Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 6, 2023
Bombing Gaza

At times it is so outrageous that even a major western news-agency can't help but to state the truth.


bigger

Comments

https://t.me/Middle_East_Spectator/3788?single
Multiple hits on tanks by fighters. Note the zero infantry protection, and how secure the fighters feel by the time they spend right next to the enemy
Posted by: Hankster | Dec 6 2023 20:32 utc | 73 ”
I dont have Telegram so the video doesnt open for me. Can you tell us if any of them show tanks ” cooking off ” , exploding turrents, burning crew members, destroyed tracks and so forth ….. ?

Posted by: Moonie | Dec 6 2023 23:55 utc | 101

@ Tom_Q_Collins
I saw the correction too late. Thanks.

Posted by: D J G | Dec 6 2023 23:56 utc | 102

jeez.. i used to come to the site for some updates on the Ukrainian war..
then I stumbled into this cesspool.
do you ever really listen to yourselves.
you people are fucked in the head
Posted by: james | Dec 6 2023 23:50 utc | 98
_____
You didn’t even come to the right thread, fake james.

Posted by: malenkov | Dec 7 2023 0:03 utc | 103

Expect to see all our favourite hasbara trolls out in force here again shortly, kvetching and oy veying about the 6 million raped women, to go with the 6 million beheaded babies and the 6 million babies cooked in ovens.
Oy vey!

Posted by: anon | Dec 7 2023 0:15 utc | 104

my own opinion is that the two-state thing is as dead as a door-nail. No Palestinian in their right mind would trust anything the zionist regime says, does or signs right now or maybe even for a generation or two after all the recent atrocities. it’s unspeakable what I’ve seen in videos and read on line
I also believe that the International Community should see to it that the violent colonialist state of israel be abolished
& one nation, Palestine, be established… where there is a right of return to ancestral lands, and where all can live in peace & cooperation, like many faiths did before 1948…..
how this is to be done, well, honestly I don’t know

Posted by: michaelj72 | Dec 7 2023 0:18 utc | 105

John Swinton (1829-1901), former chief editor of the New York Times.
In 1880 Swinton was invited to speak at a meeting of journalists in New York City about the freedom of the press. He outraged his colleagues by arguing: “There is no such thing, at this stage of the world’s history in America, as an independent press. You know it and I know it. There is not one of you who dare write your honest opinions, and if you did, you know beforehand that it would never appear in print. I am paid weekly for keeping my honest opinions out of the paper I am connected with. Others of you are paid similar salaries for similar things, and any of you who would be foolish as to write honest opinions would be out on the streets looking for another job. If I allowed my honest opinions to appear in one issue of my papers, before twenty-four hours my occupation would be gone. The business of the journalist is to destroy the truth, to lie outright, to pervert, to vilify, to fawn at the feet of mammon, and to sell his country and his race for his daily bread. You know it and I know it, and what folly is this toasting an independent press? We are the jumping jacks, they pull the strings and we dance. Our talents, our possibilities and our lives are all the property of other men. We are intellectual prostitutes.”

Posted by: Mangas coloradas | Dec 7 2023 0:19 utc | 106

Max Blumenthal responds to the latest emission of Hasbara atrocity propaganda:
Scandal-stained Israeli ‘rescue’ group fuels October 7 fabrications

Founded by a serial rapist known as the “Haredi Jeffrey Epstein,” Israeli ultra-Orthodox rescue group ZAKA is responsible for some of the most obscene post-October 7 atrocity fabrications, from beheaded babies to “mass rape” to a fetus cut from its mother.
Secretary of State Tony Blinken and President Joseph Biden have each echoed demonstrably false ZAKA testimonies about Hamas atrocities.

https://thegrayzone.com/2023/12/06/scandal-israeli-october-7-fabrications/

Posted by: Aleph_Null | Dec 7 2023 0:19 utc | 107

I suppose Saudi and UAE took the path of least resistance on that one. The Houthis are not technically “Iran backed”. They get some support from Iran but they are nobody’s puppets.
Posted by: pq | Dec 6 2023 21:45 utc | 84

Well said pq.
When Iranian analysts talk about relations within the Axis of Resistance, they often point that the whole “Proxy narrative” is a distraction. One could say that in many occasions, other parts of Axis of Resistance have greater influence then Iran in the final process of decisions-making.
Puppets and Proxies are something you can buy with money. Iran has not half so much money as US, Europe or even Saudis can offer.

Posted by: Framarz | Dec 7 2023 0:21 utc | 108

John Swinton (1829-1901), former chief editor of the New York Times.
In 1880 Swinton was invited to speak at a meeting of journalists in New York City about the freedom of the press. He outraged his colleagues by arguing: “There is no such thing, at this stage of the world’s history in America, as an independent press. You know it and I know it. There is not one of you who dare write your honest opinions, and if you did, you know beforehand that it would never appear in print. I am paid weekly for keeping my honest opinions out of the paper I am connected with. Others of you are paid similar salaries for similar things, and any of you who would be foolish as to write honest opinions would be out on the streets looking for another job. If I allowed my honest opinions to appear in one issue of my papers, before twenty-four hours my occupation would be gone. The business of the journalist is to destroy the truth, to lie outright, to pervert, to vilify, to fawn at the feet of mammon, and to sell his country and his race for his daily bread. You know it and I know it, and what folly is this toasting an independent press? We are the jumping jacks, they pull the strings and we dance. Our talents, our possibilities and our lives are all the property of other men. We are intellectual prostitutes.”
Posted by: Mangas coloradas | Dec 7 2023 0:19 utc | 107
Do you perchance happen to have a Reference for this? It has aged well.

Posted by: Don Firineach | Dec 7 2023 0:47 utc | 109

I dont have Telegram so the video doesnt open for me. Can you tell us if any of them show tanks ” cooking off ” , exploding turrents, burning crew members, destroyed tracks and so forth ….. ?
Posted by: Moonie | Dec 6 2023 23:55 utc | 102

Yes, burning vehicles, difficult to say if MTB or APC. Don’t believe in untouchable Merkava and Zionist Ubersoldiers. Just in the case of “spy cam operation” published recently, they managed to kill close to 60 Zionist soldiers. Those you see in that video returned “home” horizontally.
… But of course Resistance is not as good movie-makers as Hollywood.

Posted by: Framarz | Dec 7 2023 0:52 utc | 110

Posted by: Don Firineach | Dec 7 2023 0:47 utc | 110
It’s a pretty well known quote. I do notice that not even Wikipedia has a citation for it though.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Swinton_(journalist)#:~:text=If%20I%20should%20allow%20honest,street%20hunting%20for%20another%20job.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Dec 7 2023 0:59 utc | 111

@Tom_Q_Collins | Dec 7 2023 0:59 utc | 112
Thanks Tom. A locatable citation would be neat ….

Posted by: Don Firineach | Dec 7 2023 1:11 utc | 112

@ “How could I not be guilty?”
Posted by: Greg Galloway | Dec 6 2023 12:51 utc | 20
Am glad I ran into your post on way down to say that.
I’ll add I now understand how good Germans let themselves become BAD.
We are complicit unless we resist.

Posted by: DunGroanin | Dec 7 2023 1:15 utc | 113

fyi,
some good news
https://english.almayadeen.net/news/politics/nearly-half-a-million-israelis-left-occupied-palestine-since
Nearly half a million Israelis left occupied Palestine since October 7
“….During October (from October 7 to October 31), approximately 370,000 Israelis left Palestine, and during November, an additional 139,839 left Palestine.
The website noted that these figures do not include the tens of thousands of foreign workers and diplomats who have left Palestine after October 7th due to deteriorating conditions…..”

Posted by: michaelj72 | Dec 7 2023 1:31 utc | 114

Posted by: pq | Dec 6 2023 22:32 utc | 88
I can’t say I was much impressed by your claims of xenophobia/Islamophobia/homophobia in Crooke’s article. Lots (probably nearly all) conservatives are concerned about the future of Western civilisation and the “Great Replacement”. That is, until their pocket is touched, and they need immigrant workers to do the dirty low-paid jobs. The Tory party in UK is going through precisely that mental breakdown at the moment, with the anti-immigrant lead taken the children of immigrants themselves. In the near future this will break down, as people understand better that if their people, whites, don’t make babies, immigrants will have to replace them. Crooke is at a certain point on this path; he’s a conservative, but he’s not particularly offensive. He’s not Islamophobic to my ear; he couldn’t have lived in Lebanon if he were.

Posted by: laguerre | Dec 7 2023 1:31 utc | 115

https://t.me/rachblevins/1197
‘ ‘This Genocide is Televised’ w/ Ghadi Francis
Israel killed 700 Palestinians in just 24 hours this week, as it ramps up its bombardment of the Gaza Strip, vowing to hit the southern half with the same strength as the northern half, which has been described as “Hell on Earth.”
Lebanese Journalist and War Correspondent Ghadi Francis noted that not only is nowhere in Gaza safe, but Israel is targeting the same areas it told civilians to flee to, and the world is watching as genocide is being committed before our eyes. ‘
Inspiring informative, especially last 10 mins are spellbinding.
Houthis are Yemenis their coast is theirs they won’t sit by watching their brothers getting bombed. Having repelled years of Natzionist Imperial invasion in sandals against highest tech western weapons, they ain’t about to stand by and let it happen to their neighbours. Same goes for Syria, Iran and few others.
Like I said. We must Resist. It isn’t futile.

Posted by: DunGroanin | Dec 7 2023 1:46 utc | 116

According to the Meme Scream Media, Israel is kicking ass. Yes, they’ve bombed the shit out of Gaza and killed many children. My heart goes out to them. But, it looks like Hamas and Hezbollah are more battle hardened. What say you? And, Ukraine will march on Moscow any day now. Right after the next trillion. Cheers!

Posted by: Immaculate deception | Dec 7 2023 3:21 utc | 117

“Billion Dollar Babies”, Alice Cooper.

Posted by: Immaculate deception | Dec 7 2023 3:24 utc | 118

A couple of points:
1). The Gazan raid of 7 Oct. on Israel will go down in history and be celebrated as a huge success, no matter what the outcome of the war is afterward. The Gazans will inevitably be seen in the Arab and Muslim worlds and everywhere else that Zionist or Zionist-allied control of the press does not exist as heroes, and when they are killed, as martyrs. Nothing will alter that.
2). The preponderance of military force seems obviously to be on the Israeli side. After all, they have control of the air and sea, as well as vastly larger land forces numerically with vastly larger and stronger weaponry, so at least the military outcome should be clearly in their favor. In 1956 and 1967, they conquered the Gaza Strip in a single day. In their later interventions, they were at least able to get into better than in this one. Now, it goes on for months and they can’t finish it, and they also suffer real casualties.
3). The preponderance of ethical and moral force has switched entirely to the Palestinian side, a humongous Waterloo for the Zionist project and its propaganda machine. Zionism is exposed as intending to supplant the Palestinians entirely, stealing their livelihood and their homes, even though they never did anything to the Jews before Zionism appeared, and also as murderous and genocidal. In this latter regard, the longer the slaughter goes on, the worse it will get in the ethical arena, and the more indefensible Zionism and Israel will become at all. All they will have left is “Might makes right,” which is a thin reed to hang one’s whole lifelong project on. They are not merely in a snit of rage over this unexpected — to them — development, but are also befuddled and confused about it.
4). Jewish leadership of anti-Zionism now in western countries is clear. It is thus different than the persecution of Muslims — partly facilitated by the Zionists — after 9/11, because then the Muslims in the West, especially the US, we somewhat taken by surprise and defenseless. Even so, one factor helped greatly to protect the Muslims in the US at that time: the African American Muslims. These were not going to take any shit from the state, and they were in turn protected by the rest of the non-Muslim African Americans, who thought about the state, “You just want to get your foot in the door to attack all of us, using the excuse of Islam being bad, but we aren’t buying it and won’t allow it.” So, checkmate! Likewise in the current situation, the young anti-Zionist Jews are not going be deterred by any BS from their activism — just look at them go! As the massacre continues to get bigger, Zionism will continue to get uglier. This is a tremendous crisis for Zionism, even though it is militarily safe for the moment, and the events have nakedly exposed how the entire western power structure is entirely dedicated to supporting Zionism. However, even some of these bought, pressured, and harried politicians are starting to backtrack, because they begin to see the catastrophe for themselves in the future, as Israel’s actions are just plain indefensible.

Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 3:34 utc | 119

I found this randomly on you tube the other day. It has some relevance as it shows apparently a Jewish man heroically driving about the rave area saving people. If you look you can see the blown up cars and bodies . He at one point comes across some people he says are terrorists and drives off. There’s some gun fire, the footage only seems to lend credibility to the Apache narrative causing all that destruction. There’s even a conversation with a security guy he picks up. Anyway it a bit of extra footage to add to the event.
https://youtu.be/mvG7-PiDFyY?si=egkBy9QmXaJMfiYR

Posted by: Hankster | Dec 7 2023 3:38 utc | 120

One thing many don’t know about the houthis is they claim to be the direct descendants of Mohammed. They have that unshakeable belief in destiny , so I guess when put against the same Zionist unbendable ideology sparks will fly. A fair bit different from the Saudi who have a story of murdering then stealing the goods and identity of a silk road traveller to end up as royals

Posted by: Hankster | Dec 7 2023 3:42 utc | 121

But, it looks like Hamas and Hezbollah are more battle hardened. What say you? And, Ukraine will march on Moscow any day now. Right after the next trillion. Cheers!
Posted by: Immaculate deception | Dec 7 2023 3:21 utc | 118
It is true that both Hamas and Hezbollah are battle hardened.
Gazan HAMAS fighters and Hezbollah have returnees from Syria.

The Palestinian people are physically harder than ‘Israeli’.

But the most telling point is that the IDF has no (little?) evidence of HAMAS casualties due to ground operations.

Certainly *some* HAMAS fighters are being killed due to the carpet bombing of the strip but how can anyone say for certain in such a case especially since the civilian casualties overwhelm any possible HAMAS fighter casualties by the thousands?

If the HAMAS fighters were being massacred in droves it would be impossible to keep the images from the media … yet we see little evidence on the global communications network.

Contrast: HAMAS video clips showing IDF being gunned down at close range. Tanks being struck in such a way that IDF soldiers inside will either suffer debilitating trauma or shortly be unfit for service.

Conclusion:

It’s reasonable to assume, on the basis of the available information, that HAMAS are doing well at staying out of the IDF “line of fire” while the IDF, when they attempt to carry out infantry operations are taking the worst of it.

Of course, what’s happening to the fighters in the tunnels nobody knows. IF IDF strikes damage the ventilation systems I do not know how HAMAS fighters operating deep underground don’t suffocate. They would die silently.
But then, how would the IDF know? They wouldn’t – After all: “We Don’t Do Body Counts.”

So any numbers the IDF puts out are lies – like everything that comes out of the IDF (“By Deception You Shall Wage War”)

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 3:44 utc | 122

Apparently the Amerikastani congress passed a resolution equating anti zionism with “anti semitism.”
Other things that are anti semitic:
Anti-racism
Anti-apartheidism
Empathy
A conscience
Facts
Evidence
and
History.

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Dec 7 2023 3:50 utc | 123

2). The preponderance of military force seems obviously to be on the Israeli side. After all, they have control of the air and sea, as well as vastly larger land forces numerically with vastly larger and stronger weaponry, so at least the military outcome should be clearly in their favor. In 1956 and 1967, they conquered the Gaza Strip in a single day. In their later interventions, they were at least able to get into better than in this one. Now, it goes on for months and they can’t finish it, and they also suffer real casualties.
Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 3:34 utc | 120
In 1956 and 1967 they were fighting conventional forces in a conventional war. Their opponents were outnumbered and outclassed tactically, strategically and technologically in the domain of conventional warfare on a landscape not developed for guerrilla warfare.
This time they are fighting a specialist resistance movement in an urban warfare environment. They are encountering exactly the difficulties a conventional army encounters against resistance warfare.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 3:52 utc | 124

Apparently the Amerikastani congress passed a resolution equating anti zionism with “anti semitism.”
Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Dec 7 2023 3:50 utc | 124
Welcome To “The Free World”.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 3:55 utc | 125

This one’s too good to not post. Nutso nikkey
https://t.me/ResistanceTrench/21610
Nikki Haley: “For every 30 minutes that someone watches TikTok every day, they become 17% more antisemitic, more pro-Hamas.”

Posted by: Hankster | Dec 7 2023 3:59 utc | 126

Dear Zionists, dear Israelis,
I would like to say something about the current crisis on your behalf, really I would. Like old hippie on this site, I live in a heavily Jewish neighborhood in the US replete with Israeli flags and signs saying “We stand with Israel” and “Yachad nintsakh” (United we stand). I know many Jews, both anti-Zionist and (including most of my university colleagues) and Zionist, and many are my neighbors.
But what can we say in defense of the current “war” on Gaza? Let’s ignore all the racist, blood-curdling, genocidal, and cruel statements coming out of the mouths of Israelis these days, just for the sake of argument, calling them hyperbole. But what are you going to say, and what do you want me as your friend to say, in Israel’s defense? Mind you, we have to say only the truth here; we cannot fabricate things, because they will come back to bite us later, especially in this information age where everything is nakedly exposed. Therefore, we cannot dispute the well-established quotes, such as the one from Ben Gurion cited above by b at the beginning of this very thread admitting the expulsion of the Palestinians and the theft of their country, nor can we dispute well established facts, such as the expulsion of the 750,000 Palestinians from over 400 villages and a dozen cities and large towns in 1948, as meticulously documented by the very Zionist Israeli professor Benny Morris in multiple books, nor the general treatment of the Palestinians by the Zionist settlers (later Israelis) over more than 130 years, as documented by Achad Ha-`Am even in 1891. Nor can we adopt racist ideas that the Palestinians are different from or worse than any other people. Haven’t you observed that the same demonization used against the Palestinians can just as easily be used and said of the Israelis and in fact historically has been alleged against the Jews? People who live in glass houses shouldn’t throw stones.
I hate making my neighbors feel worse about themselves when they already feel bad enough, and it is really sad for them to be put into such a bind. But I still want to know what I can say that doesn’t sound false or bigoted, and I really don’t see any defense of a genocide and incipient Holocaust that I can make. I know that a lot of you, maybe most of you, are so embarrassed about this situation that you just remain silent, and of course you do have your enforcers on your side too to make sure you don’t step out of line. But even from the real dyed-in-the-wool Zionist believers in the US elite, most of what I see are not arguments in Israel’s defense, but only a few slogans, and especially a big country-wide campaign to suppress free speech, which, because it comes from the powerful, is a real threat to the institutions of the US republic, let alone to academia which I work in.
All I can think of for you is a humble approach, but then that will require changing, making amends, and recognizing the humanity of the other side first. Given their humanity, what can you say? If a humble and egalitarian approach is not adopted, I don’t see any favorable outcome.

Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 4:10 utc | 127

Brian Berletic sees US Sec of Defense Lloyd Austin in his recent remarks as attempting to provide plausible deniability re the US enabling of ethnic cleansing in Gaza using Hamas as pretext.
Brian also looks at a 2009 Brookings Institute Sabin Center analysis paper, “WHICH PATH TO PERSIA? Options for a New American Strategy toward Iran,” with a chapter entitled, “Leave it to Bibi: allowing or encouraging an Israeli Military strike,” and summarizes how foreign policy is made in US — not by politicians.
Whilst much has changed since 2009, especially w.r.t. Iran’s ability to defend herself, and global geopolitical plate tectonics, I fear not much has has changed with warmonger neocons. Someone recently said they, the neocons, have a flat learning curve, which is dangerous of course.
Michael Hudson recently said that what’s happening now in Palestine could develop into a case of supporting Israel “to the last Israeli,” implying that if the neocons get their war with Iran, Israel, like Ukraine, will be supported to death.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uou13mla4Ow
(ANALYSIS PAPER Number 20, June 2009 Sabin Center
WHICH PATH TO PERSIA?
Options for a New American Strategy toward Iran)
~~
“The primary principle of direct action is the defiant insistence on acting as if one is already free.” David Graeber

Posted by: suzan | Dec 7 2023 4:26 utc | 128

Sorry, I guess the Ben Gurion quote I referred to in Cabe | Dec 7 2023 4:10 utc | 128 is not on this thread. So here it is:
“If I were an Arab leader, I would never sign an agreement with Israel. It is normal; we have taken their country. It is true God promised it to us, but how could that interest them? Our God is not theirs. There has been anti — Semitism, the Nazis, Hitler, Auschwitz, but was that their fault? They see but one thing: We have come and we have stolen their country. Why would they accept that?” (David Ben Gurion — the first Israeli prime minister — quoted by Nahum Goldmann in Le Paraddoxe Juif (The Jewish Paradox), pp121.)
Cited in https://www.arabnews.com/node/220313

Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 4:28 utc | 129

asad abukhalil أسعد أبو خليل
@asadabukhalil
By Tawfiq Zayyad (my translation):
“Gentlemen, you have transformed
our country into a graveyard
You have planted bullets in our heads,
and organized massacres
Gentlemen, nothing passes like that
without account
All that you have done
to our people is
registered in notebooks”.
Quote
Said Shoaib | Gaza
@saidshoaib_gaza
·
8h
Waiting to get flour from the #UNRWA distribution centre.
#Gaza
https://twitter.com/asadabukhalil/status/1732570906353074366

Posted by: Menz | Dec 7 2023 4:45 utc | 130

I would like to say something about the current crisis on your behalf, really I would. Like old hippie on this site, I live in a heavily Jewish neighborhood in the US replete with Israeli flags and signs saying “We stand with Israel”
Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 4:10 utc | 128
New slogan :

“Those who stand with Israel should fall with Israel”

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 4:59 utc | 131

All I can think of for you is a humble approach, but then that will require changing, making amends, and recognizing the humanity of the other side first. Given their humanity, what can you say? If a humble and egalitarian approach is not adopted, I don’t see any favorable outcome.
Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 4:10 utc | 128
Here’s a thought experiment for you :

Would your “humble approach” have worked as an approach to the NAZIs in WW2?

If your approach is not applicable to every settler colonial /ethnic cleansing project henceforth and in the past then it is a corrupt approach meant to facilitate that which it claims to prevent. Aggravate that which it claims to heal.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 5:08 utc | 132

“18:30 Volker Turk, the United Nations high commissioner for human rights, highlighted that Israel had not responded to his repeated requests for access to independently investigate the Israeli allegations of sexual violence by Hamas fighters during their October 7 operation.
Turk confirmed in a press conference that for weeks he had “asked the Israeli authorities… to deploy a team, my team, to monitor, document, investigate the issues of the horrific attacks on Israelis.”
“I’ve repeated this call and I hope it will be heard but so far, I haven’t received a response.”
Various Israeli claims regarding what happened in the Hamas operation in the Gaza Envelope on 7 October, including claims of 40 beheaded babies, have not been verified by independent parties.”
https://english.ahram.org.eg

Posted by: Minaa | Dec 7 2023 5:41 utc | 133

@ Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 5:08 utc | 133
Dear Arch,
I am just trying to imagine what one could say to entice them to say something. The drama of this for me is the absoluteness of the moral bankruptcy of Zionism and Israel that has been revealed so openly for the first time. I already have known this for years; after all, I lived in Egypt for about eleven years quite a long time ago. However, Zionism before was able to make all kinds of excuses which were not convincing to me but sounded plausible to many. But it has never been so nakedly revealed for all to see before as it has now, and that is the big defeat of Zionism here that is going to have huge consequences for years, especially in the US. It is really a case of putting lipstick on a pig: How convincing can that be? Of course, change will be slow, but it will happen, despite all, because the interests of the US and of the Zionist entity are inimical to each other. Unfortunately, the situation has a lot of potential for disaster as well, as the entrenchedness of the Zionists in the US elite will be really hard to disentangle and will probably only come about violently, on top of the other split that is becoming more serious between the elite and the people. As many on MOA have commented or implied, it probably requires a revolution to solve, but it will certainly be messy and maybe catastrophic.

Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 6:14 utc | 134

As many on MOA have commented or implied, it probably requires a revolution to solve, but it will certainly be messy and maybe catastrophic.
Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 6:14 utc | 135
I’m afraid here we have only the hand of Time and the primal Universal consciousness to intercede.
Not even a revolution will help us now: We are witnessing the fall of Man, powerless to intercede even to preserve our own humanity.
Woe unto the world when humanity is removed from the human, for then not all the weapons in the armouries of the Jews will protect them from annhilation.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 6:36 utc | 135

Cabe | Dec 7 2023 4:10 utc | 128
Look it’s nice in theory. And you’re coming from a good space. But if they had any empathy and reason or some hope for humility they would have long ago already been there and recognized the inhumanity and criminality.
They aren’t the problem anyway, and they don’t need their hands held either. What’s needed is pure unadulterated overwhelming and constant military force to bring the criminal Zionist regime to it’s knees and then cut off it’s head – to end it once and for all.
Then whoever survives may they find some answers from therapy or prayer or eventually some fucking humility.
That’s how I see it.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | Dec 7 2023 7:45 utc | 136

Re: Peace ?
The way towards peace is that the war party can’t fund its wars anymore selling cheap debt. De- dollarization makes this happen.
Note – do not EVEN wish or support violent revolution. A revolution in any western society would be a horror of destruction and atrocities lasting many years.
If you want to act against the War Party – then start boycotting businesses and entities that support war – either formally or informally. Vote with your pocket book.

Posted by: Exile | Dec 7 2023 7:47 utc | 137

….. like many faiths did before 1948 …..
Posted by: michaelj72 | Dec 7 2023 0:18 utc | 105
Nah, it was a war zone —- 1920-1948 —- you need to update your history 🙂
Britain in Palestine 1917-1948
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOJqLTc6RkU
Destination 1922: A Return to Claims of the Arabs in Palestine
“The situation is rapidly going from bad to worse. Unless the plan to make Palestine the national home of the Jews is abandoned, Syria will soon be ablaze and the gravest international consequences may follow. Both the Christian and Moslem worlds are concerned. The Arabs will never consent to the Zionist program. Zionism, instead of settling Jewish problems, already threatens a world-wide revival of the anti-Semitic movement.”
This is the considered view of Arif Pasha el-Dazzinn, president of the executive committee of the Congress of the Moslem-Christian Leagues of Palestine, which represents 93 per cent of the entire population and all of the Arabs. He described to me, in a special interview, the Arab point of view and stated it with marked moderation through his secretary, who speaks English fluently. This alert, highly educated representative of one of the most picturesque races of the East, a race which kept learning alive in the Dark Ages and has left Spain a rich heritage of art and culture, upset all of one’s pre-conceived ideas of the Arab.
https://www.unz.com/article/destination-1922-a-return-to-claims-of-the-arabs-in-palestine/
The Ottoman Empire had governed today’s Palestine territories for 400 years from 1516 to 1918
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Gaza#Ottoman_era
https://www.plands.org/en/maps-atlases
http://www.passia.org/maps/38
https://www.palestine-studies.org/en/
THE BEGINNING OF THE BRITISH MANDATE, 1920
Figures compiled by the British military administration in 1918 pointed to a Jewish population in Palestine of 58,728 – less than 10% of the total. Zionist immigration following the establishment of the military administration had not increased markedly, but with the creation of the Mandate, whose first High Commissioner, Sir Herbert Samuel, was a Jew and a great supporter of the Zionist platform, Zionist diplomatic efforts were immediately rewarded. One of Samuel’s first acts was the approval of 16,500 Jewish immigration certificates; the local Zionist leadership reported to WZO head Chaim Weizmann, that the Mandate was being, “enthusiastically welcomed” by the community.
In 1920, Jewish immigration in fact rose by an unprecedented 450%, leading many Zionists to believe the British Mandate was to be simply an instrument for the fulfillment of the Balfour Declaration. Despite these important steps in empowering the Zionist movement, few European Jews were attracted to the program and even when the Zionist immigration reached these peaks, the vast majority of emigrating Jews made their way to the US. Of every 1,000 Jews in the world, only four made their way to Palestine during these immigration waves, impressing upon the WZO the imperative of expanding their political program abroad.
http://www.passia.org/maps/view/5
2018 – More than a century on: The Balfour Declaration explained
More than 100 years since Britain’s controversial pledge, here is everything you need to know about it.
https://www.aljazeera.com/features/2018/11/2/more-than-a-century-on-the-balfour-declaration-explained
2017 – Zionism, anti-semitism, and the Balfour Declaration
A complementarity between the anti-semitic desire to get rid of the Jews and the Zionist project of sending all Jews to Palestine seems ignored
https://www.opendemocracy.net/en/zionism-anti-semitism-and-balfour-declaration/
2022 – British Mandate of Palestine- a Complete Overview
https://www.wise2wisdom.org/british-mandate-of-palestine/
pick the eyes out of it.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | Dec 7 2023 8:17 utc | 138

@ Cabe | Dec 7 2023 4:10 utc | 128
Some people cannot be reached — a case in point >>>
On this matter, they [Israeli Embassy] put out a statement: “It is tragic to see the hate and incitement toward Israel expressed in such a horrific way.”
Brannon Ingram wrote: “How self-centered can you possibly be? Self immolation is never an act of ‘hate.’ It’s the opposite. It’s a desperate plea for humanity.”
https://scheerpost.com/2023/12/06/immolation-revelation/
They have become utterly disconnected from their humanity and cannot be reasoned with any more.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | Dec 7 2023 8:27 utc | 139

I’ll repost this recent article links – really excellent history review
The Chris Hedges Report: The War on Palestine Has Gone on for Over 100 Years
December 4, 2023
Historian Rashid Khalidi reframes the ‘Israel-Palestine Conflict’ in light of the 1917 Balfour Declaration and beyond, breaking down the myth of an ancient and eternal Jewish-Arab antagonism.
https://scheerpost.com/2023/12/04/chris-hedges-report-the-war-on-palestine-has-gone-on-for-over-100-years/
Note 1936 to 1939 crisis and rebellion period with summary executions of Arabs.
The Jews were assholes from the very beginning of British rule over Palestine — and the lowlife British just like the US enabled them encouraged them and armed them and then washed their hands of them.

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | Dec 7 2023 8:32 utc | 140

How Britain Started the Arab-Israeli Conflict | History Documentary
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZXfuqUhzESg
and Chris Hedges The 100 year war on Palestine w/Rashid Khalidi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cZ55JmOlSdg
Chris Hedges: … This duplicity, of course, continues to this day, as all of us who covered Gaza and the West Bank, would file our reports, and then watch the Israelis reflexively lie. But talk about this duplicity and its importance.
Rashid Khalidi: Yeah. It goes right back to an incident that I detailed at the very beginning of the book. An ancestor of mine who had been a member of the first Ottoman Parliament, who had been mayor of Jerusalem, lived in Europe, taught in Vienna, and knew German; he knew about Zionism.
We know that from his papers and from the books and Viennese newspapers that he received that are kept in the family library to this day. He knew about Zionism. He knew everything about Zionism. So he wrote to Theodor Herzl in 1899, two years after the first Zionist Congress, with full knowledge that the objective was a Jewish state in Palestine. And he tells him that we respect the Jews, they’re our cousins, we understand your suffering, and there’s nothing more noble than the idea of the Jewish people having a state, but not here; There’s already a people here.
The interesting thing is not only this letter from this ancestor of mine, a man named Yusuf Dia al-Khalidi, but Herzl’s response which is completely disingenuous, and completely ignores all the points that Yusuf Dia al-Khalidi is making. And then says in response to a question that Yusuf Dia had not even asked, we have no intention of driving the population away. If you look at Herzl’s diaries, he’s talking about spiriting the population discreetly across the borders. We’re talking in the 1890s. This is clear in Herzl’s mind. You have to get rid of the Arabs to have a Jewish state in a majority Arab country, there’s no other way to do it. And that in fact, is always the driving motive of Zionism.
[ aka COLONIALISM WITH GENOCIDE and/or EXPULSION ]
So what Weizmann is saying is profoundly deceptive in the quote that you read, which is from 1918 or 1919, because it was always understood that the objective was a majority Jewish state in what was, at that point, a majority Arab country. And that deceptiveness has been, as you say, a constant ever since. The idea of ethnic cleansing, which is something that was inherent in Zionism and which was practiced again and again in 1948, and 1967, is being practiced today in Gaza. Pushing people into the south of the Gaza Strip was always inherent in Zionism because there’s no other way to, as I’ve said, create a majority Jewish state in a majority Arab country.
iow inherent in Zionism is the eradication, genocide or ethnic cleansing of Palestinians from Palestine to create a majority Jewish state in a majority Arab country

Posted by: Lavrov’s Dog | Dec 7 2023 8:38 utc | 141

@ Don Firineach WRT Swinton, found this from 1997,
https://spartacus-educational.com/USAswintonJ.htm

Posted by: Lantern Dude | Dec 7 2023 9:00 utc | 142

Lots (probably nearly all) conservatives are concerned about the future of Western civilisation and the “Great Replacement”
….he couldn’t have lived in Lebanon if he were.
Posted by: laguerre | Dec 7 2023 1:31 utc | 115
Lebanon has a very strong Christian faction that is completely an US /EU puppet.
They are all dual citizens and flee to their nice apartments in Paris etc. at the first sign of the trouble they have stirred up. In the past they fought against the PLO and Lebanese National Movement.
I am not sure how much you know about Lebanon but it is home to some of the most rabid and bigoted Islamophobes. So the argument that he could not have lived in Lebanon if he were is compltely wrong, it’s quite the opposite: it would be the perfect base for him to stir up trouble between the various factions in Lebanon on behalf of Empire.
Christian militias have played a huge role in various massacres be it the Karantina massacre or Sabre and Shatila in which they allied with the Israeli Genocidal Forces in Beirut. Not most of course but many consider themselves “European” and therefore superior to Arabs and Muslims.
As for the bigoted conservatives worried about “Western Civilization” and the Great Replacement, where would Western civilizatio have been without wars of Empire over the last 500 years? Still in the Dark Ages. We need to get rid of the hubris and arrogance that is the main reason for the sad state of things here. You CAN’T only rape countries and not expect movements of people. And if that makes one feel insecure, it’s because they don’t have the skills to compete when it comes to real value added. I have seen this for decades in the business world.
They are totally welcome to be bigoted and blinded by prejudice if they want: it’s their choicce. I just don’t believe it ‘s going to be a winning strategy. They can destroy stuff with superior arms and dive deeper into the toilet.
Right now, I see people in the West divided into two grouos: those who genuinely believe all humans are equal. And those who think deep inside that there’s no way some African / Indian from a slum could possible be as smart and intelligent as a “Westerner”, whatever that is. Chines, they only steal stuff. Arabs too backward to get it together and so on.

Posted by: pq | Dec 7 2023 9:12 utc | 143

Question I believe has not been asked or answered here. If it has I apologize. Are Ashkenazi Jews Semetic?

Posted by: Jo P | Dec 7 2023 10:18 utc | 144

@pq | Dec 7 2023 9:12 utc | 143

[…] where would Western civilizatio have been without wars of Empire over the last 500 years? Still in the Dark Ages.

Not this shit again. Besides the fact that the idea of Dark Ages emerged in medieval Western Europe during the late Middle Ages as nostalgia for the greatness of the Roman Empire, the expression was twisted and reused by Protestants, to disparage the role of the Church during the Middle Ages, and by the Enlightment to disparage all the religious thought of the preceding centuries. As such it is a very neo-con/lib concept, dear to both Evangelical ultraconservatives and woke pseudo-sophisticated pseudo-progressives. As a matter of facts, the cultural, technical, economic expansion of Western Europe began in the IX century (with maybe a hiccup in the X) and resulted in dominance since the XV century.
What is going on in Gaza is not worse than what happened in Yemen. Nobody cared about Yemen. This is a disaster for Palestinians, whoever thinks otherwise is a sociopath.

Posted by: SG | Dec 7 2023 10:43 utc | 145

Are Ashkenazi Jews Semetic?
Posted by: Jo P | Dec 7 2023 10:18 utc | 144
No.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 11:45 utc | 146

Are Ashkenazi Jews Semetic?
Posted by: Jo P | Dec 7 2023 10:18 utc | 144
No.
Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 11:45 utc | 146
____
Not that it matters. Either way, it’s not their land.

Posted by: malenkov | Dec 7 2023 11:50 utc | 147

#145
Good point about Yemen. That story is just as horrible.

Posted by: scepticalSOB | Dec 7 2023 12:11 utc | 148

already posted but must see
https://youtu.be/NI46qq4o21g?si=exSTb6ib4Re7VLvS
good to remember that Edward Said had his doubts about Oslo
The elephant in the room that is missing from the conversation is what the Christians actually believe in and their relation to the Old Testament.

Posted by: Minaa | Dec 7 2023 12:27 utc | 149

Posted by: pq | Dec 7 2023 9:12 utc | 143
Yes, I know Lebanon very well, since I first went in 1971. I think you’re a bit out of date. The Christians haven’t dominated the country since the civil war. Indeed if Lebanon had a normal constitution (and not one fixed by the French to give the Christians permanent power), Hizbullah would be the government, but they hung back, in order not to provoke the western powers. Indeed much of the current crisis is due to the powers refusing to deal with Hizbullah (Macron for example). So what I said is true; you can’t live in Lebanon, if you’re an islamophobe, the fact that there are relics still of the old hatreds among the Maronites notwithstanding.

Posted by: laguerre | Dec 7 2023 12:30 utc | 150

good to remember that Edward Said had his doubts about Oslo
Posted by: Minaa | Dec 7 2023 12:27 utc | 149
Oslo was always a trick. Notably on Arafat to allow him to die in Palestine, and not in Tunis.

Posted by: laguerre | Dec 7 2023 12:34 utc | 151

My direct Jewish ancestors began to return to Palestine from Central Europe in the 1600’s, and thus were part of the 58,000 Jewish residents that one of Lavrov’s Dog’s posts above mentioned were in Palestine at the time of the Balfour Declaration. Most of these ancestors settled in the town known today as Safed, but then known as T’svat, where I still have many distant cousins I’ve never met. My paternal grandparent left in 1913 to avoid being drafted into the Ottoman army. Other relatives leaving Palestine around that time settled in Brazil and Argentina.
My points are: 1.before the Zionist colonialist project of Herzl and the UK, Jews were returning to the Holy Land in small but significant numbers for two reasons: religious longing for the storied ancient homeland and to escape legal discrimination and violent death. My ancestors escaped the Inquisition in Spain by relocating to Central Europe only to face restrictions on where they could live and what occupations they could pursue and then finally murderous pogroms. 2. It is absolutely true, as Palestinians and the denizens of Muslim countries assert: Jews and Muslims and Arabs of other religions were able to live side-by-side relatively amicably for centuries.
For the record, I’ve opposed Zionism since the age of 12, when I first looked into this history. If you look into the early years of the British Mandate, there was initially little protest from the Arab population. But by the mid to late 1920’s Britain was using force to put down Arab protests about the impact of swelling European Jewish immigrants,
and as it became clear to all where the Zionist project was headed. So Palestinian resistance is about a century old.

Posted by: mjh | Dec 7 2023 13:00 utc | 152

Where did I read it…?
(roughly) “If you say that you understand Lebanese politics
then you don’t understand Lebanon”.
In Feb 2006 Hezbollah and the largest Christian group signed
a Memorandum of Understanding. Here is the last section of
that agreement (emphasis mine).
https://www.peaceagreements.org/viewmasterdocument/1262

10– The Protection of Lebanon and Preserving its Independence and Sovereignty
The protection of Lebanon and the preservation of its independence and sovereignty are a national
public responsibility and duty, guaranteed by international treaties and the Human Rights Charter,
particularly in confronting any threats or dangers from any source that could harm them.
Therefore, carrying arms is not an objective in itself. Rather it is an honorable and sacred means that
is exercised by any group whose land is occupied, in a manner identical to the methods of political
resistance. In this context, Hezbollah’s weapons should be addressed as part of a global approach
that falls within two bounds:
The first bound is the reliance on justifications that meet a national consensus for keeping the
weapons, which would constitute a source of strength for Lebanon and the Lebanese people, and
the other bound is the definition of objective conditions that would lead to a cessation of the
reasons and justifications for keeping those weapons. Since Israel occupies the Shebaa Farms,
imprisons Lebanese resistance members and threatens Lebanon, the Lebanese people should
assume their responsibilities and share the burden of protecting Lebanon, safeguarding its existence
and security and protecting its independence and sovereignty by:
A. Liberating the Shebaa Farms from the Israeli occupation.
B. Liberating the Lebanese prisoners from Israeli prisons.
C. Protecting Lebanon from Israeli threats through a national dialogue leading to the
formulation of a national defense strategy over which the Lebanese agree to and subscribe
to by assuming its burdens and benefiting from its outcomes.

Général Michel Aoun
Hassan Nasrallah

The Neocons then went into hurry up mode for war.
Timeline:
April 2006 President Bush Welcomes Prime Minister Siniora of Lebanon to the White House
April 2006 Bush sends a Major General to Lebanon to see what US equipment can be supplied to the Lebanese army
April 2006 Prime Minister of the Zionist Project Ehud Olmert meets with his generals to review current plans for invading Lebanon
May 2006 US Ambassador to the UN John Bolton pushes through resolution making Syria and Iran culpable for actions of Hezbollah
May 2006 Hezbollah finds blind spot on border with the Zionist Project and attempts to seize border guards to trade for hostages – attempt fails
May-June 2006 The IDF is all over the blind spot on the border like a bear had busted a beehive.
July 2006 The IDF “misreads the intelligence” (Yes! same damn excuse they are using today!) and stands down their forces at the blind spot on the border
July 2006 The IDF assigns reserve soldiers instead of professional soldierrs to the blind spot. Doesn’t inform the reserve soldiers on that day that alarms are going off all along the border, sends them out on patrol unaware. Reserve soldiers are attacked by Hezbollah, IDF uses Hannibal Directive and hostages all die.
July 2006 Olmert, the US Neocons and the IDF get the war they wanted and the IDF invades Lebanon.
August 2006 Christian, Général Michel Aoun, who signed the Memorandum of Understanding with Hezbollah says that he was targeted for assassination by IDF jets.

Posted by: librul | Dec 7 2023 13:19 utc | 153

Lebanese TV reports:
15:06 Al-Qassam Brigades strikes two Israeli tanks in eastern Khan Younis
Comment – tally of claims now an even 100 Merkavas knocked out

Posted by: Exile | Dec 7 2023 13:45 utc | 154

https://www.cia.gov/readingroom/docs/CIA-RDP88B00443R001404090133-0.pdf 1983
the original pipeline was to go thru Syria.. Assad stopped that..
the new one originates off shore to Gaza.. ? does this answer your question’
if every politician has an interet in the new pipeline and production from the Lavantine gas reserve would that explain why none of the nations are willing to stop the Genocide.

Posted by: snake | Dec 7 2023 14:02 utc | 155

Not that it matters. Either way, it’s not their land.
Posted by: malenkov | Dec 7 2023 11:50 utc | 147
Quite right.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 14:14 utc | 156

Posted by: laguerre | Dec 7 2023 12:30 utc | 150
Islamophobia isn’t just clumsy and bigoted comments. It’s a deep seated feeling of distrust / superiority etc. that may be conveyed through quiet statements or may never be stated verbally. The Lebanese Forces party is one of the biggest troublemakers, alllied as it is with some European party.
You don’t get much more Islamophobic than allying with the US and Israeli Genocide Forces against your own people, unless you don’t view them as your own people.
ps:
https://new.thecradle.co/articles-id/1959
But despite his claims, one of the most prominent financiers of the ‘Neighborhood Watch’ is Anton Sehnaoui, the Chairman of the Board of Directors of the Societe Generale Bank de Banque au Liban (SGBL).
Sehnaoui is directly linked to the ‘Soldiers of God,’ a far-right Christian militia founded in 2020 by SGBL employee Joseph Mansour.
The Soldiers of God are ideological supporters of the LF and Kataeb parties, and harbor ultra-conservative beliefs. Moreover, they are staunchly opposed to the existence of Hezbollah and the presence of Palestinian and Syrian refugees in Lebanon.
According to an investigation by Lebanese daily Al Akhbar, in recent years many members of the Soldiers of God have been employed by Sehnaoui as security guards for SGBL branches.
An ultra-conservative Catholic who allegedly longs for the days of the Crusades, Sehnaoui saw in the extremists an opportunity to not only protect his assets from desperate depositors who have been forced to “rob banks” to retrieve their own savings, but also as a means to create a private militia that could control Beirut’s Christian neighborhoods.
According to an army intelligence investigation, in October 2021, the Soldiers of God played a part in the shooting of Hezbollah and Amal Movement supporters in the Tayouneh neighborhood of Beirut by LF snipers.

Posted by: pq | Dec 7 2023 14:35 utc | 157

An ultra-conservative Catholic who allegedly longs for the days of the Crusades, Sehnaoui saw in the extremists an opportunity to not only protect his assets from desperate depositors who have been forced to “rob banks” to retrieve their own savings, but also as a means to create a private militia that could control Beirut’s Christian neighborhoods.
According to an army intelligence investigation, in October 2021, the Soldiers of God played a part in the shooting of Hezbollah and Amal Movement supporters in the Tayouneh neighborhood of Beirut by LF snipers.
Posted by: pq | Dec 7 2023 14:35 utc | 157
It would be interesting to see if Isreal left the Christian neighbourhoods of Lebanon intact in their historical airstrikes …

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 7 2023 16:06 utc | 158

Posted by: Cabe | Dec 7 2023 4:10 utc | 127
.. recognizing the humanity of the other side first. Given their humanity, what can you say?
Thank you for comment.. from a couple of decades back, I vaguely recall an article by Amira Hass(?) describing an event during 30s-40 in a German town where a group of individuals were being marched through the middle class section of town in mid morning. The middle class mothers who had just fed their kids breakfast and send them out to school, were hanging out by their kitchen doors having a cup of coffee talking to their neighbors and watching.
They knew… but said nothing.
Now, the descendant of those individuals have mired themselves in an orgy of bloodshed and genocide of others, in a similar manner in which their grand parents were subjected to. Definition of misguided lost souls beyond words.

Posted by: Rd | Dec 7 2023 17:22 utc | 159

An interesting turn which sheds some light on why Reuters
chose to tell a truth for once.
Today Reuters main headline is about the Zionist Project killing Reuters journalists.
Also, Reuters presented a lengthy and detailed report on their murder at the hands of the IDF.
https://www.reuters.com/graphics/ISRAEL-LEBANON/JOURNALIST/akveabxrzvr/
The Zionist Project has long been known to target journalists as the Zionist Project wants full control of the public’s minds.
The murders took place on Oct 13th and Reuters has been developing their evidence.
Who knows what back-channel interactions Reuters has had with the IDF.
Maybe Reuters played hardball with the IDF to get some cooperation and to stop the murders of Reuters journalists
and that is why we saw the surprise anti-genocide headlines at Reuters.

Posted by: librul | Dec 7 2023 19:47 utc | 160