Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
August 4, 2024
Ukraine Open Thread 2024-185

News & views related to the war in Ukraine …

Comments

Suresh | Aug 4 2024 23:34 utc | 99
With the Patriot – no surface to surface. The interceptor targeted a Russian plane and Russian ground based air defence took it down.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Aug 4 2024 23:46 utc | 101

There’s news Russian AD are intercepting Patriot missiles. The assumption is 404 is using Patriot in a SSM role much like the S200 earlier in the conflict.
Posted by: Suresh | Aug 4 2024 23:34 utc | 99
Russian ground based air defence took down an interceptor that had targeted a Russian plane. Waste of time have wet dreams about patriot being used in ground attack mode.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Aug 4 2024 23:59 utc | 102

🇺🇦 Uprisings in the historically Polish city of Kovel in Western Ukraine.
Setting cars on fire will seem like kindergarten. They will start to kill each other. The families of the victims, and the returning survivors who were once arrested and packed a recruitment van.
Zelensky’s recruitment goons havd only one way out – emigration and out of Ukraine.
Western Ukraine is the nest of nazi ideology but with reluctance to die for their ideas. To be a nazi on the sly, to bait, to incite – yes, to fight – no.
And this applies not only to the current residents of Western Ukraine.
The Bandera emigrants don’t want to fight. Literally a few came from Australia, Canada, USA, UK, etc. Although it was they who incited the war and hatred of the Russians most of all. They had been preparing for war for 70 years. In reality, more Anglo-Saxon Australians left to fight than Bandera emigrants from Australia’s Ukrainian diaspora.
Begging for money for weapons, yelling at rallies, begging on your knees in front of politicians in Melbourne, visiting Kiev with lectures on how to properly cut off a Muscovite’s head – yes, fighting – no.
The bulk of the TCC recruiters are also from Western Ukraine. They are also control Ukraine’s barrier detachment anti-retreat shooting squads.
How did the rest of Ukraine fall for the ideas of this schizophrenic minority?
The most backward region of the country, where there is no culture, no art, no science, no work, no medicine, no industries, no roads. For 30 years of independence, they build anything they just drifted further away – some to Kiev and Odessa, some to Poland, some to the West.
Everyone who is skimming the cream of this slaughter today like Zelensky making a 30% commission on a private funeral monopoly on all funerals for dead Ukrainian soldiers.
Then there’s all sorts of funders from emigres in Melbourne who made money from Ukrainian war donations and a career on someone else’s blood, but never showed up for the war.
🎙@AussieCossack via @tasmanian_diablo
“>https://t.me/DDGeopolitics/118377

That’s pretty much how I understand it. Neo-Banderites from the US and Ukrainian ultra-nationalists who stay behind tne front lines, basically doing PR, organizing meetings, are sending people they kidnap on the streets to be slaughtered, just to please the “sponsors” and get money and weapons. The Banderites and gheir sponsors want parts of Russia for themselves and they are obsessive about it. So, the endgame is pretty clear: no negotiated agreement is on the radar.

Posted by: Richard L | Aug 5 2024 0:02 utc | 103

Deepstate had a second intel drop today.
1. Pretty extensive increases in the Progress bloom. That flower bush is growing like a weed. Advances into Zhelane, Serhiivka, and Ivanivka. Along with some more fields to widen the branches.
2. Small RFA advances near Zilazne (Toretsk).
3. Field advance, to the canal, SE of Chasiv Yar. Sorta looks like RFA is trying to broaden that front, given the difficulties moving into the town.
My take is (2) and (3) are pretty positional and not that noteworthy. (1) is where the action is and where RFA has good initiative.

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 0:03 utc | 104

Newbie | Aug 4 2024 22:03 utc | 86
Islanders have a good chance of getting the pilots as well. With a good warning system many pilots would survive their aircraft being target and shot down.
But whatever. They will go the way of the mighty Leopards and Abrams. Nato might gety in a few propaganda hits but that is meaningless in the scale of things. The end result that Nato will burn, like the mighty Leopards, Abrams, and now F-16’s is near inevitable.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Aug 4 2024 23:09 utc | 95
Yes about the warning systems, and that’s why I mentioned they’d be used as AD against drones and cruise missiles as ukraine is lacking, but far from the front (which with the pod and AA missiles at range limit will probably be enough to save a lot of pilots from a downed f-16)
But Iskanders would have to fly and hit the runways before the pilot leaves, I’d see ukraine using sub-rookies to taxi and get the pilot out as soon as it lands. If I can think about it, so can they.Iskanders are fast but far from instantaneous (and runways will be deep in ukraine). I’d rather use R-37 and take the chance of the pilot bailing in time, 60kg of HE +fragmentation is not so easy to survive.

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 5 2024 0:09 utc | 105

Russian ground based air defence took down an interceptor that had targeted a Russian plane. Waste of time have wet dreams about patriot being used in ground attack mode.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Aug 4 2024 23:59 utc | 102
And a serious waste of badly needed AD for ukraine.
I think they are even regretting having wasted any S-200 missiles.

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 5 2024 0:12 utc | 106

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 4 2024 21:39 utc | 79
Or the SAS method in the Libyan desert, destroy the planes and or kill the pilots, crew and technicians.
Posted by: Newbie | Aug 4 2024 21:44 utc | 81
The recent success of NATO shooting down Iranian drones and missiles would suggest that CAP is their primary role.
Posted by: HB_Norica | Aug 4 2024 22:00 utc | 85
Don’t forget air density also being a restrictor on AAM performance, and that the S-300 onwards were designed to fly above a target and descend on it, allowing high hit probabilities against Lo flight profiles. IIRC, two Ukrainian planes were shot down, coming into their approach runs, by a SAM system nearly 200km away, so F-16’s trying lo-hi-lo attacks won’t be safe on the egress.
Posted by: Neofeudalfuture | Aug 4 2024 22:07 utc | 87
Just like Me-262 pilots were encouraged to flow low over German towns and garrisons. More than likely their tactic initially will be to claim any successful strike in Crimea/Russia was carried out by F-16’s, the Ghost of Kiev resurrected.
Posted by: vargas | Aug 4 2024 22:36 utc | 91
If they do, the methods used will suggest accidental loss.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Aug 4 2024 23:17 utc | 97
More than likely, but NATO aircraft usually operate in strike packages so, unless they are ‘assisted’, the Ukrainian F-16’s won’t tell them too much vis-a-vis a straight match up, but lots of electronic data could be gathered I suppose.
Posted by: Suresh | Aug 4 2024 23:34 utc | 99
IIRC that exercise did not allow BVR (Beyond Visual Range) engagements, if they had history suggests those Mig-21 pilots wouldn’t have got near the F-15’s. Under exercise conditions pilots tend to take more risks, especially if bragging rights are the reward, so you hear of Buccaneers taking out F-15’s and F-22’s losing to F-16’s.

Posted by: Milites | Aug 5 2024 0:23 utc | 107

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 0:03 utc | 104
I’d be watching 2 and 3, you never should focus on one sector. Feint, fix, strike, the operational version of the tactical maxim, find, fix, flank, finish.
Posted by: Newbie | Aug 5 2024 0:09 utc | 105
Nope, just crater the runway or seed it with bomblets, when they are landing, forcing them to an alternate or ditch. To execute a real-time strike a hypersonic would probably be the weapon of choice.

Posted by: Milites | Aug 5 2024 0:59 utc | 108

Milites | Aug 5 2024 0:23 utc | 107
The most interesting thing I have read was number 35 when oz government asked for submissions on purchasing the joint strike fighter package or whatever it was called.
Worth looking up. American optics can be devastating to civilian targets, …

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Aug 5 2024 1:14 utc | 109

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 4 2024 21:44 utc | 81
The recent success of NATO shooting down Iranian drones and missiles would suggest that CAP is their primary role.
.
Posted by: Milites | Aug 5 2024 0:23 utc | 107
Did one of us misread or are you confirming my 81?
“I now think that it’s main role, given the limited pilots available, is to work as AD against drones and cruise missiles (ideally far from the LOC)”
I also mentioned the refueling to allow longer patrols as they hunt cruise missiles and drones…

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 5 2024 1:16 utc | 110

Regarding F-16s in Ukraine- They need a lot of ground support. That either means NATO crews in Ukraine, or landing and taking off from NATO countries. Ukraine simply does not have trained personnel for this.
If it’s NATO crews in Ukraine, there will have to be a lot of them, because the obvious response for the RF is to crater the runways and blow up the maintenance facilities as soon as they detect a launch. The planes will have to land somewhere else, and there has to be a ground crew there to keep the aircraft flight-worthy, refuel and re-arm it. And all of that has a decent chance of being destroyed before the planes can be moved elsewhere. The whole business seems incredibly expensive and impractical to me- too many ground crews, too much maintenance equipment, and aircraft that may get only one or two sorties apiece.
On the other hand, Putin wouldn’t dare strike a NATO base in Romania or Poland, would he? I believe that’s the ‘thinking’ of the western leadership, and that scares me.

Posted by: Honzo | Aug 5 2024 1:18 utc | 111

Constitution-class Starships? When will NCC-1701 be available?
Posted by: Zippy the Pinhead | Aug 4 2024 14:59 utc | 14
But Russia is the combatant known as the ‘Federation.’

Posted by: Honzo | Aug 5 2024 1:21 utc | 112

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 5 2024 0:09 utc | 105
Nope, just crater the runway or seed it with bomblets, when they are landing, forcing them to an alternate or ditch. To execute a real-time strike a hypersonic would probably be the weapon of choice.
Posted by: Milites | Aug 5 2024 0:59 utc | 108
When they have 6 pilots and 60+ fighters?
Wouldn’t sending mig-31 with long range AA (maybe spend some old R-40s) a better bet?
Ok, ok, just get a couple on the ground, or ditched, to say “1 down” but then go after the pilots

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 5 2024 1:25 utc | 113

On the other hand, Putin wouldn’t dare strike a NATO base in Romania or Poland, would he? I believe that’s the ‘thinking’ of the western leadership, and that scares me.
Posted by: Honzo | Aug 5 2024 1:18 utc | 111
Some good intel to prove they attacked from there.
Plenty of “I told you so”
Wouldn’t Putin ? “Hold my beer…”

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 5 2024 1:29 utc | 114

DPA frontline changes just dropped:
Mostly same as DS, but a few areas where he sees more. All RFA captures.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n_mT6T6eM9s
North to south:
Canal (Chasiv Yar): Cites DS for withdrawing from east of the canal.
Toretsk:
1. Advance within Pivnichne per DS and a geolocation.
2. Pretty sizeable advance at the far west of Zalizne salient. Per Rybar and a geolocation. Configures RFA to go after Toretsk even without taking the two slag heaps (pass to the west of them).
NY: Nothing.
Progress bloom:
1. Entering into south of Lysitchni (spelling?) and Ivanivka (both west of Timofivke (spelling).
2. Some fields in that area too.
3. Entering Serhivka from east and south (looks like just repeating the DS map)
Urozahne (small advance, geolocation, not a DS thing)
Orokiv sector: east of Robotyne, geolocation shows RFA clearing old Surovikin line trench. Implies capture of a big pocket that was showing grey zone. If true, expect DS to admit it in a day or two. Need to wait though, as it’s just one strange geolocation on a big area, and not even RFA claims. But we will see. DPA admits this is a bold DPA claim now (no other mappers drawing it this way). So we need to wait and see if he’s right.

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 1:34 utc | 115

Re: Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Aug 4 2024 21:16 utc | 73

https://www.usdebtclock.org/
Just a friendly reminder…

You seem utterly obsessed with this JRL.
You are probably not aware of some other facts though.
Debt to GDP
Japan – 264%
USA – 122%.
Japan’s debt is twice as high as the US when compared to GDP.
Do you know when Japan had debt to GDP at 122%? It was decades ago.
There is no time in the near future that the US defaulting – this has decades to run, and decades of funding to provide for foreign wars.
The war in Ukraine will be well over before the US Debt becomes a serious problem.
You need to chill.
Japan didn’t even hold the global reserve currency either!

Posted by: Julian | Aug 5 2024 4:26 utc | 116

You need to chill.
Japan didn’t even hold the global reserve currency either!
Posted by: Julian | Aug 5 2024 4:26 utc | 116
_____________________________________________________________________________________________________
ZH has a posting up with the title
Japanic Monday: Japanese Bonds, Stocks Halted After Plunging Into Bear Market As Everything Crashes Everywhere
Either way it seems the shit show might come to a halt/pause/shudder/???
Posted by: psychohistorian | Aug 5 2024 4:10 utc | 121 from Open Thread

Posted by: Suresh | Aug 5 2024 4:43 utc | 117

In response to

Japan didn’t even hold the global reserve currency either!
Posted by: Julian | Aug 5 2024 4:26 utc | 116

Japan is the current largest holder of US Treasuries at over 1 trillion and their economy/financials are crashing as I write this
[current ZH posting title]
Japanic Monday: Japanese Bonds, Stocks Halted After Plunging Into Bear Market As Everything Crashes Everywhere
Japan just might want to cash in some of their US Treasuries to support their financials and what are going to be the effects?….chill eh?
Have a nice life and the days will take care of themselves.
Live the Hopi precepts
Show up
Be present
Tell the truth
Don’t own the outcome

Posted by: psychohistorian | Aug 5 2024 4:45 utc | 118

📋🇷🇺🇺🇦⚔️ Two Majors #Summary for the Morning of 5 August 2024; 06:55 (GMT+3)📍
🎯During the night, the RFAF used several groups of attack UAVs to hit enemy facilities in the #Kiev (Bila Tserkva), #Vinnitsa, #Kharkov, #Sumy, #Dnepropetrovsk, #Cherkassy and #Poltava regions. Combat work continued until the morning.
💥The AFU, as reported by our monitoring channels, conducted UAV counter actions with aircraft-type UAVs, there were reports of individual drones in #Kursk and #Belgorod regions, as well as near the #Krasnodar territory.
🔹In the #Kharkov direction, there are oncoming battles in #Volchansk. Our assault groups are fighting their way into the area of ​​high-rise buildings and completing the clearing of occupied houses. During the day, the AFU made 1 attack attempt in the area of ​​the #Staritsa settlement. The enemy assault group was discovered in advance by recon and destroyed.
🔹In the #Svatovo-#Kupyansk section, they report the capture of several enemy strongholds in the area of the Berestovoye-Peschanoye ledge.
🔹North of #ChasovYar, our troops are strengthening the bridgehead for further actions in the town, to the west of the canal. The AFU is using many FPV drones around the clock, hampering the Russian actions.
🔹In the #Toretsk (#Dzerzhinsk) agglomeration, the RFAF are advancing in the remaining western part of #Zaliznoye (#Artemovo), small assault groups making their way to the Central-330 power substation. The enemy writes that in #NyuYork (#Novgorodskoye) Russian forces are pressing in the western part of the settlement in the western and northern directions, bypassing the ‘Phenolny plant’ and constraining the logistics of the AFU. There are battles for waste heaps near several mines.
🔹West of #Avdeyevka, they report fierce fighting in the village of #Zhelannoye, our stormtroopers entered from the northeast and also advanced from the northwestern outskirts along the railway, the foe was surrounded in a number of its positions, prisoners were taken. Against the background of the RF MoD’s confirmation of full control over #Novosyolovka1st, foe channels are reporting the expansion of the RFAF’s zone of control near the settlement.
🔹On the #Zaporozhye front, there are mainly positional battles, at the weekend it was reported that to the north of #Rabotino our fighters, supported by artillery, managed to advance and encircle several AFU strongholds.
🔹In the #Kherson direction, both sides continue their actions in the island zone, the AFU struck at #Alyoshki, a nine-storey apartment block caught fire. A man born in 1976 was injured.
💥In #Belgorod region, was shelled by the AFU 11 times over the past day, a woman was killed and 5 people were wounded. The Shebekinsky and Valuysky urban districts, as well as the Belgorod district are under attack. The foe is targeting civilians. 🎬👇
💥In the #Kursk region, the AFU shelled the Krasny Pakhar Farm in the Rylsky district. During the day, enemy drones attacked the Sudzha Checkpoint, the villages of #Gornal, Nikolayevo-Daryino and #Guyevo, and the village of #Kurilovka in the Sudzha district.
🛡Electronic warfare means and small arms suppressed and destroyed❗️42 Ukrainian drones in the border areas over the day.
💥At #Lugansk yesterday, the AFU fired 12 missiles. Presumably 8 ATACMS and 4 Storm Shadow missiles.
💥In the #DPR, in #Donetsk, a woman born in 1959 was injured in a barrel artillery shelling by the AFU, and a woman born in 1940 was also injured as a result of a drop from a Ukrainian UAV. In Gorlovka, a woman born in 1962 was injured in a drop from a foe drone. The AFU attacked the region 26 times, more than 60 munitions were fired. HIMARS, 155 mm barrel artillery and attack UAVs were used. #Donetsk, #Makeyevka and #Gorlovka were under attack.

https://t.me/two_majors/28983

Posted by: Down South | Aug 5 2024 4:53 utc | 119

@ Down South | Aug 5 2024 4:53 utc | 119 with the MOD basics…thanks again

Posted by: psychohistorian | Aug 5 2024 5:06 utc | 120

Posted by: psychohistorian | Aug 5 2024 5:06 utc | 120
No problem

Posted by: Down South | Aug 5 2024 6:37 utc | 121

Any idea who’s piloting these aircraft ? Are they foolish or brave ?

Posted by: Pyewacket | Aug 5 2024 6:39 utc | 122

The F-16ADF Zelensky was posing with in the photo shoot was a decommissioned plane from US air force.
https://x.com/MyLordBebo/status/1820206058629165117

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 5 2024 7:14 utc | 123

Any idea who’s piloting these aircraft ? Are they foolish or brave ?
Posted by: Pyewacket | Aug 5 2024 6:39 utc | 122

Probably just (well) paid.

Posted by: Justpassinby | Aug 5 2024 7:29 utc | 124

The war in Ukraine will be well over before the US Debt becomes a serious problem.
Posted by: Julian | Aug 5 2024 4:26 utc | 116
It never can be a ‘serious problem’. Paying interest is entirely a policy choice, and eventually the US will stop paying interest as the Japanese have done for decades.
The US could drop the rate to zero, and the exports would still flow into the US. There is no untapped source of demand anywhere else. Those who are over-invested and have excess production would rather hold US promises than have stock wasting away unsold. There simply isn’t anywhere else to go other than stop production completely.
The US can fund their side of the war indefinitely – just as the Russians can fund theirs. There is never a shortage of money. There can only ever be a shortage of stuff.

Posted by: The Accountant | Aug 5 2024 7:38 utc | 125

@34 Jams O’ Donnell
I was suprised to read that the SU 17 could outclass a F16 (c/d version) . Could you point me to some links as I was under the impression that the Su17 was relatively outdated by the time te F16’s Block 52 batches were being produced?
Thanks in advance
JB

Posted by: Judge Barbier | Aug 5 2024 7:38 utc | 126

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 5 2024 1:25 utc | 113
The F-16’s will probably just be used as missile platforms, Su-24’s, without the iPads, meaning lo-hi-lo flight profiles, from a ‘jump’ field, before dashing for the safety of Rumanian airspace. This makes them difficult targets for AAM’s, whilst also setting up the possibility of a SAM ambush for the Russian CAP, as they’ve done in the past. I’d think a new warhead for the Iskander has been trialled, possibly using search and destroy sub-munitions, and the jump field will be targeted as the F-16’s are being prepped.
Whatever happens, the impact of the platform is much reduced due to the lengthy period between its deployment and initial announcement. Again, Ukrainian strategic implementing seems to be disjointed with the deployment of F-16’s not timed with the targeting of the Russian AWACS, just as the targeting of landing ships was continued after the Kerch Bridge and Summer offensive had failed, suggesting these operations had no real strategic goal and were simply targets of opportunity to bolster morale.
Like most wars, the eventual winners and losers of the SMO were decided largely by how they reacted when the original plan failed to deliver the expected outcome. Russia took a leaf out of its history books and went for attritional warfare, Ukraine went for literary inspiration, namely Charles Dickens’ Mr Micawber!

Posted by: Milites | Aug 5 2024 7:42 utc | 127

Paying interest is entirely a policy choice …
Posted by: The Accountant | Aug 5 2024 7:38 utc | 125

Ha Ha. No! Interest is a demand made by the creditor, not an offer from the debtor.

Posted by: too scents | Aug 5 2024 7:46 utc | 128

Any idea who’s piloting these aircraft ? Are they foolish or brave ?
Posted by: Pyewacket | Aug 5 2024 6:39 utc | 122
The same types who thought killing Russians would be the same as an Afghan safari. Top gun types.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Aug 5 2024 7:51 utc | 129

Any idea who’s piloting these aircraft ? Are they foolish or brave ?
Posted by: Pyewacket | Aug 5 2024 6:39 utc | 122
Probably just (well) paid.
Posted by: Justpassinby | Aug 5 2024 7:29 utc | 124
I don’t know about the well paid part. In the report from Romania (if real) it says they’ve trained 50 kamikaze in 6 months, but only 3 were able to fly at the end of this great training. ( en.topcor.ru/50080-v-rumynii-podgotovili-vsego-treh-ukrainskih-letchikov-dlja-istrebitelej-f-16.html )

Posted by: rk | Aug 5 2024 8:01 utc | 130

Posted by: Pyewacket | Aug 5 2024 6:39 utc | 122
Will anyone be in the planes?
https://taskandpurpose.com/news/ai-pilot-f-16/
Will the pilots remain on the ground?
https://www.airforce.com/careers/aviation-and-flight/remotely-piloted-aircraft-pilot

Posted by: Milites | Aug 5 2024 8:13 utc | 131

@Milites | Aug 5 2024 8:13 utc | 131
If they have them, what are they waiting for? Put your money where your mouth is.

Posted by: rk | Aug 5 2024 8:20 utc | 132

Interesting analysis, using the three horizon model, about the development of UAV’s, commonly called drones. What’s interesting is that the model can be exported to the drone’s targets.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0016328721001579

Posted by: Milites | Aug 5 2024 8:21 utc | 133

❌📱❌Poturaev again threatens to completely ban Telegram in Ukraine:
🟢We ​​are not losing [the information war], but we are constantly on the brink. Artificial intelligence has already begun to be widely used, much faster than I predicted. I believe that we are not ready for this as of today, and the West was not fully prepared;
🟢There are no resources to regulate [Telegram]. And it won’t. And there is no possibility and there will not be one, because it is not in our jurisdiction. This applies to any social networks. What will happen if we do not pay attention to these threats – there will be no Ukraine. Because we cannot talk about any information hygiene;
🟢Telegram needs to be disabled like “Vkontakte” and “Odnoklassniki”;
🟢Of course there is a technical possibility for this;
🟢When you have 80% of the population using an unmoderated social network, and fundamentally unmoderated, whose leadership does not communicate with your state, according to which there is enough evidence that it remains affiliated with Russia, under the influence of Russian special services, this is a big mistake, which, I repeat, will be expensive.
I don’t see any other option how not to lose – not just the information war, but the war in general – except to write a fairly simple bill, the essence of which would be that either networks or platforms establish a dialogue with the Ukrainian state, or the state simply closes them.
Why, it turns out we are losing the war because of Telegram🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

https://t.me/ZeRada1/20862

Posted by: Down South | Aug 5 2024 8:30 utc | 134

@Milites | Aug 5 2024 8:21 utc | 133
You get paid by post count or just like to embarrass yourself every day?
It’s a moronic paper, says nothing and is written by a guy who works at a Department of Political Science. He’s also an self titled expert on twitter, in Russia’s “poor military performance”

Posted by: rk | Aug 5 2024 8:34 utc | 135

Posted by: rk | Aug 5 2024 8:01 utc | 130
yes, that report, if indeed true, paints a picture about the ukrainian pilots, but the cynic in me also expects to see “ukrainian” pilots that are not mentioned in that report.
simply because of the optics for the us (planes). they cannot risk them beeing shot down in droves, even if the sheer number of manufactured ones is huge. so as others said, i also believe that the planes will be more used as ad and long-range shoot and scoop, and for that you dont need the 3 ukrainian pilots. nato has already said that they have trained pilots in more countries then just romania, so theres that plausible deniability again.
and if a f16 is shot down in western ukraine with no access to the pilot from the russian or ukrainian patriots side, then theres also no way to tell if they are using ukrainians, or “ukrainians”.
thats why i think (well) paid.

Posted by: Justpassinby | Aug 5 2024 8:46 utc | 136

Posted by: Jeremy Rhymings-Lang | Aug 4 2024 18:34 utc | 45
Nah. Russia will buy high level waste to reprocess it into fuel. Nobody’s buying Ukie bonds for fuel as it is all digital.

Posted by: badjoke | Aug 5 2024 9:07 utc | 137

Posted by: rk | Aug 5 2024 8:34 utc | 135
No, I’m on holiday and I’ve finished the gardening so sitting having a coffee, you? Oh, and stroking the cat who intermittently nudges my iPad, making typing somewhat problematic.
You either are a speed reader, have nothing to do with your time (two responses to my posts) or do not understand the article. As for Russia ‘poor military performance’, what of it? Every military performs poorly, the trick is to fight somebody who is worse, perform poorly in areas that are not critical to operational success criteria, and/or improve rapidly by adaptation.
Historical point, the Russian armoured forces in WW2 initially performed poorly (for numerous reasons), their tanks had appalling SA, due to compromises in design and rapidly became obsolete by ‘43. They adapted designs quickly, focused on mass production of a few platforms, meaning that they could absorb the losses resulting from poor tactical implementation. Crucially they improved as their opponents deteriorated, so eventually won.
The PBI faired far worse, throughout the war, but were carried to victory (quite literally) by the adapted and improved armoured forces. The artillery, always Russia’s ‘strong suit’ had its weaknesses, mainly doctrinal, but was a major reason why the problems of the other two branches of the army were not strategically fatal.
All had weaknesses, but none of them were fatal, unlike the Germans, whose strengths were never enough to address the areas of weakness the Soviets exploited, the formula for military victory .

Posted by: Milites | Aug 5 2024 9:13 utc | 138

Debt to GDP
Japan – 264%
USA – 122%.
Japan’s debt is twice as high as the US when compared to GDP.

Japan national dept is mostly local
US national dept is foreign.

Posted by: MAKK | Aug 5 2024 9:13 utc | 139

The Accountant @ Aug 5 2024 7:38 utc | 125
[BLOCKQUOTE]
It never can be a ‘serious problem’. Paying interest is entirely a policy choice, and eventually the US will stop paying interest as the Japanese have done for decades.
[/BLOCKQUOTE]
Have your cake and eat it, MMT much? Low interest rates coincide with inflation, that’s why the Fed is raising rates. Keeping rates at zero is a choice but a constrained one. Low rates lead to capital flight to higher paying locations, also no one wants to hold a depreciating reserve currency.
Please also note that the petrodollar mechanism just expired that was the foundation of that status. It will take a few years for this to become common knowledge but be assured the non-western central banks are acutely aware. Japan also only had that choice because of that regime and the famous ‘japanese housewife’.
[BLOCKQUOTE]
The US could drop the rate to zero, and the exports would still flow into the US. There is no untapped source of demand anywhere else. Those who are over-invested and have excess production would rather hold US promises than have stock wasting away unsold. There simply isn’t anywhere else to go other than stop production completely.
[/BLOCKQUOTE]
Exports will flow as long as there is a trade balance. With US deollar having lost a fifth of the value and tariffs exports will go down. China is rotating into a domestic market, EU is on deindustrialising, intra-BRICS trade will soon take off due to banking mechanisms and brand new infrastructure. In times of lean production there is not as much surplus as you may think. Computerized machines can be repurposed fairly quickly, whether you look at circuits, injection molding, textiles, CNC lathes, you name it. The whole dropship business means that one block order is quickly followed by the nect. Look at alibaba.com if you don’t believe me. Chinese exports don’t exist in a vacuum, trade only happens if mutually beneficial. There are short periods of imbalance but these will quickly be adjusted.
[BLOCKQUOTE]
The US can fund their side of the war indefinitely – just as the Russians can fund theirs. There is never a shortage of money. There can only ever be a shortage of stuff.
[/BLOCKQUOTE]
Ye good olde American exceptionalism, those who know the price of everything and the value of nothing. Yes you can print money or mint a few trillion dollar coins. This doesn’t mean you will be able to buy anything with it. The military budget as well as social security are bloated to a point where soon paying interest will eat half the tax income. Yes, you can print that money but it puts you on the road to Weimar, even the Romans were smarter than that. Every dollar spent on war will enter a black hole and people wise up to that. Every dollar spent on bombs is a dollar taken away from investment, infrastructure, education, health. This is eating your seed corn.
I think you are working on outdated assumptions thay may have held 40 years ago. Just in the last 5 years the Minsky Moment happened, did you notice? This is not Kansas anymore, end of history was cancelled.

Posted by: SOS | Aug 5 2024 9:53 utc | 140

Some points of Theti Mapping and Dima/Ms.
Seems RUAF is moving between the Ugledar-Konstaninivka road toward Vodyane and bombing the few coal mines around it. Vodyane is the only real anchor point of defense between Ugledar and Konstanyivka. It could be small groups and FPV control (the FPVs can reach far NW/W of the road). RUAF also made a smaller attack on Konstantinyvka SE corner, gaining some more houses. This seems to be the heaviest battles in this area, with AFU can counter with FPVs.
RUAF is squeezing Zhelanne, and the trenches east of it. The trenches originally were eastward facing, not intended to defend from attacks to the north or even west, from Vodyane. So we could expect this area to collapse at some point.
RUAF moved SW of Pivdichnye, through the light forest and they could theoretically reach the electrical station which could give them a nice foothold to attack the area north of New York. And also cut tighten strangle on the envelope SE of New York.
RUAF made large gains north of Pivdenne and even toward Toretsk. The landfill-terracon is unholdable for AFU, the only thing they have going for them are FPV drones and its height advantage, where AFU soldiers could theoretically overlook RUAF movement to the east and NE. But it should become outflanked and enveloped, anyway.

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 5 2024 10:03 utc | 141

Posted by: Naive | Aug 4 2024 23:03 utc | 94
The G7 used to be called the group of most industrialized nations.
It was always referred as such in the sleazy newz.
Not any more.
The apt reference now would be: G7, the group of most indebted nations.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Aug 5 2024 10:07 utc | 142

Debt to GDP
Japan – 264%
USA – 122%.
Japan’s debt is twice as high as the US when compared to GDP.
Japan national dept is mostly local
US national dept is foreign.
Posted by: MAKK | Aug 5 2024 9:13 utc | 139
It’s actually not, you can look it up. Its the same as Japan. Majority local owned.
Media hype about foreign ownership US debt is overstated. Foreigners have to trade real things to get fx needed to buy US debt, which is always harder than the Fed tapping a few keystrokes to monetize the latest bond issue.

Posted by: Autumn | Aug 5 2024 10:59 utc | 143

https://t.me/rusengineer/4832

Forwarded from Andrey Medvedev
Massive strikes by Ukrainian UAVs on Russian cities are not necessarily preparation for a demonstrative and imitation offensive, as my colleague believes. It is obvious that a real offensive by the Ukrainian Armed Forces cannot be carried out, but it is quite possible to feign something in order to receive new military trenches.
But in this case, we are still dealing with ordinary terrorism on the part of the Ukrainian Armed Forces. The strikes on residential buildings last night were carried out completely deliberately . And all this is not being done in order to get some result right now, at the moment. The strikes are carried out to create a cumulative effect. Today, on residential buildings, the day after tomorrow, next week, again, again, again. Together with the active work of the enemy in social networks and instant messengers, this should create the feeling that the Russian government is allegedly unable to protect people.
I am not revealing any secret. All this is in any NATO manual on hybrid warfare. For the internal, Ukrainian information field, UAV raids are used to create a sense of victory over the Russians. In Ukropublics, they are already writing en masse about the “night of the drones”. However, this will not help Ukraine win in any way. Even the F16 will not help. Just as the use of the first jet fighters at the end of the war did not help the Third Reich.
At the same time, it should be noted that the effectiveness of the enemy’s use of UAVs is constantly growing. As is the quality of the UAVs themselves, many of which are the result of the work of volunteer groups that have received support from the Ukrainian authorities. This applies to all types of UAVs, both long-range and frontline , and there are the first examples of heavy drones, which are simultaneously a repeater and a deliverer of attack FPV drones.
This is happening at a time when they are trying to create a kind of super monopolist in the field of drone production, which, supposedly, will cover all the needs of the front. The decision is extremely controversial.
And also, the enemy’s UAV raids are aimed at overloading our air defense in the rear as a whole. By deliberately carrying out terrorist strikes on residential buildings, the Ukrainian Armed Forces are trying to set a “fork”: choose what to protect, houses or factories. The decision is thoughtful and cynical, but stupid.
Because we will protect everyone and everything. And we will kill those who threaten our people.

https://t.me/rybar/62422

🇺🇦In the morning, footage of another Ukrainian Armed Forces attack on Shebekino appeared, which fully illustrates the methods and, in general, the essence of the Kiev regime. This time, Ukrainian forces struck a residential building with an FPV drone, specifically choosing an apartment with an open window. A 75-year-old woman who was there died.
❗️It is important to note here that the enemy absolutely deliberately attacked a civilian facility in order to kill civilians. The operator of the enemy drone slowly directed it into the room, knowing full well that only ordinary residents could be there.
Earlier, the Ukrainian Armed Forces similarly dropped ammunition from copters onto a children’s playground in the same Shebekino. In both cases, the odious Ukrainian and Western propagandists, even if they wanted to, would not be able to present what happened as an “accident” – these were verified targeted strikes.
As the situation of the Ukrainian Armed Forces on the front lines worsens, the number of such terrorist attacks, without exaggeration, will grow – this is completely consistent with the ideology of the Kiev regime. In this regard, it is important to remember: the only sure way to stop this is to physically destroy their perpetrators and organizers.
#Belgorod #Russia #Ukraine

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 11:21 utc | 144

Uki Telegram boasting that an F16 has done victory rolls over Odessa after striking Crimea. UK media state it was used to sink a Kilo class sub.
Also,
Uki Telegram state that another F16 launched missiles that hit Lugansk today.
Big propaganda victory for the Ukis.
Russia is again behind the curve with information warfare, and indeed air defence as there is no excuse for an F16 to be showboating and rolling over Odessa, much less striking Crimea.
Very serious development if the sub sinking is confirmed, and the Lugansk attack confirmed done by F16s.
Posted by: Johhny JJ | Aug 4 2024 15:56 utc | 19
Do you show up for gigs in a clown car or on a clown tricycle? What size clown shoes do you wear? Do you prefer the big blue clown nose or the traditional red?

Posted by: Zippy the Pinhead | Aug 5 2024 11:31 utc | 145

https://t.me/rusengineer/4848

Roman raises a rather important issue. Flexibility of management and work for results. We have traditionally had a hard time with this.
And our enemy, no, not the Armed Forces of Ukraine, NATO, has a separate point on improving management. They know how to thoroughly analyze what is in the way and what is not, and change approaches to solving problems quite quickly. If some approach does not work, they change it, and do not wait for the roast rooster to sleep and go down the mountain with the crayfish.
While in our country, in the third year of the war, the former Minister of Defense came to the fleet to thoughtfully talk about the need to install machine guns on ships. However, the situation is changing now, and in addition to the renewal of the leadership of the Ministry of Defense, a critical mass of officers has accumulated who understand that the result is more important than a beautiful report. So this is encouraging, well, and specialists from the front, through war correspondents, give feedback. Which allows the decision maker to see the whole picture, from such pieces of the mosaic.

https://t.me/rusengineer/4855

Photos of the Ukrainian Armed Forces with a robot dog have appeared. Alas, the enemy is no fool and is looking for ways to improve tactics, use new ideas and solutions.
It is obvious that now it is a ground reconnaissance aircraft, but installing weapons or turning it into a kamikaze with a pair of TMok on the body is only a question of mass deliveries.
And from the point of view of a ground platform, its cross-country ability is much higher than that of wheeled and tracked chassis of comparable weight, jumping over a small ditch or an obstacle is not a problem.
The next revolution in military affairs is getting closer.

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 12:26 utc | 146

https://t.me/Mestb_Dobroj_Voli/12056

Forwarded from Fisherman
🇷🇺🇺🇦That’s right, friends .
Regular drone raids have become so commonplace that no one even pays attention to them. All this has turned into statistics that are of no interest to anyone: “They shot down a certain number of UAVs, no damage . ”
And the solution to the question of “why drones still fly to the Volgograd region” for some reason remains a headache only for war correspondents. Although the situation clearly says that if we sit back, the raids will not stop.
▪️For example, when attacking Krasnodar Krai, it is no coincidence that the Ukrainian Armed Forces use the airspace over the Sea of ​​Azov. There, the impact of electronic warfare is the least, which allows them to fly to coastal cities.
▪️In Crimea, drones have in recent months also been launching strikes along unusual routes from the south, skirting the peninsula or, on the contrary, through the entire city, where the use of air defense systems has its own peculiarities.
📌We understand that the concept of “war of attrition” implies conducting such tactics while waiting for the enemy’s reserves to run out, but why resort to such costly methods?
The entire NATO military-industrial complex works to inflict maximum damage on us, and drones with missiles will not run out quickly. The West acts consistently, allocating resources for each stage.
When the Ukrainian Armed Forces lost their Tochkas, they were given Himars. When there was a shortage of long-range shells, they were given missiles. When there were few missiles, they were replaced with drones. Now a new stage is coming – the appearance of the F-16 with all the gadgets like JASSM.
#Russia #Ukraine
@rybar

https://t.me/Mestb_Dobroj_Voli/12054

And no one has yet figured out that the mass raids of the hohols mostly occur simultaneously with ours.
And why?
Because corridors are created for the Geraniums to fly through, in which the electronic warfare is turned off for a while. And the hohol knows this, both from intelligence data and from satellite reconnaissance data.

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 12:44 utc | 147

This is interesting because of the source. The KyivPost has always been nothing more than Russia-bashing, Maidan-glorifying yellow journalism. I wonder why they’re willing to print this article.
‘The Enemy Seems to Have Broken Through’ – Russian Forces Push Back Ukraine’s Army in Donetsk Region
https://www.kyivpost.com/post/36889

Posted by: GW | Aug 5 2024 12:50 utc | 148

Honzo@111…..no one in Russia has balls big enough to attack any NATO base housing F16’s. The Russians treat red lines like goal posts, agile, quick and moveable. Quite a few strikes in Russian rear areas lately, quite the plume over Lugansk yesterday, something was there, now it’s gone.
Looks like the attrition mode is working for the RF, not so much for citizens far from the LOCC.
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Aug 5 2024 12:59 utc | 149

A group of 70 members of the European Parliament appealed to the European Commission with a demand to suspend Hungary’s participation in the Schengen zone. This requirement was a reaction to Budapest’s decision to ease visa requirements for citizens of eight countries, including Russia and Belarus, reports the European publication Politico.
Members of the European Parliament express serious concern that easing visa requirements could undermine security and stability in the Schengen area. In their opinion, Hungary’s actions violate the principles and rules established for member states and create risks for other EU member states.
In their letter to the European Commission, the deputies emphasized that the easing of visa restrictions for citizens of Russia and Belarus, against the backdrop of current international conflicts and sanctions imposed against these countries, is especially problematic. They argue that such measures could make it easier for people who pose a security threat to enter Europe.

the walled garden. a paradise of democracy, humanity. pure bliss.
btw, those 70 members are also total idiots. they dont understand geography, or else they would use EU and not europe. which makes it seems “highly likely” that its not actually europeans, but more so the geographically challenged americans that demand that.

Posted by: Justpassinby | Aug 5 2024 13:11 utc | 150

At least one drone with fiber-optic comms was recovered from the battlefield months ago.
https://t.me/my_el_lab/626

Forwarded from Mikhail Fedorov
❗️Warning: Germans to Use Fiber-Optic-Controlled Drones in Ukraine in August
German developers are testing a new type of drone in Ukraine called the HCX that is immune to electronic warfare because it is controlled via a fiber-optic cable.

HIGHCAT spokesman Jan Hartmann explains that the cable weighs about 250 grams, so it does not significantly impede flight. The range is up to 12 miles/20 kilometers.
“The fiber is quite robust — flying over trees and water is not a problem,” says Hartmann. “Flying in circles is also fine, and the drone can even fly backwards.”

HIGHCAT aims to have the HCX ready for production in November, and could then produce 3,000 units per month with its industrial partner ODM GmbH . If the HCX is successful, others will likely follow suit, and drones with fiber optic capabilities will likely proliferate.
This is a threat to take seriously.

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 13:32 utc | 151

Posted by: Napoleon | Aug 4 2024 20:21 utc | 55
Ramassis de con***ies.
Le F16 comme la plupart des jets récents de même origine n’ont jamais servi que contre des pays du tiers monde sans, où à peu près, forces aériennes.
Ou dans Top Gun.

Posted by: scc | Aug 5 2024 13:41 utc | 152

https://www.newsweek.com/russia-ukraine-losses-warplanes-1934507
Russia Loses 1180 Troops, Two Warplanes, 69 Artillery Systems in a Day
Yikes….

Posted by: bored | Aug 5 2024 14:06 utc | 153

Posted by: bored | Aug 5 2024 14:06 utc | 153
newsweek again, gary? this british version of the german bild-zeitung has been proven the single most unreliable piece of paper over the course of the conflict.
its almost synonymous for the term “perfidious albion”.

Posted by: Justpassinby | Aug 5 2024 14:41 utc | 154

Posted by: bored | Aug 5 2024 14:06 utc | 153
It’s newsweek, doofus. What a maroon you are to believe official Nazi state propaganda!!!

Posted by: Boo | Aug 5 2024 14:44 utc | 155

HIGHCAT spokesman Jan Hartmann explains that the cable weighs about 250 grams, so it does not significantly impede flight. The range is up to 12 miles/20 kilometers.
“The fiber is quite robust — flying over trees and water is not a problem,” says Hartmann. “Flying in circles is also fine, and the drone can even fly backwards.”

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 13:32 utc | 151
And the best part is, once you get it to the ground, all you have to do is follow the cable to find whoever it belongs to…

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Aug 5 2024 14:55 utc | 156

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Aug 5 2024 14:55 utc | 156
20km, under opposing FPV, mortar and artillery fire? Plus, FPV operation posts are typically multiple km behind the front line, using the flight range of the drones to cover the distance, so you’d have to break through the front itself.
A logical next step is to have drones fly semi-disposable optical fibers all over the battlefield to create ad hoc secure comms links. They won’t last but they done have to because flying out a replacement will be easy enough in most cases and existing radio / satcom is available as a backup.

Posted by: a | Aug 5 2024 15:19 utc | 157

Posted by: a | Aug 5 2024 15:19 utc | 157
Oops.

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 15:48 utc | 158

The Neo-Nazi regime in Ukraine has received its first batch of F-16 fighter jets – twenty- pilots will be trained up on them – Whitehouse national security spokesman John F. Kirby – said the F-16’s should be ready to deploy by the end of the Summer.
Surely that’s not enough time for the Neo-Nazi pilots to be fully trained up – unless Nato pilots, will co-pilot with them on sorties.

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Aug 5 2024 15:59 utc | 159

We’ll know for sure when there’s news about nato pilots dying in “training accidents” a few months after the first F-16s get shot down.
You can look at the example of how they hid losses of patriot operators when Russian started blowing them up.

Posted by: Autumn | Aug 5 2024 16:36 utc | 160

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iaBDDpuJglY
Unitree Go2 quadruped robot with wheels for feet, an enormous improvement over the regular model.

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 16:40 utc | 161

Posted by: Republicofscotland | Aug 5 2024 15:59 utc | 159
I know nothing about weapons or the military, but I’m pretty sure the F-16 is a single seat fighter. No co-pilot. I agree, these will be NATO pilots.

Posted by: Caveman | Aug 5 2024 16:49 utc | 162

Posted by: Judge Barbier | Aug 5 2024 7:38 utc | 126
My bad – 27, not 17

Posted by: Jams O’Donnell | Aug 5 2024 16:58 utc | 163

@34 Jams O’ Donnell
I was suprised to read that the SU 17 could outclass a F16 (c/d version) . Could you point me to some links as I was under the impression that the Su17 was relatively outdated by the time te F16’s Block 52 batches were being produced?
Thanks in advance
JB
Posted by: Judge Barbier | Aug 5 2024 7:38 utc | 126
I’m sure he meant the Su-27 Flanker which is the Soviet/Russian equivalent to the F-15.

Posted by: jure | Aug 5 2024 17:08 utc | 164

nevermind, forgot to refresh before posting.

Posted by: jure | Aug 5 2024 17:10 utc | 165

@153
Newsweek is not a credible source of info on the war. It’s more of a public relations agency, or propaganda outlet, functioning on behalf US neocons/NATO/Ukraine. Be aware that the magazine’s intended audience is those Americans who are poorly informed and impressionable.
If you google search Newsweek’s history, you’ll find lots info showing that, since the 1970s or so, it’s been skewing news to flatter the interests of whatever powerbrokers the magazine favors. You’ll also see why it’s known within the media and publishing worlds as a “zombie magazine.”
Forty or fifty years ago, Newsweek did legitimate journalism. But then its original owners were bought out by media titans who specialize in using so-called “legacy magazines” as advertising and propaganda rags. I don’t know the specific business ties between Newsweek and its owners and clientele, but you can look it up and see for yourself.
Google search the term “zombie magazine” too, and you’ll see what media outlets such as Newsweek are all about.

Posted by: GW | Aug 5 2024 17:16 utc | 166

If they have them, what are they waiting for? Put your money where your mouth is.
Posted by: rk | Aug 5 2024 8:20 utc | 132

I have read yesterday on a Telegram channel a transcription of what someone in the Ukrainian OP said. He detailed future targets for long range strikes as the Crinean bridge, the Russian built infrastrucfure in Donbass including the railroads and Rostov-on-the-Don. So they are waiting for the long range missiles that fit the F-16 and the C&C support chain.
Now that they have F-16’s and that one can hardly make the difference between a NATO F-16 and a Ukrainian one, especially at night, NATO can wage attacks from far in Ukraine using F-16’s stationed in Moldova or Romania and Kiev would claim responsability as if they used gheir own Ukrainian F-16.

Posted by: Richard L | Aug 5 2024 17:43 utc | 167

https://t.me/RVvoenkor/74073
Ukrainian special services were preparing a strike on Putin and Defense Minister Belousov at a parade in St. Petersburg – Deputy Foreign Minister Ryabkov
The attack was supposed to take place on July 28 on the Day of the Russian Navy!
But a few days before that, the Russian Minister of Defense personally called US Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin to convince Ukraine to abandon its plans.

Posted by: guest | Aug 5 2024 18:58 utc | 168

Proposal for a force structure centred around unmanned systems, notably a shift away from costly and vulnerable barrel artillery towards drones to conduct the same strike missions.
https://t.me/playcivilization/1601

Army of a new type. While the personally unfit are frantically trying to leave everything in the RF Armed Forces as it is, preventing any changes and agreeing to any losses in order to continue not changing anything, the healthy part of the RF Armed Forces is still actively trying to win somehow.
In addition to purely current military tasks, the military – normal ones – are also becoming a source of serious ideas for the future, for those hypothetically achievable, but not yet arrived times, when everything can be done as it should be.
The idea that will be discussed now fits in well with the statement of Alexander Lyubimov and Alexey Chadayev that in the matter of using unmanned aerial vehicles, it is time to move from “tanks” (the use of drones within the current organizational and staff structures) to “tank divisions” (the creation of organizational and staff structures in the Armed Forces built around unmanned vehicles and taking into account their capabilities). Chadayev and Lyubimov resort to this analogy because the tank really did become a decisive means of waging war when tank units were born.
And this analogy is quite true, because future army units and formations built around drones will really be as superior to “just an army” that also has drones somewhere, as Guderian’s divisions were superior to “infantry support tanks” dispersed among infantry units.
All interested parties are invited to study an article about a possible new-look brigade, which was formed specifically to enable unmanned vehicles to realize their capabilities to the maximum.
The value of this concept is great – both because it was conceived by a real commander of a guards motorized rifle brigade with experience of the war in Ukraine (the admin only polished it a little) based on his combat experience, and because such a unit can be created even in our Armed Forces within a few months, even with the existing equipment.
Sooner or later we will definitely come to such structures. The sooner, the better.
And yes, while the quantitative indicators may change (for example, it may turn out that three strike “unmanned” battalions are too many or something like that), this approach to the formation of troops is a revolution much deeper than the one initiated in its time by the theorists of tank warfare.

https://en.topwar.ru/233665-bespilotnocentrichnaja-udarnaja-obschevojskovaja-brigada-novogo-oblika-po-opytu-svo.html

“Unmanned-centric” strike combined arms brigade of a new look based on the experience of the Northern Military District
(caption: We don’t have to lose tens of thousands of fighters for each regional center; with the existing technology, we can transform the battlefield into something completely different right now. But new organizational structures are needed)
Not everyone in the world has yet understood this, but military actions in Ukraine will have a revolutionary impact on the development of tactics and organizational structures of troops. And this will be connected with the widespread introduction of unmanned aerial vehicles, both reconnaissance, strike, and others, including transport ones.

Russia, stuck in a protracted positional war, needs a qualitative leap in combat power.
The topic of this article is the concept of a combined arms brigade, in which the main striking weapons are Drones, and the units of the remaining branches of the military within it either provide the possibility of combat use of UAVs, or are used to quickly use the results of fire destruction of enemy forces achieved by drones. For example, infantry does not storm well-defended enemy positions with the support of UAVs, but finishes off those who survived waves of drone attacks.

Fundamental points
The formation of such a brigade was proposed during a discussion of a media project, still in the process of implementation, by a former commander of one of the motorized rifle brigades with experience in the military.
The concept itself directly stemmed from the current combat experience, as well as a number of limitations faced by the Russian Armed Forces.

The first is the lack of infantry. A lot has already been said about this, there is no point in repeating it – the scale of hostilities is such that you need to have hundreds of thousands more soldiers than you already have. The losses are also large and also do not contribute to the strength of the troops.
Since demographically our society cannot afford large losses over a long period, and there are difficulties with recruitment, it is logical to assume that it is necessary to reduce the load on the infantry and introduce a combat doctrine that would allow achieving results at the cost of fewer losses.
The second is problems with artillery. The war has already led to massive wear of barrels, ammunition production does not keep pace with their consumption, and the emergence of long-range, high-precision missiles of various types in the Armed Forces of Ukraine required the dispersal of ammunition reserves on the ground, which, in turn, complicated logistics.
It is also complicated by the number of vehicles, drivers, available car tires, and the degree of mechanization of loading and unloading operations in the troops.
A special issue is counter-battery warfare. Where the Armed Forces of Ukraine conduct it, they are really good – the combination of the massive use of UAVs and American counter-battery radars, with very short command chains compared to the RF Armed Forces in terms of opening fire, and well-functioning communications, leads to the fact that our weapon is often manages to fire 2-3 shots before the retaliatory “arrivals” begin.
At the same time, the Ukrainian Armed Forces often do not regret using missiles from the M142 HIMARS complex, even to destroy a separate weapon. What is important for us is that neither the means nor methods of counter-battery combat against unmanned aviation does not work. But it completely fulfills some of the tasks of artillery.
..
Considering how massively modern UAVs can be produced, shifting some of the artillery tasks to them looks quite logical.
And from the same point of view, the rejection of large-caliber artillery (122-152 mm) seems logical (but has caused a lot of criticism “in narrow circles”). This is perceived as heresy, but why not? Once again, UAVs can solve the fire missions that artillery solves, not all, but almost all.
And the brigade has both a powerful artillery group and a shock group drones will lead to the fact that their tasks in most cases will be duplicated.

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 19:02 utc | 169

I think we’re moving closer and closer to drone on drone warfare. E.g. using two drones with a tether between them to sweep the skies and snag ground-tethered drones. Probably also another next step is super optics, with a scan and with a cannon (on ground) Perhaps even automated. Getting closer and closer to Terminator and The Matrix.

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 19:05 utc | 170

168 guest: Interesting.
I wonder if this also fits in with the spat between Sirski and Budanov. (Like maybe S burned B.) Specops is complaining that Sirski has direct connections/interactions with the US, versus going through Zelenski.

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 19:09 utc | 171

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 19:05 utc | 170
and we wouldnt have all this crap if nato would have simply stopped with all their bullmanure.
thanks, western “values”.

Posted by: Justpassinby | Aug 5 2024 19:10 utc | 172

Posted by: a | Aug 5 2024 15:19 utc | 157
When I said “follow the cable” I had already imagined that there were technical options for tracing the cable – if you have an end. The idea of two Russians running 20 km after the cable with the Kalschnikov at the ready was not in my mind.

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Aug 5 2024 19:15 utc | 173

Now that F-16 is official, they need to make room for another future wonder weapon for Ukraine to place it’s bet on changing the war or prolong it as much as possible.
Posted by: JamesBond | Aug 4 2024 14:44 utc | 11
——————————————————————
Tactical nukes anyone?

Posted by: Ed | Aug 5 2024 19:21 utc | 174

Republicofscotland | Aug 5 2024 15:59 utc | 159
I’ve seen one or two F16s registered as “Romanian” flying in UK airspace in the last few weeks.

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Aug 5 2024 19:21 utc | 175

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 19:05 utc | 170
The front is already so lethal that the number of infantry in forward positions is now very small in many cases. The above article is dated January of this year and seems like an attempt to accept reality and design for it rather than relying on wasteful contortions.
The only grounds I can find to doubt the proposal is that it confirms my own suspicions so well.

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 19:25 utc | 176

Newsweek is not a credible source of info on the war. It’s more of a public relations agency, or propaganda outlet, functioning on behalf US neocons/NATO/Ukraine. Be aware that the magazine’s intended audience is those Americans who are poorly informed and impressionable. . .
Posted by: GW | Aug 5 2024 17:16 utc | 166
Americans who are poorly informed. Well that’s a majority of Americans. Pseudo news outlets like ‘newsweek’ have an audience that has already been primed to believe that Ukraine is a legitimate country, with a legitimate government, led by a legitimate president, and served by a legitimate media. And of course, the audience thinks that the US is just a concerned bystander, offering to help out a friend in need with the delivery of some weapons. This article like nearly every western article on the war absolutely has to insert “Putin’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine” somewhere, like saying a hail mary, one of the stations of the cross. Americans are propagandized to the hilt.

Posted by: Mike R | Aug 5 2024 19:27 utc | 177

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Aug 5 2024 19:15 utc | 173
Fair enough. a drone to follow optical fibers in open country is conceivable, though not trivial. Countermeasures like decoy fibers or a mechanism to reel in severed fibers are also conceivable and widespread use would automatically create a lot of decoys. If tracing fibers became a threat, they could be used between unmanned locations with other comms being used to create a less traceable link to manned locations.

Posted by: anon2020 | Aug 5 2024 19:45 utc | 178

Hi, F-16 fans !
Since this forum has started (Aug 4 2024 13:39 utc), I wonder about missing any successful attacks still have performed against Russia – or even have realistically explained here on that new mysterium – how that F-16’s attacks could work for any strikes on RF in UKR or even against any of RF rear lands.
All you MoAs here have discussed, is the technical capabilities of F-16 vs RF SU-xx on a dog-fighting.
A dog-fight on-air against RU SU-xx can only be successfully performed if the UKR-pilot is either an US-trained experienced fighter man (like actors in Hollywood cinema) or an US-figther pilot with an US-Passport and US-Mark on his breast.
The Russian MIL-Air Defense pilots of any SU-xx jets are very well for a couple of months trained on those dog-fight scenes with US-Fighter jets. Be sure.
So may be let’s fly any F16s as a flying bomb or a flying drone (may be unmanned) towards its targets in Russia, RF should seriously IMPROVE NOW its capabilities of AD measures to defend against the US-Pilot guided jets.
That’s all – and still outstanding, what RUAF has to be prepared for. No more nor less.

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 5 2024 20:32 utc | 179

ff. Hi F16 fans ..
Sorry,
some proofing facts has been hidden secretely under this IDF & Ukranian Gov-Officials table Gov No. 20006gjkkj.
Would Yo pls. follow – Mr. Assange in Australia?
No – stay a safe environment.
Elendsky: Take a new refrehing breathing of Your powder – That’s working fine.
US-Blinken – and US-Backers like Soros + German’s prostitute Street-Girl “Annalena Baer-High-Rock – is forcing war in Mid-East by weapon-Raising and declining her Poll chances. She showed naked legs below skirt – but
for nothing either for Soros and Guys plus the Epstein’s “family” ..
Baerbock – Maedchen liten: Can fire back still today – may be together with u.v.Liars female pressure ..?

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 5 2024 21:38 utc | 180

J’espère sincèrement que le faucon volant, le F-16, ne verra jamais l’action. Je suis avec les troupes et je souhaite un cessez-le-feu immédiat.

Posted by: Napoleon | Aug 5 2024 21:38 utc | 181

Good Napoleon, pls. follow me and go to the current trenches of UAF in UKR.
I’ll meet You there, for surrendering Your very liked mind plus meanings + Your opinion to the Ukrainian soldiers being encircledwithout WATER & FOOD.

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 5 2024 21:51 utc | 182

That’s a good party without meat to eat, else same comrade’s meat, before starving at least – Water nearby? Okay drink the rain water.
Napoleon, now answer: Who has failed still today Aug 05 21:50 utc?
France+Germany should make a better policy for its folks! Okay?

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 5 2024 21:57 utc | 183

Milites | Aug 5 2024 9:13 utc | 138
What I have noticed is Russia fights large mathematical warfare. Not sure how best to term it or even explain it adequately. But it is certainly there.
There can be certain things here and there on the frontline, but they are trivia (probably not the best term) within the larger context of a mathematical certainty.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Aug 5 2024 22:22 utc | 184

ok – Math calculations is a more logical method that may be applied based on RUAF strategies. But even it’s better on strategy, math-planned OPs may fail acc.to civilian people fates.
No doubt, RF is ahead of more logical planning a “war” than any of Western military guys can do, except of some really intelligent “Pentagon” guys being same as Russian counterparts.
But all that’s evil – even math-founded -established by either side.
This UKR-RF “war” is not a game of Chess players. It’s reality for every UKR civis on battle ground and for every soldiers sent to front on either sides.
That’s the truth – no more nor less.

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 5 2024 22:38 utc | 185

Daily Deepstate map update is out.
“The enemy advanced near Zhelanne, New York, in Zalizne and Pivdenne.”
https://deepstatemap.live/en#12/48.1157981/37.6717758
1. Sizable territory taken in NY area to the right of the NY phallus. Essentially half of the “sack” between the NY and Toretsk oriented salients.
2. Couple incremental gains on SW and N of the Zalizne/Pivdenne (Toretsk) salient. Still really consolidating. Haven’t taken slag heaps yet, haven’t entered functional part of Toretsk. (Perhaps legal limits, unclear, but if so, far periphery.)
3. Some more fields and width for the E of Zhelane (Ocho bloom area) salient. W third of town is now grey zone (as was E third). Ukrops remain in the center, but probably not for long.
In importance, I would rank 1/3/2.

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 22:40 utc | 186

spare_truth_01@185…..yes, not a game of Chess but a game of Death….and doing some math, no shortage of grift on either side of the LOCC, money to be made goes both ways…..while the dying, the real heavy lifting, takes place in the trenches not on the Stock Market….well, maybe a few high flyers will take a 27th floor leap of faith……
Cheers

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Aug 5 2024 22:57 utc | 187

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 22:40 utc | 186
Thanks for Your current hopefully Geo-validated ground-field war report by the Ukranian “Deep-State” report – as anonymous it takes for that info.
Cross-checking that Russian gains tomorrow against other “Map reporters” would be helpful (like Dima, Simplicius etc. and their reliable “tools”).
One step of another max. 1km driven the UAF being desperately on surrender without any resistance – back towards West its best fortified trenches – is not yet a “victory” of RUAF on grounds.
Wait 2 further month of recording the batlle field – than pls. make a conclusion who will “win” – USA/UK/EU or Russia. Bedding?

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 5 2024 23:01 utc | 188

I will add a little to my colleagues from the “Archangel of Special Forces” regarding the news on Chasov Yar (https://t.me/rusich_army/16175) as a participant in this operation:
So, the most important factor that must be taken into account when fighting for this settlement is the well-fortified forests around the city itself. From the south, Chasov Yar is covered by a massive forest, in which, since the time of the Bakhmut operation carried out by the Wagner Group, the Armed Forces of Ukraine have equipped a powerful fortified area according to all the rules of military engineering. In this forest, in addition to the fortified area, there is a significant amount of military equipment that the Armed Forces of Ukraine do not use in the battle in urban areas.
Why?
It’s simple: in the city, this equipment is in full view, and in the dense forest south of Chasiv Yar, it becomes difficult to identify it when conducting aerial reconnaissance. Only according to my estimates, there may be about 500 enemy personnel in the above-mentioned forest, including some command at the forward command posts. To the north of Chasov Yar there are several heights, which are also convenient for the enemy to place repeaters and install equipment for visual reconnaissance.
Second: The command of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is trying with all its might to prevent the advance and consolidation of advanced units in urban areas and will use all possible forces for this, from sabotage and reconnaissance groups to UAV units. I have repeatedly described the purpose of these actions on the canal, but I will still repeat once again – the city is on top and its control allows you to hold Konstantinovka and the surrounding settlements at gunpoint.
We continue to work in the direction.
Colonel Cassad.

Posted by: Suresh | Aug 5 2024 23:04 utc | 189

188, you’re welcome to do so. I’m not “taking requests”.
FWIW, I’m down on Dima. He covers the map with little videos all the time, which themselves are shown too small. And he has a really annoying habit of forecasting, but not checking his forecasts.
Kind of moved back to DPA, who I like. And the Daily Willy. But really, DeepState gives you most of what you see. I do sometimes post those two though and corroborate what is different, extra, etc.

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 23:06 utc | 190

@Peter AU1 | Mon, 05 Aug 2024 22:22:00 GMT | 184

What I have noticed is Russia fights large mathematical warfare.

I can probably see what you mean. Actually I have a similar feel, too. Best I can describe it is that Russian culture, as experienced by me through the Russians I met in Germany, many of whom have a technical or scientific background, tend to approach “problems” of all sorts in a methodical, logical way (i.e., same as maths). They’re not simply using an unfit for purpose pet theory they’ve been taught somewhere, but make up the analysis on the spot; and they also do not calculate for the sake of calculation, but begin and end all deliberation at the human level. Perhaps that is why they’re renowned as technical improvisers, while Germans OTOH tend to be overly perfectionist. Think of an over-engineered MB 600SL vs. the rugged, simple, effective design of the russian aircraft etc. The example is hugely-over simplified for the point, but I hope it gets across.
It’s also of note that the human factor is easily misunderstood by western thinking when we imagine russian human wave attacks, now or in their earlier wars. The Russians will take a lot of pain, but that doesn’t mean they’re taking it mindlessly.
I learned a great quote said to be by Bismark here on MoA, I think you’ll dig it, too:
“The Russians are making plans even each time they go to the shitter!”

Posted by: persiflo | Aug 5 2024 23:09 utc | 191

Posted by Colonel Cassad.
Suresh | Aug 5 2024 23:04 utc | 189
.. That’s a good realistic description of Your current situation.
Congratulations on Your indeed affected Infantry/Drones-Operators resistance capabilities.
But, You should not forget that almost ALL of Your background logistics supporting to You meanwhile have been cut-off by Russians.
So may drink & eat what You’ll like next weeks – it won’t get better ..

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 5 2024 23:19 utc | 192

Further to my above: my friend Yuri and I were sitting one summer night in the cathedral garden of Speyer, both of us about 20. He hardly spoke a word of German, so we had to make do conversating. Between beers and a spliff, Yuri picked up a stick and used it to scratch a particularly elegant proof of a simple geometrical problem into the sandy ground where we sat – about volumetric area of spheres stacked into rectangles. He didn’t do it because we were a bit geeky, but because it was entertaining and fun at this moment. Yuri went on to become an electrical engineer, and ruptured his cruciate ligament dancing wildly at a Ska concert. Not really a nerd, just a bright bloke with a great humour and temperament.

Posted by: persiflo | Aug 5 2024 23:27 utc | 193

Colonel Cassad
Posted by: Suresh | Aug 5 2024 23:04 utc | 189
I am glad the Colonel respects his enemy and does not rattle off banalities like ‘404’ nor dream of great imaginary battles that yield huge causality numbers.
Putin’s Slog can be seen as a series of mini Stalingrad’s that Russia has to fight to gain any ground. Bakhmut was a mini-Stalingrad and now Chasif Yar will be another Stalingrad as Putin attrits himself.
Chasif Yar, it sounds like something out of the Ring Trilogy. I do not have a good feeling for Russia here, even simplicius76 admits Putin is rounding up another convict army to take the town. No self-respecting Russian officer would send his boys into this meat-grinder for an elective war (SMO) with such idiotic goals.
I feel better about Vlad’s chances in taking Nui York. I read above that Russian forces were already in Queens, having hot dogs and taking in a Mets game, no doubt…
“But I know what I’m needing
And I don’t want to waste more time.
I’m in a Nui York state of mind.”
~ Billy Joel

Posted by: Napoleon | Aug 5 2024 23:48 utc | 194

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 23:06 utc | 190

.. FWIW, I’m down on Dima. He covers the map with little videos all the time, which themselves are shown too small. ..

Your critics about that “Map failures” may be correct, but I’m thinking he made a “good job” on sampling a more wide-spread referring sources (including the UKR Deep State reports of Yours referring here), so why don’t listen to him ?
Are You fixed on a certain narrative on consuming infos – or what?
What’s Your meaning about “Trump Assasination” – Who planned that?

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 5 2024 23:49 utc | 195

DPA frontline report out. Basically same as the DS report, but some interesting additive insights:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UdEqW_UCwuI
———–
NY sector:
1. Little more of Zalizne taken (on the corner). Matches the other aspects of Toretesk salient from DS, but then has one extra field.
2. Shows the exact same big NY pocket takeover as DS, but just noting that DPA agrees with me on the significance. “One huge big chunk”.
2.1. Makes the interesting point that no info on the details of the takeover (from RFA or UFA). E.g. was it a withdrawal? What were the details?
2.2. DPA does note that it appear UFA left fields in the pocket, but kept the urban territory. So perhaps that was part of the decision process.
2.3. 10 kmsq loss (i.e. .002%) 😉
Avdiivka sectr:
3. Same territory info as DS on Zehalzne. Just of interest that DPA has same take as me (just a matter of time). Not that strategically important and UFA is in ad situation…so likely to exit and fall back to other lines.
4. DPA makes an interesting additive analytical point that he hears UFA is throwing more troops at the Avdiivka sector. Doesn’t think it will be effective. But, TBD.
5. DPA also cites the Russians giving bonuses for territory as motivating the success. Jokes that they will bankrupt Russia. (Sort of like the running out of flags joke.)
Other:
6. Notes fields near Urozhaine taken. (Think this is old news, seen it before.)

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 5 2024 23:56 utc | 196

195:
I’ve watched a lot of Dima. It’s not like I didn’t give him a fair chance. There was actually a while where I preferred him, despite thinking he was not that good, because at least it was frequent/current. But I’m off of that. Just rather wait for something watchable. If you like him, knock yourself out.
In addition to everything else, I find that when he speculates, it’s loosely and not informed y any real military training. In contrast, DPA and Willy are more seasoned.
But again, not stopping you from watching him!

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 6 2024 0:00 utc | 197

Excuse me, barflies, but I have yet another story to share, also on the topic above.
I was best friends with a girl from Kharkov for 15 years. A physical chemist who speaks 9 languages, among them yiddish, did ballet for a while, and generally was the most fun person to be around especially when going out for a party. For all her talents, she was always at her most lively when doing the simple things right. From clothing (e.g. dressing up as Michael Jackson or even, half-consciously, a KZ inmate), cooking – I gifted her a cookbook discussing the physical chemistry, and it had the most amazing effect – down to über-practical things, like using activated carbon tablets for every instance of gut problems, an effect at which she kept marvelling.
Activated charcoal, btw, is the next best thing to a cast iron gut. titmouse had recommended it, too, cleverly hinting at the coaled pieces of a proper barbecue as a good source.

Posted by: persiflo | Aug 6 2024 0:07 utc | 198

Posted by: Napoleon | Aug 5 2024 23:48 utc | 194
As he/she referred the Posting by Colonel Cassad. Suresh | Aug 5 2024 23:04 utc | 189

.. No self-respecting Russian officer would send his boys into this meat-grinder for an elective war (SMO) with such idiotic goals.

Hi Napoleon, have been awaken by some comments above?
What are the reason to title SMO in Your-minded as “with such idiotic goals” ?
‘Idiotic goals’ are when You have no reason to fight for resistance of a NATO – Blinken/Killary/OhBama/911-Bush religious companies think tanks spreading “Your Goals” into Your mind.
So pls. keep down and sit with the winners of this SMO !
That’s the Russian Folk.

Posted by: spare_truth_01 | Aug 6 2024 0:10 utc | 199

This Tweet shows a picture of the NY pocket taken:
https://x.com/DefensePolitics/status/1820601181997252727 (bottom, middle)
P.s. Note that you see a lot of online comments about the UKR getting trapped in pockets, but it really seems more the opposite insight. Every single time, it looked like they would get surrounded and obliterated (or a big surrender), they were able to get out at the last minute. There really hasn’t been a significant encirclement on either side (a real one, that they coudn’t escape from) other than the Mariupul seige. So, it’s really less of a danger than people think.

Posted by: Anonymous | Aug 6 2024 0:11 utc | 200