Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
June 28, 2023
Ukraine SitRep: Prigozhin Affair – Kramatorsk Missile Attack – Updated

Updated below – June 29, 13:55 UTC

There is still some fallout from the Prigozhin affair.

The U.S. propaganda campaign that falsely claims that Russia has been weakened by Wagner's armed mutiny continues. While citing only 'western' intelligence affiliated sources the Washington Post headlines Putin’s standing as global strongman in jeopardy after revolt. Where please is evidence for that?

The New York Times assists in a useless attempt to sow fear and doubt on the Russian side:

A senior Russian general had advance knowledge of Yevgeny Prigozhin’s plans to rebel against Russia’s military leadership, according to U.S. officials briefed on American intelligence on the matter, which has prompted questions about what support the mercenary leader had inside the top ranks.

The officials said they are trying to learn if Gen. Sergei Surovikin, the former top Russian commander in Ukraine, helped plan Mr. Prigozhin’s actions last weekend, which posed the most dramatic threat to President Vladimir V. Putin in his 23 years in power.

Gen. Sergei Surovikin of course knew that something was up with Wagner. The whole Russian leadership knew of it. Orders were obviously given for everyone to stand down and to let Prigozhin do what he had planned to do.

There was zero action taken by the border guards, the internal security force Rosguardia, by the police and the Russian military. That is unexplainable unless there was an order from very high up to step back instead of seeking a fight. President Putin's primary aim was to avoid unnecessary casualties which he largely achieved.

One miscalculation happened. Wagner had a mobile Pantsir-1 air defense system that tried to cover its convoys on their trip towards Moscow. Several Russian helicopters and a plane where shot down when they came too near to them. It seems that the Pantsirs were a surprise.

Wagner was not supposed to have them:

🌻 Fertilizer Finder 🌻 – @ManiacMagic1 – 19:38 UTC · Jun 27, 2023

A source in the Russian Defense Ministry reports that neither the Ministry of Defense nor the Tula machine-building plant "Scheglovsky Val" sold Yevgeny Prigozhin and his firms the Pantsir S-1 anti-aircraft missile system worth more than $14,000,000. How the "Pantsir" ended up in the possession of the terrorist organization "PMC Wagner" and whether the governor of the Tula region Alexei Dyumin is involved in this, are now being investigated by the investigators of the GVSU of the ICR and the SU of the FSB.
Embedded video

The source above is pro-Ukrainian so this might be another false claim intelligence play but I think there is some truth to it. Russian air defenses in Ukraine work in an integrated environment where all systems from wide area surveillance and long range defense down to the short range Pantsirs are integrated. Under such a system it never made sense to give Wagner their own independent air defenses. It would instead be provided air cover by the Russian army.

As soon as the Pantsir was observed within the Wagner convoy the Russian military should have shut down the air space near Wagner's route. That it did not immediately do so was a mistake that cost it several capable pilots.

There is still the open question of how many Wagner people were actually involved in the affair. History Legend has counted the transport equipment in the various convoys and estimates 1,500 to 2,000. The number seems reasonable. It means that large majority of the current 20,000 Wagner fighters did not take part in the affair.

In his latest speech Putin said that Prigozhin catering business with the army as well as his other business will now come under scrutiny. There was without doubt some over-billing and fraud involved. Prigozhin should have know that under Putin's regime oligarchs are not allowed to intervene in politics. Putin successfully fought against those oligarchs who tried as soon as he came to power. Prigozhin's attempt to get Defense Minister Shoigu and General Gerasimov fired was such an intervention. It will likely cost him his business.

Yesterday there was a Russian* missile strike of unknown provenance* on a hotel complex in Kramatorsk:

The missile tore into the crowded Ria Lounge restaurant at dinnertime on Tuesday, setting off a large blaze that burned for more than two hours. By Wednesday afternoon, the Ukrainian authorities said that 10 people had been confirmed dead — including 14-year-old twin sisters — and 61 others were wounded."

Video from the scene taken immediately after the event show English speaking men with the one helping a wounded exposing a quad angle tattoo with the number 3 written in it on his right arm (see at 7 sec in).


bigger

This is said to be a sign of the 3rd Ranger Battalion of the U.S. army which is a part of the U.S. special operation forces.

Another video taken during rubble clearing at night has a (British?) English speaker saying "Look what these bastards are doing to this country. There's soldiers under this rubble all over."

This seems to confirm that the hotel complex and its restaurant were not exclusively used for civilian purposes but housed and catered to foreign soldiers.

*Update – June 29, 13:55 UTC:

The June 29, 2023 report by the Russian Defense Ministry on the daily operation in Ukraine says (machine translation):

According to updated information, as a result of a high-precision strike on June 27 in the city of Kramatorsk, Donetsk People's Republic, at the point of temporary deployment of the 56th separate motorized infantry brigade of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, two generals participating in the headquarters meeting, up to 50 officers of the armed forces of Ukraine, as well as up to 20 foreign mercenaries and military personnel were destroyed.

Comments

james | Jun 28 2023 22:56 utc | 194–
Having provided direct care for a person with Alzheimer’s until her death, IMO Biden doesn’t really know what he’s saying. I’m reminded of the ordeal with Reagan during his second term as the government he vowed to shrink grew to twice the size it was when he became POTUS. Someone ought to ask him about Zelensky’s cancelling Christmas to see how he responds.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 28 2023 23:11 utc | 201

Posted by: AndC | Jun 28 2023 19:38 utc | 100
1) Prigozhin went rogue and knowingly did a kamikaze move.
2) Prigozhin along with Russian intelligence staged the whole thing.
Or 3) Prigozhin lost some marbles and bearings in battle and had convinced himself the regular troops and Russian people would rally to his cause once he got his rebellion on the move; ‘Cos he da big brave man.
Posted by: GT Stroller | Jun 28 2023 19:42 utc | 103
———————————————
I am not saying that this is my view, but just to point out that the possibilities are endless, let me try one:
(4) The whole “coup” thing was an operation to flush out a small fifth column that has infiltrated the Wagner Group (to Prigo’s shame) and, perhaps, the Russian Military as well. Prigo is now in Belarus and an unknown number of fifth column actors are in jail and remain anonymous while being interrogated.

Posted by: Ed | Jun 28 2023 23:15 utc | 202

I’m puzzled by the invisibility of Wagner’s military commanders in all this. I’ve seen their names mentioned once, but who was giving orders before and during the weekend? Don’t tell me the fat civilian paymaster in flack jacket was, by the hour, commanding 4,000-25,000 troops all over southern Russia by walkie talkie or mobile phone. A plan by ONE MAN, has to be executed by MANY.

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jun 28 2023 23:16 utc | 203

Russian scholars in Russia think Putin’s Russia may have “overestimated” him. He gave a prominent role to Prighozin and this turned out to be a big mistake. A State cannot surrender too much of its security or war-making power to another entity. It’s what Putin did. Then he complained about the vanity and ambition that the mutiny leaders had, but…Putin created that outcome, which is not a surprising one but a predictable outcome. Of course, his leader image and leadership were diminished.

Posted by: tranquilocomp | Jun 28 2023 23:17 utc | 204

The latest from Mearsheimer: says Russia wins partial victory over mangled Ukraine and that NATO committed grave error in trying to extend NATO membership to Ukraine. https://mearsheimer.substack.com/p/the-darkness-ahead-where-the-ukraine?utm_campaign=post
At the very least Mearsheimer appears to be an intellectually honest interlocutor on the topic.

Posted by: Jupiter | Jun 28 2023 23:19 utc | 205

@ dh | Jun 28 2023 23:06 utc | 197
lol.. i have to concur with @ karlof1 | Jun 28 2023 23:11 utc | 203 and it really is no laughing matter.. it’s quite sad and truly a reflection of where the late great american empire is at this juncture..
@ 201 – best to speak well of others, or withhold comment.. that is my take, although i am not perfect in practicing this, i do try!

Posted by: james | Jun 28 2023 23:20 utc | 206

Until you can show me evidence that is countervailing enough, we can only say it was a masterfully- executed deception.
Posted by: Boy | Jun 28 2023 20:01 utc | 111
—————————————————-
Mr. Hack can you respond to these questions, because I can’t. As you know I think it was an operation to flush out the fifth column that was entering Wanger via lax background reviews.

Posted by: Ed | Jun 28 2023 23:25 utc | 207

“…it really is no laughing matter.”
james | Jun 28 2023 23:20 utc | 208
So true james. That is why we have serious people like Blinken to restore decorum. It would be terrible if people started laughing at Joe.

Posted by: dh | Jun 28 2023 23:29 utc | 208

James @ 171:
Alek-A’s opinion @ 155 is based on his/her assumptions of how wars are or should be fought, and on the assumption that Ukraine has unlimited support from NATO that is not based on any conditions that Ukraine has to meet.
Alek-A should have been challenged to justify the assumption that Ukraine does have unlimited support from NATO and other allied countries in the form of weapons, military vehicles, armed assistance and advice from NATO officers and soldiers, and humanitarian aid in the form of field hospitals (from MSF perhaps) and other forms of back-up. We may well ask if this unlimited support is present in Ukraine or at least forthcoming. Western news media would have been blaring out loudly and forever about all the support Ukraine is receiving. Instead we hear that eastern European NATO members have all but exhausted their supplies, that German military assistance and the performance of Leopard tanks in the field have been woeful, that Russians have been capturing or destroying German and American tanks, and that NATO states cannot keep up with the manufacture and supply of ammunition and weapons the Ukrainians need.
Wars are not always in an active phase and there will be periods – even long periods (as in, the eight-year period from 2014 to 2022 when Ukraine was walloping people in the breakaway Donbass areas of Donetsk and Lugansk oblasts) – where armies are not in direct combat, but rather, there are skirmishes or guerrilla-type fights between opposed units, or repressive measures (such as targeted assassinations) of the sort Israel uses against Palestinians.
The conflict is being conducted mainly in Ukrainian and former Ukrainian territory itself. Unless and until the conflict spills over into areas of Russia with highly populated cities and towns, I do not see that the conflict is affecting Russia much or is straining the state to breakdown. (In what way? Only 10% of Wagner soldiers, none of them military commanders, incidentally, supported Prigozhin and were prepared to march with him.) And Putin was not the one who negotiated directly with Prigozhin – it was Belarus President Lukashenka who read the riot act to Prigozhin.
Alek_A is no more privy than we are to how the Russian military conducts its campaigns or to the plans the Kremlin has made to carry out its Special Military Operation. That the Kremlin is carrying out the SMO in a way that minimises the damage and costs to the Russian people, and at the same time keeps the conflict limited (mostly) to Ukrainian territory, suggests the Russian government is doing something right and has the Russian economy balanced between maintaining military production and keeping civilians secure without forcing people to make major sacrifices, of the kind people in western Europe are being asked or forced to make.

Posted by: Refinnejenna | Jun 28 2023 23:32 utc | 209

@ dh | Jun 28 2023 23:29 utc | 210
lol… you are a real trooper dh! and a brit no less… transfer of the empire and all that rot.. long live the british, er american empire..

Posted by: james | Jun 28 2023 23:33 utc | 210

(4) The whole “coup” thing was an operation to flush out a small fifth column that has infiltrated the Wagner Group (to Prigo’s shame) and, perhaps, the Russian Military as well. Prigo is now in Belarus and an unknown number of fifth column actors are in jail and remain anonymous while being interrogated.
Posted by: Ed | Jun 28 2023 23:15 utc | 204
————————————————–
Let me clarify my position on this issue as my comment @209 may conflict. I support this position, but I am not wedded to it. I think RSH makes some very good points that must also be considered.
Unlike myself, Richard, Karlof1, and “b” have access to a broad range of information and language skills as well.
I just add the pro and cons, disregard the trolls, and come up with a point of view.

Posted by: Ed | Jun 28 2023 23:36 utc | 211

@ Refinnejenna | Jun 28 2023 23:32 utc | 211
let me try to make myself clear – not an easy task as i am too verbose when i try… i am a strong supporter of russia here.. i truly believe the west – nato and friends – are in the wrong here.. and i believe it was the usa-nato and friends that have brought this on themselves… it is a proxy war and it is being played out in ukraine.. i don’t care how the western msm spins it.. this is my take watching history unfold in this general area for at least the last 10 years..
that said, i sense some fragility in the russian sphere, and this prigozhin escapade is an example of this..i don’t know what happened here, but i trust putins steady leadership was able to navigate this in a positive way.. and yet- putin will not be around for forever.. at the same time i don’t see the west backing off.. all i see is a continued ramping up of hostilities.. and i agree with others that the west is completely negotiation incapable – the negotiators nightmare article from a few days ago perfectly sums it up…
so, where is the off ramp in all of this? when does the murder and mayhem end? how much higher up the escalatory scale do we have to go here?
i have always thought slow and easy is the best way here, but this prigozhin thing kind of freaked me out.. i am speaking honestly and to the best of my abilities… yes – we can’t know and alek_a can’t know.. as i recall alek is a poster from before who lives in russia, but i might be mistaken on this surmising on my part.. reading people from russia who live inside russia, still doesn’t give me a good grounding in the nature of russia.. i pray russia will stay strong and stand tall in all this, but i am capable of doubt too.. thanks for your post/s..

Posted by: james | Jun 28 2023 23:42 utc | 212

“You (Russia) cant keep this going for a long time, unlike the Ukrainians that have unlimited support which can. Time is not on Russia’s side.’
Punch line to a joke? Ukraine has it’s head in a bucket of water.
To Priggy’s Carnival. At least the citizens of Moscow didn’t have to endure the unendurable of having horns honking and Trudeau calling them bad names.

Posted by: kupkee | Jun 28 2023 23:46 utc | 213

Karlof1 @172
You are among the wiser heads who lean toward the simpler explanation, which I find at least as plausible as my own. Perhaps I find myself persisting in this because the simpler explanation leaves me thinking that the Kremlin could then be faulted for not handling this individual issue far earlier and (therefore) better. It just runs counter to the impression I have (and am perhaps too attached to) of extremely high competence on the Stavka’s part.
Be it through excess of loyalty on Putin’s part or excess of risk aversion this came within a whisker of becoming a very dangerous mess at a very bad time.
If for example, UKR had fared better and RuAF had not performed so spectacularly during The Offensive (TM), this persistent theme of RF military underperformance –which I consider well wide of the mark–might have gotten a noxious second wind.
Russia’s support in the RoW depends to a significant if as yet unmeasured degree on the perception that Russia is besting NATO and the DragonBear is the winning side. Certain of the smaller countries are still no doubt feeling vulnerable.
Anyway, it’s happened, it could have been worse, and RF seems to have come out of it reasonably well.

Posted by: Paul Damascene | Jun 28 2023 23:49 utc | 214

Spent Fuelrod @ 7:
I’ve heard plenty of South African accents over the past 30 years and the fellow speaking in the video does sound South African. Whether his voice is actually originally part of the video, or a soundtrack with his voice was added later might be the question.
I would not be surprised if South African soldiers are fighting as part of a combined US-led force that includes British, Canadian, Australian and New Zealand fighters, and fighters from other NATO states. Western armed forces ceased being separate armed forces during the long war in Afghanistan. That the soldiers in the video have haircuts and tattoos suggesting the soldiers are of British and American origins perhaps should not surprise us at all.

Posted by: Refinnejenna | Jun 28 2023 23:52 utc | 215

James @214
I’d concur with much of what you’ve expressed in your post.
Russia had seemed so solid to this point, I had been thinking that a slow grind for at least another year, as the wheels started to wobble on the NATO clown car, might still be the best strategy.
I think this Prigozhin affair will bring the RF strategic brain trust to think hard about pace. On the one hand, the Priggy face-plant may take some of the wind out of the hardliners’ sails, but no less concerning is the NPP disaster threat. Although all the focus is on the ZNPP, understandably, Ukraine is actually already in a position to wire the NPP near Odessa to blow if the Russians approach.
Not sure how much speed helps with that now, but there will be some who’ll say that had RF gone full bore for war from the outset, this risk would not (likely) have existed.

Posted by: Paul Damascene | Jun 28 2023 23:56 utc | 216

There’s a claim of 15K mercenaries? Does this Kramatorsk incident suggest they are poorly led such that they meet together en masse and post on social media?
Are they adventurers taking ($) Ukraine and NATO for a ride? This has come up before and really is nothing more than behavior expected from mercenaries. Fight for money is not the same as Azov fanatics.

Posted by: Eighthman | Jun 29 2023 0:01 utc | 217

ol… you are a real trooper dh! and a brit no less… transfer of the empire and all that rot.. long live the british, er american empire..
Posted by: james | Jun 28 2023 23:33 utc | 212
Brit? I don’t know about that. French father, Scottish mother. I did grow up in Albion and went to school there for a while. Glad to get out (but I kept a passport). I live mostly in Spain or Central America. No interest in empire but history fascinates me.

Posted by: dh | Jun 29 2023 0:04 utc | 218

@ Paul Damascene | Jun 28 2023 23:56 utc | 218
thanks paul.. i always look for your posts and find your commentary steady, thoughful and always relevant and on target.. i can’t always say the same for myself, as i tend to blurt out one liners a bit too much sometimes.. the past few days i have had a hard time keeping my mouth shut and he generally gets me in trouble.. back to your point – i also an unsure how changing the pace will make much difference here, and yet i would hate like hell to see another event like this prigozhan thing, and really hope this is just a one off… the whole thing has been questioning how clearly i see things here.. i knew he was a loose cannon, and i love the idea that this was all staged – which it might have been – but i can’t tell at this point.. and another part of me thinks he was trying to save his ass and put all of russia on the line.. in that regard my earlier comment that he reminds me of trump still holds true, not that this matters much.. hopefully no more jack in the boxes jump out..

Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 0:05 utc | 219

@ dh | Jun 29 2023 0:04 utc | 220
i was mostly joking with you in that comment, but i did seem to recall you lived in the uk.. how much time to you spend on an actual yactt? enjoy the sunshine… i have probably told you this before – my ancestors on my dad’s side were kicked off the highlands in the highland clearances back in the 1700’s and came to canada in 1796…

Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 0:07 utc | 220

https://awfulavalanche.wordpress.com/2023/06/28/ukraine-war-day-490-batka-builds-an-army-corpus-delicti/
The whole of Wagner in Russia amounts to around 25000-33000, and at best 8000 of them participated in the Prigoputsch. Of these only at most 2000 took part in the March On Moscow. Since Wagner in Russia is supposed to be integrated into the army, where will Lukashenko get 24000 of them out of 8000, or even 2000?
And you can be certain that these camps didn’t come up overnight. They were prepared well in advance. Only the announcement was made now.
Is Wagner being shifted almost in toto to Belarus under the cover story of the Prigoputsch?
Curiouser and curiouser, said Alice to herself!

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Jun 29 2023 0:10 utc | 221

Putin reigned in and shut down some of the most flagrant excesses of the Russian oligarchy, but he is their representative and came into power and consolidated it with its support.

Posted by: sumwunyumaynotno | Jun 29 2023 0:13 utc | 222

paul d
some excellent posts.

Posted by: watcher | Jun 29 2023 0:13 utc | 223

Metlin@192….kinda makes sense, they are getting boned up the ass.
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Jun 29 2023 0:15 utc | 224

The following is pure speculation on my part……
I wondered for months why Prigozhin published video diatribes.
I remind one and all that he is not a military man, and does not have that training, or mind set.
I noticed that as time went on, they became ever more extreme….
I speculate that the losses of his men finally got to him… at a personal level…
Perhaps he lost one or more very good friends during the Artemivsk campaign, which went on for ~ 8 months….
The video with him showing the bodies of his dead fits this….
INDY

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Jun 29 2023 0:16 utc | 225

https://t.me/myLordBebo/1628
Rifle Throwing, new sport in the Nazistani Olympics.

Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | Jun 29 2023 0:20 utc | 226

Putin reigned in and shut down some of the most flagrant excesses of the Russian oligarchy, but he is their representative and came into power and consolidated it with its support.
Posted by: sumwunyumaynotno | Jun 29 2023 0:13 utc | 224
but how much does he still depend on it, and are there splits omong the Russian oligarchs? internal conditions in Russia are very murky to me.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Jun 29 2023 0:21 utc | 227

Concerning Kramatorsk.
People who go to a war yet expect not to die, and those who want their money.
Then they —together with other nazis— are attacked, killed, and lionized by liars who pretend they don’t see the obvious and who like to believe that no one else will either.
Hard to care less.
These are the people who kill themselves when/if they get home. Understandably.
Don’t get me wrong I’m not saying I’m any better no matter how different or not I might be; such uninteresting judgement is not the point I’m making and all of the nazis could have been more or less wonderful people if living in a completely different context.
The derision is for the laughable attempt at deception and the utter denial of the sordid reality by the nazi propagandists.

Posted by: Sunny Runny Burger | Jun 29 2023 0:22 utc | 228

to expand on that, the easiest road for Putin i would assume would have been to continue to support oligarchs in looting russia, then he really would be one of the richest men in the world. but at some point he sharply diverged from the Yeltsin road.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Jun 29 2023 0:24 utc | 229

Hate to harp on the issue, but at least the concern trolls appear to have lost interest (or clocked out) for the time being.
Sorry I forgot who said it, but I agree that the video linked by james (the one that’s been circulating around purporting to show the crashed Alligator helicopter) is pegging my Fake-Dar really hard at the moment. Indeed, the firefighters not only move around stiffly and look back at the camera, but there is clearly nothing even on fire or smoking. The vapor rising from the foam is simply foam vapor, not smoke. I mean seriously, if that’s the best evidence available for the helicopter shoot-downs (the other being the still pic of the helo sitting upright on its skids while on fire) then I call bullshit. Again, IF Wagner destroyed any helicopters then they were on the ground at their bases. I guess there is the footage of a similar Ka-52 using its flares and exceptional mobility (with the dual prop system) to dodge SAMs, but it wasn’t shot down.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 0:28 utc | 230

i was mostly joking with you in that comment, but i did seem to recall you lived in the uk.. how much time to you spend on an actual yactt? enjoy the sunshine… i have probably told you this before – my ancestors on my dad’s side were kicked off the highlands in the highland clearances back in the 1700’s and came to canada in 1796…
Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 0:07 utc | 222
Well I was just kidding about the yacht but I have done some sailing in the Caribbean and met some wealthy people. I personally was not responsible for the highland clearances (before my time) but I understand it was mostly Scottish landlords who were doing the clearing.

Posted by: dh | Jun 29 2023 0:29 utc | 231

Why would MOD be monitoring Wagner mutiny mm arch with human piloted very expensive attack and sigint copters and not cheap drones.
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 28 2023 18:27 utc | 58
________________________
I agree. Also it is weird that the only casualties were helicopter pilots, and mostly non-attack EW copters at that (and one plane, ditto).
So here’s my take: the copters were actually shot down at the southern “grand offensive” theater, by AFU. Remember how they ambushed a strike force of RF aircraft that was shooting standoff missiles over the northern border? A big face-loss for the Russians. Now they did the same trick on some helis that were attacking Ukie armor at the offensive. Another propaganda win for the AFU, except that. . .
The Russkies took photos of these downed aircraft and claimed that it was Wagner that shot them down, in another location. By doing that, they (1) Voided the Ukie propaganda win. (2) Made the Wagner putsch look more serious, with actual shots fired and casualties, a kick the dog moment.
That’s how Putin is able to claim, truthfully, that these pilots died in combat, heroes of the fatherland. And at the same time present the impression that the Wagner mutiny was for real, and deadly. A good one, though still a pity for the pilots.

Posted by: BearN | Jun 29 2023 0:36 utc | 232

In following up on my earlier observation WRT Prigozhin’s suicide insurrection….
I believe he was “Acting Out” in typical juvenile fashion, to gain attention,
BECAUSE…..
At 60 years of age…. being an alpha male….. he could not find the tears…. means….
To express his grief….
Furthermore….
The anger he expressed against Shiogu/Gerasimov… was typical mis-placed anger…
At those who decided over all strategy….
Thus forced his unit into the Artemivsk battle……
To gain time….
To reorganize MoD / RuAf…
BECAUSE…..
He thinks they don’t/didn’t care….
INDY

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Jun 29 2023 0:37 utc | 233

Posted by: james | Jun 28 2023 21:34 utc | 171
“but i will be the first to admit i have it wrong..”
Might as well do it now, then, because you are. 🙂
More importantly, what the hell is the connection between a PR stunt by a nutcase and the progress of the war? I get your point that “anything can happen”. There’s a principle that says when doing something risky, do it fast – don’t give Murphy time to ruin it. Because as Richard Marcinko says, Murphy is ALWAYS present.
But the fact remains that NATO can not keep supplying unlimited weapons and ammunition – certainly not enough to outmatch Russia, which is producing a couple million artillery shells a year compared to vastly less in the West not to mention 1,000 new and upgraded tanks whereas the West is scraping to find a 100 old crap at a time. Nor can Ukraine keep throwing endless numbers of civilians into the fray, especially when they’re basically useless.
The sole reasons this war has progressed as slowly as it has I’ve stated before:
1) Putin needs to manage reactions from the Russian economy, the Russian electorate, NATO, and the RoW.
2) The MoD wants to manage casualties and hold back a reserve in case the management of NATO doesn’t work.
3) There are eight years of fortifications that the Russian military has to get through, with the concomitant casualties, which is why the Chechens took Mariupol and Wagner took Bahkmut and the Donbass militias have been fighting in Donbass more than the regular army.
4) There is is an 800-mile front which necessitates spreading one’s forces all over hell – while simultaneously trying to do 2) above.
5) As others have suggested, this is a deliberate plan to drain NATO as well as Ukraine.
Against these perfectly valid reasons, you’re going to suggest that Russia throw all that over and just crush Ukraine, damn the casualties and reactions.
Finally, let me point out that, as Martyanov and others have said repeatedly, the Russian MoD doesn’t want to do that – and they are the ones with the operational plan, the inventory they have to work with, and the political timetable.
People who question that based on essentially nothing but “shit might happen” don’t understand that shit DOES happen in war – and the quality of the participants depends on how they handle it.
So far, Russia has handled everything more or less correctly – including Prigozhin’s stunt. Judging it from a western view based on western reactions to the stunt isn’t valid. But it seems like everyone likes to get up in arms every time there is some incident that seems to damage the PR front in Russia or which demonstrates that someone in Russia made a mistake which has zero effect on the war progress.
If you were being told about the Battle of the Bulge in WWII at the time, would you have said, “The US needs to hurry up and finish the war?” When the US didn’t have any of the constraints Russia is under, that might have been applicable. In this war it’s not. The possibility of nuclear war is very real and foremost in Russia’s minds and has a very real impact on the speed at which Russia is operating. Putin and the MoD are not going to let minor setbacks and hypotheticals disrail their plan.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 0:39 utc | 234

Paul Damascene | Jun 28 2023 23:56 utc | 218–
Thanks for your reply. Yes, it’s over and the time to move on has arrived. I just finished with Lavrov’s The Great Game interview which sort of resets the situation for those concerned. I placed one excerpt onto the Week in Review thread, but it’s not the most important part, which comes at the half-way point where the so-called Zelensky Plan is discussed. The excerpt is long, but that can’t be helped, and I consider it a Must Read for it shows that the position of both sides is to achieve an unconditional surrender of the other, although Russia still says it’s willing to negotiate:

Question: Looking at the war in Ukraine and, more broadly, around Ukraine about the world order, I have a question: who is Russia at war with? If you look at the situation in Ukraine, the ground troops are Ukrainian troops, but weapons, means and intelligence (including in direct mode) are increasingly provided by the West. Planning for military operations is carried out by NATO generals and the Joint Chiefs of Staff in Washington. Ensuring Ukrainian military operations, attempts to weaken Russia in obtaining strategic materials or even dual-use materials – this is all carried out by the West. Is it possible to say in this situation that by supporting Ukraine, he is its “patron”? Or do you need to look the facts in the face and say that in fact Russia is at war with NATO, with the “collective West”? Is this a confrontation between Russia and all this, as you said, the “golden billion”, which has turned itself into the Order of the Crusaders?
Sergey Lavrov: Of course, the West is Ukraine’s patron. But Ukraine is his patron in a different sense of the word. It is an instrument of warfare against us. This is not the first time we have paid attention to this. Russian President Vladimir Putin said, assessing the situation on June 24 of this year, that we are confronted by the economic, military and information machine of the entire West. That’s the way it is.
You have listed examples of the fact that without the West, this war would no longer have happened. The goals of the special military operation would have been achieved long ago. Again, I quote EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Josep Borrell. More recently, he frankly and even naively said that if someone wants to end the war, it is very easy to do. You just need to stop supplying weapons to Ukraine and in a maximum of two weeks everything will be over. But do they want such an end to the war? Borrell added that they have no right to allow Ukraine to be defeated. The Russians must tolerate it.
This is a frank confession. And any military expert commenting on this situation now will confirm that this is the case. The West is fighting against the Russian Federation.
There are many other examples, including the status of foreigners on Ukrainian territory. Someone calls them mercenaries. There are suspicions that a number of countries under their guise are already sending their regular military personnel there. Instructors, who are definitely career military personnel, work in Ukraine. Yes, apparently, not on the line of contact. But there is a huge number of specialists and instructors working there. I remember how during the Maidan (which began in 2013 and ended with a coup d’état), even then representatives of the CIA and other special services of the United States occupied an entire floor in the Security Service of Ukraine. There is no doubt about it. Everything that they are trying to pronounce as “spells” (as NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg likes to repeat: NATO is not at war against the Russian Federation) all sounds ridiculous and pathetic. To put it mildly: adults tell outright lies. But it is all the more important to uphold justice.
I mentioned the goals of the special military operation set by President Vladimir Putin. One of them, in addition to demilitarization, is the denazification of Ukraine. We are at war in Ukraine with the West and with Nazism, which has revived in this country and is actively cultivated by our Western colleagues.
Take, for example, their approach to negotiations. They repeat every time this topic comes up that there is only one basis for negotiations – the “formula of Vladimir Zelensky” (10 points). Recently, the West has been trying in every possible way to persuade the leading developing countries, the countries of the Global South, to support this formula. A meeting was recently held in Copenhagen. It seemed to be secretive, but the information still leaked. We asked our colleagues who were represented there what the West, together with the Ukrainians, wanted to do there, inviting the leading countries of the World Majority to it.
The only basis of Vladimir Zelensky’s formula is the position of the West. The President of Ukraine and his entire administration say that there can be no other basis at all. If we remove all sorts of “vignettes” such as environmental, food and nuclear security, it lies in the fact that Russia withdraws from all territories as of 1991, the Russian leadership is placed under a special (or already existing) tribunal, our country pays reparations on the basis of an invoice that will be presented to it, and only after that a peace treaty is concluded.
At the same time, the West says that this is the only way out of this situation, Ukraine defends European and Western civilizational values in this war. This is particularly emphasised by EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy Josep Borrell, NATO Secretary General Jens Stoltenberg, President of the European Commission Ursula von der Leyen and other Western politicians.
No one doubts that the Ukrainian regime is a Nazi regime. I will not bother myself and your viewers with examples. They are well known. This regime is racist in connection with the prohibition of the Russian language everywhere, attempts to physically abuse those who dare to violate the law that you can only speak Ukrainian. This means that Europe associates itself with racism, Russophobia and Nazism, since it claims that it is the Kiev regime that professes European values. If so, then all the more we have no other choice but to prevent another revival of Nazism right on our borders.
Question: If I understand Vladimir Zelensky’s position correctly, all the conditions you mentioned are not even conditions for concluding an agreement, but only for starting negotiations. That is, if I understood his position correctly, then this means that Russia must completely capitulate, and after that it will be possible to talk. But it is not clear with whom.
Sergey Lavrov: That’s what I said. Before the start of negotiations. The list of preconditions includes withdrawal to the 1991 borders, then criminal prosecution, reparations, and only then we sit down at the negotiating table.
Question: Do you know of any serious power that could accept such conditions without it being completely defeated on the battlefield?
Sergey Lavrov: I don’t know of any. But there are powers that are considered serious by everyone and support this logic. I am referring to all those who have put their entire reputation and political future on Vladimir Zelensky. The West will not be able to “crawl away” from this absolutely dead-end position without losing face. They know, however, how to “lose face” so that they present to the public as if they had acquired it.

To recap, NATO is at war with Russia using Ukraine as its primary weapon. The Outlaw US Empire commands NATO and appears that once it exhausts its Ukrainian weapon it will use another European nation or group of nations to cause Russia to totally capitulate. IMO, no other solution is acceptable to those presently running the Empire. A complete translation is available at my VK here.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2023 0:39 utc | 235

@ Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 0:28 utc | 232
i pulled that off intel slava.. it is still on their.. if i knew how to talk to these folks on telegram, i would ask him directly.. i don’t think he is a bullshit artist, but i hear what you and richard are saying and acknowledge it could all be bullshit.. the poster s doesn’t seem to think so, but i do believe people are easily conned either way… i really don’t know what the deal is over all of this.. i plead ignorance, lol.. if more info comes available – i might take a position, but at present i have no position on it all..
@ dh | Jun 29 2023 0:29 utc | 233
thanks… i think it was an extension of the enclosure laws that got put in place in the 15 or 16oo’s in britian.. bevin would be able to say with more authority.. i read eric richards book on the highland clearances a few years ago.. good book that tries to take a neutral view on it all..

Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 0:43 utc | 236

Hard to believe, considering the source, but Ukraine claims General Surovikin was arrested. I don’t believe it until I see sources on MOA substantiate this…
https://news.yahoo.com/russian-general-surovikin-arrested-wagner-203234652.html?fr=sycsrp_catchall

Posted by: Ramsey Glissadevil | Jun 29 2023 0:50 utc | 237

Question: If I understand Vladimir Zelensky’s position correctly, all the conditions you mentioned are not even conditions for concluding an agreement, but only for starting negotiations. That is, if I understood his position correctly, then this means that Russia must completely capitulate, and after that it will be possible to talk. But it is not clear with whom.
Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2023 0:39 utc | 237
Thanks for posting that.

Posted by: Bemildred | Jun 29 2023 0:52 utc | 238

@ Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 0:39 utc | 236
richard.. i respect your viewpoint and appreciate it too.. i have said this consistently here at moa.. and that hasn’t changed.. regarding the supply chain, i listened to jacques baud a few weeks ago saying the same thing you are saying here… here is the video which can be translated into english.. Jacques Baud : “Chine-Russie, le nouvel Axe du Mal”
i plead guilty to having doubts, lol.. this prigozhin event doesn’t add up, but i hear what you are saying and will continue to express my doubts if i have them.. thanks for your posts… and yes – hopefully i am wrong to question any of this, but i do from time to time..

Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 0:53 utc | 239

Dr. George W Oprisko | Jun 29 2023 0:37 utc | 235–
I too share your analysis of Prigozhin’s mental state which became even more complicated when the info surfaced that he’d provided info to the enemy. IMO, that served to further increase his inner rage. The combat was brutal (some have suggested he escalated the tempo himself) as the meat grinder was also fed by Wagner. Then, it’s mission accomplished as he was reaching the edge of his rope because he was aware of plans to nationalize his pride and joy, he felt betrayed that he wasn’t at all being properly rewarded, but rather being disciplined for no reason he could fathom.
To try and posit that he was made into a double agent and the entire revolt was theatre when none was needed from Russia’s POV just doesn’t make sense no matter how sexy that idea might appear.
Putin did what he could to quickly right the situation as did Lukashenko. The gossip will continue for the rest of the year no doubt. But Russia must get back to the very serious task at hand. And as Lavrov stated in the excerpt I provided above, the situation for Russia is indeed dire–Russia MUST win decisively and utterly, shattering NATO and splintering the EU so they can no longer generate a threat to Russia’s security.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2023 0:57 utc | 240

james – I’m actually with you in terms of the big picture regarding the planes and helicopters. I have no effin’ idea what really happened. I’m sure you caught the, ahem, lively and spirited debate I had with a few ‘paracaidistas’ the other day; the one that degenerated into name calling. But my participation in that kerfuffle – and the number of comments/replies I posted – was entirely due to being attacked from multiple angles and by the aforementioned ‘parachutists’ (or barfleas) who descended on MoA to attack my initially simply stated theory on the planes and pilot/crew deaths. IOW, I devoted way more effort to that than I otherwise would have were it not for all the strange new names attempting to drag me and my theory through the mud. My speculation on this is almost entirely limited to the part about the aircraft.
Posted by: BearN | Jun 29 2023 0:36 utc | 234
Now that’s a new one. I’ve been reading about this for days and that’s the first time I’ve seen someone make that suggestion. And I respectfully disagree, even though you do take care of the loose ends pretty logically and consistently. It’s just that I don’t think there were any helicopters shot down at all until I see better video evidence or read memorials to the actual pilots/crew that were lost (other than the Il-22). I leave open the possibility that Wagner destroyed some idle helicopters sitting on their launch/landing pads – or maybe even that they shot one down and the crew ejected (those are among, if not the only helos in the world with ejection capability). But then, where’s the evidence? Anecdotal or otherwise. People can put anything they want in print on the Internet. They can “back it up” with official sounding terminology and cite real aircraft serial numbers. That doesn’t mean it actually happened. I’ve been fooled many times before in the past and for that reason I’m extra skeptical when it comes to outlandish sounding claims. That Wagner would allegedly be able to shoot down that many aircraft, kill that many pilots and crew and be allowed to skate completely scot free (for the moment at least) is just not believable. For that reason, I am way more open to your theory about the UAF than I am the “official” story, but I am having a hard time wrapping my head around Russia for the SECOND TIME losing that many aircraft in a single day at the hands of a weakened, demoralized, depleted Ukrainian military.
I guess I’m back to what I said in reply to james above. I really just don’t know, but my BS meter is pegged all the way to the right until better evidence is available.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 0:58 utc | 241

Posted by: Ramsey Glissadevil | Jun 29 2023 0:50 utc | 239
It was addressed earlier in this thread. https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6070264?from=top_main_5

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 0:58 utc | 242

According to the Moscow Times, Surovikin has been arrested. I came on here to see how MoA was spinning this latest disaster, but apparently you don’t even know about it.

Posted by: Muthaucker | Jun 29 2023 0:58 utc | 243

I just posted this at Larry’s blog in response to the Gaius Baltar that he posted over there…

I call bullshit on the whole theory.
As Big Serge said, this was a contract dispute using tanks.
Prigozhin was making money off Wagner and his side deals based on Wagner activities in the rest of the world.
Then Wagner was hauled in to Ukraine. Fine, Prigozhin, it will be a short war, I’ll make money here, then we can go back to doing business elsewhere. I can recruit some more guys from prison with MoD blessing and build up my private army.
Then the war lasted 18 MONTHS! And many of his troops ended up dead.
So he starts bitching about the war is being lost because it’s not going fast enough and everyone in the MoD is incompetent.
So now the MoD sees that Wagner is the best urban assault force in the world and they decide to get rid of the front man and incorporate Wagner into the regular army.
Prigozhin sees his meal ticket being stripped from him. So he tries one last desperate ploy to pressure his occasional acquaintance Putin to lean on Shoigu and let Prigozhin keep being the front man.
He fails. That’s it. It’s as simple as that.
There is no Western intel involvement or Ukrainian double-dealing like Martyanov says – unless Prigozhin was acting like a double when he gave them information. Remember Prigozhin is under the thumb of the GRU and SVR. They would know who he is, what he might do, and would keep him under observation and ignore anything he does that doesn’t inconvenience them, like making money on the side in his other businesses based on Wagner activity elsewhere. But if he turned, they would clamp down and make him a double.
All these “plausible” conspiracy theories are bullshit. Based on Prigozhin’s nature as a former (and present) criminal, his activities while being the Wagner front man, his actions in Ukraine and the results being the MoD stripping him of his position, the only probable explanation for the “stunt” is as I’ve averred above.
There may be unanswered questions about why he got as far as he did with his stunt, why Putin reacted the way he did and other extraneous matters. All those things will be explained eventually (or not) and do not constitute enough “connect-the-dots” to provide any realistic theories compared to what we actually know.
I think Larry and others like Macgregor have massively misread this whole affair based on their own biases – ex-Cia Larry for the CIA to be involved, and “Russia needs a big offensive” Macgregor on believing Prigozhin’s bullshit about the pace of the war as his motivation.
They’re wrong. The explanation is: a contract negotiation with tanks.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:00 utc | 244

Posted by: Blissex | Jun 28 2023 22:12 utc | 182
Nice catch on the Orwell quote. During this war, we should engrave it on our foreheads.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:00 utc | 245

“thanks… i think it was an extension of the enclosure laws that got put in place in the 15 or 16oo’s in britian.. bevin would be able to say with more authority.. i read eric richards book on the highland clearances a few years ago.. good book that tries to take a neutral view on it all..
Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 0:43 utc | 238”
Yes that’s right about the Enclosure Laws. It was all economic basically. Who could use the land most efficiently. Lot of injustice.

Posted by: dh | Jun 29 2023 1:02 utc | 246

Posted by: Martina | Jun 28 2023 22:38 utc | 191
Exactly. Concisely said and likely correct.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:03 utc | 247

Posted by: sumwunyumaynotno | Jun 29 2023 0:13 utc | 224
“Putin reigned in and shut down some of the most flagrant excesses of the Russian oligarchy, but he is their representative and came into power and consolidated it with its support.”
It’s been a while since he did that. Now the oligarchs are ‘his’ oligarchs and he hasn’t done much lately about it – in my opinion.

Posted by: Tim2 | Jun 29 2023 1:03 utc | 248

Some videos for today.
Arseniy Yatsenyuk admits that the Ukraine is ruled by a Nazi regime:
https://odysee.com/@Overthrown:6/arseniyyatsenyuk-epiphany:9
Russian airborne forces’ howitzer destroys enemy armored vehicle and fortified position near Artemovsk:
https://rutube.ru/video/e3a5fc56fa19ce951b5ab5bc00df3fbc/
Russian attack helicopters destroy enemy armored vehicles on the southern DPR front:
https://rutube.ru/video/0603c44a51514ff74c2133a728805630/
Russian howitzer opens fire on the enemy:
https://odysee.com/@RT:fd/D-20_280623:7

Posted by: Nate | Jun 29 2023 1:04 utc | 249

Posted by: Muthaucker | Jun 29 2023 0:58 utc | 245
Moscow Times. LOL. Tell us, you do know who runs that site and from where, correct? For the third or fourth time in this thread: https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/6070264?from=top_main_5
_______________________________________________________________________________________
I know RSH has blocked me, but I do agree with his take on NATO/CIA involvement. I don’t buy it.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 1:04 utc | 250

Posted by: Muthaucker | Jun 29 2023 0:58 utc | 245
“According to the Moscow Times, Surovikin has been arrested. I came on here to see how MoA was spinning this latest disaster, but apparently you don’t even know about it.”
It needs to be reported a little more widely by other sources as the Moscow Times isn’t, to be believable. Though I have seen Russian telegram channels also say that.

Posted by: Tim2 | Jun 29 2023 1:05 utc | 251

Posted by: Figleaf23 | Jun 28 2023 22:49 utc | 193
Bullshit. Once again, there is ZERO evidence that ANY portion of Wagner is actually going to Belarus. Lukashenko has just offered those who were with Prigozhin that they can come.
Since the possibility has been raised that Prigozhin lied to his own men about what they went to Russia for, and since we know from Russian statements that many of them quit the stunt on their own accord, and since latest counts indicate Prigozhin had at most 2,000+ fighters in Russia, this means almost none of Wagner is going Belarus, IF ANY.
People need to stop posting this inane bullshit.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:06 utc | 252

Colonel General Andrei Yudin denied the information that he, along with Colonel General – Commander of the United Forces – Sergey Surovikin, is in a pre-trial detention center in Moscow’s Lefortovo. He told about it to the correspondent of URA.RU.
“I am on vacation. At home,” Andrey Yudin said.
Earlier, military commissar Vladimir Romanov spread information that Surovikin was allegedly in a pre-trial detention center in Moscow’s Lefortovo. In his telegram channel, the military commissar reported that Surovikin was “taken away” on June 25, 2023. Later, information appeared in telegram channels that Yudin was also allegedly placed in a pre-trial detention center.
Press Secretary of the President of the Russian Federation Dmitry Peskov stated that Surovikin could not have known about the upcoming rebellion of businessman Yevgeny Prigozhin, and called such statements speculation. Telegram channel “NARRATIVES” clarified that Surovikin is at work on June 28.

https://ura.news/news/1052661997

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 1:07 utc | 253

Patroklos blows men | Jun 28 2023 23:09 utc | 201
Why don’t you blow me? While you’re at it, welcome to my block.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:09 utc | 254

Biden absent-mindedly says “Putin is clearly losing the war in Iraq”.
Zakharova responds:
“Did he really mean Iraq? Or could he have meant Vietnam?” — both of which were *US* military failures. Lmao.
Oh Maria! You’ve done it again! Who else could deliver such pointed, witty, (and sexy) barbs!!!
As well as tragedy, this war produces some of the best comedy in a long time.

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jun 29 2023 1:09 utc | 255

Someone’s looking to be banned again…

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 1:09 utc | 256

last post tonight, lol… i have a rehearsal in 1 1/2 hours..
thanks tom.. we are in the same boat on that..
@ Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:00 utc
i like your summary and think it is pretty good..
@ dh | Jun 29 2023 1:02 utc | 248
i guess that is when the whole private ownership of land kicked in… it all got taken over by the lawyers… i hate it when that happens..

Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 1:09 utc | 257

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 0:39 utc | 236
“People who question that based on essentially nothing but “shit might happen” don’t understand that shit DOES happen in war – and the quality of the participants depends on how they handle it.”
Yup, stuff continues to happen like the West continues to send arms and ammunition that will continue to kill Russians and destroy Russian infrastructure. If that is the plan, it doesn’t seem like a very good plan.

Posted by: Tim2 | Jun 29 2023 1:12 utc | 258

Posted by: Ed | Jun 28 2023 23:15 utc | 204
What the hell is a “fifth column” going to do inside Wagner?
Look, you can make up conspiracies all day long. Here’s another one: Prigozhin was a grey alien sent by the UFOs to disrupt the SMO because it was causing depleted uranium to be used in Ukraine which would damage the environment – which is why the UFOs are here, to save Earth’s environment…somehow…
All this shit does is spread more bullshit and make everyone confused and unable to see anything clearly.
Which I suspect is the purpose.
Either that or these people are just biased (like Johnson and Macgregor) or are just morons.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:13 utc | 259

“i guess that is when the whole private ownership of land kicked in… it all got taken over by the lawyers… i hate it when that happens..”
Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 1:09 utc | 259
I think private citizens can still own land in Canada. Until they stop paying taxes.

Posted by: dh | Jun 29 2023 1:13 utc | 260

Wagner matter was very heavily relied upon by NATO to create discord. Thankfully it didn’t and NATO is still reeling under massive disappointment.
NATO summit that decide the fate of Sweden and Ukraine is just two weeks away. Unless Ukraine shows some gains against Russia NATO will not even consider Ukraine.
This means Ukraine will launch many violent attacks on Russian positions in the coming 2 weeks. Forewarned is forearmed.
Russia must attack Ukraine’s energy and petroleum infrastructure once again to stop any Ukrainian adventure.
Wagner chief in Belarus is a masterstroke just ahead of planned Russian tactical nuclear weapons deployment in Belarus. NATO infiltration agents will try to disrupt it. Wagner is best suited to neutralize them.

Posted by: Jason | Jun 29 2023 1:16 utc | 261

@ dh | Jun 29 2023 1:13 utc | 262
yes they can and it has turned into a speculative frenzy which has knocked out a few generations of younger people from ever owning a house… speculation is king and owning a house is now not a reality.. i am not down with it.. we’re off topic, so last comment from me on this!

Posted by: james | Jun 29 2023 1:16 utc | 262

Ed | Jun 28 2023 23:25 utc | 209
If you’d read my fucking posts, you’d know I already did.
Since you’re contributing to the bullshit with more bullshit theories, welcome to my block.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:16 utc | 263

Posted by: Refinnejenna | Jun 28 2023 23:32 utc | 211
“Alek-A should have been challenged to justify the assumption that Ukraine does have unlimited support from NATO”
I did challenge him.
People need to read the responses to posts they’re interested in. Three times now people have asked for either my response or someone else’s, which already existed. Simple browser search for the post ID will do that for you.
The rest of your post was excellent.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:21 utc | 264

I know RSH has blocked me, but I do agree with his take on NATO/CIA involvement. I don’t buy it.
Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 1:04 utc | 252

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jun 29 2023 1:21 utc | 265

If I were Lukashenko I’d be very wary of any large contingent of Wagnerites, as these might prove a sort of Trojan Horse, through which Putin takes direct control of Belorussia and turns Lukashenko into more of a puppet or palace prisoner than he may already be, especially if things start heading even further south for Russia in Ukraine than they already and Putin decides to no longer condescend to Lukashenko’s intermediary corruption, in effect reducing Belorussia to a full colony of Russian oligarchism, without the needless “sentimentality” of sharing with local Belorussian intermediaries.

Posted by: Quintillus | Jun 29 2023 1:21 utc | 266

RT posted a time line of what happened.
It was greatly lacking in detail.
Russia makes a mistake by not help public to understand – in the absense of information rumors are becoming more widespread and entrenched. Also he should appear with Shoigu and spell out that he has full support and is not going anywhere. Seems there is a culture of keeping info from the people and so the people fill that gaps with all manner of crazy ideas – culture of kvetching.

Posted by: jared | Jun 29 2023 1:22 utc | 267

Rules of keeping a pet narcissist: Never feed them. It only makes them stronger.
Posted by: The Dolphin | Jun 29 2023 1:21 utc | 267
That’s not needed in my case. He can’t see anything I write. LOL.
What I think is pretty straightforward. Until any evidence comes out – or the Russian state takes action – I don’t see any NATO/CIA connection with Priggo. I can’t necessarily rule out 404, but even that is a stretch.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 1:25 utc | 268

karlof1 | Jun 29 2023 0:57 utc | 242
The Larry Johnson blog narrative that Prigozhin was “turned” by western intel, and that the Weekend at Rostov, March to Moscow was all some spy v spy, double-double cross is hollywood…. Larry should follow his latent desire to be a covert action movie screenwriter.
Why does western media want to insert a “we (cia) wuz there” “we knew, teehee” narrative?
Hubris, arrogance, chauvinism.
No one outside Russia understands Russian internal politics. And because it’s not understood, it’s dismissed as irrelevant.
Only the western perspective and narrative matters.
Some of the jealousies, rivalries and affiliations rubbed raw over weekend extend back a lifetime.
Back to the collapse of the USSR and the havoc and hunger of the 90s.
Just like an outsider can never really understand a family’s dynamics.. no one in the superficial west, especially the super- superficial Biden and UK administrations is going to understand WTF was happening between Putin Prigozhin Shoigu, plus other, unknown and unnamed players in the military and civilian networks.
My read of the U$ reaction in the first hours that this all started (and remember, most @bar were asleep.. literally… it all happened in Moscow time, not US time), initial U$ reaction was confusion and “oh fuck, what’s happening”. As the US came online, especially the Langleywashington time zone… it was possible to detect a “whatever is happening, let’s find a way to exploit it and exacerbate it” thrust… here @bar the trolls arrived. Posting any nonsense at all. They flooded twitter and the Ukrainian telegrams.
Everyone knows the first responders to a crime, cordon off the area to preserve uncontaminated evidence.
Here, the exact opposite happened in the information war zone… the “zone” it got flooded with noise, smoke, bullshit.
Now we’re combing through the debris trying to find the shards of facts… only the inner core of the Russian power elite know what happened…. and they won’t be releasing any info.
Enough Russians know the jackals are at the gate (again) wanting to tear the country apart (again). Putin and his core team are going to deal with this behind “enigmatic” tightly closed doors.
And our western jackal intel agencies, who think they’ve smelt blood, will continue to “flood the zone” with bullshite, misdirection and fabrications.
And closet screenwriters like Larry Johnson can play out their fantasy life on their blogs

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jun 29 2023 1:30 utc | 269

What kind of silly person, broken robot, or “idiot intelligence” translates “нет” as anything else than the extremely recognizable Russian word “njet” (meaning “no”)?
It’s as stupid as thinking that mañana is pronounced manana instead of the correct manjana, or that piñata is pronounced pinata rather than the correct pinjata 😛
And why? Such a weird thing to do or program.
I don’t speak Russian or Spanish (although I wish I could, both) and I don’t have to to know something this simple 🙂

Posted by: Sunny Runny Burger | Jun 29 2023 1:31 utc | 270

The point here is that NATO must see some results from the counteroffensive before the July summit on Vilnius. Thanks to the confusion created by Prig, the Ukies have indeed made some progress.

Posted by: Jonnthan W | Jun 29 2023 1:32 utc | 271

Posted by: james | Jun 28 2023 23:42 utc | 214
“that said, i sense some fragility in the russian sphere”
WTF is “fragility in the russian sphere”?
“all i see is a continued ramping up of hostilities.. and i agree with others that the west is completely negotiation incapable”
Yes, probably most of us do. The question is, as we say in Federal prison: “What are you going to do about it?” – meaning what is the West capable of and what will they do if they are not capable.
“so, where is the off ramp in all of this? when does the murder and mayhem end? how much higher up the escalatory scale do we have to go here?”
That depends on the West, not Russia.
“this prigozhin thing kind of freaked me out..”
Like I said earlier, people take this sort of thing and blow it out of proportion. In general, people need to stop following the “tactical minutia”, as Martyanov says constantly, and more importantly, stop following the famous “24-hour news cycle.”
This Prigozhin stunt may have ripples – most things do. Doesn’t mean anything in the overall context of the last 18 months and likely will not mean anything in the next 18 months. Speculating that it will is premature and useless.
“i am speaking honestly and to the best of my abilities…”
I get that. I’m trying to explain to you how best to deal with this sort of ridiculous situation. Especially since it has happened repeatedly in this war. The Moskva sinks due to a fire and, to quote The Joker, “Well, then everyone loses their minds!” Russia pulls out of Kherson for perfectly good reasons and everyone loses their minds.
The proper response is: get a grip. Go back to the fundamentals. Who has the most capability – Ukraine or Russia? Who has the most capability – NATO or Russia? Who has the best leadership: the West or Russia? Who has the best economy: the West or Russia? Who has the most support of their electorate: the West or Russia?
It’s not like all those questions haven’t been gone over in excruciating detail here, and the inevitable answer to all of them is: Russia.
Doesn’t mean Russia is perfect. Even Martyanov denies that. But “freaking out” over an incident that has no significant repercussions for the overall situation is not appropriate. Get a grip.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:33 utc | 272

“yes they can and it has turned into a speculative frenzy which has knocked out a few generations of younger people from ever owning a house… speculation is king and owning a house is now not a reality.. i am not down with it.. we’re off topic, so last comment from me on this!”
james | Jun 29 2023 1:16 utc | 264
Seems to me high interest rates are the big problem for first time home buyers. What causes that? Inflation. What causes inflation? Don’t blame you for not wanting to think about it. Gives me a headache too.

Posted by: dh | Jun 29 2023 1:37 utc | 273

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | Jun 29 2023 0:16 utc | 227
“I speculate that the losses of his men finally got to him… at a personal level…”
Yeah – at the most personal level – his wallet.
The stunt with the dead Wagner bodies was just another of his mind games. He’s a criminal. He couldn’t care less about those guys – even if some of them might have been ex-convict friends from when he was in prison. What mattered to him was that every dead Wagner was one less in his private army he could skim some money off of from the MoD, and one less that he could deploy (on GRU/SVR orders) in other countries where he ran his side businesses based on Wagner activities.
The current stunt was solely because the MoD was going to take Wagner away from him. HE SAID THAT.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 1:40 utc | 274

This is what I wrote today on The Z Blog, as a follow-up to my posts of the last several days:

I agree with Z-Man today and I will consider this validation of the posts I’ve written over the last couple of days. I don’t always carpet-bomb the internet with my pearls of wisdom, but in this case I think the issue was important enough to warrant a broad casting of bread upon the waters, so I cross-posted the same material to Moon of Alabama, Simplicius, Big Serge, Larry Johnson, and The Duran’s YouTube channel.
I’m still looking for some way to email Alexander Mercouris directly. If anyone knows how to contact him, please let me know or please pass along the posts on my behalf. I would be very grateful.
Now, being a “meta” sort of guy myself, I can’t help but be impressed by some of the metadata that is emerging from this whole incident. I am 100% certain that I’m right about what really happened with Prigozhin—that part was never in doubt. What’s curious is why everybody else is so wrong, because to me the whole thing seems fairly obvious.
We all know what the mainstream media is about. We know that they have their narratives and that they function as a regime mouthpiece, and that they all move in lockstep as if guided by the same inner compass. But this is the first time that I can recall the ALT-MEDIA doing the same thing, all lurching at once towards the same constellation of wrong conclusions, parroting one another’s talking points and analysis and even prose styles, and doing it so quickly that one might be forgiven for wondering if they didn’t have prearranged boilerplate coming out of the teletype.
Scott Ritter has the absolutely moronic idea that this was an honest-to-God coup attempt managed by Western intelligence. Larry Johnson follows on with the same notion and adds even more layers of 5D voodoo to the mix. Big Serge, along with The Duran boys, are content to chalk it all up to Prigozhin’s ego and business interests. This is especially disappointing coming from them, because The Duran more than anyone purports to actually have their finger on the pulse of the Russian street. So far, only the Z-Man has thought this through with any kind of clarity.
The rest of these guys are simply talking their book. This marks a pivotal day in the history of the alt-media, for it is now clear that it is no longer the cutting edge of analysis and has become itself a mature franchise, wedded to the world as it is and highly provincial in its point of view. None of these guys stepped outside their occidental confines, projecting upon Prigozhin a very Western set of possible motives and behaviors. It is obvious now that they are not really capable of doing so, for this would have been a unique opportunity to demonstrate once and for all the conceptual limitations of the Western mainstream. This was the $100 bill on the sidewalk, and they missed it.
From now on, the alt-media has to be regarded as a known quantity with limitations of its own. Just as the Covid debacle was a test of who really understood biology and Western bureaucratic overreach (washing out posers like Steve Sailer), and the Ukraine invasion was a test of who really understood geopolitics and the burgeoning multipolar world, so the Prigozhin Rebellion is a test of who really understands the Russian soul and the behaviors of battle-weary men of action.
The squishy Alt-Right, for the most part, failed that test. It will never be the same again. They could not help but see in Progozhin’s actions some analogy to their own Western clown world, and this makes them unreliable outside that very circumscribed domain.

Posted by: Intelligent Dasein | Jun 29 2023 1:42 utc | 275

Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 1:25 utc | 270
don’t see any NATO/CIA connection with Priggo
Well.. there was that one time….. you know, when he “meddled” in the sacred U$ presidential selection.
U$ intel has been fascinated/obsessed with The Prig for a decade.
They created a whole Larger Than Life persona for him being “Putin’s Chef”, based on one photo.
When Mueller overplayed his cards and decided to prosecute Concord (and Prigozhin), he was checkmated when Concord contested the charges, sent lawyers and demanded discovery.
Mueller had to quickly backpedal and the case languished with delays through the rest of Mueller’s “special inquiry”.
For all the details and minutiae I’ve forgotten… archives at Conservative Treehouse. Sundance is encyclopaedic in all of the Mueller years.
So. Western intel certainly knew of, and had had contact with Prigozhin.
That western intel turned Prigozhin and sent him on this century’s March on Moscow… no.
That’s Langley mischief, and Larry Johnson’s repressed screenwriter fantasies.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jun 29 2023 1:43 utc | 276

Wagner allegedly in Belarus. Denied by Lukashenko. Jury is still out on that too.
https://ura.news/news/1052661975
If it helps, you can say man-yAh-na or pin-yAh-ta. That’s how they’re pronounced in Latin America and Catalonia anyway. Never been to the rest of Spain.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 29 2023 1:46 utc | 277

Scott Ritter’s latest is both clear thinking and scary. Putin doesn’t really want Kharkov and Odessa. The British and US knew and were involved with Prigozhin – hence the quick denials by Biden.
He sees Russia as amping up the war in response but I’m not clear on how that works. Perhaps it relates to the ‘pulling punches’ that some of you might feel Putin has done. Wreck all Ukraine industry maybe? All rail?
The PM of Estonia talks about a ‘surprise’ coming for Ukr. NATO membership so the path to WW3 continues.
The scariest part of his latest is the highly effective fanaticism of Ukraine. There appears to be no end to gathering up Ukr men and sending them to slaughter. This is Russia’s challenge as to how this all ends as ‘to the last Ukrainian’ appears literal.

Posted by: Eighthman | Jun 29 2023 1:46 utc | 278

Posted by: Ed | Jun 28 2023 23:15 utc | 204
What the hell is a “fifth column” going to do inside Wagner?
—————————————-
I’m sorry Mr. Hack, but I thought Putin said (and I am paraphrasing) that there were conspirators who were misleading others in the Wagner group to act, and that these traitor’s (or whatever you want to call them) would be punished. It might even be possible that someone in the Wagner Group shot down Russian Aircraft, though I have no proof of that: Do you?
Silly me!

Posted by: Ed | Jun 29 2023 1:56 utc | 279

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2023 0:57 utc | 242
“when the info surfaced that he’d provided info to the enemy.”
Probability is he was doing that under orders from the GRU and SVR. I’m not familiar with the specifics but does anyone have a link establishing that what he provided was in fact useful to the Ukrainians? Note that if he provided info on the regular Russian army, well, that just fits with his mind games.
“(some have suggested he escalated the tempo himself)”
Nope. He needed those troops to increase Wagner’s significance, and hence, his income. OTOH, since I postulate that he wanted out of Ukraine precisely because he was losing troops and cutting into his businesses in other countries, perhaps he wanted to finish off Bakhmut faster so he could maneuver his way out of Ukraine. In that, he was probably delusional or desperate. We’ll probably never know unless he says so some day.
“he was aware of plans to nationalize his pride and joy”
Not his “pride and joy” – his meal ticket. One could characterize that as “pride and joy” from a criminal standpoint. I understand that. But it implies an emotional attachment to the Wagner personnel that I suspect is illusory. People keep forgetting that he was the front man. Wagner was not even founded by him, it was founded by Utkin, although some suggest he was himself a front man for Prigozhin. Prigozhin was run by GRU and SVR who were no doubt quite aware of his personality and found him perfect for the job as long as he didn’t inconvenience them.
Then he inconvenienced them and the MoD.
“he felt betrayed that he wasn’t at all being properly rewarded, but rather being disciplined for no reason he could fathom.”
Oh, he knew exactly what the reason was. He was undoubtedly told in no uncertain terms all along. He just didn’t care because his ends justified his means in his mind. Remember: criminal mind. I’m familiar.
“To try and posit that he was made into a double agent and the entire revolt was theatre when none was needed from Russia’s POV just doesn’t make sense no matter how sexy that idea might appear.”
I agree completely. But not because I think Prigozhin had any aversion to betraying anyone if he could have made as much money from that as he did from being the Wagner front man. I think he just didn’t have the opportunity because undoubtedly the GRU and SVR had people right inside Wagner to keep an eye on him. It would be insane if they didn’t, knowing his criminal personality. He was an asset and one of the rules of intelligence development of assets is you don’t let them off the leash, while at the same time not holding the leash too tightly except when necessary due to the unreliability of the asset. And as events proved and as I’m sure they knew, Prigozhin was unreliable.
Agree with the rest of your post, as usual.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 2:00 utc | 280

@karlof1 172
My dictionaries return “clandestine” and “underground” for нелегальной and разведки in acddition to “illegal”.

Posted by: Richard L | Jun 29 2023 2:02 utc | 281

Melaleuca @271
Why does western media want to insert a “we (cia) wuz there” “we knew, teehee” narrative?
Hubris, arrogance, chauvinism.
No one outside Russia understands Russian internal politics. And because it’s not understood, it’s dismissed as irrelevant. Only the western perspective and narrative matters. <<< A big thumbs up like. Although, I do believe that Ritter is one of the most well-studied, experienced, most intuitive analysts in "our" hemisphere. Of all the analysts, he has lived and worked inside both the Russian and US intel-political scenes. His book "Disarmament in the Time of Perestroika" would have to be the one of best insider/outsider references about dealing with Russia. His basic premise is: Ffs, listen to them, talk with them, establish equal trust with them, avoid confrontation with them, for everyone's benefit. But of course that is herasy in the US. Funnily, imo, the famous CIA ranks waaay below an intel analyst of Ritter's calibre (McGregor's too). They are trained and battle-hardened realists. CIA are nothing but office-thinkers, devious spooks, operating under deep state instructions. Now whom would you trust? And, btw, Martyanov ALWAYS SAYS "my good friend Larry Johnson". Hmmm, is that one of his supposed intel check points?

Posted by: The Dolphin | Jun 29 2023 2:04 utc | 282

“… It was all economic basically. Who could use the land most efficiently. Lot of injustice.” dh@248
Not efficiently, profitably. The most efficient use of the land was (and still seems to be) in peasant small holdings- self sufficiency with surpluses.
The clearances notoriously turned arable plots and peasant pastures into wool production and, finally, deer parks, where shooting rights were (and are) sold for entertainment. If we measure efficiency by the number of mouths it feeds the land could hardly have been used less efficiently.
As with enclosure everywhere the underlying purpose was to eradicate the rights of the cultivators and introduce private property in land. Property that became capital.
What made the situation in the Highlands particularly nasty was that the “landownders’ were actually trustees for their Clan’s members- not foreigners, like the Normans, but relatives of those whose land they were stealing and who they were expelling from their homes. They not only stole the peasants’ land they sold their own families.
Some went south to the cities and found work on the margins of the burgeoning industrial economy, others sailed west or south to America or Australia. And some of them survived the passage.
There is another story, which is of those who, having been dispossessed by capitalism, found in America other indigenous peoples going through the same process- losing their lands and livelihoods, homes and histories- and recognised in them, despite superficial differences of culture and appearance, fellows with identical interests and common enemies.
The reckoning is yet to come.

Posted by: bevin | Jun 29 2023 2:05 utc | 283

Due to all the comments, I’m posting too much. Need to take a break before b tells me so, as he’s done in the past.
Plus it’s time to eat and download Youtube videos. 🙂

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2023 2:06 utc | 284

“Fifth column, clandestine group or faction of subversive agents who attempt to undermine a nation’s solidarity by any means at their disposal. The term is conventionally credited to Emilio Mola Vidal, a Nationalist general during the Spanish Civil War (1936–39). As four of his army columns moved on Madrid, the general referred to his militant supporters within the capital as his “fifth column,” intent on undermining the loyalist government from within.” (Britannica.com)

Posted by: Ed | Jun 29 2023 2:08 utc | 285

Why so much hate against Shoigu?
Simple to understand.
He’s a person of color.
And the Nazi master race crowd hates that.
Face it.
Good old racism.
Well, suck it, Nazis.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Jun 29 2023 2:09 utc | 286

I’m going to challenge the notion that the rapidly depleting UAF needs to show progress by the Vilnius summit in two weeks.
Even if Ye Olde Counteroffensive continues to Shite Ye Olde Bed, why wouldn’t NATO just say, “it’s a marathon and we’re committed for the long haul?”
The real limiting factor is when warehouses are empty. And stiffs pile to the sky, while NATO sheep-dipped mercs DIE, DIE, DIE!!

Posted by: Ghost of Zanon | Jun 29 2023 2:09 utc | 287

Dolphin.
I once was a Ritter fanboi. His book on WMD inspections in Iraq was one of the first I bought when I went down my 1.5 decade 9/11 rabbit hole.
I’m wary of him now.
To fall for one Sting re cyber sex with a female of uncertain adolescent age… is unfortunate. Stings exist. To fall for a second identical sting… with a female of indeterminate adolescent age…. guy can’t be all that smart.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jun 29 2023 2:17 utc | 288

I really like how RSH challenged Matthew Yglesias with enough persistence and force in The Atlantic in 2008 that young Yglesias felt the need to respond with this:
https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2008/06/the-end/48818/

Posted by: Wisco | Jun 29 2023 2:17 utc | 289

Wisco | Jun 29 2023 2:17 utc | 291
I don’t sign up to anything…. And certainly not The Atlantic.
Got an archive link?

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jun 29 2023 2:20 utc | 290

Ukraine terrorizing Russian families w/fake phone calls
‘Combat Veteran Guy’ is a standard Russophobe but he occasionally makes an observation that his Ukrainian fan base does not like … https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nM5ScNAkB2k
He discusses a Ukrainian psyops where Ukrainians call the family of soldiers to demoralize both parties. Not certain if it is a fake officer or actual recordings of Russians spliced together, got too depressed and angry to listen to the entire thing.

He mentioned that the U.S. did something very similar in Vietnam, Ukraine is benefiting from NATO training after all.

Posted by: Christian Chuba | Jun 29 2023 2:21 utc | 291

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jun 29 2023 2:20 utc | 292
It is active. I am not signed up with The Atlantic. Accessed the site from Google.

Posted by: Wisco | Jun 29 2023 2:25 utc | 292

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jun 29 2023 2:20 utc | 292
I just clicked on it again from my own link here and it worked. But I got a warning that it was last free article to view.

Posted by: Wisco | Jun 29 2023 2:28 utc | 293

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jun 29 2023 2:17 utc | 290
To fall for one Sting re cyber sex with a female of uncertain adolescent age… is unfortunate. Stings exist. To fall for a second identical sting… with a female of indeterminate adolescent age…. guy can’t be all that smart.
In both cases the “females of uncertain age” had subscribed to a site which explicitly ask them to register their age and confirm that they are of legal age.
Ritter did nothing wrong, unless you’re suggesting he should have suspended any attempt at finding female company from then onward.
Eventually they get you, you know. Even if they have to pay a 14 year old whore to lie about her age and meet her in a hotel room …

Posted by: Arch Bunglea | Jun 29 2023 2:28 utc | 294

@ Mike R @79
As a couple of the barflies have pointed out, the ‘S-300 repurposed against ground targets’ is a zombie story, one that simply will not die. In order for that to be achieved the entire missile and its guidance system would have to be re-engineered. It’s not because the payload is smaller than that of an Iskander. It’s because the frag warhead is detonated by a proximity fuse which is maximized against a target which is the only thing solid in the sky, and if indeed a ground target would cause it to detonate, it would explode at the first thing solid enough to trigger it – there would be no way to ‘target’ it at anything. The acquisition/guidance system is only for use against aircraft, and the radar picture of the earth is just ground clutter to it; again, it would not be possible to pick out a single building. You could fire one in the direction of a city and if it did not acquire an aircraft on the way, it would probably fall on the city when it ran out of fuel, but that’s not technically an ‘attack’. It’s vertical-launch, so it is launched straight up and its parent radar is looking for air targets.
The missiles exploding on Ukrainian apartment buildings are quite possibly S-300’s, but if so, their hits are entirely random and are air-defense launches by the Ukrainians – if an S-300 does not acquire a target it is possible it might blind-impact a building, or it could fall into the city when it runs out of fuel, but the damage routinely described is not consistent with that caused by a blast-fragmentation warhead, and looks more like an unspent-fuel blast.

Posted by: Mark | Jun 29 2023 2:34 utc | 295

Regarding S300 missile systems do the newest at least explode high up in the air when they run out of fuel? It never made sense to me that these things should explode close to the ground if they miss their target.

Posted by: Christian Chuba | Jun 29 2023 2:39 utc | 296

“…saying “Look what these bastards are doing to this country. There’s soldiers under this rubble all over.”
Oh the irony. Here they are foreign mercs complaining about being in a war.

Posted by: Inki | Jun 29 2023 2:42 utc | 297

Being an icon painter (strictly amateur) in real life, I am imagining a diptych composed of two interrelated scenes – on the right panel (left side for the viewer) is the meeting between Blinken and the Chinese officials in the hall centered by Xi underneath an awesome painting of mountains, with a lotus display before him, and perhaps in the diminishing foreground there is the teensy figure of Biden on his knees, perhaps in obeisance but more likely because of a stumble…
Okay, the second, righthand panel is differently composed. No central image but instead an army marching across from the left side, spears in stiff array, shields a woven, dragonlike line of scales somewhat serpentine…approaching kremlin walls with church domes peering over them. Again, in the foreground, a diminished figure,(perhaps a little larger than the other, but smaller again than the scene behind him) – that of Putin standing arms upheld – no weapon, just a simple cloth draped from each elbow down to his parted feet and inversely curved, rainbow like, across his body. A flag perhaps, hard to say.
Who stands before these images? (I see them in inverse perspective, as icons often are, the vanishing point outward towards the viewer).
We do. And not only we, but all the world.

Posted by: juliania | Jun 29 2023 2:50 utc | 298