Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
October 17, 2023
Ukraine Open Thread 2023-241

Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

It seems that the U.S., despite denial, had already delivered long range ATACMS missiles to Ukraine. It was promptly used to destroy a Russia helicopter base:

ayden @squatsons – 12:09 UTC · Oct 17, 2023

The AFU used the MGM-140B ATACMS Block 1A (M39A1) ballistic cluster missile to strike the Berdyansk airfield earlier today.

This missile contains 275-300 M74 submunitions and is capable of hitting targets at a range of up to 300 kilometers. The very submunition was found at the airfield.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

Why everybody is always excusing such attacks with „not wunderwaffe“?
Wunderwaffel or not wunderwaffel
Egal!
Fact is that the attack was successful with a new Nato toy in the hands of ukropsychos

Posted by: tesla | Oct 17 2023 18:41 utc | 101

Why everybody is always excusing such attacks with „not wunderwaffe“?
Wunderwaffel or not wunderwaffel
Egal!
Fact is that the attack was successful with a new Nato toy in the hands of ukropsychos

Posted by: tesla | Oct 17 2023 18:41 utc | 102

Although I don’t look at the situation in US backed and led former state of Ukraine with the same granularity I did earlier, the impression I’m getting at this stage is that the Russian military is simply using this as an opportunity for batting practice against any new western weapons that expose themselves. So in the event of direct NATO/US involvement they’ll be prepared.
In my opinion the “western countries” don’t have the stomach for that.

Posted by: chunga | Oct 17 2023 18:42 utc | 103

Although I don’t look at the situation in US backed and led former state of Ukraine with the same granularity I did earlier, the impression I’m getting at this stage is that the Russian military is simply using this as an opportunity for batting practice against any new western weapons that expose themselves. So in the event of direct NATO/US involvement they’ll be prepared.
In my opinion the “western countries” don’t have the stomach for that.

Posted by: chunga | Oct 17 2023 18:42 utc | 104

43
Blablabla
Could it be the chessmaster is colorblind?
Maybe when he says red lines he means green lines?
Btw is anybody reading the daily reports
from russian MoD?
Reading this reports is better than 10 sleeping tablets

Posted by: SlowSoft | Oct 17 2023 18:51 utc | 105

43
Blablabla
Could it be the chessmaster is colorblind?
Maybe when he says red lines he means green lines?
Btw is anybody reading the daily reports
from russian MoD?
Reading this reports is better than 10 sleeping tablets

Posted by: SlowSoft | Oct 17 2023 18:51 utc | 106

Every time the Russians have a winning strategy, the US does something outrageous in an attempt to get Russia to change strategy.
It never works.
Russia is going to continue grinding down the Ukrainian army.
And when Ukraine is over and done with, and only then, are US and EU going to get the attention they have been seeking.

Posted by: Passerby | Oct 17 2023 18:53 utc | 107

Every time the Russians have a winning strategy, the US does something outrageous in an attempt to get Russia to change strategy.
It never works.
Russia is going to continue grinding down the Ukrainian army.
And when Ukraine is over and done with, and only then, are US and EU going to get the attention they have been seeking.

Posted by: Passerby | Oct 17 2023 18:53 utc | 108

https://t.me/CyberspecNews/45529
❗️Video of the launch of three MGM-140A ATACMS Block 1 cluster missiles from M142 HIMARS launchers of the Ukrainian army at the airfield in Berdyansk on the night of October 16-17.
Military Informant

Posted by: SlowSoft | Oct 17 2023 18:53 utc | 109

https://t.me/CyberspecNews/45529
❗️Video of the launch of three MGM-140A ATACMS Block 1 cluster missiles from M142 HIMARS launchers of the Ukrainian army at the airfield in Berdyansk on the night of October 16-17.
Military Informant

Posted by: SlowSoft | Oct 17 2023 18:53 utc | 110

Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 14:55 utc | 16
Exactly. Using these systems piecemeal is a telltale sign of desperation. And I’ll add a domestic US political angle to this (and other similar) attack and future attacks to come: On some very real level, this is the tail wagging the dog. I don’t know exactly how the connections work, but Ukraine still has many patrons in the US “defense” complex, probably including high ranking employees of Raytheon and the like, lobbyists, politicians and deep-staters. They aren’t happy that all the attention has been shifted to Israel/Palestine and the US populace is a fickle bunch. There has been a dearth of reportage coming out of Ukraine even prior to the flare up in the ME, so it’s not completely due to the Hamas attacks and Israel’s massively asymmetrical “response.” Point being, “victories” like the strike on the Russian airfield will be leveraged to convince TPTB to keep sending the lucre. And there’s also a tail-wags-the-dog aspect. Ukraine will seek to grab back some of the US domestic attention. This also distracts slightly from Israel’s ongoing war crimes, supported at the highest levels of government. The more shit happening, the less attention paid to Biden’s rapidly deteriorating chances of winning re-election (and of course his cognitive state). Someone – one or more of these Ukraine patrons among US/UK/NATO – is aiding them in carrying out these strikes.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:01 utc | 111

Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 14:55 utc | 16
Exactly. Using these systems piecemeal is a telltale sign of desperation. And I’ll add a domestic US political angle to this (and other similar) attack and future attacks to come: On some very real level, this is the tail wagging the dog. I don’t know exactly how the connections work, but Ukraine still has many patrons in the US “defense” complex, probably including high ranking employees of Raytheon and the like, lobbyists, politicians and deep-staters. They aren’t happy that all the attention has been shifted to Israel/Palestine and the US populace is a fickle bunch. There has been a dearth of reportage coming out of Ukraine even prior to the flare up in the ME, so it’s not completely due to the Hamas attacks and Israel’s massively asymmetrical “response.” Point being, “victories” like the strike on the Russian airfield will be leveraged to convince TPTB to keep sending the lucre. And there’s also a tail-wags-the-dog aspect. Ukraine will seek to grab back some of the US domestic attention. This also distracts slightly from Israel’s ongoing war crimes, supported at the highest levels of government. The more shit happening, the less attention paid to Biden’s rapidly deteriorating chances of winning re-election (and of course his cognitive state). Someone – one or more of these Ukraine patrons among US/UK/NATO – is aiding them in carrying out these strikes.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:01 utc | 112

Posted by: SlowSoft | Oct 17 2023 18:53 utc | 58
One hopes that the Russians have identified this launch site and setup techniques and a Kinzal or four smashes the next one before they can get off.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:03 utc | 113

Posted by: SlowSoft | Oct 17 2023 18:53 utc | 58
One hopes that the Russians have identified this launch site and setup techniques and a Kinzal or four smashes the next one before they can get off.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:03 utc | 114

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Oct 17 2023 18:19 utc | 50
Very interesting; thanks for the other angle on this. Then what of reports that ATACMS submunitions have been positively identified? Do HIMARS have submunitions?

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:06 utc | 115

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Oct 17 2023 18:19 utc | 50
Very interesting; thanks for the other angle on this. Then what of reports that ATACMS submunitions have been positively identified? Do HIMARS have submunitions?

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:06 utc | 116

@JamesBond | 33
It’s pretty much a cluster f*** at the moment. Both sides basically have everything they need. Drones, mines, satellite imagery (Uks from NATO), lots of artillery. We won’t see any big advances anytime soon.
What I hope is indeed that Ru inflicts as much damage to uke manpower as possible. It might be their only relevant option to break the deadlock.
I think your post comes closest to summing up the current state in Ukraine. The difference between Russia achieving maximalist goals and sufficient goals will be the ability of the Russian Army to conduct offensives. Still remains to be seen.

Posted by: danf51 | Oct 17 2023 19:15 utc | 117

@JamesBond | 33
It’s pretty much a cluster f*** at the moment. Both sides basically have everything they need. Drones, mines, satellite imagery (Uks from NATO), lots of artillery. We won’t see any big advances anytime soon.
What I hope is indeed that Ru inflicts as much damage to uke manpower as possible. It might be their only relevant option to break the deadlock.
I think your post comes closest to summing up the current state in Ukraine. The difference between Russia achieving maximalist goals and sufficient goals will be the ability of the Russian Army to conduct offensives. Still remains to be seen.

Posted by: danf51 | Oct 17 2023 19:15 utc | 118

Winter is coming. Ukraine better hope that it’s not a very cold one. Could be quite dark in Kiev and other cities in the west. I doubt they survive another winter with any morale intact. Which, to me, says there may be one or two major desperation attacks or even a falseflag.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:17 utc | 119

Winter is coming. Ukraine better hope that it’s not a very cold one. Could be quite dark in Kiev and other cities in the west. I doubt they survive another winter with any morale intact. Which, to me, says there may be one or two major desperation attacks or even a falseflag.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:17 utc | 120

Do HIMARS have submunitions?
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:06 utc | 61
https://www.army-technology.com/projects/himars/
”
Army tactical missile system (ATACMS)
HIMARS is capable of firing the long-range ATACMS (army tactical missile system) guided missile. The ATACMS family includes the Block I, Block IA and Block IA Unitary missiles. The Block I missile delivers 950 anti-personnel anti-material (AP/AM) baseball-sized M74 submunitions to ranges exceeding 165km.
The Block IA missile range exceeds 300km by reducing the submunition payload to 300 bomblets and adding GPS guidance. ”

Posted by: 600w | Oct 17 2023 19:18 utc | 121

Do HIMARS have submunitions?
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:06 utc | 61
https://www.army-technology.com/projects/himars/
”
Army tactical missile system (ATACMS)
HIMARS is capable of firing the long-range ATACMS (army tactical missile system) guided missile. The ATACMS family includes the Block I, Block IA and Block IA Unitary missiles. The Block I missile delivers 950 anti-personnel anti-material (AP/AM) baseball-sized M74 submunitions to ranges exceeding 165km.
The Block IA missile range exceeds 300km by reducing the submunition payload to 300 bomblets and adding GPS guidance. ”

Posted by: 600w | Oct 17 2023 19:18 utc | 122

Invitation for attacks
Strange russian Movement
https://t.me/CyberspecNews/45505
👉👉Ukrainian post
Defeat of Russian armoured column apparently near Novomikhailivka

Posted by: SlowSoft | Oct 17 2023 19:21 utc | 123

Invitation for attacks
Strange russian Movement
https://t.me/CyberspecNews/45505
👉👉Ukrainian post
Defeat of Russian armoured column apparently near Novomikhailivka

Posted by: SlowSoft | Oct 17 2023 19:21 utc | 124

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:03 utc | 60
The danger for Ukraine is that it’s one ATACMS per Himars, so three together, or they may have a remote firing capability, using deployable canisters.
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:01 utc | 59
A possible scenario, but it could also be a tacit admission that the war is ending, with manufacturers desperate to ‘test’ their systems against top-tier Russian equipment (previously they’d been used against second/third rate opponents). The Iskander is their main export rival and it’s bested the tier one Western AD systems, so perhaps this was a sales literature boost combat deployment.
Posted by: tesla | Oct 17 2023 18:41 utc | 54
That achieved what precisely, apart from, as one poster said, provide ‘batting practice’ for Russian operators and technicians. Weapons such as the ATACMS are classified by some as strategic missiles, their use is to be supporting wider operation, providing it with numerous force multipliers. Using it to strike individual targets with no operational context wastes 90% of its capability and therefore effectiveness, rather like using a chainsaw to split logs for firewood.

Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 19:42 utc | 125

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:03 utc | 60
The danger for Ukraine is that it’s one ATACMS per Himars, so three together, or they may have a remote firing capability, using deployable canisters.
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 19:01 utc | 59
A possible scenario, but it could also be a tacit admission that the war is ending, with manufacturers desperate to ‘test’ their systems against top-tier Russian equipment (previously they’d been used against second/third rate opponents). The Iskander is their main export rival and it’s bested the tier one Western AD systems, so perhaps this was a sales literature boost combat deployment.
Posted by: tesla | Oct 17 2023 18:41 utc | 54
That achieved what precisely, apart from, as one poster said, provide ‘batting practice’ for Russian operators and technicians. Weapons such as the ATACMS are classified by some as strategic missiles, their use is to be supporting wider operation, providing it with numerous force multipliers. Using it to strike individual targets with no operational context wastes 90% of its capability and therefore effectiveness, rather like using a chainsaw to split logs for firewood.

Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 19:42 utc | 126

Using it to strike individual targets with no operational context wastes 90% of its capability and therefore effectiveness, rather like using a chainsaw to split logs for firewood.
Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 19:42 utc | 66
For the small army Russia has there with limited resources and dumb generals it’s not a mistake. Also they have so many they can use them on any target, big or small, like they use regular himars. I’ve said in another thread, be happy this time they didn’t hit a city, an npp or a hospital using Gaza methods.

Posted by: rk | Oct 17 2023 19:54 utc | 127

Using it to strike individual targets with no operational context wastes 90% of its capability and therefore effectiveness, rather like using a chainsaw to split logs for firewood.
Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 19:42 utc | 66
For the small army Russia has there with limited resources and dumb generals it’s not a mistake. Also they have so many they can use them on any target, big or small, like they use regular himars. I’ve said in another thread, be happy this time they didn’t hit a city, an npp or a hospital using Gaza methods.

Posted by: rk | Oct 17 2023 19:54 utc | 128

Military summary was very insightful today.
-AFU landed marine troops across the Dniepr and made some drone strikes on the other side. No artillery strikes, possibly due to AFU having no more artillery across Dniepr in that area
-AFU launched attack on recently RUAF captured trenches west of Verbove and lost 7 tanks. It’s not known whether they regained any of the trenches
-RUAF is trying to exploit lack of AFU forces around Urozhaine area
-In Avdeevka, the assault has turned into a contest of staying power. RUAF gradually captures AFU edge areas and pounds their fortified structures
-NW of Avdeevka, RUAF has captured Dubovo-Vasylivka area, speculated 2 weeks ago but finally confirmed
-In Kupyansk the eastern most edge of that flank (Ivanivka) sees heavier clashes.
Now here’s the interesting part. Putin was not in China only for the Belt and road initiative and other multipolar projects. He was actually delivering a shopping list to China from the muslim world, with all the bits and pieces required to produce missiles and other weapons. Maybe they are starting to get finally serious of arming Israel’s neighbors.

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 17 2023 20:06 utc | 129

Military summary was very insightful today.
-AFU landed marine troops across the Dniepr and made some drone strikes on the other side. No artillery strikes, possibly due to AFU having no more artillery across Dniepr in that area
-AFU launched attack on recently RUAF captured trenches west of Verbove and lost 7 tanks. It’s not known whether they regained any of the trenches
-RUAF is trying to exploit lack of AFU forces around Urozhaine area
-In Avdeevka, the assault has turned into a contest of staying power. RUAF gradually captures AFU edge areas and pounds their fortified structures
-NW of Avdeevka, RUAF has captured Dubovo-Vasylivka area, speculated 2 weeks ago but finally confirmed
-In Kupyansk the eastern most edge of that flank (Ivanivka) sees heavier clashes.
Now here’s the interesting part. Putin was not in China only for the Belt and road initiative and other multipolar projects. He was actually delivering a shopping list to China from the muslim world, with all the bits and pieces required to produce missiles and other weapons. Maybe they are starting to get finally serious of arming Israel’s neighbors.

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 17 2023 20:06 utc | 130

It is laughable to call this attack “desperation” or “straw clutching”. The reality is this:
This is a conflict between Russia and Ukraine that is tightly moderated by the collective West and the United States in particular. It would be a big mistake to think than any actor in the US wishes to defeat (or even, seriously hurt) Russia. I think any critical observer completely understands by now that in a hypothetical scenario, the NATO is capable to defeat most of the Russian military in a matter of weeks without using WMDs and with acceptable collateral damage, because the performance of Russia in this war has shown how massive the gap between Russia and the collective NATO in all aspects – in technology, production capabilities and sheer manpower. But nobody needs this. Rather, actors in the US are more interested in ensuring that the war will continue for as long as it can, because it allows the American defence industry to earn considerably more profits, employ more people and test more innovative products. In order to ensure this, not only Russia is limited in using WMDs and causing significant civilian or infrastructure losses in Ukraine by promises of swift economical suffocation, Ukraine is also limited by the promise the Ukrainian government has made to not use the provided long-range weapons on the internationally recognized territory of Russia. The WW1-style “deadlock” we see on the front lines is completely artificial, and stems from the fact that Ukraine has no long-range weaponry of its own that is capable to hurt Russia’s logistics in any meaningful way. The effect the potential destruction of Russian logistics has been already observed in summer of 2022, when giving to Ukraine just 17 HIMARS systems with rockets with just 57 miles range, caused Russia to retreat from Kharkiv oblast and Kherson city. This disturbance of the equilibrium was not expected or desired by anyone in NATO. Now, this won’t happen again. Russian generals will eventually understand that expensive aircraft should be deployed in the operative range of Western long-range rockets, all main Russian logistic lines will be moved to internationally recognized territory of Russia that Ukraine is not capable to hit because of the promise, everything will stay the same for several years at least, the front line will be static, the men will get maimed and killed on both sides in the Ukrainian villages of the same names, and the American defence industry will continue to earn superprofits.
God bless America.
The attack in question was just a gentle push of the equilibrium in another direction.

Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 131

It is laughable to call this attack “desperation” or “straw clutching”. The reality is this:
This is a conflict between Russia and Ukraine that is tightly moderated by the collective West and the United States in particular. It would be a big mistake to think than any actor in the US wishes to defeat (or even, seriously hurt) Russia. I think any critical observer completely understands by now that in a hypothetical scenario, the NATO is capable to defeat most of the Russian military in a matter of weeks without using WMDs and with acceptable collateral damage, because the performance of Russia in this war has shown how massive the gap between Russia and the collective NATO in all aspects – in technology, production capabilities and sheer manpower. But nobody needs this. Rather, actors in the US are more interested in ensuring that the war will continue for as long as it can, because it allows the American defence industry to earn considerably more profits, employ more people and test more innovative products. In order to ensure this, not only Russia is limited in using WMDs and causing significant civilian or infrastructure losses in Ukraine by promises of swift economical suffocation, Ukraine is also limited by the promise the Ukrainian government has made to not use the provided long-range weapons on the internationally recognized territory of Russia. The WW1-style “deadlock” we see on the front lines is completely artificial, and stems from the fact that Ukraine has no long-range weaponry of its own that is capable to hurt Russia’s logistics in any meaningful way. The effect the potential destruction of Russian logistics has been already observed in summer of 2022, when giving to Ukraine just 17 HIMARS systems with rockets with just 57 miles range, caused Russia to retreat from Kharkiv oblast and Kherson city. This disturbance of the equilibrium was not expected or desired by anyone in NATO. Now, this won’t happen again. Russian generals will eventually understand that expensive aircraft should be deployed in the operative range of Western long-range rockets, all main Russian logistic lines will be moved to internationally recognized territory of Russia that Ukraine is not capable to hit because of the promise, everything will stay the same for several years at least, the front line will be static, the men will get maimed and killed on both sides in the Ukrainian villages of the same names, and the American defence industry will continue to earn superprofits.
God bless America.
The attack in question was just a gentle push of the equilibrium in another direction.

Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 132

Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
Bless your heart, if you really believe what you wrote the conclusion to the SMO is going to really confusticate you.
Posted by: rk | Oct 17 2023 19:54 utc | 68
If they have to use 18 to KO 2 helicopters they’ll run out pretty quick, (check out the numbers used in previous conflicts) I think total production ceased at just under 600 units total btw. Those stupid generals have destroyed the Ukrainian Army 2.5 times now, and if you think Himars is being used on infantry formations because they have an abundance, perhaps the epithet you directed toward the General staff fits closer to home.

Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 20:23 utc | 133

Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
Bless your heart, if you really believe what you wrote the conclusion to the SMO is going to really confusticate you.
Posted by: rk | Oct 17 2023 19:54 utc | 68
If they have to use 18 to KO 2 helicopters they’ll run out pretty quick, (check out the numbers used in previous conflicts) I think total production ceased at just under 600 units total btw. Those stupid generals have destroyed the Ukrainian Army 2.5 times now, and if you think Himars is being used on infantry formations because they have an abundance, perhaps the epithet you directed toward the General staff fits closer to home.

Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 20:23 utc | 134

Poor Zelensky. He would have gotten some press for the wonder weapon attack, maybe even an editorial about turning the tide. And then Bibi had to go and bomb a hospital. So nobody cares at all about how he destroyed 3-5 helicopters.

Posted by: Lex | Oct 17 2023 20:25 utc | 135

Poor Zelensky. He would have gotten some press for the wonder weapon attack, maybe even an editorial about turning the tide. And then Bibi had to go and bomb a hospital. So nobody cares at all about how he destroyed 3-5 helicopters.

Posted by: Lex | Oct 17 2023 20:25 utc | 136

Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
I doubt the US army, or the collective Nato for that matter could have defeated Ukraine from Russian position in February 2022. They would have gotten frustrated in the first months and turned Kiev into a parking lot like Israel, “the best spearhead of the west” is doing now, and they haven’t yet set foot in Gaza against inferior sub-human sandal men as they call it.
I think the US doctrine would have definitely led to the US air force getting slaughtered over Ukraine, and they would have impaled themselves on Avdeevka from the beginning.
Fortifications are a force multiplier, but only if you have troops to occupy them.
If Russia built 10 Avdeevka’s on, say, the Belarus border with Lithuania and Poland, and the border with Estonia, and the border with Finland, it would lead to Nato troops getting impaled.
Nato is only powerful through its air power, which in the case of Ukraine have been used more stand-off role. Of course, modern air defense reduces the opportunity to use aircraft WW2 style. Who has better and longer range stand-off weapons and gliding bombs, wins in this category. Also who has better air defense. Nato air force would not manage to do what their doctrine says against Russia.
Russia lost AD systems too, but they will eventually saturate all the important fronts, and learn from Ukraine against Nato.
I can’t agree with the notion that US army could beat the Russian army, at all. Send them to any front in Ukraine and see what happens. Not to say, US isn’t powerful, just they aren’t any sort of supermen. Russia has more than enough mobilization potential if Nato decides to attack it (they probably won’t, but you never know with ziocons).
Ukrainian logistic node is in Lwow and Rzeszow and trains still seem to run to Kiev shipping even heads of state. The truth is you can’t stop or hinder supplies to eastern Ukraine without cutting those rails and bridges (maybe even moot), but Ukraine has the most redundant rail system in the world due to generous Soviet infrastructure building, where everything was built with a safety multiplier of 10x. If US destroys one line, here are 9 others.
So your comparison is apples and oranges. Ukraine is just being used with no regard for its future as a state, and Russia doesn’t want to mindlessly take territory just for the heck of it, because then you need to feed and fund it.
US would probably have used a nuke against Kiev by now. Even in WW2 when they were at their strongest, they were very close to nuking Berlin, despite Red Army doing already 85% of the work.

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 17 2023 20:29 utc | 137

Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
I doubt the US army, or the collective Nato for that matter could have defeated Ukraine from Russian position in February 2022. They would have gotten frustrated in the first months and turned Kiev into a parking lot like Israel, “the best spearhead of the west” is doing now, and they haven’t yet set foot in Gaza against inferior sub-human sandal men as they call it.
I think the US doctrine would have definitely led to the US air force getting slaughtered over Ukraine, and they would have impaled themselves on Avdeevka from the beginning.
Fortifications are a force multiplier, but only if you have troops to occupy them.
If Russia built 10 Avdeevka’s on, say, the Belarus border with Lithuania and Poland, and the border with Estonia, and the border with Finland, it would lead to Nato troops getting impaled.
Nato is only powerful through its air power, which in the case of Ukraine have been used more stand-off role. Of course, modern air defense reduces the opportunity to use aircraft WW2 style. Who has better and longer range stand-off weapons and gliding bombs, wins in this category. Also who has better air defense. Nato air force would not manage to do what their doctrine says against Russia.
Russia lost AD systems too, but they will eventually saturate all the important fronts, and learn from Ukraine against Nato.
I can’t agree with the notion that US army could beat the Russian army, at all. Send them to any front in Ukraine and see what happens. Not to say, US isn’t powerful, just they aren’t any sort of supermen. Russia has more than enough mobilization potential if Nato decides to attack it (they probably won’t, but you never know with ziocons).
Ukrainian logistic node is in Lwow and Rzeszow and trains still seem to run to Kiev shipping even heads of state. The truth is you can’t stop or hinder supplies to eastern Ukraine without cutting those rails and bridges (maybe even moot), but Ukraine has the most redundant rail system in the world due to generous Soviet infrastructure building, where everything was built with a safety multiplier of 10x. If US destroys one line, here are 9 others.
So your comparison is apples and oranges. Ukraine is just being used with no regard for its future as a state, and Russia doesn’t want to mindlessly take territory just for the heck of it, because then you need to feed and fund it.
US would probably have used a nuke against Kiev by now. Even in WW2 when they were at their strongest, they were very close to nuking Berlin, despite Red Army doing already 85% of the work.

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 17 2023 20:29 utc | 138

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Oct 17 2023 18:19 utc | 50

18 missiles to destroy 9 helicopters,…

300 km from the border, how far to the battle line? Maybe 400km. Outbound flight and return flight 800 km. These are unimportant helicopters(80% unimportant), this are no combat helicopters.
But they could also be Mi 26 transport helicopters(20%).
9 Mi 26 helicopters, offline some weeks, would not be so good.

Posted by: theo | Oct 17 2023 20:39 utc | 139

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Oct 17 2023 18:19 utc | 50

18 missiles to destroy 9 helicopters,…

300 km from the border, how far to the battle line? Maybe 400km. Outbound flight and return flight 800 km. These are unimportant helicopters(80% unimportant), this are no combat helicopters.
But they could also be Mi 26 transport helicopters(20%).
9 Mi 26 helicopters, offline some weeks, would not be so good.

Posted by: theo | Oct 17 2023 20:39 utc | 140

Russia must also use cluster munitions against Ukrainian targets. So far Russian use of cluster munitions has been quite insignificant.
By disabling Russian aviation in attacked areas Ukraine seems to be trying a ground offensive in the east. Recent Russian air strikes crippled Ukie troops.

Posted by: Jason | Oct 17 2023 20:42 utc | 141

Russia must also use cluster munitions against Ukrainian targets. So far Russian use of cluster munitions has been quite insignificant.
By disabling Russian aviation in attacked areas Ukraine seems to be trying a ground offensive in the east. Recent Russian air strikes crippled Ukie troops.

Posted by: Jason | Oct 17 2023 20:42 utc | 142

@ unimperator, §73:
The US couldn´t have nuked Berlin. Germany surrendered on May 8th 1945.
The US didn´t even know the A-bomb would work until the ´Trinity´ test at Alamogordo on July 16th 1945.
Hiroshima got the real thing on August 6th 1945 and Nagasaki on August 9th 1945.

Posted by: John Marks | Oct 17 2023 20:49 utc | 143

@ unimperator, §73:
The US couldn´t have nuked Berlin. Germany surrendered on May 8th 1945.
The US didn´t even know the A-bomb would work until the ´Trinity´ test at Alamogordo on July 16th 1945.
Hiroshima got the real thing on August 6th 1945 and Nagasaki on August 9th 1945.

Posted by: John Marks | Oct 17 2023 20:49 utc | 144

Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
I always like a nice conspiracy theory but this story of yours is almost funny in how stereotypical it is of the well known american exceptionalism farce.
One thing you forgot: you will be breathing radioactive dust if NATO dared intervene directly, let alone “defeat” the RF in few weeks.

Posted by: alek_a | Oct 17 2023 20:54 utc | 145

Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
I always like a nice conspiracy theory but this story of yours is almost funny in how stereotypical it is of the well known american exceptionalism farce.
One thing you forgot: you will be breathing radioactive dust if NATO dared intervene directly, let alone “defeat” the RF in few weeks.

Posted by: alek_a | Oct 17 2023 20:54 utc | 146

Posted by: John Marks | Oct 17 2023 20:49 utc | 76
I agree other wise.
Let’s make a scenario where the D-Day landings failed miserably – say – due to the front in the east frozen for one or the other reason, leading to the bulk of Wehrmacht and Luftwaffe transferred to France. US/UK landings would get demolished and 3 years of preparations down the drain.
Now fast forward one and a half years to late 1945 – US has The Bomb and they are so frustrated that their Germany First strategy isn’t working out, and they see no prospect of making a new landing anytime soon. They bomb Berlin instead, that’s what would inevitably happen.

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 17 2023 20:55 utc | 147

Posted by: John Marks | Oct 17 2023 20:49 utc | 76
I agree other wise.
Let’s make a scenario where the D-Day landings failed miserably – say – due to the front in the east frozen for one or the other reason, leading to the bulk of Wehrmacht and Luftwaffe transferred to France. US/UK landings would get demolished and 3 years of preparations down the drain.
Now fast forward one and a half years to late 1945 – US has The Bomb and they are so frustrated that their Germany First strategy isn’t working out, and they see no prospect of making a new landing anytime soon. They bomb Berlin instead, that’s what would inevitably happen.

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 17 2023 20:55 utc | 148

It’s a shame the Russian government has muzzled Strelkov because his TG posts would have been highly entertaining over the past week. I’m not even thinking of the supposed ATACMS strikes (which we knew we’d see sooner or later) though I’m sure he’d have something to say about those as well. I’m primarily thinking of how he’d rip into the decision to headbutt against the Avdeevka area again.

Posted by: Mike314159 | Oct 17 2023 21:01 utc | 149

It’s a shame the Russian government has muzzled Strelkov because his TG posts would have been highly entertaining over the past week. I’m not even thinking of the supposed ATACMS strikes (which we knew we’d see sooner or later) though I’m sure he’d have something to say about those as well. I’m primarily thinking of how he’d rip into the decision to headbutt against the Avdeevka area again.

Posted by: Mike314159 | Oct 17 2023 21:01 utc | 150

Posted by: theo | Oct 17 2023 20:39 utc | 74

300 km from the border, …

I have think Briansk
my post#74 is trash 🙂

Posted by: theo | Oct 17 2023 21:06 utc | 151

Posted by: theo | Oct 17 2023 20:39 utc | 74

300 km from the border, …

I have think Briansk
my post#74 is trash 🙂

Posted by: theo | Oct 17 2023 21:06 utc | 152

Is it possible to think that Isreal is being used as a proxy also like ukraine. I am.in no way as educated in depth like the true thinkers here but my 20 years of military service tells me I am smelling bullshit. Isreal is doing this “look at poor me I’m.being bullied” cry cry cry. Yet the US as we suspect needs an off ramp but also gains if the Arabs fight each other to stop the BRICS multipolar scenario. I am just so confused to the evil going on today

Posted by: Scot1and | Oct 17 2023 21:07 utc | 153

Is it possible to think that Isreal is being used as a proxy also like ukraine. I am.in no way as educated in depth like the true thinkers here but my 20 years of military service tells me I am smelling bullshit. Isreal is doing this “look at poor me I’m.being bullied” cry cry cry. Yet the US as we suspect needs an off ramp but also gains if the Arabs fight each other to stop the BRICS multipolar scenario. I am just so confused to the evil going on today

Posted by: Scot1and | Oct 17 2023 21:07 utc | 154

I think any critical observer completely understands by now that in a hypothetical scenario, the NATO is capable to defeat most of the Russian military in a matter of weeks

No serious observer would say that. At least, noone who didn’t want to be laughed out of the room.
This war has shown Maerican military technologies are not fit for purpose, her doctrines outdated, her officers inexperinced. Her weaponry is at least a decade behind her competitors. It’s no wonder since she has spent the last several decades fighting counterinsurgencies (poorly one might add) against poorly armed militias with no air force.
Maerica and her propgandized, mesmerized populace has a bloated sense of her own might which any astute observers can see has been utterly devastated by her performance in Ukraine, as she hides behind her mutilated proxy.
I expect your analysis originates more from the patriotism you clearly still feel towards your Alma mater instead of any sober and realistic assessment of Maerican power. Maerica couldn’t win a war against Russia or China on their own … and certainly not against both.
Wake me up when Maerica gets planes that can fly more than 60% of the time. Or hypersonics. Or air defense worth the name. Or anything really other than a bloated defense industry high on its own supply of bullshit.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | Oct 17 2023 21:21 utc | 155

I think any critical observer completely understands by now that in a hypothetical scenario, the NATO is capable to defeat most of the Russian military in a matter of weeks

No serious observer would say that. At least, noone who didn’t want to be laughed out of the room.
This war has shown Maerican military technologies are not fit for purpose, her doctrines outdated, her officers inexperinced. Her weaponry is at least a decade behind her competitors. It’s no wonder since she has spent the last several decades fighting counterinsurgencies (poorly one might add) against poorly armed militias with no air force.
Maerica and her propgandized, mesmerized populace has a bloated sense of her own might which any astute observers can see has been utterly devastated by her performance in Ukraine, as she hides behind her mutilated proxy.
I expect your analysis originates more from the patriotism you clearly still feel towards your Alma mater instead of any sober and realistic assessment of Maerican power. Maerica couldn’t win a war against Russia or China on their own … and certainly not against both.
Wake me up when Maerica gets planes that can fly more than 60% of the time. Or hypersonics. Or air defense worth the name. Or anything really other than a bloated defense industry high on its own supply of bullshit.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | Oct 17 2023 21:21 utc | 156

Posted by: Jmaas | Oct 17 2023 14:33 utc | 9
Bold of you to assume the US was not also delusional, given that DC was convinced that every anti-colonial rebellion was swarming with russian spies and communists were hiding under their beds. Hell, the Soviet-Afghan war was, in America’s mind, “revenge for Vietnam” because Americans are so fucking insane they actually think the Vietnamese had zero reason to fight unless they were thralls to the Soviets.

Posted by: fsd | Oct 17 2023 21:23 utc | 157

Posted by: Jmaas | Oct 17 2023 14:33 utc | 9
Bold of you to assume the US was not also delusional, given that DC was convinced that every anti-colonial rebellion was swarming with russian spies and communists were hiding under their beds. Hell, the Soviet-Afghan war was, in America’s mind, “revenge for Vietnam” because Americans are so fucking insane they actually think the Vietnamese had zero reason to fight unless they were thralls to the Soviets.

Posted by: fsd | Oct 17 2023 21:23 utc | 158

God bless America.
Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
Just not it’s public school system which apparently failed to teach you the value of using paragraphs while composing ones literary offering. Among the benefits of said usage is that the targeted audience is far more likely to read what you write, screed or otherwise

Posted by: bubbles | Oct 17 2023 21:23 utc | 159

God bless America.
Posted by: AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
Just not it’s public school system which apparently failed to teach you the value of using paragraphs while composing ones literary offering. Among the benefits of said usage is that the targeted audience is far more likely to read what you write, screed or otherwise

Posted by: bubbles | Oct 17 2023 21:23 utc | 160

@ Posted by: John Marks | Oct 17 2023 20:49 utc | 76
Don’t confuse the revisionist history buffs with actual facts. I have tried, they just don’t listen.

Posted by: BroncoBilly | Oct 17 2023 21:32 utc | 161

@ Posted by: John Marks | Oct 17 2023 20:49 utc | 76
Don’t confuse the revisionist history buffs with actual facts. I have tried, they just don’t listen.

Posted by: BroncoBilly | Oct 17 2023 21:32 utc | 162

I think missing from this thread are warnings from Russian officials about commercial space assets being designated as targets.
O/T, but has anyone contemplated a false flag attack (blamed on Hezbollah) on the juicy targets the 2 US carrier groups have provided for Israel to drag the US into the ME conflict?
Won’t be the first time Israel attacked a US warship or the US…

Posted by: Suresh | Oct 17 2023 21:45 utc | 163

I think missing from this thread are warnings from Russian officials about commercial space assets being designated as targets.
O/T, but has anyone contemplated a false flag attack (blamed on Hezbollah) on the juicy targets the 2 US carrier groups have provided for Israel to drag the US into the ME conflict?
Won’t be the first time Israel attacked a US warship or the US…

Posted by: Suresh | Oct 17 2023 21:45 utc | 164

I am just so confused to the evil going on today
Posted by: Scot1and | Oct 17 2023 21:07 utc | 81
If it’s any consolation, you’re not alone. One might see current events in a prism of ‘good vs. evil’, a much discussed topic in religious circles. Unfortunately even in that realm they rarely agree as to who is good, and who is evil. Curious that a core problem the world faces now, once again involves the Abrahamic religions, or versions thereof.
Especially difficult for those with significant military background to grasp imho.
Their’s not to reason why
Their’s but to do and die
I remember the words of Rodney King after he was savagely beaten by LA police for no good reason.
“Can’t we all just get along?”
Apparently not, the messianic, the greedy and psychopaths won’t allow it.
So we fight because the TV tells us those folks are bad folks, and we are good folks..
Tune in at 6 for the latest booster shot of conviction.

Posted by: bubbles | Oct 17 2023 21:54 utc | 165

I am just so confused to the evil going on today
Posted by: Scot1and | Oct 17 2023 21:07 utc | 81
If it’s any consolation, you’re not alone. One might see current events in a prism of ‘good vs. evil’, a much discussed topic in religious circles. Unfortunately even in that realm they rarely agree as to who is good, and who is evil. Curious that a core problem the world faces now, once again involves the Abrahamic religions, or versions thereof.
Especially difficult for those with significant military background to grasp imho.
Their’s not to reason why
Their’s but to do and die
I remember the words of Rodney King after he was savagely beaten by LA police for no good reason.
“Can’t we all just get along?”
Apparently not, the messianic, the greedy and psychopaths won’t allow it.
So we fight because the TV tells us those folks are bad folks, and we are good folks..
Tune in at 6 for the latest booster shot of conviction.

Posted by: bubbles | Oct 17 2023 21:54 utc | 166

From RWA Twitter

“When some of our hotheads demanded: ‘…wipe out entire city blocks, show no mercy, bomb them with huge bombs…’ – keep in mind that the world would have looked at us just as it looks at Israel now.
Some will say: they look at us like that anyway.
No.
They don’t look at us like that.
And, by the way, today’s spectacular photos of Vladimir Putin in the midst of real world leaders confirm this.
We managed to fight for almost two years, take cities, hit the most complex targets, and not deliver a single blow like that.
Glory to Mother Russia. Glory to her sensible rulers. Glory to her kind people. Thank you, Lord, that we didn’t become savages.”
-Zakhar Prilepin

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 21:58 utc | 167

From RWA Twitter

“When some of our hotheads demanded: ‘…wipe out entire city blocks, show no mercy, bomb them with huge bombs…’ – keep in mind that the world would have looked at us just as it looks at Israel now.
Some will say: they look at us like that anyway.
No.
They don’t look at us like that.
And, by the way, today’s spectacular photos of Vladimir Putin in the midst of real world leaders confirm this.
We managed to fight for almost two years, take cities, hit the most complex targets, and not deliver a single blow like that.
Glory to Mother Russia. Glory to her sensible rulers. Glory to her kind people. Thank you, Lord, that we didn’t become savages.”
-Zakhar Prilepin

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 21:58 utc | 168

“What the Zionist criminal forces carried out in the 🇵🇸 Baptist Hospital [Al Ahli Arab Hospital] constitutes one of the most heinous massacres against humanity….
This heinous crime only reminds us of the crimes of this entity that was established and founded on massacres.”
-The Lion of Syria, Bashar Al-Assad

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 22:00 utc | 169

“What the Zionist criminal forces carried out in the 🇵🇸 Baptist Hospital [Al Ahli Arab Hospital] constitutes one of the most heinous massacres against humanity….
This heinous crime only reminds us of the crimes of this entity that was established and founded on massacres.”
-The Lion of Syria, Bashar Al-Assad

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 22:00 utc | 170

Apologies for posting in the wrong thread. 🫢

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 22:04 utc | 171

Apologies for posting in the wrong thread. 🫢

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 22:04 utc | 172

Apologies for posting in the wrong thread. 🫢
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 22:04 utc | 90

It was worth repeating. 😀

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 17 2023 22:08 utc | 173

Apologies for posting in the wrong thread. 🫢
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 22:04 utc | 90

It was worth repeating. 😀

Posted by: malenkov | Oct 17 2023 22:08 utc | 174

Ukrainian forces have a breakthrough in the Kherson direction

Kherson direction: breakthrough of the Armed Forces of Ukraine to Peschanivka,
situation to the end on October 17, 2023
🔻In the afternoon, two assault groups of the 35th and 36th Marine Brigades of the Ukrainian Navy, after regrouping, continued the attack along the railway bridge. As a result of the breakthrough, with the support of artillery and FPV drones, the Marines were able to occupy the village of Poyma .
▪️There, enemy units took up a perimeter defense, and after reinforcements arrived, they reached the northern outskirts of Peschanivka . According to some reports, several houses on the northern outskirts were occupied by Ukrainian formations.
▪️Artillery was intensively used in the areas where the Ukrainian Armed Forces were located, which is why the Ukrainian Armed Forces suffered losses. Some of the seriously wounded were evacuated to the northern part of the island. But nevertheless, the situation in Poyma and Peschanivka now remains a mystery due to the “fog of war.”
🔻At the same time, on the opposite side, near Sadovoy and Pridneprovsky , the 501st and 1st battalions of the 36th infantry brigade (up to 300 people) are preparing to cross the Dnieper , whose task is to capture Peschanivka and reach Podstepnoye .
▪️At the same time, to the north of the Kozatsky and Melky islands, several more assault groups of the Ukrainian Navy are preparing to attack the Cossack Camps – Krynki line . All day on October 17, weapons and ammunition were transferred from the Ingulets area .
❗️The tactical success of the assault detachments of the 36th brigade creates the preconditions for a more active entry of the Katran strike group into battles in the Kherson direction .
This is indirectly confirmed by the movement of counter-battery weapons to the contact line, such as the Cobra and AN/TPQ-36 radars, as well as Bukovel electronic warfare stations, which, as a rule, are kept at a distance because of their value.
And the question arises: how was such a breakthrough allowed to reach two populated areas? We wrote for several months that there is a bridgehead of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in the island zone and in some areas of the left bank of the Dnieper, but no measures were taken. I would like to believe that the threat will now be taken more seriously.

Posted by: MiniMO | Oct 17 2023 22:26 utc | 175

Ukrainian forces have a breakthrough in the Kherson direction

Kherson direction: breakthrough of the Armed Forces of Ukraine to Peschanivka,
situation to the end on October 17, 2023
🔻In the afternoon, two assault groups of the 35th and 36th Marine Brigades of the Ukrainian Navy, after regrouping, continued the attack along the railway bridge. As a result of the breakthrough, with the support of artillery and FPV drones, the Marines were able to occupy the village of Poyma .
▪️There, enemy units took up a perimeter defense, and after reinforcements arrived, they reached the northern outskirts of Peschanivka . According to some reports, several houses on the northern outskirts were occupied by Ukrainian formations.
▪️Artillery was intensively used in the areas where the Ukrainian Armed Forces were located, which is why the Ukrainian Armed Forces suffered losses. Some of the seriously wounded were evacuated to the northern part of the island. But nevertheless, the situation in Poyma and Peschanivka now remains a mystery due to the “fog of war.”
🔻At the same time, on the opposite side, near Sadovoy and Pridneprovsky , the 501st and 1st battalions of the 36th infantry brigade (up to 300 people) are preparing to cross the Dnieper , whose task is to capture Peschanivka and reach Podstepnoye .
▪️At the same time, to the north of the Kozatsky and Melky islands, several more assault groups of the Ukrainian Navy are preparing to attack the Cossack Camps – Krynki line . All day on October 17, weapons and ammunition were transferred from the Ingulets area .
❗️The tactical success of the assault detachments of the 36th brigade creates the preconditions for a more active entry of the Katran strike group into battles in the Kherson direction .
This is indirectly confirmed by the movement of counter-battery weapons to the contact line, such as the Cobra and AN/TPQ-36 radars, as well as Bukovel electronic warfare stations, which, as a rule, are kept at a distance because of their value.
And the question arises: how was such a breakthrough allowed to reach two populated areas? We wrote for several months that there is a bridgehead of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in the island zone and in some areas of the left bank of the Dnieper, but no measures were taken. I would like to believe that the threat will now be taken more seriously.

Posted by: MiniMO | Oct 17 2023 22:26 utc | 176

-The Lion of Syria, Bashar Al-Assad
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 22:00 utc | 89
Assad appears to be very different to Western leaders. Foremost, he couldn’t be bought off. Maduro is similar, but he lacked the extraordinary charisma of Chavez. Maybe the vultures in Washington thought Guido was more charismatic? But above all, they had a score to settle on behalf of their Giant Oil Co’s, so that’s all that really matters.
See recent news of US lawfare re: Citgo. Final synopsis; We stole it fair and square for our Corporations, the American way.

Posted by: bubbles | Oct 17 2023 22:33 utc | 177

-The Lion of Syria, Bashar Al-Assad
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Oct 17 2023 22:00 utc | 89
Assad appears to be very different to Western leaders. Foremost, he couldn’t be bought off. Maduro is similar, but he lacked the extraordinary charisma of Chavez. Maybe the vultures in Washington thought Guido was more charismatic? But above all, they had a score to settle on behalf of their Giant Oil Co’s, so that’s all that really matters.
See recent news of US lawfare re: Citgo. Final synopsis; We stole it fair and square for our Corporations, the American way.

Posted by: bubbles | Oct 17 2023 22:33 utc | 178

Interview of Serguei Karaganov, October 2023 (In French).
One year ago, msm reported that Karaganov was threatening Europe of a nuclear war.
From the interview, I think that it is not exactly what he says.
For him, European young leaders have a low cultural level and they are no more afraid of nuclear dissuasion.
Russia should change its current doctrine concerning nuclear usage to be more dissuasive.
This is the way to make these young leaders understand and prevent a nuclear war.
For Karaganov, in case of a nuclear war in Europe, USA will not intervene.
https://reseauinternational.net/dissuasion-nucleaire-la-bascule/

Posted by: FromFrance | Oct 17 2023 22:36 utc | 179

Interview of Serguei Karaganov, October 2023 (In French).
One year ago, msm reported that Karaganov was threatening Europe of a nuclear war.
From the interview, I think that it is not exactly what he says.
For him, European young leaders have a low cultural level and they are no more afraid of nuclear dissuasion.
Russia should change its current doctrine concerning nuclear usage to be more dissuasive.
This is the way to make these young leaders understand and prevent a nuclear war.
For Karaganov, in case of a nuclear war in Europe, USA will not intervene.
https://reseauinternational.net/dissuasion-nucleaire-la-bascule/

Posted by: FromFrance | Oct 17 2023 22:36 utc | 180

@ AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
Your copium is hilarious.

Posted by: Figleaf23 | Oct 17 2023 22:52 utc | 181

@ AI_Avenger | Oct 17 2023 20:07 utc | 70
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
Your copium is hilarious.

Posted by: Figleaf23 | Oct 17 2023 22:52 utc | 182

I think AI_Avenger is maybe trying to be comical? Feeding NATO prop into one of the chat bots and posting here? God Bless America kind of gave it away for me.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 22:57 utc | 183

I think AI_Avenger is maybe trying to be comical? Feeding NATO prop into one of the chat bots and posting here? God Bless America kind of gave it away for me.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Oct 17 2023 22:57 utc | 184

Posted by: MiniMO | Oct 17 2023 22:26 utc | 92
I guess they’re trying to repeat the success of the 100+ day offensive, this time without any armoured support and most of the artillery stuck on the far bank. Lots of Telegram Chicken Little’s squawking, it’s almost as though someone’s coordinating them.
Just for a bit of historical perspective, river/maritime assaults have always been risky propositions, not only due to the inherent risks involved but also due to the density of the troops in the bridgeheads they create, which is why they need to be quickly reinforced and expanded. Without any mechanised units though, these troops will find that a hard proposition. If the Ukrainians don’t immediately expand their perimeter this move is once again a PR move designed to keep the West engaged.
Posted by: theo | Oct 17 2023 20:39 utc | 74
True, but the Russians knew the Ukrainians had the system so keeping strategically valuable assets within its range (a known quantity) would work against their contingent planning models. I wonder if any were decoys though, I doubt the Russians unlearned the lessons of the Serbian conflict and the dangers of only relying on electro-optical systems for recce and BDA.

Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 23:00 utc | 185

Posted by: MiniMO | Oct 17 2023 22:26 utc | 92
I guess they’re trying to repeat the success of the 100+ day offensive, this time without any armoured support and most of the artillery stuck on the far bank. Lots of Telegram Chicken Little’s squawking, it’s almost as though someone’s coordinating them.
Just for a bit of historical perspective, river/maritime assaults have always been risky propositions, not only due to the inherent risks involved but also due to the density of the troops in the bridgeheads they create, which is why they need to be quickly reinforced and expanded. Without any mechanised units though, these troops will find that a hard proposition. If the Ukrainians don’t immediately expand their perimeter this move is once again a PR move designed to keep the West engaged.
Posted by: theo | Oct 17 2023 20:39 utc | 74
True, but the Russians knew the Ukrainians had the system so keeping strategically valuable assets within its range (a known quantity) would work against their contingent planning models. I wonder if any were decoys though, I doubt the Russians unlearned the lessons of the Serbian conflict and the dangers of only relying on electro-optical systems for recce and BDA.

Posted by: Milites | Oct 17 2023 23:00 utc | 186

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | Oct 17 2023 17:37 utc | 41
I agree w all you say,yet….
American lives lost vs Russian speaking slav lives lost
This is a win. Dont forget alot of them (westerners) dont see it yet, and the leadership wont suffer consequences just the lowest 90% will

Posted by: Tannenhouser | Oct 17 2023 23:16 utc | 187

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | Oct 17 2023 17:37 utc | 41
I agree w all you say,yet….
American lives lost vs Russian speaking slav lives lost
This is a win. Dont forget alot of them (westerners) dont see it yet, and the leadership wont suffer consequences just the lowest 90% will

Posted by: Tannenhouser | Oct 17 2023 23:16 utc | 188

2. Ukrophiles have been talking up how they devastated Russian at Avdeevka by using minefields and drone spotted artillery. Anyone know if this is true? Both Russian and Ukraine claim to thwart attacks using this method. How will tactics change as a result of this war. It looks like mine clearing technology is a must.
Posted by: Christian J Chuba | Oct 17 2023 16:36 utc | 31

Echoes of WW1 where reconnaissance and spotting were provided (not in real time) by early string bag flying machines. I guess soon we will soo

2. Ukrophiles have been talking up how they devastated Russian at Avdeevka by using minefields and drone spotted artillery. Anyone know if this is true? Both Russian and Ukraine claim to thwart attacks using this method. How will tactics change as a result of this war. It looks like mine clearing technology is a must.
Posted by: Christian J Chuba | Oct 17 2023 16:36 utc | 31

Echoes of WW1 where reconnaissance and spotting were provided (not in real time) by early string bag flying machines. I guess soon we will soon see drone on drone dogfights.
n see drone on drone dogfights.

Posted by: ChatNPC | Oct 17 2023 23:35 utc | 189

2. Ukrophiles have been talking up how they devastated Russian at Avdeevka by using minefields and drone spotted artillery. Anyone know if this is true? Both Russian and Ukraine claim to thwart attacks using this method. How will tactics change as a result of this war. It looks like mine clearing technology is a must.
Posted by: Christian J Chuba | Oct 17 2023 16:36 utc | 31

Echoes of WW1 where reconnaissance and spotting were provided (not in real time) by early string bag flying machines. I guess soon we will soo

2. Ukrophiles have been talking up how they devastated Russian at Avdeevka by using minefields and drone spotted artillery. Anyone know if this is true? Both Russian and Ukraine claim to thwart attacks using this method. How will tactics change as a result of this war. It looks like mine clearing technology is a must.
Posted by: Christian J Chuba | Oct 17 2023 16:36 utc | 31

Echoes of WW1 where reconnaissance and spotting were provided (not in real time) by early string bag flying machines. I guess soon we will soon see drone on drone dogfights.
n see drone on drone dogfights.

Posted by: ChatNPC | Oct 17 2023 23:35 utc | 190

Two things:
1) The casus belli is irrelevant. The battle is for the World Basket, of which Russia, Ukraine and Israel are a part of. It is win or be destroyed; the ultimate rulers of the planet are squaring off.
2) Is it possible that Russia has already been strategically defeated? A sick Europe is on their backs, and the USA can sit back, oceans away, while Russia has to deal it. The destruction of Nordstream shows that the U.S. doesn’t have to run faster than the bear, one just has to shoot Germany in the leg so the bear has to deal with it.
I am no Russophobe, but the reluctance of Russia to close the door means it can’t. It seems that it is capable militarily, so Russia knows its been had and that there will be direct conflict with NATO; Russia is prepping for global war.

Posted by: ICPtasking | Oct 17 2023 23:53 utc | 191

Two things:
1) The casus belli is irrelevant. The battle is for the World Basket, of which Russia, Ukraine and Israel are a part of. It is win or be destroyed; the ultimate rulers of the planet are squaring off.
2) Is it possible that Russia has already been strategically defeated? A sick Europe is on their backs, and the USA can sit back, oceans away, while Russia has to deal it. The destruction of Nordstream shows that the U.S. doesn’t have to run faster than the bear, one just has to shoot Germany in the leg so the bear has to deal with it.
I am no Russophobe, but the reluctance of Russia to close the door means it can’t. It seems that it is capable militarily, so Russia knows its been had and that there will be direct conflict with NATO; Russia is prepping for global war.

Posted by: ICPtasking | Oct 17 2023 23:53 utc | 192

I am no Russophobe, but the reluctance of Russia to close the door means it can’t. It seems that it is capable militarily, so Russia knows its been had and that there will be direct conflict with NATO; Russia is prepping for global war.
Posted by: ICPtasking | Oct 17 2023 23:53 utc | 100
Do you prefer a crystal ball or tarot cards?

Posted by: bubbles | Oct 18 2023 0:15 utc | 193

I am no Russophobe, but the reluctance of Russia to close the door means it can’t. It seems that it is capable militarily, so Russia knows its been had and that there will be direct conflict with NATO; Russia is prepping for global war.
Posted by: ICPtasking | Oct 17 2023 23:53 utc | 100
Do you prefer a crystal ball or tarot cards?

Posted by: bubbles | Oct 18 2023 0:15 utc | 194

Milites 17
One War, Ukraine and Gaza, with one adversary, USUKIS . Thank you , Blighty for showing your face. It will be easier now for RoW 87% to focus where, who and why they need to strike.

Posted by: Giyane | Oct 18 2023 0:19 utc | 195

Milites 17
One War, Ukraine and Gaza, with one adversary, USUKIS . Thank you , Blighty for showing your face. It will be easier now for RoW 87% to focus where, who and why they need to strike.

Posted by: Giyane | Oct 18 2023 0:19 utc | 196

2) Is it possible that Russia has already been strategically defeated? A sick Europe is on their backs, and the USA can sit back, oceans away, while Russia has to deal it. The destruction of Nordstream shows that the U.S. doesn’t have to run faster than the bear, one just has to shoot Germany in the leg so the bear has to deal with it.
I am no Russophobe, but the reluctance of Russia to close the door means it can’t. It seems that it is capable militarily, so Russia knows its been had and that there will be direct conflict with NATO; Russia is prepping for global war.
Posted by: ICPtasking | Oct 17 2023 23:53 utc | 100
There are multiple factors that go into war-making. Remember that Russia wants to absorb these territories eventually, so the more they destroy the more they will have to rebuild. Taking it slow doesn’t mean they’re losing.
Secondly, how will there be any direct conflict with NATO? NATO had multiple times to bring Ukraine into the alliance, which would create the conditions for direct conflict, but they didn’t do that. Now almost two years into the war and NATO support is clearly waning.
Russia has shown restraint and it is paying off. Russia’s not going win this war on your timeline, it will win the war on its own timeline. And win it will, and NATO, Europe, and the US will have to accept that new reality.

Posted by: James M. | Oct 18 2023 0:53 utc | 197

2) Is it possible that Russia has already been strategically defeated? A sick Europe is on their backs, and the USA can sit back, oceans away, while Russia has to deal it. The destruction of Nordstream shows that the U.S. doesn’t have to run faster than the bear, one just has to shoot Germany in the leg so the bear has to deal with it.
I am no Russophobe, but the reluctance of Russia to close the door means it can’t. It seems that it is capable militarily, so Russia knows its been had and that there will be direct conflict with NATO; Russia is prepping for global war.
Posted by: ICPtasking | Oct 17 2023 23:53 utc | 100
There are multiple factors that go into war-making. Remember that Russia wants to absorb these territories eventually, so the more they destroy the more they will have to rebuild. Taking it slow doesn’t mean they’re losing.
Secondly, how will there be any direct conflict with NATO? NATO had multiple times to bring Ukraine into the alliance, which would create the conditions for direct conflict, but they didn’t do that. Now almost two years into the war and NATO support is clearly waning.
Russia has shown restraint and it is paying off. Russia’s not going win this war on your timeline, it will win the war on its own timeline. And win it will, and NATO, Europe, and the US will have to accept that new reality.

Posted by: James M. | Oct 18 2023 0:53 utc | 198

I haven’t read a single “expert” or pundit offer a simple point about sanctions.
Every year, to qualify as a Federal contractor, you have to swear that you don’t do business with Sudan or Iran or get bricks from Burma. It’s a long list.
Eventually,the US sanctions so many nations for so many things that they hit a critical mass in which the Sanctioned World doesn’t need anything from the US. They can trade among themselves, both resources and finished goods, while an angry Federal gov. isolates itself from the Rest Of The Earth.
The failure of sanctions on Russia happened because of their high degree of autarky. Now, they help Iran and Congress demands (today) more sanctions. And they can’t stop.

Posted by: Eighthman | Oct 18 2023 1:15 utc | 199

I haven’t read a single “expert” or pundit offer a simple point about sanctions.
Every year, to qualify as a Federal contractor, you have to swear that you don’t do business with Sudan or Iran or get bricks from Burma. It’s a long list.
Eventually,the US sanctions so many nations for so many things that they hit a critical mass in which the Sanctioned World doesn’t need anything from the US. They can trade among themselves, both resources and finished goods, while an angry Federal gov. isolates itself from the Rest Of The Earth.
The failure of sanctions on Russia happened because of their high degree of autarky. Now, they help Iran and Congress demands (today) more sanctions. And they can’t stop.

Posted by: Eighthman | Oct 18 2023 1:15 utc | 200