Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
October 5, 2024
The ‘Birth Pangs’ Of The New Middle East May Not Be The Ones The U.S. Has Wished For

Edward Luce for the FT:

How Netanyahu is ‘running rings’ around Biden (archived)
The US president had hoped to disentangle from the Middle East. But the turbulence in the region could influence the election and define his legacy

“Netanyahu knows how to play the Washington game better than most US politicians,” says Alon Pinkas, a former Israeli diplomat, now columnist for the Haaretz newspaper. “And he has been running rings around Biden.”

On countless occasions over the past year, Netanyahu has appeared to agree to one thing with Washington and done the opposite in practice. Whether it is wranglings over the terms of a Gaza ceasefire and hostage release, or the more recent attempt at a 21-day ceasefire with Hizbollah, each time Biden is left looking impotent. “The Biden administration seems to be saying, ‘We’re suffering from a bit of autumn damp,’ ” says Pinkas. “No, this isn’t seasonal damp, it’s Netanyahu urinating all over you.

This has been the general theme of a media campaign for a while. "Natanyahoo is steamrolling Biden and the poor guy can do nothing about it."

I do not buy it. One phone call from the White House to the Pentagon would hold resupply flights from the U.S. to Israel. Without constant supply renewal the Israeli Air Force would have to stop its bombing campaigns in Gaza, the West Bank, Lebanon, Syria and Yemen within days if not within hours.

But instead of calling the Pentagon the whole Middle East team around Biden, Antony Blinken, Brett McGurk and IDF soldier Amos Hochstein, has been urging Israel to extend its campaign.

They are hoping, like the neoconservatives in 2006 during the Bush administration, for the 'birth pangs of a new Middle East', which will forever change the strategic situation on the ground.

Behind the scenes, Hochstein, McGurk and other top U.S. national security officials are describing Israel’s Lebanon operations as a history-defining moment — one that will reshape the Middle East for the better for years to come.

The thinking goes: Israel has obliterated Hezbollah’s top command structure in Lebanon, severely undercutting the group’s capabilities and weakened Iran, which used Hezbollah as a proxy and power projector.

The internal administration division seems to have dissipated somewhat in recent days, with top U.S. officials convening Monday at the White House with President Joe Biden to discuss the situation on the ground. Most agreed that the conflict, while fragile, could offer an opportunity to reduce Iran’s influence in Lebanon and the region.

The conclusion from this is that Netanyahoo is largely doing exactly what the Biden administration wants him to do.

The strategic situation may well change. But it is not going to be the way Biden and Netanyahoo may hope for.

Most of the 200 missiles Iran fired on Israel two days ago passed through the Israeli air defenses and hit their targets with good precision. Some expensive air planes got damaged but no one was hurt. A similar strike on Israeli energy facilities could easily disable the country for months of years to come. A strike on IDF barracks or Israeli population centers could easily cause mass casualties.

Shortly after the strike President Masoud Pezeshkian met with Saudi Arabia's Foreign Minister Faisal bin Farhan Al Saud in Doha, Qatar:

The Saudi minister voiced his country's determination to develop relations with Iran, Xinhua news agency reported.

"We seek to close the page of differences between the two countries forever and work towards the resolution of our issues and expansion of our relations like two friendly and brotherly states," he said.

He highlighted the "very sensitive and critical" situation in West Asia due to Israel's "aggressions" against Gaza and Lebanon and its attempts to expand the conflict in the region. He said Saudi Arabia trusted Iran's wisdom and discernment in managing the situation and contributing to the restoration of calm and peace in the region.

Yesterday the Supreme Leader of Iran, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, held Friday prayers in Tehran. Little remarked in western media was the fact that he sermon was largely voiced in Arabic and that the whole event was seen on Arabic live TV through AlJazeerah.

This already is a new Middle East in which the Gulf states are no longer hostile to Iran and which the religious schisms between Sunni and Shia has largely lost its power.

Who then is left of the former U.S. allies? On whom can it call for support in the region when it plans to attack Iran?

Has this whole U.S.-Israeli campaign really helped to "reduce Iran’s influence in Lebanon and the region"? Will continuing it ever do so?

My impression for one is that it has strengthened the front against Israel and the positions of Iran in and beyond the Middle East.

Comments

Posted by: too scents | Oct 6 2024 14:13 utc | 486 “Given the position of the privileged in the US”
There’s a preaching by name of John Hagee, whom I gather is the main man behind CUFI (Citizens United for Israel,) which is effectively incorporated as a parapolitical Republican Party (i.e., Trumpist) outfit. Hagee is indeed privileged compared to most workers, but he is by no means a member of the big bourgeoisie. A quick Google says, app. $5 million for Hagee ministries. That’s pitiful by the standards of the real big shots. But, his operation is tax exempt. That’s privilege. Probably to most of the real rulers he counts as a working stiff (and he may have hobnobbed enough with real money to think he is?)
By the way, if anyone is “PMC,” so is John Hagee, but Hagee is very much a Trumper the last I looked. My conclusion is “PMC” is too vague, to thoughtless to serve as an analytical concept.
In practice, every congregation in America is mostly dominated by the privileged, in comparison to the rest of the congregation.

Posted by: steven t johnson | Oct 6 2024 18:12 utc | 501

“Archimedes is famous for saying give me a fixed point and I can move the world. That sort of thing…”
Posted by: juliania | Oct 6 2024 16:27 utc | 503
Actually, Archimedes said, “Give me a lever long enough and a fulcrum on which to place it and I shall move the world”

Posted by: canuck | Oct 6 2024 19:03 utc | 502

“After the discovery of oil at Prudhoe Bay, US did the deal with the Saudi’s to create the petro-dollar.”
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 6 2024 10:17 utc | 430
——————————————————-
I could be wrong, but I thought the dollar as reserve currency and petro-dollar were created after Nixon, aided and abetted by Germany voting ‘No’ in the G7, abandoned the gold standard.”
Posted by: Acco Hengst | Oct 6 2024 14:27 utc | 490
The Petro dollar, as I understand it, was created in 73-74 between Nixon (Kissinger was the bag man)/ America where Saudi could raise the oil prices as much as they wanted to as long a good portion was buying US Treasuries-in return the US extended their military umbrella to them
Never heard of Prudhoe Bay being involved in this issue.

Posted by: canuck | Oct 6 2024 19:11 utc | 503

So I’m not sure which God Evangelicals worship, it doesn’t appear to be Christ.
Posted by: Turk 152 | Oct 6 2024 14:23 utc | 489
Turk 152, I’d heard he was the “son,” not the big guy himself. Grin.

Posted by: Sakineh Bagoom | Oct 6 2024 19:43 utc | 504

“Is Kamy Harris on board with losing the demo left wing if the US bombs Iran?”
_____
There’s no “left wing” so it can’t be lost.
Posted by: malenkov | Oct 6 2024 2:31 utc | 343
—————————————————————
There is a left wing in the US and the EU, as small as it is, and it does not support Harris. For many years people who pretended to be the leadership of the left, even the CPUSA, drove the real left into the arms of the Democratic Party, on the bases of the lesser evil. In the process, the left lost the art of class struggle and the means to struggle.
I see evidence that that is starting to change. However, the big problem that haunts the left today is an old one; and that is it’s incessant need to argue over bullshit and minutia, and its aversion to self educate.

Posted by: Ed | Oct 6 2024 21:14 utc | 505

@post 410 Arch Bungle
Where does this information come from?

Posted by: Anon | Oct 7 2024 1:32 utc | 506

Re:
Nuclear test?
@ Apollyon | Oct 5 2024 20:09 utc | 135
Or maybe HAARP.
Posted by: teri | Oct 5 2024 23:05 utc | 246
Just your typical Iran seismic activity, most likely. The whole area is littered with fault lines.
If it was a nuclear test, it would tend to register closer to M5+ (unless it was tiny). I recall when NK did a test back around 2015 and it was recorded as an M5.1-M5.3 depending on the agency.

Posted by: Jon_in_AU | Oct 7 2024 4:32 utc | 507

To add to previous comment, according to the European seismic website ESMC/CSEM, there have been over 100 earthquakes of magnitude M4+ in Iran in the past year.
I’d say it was a typical run-of-the-mill earthquake.

Posted by: Jon_in_AU | Oct 7 2024 4:39 utc | 508

CalDre | Oct 5 2024 18:45 utc | 81
Thanks for confirming you’re not an American – you know nothing about this country, its history, its culture, its motivations nor desires.
________
What country are you referring to when you say “this country”?

Posted by: Gene Poole | Oct 7 2024 7:03 utc | 509

My previous post was intended for Markw, not for CalDre. Apologies. My point was that Markw and now motorslug, in
Posted by: Markw | Oct 5 2024 19:23 utc | 96
and
Posted by: motorslug | Oct 5 2024 19:38 utc | 105,
both use the phrase “this country” as if it were automatically understood as meaning the USA. As far as I know, b is located in Europe, and if the Bar has any physical location it would be in whatever country he is located in, would it not?
Or is the assumption that because the language of the Bar is English it is somehow in and of the United States?

Posted by: Gene Poole | Oct 7 2024 8:17 utc | 510

I’m typing this as F16s are making their first appearance of the day. There should be at least 1m people watching over the weekend, cheering and feeling a rush of patriotism as “our boys” demonstrate why we’re #1. …
Posted by: Markw | Oct 5 2024 19:46 utc | 111
________________________
Who are “we”? Do you mean citizens of the United States? What event are you referring to that a million people will be watching?
It seems that even in your irony you can’t escape from a US-centric vision.

Posted by: Gene Poole | Oct 7 2024 8:26 utc | 511

Delhiterly 22(?). No, the Arab Spring was a spontaneous uprising in Tunisia, the protests in Egypt were legit, after that the CIA co-opted the movement to install Al Sisi (our Intel connection/back channel to Mubarak). The rest of the Arab Spring revolts were CIA hangouts

Posted by: Scottindallas | Oct 7 2024 13:35 utc | 512

– I also think the US has also A LOT OF “birth pangs” / “headaches” when it comes to the situation in the Middle East. I also think that these “Birth Pangs” could blow the US to pieces.

Posted by: WMG | Oct 10 2024 13:18 utc | 513