Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
September 28, 2023
China’s ‘Shared Future’

The U.S. fears that China's growth will lead to a competition between the countries over hegemony on earth.

But China rejects hegemony. No only the one the U.S. is obviously trying to achieve but, more general, also for itself.

Yesterday the Global Times editorial pointed to a new guideline paper issued by China's State Council:

On September 26, China's State Council Information Office released a white paper titled "A Global Community of Shared Future: China's Proposals and Actions." Against the backdrop of the 10th anniversary of President Xi Jinping's proposal of building a global community of shared future, China has introduced the theoretical base, practice and development of a global community of shared future, and points the way toward a better future for the world. Anyone, be they are developing countries seeking to learn from China or individuals from Western countries who are interested in gaining a deeper understanding of China, will find inspiration in it as long as they approach it without biased views.
…
Human society is now facing a "life-or-death choice:" whether to enter into a vicious cycle of continuous confrontation and division or to seek a path of cooperation and win-win, ultimately allowing more than 7 billion people to have a better life. The whole world is searching for answers. This also confirms the highly prescient and forward-looking nature of the concept of a global community of shared future.
…
Today's world has become a community of shared future, with countries riding together on a ship of shared fate. A small boat cannot withstand the wind and waves, only a giant vessel can withstand the stormy seas. No matter how powerful a country may be, it cannot dominate the world alone and must engage in global cooperation.

As the white paper says, "This is an integrated world. Those who turn their back on it will have no place in it." In such a world, the true power that transcends time is contained in the silent and subtle ideas, just like the practical greatness demonstrated by the concept of global community of shared future.

The paper is available here.

It is 22,000 words long but quite readable. It is a recipe for a just and equalitarian world that will peacefully develop for everyone while allowing for a diversity of cultures and ideologies. It is thus building on China's decade old concept of a Community of Common Destiny for Mankind.

The most interesting part is probably this paragraph:

There is no iron law that dictates that a rising power will inevitably seek hegemony. This assumption represents typical hegemonic thinking and is grounded in memories of catastrophic wars between hegemonic powers in the past. China has never accepted that once a country becomes strong enough, it will invariably seek hegemony. China understands the lesson of history – that hegemony preludes decline. We pursue development and revitalization through our own efforts, rather than invasion or expansion. And everything we do is for the purpose of providing a better life for our people, all the while creating more development opportunities for the entire world, not in order to supersede or subjugate others.

Other strategic statements by China, like the one issued in 2013 that laid the ground for its Belt and Road program, had been dismissed when they were issued. But the record shows that China acts on such programs exactly as its papers promise to do. It profits from doing so.

Is its thesis in this new paper, that hegemony preludes decline, valid?

Should we therefore trust its claims that it rejects hegemony, not only of others but also for itself?

Comments

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 28 2023 23:10 utc | 232
“A simple example: the British Channel Islands are much, much closer to France than they are to England, but there is no question that sovereignty over those islands lies with the UK.”
I guess you were never taught about the centuries of wars between Britain and France?? Guess who got to keep the islands since winning the last one. Had Napoleon won in Waterloo… they’d likely be French today. Had Germany won WW2 they’d be theirs. Get the point?
“China isn’t claiming the “waters” within that dashed line.
They are claiming sovereignty over the islands that lie within that dashed line.”
Try telling that to the local fishermen. If you own the land, you own the water that surrounds it. Pretty self explanatory that one.
Focus on facts, and worry less about people’s ‘intentions’.

Posted by: Rubiconned | Sep 29 2023 8:04 utc | 601

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 28 2023 23:10 utc | 232
“A simple example: the British Channel Islands are much, much closer to France than they are to England, but there is no question that sovereignty over those islands lies with the UK.”
I guess you were never taught about the centuries of wars between Britain and France?? Guess who got to keep the islands since winning the last one. Had Napoleon won in Waterloo… they’d likely be French today. Had Germany won WW2 they’d be theirs. Get the point?
“China isn’t claiming the “waters” within that dashed line.
They are claiming sovereignty over the islands that lie within that dashed line.”
Try telling that to the local fishermen. If you own the land, you own the water that surrounds it. Pretty self explanatory that one.
Focus on facts, and worry less about people’s ‘intentions’.

Posted by: Rubiconned | Sep 29 2023 8:04 utc | 602

@253 Lysias
“If Tibet was a rebel province of China to which China had a right, that presumably means that Ireland was a rebel province of Britain to which Britain had a right.”
Prior to 1919 Ireland was not a “rebel province of Britain” (actually, the United Kingdom, but no matter) because until that date the “provincial government” in Ireland pledged its allegience to the Crown.
So prior to 1919 Ireland wasn’t a “rebel province of the UK”, it was a province that was gripped by an insurrection.
But in 1919 Sinn Féin was elected to that government and then unilaterally declared independence, at which point Ireland did indeed go from being a province in the grip of an insurrection to become a rebel province of the UK.
It remained that until 1921 when the Anglo-Irish Treaty was signed, at which point “Eire” became an independent country and “Northern Ireland” remained as a province of the UK, albeit one that was still wracked by insurrection.
Which is why PRIOR to 1921 the UK’s full title was “The United Kingdom of England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland” and AFTER 1921 its full title was “The United Kingdom of England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland”, and it remains that way to this very day.
This is all news to you, is it?
A country can consist of provinces which acknowledge the sovereignty of the central government.
Some provinces can be happy and content about that arrangement, some can be wracked by insurrection.
Sometimes the insurrectionists form the provincial government, at which point it becomes a “rebel province”
Less often they win, and the central government signs a treaty recognizing their independence.
Hardly rocket-science, and the only wrinkle with respect to the UK is that those “provinces” are really countries in their own right (as in: that’s why it is a “United Kingdom”).

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 8:28 utc | 603

@253 Lysias
“If Tibet was a rebel province of China to which China had a right, that presumably means that Ireland was a rebel province of Britain to which Britain had a right.”
Prior to 1919 Ireland was not a “rebel province of Britain” (actually, the United Kingdom, but no matter) because until that date the “provincial government” in Ireland pledged its allegience to the Crown.
So prior to 1919 Ireland wasn’t a “rebel province of the UK”, it was a province that was gripped by an insurrection.
But in 1919 Sinn Féin was elected to that government and then unilaterally declared independence, at which point Ireland did indeed go from being a province in the grip of an insurrection to become a rebel province of the UK.
It remained that until 1921 when the Anglo-Irish Treaty was signed, at which point “Eire” became an independent country and “Northern Ireland” remained as a province of the UK, albeit one that was still wracked by insurrection.
Which is why PRIOR to 1921 the UK’s full title was “The United Kingdom of England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland” and AFTER 1921 its full title was “The United Kingdom of England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland”, and it remains that way to this very day.
This is all news to you, is it?
A country can consist of provinces which acknowledge the sovereignty of the central government.
Some provinces can be happy and content about that arrangement, some can be wracked by insurrection.
Sometimes the insurrectionists form the provincial government, at which point it becomes a “rebel province”
Less often they win, and the central government signs a treaty recognizing their independence.
Hardly rocket-science, and the only wrinkle with respect to the UK is that those “provinces” are really countries in their own right (as in: that’s why it is a “United Kingdom”).

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 8:28 utc | 604

Posted by: Shocked | Sep 28 2023 22:18 utc | 222
Good question about intended result.
It’s difficult to answer. Sometimes I have the sensations that West/USA acts out of impulse and with quite a bit of ‘wishful thinking’.
War in Ukraine seems a confirmation to me.

Posted by: Mario | Sep 29 2023 8:37 utc | 605

Posted by: Shocked | Sep 28 2023 22:18 utc | 222
Good question about intended result.
It’s difficult to answer. Sometimes I have the sensations that West/USA acts out of impulse and with quite a bit of ‘wishful thinking’.
War in Ukraine seems a confirmation to me.

Posted by: Mario | Sep 29 2023 8:37 utc | 606

@299 Rubiconned “I guess you were never taught about the centuries of wars between Britain and France??”
Yeah, it’s called “history” for a reason, you know….
“Guess who got to keep the islands since winning the last one.”
I don’t need to guess, dude.
“Had Napoleon won in Waterloo… they’d likely be French today.”
And if pigs could fly we’d all need to carry umbrellas when we go outside.
Because I’m telling you now that discussing how territory changed hands in 1812 via conquest is about as relevant to questions of sovereignty in the 21st century as is a discussion regarding the resolutely Earth-bound nature of cloven-hoofed animals.
“Try telling that to the local fishermen. If you own the land, you own the water that surrounds it. Pretty self explanatory that one.”
*sigh*. You are the person who first brought up the nine-dashed line, but it appears that you have never actually looked at it.
Do so now. Note the islands. Note that if everyone were to accept the Chinese claim to sovereignty over those islands – a thought experiment, if you like – then you’d be able to draw lines around each of those islands to the universally-acknowledged 12 nautical mile limit of territorial waters.
Do that, and then compare the waters enclosed by THOSE lines to the waters enclosed by the nine-dash line.
They. Do. Not. Remotely. Coincide. With. Each. Other.
China is NOT claiming sovereignty over the waters enclosed within the nine-dash line.
They are claiming that this dashed line defines which islands within it belong to them and, yes, those islands come with a 12 nautical mile limit around them. As is true of all islands.
“Focus on facts, and worry less about people’s ‘intentions’.”
Maps, dude. They are a thing. I suggest you refer to them before you embarrass yourself further.

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 8:42 utc | 607

@299 Rubiconned “I guess you were never taught about the centuries of wars between Britain and France??”
Yeah, it’s called “history” for a reason, you know….
“Guess who got to keep the islands since winning the last one.”
I don’t need to guess, dude.
“Had Napoleon won in Waterloo… they’d likely be French today.”
And if pigs could fly we’d all need to carry umbrellas when we go outside.
Because I’m telling you now that discussing how territory changed hands in 1812 via conquest is about as relevant to questions of sovereignty in the 21st century as is a discussion regarding the resolutely Earth-bound nature of cloven-hoofed animals.
“Try telling that to the local fishermen. If you own the land, you own the water that surrounds it. Pretty self explanatory that one.”
*sigh*. You are the person who first brought up the nine-dashed line, but it appears that you have never actually looked at it.
Do so now. Note the islands. Note that if everyone were to accept the Chinese claim to sovereignty over those islands – a thought experiment, if you like – then you’d be able to draw lines around each of those islands to the universally-acknowledged 12 nautical mile limit of territorial waters.
Do that, and then compare the waters enclosed by THOSE lines to the waters enclosed by the nine-dash line.
They. Do. Not. Remotely. Coincide. With. Each. Other.
China is NOT claiming sovereignty over the waters enclosed within the nine-dash line.
They are claiming that this dashed line defines which islands within it belong to them and, yes, those islands come with a 12 nautical mile limit around them. As is true of all islands.
“Focus on facts, and worry less about people’s ‘intentions’.”
Maps, dude. They are a thing. I suggest you refer to them before you embarrass yourself further.

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 8:42 utc | 608

Re: Ireland
Yeah, Right – might do well to listen to the song ‘Foggy Dew’ for a very different perspective.
BTW – The English occupation of Ireland was extraordinarily brutal even by the low standards of English colonialism. The Holocaust of 3 million Irish men, women, and children is a story of unimaginable horrors. Ireland didn’t regain its 1840s population until 150 years later.
Interestingly – after a century of hard work and diligence, the Irish are now prosperous and have a significantly higher standard of living versus the English.
Four Green Fields indeed

Posted by: Exile | Sep 29 2023 9:03 utc | 609

Re: Ireland
Yeah, Right – might do well to listen to the song ‘Foggy Dew’ for a very different perspective.
BTW – The English occupation of Ireland was extraordinarily brutal even by the low standards of English colonialism. The Holocaust of 3 million Irish men, women, and children is a story of unimaginable horrors. Ireland didn’t regain its 1840s population until 150 years later.
Interestingly – after a century of hard work and diligence, the Irish are now prosperous and have a significantly higher standard of living versus the English.
Four Green Fields indeed

Posted by: Exile | Sep 29 2023 9:03 utc | 610

“It is a recipe for a just and equalitarian world that will peacefully develop for everyone while allowing for a diversity of cultures and ideologies.”
With great respect to b, who has an excellent site here, very few countries in modern history say openly they wish to dominate the globe, the only example I can think of being the Brezinski/Wolfowitz doctrine of the 1990s (which AFAIK the US has never repudiated), that no nation other than the US should be able to project military/economic power on a global scale.
Everybody is ostensibly in favour of motherhood and apple pie.
“Is its thesis in this new paper, that hegemony preludes decline, valid? Should we therefore trust its claims that it rejects hegemony, not only of others but also for itself?”
It’s a truism that from the top the only way is down. But China was probably the world’s major economy right up to the industrial revolution – maybe a thousand years. Even Hitler didn’t project domination beyond that. I’m sure China would love to be the world hegemon – what’s not to like?
Glubb Pasha, in his studies of the rise and fall of great powers, reckoned 250 years as a typical power span. Few of us can even project beyond our own lifespans, and unless we have children may have no reason to do so.
http://people.uncw.edu/kozloffm/glubb.pdf

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Sep 29 2023 10:00 utc | 611

“It is a recipe for a just and equalitarian world that will peacefully develop for everyone while allowing for a diversity of cultures and ideologies.”
With great respect to b, who has an excellent site here, very few countries in modern history say openly they wish to dominate the globe, the only example I can think of being the Brezinski/Wolfowitz doctrine of the 1990s (which AFAIK the US has never repudiated), that no nation other than the US should be able to project military/economic power on a global scale.
Everybody is ostensibly in favour of motherhood and apple pie.
“Is its thesis in this new paper, that hegemony preludes decline, valid? Should we therefore trust its claims that it rejects hegemony, not only of others but also for itself?”
It’s a truism that from the top the only way is down. But China was probably the world’s major economy right up to the industrial revolution – maybe a thousand years. Even Hitler didn’t project domination beyond that. I’m sure China would love to be the world hegemon – what’s not to like?
Glubb Pasha, in his studies of the rise and fall of great powers, reckoned 250 years as a typical power span. Few of us can even project beyond our own lifespans, and unless we have children may have no reason to do so.
http://people.uncw.edu/kozloffm/glubb.pdf

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Sep 29 2023 10:00 utc | 612

Exile | Sep 29 2023 9:03 utc | 304
“after a century of hard work and diligence, the Irish are now prosperous and have a significantly higher standard of living versus the English”
I would beware of GDP figures in isolation. Dublin is the other Luxembourg of the EU, because of its 12% corporation tax rate. Companies all over the EU, and US corporations, have their HQs in Dublin and profits/revenues are reported there.
Though even 12% is too much for Microsoft.
https://www.ifcreview.com/news/2021/june/ireland-microsoft-s-irish-subsidiary-paid-zero-corporation-tax-on-220bn-profit/
The Irish, like the Icelanders, were hard working and diligent before joining the EU, but they were, like the Icelanders, also pretty poor. (OK, Iceland is in the EEA but the effects are pretty much the same).

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Sep 29 2023 10:10 utc | 613

Exile | Sep 29 2023 9:03 utc | 304
“after a century of hard work and diligence, the Irish are now prosperous and have a significantly higher standard of living versus the English”
I would beware of GDP figures in isolation. Dublin is the other Luxembourg of the EU, because of its 12% corporation tax rate. Companies all over the EU, and US corporations, have their HQs in Dublin and profits/revenues are reported there.
Though even 12% is too much for Microsoft.
https://www.ifcreview.com/news/2021/june/ireland-microsoft-s-irish-subsidiary-paid-zero-corporation-tax-on-220bn-profit/
The Irish, like the Icelanders, were hard working and diligent before joining the EU, but they were, like the Icelanders, also pretty poor. (OK, Iceland is in the EEA but the effects are pretty much the same).

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Sep 29 2023 10:10 utc | 614

Allen
Can you explain why China doesn’t give out z visas for over 60s please. Are us oldies a threat to national security?
Seems very strange.

Posted by: Giyane | Sep 29 2023 11:39 utc | 615

Allen
Can you explain why China doesn’t give out z visas for over 60s please. Are us oldies a threat to national security?
Seems very strange.

Posted by: Giyane | Sep 29 2023 11:39 utc | 616

SirKeef: One of the most consistent findings in public opinion surveys of Chinese citizens is the high level of support for the communist party and the central government. This includes World Values Surveys, the Asian Barometer Surveys, the Pew Surveys, the Chinese General Social Surveys, and the Chinese Urban Surveys, as reported in “The “Surprise” of Authoritarian Resilience in China” By Wenfang Tang https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2018/02/surprise-authoritarian-resilience-china/

Posted by: greetings from Hubei | Sep 29 2023 11:49 utc | 617

SirKeef: One of the most consistent findings in public opinion surveys of Chinese citizens is the high level of support for the communist party and the central government. This includes World Values Surveys, the Asian Barometer Surveys, the Pew Surveys, the Chinese General Social Surveys, and the Chinese Urban Surveys, as reported in “The “Surprise” of Authoritarian Resilience in China” By Wenfang Tang https://americanaffairsjournal.org/2018/02/surprise-authoritarian-resilience-china/

Posted by: greetings from Hubei | Sep 29 2023 11:49 utc | 618

Exile @290
Re: Chinese STEM … my relative is a Math Prof at a leading U.S. Uni. One of his American PhD students came into his office,… nearly in tears …… I feel so dumb next to the Chinese educated PhD students, most of the time I don’t even understand what Math concepts they are talking about
It seems Exile you may want to have a talk wit your relative the math professor why their instruction was so deficient that one of their student would feel that way.
Also, ask the good professor why the Chinese students are hanging around their university if they’re that advanced? A piece of wall paper?
It seems the professors at the universities are the ones responsible for the deficiencies in education of its students.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 12:33 utc | 619

Exile @290
Re: Chinese STEM … my relative is a Math Prof at a leading U.S. Uni. One of his American PhD students came into his office,… nearly in tears …… I feel so dumb next to the Chinese educated PhD students, most of the time I don’t even understand what Math concepts they are talking about
It seems Exile you may want to have a talk wit your relative the math professor why their instruction was so deficient that one of their student would feel that way.
Also, ask the good professor why the Chinese students are hanging around their university if they’re that advanced? A piece of wall paper?
It seems the professors at the universities are the ones responsible for the deficiencies in education of its students.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 12:33 utc | 620

Posted by: greetings from Hubei | Sep 29 2023 11:49 utc | 309
Thank you. So many small-minded and mean-spirited conversations. You would think they would understand that people prefer to be treated well, and that they will work hard in return, fight to keep it. Well they did know that at one time, but their descendants had other ideas.
My older brother & his Japanese-born wife visited China in the 1990s and were very impressed. I for one wish you all well.
Greetings from California.

Posted by: Bemildred | Sep 29 2023 12:38 utc | 621

Posted by: greetings from Hubei | Sep 29 2023 11:49 utc | 309
Thank you. So many small-minded and mean-spirited conversations. You would think they would understand that people prefer to be treated well, and that they will work hard in return, fight to keep it. Well they did know that at one time, but their descendants had other ideas.
My older brother & his Japanese-born wife visited China in the 1990s and were very impressed. I for one wish you all well.
Greetings from California.

Posted by: Bemildred | Sep 29 2023 12:38 utc | 622

1 – What did the CCP do, with regard to increasing prosperity, except get out of the way? Encouraging free enterprise requires very little government activity.
Posted by: FrankDrakman | Sep 28 2023 17:06 utc | 139
Pure nonsense. You are economically uneducated, so it would be a waste of time to argue with you.
I wonder why the US got pissed by the 2030 technology program and BRI designed by CPC.

Posted by: RB | Sep 29 2023 12:44 utc | 623

1 – What did the CCP do, with regard to increasing prosperity, except get out of the way? Encouraging free enterprise requires very little government activity.
Posted by: FrankDrakman | Sep 28 2023 17:06 utc | 139
Pure nonsense. You are economically uneducated, so it would be a waste of time to argue with you.
I wonder why the US got pissed by the 2030 technology program and BRI designed by CPC.

Posted by: RB | Sep 29 2023 12:44 utc | 624

In re: Uyghur issue
Been to Xinjiang. Beautiful place. If you go you’ll see LOTS of Uyghur policemen carrying machine guns.
If China were committing genocide or anti-Uyghur policies, they’d be dumb to let any Uyghur near any weapon.
Have you seen Palestinians in the Israeli SDF? Yeah thats real apartheid & genocide

Posted by: HANDSOMEMAN | Sep 29 2023 13:02 utc | 625

In re: Uyghur issue
Been to Xinjiang. Beautiful place. If you go you’ll see LOTS of Uyghur policemen carrying machine guns.
If China were committing genocide or anti-Uyghur policies, they’d be dumb to let any Uyghur near any weapon.
Have you seen Palestinians in the Israeli SDF? Yeah thats real apartheid & genocide

Posted by: HANDSOMEMAN | Sep 29 2023 13:02 utc | 626

That *you* think that amounts to a Chinese annexation of Tibet says far more about your lack of understanding that it does about the Chinese mindset.
Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 28 2023 23:20 utc | 240
…………………
You are using the Chinese line.
But none of the Tibetans I met or lived with spoke Chinese or regarded themselves as Chinese. All of them view Tibet as an independent and unique culture and nation. Obviously, the Chinese who killed many and destroyed monasteries and imprisoned lamas are ‘right’ in that they prevailed. Making all of the Tibetans I know wrong. But being wrong still doesn’t make them Chinese. They are Tibetans, whatever CPC proclaims to the contrary.
Methinks people are getting into a quasi religious true-believer mentality with China and Russia; also with the West, conflating an out of control robber Baron financial system with an entire race being congenitally wicked. On both sides these sorts of faith-based fundamentalist-style projections are both oversimplistic and wrong. Though hardly surprising; (small) minds are more at ease taking sides.
I used the word ‘annex’ to be as non-inflammatory as possible. For you to get all in a huff about it says far more about *you* than about me!

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 13:21 utc | 627

That *you* think that amounts to a Chinese annexation of Tibet says far more about your lack of understanding that it does about the Chinese mindset.
Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 28 2023 23:20 utc | 240
…………………
You are using the Chinese line.
But none of the Tibetans I met or lived with spoke Chinese or regarded themselves as Chinese. All of them view Tibet as an independent and unique culture and nation. Obviously, the Chinese who killed many and destroyed monasteries and imprisoned lamas are ‘right’ in that they prevailed. Making all of the Tibetans I know wrong. But being wrong still doesn’t make them Chinese. They are Tibetans, whatever CPC proclaims to the contrary.
Methinks people are getting into a quasi religious true-believer mentality with China and Russia; also with the West, conflating an out of control robber Baron financial system with an entire race being congenitally wicked. On both sides these sorts of faith-based fundamentalist-style projections are both oversimplistic and wrong. Though hardly surprising; (small) minds are more at ease taking sides.
I used the word ‘annex’ to be as non-inflammatory as possible. For you to get all in a huff about it says far more about *you* than about me!

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 13:21 utc | 628

Jerr @310: “It seems the professors at the universities are the ones responsible for the deficiencies in education of its students.”
Absolutely wrong and a display of true ignorance of what university actually is. In fact, it is this very ignorance the “Derr” potser puts on display that is largely responsible for the decline in western academia that has become no less than spectacular in recent years. The `tard apparently doesn’t realize that at university, the professors are the students too, though sometimes with a few years offset. Professors are supposed to remain students for their entire lives. Reducing university to a crude marketplace where students/consumers buy a “product” sold by professors/vendors corrupts the very purpose of university. After such corruption it is no surprise that the students/consumers end up with crappy Walmart/McDonalds level products. That’s what the customer wants and expects, after all, and in the marketplace the customer is always right, right?
It’s sad. The STEM side of western universities held onto the university ideal longest, but even that is collapsing into least-common-denominator consumerist crap now. Morons like Jerr wouldn’t have it any other way, though.

Posted by: William Gruff | Sep 29 2023 13:31 utc | 629

Jerr @310: “It seems the professors at the universities are the ones responsible for the deficiencies in education of its students.”
Absolutely wrong and a display of true ignorance of what university actually is. In fact, it is this very ignorance the “Derr” potser puts on display that is largely responsible for the decline in western academia that has become no less than spectacular in recent years. The `tard apparently doesn’t realize that at university, the professors are the students too, though sometimes with a few years offset. Professors are supposed to remain students for their entire lives. Reducing university to a crude marketplace where students/consumers buy a “product” sold by professors/vendors corrupts the very purpose of university. After such corruption it is no surprise that the students/consumers end up with crappy Walmart/McDonalds level products. That’s what the customer wants and expects, after all, and in the marketplace the customer is always right, right?
It’s sad. The STEM side of western universities held onto the university ideal longest, but even that is collapsing into least-common-denominator consumerist crap now. Morons like Jerr wouldn’t have it any other way, though.

Posted by: William Gruff | Sep 29 2023 13:31 utc | 630

@305 Exile
What it is with people and their straw man arguments?
“Yeah, Right – might do well to listen to the song ‘Foggy Dew’ for a very different perspective.”
Man, we are right back to the beginning, a very good place to start….
What has the British treatment of the Irish got to do with the sovereignty of the crown over that territory?
Some sovereigns are cruel? No shit, I’m shocked. Shocked to my core.
But did that mean that the Crown WASN’T the sovereign of Ireland until 1921?
No, it did not.
“BTW – The English occupation of Ireland was extraordinarily brutal even by the low standards of English colonialism.”
Fer’ f**k’s sake. Does “brutalism” invalidate a sovereign’s claim?
No, it does not. The Crown was the sovereign power, irrespective of it brutality levels.
“The Holocaust of 3 million Irish men, women, and children is a story of unimaginable horrors. Ireland didn’t regain its 1840s population until 150 years later.”
Honestly, words fail me.
The questithat was posed was one of sovereignty, it is not one of butality.
Here, I’ll repeat it because you appear to have come late to the party:
@255 Lysias “If Tibet was a rebel province of China to which China had a right, that presumably means that Ireland was a rebel province of Britain to which Britain had a right.”
Why, yes. Yes it does.
“Interestingly – after a century of hard work and diligence, the Irish are now prosperous and have a significantly higher standard of living versus the English.”
Well, whoop-de-do. I’m very pleased for them.

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 13:41 utc | 631

@305 Exile
What it is with people and their straw man arguments?
“Yeah, Right – might do well to listen to the song ‘Foggy Dew’ for a very different perspective.”
Man, we are right back to the beginning, a very good place to start….
What has the British treatment of the Irish got to do with the sovereignty of the crown over that territory?
Some sovereigns are cruel? No shit, I’m shocked. Shocked to my core.
But did that mean that the Crown WASN’T the sovereign of Ireland until 1921?
No, it did not.
“BTW – The English occupation of Ireland was extraordinarily brutal even by the low standards of English colonialism.”
Fer’ f**k’s sake. Does “brutalism” invalidate a sovereign’s claim?
No, it does not. The Crown was the sovereign power, irrespective of it brutality levels.
“The Holocaust of 3 million Irish men, women, and children is a story of unimaginable horrors. Ireland didn’t regain its 1840s population until 150 years later.”
Honestly, words fail me.
The questithat was posed was one of sovereignty, it is not one of butality.
Here, I’ll repeat it because you appear to have come late to the party:
@255 Lysias “If Tibet was a rebel province of China to which China had a right, that presumably means that Ireland was a rebel province of Britain to which Britain had a right.”
Why, yes. Yes it does.
“Interestingly – after a century of hard work and diligence, the Irish are now prosperous and have a significantly higher standard of living versus the English.”
Well, whoop-de-do. I’m very pleased for them.

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 13:41 utc | 632

More Ireland:
The English occupied Ireland. And yes – brutality and Holocausting one’s subjects is cause for losing the right to rule. After all, in civilized societies, it’s generally accepted that rulers care for and benefit their subjects.
For Barbarous tyrannies – (yeah, rights) arguments hold sway. One must conclude that (yeah, right) believes the English are barbarous tyrants.

Posted by: Exile | Sep 29 2023 13:52 utc | 633

More Ireland:
The English occupied Ireland. And yes – brutality and Holocausting one’s subjects is cause for losing the right to rule. After all, in civilized societies, it’s generally accepted that rulers care for and benefit their subjects.
For Barbarous tyrannies – (yeah, rights) arguments hold sway. One must conclude that (yeah, right) believes the English are barbarous tyrants.

Posted by: Exile | Sep 29 2023 13:52 utc | 634

@314 Scorpion “You are using the Chinese line.”
Spare me.
“But none of the Tibetans I met or lived with spoke Chinese or regarded themselves as Chinese.”
And? So?
The Basques of Spain have exactly the same view regarding Spanish or Spaniards.
And? So?
“All of them view Tibet as an independent and unique culture and nation.”
And? So?
“Obviously, the Chinese who killed many and destroyed monasteries and imprisoned lamas are ‘right’ in that they prevailed.”
This is just getting stupid. China is the sovereign power because Peking never renounced that sovereignty.
These are real words with real meaning: “sovereignty” and “authority”.
Thanks to British meddling Peking lost its “authority” over Tibet, but not its “sovereignty”, and what happened in 1950 was nothing more – nor less – than the reassertion of that “authority”.
“Making all of the Tibetans I know wrong. But being wrong still doesn’t make them Chinese. They are Tibetans, whatever CPC proclaims to the contrary.”
All the rest of your stupid comment amounts to an avoidance of that central point.
The Chinese are cruel towards their Tibetan citizens?
They destroyed monasteries and imprisoned lamas?
The Tibetans think of themselves as Tibetans?
All very reprehensible, to be sure.
But what does that have to do with Chinese sovereignty over that territory?
Because the answer is “Nothing. Nothing at all”

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 13:57 utc | 635

@314 Scorpion “You are using the Chinese line.”
Spare me.
“But none of the Tibetans I met or lived with spoke Chinese or regarded themselves as Chinese.”
And? So?
The Basques of Spain have exactly the same view regarding Spanish or Spaniards.
And? So?
“All of them view Tibet as an independent and unique culture and nation.”
And? So?
“Obviously, the Chinese who killed many and destroyed monasteries and imprisoned lamas are ‘right’ in that they prevailed.”
This is just getting stupid. China is the sovereign power because Peking never renounced that sovereignty.
These are real words with real meaning: “sovereignty” and “authority”.
Thanks to British meddling Peking lost its “authority” over Tibet, but not its “sovereignty”, and what happened in 1950 was nothing more – nor less – than the reassertion of that “authority”.
“Making all of the Tibetans I know wrong. But being wrong still doesn’t make them Chinese. They are Tibetans, whatever CPC proclaims to the contrary.”
All the rest of your stupid comment amounts to an avoidance of that central point.
The Chinese are cruel towards their Tibetan citizens?
They destroyed monasteries and imprisoned lamas?
The Tibetans think of themselves as Tibetans?
All very reprehensible, to be sure.
But what does that have to do with Chinese sovereignty over that territory?
Because the answer is “Nothing. Nothing at all”

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 13:57 utc | 636

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 13:21 utc | 314
——————

Tibet, Tibet

The chameleon ,er, scorpion, showing its true color here again, shedding its philosophistry fig leaf
I asked it why the fetishism with TW, TIBET, WHO ‘re literally in heaven when compared to the Chagosians, Ryukyu ren,Kashmiris, etc….the prof had no answer and resorted to blocking me, for trolling. !
[190]
https://tinyurl.com/yuadjd6c

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 14:06 utc | 637

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 13:21 utc | 314
——————

Tibet, Tibet

The chameleon ,er, scorpion, showing its true color here again, shedding its philosophistry fig leaf
I asked it why the fetishism with TW, TIBET, WHO ‘re literally in heaven when compared to the Chagosians, Ryukyu ren,Kashmiris, etc….the prof had no answer and resorted to blocking me, for trolling. !
[190]
https://tinyurl.com/yuadjd6c

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 14:06 utc | 638

@317 I am being struck repeatedly by feathers wielded by bleeding hearts. Oh, the pain. The pain….
“The English occupied Ireland.”
I’ll repeat this again, because it never gets old: the full title of the UK was “The United Kingdom of England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland”.
“And yes – brutality and Holocausting one’s subjects is cause for losing the right to rule.”
It has been a cornerstone of international relations since, oh, the Treaty of Westphalia that you are wrong on that score.
“After all, in civilized societies, it’s generally accepted that rulers care for and benefit their subjects.”
Oh, really? Because where I come from the way in which a country is ruled is no business of anyone other than that country itself.
“For Barbarous tyrannies – (yeah, rights) arguments hold sway. One must conclude that (yeah, right) believes the English are barbarous tyrants.”
I’m going to let you in on a little secret: I don’t give a rat’s arse what the “English” are, nor to I presume to possess the arrogance to judge who is a tyrant and who is a benevolent ruler in fluffy slippers.

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 14:07 utc | 639

@317 I am being struck repeatedly by feathers wielded by bleeding hearts. Oh, the pain. The pain….
“The English occupied Ireland.”
I’ll repeat this again, because it never gets old: the full title of the UK was “The United Kingdom of England, Scotland, Wales and Ireland”.
“And yes – brutality and Holocausting one’s subjects is cause for losing the right to rule.”
It has been a cornerstone of international relations since, oh, the Treaty of Westphalia that you are wrong on that score.
“After all, in civilized societies, it’s generally accepted that rulers care for and benefit their subjects.”
Oh, really? Because where I come from the way in which a country is ruled is no business of anyone other than that country itself.
“For Barbarous tyrannies – (yeah, rights) arguments hold sway. One must conclude that (yeah, right) believes the English are barbarous tyrants.”
I’m going to let you in on a little secret: I don’t give a rat’s arse what the “English” are, nor to I presume to possess the arrogance to judge who is a tyrant and who is a benevolent ruler in fluffy slippers.

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 14:07 utc | 640

William Gruff @ 315
Thank you for supporting my position.
Of course, the professors are responsible and as you suggest they seem to have abrogated that responsibility.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 14:54 utc | 641

William Gruff @ 315
Thank you for supporting my position.
Of course, the professors are responsible and as you suggest they seem to have abrogated that responsibility.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 14:54 utc | 642

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 13:57 utc | 318
The real problem is that the sinophiles refuse to admit that there is another side to the story. You have won, you have Tibet, you have claimed sovereignty, it’s over. But that doesn’t change the fact that many Tibetans regard this as a personal and national tragedy. Don’t you care about people, like you claim? Have you no compassion or decency? No, you care only for ideology.
I am not whining about it – nor did my Tibetan friends, actually, who knew very well that their society had issues. It’s just a fact. People who were born Tibetan and raised as Buddhists suddenly became persecuted in their own country. This happened. No amount of faux outrage on your part can change this simple fact.
The reason anyone saying this simple thing makes you uncomfortable is that it implies that oft-repeated claims about China’s spotless non-imperial record are a tad hypocritical. No big deal; all major nations are a tad hypocritical. Drop believing in your side as spotlessly pure crusaders. Smacks of religious fundamentalism. The Chinese can be selfish, hard-nosed bastards too, just like every other major power in history. Stop drinking the fundamentalist CPC Kool-Aid! Your protesting so much makes you look guilty!
This sidebar discussion arose because I wondered if, ‘after China annexed Tibet’, India had issues with China controlling vital headwaters. So: what is the politically correct way you would prefer me to have phrased that question? Or is heresy to even bring it up at all?

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:03 utc | 643

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Sep 29 2023 13:57 utc | 318
The real problem is that the sinophiles refuse to admit that there is another side to the story. You have won, you have Tibet, you have claimed sovereignty, it’s over. But that doesn’t change the fact that many Tibetans regard this as a personal and national tragedy. Don’t you care about people, like you claim? Have you no compassion or decency? No, you care only for ideology.
I am not whining about it – nor did my Tibetan friends, actually, who knew very well that their society had issues. It’s just a fact. People who were born Tibetan and raised as Buddhists suddenly became persecuted in their own country. This happened. No amount of faux outrage on your part can change this simple fact.
The reason anyone saying this simple thing makes you uncomfortable is that it implies that oft-repeated claims about China’s spotless non-imperial record are a tad hypocritical. No big deal; all major nations are a tad hypocritical. Drop believing in your side as spotlessly pure crusaders. Smacks of religious fundamentalism. The Chinese can be selfish, hard-nosed bastards too, just like every other major power in history. Stop drinking the fundamentalist CPC Kool-Aid! Your protesting so much makes you look guilty!
This sidebar discussion arose because I wondered if, ‘after China annexed Tibet’, India had issues with China controlling vital headwaters. So: what is the politically correct way you would prefer me to have phrased that question? Or is heresy to even bring it up at all?

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:03 utc | 644

I fear that a lot of us Americans haven’t overcome our childhood political education (=anti-commie brainwashing). I flushed my Cold War stereotypes down the toilet during our Central American Proxy Wars (=murder campaigns) but too many others cling to the fantasy that PR China hasn’t changed since the ’60s. No matter how many US capitalists go to Shanghai, do business with Chinese private enterprise businessmen, they still think everything is just like in the ’50s-’60s, that the Party is still Communist in some meaningful way, etc.

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 15:03 utc | 645

I fear that a lot of us Americans haven’t overcome our childhood political education (=anti-commie brainwashing). I flushed my Cold War stereotypes down the toilet during our Central American Proxy Wars (=murder campaigns) but too many others cling to the fantasy that PR China hasn’t changed since the ’60s. No matter how many US capitalists go to Shanghai, do business with Chinese private enterprise businessmen, they still think everything is just like in the ’50s-’60s, that the Party is still Communist in some meaningful way, etc.

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 15:03 utc | 646

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 14:54 utc | 321
he didnt support your position, minor detail for you i know.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 15:04 utc | 647

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 14:54 utc | 321
he didnt support your position, minor detail for you i know.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 15:04 utc | 648

Pretzelattack @324
See WG quote below. The professors have the responsibility and they’ve seem to have abandoned it, as I said.
“It’s sad. The STEM side of western universities held onto the university ideal longest, but even that is collapsing into least-common-denominator consumerist crap now.”

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 15:13 utc | 649

Pretzelattack @324
See WG quote below. The professors have the responsibility and they’ve seem to have abandoned it, as I said.
“It’s sad. The STEM side of western universities held onto the university ideal longest, but even that is collapsing into least-common-denominator consumerist crap now.”

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 15:13 utc | 650

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 15:13 utc | 325
universities have been corrupted like most other institutions in society, you lay the blame on the workers, not the corrupters. why do you do that?

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 15:22 utc | 651

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 15:13 utc | 325
universities have been corrupted like most other institutions in society, you lay the blame on the workers, not the corrupters. why do you do that?

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 15:22 utc | 652

@ Jerr | Sep 29 2023 15:13 utc | 325
Gruff should have pointed out — perhaps he didn’t because it’s so bleeding obvious — that if American STEM faculty have relaxed standards, then only under immense pressure from university administrations and even students. Can’t fail them all, after all, and the customer is always right…
So if the faculty are at fault, then hardly uniquely and exclusively so.

Posted by: malenkov | Sep 29 2023 15:28 utc | 653

@ Jerr | Sep 29 2023 15:13 utc | 325
Gruff should have pointed out — perhaps he didn’t because it’s so bleeding obvious — that if American STEM faculty have relaxed standards, then only under immense pressure from university administrations and even students. Can’t fail them all, after all, and the customer is always right…
So if the faculty are at fault, then hardly uniquely and exclusively so.

Posted by: malenkov | Sep 29 2023 15:28 utc | 654

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 14:06 utc | 319
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 13:21 utc | 314
——————
Tibet, Tibet
The chameleon ,er, scorpion, showing its true color here again, shedding its philosophistry fig leaf
I asked it why the fetishism with TW, TIBET, WHO ‘re literally in heaven when compared to the Chagosians, Ryukyu ren,Kashmiris, etc….the prof had no answer and resorted to blocking me, for trolling. !

Ooops! The filter was off when I changed browsers!
There is no ‘fetishism’ on my side, Denk. I just happen to know a little about the issue because I lived with and met many Tibetans. Not news stories. Not movies. Real people. As it happens, I don’t like Tibetan society all that much, though I did love studying esoteric Buddhism under a Tibetan lama. When I went to India and spent time in Tibetan exile communities, I soon realized that their feudal theocracy was not my cup of tea. No doubt China has improved things materially in Tibet but not for religious practitioners. As also evidenced to this day by old-school qigong masters leaving China.
The CPC regime regards religion as a danger to the state, presumably because it might threaten their authority if a following gets too large. It’s understandable, but hardly enlightened and I think reveals a fundamental weakness. But since am not Chinese and don’t live there, I don’t have a dog in the fight. Based on my first-hand experience with Tibetans and qigong masters, though, I believe that the secularist CPC regime has a problem with religious faith.
Make of that as you will. But I have no ‘fetish’ about Tibetans. You seem to have one about any sort of criticism of China being worthy only of invective and racist insult. It’s narrow-minded and fanatic on your part.
As the saying goes: ‘Don’t drag me into your troubled world!!’

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:34 utc | 655

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 14:06 utc | 319
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 13:21 utc | 314
——————
Tibet, Tibet
The chameleon ,er, scorpion, showing its true color here again, shedding its philosophistry fig leaf
I asked it why the fetishism with TW, TIBET, WHO ‘re literally in heaven when compared to the Chagosians, Ryukyu ren,Kashmiris, etc….the prof had no answer and resorted to blocking me, for trolling. !

Ooops! The filter was off when I changed browsers!
There is no ‘fetishism’ on my side, Denk. I just happen to know a little about the issue because I lived with and met many Tibetans. Not news stories. Not movies. Real people. As it happens, I don’t like Tibetan society all that much, though I did love studying esoteric Buddhism under a Tibetan lama. When I went to India and spent time in Tibetan exile communities, I soon realized that their feudal theocracy was not my cup of tea. No doubt China has improved things materially in Tibet but not for religious practitioners. As also evidenced to this day by old-school qigong masters leaving China.
The CPC regime regards religion as a danger to the state, presumably because it might threaten their authority if a following gets too large. It’s understandable, but hardly enlightened and I think reveals a fundamental weakness. But since am not Chinese and don’t live there, I don’t have a dog in the fight. Based on my first-hand experience with Tibetans and qigong masters, though, I believe that the secularist CPC regime has a problem with religious faith.
Make of that as you will. But I have no ‘fetish’ about Tibetans. You seem to have one about any sort of criticism of China being worthy only of invective and racist insult. It’s narrow-minded and fanatic on your part.
As the saying goes: ‘Don’t drag me into your troubled world!!’

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:34 utc | 656

more philosophistry, as Denk might say.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 15:38 utc | 657

more philosophistry, as Denk might say.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 15:38 utc | 658

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:03 utc | 322
———————

You have won, you have Tibet, you have claimed sovereignty, it’s over

What do you suggest prof, Hans outta Tibet ?

Don’t you care about people, like you claim? Have you no compassion or decency?

Say who ?
The one who dismiss the entire unpeople a mere ‘sorry list‘ not worthy of its compassion !

India had issues with China controlling vital headwaters.

The scorpion [sic] had no issue all these years when India invaded China in 1962, provoked numerous border skirmishes until this day.
When India partake in all anti Chinese posse like QUAD, when India called its missiles ‘China killer’, when Bharat boasted ‘Indian ocean is where we get the chicom by their balls‘, meaning a joint op with NATO to choke off China’s jugular…..
China ‘controlling vital headwaters’ ?
That’d teach Bharat to think twice before engaging in another brinkmanship
Whats not to like ?
Or would you prefer China launching a pre-emptive first strike to take out this constant menace to the South ?

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 15:46 utc | 659

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:03 utc | 322
———————

You have won, you have Tibet, you have claimed sovereignty, it’s over

What do you suggest prof, Hans outta Tibet ?

Don’t you care about people, like you claim? Have you no compassion or decency?

Say who ?
The one who dismiss the entire unpeople a mere ‘sorry list‘ not worthy of its compassion !

India had issues with China controlling vital headwaters.

The scorpion [sic] had no issue all these years when India invaded China in 1962, provoked numerous border skirmishes until this day.
When India partake in all anti Chinese posse like QUAD, when India called its missiles ‘China killer’, when Bharat boasted ‘Indian ocean is where we get the chicom by their balls‘, meaning a joint op with NATO to choke off China’s jugular…..
China ‘controlling vital headwaters’ ?
That’d teach Bharat to think twice before engaging in another brinkmanship
Whats not to like ?
Or would you prefer China launching a pre-emptive first strike to take out this constant menace to the South ?

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 15:46 utc | 660

There is no ‘fetishism’ on my side,
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:34 utc | 328
————————
Make it obsession then.
Why no compassion with the unpeople ,who’r literally living in hell !
hAVE you ever bothered to ask the TW, TIBETANS, whether they wanna trade places with the unpeople ?
Hmm,,
Inspite of ‘blocking’ me, the scorpion
seems to be on of my faithful fan 😉

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 16:00 utc | 661

There is no ‘fetishism’ on my side,
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:34 utc | 328
————————
Make it obsession then.
Why no compassion with the unpeople ,who’r literally living in hell !
hAVE you ever bothered to ask the TW, TIBETANS, whether they wanna trade places with the unpeople ?
Hmm,,
Inspite of ‘blocking’ me, the scorpion
seems to be on of my faithful fan 😉

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 16:00 utc | 662

“Can we ask a Uighur living in China for their feedback?” – Paul Schneider
Have you ever asked a Lakota, a Winnebago, an Omaha, if the US govt. should start yet another trillion dollar war?The US does have plenty of its own indigenous people who are not prospering.
For that matter, the idea of the US govt. defending Muslims after 30-40 years of slaughtering them like mosquitoes is hard to believe.

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 16:03 utc | 663

“Can we ask a Uighur living in China for their feedback?” – Paul Schneider
Have you ever asked a Lakota, a Winnebago, an Omaha, if the US govt. should start yet another trillion dollar war?The US does have plenty of its own indigenous people who are not prospering.
For that matter, the idea of the US govt. defending Muslims after 30-40 years of slaughtering them like mosquitoes is hard to believe.

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 16:03 utc | 664

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 15:46 utc | 330
Unpeople: not my issue; strawman.
What do I suggest? Nothing. In the quote immediately above I said that China has claimed sovereignty. As others have posted here, that’s that. Doesn’t mean that what happened was all love and light, though, nor that people who were persecuted did so voluntarily. Stop being so silly.
As to the Indian stories: Your commentary there shows that India and China are quarreling. Men paint things on missiles. Fine. Sounds interesting. But my question remains: was part of India’s problem to do with sudden Chinese control of headwaters? It’s a simple question. I ask because I don’t know the answer not because I’m flogging some cause (like you, seemingly).
Be interesting to see if you can answer without going into endless ad hominem. It’s a simple question. Or maybe you don’t know? Nothing wrong with that, either. I certainly don’t but I vaguely recall reading – long time ago – that it was an issue.

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 16:24 utc | 665

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 15:46 utc | 330
Unpeople: not my issue; strawman.
What do I suggest? Nothing. In the quote immediately above I said that China has claimed sovereignty. As others have posted here, that’s that. Doesn’t mean that what happened was all love and light, though, nor that people who were persecuted did so voluntarily. Stop being so silly.
As to the Indian stories: Your commentary there shows that India and China are quarreling. Men paint things on missiles. Fine. Sounds interesting. But my question remains: was part of India’s problem to do with sudden Chinese control of headwaters? It’s a simple question. I ask because I don’t know the answer not because I’m flogging some cause (like you, seemingly).
Be interesting to see if you can answer without going into endless ad hominem. It’s a simple question. Or maybe you don’t know? Nothing wrong with that, either. I certainly don’t but I vaguely recall reading – long time ago – that it was an issue.

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 16:24 utc | 666

universities have been pretzelattack @326 “corrupted like most other institutions in society, you lay the blame on the workers, not the corrupters. why do you do that?”
The notion of professors as workers gave me a chuckle.
Professors are the Instition. They permit the corruption to exist. That is why my friend, they are responsible for the state of the Institution and hence education.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 16:26 utc | 667

universities have been pretzelattack @326 “corrupted like most other institutions in society, you lay the blame on the workers, not the corrupters. why do you do that?”
The notion of professors as workers gave me a chuckle.
Professors are the Instition. They permit the corruption to exist. That is why my friend, they are responsible for the state of the Institution and hence education.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 16:26 utc | 668

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 16:24 utc | 333
——————–
unpeople
Exhibit Ryukyu

The Rev. Taira says the islanders have had enough. “The soldiers get drunk and crash their cars. There are four accidents a day; two rapes a month. Almost every person on Okinawa has a family member who has been assaulted. Then the soldiers go off to kill poor people in Iraq and Afghanistan. It makes my blood boil.”

This is just straw man, say the scorpion.
His pet peeve is with the Tibetans ‘plight‘
LIke so.,,
Exemption in Tax
Subsidy in economy, education
exemption from one child rule

With such ‘oppression’.
I bet the Ryukyu ren wouldnt mind to trade place with your beloved Tibetans,!
hehehhe

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 16:44 utc | 669

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 16:24 utc | 333
——————–
unpeople
Exhibit Ryukyu

The Rev. Taira says the islanders have had enough. “The soldiers get drunk and crash their cars. There are four accidents a day; two rapes a month. Almost every person on Okinawa has a family member who has been assaulted. Then the soldiers go off to kill poor people in Iraq and Afghanistan. It makes my blood boil.”

This is just straw man, say the scorpion.
His pet peeve is with the Tibetans ‘plight‘
LIke so.,,
Exemption in Tax
Subsidy in economy, education
exemption from one child rule

With such ‘oppression’.
I bet the Ryukyu ren wouldnt mind to trade place with your beloved Tibetans,!
hehehhe

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 16:44 utc | 670

Professors are the Instition. They permit the corruption to exist. That is why my friend, they are responsible for the state of the Institution and hence education.
Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 16:26 utc | 334

As a former academic myself, I have to admit this elicited a tired chuckle. Sure, there are professors who long for the days when professors “were the institution,” were solely responsible for the curriculum, enjoyed freedom in research and the classroom limited only by the standards of their disciplines, and were willing to settle for “shared governance” — after all, they never had any real power when it came to budgetary matters.
But those days are well and truly over. An ever dwindling majority has or can aspire to that freedom-of-speech-within-discipline known as tenure, and most real decisions, including programmatic ones, are made by administrators who themselves frequently serve at the pleasure of trustees whose interest in the institutions, to the extent they have such interests, are not always beneficial.

Posted by: malenkov | Sep 29 2023 16:56 utc | 671

Professors are the Instition. They permit the corruption to exist. That is why my friend, they are responsible for the state of the Institution and hence education.
Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 16:26 utc | 334

As a former academic myself, I have to admit this elicited a tired chuckle. Sure, there are professors who long for the days when professors “were the institution,” were solely responsible for the curriculum, enjoyed freedom in research and the classroom limited only by the standards of their disciplines, and were willing to settle for “shared governance” — after all, they never had any real power when it came to budgetary matters.
But those days are well and truly over. An ever dwindling majority has or can aspire to that freedom-of-speech-within-discipline known as tenure, and most real decisions, including programmatic ones, are made by administrators who themselves frequently serve at the pleasure of trustees whose interest in the institutions, to the extent they have such interests, are not always beneficial.

Posted by: malenkov | Sep 29 2023 16:56 utc | 672

As to the Indian stories: Your commentary there shows that India and China are quarreling. Men paint things on missiles. Fine. Sounds interesting. But my question remains: was part of India’s problem to do with sudden Chinese control of headwaters? It’s a simple question. I ask because I don’t know the answer not because I’m flogging some cause (like you, seemingly).
Be interesting to see if you can answer without going into endless ad hominem. It’s a simple question. Or maybe you don’t know? Nothing wrong with that, either. I certainly don’t but I vaguely recall reading – long time ago – that it was an issue.
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 16:24 utc | 333
—————–
Indian aggression against China becomes Beijing./Bharat quarreling‘ !
I dont call this troll prof of philosophistry for nuthin you know !
Like I saY,
So what if ‘China controlling vital headwater’ causing problem in India ?
It would be a constant reminder to the hotheads in Delhi who contemplate a 1962 replay .
‘Dont push your luck…..and make my day’

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 16:57 utc | 673

As to the Indian stories: Your commentary there shows that India and China are quarreling. Men paint things on missiles. Fine. Sounds interesting. But my question remains: was part of India’s problem to do with sudden Chinese control of headwaters? It’s a simple question. I ask because I don’t know the answer not because I’m flogging some cause (like you, seemingly).
Be interesting to see if you can answer without going into endless ad hominem. It’s a simple question. Or maybe you don’t know? Nothing wrong with that, either. I certainly don’t but I vaguely recall reading – long time ago – that it was an issue.
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 16:24 utc | 333
—————–
Indian aggression against China becomes Beijing./Bharat quarreling‘ !
I dont call this troll prof of philosophistry for nuthin you know !
Like I saY,
So what if ‘China controlling vital headwater’ causing problem in India ?
It would be a constant reminder to the hotheads in Delhi who contemplate a 1962 replay .
‘Dont push your luck…..and make my day’

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 16:57 utc | 674

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 16:44 utc | 335
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 16:24 utc | 333
——————–
unpeople
Exhibit Ryukyu
The Rev. Taira says the islanders have had enough. “The soldiers get drunk and crash their cars. There are four accidents a day; two rapes a month. Almost every person on Okinawa has a family member who has been assaulted. Then the soldiers go off to kill poor people in Iraq and Afghanistan. It makes my blood boil.”
This is just straw man, say the scorpion.
His pet peeve is with the Tibetans ‘plight’

My ‘pet peeve’ was a question: did the sudden takeover of headwaters concern India? Whatever is going on in an island in Japan has absolutely nothing to do with it. Are you saying that because I don’t care about those islanders raising issues about Tibetans is hypocritical? I didn’t even raise issues about Tibet except insofar as mentioning that China took it over – I used the seemingly objectionable word ‘annexed’ (!) – after which they had control of headwater which hundreds of millions of Indians depend upon.
Anyway, like I thought, and as always, you won’t engage in discussion of the topic and only go to irrelevant wacky and insulting ad hominem.
Bye Bye Denk!!
(You get the last words, have at it! I won’t read them!)

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 17:00 utc | 675

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 16:44 utc | 335
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 16:24 utc | 333
——————–
unpeople
Exhibit Ryukyu
The Rev. Taira says the islanders have had enough. “The soldiers get drunk and crash their cars. There are four accidents a day; two rapes a month. Almost every person on Okinawa has a family member who has been assaulted. Then the soldiers go off to kill poor people in Iraq and Afghanistan. It makes my blood boil.”
This is just straw man, say the scorpion.
His pet peeve is with the Tibetans ‘plight’

My ‘pet peeve’ was a question: did the sudden takeover of headwaters concern India? Whatever is going on in an island in Japan has absolutely nothing to do with it. Are you saying that because I don’t care about those islanders raising issues about Tibetans is hypocritical? I didn’t even raise issues about Tibet except insofar as mentioning that China took it over – I used the seemingly objectionable word ‘annexed’ (!) – after which they had control of headwater which hundreds of millions of Indians depend upon.
Anyway, like I thought, and as always, you won’t engage in discussion of the topic and only go to irrelevant wacky and insulting ad hominem.
Bye Bye Denk!!
(You get the last words, have at it! I won’t read them!)

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 17:00 utc | 676

My ‘pet peeve’ was a question: did the sudden takeover of headwaters concern India? Whatever is going on in an island in Japan has absolutely nothing to do with it. Are you saying that because I don’t care about those islanders raising issues about Tibetans is hypocritical?
Bye Bye Denk!!
(You get the last words, have at it! I won’t read them!)
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 17:00 utc | 338
——————
The scorpion is really full of it !
Its of course a fucking hypocrite,
harping on and on about unsubstantiated
‘plights’ of Tibetans while dismissing
real atrocities of the unpeople as
‘straw man’
That Indo/sino dispute is a completely
different issue, WTF has it gotta do
with Tibet/Ryukyu ?
Once again, being koed for the umpteenth
time, the scorpion ‘cancel’ me off and declare victory.
BUt I know he’d remain a silent admirer/

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 17:13 utc | 677

My ‘pet peeve’ was a question: did the sudden takeover of headwaters concern India? Whatever is going on in an island in Japan has absolutely nothing to do with it. Are you saying that because I don’t care about those islanders raising issues about Tibetans is hypocritical?
Bye Bye Denk!!
(You get the last words, have at it! I won’t read them!)
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 17:00 utc | 338
——————
The scorpion is really full of it !
Its of course a fucking hypocrite,
harping on and on about unsubstantiated
‘plights’ of Tibetans while dismissing
real atrocities of the unpeople as
‘straw man’
That Indo/sino dispute is a completely
different issue, WTF has it gotta do
with Tibet/Ryukyu ?
Once again, being koed for the umpteenth
time, the scorpion ‘cancel’ me off and declare victory.
BUt I know he’d remain a silent admirer/

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 17:13 utc | 678

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 16:26 utc | 334
like i say, you blame the workers and not the administrators and the trustees and the donors. revealing.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 17:16 utc | 679

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 16:26 utc | 334
like i say, you blame the workers and not the administrators and the trustees and the donors. revealing.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 17:16 utc | 680

Victor Gao vs two Ozzies
Read badass !
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IrKg2WUIh_k&t=394s

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 17:59 utc | 681

Victor Gao vs two Ozzies
Read badass !
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IrKg2WUIh_k&t=394s

Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 17:59 utc | 682

I can’t help thinking that the USA government ought to give away bits of it’s own territory, as an example, before it starts “liberating” bits of other people’s countries. Restore the Hawaiian KIngdom! Give Alaska to Canada! Pay Mexico to take Texas back! Grant independence to Manhattan Island!

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 18:13 utc | 683

I can’t help thinking that the USA government ought to give away bits of it’s own territory, as an example, before it starts “liberating” bits of other people’s countries. Restore the Hawaiian KIngdom! Give Alaska to Canada! Pay Mexico to take Texas back! Grant independence to Manhattan Island!

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 18:13 utc | 684

pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 17:16 utc | 340
As revealing here that you absolve the professor completely and imagine them to be workers. The later association is so incorrect as to be misleading of university hierarchy and purpose. Professors as victims, another chuckle.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 18:18 utc | 685

pretzelattack | Sep 29 2023 17:16 utc | 340
As revealing here that you absolve the professor completely and imagine them to be workers. The later association is so incorrect as to be misleading of university hierarchy and purpose. Professors as victims, another chuckle.

Posted by: Jerr | Sep 29 2023 18:18 utc | 686

Jerr @321: “Thank you for supporting my position.”
You’re not very bright. The university culture has degenerated to allow people like you to get diplomas and pretend to be smart.

Posted by: William Gruff | Sep 29 2023 18:20 utc | 687

Jerr @321: “Thank you for supporting my position.”
You’re not very bright. The university culture has degenerated to allow people like you to get diplomas and pretend to be smart.

Posted by: William Gruff | Sep 29 2023 18:20 utc | 688

It should be noted that the first US government to claim hegemony was Roosevelt’s, when WW2 was approaching its end. All the time up to then the US was content to build up its capacities, like China is doing now.

Posted by: Jan Wiklund | Sep 29 2023 18:21 utc | 689

It should be noted that the first US government to claim hegemony was Roosevelt’s, when WW2 was approaching its end. All the time up to then the US was content to build up its capacities, like China is doing now.

Posted by: Jan Wiklund | Sep 29 2023 18:21 utc | 690

“The Chinese government’s policies led to tens of millions” not dying in their first year, along with their mothers, because modern maternity hospitals and a modern medical system were installed very quickly. Babies born in Chiang Kai-shek’s last year, 1949, mostly died in their first year, along with a lot of their mothers. Those born in 1953 are mostly still alive, in spite of the Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution. That’s why the population is so much larger now than in ’49.
It’s much the same story for literacy: in 1949, almost no one was literate; now, almost everyone is literate.
I’m no a communist, but the Maoist regime managed to be better than the Chiang Kai-shek and the warlords. In any case, communism has largely disappeared since 1980. CPC ought to stand for Capitalist Party of China, nowadays.

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 18:23 utc | 691

“The Chinese government’s policies led to tens of millions” not dying in their first year, along with their mothers, because modern maternity hospitals and a modern medical system were installed very quickly. Babies born in Chiang Kai-shek’s last year, 1949, mostly died in their first year, along with a lot of their mothers. Those born in 1953 are mostly still alive, in spite of the Great Leap Forward, the Cultural Revolution. That’s why the population is so much larger now than in ’49.
It’s much the same story for literacy: in 1949, almost no one was literate; now, almost everyone is literate.
I’m no a communist, but the Maoist regime managed to be better than the Chiang Kai-shek and the warlords. In any case, communism has largely disappeared since 1980. CPC ought to stand for Capitalist Party of China, nowadays.

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 18:23 utc | 692

Jerr @334: “That is why my friend, they are responsible for the state of the Institution and hence education.”
Stop being idiotic. The faculty are not the ones who decided that the universities were “businesses” selling “products”. It was fools like yourself who complain about “Getting my money’s worth!” and “Return on investment!” University administrators heard that and imposed it upon the faculty.

Posted by: William Gruff | Sep 29 2023 18:26 utc | 693

Jerr @334: “That is why my friend, they are responsible for the state of the Institution and hence education.”
Stop being idiotic. The faculty are not the ones who decided that the universities were “businesses” selling “products”. It was fools like yourself who complain about “Getting my money’s worth!” and “Return on investment!” University administrators heard that and imposed it upon the faculty.

Posted by: William Gruff | Sep 29 2023 18:26 utc | 694

@ Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:34 utc | 328

The CPC regime regards religion as a danger to the state, presumably because it might threaten their authority if a following gets too large.

The fourteen years long ordeal known as the Taiping Rebellion (1850-1864) comes to mind…. oh, and the White Lotus Rebellion of the late eighteenth century and the Red Turban Rebellion of the fourteenth century too. I think those bits of history are taught within the Chinese educational system.

Posted by: majoab | Sep 29 2023 18:27 utc | 695

@ Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 15:34 utc | 328

The CPC regime regards religion as a danger to the state, presumably because it might threaten their authority if a following gets too large.

The fourteen years long ordeal known as the Taiping Rebellion (1850-1864) comes to mind…. oh, and the White Lotus Rebellion of the late eighteenth century and the Red Turban Rebellion of the fourteenth century too. I think those bits of history are taught within the Chinese educational system.

Posted by: majoab | Sep 29 2023 18:27 utc | 696

BUt I know he’d remain a silent admirer/
Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 17:13 utc | 339
Sadly, not so silent.
Obviously an admirer though. hehehe!
And despite
“Bye Bye Denk!! (You get the last words, have at it! I won’t read them!)”
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 17:00 utc | 338
,
he’ll read them. Can’t help himself.
Narcissists have no self-control.
Your perfect record intact.

Posted by: waynorinorway | Sep 29 2023 19:23 utc | 697

BUt I know he’d remain a silent admirer/
Posted by: denk | Sep 29 2023 17:13 utc | 339
Sadly, not so silent.
Obviously an admirer though. hehehe!
And despite
“Bye Bye Denk!! (You get the last words, have at it! I won’t read them!)”
Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 29 2023 17:00 utc | 338
,
he’ll read them. Can’t help himself.
Narcissists have no self-control.
Your perfect record intact.

Posted by: waynorinorway | Sep 29 2023 19:23 utc | 698

‘Barring nuclear Holocaust, china and it’s allies will win the world. What they will do with it is an open question.”- Ahenobarbus
Hopefully, they’ll fix global warming/climate change before it’s too late. US pretences that “It ain’t happening!” or “it’s totally natural!” remind me of a relative who let his house cave in rather than fix the leaky roof. 🙁
China’s leaders are mostly engineers, used to making things actually happen. US leaders are mostly lawyers (and lately TV actors), used to talking a lot.

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 19:33 utc | 699

‘Barring nuclear Holocaust, china and it’s allies will win the world. What they will do with it is an open question.”- Ahenobarbus
Hopefully, they’ll fix global warming/climate change before it’s too late. US pretences that “It ain’t happening!” or “it’s totally natural!” remind me of a relative who let his house cave in rather than fix the leaky roof. 🙁
China’s leaders are mostly engineers, used to making things actually happen. US leaders are mostly lawyers (and lately TV actors), used to talking a lot.

Posted by: lester | Sep 29 2023 19:33 utc | 700