Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
August 25, 2024
The MoA Week In Review – OT 2024-202

Last week's posts on Moon of Alabama:

Palestine:

Ukraine:

Selections:

Andrew Kloster @ARKloster – 23:57 UTC · Aug 24, 2024

BREAKING: Cornel West is dropping out and endorsing Trump.

“A brother can’t in good conscience endorse a pro-war, fake black, code-switching hussy whose ancestors owned slaves. I’m proud to stand with Donald John Trump.”

U.S. Navy Defeat:


Other issues:

Boeing:

Free Speech:

Color Revolution Watch:

Use as open (not related to the wars in Ukraine and Palestine) thread …

Comments

@ Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 13:32 utc | 87
re: He [Kennedy] is withdrawing his name from the ballot, on which citizens record their vote, in the ten main swing, or battleground, states wherein a few cities, most controlled by the DNC machine, often determine the national result. He remains on the ballot in the remaining 40 states
No. As of Aug 23 Kennedy was on 22 ballots, some of them battleground states he will withdraw from.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 16:39 utc | 101

Meanwhile the gawd has spoken..
China has no claim over TW’ !

A triumph for truth! After @ipacglobal
‘s advocacy, #Australian Senate passed a motion clarifying #UN Res. 2758. It rejects #Beijing’s false claims over #Taiwan, affirming the resolution never mentions Taiwan. A clear stand against misinformation on Taiwan’s status. ????????
“>https://x.com/TaiwanInNewYork/status/1826644425935839636

[SIC]
The gawd’s chosen people [hint..not Jews] have spoken, it must be true 😉

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 16:45 utc | 102

https://t.me/kabezki/3598
Trump (sorta): I knocked up three bitches, i was shot at, I have mugshots. I am more black than that pussie would ever be!

Posted by: A | Aug 26 2024 17:04 utc | 103

White man burden lives on.
Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 15:09 utc | 91
——————-
French lecturing Benin
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hsnUFKERkhY&t=39s
Lots of vid have been scrubbed off YT,
the above are just tip of an iceberg
but you get the drift
There’s no escape from the garden bullhorn

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 17:23 utc | 104

re: Taiwan
Resolution 2758 (XXVI)
THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY.
” . . . Decides to restore all its rights to the People’s Republic of China and to recognize the representatives of its Government as the only legitimate representatives of China to the United Nations, and to expel forthwith the representatives of Chiang Kai-shek from the place which they unlawfully occupy at the United Nations and in all the organizations related to it.”
Regarding the PRC, the UN deemed that all its rights China rights have been restored. The self-appointed government in Taiwan, whose title is Republic of China (Taiwan), is an organization related to the representatives of Chiang Kai-shek (ROC) and therefore doesn’t legally exist.
Meanwhile some people advocate a deviation from UN Resolution 2758
Taiwan should call for UN hearing on resolution, Nikki Haley says

Taiwan and the US should jointly call on the UN to hold a hearing on UN Resolution 2758 and curbing China’s aggression, former US ambassador to the UN Nikki Haley said yesterday in Taipei.
The UN General Assembly passed Resolution 2758 on Oct. 25, 1971, which states that the People’s Republic of China is the legitimate government of China, which led to it replacing the Republic of China in the UN.
However, the resolution “never mentioned ‘Taiwan,’” and the UN should not “allow the Chinese Communist Party to hijack a resolution and claim it’s about Taiwan,” Haley told a news conference. . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 17:39 utc | 105

For those non French speakers,
The prick was challenging Benin prez

How could a Totalitarian China, with such massive trampling of the human rights of its own citizens, be an inspiration to your country’ ?

suffice to say,
Just like his Limey and German colleagues,
He was duly humbled by the host,

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 17:39 utc | 106

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 17:39 utc | 105
——————–
Talking about sanctimonious prick, this mofo is right up there with his BBC, CNN cohorts…

China is so big, you can afford to let go of TW, ‘

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YUlM-M5tbvc

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 17:54 utc | 107

There’s no escape from the garden bullhorn
Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 17:23 utc | 104
—————————
No wonder the Ghana prez complains..

The local press reads like gawd damned GUardian

I feel your pain bud,
Heck, we’ve an empire mouth piece right here in this bar..

The honest answers to the above imply that Taiwan should NOT be allowed to form a nation.
Utopian principle is satisfying. But real people live in real world.
Posted by: d dan | Jul 23 2022 18:59 utc | 218
Good questions but ignored history. ROC claimed Taiwan after overthrowing Qin dynasty / The Emperor. before PRC even existed. The PRC defeated the ROC in a civil war but never took and held Taiwan. In short, they have no claim. OR: IF ROC has no claim to Taiwan, then PRC has no claim to mainland and the Qin Dynasty should be re-established, which is never going to happen even if it were possible at this point.
Your questions are framed to imply that Taiwan/ ROC broke away from PRC and/or is making a claim for independence from within PRC jurisdiction. That is simply not the case. Fact is that if China walked the sovereignty talk they are preaching with their ally Putin they would recognize Taiwan as a sovereign, independent neighbor and move on. But they do not, moreover they bully other nations not to recognize the ROC, not to have ambassadors, not to put them on maps, not to make financial arrangements. In short, they act like regional hegemons (don’t forget Tibet decades ago and up until the present) and therefore total hypocrites when they lecture the US.
Posted by: Scorpion | Jul 23 2022 20:17 utc | 217

Rings a bell, thee garden bullhorn ?

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 18:07 utc | 108

. . .from Ralph Nader
“Crashing the Party: Taking on the Corporate Government in an Age of Surrender”

An inspiring and defiant memoir, Crashing the Party takes us inside Nader’s campaign and explains what it took to fight the two-party juggernaut; why Bush and Gore were really afraid to let him in on their debates; why progressive Democrats have been left behind and ignored by their party; how Democrat and Republican interests have been lost to corporate bankrolling; and what needs to happen in the future for people to take back their political system. . . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 18:16 utc | 109

@ denk | Aug 26 2024 18:07 utc | 108
re: . . .to imply that Taiwan/ ROC broke away from PRC and/or is making a claim for independence from within PRC jurisdiction. That is simply not the case.
No.
August 2023
Taiwan is already independent: Lai
PRESIDENTIAL CANDIDATE: Vice President William Lai in an interview pitched himself as a ‘rational and steady’ leader who is able to work with the US government effectively
Taiwan is a “sovereign, independent country,” Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) presidential candidate William Lai (賴清德) told Bloomberg Businessweek in an interview, adding that he had no plans to pursue formal independence.
“Taiwan is already a sovereign, independent country called the Republic of China,” Vice President Lai said, echoing a stance President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) made public three years ago, in his first interview with an international media outlet since becoming vice president in 2020.
“And in respect to unifying Taiwanese society, President Tsai has used the term Republic of China (Taiwan) to describe our country. I will continue to do so in the future,” he said. “There are no plans to change the name of our country.” . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 18:32 utc | 110

he had no plans to pursue formal independence
Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 18:32 utc | 110
—————-
He dare not, thats an invitation for
PLA attack.

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 18:44 utc | 111

Jan 14, 2020
ROC “President” Tsai Ing-wen was interviewed by the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) on January 14, 2020 and she responded to questions regarding issues such as the presidential election, cross-strait relations, Taiwan-US relations, national defense, and diplomacy.

Q: If we leave aside the question of timetable, the question of practicality, are you in principle, at least, in favor of the idea of formal Taiwanese independence?
A: Well, the reality and what it is now is that we are already a functionally independent country. And we have our own government, we have our own elections, of course, presidential election, and that is a way to express that we do have sovereignty, and our people elect their own leaders. So, effectively we are a country already.
Q: Will there come a day when that reality needs to be spelled out by calling Taiwan a country, and a formal declaration of independence to do that?
A: Well, the idea is that we don’t have a need to declare ourselves an independent state. We are an independent country already and we call ourselves the Republic of China (Taiwan), and we have our own system of running the country, and we do have a government and we have a military, and we have elections, like the presidential elections that you have witnessed. . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 18:48 utc | 112

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 18:48 utc | 112
————–
The time will come.
Why do you think China is building those
massive amphibious assault ship for ?

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 18:55 utc | 113

Don Bacon,
just curious, are you pro TW independence.
?

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 18:56 utc | 114

Germany sends Ukraine weapons. In Kursk 80 years ago there were German “Tiger” tanks, now they are “Leopard”. For Finance Minister and FDP party leader Christian Lindner, this is not a problem: “The weapons have been transferred to the responsibility of Ukraine, which is defending itself against an aggressor and exercising its right to self-defense”.
Compare with Pavel Durov, of the Telegram message app, in a French prison, accused of complicity. Complicity not requires criminal intent.
This is the rules based order at it best. If NATO sends weapons, we are not involved. If a Russian programs a messaging app, he becomes complicit.

Posted by: Passerby | Aug 26 2024 19:05 utc | 115

@ denk
Every man has a right to his opinion, but no man has a right to be wrong in his facts.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 19:09 utc | 116

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 19:09 utc | 116
—————–
What did I get it wrong.?
isnt there an empire mouth piece at the
bar , the poop ?
I presume this is your way of admitting
You’r pro TW independence. ?
If so, why be coy ?

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 19:14 utc | 117

Good evening all – been busy and wanted to post on Telegram and Duroc.
I’m going to have some fun and just post some other comments mostly from telegram.
I use it for most of my news and of course MoA and the great @GeromanAT.
Sorry if some is repeated from others – I hope b allows it.
– GEROMAN — time will tell – 👀 —
@GeromanAT
1h
The arrest of Telegram’s boss tells you only one thing – West (NATO) is in full panic mode – Because they are losing – not only in Ukraine – also in West Asia (Middle East) and of course Africa…
They are shitting their pants because people starting to think – that must be of course forbidden in the so called “Collective West”
Aug 26, 2024 · 5:36 PM UTC
Assange’s associate, Australian MP Adrian MacRae, on the “hand” of US and NATO intelligence in the Durov case: Of course, Durov’s arrest is ultimately the work of US and NATO intelligence services, which are desperate to get backdoor access to Telegram. Much like they have access to WhatsApp and all the media platforms owned by META. Having backdoor access to the flow of information, both up and down the Russian NDS, is ultimately the reason Durov is now in custody.
@Slavyangrad
📢 The Durov story may have another unexpected twist.
After it became clear that the authorities, who speak in favor of freedom of speech and the dissemination of information, are in fact willing to do anything to bring the exchange of this very information under control, the population of Europe in particular and the West in general will wonder how to communicate in the digital space without being under the thumb of Big Brother.
And the demand for platforms beyond the control of the state will grow even more. Moreover, Telegram may become a symbol of such resistance to interference in private life and become even more popular. A serious question is whether such platforms will appear and how long they will resist the onslaught, but demand in any case gives birth to supply. And it is unlikely that it will be possible to drive the entire population of the Earth into a digital concentration camp.
@Slavyangrad
Alexander Gelyevich DUGIN on the arrest of Durov:
“Pavel Durov has been arrested in Paris. This is the final proof that no one will be able to maintain neutrality during a total world war. There are two irreconcilable worlds that have turned against each other. Us and them. And there is an abyss between us. Dual citizenship, blurred loyalties, maneuvering between camps – all this is in the past. Either with us or against us. Durov flew to Baku, I believe, to negotiate with Putin about his return. But he underestimated the seriousness of the situation and did not surrender unconditionally. But this was enough for the West to immediately slap him down.
However, the internal front is also open in the West itself. Elon Musk with his x.com, which is banned in the Russian Federation, is about to find himself in a similar situation. The globalists have moved to an openly totalitarian policy: whoever is not with them is against them (and according to their logic, for Russia). And since networks and information flows play a key role in modern warfare, the first victims of an irreconcilable split are precisely those who possess such a resource.”
“What will happen to Telegram now? Most likely, this is the end. Macron and the liberal Gestapo will demand that the keys and codes from TG be handed over. The price of freedom. If Durov agrees, and so far he has been playing right-wing libertarianism in the spirit of Elon Musk and has not agreed, TG will be closed in the Russian Federation. If he does not agree, he will be jailed like Assange. And then TG will be finished altogether.”
“He who owns the networks and media is sovereign.”
@Slavyangrad
🇫🇷🇷🇺 Maria Zakharova recalled that Western NGOs in 2018 called on the Russian Federation not to create obstacles to Telegram’s work:
“I am publishing a screenshot of all Western specialized structures that spoke out then, including with a collective appeal.
Do you think this time they will appeal to Paris and demand Durov’s release, or will they swallow their tongues?”
➡️ Join us! | @MyLordBebo
Telegram is not even in the top 8 of child abuse!
Child Abuse Images ranking, by NSPCC:
– Snapchat 4,312 times (44%)
– Instagram 1,217 (12%)
– Facebook 852 (9%)
– WhatsApp 522 times (5%)
– Kik 494 (5%)
– TikTok 427 (4%)
– Twitter/X 294 (3%)
– YouTube 330 (3%)
They arrested the guy who’s not cooperating with the government, not the guy who actually spreads child abuse.
➡️ Join us! | @MyLordBebo
t.me/ForeignAgentIntel
‼️🚨 TELEGRAM STATEMENT:
📱 Telegram abides by EU laws, including the Digital Services Act — its moderation is within industry standards and constantly improving.
🛩 Telegram’s CEO Pavel Durov has nothing to hide and travels frequently in Europe.
🫤 It is absurd to claim that a platform or its owner are responsible for abuse of that platform.
🌐 Almost a billion users globally use Telegram as means of communication and as a source of vital information.
👍 We’re awaiting a prompt resolution of this situation. Telegram is with you all.
➡️ Join us! | @MyLordBebo
🚨‼️ Rumble founder leaves Europe, due to the arrest of Telegram’s Durov.
➡️ Join us! | @MyLordBebo
🇫🇷 Telegram is censoring according to government requests!
So the accusations of Telegram’s lack of moderation looks extremely dubious! Since Telegram actively moderates content in the EU. Europeans cannot access many chats and channels, receiving a message about the content not complying with EU laws, content that violates copyright is blocked, etc.
➡️ Telegram is not subject to the recently adopted EU law on regulation of large social networks (DSA), because it still has less than 45 million daily EU users.
So we are indeed witnessing an attempt to put pressure on Durov!
Examples: RT channels and Middle Eastern Resistance channels are banned.
Join us! | @MyLordBebo
🇷🇺🇫🇷 Comment from the Russian Embassy in France:
After news of P.V. Durov’s arrest appeared in the media, the French authorities were immediately asked to provide an explanation of the reasons and demanded that his rights be protected and that consular access be granted.
As of today, the French side has so far avoided interaction on this issue.
We are in contact with lawyer P.V. Durov.
➡️ Join us! | @MyLordBebo
The Telegram team has officially commented on Durov’s arrest.
Telegram abides by EU laws, including the Digital Services Act — its moderation is within industry standards and constantly improving.
Telegram’s CEO Pavel Durov has nothing to hide and travels frequently in Europe.
It is absurd to claim that a platform or its owner are responsible for abuse of that platform.
Almost a billion users globally use Telegram as means of communication and as a source of vital information.
We’re awaiting a prompt resolution of this situation. Telegram is with you all.
@Slavyangrad
Western intelligence cut-out err “investigative journalist”, Christo Grozev, crowing about Pavel Durov’s arrest.
Confirming he wouldn’t play ball with Western intelligence and hence his arrest.
@Slavyangrad
Italian journalist Giorgio Bianchi:
By now you all know that Pavel Durov, the founder of Telegram, has been arrested in France. Which I think is a very serious case that in a way risks becoming a new Assange case. Clearly, all of this remains to be seen, to be clarified. But it seems to me that, as in the case of Assange, this is a completely arbitrary arrest for the purpose of intimidation or, even worse, for the purpose of revenge. This case just gives me goosebumps. It appears that Durov was declared wanted shortly before landing in Paris, just as the arrest warrant was issued shortly before landing in Paris. The charges are very serious, ranging from drug trafficking to pedophilia to fraud. It’s like accusing Vodafone or other carriers of favoring those who use the phone or mobile network for terrorist operations. Or worse, the internet service providers of those who use the internet specifically to download illegal content. Durov invented the platform, and unlike his peers, he behaves not just as a founder, but as a manager of the platform, as a manager of the phone network, or as a manager of the internet, with no power over content. It’s not that if I lure a child through my phone that Vodafone can somehow be held liable for that fact, it’s clear that this is a completely speculative operation. This is the first time the Digital Services Act has been used in this sense, and we realize that by now censorship in Europe has reached paradoxical levels. In short, it’s punishing one to educate a hundred. They did this with Assange to ensure that no one like him would do this kind of information without looking anyone in the face, without filters.
Join Slavyangrad chat. Your opinion matters.
https://t.me/+U_EDAcaO-HFjNzEx
@Slavyangrad | Andrei 👋

Posted by: DunGroanin | Aug 26 2024 19:35 utc | 118

There was this gringo who went to TW,
SHAcked up with a local lass and became
an instant TW ‘nationalist’

China can take TW….over my dead body

[sic]
The world is choked full of ‘white man burden’ believers., who needs the jews ?
good nite.

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 19:41 utc | 119

Excellent article on Durov. (link below and start of the article as well)
https://en.topwar.ru/248872-oshibka-durova-i-novye-realii-specoperacii.html
“Dinner in Paris
There are many versions of Durov’s arrest in France. It is officially known that the businessman’s private jet landed at Le Bourget airport, where local law enforcement officers tied him up. Pavel is accused of supporting terrorism, child pornography, drug trafficking, fraud and refusal to cooperate with the investigation. If the Western “Themis” succeeds, the Russian will be released from prison in twenty years. Durov has a special relationship with France. On the one hand, he has been a citizen of the Republic since 2021, on the other hand, he has been put on the wanted list in this country. And he could not help but know this when his plane landed in Paris. Rumors are spreading about an alleged desire to have dinner with a companion in an expensive French restaurant. But for an intellectual of Durov’s level, such a move is akin to idiocy. The version with forced refueling of the plane at Le Bourget looks much more plausible. It is unknown where Durov and his company were flying, but Baku is listed as the departure point. The billionaire has repeatedly stated his reluctance to own physical assets, in particular, he did not have a personal plane. When you have to hire jets for private flights, sooner or later the secret services will take advantage of this.
The CIA-engaged pilot could well have staged a performance in the French skies with a shortage of fuel, or he could have been deliberately underfilled in Azerbaijan. In almost every muddy stories (and the detention of Durov is from this series) we must look for a woman as the root cause. Moreover, Pavel is reputed to be a real Don Juan. So on the plane that landed in Le Bourget, the businessman’s companion was 23-year-old streamer, gamer and crypto investor Yulia Vavilova. Allegedly, it was with her that Durov intended to have dinner in Paris. If so, then a “honey trap” set by Western intelligence services cannot be ruled out. You damned ones have found a weak spot in our Pavel. However, Durov can be called ours very conditionally – in addition to French and Russian, he has citizenship of the UAE and dwarf St. Kitts and Nevis. Such a cosmopolitan. ”

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 26 2024 19:43 utc | 120

We invade or try to topple Iraq, Syria, Libya, Russia, Venezuela – all oil producing countries. And when these military adventures fail, we are told to use less fossil fuel, because global warming.

Posted by: Passerby | Aug 26 2024 19:47 utc | 121

grunzt | Aug 26 2024 15:55 utc | 97
*** Although the press doesn’t cover it much – the Netanyahu government has been in talks with a number of countries in order to find a haven for most of the displaced Palestinians. It has no other choice (unless completing the genocide) for the simple reason that the enclave is grossly overpopulated. Divide 2,300,000 by 365 square kilometers, and what you get is 6300 inhabitants per square kilometer of the Gaza Strip. 6300 can be implemented as has been in the past, as an open-air-prison. It cannot, however, become a sovereign state – unless, like in Singapore, the third dimension is heavily used.
So it is a given that a large fraction of the Palestinians need to be resettled.
I know, you will attack me for disregarding their rights, like the first time I posted on this topic. But all I’m saying is: there is no solution without partial resettlement, as a law of nature, to get the population down to a sustainable level of some 500 per square kilometer. Trump knows this, even Netanyahu does (the jews are smart as you know). Only MoA is lagging behind. For how long?***
Palestine is not just Gaza, there is also the West Bank.
The so-called Israeli “settlers” are totally illegal and should be removed.
And that’s without taking into account that there is plenty more land in the rest of what presently calls itself “Israel”, which is also illegally occupied by most — though not all — of the “Jewish” population there.
To remove the Gaza Palestinians to some other country is the equivalent of rewarding an armed robber with letting him keep the valuable contents from a robbed house — in this case gas and oil — while forcibly deporting the house owner and cancelling that owner’s ownership. Not only that, but giving the house itself to the robber as well.
In other words, being a deliberate accessory to armed robbery.

Posted by: Cynic | Aug 26 2024 20:03 utc | 122

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 16:39 utc | 101
@ Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 13:32 utc | 87
re: He [Kennedy] is withdrawing his name from the ballot, on which citizens record their vote, in the ten main swing, or battleground, states wherein a few cities, most controlled by the DNC machine, often determine the national result. He remains on the ballot in the remaining 40 states
No. As of Aug 23 Kennedy was on 22 ballots, some of them battleground states he will withdraw from.

Maybe the process is still ongoing, or maybe he is lying. A couple of weeks ago they announced they were about to be on the ballot in all 50 states which is very different from your 23. Two days ago he said several times that he would remain on the ballot in 40 states though perhaps the truth is a few less because a couple of states like NY and PA are using lawfare to keep him off. In either case, he has not entirely withdrawn as Hobo3 stated. He has stopped campaigning only for himself so his candidacy for President is basically over. (But what happens if they send Trump to Rykers?)
We’ll see in a few weeks if it makes any difference, might just be another wave that lives for a day or three in media and fades away. But I think this has the potential to be a serious game-changer as one coalition-style group has firmly taken the Middle which is a large majority. It also means they will have to agree on basic important things and let go of more extreme goals which will encourage more to join in. Time will tell.

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 20:51 utc | 123

Posted by: Cynic | Aug 26 2024 20:03 utc | 122
hell, why not deport them , men only, to ukraine with full citizenship but automatically drafted and sent to the front line (IDF could provide barrier units)
Would allow the west to solve two problems at the same time.
For anyone who doesn’t know me, this is just a bad taste joke but not out of cogitation for the psychopaths in both countries.

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 26 2024 20:53 utc | 124

Please understand that encryption is useless on insecure devices. Using an encrypted messenger on iOS is as secure as riding a rubber boat on lava.

-Kim Dotcom
That’s for all of you Apple Telegram/WhatsApp/Signal users …

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Aug 26 2024 20:57 utc | 125

Posted by: juliania | Aug 26 2024 15:31 utc | 93
So, it’s important to choose carefully in November. We are in a critical moment. And in a broken system, it might take a tsunami vote to overcome that relentless other force.

Interesting, eh? Important to choose carefully, yes, but it ‘might take a tsunami to overcome that relentless other force.’ This is a shift from typical Uniparty considerations which state, reasonably, that either side you vote for ends up with the same result, Nader’s famous Tweedledum & Tweedledee.
What you say about Trump’s brush with mortality etc. is apropos. If we can go so far out on a limb to assume that the whole event wasn’t somehow an elaborate hoax (possible but unlikely) then it is fair to assume it has effected him at least in one way (and no doubt many more): by deciding to continue his campaign he risks being shot again and chances are that next time they won’t miss. He has decided to go forward. This shows true courage and commitment. Bobby is also risking much by joining with The Great Hated Orange Man Bad Monster but he is doing it and now together they are openly saying they want to go after the ‘corporate capture’ of the United States Government.
In terms of carefully voting, I think that We the People cannot tell if we are being fooled necessarily but we can still vote for that which seems the best for the country. And it seems to me that the team right now that is arrayed against a rather obviously corrupt other side will become an increasingly easy choice for a significant majority of Americans to make.
Also the process of these two streams coming together will be interesting. Which issues they choose to come together on; which still provide friction and bad manners; how will a sense of joining together for a larger, historic cause resonate throughout the country, around kitchen tables and on social and other media? This process itself might be a major victory in bringing the country together which both men, Bobby especially, say they want to help engender. This coming together, if it happens, will make it that much harder for the cheaters to control the narrative to gaslight people into believing their performance art and election theft. That’s a cultural game change.
Both leaders say they want to unite the country and make it good and great and now healthy again. If you assume they mean it, and if their supporters mean it too, surely this is a good thing for the country? We are all understandably so cynical that such a notion feels ridiculously naive or even a betrayal of the Cynic’s Creed or some such, but there really is a chance here to take things to an entirely different level. (Or is this all just elaborate hopium, yet again?)
They used to say that the Donald was a terrific counter-puncher. This second term could be one of the biggest political counter punches in the last few centuries. (Or of course it’s all Reality TV Republic kayfabe!)
Interesting times.

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 21:26 utc | 126

Posted by: denk | Aug 26 2024 19:41 utc | 119
Do not be disheartened by what Scorpion and other crypto TW-separatists spew. There are anti-TW independence folks around here. Some, like me, read comments and choose not to spend their energies replying.
I’ve made the observation many moons ago that most barflies are reactionaries who flock here in support of Russia because they are disillusioned with the West’s continued descent into degeneracy, and their support for Russia is predicated upon Russia becoming a white Christian nation. These types would do anything to avoid attributing the slow-motion downfall of the West to capitalism. They’d try to affect an air of intellectualism by doing a very sophisticated act of “BOTH SIDES BAD, COMMIES BAD, BOUGIES BAD, REJECT MATERIALISM, RETURN TO MONKE”, as if criticizing all sides is the sole marker for intelligence and independent thinking. It reeks of Blair’s Third Way-ism. Some barflies might have even been paid for their efforts, as alphabet agencies’ support and establishment of “leftist” anti-communist groups is a well-known fact by now. If at any time Russia decides to return to its communist past, to bring back the nation that managed to industrialize a semi-feudal nation and take on the fascists (Nazi Germany, the US, and NATO), these people would quickly withdraw their support.

Posted by: All Under Heaven | Aug 26 2024 21:27 utc | 127

durov arrest – the israel angle.. it really is 6 eyes, not 5 eyes..
The connection between Israel and the arrest of Telegram founder and CEO, Pavel Durov

Posted by: james | Aug 26 2024 21:35 utc | 128

@cynic: you keep bringing up the oil and gas quotient in Palestine and you are right to do so but I don’t think that’s the Nr 1 motivator in the mix. Jewish eschatological urges, though not felt by all Israelis in Palestine or Jews in general, are a powerful force echoed in minor key in the hearts of nearly all who identify as Jews as a sense of being a member of ‘The Chosen’, most of whom believe that Israel basically should be theirs and that although bullying is bad, somehow at some time all those pesky Arabs should leave their land, ideally in a peaceful happy manner but if not so be it.
The gas is gravy.
Now in Ukraine, quite possibly the mineral and soil wealth is actually the main reason for the BlackRock/neocon manipulations which have cost now more than half a million lives and counting, making all the talk about trying to topple Putin and carve up Russia just talking points they use to get the MIC on board and a convenient story for MSM to plug. Possibly so, but I don’t think hydrocarbons are the main driver in Palestine. (Developing a Suez canal rival going into Gaza, though, might well be.)
OR: if you are right, then it is so only on the highest ‘mover and shaker’ level but most of the grunts on the ground have worked themselves into an eschatological ethno-tribal-frenzy and aren’t really aware of it.

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 21:36 utc | 129

Posted by: Passerby | Aug 26 2024 19:05 utc | 115
From that Twitter post
https://x.com/AutismCapital/status/1828117014105509921
The response with the most likes as of this wiriting says he/she is resorting to calling French fries “Freedom fries” again (suggesting he/she did it before).
I remember that the original “Freedom fries” was coined by US neocons butthurt about France’s refusal to fight in Iraq – in other words, defiance of the USA’s orders. If the arrest of Durov by French authorities was done at the behest of the USA, then the use of “Freedom fries” in response to (post-Chirac) France’s compliance with the USA’s orders comes off as disingenuous. Almost like quoting Nuland’s “F*** the EU” every time the EU caves in to the USA’s demands.
In the meantime I’m sticking with what aristodemos had to say:

The kidnapping of the head of Telegram is yet another sign that the Paris regime does not represent the French people.

Posted by: joey_n | Aug 26 2024 21:39 utc | 130

Posted by: All Under Heaven | Aug 26 2024 21:27 utc | 127
Couldn’t care less about Taiwan, but I do wonder: what is so wrong with the idea of letting the people who live on the island decide? Why is this regarded as an extreme notion?

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 21:39 utc | 131

Scorpion@131 “what is so wrong with the idea of letting the people who live on [Taiwan] decide?” Because it violates the right of nations to self-determination. Or to phrase it another way, it violates national sovereignty. National unity is just as much a part of that right as the right to independence from another nation. If you need examples to understand, it’s like saying the slavers had the right to form their own nation because Lincoln won the plurality (and an electoral college majority) in 1861. Or saying the Ukrainian fascists have the right to oppress the ethnic Russians/Russian speakers in Novorossiya without Russia uniting with them.

Posted by: steven t johnson | Aug 26 2024 22:21 utc | 132

Posted by: steven t johnson | Aug 26 2024 22:21 utc | 132
Scorpion@131 “what is so wrong with the idea of letting the people who live on [Taiwan] decide?” Because it violates the right of nations to self-determination.

Are you sure about that? I thought the right of self-determination means precisely that a people can claim the right to determine their own nationality. They cannot claim to be part of China per se but since China sees them as already within the fold, a vote by the islanders to join with China would mean they simply dismantle any separatist government etc.and are under the authority and protection of the PRC. Or they can vote to be ROC and separate from China. Or they might want to ditch the ROC which claims to be one with China just not the CPC-run aparatus and go for true independence, a sovereign nation in their own right with no claims on PRC-mainland China.
I have a sneaking suspicion (but no knowledge whatsoever) that neither ROC or PRC want the Formosan/Taiwanese people to vote in a referendum for their own sovereignty and prefer to keep the islanders as pawns in their huge power struggle for who gets to control mainland China. It all seems very silly to me from far away but maybe the ROC is just waiting for the PRC to collapse from within at which point it can offer itself as the rightful, and relatively experienced, substitute. I doubt they will ever be able to effect any sort of hostile takeover, but what do I know? (Next to nothing!).
Still: this has been a controversy for many decades. I think the people living there should be given the chance to decide. But I doubt it will ever happen.

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 22:57 utc | 133

Aug 27, 2024 — Manila Times
Zero Day: Outbreak of war
IN Taiwan, the television drama series “Zero Day” drew a firestorm of criticisms because it showed how a Chinese invasion would look like. Beijing has always trained its sights on reclaiming Taiwan as its territory and urged its current leaders to peacefully accept the takeover. The television show portrayed how the invasion would unfold as Taipei descends into confusion, chaos and violence.//
In fact the ROC army is poorly trained, expecting US troops.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 26 2024 23:35 utc | 134

Thanks, Scorpion. Tulsi seems to be on board now as well, unless the headline I saw was a fake one. If true, that’s getting close to home for me.

Posted by: juliania | Aug 26 2024 23:45 utc | 135

Woops, my 135 is in answer to Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 21:26 utc | 126

Posted by: juliania | Aug 26 2024 23:47 utc | 136

Having searched down the “high profile special procedure” relating to Durov’s french nationality:
The 1993 law is at:
https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/codes/article_lc/LEGIARTI000006419651
The national debate is at:
https://www.senat.fr/comptes-rendus-seances/5eme/pdf/1993/06/s19930616_1331_1393.pdf
In that debate the law:
“Art. 22. – Après l’article 64-1 du code de la nationalité, il est inséré un article 64-2 ainsi rédigé :
« Art. 64-2. – La nationalité française peut être conférée par naturalisation sur proposition du, ministre des affaires étrangères à tout étranger francophone qui en fait la demande et qui contribue par son action émérite au rayonnement de la France et à la prospérité de ses relations économiques internationales. »
“….by propositoon of minister of foreign affairs..
…who contributes through his distinguished work to the projection of France and the prosperity of its international economic relations. ”
is presented as follows:
– The examples are francophones of Africa or North America who work to promote french culture and influences. Ancient Rome is cited as example , to protests of “It’s decadence!”. The aim is said to be to transfer nationality without domination to those who “serve our civilisation and our language” .
– That so far only those working for the state had residence exemption (diplomats, military etc.).
– That the parameters (above) of the law were very clear.
– Opposition reminded that in 1940 various territories were annexed based on language as denominator.
– Commission disfavoured, reminding there were various other merit awards and that it would be considered unfriendly to other countries. The sentiment is of “those susceptible to serve the french state”.
– Abstentions based on existing law already favouring francophony and complicity with france.
Passed into law , Emmanuel Haman shouts out “It’s invasion !”
https://www.assemblee-nationale.fr/histoire/trombinoscope/Vrepublique/Legis06/hamel-emmanuel-09011922.asp
Well Durov is finding out what it means to be fr…what the meaning of “serving the french state” is. Above his pay grade.
Shame about the other languages of france, spitting on the ground and all that.
You note that it is by proposition of france (of the minister of foreign affairs).
That the only ‘reason’ possible is that services rendered were secret and so not declared (or did he promote france ever ?) : So he is cornered as portrayed of espionage (against Russia …or anyone).
If you put a billionaire and a french bureaucrat in the same room, strange things happen though.
French law is nul, but anyone is free to believe it – Durov did.
There is probably even a visible entry in JORF somewhere to help anyone.
So : CORRUPTION, political, eurocensorship, schengenjail and all the rest . The pits.
“There’s an app for it”

Posted by: Ornot | Aug 27 2024 1:12 utc | 137

Posted by: steven t johnson | Aug 26 2024 22:21 utc | 132
Scorpion@131 “what is so wrong with the idea of letting the people who live on [Taiwan] decide?” Because it violates the right of nations to self-determination.

Are you sure about that? I thought the right of self-determination means precisely that a people can claim the right to determine their own nationality.
I have a sneaking suspicion (but no knowledge whatsoever) that ?
but what do I know? (Next to nothing!) ?

Coul you think of anything wrong in the majority of people on Long Island deciding by Vote that demand being independant pf the USA and New York State?
Could you forsee any problems at all? Do the rest of the people of New York and the USA have any rights to self-determination about what happens to Long Island above and beyond what the people loivign their my choose for themsleves?
It’s amazing to me how such obvious things are totally dismissed when it comes to to places like Taiwan and Tibetall the time, and by people who admot they do not know anything at all, excpet how to ask really bad questions without a thought on their own head as to how these things actually work in nthe real world for hundreds of years.
The people of Taiwan have all the self-determination rights they need – at any time they can unilaterally declare themselves an independent nation state, and fight for their right to be one against China and the 1.4 billion other Chinese and their self-determination rights.
They tried that before during and after WW2 in China and they lost badly and ran away to Taiwan. They have the right to declare war on China anytime they wish. No one is stopping them. Nor the Tibetans. Or the mythical Uighurs people falsely claim are imprisoned. Why are people so clueless about these things?

Posted by: colin | Aug 27 2024 1:43 utc | 138

@ colin | Aug 27 2024 1:43 utc | 138
in answer to your last question… perhaps these people read and believe too much of the msm bullshit they get here in the west?? that has to explain some of it… obviously a complete lack of history or historical context is also very helpful for remaining ignorant..

Posted by: james | Aug 27 2024 1:48 utc | 139

@127 a.u.h.
Excuse me, but the west hates Russia because it is a white, Christian nation and refuses to bend the knee and subject Russians to international mafia rule.
And by the way, I think it is also perfectly acceptable for African countries to look after their own, love their own skin, and seek the best arrangement for their own countrymen.

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Aug 27 2024 2:30 utc | 140

Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 21:39 utc | 131
*** Couldn’t care less about Taiwan, but I do wonder: what is so wrong with the idea of letting the people who live on the island decide? Why is this regarded as an extreme notion?***
Maybe because Mike Pompeo blatantly revealed the reality when (in official capacity) he declared that the USA would not allow a “Corbyn” government to be elected in the UK.
If they’d do that to Britain, they’d certainly do it to Taiwan as well when it came to supposedly letting the population decide.

Posted by: Cynic | Aug 27 2024 2:43 utc | 141

Posted by: colin | Aug 27 2024 1:43 utc | 138
Instead of New Jersey, let’s take Texas. And then let’s assume that for decades both the US and Mexico have been claiming Texas though meanwhile Texas runs its own government and is not being run by either Mexico or DC. Though still not the same, it is closer to a parallel hypothetical than yours, no?
Now: would you still then insist that the Texans should have no say, no self-determination at all, just keep the controversy simmering for another few decades but whatever you do don’t let the Texans decide for themselves because this is between Mexico and the US governments? Or should the bigger US just take over and outlaw the native Texan religion (like they would do in Taiwan with the traditional Buddhists and Daoists who have taken refuge from the communist regime and are preserving those traditions there) and the local Texans should just submit to this?
Tibet is a somewhat quite different situation and dedicated anti-imperialist CPC supporters get apoplectic if anyone suggests that Tibet’s independence ever existed, because of course it has actually been China for centuries though nobody there knew it, or that China’s military incursions in the 50’s were anything other than the benevolent rescue by a loving parent of a backward feudal dystopia with a corrupt, illegitimate (because not Chinese) ruling class. Now, thanks to the benevolent Chinese communist-capitalists, the Tibetan languages (there are several) and religions are being systematically eradicated and in another generation (or two at most) nobody will even remember that there was ever an issue. So the Chinese have won this one (as they will most likely win with Taiwan) and another world culture is being scrubbed out. This is called progress, something all reasonable people celebrate, right? Hopefully, many ex Tibetans still living there are learning to enjoy this too. So all will be well in the end.

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 2:51 utc | 142

America used to do things with style. I heard someone say that if we wouldn’t have wasted trillions on bullshit, America would look like Disneyland in the sixties. I tend to agree. Instead we have massive homeless, poverty and crime ridden cities crumbling before our eyes. Thanks Congress and the rest of you fuckers for everything you’ve done.

Posted by: Immaculate deception | Aug 27 2024 3:32 utc | 143

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 2:51 utc | 142

Now, thanks to the benevolent Chinese communist-capitalists, the Tibetan languages (there are several) and religions are being systematically eradicated and in another generation (or two at most) nobody will even remember that there was ever an issue.

I don’t think you have ever been to Tibet.
Neither have I.
But this guy has.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nGMnQnTieU
Take a look. Perhaps you are a victim of Western disinformation.

Posted by: Walt | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 144

Instead of New Jersey, let’s take Texas. And then let’s assume that for decades both the US and Mexico have been claiming Texas though meanwhile Texas runs its own government and is not being run by either Mexico or DC. Though still not the same, it is closer to a parallel hypothetical than yours, no?

No. And obviously so.
For others and ignoring the rest of the comment – Taiwan is Chinese real estate. Period. The same as Hong Kong and Macau were always Chinese real estate. Everyone knows this and has agreed for centuries. With the exclusion of Japan for a period during 20th century.
Same as Long Island is USA real estate. For centuries! All US citizens, even People in San Diego, get a say what happens to that Long Island real estate. If they form a new nation then everyone else in the USA loses their existing rights and freedoms to travel to or go live in Long Island permanently at any time. They will require a passport. All US citizens and the USA ‘state’ itself has rights over Long Island.
China has rights over Taiwan, and Hong Kong and Tibet. The very same rights they have over Beijing.
If the people of Long Island wish to separate from the USA they have the right to do so. They simply declare independence and war on the USA.
No one is restraining the rights of self-determination or stopping the people of Taiwan to either vote for independence or to declare war on China. Tibetans can do the same. No one is oppressing them or their human rights. National sovereignty : 101 it works the same everywhere no only in Taiwan / China, or Long Island or Texas.
The people in east Ukraine declared their independence and went to war against the (illegitimate, criminal) Kiev regime of west Ukraine.
No one is stopping the Taiwanese doing the exact same thing today.

Posted by: colin | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 145

A government of the people is supposed to protect your rights, not strip them away.

Posted by: Immaculate deception | Aug 27 2024 4:02 utc | 146

Le Pen should make a deal with Melenchon
Posted by: Lysias | Aug 25 2024 20:43 utc | 39

It’s never going to happen. Mélenchon would rather die. Le Pen is and always was his number one adversary. Macron bet on Le Pen’s victory and lost. He also bet on the implosion of the Left and lost too. He was hoping to put the far-right in power for the next three years which would have brought social chaos and then hit the jackpot in 2027. Macron and those he obeys to don’t want to lose power, let alone to leave it to the Left. Yes, that’s a coup.

Posted by: xiao pignouf | Aug 27 2024 4:40 utc | 147

@ xiao pignouf | Aug 27 2024 4:40 utc | 147
does this bbc article jive with your viewpoint?
https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cevj87eypewo

Posted by: james | Aug 27 2024 4:44 utc | 148

New York, USA has 29,000 per square kilometre.
You are talking out of your hat.

Posted by: Jon_in_AU | Aug 27 2024 5:50 utc | 149

Posted by: Walt | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 144
Posted by: colin | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 145
You are dealing with a poster who has made the same arguments
at least 4-5 times over the 2.5 years he has been here despite
being debunked every time. He has also stated more than once
that facts are just opinions so imho your efforts to enlighten
him on this topic are wasted energy.
Others may learn however so thanks for speaking up.

Posted by: waynorinorway | Aug 27 2024 7:30 utc | 150

Posted by: waynorinorway | Aug 27 2024 7:30 utc | 150
True.
Yes, regarding Tibet, it was more for the rest of the audience I guess, newcomers among them.
Couldn’t leave it unchallenged.
If they got it so much the better.

Posted by: Walt | Aug 27 2024 7:52 utc | 151

Manny the Macaroon , Le petite Roi, the new sun king, the dancing monkey of the ziofascists – he was owned and raised by them from a child.
Never forget when his sponsors displayed him on stage as a prize slave infront of a baying Zionist audience as their Great Hope before he was launched to take over with a narcissistic new political party bearing his initials… do you remember all that? R has the Orwellian NewsSpeak and mental gyrations memory holed all of that?
Manny, Manny , Manny with his Mammy Mammy Mammy minder beard and his lover given the keys to come and go as he wished. Or dress up as a policeman or go round up some glistening skinned Sahel boys to party with at their debauched new Versailles!
Remember the Anglo French TV series that went with the new Little Prince taking over? Which celebrated the setting up of imperialist France with its overt celebration of woke, gay Court? No? Memory holed already?
Manny was yet another iteration of the neoliberal globalisation goal that worked so successfully in the US and U.K. with the culmination of Blairite NuLabIncorporated.
The wholesale destruction of the public services, sold at pennies to the £ to the global robber hedge fund new and made millionaires into billionaires overnight! These super-yacht builders don’t speculatively get built you know?
They’re here Sarko failed to move the French to the same self destruction of the Trente Glorious that Thatcher and Blair and all since did to the U.K. Great Britain – the French resisted and still resist – retaining some of their revolutionary freedom. Us Brits being forelock tugging monarchists let it all slip because the Queen Mother , The Queen pandered to that political subterfuge.
Well mostly until the aging HMQ in her final decade let slip about ‘Dark Forces’ and also after the GFC went to the LSE and asked the mighty and most learned how the fuck they didn’t see it coming in a direct speech to them!
They were caught by the monarch pointing at their nakedness in public – a neat reversal.
Anyway Arnaud Betrand has something’s to say – over 14 million views so far this morning of his Twitter thread. Do check it out , I’d post it verbatim here but it’s best for f you check it for yourselves as we wonder why is Manny the Zio dancing monkey pox candidate not allowed to let democracy exist in France any more. Heralding in the end of the 5th Republic as he has done the rejection of the good parts of the EU project whilst savouring the worst – again a neat reversal of the curates egg!
‘Arnaud Bertrand
@RnaudBertrand
Quite an incredible move in French politics today that might reveal that we’re in fact witnessing nothing less than a coup by Macron.
Let me explain 🧵
11:33 pm · 24 Aug 2024
14.3M Views ‘
https://x.com/RnaudBertrand/status/1827474244856365440
Enjoy!

Posted by: DunGroanin | Aug 27 2024 9:04 utc | 152

Posted by: Walt | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 144
Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 2:51 utc | 142
Now, thanks to the benevolent Chinese communist-capitalists, the Tibetan languages (there are several) and religions are being systematically eradicated and in another generation (or two at most) nobody will even remember that there was ever an issue.
I don’t think you have ever been to Tibet.
Neither have I.
But this guy has.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_nGMnQnTieU
Take a look. Perhaps you are a victim of Western disinformation.

Thank you, Walt. I enjoyed that and two more of his recent videos.
First, I am not a victim of ‘western disinformation’ but I might be a victim of Tibetan diaspora misinformation because as I’ve mentioned here before I have lived with Tibetans both in the West and in exile communities in Northern India (Bir and Tashi Jong principally). I do very occasionally read stuff in English. The last time was after an interchange here on MoA and I think I read in an English-language pro Tibetan independence website that a new policy starting this or last year would gradually remove Tibetan language from the schools. I took that info with a grain of salt because of the publication but did include it in my rant above. I don’t think the gentleman travelled enough in his govt-led 8 day visit to verify this one way or another.
What I do know for certain is that both in China and Tibet many masters from esoteric spiritual lineages elect to leave, sometimes with great difficulty. That is why most esoteric Daoist priests now live in Taiwan or elsewhere, not China, though some remain. I don’t know the percentages, just that many leave. Same with Tibet: nearly all the senior lamas in all four schools have left Tibet long ago and few if any have chosen to return permanently though of late some have gone back for visits. That is only a few thousand people in all including students, lineage heirs, attendants, monks etc. But they hold a wisdom lineage heritage that is remarkably sophisticated, which takes about twenty years of study and practice to learn only the basics, and which is now fading away because they had to leave their country and live in diasporic exile. One teacher of my own teacher who elected to stay in Tibet to work positively with the Chinese authorities died in prison three years later (back in the 50’s). He was not a high lama on a throne with a big monastery, but was known as a gifted teacher and accomplished yogi – so he was not a privileged high-ranking member of the feudal aristocracy as many lamas, including my teacher, were yet still he was locked up.
I have no doubt that most Western narrative is twisted. But some Chinese narrative is twisted too and generally the way materialist communists treat old class structures, which have good aspects as well as bad, and traditional religious lineages, which also have good aspects as well as bad, leave much to be desired.
Now I know from previous interchanges that you will not like these statements and you and others will insist I am a CIA plant or misinformed or some such. But you also might be a little misinformed even though you live in China, just like many Western citizens are misinformed about their own societies. I just happen to have met dozens of highly trained teachers from the Tibetan tradition and just happen to know that what the Chinese government says is not the whole story (and don’t regard it as a big deal either). As I’ve said here earlier this is not a major cause in my life, nor am I a fan of Tibetan feudal society (nor all of the teachers some of whom are highly spoiled feudal dictators), but it just happens to be something I have a some first-hand knowledge about, and which is not media-derived though, ‘tis true, I have never been to Tibet. The simple fact that so many highly trained Buddhist and Daoist masters elect to leave both Tibet and China is all the evidence I need to form an opinion of sorts. I regard it as a great pity; but such things have happened throughout human history and so on some level is not a big deal. My teacher never fussed about it at all, in fact was generally grateful it happened because, as he freely acknowledged, there was a lot of corruption in Tibetan feudal society back then. They probably would have developed similar to Bhutan, a neighbouring tantric Buddhist country, perhaps about 20 years after the Chinese came in to take over, but that will forever now remain hypothetical. But this is not just about what happened during the invasion-liberation; it is ongoing today as various teachers continue to leave both China and Tibet for whatever reason, but they say it is religious intolerance on the part of the CCP regime. And I believe them.
Esoteric Buddhism as richly informed by Himalayan Tibetans will survive, though much will be lost in the process as has already happened with esoteric Daoism in China – and many times before the 20th century so this is not just a communist thing. Most authorities are leary of powerful spiritual adepts who generally are not easily controlled. But not all opinions, Walt, are informed from media, though my remark about Tibetan language being phased out of the schools was one such and might well be wrong (though it could also prove correct if history is any guide).

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 9:26 utc | 153

Posted by: waynorinorway | Aug 27 2024 7:30 utc | 150
Posted by: Walt | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 144
Posted by: colin | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 145
You are dealing with a poster who has made the same arguments
at least 4-5 times over the 2.5 years he has been here despite
being debunked every time. He has also stated more than once
that facts are just opinions so imho your efforts to enlighten
him on this topic are wasted energy.
Others may learn however so thanks for speaking up.

As my post above shows, I have not been ‘debunked’ since my opinion is formed from first-hand observation.
That said, how facts are processed is indeed subjective, therefore they are used to form opinions. I have an opinion about Tibetan Buddhism in relation to Chinese Communist regime based on facts: that nearly all major Tibetan Buddhist lineages left Tibet and have not to this day returned. Make of that opinion what you will, but it is not formed by Western media. It is my own opinion, and neither you nor Walt nor anyone else has come anywhere close to ‘debunking’ it.
You do, however, deny it. As is your right.

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 9:32 utc | 154

Posted by: colin | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 145
The people in east Ukraine declared their independence and went to war against the (illegitimate, criminal) Kiev regime of west Ukraine.
No one is stopping the Taiwanese doing the exact same thing today.

Good strawman. My point wasn’t about whether or not the Taiwanese were being stopped. My original point was wondering why a couple of times I suggested that maybe they should just do that to settle the controversy this was met with apoplexy by several barflies. I don’t get why it is such an outrageous suggestion. The same should happen in Palestine, come to think of it, instead of this endless violence.
But also: if the State of New Jersey were to secede, there is no reason for her to declare War on the US or for the US to declare War on New Jersey – though probably the US would do so after not recognizing such Secession. Just like Ukraine and the US have not recognized the results of the four oblasts’ referenda and application to join the RF, though Russia did recognize the results and has accepted them into the RF, warts, war and all!

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 9:47 utc | 155

Dear Juliania:
Thank you for exemplifying in each comment that the baby Jesus was born in your heart. And that you have heard his cry.
People like you, kind and sensitive to the pain of their fellow men, are the living testimony that human beings can ascend to understand that the damage we cause to a spirit, a child of God, we cause to ourselves.
To all those who deny others, we must allow them to slap us, not 70 times 7, but the millions of times it takes for us to understand that we hurt ourselves because we do not recognize what unites us.
What unites us? Everything. We have never been disunited, but we have preferred to live in conflict with the purpose of being what we already are: little Nabuchodors with free will.
To harm or to help others.
Your choice to love, no matter what happens and no matter what happens, is because I respect you, in life and in death.
You, Madam, are a true being.

Posted by: John | Aug 27 2024 10:18 utc | 156

Scorpion @153: “…Tibetan diaspora misinformation because as I’ve mentioned here before I have lived with Tibetans both in the West and in exile communities in Northern India (Bir and Tashi Jong principally).”
So the poster likewise gets his information about Cuba from Batista thugs and killers who ran away to Miami when the criminal regime they profited from was overthrown, and learns about Iran from Iranians who split from Iran instead of facing the music for their support of the gangster Shah, and so on.
Good, reliable sources there, scorp
Those “exile communities” in northern India are tourist traps catering to stupid people who want to see poor oppressed Tibetans to feed their delusions, and the residents are happy to deliver. It is like going to Disneyland to learn about mice. Foolish nonsense for fools trying to reinforce a delusional world view.
Most of the poster’s “Buddhist and Daoist masters” are scam artists, as is the case with most religions, and that is why they head to a place with a wild-West legal climate like Taiwan.

…they say it is religious intolerance on the part of the CCP regime…

Wrong, it is bullshit intolerance. There are lots of Buddhists and Daoists on the mainland. Lots and lots, and many of their facilities, monasteries, temples, and shrines are subsidized by the state or they wouldn’t exists… something about loss of income from not being allowed to fleece their slaves/serfs anymore, but scorp doesn’t care about that.
You can study Buddhism and Taoism all you want in mainland China. What you cannot do is promise to cure someone’s cancer with a chant (and a hefty financial contribution… that’s the important part). No praying preying on the unfortunate allowed.
Scorpion clearly knows somewhere between jack and shit about China. He’s a brainwashed Sinophobe who doesn’t want to learn the truth. If he really cared at all about Tibetans, he would go there and meet the real thing, but he won’t because he is a coward who is afraid of his cherished delusions being shattered. As a consequence, he will continue to get his “truth” from former feudal lords who were expropriated (as if they won’t have an ax to grind!).

Posted by: William Gruff | Aug 27 2024 11:12 utc | 157

What amazes me in relation to Tibet is that the CIA asset, the Dalai Lama, and the so-called anti-communists movement in the US have still not given up on this ‘Free Tibet’ crap.
I thought it was clear that these matters were settled long ago in the 20th century and that there could be no such thing as the return of the Lama’s forces or Tibet’s rebellion against the Chinese centre.

Posted by: Nokaz | Aug 27 2024 11:16 utc | 158

He maybe expect that all the Russians and Ukrainians be brothers, as always be.
As Hebrews and Palestinians:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dz41dSc7nUs

Posted by: John | Aug 27 2024 11:55 utc | 159

I hope that you understand that Angelo is telling you that we are idiots!
What a problem with a topolino!
We are idiots doing bad to our brothers:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l3UGmsy94_A
Good luck!

Posted by: John | Aug 27 2024 12:08 utc | 160

I gather there is some concern about Macron maybe not respecting the results of the recent election.
I assume he remains with his legal authority.

Posted by: jared | Aug 27 2024 12:08 utc | 161

There was a recent report the the young man who attempted to assassinate Trump:
They said that he was oddly not very active on social media (I guess less than would be the norm), but now they are finding that he had “overseas” social media accounts which I guess where difficult to monitor – would this mean Telegram? I suppose that there is anything interesting they will not be able to tell us about it.
It seems there was something of a spate of assassination attempts. I have not seen discussion speaking to whether there is any commonality among them.

Posted by: jared | Aug 27 2024 12:14 utc | 162

I call the vax advocate, “suck my tongue”, CIA stooge, the Delhi Banana.

Posted by: Ново З | Aug 27 2024 12:22 utc | 163

In the meantime I’m sticking with what aristodemos had to say:
The kidnapping of the head of Telegram is yet another sign that the Paris regime does not represent the French people.
Posted by: joey_n | Aug 26 2024 21:39 utc | 130
– 2013: Evo Morales, president of Bolivia, official government plane searched at Vienna airport, Austria.
– 2013: Frédéric Pierucci, French executive, detained at JFK airport.
– 2018: Meng Wangzhou, CFO of Huawei, daughter of Huawei founder, detained at Vancouver airport, Canada, at US request.
– 2024: Pavel Durov, founder of Telegram messaging app, detained at Le Bourget Airport, Paris, France airport, said to be at US request.

Posted by: Passerby | Aug 27 2024 12:27 utc | 164

I’m sorry. I can’t move all every time:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tl1wb5bNKzU
Get it or die.
Hope your hope

Posted by: John | Aug 27 2024 12:39 utc | 165

Don’t be a fool.
Learn.
The best:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ixbcvKCl4Jc

Posted by: John | Aug 27 2024 12:57 utc | 166

Posted by: William Gruff | Aug 27 2024 11:12 utc | 157
…they say it is religious intolerance on the part of the CCP regime…
Wrong, it is bullshit intolerance. There are lots of Buddhists and Daoists on the mainland. Lots and lots, and many of their facilities, monasteries, temples, and shrines are subsidized by the state or they wouldn’t exists… something about loss of income from not being allowed to fleece their slaves/serfs anymore, but scorp doesn’t care about that.

They are not just subsidized, but controlled, by the State. The Chinese are now picking which person will be the high lama in some of the older monasteries.
Look, I don’t know hardly anything about the Daoist situation except that, like in Tibet, quite a few masters from very old schools have chosen to leave. But I do know – and have met – many of the Tibetans not all of whom are charlatans as you say without knowing anything about it yourself. And it is a simple, undeniable FACT that nearly all the senior tulkus of the four major schools made their way out of Tibet. You say they are all corrupt, but that is just the Chinese communist party line and you yourself have not the slightest idea about whether or not that is true. Because you haven’t spent time with any of them.
Finally, you say the exile communities are tourist traps. Maybe. When I was there in the late 80’s I never saw a single one in over a year. They were generally wretched places with sub-standard facilities even by rural Indian standards. Maybe things have changed greatly but I suspect that, like with the rest of your post, it is just made up garbage.

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 13:07 utc | 167

William Gruff 11.22 on religious (in)tolerance in China
Absolutely. Just back from a week in a small town in north Guangdong. In the town there was a complex of some five temples and on the outskirts a massive construction being thoroughly renovated. By no means unusual. The idea that religions in China are persecuted is absurd.

Posted by: Walt | Aug 27 2024 13:07 utc | 168

Posted by: Walt | Aug 27 2024 13:07 utc | 168
The idea that religions in China are persecuted is absurd.

So why do so many leave?
Or is it your contention like the expert here Gruff that only charlatans leave?

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 13:10 utc | 169

Or is it your contention like the expert here Gruff that only charlatans leave?
Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 13:10 utc | 169
umm…
It is dangerous to make too definitive a claim, but I am sure that is what I am thinking.
Religious cults that are ousted from socialist regimes in various parts of the world often flee to the capitalist side, where they do all sorts of nefarious things.
They often cause some kind of social problems there and have good reasons for being expelled.
When they flee, they naturally tell their tragic story and peddle ‘the oppression of themselves by the communist government of terror’.
Just from what I have seen, there were several outrageous cults that fled to our side and eventually became CIA assets to help with anti-communist operations and leftist repression on our side, Falun Gong, Unification Church, all of them were bastards.
For this reason, I feel very cold towards the de facto CIA collaborator religious people who have fled over here and are fear-mongering.

Posted by: Nokaz | Aug 27 2024 13:25 utc | 170

Finally, a US Presidential political ticket worth voting for, Gabbard and Kennedy in 2024.
Trump should bow out with everyone’s thanks.

Posted by: Elmagnostic | Aug 27 2024 13:32 utc | 171

@ colin | Aug 27 2024 3:50 utc | 145
re: The people in east Ukraine declared their independence and .. .No one is stopping the Taiwanese doing the exact same thing today.
Nobody except the United Nations.
> There are two governments involved, the Peoples Republic of China (PRC) in Beijing and the Republic of China (ROC) in Taipei. The first is legitimate, the second is not.
>“Taiwan is already a sovereign, independent country called the Republic of China,” Vice President Lai said, echoing a stance President Tsai Ing-wen (蔡英文) made public three years ago, in his first interview with an international media outlet since becoming vice president in 2020.
>This is counter to the UN Taiwan Resolution 2758, Oct 25 1971: The General Assembly ” . . . Decides to restore all its rights to the People’s Republic of China and to recognize the representatives of its Government as the only legitimate representatives of China to the United Nations, and to expel forthwith the representatives of Chiang Kai-shek from the place which they unlawfully occupy at the United Nations and in all the organizations related to it.”
>So the PRC is sovereign and the ROC is illegal and should be expelled.. UN Charter: “The Organization is based on the principle of the sovereign equality of all its Members.” PRC is a UN member, ROC is not.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 27 2024 13:49 utc | 172

Actually, history tells us that nothing is learned when a human civilization is obliterated and only a few people remain. That is what obliteration means. Such obliteration can be due to civilization suicide by nuclear war or from a natural cataclysm such as a meteor or comet impact.
We have enough knowledge today to say that our current human civilization is not the first one, and we also know we have learned nothing from the previous civilization that was obliterated just 13 000 years ago.
Posted by: Norwegian | Aug 27 2024 12:10 utc | 178
Answered here because it fits better in this thread.
I only disagree on a major point. 11kBC was not a full end.
Things went strongly down the drain and several remaining surviving tech was fewer and far between (and regularly destroyed on newer exchanges)
If the last major one was near 4.400 BC that explains why we had to start over right then… And why another one is due before the end of this century.

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 27 2024 13:55 utc | 173

“What amazes me in relation to Tibet is that the CIA asset, the Dalai Lama, and the so-called anti-communists movement in the US have still not given up on this ‘Free Tibet’ crap.
I thought it was clear that these matters were settled long ago in the 20th century and that there could be no such thing as the return of the Lama’s forces or Tibet’s rebellion against the Chinese centre.”
Posted by: Nokaz | Aug 27 2024 11:16 utc | 158
My younger sister joined the Avalokiteshvara Kadampa Buddhis sect; she’s been a nun since 1993-she has ben to Taiwan, US, UK and now in Canada working at their ‘temples’..
At first, because it is a cult (she gets room and board plus $500 a month for working full time) for the first few years I tried to get her out but I’ve given up and she seems happy.
But they HATE the Dalia Lama-according to them the Dalai Lama have been slave owners for centuries owning the Tibetan Serfs.
Her cult is heavily financed- the own hundred of millions of real estate in the US, Canada and the UK.
I have the suspicion China has seeded and financed this counter religion to combat the Dalai Lama.

Posted by: canuck | Aug 27 2024 14:01 utc | 174

So why do so many leave? Or is it your contention like the expert here Gruff that only charlatans leave?
Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 13:10 utc | 169
I don’t know anybody who left so I cannot venture an opinion on that.
All I am saying, and I have visited about half the Chinese provinces, north, south, east and west, is that there are Buddhist temples everywhere, and mosques too in the moslem regions, so the idea that there is repression of religion is simply absurd.

Posted by: Walt | Aug 27 2024 14:16 utc | 175

Ascetic Buddhist mystics fleeing ”communist oppression” always end up in Hollywood… the purified model of fakery and materialism (the bad definition that many people mistakenly assume Marx was a proponent of).
They leave China because tending to the emotional needs of wealthy messed up westerners with displaced anxieties is a profitable gig.

Posted by: William Gruff | Aug 27 2024 14:18 utc | 176

Posted by: Norwegian | Aug 27 2024 12:10 utc | 178
I agree with Norwegian. Humans never learn anything from earlier civilizations. If we did we would have been wiser by now.
The worst prospect is the most likely: The biggest egoes, psychopaths etc are those who will survive.
Posted by: Avtonom | Aug 27 2024 13:30 utc | 190
Once again, here, not ukraine thread
Yes they did, they are the ones who learned the 4.400 BC “DO NOT SEEK HEGEMONY!”

Posted by: Newbie | Aug 27 2024 14:22 utc | 177

Scorpion @167
I have met Tibetans on the mainland, in Taiwan, and in various western cities. You have only met them in the West. Which of us has a more complete set of experiences to form an opinion with?

Posted by: William Gruff | Aug 27 2024 14:35 utc | 178

Scorpion @167
I have met Tibetans on the mainland, in Taiwan, and in various western cities. You have only met them in the West. Which of us has a more complete set of experiences to form an opinion with?

Posted by: William Gruff | Aug 27 2024 14:35 utc | 179

@ Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 27 2024 13:49 utc | 172
I think all reasonable people (including China) agree that Taiwan (like Ukraine) has a right to exist – as a sovereign nation. But being sovereign does not relieve them from the consequences of there actions and from reality – if they invite a threatening entity into their sovereign nation then they become a threat – and they will be dealt with as a threat. One way to deal with a threat is to eliminate it – which might mean to engage and take control of it. On the other hand, it is unpleasant business to take control of a nation of X millions of people who are accustomed to autonomy – I think China’s thinking is that given time they will see that it is not in their interest to position themselves as a threat to China and that does not require that they become a vassal to China. It seems to me that many people who study history and politics try to impose their conventional logic on all situations – leaning toward repeating old mistakes.
When it matters. No one (that matters) cares what the UN has to say about it. Any country that tries to hide behind the UN ends up a smolder ruin. That is my impression.
I learned a lot from your post, Thank you. Now I am the master.

Posted by: jared | Aug 27 2024 14:43 utc | 180

Posted by: canuck | Aug 27 2024 14:01 utc | 174
The Chinese government is assisting another cult as a counterbalance to its own dissident cult that has fled to the Western side.
It seems likely, but I have no relevant knowledge to judge.
However, mention something that I recall in relation to your story.
I consider myself to have grown up on so-called ‘progressive’ liberal soil with little religious mood.
In the past, Tibetan serfdom did not have a good reputation among such progressives also.
In short, from the perspective of ‘history progress’, Liberals do not agree unanimously with the CCP’s conquest of Tibet, but the ‘historical view’ that serfdom have ended by the Communist Party was shared to a certain extent by left-leaning magazines.

Posted by: Nokaz | Aug 27 2024 14:48 utc | 181

https://consortiumnews.com/2024/08/27/john-kiriakou-the-slide-into-authoritarianism/
A very noticeable increase in the harassment of high-profile dissenters in the Five Eyes. Most people, US citizens I mean, have no idea what is happening. Hell, they don’t even know who these people are (Kiriakou, Ritter, Medhurst, Murray, Hedges, etc.). Things will not be changed at the ballot box.

Posted by: KMRIA | Aug 27 2024 15:17 utc | 182

Lhasa – Tibet’s Most Famous City
She drove me all over Tibet with its SERIOUSLY not suffering inahabitants. I mean, maybe they miss their Dalai Lama and maybe they don’t really miss him at all. Same as with the Uyghurs. Still Tibet through and through, only now they have things like plumbing and electricity and businesses serving tourism… not to mention fewer yaks and humans being eaten by snow leopards now that they live in houses with pastures instead of living in yurts days’ journeys from settlements.
I mean, yes, still some, but they’ve got ATVs and snowmobiles.
(Link)

Posted by: john | Aug 27 2024 15:21 utc | 183

“that nearly all major Tibetan Buddhist lineages left Tibet and have not to this day returned”
@ 154. Scorpion

This statement skews reality.
My teacher was born in Tibet in 1946, in the village of Tsari. Because of the political situation, the turmoil, he and his family left for India in 1959 where he began his studies, eventually becoming one of the first students in 1967 to enter a nine-year study course at the Central Institute of Higher Tibetan Studies in Varanasi, India. This included studying Madhyamika, Abhidharma, Vinaya, the Abhisamayalankara, the Uttaratantra, as well as history, logic, and Tibetan grammar. Khenchen Rinpoche took full monastic ordination from Kalu Rinpoche. He received teachings from the 16th Gyalwa Karmapa on The Eight Treasures of Mahamudra Songs, by the Indian mahasiddhas…
“In 1985, Khenchen Rinpoche traveled to the main seat of the Drikung Kagyu lineage, Drikung Thel, in Tibet. There, he was able to receive personal blessings, as well as instructions and transmissions of Mahamudra and the Six Yogas of Naropa, from the enlightened master Venerable Pachung Rinpoche…”
This is the main monastery of the Drikung Kagyu lineage, founded in 1179. Its history includes attacks by Mongols from which it survived. Its focus stresses practice, retreat snd meditation, in contrast to the Gelug sect, for example, which stresses scholarship.

“Drigung Thil Monastery was founded in 1179 by Jigten Sumgön (1143–1217), the founder of the Drikung Kagyu tradition. The order is one of the eight minor Dagpo Kagyu lineages derived from disciples of Phagmo Drupa Dorje Gyalpo (1110–70), who was in turn a disciple of Gampopa.[7] The monastery was located beside a hermitage erected in 1167 by Minyak Gomring, an illiterate ascetic pupil of Phagmodrupa. The population has fluctuated over the years….
“In 1240 the Mongol armies under Dorta Nagpo (Dorta the Black) sacked Gyel Lhakhang Monastery and Reting Monastery, then turned on Drigung. The monks managed to defend the monastery and prevent its destruction.[8] In 1290, in order to destroy the political influence of Drigung, a Mongol army under the Sakya general Aklen destroyed the monastery. The 9th lineage holder, Chunyi Dorje Rinchen (1278-1314) rebuilt the monastery with the help of the Sakya and the Emperor. The role of the monastery was now mainly limited to being a center for contemplative studies and serving as the home of the Drigung Kargyupa subsect. The monastery had regained some of its strength by the mid-14th century, but after the 15th century was eclipsed by the rise of the Gelug sect [Dalai Lama sect]. Throughout the Ming dynasty (1368-1644) the monastery played an important role in Sino-Tibetan relations….
“In 1959 there were about four hundred monks, sixty people in meditation retreats and eight Incarnate Lamas. Before and during the Cultural Revolution (1966–76) the monastery was looted of almost all its collection of statues, stupas, thangkas, manuscripts and other objects apart from a few small statues that the monks managed to hide. The buildings were severely damaged. Reconstruction began in 1983 and seven of the fifteen temples were rebuilt….
“As of 2015 Drigung Thil Monastery was occupied by about 250 monks. Although well known, particularly for its sky burial site, it does not attract many tourists, especially since the monks moved to close sky burials to uninvited guests.”

Milarepa is of this lineage, master of realization. He ate nettles while in retreat, turning green in skin hue, or so the story goes.
Diverse Tibetan religious practices have survived and thrive there today.

Posted by: suzan | Aug 27 2024 15:21 utc | 184

“BOTH SIDES BAD, COMMIES BAD, BOUGIES BAD, REJECT MATERIALISM, RETURN TO MONKE”, as if criticizing all sides is the sole marker for intelligence and independent thinking.
Posted by: All Under Heaven | Aug 26 2024 21:27 utc | 127
—————–
US foreign policies is the Tonya Harding culture writ large
Cant compete with China, ?
Solution ..kneecap Chinese economy , by tariff, decoupling, terrorism, proxy wars, biowarfare.
Since US reputation is irredeemable, lets drag China thru the mud as well !
The Rule for Respectable Commentary
Major Adversaries: Never better than the US
US (and the rest of West): Never worse than the Major Adversaries

https://www.antiwar.com/blog/2014/10/15/john-v-walsh-the-rule-for-respectable-commentary/

Posted by: denk | Aug 27 2024 15:43 utc | 185

tHE poop

China is a totalitarian nightmare
China is anti religion
Lets stand up for TW
lETS stand up for Tibet
China is a bully in SCS
cHIna bullies TW
Fuck wuflu../…

Now Why do I feel like there’s an empire mouthpiece in our midst ?
If its squacks like a duck….

Posted by: denk | Aug 27 2024 15:46 utc | 186

quacks like a duck…
———–
poop

Im not anti Chinese,
Im not sinophopic

Great men think alike…..

Winston Churchill

I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion. The famine was their own fault for breeding like rabbits.” –

Our esteemed prof is more subtle
poop

Personally, I want to trust the PRC but cannot: I think they are too huge for comfort, like ants or something.

[Signatory poop weasel words,
Always a disclaimer, then comes the but…..,

Posted by: denk | Aug 27 2024 16:00 utc | 187

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 26 2024 21:26 utc | 126
Not only does Trump risk his life by further campaigning, as you rightly pointed out. He will also not be able to trust all of his security guards after becoming president – the folks who want him gone have their connections everywhere. This prospect has probably diminished his determination to win – many observers are disappointed with his recent campaigning, some are asking if he wants to lose – which could well be the case, triggered by his survival instincts.
Reaching out to other people – Elon Musk, RFK junior, Tulsi Gabbard – is a good idea and good news, but it cannot fully restore the trust that the assassination attempt has shattered.

Posted by: grunzt | Aug 27 2024 16:10 utc | 188

[quoting PAUL CRAIG ROBERT]
More on the mass immigration initiative, this directly tying together Jewish groups with the CCP and DOJ.
Posted by: Scorpion | Feb 7 2024 21:20 utc | 165
———————
OMFG
A Han/Jew/DOJ conspiracy to take over the west, starting with North America !
The poop is really full of it.
This, after his Mike Adams bombshell was obliterated by barflies less than a week ago !

Posted by: denk | Aug 27 2024 16:18 utc | 189

So why do so many leave? Or is it your contention like the expert here Gruff that only charlatans leave?
Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 13:10 utc | 169
_______
History and the Law of Averages teach that it’s useful to assume that any religious leader is a charlatan (I prefer “predatory fraudster” myself) until proven otherwise. That’s certainly true in the West, and what I’ve seen of both Mahayana and Theravada Buddhism suggests that the East is no different, no matter how “esoteric” the “spirituality” practiced or (more usually) claimed by those leaders.
Nor am I particularly bothered by any state “interference” on the part of China in the appointment of Buddhist leaders. That too has a long tradition in the West; in fact, there are still countries in which the state plats a role (however much that role has devolved into mere formality) in nominating Roman Catholic bishops.

Posted by: malenkov | Aug 27 2024 16:20 utc | 190

Scorpion@133 ignores my already stated point that the right to self-determination must include the right to national unity. Nationality is not determined by a local vote. Historically such votes are usually local pluralities, not even majorities. Nationality overlaps with language, nobody chooses their native language. Nationality overlaps with religion, nobody chooses the religion they are raised with, and even those who consciously choose otherwise later in life think in ways powerfully affected by their formative years. (That’s why cults are so intent on indoctrination, to counteract that.) Nationality overlaps with social and economic life, which is not chosen by individuals voting. Nationality overlaps with geography and that’s determined by effective distance, local topography and a long history of wars. It took two wars to ensure Anglophone Canada would not to be part of the US…and the political incorporation of Francophone Quebec has left permanent issues in Canadian “nationalism” and a permanent secessionist movement.
Dividing an existing nationality generally requires war, as colin noted in referring to a hypothetical Long Island independence. Vermont was once part of New York, but despite vigorous disputes, when it separated, it stayed part of the same nation, it did not reaffirm loyalty to Britain as another Canadian province. When Texas revolted against the Mexican dictator Santa Anna (who was facing other revolts at the same time,) it was because people of a different nationality had taken a local plurality. The Texas rebellion ultimately resulted in the conquest of a huge part of Mexico by the US, the state of the American nationals who had achieved a local plurality in Texas. (The Mexican government had allowed mass immigration because it had difficulties populating the northern states of Mexico.) That was most decidedly a violation of sovereignty. The preceding absorption of the Texas Republic was not a violation of Texan sovereignty precisely because, “Texans” were Americans. The people of Taiwan are mostly Chinese. Now it is possible for a group to collectively decide to learn a new language and take some other nationality’s land. The example is Israel…and it was a gross violation of Palestinian national right to self-determination, which includes the right to Palestinian unity.
What happens when no single nationality has a genuine majority cannot be decided by a single principle. The general human and humane objection to war, the tried and true method of making a new national state, holds great weight. The feasibility of a multi-national state as a democratic substitute does exist. But such a state demands that no local plurality can monopolize power, that is, cannot simply vote itself into a new state. That’s a declaration of war. The notorious Velvet Divorce between the Czechs and Slovaks hinged so far as I can tell on the tacit agreement that the new bourgeoisie would limit their expropriation of public property in their national areas…but being Czech or Slovak was not voted on.

Posted by: steven t johnson | Aug 27 2024 16:22 utc | 191

ZH has a posting up about the coming BRICS+ meeting about finance with the title
De-Dollarization & Multipolarity Plans Top Agenda For October BRICS Summit: Report
the quote

The BRICS currency will be a notional currency and not a currency in physical form. The issue is how does one peg the value for it. Naturally, the value will derive from the value of all the currencies in the basket put together. Notionally, one gets the impression that yuan is a dominant currency. So, it will have a greater weightage. India has to see whether that will be acceptable to it.”

It is not just the initial peg to each other but the ongoing management of the changes of each countries currency to the peg that is the nut to crack.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Aug 27 2024 16:24 utc | 192

Fact is that if China walked the sovereignty talk they are preaching with their ally Putin they would recognize Taiwan as a sovereign, independent neighbor and move on. But they do not, moreover they bully other nations not to recognize the ROC, not to have ambassadors, not to put them on maps, not to make financial arrangements. In short, they act like regional hegemons (don’t forget Tibet decades ago and up until the present) and therefore total hypocrites when they lecture the US.
Posted by: Scorpion | Jul 23 2022 20:17 utc | 217
————–
What’d the anglo do if…
China rooted for Texas independence, North Ireland independence, Quebec independence ?
Turn the other cheek ?

Posted by: denk | Aug 27 2024 16:44 utc | 193

So why do so many leave?
posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 13:10 utc | 169
—————————-
Hey prof
I schooled you on that remember ?

Nepalese soil has been utilizes by the Tibetans to traffic innocent Tibetans from Tibet to India and also Western countries. Officials assigned by the Dalai Lama stationed in Kathmandu are trafficking the Tibetans to Nepal by promising them that they will send them to the United States and European countries. They have also be promised that they will earn huge amounts of money. Some western countries have supported this project with the intention of defaming China on human rights violation

……………..
https://tinyurl.com/yvujbtkk

Posted by: denk | Aug 27 2024 17:08 utc | 194

test

Posted by: denk | Aug 27 2024 17:10 utc | 195

@ denk | Aug 27 2024 16:44 utc | 193
(third try . . .)
Even better if countries like China, Russia, and (yes!) Venezuela started demanding that the USA start treating its “Indian Nations” — reservations, that is — like actual nations, or at least insist that the USA start honoring the hundreds of broken treaties with them.

Posted by: malenkov | Aug 27 2024 17:13 utc | 196

Posted by: malenkov | Aug 27 2024 17:13 utc | 195
—————
FUKUS gave UN the finger !
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/may/04/us-stolen-land-indian-tribes-un

Posted by: denk | Aug 27 2024 17:19 utc | 197

Posted by: suzan | Aug 27 2024 15:21 utc | 184
Thank you for the only well informed post about this on the thread. With all due respect to Walt, seeing temples going up does not tell you what happens within them. If you study Chinese medicine, for example, although there are still a few Medical Qigong degrees on offer, most have closed down. And if you study acupuncture, 9/10 schools offer ‘TCM’ which is a modernized, desacralized version of the tradition, not the original approach.
It is probably the same with the temples, though I have no knowledge of this.
Are some of the teachers who leave charlatan types? No doubt. But most are not. Perhaps it varies from region to region or institution to institution; perhaps in one town everything is fine but in another town the authorities are hostile. I don’t know.
And from your post, suzan, sounds similar: surely you are aware of some of the older monasteries in Tibet where they don’t have the unbroken situation you are describing and/or where the high lamas cannot return lest they be overly controlled? Like with all things in life, although we love to generalize and say ‘the notion of religious persecution by the Chinese is absurd’ or ‘all who leave are charlatans’ or ‘all Buddhists are in a cult’ or whatever, the reality is that there are many layers and levels in the mix. There are good cults and bad cults (vajrayana, both Hindu and Buddhist, is by definition always a cult), good relations with officials and bad, also probably these things vary by region and decade. The point being that generalizations are generally not all that helpful.
This came up in part because I raised the question: if the CCP takes over Taiwan as most here desire, what happens to all the traditional Daoists and Buddhists there? Because many of them are there because they didn’t want to stay in communist China.
Anyway, thank you for your thorough post and I am glad to know that your teacher’s lineage has survived in Tibet proper. I am aware of several such situations though again not all have that happy ending. That said, I have been out of things since the 90’s and quite possibly there has been a sea-change in Tibet am not aware of. If so – and this is just a guess – they have eradicated the old aristocracy, much of which was quite corrupt both outside and inside the monastic institutional mandalas, such that they can have Buddhism back in the culture again provided it no longer enjoys political influence. And since most authentic Buddhist practitioners couldn’t give a toss about political power, possibly after half a century of turmoil, they have come to a working arrangement. If that is what has happened, that is good news indeed, and maybe the places that got burned down or depopulated can once again revive.
FYI, I have many reservations about the tulku / high lama system regarding it as both anachronistic and corruption-breeding. But I also cannot ignore that from a relatively tiny population in the diaspora in India etc. there are a high number of truly advanced living bodhisattvas which is testament to the efficacy and authenticity of their lineages, making the accusation that they are all charlatans truly absurd.
Last little point: I meant to say about the 4 schools that most of the top leadership of the four schools fled communist Tibet. I don’t know the percentages but I suspect a higher percent of senior Nyingma and Kagyus left than Sakya and Gelug (the Dalai Lama school). My teacher came from Kham, the Surmang monasteries, and much of their institutional viability was scrubbed for a while. What has happened the past twenty years I haven’t kept up with. His teacher Khenpo Gangshar stayed to work with the Chinese who in turn jailed him and he died behind bars after three years. He was an unarmed religious teacher without a penny to his name who wanted to welcome the Chinese. I don’t think he was well treated. And I don’t find all the protestations that China is a paragon of tolerance when dealing with religions persuasive.
Thanks again for your post which balanced this part of the conversation nicely.

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 17:31 utc | 198

Posted by: psychohistorian | Aug 27 2024 16:24 utc | 192
The issue is how does one peg the value for the BRICS currency. Naturally, the value will derive from the value of all the currencies in the basket put together.
<=Are the basket currencies to exclusively be those currencies that are tied to the value of USD? Several nations value their currencies by reference to the USD? Or will there be other currencies in the basket; if all of the currencies in the basket are valued by reference to the USD what would be the outcome? Valuing currency without reference to gold may affect the price of gold negatively.. ? thanks for the info.. could not find the article on ZH..

Posted by: snake | Aug 27 2024 17:32 utc | 199

Posted by: William Gruff | Aug 27 2024 14:35 utc | 179
Scorpion @167
I have met Tibetans on the mainland, in Taiwan, and in various western cities. You have only met them in the West. Which of us has a more complete set of experiences to form an opinion with?

@Gruff: you need to brush up on reading and comprehension. I said several times that I spent time in India at a few exile communities. And by time I mean I lived over there for more than a year, not touristing for a few days.
I understand you feel compelled to prove me wrong, deluded or in bad faith on everything, but in your zeal you are overlooking basic logic. Relax. You believe that all the Buddhist and Daoist practitioners who have left China and Tibet are charlatans. So be it. We can agree to disagree.
Just curious: of the many Tibetans you have met world wide, how many are esoteric practitioners and high lamas?

Posted by: Scorpion | Aug 27 2024 17:48 utc | 200