Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
May 12, 2024
Palestine Open Thread 2024-137

Only for news & views directly related to the war in Palestine.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

I had not seen this posted yet – fyi via RT
Israel claims lowest civilian casualty ratio in history – Blinken agree with numbers
West Jerusalem has released its first estimate for deaths of non-combatants in Gaza, claiming that Hamas figures are “fake”
https://www.swentr.site/news/597605-israel-gaza-civilian-death-estimate/
Israel has provided an estimate of the civilian death toll in Gaza for the first time since its war with Hamas began in October, claiming that its forces are “setting the new gold standard” for minimizing harm to non-combatants in an urban conflict.
Speaking in an online video statement on Monday, Israeli government spokesman Avi Hyman pegged the war deaths in Gaza at over 14,000 “terrorists” and around 16,000 civilians. Local health authorities in the Hamas-governed Palestinian enclave have reported more than 35,000 deaths, claiming that most of the deceased were women and children.
Hyman scolded media outlets and the United Nations for reporting Hamas casualty claims as fact, saying Israel had been condemned globally based on “fake and fabricated” numbers. Now that the Israeli government has released its statement, he added, “we would expect everyone to now take these figures as a genuine estimate from a free democratic country that fights in strict accordance with the laws of armed conflict in one of the most challenging urban warfare scenarios in history.”
The spokesman said Israel views every civilian casualty as a tragedy. He blamed Hamas for the deaths, accusing the militant group of using non-combatants as human shields. He told Fox News, “In reality, Israel is setting the new gold standard for urban warfare with what appears to be the lowest civilian-to-combatant casualty ratio in history.”
The Israeli statement comes less than one week after Hyman was grilled by podcast host Piers Morgan for having “no idea how many civilians you’ve killed.” It also comes after the UN cut its estimate last week for the number of women and children killed in Gaza by nearly half.
The UN revision was driven by a decision to report the figures based on the nearly 25,000 fatalities for which Gaza health officials have complete details, rather than including the more than 10,000 people who are estimated to be “missing or under the rubble.” The UN hasn’t suggested that the Hamas figures were inflated. The World Health Organization said on Tuesday that it sees “nothing wrong” with the figures reported by local health officials.
The casualty breakdown provided by Gaza authorities was about 40% men, 20% women, 32% children, and 8% elderly. Even by the Israeli estimate, over 53% of the deceased in Gaza were civilians.
US Secretary of State Antony Blinken noted on Sunday that Israeli forces had killed more Palestinian civilians than Hamas fighters. He said Washington agrees with the Israeli casualty estimates.
“Israel has processes, procedures, rules and regulations to try to minimize civilian harm,” Blinken said in a CBS News interview. But they “have not been applied consistently and effectively. There’s a gap between the stated intent and some of the results we’ve seen.”

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 15 2024 7:59 utc | 201

Posted by: laguerre | May 13 2024 21:23 utc | 111
Thierry is likely referring to the first time Zionist Officials with British Govt Authority and Approval, as well as British administrators some who were also Zionist Jews and part of the Zionist Movement long term, OFFICIALLY set foot in Palestine in mid-1922 to take control.
That’s one century plus 2 years … that is when the rot truly set in on the ground in Palestine. Most decent historical sources confirm these events ….. the British finally had League of Nations / WW1 treaties approval to implement their Mandate iow – before that it was still being run by the British Military (IIRC – no guarantees – all other things being equal)

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 15 2024 8:07 utc | 202

…. imperial Britain was committed to a Jewish state at an early stage in the 1WW. It wasn’t, and the Balfour Declaration says the reverse. There were multiple British policies, in obvious contradiction with one another.
Posted by: laguerre | May 15 2024 7:02 utc | 198
YES, I believe you are correct on this point.
imho it more likely that the British were just weak … and multiple sectors in the UK were pushing the various govts in several directions at once, depending on who was in office at the time.
There is no way the Govt intention during or before WW1 was for a Jewish State …… though many individuals were surely pushing for that all the time since the late 1800s.
In the end the British were simply word down and worn out and QUIT.
Fact is the, biggest point against the Brits pushing for a Jewish State was that it was ILLEGAL under international law to create such a thing out of a Mandate jurisdiction …. from before WW1.
The UK was required under international Law to act to bring about a PALESTINE State for all citizens of that territory. They failed to do so. Which is why we are here.
Elsewhere Syria, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, etc were formed into new states.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 15 2024 8:16 utc | 203

I’d like to offer a moral contemplation, a labyrinth if you will Lydia, about your very reasonable lament here (which you answered in truth immediately thereafter):

Thank you sun and juliana, it doesn’t seem any human agency can stop this horror. They don’t neglect the spiritual, neither should we.
Deliver me, O LORD, from the evil man: preserve me from the violent man;
2 Which imagine mischiefs in their heart; continually are they gathered together for war.
3 they have sharpened their tongues like a serpent; adders’ poison is under their lips. Selah.
4 Keep me, O LORD, from the hands of the wicked; preserve me from the violent man; who have purposed to overthrow my goings.
https://www.kingjamesbibleonline.org/Psalms-140-1/
Pray that people will return to the Lord Jesus.
https://anastpaul.com/
Posted by: Lydia Gorbik | May 15 2024 2:17 utc | 192

What if one can boil down the work of the divine as the whisper of conscience and the revelation of the wicked lost amongst us? The next step is our free will to move beyond escapism, apathy, and fear: the sin of sloth. The next step *is* human agency. =)
Look back at the prayer… it can all be answered by the divine’s clarity of discernment followed by human agency. 😉 Awareness in and of itself gives answer, and action shows inner strength to “return to the flock instead of the wilds”, naturally separates the wheat from the chaff. We never needed superman, we needed the teacher, we needed ourselves and each other to do the right thing as best we can.
I think a profound, revealing providence has been at work these past few years. And I believe this is so at levels that reels everyone globally and of differing political yet humanistic persuasions. The next step is us: where do we choose to go? 🙂
The Labyrinth, contemplate how does one be brave, true to ourselves, to stop these ongoing horrors in our power & capacity? Who do we need to reach out to in order to increase our power & capacity? What is our restraint, our guardians, that protect us from the temptations of privilege & immunity?
The mystery is to find our own way to Compassion, Judgment, & Strength to Act so as we may tend our garden. 🙂 Must Another do all the heavy lifting? Was not eyes, heart, mind, voice, and body enough gift to leave imprint upon this borrowed Earth? Maybe we can, if we try, but we can only know if we try.

Posted by: titmouse | May 15 2024 8:36 utc | 204

And PS on Thierry ref article …
“On this basis, (CROMWELL) established a Puritan regime, lifted the 1656 ban against Jews settling in England and announced that his country was committed to create the State of Israel in Palestine [4].”
https://www.voltairenet.org/article184973.html
His ref goes to his own book, you need to buy in order to find out wtf he is talking about “new info”
Sorry this is bollocks …. Cromwell has nothing to do with anything (imho). How desperate do people need to be to spin a 460 year old conspiracy theories like this — it is irrelevant to today. and to the creation of Israel as well.
IN the mid-1600s the Dutch were kicking out their Jews yet again … there was a big push to let them back into Britain and bring all their monied wealth with them …. many were/became big players in the East India company as well…. especially diamonds which started a long line of jewish diamond traders jewelers etc etc but that is another story unrelated to UK-Israel as well.
Crazy political, economic and religious shit was the norm all time in Europe for hundreds of years ….
he adds … “The Cromwell sect was in turn overthrown at the end of the “First English Civil War,””
what rubbish … Cromwell sect …how ludicrous LOL

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 15 2024 8:39 utc | 205

In the end the British were simply word down and worn out and QUIT.
Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 15 2024 8:16 utc | 203
No, that was after the second WW. The original British and French idea was to turn the Ottoman territories into colonies of the empire. They were only called ‘mandates’ because of Woodrow Wilson, and even then they didn’t appreciate that Arab opinion wouldn’t stand for British and French colonisation. Independence was forced on the mandatory powers pretty quickly, less than 15 years in the case of Iraq, though effective influence lasted quite a bit longer. but it was already evident that Palestine was going to be different. A Jewish governor was appointed, and Transjordan separated off: it was in the early 1920s that a future of a Jewish state was first recognised by the British. But by 1939 they’d realised it wasn’t going to work. It was the Labour Christian Zionists (chapel-goers) after the war who surrendered Palestine to American decision.

Posted by: laguerre | May 15 2024 8:40 utc | 206

sorry one more ….
“It reappears in the eighteenth century with the “Second English Civil War” (according to UK school history textbooks), which the rest of the world knows as the “War of Independence of the United States” (1775 – 83).”
horseshit – The Second English Civil War took place between February and August 1648 in England and Wales.
aka Cromwell and co as well.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_English_Civil_War
“George Washington, Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin, to name a few, presented themselves as the successors of the exiled supporters of Oliver Cromwell. The United States logically resumed the Zionist project.”
Bullshit! Totally crazy!
Gawd I’m never believing another thing from https://www.voltairenet.org without major other sources confirming it. This is really nutty stuff imho. I used to think he was credible and reasonably reliable and did good historical research … oh well. Live n learn.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 15 2024 8:45 utc | 207

Re: IDF setting the new gold standard” for minimizing harm to non-combatants in an urban conflict.:
1) the mass graves with women and children being buried alive after having their organs harvested might beg to differ
2) the IDF AI killing algorithm calculates a 99% civilian kill ratio for 1 Al-Qassem Major is worth it. The algorithm also calculates for lower ranked Al-Qassem that a 95% civilian kill ratio for 1 Al-Qassem low ranked fighter is worth it.
3) the Likud considers Gaza postmen, kindergarten teachers, nurses, and the like as ‘Hamas Terrorists’
4) The ICJ already decided that the Likud was engaged in a plausible genocide.
Who you going to believe the Likud or your own lieing eyes ?

Posted by: Exile | May 15 2024 8:53 utc | 208

Well done Georgia for passing the Foreign Agents Bill, Western governments are captured by foreign agents and that’s part of why the genocide in Gaza is well under way.

Posted by: Republicofscotland | May 15 2024 10:59 utc | 209

laguerre 198
Thierry Myessan has an allergy to religion of any sort, which enables him to conflate Cromwell with US Christian Zionism.
Halfway through the USUKIS proxy war against Islam he talked with some Jihadists and discovered their
sincerity. Unfortunately the sincerity of some is the political cover for the likes of Brett MuckDurt their US commanding officer.
Asia is controlled by tribes, not Western style ideologies. The Iraqi Ashshari tribes supported Barzani’s, Mossad- controlled “””””””””” Democratic””””””””” Party in its slaughter and rape of the Yazidis.
Deeply entrenched , extremely right wing, Fascists of a feather, with Nutjob and Jellybaby.
What have Biden and Sunak got in common with Zionist Nazism? Grift.
To live in Asia you have to use your head, not your emotions, because a tribe represents Grift. The Jews think that their alliance with USUK politics makes public opinion irrelevant and they can do what they like.
But Islam says that all respect is with Allah. Thierry Myessan disrespects religious, tribal and political grift, and he is not unaware of or unconscious of the vast respect that Allah confers on people of faith. Oliver Cromell was a man of faith. Netanyahu is not. He is a man of Khazarian , Ukrainian, Nazi , Grift.

Posted by: Giyane | May 15 2024 12:16 utc | 210

210
Oliver Cromwell by executing the king did what Hamas and Iran have done to the zionists, viz punctured their aura of invincibility.
Yes, he pursued his hatred of Papal ignorance against the innocent Irish, but Britain had been under the Viking thugs of Rome since 1066 and Irish Catholics wrongly became the scapegoats for Papal oppression.
If I may ask one question. Who will get blamed for the USUKIS forced genocide of Palestine in years to come? Christian Zionists?, grift
politicians or Jews?
The Jews were misled by the nationalist dog whistles of corrupt politicians. The grift politicians were led by grift. It is the Christian Zionists who are
the hypocrites because they never bothered to read their own Gospels.
God nor man forgive hypocrites.

Posted by: Giyane | May 15 2024 12:53 utc | 211

Oliver Cromell was a man of faith. Netanyahu is not. He is a man of Khazarian , Ukrainian, Nazi , Grift.
Posted by: Giyane | May 15 2024 12:16 utc | 210
Not really, Cromwell was your everyday toxic Puritan psychopath, utterly delusional and murderous vile creature bring genocide and death wherever he went. His peers traveled to the Americas at the same time circa 1620 taking their toxic psychopathy with them and proceeded to inflict genocide and vile slavery upon the peoples there for hundreds of years until eventually they began exporting it to the world the Puritans a long distant fading memory.
Cromwell was vile narcissistic human being . With delusions of grandeur he was being led by god when in fact it was the Jinns and his own demented bigoted self-righteous cruel ego. No better than a netanyahu and the rest.
How’s that sound? Better? Maybe not but I think a sight more accurate description of what went down.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 15 2024 13:53 utc | 212

“Who you going to believe the Likud or your own lying eyes ?
Posted by: Exile | May 15 2024 8:53 utc | 208
“You can’t hide your lyin’ eyes
And your PR is a cheap disguise
I thought by now you’d realize,
There ain’t no way to hide your lyin eyes..”

Posted by: canuck | May 15 2024 14:04 utc | 213

“Fact is the, biggest point against the Brits pushing for a Jewish State was that it was ILLEGAL under international law to create such a thing out of a Mandate jurisdiction …. from before WW1.
The UK was required under international Law to act to bring about a PALESTINE State for all citizens of that territory. They failed to do so. Which is why we are here.
Elsewhere Syria, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, etc were formed into new states.”
Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 15 2024 8:16 utc | 203
You all are missing the most importance piece in the ME turning into a quagmire in the last century.
For 1200 or so years the levant was ruled by the Muslims/Ottomans with some interruptions -ie the Crusades.
When General Allenby and Lawrence of Arabia conquered the Levant in 1916-17 the dynamic changed radically.
There was no concerted plan to Zionize the Levant by the big powers (at the time UK/France Sykes/Picot 1917 treaty)they were caught with their pants down with crafty Zionist leaders taking advantage of the power vacuum created by the UK/French conquest..

Posted by: canuck | May 15 2024 14:13 utc | 214

Lavrov’s Dog 212
I don’t mind my heroes being branded as psychopaths . I was being carefully groomed by a Kurdish psychopath for joining Islamic State for a while, and , as you do if you’re a normal psychopath, he’s been gaslighting me ever since for mothering him a buck or two.
It teaches trust in God Alone to find that even your local Muslim community wants to sell you. If I was a Palestinian and the local Muslim-not tribal mafia were skimming the charity being sent to me and helping Netanyahu’s Israeli arms deals to Bosnia for the odd million or two, I would support Hamas to the full.
Judge not, lest we be judged. We’d probably be doing the same given the same circumstances.
But Cromwell trashed the British Royal dynasty, whatever other terrible things he might have done as well. I am.hoping that Respect Party George Galloway is going to kick the starus quo. Go on , tell me he’s a racist ego-path too.

Posted by: Giyane | May 15 2024 14:39 utc | 215

Mothering?! Not earning him a buckor two. Lol

Posted by: Giyane | May 15 2024 14:45 utc | 216

canuck 214
It’s a bit of a broad brush to call the Ottomans : Muslim . A bit like calling Ukrainian, Khazar, Revisionist Zionist Nazis : Jews.

Posted by: Giyane | May 15 2024 14:51 utc | 217

I would like to bring attention to a noticeably absent point in the Palestinian discussions and that is the role of the Saudis in all this. I have heard significant gripping about Erdogan and Turkey’s lack of action over Palestine. Now that Turkey, is sacrificing its substantial trade with Israel, I hope that meme is wanning. My is was that this is a diversion to obfoscate the real culprit who is responsible for the collapse of Arab support – MbS and the Saudis. MBs is doing this because he depends on the US and Israel to maintain his vice grip on power. A people’s uprising such as a Palastian revolution is exactly the type of treat this monarch fears the most. The Saudis hide their corruption by fund a massive PR and influence peddling operation in the West. For better or worse, Erdogan works in a Democratic system whose election results seen as valid, even by its critics. Erdogan and Hamas are affiliated with the Muslim Brotherhood which has more of a People oriented mission, a grave threat to the Monarchs. Thus this isn’t a collapse of Muslim support for the resistance, but a revolution that is a threat to the Arab monarchs that have been installed by the British and ruled over the Arabs during the last century.

Posted by: Turk 152 | May 15 2024 15:31 utc | 218

“Hyman scolded media outlets and the United Nations for reporting Hamas casualty claims as fact, saying Israel had been condemned globally based on “fake and fabricated” numbers. Now that the Israeli government has released its statement, he added, “we would expect everyone to now take these figures as a genuine estimate from a free democratic country that fights in strict accordance with the laws of armed conflict in one of the most challenging urban warfare scenarios in history.”
Trust me goyim, I’m not lying to you THIS time!
Pathetic.

Posted by: Archetypex | May 15 2024 16:39 utc | 219

That is the first psalm, sunof27. I think I can recite it by heart, let’s see. And I’ve also set it to a melody for myself in the past.
Posted by: juliania | May 15 2024 1:44 utc | 190
Salaam juliania. Yes it is. One of my favorite Psalms. And I too sing along with it, definitely 🙂
وَرَبُّكَ أَعْلَمُ بِمَنْ فِي السَّمَاوَاتِ وَالْأَرْضِ ۗ وَلَقَدْ فَضَّلْنَا بَعْضَ النَّبِيِّينَ عَلَىٰ بَعْضٍ ۖ وَآتَيْنَا دَاوُودَ زَبُورًا
Your Lord knows whoever is in the heavens and the earth.
Certainly,
We Graced some prophets over the others
and We Gave David the Psalms. | Al-Israa : 55
& Salaam

Posted by: sunof27 | May 15 2024 18:39 utc | 221

“”George Washington, Thomas Jefferson and Benjamin Franklin, to name a few, presented themselves as the successors of the exiled supporters of Oliver Cromwell. The United States logically resumed the Zionist project.”
Bullshit! Totally crazy!
Gawd I’m never believing another thing from https://www.voltairenet.org without major other sources confirming it. This is really nutty stuff imho. I used to think he was credible and reasonably reliable and did good historical research … oh well. Live n learn.””

@ Lavrov’s Dog | 208
Live n learn, indeed. You need to learn a lot more. Events of the 1640’s and 1650’s are entirely relevant today. Just ask the Irish. Think for yourself about how the founding of the Bank Of England in 1694 must have been prepared long before.
Thierrey Meyssan is very reliable. What clinched his truthfulness for me was back in 2005 or 2006. Former Lebanese Prime Minister Rafic Hariri was murdered in a truck bombing or a missile attack in 2005. If it was a truck bomb, it could have been anyone. If it was a missile it could only have been Israel. The crater was unusually deep and some eyewitnesses thought they heard the whine of an incoming missile. There were no leftover truck pieces at the crime scene, which was odd. Meyssan wrote that the French government wanted to answer that truck/missile question too, so they secretly shipped 20 tons of dirt from the bomb scene to a French army base for testing with high explosives to see if a truck bomb could have caused such a deep crater. Well, Meyssan’s claim was too much for me to believe and I stopped reading voltairenet.org. But I kept reading mainstream French media and about 4 months later, I read not one, but two different credible reports that indeed the dirt had been taken to a French army base which they both named, and was tested with explosives. Neither story said what the test showed. Wow ! Meyssan was right all along! I hadn’t read much voltairenet before, but I became a regular reader after that, and have never found anything dishonest or “wild claims” at voltairenet.org. Meyssan sometimes goes into the historical depths of how all this came to be. I can’t say he is always right because I haven’t gone into the same depth of detail, but he points his finger in the right direction.
If you read Lyndon Larouche, for example, you will find the same historical effort to understand modern events as consequences of 1400-1700. Larouche calls out the Venetians, but it’s the same nexus in England of 1640-1660. Larouche is someone I initially didn’t respect because the few Larouchies I ran into were chain-smoking crazies. Venice, 1650’s, blah blah – whatever. But Larouche had scholarship and proper historical references which I discovered through Webster Tarpley, a former Larouchie, who was a formidable intellect before he lost his mind and became a Hillary Clinton supporter. Tarpley too, had hard-core historical foundations for things you would not otherwise believe. Even Michel Foucault, the gay leather darling of the Left, in his early book “The Order Of Things” (which in the early 1970’s I thought was a big deal), wrote that the few years around 1650 AD saw a major shift in peoples’ understanding of the world.
History has some strange perspectives. Too far back and we don’t have much data. Too recent, such as what the French call “Contemporary History” and it’s still so important to today’s realities, that it’s mostly stuffed with crap by lying spin-masters. Anther oddity about History is that there is often far more written material than you might expect. There’s plenty about the 1400-1700 era, enough to form well-grounded conclusions. But you have to have the patience to sift through a lot of books, and a sense for truth and relevance so you don’t get lost.

Posted by: JessDTruth | May 15 2024 23:42 utc | 222

Posted by: JessDTruth | May 15 2024 23:42 utc | 223
Thank you for the serious and informative response. I appreciate the effort you made and helpful tone.
Yes, I agree with you in that determining an accurate (useful) history is both complex and hard work.
My bottom line, I guess, is that no one person’s interpretation or personal history research is perfect. I am not inexperienced in conflicting history and intentional distortions, I trust my own instincts given what I see and know (about how people think and operate) and not upon only the technical research aspects of is it true or false.
I hear what you’re saying about the importance of 1600s history and how ended up here. Without ships of settlers from Britain the US would (clearly) not be like it is today in many ways. One thing does indeed to another thing in order. Yes. However a Cromwell Cult still active today and why now is like it is in Palestine, sorry, a bridge too far for me. Totally unnecessary to explain todays situation of how we got here. And I have no motivation to look into it further.
Best regards to you, and thanks again.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 16 2024 3:58 utc | 223

psychopaths and Cromwell in the 1600s and
I am.hoping that Respect Party George Galloway is going to kick the starus quo. Go on , tell me he’s a racist ego-path too.
Posted by: Giyane | May 15 2024 14:39 utc | 216
Discussing Galloway and his policies and values seems an eminently more sensible kind of conversation to be having.
Thanks for your commentary and your responses. I am well aware of sincere Muslim beliefs and practices (and psychology) of various kinds and respect them (but will not get into that, or why to is so, as peoples intimate beliefs are personal imo). warm regards.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | May 16 2024 4:27 utc | 224

to turk 152 #219. Yes the Saudis are slippery fucks. Currently partnering with J. Kushner to build “luxury condos” on the site demolished by Nato/Slick Willie in what used to be called Yugoslavia. That is known fact. Announced by Kushner himself. Also rumored is that the Saudis with Horrible Weasel Munchkin (remember Ally finance?) have a partnership to build “luxury condos” on the Gaza beach front recently destroyed by Izzyhell. How convenient that they now have a pier to unload their “security” forces and materials.

Posted by: Formerly Miss Lacy | May 17 2024 18:08 utc | 225