Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
July 8, 2023
Ukraine Open Thread 2023-162

Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.

The current open thread for other issues here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

So cluster munitions will be the only ammunition Ukraine will be using for quite a while.
Posted by: unimperator | Jul 8 2023 19:52 utc | 78
Yep but according to AP the US has about 3 million of them, that’s about the same amount of conventional shells which had already be sent (including allies).

Posted by: Zet | Jul 8 2023 20:30 utc | 101

Posted by: Figleaf23 | Jul 8 2023 18:45 utc | 54
Since NATO is the enemy, I think your itemization, while well-considered and needful, is insufficient to the day. Perhaps by now, after posting, you do as well. Russia fights NATO, not Ukraine. Unconditional surrender by and dissolving of NATO seem to me the minimum starting points for a nation in Russia’s geographical, spiritual, and historical circumstances.

Posted by: The Rev. David R. Gr | Jul 8 2023 20:31 utc | 102

Why assume that Erdogan was totally onboard with giving up the five Azov commanders? That he shook hands with Zelensky only means that a “deal” was made and that Zelensky had cleaned under his nails.
Two alternatives, either Erdie was being blackmailed into it or he saw some advantage by doing it. (the two are more or less the same.)
Consider his/the Turkish position in Syria. Where the US wants the SDF and Kurds to be the “official” occupiers of Eastern Syria (to give them legitimation) and do some of the fighting and dirty work, but Turkey wants to expand the area it holds and eliminate the Kurds. ie not what the US wants.
Neither want Russia to spoil their respective plans.
The US needs Turkey to be “onboard” at Vilnius, for whatever they have planned.
The second item is the recent French “near regime coup”. France/Macron has a also shown signs of wanting to take another path that doesn’t follow the USUK plot. This is possibly also wanted by his backers – the Rothschilds and Schwab. The rioters had about 10% of “foreigners” and imported arms from Ukraine. Once Macron had stopped trying to join the BRICs and cowed down about a EU armed force that wouldn’t follow US/UK dicktats, the rioting suddenly stopped, didn’t it?
So by using the threat of a regime change against Erdogan, and using France as an example, some sort of visible sign of “allegiance” could have been demanded. All in the leadup to Vilnius. Note that both Hungary and Turkey were also in “danger”of having their membership of NATO “reviewed” by the US.
***
links;
Luongo
https://tomluongo.me/2023/07/07/macron-nato-and-the-fate-of-the-empire-part-i/
and Krainer for the French colour revolution as run by the British
https://alexkrainer.substack.com/p/france-under-attack

Posted by: Stonebird | Jul 8 2023 20:37 utc | 103

@ed and his fleas.
You are also diminished by this incredible analogy.
Posted by: Neofeudalfuture | Jul 8 2023 20:12 utc | 90
————————————————————–
Neo, we have butted heads in the past, so we both know where each other stands on most issues. Karls’s analogy of fleas to trolls is just that, an analogy.
An analogy is saying something is like something else to make some sort of explanatory point. For example, “Life is like a box of chocolates—you never know what you’re gonna get.” You can use metaphors and similes when creating an analogy. A simile is a type of metaphor.
Get over it, I hear much worse from the trolls on almost every thread. You survived this long at MoA because you often present views that, like it or not, often have merit and often deserve a comment or a reply.

Posted by: Ed | Jul 8 2023 20:38 utc | 104

What were the Russians supposed to do with them? The nazis went to Turkey as part of a surrender deal. They didn’t want to go to Ukraine or Russia. Going to Turkey was their choice.
The Russians got what they wanted – they got them out of that steel plant in Mariupol. And if the nazis now go back to Ukraine… do you think Russia will offer them such good terms a second time?
Posted by: Martina | Jul 8 2023 19:36 utc | 70

One of the two announced goals of the SMO by Putin was the denazification of Ukraine. You don’t denazify by freeing the Nazis you captured, especially that many of these were the AZOV leadership.
Putin took great care to capture them mostly unharmed when they could have wiped them out using thermobaric ordnance and suck the oxygen out of these Azovstal tunnels.
They where supposed to be publicly trialed for crimes committed in Donbass the previous years and to show the world Russia was indeed fighting against Nazis.
Then they got freed instead of any of the previous scenarios.
Then I saw videos of some of them dancing and celebrating with rabbis in Israel…
As AZOV has been financed by a Jewish billionaire it makes sense that its leadership is mostly Jewish.
Putin has extremely strong ties with Jews since the beginning of his career which started as as a shabbat goy in St Petersburg many years ago. Prominent rabbis have later been showering praises on him for all he did for the Jews in Russia as its leader.
Putin could not possibly kill all the mostly Jewish AZOV leaders nor expose them as Nazis in public trials now, could he?
Perhaps it also gives a clue why the Russians reportedly stopped shelling Kherson one hour before Zelenski arrived for a visit and resumed shelling one hour after he left, or more generally why the Kiev regime which is constantly branded as evil by the Russian authorities is never targeted.
I am afraid this war is primarily about culling generic Ukrainians and is quite carefully managed from both sides to yield precisely that to the maximum possible degree.
For whose benefit? Well, take a guess…

Posted by: Mushroom | Jul 8 2023 20:43 utc | 105

Saturday which means the first string trolls have the day off.

Posted by: Exile | Jul 8 2023 20:47 utc | 106

Posted by: Stonebird | Jul 8 2023 20:37 utc | 103
Ukraine never misses a chance to make a media spectacle out of anything. They will even spin losing half of Nato granted attack force in 3 weeks to a great victory. They spin returning 5 Azov guys into a great victory.
The fact is those men are pretty much useless. They can’t build weapons, they don’t advance AFU offensive toward Melitopol. Ukraine propaganda is even more over-the-top than nazi propaganda. Did you also know Ukrainians built the pyramids, and they were the first to discover Venus? Stuff like that. One AFU conscript said that he is fighting to defend the McDonald’s restaurant of his home region against the evil russkies who are trying to take it away.
The only value that you could think of is maybe the PR value is enough to bring a few more mercs to Ukraine. But in all honesty, the number of mercs has long plateaued and is on decline. Because the war is becoming less adventurous and more industrial static grinding, which Nato isn’t up to.

Posted by: unimperator | Jul 8 2023 20:47 utc | 107

What you need to understand about the return of the Azov people from Turkey to Ukraine.
The decision to return these people to Ukraine in violation of the agreements changes absolutely nothing on the battlefield. All the stories about the fact that the morale of the AFU fighters will be raised after that are lies. The arrival of these characters in Kiev will not strengthen the offensive on the Vremevsky salient and will not help to move through minefields in Zaporozhye, because this is not what is needed for combat operations.
It should also be remembered that the topic of the return of these people to Ukraine is being actively sold to the Western public at the peak of an unsuccessful offensive intentionally in order to shift the focus of attention from the huge losses of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and silence the unsuccessful frontal attacks, to which the command of the Ukrainian army is now actively trying to come up with an alternative. They are trying to wash away the 34 days of the unsuccessful offensive of the APU with one event, the real, practical, and not the media value of which is at zero.
They have tried to raise morale with similar events before. If you recall the story of the British mercenary Aiden Eslin, then you can make sure: these people can only play on camera, but they are useless on the battlefield.
In fact, the return of people who escaped to the basements of Azovstal and hid behind civilians until the last moment will not affect the trajectory of the artillery shell.
The organization “Azov” is recognized as a terrorist organization by the decision of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation dated 02.08.2022.
milchronicles

Posted by: 03POK | Jul 8 2023 20:50 utc | 108

Posted by: The Rev. David R. Gr | Jul 8 2023 20:20 utc | 98
——————————————————————-
Huuum! I have seen that some were before (perhaps on another thread). However, it is hard to argue with your logic. Still, I don’t know what Heidegger has to do with it. Sounds more like Sun Tuz or Carl Clausewitz.

Posted by: Ed | Jul 8 2023 20:54 utc | 109

The release of the 5 Azovs makes me both sad and angry. Sad that Putin got shafted, and angry at the breach of yet another deal that Russia made in good faith. And I don’t believe it is part of some concocted deal. It is pure, unadulterated malfeasance by Erdogan. SNAKE SNAKE SNAKE. Think how Denis Pushilin of the DPR now feels and all the citizens of Mariupol feel about no retribution for the 9 years of persecution by those cunts and their moronic juniors.
The mission of denazification has just sufferred a major PR setback in equal proportion to the PR win of Kiev and that smug prick Zelensky.
Unbelievable, just unbelievable shit by Erdogan. Next he’ll be opening the Bosphorus to let US/NATO ships into the Black Sea, which would not only be a slap to Russia but a breach of International Law.

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 8 2023 20:54 utc | 110

So Prokopenko and the Mariupol Azov nazis have been released by Erdoğan and are back in Ukranazistan, already declaring their intention to go right back to the front. How many times is Putin going to be taken advantage of before the Putin Plays 55555D Chess cultists finally realise maybe he isn’t all that good at this?

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Jul 8 2023 20:55 utc | 111

@Biswapriya Purkayast
“So Prokopenko and the Mariupol Azov nazis have been released by Erdoğan and are back in Ukranazistan, already declaring their intention to go right back to the front.”
Very good. And there, they will die.

Posted by: Apollyon | Jul 8 2023 20:57 utc | 112

Still, I don’t know what Heidegger has to do with it. Sounds more like Sun Tuz or Carl Clausewitz.
Posted by: Ed | Jul 8 2023 20:54 utc | 109
Heidegger because of his philosophy of being / existentialism: “Dasein” (part of the name of that troll “Intelligent Dasein”).
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dasein

Posted by: Zet | Jul 8 2023 20:59 utc | 113

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Jul 8 2023 20:55 utc | 111

You’re exactly right. Putin is just not a wartime consigliere. He is Russia’s Tom Hagen.
By the way, that piece by Tom Luongo that Stonebird linked to above is utterly absurd. It seems like Tom Luongo, like Scott Ritter, is another one of these ersatz commentators whose “analysis” has proven to be worthless during the last few weeks of real events.

Posted by: Intelligent Dasein | Jul 8 2023 21:04 utc | 114

unimperator | Jul 8 2023 20:47 utc | 107
“Did you also know Ukrainians built the pyramids?”
Well, I did know that the Sphinx was made in Zelenskys’ likeness, but his nose fell off as it was only some sort of white powder.
**
The featureless five are for PR, and will be used as such in the west as well as for Ukrainian consumption.
***
I have this gut feeling that some notable PR action is planned for Vilnius, for which apparent cohesion across all the NATO participants is necessary. Maybe even going so far as to “start the process” of Ukraine joining. There is not much of a secret that NATO is already involved physically, (except for those that watch TV or follow MsM) so there could be an announcement of increased participation (use of planes for a “no-fly zone in Ukraine? Suicidal if complete, but could be limited to “Allow the grain deal over the Black sea”) for example.
***
As long as the Ukes are not fighting for Bud lite, there may be hope for some sanity remaining.

Posted by: Stonebird | Jul 8 2023 21:05 utc | 115

” Russian Militia Has Links to American Neo-Nazi and Anti-Trans Figures
The leader of the anti-Putin Russian Volunteer Corps is publicly connected to Robert Rundo and Christopher Pohlhaus. ”
https://theintercept.com/2023/07/08/american-neo-nazis-ukraine-war/
p.s. anyone remember the fine political thriller “Eastern Promises”? About KGB/FSB vs Vory v Zakone.
Canadian movie director David Cronenberg back in 2007 gave an interview.
He sort of exonerated Putin. Adding, that Putin would probably like his film.
I liked those statements back then.
Dont know if Cronenberg being a businessman naturally as well (films are expensive) would have had the guts to talk this way now. Hope so…

Posted by: AG | Jul 8 2023 21:06 utc | 116

Erdoghan clearly miffed at Russia bombing his islamic mates in idlib province, lil bit of payback.

Posted by: Oh | Jul 8 2023 21:06 utc | 117

114 – Not a bad analogy. He is far more like Tom Hagen, than, say, Michael or Sonny Corleone.

Posted by: Waldorf | Jul 8 2023 21:09 utc | 118

Again trolls are out in force. So it doesn’t matter that Ukraine is losing a lot of soldiers every day and NATO ammunition is draining sky high. What matters is that 5 Azov cunts are back in Ukraine. Because of course, for the soldiers dying in trenches that will fix the morale back up after weeks of intense fighting.
The fact that Erdogan choosed to send those Azov soldiers back home shows that he cannot be trusted. It’s not something that the russians didn’t expect down the road.
Again, reading the same garbage with red lines and carpet bomb cities. What will that achieve? Bakhmut was almost leveled, did it change anything? The war is still ongoing because Ukraine has enough manpower to sustain losses. We will see who will win the attrition war though.

Posted by: JamesBond | Jul 8 2023 21:12 utc | 119

The fact that some people compare Putin which is a leader of nation with some mobster from a movies, shows the level of knownledge that those people posses.

Posted by: JamesBond | Jul 8 2023 21:14 utc | 120

My post has disappeared so let me try again:
Just a thought:
What will an ordinary Ukrainian soldier think after seeing all these celebrations re return of Azov people to Kiev?
Maybe: “Should I fight and die or should I surrender and return as a hero?”

Posted by: 2+2=5 | Jul 8 2023 21:14 utc | 121

“The Ukrainian TG channel ” Resident ” writes that his source in Zelensky’s OP told how they managed to pick up the leaders of Azov*:
” For three weeks, the Russian Aerospace Forces methodically destroyed Turkish proxies in Syrian Idlib. Erdogan could not prevent this by military means, which made him very angry with the Russians.
Having learned about this through intelligence sources, the Office of the President came out with a request to hand over the Azov people. The stars successfully converged – and the captured commanders from Azovstal go home to raise Zelensky’s rating before the obviously indiscriminate NATO summit. Moreover, under AZOV they launched a campaign of 500 days of heroic resistance, on Bankovaya they are slowly transforming the meanings from the liberation of Ukrainian lands to heroic defense / protracted war.” (Via Masno)

There you go with the actual backstory. A bunch of jihadists were continuously bombed for weeks in northern Syria, Erdo got angry and released the 5 Azov dudes. Who will probably be used for the perceived continuous insignificant PR purposes, contrary to the claim of “wanting to get back in the fight”.

Posted by: unimperator | Jul 8 2023 21:20 utc | 122

So Prokopenko and the Mariupol Azov nazis have been released by Erdoğan and are back in Ukranazistan, already declaring their intention to go right back to the front. How many times is Putin going to be taken advantage of before the Putin Plays 55555D Chess cultists finally realise maybe he isn’t all that good at this?
Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Jul 8 2023 20:55 utc | 111
————————————————————-
Talking about fleas!

Posted by: Ed | Jul 8 2023 21:22 utc | 123

Heck, all they’d have to do is offer a slightly discounted price for CNY rather than USD purchases and the demand for yuan would skyrocket as much or as little as they wanted.
Posted by: BillB | Jul 8 2023 17:32 utc | 25
For years, China has purposely kept its RMB pegged at around 6.7 for a US dollar. The explanation I read way back when was to stabilize their purchasing power. Now? Will that change? So far, it hasn’t.

Posted by: HelenB | Jul 8 2023 21:24 utc | 124

Posted by: unimperator | Jul 8 2023 21:20 utc | 122
I’m also wondering if Erdogan is piqued because he’s heard hints that the grain deal won’t be extended?

Posted by: West of England Andy | Jul 8 2023 21:24 utc | 125

This is hilarious. I guess building tanks 24/7 happens in Russia now because they “bled the west” of 12 leopards. You should rename to HateDonbass or HateKremlin or HateBelgorod, it would match your post logic
Posted by: rk | Jul 8 2023 18:37 utc | 51
#############
Why would I take a negative username? That seems like very small and petty thinking. I *try* to rise above my baser instincts.
You should give it a shot. Life is better with a positive outlook and pro-social attitude. Switch it up, surprise everyone! ❤️

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Jul 8 2023 21:25 utc | 126

“Sadly, patience and restraint are not virtues in the modern era, particularly in the West. If the Russians weren’t so patient and enduring, many of the Western regulars at the bar may be feeling the kinetic effects of war touching their lives, and the lives of their loved ones.” – Posted by: LoveDonbass | Jul 8 2023 17:59 utc | 29
Patience and restraint are essential in the nuclear era; our survival depends upon them.
If the Russians weren’t so patient and enduring, the few surviving regulars at the bar might be feeling the horrible effects of radiation poisoning ending their lives and the lives of their loved ones.

Posted by: DocHollywood | Jul 8 2023 21:27 utc | 127

Ah, the failure to see past the flea metaphor to the Big Picture painted by Dr. Hudson in Killing the Host–fleas are the tiny pet parasite kept by their Neoliberal parasite Masters.
But onto Ukraine. Alastair Crooke’s al-Mayadeen column is now available, “Indecision Haunts the West: Events on the Ukraine Front Sends It Reeling”, which is rather short this week, so I’m rather tempted to copy/paste it in full. But, since the publisher isn’t censored by the West, all can read it. Instead, I’ll excerpt the important parts that past commentary shows many can’t accept:

It is clear that NATO’s doctrinal approach to conflict with any adversary — other than a polyglot lightly-armed insurgency — is flawed. NATO is still fighting the Battle of 73 Easting in the Iraqi desert: An ‘armoured fist’ that punched, backed by air superiority; one that knocked the opposition ‘for six’. But, as the US commander at that battle (Colonel Macgregor) admits, its outcome was accidental. Nonetheless it became a NATO myth, with a general doctrine built around its unique circumstance.
The western Intelligence community was already reeling from the videos of Ukraine’s NATO-supplied, burnt-out ‘armoured fists’ – when the Prigozhin débacle hit.
The problem with the ‘default option’ (frozen conflict) as ‘what to do next’ is that it just won’t work. Not least because Russia won’t accept a frozen conflict. FM Lavrov has said so, explicitly….
[The frozen conflict] It is bunkum….
A frozen conflict would be unsustainable too from the simple perspective that the two parties are not frozen in the basic meaning of the term — a conflict in which neither side has been able to prevail over the other and are stuck.
Put simply, whereas the Ukraine structurally is in stasis — and the ‘state’ hovering at the brink of implosion — Russia, by contrast, is fully plenipotent: It has large, fresh forces. It dominates the airspace and has near domination of the electromagnetic airspace. Its supply lines are ‘flowing as a river in spate’.
But fundamentally, Moscow wants the present Kiev collective gone. Recently, the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs stated that the Ukrainian state has no legal standing or legitimacy in the wake of the Maidan coup, as neither Poroshenko or Zelensky had approved the reconciliation instruments with Russia, after Maidan.
Simply said: It is a signal that Moscow has no intention of colluding with the West in mounting the fiction that Kiev fought Russia to a standstill, in which neither party prevailed, thereby giving Kiev a faux moral standing, as if, in the boxing ring, the referee raises the arm of both battered, contending boxers aloft, and calls ‘a tie’.
The Ukraine conflict is no ‘tie’. [My Emphasis]

I placed the emphasis because that is but one of the lead indicators recently made that Russia considers Ukraine to be an artificial state. S recently provided some excellent evidence as to why Lenin was predisposed to favor the creation of a Ukraine, and you can be 100% sure that Team Putin is well aware of that history as Putin himself has expounded on it several times. Then we come to NATO which I said was Nazi in my commentary yesterday, a view shared by Team Putin. China too is coming to have that view. If Western “leaders” are seen as Nazi and only capable of unconditional surrender and clearly incapable of conducting any form of serious negotiations, then what will Russia, China, and RoW do?
I expect Russia to continue doing what it’s been very successfully doing and continue to push Ukie forces to the Dnieper while EU/NATO continues to fragment politically and disarm itself. At the same time, Russia will join with its many partners and China to begin the implementation of China’s Global Security Initiative, which has the potential to rapidly progress and by the 2024 POTUS election present whoever the candidates are with a huge problem. And as Crooke states in his conclusion, Europe is faced with a great many questions and very few answers at this juncture. Imagine the continual grind going through Fall and into Winter with Ukie forces either doing the right thing and retreating beyond the Dnieper; or as the Nazis would probably prefer, to continue the slaughter of “impure” Slavs until they are forced to withdraw beyond the river as Winter sets in. Meanwhile while that’s occurring, civil strife will very likely continue to escalate causing governments to fall. IEA projections are for not enough gas to be stored for a normal Winter, and prices are already too high now. Jobs are being lost bigtime, which means governments are coming up very short on the revenues they need to operate within the deficit restrictions of the EUCB. Not only will EU nations be broke, but the EU itself will be busted. And that also means no monies for NATO or Ukraine or for the Outlaw US Empire’s MIC. OUCH!
All that and more face those gathering at Vilnius, but how many will actually talk about that very grim future possibility that currently appears very likely? You an be sure Team Biden won’t, nor will its Nazi attack dogs. But what of France; will Macron even attend? Germany is in very poor condition and worsening daily. The Netherlands just had their government ousted. Belgium has France’s events overflowing into its region. Denmark appears it will remain an attack dog, but that could change. Of Norway and Finland, only Norway has any monies, but its hydrocarbon extraction rates are in decline, and the Fins without Russia as a commercial partner are on very thin ice with an EU moving into Depression. That leaves Italy, Czechs, Slovaks, and the Balkans, while Hungary and Austria saved themselves by not kowtowing to the demanded suicide via cutting off Russia hydrocarbon flows.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 8 2023 21:31 utc | 128

Listening one of those Azov commanders eagerly waiting to get back to the front. Like many of his ilk, I do hope so. He will not get another chance this time.

Posted by: JamesBond | Jul 8 2023 21:31 utc | 129

From RT:
Russia confirms that it is launching a gold-backed BRICS currency. The topic will be on the agenda of the BRICS summit in South Africa in August. Many other countries have applied to join BRICS. De-dollarisation is accelerating.
https://t.me/+B6ixfOM5VkxhODQx
Maybe barflies have already discussed this, maybe on the other open thread but worth posting here – this is big news. Word up to now was that there would be no BRICS+ currency, I think that was directly from Glazyev, that for now, now being a couple years, de-dollarization would be limited to exchanges in national currencies as a BRICS currency would be an overwhelming challenge. If this news is true China and Russia and I’d add KSA are rising to the challenge and throwing down the gauntlet. Uncle Sam will be extremely angry.
Granted, the “launch” could be incremental over several years, in which case – in the words of Emily Litella, “never mind”.
BTW a gold back world currency would be of great benefit to countries that mine gold, Russia, China of course but South Africa, Australia, Canada, Mexico, come to mind. Australia would be much better off in BRICSland than in Petrodollaland, wonder if they understand that?

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Jul 8 2023 21:42 utc | 130

“The Ukrainian TG channel ” Resident ” writes that his source in Zelensky’s OP told how they managed to pick up the leaders of Azov*:
” For three weeks, the Russian Aerospace Forces methodically destroyed Turkish proxies in Syrian Idlib. Erdogan could not prevent this by military means, which made him very angry with the Russians.
Posted by: unimperator | Jul 8 2023 21:20 utc | 122
————————————————————-
I am not buying this story: This is just Ukrainian horse shit. As long as the Turks were attack the Kurds, Russia would not get involved. If, however, the Turks were attacking the forces of the Syrian government or Iran, then that is horse of a different color. The Turks would be attacking Russian allies, allies the Erdogan was supposed to be working to make amends.
Yes, there could be some NATO/US pressure being applied, but I do doubt that these problems and issues are communicated between Putin and Erdogan through secret diplomatic communications.

Posted by: Ed | Jul 8 2023 21:46 utc | 131

Weren’t those Azov traded for Russian officers and pilots anyway?
Making the go to Turkey was just icing. Now the icing is scraped off. Nbd.

Posted by: UWDude | Jul 8 2023 21:48 utc | 132

2+2=5 | Jul 8 2023 21:14 utc | 121–
Many Ukie conscripts are thinking of themselves by laying down in the trenches their hands very visibly empty in an unmistakable posture of surrender, a scene I’ve seen in a half-dozen videos over the last two days. But those are the lucky ones. The worst place to be is inside an APC or one of the many soft vehicles now pressed into use for troop transport as they’re not only easy targets but offer no protection and are thus taxi coffins or hearses. Those losses are why Ukies are essentially advancing on foot without any escort at all. I saw one such two-squad size group get tricked by thinking they lucked into capturing an empty trench line, but that trench was heavily mined and pre-zeroed for artillery, and the whole force was killed, all under the watchful drone’s eye. Those deaths are the direct result of the Outlaw US Empire’s policy–a policy with very deep roots and Nazi too boot.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 8 2023 21:49 utc | 133

Yes, there could be some NATO/US pressure being applied, but I do [NOT] doubt that these problems and issues are [being] communicated between Putin and Erdogan through secret diplomatic communications.
Posted by: Ed | Jul 8 2023 21:46 utc | 131
————————————
Sorry about that, I hir POST instead of PREVIEW.

Posted by: Ed | Jul 8 2023 21:51 utc | 134

RT reports, “‘Russian victory’ worse than civilian cluster-bomb deaths – Pentagon.” Yes, the Outlaw US Empire is now 100% Nazi:

US fears of Russian success on the battlefield outweigh concerns that deliveries of cluster bombs to Ukraine could result in civilian casualties, a senior Pentagon official acknowledged on Friday….
Asked if the Pentagon has assured its allies that the munitions will not cause excessive civilian harm, Kahl replied: “I’m as concerned about the humanitarian circumstance as anybody, but the worst thing for civilians in Ukraine is for Russia to win the war. And so it’s important that they don’t.”
He added that Kiev had promised not to use cluster munitions in civilian-populated urban areas and to keep records of where the weapons are deployed to make future de-mining efforts easier. The official also portrayed the deliveries as a stop-gap measure until Kiev’s Western backers can ramp up production of conventional shells. [My Emphasis]

Of course, why the bolded explanation is true isn’t provided whatsoever. It isn’t pointed out that every Ukie military casualty was a civilian to begin with, but then the Empire isn’t man enough to admit starting it all with its 2014 coup so we should always expect lies from that source. There’s a bit more in the article, including the utterly false and lame reason for providing those munitions:
“In an interview with CNN’s Fareed Zakaria, US President Joe Biden described the decision to supply the controversial shells to Ukraine as ‘difficult.’ He said that it was in part motivated by the fact that both Kiev and Washington recognise a deficit in ordinary ammunition, adding that Ukraine ‘needed’ cluster munitions to prevent Russia from stopping its ongoing counteroffensive.”
Yes, it is a Howler.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 8 2023 22:00 utc | 135

Erdogan is and always will be Erdogan. He plays his own angles. His statements after the fact do suggest that he’s pretty pissed about something. Unfortunately, he does have Putin over the barrel of Black Sea access. NATO warships entering would be a significant complication.
At the end of the day it’s a PR victory to win a media cycle for Zelensky. It doesn’t solve any of his real problems but it does violate the Geneva convention on POWs and it does make it obvious that, yes, Ukraine is a Nazi state. Those are the very minor bright sides.

Posted by: Lex | Jul 8 2023 22:05 utc | 136

@ed 104
Thank you for the compliment at the end. I was miffed because it’s been directed at me, unfairly I feel, because I know I’m just trying to figure things out.
So in that vein I’m going to say I’m leaning towards not thinking putin is an undercover traitor trying to break up russia. He had the golden opportunity to prove that thesis right with prigozhin, and instead of starting a russian Civil War he quickly snuffed it out. So I’m just a regular guy trying to figure it out, I just want data not emotional invectives to do so.
Cheers

Posted by: Neofeudalfuture | Jul 8 2023 22:07 utc | 137

Well, Erdogan just gave Russia the perfect excuse not to take prisoners the Nazi scum, but to kill them on the spot. Or at the very least to limit all future prisoners exchange to force-conscripted Ukrainian mobiks, and not to Svoboda/Azov/Right Sector goons.
Karlof1:
I think Russia is still being soft and prudent. At this point in history, it should be absolutely obvious to anyone paying attention that the true end goal in the global confrontation is not just that Ukraine ceases to exist as a country. NATO will have to cease to exist. EU will have to cease to exist. The United States of America will have to cease to exist as a country, at long last. It’s only when this last requirement is achieved that any lasting peace can be hoped for. Though I can understand that you’re not going to proclaim to a nuclear-backed behemoth what you actually intend to achieve.

Posted by: Clueless Joe | Jul 8 2023 22:16 utc | 138

As previously agreed, these people would remain in Turkey until the end of the armed conflict. Among the commanders transferred are Denis Prokopenko, Svyatoslav Palamar, Sergei Volynsky, Oleg Khomenko and Denis Shlega
Posted by: A.cagliostro | Jul 8 2023 15:37 utc | 6

Can anybody explain why these guys were in Turkey rather than in Russia as POWs?

Posted by: ChatNPC | Jul 8 2023 22:20 utc | 139

Azov fighters being released, solves 2 problems – How was Turkey going to get rid of them and how was Russia finally going to denazify them.
SloMO – How will Russia adjust to the new USnaTO tactics of not advancing and instead creating a new fortified defensive line and getting the “Korean Solution” implemented on the ground?
Dedollarisation – What’s going on with Armenia and Azerbaijan both setting up Russian peacekeepers to fail? Why did Kazakhstan unilaterally announce the end of the Astana process without consultation with Iran, Russia and Turkey? What are the British PMCs doing in Uzbekistan?
What other colour revolution/coups/nefarious plots being cooked up in those dissenting Global Majority nations and which ones will fall next?
Sure, the Yuan at the moment is gaining momentum, but does everyone believe the “Crazies in the Basement” are going down without a fight?

Posted by: Suresh | Jul 8 2023 22:21 utc | 140

Posted by: West of England Andy | Jul 8 2023 20:11 utc | 89
Azov and the rest of the Neo-Nazis as Sardaukar perhaps, both had no compunctions about killing civilians to inflict terror. The recent Dune film was somewhat subtle about it, but imo it tried to give a Viking (warrior cult) vibe to the Sardaukar, and we’ve seen how the Neo-Nazis go all ga-ga over all those kinds of runes, patches, and emblems.
NATO would be all the Great Houses who followed the Emperor’s lead in going to Arrakis for the final punch, and to collect their share of the profits of exploiting the planet’s resource, the spice.
Herbert had made it clear that the spice was analogous to oil, and the West is seriously lusting for Russia’s.
Edit: One last analogy, Russians and Ukrainians are closely related, and in the books we learn (spoiler alert!) that the Baron Harkonnen is Jessica’s mother, Paul and Alia’s grandfather. The beef with the Harkonnens goes back to an ancient battle.
And the Emperor is related to Duke Leto, by way of a maternal ancestor of Leto.
And the ancestors of the Fremen were originally religious wanderers, who even spent some time on Salusa Secundus, the home of the Sardaukar, before finally arriving at Arrakis, so they are related as well.

Posted by: Babel-17 | Jul 8 2023 22:24 utc | 141

LightYearsFromHome | Jul 8 2023 21:42 utc | 130–
I just conducted a search at RT using BRICS as the keyword and got no such article. The most recent item returned was published July 6th, “Russia proposes alternative to EU clearing houses,” which is part of what I was discussing on the open thread on the dedollarization topic. What’s proposed is a mjor move in the right direction to establish non-Western circulation portals for the new international financial system:

An international depository settlement hub should be created in the Persian Gulf to provide an alternative to EU securities transactions companies Euroclear and Clearstream, the CEO of Russia’s second-largest bank VTB, Andrey Kostin, said on Thursday….
Euroclear settles securities trades on European exchanges and serves as a securities central depository for financial institutions operating in Europe. The company ceased transactions with Russia’s National Settlement Depository (NSD) and blocked NSD accounts within its system in line with sanctions against the Russian clearing house imposed in mid-2022. The move effectively made Russians unable to access their assets held within Euroclear. It has been estimated that Russian assets stuck at Euroclear amount to €196.6 billion ($211.1 billion), the vast majority of which is owned by the country’s central bank.
Kostin also called for an alternative to SWIFT, the international financial messaging system. Russian banks were cut off SWIFT last year, which made it impossible for them to carry out transactions with foreign financial institutions….
According to the banker, new tools to attract capital should also be developed.
“Today it’s mostly Eurobonds. The entire financial infrastructure is built in the West. We propose to create new instruments which would respond to the needs of national currency and market regulation,” Kostin explained. The new financial infrastructure will attract Western investors and companies, he added.

So, what I found is important but is peripheral to the issuance of a new currency.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 8 2023 22:24 utc | 142

unimperator | Jul 8 2023 20:47 utc | 107
*** Ukraine propaganda is even more over-the-top than nazi propaganda. Did you also know Ukrainians built the pyramids, and they were the first to discover Venus? Stuff like that. One AFU conscript said that he is fighting to defend the McDonald’s restaurant of his home region against the evil russkies who are trying to take it away.***
No more unhinged than a lot of the “Black History” month stuff.
Also funded and incited by many of the same suspects.
(which isn’t a compliment)

Posted by: Cynic | Jul 8 2023 22:26 utc | 143

At # 89 – the Dune Analogy to the SMO
Myself, I would cast Zelensky as the Baron Vladimir Harkonnen; Beast Raban would be Budanov; and the Emperor, Shaddam IV, would be Biden.
Paul Atreides would be Putin. Paul’s father Leto II would be Yelstin.

Posted by: canuck | Jul 8 2023 22:27 utc | 144

The later part of Bakhmut fight noted the absence of videos of Wagners taking prisoners. Prigo announced they are not taking prisoners.
This came about after many videos surfaced showing Ukies shooting wounded Wagners outright. You don’t see those but I did.
Azoz is a murderous gang that cannot be dealt with as ordinary captured soldiers.

Posted by: Surferket | Jul 8 2023 22:30 utc | 145

Figleaf23@26 ….ending the conflict asap, saving human lives….before it spills outside the conflict zone and engulfs the ROW more so than it already has…..that makes people western agents….. that’s just dumbfuckery.
Cheers M
Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Jul 8 2023 18:00 utc | 30

Fig did say “many” not all. I too want this to end ASAP but life isn’t a video game where victory can be achieved within hours. And more importantly, there’s no reset button to respawn back to life if you fucked it up.

Posted by: Ian2 | Jul 8 2023 22:31 utc | 146

SloMO – How will Russia adjust to the new USnaTO tactics of not advancing and instead creating a new fortified defensive line and getting the “Korean Solution” implemented on the ground?
Posted by: Suresh | Jul 8 2023 22:21 utc | 140
#########3
It’s not going to be easy to build a defensive line without air cover and against increasingly effective glide-bomb attacks. Stand-off weaponry is a huge asset for the Russian side in this conflict.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Jul 8 2023 22:32 utc | 147

Can anybody explain why these guys were in Turkey rather than in Russia as POWs?
Posted by: ChatNPC | Jul 8 2023 22:20 utc | 139
It was a deal done to release a Putin friend. They were supposed to be exiled to Turkey and never return to Ukraine until the fighting ends. This was Once done on European battlefields for captured soldiers.
So Putin got shafted by Erdo, just as he got shafted by Merkel and the Frenchie in the fake Minsk1&2.
Putin is delusional that the West will honour any deals with Russia.

Posted by: Surferket | Jul 8 2023 22:34 utc | 148

@ unimperator | Jul 8 2023 21:20 utc | 122
To me, as it seems. Erdo gave the good excuse to the RF to stop the grain deal, as a consequence of his goodwill gifts to Zelensky. Erdo knows he will be juiced dry in Vilnius. I think he might have an extra joker there to trump them, if they argue too much.
For the overall strategy, it is important to stop traffic in that sector of the Black Sea. Giving a couple of Nazis to Zelensky, Erdo made him to swallow the hook, float and a nylon.
Achieving that, RF has a free reign in the Black Sea for some time, pending on ambitions and achievements during that time.
I mean if the RF goes for Odesa, go for it, but prepare the field first.

Posted by: whirlX | Jul 8 2023 22:35 utc | 149

Again, these would be struck to disrupt a Russian offensive, not support the Ukrainian remake of the Somme.
Posted by: Milites | Jul 8 2023 20:01 utc | 83
————————————————–
Thanks, Milites. Makes one wonder if they have enough resources altogether to bring that of.

Posted by: Acco Hengst | Jul 8 2023 22:37 utc | 150

I rarely watch Dima, too mentally spazzy for me, but he has an interesting take on the Azov Prisoner release. Dima has a lot of interesting takes that amount to nothing other than that but this is worth watching for in the next couple of weeks. His take is that the Russians were looking for a legal way out of what turned out to be an embarrassing grain deal, quite simply they got hustled. In Dima’s take Erdogan did a favor to Russia with the Nazi release giving them the legal pretext they were looking for. It’s actually both a tactical and strategic favor to Russia and Dima ties it with Zelensky’s rather weird visit to Snake Island.
As for Erdogan, the word “byzantine” wasn’t just coined to describe architecture, but, my own guess is that quite simply Uncle Sam like all its allies has Erdogan’s balls in a vise, given Turkiye’s strategic importance they try to refrain from cranking down the vise too much but with Ukraine going down the shitter it’s no more mister nice guy and its back to harsh threats and coups again. Erdogan is old, frail, and likely still resentful of the USA’s coup against him, which is why I entertain Dima’s idea – it would be vengeance served up cold.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EsrdKO-DMBY

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Jul 8 2023 22:40 utc | 151

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Jul 8 2023 21:25 utc | 126
🙂
Great advice, cheers!

Posted by: Suresh | Jul 8 2023 22:45 utc | 152

Clueless Joe | Jul 8 2023 22:16 utc | 138–
Thanks for your reply. Back in February 2022 when this commenced, I articulated much of what you said, although I didn’t say the USA would need to be dismembered; rather, I said the Outlaw US Empire must cease to exist and become the USA it never really has been. Much of that discourse occurred here over the years prior to 2022 as we discussed how America might be remade politically, and thus economically. My current thinking is that the RoW is capable of rapidly becoming something else that would represent a great evolutionary step forward for human development. The problem exists with those dominating what are becoming the former Plundering nations as they fiercely want the status quo retained even as that status quo is eroding under their feet. Macron in a moment of candid lucidity on his way back from China said that in so many words but then reverted once on French soil.
I wrote back in February 2022 and again recently that the West is faced with a fait accompli if it tries to act as Hitler did; and so far, that’s what it’s doing. The Neoliberal West cannot beat the RoW in the war it’s waging against it. And the longer it continues the more it becomes clear that the West must have the Neoliberalism beat out of it–thrashed as badly as possible. For as Russia has said–the longer this continues the harsher the negotiation terms will become until a point is reached where there will be no terms, just unconditional surrender. What marks Russia off as different from the West in that regard is Russia doesn’t seek the elimination of a particular class of people or of a specific polity other than those that are Nazi. Meaning, unlike Russia, this conflict isn’t existential for the West unless it forces Russia to make it so. And IMO, the RoW is sophisticated enough to understand and see that vital difference.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 8 2023 22:46 utc | 153

of one thing we are certain the Chechen soldiers who gave their lives to liberate mariupol from azov criminals are turning over in their graves,
that the Russian administrations were a tangle of corruption was and is a well-known fact that they sold the lives of their soldiers in exchange for personal benefits and the hope of a safe-conduct if the pusillanimity of the government did not get the better of the coveted West.

Posted by: A.cagliostro | Jul 8 2023 22:47 utc | 154

Posted by: Lex | Jul 8 2023 22:05 utc | 136
Unfortunately, he does have Putin over the barrel of Black Sea access. NATO warships entering would be a significant complication.
—-
The Bosphorus access/denial is governed by the The Montreux Convention which regulates maritime traffic through the Turkish Straits. It guarantees “complete freedom” of passage for all civilian vessels in times of peace. In peacetime, military vessels are limited in number, tonnage and weaponry, with specific provisions governing their mode of entry and duration of stay. If they want to pass through the Strait, warships must provide advance notification to the Turkish authorities, which, in turn, must inform the parties to the convention.
*** In wartime, if Turkey is not involved in the conflict, warships of the nations at war may not pass through the Straits, except when returning to their base.***
When Turkey is at war, or feels threatened by a war, it may take any decision about the passage of warships as it sees fit. The US is not a signatory to the Convention.
While it was designed for a particular geopolitical context, and remains unchanged since its adoption, the Montreux Convention has endured as a “solid example of a rules-based international order”, since most of its terms are still followed.

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 8 2023 22:48 utc | 155

The City of Phoenix, AZ city council has apparently decided to ship all of the police department’s “unclaimed” confiscated or turned-in firearms to Ukraine. LMAO

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 8 2023 22:49 utc | 156

karlof1 @ 142
Click the link, it contains the vid clip from RT news. RT news is available on Odysee maybe more can be found there. RT could be getting out ahead of themselves, they might be Ruskie but they are very msm-ish, not really the word of the CCP like Global Times.
Here’s a quick found hit from my Googling:
https://www.kitco.com/news/2023-07-07/Russia-confirms-BRICS-will-create-a-gold-backed-currency.html

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Jul 8 2023 22:53 utc | 157

“Russia is getting a mothelode of information on the US-NATO militaary capabilities from this conflict.”
This is true. We shall see if they can survive it.

Posted by: Fnord73 | Jul 8 2023 22:53 utc | 158

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 8 2023 20:54 utc | 110
this only is the continuation of Minsk 2 where Putins western PARTNERS pranked a naive wannabe chessmaster
Now his turkish partner is backstabbing
so many russian fighters have died for Mariupol
What is vlad doing?
Releasing the nazis to ukraine is breathtaking
Nobody is respecting the chessmaster

Posted by: hartz4 | Jul 8 2023 22:59 utc | 159

Everyone’s had their view on this, overall seems mostly negative.
Here’s my posative speculation…
Awhile ago Erodigan offered to mediate between Uqraine and Russia.
Turkey agreed to keep the Azov prisoners till the end of the war,,,,
The wars over.
Zelinsky had enough, in so many ways.
Wants out.
Shook hands with Erodigan.
Of course Ukrain being agreement incapable,the only way forward is tangible actions on all side.
Putin wins the SMO,
Zelensky gets to join nato. to be announced at Villenus in a few days time.
Biden gets an election plus.
Erodigan gets to be the hero who sorted it out.

Posted by: Mark2 | Jul 8 2023 23:04 utc | 160

Hmmm….weird. I guess the Phoenix AZ gun donation scheme is more complicated than the local PD. Seems like a few Ukrainians set up a shell/front company to handle this transfer of guns. As with everything US-Ukraine related there’s a scam of some kind.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 8 2023 23:06 utc | 161

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Jul 8 2023 22:32 utc | 147
Good point, and might I add that Russia by dint of having direct access to all their resources and factories, having great air defenses, and Ukraine being occupied elsewhere, was able to with no interference employ a large number of construction vehicles to construct its lines of trenches, and to outfit them properly with things like wooden flooring where it was needed.
Imo the Ukrainians would have an exceedingly tough time now assembling a similar amount of bulldozers, backhoes, pay-loaders, and whatnot, and getting it delivered from the North and West to the defensive trenches they are attempting to expand. Plus they’ll need hundreds of kilometers of barbed wire, and loads and loads and loads of anti-tank obstructions, land mines, and sensors.
I am no expert but I imagine targeting such construction vehicles and mounds of construction equipment would become a priority for Russian drone operators. Even a small drone hitting the engine compartment, or even a wheel or track, of a construction vehicle should disable it.

Posted by: Babel-17 | Jul 8 2023 23:06 utc | 162

@66 Echo Henry –
So, debt is bought after the sum is spent?
Or is it concurrently?
Does the state offer a money expansion that becomes actual once debt is bought?
What happens after that? Does the money expansion dilute previous prices at the markets? Would this end up as inflation?
Can the state, as guarantor of the issued money, undo the expansion by withdrawing the money from circulation? Yes, sure, but can this be done without hurting the taxed entities?
If not, how would a money expansion, equalling debt, be defused, so as not to hurt the international standing of the currency in question?
We’re speaking about the dollar here, of course. Please explain how de-dollarization is not what it seems. I’m genuinely curious.

Posted by: persiflo | Jul 8 2023 23:07 utc | 163

“ “The City of Phoenix, AZ city council has apparently decided to ship all of the police department’s “unclaimed” confiscated or turned-in firearms to Ukraine. LMAO
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 8 2023 22:49 utc | 156”
— but they’re keeping all of the money seized via “civil asset forfeiture,” no doubt. And worse for elensky, they’re keeping all of the drugs they’d seized.

Posted by: malenkov | Jul 8 2023 23:14 utc | 164

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 8 2023 22:49 utc | 156
Lol, puts me to mind of the goddess Milla Jovovich’s “The Mission (M is for Milla mix)”.

[Chorus: Milla Jovovich]
Bought a hot shot gat from a north end Guinea
(What do you know?)
Ante up with your ass ’cause you ain’t got a penny
(What do you know?)
Droppin’ bombs from above cut ya all down to size
(What do you know?)
‘Cause they’re hip to the bull and they’re hip to the lies
(What do you know?)

https://genius.com/Puscifer-the-mission-m-is-for-milla-mix-lyrics
https://youtu.be/MrQOBcFfEj0
This live version below is low quality but might induce puberty even to those on hormone blockers. lol
https://youtu.be/6OiWfZYARio

Posted by: Babel-17 | Jul 8 2023 23:14 utc | 165

I haven’t watched this but seems The Duran is stating it too:
Trade without USD BRICS currency (backed by gold) coming soon
My take is “coming soon” is five years, I don’t think Glazyev would be so circumvented on this but who knows he could have been running a diversion. SURPRISE! would be pretty fun but China and Russia don’t function like that.

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Jul 8 2023 23:16 utc | 166

Mark2: How does Russia win the SMO in your scenario when large parts of recently acceded Russian state territory remain under 404 control?

Posted by: malenkov | Jul 8 2023 23:16 utc | 167

ZH has a posting up with the title that says it all
Germany Rejects Cluster Bombs For Ukraine As Clip Surfaces Of Biden Admin Previously Calling Them A ‘War Crime’

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 8 2023 23:17 utc | 168

Tom_Q_Collins @ 156

The City of Phoenix, AZ city council has apparently decided to ship all of the police department’s “unclaimed” confiscated or turned-in firearms to Ukraine. LMAO

Saturday Night Specials to Country 404. You can’t make this stuff up – unless you’re writing dystopian fiction.

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Jul 8 2023 23:20 utc | 169

Malenkov @165
Fair point !
Zelensky has thrown the towel in the ring.
He knows it’s all over, just look at his spring/summer offensive.
His troops are already retreating.
From here on it will be face saving for the west but a win for Russia.
The territory thats under dispute will all of it go to Russia.
Again pure speculation on my part but this is how it reads.

Posted by: Mark2 | Jul 8 2023 23:28 utc | 170

That Turkey would return these dudes back to Ukraine after a set amount of time, to Russian “surprise and dismay”, could also have been part of the deal back when it was struck. Everyone hyped these commanders up to the brim, including the Russians, and I doubt it was done to make segments of the Russian public salivate over the prospect of seeing them hang — that was more a case of unintended consequences. They were destined to be traded off in exchange for more practical returns, no matter how it looked, and temporarily holding them in Turkey made the pill easier to swallow.
Some people are acting as if they’ve gone back to Russia to receive a full pardon for their war crimes and a return to civilian life, when in fact they’re going back to Ukraine to be pushed into the meatgrinder. We’ll be seeing intermittent blips in the news as they get taken out in battle or as a result of a long-range strike, if their deaths even end up warranting the extra attention and that will be that.

Posted by: Skiffer | Jul 8 2023 23:37 utc | 171

LightYearsFromHome | Jul 8 2023 22:53 utc | 157–
Thanks for replying. I did click your link and got a Telegram page I can’t open. The other link says Russian government then says Russian embassy but doesn’t say which on and has a link to Twitter I also can’t access. Ah, by increasing the zoom, I can see it’s the Russian embassy in Kenya, but there’s absolutely nothing at that embassy’s website. And I again went through RT’s business and all Russian sections–nothing. Another purported news site has no links to anything but just says RT said so, and that RT reports that Russia’s government said so–and that was supposedly ten+ hours ago. But there’s zilch anywhere. Plus, we have Pepe Escobar’s announcement in his most recent article that no new currency will be announced at the BRICS Summit.
Red Herring is what I sense.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 8 2023 23:41 utc | 172

Reading about the release of the Azov militants my first thought was “Bye-bye grain deal extension”.
It’ll be verrry interesting to see how that plays out.
Posted by: West of England Andy | Jul 8 2023 19:32 utc | 67
Hey. That was my first thought.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jul 8 2023 23:44 utc | 173

Theres lots of ways Erdogan actions can be looked at. On a personal level is its valuable to know someone is not trustworthy. That knowledge can be painful to obtain. The pain may be worth the knowledge however. Or little things dont matter. The Bosporus is still closed. Who does that benefit? I would say humanity. If it was open US UK would have felt obliged to sail the minnow into the black sea. I dont know but I dont think it would have ended well. OR Erdogan is looking out for Turkey no one else. I think thats honorable. Too bad the EU cant do that and fulfill its responsibility to its inhabitants. Not that the USAs actions seem to have the best interest of its inhabitants as a motivator in the least. It was also early in the conflict when the deal was struck. Putin was still trying to play nice with a neighbor that is going to be there no matter what. Russia cant move away from a crazy neighbor so best to avoid extreme actions. I still think the Putin soft approach is the best. Hard is nuclear. Best avoided. Now Putin knows. It can trust no one except Belarus. Certainly not China. Its in this fight alone. Its better to know the truth. Which doesnt mean Russia cant develop ongoing economic relationships with countries. Russia is in a fight a not very nice one and continues to demonstrate character. I think its important. If it goes bad and the nuclear weapons are deployed there will be no questions about too soft. If somehow against all odds the world avoids a strategic nuclear exchange Russias character will be remembered and it will have value. Erdogans actions will be remembered too. A couple Azov freaks are not going to make or break this war.

Posted by: sillydog | Jul 8 2023 23:46 utc | 174

Red Herring is what I sense.
Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 8 2023 23:41 utc | 172
I agree. The white banners in the screenshots of that tweet are too white IMO. The banners on real RT TV screens aren’t that bright. I guess someone is trying to pump up the price of gold with these fakes… dunno but something is definitely fishy.

Posted by: Zet | Jul 8 2023 23:48 utc | 175

New currency for BRICS
Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 8 2023 23:41 utc | 172
Pipe dream? Currency needs stability. Manufacturing needs stability to know whether they will be able to afford their operation. People need monetary stability to know what they can afford.
Currency created in the middle of war is of course unstable.

Posted by: HelenB | Jul 8 2023 23:49 utc | 176

Ok, found the video re BRICS currency:
https://t.me/Slavyangrad/53871

Posted by: Zet | Jul 8 2023 23:56 utc | 177

Posted by: Skiffer | Jul 8 2023 23:37 utc | 171
” … when in fact [the 5 Azovs] are going back to Ukraine to be pushed into the meatgrinder”.
No no no. How can you think that? Presuming that fighting will still be going on in the same nazi way for months yet, they will be tasked into reforming, rebuilding Azov corps for the hardest, nastiest missions against the Ruskies. Quality, high morale officers are in great shortage now. They are now national heroes and will be kept way away from dangerous bullets and mines. Prokopenko will be duly decorated and promoted, maybe invited into MoD Bankova.
My only hope is that a Kaliber will get them during some top level meeting.

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 8 2023 23:57 utc | 178

Posted by: HelenB | Jul 8 2023 23:49 utc | 176
I tend to agree. Still very early days for the multipolar economy. Imo, a global convention like the US Dollar hegemony will take decades to dismantle. Still, gotta do all things possible every day! Although, it could be argued that wartime is a GOOD time for transformative momentum. Come peacetime, apathy and status might too easily return.

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 9 2023 0:03 utc | 179

apathy and status might too easily return.
Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 9 2023 0:03 utc | 179
Ooops, “… status quo …”

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 9 2023 0:13 utc | 180

LightYearsFromHome | Jul 8 2023 21:42 utc | 130
Australia would be much better off in BRICSland than in Petrodollaland,

Yep.
wonder if they understand that?🤣🤣😂🤡🥴

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jul 9 2023 0:18 utc | 181

The release of the Azov scum reminds me of a previous prisoner exchange … its Sunday morning and I’m still in my jammies, so too lazy to do research, so will rely on patchy memory..
In 2014 at the time of the hot shooting between Ukraine and the LPR-DPR a female Ukrainian soldier shot and killed 2Russian journalists.
Something Shevenko (sp) was her name. She was extradited to Russia, convicted of murder and sent to prison.
Ukraine did it’s thing of hysterical howling and she became a Hero … constant reports on her and the terrible conditions and torture she was undergoing in Russia. Eventually she was prisoner exchanged for 2 Russians.
It was a big deal in Russia, outrage… how can Putin betray the families of the slain journos…. Putin is weak…
Eventually a family member of one of the journo said something like “ours are dead, nothing can be done for them. A prisoner exchange allows these other families to have theirs return”. Magnanimous. Public opinion swung to, yeah, OK.
Shevenko goes back to Ukraine. Hero Heroine. Huuuuge celebrations. She’s a celebrity. In her absence, while in prison, she’d been elected to the Rada.
On her return she takes her seat in the Rada. Hero, celebrity.
In a very short time she starts saying things that those boosting her don’t like.
She was then turned on and hounded. A pariah.
At moments like these I muse as to what happened to her.
The Azov boys return as heros, but the Ukraine they left a year ago no longer exists. None hold more responsibility for the destruction of Ukraine then they.
I watch their fate, from afar. I’m anticipating much theatre.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jul 9 2023 0:48 utc | 182

Posted by: Babel-17 | Jul 8 2023 23:14 utc | 165
Maynard’s “Right in Two” where the lyric “Monkeys killing Monkeys” cuts to the chase, is more my cup of tea.
I profess ethnic appreciation for fantastic Tubla solo too. Enjoy.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PSLOCedWmWM

Posted by: Suresh | Jul 9 2023 0:49 utc | 183

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jul 9 2023 0:48 utc | 183
#######
Great anecdote. Very few things turn out exactly as we expect.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Jul 9 2023 0:53 utc | 184

I thought it was recently reported that Putin was going to Turkey soon for a visit.
Is he still going?

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 9 2023 0:57 utc | 185

Posted by: Suresh | Jul 9 2023 0:49 utc | 184
Correction – “Tabla” solo. Video probably conveys what President Putin is alluding to as the fight against Evil.

Posted by: Suresh | Jul 9 2023 1:02 utc | 186

As the day progresses, my anger over the Azovs is abating, slightly. I am remembering that Russia in general, the Kremlin, and Putin’s team, basically does not give a shit about what anyone else in the world thinks about what they do. They rarely play the PR game, tit-bullshit for tat-bullshit, nor consider any likely moral outrage SMO spectators might feel. Somehow the Russian people get over it through a resilience that westerners just don’t have. I feel most for the dead and tortured Mariupol civilians and fighters.
Putin has such a nationalist broadview that “little things” like unfair prisoner swaps, unfair grain deals, unfair DU shells, unfair cluster bombs, unfair bridge sabotage, unfair POW tortures, are ameliorated by the BIG BIG, LONG TERM GOALS. Funnily, Zelensky is the polar opposite. He cries victim at every speed bump.
In the end, and in retrospect, I believe Putin’s legalistic and moral compass for his country will be hailed throughout future history.
There. I’ve rationalised myself into feeling a bit better after the worst news I heard all month!

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 9 2023 1:16 utc | 187

Putin 2 Turkiye
>…Is he still going?
Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 9 2023 0:57 utc | 186
Probably. My guess.
Before Putin 2 Turkiye was announced (by Erdogan at the Zelensky press conference) 🔥
There would have been months + months of prelim meetings with Foreign Affairs staffers and an already agreed agenda and agreed docs to sign.
Putin may be peeved with The Sultan doing his duplicitous Sultan prisoner release.. but my read is Putin will keep to his commitment.
The Sultan should know by now… negotiating the next concession just got that much harder..
Putin in Turkiye is gonna sting back at “State”. Blinken will be indeed blinking. It’s worth the trolling to go ahead. IMO.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jul 9 2023 1:17 utc | 188

Mark2 | Jul 8 2023 23:28 utc | 170
*** The territory thats under dispute will all of it go to Russia.
Again pure speculation on my part but this is how it reads.***
Odessa?

Posted by: Cynic | Jul 9 2023 1:22 utc | 189

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jul 9 2023 0:48 utc | 183
“I watch their fate, from afar. I’m anticipating much theatre.”
No drama, it’ll be a sudden ka-Boom, then their pics posted with big red X’s on ’em…

Posted by: nathan in WA US | Jul 9 2023 1:35 utc | 190

The Dolphin | Jul 9 2023 1:16 utc | 188
One thing about Putin not responding directly or aggressively to Erdogan’s release of the Azov is that it diminishes both Erdogan and his action.
It is one of the hidden powers of turning the other cheek. As an Orthodox he does understand that the Innocents must be protected.

Posted by: Jerr | Jul 9 2023 2:04 utc | 191

https://www.rt.com/news/579413-allies-cluster-bombs-us-kiev/
Opposition to this is surprising – Germany, Canada, Britain, Spain.

Posted by: Eighthman | Jul 9 2023 2:31 utc | 192

Looking at pic of ClownZ and his new best Azov friends…. He barely reaches their shoulders. They are not likely to respect a small, coke snorting ex-clown.
He’s been getting rid of any opposition, but now he’s burdened by surrounding himself with a Dirty Dozen of the very nastiest nazis.
Plot twist: One of his new pets decides to take him out.
https://t.me/warmonitors/12187
>…”Zelenskyy appointed combat officer, Oleksandr Pivnenko as the new commander of the National Guard.”
Looking at this guy… can imagine him snapping Z’s neck..
https://t.me/warmonitors/12190

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jul 9 2023 2:33 utc | 193

Open use of cluster munitions by NATO against Russia is a licence to Russia to develop long range cluster munitions shells and missiles. Placed along the new NATO border along Finland, along NATO’s most vulnerable border along Poland and Baltic states and in Kaliningrad, Russian long range cluster munitions will be a game changer and a troop multiplier.
If also deployed to Syria, it will be an absolute stunner against US interests.
Russia should also invest in developing floating and variously submerged cluster munitions that can tame NATO sea piracy. NATO has the world’s largest fleet of warships. Low cost cluster munitions in the seas can reduce them to a handful and tie them down to ports, repair yards and junk yards.

Posted by: Jason | Jul 9 2023 2:36 utc | 194

It’s not going to be easy to build a defensive line without air cover and against increasingly effective glide-bomb attacks. Stand-off weaponry is a huge asset for the Russian side in this conflict.
Posted by: LoveDonbass | Jul 8 2023 22:32 utc | 147
Russian guild bombs current estimated range is between 70 – 80 km. Plot a line 100 kilks out from current FEBA and where does that go? Cities are by nature fortified objectives and USnaTO/proxy 404 preferred tactic is to use civilian cover, now these are major cities in size compared to Mariupol.
Beyond that?
I do not mean to imply an escalation to current SMO, the objectives there can never result in Demilitarization as per 2021 Security Proposal by Russia. Russia is not going to fight in the cities, Period!
The entire rotten bunch will just decamp 404 and create a Government in Exile, and then what? Freedom fighters (terrorism) against an occupational Army was always Plan A.
The military option in 404 proper is finished. Russia has won but there’s a festering sore that could lead to gangrene.
I am hoping for a Russian military-technical solution to USnaTO’s malfeasance, leading to a complete fracturing of the Beast.

Posted by: Suresh | Jul 9 2023 2:39 utc | 195

“Opposition to this is surprising – Germany, Canada, Britain, Spain.
Posted by: Eighthman | Jul 9 2023 2:31 utc | 193”
I suspect it really isn’t opposition. It’s just preening.

Posted by: malenkov | Jul 9 2023 2:41 utc | 196

Re: #156
” ” The City of Phoenix, AZ city council has apparently decided to ship all of the police department’s “unclaimed” confiscated or turned-in firearms to Ukraine. LMAO
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 8 2023 22:49 utc | 156 ” ”
IMO:
Hope they noted the numbers and particulars . . .
Wouldn’t it be cheaper, and wholesome, to send it directly wholesale to some banlieue (suburb) of Paris or to Belgium?

Posted by: LogosApplied | Jul 9 2023 3:07 utc | 197

Posted by: malenkov | Jul 9 2023 2:41 utc | 198
Too many in the countries are on record as actively opposing cluster bombs. In the UK for instance, Princess Diana made it a “cause” so as a minimum I think you have the heir to the throne and possibly the King, extremely hostile to their use.

Posted by: watcher | Jul 9 2023 3:07 utc | 198

TASS — a few moments before this post —
“In Lithuania next week, Biden plans to hold meetings with all leaders of NATO member countries, as well as with several heads of NATO’s European and Asia-Pacific allies.”
We have passed the point of parody. This guy just getting across the room is a success.
In as large matters– After the delivery of the child-approved cluster bombs is there any red line Putin will not ignore or will he go down in history as a suit and tie administrator and not a President who would face up to an outrageously hostile nation throwing everything but a nuclear kitchen sink to win? Stay by your radios. . .
N.B. The multi-force bums’ rush? Not room list all the simultaneous locales. Syria, Serbia for the S’s.
“Whistle or lose it” is an old Southern saying. I’m sure there’s a Russia version gadflying his spirit and will. Good luck, I’m counting on you..

Posted by: Elmagnostic | Jul 9 2023 3:14 utc | 199

Echo Chamber @66
>If you want me to explain how the primary dealers are given the funds to buy the treasuries just ask and I’ll explain to you.
Yes please!
I’m not convinced about nobody buying Treasuries when a USD in Irkusk or NYC will both be purchasing UST for the returns. Dollars are not destroyed with the rise of BRICKS-doneros. They will come “home” and the Fed will sop them up and finally balance their books.
I am convinced that the USD is at the root of this world wide conflict, as hyper-inflation is a possibility. But I need to learn more. Much more.
Is that site yours EC?

Posted by: bobzibub | Jul 9 2023 3:17 utc | 200