Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
July 9, 2023
The MoA Week In Review – (Not Ukraine) OT 2023-163

Last week's post on Moon of Alabama:

> Q: Thanks, Jen. There are reports of illegal cluster bombs and vacuum bombs being used by the Russians. If that’s true, what is the next step of this administration? And is there a red line for how much violence will be tolerated against civilians in this manner that’s illegal and potentially a war crime?

MS. PSAKI: It is — it would be. I don’t have any confirmation of that. We have seen the reports. If that were true, it would potentially be a war crime. <


Other issues:

Europe:

Economy:

Spinning:

Use as open (not Ukraine related) thread …

Comments

Blinken went to China.
Yellen went to China.
Neither went to reestablish dialogue
Just to lecture and admonish.
The whole facade is beyond comprehension at this point.
The US needs China more than the reverse proposition.
The facade of full spectrum domination is wearing thin.
Might not be a good idea to over play the hand anymore.

Posted by: jpc | Jul 9 2023 12:48 utc | 1

US delegation brings ‘human rights concerns’ to India
— RT today (I know that is “Russia Today today”, so its redundant, I don’t care.)
I find myself wondering at what point will these “delegations” become too embarrassed to bring this sort of thing up. Yellen wants to lecture on climate change, to China. Now we want to lecture India, colonized by the Brits, about human rights. You want a holocaust, what the Raj did in India was a holocaust. What the Yurpeans did in China and Africa was a holocaust. What the “Americans” did in N. America was a holocaust. What Spain and Portugal did in S. & C. America was a holocaust. Deal with that or shutup about other people.

Posted by: Bemildred | Jul 9 2023 13:10 utc | 2

Thanks, b, for another Week in Review. I’ve started with that first section on China, and I just had to jump in with my comments — a series of ‘Maytag moments’, that was my experience.
From the NYT, “China is a major market for chips, since it is home to many factories that make chip-rich products, including smartphones, dishwashers, cars and computers, that are both exported around the world and purchased by consumers in China.” Maybe it’s just me, but I’d never think to put dishwashers at the top of a list of products that depend on chips. Maybe this reflects the importance of the Maytag lobby in Washington?
On Mr. X, I was struck by this: “Moreover, Kennan rejected the mythology that anyone “won” the Cold War, which he called a “a long and costly political rivalry, fueled on both sides by unreal and exaggerated estimates of the intentions and strength of the other party.”” I think that says that Kennan’s side, which was neither the USSR or the USA, lost the Cold War. Another Maytag moment – some hidden powerful lobby.
I presume that you wish us to draw a straight line from Kennan to Bertrand, b. Lots to consider there, but for me, these comments by Bertrand stood out:
“If you look at the Chinese way of development, it is very unique. If China just followed the methodology advised by the IMF or the World Bank or all those organizations that typically advise countries on their development, China would become all those other countries that have not developed. That was the key – to be able to think for itself, picking what makes sense, what was good for China, but also having the strength to refuse what wasn’t.”
To all those long-suffering nations in the Caribbean and Latin America, Bertrand says, just say no! Wow! What an extraordinary way to look at dependency on funds from IMF and the World Bank! (I’m seeing Maytag again.)
It brought to mind a bit of news from Canada’s Global News that I almost included in my post alerting of British humour yesterday. “Robots say they won’t rebel against humans as dozens gather at Switzerland summit”
https://globalnews.ca/news/9817505/ai-humanoid-robots-summit-fears-switzerland/
Exactly!!

Posted by: Bruised Northerner | Jul 9 2023 13:11 utc | 3

Zoltan Pozsar: New World Monetary Order, Dedollarization and the Role of Gold – Gold Broker
————
I thought this was an important point from the interview with Zoltan:
“”I mention this because I don’t think that the journey for the renminbi to a reserve currency is that countries will start accumulating it; it’s going to be managed through swap lines. I keep on re-reading President Xi’s address to the GCC leaders; there’s a lot to unpack there. He says, “We are going to trade with each other a lot more and we are going to invoice everything in renminbi” and “You will have a surplus, I will have a deficit; or I will have a surplus and you will have a deficit, and then there’s going to be an interstate means of how we are going to recycle and manage the surpluses and deficits”.
It seems to me that what the Eastern vision for the Eurasian landmass under Belt and Road looks like from a monetary perspective is that there will be interstate mechanisms to recycle surpluses and deficits. And it’s not going to be as driven by the private sector as the dollar system is being driven by it; it’s going to be a more managed system. That’s how I think about China and renminbi as a reserve currency, more of a trading and invoicing service, or something like that.“”

Posted by: financial matters | Jul 9 2023 13:35 utc | 4

I just love it when retired international officials and propaganda organs that were so obviously tools of the elites try their mea culpas to say that they were “naive”, “misled” blah, blah, blah. The post-Iraq invasion mea culpa of the US media was such an event, as they wailed that they were so sorry for allowing themselves to be misled.
Now we have Christiana Figueres, the ex-head of the UN climate bureaucracy wailing that it was wrong to think that the fossil fuel industry would be a reliable partner in the cutting of emissions that would lead to the destruction of their own corporations! And as usual the milque-toast climate “activists” celebrate this “insight” from the capitalist tool. Reading the article about Figures “sudden” insight made keeping my breakfast down somewhat difficult.
When I say milquetoast climate “activists” I mean the ones whose only real reason for existence is to give the upper middle class a nice warm feeling and mislead the youth down completely pointless alleys of action and set them up for “capitalist” solutions. The Swedish establishment-loving version, Ms. “how dare you” has shown her true colours by visiting Zelensky – how dare you Greta!
https://www.commondreams.org/news/un-fossil-fuel-industry
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1LXYp6bYg-g
The El Nino has hardly got going yet and we are seeing record global temperatures for the industrial era, thats what happens when you keep pumping CO2, CH4 and N2O plus other warming gases into the atmosphere. The temperatures that we will see this year and next will be the normal temperatures of the early 2030s, the next El Nino and a year of 2 degrees will be a reality. This site provides a good tracker of the progression of the El Nino:
https://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/analysis_monitoring/lanina/enso_evolution-status-fcsts-web.pdf
And of course another day of global temperatures well above the previous high.
https://climatereanalyzer.org/clim/t2_daily/
The climate “fix” of blocking out the Sun with particles high in the atmosphere, “solar radiation management” is slowly gaining force as it is the only way that climate action can be reconciled with ongoing growth and great power competition. I saw this coming a decade ago but it still makes me sad that we are here, after another wasted decade.
There will always be those that deny anthropogenic climate change, equating it with so many actual government conspiracies, but in this case we have an actual real scientific community who are doing their jobs. I will not engage with such individuals, as I consider such nonsense on the same level as the denial that sex is a binary. Basic science is basic science, which is very different from the profit-driven corruption of the pharmaceutical industry.

Posted by: Roger | Jul 9 2023 13:42 utc | 5

Jeez – Yellen repeatedly bowing to a Chinese minister while shaking his hand is so embarrassing for the minister! She is shameless. A greasy market spiv trader – with fake flattery hoping to get a deal and make a killing, whilst treating their ‘partner’ with contempt!
The aide then trying to get her to stop doing it and leave.
Face palm , embarrassment, The Wankers have broken ranks with their owned Western Natzos and are desperately seeking some space in the multipolar world without having to give up power or stolen wealth of countless generations of slavery and piracy.
Look it up its cringe worthy.

Posted by: DunGroanin | Jul 9 2023 13:46 utc | 6

Posted by: DunGroanin | Jul 9 2023 13:46 utc | 6
It’s almost as if the budget for cultural etiquette has been removed.
It’s unintentionally hilarious.

Posted by: jpc | Jul 9 2023 14:13 utc | 7

Bemildred@2
1/ I don’t see that as a redundancy- Today is part of a proper name!
2/Regarding the ‘human rights abuses’ in India- the US is in a cleft stick here because the RSS neo-nazi ideas behind Modi’s demagogy, were not only encouraged by the Raj, always seeking for sticks with which to beat the muslims and divide communities, they also conform with the policies that the US has been promoting for a long time.
All forms of genocidal politics got a boost after 1492. The American origins of Nazism are well known. It’s hard to be consistent-or even make sense- when speaking on behalf of a system in which criminality and industrial scale massacres have always marched hand in hand with Puritan hypocrisy and a Presbyterian substitute for democracy in which the rich and powerful tell the people what is inevitable.
What the State Department delegation is telling Indians is that genocide needs to be disguised as a social service- a favour that muslims and other minorities ought to be grateful for as it wipes out the very divisions in society that give rise to clashes and hatreds.

Posted by: bevin | Jul 9 2023 14:35 utc | 8

Boris Rozhin has posted a photo of the Wagner PMC rules signed by Yevgeniy Prigozhin and Dmitriy Utkin on May 1, 2014. The photo was taken during the search of Prigozhin’s mansion. Here’s my translation of the rules:

Due to the difficult situation in the Ukraine and the need to protect Donbass (the heart of Russia), we, the undersigned, undertake to abide by the following rules:
Director’s responsibilities:
1. Provide weapons;
2. Provide funding;
3. Provide guarantees for KIAs and WIAs;
4. Provide permanent employment;
5. Protection from prosecution for mercenary activities ([Article] 359 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation);
6. Solve all issues in a collegial manner;
7. Participate personally;
8. Not act against the Russian people.
[Written in with a pen] 9. Do what must be done, and come what may
[Underlined] Director
Prigozhin Ye
(Prigozhin’s signature)
Commander’s responsibilities:
1. Assemble a team;
2. Train people;
3. Get rid of deserters;
4. Prohibition (alcohol, drugs);
5. Solve issues in a collegial manner;
6. Fully utilize the acquired knowledge and experience, complete missions to the end;
7. Not act against VVP [Putin];
8. Not lie or dissemble, always tell it [extra space] like it is.
May 1, 2014
(Utkin’s signature)
“Wagner”
[The lower part of the paper was used for unrelated notes.]

Posted by: S | Jul 9 2023 14:50 utc | 9

The Russian Telegram channel China army has posted a video of a Chinese People’s Armed Police Force FPV drone exercise: passing through an obstacle, attacking an air target.

Posted by: S | Jul 9 2023 15:06 utc | 10

@Roger | Jul 9 2023 13:42 utc | 5

There will always be those that deny anthropogenic climate change, equating it with so many actual government conspiracies, but in this case we have an actual real scientific community who are doing their jobs. I will not engage with such individuals, as I consider such nonsense on the same level as the denial that sex is a binary. Basic science is basic science, which is very different from the profit-driven corruption of the pharmaceutical industry.

I agree with you on most subjects, but this is practicing the equivalent of “guilt by association” due to lack of proper scientific arguments. I think you can do better.

Posted by: Norwegian | Jul 9 2023 15:45 utc | 11

thanks b for all you do and offer here… thanks to the many fine posters here too..
first some improv music from a quebec piano player andres vial..
When Is Ancient?
indian punchline latest – Russia, US exchange glances as Prigozhin heads for Moscow
john helmer also has an article up today..
THE RETREAT FROM SAIGON, AGAIN – WHAT THE CIA, US THINK TANKS, REPUBLICAN HOPEFULS ARE DOING TO AVOID THE WORST BATTLEFIELD DEFEAT THE US HAS SUFFERED

Posted by: james | Jul 9 2023 15:59 utc | 12

btw – that quote from jen psaki is worth repeating… it’s a war crime if russia uses cluster munitions, but if the usa gives these to ukraine for use, it isn’t a war crime… more hypocrisy on full display.. it seems some of the nato sheeple are getting anxious about this, seeing as they signed onto banning cluster munitions in 2010.. they spoke up yesterday..

Posted by: james | Jul 9 2023 16:07 utc | 13

james’ re Helmer: you beat me to it. Worth reading.

Posted by: bevin | Jul 9 2023 16:09 utc | 14

@Norwegian | Jul 9 2023 15:45 utc | 11 —
oldhippie on the previous open ot thread provided measurement data of radiative energy flux for Terra, giving a number of 300 in and 299 out [W/m2]. Thanks for that.
I haven’t researched the source’s methodology (and probably won’t do, as it is too out of my scope), but it really is the very number I had been looking out for since many years.
With both in and out fluxes recorded, it should be possible to separate the two basic drivers of temperature change, i.e. solar and terrestrial. Modeling the terrestrial part is a bit of a mess, as cloud cover remains off limits to a dynamical integration; at least that was the state of things back when I was looking into climate science in my university days. Still, the apparent fact that there is a residual energy deposit that drives temeperature on Terra would be enough to allow a call for great caution, or so I think.
I’d be very curious if barflies expanded on the question.

Posted by: persiflo | Jul 9 2023 16:21 utc | 15

james | Jul 9 2023 15:59 utc | 12
first some improv music from a quebec piano player andres vial
Lovely album, james. There’s that melody again. Thanks.

Posted by: john | Jul 9 2023 16:38 utc | 16

@ bevin | Jul 9 2023 16:09 utc | 14
the focus on mark rutte is interesting, seeing as he resigned yesterday.. john helmer has a good overview on him seeing as he wrote a book on the mh17 event… i agree.. johns article is worth pursing, although i have not read his books.. it would be interesting to read some alternative views on why rutte is resigning now at this point.. i read an article on the hill that concludes it is all about the immigration policy and the main parties in power not coming to an agreement.. i wonder if that is all it is?? john helmer links to the article in his article..

Posted by: james | Jul 9 2023 16:38 utc | 17

There will always be those that deny anthropogenic climate change, equating it with so many actual government conspiracies, but in this case we have an actual real scientific community who are doing their jobs. I will not engage with such individuals, as I consider such nonsense on the same level as the denial that sex is a binary. Basic science is basic science, which is very different from the profit-driven corruption of the pharmaceutical industry.
@Roger | Jul 9 2023 13:42 utc | 5
Most people who blindly and unquestioningly believe in religious dogma won’t or can’t engage with people who with different opinions so have to resort to close-mindedness and ad hominem.However, “climate change” is not basic science and has nothing to do with basic science. It’s scientism at best and religous dogma at worst.
At least you brought the denial argument up to date with the denial that sex is binary thing instead of comparing people to Holocaust deniers.

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 9 2023 16:39 utc | 18

@ john | Jul 9 2023 16:38 utc | 16
yes – i agree! i have an acquaintance who has worked with him a bunch – vibes player michael davidson out of toronto.. they both played on joe chambers most recent album for blue note – dance kobina… you might want to check that recording out.. title track is a song andres vial composition..

Posted by: james | Jul 9 2023 16:41 utc | 19

It puzzles me that the EU has no response to kidnapping and slaughtering Ukrainian men. They pride themselves on opposing capital punishment and mostly unrestricted immigration. Yet somehow, not a single word about 500 – 1000 Ukr men dead per day, untrained, unsupplied, etc. Nor any recognition that they would be far better off ruled by Russia outright (um…..like still alive)

Posted by: Eighthman | Jul 9 2023 16:45 utc | 20

US delegation brings ‘human rights concerns’ to India
— RT today (I know that is “Russia Today today”, so its redundant, I don’t care.)
I find myself wondering at what point will these “delegations” become too embarrassed to bring this sort of thing up.
Posted by: Bemildred | Jul 9 2023 13:10 utc | 2

As said in my comment in yesterday’s post, Indian Prime Minister Modi went to US to meet Biden and “China security concern” was apparently one of the talking points as US woos India against China.
Modi heads back, a week later, in a humiliating gesture, it’s announced that Indian refiners now buy Russian oil in Chinese currency.
Biden administration is fuming. Can’t sanction India and remove India from SWIFT since that would only accelerate de-dollarization. Can’t sell a war over this.
Throwing a tantrum with “human rights violation” is all the Biden administration could do. Like a child throwing a tantrum, the best treatment is ignoring them, until they tire out and realize nobody cares about their little desires.
We’ve reached a point when the US economy needs the dollar reserve status more than the global south needs the dollar as a reserve currency. It’s been that way for sometime whether economists & politicians realized this or not.
Time for the global south to get together collectively bargain with US. About anything.

Posted by: FieryButMostPeaceful | Jul 9 2023 16:49 utc | 21

Thanks b, for posting Naked Capitalism’s link to Michael Hudson’s article. As one who followed much more closely than now the former analyses and discussions by Yves Smith as events were happening that she references in her intro, kudos to you, b, for presenting the thread in its entirety, even if not that earlier discussion. I believe Yves is correct, and that it is rather like trying to explain where the Ukraine/Russia conflict is now, without going back to see how it became what we witness today.
So, kudos to Yves as well.

Posted by: juliania | Jul 9 2023 16:54 utc | 22

Thanks, b, for Jen Psaki’s quote: “it (the use cluster munitions) would potentially be a war crime.”
A couple of days ago US Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Colin Kahl made the following remark about cluster munitions: “And look, I’m as concerned about the humanitarian circumstance as anybody but the worst thing for civilians in Ukraine is for Russia to win the war. And so it’s important that they don’t.”
https://www.defense.gov/News/Transcripts/Transcript/Article/3452000/under-secretary-of-defense-for-policy-dr-colin-kahl-holds-press-briefing/
Apparently he believes that to prevent Russia from winning the war it’s OK to commit a war crime.

Posted by: TN | Jul 9 2023 16:54 utc | 23

Posted by: juliania | Jul 9 2023 16:54 utc | 22
Oops, more correctly: “…As one who followed — in her intro , I gratefully extend kudos to you, b ….”
Forgot to link subject to antecedent, my bad.

Posted by: juliania | Jul 9 2023 17:00 utc | 24

Posted by: FieryButMostPeaceful | Jul 9 2023 16:49 utc | 21
RE India: about right.
I think “Biden” is pretty annoyed with Erdogan too, I think he gave up the Azov captives as a kind of PR bone for the west to chew on while he was refusing to let Sweden join NATO. Moscow will make noise about it but do nothing.

Posted by: Bemildred | Jul 9 2023 17:01 utc | 25

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 9 2023 16:39 utc | 18
bullshit. it is basic science. you fell for fossil fuel company propaganda. fossil fuel companies are some of the richest and most powerful organizations. they are no more innocent and helpless victims than defense contractors or bankers.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Jul 9 2023 17:13 utc | 26

Grayzone – Reuters – Egypt// Really important; thank you, b! This was a revolution orchestrated in the midst of full media attention — we all saw what was ‘happening’ as we were meant to see. Poor Egypt!

Posted by: juliania | Jul 9 2023 17:18 utc | 27

Posted by: pretzelattack | Jul 9 2023 17:13 utc | 26
Thanks for the response, although I don’t recall mentioning anything about fossil fuel companies, much less defense contractors or bankers. However, I tend to agree with you on the defense contractors and bankers.
However, you proved my main point in that you deflected and attacked and didn’t address the (lack of) basic science.

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 9 2023 17:19 utc | 28

james | Jul 9 2023 15:59 utc | 12
Thanks for the links, james (not fake).
The article by Ivan Timofeev Bhadrakumar links to is also a worthwhile read. It makes clear what lies at the heart of the problem; namely that the imperial scumbags are entirely lacking in empathy (understanding/appreciating how others might feel). It is only out of self preservation that any remotely conciliatory gesture (or “flexibility) issues from the likes of the CIA hand in the State Department glove. Definitely recommend that article to all as well.
Thanks for all the good stuff, b.

Posted by: robjira | Jul 9 2023 17:22 utc | 29

james@17
I get the feeling that, for Rutte, the jig was up. He had followed through on the programme- loyal satellite of NATO, neo-liberalism in the economy, ‘greenish’ intitiatives to please the Swedish schoolgirls, harvesting the cheap labour that comes from imperialist aggression, giving up cheap energy from the east…etc etc
And in the end nobody in the Netherlands-outside the circles of those who prop up Capitalist ideology for a living- was happy. And the farmers were livid- I live in a part of Ontario where much of the farming is carried out by the sons and grandsons of post WWII Dutch immigrants, they keep in touch with the homeland, some return annually, and they have no time for Rutte. It’s nothing to do with Foreign Policy, but they fear the consequences of his agricultural ideas spreading to Canada, where, notoriously, the government is like a sofa and takes on the shape of those who sat on it most recently.

Posted by: bevin | Jul 9 2023 17:25 utc | 30

pretzelattack@26
And the moral of the story is : No more Fossil Fuel Corporations. The importance of these fuels is simply to great to be left in private hands which employ their immense resources to enhance the value of a resource that it is obviously the property of the public. And only ceases to be so when it is given away to kleptocrats and oligarchs who thus receive the power not only to toy with the public interest but to compromise the future prospects of life itself.

Posted by: bevin | Jul 9 2023 17:32 utc | 31

Posted by: Roger | Jul 9 2023 13:42 utc | 5
“Basic science is basic science”
That’s true enough. Climate science, however, is not basic science. Climate science is advanced science. It is breathtakingly complex. On top of that, it’s also pretty young as a subject (read: early idiotic misconceptions), and it’s awash with money (read: corruption).

Posted by: Scotch Bingeington | Jul 9 2023 17:33 utc | 32

Posted by: Scotch Bingeington | Jul 9 2023 17:33 utc | 32
more bs. the fossil fuel companies are awash in money. climatologists aren’t. Maggie Thatcher recognized it is sound. it is only after the fossil fuel companies launched their propaganda campaign in roughly 1990 that we started hearing all this bs.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Jul 9 2023 17:36 utc | 33

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 9 2023 17:19 utc | 28
yeah you didn’t mention fossil fuel companies, the omission is glaring. that’s the context, not your bleatings about a so called “lack of basic science”. the fossil fuel companies, oddly, cannot produce or fund a research study showing that alleged “lack of basic science”. when they tried, they failed. their own scientists told them about fossil fuel use causing climate change, in the 70’s and 80’s. since they couldn’t refute it, they launched a propaganda campaign. you fell for it. end of story.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Jul 9 2023 17:40 utc | 34

In 1996 Al Gore led the US delegation to Kyoto, where he negotiated loopholes for the US wide enough to fly a squadron of F-35s through, in the Accord.
Worse, he turned the climate over to Wall Street, to let corporations clear-cutting entire forests to burn for fuel get “carbon credits” for using “renewable sources”, for one example, along with other boondoggles.
Since then the environmental movement has been sidetracked from advocating for clean air, clean water, wildlife protection, forest protection, stopping ocean acidification and the dumping of plastics into the oceans, saving endangered species, etc., all of which used to be part of the movement, into concern about climate change and only climate change.
That is why people get suspicious. If capitalists jump onboard a cause with such enthusiasm, people with memories of past abuses should check for the profits being made.
The Empire of Hypocrisy lecturing China is, as usual, cringingly embarrassing.
If the US switched to regenerative agriculture, instead of topsoil stripping, that would be a giant step towards sequestering carbon, in the soil, where it belongs. In the soil, it is a boon to plant growth. The “Carbon Sequestration” scams being pushed instead waste fossil fuels in an attempt to put carbon under the ground in porous rocks! Are they complete idiots, or do they not give a flying F about the climate crisis?
If they preserved wetlands along watersheds and rivers, fertilizer run-off would be stopped before it entered the Gulf of Mexico, where there is a giant dead zone caused by the run-off.
If they cared about the environment that would be done. It is not done. Again, this raises suspicions about their concern for Mother Earth.

Posted by: wagelaborer | Jul 9 2023 17:42 utc | 35

The name of the turning over the environment to Wall Street speculators is “cap and trade”.

Posted by: wagelaborer | Jul 9 2023 17:43 utc | 36

Occasionally my daughter informs her father, which is distinctly pleasurable but still too rare an occurrence. In this case, she brought to my attention an author, Matthew Desmond, and his current best selling work, Poverty, By America; previously, Desmond was awarded the Pulitzer Prize for Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City, which can be read at The Archive. Given the circumstances my daughter faces, I see that she’s reading about the Why of her condition as this well written review outlines.
We rarely delve into SES issues within the Outlaw US Empire, so few reference works are mentioned; here are two. Reading the review, I note that previous works written along the same lines have been published and won awards but the Narrative never allows them to enter the dialog. Two works that immediately came to mind as I read the review were People of Paradox and Empire as a Way of Life. I haven’t read anything along the lines of Desmond’s books since Nickle and Dimed: On (Not) Getting By in America that’s now almost 30 years old.
I’m very pleased my daughter brought Desmond and his works to my attention. Unfortunately, based on the linked review, not much has changed since People of Paradox was published in 1972, which is proof that the Establishment Narrative has been very successful over the last 50 years.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 17:43 utc | 37

Austria will continue to import Russian gas and Hungary has approved the second part of its contract with Rosatom to expand its current nuclear complex.
RT reports that it’s more than just getting approval for Hungary. IMO, this is one of several levers working to fracture EU/NATO, “Russia greenlights loan for power plant in EU state: The funds will go to the expansion of the Paks Nuclear Power Plant, which currently provides about half of Hungary’s electricity.”

The Russian government has approved a state loan to finance the construction of two nuclear reactors for Hungary’s Paks Nuclear Power Plant, known as the Paks-2 project, according to a decree published on the government’s official portal for legal information on Saturday.
Under the decree, Moscow has pledged to allocate up to €10 billion ($10.2 billion) for the project, which is scheduled to launch in mid-2024. The loan is expected to finance the majority of the project, which in total is estimated at €12.5 billion….
Paks is Hungary’s only nuclear power plant. Under the deal, which was signed in 2014, Russian state nuclear energy major Rosatom is to build power units 5 and 6 of the plant, with a capacity of 1.2 gigawatts each. The four existing reactors at Paks were brought online between 1982 and 1987, and produce about half of the country’s electricity. With the new modern nuclear reactors, the authorities expect to double the plant’s power output.
The Paks-2 project has been hit with long delays, but Budapest has already issued the license for the construction of the power units by Rosatom. It was also recently granted permission to amend its contract with Russia and include a project management company to speed up the construction process.

As for Austria, the company that purchases and distributes about 30% of Austria’s needs isn’t going to change its arrangements:

Austrian oil and gas conglomerate OMV will continue to buy most of its gas from Russia this winter, CEO Alfred Stern said in an interview with the Financial Times published on Sunday.
According to Stern, the company signed a long-term contract with Gazprom in 2018, which runs until 2040, and OMV does not plan to exit the agreement any time soon.
“As long as Gazprom will supply… we will continue to take these quantities from Gazprom,” Stern stated. Russian gas is currently not subject to the Ukraine-related EU sanctions on Moscow, and while the issue is “for policymakers to decide,” placing restrictions on it and thus “eliminating certain [energy] sources will also drive price rises,” he warned.
“There is an obligation we have as an industrial company to ensure that we use those sources as long as they are legally acceptable,” Stern said.

At the end of that report is this note:
“The company has also recently approved the allocation of €2 billion ($2.2 billion) to a joint venture with Romania’s Romgaz for the development of the Neptun Deep gas field in the Black Sea. The field is set to go online by 2027 and will bring an additional 100 billion cubic meters of natural gas to the European market.”
Now, is that 100 billion cubic meters projected over the life of the project which is how many years and at what rate of flow annually? Yes, the details are important.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 18:08 utc | 38

A further energy note is provided by Sputnik, “Russia Becomes Main Supplier of Gas to Spain in June – Enagas”:

According to the company, Spain imported 7,673 gigawatt hours (GWh) of liquefied natural gas from Russia last month, which accounted for 26.8% of the kingdom’s total purchases. From January to June, Spain purchased 41,145 GWh of LNG from Russia, Enagas added.
Russia is followed by Algeria and the United States. Algeria exported to Spain 21% of the total amount of gas, and the United States – 18.5%.
Earlier, media reported, citing sources, that Madrid urged Spanish importers of Russian gas not to sign new contracts with Moscow and to increase the diversification of LNG supply contracts.
In March, Enagas reported that gas imports from Russia to Spain in February 2023 increased by 151%. According to the company, the kingdom’s imports of Russian gas increased from 2,174 gigawatt hours (GWh) in February 2022 to 5,465 GWh in 2023, accounting for 17.2% of total gas imports.
Spain is currently positioning itself as a major gas hub, capable of solving the European energy crisis due to the reduction of Russian gas supplies. The country is one of the EU member states with the most diversified list of natural gas suppliers. Since the beginning of the year, more than 20 countries have exported gas to Spain.

So, Spain at one end and Turkey at the other. Clearly, many European nations have decided not to commit energy and economic suicide like Germany.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 18:18 utc | 39

TN | Jul 9 2023 16:54 utc | 23
*** Apparently he believes that to prevent Russia from winning the war it’s OK to commit a war crime.***
Of course, since even if the word “Russia” is changed to … well, anywhere or anything … that’s exactly the reasoning of those who rule the USA, big business/finance and its NATO puppets.
Because their interests are exceptionalist and virtuous, it is heresy to resist.

Posted by: Cynic | Jul 9 2023 18:19 utc | 40

Re: sanctions
MADE IN TURKEY – CONSUMER ALERT
BRAND:. Great Value
LOCATIONS: Walmart Sam’s club
PRODUCT: Sour Gummy Worms
SKU: 0 78742 01502 / 0120-0012 GV SR WRMS CHWY
10,500 Walmart stores today are selling Candy originating from nato-nation-turkey that is harmful.
Manufacturer ‘combined chewing-gum with gummy bear ingredients’ labeled as candy. Dangerous lack of quality, mislabeling, or intent to harm. Warning, this product is still sold on the shelf consuming to gum leads to bezoar or enterolith, bleeding abdominal stones in children.

Posted by: Merlin | Jul 9 2023 18:21 utc | 41

pretzelattack | Jul 9 2023 17:36 utc | 33
(Global warmism) *** Maggie Thatcher recognized it is sound.***
No, that isn’t quite the story.
Thatcher was a competent industrial chemist who had reputedly worked on developing Mr Whippy ice cream. But that’s all the science she knew.
The heads of other EEC/EC (forget which it was at the time) countries had hardly any science background at all. They regarded Thatcher a bit dismissively as a political lightweight — which she was.
So just to impress them, Bell her chief spin-doctor cooked up a concern about “global warming”.

Posted by: Cynic | Jul 9 2023 18:31 utc | 42

Sputnik highlights the #1 world problem that was confessed by Biden today. But before we go further, I highly suggest viewing this political cartoon.
Okay, context is now set, “Biden Believes China Wants to ‘Replace US as Leading Power'”. IMO, the problem is the mindset that the world needs/wants a “leading power” at all. Recall the basis for the UN Charter–all nations are to be considered equal; all are to have the same weight with regard to their voice in international affairs. And clearly with China’s Three Initiatives, that’s their basic philosophical foundation. The basis for the centuries of competition, rivalries and conflict between nations is based on the Zero-sum idea that One Must Be King of the Hill–that’s precisely what’s behind the Ukraine Crisis and the Nazi ideology driving it. The Zero-sum garbage of the past is not what China or the RoW desire. What they do desire is Win-Win cooperation where all work together to advance all.
Here are some of the things Biden said that Sputnik reported:

“I’m confident he wants to have the largest economy in the world and have the largest military capacity in the world,’ Biden said.
He added that Xi also wanted to rewrite certain rules of the international order, but “not all of them.”
“I think so. Not all of them. But he pointed out to me and said we weren’t there when those rules were written … But I don’t think he wants, he’s looking for a war conflict, expansion of territory,” Biden said.

It’s plain to see Biden is projecting. Plus, Xi has said he obeys the UN Charter which is the genuine International Order, which is reflected in China being a co-founder along with Russia of the group of Friends in Defense of the UN Charter–if the Outlaw US Empire was truthful about obeying the UN Chater, then why isn’t it amongst its defenders? Well, we know very well why that is.
As for China wanting to have the largest economy, with 1.4 Billion people, it ought to have the largest economy and already does if honest measures were taken. And if there’s to be a “World Leader,” that person ought to be the United Nations Secretary General, not some national politician.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 18:44 utc | 43

Breaking News… via BBC Radio.
Now that The Hobbit is on her way home to USA after a successful Lecture Tour of China, John (“Assad Must Go”) Kerry is planning a visit.
Could be good for a few LoLs?

Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Jul 9 2023 18:48 utc | 44

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 18:44 utc | 43
Even if the men in Washington think that the US is going to be overtaken by China as leading world economic power, how is it they think that the situation can be reversed by *military* action. I’ve never understood that.

Posted by: laguerre | Jul 9 2023 18:56 utc | 45

Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Jul 9 2023 18:48 utc | 44
I never thought Truss was as clever as a Hobbit.

Posted by: laguerre | Jul 9 2023 18:58 utc | 46


Posted by: laguerre | Jul 9 2023 18:58 utc | 46
Oops! My mistake?
My Hobbit is USA’s Yellen.

Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Jul 9 2023 19:07 utc | 47

@ robjira | Jul 9 2023 17:22 utc | 29
thanks for pointing out the timofeev article robjira.. 2 things that stick out from the article for me are that russia sees how serious the west is in completely undermining russia.. here is the first quote to reflect this..
” There is an increasingly widespread view in Russia that the goal of the US – and the “collective West” it leads – is to achieve a “final solution” to the “Russian question.” The goals are believed to be defeating Russia, wrecking its military potential, restructuring its statehood, reshaping its identity and possibly eliminating it as a state, in its current form.”
here is the 2nd quote which i think is also very relevant.. “There will be no return to the reality of 2021. It is clear that Russia will do everything it can to protect the new territorial status quo and to undermine Ukraine’s military potential as much as possible. It is also clear that the West will do everything it can to undermine Russia and, if the circumstances are right, will also use any internal problems to its advantage.
The question remains as to how the current crisis will end.
There is currently no political solution to the Russian-Ukrainian conflict in sight. The sustainability of any peace agreement, even if reached, is highly questionable. The West fears an abrupt military escalation and a war with Russia that could quickly turn into a nuclear exchange. However, NATO’s gradual direct military involvement in the conflict cannot be ruled out.”
not sure how this works out..
@ bevin | Jul 9 2023 17:25 utc | 30
thanks bevin… that is interesting the dutch connection in southern ontario to those farmers in the netherlands.. that graph from helmers link is most telling.. it would be nice if something similar happened here in canada… i share the link again below..
Netherlands — National parliament voting intention

Posted by: james | Jul 9 2023 19:11 utc | 48

@ Hoarsewhisperer | Jul 9 2023 19:07 utc | 47 with the hobbit visit to China
I knew who you were referring to and want to add that currently Xinhuanet currently has ZERO media coverage of the results of her visit or even that it happened….grin

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 9 2023 19:16 utc | 49

Posted by: Roger | Jul 9 2023 13:42 utc | 5
Just wait for the winter solstice, the Antarctic sea ice is 1.5 million square kilometers below the previous record. That is a hell of a lot of energy uptake when you go from an albedo of 0.6-0.9 down to 0.06. Especially at the high angle of incidence were the missing ice is located.

Posted by: badjoke | Jul 9 2023 19:21 utc | 50

@Posted by: james | Jul 9 2023 15:59 utc | 12
From Helmer’s article “This is the European allies’ last stand, their backs to the wall at the Dnieper River. It is the rationale for desperate measures on the battlefield, and at the NATO summit on July 11.”
I really wish it were so, but just like with the Soviet fight against the Nazis, there will have to be many more battles before this is over. The Battle of Ukraine may be equivalent to Stalingrad or Kursk, but these slimy European elites will find ways to survive. A Baerbock or a Macron may be thrown to the populist wolves, compromises made here and there, perhaps a good bit of fascism instituted but they will find a way. They survived putting Hitler and Mussolini in power and then losing a world war, just look at the family who owns BMW and many other such oligarchic German families.
Just look at the Italian leader, Giorgia Meloni, a member of the Aspen Institute since 2020 and the International Republican Institute and a regular speaker at CPAC. Meet the Real Meloni. I am sure that behind the scenes the oligarchs are already reaching out to the AfD and the NF to reach an agreement to let them rule. They did the same with the ANC from the mid 1980s onwards, with many ANC-members living abroad to escape the South African apartheid regime. Upon gaining power the ANC went from Marxist to neoliberal in a heartbeat with Mbeki’s government lauded by conservative US think tanks!
The rhetoric against immigrants will be ramped up, maybe even all the TQ++++ stuff reversed, the Russians will be seen to be “at our door”. Its good to see the Balkans, Austria, Hungary and perhaps the Iberian peninsula turn away from this but I cant see the Atlanticist elites of North Western Europe and Poland giving up for many, many years if at all.

Posted by: Roger | Jul 9 2023 19:37 utc | 51

more bs. the fossil fuel companies are awash in money. climatologists aren’t. Maggie Thatcher recognized it is sound. it is only after the fossil fuel companies launched their propaganda campaign in roughly 1990 that we started hearing all this bs.
Posted by: pretzelattack | Jul 9 2023 17:36 utc | 33
There’s an ongoing war out there.
Maggie Thatcher used the ideology spewed out by East Anglia University to destroy and dismember the British coal industry …
Climate Change – lately “Green House Effect” theory – is a tool in the hand of the Nuclear Industry in its fight against the Oil Industry in the war of supremacy for the One World Energy Provider position.
One should remember that the Windsor family is the main uranium mine owner in the World.

Posted by: Greg Galloway | Jul 9 2023 19:40 utc | 52

persiflo @15
It was Aleph Null who came up with the numbers for energy imbalance, not I. His cite was better than any I’d previously read. Measured, not modeled.
One more that has come to bear since that article was published. Global sea ice area is at record lows and enough millions of square kilometers to make a difference. The troglodytes like to make a big deal out of Arctic ice being (from one squinty eyed point of view) basically static a decade now. Or they claim it has rebounded, which is beyond rubbish. Antarctic ice is way down. In terms of global imbalance doesn’t matter if the dark blue water is north or south. So just in the four years since data for the article was gathered, energy imbalance is going to be a good bit more than one watt per square meter.

Posted by: oldhippie | Jul 9 2023 20:09 utc | 53

more bs. the fossil fuel companies are awash in money. climatologists aren’t.(emphasis added)
Posted by: pretzelattack | Jul 9 2023 17:36 utc | 33

True, but climatologists are generally dependent on funding from foundations and other sources that expect their work to bolster the climate change concept. A climatologist who publicly questions climate change might find himself or herself on the unemployment line in short order.
Climatology is just one of the many so-called disciplines whose researchers are financially coerced into conclusions that the funders want to see. Scholarly research is to a large extent a racket.

Posted by: David Levin | Jul 9 2023 20:22 utc | 54

laguerre | Jul 9 2023 18:56 utc | 45–
Thanks for your reply. The only way to degrade China’s economic ability is to destroy its works or to eliminate its workers. IMO, the last method’s been attempted at least twice. Trump and others thought disconnecting China from the Outlaw US Empire’s market would impede China’s progress, but that attempt and Biden’s continuation of that policy has utterly failed and caused more harm in the Metropole. The problem from the outset is the West’s and especially the Neoliberal Weltanschauung, which I touch on in my comment. When Xi announced BRI in 2013, I wrote: Here’s an excellent opportunity for the US to combine with China and Win-Win together. Of course, the opposite course was taken and the Outlaw US Empire has declined annually since then, just as it was declining before 2013.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 20:22 utc | 55

Russia Has ‘Harassed’ US Drones In Syria For 3 Straight Days: Pentagon
It’s unfair. The US has not blown up the North Stream undersea gas pipeline, is not shelling the Zaporozhye nuclear power plant, has nothing to do with the bombing of the Kerch bridge, has not sent drones to bomb the Kremlin. But those bad, bad Russians are harassing American drones, flying mostly peacefully above Syria. Three days already!

Posted by: Passerby | Jul 9 2023 20:27 utc | 56

@ Roger | Jul 9 2023 19:37 utc | 51
roger – thanks for your insights which you share here at moa and on your substack page.. i appreciate it.. and i agree with your take on helmers comment you isolated.. helmer is optimistic, but i too share your viewpoint… we are into the proxy war for 1 1/2 years approx.. i can see it going on a lot longer unfortunately…in fact, i find it hard to imagine an end to this as neither side – usa led nato, or russia are going to willingly let the other side off the hook here..
in spite of increasing agitation within europe over the continuation of this proxy war, i suspect the powers that be will find a way to continue on and any unrest will be forcefully quelled… so much for the people having a voice or a democracy with so much of the european state a type of servant or vassal of the usa foreign policies agenda here.. although it seems promising mark rutte stepping down, we will have to wait and see how things pan out in the netherlands, another very support puppet of the usa foreign policy agenda..

Posted by: james | Jul 9 2023 20:35 utc | 57

bevin @30, james @48
I’m glad you brought up the Netherlands and the sofa analogy because I think the Dutch influence on Canadian policy is underestimated. (See MAID.) I would also like to raise the Dutch presence in the Lower Mainland and the Fraser Valley with the very powerful greenhouse industry. Let us not fool ourselves, though (I say with bias.) The relationship is colonial — what’s good for the goose is not good for the gander (Lebensraum for Dutch interests). If we in Canada wish for reform in the agricultural industry, King Charles is a much more likely co-sponsor. Land rights and use is a sticky subject.

Posted by: Bruised Northerner | Jul 9 2023 20:37 utc | 58

An FYI: I’ve finally established a substack page that still needs more tinkering but functions. It’s first publication is also available above, ‘World to Biden: We Don’t Need Another “Leading Power”.’ It can be found here for those wanting to subscribe, https://karlof1.substack.com/

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 21:40 utc | 59

@james, bevin, anyone else talking about Helmer’s latest, S if you’re reading:

The apprehension of the allies in Europe was revealed a few days ago when Jacques Attali answered a telephone call he thought was from former Ukrainian president Petro Poroshenko, but which came instead from the Russian pranksters Vovan and Lexus. Attali, French presidential adviser, US retainer, and ex-head of the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development, said he knew French President Emmanuel Macron well and that Macron was afraid the US would abandon the Ukrainians to save itself. There was the same fear among the Germans and British, Attali added. “The weak point is what happens in Washington.”
“[This is] a nightmare scenario. That would be the US saying, well, enough is enough. We are not going to help Ukraine more. You have to go to negotiations, to the negotiating table. And that’s it. … Neither France, Germany or the UK can do that. But the US could arm-twist your [Poroshenko’s] government and your country [Ukraine] to say we want a ceasefire whatever it costs and stop [the war]. The most important thing is to avoid that.”
There is no other way than a total win and to get rid of Putin…We have to take all risks for that. No compromise is possible, no compromise.

Emphasis (bold) obviously mine. So let’s play doom-and-gloom here and accept that through this man we may divine the real mindset of the highest up among NATO country leaders. Helmer is always meticulous with his details and his short version of Attali’s bio checks out – he is said by some to be the person who actually picked out Emmanuel Macron from his job at Rotschild & Co., introducing him to Hollande and proposing to make him Minister of Economy, so yeah – He probably knows Macron pretty well, and I’m going to assume that he remains “plugged-in” to the goings on in Paris and Brussels, not so much Washington D.C.
Having accepted this, namely that at least some very high ranking NATO and EU officials – certainly along with their American counterparts – view this conflict as existential and that by getting rid of Pootie all their problems will be solved, let me try to dive in a little deeper, both into their mindset, the implications of and for Putin, and the typical wake of death, despair, destruction and chaos that follows most US/NATO wars and proxy wars.
First, I want to think about Putin and Russia and I’ll do so from a cynical and/or fearful frame of reference. Some questions occurred to me over the last 24 hours that I have been unable to completely answer to my own satisfaction. First, I know that Russia is a democracy in the same way that many western countries are and that whoever succeeds Putin will have to ostensibly win the popular vote in an election (assuming no crazy coups). Does Putin or Yedinaya Rossiya (United Russia) have a candidate ready to go and likely to win? It occurred to me that by winning so many elections, Putin has had too much of the grand plan vested in himself and his (assumed accurate in reality) image of being tough on the oligarchs, willing to back down to the will of the people over neoliberal economists (on the pensions for example), and in general very staunch in his defense of the RF and its resources & people against western oligarchical private capitalist/financial interests. If he runs and wins again in 2024, this will be even more true. It also crossed my mind that he (or his Yedinaya Rossiya successor) could be subject to the exact same whims of greed, short-sightedness and selfishness that most western politicians are and that he’s prepared to retire in comfort no matter what happens to the RF after his departure from office. Of course if he leaves in 2030, he’ll be 80 years old. That last part probably isn’t the case, however, with him knowing that the ICC issued that joke of a warrant for his arrest, and that only a strong, sympathetic Russian state may stand between him and a show trial in the Netherlands. I suppose I am rambling a bit now.
But back to the question – Has anyone heard from Alexei Kudrin since he resigned as head of the Russian Audit Chamber and took over Yandex? Allegedly this is actually a career path to succeeding Putin for Kudrin as an Independent (I have no idea if such a thing could happen in Russia) or representing another party like LDPR. Helmer wrote about Kudrin’s likely desire to become President of Russia and of the suspiciously favorable view of Washington D.C. of this scenario. Likely because he’d be much more willing to find favor in Brussels and D.C. through corrupting the RF and re-empowering the oligarchs.
https://mronline.org/2022/12/01/alexei-kudrin-starts-his-run-to-succeed-president-vladimir-putin/
Anyway, that part really amounts to a long-winded question about Putin, Russia’s future and (implied not stated) how willing/able the western private finance goons are to play the “long game” in light of Attali’s statement, which echoes many among the Beltway elite (Joe Biden for one) in saying “Putin has to go.” What is the most likely scenario for HOW Putin “goes” and what happens to the RF after? Furthermore, who among the western financial elite will be around to benefit like what happened in the 90s?
Second part of my musings kinda builds off that last bit but hinges more on the success or failure of this NATO-404 proxy war inasmuch as it is 1) existential to the current US-led “world order” (and let’s say the RF as it is currently situated – meaning strongly) and 2) likely or unlikely to push Putin from power earlier than expected. What is the worst case scenario in terms of the RF falling apart/prey to the western “globalist” corpora-financial elites? By that I mean what could realistically happen in the current military political conflict in Ukraine (and beyond?) that could actually cause a major change of direction in Russian leadership and an austerity based rapprochement/genuflection/subjugation with/to the western neoliberal financial parasites?

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 9 2023 21:45 utc | 60

What does the bar make of this from Al Jazeera?
https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2023/6/27/dont-see-why-not-china-envoy-on-backing-ukraines-91-borders

Brussels, Belgium – China’s envoy to the European Union has suggested that Beijing could back Ukraine’s aims of reclaiming its 1991 territorial integrity, which includes Crimea – the peninsula annexed by Russia in 2014.
In a recent interview with Al Jazeera and two other media outlets, when Fu Cong was asked about supporting Kyiv’s goals, which includes reclaiming other Ukrainian regions now occupied by Russia, the senior Chinese diplomat said: “I don’t see why not. We respect the territorial integrity of all countries. So when China established relations with the former Soviet Union, that’s what we agreed. But as I said, these are historical issues that need to be negotiated and resolved by Russia and Ukraine and that is what we stand for.”

Sounds suspect to me. Al Jazeera has taken a decidedly anti-Russia stance in the conflict with Ukraine and NATO. And what is the real meaning/translation of the Chinese diplomat’s statement? He is supposedly the envoy to the EU. What sort of diplomacy games might he be playing assuming he really means that China would be fine with seeing Ukraine somehow retaking Crimea? Is this even worth addressing?

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 9 2023 21:54 utc | 61

Re: My comment #68 – To be clear, this was published the day after the Al Jazeera article, but I was curious if any more had come of the ALLEGED statements from Fu Cong.
https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202306/1293322.shtml

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 9 2023 21:57 utc | 62

Sometimes, I’m surprised to see an article like this in an unexpected place:
https://theconversation.com/u-s-allies-should-rethink-their-allegiance-to-an-aggressive-but-declining-superpower-207786
Does anyone see this as a sign of (very creeping) growing disquiet in the ‘West’, or is it just one of those exceptions?

Posted by: Deeplurker | Jul 9 2023 22:04 utc | 63

karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 21:40 utc | 59
I’ve finally established a substack page
Yah!!!!
I could never access your VK.
Maybe once of the tech-heads here could help with a ?script? to dump your VK Putin and Lavrov speeches across.
Is it possible to take the work on biolabs that Peter did and host that at your substack???
(I could never access his VK either)
Thanks Karl for your persistence in making primary Russian material available.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jul 9 2023 22:05 utc | 64

Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 9 2023 21:45 utc | 60
One of the big positives of the SMO is that it is shaking up the whole political setup in Russia. Maybe Putin believes his ‘revolution from above’ has run its course and it’s time for the Russian masses to be in the driver’s seat. The SMO separates the men from the boys, the oligarchs from the national bourgeoisie, the ‘parquet generals’ from the heirs of Zhukov and real patriots from the 5/6th columnists. Surovkin/Zyuganov 2030 for the KRPF?
PS, well done demonstrating that not all expressions of concern are ‘concern trolling’.

Posted by: S.P. Korolev | Jul 9 2023 22:06 utc | 65

Climate–
This ought to be enough to get any open-minded person inquiring further about the changes that are taking place on the Earth.
It’s often said that Earth’s climate is always changing. Very true, but the question is how much and how fast. Go to this link and scroll down to the temperature by time chart toward the bottom. Click on it to enlarge it and examine it. While the chart shows lots of fluxuation over the millions of years covered, it levels out over the last 10,000 years, a period called the Holocene. Essentially, humanity has commenced agriculture and civilization during a climate “sweet spot” more stable than any preceding period in the planet’s history–stable until the effects of human industrialization began to increase the average temperature over the past 200 years.
If you’re skeptical about these prehistoric temperature estimates, here are two articles that explain what these calculations are based upon:
A New Zealand weather agency’s explanation
A site based in India with a good explanation
What is the mechanism for this departure from the Holocene stability? This article provides the 19th century history of the discovery of carbon dioxide’s property of absorbing photons. Oxygen and nitrogen do not absorb photons, i.e. energy, from sunlight, but CO2 does. The more CO2 in the atmosphere, the more heat is retained. As some of the articles cited above detail, it’s quite easy to demonstrate a connection between the CO2 concentration in the atmosphere and Earth’s average temperature.
Why care about 1.5 degrees C of warming? Because human civilization and the agriculture that feeds us have come into being during Earth’s most stable climate period. Our still increasing dumping of CO2 into the atmosphere is changing that and moving the Earth’s climate to a new level we have not seen before. More energy in the atmosphere, more energy in the ocean that absorbs most of this new heat, more violent storms, more intense droughts.
We’re living in an experiment, having thrown the precautionary principle to the winds. But then, I sure don’t want to interfere with anybody’s Happy Motoring.

Posted by: Henry Moon Pie | Jul 9 2023 22:14 utc | 66

S # 15:06 utc | 10

The Russian Telegram channel China army has posted a video of a Chinese People’s Armed Police Force FPV drone exercise: passing through an obstacle, attacking an air target.

Awesome, thank you.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Jul 9 2023 22:26 utc | 67

wagelaborer # 17:42 utc | 35

In 1996 Al Gore led the US delegation to Kyoto, where he negotiated loopholes for the US wide enough to fly a squadron of F-35s through, in the Accord.
Worse, he turned the climate over to Wall Street, to let corporations clear-cutting entire forests to burn for fuel get “carbon credits” for using “renewable sources”, for one example, along with other boondoggles.
Since then the environmental movement has been sidetracked from advocating for clean air, clean water, wildlife protection, forest protection, stopping ocean acidification and the dumping of plastics into the oceans, saving endangered species, etc., all of which used to be part of the movement, into concern about climate change and only climate change.
That is why people get suspicious. If capitalists jump onboard a cause with such enthusiasm, people with memories of past abuses should check for the profits being made.
The Empire of Hypocrisy lecturing China is, as usual, cringingly embarrassing.

Thank you and well said.
Al Gore is a despicable lead actor in the decapitation of the environment movement and its capacity to lobby for change. He and his carbon copy suave ‘thought leaders’ (including Thunberg) are useless turds. They are installed/promoted to render attitude change harmless to the empire of growth at any cost.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Jul 9 2023 23:18 utc | 68

Tom_Q_Collins # 21:45 utc | 60
Thank you for that Helmer take on Macron. Some are saying that Macron is being coloured out of the frame: https://alexkrainer.substack.com/p/france-under-attack
I posted this at the dead stage of the last open thread.
It is worth the read because the stakes are extreme here for both Russia and USA.
All vassal states of the USA that exhibit the least sign of deviance can expect savage, direct interventions across the spectrum to maintain CONTROL.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Jul 9 2023 23:35 utc | 69

While the chart shows lots of fluxuation over the millions of years covered, it levels out over the last 10,000 years, a period called the Holocene.
Henry Moon Pie | Jul 9 2023 22:14 utc | 66
You misread or misinterpreted the graph. Since you obviously don’t understand logarithmic scales and how they can distort the way data series are plotted and viewed on a graph, the rest of your post can be ignored.

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 9 2023 23:37 utc | 70

@ karlof1 with the new Substack platform….congratulations and hope it works well for you….
I really like the political cartoon
https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202307/1293999.shtml
Playing victim is a sick ploy of desperate bullies

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 9 2023 23:49 utc | 71

Melaleuca | Jul 9 2023 22:05 utc | 64–
Thanks for your reply. I’m not certain how much direct translations I’ll post to the substack. What I’ll likely do is after I’ve compiled 50 or so subscribers, I’ll hold a poll asking if they’d like to get flooded with such content. Long ago at VK, I used to parse the transcripts but reached the point where it seemed better to post the entire document–viewers increased after I did that. I’m also miffed at VK’s length restrictions. From what I see at substack, that isn’t an issue, although I’ll soon discover if it is or not.
psychohistorian | Jul 9 2023 23:49 utc | 71–
Thanks for your reply. Yeah, I need to figure out how to insert images and such into articles so readers don’t need to look for themselves. That was a good little editorial so I thought I’d use is as my primer. I have several large projects I’ve had in mind for awhile that will be my next several items, although I still need to fiddle with the header graphic and a few other items to get the page the way I want it.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 10 2023 0:22 utc | 72

@ Bruised Northerner | Jul 9 2023 20:37 utc | 58
i don’t know if you remember bill vanderzam, the bc premier for a number of years, going back to the 70’s or was it the 80’s? he was from holland and is the successful business man who started art knapps nursery which continue to be successful in the lower mainland and around b.c. i never really thought of how much his or the netherland influence was in b.c. i know a lady here named gerta whose sister and many family members are still in holland.. she is an artist – 75 years old, and doing well.. she told me a story about ward airs owner (max ward) the precursor to canadian airlines, and how she knew max and used to fly with him when he first started.. so many these dutch people are better connected them i realize! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Max_Ward_(aviator)
@ Tom_Q_Collins | Jul 9 2023 21:45 utc | 60
good questions, but the only answers can be speculative.. it is impossible to know.. it seems time is the key ingredient here and time might be on one side more then the other.. i can’t figure it out.. a lot can happen in a short amount of time to change the situation.. as we saw with prigozhin – anything can happen, but on balance i think russia hold a very strong hand here. putin seems solid and the public seem to be very supportive of him.. so who cracks first?? by the look of it – europe – germany in paricular… what will come of that, if the german public find a representative to offer an alternative viewpoint to this madness here? look at mark rutte stepping down yesterday in the netherlands… the farmers have gained an upper hand, although they were castigated at the time for challenging the political authorities… france is on edge and i don’t see that lessening any time soon… all in all – hard to give an answer to your question, but things are not happy in the usa empireland at present.. they may not be perfect in russia either, but at this point, if one could remove the unpredictablity of what time can bring – russia seems to have the upper hand..

Posted by: james | Jul 10 2023 1:05 utc | 73

RE Greg Galloway | Jul 9 2023 19:40 utc | 52 who claimed “One should remember that the Windsor family is the main uranium mine owner in the World.
You have evidence of this? I would be interested in seeing it.

Posted by: Debsisdead | Jul 10 2023 1:08 utc | 74

RE Greg Galloway | Jul 9 2023 19:40 utc | 52 who claimed “One should remember that the Windsor family is the main uranium mine owner in the World.
You have evidence of this? I would be interested in seeing it.

Posted by: Debsisdead | Jul 10 2023 1:08 utc | 75

@ Deeplurker | Jul 9 2023 22:04 utc | 63
it is another one of those platforms that seem to want to get their foot in every country and area they can and develop a following and to generate revenue off it… nothing wrong with that… all the social media outlets do that..
this page suggests nothing exceptional about them.. maybe there will be some good articles – maybe not..

Posted by: james | Jul 10 2023 1:13 utc | 76

double posting again? I wish the typepad or whatever it is would make up its mind. All post I made over weekend disappeared into the ether now it’s double posting my stuff.

Posted by: Debsisdead | Jul 10 2023 1:14 utc | 77

“…Xi has said he obeys the UN Charter which is the genuine International Order, which is reflected in China being a co-founder along with Russia of the group of Friends in Defense of the UN Charter–if the Outlaw US Empire was truthful about obeying the UN Charter, then why isn’t it amongst its defenders? Well, we know very well why that is…”
Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 18:44 utc | 43
This is a truthful and important post, karlof1! The insistence on the selfdefeating policies of the West that suppose other nations to be as obsessed with riches, power,domination as they are — this is madness shared only by megalomaniacs! The US has forced the world in a direction away from cooperations among peoples which clearly are currently the only possible actions needed to save humanity and planetary health! They have seized the public microphone to deafen us with distraction; but that is ending because most of us are not what they have become.
It doesn’t need to be an ‘us against them’ scenario, there needs to be trust, accomodation, generosity — not fear and suspicion,curses, threats and lies! The only reason for those false reactions is because the demented few cannot give up their fiendish powers of death and destruction, the only ‘security’ they know — because it has made them rich.
But now, see, the weapons fail, nations have been and are being destroyed. Who will be left to buy? And if nobody buys, who profits? This is not even the fall of Saigon; we limped along a bit longer after Saigon fell. Kicked the can further down the road. Made some more millions because folk couldn’t believe a once credible mighty nation had fallen so low. But now, the can is so big it can’t be kicked!
The way up is the way down. We are nearly there!
I quote from the Bertrand article b linked:
“…Bit by bit we will see a new multilateral order appear and soon politicians in the West will realize the mistakes made by the previous generation…”
Thank you, Xi; thank you, Putin; thank you b, thank you, karlof1.
Thank you, world.

Posted by: juliania | Jul 10 2023 2:35 utc | 78

Michael Hudson continues to churn out stellar pieces about the plumbing of our social structure and I commend him for that
https://michael-hudson.com/2023/07/should-there-really-be-a-supreme-court/
READ IT!

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 10 2023 2:38 utc | 79

Below is the sort of China bashing you get from some postings at ZH

For those of you who have listened to our calls or watched our webinars, you know that we are not doubting the dollar as the reserve currency, but do see the dollar as the “world wide web” and the yuan as the “dark web”. The scale sounds about right, but maybe it attributes too many negative connotations to trade using the yuan (or maybe not enough depending on your view).

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 10 2023 2:57 utc | 80

If global cooling/warming/climate change (it’s always changing!?) is the threat it’s claimed to be, then why is it that 16 boats can make more pollution than all the vehicles in the world?
Carnival cruises. Just one company makes more pollution than 293 million cars in Europe.
Yet somehow, my car and your cooker are the root of all evil?
A chap in London bought a pollution detector. Wandered around London as he explained that the WHOs recommended pollution level is less than 10 (10 what exactly, I don’t know). Anyways, he sat down next to a very busy road. The score was 4 I believe. It certainly wasn’t over 10. They want you on public transport. Like the underground. Funny that, as he recorded a score of 170 as a train pulled in.
It stinks

Posted by: Some Random Passeby | Jul 10 2023 3:06 utc | 81

“…You have evidence of this? I would be interested in seeing it.” Debsisdead@75
The ‘evidence’ will almost certainly involve the definition of Crown Lands (of which there are many acres around the world) as the private property of the ‘Windsor’ family.

Posted by: bevin | Jul 10 2023 3:50 utc | 82

re bevin | Jul 10 2023 3:50 utc | 82
That is drawing a very long and likely just plain wrong bow. It ignores the fact that by far the largest viable deposit is found in Kazakhstan or that there are countless other places all over the world with uranium ore currently considered ‘unviable’ because of the decrease in demand for nuclear power stations in the last two decades, something that will change if demand increases, however that is not what sets me off about the original post.
It is the asinine claim that a bunch of intellectually challenged, in-bred drongos have agency over anything much in the current corporate capitalist world, I find this type of assertion as bad as those who claim the PTB are lizards in zip up human suits. Not only are they ludicrous and feed the flames of alleged conspiracy under every bed nonsense, they divert attention away from the real war-mongers and decision makers. Monarchs haven’t been required to be the ultimate holders of wealth since the end of WW1 when the rise of corporate power began to supercede sovereign rights.
The sad truth is that the CEOs of mega funds such as Blackrock have far more power (financial & political) than any ‘royal family’ ever has. Whilst it is true that they are no less sociopathic than those, it is a myth that they operate in unison or are any more omniscient than them either.
One just has to consider the actions of that pair of second rung players zuckerburg & musk to see that corporate capitalists are equally as riven with petty jealousies and destructive rivalries as victoria’s grandsons.
Blaming the ills of the planet on windsors, rothschilds or lizardmen gives these creeps succour IMO.

Posted by: Debsisdead | Jul 10 2023 4:45 utc | 83

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 9 2023 23:37 utc | 70
I didn’t misread the chart. The scale is the same for the last million years. The difference in variability is obvious.
We’ll give you an explicit verbal interpretation that will not require you to understand the chart or view it honestly:

To sum up, the Holocene shows both long-term trends (including changes in the nature of ENSO) and millennial time-scale variability although the amplitude of the variability is small compared with that characteristic of Ice Ages. As more detailed information becomes available, the timing of the Holocene maximum warmth is seen to differ across the globe. There appears to be a south to north pattern, with southern latitudes displaying maximum warming a few millennia before the Northern Hemisphere regions. Interestingly, the Holocene appears by far the longest warm stable period (as far as seen from the Antarctic climate record) over the last 400 ky, with profound implications for the development of civilisation (Petit et al., 1999).

That was from the IPCC. This is from the study itself:

The temporal evolution and duration of stages 5.5 and 9.3 are indeed remarkably similar for all properties recorded in Vostok ice and entrapped gases. As judged from the Vostok record, the long, stable Holocene is a unique feature of climate during the past 420 kyr, with possibly profound implications for evolution and the development ofcivilizations.

One of the reasons that people dismiss climate skeptics is that they resort to bad faith argumentation and reliance on liar-for-hire outfits like the Heartland Institute.

Posted by: Henry Moon Pie | Jul 10 2023 5:18 utc | 84

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 10 2023 2:57 utc | 80
It’s not “some postings” about China of negative character at ZH, in 20+ years of observation I have never seen a positive posting concerning China.
The economy is always in a state of collapse, real estate in big trouble ad nauseum.

Posted by: SwissArmyMan | Jul 10 2023 5:45 utc | 85

From Xinhuanet
Posting title: China unveils regulation on private investment funds
The Link: https://english.news.cn/20230709/fceac501c00048fc97fc3ca3203d6957/c.html
The quote

BEIJING, July 9 (Xinhua) — China published a regulation on Sunday concerning the supervision and administration of private investment funds, the country’s first administrative regulation on the sector, marking the latest move to safeguard the healthy development of the industry and protect investors.
The regulation, with 62 items in seven chapters, will come into effect on Sept. 1, 2023, the State Council said in a statement.
The regulation aims to encourage the standardized and healthy development of the private investment fund industry, better protect the legitimate rights and interests of investors, and encourage the industry to further play a role in serving the real economy and promoting scientific and technological innovation.
The regulation clarifies the scope of application, specifies the obligations and requirements of private fund managers and custodians, regulates fundraising and investment operations, and strengthens supervision and management as well as legal liability.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 10 2023 5:48 utc | 86

@ SwissArmyMan | Jul 10 2023 5:45 utc | 85 who says ZH never says anything nice about China
I have been reading ZH since the comment section was manageable….grin. I agree with the not being nice part but occasionally the truth about China slips into a posting because it can’t be denied within the context of the article of theirs or from one of their sources.

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jul 10 2023 6:08 utc | 87

@Debsisdead | Jul 10 2023 1:08 utc | 75
The following link mentions the possession of uranium mines a decade ago
” UK Royalty Owns 85% Of World’s Uranium Mineral Right”
https://www.agreenroadjournal.com/2013/09/queen-of-england-uranium-mines-nuclear.html

Posted by: petergrfstrm | Jul 10 2023 8:11 utc | 88

karlof1 | Jul 9 2023 18:08 utc | 38
100 billion cubic meters for Romanian project?
According to
https://www.offshore-technology.com/projects/neptun-deep-gas-field-project-black-sea/
630 million cubic feet per day, which translates to about 6.5 billion cubic meters per year,
so must be projected over about 15 years.

Posted by: Cindy Martin | Jul 10 2023 8:29 utc | 89

re petergrfstrm | Jul 10 2023 8:11 utc | 88
As far as I can tell your evidence is a long rant which seeks to implicate the englander ‘royal family’ but which provides no actual verifiable evidence.
I get it no one likes having that mob of parasites hanging off their tit, however as I pointed out above, mindlessly ascribing the state this old rock is in to a mob of half-witted has-beens does distract attention away from contemporary culprits. No one has uranium cornered. It is available for those who seek it regardless of the chinless wonders and I reckon nowdays they’re little more than a distraction.
Sure a distraction englanders need to solve but one that is solely down to you mob. The two mobs most important to me, Oz & Aotearoa, are in the process of ditching ’em and if one were to compare the pittance Chuck III gets off Oz each year to the $340 billion the amerikan MIC is demanding from Oz in protection premiums, the chinless wonder component is slight.
The real issue for englanders is that far more witless englanders turned out to kiss royal arse than those which demanded their heads. Sort out the bourgeois drongos, then englanders can resist more successfully.
I could not help but notice that the dire & deceitful graun ran a story about how citizens of the Orkney Islands, the lands my antecedents emigrated from to Aotearoa are now demanding separation from the UK, as they want their connection with Scandinavia who they were part of for much longer than they were part of the UK, properly acknowledged, not just historically, also administratively .

Posted by: Debsisdead | Jul 10 2023 8:40 utc | 90

One thing that you could see as a sign of the failing empire. Producer price index (PPI) has fallen near zero or negative and consumer price index (CPI) to 0-3 % in Russia and China. And US and EU are now taking the role of Russian inflation in the 1990s, or other third tier countries.

Posted by: unimperator | Jul 10 2023 8:52 utc | 91

Phil R (70) is correct that Henry Moon Pie (66) is incorrectly
reading the graph.
https://muchadoaboutclimate.files.wordpress.com/2013/08/blog4_temp.png
However, the graph is not logarithmic: it is a concatenation of 7
linear scales, which become more dilated going left to right. In
particular, the 4th and 5th panels show 500 kyr (500,000 years) and 10
kyr, respectively. Hence, the former is compressed by a factor of 50
relative to the latter. This means that the current stable period is
similar to the brief stable period shown in the 4th panel
about 100 kyr ago, which also lasted about 10 kyr. Then, looking at
the “Milankovitch cycles” over the past 2.5 million years, it is clear
that there are many “brief” (few kyr) periods when the temperature
was similar to today, embedded in a long trend that is dominated
by ice ages of declining temperature.
I have not investigated the reliability of this graph, but if one
were to accept it and were to try to figure out climate policy
by reading it (which I do not advocate), then the main conclusion
would be that we should be dumping as much CO2 into the atmosphere
as possible to prevent the “imminent” (few kyr) return to a new
ice age.

Posted by: Cindy Martin | Jul 10 2023 9:59 utc | 92

Looks like Erdogan started trolling the west again. He said it’s time to pave the way for Turkish EU membership, after which they will pave the way for Swedish Nato membership.

Posted by: unimperator | Jul 10 2023 10:24 utc | 93

I didn’t misread the chart. The scale is the same for the last million years. The difference in variability is obvious.
Henry Moon Pie | Jul 10 2023 5:18 utc | 84
You misread the chart. And then get defensive and aggressive rather than actually trying to understand the point. If you understand how to read an axis scale, the first section on the right is scaled in thousands of years (youngest on the right and older to the left). Even this section of the scale is not the same for the first 5,000 years, and certainly not for the “last million.”
I’ll try to explain but not sure you will understand.
The first 0.15 time interval on the right side of the scale is 0.15 x 1,000 years, or 150 years (or back to about the year 1850). The scale interval between 0.15 and 1 (1,000 years) represents 850 years, or almost six times the the length of the first 150-year period. It gets worse the farther back you go.
1) The scale intervals are not equal, even for the first few thousand years,
2) This artificially and significantly expands the graph on the right-hand side and compresses it on the left. This misleads people like you to think it’s significant when it’s not.

One of the reasons that people dismiss climate skeptics is that they resort to bad faith argumentation and reliance on liar-for-hire outfits like the Heartland Institute.

Henry Moon Pie | Jul 10 2023 5:18 utc | 84
One of the reasons people dismiss climate doomers like you is that they can’t understand even simple points and always resort to argument from authority and ad hominem attacks.
You are wrong about the graph. I don’t expect you to understand, but maybe people with more open minds will find this useful.

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 10 2023 10:29 utc | 94

Putin met with Prigozhin in the Kremlin on June 29 (RIA Novosti, July 10, 2023 — in Russian)

Russian President Vladimir Putin, five days after the attempted mutiny, met in the Kremlin with the leadership of the Wagner PMC, Dmitriy Peskov, the press secretary of the head of state, said.
“Indeed, the president had such a meeting. He invited 35 people to it. All the commanders of the detachments and the management of the company. Including Prigozhin himself. This meeting took place in the Kremlin on June 29. It lasted almost three hours,” he told reporters.
According to Peskov, during the event Putin “gave an assessment of the company’s actions at the front during the SMO and also gave his assessment of the events of June 24, listened to the explanations of the commanders and offered them further options for employment.”
“They emphasized that they are staunch supporters and soldiers of the head of state and the supreme commander-in-chief,” the Kremlin spokesman added.
When asked if representatives of the Ministry of Defense were present at the meeting, Peskov replied that he “has nothing more to say about this meeting.”

Posted by: S | Jul 10 2023 10:56 utc | 95

This is an interesting read about the murky waters of the MIC.
https://johnmenadue.com/sinking-billions-undergunned-and-over-priced-part-1/
The Aussies don’t have much luck with naval acquisitions.
Shafted by the Americans with the submarine deal, and, as it would seem from this article, shafted by the British over the frigate deal.

Posted by: auximenes | Jul 10 2023 11:59 utc | 96

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 10 2023 10:29 utc | 94
Are you ready to admit that your first claim that this a logarithmic graph was wrong? The Y-axis is clearly labeled as degrees Celsius with the “0” being the average temperature in the mid-1900s. No logs as Cindy points out.
You do seem to understand the X-axis which compresses as we move further back in time. The creator’s goal was to create a long view going back millions of years but showing more detail over the past 400,000 years and especially the past two centuries.
That has no affect on my point. Stability is reflected in the amplitude of the swings between high and low temps, and since the Y-axis is consistent throughout the graph, that is unaffected by the way the graph creators have arranged the X-axis. In the Pleistocene, when humans were surviving largely by hunting-gathering, the swing in temps from high to low was over 3 degrees Celsius. During the Holocene, as humans took up agriculture in a major way, the swing was only 1 degree Celsius. Humans could adapt to the large swings in the Pleistocene because they could simply walk to areas where the climate remained more hospitable. That’s exactly what they did during the cold part of the swing, i.e. ice ages. That’s a little tougher to do with permanent agriculture fields and cities and 8 billion people.
This new Holocene stability, as highlighted in the two quotes provided to which you have not responded, has led scientists to argue that humans did not engage in agriculture before the Holocene not because they were socially or intellectually incapable but because the Pleistocene was inhospitable to agriculture: Was Agriculture Impossible during the Pleistocene but Mandatory during the Holocene? A Climate Change Hypothesis by Peter J. Richerson, Robert Boyd and Robert L. Bettinger.
Posted by: Cindy Martin | Jul 10 2023 9:59 utc | 92
You do seem to understand the graph. Indeed, it is not logarithmic despite what Phil says. You do seem to completely miss my point. Do you notice the difference in amplitude between the swings in temperature during the Pleistocene and the Holocene? The Pleistocene swings are at least 2 degrees Celsius greater than the Holocene. As for adding more CO2, unless you’re a dinosaur, you wouldn’t really like the effect. Do you notice that we are now breaching what had been the maximum average temperature during the Holocene? We are even approaching the maximum for the Pleistocene. We are now living in a warmer Earth than humans have seen since the advent of agriculture and civilization. MIT’s ENROADS simulator now projects a 3.3 degrees C rise in temperature from the beginning of industrialization, another 2+ degrees of warming above where we are now. This will exceed any average temperature since hominids have been on the planet. This means more energy in the atmosphere and ocean, more violent and frequent storms, worse droughts and floods, more crop failures.
I can understand why climate deniers would like to ignore or distort this graph because it tells a tragic tale. As life on Earth evolved, the biosphere went from a place with violent swings from ice age to hot house to a much more stable environment that made human civilization possible. Tragically, humans became bewitched by the power and convenience provided by the ancient stored sunlight under the ground, addicted to Happy Motoring and blinded by hubris to the damage they were doing.

Posted by: Henry Moon Pie | Jul 10 2023 12:18 utc | 97

Posted by: Cindy Martin | Jul 10 2023 9:59 utc | 92
It is a really crappy misleading graph. I wouldn’t touch it with a pole. Not even having to do with anything else, just a really crappy graph. The sort of thing that becomes an example of what not to do. It is not, as the fellow says, even logarithmic, it is patched together.
I usually stay out of the climate argument because I think they are both wrong (i.e. nobody knows what the climate is going to do), but that is just annoying.
However I agree with you, the way to bet is another ice age, or what was here before the ice ages. However the methane clathrates could provide some short term excitement, yes, they have before.

Posted by: Bemildred | Jul 10 2023 12:28 utc | 98

However, the graph is not logarithmic: it is a concatenation of 7
linear scales, which become more dilated going left to right.
Posted by: Cindy Martin | Jul 10 2023 9:59 utc | 92
Thanks for your comment. You are correct and I may have oversimplified to make a larger point. I was focusing on the timescale (x-) axis and not the y-axis. Looking at it again, I think it’s worse. It appears to be some combination. It is obvious that even the time intervals in the first 10,000 years are not the same.

I have not investigated the reliability of this graph, but if one
were to accept it and were to try to figure out climate policy
by reading it (which I do not advocate), then the main conclusion
would be that we should be dumping as much CO2 into the atmosphere
as possible to prevent the “imminent” (few kyr) return to a new
ice age.

Posted by: Cindy Martin | Jul 10 2023 9:59 utc | 92
I absolutely agree with this paragraph.

Posted by: Phil R | Jul 10 2023 12:37 utc | 99

Posted by: S | Jul 10 2023 10:56 utc | 95
I just want to say I appreciate your efforts to keep us informed here. Along with all the others here (karlof1) who help get all sides of the question out. Given the windstorm of obfuscation and self-serving twaddle, we need all the help we can get.

Posted by: Bemildred | Jul 10 2023 12:42 utc | 100