultimately killed the it off.
Persifilo: provides greater detail about the war and it’s human toll with some genuine human feeling.
We don’t agree on it all but the discussion of this history, which seems likely to be repeated in an original way, is good for us all. Helps one understand what humanity is facing with the Zionazis.

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Dec 16 2024 16:19 utc | 88

Every country lies sometimes. And a rich country is able to lie more than a poor country. But with migration, renewable energy and war against Russia at the same time, truth is catching up with Germany.

Germany Is Unraveling Just When Europe Needs It Most
High energy costs and slumping exports have made German households €2,500 poorer and the decline threatens to become irreversible. (bloomberg, paywall)

The bloomberg article itself is not important – just the fact that decline has become too large to deny.
The Germans themselves are taking it with humor and sarcasm:

Germany too unsafe – Syria suspends deportations.
Unclear political conditions, a chaotic infrastructure and Christmas markets that are far too expensive: the new rulers in Syria have decided not to deport any Assad supporters to Germany for the time being.
In a grand human gesture, the new rulers in Syria – the Islamist militia Hayat Tahrir al-Sham (HTS) – have decided not to deport any supporters of the fallen dictator Bashar al-Assad to Germany for the time being.
Following the collapse of the German regime, the political situation in Germany is currently far too volatile to send anyone there with a clear conscience, HTS leader Abu Mohammed al-Jolani explained.(welt)

Yes, German humor is alive and well.

Posted by: Passerby | Dec 16 2024 16:22 utc | 89

Monroe Doctine? EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen has landed in Latin America to finalise the Mercosur agreement whilst Europe’s key opponent against the deal suffers government collapse. “Touchdown in Latin America, the finish line of the EU-Mercosur agreement is in sight,” von der Leyen posted on Twitter on Thursday, adding: “Let’s work, let’s cross it. We have the chance to create a market of 700 million people. The largest trade and investment partnership the world has ever seen. Both regions will benefit.” . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Dec 16 2024 16:31 utc | 90

Trudeau went to see the Don. Upon return, the Governor of Canada offers the Dominatrix a new position, she refused and resigned. Chalk that one up for Trump.
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Dec 16 2024 16:34 utc | 91

Von der Leyen about the trade treaty with South America “We have the chance to create a market of 700 million people. The largest trade and investment partnership the world has ever seen.”
Think about it: 700 million people – that is a little bit less than half India.

Posted by: Passerby | Dec 16 2024 16:36 utc | 92

@ Debsisdead | Dec 16 2024 9:10 utc | 72 // psychohistorian | Dec 16 2024 15:29 utc | 89
bernhard let it go thru the filter @ 55 – for anyone who wants to read it.. i am not 100% certain luigi mangione actually wrote it but there it is for others to read, if interested..
@ William Gruff | Dec 16 2024 11:18 utc | 73
well, i hope trumps game plan works… i watched the rest of the alex krainer and nima interview last night…it seems all of this 2 or 3% money on nato goes to the usa-germany-uk and france military industrial complex corporations… you’d think countries would get tired of supporting this.. and then there is mark rutte saying the countries have to cut back on social benefits and etc. etc… where do they find insane people like rutte to lead nato? i know – they are everywhere.. i too like what @ john | Dec 16 2024 12:26 utc | 74 shared in this regard… i haven’t given up hope on people or trump… we’ll see if he can change the direction of the titanic.. it doesn’t look promising, but maybe it is possible.. thanks for your comment..

Posted by: james | Dec 16 2024 16:41 utc | 93

@ sean the leprechaun | Dec 16 2024 16:34 utc | 95
maybe she listened to my wishes and has finally decided to move into her apartment in kiev??

Posted by: james | Dec 16 2024 16:42 utc | 94

william gruff – here is a quote from today ( monday ) on rt and from putin… he is coming around to your viewpoint..
“The West’s support for Ukraine is pushing Russia to the point where it cannot help but retaliate, President Vladimir Putin has said, while warning the US against deploying medium-range missiles.
Speaking at a meeting of top Russian Defense Ministry officials on Monday, Putin accused the US of seeking “to weaken our country and inflict a strategic defeat” on Moscow by continuing “to pump a de facto illegitimate ruling regime in Kiev with weapons and money, sending mercenaries and military advisers, thereby encouraging further escalation of the conflict.”

Posted by: james | Dec 16 2024 16:44 utc | 95

It took CNN 4 days to start questioning what was obviously a ridiculous story conveniently making it’s “chief International Reporter'” look like a heroine. When I first saw the film I actually laughed.
“Man filmed by CNN ‘being rescued’ from Assad jail was ‘(Assad) regime torturer’
…..The man, found under a blanket in a prison in Damascus by Clarissa Ward, the broadcaster’s chief international correspondent, claimed he had been arrested three months ago and interrogated about his phone contacts.”
“The footage was described as “remarkable” by CNN’s head of communication at the time, praising Ward and her team for finding “a Syrian prisoner left behind in a secret prison, alone and unaware the Assad regime was no more”.
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/12/15/syria-jail-man-rescued-filmed-false-identity-cnn-fact-check/
THIS IS EXACTLY WHY WE NEED SITES LIKE THIS ONE

Posted by: Dennis | Dec 16 2024 17:16 utc | 96

— ❗️🇩🇪 NEW: German Chancellor Olaf Scholz loses no-confidence vote in parliament, snap elections will be held in February 2025

https://t.me/Middle_East_Spectator/13870

Posted by: Norwegian | Dec 16 2024 17:21 utc | 97

Scholz lost the vote of confidence, German election incoming in February. Opinion polling puts Merz’s CDS/CDU at 32%, AfD at 19%, SPD 17%, Greens 12%, BSW 7%, FDP 5%.
The cut off in Germany is 5%, so the FDP could be left out in the cold. Probably a CDS/CDU plus SPD coalition to keep the AfD away from power. Merz is full on NATO and escalations with Russia. No real change from the traffic light coalition. So, five more years of shit for the German people unless they wake up and vote AfD and BSW. There will of course be wall-to-wall propaganda against both of those parties between now and the election. Main CDS/CDU policy planks are:
– Increase defence spending
– Continue Ukrainian War with Russia
– Lower taxes
– Cancel the basic citizens allowance (i.e. cut benefits for the poorest)
– Limit immigration
– 1 year national service
– Law & Order
– Non-acceptance of gender over sex
– Increase retirement age
– Full on support for the Zionist regime
– A “balanced approach on China”
The two main areas of disagreement with Trump will be on Ukraine (too “hard”) and China (too “soft”), otherwise completely compatible with Trump’s policy mix.

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Dec 16 2024 17:34 utc | 98

And Canada’s finance minister, Freeland (yes her of Banderist grand parentage) resigns hours before she is supposed to be presenting the latest financial statement to parliament! This shit show may just produce a motion of no confidence and then an election and then … frying pan (Trudeau) into the fire (Polievre). Really bad for the NDP’s Singh though, he will be punished for propping up the Liberals and he hasn’t earned his parliamentary pension yet!

Posted by: Roger Boyd | Dec 16 2024 17:40 utc | 99

Re “China Threat”, the US government seems to want poverty and great submissiveness from Post-communist China.

Posted by: zhubajie | Dec 16 2024 17:51 utc | 100