Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
April 9, 2024
Ukraine Open Thread 2024-104

Only for news & views directly related to the war in Ukraine.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

Posted by: UWDude | Apr 10 2024 3:42 utc | 100
“Santería is a religious belief system historically practiced by Yoruba-speaking peoples in present-day Nigeria and Benin; it was transplanted to Cuba in the 19th century through the massive importation of slaves from this region of West Africa. In Santería, the warrior Ṣàngó is an òrìṣà, or Yoruba spiritual being.”
https://latino.si.edu/exhibitions/presente/latino-identity/ceremonial-axe-sango

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 3:58 utc | 101

Kagan’s Latest Bugle for Ruinous Empire
Robert Kagan is deaf to the timeless wisdom of Hamilton, Quincy Adams and Lincoln, envisioning the end of the free world if the U.S. neglects to stand with Ukraine whatever it takes, argues Bruce Fein.
https://consortiumnews.com/2024/04/08/kagans-latest-bugle-for-ruinous-empire/
“Whom the gods would destroy, they have first to listen to Robert Kagan.
Kagan postulates in a profusion of books and articles that Americans are God’s chosen people, that the United States is the indispensable nation, and that the putative cures America has for the infinite ills of the world are superior to the diseases. Fleas are magnified into elephants to justify projecting the military strength of the United States everywhere under the Orwellian banner of anticipatory self-defense, i.e., destroy first, ask whether you killed innocents later.
Kagan’s latest cri de coeur blazed forth in an Opinions Essay in The Washington Post on March 31, “Trump’s anti-Ukraine view dates to the 1930s. Americans rejected it then. Will we now?”(p. A20-21). He absurdly assumes that the national security of the United States will be imperiled unless we provide Ukraine with infinite funds and weapons to defend against Russia’s attack launched in 2022.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | Apr 10 2024 4:02 utc | 102

Postado por: UWDude | 10 de abril de 2024 3:42 UTC | 100
Sorry, barflies. However, I would like to know what macumba has to do with Ukraine?

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 4:05 utc | 103

Sorry, barflies. However, I would like to know what macumba has to do with Ukraine?
Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 4:05 utc | 103
Something about Camus and the french meaning of “l’entranger”?

Posted by: UWDude | Apr 10 2024 4:08 utc | 104

Posted by: UWDude | Apr 10 2024 4:08 utc | 104
Camus’ l’Étranger message may have something to do with SMO in Ukraine. However, I can’t see a link with Santeria.
“L’Étranger” raconte la méchanceté du quotidien, l’ambivalence du soleil, la tendre indifférence du monde et la folie des hommes, sacrifiant sur l’étal de leurs certitudes celui qui, parce qu’il ne sait pas mentir ni pleurer, ne leur ressemble pas.

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 4:22 utc | 105

3. The perpetrators have admitted to a Kiev involvement.
Posted by: HERMIUS | Apr 9 2024 22:01 utc | 61
Buuuuuut they were tooorchereeed!! Cuz Roooosha!!
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Apr 9 2024 22:33 utc | 67
Under what tortures did they flee to the Ukrainian border at a speed of 170 km/h? If you don’t have an answer, you’re a stupid person.

Posted by: Виктор | Apr 10 2024 4:37 utc | 106

https://www.rt.com/news/595671-terrorism-ukraine-western-backers/
mentions Burisma Holdings, Crocus City Hall, public figure assassination, Nord Stream gas pipeline?
https://www.rt.com/russia/595652-hunter-biden-burisma-terrorist-attack/
from the article: linked to corruption, terror attacks, and political assassinations in Ukraine.
https://www.rt.com/russia/591201-us-president-corruption-ukraine/
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Apr 9 2024 21:39 utc | 58
I read something about US sending Iranian weapons that the US had stolen to Ukraine. Assault rifles. a few RPG’s. Using still live bodies armed with assault rifles to stop artillery, glide bombs, drones, tank fire ect…<= have a look here https://www.rt.com/news/595674-ukraine-seized-iranian-weapons/
n April 4 and included “enough materiel” to equip a single Ukrainian brigade with small arms, CENTCOM said in a post on X (formerly Twitter).
“The US government transferred over 5,000 AK-47s, machine guns, sniper rifles, RPG-7s and over 500,000 rounds of 7.62mm ammunition to the Ukrainian armed forces,” it wrote.
corruptive going-ons at the top are surfacing everywhere .
apparently the governed masses must rely on the resources of foreign governments to bring these kind of things to light..

Posted by: snake | Apr 10 2024 4:43 utc | 107

UWDude @ 100, Elder @ 103:
I cannot see the connection between the cult of Santa Muerte on the one hand and on the other hand, the religions brought to the Americas by African slaves, now known by various names like candomble, macumba, umbanda and vodun depending on where they are practised. BroncoBilly @ 96 however pinned down the connection with the Aztec religion and the worship of deities associated with death.
There used to be similar cults in Europe before the arrival of Christianity. Most such cults revolved around the worship of the mother earth goddess as a death goddess. This makes sense, since the earth gives life but life also returns to the earth.
However the invocation of Santa Muerte and Jesus Malverde by drug cartel members, and the abuse of the cult by drug cartel leaders to compel their followers to commit murder and other crimes, look like recent phenomena born in a context of continuing violence and poverty in Mexico and other parts of Latin America.

Posted by: Refinnejenna | Apr 10 2024 5:29 utc | 108

This conflict has reached the (confiscated) small arms vs. glide bombs phase.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Apr 10 2024 5:32 utc | 109

@97 Elder
Entendido.
Muitíssimo obrigado

Posted by: Soviético | Apr 10 2024 6:05 utc | 110

Obrigado também para Paranaense @99.

Posted by: Soviético | Apr 10 2024 6:08 utc | 111

A very insightful read by an Asian expert on NATO.
NATO shows real signs of impending demise
karlof1 – I hope you find time to read it. I think it is up your alley.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Apr 10 2024 6:13 utc | 112

Russia has carefully preserved its fighting capacity almost certainly for this very contingency.
Posted by: Melaleuca | Apr 10 2024 1:58 utc | 93
So Brian (another clickbait “expert” of youtube) thinks Russia “preserved” something intentionally for three years. The smo is the easiest not-war possible, it can’t get any easier or any closer. Yet somehow they failed at all steps after the first successful months. The smo is so good that today most biolabs in Ukr still work and Russia still complains about it. That is proof the smo is the best of the best they can do. If FR or UK or others want to take Odessa they’re free do to so, no Russian soldier is anywhere near, no soldiers are available and a few missiles twice a year on some empty buildings won’t hurt anyone.
What is even more hilarious is that nato ground forces headquarters will be built at the Finland-Russia border ( tass.com/world/1772807 ). What will Shoigu with no real military training do? or Gerasimov who only reads books from 1600s. If you answered “nothing”, that is the correct answer.

Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 6:20 utc | 113

If FR or UK or others want to take Odessa they’re free do to so, no Russian soldier is anywhere near, no soldiers are available and a few missiles twice a year on some empty buildings won’t hurt anyone.
Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 6:20 utc | 113
So why don’t they? Think hard on the reasons why there are no “NATO” ground troops within sight of the Russian SMO.

Posted by: James M. | Apr 10 2024 6:26 utc | 114

Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 6:20 utc | 113
Let me just remind you that Russia is at war with more than 50 countries. Is it still funny to you? Or should Gerasimov run with a pistol to the location of the headquarters, which is still in the fantasies of NATO, which does not know how to make shells for itself?

Posted by: Виктор | Apr 10 2024 6:38 utc | 115

@112
@113
I’m still reading the article. I would like to dedicate the following excerpt to RK:
“I also wouldn’t dignify NATO’s move with the word “pivot.” It is simply inflating itself to do what it is not designed to do, go where it has no business to be. This is part of the hollowing out of any meaning to NATO. It was a Cold War enterprise. After 1991, turning its back on any “peace dividend” from the end of the Cold War, it reinvented itself as the enforcer of unipolar order with the bombing of Serbia. It has since prosecuted wars of aggression in Afghanistan and Libya. Tuning its own enlargement into a sacred principle, it has expanded to the borders of Russia, where it is engaged in a proxy war with a nuclear superpower.”

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 6:55 utc | 116

Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 6:20 utc | 113
If you live in the Baltics or Moldova you are right being so scared of Russia, but if you live anywhere else you can relax, no need to convince yourself of Russia’s inaction.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Apr 10 2024 7:01 utc | 117

@112
@113
And this excerpt:
“Europe doesn’t need to be defended from a vibrant, peaceful China peacefully integrated into the global economy and its home region. Europe needs to grow its trade and investment relationships and profit from the dynamism of East Asia, not show up, waving NATO’s flag as a tin pot colonial adjutant.”

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 7:01 utc | 118

@112, last words of the article:
“NATO is the exact model of everything that ASEAN despises in the way inter-state relations can be organized. It is a throwback to the world of European Great Power competition and imperialism that once enslaved our entire region. NATO is the sordid past. It is antithetical to the future that we envision in a multipolar world, built not on military alliances but on associations and regionalisms that are open to all and based on peaceful win-win cooperation.”

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 7:17 utc | 119

Ukraine denied more air defense systems because most of Nato has run out of SAMP-T, Nasams, Iris-T and Patriot PAC-3 launchers. Most Nato air defenses have been demilitarized in Ukraine.
Quite a wowzer.

#gossip
There were rumors that the partners “denied” Ukraine the supply of new air defense systems. The reason was stated as “out of stock”.
There is currently a shortage of air defense and ammunition in the world.
For Ukraine, this is bad news against the background of the offensive of the Russian Armed Forces in all positions, especially in the Donbass.
Ze_Kartel

Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 7:32 utc | 120

📋🇷🇺🇺🇦⚔️ Two Majors #Report #Summary for the Morning of 10 April 2024; pub. 06:53📍
🎯 The RFAF continued to launch attacks by UAVs and missile weapons on targets in the #Odessa and #Nikolayev regions during the day. Clusters of enemy personnel and their defensive formations in #ChasovYar and #Konstantinovka are being defeated. For purposes in the #Kharkov region, FABs with UMPC are used. A lot of objective control personnel with the defeat of AFU military equipment and depots indicate the placement of military equipment by the enemy in urban areas.
🔹In the #Kherson direction, the enemy is reorganising units of Territorial Defence and Marines. Due to the losses, the surviving Territorial Defence fighters are assigned to the Marines as assault groups. The AFU are firing at civilians. #Kakhovka, Cossack Camps, Novaya Mayachka, #Alyoshki and #Dneprany are under fire. The RFAF hit enemy targets in #Kherson.
🔹On the #Zaporozhye front, the RFAF are attacking enemy positions northwest of #Verbovoye. The enemy is building fortifications in the area of #Orekhov and Malaya Tokmachka, preparing for a long defence. At the same time, they report the arrival of foreign mercs at the site, and AFU attempts to counterattack in #Rabotino, the southern part of which is under the RFAF control, are not ruled out. The AFU sends FPV drones deep behind the frontline due to a network of repeaters, hit civilian cars, and use UAV bombers “Baba Yaga” (hexacopters) at night. Yesterday, the AFU once again attacked the #ZNPP with a drone (the training center of the reactor hall). The Russian Permanent Mission to international organisations in #Vienna sent a note to the IAEA stating that damage to the NPP could lead to a disaster, and the members of the IAEA and the agency’s leadership should condemn #Kiev.
🔹In the #SouthDonetsk (#Ugledar) direction, the RFAF continue to liberate #Novomikhaylovka. The fighting at #Krasnogorovka intensified.
🔹On #ChasovYar, the Russian army is advancing. The enemy plans to detain our troops in the eastern part of the town, behind the Seversky Donets-Donbass Canal line. They are transferring reinforcements from other front sectors to the town. The RFAF are actively using FABs with UMPC, destroying suitable reserves.
🔹At #Belogorovka, the battle continues. In the southern section of the #Seversk sector, the RFAF are conducting reconnaissance by combat.
💥The #Belgorod border area is under Nazi attacks. In the Shebekinsky urban district, three AFU kamikaze drones attacked a bus and a minibus moving along the road. Two civilians were injured. Also, an FPV drone attacked an infrastructure facility in the settlement of #Grafovka in the Krasnoyaruzhsky district, the village of #Tishanka in the Volokonovsky district came under AFU fire 4 aircraft-type UAVs were destroyed over the region.
💥In the #Bryansk region, the shelling of #Klimovo. A woman and a child have been killed. Three civilians were injured. In the #DPR, a teenager born in 2008 was injured by the detonation of a previously dropped AFU ammunition.
🎬 #KrasnyLiman direction – massive strike on enemy positions. Judging by the comments of the frontline soldiers in the video, they were satisfied.

https://t.me/two_majors/22039

Posted by: Down South | Apr 10 2024 8:04 utc | 121

Our source in the General Staff said that the Ukrainian Armed Forces cannot build an adequate defense against the new Russian assault tactics.
In all directions it happens the same way, first 70-90 KABs are dropped on our positions, and then they level the positions with artillery, after which small assault groups come, which calmly enter the scorched positions of the Ukrainian Armed Forces.
The only chance to hold the front is to flood the positions with reservoirs of two or three rushes per day, but this method simply washes away our strength.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/22377

Posted by: Down South | Apr 10 2024 8:06 utc | 122

Our source from the Office of the President reported that Syrsky, before being appointed to the post of Commander-in-Chief, promised Zelensky to prepare a new counter-offensive, and it is for him that a new bill on mobilization will be adopted.
The first operations are expected at Bankova in May in order to return the war in Ukraine to the focus of the election campaign. IN THE USA.
Zelensky said yesterday that Ukraine has developed a plan for a new counter-offensive.
“Yes, we have a counter-offensive plan. Yes, Russia has more people, more weapons. But the united West has modern weapons systems. Therefore, we are counting on receiving certain technologies. And if we continue to increase production, and obtain licenses from our partners” , then it’s not about the number of people. It’s only a matter of the quality of the weapon,” Zelensky noted.
Zaluzhny opposed a new counter-offensive, considering such actions to be suicide for the Armed Forces of Ukraine and Ukraine, which is why his resignation occurred so quickly.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/22379

Posted by: Down South | Apr 10 2024 8:08 utc | 123

Our source at the General Staff said that AZOV refused to go to Chasov Yar to hold the front; the third assault brigade now considers this maneuver pointless. The Commander-in-Chief believes that the brigades cannot choose in which direction to operate, but Syrsky cannot influence the situation, since in Avdeevka the third assault brigade refused to enter the city, and later abandoned the coke plant.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/22380

Posted by: Down South | Apr 10 2024 8:09 utc | 124

Let me just remind you that Russia is at war with more than 50 countries. Is it still funny to you? Or should Gerasimov run with a pistol to the location of the headquarters, which is still in the fantasies of NATO, which does not know how to make shells for itself?
Posted by: Виктор | Apr 10 2024 6:38 utc | 115
Please use the correct wording: smo or NOT-war. And it’s the easiest police action imaginable, at the best location imaginable. Failing by design of general staff, sleeping since 2014 and acting very late and very slow, only when failure is guaranteed. Headquarters or not, the same bases in Poland and Romania will appear in Finland, and Finland also publicly demands nukes.
You very conveniently call it “war” because you want to find reasons for Gerasimov’s failures. There’s war only for Donbass, Crimea and border regions, but there’s nothing they can do about that. And it will only spread, as nato will bring more bases in border countries, eventually nukes, then push them to do what Israel does to everyone there. They’re already Syria, moving to Gaza level.
If you live in the Baltics or Moldova
Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Apr 10 2024 7:01 utc | 117
Looking at your name, you should worry about yourself as guaranteed future cannon fodder.

Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 8:17 utc | 125

Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 9 2024 15:54 utc | 10
.
.
Correct !
Everyone has no idea what Russia is doing in the east of this big, very big country.
Entire cities are emerging from the existing military industrial complexes where previously there was only steppe taiga. Why so far in the East? That’s right, to make Russia uninhabitable with nuclear weapons alone because of its size, ALL of the West’s nuclear weapons are not enough, taking into account that only a part of them will get through and taking into account that China North Korea Iran will be there, by the way, they all already have hypersonic technology, WHO doesn’t have these? Let alone the possibility of intercepting this? Right the West
But as I said, no one mentions this construction activity in the east of Russia, nor does anyone mention Russia itself. This shows that Russia is very much occupied and preparing for a confrontation with the West (NATO).
The military complex ONLY in the East is something that the layman can hardly imagine, self-contained independent of foreign energy and raw materials, entire cities within the exclusion zones, own power plants, steelworks, chemical industries, from bakers to butchers, agricultural areas..
YOU have no idea the size of this country in which the entire USA fits 4 times and where Putin flew from Moscow to New York faster than from Moscow to his dacha in the east of his own country. Start rethinking your idea of it, or don’t discuss something that is beyond your imagination. I saw some of it myself before Putin built cities out of the ground there, but even that was frightening what security there was, what huge areas there were full of tanks etc, and those were only the visible ones, what was happening underground was unimaginable!
Feedback geben
Seitenleisten
Verlauf
Gespeichert
Etwas beitragen

Posted by: ossi | Apr 10 2024 8:24 utc | 126

Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 8:17 utc | 125
Your dreams of the might of NATO are crossed out by one phrase of a European official – “our children will not die for Ukraine.” I don’t feel any fear from NATO, everything is different behind its beautiful facade.

Posted by: Виктор | Apr 10 2024 8:38 utc | 127

No one can foresee a single move on this SMO board! There are surprises and unexpected situations from the beginning!
BUT NOW I AM SURE OF ONE THING: the West did not accept defeat; is not accepting defeat; and will not accept defeat!
I agree with Ossi, @126
“This shows that Russia is very much occupied and preparing for a confrontation with the West (NATO).”

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 8:53 utc | 128

So why don’t they? Think hard on the reasons why there are no “NATO” ground troops within sight of the Russian SMO.
You’re asking a bad checkers playing to understand a masters-level chess game.

Posted by: TJandTheBear | Apr 10 2024 9:07 utc | 129

Nato is merely drip feeding weapons at this point (I mean really important weapons like air defense) to Ukraine. Very indicative of this is Germany running out of Patriot PAC-3 launchers and Raytheon building one per month. Guess who will get the launcher – Ukraine or a paying eurovassal customer?
The Soviet and Nato air defenses of Ukraine have been demilitarized, there’s no more coherent air defense. What exists is sporadic and opportunistic ambush attempts of an aircraft here or there. That is, drag the launcher into a forest and wait for a plane to fly close (indicated by Nato airborne radar somewhere). It’s a joke. Ukraine’s army get bombed to smithereens, Nato simply run out of air defense weapons.
Forget about defending against vast majority of drones and missiles. Any fixed target in Ukraine is now left bare for most strikes to hit. That also means any factory or base Nato attempts to set up.
It’s over. Like Scott Ritter said, Ukraine is fighting with Mike Tyson in his prime, just hunching and hoping for the round to end. The Nato trainer after the 10th round is screaming ‘get back in the arena!’.

Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 9:08 utc | 130

I don’t see why NATO would need a new HQ closer to the Russian borders. They have a perfectly good one in Brussels. Said to be “nuclear proofed” and which cost a cool billion (Euros probably, when they were worth more than today). Aahh, that might be it => “nuclear proofed”. They could be looking into it as an discrete form of bunker for the not-worthies (Typo?; “Note-worthies?), who hang out in those halls of power (or something like that).
****
Re; Chasov Yar (Down South)
What is not mentioned are the increasing numbers of those who just surrender. As a variation on a theme suggests, changing into civilian clothes and just waiting in a village or town until the Russians arrive. “Exchanges” have probably stopped because no one now wants to go back, and be used again as gun fodder.

Posted by: Stonebird | Apr 10 2024 9:11 utc | 131

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 8:53 utc | 128
.
.
True, but it’s less about the defeat itself, it’s about YOU losing face.
And no longer being taken seriously in the rest of the world.
It’s true that hardly any country outside the Western bubble is taking any notice of it, even WITHIN its bubble doubts are being raised, and not just behind closed doors, as in the last 70 years or so.
IT WORKS
To lose face, to sell defeat as a victory, and perhaps to save something (including Ukraine).
It is clear to everyone in the West / USA what would happen if nuclear weapons (even smaller ones) were used, everyone knows that in the USA in particular people are dreaming of limiting nuclear war.
Why do Biden and & always assert WE WERE NOT right? It was the Europeans or it should appear that way to the outside world.
PLEASE no hypersonics on New York or Boston, and anyone who believes that the Americans will sacrifice Boston or New York for Paris, Berlin, or Warsaw or even the Baltic states should keep dreaming
Russia is doing it RIGHT and assuming the WORST of all cases
From around May 20, 2024, around 140,000 NATO soldiers are concentrated along the Belarusian border along the Baltic States along the Polish border with Ukraine, disguised by various maneuver names, and this is not reported in connection with the maneuvers. Russia and China know it, except in the West Bubble the entire world.
And wait with anticipation, the Russians’ breakthrough towards Kiev will be the starting command, one assumes

Posted by: ossi | Apr 10 2024 9:17 utc | 132

Posted by: Stonebird | Apr 10 2024 9:11 utc | 131
.
.
From around May 20, 2024, around 140,000 NATO soldiers are concentrated along the Belarusian border along the Baltic States along the Polish border with Ukraine, disguised by various maneuver names, and this is not reported in connection with the maneuvers. Russia and China know it, except in the West Bubble the entire world.
And wait with anticipation, the Russians’ breakthrough towards Kiev will be the starting command, one assumes
.
.
Explanation enough why headquarters near the Russian border?

Posted by: ossi | Apr 10 2024 9:20 utc | 133

unimperator | Apr 10 2024 9:08 utc | 130
The Russians are getting “creative”; The successful use of a T72 danaged tank disguied as a “Shed” as an anti-mine vehicle; or the use of troops on motorbikes supported by artillery (to keep heads down), to take a strong point. (also successfully); and the use of various forms of robot “vehicles” to see which work the best, (Some do, some don’t).
*
The bombing of a diesel train ON a bridge, showing praiseworthy thrift in the use of ammunition (Two for the price of one).
*
As I think Reisner said, the Russians are “playing” with the Ukrainians. The “resistance” in Ukraine is also showing signs of efficiency.
*
It must only be a question of time before the Ukrainian population itself decides to stop the SMO/war by getting rid of Zelensky and his henchmen. At that point even Odessa will be part of any peace settlement, whatever NATO and the US/EU want.

Posted by: Stonebird | Apr 10 2024 9:27 utc | 134

At least some of the information is available to everyone.
When, where, which maneuver, which troops will be moved to the Russian-Belarusian-Ukrainian borders by when.
In addition, the troop contingents that are NOT reported in advance
According to the analysis, as of around May 20, 2024, around 140,000 troops are stationed in such a way that they can intervene WHEN?
Breakthrough of the Russians’ offensive announced by the West, or breakthrough of the Russians towards Odessa, where, by the way, the troops from France were sent from ODESSA.
So what is Putin preparing for, escalation, war?
WHAT are they NOT telling us, why are we not finding out about such a concentration of troops in the media and with descriptions like Battalion Germany in the Baltics, and other fairy tales about maneuvers ALL of which have a common date, mid-May 2024

Posted by: ossi | Apr 10 2024 9:31 utc | 135

ossi | Apr 10 2024 9:20 utc | 133
Being cynical, I would assume that they need to send out boy scouts with handwritten letters or pigeons (as in WWI and the Boer War) to anticipate interrupted communications.
***
Do they need to be closer – looking at that lot, I would more or less expect them to move further away for safety?

Posted by: Stonebird | Apr 10 2024 9:32 utc | 136

At this time, Russia launches the historic Angara-5 rocket. Countdown. Watch live:
https://vk.com/video-211380376_456243268
Or
https://latamnews.lat/20240410/rusia-lanza-el-cohete-angara-a5-desde-el-cosmodromo-de-vostochni-1149622699.html

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 9:33 utc | 137

NATO seems to be planning the same mistaken procedure for sending troops as for sending equipment, one step at a time to make the Russian army’s task easier. The solution they should have considered from the outset was to attack head-on, all together, but they are deceitful and will lose…
Похоже, что НАТО планирует такую же ошибочную процедуру отправки войск, как и отправки техники, шаг за шагом, чтобы облегчить задачу российской армии. Решение, которое им следовало бы рассмотреть с самого начала, – это атаковать в лоб, всем вместе, но они обманывают и проиграют…

Posted by: OLIVIER | Apr 10 2024 9:34 utc | 138

Posted by: karlof1 | Apr 9 2024 20:14 utc | 46
At least he agrees that the war is taking place in Russia.
Posted by: Andrew Sarchus | Apr 9 2024 20:50 utc | 54
Like the would-be profiteers of Genie Energy, patrons of a global brothel.

Posted by: anon | Apr 10 2024 9:35 utc | 139

ossi | Apr 10 2024 9:31 utc | 135
One thing to note are the increased use of Spy planes around Kalingrad, Estonia (etc) and circling back down to the Belarussian border. Possible future use of drones?

Posted by: Stonebird | Apr 10 2024 9:38 utc | 140

Posted by: OLIVIER | Apr 10 2024 9:34 utc | 138
The lack of air defense weapons from Nato enables Russia to destroy AFU much more.
Later, when Nato might have some more weapons, it won’t matter merely as much because there’s no more ‘grunts’. So Nato drip-feeding, occurring from forced conditions rather than choice, actually help Russia and tip the scale balance for good.
Also, a comment about these so-called security agreements between Ukraine and Eurovassals. When any Eurovassal signs a ‘security agreement’ with Ukraine, usually they are supposed to deliver some weapons.
But in reality the way it works is this. The Eurovassal takes on more debt, or makes more curtailments in their national budget, and sends that money to a US company like Raytheon. Raytheon is able to produce a single Patriot PAC-3 launcher per month.
Now you see the problem here. There is a massive backlog of needing to supply Eurovassals and both Ukraine (where Nato de-militarization is industrial paced). That means Nato can fulfill maybe 5 % of the requirements for a coherent air defense in Ukraine at any one point in time.
How does 5% coherent air defense in Ukraine affect the war? That’s right, it manifests itself through Ukraine getting obliterated and any later potential commitments in Ukraine making very little difference.

Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 9:44 utc | 141

Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 9:44 utc | 141
.
.
And don’t forget one thing.
You the vassals know that your investment is lost.
Maybe a reason why the USA doesn’t invest more?
Now the vassals should make it their mission to generate as much dividend as possible IN THE USA before it’s over.
Capitalism’s motto is the last thing out as long as there is something to be had.

Posted by: ossi | Apr 10 2024 9:51 utc | 142

Russia has NOTHING to fear from the EU. The Ukrainian people have EVERYTHING to fear if they join.
Latest European Union rules provide no serious reform or increased capacity to meet the actual challenges ahead.
https://billmitchell.org/blog/?p=61666
The money scarcity gang, “sound finance” brigade will be overjoyed. In otherwords, the mouthpieces and ideologues who beat the drum for the banking class. Wall Street, City of London, Paris and Frankfurt.
I can see the damage this ideological drivel has caused with my own eyes this morning, as I sit in Spain by the sea with my morning coffee. As it opens its borders to mass tourism to try and get its hands on Euro’s ( a foreign currency) to pay back its foreign debt. Spanish Workers can no longer afford to live in these resorts, who work long hours to serve the needs of the foreigners who visit. Now import cheap labour from Argentina and other South American countries. Most of the resort’s infrastructure is crumbling and not fit for purpose.
Because most also have a food deficit, energy deficit and manufacturing deficit. And fast forward 5, 6, 7 decades, you have massive unsustainable debts and you have massive conditionalities imposed on their economy, and now they can’t even prioritise investing in health or education or infrastructure, let alone investing in climate adaptation and so on.
All Compounded by export oriented growth, imposed on them by Brussels, which is the old gold standard, fixed exchange rate model that locks them at the bottom of the value chain.
Foreign direct investment, they tell you that FDI is going to get you out of poverty. Well, FDI is worse than export-oriented growth because at least export-oriented profits that are generated are retained within the country, reinvested, possibly. But FDI profits are repatriated to other nations, so it’s even more extractive than your domestic export-oriented manufacturing.
Tourism, again, is extractive, because if you don’t have food, if you don’t have energy, the more tourism you have, the more food and energy you have to import, the more high tech equipment you have to import for hotels and entertainment and transportation for tourism and all of that. So it’s all of these things that are supposed to bring foreign currency reserves to get you out of the foreign debt trap, they tend to actually push you further and deeper into the foreign debt trap.
The money scarcity gang, “sound finance” brigade will be overjoyed. Those ideologues who support this nonsense then say they are fighting against neoliberalism and fighting against the blob, fighting back against corporations and the elite upper class, are nothing more than a bunch of ideological driven fools. As per usual, talking out of both sides of their mouths saying different things. Their ideological drivel fully supports neoliberalism, the blob, corporations and the elite upper class and the banking class.
All of these causes are at the very heart of money scarcity and ” sound finance ” ideology.

Posted by: Echo Chamber | Apr 10 2024 9:51 utc | 143

Personally I found this very delusional.
https://sputnikglobe.com/20240410/russia-urges-west-to-admit-ukraine-carried-out-zaporozhye-nuclear-plant-attacks–1117842690.html

Posted by: Surferket | Apr 10 2024 10:02 utc | 144

Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 8:17 utc | 125
Thank you for your concern.

Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Apr 10 2024 10:11 utc | 145

Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 7:32 utc | 120
If true, a clear indication the West is washing its hands of the whole mess. No doubt the electorally beneficial narrative is being crafted, that blames the Republicans for ‘stabbing the Ukrainians’ in the back, disguising the real assassins. Like all failed corporate projects, it’s being quietly swept away and the architects re-assigned, or subject to PR statements talking about ‘their valuable contributions, and ‘time now to now move on and start a new chapter’.
It’s over, bar the CAS and gas-turbines singing, and the PTB are already accounting for the loss and starting projects, years in the making, that will impact millions of lives. It’s how they maintain their dominance, the masses and their supposed representatives react to what’s in front of them, whilst their self-ordained ‘overlords’ are already manoeuvring away to plan new attacks. Typical OODA dominance, if you want to pin them down predict where they’ll be, not where they are. Col. Boyd after all, was also a practitioner in deflection shooting.

Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 10:20 utc | 146

Dima says RU troops entered Urozhaine/Staramayorsk agglomeration, and SE/E part of Krasnogorovka. AFU counter-attacks in these areas were defeated.
Pervomaiske is in RU control.
The field in Netailove-Umanske line is contested. Obviously the aim is to cut this road and dissect the defense belt.
Clashes NE of Chasov Yar. Some small RU gain W of Ivanivske.
RU managed to hit a warehouse in Konstantinovka.
AFU managed to push RUAF east from Terny. Seems RUAF not doing that well in this flank.

Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 11:10 utc | 147

“We have received information about the preparation of a chemical attack from Ukraine.
Toxic substances packaged in bags, as well as bottled drinks containing toxic substances, were delivered to one of the railway stations of the Lviv region.
We are finding out the geographical targets of the attack.”
A rabid dog foaming at the mouth…

Posted by: Виктор | Apr 10 2024 11:15 utc | 148

Radio interception data of conversations between Ukrainian junior commanders at positions in the Pervomaisky and Netailovo areas has appeared online. Let us recall that to date, the Russian Armed Forces have inflicted fire on the enemy over most of the territory of the village of Pervomaiskoye, pushing out units of the Armed Forces of Ukraine to the western outskirts of this settlement. At the same time, there is an advance towards Netailovo from Vodyanoye, liberated by our troops.
According to radio interception data, the command “above” set the Ukrainian Armed Forces the task of “with all our might to hold the intersection of country roads in the Netailovo area.” We are talking about the intersection of the Vodyanoye-Netaylovo and Pervomaiskoye-Vodyanoye-Netaylovo roads. North of this junction, the country road goes into the fields and turns into a dirt road, along which in good weather you can get to Yasnobrodovka and Umanskoye.
The junior command staff at the positions of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in Netailovo expresses, to put it mildly, bewilderment that it is necessary to hold this particular object (road intersection). The reasoning is roughly as follows: why try to hold it, if in dry weather in this area you can advance along any of the fields, even to Netailovo, even to Yasnobrodovka, and in bad weather the existing road turns into mush…
To date, the specified intersection (joint) of roads near the village of Neitalovo is designated on Ukrainian maps as a “gray zone”. A number of Russian sources mark it as partial ownership of the RF Armed Forces.
Fighting on the approaches to Netailovo continues.

https://en.topwar.ru/240010-dannye-radioperehvata-svidetelstvujut-chto-pered-vsu-postavlena-zadacha-oboronjat-perekrestok-dorog-na-podstupah-k-selu-netajlovo.html

Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 11:19 utc | 149

UWDude@66…..I honestly don’t know what they’d be thinking but if they have a plan to leave 404, they should share it with the Ukie draft dodgers, they seem to be having an issue leaving the country.
Cheers

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Apr 10 2024 11:26 utc | 150

Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 7:17 utc | 119
There are reasons there is no NATO in Asia.

Posted by: James M. | Apr 10 2024 11:32 utc | 151

Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 6:20 utc | 113
You must have learned military strategy from gaming. All you can see is what’s happening on a tactical / operational level.
First you are correct. Russia is at war but with the USA not with NATO or Ukraine. They skirmish with Ukraine and NATO but the enemy is the USA.
Second war are won and lost by economic and industrial might not small arms combat. The real fight is over access to resources.
Germany lost WW1 because they were starved into surrender by a naval blockade.
Germany lost WW2 because they couldn’t fight their way to a supply of oil. Their population size and access to other minerals was also a disadvantage but WW2 was mainly fought over oil. Military nerds like to argue over whose tanks or aircraft were better or how Hitlers meddling caused Germany’s defeat but the real reason German lost was because they didn’t have the resources or economic / industrial power to win the war.
In the post war years the USA has been trying out a strategy of skipping the skirmishes and going straight to controlling the worlds access to oil and other strategic resources. They can sting you with bombs and missiles but the real weapon they use are sanctions and economic power.
So you want to argue how NATO is bigger, smarter and better equipped than the Russians but what really matters is what Russia and China are up to deep inside Asia. Unless large oil deposits are suddenly found in western Europe it doesn’t really matter how many bases Finland builds on Russia’s borders. On a strategic level it doesn’t really matter if Fins take St. Petersburg … NATO can win battles but short of launching a nuclear war NATO is in a losing position in Europe and the economic power of the USA that backstops NATO is diminishing not increasing.

Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 11:35 utc | 152

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vAFdSVHXRuU
Very minimal map changes. Finally took last few houses in Pervomiaske (spelling -1). Other field or two elsewhere.
I’ve gotten to the point where I don’t even bother looking at Dima’s afternoon update. The war is moving at a glacial pace. And his titles are almost always clickbait, bait and switch, where his actual video does not show the “breakthrough” that the title advertises.
I just wait for Willy in the AM. Advance through the front matter (not enough territory change to justify whole video, so he has other, quite good, content). Then watch Willy at 2X, while eating oatmeal and drinking coffee.
Really, I could get almost as good by just looking at DeepState Map. Yes…I know it’s from the evil other side. Boo, boo…trolls. Facts and geography are “trolls”! But if the advances are real, they show up there eventually. And the Russophile commentary has a bad habit of “getting ahead” of actual territory moves…the Telegrammers will interpret infantry probing as actual control (which it is not) and then Suriyak and the like recycle that into map changes…after all, it’s more exciting content.

Posted by: Anonymous | Apr 10 2024 11:36 utc | 153

“Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 6:20 utc | 113
You must have learned military strategy from gaming. All you can see is what’s happening on a tactical / operational level.
First you are correct. Russia is at war but with the USA not with NATO or Ukraine. They skirmish with Ukraine and NATO but the enemy is the USA.
Second war are won and lost by economic and industrial might not small arms combat. The real fight is over access to resources.
Germany lost WW1 because they were starved into surrender by a naval blockade.
Germany lost WW2 because they couldn’t fight their way to a supply of oil. Their population size and access to other minerals was also a disadvantage but WW2 was mainly fought over oil. Military nerds like to argue over whose tanks or aircraft were better or how Hitler’s meddling caused Germany’s defeat but the real reason German lost was because they didn’t have the resources or economic / industrial power to win the war.”
Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 11:35 utc | 152
Well done post. Thanks
I think if Italy hadn’t got themselves in trouble in East Africa in 1940-41 in a disatrous military campaign which the Brits under General Cunningham and local leader Haile Selassie routed the Italian force even while being outnumbered 2-1- forcing Hitler to reinforce his Africa Corps;without the German reinforcement in Africa the Wehrmacht might have had enough troops in Operation Barbarossa to seize the Balkans oil reserves -history might have been quite different.
Many people don’t realize that it was an Allied naval blockade that starved Germany and ended WW1.

Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 11:46 utc | 154

Video about YT wargamers and following the U/R war:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0nPfPC2uQy4
While I like both of the individuals (really, they have nice mood to themselves), it pretty much does show how a lot of commentary is coming from wargamers. FWIW, I would probably take wargamers (on either side!) over the TV generals. Frigging fat asses. See them in the DC area, getting on the Metro, like little government workers.

Posted by: Anonymous | Apr 10 2024 11:48 utc | 155

Melaleuca@93
“It would be a mistake for Russia to underestimate how far the West will go and what they will do to reverse their flagging fortunes.
It remains to be seen whether the US and its proxies are setting a trap for Russia, of ultimately for themselves.”
Sound advice…..no one knows on any given day how this plays out and as for 5D chess masters against Checker lackies….once the board is kicked over the game at hand is moot.
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Apr 10 2024 11:56 utc | 156

“All of these causes are at the very heart of money scarcity and ” sound finance ” ideology.”
Posted by: Echo Chamberpot | Apr 10 2024 9:51 utc | 143
Well Chanmberpot the ‘sound money” (gold) isn’t receiving your ‘sound ‘ advice:
Gold SPOT MARKET IS OPEN
Will CLOSE in 9 hrs. 5 mins.
Apr 10, 2024 8:00 AM NY Time
Bid/Ask
2,347.10
2,348.10
If one wants to make money just do the opposite of Echo Chamberpot’s advice and you will do just fine.
–

Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 12:03 utc | 157

The Kremlin only goal is to be BFF with western oligarchs and drink Champagne with them (again).
They are slowly getting that they are being pranked by their would-be BFFs.
But they still seek their company.
‘Do not ask why your butt hurts in the morning, rather ask whom you went to bed with.’

Posted by: Greg Galloway | Apr 10 2024 12:10 utc | 158

Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 12:03 utc | 157
Gold might fall in the event there is a liquidity crunch. A liquidity crunch may precede a debt crisis, as loan holders scramble to liquidate everything they can to pay for loans. Of course, this would occur in conjunction with other assets. However, soon loans will be delinquent and defaulted upon, after the liquidity crunch and massive wide spread defaults, the monetary system itself is toast and gold will go up in value as a real hard asset.
However, under normal circumstances we can expect central banks to lower rates and purchase bonds for various different reasons, which with current sticky inflation will lower rates and cause gold go up. Sorry ot.

Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 12:17 utc | 159

without the German reinforcement in Africa the Wehrmacht might have had enough troops in Operation Barbarossa to seize the Balkans oil reserves -history might have been quite different.
Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 11:46 utc | 154
The Balkans were seized before Barbarossa precisely as a prerequisite for it, those which had not already become Axis vassals that is: among the latter Romania which was where the main supply of oil in the area was. If you are referring instead to Fall Blau… it can be argued it went as well as it could given the available forces, logistics, leadership etc.

Posted by: Satepestage | Apr 10 2024 12:45 utc | 160

Typical OODA dominance, if you want to pin them down predict where they’ll be, not where they are.
Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 10:20 utc | 146
Elon Musk just opened a new front in Brazil. Latin America will be the main theater for some time to come.

Posted by: Honzo | Apr 10 2024 12:57 utc | 161

“Typical OODA dominance, if you want to pin them down predict where they’ll be, not where they are.”
Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 10:20 utc | 146
“Elon Musk just opened a new front in Brazil. Latin America will be the main theater for some time to come.”
Posted by: Honzo | Apr 10 2024 12:57 utc | 161
Protecting ‘free speech’ is not a ‘new front’; you have descended into a conspiracy theory on this issue.

Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 13:05 utc | 162

“Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 12:03 utc | 157
Gold might fall in the event there is a liquidity crunch. A liquidity crunch may precede a debt crisis, as loan holders scramble to liquidate everything they can to pay for loans. Of course, this would occur in conjunction with other assets. However, soon loans will be delinquent and defaulted upon, after the liquidity crunch and massive wide spread defaults, the monetary system itself is toast and gold will go up in value as a real hard asset.
However, under normal circumstances we can expect central banks to lower rates and purchase bonds for various different reasons, which with current sticky inflation will lower rates and cause gold go up. Sorry ot.”
Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 12:17 utc | 159
Of course there will be some liquidation of gold in a liquidity crunch short term but I stick to my suggestion that gold will be $3k /oz this year.
With the US adding $1 trillion every 100 days to its debt the greenback is toast-that’s why the Empire has gotten so desperate.

Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 13:10 utc | 163

canuck | Apr 10 2024 13:05 utc | 162
Color revolution, political manipulation, influence operations are not free speech.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Apr 10 2024 13:19 utc | 164

“canuck | Apr 10 2024 13:05 utc | 162
Color revolution, political manipulation, influence operations are not free speech.”
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Apr 10 2024 13:19 utc | 164
No, I disagree; you are on the wrong side on this issue:
“The flare-up came after US journalist and activist Michael Shellenberger last week accused Moraes of a “sweeping crackdown on free speech,” in a report based on the “Twitter Files,” a cache of internal documents Musk released in 2022 after buying the company…. Shellenberger said the files showed Moraes “sought to censor… sitting members of Brazil’s Congress” and “weaponize Twitter’s content moderation policies against supporters of then-president @jairbolsonaro.”(1)
Censorship by any government is anathema to free speech.
Musk is one of the few oligarchs standing up to the Empire-by criticizing him you are basically denigrating your own side.
1.https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/tech/technology/elon-musk-vs-brazil-supreme-court-five-things-to-know/articleshow/109186463.cms?from=mdr

Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 13:33 utc | 165

canuck | Apr 10 2024 13:33 utc | 165
Musk is not ‘standing up to empire’. Nobody in the US gets to control so much wealth by standing up to empire. Doing a 180 on Israel is not ‘standing up to empire’.
Watch Musk’s actions in south America in the coming years.
It’s becoming obvious a number of individuals are being groomed/promoted to become the new face of hope and change in the US.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Apr 10 2024 13:48 utc | 166

Posted by: Anonymous | Apr 10 2024 11:36 utc | 153
Read post No. 152. Then repeat. Then again…

Posted by: Виктор | Apr 10 2024 13:52 utc | 167

Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 6:20 utc | 113
What is even more hilarious is that NATO ground forces headquarters will be built at the Finland-Russia border ( tass.com/world/1772807 ).
Posted by: rk | Apr 10 2024 8:17 utc | 125
Russia is at war with more than 50 countries.
Posted by: Elber | Apr 10 2024 7:17 utc | 119
[NATO].. is a throw back to the world of European Great Power competition and imperialism that once enslaved our entire region <= I see it as a continuation of the colonization. the greedy used their governments to colonize nations that good profit potential.. The Americas produced mass amounts food and hemp produced cheaply when slaves were brought in and forced to produce the food and they had large amounts of valuable minerals, again produced by slave labor or stolen by armed government forces. https://www.southfront.press/moscow-opened-criminal-case-against-us-nato-officials-for-financing-terrorism-through-ukraine/
presents a graphic collage centered around Burimsma featuring Mykola Zlochevsky, Burisma founder ..former Energy minister in Yanukovych’s govt. target of investigation in 2014; Hunter Biden, BoD since 2014 until April this year; Aleksander Kwasniewski, former Polish president, joined BoD Burmisa @same time Biden; Igor Kolomoisky, owner TV network; and Joseph Cofer Black, Former CIA.
Slowly evidence is appearing to explain why NATO did not disband when the cold war was over. Evidence now appearing suggest NATO has been reassigned the duty to protect the Oil and Gas industry privately owned by the global elites? The NATO weapon has been aimed at protecting western ownership of oil and gas reserves, O&G transport (trucking, barges, ships, tankers, and pipeline, and refinery operations) where ever located in the world actual or potential competition to these industries appear?
Emerging is sufficient information to accuse NATO and the CIA of having become the protector of the privately owned oil and gas industry? The war in Ukraine seems to be the same war, different place, same subject, as is happening in Gaza.
In Gaza the Gazaians are being pushed off the land because of the massive O&G finds in the Levantine Basin Reserves, and under the GAZA land and in Eastern Egypt, Syria, Yemen, etc (Ottoman land oil)..
Both wars, IMO, seem to have been orchestrated to serve the interest of the very few who privately own and control the oil ang gas cartels<=this is the underlying deep state, the MIC and the think tank industry and the money cartels are likely off-shoots of the basic cause of these wars. Probably explains why Nord stream II was destroyed, denied access to SWIFT, sanctions from hell were used to attack and were designed to prevent Russian Oil or Gas from appearing in any global market worldwide. The threats against the North Sea LNG facilities operated by Russia are probably driven by the same underlying O&G interest? Adopting this view, explains the slow motion SMO approach used by Russia in Ukraine. I am guessing wherever the gas station in the East has an interest NATO will invent a way to attack it, because protect the private profit interest of the O&G cartels has become the function of NATO? Please convince me otherwise? I am also projecting that if the investigators in the world look deep into the goings'on in the top echelons on the national governments that govern the people of the nation nations, that they will find these individuals in the top echelons have been promised a profit interest in the Russian O&G once Russia is defeated? NO wonder, these leaders in the NATO nation states don't care that those they govern don't want a war with Russia and don't want nuclear weapons to be used.. The greedy few, driving the nation state leaders, don't care, they want the money and will do whatever it takes to get it. One solution to this O&G greed is to internationalize oil and gas.. Have the 2nd government take possession of the oil and gas and other minerals everywhere in the world [because these minerals belong in-equal-share "by right of being human" to each human who lives on the earth] <=no government no person no corporation has the right to those minerals, except that they be used to serve humanity equally] hence such minerals should be allocated equally to the global living human populations. Human rights are transparent to national boundaries. The profits these allocations produce to each nation state would be more than the nations get from taxing the individuals who live there. Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 11:35 utc | 152 Russia is at war but with the USA not with NATO or Ukraine. They skirmish with Ukraine and NATO but the enemy is the USA. <= I disagree with you, the USA is being used by the O&G industry to wage wage against Russian profiting from its ownership of, or and use of, its oil and gas reserves .. the driving interest to this war is the O&G industry and they are strong in Britain, France, Israel, and the USA.

Posted by: snake | Apr 10 2024 13:52 utc | 168

Posted by: Anonymous | Apr 10 2024 11:48 utc | 155
Inevitable, if the professionals are aligned with regime objectives, or too intimidated to question it. Wargaming and military analysis go hand in hand, so more specifically, the debate can sometimes be monopolised by commercial wargamers, whose disparate nature makes it hard to pass generalised comments about their efficacy as analysts.
Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 11:46 utc | 154
One of the most perceptive comments I have read about the High Seas Fleet was that it inflicted far more damage on Germany than on her enemies. A monumental waste of resources before ever firing a shot. One of my distant naval relatives witnessed its scuttling in Scapa Flow and said it nearly bought tears to his eyes, even though, as a senior gunnery officer, he’d trained to destroy it!

Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 14:03 utc | 169

without the German reinforcement in Africa the Wehrmacht might have had enough troops in Operation Barbarossa to seize the Balkans oil reserves -history might have been quite different.
Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 11:46 utc | 154
In November 1941 Stalin said: Modern wars are won by engines. Together with our partners we produce three times as many engines as Germany. So we will win.

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Apr 10 2024 14:04 utc | 170

Sound advice…..no one knows on any given day how this plays out and as for 5D chess masters against Checker lackies….once the board is kicked over the game at hand is moot.
Cheers M
Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Apr 10 2024 11:56 utc | 156
I like the chess analogy. Here’s my take on it.
Chess is all about getting your pieces in position and getting the king safely castled before you attack. For Russia / China that means creating a joint military industrial complex deep inside Asia and a network of trade routes that have minimal trade routes exposed to the US navy / air force so they can’t be interdicted.
Strategically the USA can’t allow Russia to ally with China. That creates an unassailable combination of technology, industrial might, resources and military might that makes the US navy and air force impotent.
The problem with the Americans is they have this evangelic belief that the way they live is the way everyone wants to live. Their belief in their ideology is so great it blinds them to the strategic moves other countries have made.
I watched the Trump administration completely lose sight of the threat that the alliance of China and Russia was becoming. By the time Biden got into office it was too little too late. The money printing during covid put them in a very vulnerable position that Russia and China are now exploiting through the BRICS alliance.
Russia didn’t beat sanctions in 2023 … they beat sanctions because they’ve been preparing to beat sanctions in cooperation with China since 2008. Going back to the chess analogy Russia / China had their king castled and minor pieces developed long before the 2022 SMO in Ukraine. The USA otoh can can only react to Russia / China’s moves. The kicking over the chess board move doesn’t work because at the present time Russia has better nuclear delivery systems and the the best case scenario for the USA is everyone loses.

Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 14:08 utc | 171

Posted by: snake | Apr 10 2024 13:52 utc | 168
After the Cold-War NATO jumped at the lifeline their new progressive masters offered them, eagerly adopting the dual role of peace-keepers and regime changers Continued NATO membership also served the continuing strategic goals of both the US and the Europeans, as the Warsaw Pact had similarly allowed the Soviet Union control over her satellites.

Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 14:19 utc | 172

“The scuttling was carried out on 21 June 1919. Intervening British guard ships were able to beach some of the ships, but 52 of the 74 interned vessels sank. Many of the wrecks were salvaged over the next two decades and were towed away for scrapping. Those that remain are popular diving sites. The ships are a source of low-background steel.”
Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 14:03 utc | 169
I had never heard of the scuttling at Scapa Flow (1)-thanks for the tutorial!
1.”Shortly after the end of the First World War, the Imperial German Navy was scuttled by its sailors while held off the harbour of the British Royal Navy base at Scapa Flow, in the Orkney Islands of Scotland. The High Seas Fleet was interned there under the terms of the Armistice while negotiations took place over the fate of the ships. Fearing that either the British would seize the ships unilaterally or the German government at the time might reject the Treaty of Versailles and resume the war effort (in which case the ships could be used against Germany), Admiral Ludwig von Reuter decided to scuttle the fleet.
The scuttling was carried out on 21 June 1919. Intervening British guard ships were able to beach some of the ships, but 52 of the 74 interned vessels sank. Many of the wrecks were salvaged over the next two decades and were towed away for scrapping. Those that remain are popular diving sites. The ships are a source of low-background steel.” (2)
2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scuttling_of_the_German_fleet_at_Scapa_Flow#References

Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 14:20 utc | 173

the USA is being used by the O&G industry to wage wage against Russian profiting from its ownership of, or and use of, its oil and gas reserves .. the driving interest to this war is the O&G industry and they are strong in Britain, France, Israel, and the USA.
Posted by: snake | Apr 10 2024 13:52 utc | 168
The USA isn’t the 340 million Americans who populate the country and get to choose their favorite puppet every 4 years. They are a domesticated animal known as “the consumer”. They’re role is to burn oil and buy cheap, hugely marked up shit made in China or Mexico.
The USA IS the Oil and Gas industry … or rather the means of control of the worlds oil and gas trade through the exclusive use of the $USD for oil and gas trade. The deal is oil is traded in $USD with the Americans taking a cut of every trade and in return the US navy and air force makes sure the trade routes remain open and “free”. Sure France, Israel, GB and others are in the oil business but the protection racket is run by the USA and none of these countries have oil or the military power to run the protection racket. They all trade oil in $USD and reap none of the profits from SWIFT.
Please take notice that the real war isn’t being fought in Israel or Ukraine. It’s being fought with the BRICs, Houtis, China’s BRI initiative and sanctions.
Russia has won in Ukraine by beating sanctions and Putin’s reelection. Even in the unlikely event they suffer a military defeat at the hands of NATO they are still the victors in this battle.

Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 14:27 utc | 174

I watched the Trump administration completely lose sight of the threat that the alliance of China and Russia was becoming. By the time Biden got into office it was too little too late.
Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 14:08 utc | 171
##########
That is my main issue with democracy. There is little continuity, by design. Societies with regularly rotating authority (personalities and aims) are vulnerable and lack the strength to stand up to color revolutions or outside pressure from other states. The deals that Obama, Trump, and Biden cut are all up in the air the moment an election is over. This creates instability among international partners like Russia and China whose leadership has dealt with multiple US Presidents and congresses.
Many citizens believe that because they vote they are participating in the process. And yet, any intelligent person in the West should be able to admit that the government is unresponsive to any topic they find important, regardless of the popular support for action on that issue.
As soon as a people try to force change, someone new is elected with a clear mandate from the previous incompetence.
And so the cycle starts over again.
Same story, new cast.
This is how a Deep State (weaponized bureaucracy) gains control and reach, as they are the only consistent power center in the government decade over decade, existing without a transparent mandate or any accountability to the people paying for the whole thing.
Damn those Rooskies for noticing that the more America holds elections, the more that things remain unchanged!!!

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Apr 10 2024 14:40 utc | 175

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Apr 10 2024 14:04 utc | 170
Another quote attributed to Stalin that, A) was probably fictitious, or B) made years later to show his prophetic genius. It’s dumb because it’s not the ratio that matters it’s the replacement rate after attrition and the ability to sustain those engines. In the summer of ‘41 the Germans were inflicting far higher loss ratios than 3:1 and that’s not including the ‘engines’ that were lost due to being abandoned.
As for delaying Barbarossa, Operation Mercury also cost vital months, and crucially limited German logistical capabilities, both factors that possibly would have made the capture of Moscow a feasible outcome. The impact of losing the largest rail hub in the Soviet Union has kept the alternative historians in clover for years. I’m sure after the last piece of rubble has bounced, and the final regime henchman has fled, there will be ‘alternative histories of the SMO’ being penned, if not sooner.

Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 14:41 utc | 176

Musk is not ‘standing up to empire’. Nobody in the US gets to control so much wealth by standing up to empire. Doing a 180 on Israel is not ‘standing up to empire’.
Watch Musk’s actions in south America in the coming years.
It’s becoming obvious a number of individuals are being groomed/promoted to become the new face of hope and change in the US.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Apr 10 2024 13:48 utc | 166
Spot on. Musk is participating in a color revolution op in Brazil. As I have been saying, the current meta-strategy of the PTB is Fortress America, which involves tight control over North and South America, stealing as much as possible of Europe’s industrial/tech base, and creating captive markets in Europe and Latin America. It remains to be seen how much of the supply chain coming out of Asia and Africa can be held onto, but it’s clear that anything requiring transit across the oceans is unsustainably vulnerable. If possible, the PTB would like to completely isolate the western hemisphere from the Old World politically and to a large extent, economically. Musk ‘going to war with Brazil over free speech’ as the headlines have it, is an extension of long-standing American policy in the region, but also a sign that this will be the next focus of operations.

Posted by: Honzo | Apr 10 2024 14:54 utc | 177

@ LoveDonbass, §175:
Yep: “Plus ça change, plus c´est la même chose.”
So, we now need: “Citoyens, aux armes!”

Posted by: John Marks | Apr 10 2024 14:54 utc | 178

Of course there will be some liquidation of gold in a liquidity crunch short term but I stick to my suggestion that gold will be $3k /oz this year.
Posted by: canuck | Apr 10 2024 13:10 utc | 163
I agree with you. But the main buyers of gold are now central banks and China, few of whom have liquidity problems and many of which are using gold to divest themselves of US$. These buyers will buy at almost any price and if it falls will just buy more.
The continuing actions (like sending their old bird to Beijing) of the US apparently forcing the rest of the World to gang up against the West go against all logic of them wanting to remain the hegemon.
I have little doubt that the Russians see the end of the SMO being driven by finance as much as war and one of the reasons for their slow moves is to allow time for the forthcoming non US$ trade financing to be put in place.
Once US debt financing soars through $T a year and the US$ is no longer needed as much for trade we will be in a very dangerous position where, following precedent, the US acts with war as the solution to every problem and this will be the Mother Of All Problems MOAP.

Posted by: JohninMK | Apr 10 2024 15:51 utc | 179

@ JohninMK, §179:
US interest on its debt is already above $1T/yr.

Posted by: John Marks | Apr 10 2024 16:01 utc | 180

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Apr 10 2024 14:04 utc | 170
Another quote attributed to Stalin that, A) was probably fictitious, or B) made years later to show his prophetic genius. It’s dumb because it’s not the ratio that matters it’s the replacement rate after attrition and the ability to sustain those engines. In the summer of ‘41 the Germans were inflicting far higher loss ratios than 3:1 and that’s not including the ‘engines’ that were lost due to being abandoned.
As for delaying Barbarossa, Operation Mercury also cost vital months, and crucially limited German logistical capabilities, both factors that possibly would have made the capture of Moscow a feasible outcome. The impact of losing the largest rail hub in the Soviet Union has kept the alternative historians in clover for years. I’m sure after the last piece of rubble has bounced, and the final regime henchman has fled, there will be ‘alternative histories of the SMO’ being penned, if not sooner.
Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 14:41 utc | 176
J. V. Stalin
Speech at Celebration Meeting
of the Moscow Soviet
of Working People’s Deputies
and Moscow Party and Public Organizations
November 6, 1941
…
There is, finally, the coalition of the U.S.S.R., Great Britain and the United States of America against the German-fascist imperialists. It is a fact that Great Britain, the United States of America and the Soviet Union have united into a single camp, which has set itself the aim of smashing the Hitlerite imperialists and their predatory armies. The present war is a war of engines. The war will be won by the side that has an overwhelming preponderance in engine production. If we aggregate the production of engines in the U.S.A., Great Britain and the U.S.S.R., then we get a superiority of at least three times in comparison with Germany. That is one of the grounds for the inevitable doom of Hitler’s robber imperialism.
…

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Apr 10 2024 16:05 utc | 181

Posted by: JohninMK | Apr 10 2024 15:51 utc | 179

The SMO was clearly intended to be a swift putsch like maneuver leaving the stupefied west to accept the fait accompli.
That failed, and obviously it was abundantly clear that what follows is an existential survival game against all the collective west, and the transformation and game play have been effective and careful and successful.
The reluctant swimmer fell into the cold water he would have in any case to face later. An fortunate accident.

Posted by: Catilina | Apr 10 2024 16:09 utc | 182

https://t.me/vysokygovorit/15339

Ukrainian channels reported that the Ukrainian Armed Forces were strengthening the air defense of Kharkov and were waiting for our attack. Let’s leave speculation about the offensive to all sorts of experts, and let’s dwell on air defense in more detail.
During March-April, our group very seriously thinned out the Ukrainian air defense, the video of the destruction of the position area near Kharkov spread across all the largest Tg channels, but the enemy significantly increased the number of MTF (mobile fire group).
The MTF on a pickup truck, armed with a DShK or ZU-23-2, which is also equipped with a thermal imager, and the crew has a spectrum analyzer, cover Kharkov both from the attacks of our Geraniums and hunt for the Supercam Halls. Specifically, in the video provided, you can see how MTF Khokhla is firing at our UAV from the Kharkov district (north-north-east of the city) tonight.
There is nothing wrong with using the enemy’s experience; we can make exactly the same MTFs ourselves and use them to cover infrastructure facilities, especially oil refineries. Considering that hochlodrone raids are mostly single aircraft, the MTF will be very effective.

https://t.me/vysokygovorit/15320

Again I will touch on our attacks on Kharkov and the region. The difficult situation with the shelling of Belgorod prompted the GPGG to be one of the first to use a modern ARM, where several minutes pass between detecting and hitting a target. Not always and not everywhere, but there are more and more similar examples and I hope that they will spread to other units and formations operating on all fronts of the Northern Military District.
Constant control of the sky and an instant strike on a detected target is the key to success. It doesn’t matter how this strike was delivered, by an FPV drone, Lancet, artillery, rocket, aircraft or MLRS, it all depends on the nature of the target, but the principle of operation does not change. The operator discovered that the intelligence officer (or the operator himself) gave the order to open fire, bypassing a bunch of useless and unnecessary approvals.
By the way, this, in turn, will significantly reduce the unnecessary staff where various kinds of coordinators sit; they will be much more useful in the advanced infantry formations than in the headquarters.
To summarize, I will say that we are fighting more and more as a modern army should, except for us, only crests do this, all other potential opponents essentially have no idea how to fight and what needs to be done. It doesn’t matter what budgets are included in their military budget and how many military bases with aircraft carriers hang on the balance sheet of the military department.

https://t.me/geromanat/24152

American drones have proved ineffective — Wall Street Journal
The American UAV manufacturing company Skydio hoped to demonstrate the effectiveness of their models on the battlefield to increase sales, but the plan failed.
UAVs cannot cope with Russian electronic warfare and are off course.
▪️”American—made drones are expensive, malfunction and difficult to repair,” say both the heads of companies producing the devices and the Ukrainian military.

https://t.me/milinfolive/120052

In the 1980s, during the war in Angola, the South African Air Force for the first time encountered serious enemy air defense.
Therefore, attacks on targets began to be carried out widely (and successfully) using the technique of “throw bombing” (bombing from a pitched position). When the carrier aircraft approaches the target at low altitude, remaining below the radar field of view, it then accelerates, sharply gains altitude at an angle of about 45 degrees, and drops a bomb, which flies upward along a ballistic trajectory. Under the influence of this experience of the war in Angola, the development of new weapons to combat enemy air defenses began.
And in 1992, Grinaker Avitronics first introduced the BARB (Boosted Anti-Radar Bomb) guided anti-radar bomb. This is, in fact, an ordinary unguided Mk.82 bomb, but on which aerodynamic rudders, a control unit, a passive radar seeker, and a rocket accelerator based on a rocket for the domestic 127-mm Valkiri MLRS were installed.
As a result, such a bomb, homing on a working radar (or other emitting object) and operating range from pitching up to 12-14 km, cost 5 times less than the anti-radar missiles then available on the market. The seeker provided guidance with an accuracy of up to 15-25 m. The warhead made it possible to reliably hit manpower and unprotected equipment within a radius of 10-20 m, and also provided an acceptable fragmentation effect at a distance of up to 50 m (2 fragments per 1 sq. m of projection).
In 1994, a new version of BARB appeared – this time as a representative of the Guided Boosted Bomb family. The operating range from pitching up reached 18 km, and from an altitude of 10 km – 80 km!
But political upheaval was already in full swing in South Africa. Therefore, the development suffered the same fate as many other things created in the country’s defense in those years.
However, even today our Aerospace Forces would not be hindered by the appearance in their arsenal of such a smart bomb “that independently emits radio emissions”, capable of being effectively used both from a pitch-up and from high altitudes. There are plenty of targets in the NWO zone.

Posted by: anon2020 | Apr 10 2024 16:13 utc | 183

Gold might fall in the event there is a liquidity crunch.
Posted by: unimperator | Apr 10 2024 12:17 utc | 159
_____
Are you talking paper gold, or the real thing?

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 10 2024 16:20 utc | 184

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Apr 10 2024 16:05 utc | 181
A month before that speech he was planning to flee Moscow, wonder what changed? Thought as well that the Allied contribution to Russia defeating the Germans was of minimal importance, according to numerous posters here. As for proving what Stalin said by looking at an official transcript of his speech, read, or re-read, ‘1984’ there was a reason Orwell gave Winston Smith his particular job in the Ministry of Truth.
Again, if the ratio included all the Allies production capabilities, then the Russian replacement rate was even worse, given the amount of materiel they had already lost.

Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 17:06 utc | 185

Posted by: Oliver Krug | Apr 10 2024 16:05 utc | 181
One of the problem with translations of Russian speeches is they’re translations and therefore subjective. I don’t think Stalin meant “engines” as in combustion motors but engines as in “engines of war” or “siege engines”. Whoever can produce the most weapons will usually win the war all other things being equal. Western translators do everything in their power to make Russian look bad. Everyone knows all Russian brutes want out of life is to kick you to the curb and seize your house then put five proletariat families in it along with all their livestock. That’s what they live for.

Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 17:16 utc | 186

Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 17:16 utc | 186
Alternatively, Russian is very hard to accurately translate as many words don’t have any direct counter-part in english, or their meaning can be context dependent. That’s what Russians I’ve know have always said, still, what do they know, it’s obviously the blood-thirsty Anglo-sphere besmirching Communists again.
The produce more weapons usually win thing is often taken as gospel, it does come with quite a few caveats though, like the 3:1 ratio needed to attack and fighting in BUA’s always benefits the defender.

Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 17:56 utc | 187

Everyone knows all Russian brutes want out of life is to kick you to the curb and seize your house then put five proletariat families in it along with all their livestock. That’s what they live for.
Posted by: HB_Norica | Apr 10 2024 17:16 utc | 186
The Clan which controls Israel has done a great job of doing just that in Ukraine after 1990. It certainly was not the Russians.

Posted by: Tom_12 | Apr 10 2024 18:17 utc | 188

Churchill said in December 1941 that the British Empire, USA and Russia, fighting for their lives, were twice or even thrice the warmaking potential of Germany and Japan – the moment the USA joined he knew the war was won, despite the “terrible forfeits to come”.
Similarly he said of the invasion of Crete

“We did not know how many parachute divisions the Germans had. Indeed, as the result of what happened in Crete, we made preparations, as will presently be described, for home defence against four or five of these audacious airborne divisions; and later still we and the Americans reproduced them ourselves on an even larger scale. But in fact the 7th Airborne Division was the only one which Goering had. This
division was destroyed in the Battle of Crete…Goering gained only a Pyrrhic victory in Crete; for the forces he expended there might easily have given him Cyprus, Iraq, Syria, and even perhaps Persia. These troops were the very kind needed to overrun large wavering regions where no serious resistance would have been encountered. He was foolish to cast away such almost measureless opportunities and irreplaceable forces in a mortal struggle, often hand-to-hand, with the warriors of the British Empire.”

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Apr 10 2024 18:20 utc | 189

As for delaying Barbarossa, Operation Mercury also cost vital months, and crucially limited German logistical capabilities, both factors that possibly would have made the capture of Moscow a feasible outcome. The impact of losing the largest rail hub in the Soviet Union has kept the alternative historians in clover for years. I’m sure after the last piece of rubble has bounced, and the final regime henchman has fled, there will be ‘alternative histories of the SMO’ being penned, if not sooner.
Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 14:41 utc | 176
Care to elaborate on the logistics issue? German logistics at the end of the day relied on railways which had to be converted from russian to standard gauge as they advanced further into the USSR. The dedicated battalions worked relatively fast but could do only so much, plus there were a number of other issues due to the differences between how the two different railways systems operated.

Posted by: Satepestage | Apr 10 2024 18:28 utc | 190

re: sean the leprechaun | Apr 9 2024 21:24 utc | 57 and Soviético | Apr 9 2024 23:26 utc | 76
Thanks and Gracia for your replies.

Posted by: Perimetr | Apr 10 2024 18:48 utc | 191

sorry, *Gracias* for your reply

Posted by: Perimetr | Apr 10 2024 18:48 utc | 192

Posted by: Satepestage | Apr 10 2024 18:28 utc | 190
Losing 150 transport aircraft and their highly experienced crews, and nearly a hundred damaged, had an impact on the Luftwaffe’s operational logistical capability. The loses to the assault force in Crete also destroyed their aerial assault capabilities, relegating their role to elite leg infantry, which was a waste of their specialised and costly training. Who knows how the Barbarossa time-table might have changed, if the Germans had conducted a series of air assaults to hold key objectives. With total air supremacy, after destroying the best part of the Red Airforce in the opening weeks of June, the conditions would have been near-ideal for such operations.
I’m aware of the importance of rail logistics, hence my comment, in an previous post, about Moscow’s capture severely dislocating any Russian logistical capability, but losing up to 400+ tonnes of air transport capacity hurts. To put the figure into perspective, that’s the daily shortfall in the Stalingrad airlift, that would have made 6th Army combat effective.

Posted by: Milites | Apr 10 2024 21:41 utc | 193

anon2020 | Apr 10 2024 16:13 utc | 183
Well, a “toss bombing” and its variants was nothing new at the time and it has been a classic air-force dumb bombing tactics since 40s, so as a combat pilot that is what you learn on the ground support mode roles. I do not know what they teach now.
The only issue in Angola was a new Russian, via Cuba imported, AA Osa system, and SADF went for it and captured some. Mirage F1 was suited for such toss missions. I think one Buccaneer crashed when tried tossing, never used afterwards, only for laser designated missiles and at night.
It pleases me to see that Russian Paratroopers studied and practiced 150 m low jumps, as were used in FireForce tactics.

Posted by: whirlX | Apr 10 2024 22:40 utc | 194

Posted by: whirlX | Apr 10 2024 22:40 utc | 194
The Buccaneer was specifically designed to toss-bomb for both its initial roles, of maritime strike aircraft and nuclear bomber. Odd that the SADF could not get it to perform in the the role it was designed for, as an ultra-low level platform.

Posted by: Milites | Apr 11 2024 0:48 utc | 195

Milites | Apr 11 2024 0:48 utc | 195
I am not sure how many we had in 1978 but what I understood – a sanctions and embargo – there were not enough spare parts, so this one that crashed (apparently) was technically challenged. Of course they were using them for everything CAS, but also kept them in a rear for a nuke or precision attacks.
Those were pretty good planes, certainly better for CAS than F1.
F3, I could argue, but at the time the best SADF had.
I estimate 10, internet says 16 , and at the end of the life there just 5 or 6 left flying. Some have been ordered and never delivered by the UK.

Posted by: whirlX | Apr 11 2024 2:16 utc | 196