Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.
The current open thread for other issues here.
Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.
|
|
|
|
Back to Main
|
||
|
July 1, 2023
Ukraine Open Thread 2023-155
Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict. The current open thread for other issues here. Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.
Comments
Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 8:02 utc | 303 Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jul 2 2023 8:18 utc | 301 While all the ‘counteroffensive’ of the Ukraine/US/NATO only resulted in death of many Ukrainians, foreign mercenaries, the German ‘cats’ and the US Bradleys, etc, etc, the drugged Zelensky regime will be trying to have a final ‘counteroffensive’ in the Zaporozhye direction. Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 8:18 utc | 302 Posted by: sln2002 | Jul 1 2023 23:58 utc | 201 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 8:20 utc | 303 RT EuromaidanPress: Russia cancels MAKS 2023, its premier international air show, probably due to security concerns and the risk of reputational damage -“ Posted by: Noam A. Larkey | Jul 2 2023 8:20 utc | 304 French Military makes veiled threat to Macron for possible coup Posted by: France is fucked | Jul 2 2023 8:21 utc | 305 French Military makes veiled threat to Macron for possible coup Posted by: Tim | Jul 2 2023 8:27 utc | 306 Well, back to the next episode of “Strike Back” and Yasmin: Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jul 2 2023 8:31 utc | 307 Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 2 2023 6:02 utc | 292 Posted by: UWDude | Jul 2 2023 8:36 utc | 308 … So it would appear your ‘concern’ is rather misplaced. Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 8:42 utc | 309 The BBC calls them “riots” im France. If they were happening in russia, beijing, hong kong or venezuela, the BBC wd call them “protests” Posted by: HERMIUS | Jul 2 2023 8:42 utc | 310 About those … happenings (?) in France, I just checked Geopolitica’s Carlos Aguiar and he posts this: Posted by: Bruised Northerner | Jul 2 2023 8:55 utc | 311 Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 2 2023 6:02 utc | 292 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 8:58 utc | 312 https://www.businessinsider.de/politik/ukraine-krieg-bundeswehr-reservisten-planen-in-verschluesselten-chat-gruppen-kriegseinsatz-als-fremdenlegionaere-b/ Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Jul 2 2023 9:01 utc | 313 To be clear, are you claiming that RF couldn’t realistically clear and maintain a buffer zone on the UA side of the river from ZNPP, ordering a civilian evacuation and then policing the area drone surveillance backed up by artillery, rocket artillery, kamikaze drones, Gerans, remote mine laying etc, all things we know they could do with relative ease? Posted by: UWDude | Jul 2 2023 9:03 utc | 314 Posted by: Scuppers | Jul 2 2023 7:13 utc | 296 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 9:03 utc | 315 21,000 Wagner mercenaries killed in Ukraine, says who? Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Jul 2 2023 9:04 utc | 316 French Military makes veiled threat to Macron for possible coup Posted by: rk | Jul 2 2023 9:05 utc | 317 Posted by: Eighthman | Jul 2 2023 0:55 utc | 218 Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Jul 2 2023 9:07 utc | 318 @Ed | Jul 1 2023 20:20 utc | 102 Posted by: gT | Jul 2 2023 9:08 utc | 319 Posted by: Scuppers | Jul 2 2023 7:13 utc | 296 Posted by: Milites | Jul 2 2023 9:15 utc | 320 Posted by: UWDude | Jul 2 2023 0:27 utc | 210 Posted by: Greg Galloway | Jul 2 2023 9:15 utc | 321 A rally was held in Kiev demanding to increase the number of places in cemeteries and the total number of cemeteries in Ukraine. Posted by: Citan | Jul 2 2023 9:23 utc | 322 @Richard Steven Hack Posted by: begob | Jul 2 2023 9:30 utc | 323 Posted by: Scuppers | Jul 2 2023 7:13 utc | 296 Posted by: Greg Galloway | Jul 2 2023 9:36 utc | 324 Re: French Uprising Posted by: Exile | Jul 2 2023 9:40 utc | 325 Posted by: UWDude | Jul 2 2023 9:03 utc | 322 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 9:47 utc | 326 With the notable exception of Lenin, the majority of the leading figures are Jews. Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Jul 2 2023 9:47 utc | 327 Posted by: UWDude | Jul 2 2023 8:36 utc | 316 Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 2 2023 9:48 utc | 328 Posted by: begob | Jul 2 2023 9:30 utc | 331 Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jul 2 2023 9:51 utc | 329 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 8:42 utc | 317 Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 9:51 utc | 330 Marty from America said 60% of Wagners died because they’re so bad bad bad… Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 9:54 utc | 331 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 9:47 utc | 334 Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 9:56 utc | 332 Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 2 2023 6:02 utc | 292 Posted by: UWDude | Jul 2 2023 9:56 utc | 333 Posted by: English Outsider | Jul 1 2023 17:43 utc | 27 Posted by: Stierlitz | Jul 2 2023 10:02 utc | 334 Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 9:51 utc | 338 Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:04 utc | 335 Posted by: Exile | Jul 2 2023 9:40 utc | 333 Posted by: The Dolphin | Jul 2 2023 10:08 utc | 336 Posted by: Stierlitz | Jul 2 2023 10:02 utc | 342 Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 10:09 utc | 337 Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:04 utc | 343
This is the kind of experience you need to to deal with the possibility of mass attacks on nuclear facilities … Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 10:13 utc | 338 The political parties that have warned against a French-type situation have been so-called extreme right parties. Many of them, like the AfD are also “Russia-friendly”. Doing something about the riots – in a dramatic way – is going to be politically as suspect as calling Putin a good leader. There is, then, an indirect but still causal, link. Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 10:17 utc | 339 Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 10:13 utc | 346 Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:18 utc | 340 A. Dugin believes the Prigozhin “incident” was very much real and ongoing: https://www.geopolitika.ru/en/article/after-movement-point-bifurcation Posted by: Jupiter | Jul 2 2023 10:18 utc | 341 Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:18 utc | 348 Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 10:23 utc | 342 two observations: Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 10:23 utc | 343 1) it is a race to the bottom – the question is who is going to hit the bottom first: the west or Russia. Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:29 utc | 344 Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 9:56 utc | 340 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 10:29 utc | 345 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 10:29 utc | 353 Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:32 utc | 346 Slavyangrad reports that Zelensky’s mobilization goons now break into peoples houses. They would be liable to get shot. Posted by: unimperator | Jul 2 2023 10:33 utc | 347 I am fully aware that ALL MILITARY HISTORY is studied for war theory. Posted by: UWDude | Jul 2 2023 10:34 utc | 348 Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:29 utc | 352 Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 10:35 utc | 349 Nato overplays its hand, sends a coalition of the willing into western Ukraine and tactical Russian nukes take them out. Yes, tactical nuclear warfare with Nato might be the cathartic moment that shuts the western alliance down for good. Posted by: Greg Galloway | Jul 2 2023 10:38 utc | 350 what lesson would the “soviet one” impart? Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:39 utc | 351 Prigozhin will, as some have suggested, “fall off a balcony Posted by: Greg Galloway | Jul 2 2023 10:42 utc | 352 Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 10:29 utc | 353 Posted by: UWDude | Jul 2 2023 10:45 utc | 353 It would be too hard to for a US American to fathom… 🙂 Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 10:45 utc | 354 A NATO force of any kind would be destroyed like the destruction of the Ukie group that squatted under the Antonovsky Bridge and was destroyed by Iskanders today Posted by: Tim2 | Jul 2 2023 10:45 utc | 355 Nato overplays its hand, sends a coalition of the willing into western Ukraine and tactical Russian nukes take them out. Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:46 utc | 356 ostro should also remind us that he stopped listening to mercouris because his own analytical skills are vastly superior Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 10:49 utc | 357 Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 10:49 utc | 365 Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 10:52 utc | 358 ostro as long as this comment board keeps you from doing any serious damage keep going Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 10:54 utc | 359 Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jul 2 2023 8:07 utc | 305 Posted by: Tim2 | Jul 2 2023 10:56 utc | 360 As French violence – powered by US weapons from Ukraine – spreads to Switzerland and Belgium. Twitter is completely jammed. Coincidence? Posted by: unimperator | Jul 2 2023 10:56 utc | 361 As French violence – powered by US weapons from Ukraine Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 10:59 utc | 362 Posted by: Jupiter | Jul 2 2023 10:18 utc | 349 Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jul 2 2023 10:59 utc | 363 The Ukrainian authorities are going to leave the cities of Sumy and Kharkov. This was announced on the morning of July 1 by the Russian voenkor Alexander Sladkov on his Telegram channel. Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 11:00 utc | 364 Interesting hint. this is what budanov meant? and the us is really intent on destroying europe? Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 11:02 utc | 365 4th night of riots: Posted by: france is fucked | Jul 2 2023 11:04 utc | 366 Posted by: france is fucked | Jul 2 2023 11:04 utc | 374 Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jul 2 2023 11:07 utc | 367 as I said this is a race to the bottom and the EU is approaching at a lightning speed. that is why they need to destroy russia first. and get destroyed by their own weapons in the process. Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 11:13 utc | 369 in france it is about gas prices (yellow vests), retirement age, macron forcing his legislation through the national assembly, immigration and conversely racism. france found a way to self-destruct and will take the eu with it. Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 11:16 utc | 370 @165 Posted by: line islands | Jul 2 2023 11:25 utc | 371 Riots spreading to Switzerland and Belgium ? Posted by: Exile | Jul 2 2023 11:27 utc | 372 На Херсонском направлении завершено уничтожение подразделений ВСУ, высадившихся на острове Антоновский в районе антоновского моста. Posted by: Antonovsky Bridge | Jul 2 2023 11:36 utc | 374 I don’t know about France. Every X years they seem to have riots and everything – but the government, or at least A government always survives. Problem is these rioters never have a coherent program. Even that coherent program is to wreck everything, it would be better than JUST wrecking everything. Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jul 2 2023 11:40 utc | 375 Posted by: Ahenobarbus | Jul 1 2023 16:55 utc | 13
Disagree on some minor points. I quote from Mearsheimer. First, about Russian goals:
Two objections. First, taking Ukrainian territory populated by ethnic Ukrainians would be highly facilitated by ethnic Ukrainians running en masse to Poland, Romania, and from there to Germany and other affluent Western European countries. Second, there are examples where fanatic poeples whose nations have been conquered become submissive (e.g. Germany, Japan). So I don’t see any serious issue with Russia conquering all of Ukraine if the Russians know how to turn fierce foes into submissive eunuchs.
I don’t think that the Russo-Ukrainian war is existential for the West. A Russian victory will just mean they lost a large and well located outpost that they almost had within their reach. It doesn’t mean any loss, just a potential new gain that didn’t materialize. So the West is the least-motivated party in the war and crucially, Ukraine completeley depends on the West for everything, it’s entirely subsidized by the West.
Since the West is the least-motivated party and Ukraine totally depends on West’s handouts to just trudge along I’d say that resolve is also stronger on the Russian side.
This relies on the assumption of equal resolve but as pointed out above resolve is weaker on the Ukrainian side because it is subsidized by the West and the West’s resolve is weaker as the West can go on as usual even if Russia wins decisively. Rhetoric notwithstanding, for the West this war is not existential. So I think there is a higher chance of a negotiated settlement, favourable to Russia, than Mearsheimer assumes there is.
There is a higher chance than Mearsheirmer acknowledges to have a lasting peace in the Ukraine through Kiev’s complete capitulation after the least-motivated party, the West, starts to downgrade the conflict and focus on other, more important issues, such as de-dollarization, China’s ascent, and local electioneering. Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Jul 2 2023 11:44 utc | 377 reply to 330 Posted by: Eighthman | Jul 2 2023 11:46 utc | 378 Tour de France and Montreaux Jazz Festival seems to have everyone occupied Posted by: SwissArmyMan | Jul 2 2023 11:47 utc | 379 Already the Russian ‘trace’ had surfaced…as always…how can it be without that?!
Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 11:49 utc | 380 Posted by: Antonovsky Bridge | Jul 2 2023 11:36 utc | 382 Posted by: Tim2 | Jul 2 2023 11:52 utc | 381 Tour de France and Montreaux Jazz Festival seems to have everyone occupied Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 11:53 utc | 382 Tour de France and Montreaux Jazz Festival seems to have everyone occupied Posted by: Laguerre | Jul 2 2023 12:04 utc | 383 The neoliberal influenced French in London are not getting it as they all sup from the same PR News narratives as the rest of the Collective Waste. Posted by: DunGroanin | Jul 2 2023 12:06 utc | 384 The situation continues to spiral out of control and Macron appears to be in hiding. Posted by: laguerre | Jul 2 2023 12:07 utc | 385 My son took me over the St Bernard Pass for lunch in Aosta Italy and returning through the ski resorts and the Mont Blanc Tunnel yesterday, holiday traffic was heavy! Posted by: SwissArmyMan | Jul 2 2023 12:08 utc | 386 It is also important to note that according to our friend ostro’s quote the riots are russia-backed . Seeing the west from outside the west, the place is just not very muslim-friendly, while Russia has gone out of its way to say that the Quran-burning in Sweden, for instance, was disgusting. Besides Russia has devout Muslims in its Chechen fighting force. which way is the global south going to lean here? So what better copout for the west than to say all their troubles are Russia-backed? Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 12:11 utc | 387 Things are calming down. We were the ones who had the first disturbances the first night, and now it’s back to normal. Posted by: ostro | Jul 2 2023 12:11 utc | 388 French violence – powered by US weapons from Ukraine Posted by: laguerre | Jul 2 2023 12:12 utc | 389 @Richard Steven Hack Posted by: begob | Jul 2 2023 12:13 utc | 390 Not so hard for an American to believe, it’s exactly how riots play out Posted by: SwissArmyMan | Jul 2 2023 12:17 utc | 391 Can you guarantee yourself that it would be a safe night today? No one will burn your car or your neighbours? Posted by: laguerre | Jul 2 2023 12:21 utc | 392 “The situation continues to spiral out of control and Macron appears to be in hiding. Some speculate that he may be planning to abandon France and flee.” Posted by: Panza | Jul 2 2023 12:22 utc | 393 .. All those arguments are from the point of view of the US Americans. Posted by: anon2020 | Jul 2 2023 12:26 utc | 395 Posted by: Johan Kaspar | Jul 2 2023 11:44 utc | 385 Posted by: Revelo | Jul 2 2023 12:28 utc | 396 As an American I’m getting tired of being told that the Ukraine war is exclusively America’s fault. Has it occurred to anyone that certain large German corporations might have an interest in Siberia? Has anyone else looked at the polls that show deeper and wider European support for the war than American? Posted by: laguerre | Jul 2 2023 12:28 utc | 397 More rumblings about Iran’s plan to set up naval alliances with Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States to control the Straits of Hormuz. Posted by: scepticalSOB | Jul 2 2023 12:29 utc | 398 I think the point about Belgium is that the police have warned for years that the criminal gangs in Brussels and Antwerp have military-grade weapons against which the weapons the police have are no match. Same could be said across Europe I guess, hence this harebrained talk about a EU army that will come and sort it out. Posted by: Jonathan W | Jul 2 2023 12:30 utc | 399 Perhaps reports of the appearance of weapons previously shipped to the Ukraine in the hands of the rioters got on their nerves. Posted by: laguerre | Jul 2 2023 12:33 utc | 400 |
||