Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
August 19, 2023
Ukraine SitRep: Chernihiv Drone Exhibition – Russian Offensive

This morning at around 10:00 local time a Russian missile hit the drama theater in Chernihiv, some 150 kilometer north of Kiev:

"Five people died," Ukrainian Interior Minister Igor Klymenko said about the Chernihiv attack on Telegram. "Thirty-seven people were wounded, including 11 children."

Zelensky said the attack hit "in the center of the city" in a square that houses a "polytechnic university, a theatre".

"An ordinary Saturday, which Russia turned into a day of pain and loss," the Ukrainian leader said after he had arrived in Sweden.

He posted a video from the scene that showed debris around a large Soviet-era building, with parked cars around it that were partially destroyed, with smashed roofs and windows blown out.

AFP reporters saw fire trucks outside the Taras Shevchenko Drama Theatre and Music Academy, which suffered some damage.

The Ukrainian news site Strana reported that the missile hit a conference and exhibition about drones (machine translation):

13:54 There was a comment from the organizer of the drone exhibition at the Chernihiv Drama Theater, which was the target of a Russian strike.

Recall that after the strike, it turned out that the announcement of the exhibition was published in advance. Because of this, the organizers of the exhibition in social networks were accused of actually pointing the missiles themselves, revealing information about the event in advance.

The organizer of the exhibition, a well-known volunteer Maria Berlinskaya, denies the charges. She says that information about the specific venue was not publicly available, and it was sent to participants a few hours before the start of the exhibition. She also says that as soon as the air raid alert started, the exhibition was stopped.

At the same time, judging from the message of Berlinskaya, some of the participants of the exhibition suffered from the impact, as after the alarm was announced, they went not to the shelter, but to the street.

This week the Ukrainian army committed its last reserve brigade with western equipment to its counter-offensive. It will get ground up just like the forces it is replacing. The furthest the counter-offensive has gone in total was in the south of Orkiv where it progressed some 12 kilometer. It took more than 72 days, and many losses of men and material, to get that far. Tokmak, an important traffic center that Ukraine would like to take, is still 12 kilometer away. It is also protected by several well build defensive lines which the Ukrainian forces will be unable to cross.


bigger

On the second axis of the counter-offensive, south of Velyka Novosilka, the maximum progress is some 6 to 8 kilometer. Several small villages, now destroyed, were captured along the way. The number of lives lost during the fight is much bigger than the number of inhabitants those villages previously had.

The aim of the counter-offensive was to reach the Azov Sea or, if that was not possible, to go far enough to get all southern roads under artillery fire. The distance from the frontline to the sea as of June 5 was 100 kilometer. There are still 88 kilometer to go. But time is running out and all reserves have been committed.

Over the last week the Russian Defense Ministry reported on average 770 Ukrainian frontline casualties per day. The Ukrainian counter-offensive will likely culminate next week. It has reached is maximum potential and will now peter out.

That is the moment when the Russian army will go on the offensive. A sure sign of this was last night's visit of President Putin to Rostov-on-Don from where the 'special military operation' is controlled. General Gerasimov, the leader of the Russian military, and others briefed Putin about their plans.

I have no idea where or how large the Russian offensive will be, but two days ago the Belorussian President Lukashenko gave a hint of its potential size:

COMBATE |🇵🇷 – @upholdreality – 21:56 UTC · Aug 17, 2023

LUKASHENKO to Ukrainian reporter: "Your counteroffensive cost 45,000 people in dead and maimed. 45,000!.. Your losses are 1 to 8 at the frontline. And [Russia has] 250,000 people in reserve with cutting-edge hardware. You will be crushed… and the Poles rub their hands in glee. Pushed by the Americans, they will cut off the western regions… You have to take your head into your hands and act on the basis of reality. Act in the interests of this huge and beautiful territory."
video

Here is a longer version of the Lukashenko video with close captioning and the complete interview which unfortunately has no close captioning.

Comments

Your premise heavily depends on those asserted casualty numbers actually being true, though…
Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 21:21 utc | 94
Take a stroll out of your Langley basement and grab a Washington Post for the casualty numbers, my poison dwarf. Even your masters are accepting that.
They’re gonna can you if you don’t step up your game, Inkster!

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Aug 19 2023 21:48 utc | 101

The Russian counter-offensive (after the UkraNazi one is finished) still looks to me like a myth. The fact that Lukashenko hints at it, just makes me even more skepital.
It reminds me of Serbia’s President last year saying that Russia was going to propose a peace plan and, if not accepted, then Putin would unleash hell.
It’s been almost a year since those words and the only hell I see is in the lives of Ukrainian civilians near front lines and near Russian missile targets, and in the lives of Russian civilians in the border of several Russian oblasts like Bryansk, Kursk, and Belgorod, but also in Lugansk, Donetsk, and Crimea.
What kind of “plan” is this? An old man cleaning the street in Rostov-on-Don said it all, full of sarcasm, during the Wagner thing (insurrection? protest?):
“it’s all according to plan”.
What plan? No one knows. But whatever happens, it’s according to that “plan”. If Moscow suffers drone attacks, “it’s according to plan”. If UkraNazis daily shell Donetsk city, “it’s according to plan”, if UkraNazis dladvance 0, 6, 12, or more Km, it doesn’t matter the distance, “it’s all according to plan”, etc.
So now my attitude towards the 100% provoked and very justified Russian military intervention is to wait and see.
All attempts to predict the future events are a waste of time.
How can Russia make a counter-offensive with quick and deep movements, if even yesterday a Ka-52 was shot down by a Manpad near the frontline, on the Russian side?
What is the Russian stash of “wonder weapons” that Lukashenko is talking about?
Where are (and doing what) those 250 thousand reserves?
How can Russia reach Kherson again if they’re not even able to defeat the UkraNazi tiny bridgehead near the Antonovsky bridge in one of the Dniepr’s islands supposedly controlled by Russia?
And the billion Ruble question: what’s the rationale in having allegedly 1-8 casualty ratio (= +5 thousand Russian casualties only during this UkraNazi counteroffensive) and keep waiting for more waves of western military aid, instead of making a real siege of Kiev and attacks at the decision centers in order to overthrow the UkraNazi regime and end this thing?
Are a few photos of a dozen burned Leopards worth all of those Russian casualties?
How many more will be worth just to see 1 or 2 Challengers burn? And a Patriot launcher? And then a few Abrams? And then maybe a dozen F16?
Posted by: Carlos Marques | Aug 19 2023 15:32 utc | 12

My dear Carlos….
The point of killing and / or maiming 8 of your enemies for every one of your men is to de-militarize them…
Your nunbers are off by the way…. The Ukies lost 12,000 kia/wia during the first 2.5 weeks of August, in addition to the 43.000 they lost during June-July. This totals 55,000 of the 60,000 they reserved for the offensive.
Then there is the not so small matter of 1 million Ukie KIA/WIA as evinced by the SIM card data….
To us the plan is obvious…. hunker down in prepared positions and let the bastards come at us in the open where we can kill them…. All the while we find and destroy their ammo, fuel, artillery, aircraft, power plants, water supplies, and traction stations… While we take as few casualties as possible and we recruit 400,000 more men, and we outfit them for battle…
It is unfortunate that you cannot see this…. Perhaps English/German/Russian lessons might be appropriate???
INDY

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Aug 19 2023 21:52 utc | 102

Borzzikman released a video of the AFU’s elite group Maroon, which has been deployed in the right bank of Dnepr river in Kherson direction. Apparently Maroon group is equipped with the British Challenger tanks, 40 M-777 pieces and M-109 Paladin. The Maroon group originally was planned to deliver the final blow to RU army, after the counter-offensive defeated it. Therefore AFU has intensified its attack actions across the southern front, in order to ensure Maroon group receives as little resistance as possible.
Maroon group is planning to make artillery preparation and cross the Dnepr river.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6jJIp8azc6U

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 21:55 utc | 103

Aside from Putin having attended the meeting, nothing else was revealed by the Kremlin’s readout of the Rostov on Don visit. Meanwhile, Lavrov was interviewed by International Affairs magazine and is now my latest substack article. Here’s the opening question:
“The world has entered a period of confrontation between the concepts of global development: the positions of Russia, China and, in general, the non-West as opposed to the policy of Western domination. Was it inevitable, based on the differences in civilizations, approaches to the use of force and international law, an understanding of the role of international institutions? In the context of current challenges, what, in your opinion, is the role and mission of Russia?”

Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 19 2023 21:57 utc | 104

knighthawk | Aug 19 2023 21:40 utc | 99
It’s a question of which side either cracks or just runs out of bodies, and with zero inside knowledge (but looking at “the balance of forces”) it seems likely to me that it’ll be rump Ukraine which cracks.
When that’ll be would need inside info to determine. When Bakhmut fell we were looking forward to a move on Kramatorsk and Sloviansk, but Ukrainian resistance has been strong. But what can’t go on forever won’t. It looks as if the slaughter will continue until that point is reached.
Anyone else with info on Carpathian Rail Tunnel attacks? Did they happen, or were they dreams?

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Aug 19 2023 22:07 utc | 105

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6jJIp8azc6U
This suggests that Ukraine has the 82nd and Maroon left and that’s it. This would explain the rather flat clobber list results: they’re running dry.

Posted by: Eighthman | Aug 19 2023 22:08 utc | 106

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Aug 19 2023 21:48 utc | 101
You show yourself prone to delusion if you’re deluded enough to think that I’m working for some imaginary “masters”.

Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:09 utc | 107

Melitopol will not be reached by Ukrainian troops! Kiev has suffered heavy losses – more than 500.000 military personnel, not counting civilian casualties! Kiev will have to give up some of their territories to save the most part of the country! – That all was proclaimed by Washington this month.
The U.S. intelligence had prepared a detailed report on the situation in Ukraine which was presented to the government this week. According to the report, Kiev will not able to get back its territories in the near future by military means. The plan to take under Ukrainian control Melitopol and cut off Crimea from Russia has not been implemented by the AFU. In addition, Ukrainian troops suffer heavy casualties during the “counteroffensive” and the total number is over 500.000 KIA and injured military personnel. This information was also presented to the whole world by main American mass media (for example – The New York Times).
The result of the report was the consideration by Congress of the issue of curtailing a new package of military assistance to Ukraine and showing a desire to bring the conflict to its final stage and begin the negotiation process. These issue are especially acute against the backdrop of the upcoming presidential elections in the United States.
https://t.me/heraldodetoledo/1746

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 22:09 utc | 108

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 22:09 utc | 108
The U.S. intelligence had prepared a detailed report on the situation in Ukraine which was presented to the government this week. According to the report, Kiev will not able to get back its territories in the near future by military means.
That’s not the same as saying Melitopol will not be reached at all. Nowhere in the report did US intelligence say it expected Ukraine to give up on reaching the city, and there’s no indication that Ukraine is slowing down its advance. If it does reach Melitopol, it won’t matter much if it did during the summer or if it took one like like it did for Russia in Bakhmut.
Posted by: Constantine | Aug 19 2023 21:43 utc | 100
You can’t be liberal milieu and fascist trash at the same time. Reminds me of how right wing attacks would call the same person Communist and Fascist.

Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:17 utc | 109

The next russian offensive will be on Kharkov. It is in fact already in play because they are aiming at kupyiansk to secure the LPR, but that also gives them a broad swathe of territory in kharkiv oblast.
There’s been a lot of mobilization and military infrastructure built up due to the Ukrainian incursions into belogorad, so that leads me to believe they’ll be increasing pressure gradually there till next summer when they’ll have the Ukrainian army really strung out over the current front and straining to defend Kharkov.
After they besiege Kharkov in earnest then events will get chaotic with both sides reacting to sudden gaps and salient the front becomes unstable, due to thinned defensive lines.
Anyways that’s then plan for russia. Look for cease fire calls to increase from Washington if they get worried, then you’ll know something big is about to move.
Assuming russia has dropped its inferiority complex and has the will to see its plans implemented. So far looks like they’ve finally, painfully learned they can’t negotiate as equals, it has to be from a position of power.

Posted by: Neofeudalfuture | Aug 19 2023 22:23 utc | 110

Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:17 utc | 109
Do you know what a Pyrrhic victory is? One definition would be reaching Melitopol eight months after your counteroffensive began, with all your reserves exhausted, and your small vanguard at the end of a very long and vulnerable logistics tail, against a vastly superior, both in terms of men and material, force with a high morale. What do you think will happen in that situation?

Posted by: James M. | Aug 19 2023 22:30 utc | 111

Posted by: James M. | Aug 19 2023 22:30 utc | 111
Yes, I know what a Pyrrhic victory is. The press wouldn’t stop characterizing Russia’s seizing of Bakhmut as that.

Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:33 utc | 112

The UN has a Canadian in Ukraine looking after humanitarian affairs during this war. How touching! Ms. Denise Brown is the UN humanitarian coordinator in Ukraine. She said:

I am extremely disturbed by the news of yet another Russian strike that hit shortly ago the heart of Chernihiv, in northern Ukraine, leaving dozens of civilians killed and injured, including children. It is heinous to attack the main square of a large city, in the morning, while people are out walking, some going to the church to celebrate a religious day for many Ukrainians.
I condemn this repeated pattern of Russian strikes on populated areas of Ukraine, causing deaths, massive destruction and soaring humanitarian needs.
Attacks directed against civilians or civilian objects are strictly prohibited under international humanitarian law. It must stop. . .here

Where was the UN when the US and allies were destroying whole cities, even on Sunday when people were out walking?

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 19 2023 22:39 utc | 113

You can’t be liberal milieu and fascist trash at the same time. Reminds me of how right wing attacks would call the same person Communist and Fascist.
Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:17 utc | 109
Augusto Pinochet begs to differ. And the right-wingers that usually do use this defamatory tactic are liberal vermin like you. It is liberal swine such as you that described in Wikipedia – a right-wing liberal and not libertarian propaganda medium – the leftist Grayzone Project as “far right and far left”. In short, the very tactic that liberal slime such as you decry is the one they took to another level to attack an alternate media outlet that has been consistent, succinct and fairly to the point and never had to retract anything or defend itself against charges of disinformation.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 19 2023 22:39 utc | 114

Info on Southfront:
“Slightly off topic, but war monitor site Southfront has a new domain after the US controlled International Domain Name Registry delisted their .org address. It is now southfront.press. Just edit the .org to .press in your bookmark, or enter that in the address bar and then re-bookmark it.
https://southfront.press/so…”
Taken from comment on wsws

Posted by: ThusspakeZarathustra | Aug 19 2023 22:40 utc | 115

richard steven hacks latest..
Dmitry Medvedev Agrees With Me…
On the future of Ukraine…

Posted by: james | Aug 19 2023 22:43 utc | 116

Posted by: Don Bacon | Aug 19 2023 22:39 utc | 113
Starting with tis own Secretary-General Gutierrez, the UN has been extensively compromised. The minions of the Anglo-American empire within it will push their masters’ goals short of going out openly and completely undermining the institution that more often than not serves the interests of the imperialists.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 19 2023 22:45 utc | 117

AG | Aug 19 2023 19:51| 78
“But then these are also people you can talk to in real, who have families, who you might know privately. And then you will find that they just will not believe anything contradicting. In fact they look at you like you were a mad person”
Funny that you mention this again. You made a similar point on Craig Murray’s blog a couple of months ago. I meant to say then, consider the fate of the puppies of the two dogs (blubell and daisy maybe?) in “Animal Farm” by G. Orwell and have a look at the following book
The Folly of Fools:
The Logic of Deceit and Self-Deception in Human Life by Robert Trivers is a book that examines the evolutionary explanations for deceit and self-deception.
A gentle read pitched for the general reader. One of the chapters deals with false historical narratives. If you read this chapter, it might help explain the phenomena you describe. He does a few utube vids which explain his basic ideas if you don’t want get the book.

Posted by: will moon | Aug 19 2023 22:46 utc | 118

“Do you believe that some in the government lied to get us into the second Iraq War?” as well.
Posted by: Roland | Aug 19 2023 20:43 utc | 89
———————————————————–
Roland, you made some very good points, but I do not give the US an out for the first Iraq war and the Iraq invasion of Kuwait. The Bush Sr. Administration lied to get the US involved in that as well. Saddam would never have entered into Kuwait without the permission of the President of the United States. See the transcript below.
APRIL GLASPIE TRANSCRIPT
Yes, remember April Glaspie and her amazing stint at Middle East diplomacy?
Saddam-Glaspie meeting
Transcript of Meeting Between Iraqi President, Saddam Hussein and U.S. Ambassador to Iraq, April Glaspie. – July 25, 1990 (Eight days before the August 2, 1990 Iraqi Invasion of Kuwait)
July 25, 1990 – Presidential Palace – Baghdad
U.S. Ambassador Glaspie – I have direct instructions from President Bush to improve our relations with Iraq. We have considerable sympathy for your quest for higher oil prices, the immediate cause of your confrontation with Kuwait. (pause) As you know, I lived here for years and admire your extraordinary efforts to rebuild your country. We know you need funds. We understand that, and our opinion is that you should have the opportunity to rebuild your country. (pause) We can see that you have deployed massive numbers of troops in the south. Normally that would be none of our business, but when this happens in the context of your threat s against Kuwait, then it would be reasonable for us to be concerned. For this reason, I have received an instruction to ask you, in the spirit of friendship – not confrontation – regarding your intentions: Why are your troops massed so very close to Kuwait’s borders?
Saddam Hussein – As you know, for years now I have made every effort to reach a settlement on our dispute with Kuwait. There is to be a meeting in two days; I am prepared to give negotiations only this one more brief chance. (pause) When we (the Iraqis) meet (with the Kuwaitis) and we see there is hope, then nothing will happen. But if we are unable to find a solution, then it will be natural that Iraq will not accept death.
U.S. Ambassador Glaspie – What solutions would be acceptab le?
Saddam Hussein – If we could keep the whole of the Shatt al Arab – our strategic goal in our war with Iran – we will make concessions (to the Kuwaitis). But, if we are forced to choose between keeping half of the Shatt and the whole of Iraq (i.e., in Saddam s view, including Kuwait ) then we will give up all of the Shatt to defend our claims on Kuwait to keep the whole of Iraq in the shape we wish it to be. (pause) What is the United States’ opinion on this?
U.S. Ambassador Glaspie – We have no opinion on your Arab – Arab conflicts, such as your dispute with Kuwait. Secretary (of State James) Baker has directed me to emphasize the instruction, first given to Iraq in the 1960’s, that the Kuwait issue is not associated with America. (Saddam smiles)
On August 2, 1990, Saddam’s massed troops invade and occupy Kuwait. _____
Baghdad, September 2, 1990, U.S. Embassy
One month later, British journalists obtain the the above tape and transcript of the Saddam – Glaspie meeting of July 29, 1990. Astounded, they confront Ms. Glaspie as she leaves the U.S. Embassy in Baghdad.
Journalist 1 – Are the transcripts (holding them up) correct, Madam Ambassador?(Ambassador Glaspie does not respond)
Journalist 2 – You knew Saddam was going to invade (Kuwait ) but you didn’t warn him not to. You didn’t tell him America would defend Kuwait. You told him the opposite – that America was not associated with Kuwait.
Journalist 1 – You encouraged this aggression – his invasi on. What were you thinking?
U.S. Ambassador Glaspie – Obviously, I didn’t think, and nobody else did, that the Iraqis were going to take all of Kuwait.
Journalist 1 – You thought he was just going to take some of it? But, how could you? Saddam told you that, if negotiations failed , he would give up his Iran (Shatt al Arab waterway) goal for the Whole of Iraq, in the shape we wish it to be. You know that includes Kuwait, which the Iraqis have always viewed as an historic part of their country!
Journalist 1 – American green-lighted the invasion. At a minimum, you admit signaling Saddam that some aggression was okay – that the U.S. would not oppose a grab of the al-Rumeilah oil field, the disputed border strip and the Gulf Islands (including Bubiyan) – the territories claimed by Iraq?
(Ambassador Glaspie says nothing as a limousine door closed behind her and the car drives off.)
_____
To the best of our knowledge, the text on this page may be freely reproduced and distributed. Information last updated on: 02/09/96
https://whatreallyhappened.com/WRHARTICLES/ARTICLE5/april.html

Posted by: Ed | Aug 19 2023 22:48 utc | 119

Lukasz is right. The Strain 404 will perish and all Kozaks, “Nazis” and Banderistas with it. That beautiful land must be cleared of that s…
After that, Strain 405 ( White Rus ) will go, with Lukasz ( Lukash-szenko), the same way.
The number of Whites will go down because they are full of s…, by killing themselves,instead of their real enemies.

Posted by: Lech | Aug 19 2023 22:53 utc | 120

Military Summary reported (from his sources) that the Chernigov strike was not merely a drone exhibition, there was also a meeting between security services and special forces of Ukraine, Poland and Baltic states. Probably dozens of high ranking Nato officers participated.
Also AFU had launched a large attack on Kleschevka and Andryivka today. 5 attacks were repelled with 400 casualties and 16 AFVs and it was characterized as a suicidal attack. Another attack in the area of Dubovo-Vasylivka (north of Artemovsk) also repelled.
Missile/Grad strikes in Kramatorsk industrial zone hitting AFV and ammo storage and some air defense system hit in Novoolenivka. RU camera drones are flying now even 20 to 25 km behind AFU lines and taking videos.
RU has stepped up their counter-artillery at Robotyne destroying M-777 and Krab self propelled artillery deep behind the lines. Heavy fighting for Robotyne itself.
AFU has deployed 1st tank brigade to the Velyka Novosilka area, and a large tank attack/battle expected within a few days across wider front of Vremievka area. AFU has already gathered a lot of intelligence with drones from this area and they probably know what are safe supply roads to them / something about RU disposition. If RU decide to withdraw, the problem is they can’t distant mine before they regroup, although they have a lot of possibilities to do this.
Putin visited Rostov HQ, probably about this situation.
Serebryansk forest / Torske. AFU is sending a lot of small groups through the forest to establish visual contact to the main supply road running west-east to the Torske salient, which is problematic for RU side. If they can’t push AFU further back in the forest / away from road, they may need to abandon the salient.
North of Lyman RU possibly advanced along the road from Raihorodka and captured Pershotravneve but not confirmed. That would be a very large penetration of AFU defense line.
Kupyansk: RU trying to encircle Sinkovka from west and east. Since the beginning of the month RU managed to destroy 20 artillery systems in the Kupyansk area and has managed to gain almost complete superiority here. Slow squeeze toward Kupyansk from the east.
AFU landing attempt west of Kozachi Laheri foiled, RU claims a group of 150 enemy were destroyed.

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 22:54 utc | 121

Reminds me of how right wing attacks would call the same person Communist and Fascist.
Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:17 utc | 109
Communists (international scoialists) and fascists/nazi (national socialists) are both collectivist militaristic
totalitarian ideologies. As such, they differ only in details (does State fully control production or owns it ouright?… does the notorious ethnic group run the mass slaughter or is it inluded into victim groups?)
So, yes, one can be both fascist amd communist at the same time by holding to a sycncretic ideology, which combines details from both (the fundamentals are the same anyway). That is what our homegrown American “progressives” are.

Posted by: averros | Aug 19 2023 22:55 utc | 122

This attitude that the Russian government is composed by demigods who should be immune to any form of criticism is absurd and for this blog, harmful and unacceptable. Especially when the criticism aims at the confounding of the murderous Anglo-American empire. One may well disagree with aspects of said criticism (such as “shadowbanned” suggesting casually the use of tactical nukes and worse, for my part), but at no point should different voices be silenced in order to create a safe echo chamber.
Posted by: | Aug 19 2023 21:43 utc | 100
————————————————————–
Gee, Constantine, I Methinks that you do protest too much. What crawled up your arse to make you lie about what I wrote which is all completely fucking true. Show me where I said or suggested that “the Russian government is composed by demigods who should be immune to any form of criticism.” I only criticized concern trolls on MOA for repeating Russia phobic content as if we are too stupid to read it (or view it) for ourselves.
And if someone wants to push the US/NATO narrative, they have every right to do so, and I have the right to call them a US/NATO Troll. Do we agree on that much Constantine: “shadowbanned” is a serial Troller, and deserves to be called out.

Posted by: Ed | Aug 19 2023 23:03 utc | 123

Chas | Aug 19 2023 19:52 utc | 79
How the rest of the world perceives the end of the war in the Ukraine is important to Russia. Does Russia want the RoW to see primarily a Russian victory or a NATO defeat? I think the latter and so there will not be a big arrow offensive. IMHO Russia will continue its active defense supplemented by drone and missile attacks behind the lines. This will continue until the Ukrainian army collapses, until the soldiers throw down their weapons and walk home. That will signify the unconditional surrender of the Ukrainian army. Then Russia will launch a bigger offensive but not big arrow. That won’t happen until NATO stops sending money and weapons into the Ukraine, which will signify NATO’s surrender. I think Russia wants to create a situation where it will be clear to all that Ukraine lost because NATO is a cowardly organization that promised to support the Ukraine for as long as it takes to victory and then broke its promise.
——————————————————————-
Well stated and not a single comment.
That should take care of big movement expectations. Follows Lavrov in getting the RoW to realign with multilateral coexistence and showing Russia’s rather incredible patience.

Posted by: Acco Hengst | Aug 19 2023 23:04 utc | 124

“Neoliberal thinking” does NOT promote the wellbeing of the people, which is precisely what Russia’s Political-Economy under Putin has done. That BigLie renders your entire comment non-credible.
Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 19 2023 18:48 utc | 69

It has promoted the wellbeing of some people

Posted by: shаdοwbanned | Aug 19 2023 23:05 utc | 125

Posted by: shаdοwbanned | Aug 19 2023 15:01 utc | 3
Which once again raises the question why US bases in Europe and the US itself are not having their planes destroyed one by one the same way.
———————————————————————-
You are persistent if not obsessive, but the question has been answered numerous times in these spaces.
Consider abstinence for a while?
Posted by: Acco Hengst | Aug 19 2023 15:28 utc | 10

Do you realize that there are only ~60 of the Tu-22M3 bombers in service, with who knows how many actually in working condition?
For Tu-160 the number is 16, and for Tu-95MS it is 55.
They are building one new Tu-160 a year, and no new Tu-22M3 and Tu-95MS.
That sort of thing — quadcopters taking them out from near the airport — can be done to the whole fleet one by one, and there is little that can be done to stop it other than completely shutting down the borders (which arguably should indeed have been done in late February 2022), and mercilessly hunting down all sleeper cells on the territory.
Or making sure deterrence works, by taking reciprocal measures.
Borders are not being shut down, and reciprocal measures are not taken. Then what is the conclusion about what is to follow?
Again, this is strike #4, FFS…

Posted by: shаdοwbanned | Aug 19 2023 23:06 utc | 126

Posted by: Carlos Marques | Aug 19 2023 15:32 utc | 12

Well said.
Meanwhile talk continues to be as cheap as ever:
https://t.me/medvedev_telegram/376

Dmitry Medvedev✔
The defeat of the West in the Ukrainian direction is inevitable.
And let their leaders, who have forgotten about their own citizens, shout with each other that they will support the stubs of the Square with weapons and money for as long as it takes. They will train soldiers for the Kyiv meat-packing plant, they will restore the ruins of the dying economy of the Bandera regime. Will maintain insane sanctions against Russia. It won’t help. Why?
For them, this is a strange war in which people who are strangers to them are dying. And although they do not feel sorry for them, the West will never go beyond the fact that it will begin to harm its interests too much. No matter how loudly he laments at his summits and at the UN. Someone else’s war sooner or later becomes boring, costly and irrelevant.
And for us it is a tragedy involving our people.This is an existential conflict. The War for Self-Preservation . Either they or we.
Some time will pass. Western authorities will change, their elites will get tired and beg for negotiations and a freeze on the conflict. Any counteroffensive will fizzle out. The dead will be buried, the wounds will be licked.
But we must not stop until the current, inherently terrorist Ukrainian state is completely dismantled. It must be destroyed to the ground. Or rather, so that even the ashes from it did not remain. So that this abomination could never, under any circumstances, be reborn.
If it takes years or even decades, then so be it. We have no choice: either we will destroy their hostile political regime, or the collective West will eventually tear Russia to pieces. And in this case, he will perish with us.
Nobody needs this.
Therefore, the only way is the complete disposal of the state machine of a hostile country and absolute guarantees of loyalty for the future.
They can only be given by Russia’s control over everything that is happening and will happen in the territories of the former Bandera state. And we will achieve it.

Posted by: shаdοwbanned | Aug 19 2023 23:07 utc | 127

Dimitry Medvedev is quoted as follows…..
Dmitry Medvedev talks about the inevitable, about what I have told you more than once. This war can only end with the victory of Russia. And there are no other options: “The defeat of the West in the Ukrainian direction is inevitable.
And let their leaders, who have forgotten about their own citizens, shout with each other that they will support the stubs of Ukraine with weapons and money for as long as it takes. They will train soldiers for the Kyiv meat-packing plant, they will restore the ruins of the dying economy of the Bandera regime. Will maintain insane sanctions against Russia. It won’t help. Why?
For them, this is a strange war in which people who are strangers to them are dying. And although they do not feel sorry for them, the West will never go beyond the fact that it will begin to harm its interests too much. No matter how loudly he laments at his summits and at the UN. Someone else’s war sooner or later becomes boring, costly and irrelevant.
And for us it is a tragedy involving our people. This is an existential conflict. War for self-preservation. Either they or we.
Some time will pass. Western authorities will change, their elites will get tired and beg for negotiations and a freeze on the conflict. Any counteroffensive will fizzle out. The dead will be buried, the wounds will be licked.
But we must not stop until the current, inherently terrorist Ukrainian state is completely dismantled. It must be destroyed to the ground. Or rather, so that even the ashes from it did not remain. So that this abomination could never, under any circumstances, be reborn.
If it takes years or even decades, then so be it. We have no choice: either we will destroy their hostile political regime, or the collective West will eventually tear Russia to pieces. And in this case, he will perish with us.
Nobody needs this.
Therefore, the only way is the complete disposal of the state machine of a hostile country and absolute guarantees of loyalty for the future.
They can only give full control of Russia over the territories of the former Bandera state. And we will achieve this.”
“>https://t.me/vicktop55/16535

I stated earlier…
Russia must destroy NATO to secure it’s western border(s)
Capische????
INDY

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Aug 19 2023 23:15 utc | 128

How the rest of the world perceives the end of the war in the Ukraine is important to Russia. Does Russia want the RoW to see primarily a Russian victory or a NATO defeat? I think the latter and so there will not be a big arrow offensive.
Posted by: Acco Hengst | Aug 19 2023 23:04 utc | 123

Nato/MSM need a “clear ending” to this Ukraine affair. It’s apparent that they (Biden admin) want to get rid of this affair and memory-hole it, but it seems MSM has just recently sunk into a more hyperbolic propaganda drive. It will probably calm down within a week or two again. They want to present this “clear ending” as a devastating RU loss… but that is something they won’t get.
I agree that much more important is the way Global South perceives it. No one cares what the mediocre intelligence westerner thinks.
RU security council said today that it will continue as long as it takes to clear Nato out of Ukraine.

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 23:16 utc | 129

Ukraine’s last big push? Maroon group? New to me, Pentagon always has something up it’s sleeve:
Something Terrible Is On The Horizon┃NATO & Kyiv Send An Elite Group MAROON against Russian STORM-Z

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Aug 19 2023 23:21 utc | 130

james | Aug 19 2023 22:43 utc | 115–
I worked Medvedev’s Telegram posting into a comment reply and note I don’t need to post it here, although the text provided omits the original emphasis and should ead thusly:
“And for us it is a tragedy involving our people. This is an existential conflict. The War for Self-Preservation. Either they or we.”
However, IMO Medvedev’s most important point is within this:
If it takes years or even decades, so be it. We have no choice: either we destroy their hostile political regime, or the collective West will eventually tear Russia to pieces. And in this case it will perish with us.”
Killing the Outlaw US Empire’s proxy nation saves both Russia and the West, a point I agree with, as does Lavrov in his interview as I discuss in the comments.

Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 19 2023 23:21 utc | 131

Deborah Patta, the CIA’s ringer at CBS had a report on the US national news tonight.
1) She said her team were headed to Chernihiv. Why there on a Saturday?
2) Strana – a Ukrainian news outlet that actually reports news responsibly noted that there was a conference of drone operators/manufacturers in the building. See further down the local outrage – at making the Drama Center itself a target.
https://strana.news/news/443037-udar-po-chernihovu-1908-chto-izvestno-o-prilete-po-dramteatru.html
https://strana.news/news/443037-udar-po-chernihovu-1908-chto-izvestno-o-prilete-po-dramteatru.html

Posted by: daffyDuct | Aug 19 2023 23:23 utc | 132

unimperator | Aug 19 2023 23:16 utc | 128–
RU security council said today that it will continue as long as it takes to clear Nato out of Ukraine.
Do you have a source for that statement?

Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 19 2023 23:24 utc | 133

France’s former president Nicolas Sarkozy has stirred outrage in Kyiv and Paris by suggesting Russia’s invasion of Ukraine could be ended with new referendums in occupied territories.
https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20230817-france-s-sarkozy-blasted-for-call-to-compromise-with-russia
———————————————
The hornets got mad.

Posted by: Acco Hengst | Aug 19 2023 23:27 utc | 134

So, Ukr. may send Maroon across the Dneiper with their ‘dozens’ of Challenger tanks to attack Kherson. Like the Russians will be out to lunch or on a smoke break.
Good Grief. What next? Maybe they could rivet pilots into missiles and aircraft to die for the Emperor. Or get troops to yell Banzai and charge with bayonets. Their eagerness to commit suicide is just amazing.

Posted by: Eighthman | Aug 19 2023 23:27 utc | 135

In short, the very tactic that liberal slime such as you decry is the one, they took to another level to attack an alternate media outlet that has been consistent, succinct, and fairly to the point and never had to retract anything or defend itself against charges of disinformation.
Posted by: Constantine | Aug 19 2023 22:39 utc | 114
————————————————————
I mean, sure, there have been trolls who have expressed fake concern, but they have been transparent due to their suggestions. And then, there has been fascist trash of the liberal milieu like the Inkanafo. But they do not define actual critical voices: Constantine @ 100.
————————————————————-
Watch out, you are very close to calling the kettle black. Everyone has a right to their views. I never heard of the “Inkanafo,” but if they want to be liberal Nazis, the west is full of them. But don’t you ever attack me for attacking Trolls again after this display.

Posted by: Ed | Aug 19 2023 23:38 utc | 136

dh @82, regarding https://news.yahoo.com/ukraine-sends-powerhouse-82nd-air-090535187.html, Ukraine sending in their last reserve battalion
That is an excellent citation, yahoo has to polish the turd by making it sound like Russia is on the ropes. You have to read in between the lines to discover the truth. This is exactly what the Russians had to do in the USSR days but now they are the skeptics and the U.S. are the fools.

Posted by: Christian J Chuba | Aug 19 2023 23:39 utc | 137

Posted by: Mbartv | Aug 19 2023 16:57 utc | 34
I’ve been wondering why this Important step hadn’t been or hasn’t been taken, to cut off the flow of Western arms. Has any more info come out?
#######
So many people fail to grasp why and how Russia is not more fervently stopping weapons imports from the west.
My suspicion is that Russia is intentionally letting them in to clobber closer to the fronts at big ammo depots and WITH their operators. Yes, a little risky that some get used against their own guys, but a far better strategy to empty NATO pantries and humiliate their offensives.
And I see it like a treatment option for an infection (weapons being bacteria): you can artificially suppress the symptoms in the whole body or you can let the body’s defence mechanism of an increased temperature overpower them at the site of infection. Full suppression of imports will just make for a longer cat and mouse game … ie, recurring infections for years. The sooner the bacteria supplies can dwindle the more natural cure is the best for eventual resilience.
Also, maybe the tunnel bombing was not so much for weapons but some impending Polish troops imports that RF Intel knows about. It’s not that RF can’t hit it. They’ve intelligently chosen not to until this week. Blocking that main line will thus force imports onto minor lines and different storage places.
Wtf would we know? No doubt MoD has clever tactics tiwards their bigger advantage.

Posted by: SCCC | Aug 19 2023 23:40 utc | 138

Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 19 2023 23:24 utc | 132
These are TG sources, and it wasn’t related directly to Nato, but dismantling the Ukraine state (which is effectively same as kicking Nato out completely, I guess).
-Russian Federation National Security Council: The Special Military Operation will not stop before the Total dismantling of the current state of Ukraine, even if it takes years or even decades
https://t.me/BellumActaNews/101705
-Russian Federation National Security Council: We have reached the conclusion that we have no choice either to destroy the hostile political system in Kiev entirely or the West will tear Russia apart
https://t.me/BellumActaNews/101704

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 23:41 utc | 139

Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:33 utc | 112
Then you know the scenario I posted would be a Pyrrhic victory for Ukraine. Who gives a flying flip if they reach Melitopol if they cannot keep the city and their army is decimated in the process. In fact as a supporter of Russia, I certainly hope they do continue with their offensive.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 19 2023 23:42 utc | 140

France’s former president Nicolas Sarkozy has stirred outrage in Kyiv and Paris by suggesting Russia’s invasion of Ukraine could be ended with new referendums in occupied territories.
https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20230817-france-s-sarkozy-blasted-for-call-to-compromise-with-russia
———————————————
The hornets got mad.
Posted by: Acco Hengst | Aug 19 2023 23:27 utc | 133
—————————————————-
Heavens to Betsy, we would never want to do something so “Democratic.”

Posted by: Ed | Aug 19 2023 23:43 utc | 141

Hahahahahaha, Martyanov now:

“Accidentally*, Russians simply withdrew from around Kharkov in 2022 because saw no military sense in expending resources on it.”

[Source: http://smoothiex12.blogspot.com/2023/08/define-win.html?m=1 ]
(*Accidentally?)
Martyanov in September 2022:
“This is a brilliant 5D chess move and the Russian army is going to launch an imminent pincer counterattack that will surround and destroy the attacking 404 forces and anyone who disagrees with me is a paid troll!”
By the way, Marty, if Russia withdrew because it saw no point in expending resources on it, why is it expending so many resources now taking back Kupyansk and advancing on Krasni Liman?

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 19 2023 23:44 utc | 142

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 19 2023 23:44 utc | 141
Perhaps because they have more resources to expend now than they did then? Logic and reasoning, nah, what’s that.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 19 2023 23:49 utc | 143

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 19 2023 23:44 utc | 141
Well tbh if you ask that.
You could ask why the French spent so many military resources trying to take back Ypres from the Germans after they simply gave it up. Why did Russians spent so many resources taking back Borodino and other places along Napoleon’s path. Why McArthur spent so many resources taking Philippines back. Why did the French spent so many resources taking back Normandy from the British. Etc.

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 23:51 utc | 144

unimperator | Aug 19 2023 23:16 utc | 128–
——————————————————
RU security council said today that it will continue as long as it takes to clear Nato out of Ukraine.
Do you have a source for that statement?
Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 19 2023 23:24 utc | 132
——————————————————-
unimperator, we are waiting, curious minds want to know?

Posted by: Ed | Aug 19 2023 23:54 utc | 145

Posted by: Ed | Aug 19 2023 23:54 utc | 144
Well read the message @138. And RT has it too apparently, was referring to Medvedev, apparently.

The hostilities between Russia and Ukraine may end up dragging on for years or even decades, former Russian President Dmitry Medvedev said on Saturday.
For Russia, it is an “existential” conflict and a fight for its very existence, Medvedev, who is currently deputy chairman of the Russian Security Council, wrote in a Telegram post. Russia must destroy and fully dismantle the Ukrainian state that is “terrorist in its essence,” making sure “this filth” never re-emerges again, he stressed.
“Should it take years or even decades, then so be it. We have no choice: either we will destroy their hostile political regime, or the collective West will eventually tear Russia to pieces. And in this case, it will perish with us. Nobody needs this,” Medvedev wrote, presumably hinting at all-out nuclear destruction.

https://www.rt.com/russia/581518-medvedev-west-ukraine-conflict/

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 23:59 utc | 146

Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:33 utc | 112

Yes, I know what a Pyrrhic victory is. The press wouldn’t stop characterizing Russia’s seizing of Bakhmut as that.

But, but, 180% ze wrong way !!
Damn, your arse looks big in that !

Posted by: Sarlat La Canède | Aug 20 2023 0:00 utc | 147

https://www.rt.com/russia/581423-lukashenko-goals-reached/

“Everything was leading up to this. Probably the only mistake we made was that we did not resolve this issue in 2014-2015, when Ukraine had neither an army nor resolve,” he said.

This is entirely, 100%, Putin’s fault. Everyone including the Donbass people were awaiting a Russian intervention. Now the only ones still defending Russia not intervening then are looking even stupider than ever with Luka and Putin themselves admitting it was a blunder.

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 20 2023 0:01 utc | 148

Does anyone suspect that come autumn, Russia might remind Bankova about its (rather mild) pinpointed 250kv electricity hits last autumn, and then threaten a full 750kv countrywide decimation if not for an immediate surrender? RF could start with 1 per day to show they’re serious, increasing exponentially until surrender. A bit like Hiroshima >>> Nagasaki, except why stop at two.
Surely, Bankova wouldn’t wilfully do that to its 20 million citizens.

Posted by: SCCC | Aug 20 2023 0:03 utc | 149

Constantine | Aug 19 2023 22:45 utc | 116

Starting with tis own Secretary-General Gutierrez, the UN has been extensively compromised. The minions of the Anglo-American empire within it will push their masters’ goals short of going out openly and completely undermining the institution that more often than not serves the interests of the imperialists.

Verité ! Comment se débarraser des ripoux? Les forces de l’ordre (hahaha) obéissent ceux qui payent leurs retraites ! Be careful, trust almost no-one !

Posted by: Sarlat La Canède | Aug 20 2023 0:05 utc | 150

@James M 142:
But but but didn’t Marty claim that Russia alone knew what “real war is” and that it had fully prepared for it and had the forces ready for the pincer counterattack?
Oh yes he did.
Memory of what Marty said a year ago, what’s that.
@unimperator 143
Did MacArthur et al give up those territories voluntarily like Marty *now* claims Russia did?

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 20 2023 0:05 utc | 151

By the way, Marty, if Russia withdrew because it saw no point in expending resources on it, why is it expending so many resources now taking back Kupyansk and advancing on Krasni Liman?
Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 19 2023 23:44 utc | 141
—————————————————————-
That was before the mobilization, I suspect that Russia didn’t want to hold on to territory that they couldn’t hold on to through the winter. Besides the Russians made Kiev pay dearly for that territory. If Russia stayed and then got separated and then overwhelmed by the AFU forces, I can imagine what you comment would have been then?

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 0:09 utc | 152

Posted by: averros | Aug 19 2023 22:55 utc | 121

So, yes, one can be both fascist amd communist at the same time by holding to a sycncretic ideology, which combines details from both (the fundamentals are the same anyway). That is what our homegrown American “progressives” are.

Fascists and communists hate each other. But they do have one thing in common: they both despise liberals.
No surprise they look similar to you.

Posted by: hopehely | Aug 20 2023 0:10 utc | 153

…Communists (international scoialists) and fascists/nazi (national socialists) are both collectivist militaristic totalitarian ideologies. As such, they differ only in details (does State fully control production or owns it ouright?… does the notorious ethnic group run the mass slaughter or is it inluded into victim groups?)…” averros@121
This is drivel. The first sentence is banal to the point of being meaningless. The second identifies you as a fascist, repeating the familiar (since Goebbels) anti-semitic slurs.
Why not read a book instead of warming up decades old bad reviews?

Posted by: bevin | Aug 20 2023 0:12 utc | 154

“Thirty-seven people” (civis) have died (ref.to b above), but within what time-span?
Within 3 days – or what?!
Also: “That is the moment when the Russian army will go on the offensiv ..”.
Hope so now, but UAF now has recovered obviosly its “latest reserves” brigades power.
And UAF having some success to destroy RF soldier postitions on ground and establish more bigger fear of civilians by firing US- delivered CLUSTER-bombs (today reported on Donetzk city center).
– What is this – going on?
– Even Army of RF planning is – nowadays? – more expanded, and would go a more aggressive tactics towards “The West of UKR”, RF has now to fire with “all” they still have. Otherise, the never ending NATO support will then win the “last” battle, even in “The Black Sea”.
Does not matter, how often PM of RF will visit the front line commanders ..

Posted by: spare_truth | Aug 20 2023 0:18 utc | 155

You show yourself prone to delusion if you’re deluded enough to think that I’m working for some imaginary “masters”.
Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 22:09 utc | 107
You may be right. I suppose you could be spouting endless imperialist propaganda at the bar out of conviction, which is even sadder.

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Aug 20 2023 0:18 utc | 156

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 20 2023 0:05 utc | 150
I don’t know who Marty is nor do I care, I don’t read him. If you have an issue with him take it up with him.
My only point being, there were logical and sound reasons for Russia’s tactical withdrawal last year, just as there may be logical and sound reasons for their advance this year in the same region. War is messy and will not go according to plan, especially the armchair general plan.
All that matters is the end result – Ukraine continues to be demilitarized and has not joined an alliance hostile to Russian interests.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 0:19 utc | 157

Did MacArthur et al give up those territories voluntarily like Marty *now* claims Russia did?
Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 20 2023 0:05 utc | 150
————————————————-
Doesn’t anyone remember that Zelensky came to the negotiation table in March 2022. That was Putin’s plan, Biden and Bojo fucked it all up, and did people of Ukraine no favors. After that, the Russian MOD knew that they needed more trained troops for a much longer slog then they first realized.
Biswapriya Purkayast, what is your point? You keep attack the Russian MOD as if they are supposed to be Demi-Gods. See Constantine @ 100 for that one.

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 0:21 utc | 158

…Communists (international scoialists) and fascists/nazi (national socialists) are both collectivist militaristic totalitarian ideologies. As such, they differ only in details (does State fully control production or owns it ouright?… does the notorious ethnic group run the mass slaughter or is it inluded into victim groups?)…” averros@121
This is drivel. The first sentence is banal to the point of being meaningless. The second identifies you as a fascist, repeating the familiar (since Goebbels) anti-semitic slurs.
Why not read a book instead of warming up decades old bad reviews?
Posted by: bevin | Aug 20 2023 0:12 utc | 153
Here, here! Notice he riffs off of old inky.
The two perspectives are polar opposites. They fought to the death before the Nazis took over in Germany and then again in WW2 when the soviets buried the Nazis.
The false equivalency was developed by the Frankfurt school and then the post mods in the 60s for US consumption. The two extremes meet! What a bunch of bullshit as proven on barricades across the world for 100 years or so.
Your one or the other Averros or you’re some moron waffling in between hoping for a return of healthy pre imperial capitalism. Many such wafflers have been crushed trying to play the middle.

Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Aug 20 2023 0:26 utc | 159

unimperator | Aug 19 2023 23:41 utc | 138–
Thanks for your reply and clarification. Seems telegraphers have made Medvedev into the entire Russian Security Council purging all else. Sometimes, Wiki pages are helpful as this supplies the security council roster.
I’ve yet to read any published statement by Russia’s Security Council. Some of its members, yes. And it even has its own website where you’ll see this excerpt from Patrushev’s interview with Izvestiya I translated and posted to my VK back in May:
“Herewith the preservation of Ukraine as a state is not included in the plans of the United States.”
Now that differs from what Medvedev wrote, but the end result is similar. The interview’s in Russian as is the website as one should expect.

Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 20 2023 0:27 utc | 160

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 0:19 utc | 156

My only point being, there were logical and sound reasons for Russia’s tactical withdrawal last year, just as there may be logical and sound reasons for their advance this year in the same region.

It was a blunder, a screwup, plain and simple. A number of field officers were severely punished for that. Very, very severely.

War is messy and will not go according to plan, especially the armchair general plan.

That is true but if you as a leader make a mistake that resulted in heavy and/or irreparable losses your shoulder blades will kiss the wall. That is the way the cookie crumbles over there.

Posted by: hopehely | Aug 20 2023 0:41 utc | 161

@ unimperator | Aug 19 2023 22:54 utc | 120
thanks for this and your many other posts..
@ karlof1 | Aug 19 2023 23:21 utc | 130
thanks karl, for the additional notes and commentary on this..

Posted by: james | Aug 20 2023 0:42 utc | 162

Posted by: Rob | Aug 19 2023 21:16 utc | 92
Posted by: Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 21:21 utc | 94
etc.
These numbers are pretty much junk. Did anyone do a comparison of KIA to WIA?
Look at the Russian wounded-to-killed of 1.5-to-1. 180,000 to 120,000. Do you believe that?
The ratios are worse than on the Eastern Front in WW2.
It looks like reporters talked to a number of “anonymous” officials who has likely made up their own estimates and the reporters put together pieces from different sources.
As an offshoot of the question, how do the Russians count someone as wounded? For example, I read that in WW2 the Germans counted their wounded only if they had a hospital stay of more than one night. The US Army had a rule that required a one night stay but you got ‘carded’ if you didn’t need a one night stay so you could get a Purple Heart. But you were not counted as ‘wounded’.
Anyone know anything about this?

Posted by: Ed4 | Aug 20 2023 0:46 utc | 163

@ Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 20 2023 0:05 utc | 150
i realize you don’t like the fact rsh and smoothie don’t get everything right, but then neither do you! i wish you’d lay off all that and offer something relevant.. but you continue to dwell on the past.. i am sure russia learns from its mistakes… and yes, they do make mistakes, as does everyone else in this world… the biggest one here as i see it is the west in its obsession to take russia down.. that is the biggest mistake here as i see it, and it has cost countless lives, but there will be no admission on the wests role in all of this – that you can be sure.. and don’t bother blaming them either, lol… finding a solution is much harder, except for the armchair generals of course…

Posted by: james | Aug 20 2023 0:47 utc | 164

Posted by: Ed | Aug 19 2023 22:48 utc | 118
For this expose I have to commend you. Many give the US&Co a free pass for creating the conditions for the first war with Iraq, when it was led by the good friend of Washington, Saddam Hussein. I was actually looking for some time for this transcript.
As for me attacking you for excoriating trolls, I never did that. My point was that the commenters you described as trolls are not deserving of the label. They are criticizing the Russian government for its policies not from the Anglo-American point of view (that Vova and the bad Russkies are threatening the peaceful world the weserners have created), but from that of those who would see more decisive action and less consideration for the views of western leaders. One may very well disagree partly or wholly with said posters, but there is a very marked difference between them and those who make pathetic theatrics or with liberal scum like Inkanafo.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 0:48 utc | 165

This is entirely, 100%, Putin’s fault. Everyone including the Donbass people were awaiting a Russian intervention. Now the only ones still defending Russia not intervening then are looking even stupider than ever with Luka and Putin themselves admitting it was a blunder.
Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 20 2023 0:01 utc | 147
———————————————————————-
You never give it a rest, do you? I guess the question to ask is: Was Russia ready to take on NATO in 2014? You have to be pretty dumb not to ask that question first, before you start pointing your finger at Putin and saying, “This is entirely, 100%, Putin’s fault.”
No, it was Obama/Biden’s fault you goofy windbag. And, if they (Obama/Biden) were capable of fomenting a violent coup that killed many people in Kiev and then allowing their hand-picked Nazis to attack the people of the Donbass, why wouldn’t they send in NATO forces if the Russian forces come streaming across the border while unprepared to fight a war with NATO: That would have been Obama/Biden’s wet dream in 2014.

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 0:49 utc | 166

Posted by: Ed | Aug 19 2023 22:48 utc | 118
For this expose I have to commend you. Many give the US&Co a free pass for creating the conditions for the first war with Iraq, when it was led by the good friend of Washington, Saddam Hussein. I was actually looking for some time for this transcript.
As for me attacking you for excoriating trolls, I never did that. My point was that the commenters you described as trolls are not deserving of the label. They are criticizing the Russian government for its policies not from the Anglo-American point of view (that Vova and the bad Russkies are threatening the peaceful world the weserners have created), but from that of those who would see more decisive action and less consideration for the views of western leaders. One may very well disagree partly or wholly with said posters, but there is a very marked difference between them and those who make pathetic theatrics or with liberal scum like Inkanafo.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 0:50 utc | 167

Posted by: hopehely | Aug 20 2023 0:41 utc | 160
Was it a fatal mistake? Did Russia lose the war? No, it wasn’t even a strategic mistake. Russia was occupying territory just to occupy territory without the manpower to hold it. Their withdrawal shored up their defensive lines so they could more effectively take on the AFU, as evidenced currently.
Now, facing a much weaker, and stretched Ukrainian army the Russians can better exploit gaps in Ukrainian lines, retake that “lost” territory and hold it better against any forthcoming offensive.
If Russia is forced to withdraw again, then we’ll talk about failure.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 0:51 utc | 168

“Reminds me of how right wing attacks would call the same person Communist and Fascist.”
Well considering that in the 21st century both of these labels are totally meaningless leftovers from a distant past, then yeah, they might as well apply to the same person. Neither means anything at all. Some people need to shake off their 1960s paradigms. There have been zero fascists or communists for several decades at least. Move on, boomer.

Posted by: ASensibleMan | Aug 20 2023 0:54 utc | 169

“They are criticizing the Russian government for its policies not from the Anglo-American point of view… but from that of those who would see more decisive action and less consideration for the views of western leaders. One may very well disagree partly or wholly with said posters, but there is a very marked difference between them and those who make pathetic theatrics or with liberal scum like Inkanafo.
Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 0:48 utc | 164
———————————————————-
Then they should send their complaints to the Russian MOD and offer an alternative. That is the nature of this this kind of troll, love the war, wish it were more destructive, hate Putin for fighting a Sissy War. But I do understand your point as well, I just don’t accept it. Why attack Putin, what do you and they want? A coup in the Kremlin, which is exactly what Washington wants: Get my drift?

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 0:59 utc | 170

People on here seem to be oblivious to the fact that Russia has been focused on securing the territories that voted to join Russia. It is critically important for the Russian govt to show its commitment to those voters, that it is able to protect them. There is still Ukrainian military active in those territories. Venturing into new territory is not the priority, at least for now. Russia cannot advance into other major areas like Kiev or Odessa without the bulk of its forces and that would mean risking attacks in Russian lands by those remaining Ukrainian forces.

Posted by: let’s get bizzay | Aug 20 2023 1:03 utc | 171

On the SouthFront issue, the same might have been done to remove ShadowStats presence:
“As background to the changes and disruptions at ShadowStats.com, our website was hosted on the Web by a company we had dealt with for more than a decade, but which went out of business mid-August, with little warning.”
It’s been down for a full month. I don’t get the newsletters, but his open-source data as all barflies ought to know contradicted USG economic statements consistently to the point where the USG was clearly lying about many things, particularly inflation, employment, and GDP.

Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 20 2023 1:04 utc | 172

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 0:51 utc | 167
Retreating from Kherson after making publicly at every opportunity a point of never going to leave this city is a failure. Abandoning hard won territory and numerous civilians whose loyalty you have asked and who have been reassured about their safety from Nazi reprisals is a horrific failure.
Sure, you can expose and denounce the Ukro-Nazi murderer who uploaded the tossing of his victims in a pit – before the hypocritical “expression of concern” by western liberals compelled him to claim he found the video in the phone of an “occupier” – yet this doesn’t help in the least, both in terms of local support and on a human level. And this happened after the massacre in Bucha, so no one can claim it was unexpected.
And while it is easy for commenters in the warmness of their houses far away to ask from these people to leave their homes, it would be more proper to demand that they be protected by those who sought the loyalty and support of said locals. Had there been sufficient troops this would not have happened.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 1:05 utc | 173

ASensibleMan | Aug 20 2023 0:54 utc | 168–
Quite the Orwellian moniker for the nonsensical comment proffered.

Posted by: karlof1 | Aug 20 2023 1:05 utc | 174

Lukashenko is Legend, he is The Man.
This interview with a Ukrainian woman journalist is brilliant strategy, and Russia owes Lukashenko a debt of gratitude. And I suspect the Global South holds the Belorussian leader in very high esteem.

Posted by: Australian lady | Aug 20 2023 1:07 utc | 175

Look at the Russian wounded-to-killed of 1.5-to-1. 180,000 to 120,000. Do you believe that?
The ratios are worse than on the Eastern Front in WW2.
Posted by: Ed4 | Aug 20 2023 0:46 utc | 162
The ratios should be much higher than that. In WWII the ratio of wounded-to-killed for US Army was 4.25. In Vietnam it was 4.45. In Iraq it was higher.
I don’t know how the Russians count their wounded but historically, since 1898, less than ten percent of wounded die of wounds, and probably less than five percent now. So, likely a good portion of the wounded, unless they lose a limb, are not terribly wounded.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 1:09 utc | 176

All Western poltiticians like Scholz, Macron, Obama Biden’s etc. + its followers must be sent to jail – or better killed by snipers asap.
Otherwise, the whole dilemma of proxy wars won’t stop ..
Now . proceeding in Africa .. Uranium, Oil, Special-Earth resources shipment will decrease due to awakening local inhabitants. Same as in Ukraine: it has a lot of resources, even most of them have already been sold to the ‘Blackrock’ companies ..
So: Free Ukrania – for itself ! (but not by EU-Polish mafia a la v.d. Liars)

Posted by: spare_truth | Aug 20 2023 1:11 utc | 177

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 1:05 utc | 172
Okay armchair general, it’s a failure, gotcha. Sorry, a horrific failure. I’ll remember that after Russia retakes Kherson.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 1:13 utc | 178

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 0:59 utc | 169
Ed, there isn’t going to be a coup in Russia due to some posters in MoA. Even Girkin, with whom I disagree on most issues didn’t support such an option. But criticism is natural when things take a course different from one evangelised by those in power.
Again, I think it is imperative to distinguish between trolls who actively try to subvert dissident blogs from posters who have a more belligerent view towards the ussian government for not, in their view, acting more decisively against the western threat. The one group consciously serves the interests of the imperialists, while the other opposes them with a set of views that may or may not be correct.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 1:13 utc | 179

There have been zero fascists or communists for several decades at least. Move on, boomer.
Posted by: ASensibleMan | Aug 20 2023 0:54 utc | 168
——————————————-
I am a communist, have been one for over half my life, and I am 70 years old, and for ten years before I became a communist, I called myself a socialist, and personally know hundreds of both on a personal basis.
And if you think there are no fascist left, you don’t know shit about MODERN Ukraine.
You may not know the difference, but we do.

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 1:16 utc | 180

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 1:13 utc | 177
I may be an armchair general about as much as you. But the slaughter of people who were left behind and the demoralisation of the remaining elements opposing the Ukro-Nazis isn’t a matter of personal interpretations, but an undisputed fact. The Russian military and government may have been surprised form the events at Bucha (and the victims weren’t even active supporters of Russia or enemies of the Maidanist regime), but they should have been aware of this terrible peril in the case of similar retreats.
And no, criticizing the Russian government for this doesn’t constitute any “defense” for the Ukro-Nazis as has been disgustingly suggested by some. It is, in fact, the very exact opposite, a recognition of the threat they constitute and the need to be taken seriously.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 1:19 utc | 181

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 1:16 utc | 179
Very good response to the”Nonsensible” poster. This one’s nonsesne could actually be construed as trolling since it aims to undermine the reality in Ukraine, if not the entire west, where fascism of the most insidious form is promoted by the liberal.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 1:24 utc | 182

SCCC@137….according to Prigozhin, they have problems, I don’t know, I’m not there, but he was. Maybe it’s a tactic of a bigger plan….or maybe they are just another army like any other and they fuck up at times.
As for tunnels, that horse left long ago, planes fly over tunnels…..and sometimes the cure, kills the patient.
Cheers Malcolm

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Aug 20 2023 1:29 utc | 183

Rybar expects some major Ukrainian offensive peaking around the 24th as he writes at the end of this article,
https://t.me/sitreports/13515

Posted by: Richard L | Aug 20 2023 1:29 utc | 184

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 1:19 utc | 180
One difference though, I don’t make critical comments on military matters of the current operation. At most I toe the Russian MoD line, since I have limited information otherwise to make any kind of informed comment. Of course having limited or no information doesn’t stop some commenters.
I will comment on other things that I know a lot about, theoretical concepts within the international relations discipline for example, or historical cases where I have data to back up my points.
Everything else you wrote is just an appeal to pity.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 1:29 utc | 185

https://www.rt.com/russia/581518-medvedev-west-ukraine-conflict/
Posted by: unimperator | Aug 19 2023 23:59 utc | 145
————————————————————
LOL, I knew you could do it with a little encouragement.

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 1:33 utc | 186

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 1:19 utc | 180
———————————————————-
It was a “faint” operation. What did you want the Russians to do, announce to everyone? It was the victims’ neighbors that tipped of the Nazis. It was Ukraine that blamed Russia, and it was the western media spread the lie all around the world. But you manage to blame Putin!!!!!

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 1:41 utc | 187

hey guys.. constantine is russian… not sure if he lives inside russia, but hes no troll.. peace out..

Posted by: james | Aug 20 2023 1:46 utc | 188

Posted by: Ed | Aug 20 2023 1:41 utc | 186
Not sure what you’re responding to. My argument was that after the massacre at Bucha, there should be no illusions about the fate of any pro-Russian elements in Ukraine passing under the control of the Ukro-Nazis. There should be maximum effort for the avoidance of anything similar (and if faint was the goal and they were aware of the dangers, they should not have contacted the populace, though, as I suggested, they may have been naive about themurderous intensity of the Ukro-Nazis).
Yet, once again, you jump in the defense of the hapless Russian president who is unjustly maligned. Well, who bears responsibility for the fact that there were hardly any Russian forces by the end of August in Ukraine. Who should have been aware that NATO intelligence would expose such weaknesses to the proxy regime. Who should be careful about public declarations about Kherson, when the danger of the city being abandoned was real?
Seriously, Ed, is there any room for criticism towards the Russian authorities? Should Putin bear some responsibility, since he IS the Commander in Chief? Ditto for other top military brass or political personnel involved. It is simply absurd to create a framework where no meaningful criticism is allowed. Hence my comment about demigods with unimpeachable credentials and positions.
And if you think that I am too harsh, what about other, infinitely more prominent people like the martyred Tatarsky? He did offer plenty of criticim for options and tactics that did cost to the troops. What then, was he part of the “6th column too?

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 2:00 utc | 189

Posted by: james | Aug 20 2023 1:46 utc | 187
So there can’t be Russian trolls? If you live in Russia and are Russian you get carte blanche, even when he posts from an emotional standpoint, appealing to pity, instead of using logic? Okay, that’s fine. I just want to make sure I know the rules here.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 2:03 utc | 190

@183 – Richard L
as ref by Rybar “..the coastline of Romania and Bulgaria” as a starting point for new terror attacks in ‘The Black Sea’?
That’s an issue RF-Commanders should have to ‘discuss’ anyway, just before the 24th August.
Though further then, this “war” will expand to attack the RF-Navy by “means of US reconn” and/or direct US-guided naval attacks .. that remains to expect for sure.

Posted by: spare_truth | Aug 20 2023 2:05 utc | 191

Posted by: james | Aug 20 2023 1:46 utc | 187
Trust me, national identity is not a guarantee for trolling activities or the lack therof, as the Navalny fanboy posting from Germany has proven.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 2:05 utc | 192

Everything else you wrote is just an appeal to pity.
Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 1:29 utc | 184
Abandoning your own is being squemish now? Sure, why not? Especially when one posts from a safe distance.

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 2:08 utc | 193

Listening to Mercouris today. He does his usual careful analysis and I learn things about events and world affairs from his discussion – I have greatly benefitted from his efforts. I am sometimes curious about what drives him to put so much effort, but his product is better than anything from any msm outlet.
One point of his performance that does make me uncomfortable is his tendency to chuckle a bit when referring to Ukrainian losses or failures.
But an aspect today that I find particularly odd is his increasing effort to blame Zaluzny and make reference to his supposed political ambitions. Anyone invovled can be assigned some blame, but constructive blame lies with those responsible and no one else: So for example the US junta would blame the intelligence services and no one else – are the intelligence services going to lay blame on NY Times or on Zaluzny or on Putin. They might actually try I suppose, but it would only serve to underline thier incompitence.
But why would Mercouris in any way lay blame one Zaluzny?
He executed the offensive that his boss required him to execute and his boss required it not because he believed it could succeed but because his benefactors required it be done and on a certain schedule. When Zaluzny said in an media interview “give me 500 tanks and 1000 howitzers…and I will win this thing” I guess he neglected to say “good” tanks etc and “real” training and “let me sett achievable plan and objectives” and really he did not expect to have his bluff called – what he was actually saying (if one were listening) was that Ukraine had no way to win. Ukraines military is a fusion of regular (corrupt and under equipped and funded) with nationalist militias (corrupt, ignorant and led by CIA) and volunteer mercenaries – it is amazing they have gotten as far as they have, but it has really only been a frontal meat assault. Well todays missiles, drones, communications and truckloads of money makes any mob boss and force to be feared. Anyway I doubt that Zaluzny actually has much real control over this mob (Zelensky seems to have Napoleonic aspirations or at least pretenses).
I dont feel any wish to defend Zaluzny, but I am left wondering at what is the motivation to lay blame with him – might just as well blame it on the dog.

Posted by: jared | Aug 20 2023 2:19 utc | 194

As the above scenario paints, Ukie general staff would be in dire straits. How long would they continue to pursue a hopeless cause? Zelensky and his NATONazis, a la Hitler, won’t capitulate politically.
karlof1 | Aug 19 2023 18:39 utc | 67
And then you will find that they just will not believe anything contradicting. In fact they look at you like you were a mad person.
AG | Aug 19 2023 19:51 utc | 78
Those two are the same argument. And they cover the big picture. Until NATO surrenders this war will not end. Russia can’t do it too fast because that will leave NATO with too many resources; keeping Zelensky in power suits just fine: let the natonazis come and blow them away.
How exactly does that apply to the crazies in the western media and government, because they are just as deranged? Go slow, grind them down, maybe not kill them but destroy their support base. That will take time because Russia has to bleed out the entire system. And at some point, the western citizenry will have to step in because the war will have to continue until they do.

Posted by: oracle | Aug 20 2023 2:28 utc | 195

Posted by: Constantine | Aug 20 2023 2:08 utc | 192
Appeal to pity is a logical fallacy, an appeal to emotions. It is unsound and illogical. English may not be your first language so this is simply an explanatory note. When trying to make an argument: online, in person, or whatever, it is best to avoid logical fallacies as they undercut your argument.

Posted by: James M. | Aug 20 2023 2:28 utc | 196

i realize you don’t like the fact rsh and smoothie don’t get everything right, but then neither do you! i wish you’d lay off all that and offer something relevant.. but you continue to dwell on the past.. i am sure russia learns from its mistakes… and yes, they do make mistakes, as does everyone else in this world…
Posted by: james | Aug 20 2023 0:47 utc | 163

There is not getting everything right, and then there is making a complete fool of yourself for a year and half continuously…

Posted by: shаdοwbanned | Aug 20 2023 2:41 utc | 197

Did MacArthur et al give up those territories voluntarily like Marty *now* claims Russia did?
Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Aug 20 2023 0:05 utc | 150

No, but MacArthur didn’t really have any choice in that matter as his back was against the water. RU light screening force simply withdrew, even bought time by holding Izyum against massively overwhelmin odds for a few weeks until they created a pretty solid line from Svatovo-Lyman.

Posted by: unimperator | Aug 20 2023 2:41 utc | 198

Inkan1969 | Aug 19 2023 20:51 utc | 90
“Moon of Alabama would not even exist without Daily Kos.”

Say what?
Please explain. I’m from Missouri

Posted by: ChasMark | Aug 20 2023 2:42 utc | 199

@ Posted by: UWDude | Aug 19 2023 15:44 utc | 18
That is worthy of framing and hanging.
South front is an example to other would be news media.

Posted by: jared | Aug 20 2023 2:44 utc | 200