Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
July 22, 2023
Ukraine Open Thread 2023-174

Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.

The current open thread for other issues here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

Posted by: William Gruff | Jul 23 2023 13:58 utc | 93
Lavrov is no fool, so Hiroshima and Nagasaki cannot have been what he was referring to, though exactly what he meant was left unstated. After all, why shred the last remaining inhibitory value of MAD? So I am confident he was referring to the Nord Stream attacks,
Just FYI, Lavrov has referred to the use of DU rounds in Ukraine as “nuclear weapon use”. He could well have meant that.
(This is no defense of shadowbanned, who operates exactly in the manner of a psyop operator or specialist in propaganda. The key tell is his persistent repetition of the message based on the principle of “If you repeat the lie long enough and frequently enough, they’ll begin to believe it”.)

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 23 2023 14:56 utc | 101

Arch Bungle @101: “Lavrov has referred to the use of DU rounds in Ukraine as “nuclear weapon use”. He could well have meant that.”
Lavrov could have meant that, but I am skeptical. DU ammunition use is still quite a few salami slices worth of escalation away from undermining MAD.
That repetition thing the trolls do can have a strong opposing effect if the trolls are spotlighted. Unmasking a paid propaganda spigot can be worth ten thousand words of reasoned and well referenced argument as readers flip the trolls’ words on their heads looking for truth..

Posted by: William Gruff | Jul 23 2023 16:10 utc | 102

#48 so the Gulf War never happened?
I don’t believe the Abrams will be any more effective in the Ukraine theater than the Leopards. There is more to combat than “fearful” weapons. Combat tactics are essential. The UF are not adequately trained to utilize many of the weapons we send.
And drones have added a new perspective to the battlefield.

Posted by: czechlist | Jul 23 2023 16:19 utc | 103

UWDude | Jul 23 2023 12:41 utc | 80
“Well, it is easier said than done. Without a leader, it is near impossible. Peasant rebellions are common in history, but becoming less so because the elites are using technology to make sure their nightmare of peasant revolt never happens.
Also, most peasant revolts were quickly crushed. We mostly never hear or read about them because they are unglorified or caste as bandits. Their success is very rare.”

God knows the current Russian and Chinese regimes (and their consumerist masses) haven’t the slightest revolutionary impulse, but only want a “multipolar” (ugly, ugly academia-type term) version of Satan’s Babylon.
They’ll happily work with the US regime to quash anyone who gets uppity, once the current kayfabe gets worked out.

Posted by: Flying Dutchman | Jul 23 2023 17:58 utc | 104

Yeah Lephrechaun, there surely is a war going on and Ukraine might be able to occasionally use some of the untold billions of dollars in weaponry shoveled to it effectively. They hit a ammo depot. Wow.
This kind of localized tactical success (which Russia repeats at scale every day) doesn’t make up for the fact that NATO gear is essentially uninteroperable trash meant to impress brass and fill MIC pocketbooks not win wars, nor does it change the inexorable overall flow of the conflict.
I listen to devils advocates, and believe having a contrarian is important. That doesn’t change the fact that this situation is a massive fuck up by Western planners who are essentially improvising now. What, should we be bragging we are being outfoxed by the ‘gas station with nukes’?
They need independent opinions in Washington and Brussels, have you offered your critique there? Where I sit your criticism is pretty one-sided and stands out merely because from my point of view the oppoiste is true.
Russia has played a bad hand masterfully and Maerica has played a rigged game like a stupid drunk who thought they couldn’t lose.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | Jul 23 2023 18:08 utc | 105

Doctor Eleven | Jul 23 2023 18:08 utc | 105
“Russia has played a bad hand masterfully…”
Why was their hand so bad? I kept being told for years about Russian superiority in weapons technology (apparently it’s taboo to remind anyone, but up till the invasion commenced the party line among “pro-Russians” was that there would be no invasion because “stand-off weapons” would effortlessly obliterate the Ukronazis that were shelling the Donbass, and therefore “not a single Russian soldier will need to set foot across the border”), and that the leadership understood fully that the empire was “not-agreement capable”.
Of course the Borderland is right there, and on the other side of the world from the imperial nest.
Sounds like Russia should’ve been able to fix this problem right away, if the leadership really wanted to.

Posted by: Flying Dutchman | Jul 23 2023 18:28 utc | 106

Intelligent Dasein | Jul 23 2023 12:26 utc | 73

As it stands, Russia’s strategy seems likely to bring about the worst of all possible worlds. We’re going to get economic collapse, revolution, and WWIII all at once.

I know what the yankees and the Europeans could do to let this become a better world (above all, stop weapons shipments…), but I need your help in understanding what Russia could do. Could you, please, elaborate a bit?

Posted by: grunzt | Jul 23 2023 19:19 utc | 107

Shadowbanned et al, with their neverending “Putin should do X” and “Why did Putin do Y?” themes, seem to live in a world where competent political leaders are ten a penny. The fact that Putin was raised to power by the oligarchs who totally owned Russia, then bit by bit stripped those oligarchs of power who acted against Russian national interest.
Who else could have done it? Who’s kept the Russian economy up in the face of sanctions, and stopped the “ruble becoming rubble”?
This guy is no friend of Russia, but seems to think they are doing well.
https://twitter.com/Gerashchenko_en/status/1683103051563794433
Isn’t it possible that Putin has a better grasp of Russian interests than (with respect) some online randomer?
It’s not like that in the US – the Deep State ensures continuity, with the occasional Trump hiccup. In many ways the Biden admin is the Hillary admin we never got in 2016.

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Jul 23 2023 21:28 utc | 108

I ask you… ?
Posted by: arthur brogard | Jul 22 2023 22:51 utc | 21
I ask you…?
Where do people get the right to make up rights. And then:
Where do you get the right to make up laws?
My comment to the Salem Witch Trials Government Loving People:
Other people are NOT your property. That is a behavior from the animal world. Please evolve. Please. Before it’s too late.

Posted by: Drapetomaniac | Jul 23 2023 21:48 utc | 109

Indian punchline
“In strategic terms, without control over Odessa, NATO cannot have force projection in the Black Sea region or hope to resurrect Ukraine as an anti-Russia outpost.”
That is why england has already got promise of a british base in odessa. Clueless Russia is seeking over danger of english occupation of odessa.

Posted by: Sam | Jul 24 2023 3:18 utc | 110

Yeah Dutchman they got death rays. And sharks with lasers and shit.
But in reality NATO hardware is 5 decades old on average and Russian kit IS leagues ahead of competitors in most aspects. I didn’t assert that Russia would zap Ukraine with wunderwaffen and win with a snap of their fingers, that seems to be a NATO politicians thing.
Going to repeat that if anyone looks completely fucking incompetent, it’s Jake the snake Sullivan and his clown posse of goofballs pretending to be strategists. Putin looks like goddamn Yoda by comparaison.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | Jul 24 2023 19:34 utc | 111

Agent Zelensky’s Ritter has just gone from Youtube through the usual trick (Cette vidéo a été supprimée, car elle ne respectait pas les conditions d’utilisation de YouTube). Is it only in France (or EU)? I ask because I know we are champion of censure here (RT, Sputnik, Rumble have long time disappeared).

Posted by: jean l | Jul 28 2023 6:37 utc | 112