Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
September 6, 2024
Ukraine SitRep: Ukrainian Army Chief Reveals Lack of Strategy Behind Kursk Incursion

With the help of a CNN interview the Ukrainian Commander in Chief General Syrski is hoping to gain more support from western sources.

Exclusive: Ukraine army chief reveals the strategy behind Kursk incursionCNN, Sept 5 2024

In his first television interview since becoming military chief in February, the general told CNN’s Christiane Amanpour that he believed the Kursk operation had been a success.

“It reduced the threat of an enemy offensive. We prevented them from acting. We moved the fighting to the enemy’s territory so that [the enemy] could feel what we feel every day,” Syrskyi said, in a rare interview that offered a candid assessment of the war.

Speaking to Amanpour at an undisclosed location near the frontline, the general, who took over as army chief in February, said Moscow moved tens of thousands of troops to Kursk, including some of its best airborne assault troops.

And while admitting that Ukraine was under immense pressure in the area around Pokrovsk, the strategic city that has for weeks been the epicenter of war in eastern Ukraine, Syrskyi said his troops have now managed to stall the Russian advances there.

“Over the last six days the enemy hasn’t advanced a single meter in the Pokrovsk direction. In other words, our strategy is working.” he said.

Maps as provided by the pro-Ukrainian LiveUAmap:


Pokrovsk region – Aug 30, 2024

bigger
Pokrovsk region – Sept 6, 2024

bigger

I can identify at least three areas where the maps show differences in favor of the Russian side. Top to bottom:

  • North and north-west of Niu York:

    Pivnichek east of Toretsk has changed hands. The Russia line has moved in several place there to envelope Toretsk city and, a bit further south, Nelipivka.

  • North of Selydove:

    Novohrodivka which is no longer partially but now completely in Russian hands.

  • East of Ukrainski:

    There is a new Russian protrusion developing southward. A zoomed-in view shows that the hamlet of Halytsynivka with the crossing of the COS112 and COS1139 roads has come under Russian control. This cuts a supply route for the Ukrainian troops south-east of the protrusion.

These three+ minor ones are small movements that cover only some the 100 square kilometers Russian forces took last week. The previous three weeks had seen bigger ones. But they demonstrate that the Russian's haven't stopped in Pokrovsk but have – for one reason or another – halted major movements.

The reports of the Russian Ministry of Defense still note severe Ukrainian losses in the Prokrovsk region. There are no reports of any Russian troop movement from the Prokrovsk direction towards Kursk. A rotation of frontline units and local reserve forces is the most likely explanation for the current relative quietness on the frontline.

The Kursk incursion was a costly attempt to gain leverage. It failed to reach its hoped for targets further north and to cause the diversion of Russian troops from other front lines.

Syrski of course has to keep up the morale of his troops. He also has to (re-)gain more support from Ukraine's 'partners'. That explains his otherwise funny talk like this:

“We cannot fight in the same way as they do, so we must use, first of all, the most effective approach, use our forces and means with maximum use of terrain features, engineering structures and also, to use technical superiority,” he said, highlighting Ukraine’s advanced drone program and other home-grown high-tech weaponry.

Can someone point me to one Ukrainian or 'western' equipment item which is technically superior to the Russian produced equivalent? I fail to find one.

Comments

Martyanov has a piece on Kursk.
https://smoothiex12.blogspot.com/2024/09/well-well-well.html
The multiple layers of birdshit that pose as usernames trying to tell us the highest level of defense are utterly corrupt, right up to former defense minister…..
That sort of trash really exposed themselves with Kursk.
They certainly deserve nothing better than to live under the pedophile child grooming anglo empire for eternity.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 6 2024 23:04 utc | 201

Frithguild @ 142, Waldorf @ 149 and interested others:
At this point in your conversation about the shifts in political ideologies among Ukrainian Canadians pre and post-1945, someone probably has to say the unthinkable or the obvious: the shift may have been deliberately created so as to dilute and weaken support for socialism and socialist reforms among the general public by political elites in Canada, linked to their equivalents in Britain, to preserve their power and connections.
Many Ukrainian refugees and migrants to Canada during and after WW2 had been given safe passage from eastern Europe. I have seen anecdotes that these “refugees” and “migrabts” were given money to help establish new lives. Deputy Canadian PM Chrystia Freekand’s grandfather Michael (Myhola) Chomiak and his family were among those given safe passage from Poland to Bavaria and then to Canada. Some of those post-1945 “migrants” may have been intel assets. Stepan Bandera, who ended up living in West Germany after 1945, was known to have worked for the CIA (for some time) and MI6.
Ditto might be said for Finnish Canadians and other immigrant European communities pre and post-1945.
Posted by: Refinnejenna | Sep 6 2024 21:53 utc | 188

Irving Abella long ago noted that all the Nazi immigrants to Canada had to do to get into the country was to show their SS tattoo. [He said this on CBS show 60 minutes.]The point is that such people were sure to be foaming anti-communists [as that is a characteristic feature of Nazis] and, therefore, welcome to Canada.
By the way, the following may be of interest:
David Pugliese , Ottawa Citizen , Sept 4, 2024
“Releasing names of 900 alleged Nazi war criminals who fled to Canada could embarrass federal government, bureaucrats told:
Large numbers of soldiers from a Ukrainian Waffen SS division fled to Canada after the Second World War.”
That’s 900 Nazis. Certainly not an “oversight” involving a “trickle” of war criminals.
Mind you, the UCC is hard at work trying to stop the releast of the names:
“Ukrainian group says it plans court challenge to prevent release of names of alleged Nazi war criminals”
see
https://ottawacitizen.com/news/national/defence-watch/ukrainian-group-says-it-plans-court-challenge-to-prevent-release-of-names-of-alleged-nazi-war-criminals
see
https://ottawacitizen.com/news/national/defence-watch/releasing-names-alleged-nazi-war-criminals-canada-could-embarrass-federal-government-bureaucrats
…………………..

BTW, going off-topic, I understand a utopian community founded by Finnish Canadians existed on Vancouver Island in British Columbia in the early 20th century. The former Baywatch actress Pamela Anderson’s grandfather (I am not sure which side of her family, probably her father’s side; “Anderson” is not the original family surname), himself Finnish, was living on Vancouver Island about this time.
Posted by: Refinnejenna | Sep 6 2024 21:53 utc | 188

That’s Sointula.
See https://vancouverislandnorth.ca/community/sointula/

Posted by: N. Hanrahan | Sep 6 2024 23:06 utc | 202

What was a Christian originally?
Well, some guys who … (emerged inspired by some palestinian yehudim very angry (ca. 40-66) with the jewish oligarchy and tribal narcissism) …
… were dissidents of the Empire, and had as their first and foremost value … Peace
Posted by: Simon | Sep 6 2024 16:44 utc | 120

Exactly this! The sandal wearing, long haired, antiwar, draft resisters of the USA in the late 1960s – early 1970s contained many authentic Christians. Meanwhile, the mainline Judeochristian churches were waving the imperial battle flag and supporting the carnage in both theatres. When I left the Baptists back then, I thought that if Jesus showed up in that church they would crucify him again.

Posted by: Drifter | Sep 6 2024 23:11 utc | 203

Giving succor to Banderism during Soviet times made some sense to me.
Posted by: frithguild | Sep 6 2024 22:39 utc | 198
Why just Soviet times but not Russian federation? Communists took down the wealthy elite which the western elite greatly feared. Couldn’t have that idea spreading to their peasants. Putin took down the oligarchs that were screwing the people. That also is something the western elite greatly fear. In fact Putin is even more hated than the communists.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 6 2024 23:22 utc | 204

UAF launched counterattack in New York and were then surrounded
Russian troops have expanded their area of ​​control north of Krasnogorovka. As of the beginning of the day on September 7, the Russian Armed Forces had advanced north of this city by up to 1,5 km, completing a long operation to liberate it. The enemy lost tens of thousands of servicemen, including the wounded, during the defense of
At the same time, in territories north of New York (Novgorod), the enemy, with the forces of several units of the National Guard Brigade, counterattacked today, coming out from the direction of Nelepovka to Novgorodskoye. The NGU breakthrough was completed north of the Fenolnaya station, which initially might have seemed like a considerable success for the enemy army.
However, Russian troops took advantage of the situation and launched flanking attacks from the northeast and northwest. Ultimately, the enemy forces that counterattacked New York (Novgorodlskoye) were cut off from Nelepovka and were surrounded north of the Fenolnaya station, located in the northern part of Novgorodskoye. It is noteworthy that we are talking about elite formations of enemy troops, for the rescue of which the NGU-VSU command will have to throw new units into the defensive line of our army.

Posted by: HERMIUS | Sep 6 2024 23:23 utc | 205

Re the Nazi’s in Canada. Something not mentioned in this thread is prewar fascism in Canada. Prewar fascist parties were I believe present in virtually all western countries. I have no idea how large or small it was in Canada but am wondering if that too may have played a part in the movement of a great many nazi’s to Canada post war?

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 6 2024 23:31 utc | 206

The author of this site assured me two years ago the Ukrainian Army was finished, yet they still fight on.
Was that a hallicnation?

Posted by: evilsooty | Sep 6 2024 23:38 utc | 207

Posted by: SattaMassaGana | Sep 6 2024 20:25 utc |
What you mention is already three quarters of the budget shortfall.
Posted by: Passerby | Sep 6 2024 21:43 utc | 185

Yes Passerby, it is and it is based on my inexpert accumulation of a few facts. If we were to gather all economic and financial data and then forensically examine it, I am pretty sure it would exceed that budget shortfall.
Further, if we were also to follow that data to see where the money went I am also sure that any inaccuracy in unimperator’s post (Sep 6 2024 20:34 utc | 179) wouldn’t be because he was wrong, but simply because he hadn’t sufficiently identified all the grifters outside of Ukraine as well as those inside it. (To be fair that would be a massive undertaking)
As unimperator also notes the grift is coming to an end and I think the biggest fish have mostly gotten their fill and are looking for an out.
Expect to see some of Ukraine’s finest turning up in London as Zaluzhnyi earns his slice.

Ukraine’s popular former army chief Zaluzhnyi appointed ambassador to UK
https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraines-popular-former-army-chief-zaluzhnyi-appointed-ambassador-uk-2024-05-09/

Posted by: SattaMassaGana | Sep 6 2024 23:47 utc | 208

Welcome back b, and great question.
I think indoctrination and propaganda are the greatest “weapon” the West wield.
Although, I find the RoW are slowly waking up.
There used to be a fantastic documentary by North Korea about US propaganda on YouTube before suppression of official narrative was a thing.

Posted by: Suresh | Sep 6 2024 23:47 utc | 209

Welcome back b, and great question.
I think indoctrination and propaganda are the greatest “weapon” the West wield.
Although, I find the RoW are slowly waking up.
There used to be a fantastic documentary by North Korea about US propaganda on YouTube before suppression of official narrative was a thing.

Posted by: Suresh | Sep 6 2024 23:48 utc | 210

The author of this site assured me two years ago the Ukrainian Army was finished, yet they still fight on.
Was that a hallicnation?
Posted by: evilsooty | Sep 6 2024 23:38 utc | 207
Mmm….if I remember rightly, the kiev regime and its NAFO orcs on twitter, as it was called then, were saying that the UAF would be in Crimea by the August of 2023. What say you now, Mr Sooty?

Posted by: HERMIUS | Sep 6 2024 23:52 utc | 211

Weird Thought for Today:
In Startrek, the Federation and Klingons are bitter, violent enemies. After some decades, they transform into allies and support the Federation. This seems not credible, just a convenient plot twist, just nonsense from lazy fiction writers.
Really? Think about Chechnya and its history and their present apparently eager willingness to destroy Ukraine for their “Federation”. This situation blows my mind. I guess it’s one of those cultural things that Western minds have trouble grasping.

Posted by: Eighthman | Sep 6 2024 23:55 utc | 212

Probably the only canonized mother who had a bastard son.
Posted by: canuck | Sep 6 2024 15:41 utc | 109
Isn’t Mary a saint?
Posted by: Honzo | Sep 6 2024 22:50 utc | 199
Unfortunately in those days we were all bastards.
Sad but true.

Posted by: Ornot | Sep 7 2024 0:03 utc | 213

Why just Soviet times but not Russian federation? ***
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 6 2024 23:22 utc | 204
Post WWII execution of Soviet policy appeared to Americans to be expansionist, seeking a Communist International. This was in part a misperception for what was a very rational Russian societal revulsion from the losses it suffered. So the 50’s was the start point for containment policy and clandestine activities such as funding separatist sentiments in Galicia Volynia.
Post Metallica playing Enter Sandman in Moscow, containment just seems silly. Containment slumbered a bit, but has remained alive albeit without its previous justification. Clinton, Bush and Obama each played a role in feeding this unholy monster for a justification that seems just too complicated for simple news consumers like me to know.
So yes, to me there is a justifyable difference between policy toward Soviet Russia and what policy should be toward the RF.

Posted by: frithguild | Sep 7 2024 0:34 utc | 214

******Posted by: N. Hanrahan @202 et al canuck, Frithguild @ 142, Waldorf @ 149.*****
Croatian Concentration Camp guards were a big import items after WW2 into US especially in Chicago area.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 7 2024 0:37 utc | 215

In this days
.
Make a dna test and ask your mother who is your real Son of a Bitch Dady.
Most of these idiots don’t know even at the end that they’re bastard.
Hey, at least, imagine who was your father.

Posted by: Dela | Sep 7 2024 0:37 utc | 216

In a proportion of 1 to 5
Your father is not your father.

Posted by: Dela | Sep 7 2024 0:41 utc | 217

And to be clear: you really know it, in your inside.
Time, to not talk with mama. Let her to be right
The son has 60 yo and it is better not to be interested.

Posted by: Dela | Sep 7 2024 1:06 utc | 218

frithguild | Sep 7 2024 0:34 utc | 214
I think it is more along the lines of simple hatred of communism. That remains in the US today. Heaps of Americans that hate Venezuela because it is ‘communist’. Most Americans hate China because it is communistic. Communism is considered a threat to their ‘freedumb’.
And Chinese must be brainwashed and ruled by evil dictators to be living under communism blah blah. I see that some much in US that it seems an essential pert of American ‘culture’. No other country in the world like it. Brainwashed fools.
As for the Soviet Union, the Brits hated the Russian Empire, the Soviet Union, and now the Russian federation. The Brit elite just hate Russians regardless, though the ideology of communism was a threat to them if it were to take hold in a big way amongst the British peasants. That is why the cold war was the period of peak democracy, peak prosperity of the peasants here in the west. With the threat of communist ideology/ideals fading in the west in the last years of the Soviet Union, he elite in the west here could once again resume the favorite pastime of screwing the peasants for every penny they got.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 1:30 utc | 219

Really? Think about Chechnya and its history and their present apparently eager willingness to destroy Ukraine for their “Federation”. This situation blows my mind. I guess it’s one of those cultural things that Western minds have trouble grasping.
Posted by: Eighthman | Sep 6 2024 23:55 utc | 212
For that you need to understand what the so called second Chechen war was all about and then it is hardly mindblowing. CIA machinations backfired bigtime. Made the Chechen’s realize their true enemy was the CIA and US, not the Russian Federation.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 1:39 utc | 220

Posted by: watcher | Sep 6 2024 22:11 utc | 192 “If we look at the NATO nations”
You are more optimistic than this guy:
Leonid Ivashov, a retired Colonel-General in the Russian Army a week or two ago on Russian TV:
“How is it possible to confront the NATO bloc? Confronting the NATO alliance with conventional weapons, in view of its superiority in conventional means of warfare, well, from our side, any course of action would be extremely disadvantageous. Well, this superiority in almost all positions is several times. And that is why as it seems to me, any confrontation with the NATO bock is possible only with the use of nuclear weapons. There is simply no other option.”

Posted by: Ed4 | Sep 7 2024 1:46 utc | 221

Leonid Ivashov, a retired Colonel-General in the Russian Army a week or two ago on Russian TV:
Posted by: Ed4 | Sep 7 2024 1:46 utc | 221

Yeah, the very same guy who called for creation of a “Magi Council” to decide how to end the SMO. You really are scraping the barrel.

Posted by: Poslan1 | Sep 7 2024 2:08 utc | 222

@221 Ed
NATO knows this (though others will disagree that is the balance) and yet they still push confrontation.
We have to watch while NATO comes as close as possible to calling Russia’s bluff.
That is not sensible.
Equally there is a mirror circumstance in Palestine, except ‘the west’ is clearly occupying and not reclaiming, and where ‘the occupation’ is projecting not to call its bluff.
This is all a very bad equation.

Posted by: Ornot | Sep 7 2024 2:08 utc | 223

Down South | Sep 6 2024 10:13 utc | 22
…The first phase …Kursk
Re The second direction …?
Tick for Crimea (landing of troops) (the Brits always fantasise about storming the beaches).
Tick for Zaporizhia [Grossi went sniffing there again recently, so I wondered what’s up]
Scratch …Belarus, abandon / abort … Lukashenko has too many troops on “our” border {which Ukraine cried about like a tot whose toy has been snatched by a bigger sibling}
Passerby | Sep 6 2024 11:06 utc | 30
There’s a macabre symmetry. Ukraine pensioners are to freeze (and die) this winter because of British adventurism.
And so too British pensioners will freeze (and die) … because of the same adventurism.
Both countries are cynical enough to see old people~pensioners as extremely useless eaters… Tis but A Modest Proposal to remove heat and ergo, remove the problem.
Multipolar Panda | Sep 6 2024 12:15 utc | 40
Yep. Kursk was part of a two-step/ three-step manoeuvre. It wasn’t the Ukrainians acting “rogue” as now the U$ Lloyd Austin, Kirby and Snake Sullivan are intimating.
Every one of the U$NATO geniuses believed Russia would be forced to rush troops from Donbass to Kursk. None of them understood Russia would do what Russia does, take the “humiliating” blow of having foreign troops inside Russia, and stay focused on their objective… liberating all of Donbass.
DunGroanin | Sep 6 2024 12:54 utc | 49
You know what’s up, brother!
Peter AU1 | Sep 6 2024 13:13 utc | 53
The term Ukrainian first appeared on old European maps to denote the part of Poland that was Rus
“Ukraine”, in the original meaning of the word: “borderlands”. The space between Lithuania-Poland and Russia was indeed a messy I’ll-defined “borderland”.
ChecksandBalances | Sep 6 2024 13:32 utc | 60
Yes. “Borderlands”. A space between Poland and Russia that is just “not Russia”…
canuck | Sep 6 2024 13:34 utc | 62
Which is why the Bankers conspired to take away people’s gold (and silver), and give them paper “money”. … Now most Aussies don’t even have paper… their “money” just numbers on a computer.
Waldorf | Sep 6 2024 17:32 utc | 132
inner workings of his pylorus and other nuggets of great interest to a desperate world. Thanks for the laugh. And yes, I know a thread is about to go to shit when Tony Off-Topic arrives. Fuck him.
Waldorf | Sep 6 2024 18:15 utc | 144
Mongolia. Demoncracy. I’d never until today known that Mongolia was a Far Eastern Outpost of demoncracy. And that its failure to arrest Putin was a egregious failure. Huh. I learn something every day, and today that is it.
>…Anyone else enjoy the pic of Putin and Ukhnaa having a Meeting of State in that sumptuous yurt. Glorious. I think it was on Pepe Escobar’s telegram if anyone wants to hunt for it.
Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Sep 6 2024 18:51 utc | 160
I’m really curious as to why IMF is now “engaging” with Russia?
They were happy to play No Speaks for the past several years.
Why visit Moscow in winter? I have a hunch it’s about Russian-held Ukrainian debt.
You?
David G Horsman | Sep 6 2024 19:03 utc | 162
he said, “ignore my Wikipedia Well. I’ll take that as a solid endorsement of his bonafides.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Sep 7 2024 2:09 utc | 224

” Multipolar Panda | Sep 6 2024 12:15 utc | 40
Every one of the U$NATO geniuses believed Russia would be forced to rush troops from Donbass to Kursk. None of them understood Russia would do what Russia does, take the “humiliating” blow of having foreign troops inside Russia, and stay focused on their objective… liberating all of Donbass. ”
Actually, ZATO assumed correctly because they understood Russia must not have had the men power to confront the Kurk invasion with quick, decisive force. Furthermore, it is humiliating as, supposedly, Russia was only using minimal troop numbers in Ukraine to ” wear down the West” till it collapses economically. Well, if thats true, where are the rest of the troops? Where are the conscripts? Where are the reserves? Where are the 300,000, or more, freshly raised troops we heard about so often? Last I checked, the Ukrainians are still holding the territory weeks after the invasion. Humiliating indeed.

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 2:43 utc | 225

” We have to watch while NATO comes as close as possible to calling Russia’s bluff.
Posted by: Ornot | Sep 7 2024 2:08 utc | 223 ”
You wont have to wait long, as Moscow is about to get hit with long range missiles. What will Russia do then, Hit Kiev?
The ZioWest doesn’t care.
Strike at a ZATO member?
Thats what the West wants according to popular opinion here.
Therefore, Red lines here we come.

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 2:48 utc | 226

“Ukraine”, in the original meaning of the word: “borderlands”. The space between Lithuania-Poland and Russia was indeed a messy I’ll-defined “borderland”.
Melaleuca | Sep 7 2024 2:09 utc | 224
I believe the Poland Lithuanian Commonwealth at some point became just Poland. I have not yet seen where Ukraine directly translates into another language as borderlands. Makes me wonder if the name given that region became associated with Poland’s borderlands and if so where the name originated from.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 2:53 utc | 227

” For that you need to understand what the so called second Chechen war was all about and then it is hardly mindblowing.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 1:39 utc | 220 ”
Russia won that war because they went in with all guns blazing and offered “no quarter” to anyone resisting. Which brings up the question, ” Why didnt they do that in Ukraine? ”
Popular answer here, ” Because they consider them as brothers “.
Fair enough, but werent the Chechens considered Russian and ” brothers “? I guess not. Seems the brown Russians arent as important as the white Russians, or the ” brotherly love ” theory is BS.
The folks here can decide.

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 2:56 utc | 228

Moonie | Sep 7 2024 2:48 utc | 226
Fuck off troll.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 2:57 utc | 229

” Martyanov has a piece on Kursk.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 6 2024 23:04 utc | 201 ”
Which country is he based out of ?

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:03 utc | 230

” Fuck off troll.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 2:57 utc | 229 ”
Follow B’s rules or leave the bar.

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:04 utc | 231

As for the difference between the two maps, I prefer to believing my lyin’ eyes.
However, this was just a visual example uncharacteristic of what’s now occured–most all quarters understand Ukraine is significantly changed and its armed forces all but spent.
Dame Fortune, though, says it isn’t over until it’s over. Or was that Yogi Berra? But even in a semi-rational world (like our third planet out) the fat lady clears her voice to sing and none too soon. What a shambles the new Ukraine will be.

Posted by: Elmagnostic | Sep 7 2024 3:07 utc | 232

Wikipedia of all places.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Name_of_Ukraine
“The earliest known usage of the name Ukraine (Ukrainian: Україна, romanized: Ukraina [ʊkrɐˈjinɐ] ⓘ, Вкраїна, romanized: Vkraina [u̯krɐˈjinɐ]; Old East Slavic: Ѹкраина/Ꙋкраина, romanized: Ukraina [uˈkrɑjinɑ]) appears in the Hypatian Codex of c. 1425 under the year 1187 in reference to a part of the territory of Kievan Rus’
Could be just Ukraine fictional history bullshit but I don’t think so. Basically a region of Kieven Rus taken by Poland. Kievan Russ was originally a number of separate east slavic tribes that became regions of Kievan Rus. The tribes likely also had their own dialects.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 3:24 utc | 233

@ Moonie | Sep 7 2024 2:56 utc | 228 with the shallow perspective
This is a civilization war and thoughts of the complexities of what is going on from that perspective seems beyond your capability.
that or have a bevin on me

If you aren’t paid to throw sand into readers’ eyes and you do so out of malice, vanity or stupidity, not even the plea of economic necessity excuses your egregious behaviour.
Kindly leave the stage- to honest actors.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Sep 7 2024 3:25 utc | 234

Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:04 utc | 231
Do I have to repeat myself troll? Fuck of.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 3:26 utc | 235

Thanks for all the reply on last thread, but this one is so good, I have taken the liberty to share again.
—————————————————————————–
NATO is indeed Russia’s ally in this special operation. NATO is doing everything right. Controlled escalation to continue the war, but in such a way as not to create a threat of defeat for Russia. Then the war will end with a complete victory for Russia, at the moment when the Ukrainian Nazis are gone. And this will be denazification along with demilitarization.
https://x.com/vicktop55/status/1831963799038967886
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 6 2024 8:42 utc | 642

Posted by: Suresh | Sep 7 2024 3:28 utc | 236

” Do I have to repeat myself troll? Fuck of.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 3:26 utc | 235 ”
Whats one of B’s main rules?
” Notice Of Absence
@all – I will be offline for the next two or so days.
Please behave.
b.
Posted by b at 5:07 UTC | Comments (0) ”

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:38 utc | 237

*** Communism is considered a threat to their ‘freedumb’. ***
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 1:30 utc | 219
I won’t endorse this thinking for even a second. True, US political discourse has made Communism a boogeyman, because all politics needs a boogeyman. That as far as this thinking can go, while still making sense.
Communism is a religion where the State is worshipped based on the promise that once it has enough power, human nature will be transformed and basic needs will be met. Makes sense if you consider Marx was an avaricious, broke, antisocial little prick. After enough study in earning my history degree 40 years ago, I concluded the only utility for this ideology is to sieze and keep power. I see no reason to differ now, given all the failures in the intervening ti.e.
If you look at tens of millions of “justified” homicides, the cost benefit analysis augers against it, don’t you think? Human nature can’t be changed by a system of government, which is an American way of looking at it.
Likewise, Communism makes the most sense to those socialized in societies where exogenous communitarian family structures prevail. Such Mongol roots don’t really exist outside of the general Russia / China region. So I guess I can see that Western reflexive dismissal of what is important to exogenous communitarian easterners can be seen as slavish and thoughtless cleaving onto “freedumb.” So you are completely wrong, but I’ll give you a pass for now.
As far as the Brits, your observations are spot on. They have had the same policies toward Russia as since before the Crimean War. At this point, British russophobia qualifies as proper and polite irrational hatred and nothing more. The reasons don’t seem very apparent, but it might have to do with banking … I dunno

Posted by: frithguild | Sep 7 2024 3:39 utc | 238

” If you aren’t paid to throw sand into readers’ eyes and you do so out of malice, vanity or stupidity, not even the plea of economic necessity excuses your egregious behaviour.
Kindly leave the stage- to honest actors.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Sep 7 2024 3:25 utc | 234 ”
Your evasive word salad is not impressive. Address my points. If you can that is.

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:40 utc | 239

I believe the Poland Lithuanian Commonwealth at some point became just Poland. ***
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 2:53 utc | 227
There was a partition and Poland did not exist as a state from 1975 to 1918 with the creation if the Second Republic. You really should read some history.

Posted by: frithguild | Sep 7 2024 3:53 utc | 240

” Marx was an avaricious, broke, antisocial little prick. After enough study in earning my history degree 40 years ago, I concluded the only utility for this ideology is to sieze and keep power. I see no reason to differ now, given all the failures in the intervening ti.e.
Posted by: frithguild | Sep 7 2024 3:39 utc | 238 ”
Careful, you’ll rile up the Marxist brigade here 😉

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:55 utc | 241

” There was a partition and Poland did not exist as a state from 1975 to 1918 with the creation if the Second Republic. You really should read some history.
Posted by: frithguild | Sep 7 2024 3:53 utc | 240 ”
I think you meant 1775 good sir. Also, get ready to be called a troll by good ‘ole Pete.

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:58 utc | 242

@ 39
I agree – drawing the line at The Dnieper is simplistic. Kiev and Odessa are too much to abandon. I tend to think at some point a negotiated settlement will allow each province a referendum on whether to join Russia or not – to be supervised by poll scrutineers drawn from a range of nations but excluding NATO and the US. It will take time.
Logistically, it’s true continuing westward across The Dnieper presents great costs – even using Belarus as insertion point is complicated. Both sides know this and when Ukraine has lost enough of The Dombass and key cities on The Dnieper, a cautious set of referenda will look like a face-saving measure.

Posted by: Gerry Bell | Sep 7 2024 4:03 utc | 243

frithguild | Sep 7 2024 3:39 utc | 238
I don’t think communism can be vied as a religion. We must look back at the times preceding the Russian Empire and China revolutions. The majority of those populations were illiterate poverty stricken peasants. Early communism was a theory, an ideal. Some, many parts, very good. Others simply a utopia that did not take full account of human character.
Because of perhaps the illiteracy, much of this became dogma in the early decades. Soviet Union I think did not fully break out of this, but I believe China did after the death of Mao. That early belief was I think required to take them through the hardship and tragedy of revolution, but a hindrance to their future. After the death of Mao, China set a course on pragmatic socialism which began to blossom around, perhaps before 2000. Communism with Chinese characteristics. Communism I think of as the time of class war – as in all educated, regardless they supported the revolution are the enemy – and full nationalization of everything which destroys individual initiative.
China I regard simply as a socialist state that has brought its people from abject poverty to prosperity very quickly.
Soviet union I think never full broke away from the early dogma, though it had much more pressure against it from the western powers. Or as is turned out, power, in the form of the US and vassals. Wide open ‘capitalism’ and American privatization of the 90’s, then with the advent of Putin, a move back to socialism with Russian characteristics.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:08 utc | 244

Careful, you’ll rile up the Marxist brigade here 😉
Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:55 utc | 241
Maybe it’s too close to last call lights on for incoming from them :))
Regardless, I speak truth about Marx the person.
Thanks for the date correction btw.

Posted by: frithguild | Sep 7 2024 4:13 utc | 245

frithguild | Sep 7 2024 3:53 utc | 240 “You really should read some history.”
Piss off idiot. You are like trying to explain something to a smartarse child. You know no history so come up with crap talking points…. been wasting my time on a shithead.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:15 utc | 246

” Piss off idiot. You are like trying to explain something to a smartarse child. You know no history so come up with crap talking points…. been wasting my time on a shithead.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:15 utc | 246 ”
Like clockwork.

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 4:18 utc | 247

Moonie | Sep 7 2024 4:18 utc | 247
Sometimes I wrote “Piss of Troll”. That sounds really bad because I reckon the urine of a troll would be really nasty stinky stuff. ‘Fuck of troll’ – wow that boggles the imagination. Makes spawn of the devil appear saintly.
I really should work on my typos. They can create the wrong impression.
I’m really not that bad. Now piss off troll.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:25 utc | 248

“As for the Soviet Union, the Brits hated the Russian Empire, the Soviet Union, and now the Russian federation. The Brit elite just hate Russians regardless, though the ideology of communism was a threat to them”
I know nothing of history, but a little link hopping over a Stones lyric made something a little clearer.
“Nicholas was of primarily German and Danish descent and was related to several monarchs in Europe. His mother’s siblings included Kings Frederick VIII of Denmark and George I of Greece, as well as the United Kingdom’s Queen Alexandra (consort of King Edward VII). Nicholas, his wife Alexandra, and Wilhelm II, German Emperor were all first cousins of King George V of the United Kingdom. Nicholas was also a first cousin of both King Haakon VII and Queen Maud of Norway, as well as King Christian X of Denmark and King Constantine I of Greece”
Seems like the long running resentment may be more personal than sociopolitical.

Posted by: Not Ewe | Sep 7 2024 4:25 utc | 249

” I’m really not that bad. Now piss off troll.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:25 utc | 248 ”
B’s rules. Learn them.

Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 4:31 utc | 250

Not Ewe | Sep 7 2024 4:25 utc | 249
For Brit vs Russia, the starting point is the American revolution. US was on good terms, friendly terms with Czarist Russia until the communist revolution.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:37 utc | 251

Not Ewe | Sep 7 2024 4:25 utc | 249
That lyric. That is what made US unique in the European world in its day. It did not have a hereditary head of state and so, many Europeans flocked to America. And free land. Freely taken from its inhabitants. Still Greeco-Roman westphalian culture but free of the old world.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:47 utc | 252

Posted by: Simon | Sep 6 2024 16:44 utc | 120
What was a Christian originally?”
Your weak attempt to define a Christian without any reference to what Jesus laid out as defining features seems to indicate that you are speaking out of your ignorance on the subject. Your definition brings to mind the poem,
The Blind Men and the Elephant.
It was six men of Indostan, to learning much inclined,
who went to see the elephant (Though all of them were blind),
that each by observation, might satisfy his mind.
The first approached the elephant, and, happening to fall,
against his broad and sturdy side, at once began to bawl:
“God bless me! but the elephant, is nothing but a wall!”
The second feeling of the tusk, cried: “Ho! what have we here,
so very round and smooth and sharp? To me tis mighty clear,
this wonder of an elephant, is very like a spear!”
The third approached the animal, and, happening to take,
the squirming trunk within his hands, “I see,” quoth he,
the elephant is very like a snake!”
The fourth reached out his eager hand, and felt about the knee:
“What most this wondrous beast is like, is mighty plain,” quoth he;
“Tis clear enough the elephant is very like a tree.”
The fifth, who chanced to touch the ear, Said; “E’en the blindest man
can tell what this resembles most; Deny the fact who can,
This marvel of an elephant, is very like a fan!”
The sixth no sooner had begun, about the beast to grope,
than, seizing on the swinging tail, that fell within his scope,
“I see,” quothe he, “the elephant is very like a rope!”
And so these men of Indostan, disputed loud and long,
each in his own opinion, exceeding stiff and strong,
Though each was partly in the right, and all were in the wrong!
So, oft in theologic wars, the disputants, I ween,
tread on in utter ignorance, of what each other mean,
and prate about the elephant, not one of them has seen!

Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 7 2024 4:49 utc | 253

Not Ewe
This is well worth a read to understand Putin’s Russia.
https://patrickarmstrong.ca/2018/06/20/yes-putin-once-dreamed-the-american-dream/
In the depression years, to crate employment, the US government spent massively on well planned infrastructure to create jobs. That infrastructure was the underpinning, the foundation, the seed, of Americas future decades of prosperity for the people. The inheritors burned it, squandered it. Now if anything thing like that was tried again in US, all would be screaming commies…. communism blah blah.
China? What was the first thing it did? China educated the people and built infrastructure. Then came the ever increasing prosperity of the common people built on those foundations.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:58 utc | 254

The author of this site assured me two years ago the Ukrainian Army was finished, yet they still fight on.
Was that a hallicnation?
Posted by: evilsooty | Sep 6 2024 23:38 utc | 207
Just because they’re still “fighting on” doesn’t mean they’re weren’t finished before it even started.

Posted by: PalmaSailor | Sep 7 2024 5:02 utc | 255

Posted by: canuck | Sep 6 2024 17:16 utc | 128
“One of the main tenets of early Christianity was Jubilee years such that debts were cancelled or written down as happened in Assyria, Sumer, Babylon, Jesus preached it, one of the reasons the Pharisees despised him.”
Like Simon, you too seem to be ignorant of Biblical Christianity as described by Jesus. The Jubilee you describe is a Jewish celebration found in the Old Testament. I can assure you that Jesus didn’t teach it, though he made one reference to it by comparison in Luke 4. If that’s all you know of Christianity then you are missing the heart of the matter. Check out the poem The Blind Men and the Elephant I posted in 253.

Posted by: Paranaense | Sep 7 2024 5:08 utc | 256

In wasted repsonse to

Address my points. If you can that is.
Posted by: Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:40 utc | 239

I will repeat my address to your points and your lack of responding to it and telling me I haven’t proves my point

This is a civilization war and thoughts of the complexities of what is going on from that perspective seems beyond your capability.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Sep 7 2024 5:17 utc | 257

It seems that EU amnd UK have decided to finance this war forever. It is amazing how all social classes in Europe agree on this projects. The absence of any protests proves that EU nations just love this war.
In essence this is the war Europe always wanted.

Posted by: vargas | Sep 7 2024 5:39 utc | 258

about monarchy Not Ewe | Sep 7 2024 4:25 utc | 249
I don’t think ‘resentment’ among related european monarchs was the issue at all. I’m not cinvinced of the reported ‘hatred’ of brits to russia is in the 19th century onwards is as bad as we’re told it was.. But really it doesn’t matter now anyway — they ‘hate them today’ for sure. It’s an irrational pathological hatred but seems entrenched. Why, I dont know. Maybe the soviet spies in the British elites? Best read up on good history sources.
kind of OT but if anyone is interested in the inbreds of Europe a quick summary here lays out most of it simply enough.
https://www.thecollector.com/the-grandmother-of-europe-how-queen-victoria-rules-the-continent/

Posted by: Fred | Sep 7 2024 5:44 utc | 259

@ Moonie | Sep 7 2024 3:03 utc | 230
You know that most here know who you are. It adds to the amusement of watching you half ass your lies. Why can’t more of you be like a vargas. A vargas doesn’t care what he posts and wastes no one’s time.

Posted by: boneless | Sep 7 2024 5:49 utc | 260

vargas | Sep 7 2024 5:39 utc | 258
Good. They are full of piss and wind and will soon collapse of heart attack or similar. They are in no condition, do not have what it takes to run a marathon.
There was a couple of separate articles in the Uk Media. 1) The UK can no longer afford to give their peasants pensions. 2) UK has allocated whatever millions/billions to the war against Russia.
The Right Royal Kiddy Fiddlers have taken Britain to the point where it resembles a lump of rotting meat writhing with maggots.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 6:01 utc | 261

…. been wasting my time on a shithead.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:15 utc | 246
Projection much?
” I’m really not that bad. Now piss off troll.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:25 utc | 248 ”
No. You are not that bad. You are worse.
Because you should know better.
And now I’ll add you to my ignore list.

Posted by: Martina | Sep 7 2024 6:11 utc | 262

The war remains a war of attrition and not of gaining new ground. When Russia see that the Ukrainians are week at a certain front, they advance so that the Ukrainians are forced to send new troops. Then these troops are decimated with artillery. If there are not enough Ukrainians on the battlefield your artillery does not work efficiently. The Ukrainian troops are now at such a level that they can only reinforce one front by moving troops from another front. At that moment the Russian troops feel weakness at that front and advance, etc.. Remaining a certain battlefield as long as possible is interesting because you do not need to change the supporting logistical network. The strategy of Russia, except for the first few weeks has always been how can we most efficiently destroy the Ukrainian army and that is not by having them on the run.

Posted by: hubert | Sep 7 2024 6:19 utc | 263

boneless | Sep 7 2024 5:49 utc | 261
Yeah. I found him a bit annoying at the start, but now, more like the local village idiot. Always around but not particularly annoying.
Dima…. my son at about eight years old would always go out and talk to the farmer who owned the house we rented when he was about. He was a good bloke and my son was a good talker. My son would ask what he was doing and the farmer would explain and son would come back and tell me. One day, Ken tells son- “if you plant a feather you can grow a chook”. I said I didn’t think so. No dad, Ken said so. mmm. Some weeks later son comes home and says Ken said there were trouser snakes. Son asked me if I has seen one. I thought about it a bit and said no, you had better ask your teacher about them. Teacher was a sixty plus year old spinster. Very old school and strict. I don’t know what the reaction was, but the the tall stories from the farmer certainly came to a harsh end.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 6:20 utc | 264

There was a couple of separate articles in the Uk Media. 1) The UK can no longer afford to give their peasants pensions. 2) UK has allocated whatever millions/billions to the war against Russia
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 6:01 utc | 262
But still they can afgord financing of the war in Ukraine.
So, clearly, the peasents accept to sacrifice themselves for this project. It is not hust UK. All EU peasents feel the same.

Posted by: vargas | Sep 7 2024 6:24 utc | 265

The people of the land” (“am ha’eretz”) who fought against the Romans are the ancestors of the present-day Palestinians
It must be remembered that “Yahweh” is an Arab deity, and the great Temple was built by an Arab king, Herod “the Great”, son of “the Idumean” and a princess of Petra, not by a rabbi from Ukraine
The Ukrainians, the Russians and the Palestinians now suffers two thousand years of tales and bloody fantasies
Posted by: Simon | Sep 6 2024 17:45 utc | 137
Bullshit man

Posted by: Flash | Sep 7 2024 6:25 utc | 266

All of you neglect Russia’s greatest weapon – patience. …
Posted by: OldFart | Sep 6 2024 9:53 utc | 17

The Mongols in Russia“, by Jeremiah Curtin (1908).
background:
The Mongol horde invaded the ancient Rus principalities in 1238, razing many cities, killing and enslaving untold numbers. They said, “pay tribute, or perish,” (AKA ‘the Tatar Yoke’) but let the survivors manage their own affairs subject to the whims and vetoes of the Khan of the Golden Horde in Sarai (who himself was subject to the Great Khan back in Mongolia).
Alexander Nevskiy (lived 1221-1263, ruled 1252-1263): never defeated in battle.
p.290:

When the great Peter had founded St. Petersburg on the Neva, concluded peace with the Swedes and restored the ancient patrimony of Ijora, he brought Nevski’s bones to the capital, where they repose in the monastery of Alexander Nevski, and are honored at present and will be for the ages to come as relics of a saint and a hero. There is no better saint in the whole Russian calendar, and no greater statesman or warrior in its history than Alexander Nevski. By his wisdom and by his policy of yielding with apparent resignation to the tyranny of the Mongols, he suppressed revolts which would have perhaps brought about the abolition of native government, with the substitution of Mongol for Russian princes. Such substitution would have endangered the language, religion and race of the Russian people. This had to be avoided at every sacrifice. No man knew the relative strength of the Mongols and Russians better than Alexander Nevski; no man was more devoted to Russia than he; no man was more respected by his own; therefore his words had weight, and when he explained that resistance would be ruin and submission was the only road to salvation the people believed and obeyed him. In this way he rescued Novgorod and many another city from utter destruction, and saved the lives of untold thousands. Above all his influence remained; it curbed passion and instilled patience and courage into the minds of men, and the knowledge that violence only made the yoke more oppressive.

Which is to say, the Russians put up with the Horde’s tyranny for 250 years, biding their time…
Patience.

Posted by: retroflecks | Sep 7 2024 6:34 utc | 267

Posted by: Ed4 | Sep 7 2024 1:46 utc | 221
I do not place much store by retired colonels, especially on matters relating to the economy. He might of course be quite right IF WWIII breaks out and there are naval battles but on a land based war not so much.

Posted by: watcher | Sep 7 2024 6:38 utc | 268

Posted by: vargas | Sep 7 2024 6:24 utc | 266
Not sure you can say that about East Germany or France. let us wait and seee. A cold winter with food chortages clears the minds of many

Posted by: watcher | Sep 7 2024 6:40 utc | 269

Posted by: vargas | Sep 7 2024 6:24 utc | 266
They (the governments) can keep moving the chairs on the deck and the Orchestra can keep playing but they will sink as Titanic sunk.

Posted by: Mario | Sep 7 2024 6:46 utc | 270

@Gerry Bell | Sep 7 2024 4:03 utc | 243

TI tend to think at some point a negotiated settlement will allow each province a referendum on whether to join Russia or not – to be supervised by poll scrutineers drawn from a range of nations but excluding NATO and the US.

Just a comment about “NATO and the US”. This seems to assume that NATO and the US are somehow separate entities. NATO is a US tool for suppression of European countries and for exerting aggression against Russia.

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 7 2024 7:20 utc | 271

retroflecks | Sep 7 2024 6:34 utc | 268
That thick file of Russian history Putin gave to CIA rep Carlson…. The Russians understand war.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 7:22 utc | 272

Posted by: tonyopmoc | Sep 6 2024 15:22 utc | 99
Why don’t you subscribe to the substack and message me. Then I’ll put a link up to some of my ‘busking’. Interesting to hear you have connections with the Borders. My father’s family was from Glasgow.

Posted by: Dr. Rob Campbell | Sep 7 2024 7:25 utc | 273

All EU peasents feel the same.
Posted by: vargas | Sep 7 2024 6:24 utc | 266
I dont. And i am voting with my wallet and future cannonfodder by leaving germany and the eu for good.
My children will not die for nazism.

Posted by: Justpassinby | Sep 7 2024 7:27 utc | 274

@vargas | Sep 7 2024 5:39 utc | 258

In essence this is the war Europe always wanted.

“Europe” does not exist as an entity that wants things. Europe is a peninsula on the Eurasian landmass, containing multiple diverse countries and languages with very different interests. The anti-democratic and treasonous “EU” likes to call itself “Europe” as a disguise for the US tool that it is. That should tell you which entity that “always wanted” this war.
As the 18th century was the age of reason, the 21st century is the age of treason.

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 7 2024 7:34 utc | 275

Posted by: watcher | Sep 7 2024 6:38 utc | 269 ‘I do not place much store by retired colonels, especially on matters relating to the economy.”
How about colonel generals? Looks like they out rank colonels by quite a bit.

Posted by: Ed4 | Sep 7 2024 7:42 utc | 276

Posted by: HERMIUS | Sep 6 2024 23:52 utc | 211 “What say you now, Mr Sooty?”
Well, not Mr. Sooty, I’d say the Russians are losing over 100 KIA every day, Putin is calling for every Russian woman to have 8 or 9 kids and this thing has no end in sight.
Ukraine is a write off but they fight on, aided by the Western wunderwaffen, which is the continued flow of arms across the border. From NLAWS to F-16’s.

Posted by: Ed4 | Sep 7 2024 7:48 utc | 277

Rob Campbell (and blog) is certainly on topic and detailed. Good work Rob.
https://robcampbell.substack.com/p/ukraine-weekly-update-250
Posted by: David G Horsman | Sep 6 2024 18:27 utc | 150
Much appreciated David – thanks.

Posted by: Dr. Rob Campbell | Sep 7 2024 7:53 utc | 278

Brian Berletic with Danny Haiphong was very interesting to day Sept 6/7 depending on where you are on the planet. The long view of the SMO and other conflicts, proposed conflicts and meddling.
“BRIAN BERLETIC: PUTIN DROPS BOMBSHELL ON NATO AS UKRAINE’S FRONTLINE COLLAPSES, KURSK BACKFIRES”
I didn’t hear a Putin bombshell but the rest was worth it.

Posted by: Inki | Sep 7 2024 7:53 utc | 279

Dmitry Orlov is a straight talker with a clear mind. He has been in live conversations with the excellent Nima Alkhorshid multiple times. Yesterday was no different
Dmitry Orlov: Russia’s Masterplan in Ukraine
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWTLcaXJ6Ts
Except, it was different this time. The conversation was plagued with “microphone noise” which to me sounded like 3rd party interference. The whole conversation had to be abandoned.
What do you think? Was it a technical glitch or was it sabotage?

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 7 2024 8:03 utc | 280

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 7 2024 4:25 utc | 248
Yeah I noted the typos and they were funny, piss of troll, fuck of troll, lol!

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 7 2024 8:07 utc | 281

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 7 2024 7:20 utc | 272
And so is the EU, planned and funded by the USA since the early decades of post-WWII, as proved by declassfied documents in the National Archives.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 7 2024 8:13 utc | 282

@frithguild | Sat, 07 Sep 2024 03:53:00 GMT | 240

Poland did not exist as a state from 1975 to 1918

Before you lecture someone on history you should at least get the dates correct, or are you dyslexic.

Posted by: James M. | Sep 7 2024 8:18 utc | 283

“Europe” does not exist as an entity that wants things. Europe is a peninsula on the Eurasian landmass, containing multiple diverse countries and languages with very different interests. The anti-democratic and treasonous “EU” likes to call itself “Europe” as a disguise for the US tool that it is. That should tell you which entity that “always wanted” this war.

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 7 2024 7:34 utc | 276
“Vargas” has been outed as a troll multiple times, and so I doubt he’d even care to speak for himself in his questionable assertion that

All EU peasents feel the same

or at least prove it.
Speaking of US tools, the fact that Germany has not signed a peace treaty with the US or the UK and remains occupied territory by the former has been talked about here and elsewhere, so I must wonder what Tim Lynch (190) means when he says

#Denazify Germany properly this time – smash Germany into a million pieces and drive its genocide racist Zionist filth out of Europe.

[Enphasis mine]

Posted by: joey_n | Sep 7 2024 8:23 utc | 284

Posted by: Norwegian | Sep 7 2024 7:34 utc | 276

As the 18th century was the age of reason, the 21st century is the age of treason.

Great writing!
But the 21st is still young, at 24.
It may turn into a new age of reason if groups like AfD and BSW (just to provide examples) manage to join to defenestrate the corrupt halfwit liberals that pollute government offices and public discourse in the West.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 7 2024 8:24 utc | 285

Posted by: Ed4 | Sep 7 2024 1:46 utc | 221
What does he know! As I’ve said repeatedly, the strategic stupidity of the Western response to the SMO was that it helped create an environment in which the inherent, organic weaknesses of the Russian military were largely shielded, whilst severely blunting its own traditional strengths and long-established advantages, in that field.
Fast forward, and using the crucible of a highly moderated near-peer conflict, Russia has been able to begin to address those weaknesses, which, as any organisational analyst knows, has resulted in a substantial improvement in its capabilities. The SMO has, in simple terms, become an investment opportunity, allowing the effect of decades of under-funding, mis-management and corruption, in a sclerotic system, to be tackled directly. These incremental improvements have an impact far greater than their input, as they help create a synergistic wave that builds over time, and whose sweeping impacts are transformative.
The Ukrainian experience is diametrically opposite, in terms of point of origin and current position, especially in the impacts that that declining trajectory has caused. This is why I largely refer to the conflict in abstract terms, because it allows, counter-intuitively, a greater understanding of its dynamics, aids in predicting events, however generalised those predictions might be, and addresses the problem of having to rely on open, and therefore often highly-compromised, sources in making those predictions.
Lastly, it helps avoid the paralysis by analysis and attendant superiority argument obsessions that routinely dog any such assessments, when the wrong elevation is chosen by the observer. Instead of focusing on the impactor, look at its impact, that’s the real definition of who is achieving any kind of ‘superiority, technically or otherwise.

Posted by: Milites | Sep 7 2024 8:25 utc | 286

@Moonie | Sat, 07 Sep 2024 03:58:00 GMT | 242

Also, get ready to be called a troll by good ‘ole Pete.

He calls them as he sees them. Helps improve my blocked list. Makes for a much easier and shorter read on MoA. I’m guessing you’re one, so you’ll be blocked after this.

Posted by: James M. | Sep 7 2024 8:26 utc | 287

https://t.me/sashakots/48836

High-precision strikes on enemy targets in a week
✔️On August 28, an Iskander-M missile strike was launched against a dry cargo ship that was unloading weapons and ammunition for the Ukrainian Armed Forces near the settlement of Burlachya Balka. As a result, 20 foreign mercenaries, 12 unmanned boats and part of the ammunition were destroyed, and another 38 unmanned boats were damaged.
✔️On September 2, an Iskander-M OTRK crew struck a temporary deployment point for foreign mercenaries located in a hotel building in Zaporozhye. As a result, up to 50 Ukrainian Armed Forces servicemen were killed, including 19 mercenaries from Great Britain. Another 20 militants were wounded.
✔️On September 3, a group missile strike by the Iskander-M OTRK was launched against the 179th Joint Training Center of the Ukrainian Armed Forces Signal Corps in Poltava.
The strike killed and wounded about 500 specialists. Among the dead and wounded were Ukrainian Armed Forces and National Guard servicemen – communications specialists, operators of electronic warfare systems, electronic intelligence, unmanned aerial vehicles, as well as foreign mercenaries from Poland, France, Germany and Sweden who trained Ukrainian military personnel.
✔️On September 4, as a result of a missile strike carried out by an Iskander-M OTRK crew, a finished products workshop of an ammunition plant in the settlement of Novomoskovsk (Dnipropetrovsk region) was destroyed.
On the same day, as a result of a combined missile strike carried out on three temporary deployment points of foreign mercenaries in the city of Krivoy Rog, the enemy lost more than 250 militants. Among them were about 70 French and Romanian air defense and UAV production specialists.
And as a result of a missile strike by an Iskander-M OTRK on a temporary deployment point of foreign mercenaries in the settlement of Konstantinovka, about 50 French militants were destroyed.
Also, on September 4, an Iskander-M OTRK missile strike was carried out on a storage and preparation site for enemy unmanned boats in the Odessa area. 20 UAVs were destroyed.
✔️In total, from August 28 to September 5 of this year, 48 Ukrainian BECs were destroyed, including 16 BECs at sea and 32 BECs in ports.
Another 38 BECs were damaged in storage areas.
According to our source in the Ministry of Defense, such high-precision strikes on deployment points of the Ukrainian Armed Forces and mercenaries, as well as military facilities, will now become regular.

Posted by: anon2020 | Sep 7 2024 8:34 utc | 288

“Vargas” has been outed as a troll multiple times, and so I doubt he’d even care to speak for himself in his questionable assertion that
All EU peasents feel the same
when I say “All” that means 85%

Posted by: vargas | Sep 7 2024 8:34 utc | 289

Posted by: vargas | Sep 7 2024 8:34 utc | 290
“all” means 100%

Posted by: Justpassinby | Sep 7 2024 8:36 utc | 290

Refinnejenna | Sep 6 2024 22:27 utc | 196
“I have looked up the Bibi Ghar massacre in Cawnpore (Kanpur) in 1857 on Wikipedia”
Wiki, as everyone here should be well aware, is wholly useless for anything which can be considered political. Great for energy levels in hydrogen atoms, useless for contentious topics.

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Sep 7 2024 8:37 utc | 291

@Milites | Sat, 07 Sep 2024 08:25:00 GMT | 287
I wouldn’t waste any time on Ed4. The dude’s a troll, who posits false premises and never deviates from them. Waste of time, better things to do.

Posted by: James M. | Sep 7 2024 8:39 utc | 292

Getting back to the events.
The Brits and French appear to have permitted their cruise missiles, scalp and whatever storm shadow to be used for deep strikes into Russia.
Where’s the next escalation in return going to be?

Posted by: jpc | Sep 7 2024 8:42 utc | 293

Don’t be shy, Two Majors post more than armchair summaries, their channel can be ready perfectly well in browser-translation, I find Chrome / Google to be far more accurate than Safari / Apple on Russian-to-English.
https://t.me/dva_majors/51804

⚡️The West is trying to patch up the holes in the Ukrainian air defense system and load up its military-industrial complex
🇩🇪Germany announces the delivery of 2 IRIS-T SLM batteries (each with 3 launchers), 1 IRIS-T SLS battery with one additional launcher of this modification by the end of 2024. In 2025-2026, another 6 SLM batteries and 4 SLS batteries with two additional SLS launchers will be delivered .
🇷🇴Romania, at the behest of the owners of🇺🇸The US has passed a bill to transfer Patriot air defense missile systems (probably one or more launchers) to Ukraine. The Americans themselves will send RIM-7 Sea Sparrow ship-to-air air defense missiles to Ukraine.
🇪🇸Spain has announced the immediate provision of a full battery of HAWK air defence missile systems , including six launchers.
🇨🇦Canada will transfer the NASAMS air defense system to Ukraine in early 2025, having spent more than $400 million on this.
🇬🇧Britain will provide 650 LMM Martlet missiles in the anti-aircraft modification. The British Ministry of Defence reports that the first batch of LMMs will be sent to Ukraine before the end of this year, with the rest to follow in 2025 .
✨The urgent nature of the transfer of air defense systems was probably influenced by the speed of their destruction by the Russian army. At the same time, such a quantity would barely be enough to cover critically important objects , not to mention creating an echeloned defense for the enemy. In addition, time constraints will definitely not allow training operators of foreign systems from among the Air Force, which means the use of⚡️NATO “vacationers” .
✨⭐️Let’s note right away. Such conclusions are not boastfulness. But a window of opportunity. Not for long.

Posted by: anon2020 | Sep 7 2024 8:46 utc | 294

Two-Tier Kier is getting a Siberian cat:
https://www.theguardian.com/politics/article/2024/sep/07/starmer-compromise-new-family-pet-siberian-kitten-dog-like-cat
If the cat is a true breed, the Starmers would also appear to be lucky in getting a Siberian at a time when Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine has caused some breeders in Britain to pause before importing new additions from Russia. Staveley said: “They have only really been here since around 2002 when someone imported one and, for most breeders, the basic stock is from Russia. The true, traditional Siberians are based on Russian breeding – and Russians are very guarded about anyone using anything that interfere with those lines.” She added that adverts offering Siberian cats for as little as a few hundred pounds should be treated with caution.
They forgot to say “full-scale” and “unprovoked”.

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Sep 7 2024 8:46 utc | 295

Deluge
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deluge_(history)
This is the origin
This is the origin of the whole mess
The rabbis after the expansion of Christianity decided not to be a religion …
(which is what it had been in the past in the times of the Persians, the Greeks and the Romans, when Judaism was made up of people from “all the nations of the world”, of the world of that time seen from the mediterranean)
… and with the passage of time the rabbis forged an ethnic group: the Yiddish people
and the Yiddish people triumphed demographically in Poland-Lithuania by finding a place in the totem pole
A) Catholic aristocracy
B) Yiddish people
C) Christian peasantry
Hell for C, paradise on earth for A and B
until the Cossacks and the Russians destroyed the paradise
the Ukrainians, the Russians and the Palestinians … They are paying this old broken porcelain

E x a c t l y

Posted by: Simon | Sep 7 2024 8:46 utc | 296

Posted by: James M. | Sep 7 2024 8:39 utc | 293
Disagree. I didn’t read Ed4 comment and Milites reply was very interesting. So thanks Ed4 for bringing up that response with whatever it is that you wrote.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Sep 7 2024 8:52 utc | 297

Glowie slime have been trying to gainsay reports like this from the outset and yet here we are, still.
The question of motive is to be expected.
https://t.me/dva_majors/51801

Forwarded from Revenge of good will
How many times in the last six months in the Voronezh region, due to “falling debris from a downed or suppressed UAV”, a fire breaks out, which spreads to explosive objects.” And they begin to detonate….
What kind of genius in the group did not understand the first time that these objects need to be dispersed as much as possible?
How many times can you catch the same feed from the hohols in the same Ostrogozhsk district?
Well, maybe then someone should set up a headquarters in the place where those very explosive objects are stored, and put the most responsible person on the boxes with those objects? Since you can neither disperse nor provide air defense for your warehouses.
You are wasting in such a worthless and useless way such now so precious “explosive objects”, the production of which was established by the Motherland. Factories are working around the clock, and your “military genius” hasn’t been able to come up with anything worthwhile, and shells from UAV crashes continue to explode in warehouses in the same areas of the same region…

Posted by: anon2020 | Sep 7 2024 8:54 utc | 298

Posted by: anon2020 | Sep 6 2024 15:57 utc | 110
Real purposes of meshes in this case is either to crush warhead and prevent proper forming of cumulative jet stream, or remote chance warhead (drone etc.) to entangle in it and not detonate at all (most of drone warheads have that copper wire in front so detonation is almost ensured). Lancets have laser proximity fuse so no help with that too.
Standoff distance for HEAT warheads is large enough – detonating it 1 meter or even 2 meters from the vehicle has negligible or small effect on reducing penetrating power of modern warheads.

Posted by: Abe | Sep 7 2024 8:58 utc | 299

“Jesus (…)”

The clash was with the Sadducean oligarchy, and in particular the clan of the Annas, who held power in the sun and in the shade between the cadastral census of Sulpicius Quirinius (ca. 6) and when Menahem (ca. 66) -“no more lord than the Lord”- beheaded the high priest Annas the young son of Annas the old father-in-law of Caiaphas … and …
“burned the archives of the Debts”
the sons of the oligarchy killed Menahem “after subjecting him to many torments” … and they redirected the agrarian revolt, giving rise to “the events that occurred among us”, which are three:
(1) the civil war in Syria
(2) the civil war between the jewish population and the jewish people, and
(3) the war against the Romans
Posted by: Simon | Sep 6 2024 17:33 utc | 133

(You should look for another insult, for example arrogant hebrew, because calling me ignorant seems funny to me coming from the mouths of complete ignoramuses)

Posted by: Simon | Sep 7 2024 9:02 utc | 300