Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 21, 2023
Palestine Open Thread 2023-311

Only for news & views directly related to the war in Palestine.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

Herbert W. Armstrong, the founder of the Worldwide Church of God (WCG), was rumored to have had occasional interactions with individuals associated with the CIA (Central Intelligence Agency). There are claims and reports suggesting that Armstrong might have had some contact or communication with members of the intelligence community, but the exact nature and extent of these interactions remain unclear and surrounded by speculation rather than concrete evidence.

Posted by: Jonathan W | Dec 22 2023 11:28 utc | 201

Interesting analysis by Military Summary that China supporting Yemen and stretching the US navy.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0Wqj2G-SvA

Posted by: Menz | Dec 22 2023 11:31 utc | 202

In response to

Remember the Zionists go nowhere without the City-thus Anglo/Zionists
Posted by: canuck | Dec 22 2023 1:16 utc | 123

I agree and continue to call out the God Of Mammon cult instead of positing that if the Zionists or Nazis were gone, all would be good……monotheism is just another proxy war for the global financial elite.
bevin is sensitive to folks positing that the City of London Corp may be a more significant center of the God Of Mammon cult than the US Fed owners. That said, most of the history he provides is insightful.
Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 22 2023 4:27 utc | 148
I agree; bevin, most of the time the history that he provides is , ‘insightful’- but, of course, like all of us he is not infallible. His ignorance of the City’s massive influence is certainly a major blind spot.

Posted by: canuck | Dec 22 2023 11:33 utc | 203

Jane @1920
Interesting sidenote on Baghdad Jews: The original founder of the Saudi dynasty was a Jewish merchant from Baghdad, who much like the Donmei in Turkey, converted to Islam and allied himself with the Islamic fanaticist Wahabis and with their assistance, managed to conquer most of the Arabian Peninsula in the first third of the 20th Century.
Could it be said that the Saudi rulers are Cryptos? Wondering whether anyone has researched that.
Posted by: aristodemos | Dec 22 2023 5:07 utc | 156
I have heard that .rumpour’ many times. Here is what I found ,whether its true or not?
“Historians have traced that the Sauds belonged to Anza tribe who were settled in Najd around 1450 AD. It is said that Sauds were originally Jews and shrewd Feudal Lords.
Saudi%20Family.jpg
King Faisal (1906-1975), who ruled the Kingdom between 1964-75, confirmed Jewish ancestry of Saudi Royals. In an interview to Washington post on September 17, 1969, King Faisal is reported to have said “We, the Saudi family are cousins of the Jews.
We entirely disagree with any Arab or Muslim Authority which shows any antagonism to the Jews; but we must live together with them in peace. Our country (Arabia) is the Fountain head from where the first Jew sprang, and his descendants spread out all over the world.”Read more…..(2)”
1.https://www.jpost.com/middle-east/iran-news/article-692595
2. https://pdf.defence.pk/threads/the-origin-and-historical-background-of-saudi-royal-family.375044/

Posted by: canuck | Dec 22 2023 11:43 utc | 204

Jane @ 135:
I re-read the part I wrote that you asterisked. I did mean for that part to be general, to emphasise that Zionist beliefs and ideology might have come out of a selective mix of beliefs and ideologies that actually didn’t make sense put together.
The ideas and beliefs that came out of the Enlightenment, when mixed with other pre-Enlightenment beliefs, from perhaps Christian traditions, Jewish traditions and any other belief systems, would have had consequences in the way people viewed their world and history, and shaped their attitudes towards themselves and towards other peoples, especially other peoples in Asia, Africa, the Americas and Oceania. This worldview might have led to a hierarchical view of humans and their cultures, with European and other Western cultures at the top and non-Christian cultures at the bottom. This view was reinforced by a selective interpretation of Charles Darwin’s theory of natural selection when he published his work “On the Origin of Species” in the 1850s.
In many European societies in the 1800s and early 1900s, Jewish people were often the most educated people and were the basis of those societies’ middle classes. They would have been public bureaucrats, doctors, educators in universities and schools and journalists. They would have been the people most exposed to an eclectic mix of Enlightenment and other ideals and values, and many if not most of these beliefs espoused the notion that all humans could and should be categorised hierarchically on the basis of their supposed biological and intellectual achievements – or backwardness.
From the 1860s onwards, with European and Western colonialism rife throughout the world, industrialisation spreading across the West at the same time, and Christian missionaries active in many Western colonies, people came to the conclusion that Westerners were naturally superior to other peoples, and this idea was bolstered by the misuse of Darwin’s theories and discoveries and findings in other sciences that were then in their infancy (among them linguistics, archaeology and anthropology). Such misuse of scientific discoveries was used not only to justify imperialism / colonialism but also to deny women and working-class people equal rights and responsibilities and participation in the political process in Western nations.

Posted by: Refinnejenna | Dec 22 2023 11:45 utc | 205

The narrative is changing in the MSM:
Israel is losing the war against Hamas – but Netanyahu and his government will never admit it
Paul Rogers

Until recently the war narrative on Gaza has been very largely controlled by the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and the country’s ministry of defence… That changed as a different picture began to emerge
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/dec/21/israel-losing-war-against-hamas-netanyahu-idf?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

Posted by: Menz | Dec 22 2023 11:48 utc | 206

From Jewpaedia (FWIW for those actual historians in our midst)

Himyarite Kingdom
The Himyarite Kingdom (Arabic: مملكة حِمْيَر, romanized: Mamlakat Ḥimyar, Hebrew: ממלכת חִמְיָר) or Himyar (Arabic: حِمْيَر, Ḥimyar; Ṣayhadic: 𐩢𐩣𐩺𐩧𐩣, Ḥmyrm), historically referred to as the Homerite Kingdom by the Greeks and the Romans (its subjects being called Homeritae), was a polity in the southern highlands of Yemen, as well as the name of the region which it claimed. Until 110 BCE, it was integrated into the Qatabanian kingdom, afterwards being recognized as an independent kingdom. According to classical sources, their capital was the ancient city of Zafar, relatively near the modern-day city of Sana’a.[1] Himyarite power eventually shifted to Sana’a as the population increased in the fifth century. After the establishment of their kingdom, it was ruled by kings from dhū-Raydān tribe. The kingdom was named Raydān.[4]
The kingdom conquered neighbouring Saba’ in c. 25 BCE (for the first time), Qataban in c. 200 CE, and Haḍramaut c. 300 CE. Its political fortunes relative to Saba’ changed frequently until it finally conquered the Sabaean Kingdom around 280.[5] Himyar then endured until it finally fell to invaders from the Kingdom of Aksum in 525 CE.[6]
The Himyarites originally worshiped most of the South-Arabian pantheon, including Wadd, ʿAthtar, ‘Amm and Almaqah. Since at least the reign of Abikarib Asʿad (c. 384 to 433 CE), Judaism was adopted as the de facto state religion. The religion may have been adopted to some extent as much as two centuries earlier, but inscriptions to polytheistic deities ceased after this date. It was embraced initially by the upper classes, and possibly a large proportion of the general population over time.[4]
Descendants of the Himyarites, namely the aristocratic families of Dhu’l-Kala and Dhu Asbah, played a prominent role in early Islamic Syria. They led the South Arabian contingents of the Muslim army during the conquest of Homs in 638 and contributed to making Homs a center for South Arabian settlement, culture and political power. Their chiefs supported Mu’awiya ibn Abi Sufyan against Caliph Ali in the First Muslim Civil War (656–661). Their influence waned with their defeat at the Battle of Marj Rahit against the Quda’a confederation and the Umayyad caliph Marwan I in 684 and practically diminished with the death of their leader at the Battle of Khazir in 686.
Nonetheless, members of the Dhu’l-Kala and Dhu Asbah played important roles at different times through the remainder of Umayyad rule (661–750) as governors, commanders, scholars, and pietists.
.
.
.
The form of Judaism practiced appears to have differed somewhat from rabbinic Judaism; for example, inscriptions found make no mention of the afterlife, suggesting that Himyarite Jews did not believe in the afterlife. It is possible that Himyarite Judaism descended from a non-rabbinic movement such as the Sadducees

Proximity and Affinity with the remnants of the Himyarite Kingdom, ostensibly a swarthy rabble roaming the sands of Arabia for centuries after the fall of the Hymyarite Kingdom?
A whole new can of worms here …

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 22 2023 11:55 utc | 207

Posted by: canuck | Dec 22 2023 11:43 utc | 208
Nobody doubts there were Jews in Arabia when Muhammad was alive as their presence is attested to in the hadiths and if my memory serves also in the Quran. Cousins of Jews could just refer to Ishmael and Isaac.

Posted by: Jonathan W | Dec 22 2023 11:55 utc | 208

Five songs about Palestine:
https://www.palestinechronicle.com/solidarity-music-you-will-love-these-five-songs-about-palestine/
While all is going on, in the background, the PLO is being prepared to govern The West Bank and Gaza after the fighting is over.
Hussein al-Sheikh, the Secretary-General of the Executive Committee of the Palestine Liberation Organization, is being groomed to replace Abbas:
https://en.imarabic.com/the-palestinian-authority-pledges-to-hold-hamas-accountable-after-the-end-of-the-war/
https://www.middleeasteye.net/live-blog/live-blog-update/uae-foreign-minister-and-plo-official-meet-abu-dhabi-discuss-ceasefire

Posted by: JB | Dec 22 2023 12:09 utc | 209

Tom_Q_Collins 165
The scumbags are the US politicians that make the nuclear fusion missiles for use in real war and then divert their use to bomb innocent civilians. We’ve got no immediate use for these nuclear bombs, why not send them to Israel and see what happens. This door to using nuclear-munitions on civilians shows the massive level.of corruption in the US military , that even after Vietnam, it hasn’t learned not to utilise WMD on people.
Since we’re in a bar, it’s worth mentioning that if the bar only served coffee and Pepsi like a school canteen, it wouldn’t stop crazies coming and murdering children. But the Politicians are now crazy. What’s the difference morally, apart from in scale, between a sniper murdering kids and a US politician like Blinken sending WMD to fire at civilians ?
It’s the same as the logic of the sniper, our plan to take out Russia didn’t work, because Russia was too powerful, so next time we will target innocent women, children and male civilians.
Sick, or what? Blinken needs to locked up in a psychiatric hospital and the key thrown away.

Posted by: Giyane | Dec 22 2023 12:15 utc | 210

Videos of a pro-Palestinian demonstration at Toronto’s Eaton Centre on Sunday have gone viral after images emerged of a masked protester telling someone in the presence of Toronto police officers: “I’ll put you six feet deep.”
National Post:
The words are heard early in the video, which was widely shared on social media. A protester is seen pointing toward police officers who are in the mall, and saying: “I’ll put him on the ground.” He adds: “You come near I’ll put you lay down on the floor (sic) … I’ll put you six feet deep.” The camera then swings to take in the police, who look at one another as the man moves on.
https://nationalpost.com/news/ill-put-you-six-feet-deep-masked-pro-palestinian-protester-threatens-toronto-police-officer#:~:text=A%20protester%20is%20seen%20pointing,as%20the%20man%20moves%20on.
Posted by: ld | Dec 22 2023 7:10 utc | 175
Yes I heard all about the ‘incident’ on Toronto talk shows.
The irony is that the MSM are infuriated that a pro Palestinian man threatened a police office and didn’t get charged.
How about being infuriated with Israel bombing Gaza children indiscriminately?
For fucks sake-I hate provincial minded stupid Canadians!!

Posted by: canuck | Dec 22 2023 12:22 utc | 211

Jonathon W 212
Ameleks and Caananites were probably Ishmelite cousins of the Children of Israel. Go back a bit further and we’re all from Adam and Eve.
Britain has fessed up and admitted its criminal past but not apologised. The US and Empire 2 Tories in power in Britain have both stated their joint aim of extending the USUKIS empire to the Pacific , in other words from the US round to the US.
Greater Israel and Ukraine are geopolitical steps 1 and 2.
Greater Israel and Ukraine are geopolitical steps 1 and 2
Greater Israel and Ukraine are geopolitical steps 1 and 2.

Posted by: Giyane | Dec 22 2023 12:30 utc | 212

What goes up must come down, that is also a psychologicl fact.
The crazed killing frenzy by the izzies fuiled by adrenlin and endorohine will enevitably soon run out.
Run out as is its nature. And when that happens depression will set in. Along with the cold light of the reality of what they have done, and the harm it has done to the wider jewih people.
A self inflicted wound lasting hundreds of years.

Posted by: Mark2 | Dec 22 2023 12:38 utc | 213

216
Now we know what the neocon-European Atlantacist plan is, what care we going to do ? We know who the head of the snake is. Let the dead Bury their dead .
There are more important things to do.
Eliminate the neocons in their bolted apartments.
Eliminate the Atlantacists in their AI – elected parliaments.
Couple of khinzals and 100 Snipers and these monkeys can be locked back up in the zoo.
Their proxies like Erdogan and Nowttodowiyu and Jellybaby, are
truly disposable assets like Prigizhin who blew himself with his team rather than be couped up in Gulag.

Posted by: Giyane | Dec 22 2023 12:56 utc | 214

Well the Ziocons did it. The US got the worthless wording it wanted.
The UN is finally ready to vote on a ceasefire in Gaza.
The US got the wording on the agreement watered down.
From:
“for a sustainable cessation of hostilities” was
changed to
“for creating the conditions for a sustainable cessation of hostilities”.
Do you see it?
They removed the beef from the Nothing Burger.

Posted by: librul | Dec 22 2023 13:45 utc | 215

Headline in Haaretz:
Israelis Need the Army Spokesman’s Lies to Keep Believing We’re Winning

Posted by: Jonathan W | Dec 22 2023 13:50 utc | 216

The crazed killing frenzy by the izzies fuiled by adrenlin and endorohine will enevitably soon run out.
Posted by: Mark2 | Dec 22 2023 12:38 utc | 218
This only applies to normal, fully functional human beings.
As someone pointed out on this forum, 90% of Izzraelis are not normal.
They are filtered and bred for their capacity for psychopathy and tolerance for cognitive dissonance.
There’s no “come down” for these people, it’s HATE HATE HATE permanently all the time like a cheap, noisy toy with a broken off-switch.
(The remaining 10% are irrelevant)

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 22 2023 14:15 utc | 217

I once wrote that the only way to stop the genocide, there would have to be a military defeat of the occupation state. The more I think about it, the more I’m in favor of economic aspect that would help bring about the end as well.
Reasoning: African American Montgomery bus boycott — 1955-56. What the Houthis are doing now in Red Sea. It wasn’t until the white southerner got hit in the pocket that the change came about. Unfortunately that boycott lasted 381 day, and it wasn’t without resistance from whites/KKK afterwards. I don’t see anybody alive if this genocide lasts that long.
Go Houthis, go.

Posted by: Sakineh Bagoom | Dec 22 2023 14:23 utc | 218

Arch Bungle @ 222
Beg to differ.
What ever the mind the body is a pysiological
machine when the fuil runs out you/it stop.
I speack as a life long adrenalin junky.
Moving on… were on the same page regards the pycopathic nature of this war.
As such heres a valuable aspect..
The izzies will be rubbish at predicting the outcome. Basicaly they and US UK have predictably ‘lost control’ i see it.
Example as a case in point….
(Q) how do you dispose of two million dead bodys in a small area the size of the ise of white, see a uk map. And that in front of the whole world watching on internet.
Its always the practical detail that trips up the mass murderer.. to qoute the great detective Calumbo.
Easy to over look the obveous.
Watch this space people are now dying of starvation and infection two months time imagine the scenes of horror….
TWO MILLION OF THEM.
Cheers and respect.

Posted by: Mark2 | Dec 22 2023 15:45 utc | 219

After the internet blackout of the past two days it was revealed that 390 were killed in the last two days and 734 injured.
This morning Israel laid siege to the Jabalia ambulance centre, burning the ambulances and taking away the medics and paramedics to god knows where.
Settlers in the West Bank are uprooting olive trees and of course some Palestinians shot doead there. Over 300 since Oct 8 so well over 500 in 2023.
I am scared to check the Telegram channels every day.
What is entirely different about Zionist crimes from ALL other crimes documented in history is that there are usually attempts to cover up, there are debates and denials.
Instead we have a tik tok army proudly documenting their own crimes with full confidence they will never be held accountable. What we see is the tip of the iceberg.
Yesterday there was some discussion about when did Zionists become as evil as Nazis (something like that).This question cements the mythology that Allies were somehow a lesser evil than Nazis. Evil is inevitable when one sees another human being as not a person. Nazis did not have a monopoly on this. This mentality exists today as voiced by Borrell with his Garden Jungle thing.
Most of what we are allowed to know about Nazi evilness comes from Zionists. The first document written soon after the liberation of Auschwitz is a lurid tabloid article by Soviet Jews. Israel does not allow the Red Cross to visit Palestinian prisoners whereas the Nazis did allow Red Cross. The detailed records are now in the exclusive possession of the Holocaust Industry. In June 1992 the plaque at Auschwitz was changed from “4 million people” to “1.5 million mostly Jews”??? There was an accounting error and they were off by 2.5 million. Don’t ask how, it’s criminal to do so.
I disagree with dumping all the blame on one party because the winners get to write history after carpet bombing one country and dumping atomic bombs on another. The US hadn’t even given the vote to blacks who fought in WWII. The British Army was more Dad’s army without its millions of colonial “subjects”.
Most of Europe collaborated with the Nazis. I’ve never met a French, Dutch, Scandinavian or Italian who feels responsible for dispatching Jews to camps. They just keep opening museums and putting plaques all over the place. French and Italian resistance fighters are heroes whereas Palestinians resistance is illegal and criminal. The hypocrisy exists TODAY.
The Holocaust is specific to European jewry because Arab / Muslim world even under French or British occupation mostly did not cooperate in deportation of Mizrahim.
If Nazism was the ultimate evil explain how leading Nazis ended up heading NATO in Europe? Others went to North America with Operation Paperclip to good jobs in NASA etc. Bandera was protected by MI6 to help foment trouble in Ukraine against the USSR. Ever heard of Operation Unthinkable? Churchill wanted Germany to fight the USSR after WWII. Why did Zionists cooperate with Nazis in so many different ways?

Posted by: pq | Dec 22 2023 16:32 utc | 220

At some point in Afghanistan it occurred to me that these guys are Eurasian Rednecks. They have their farms and their families, they drive around in their 4x4Toyota pickups with their assault rifles, they’re religious conservatives and they just want to farm, live their lives and be left alone .
But if you do mess with them they will rain down holy hell. And they will defeat you. From Alexander the Great until modern times nobody has ever been able to defeat these Rednecks. Not for thousands of years. Why does the world keep messing with these people? They are clearly unbreakable and cannot be defeated.
Maybe bring them into the fold. They are characterized as prehistoric. They are not. I can tell you that they are much more politically sophisticated than the average Westerner. They can see through your bullshit immediately. Even the ones who are illiterate.
Maybe bring the Palestinians into the fold s well. In the course of fighting the Muslim for the last 30 years I have come to know the Muslims and Islam somewhat. Yes I will always be an infidel. I cannot speak Arabic and the Koran can only be truly understood if it is read and understood in Arabic. But I have developed the utmost respect for the Muslims and Islam.
The United States should be allied with Islam, not with Israel.

Posted by: RLTW | Dec 22 2023 21:38 utc | 221