Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
June 27, 2023
Ukraine Open Thread 2023-152

Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.

The current open thread for other issues here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

So UK senses that Biden has thrown it under a bus – who next Germany or Poland ?

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Jun 27 2023 16:54 utc | 1

Putin must do something about Prighozin. He has been grossly disrespected by him over again.

Posted by: AodhOSeachnasaigh | Jun 27 2023 16:56 utc | 2

So, Mr. Stoltenberg is being extended as Nato head because POTUS Biden doesn’t want UK’s Wallace from what I heard.
UK maybe overextended their enthusiasm for escalation dominance for the US’s taste?

Posted by: Fudup | Jun 27 2023 17:19 utc | 3

Just today UK was again flying a recon aircraft and two of their Typhoon fighter jets just on the fringes of Crimean air space.
I’d recommend reading the newest BMA (Aleks’) article on strategic stability and potential for nuclear war.
UK is definitely not in a very good position, if it’s counting on uncle Schmuel coming to help it if the Russkies decide to sink it into the ocean. Turns out the American oligarchs might not be very interested or willing to sacrifice their interests, or lives, for European fringe vassals, and that extends to UK if they really get into a hot war.
https://bmanalysis.substack.com/p/strategic-stability-and-prospects

Posted by: unimperator | Jun 27 2023 17:30 utc | 4

I am hearing reports that negotiations will soon start to end the Russo/Ukrainian war.
Such could turn out to be a ruse from both parties to placate their populations and to lull the opposite side into a lull or sleep.
Whenever, these negotiations get started just realize the Russians have no trust in the West. The West has proven to lie to Russia repeatedly over the decades.
Also, realize the USA has no choice but to ultimately take Russia down. Otherwise, it will quickly lose the world reserve currency status of its United States Dollar (USD).
The Russians will not be serious at negotiating a real peace anymore than the United States will be serious at negotiating a real peace.
Since it has become obvious that the taking down of Russia is not going to occur along the zero line in the Donbas, Kharkiv, Zaporizhzhia, and Kherson, it really does not matter so much what Ukraine does or does not do.
This leaves the USA with only one option. That option will be used to preserve its hegemony. However, it will not work.

Posted by: young | Jun 27 2023 17:31 utc | 5

Ukraine has established a bridgehead under a bridge literally at the antonovsky bridge. They have some ew stopping russian lancets and are able to defend effectively on the ground
Russia is currently using glide bombs and heavy flame throwers, but maybe ukraine will be able to expand the bridge head

Posted by: Neofeudalfuture | Jun 27 2023 17:35 utc | 6

Prigozhin is the Kreml’s lighening rod, Putin, it’s “face”.
Prigozhin’s whining is just the sort you’d expect to hear
in the trenches and factories whenever shit goes sideways.

Posted by: Fubar El Haq | Jun 27 2023 17:40 utc | 7

UK’s Wallace is a short *rsed little pr***.
I’m glad he’s been snubbed.

Posted by: scepticalSOB | Jun 27 2023 17:50 utc | 8

According to Russian speaking Rolo Slavskiy the situation in Russia / Ukraine is highly more complex than the picture painted by the non Russian speaking commentators.
Here is a link that I repost from someone else who posted it this morning on yesterday’s thread.
https://www.corbettreport.com/interview-1813-wtf-just-happened-in-russia-with-rolo-slavskiy/

Posted by: Richard L | Jun 27 2023 17:53 utc | 9

Greyzone has published an independent audit of US funding of Ukraine.

In the absence of official scrutiny of Washington’s spending spree on Ukraine, The Grayzone conducted an independent audit of US funding for the country. We discovered a series of seemingly wasteful, highly unusual expenditures the Biden administration has yet to explain.

https://thegrayzone.com/2023/06/27/gravy-train-independent-audit-ukraine

Posted by: too scents | Jun 27 2023 17:55 utc | 10

The Ukrainian Civil War is costing Mr. Stoltenberg maybe 2 million Euros a month in lost income because he can’t take on his Norwegian Sovereign Wealth Fund Job. Stoltenberg must be hopping mad.

Posted by: Exile | Jun 27 2023 18:11 utc | 11

Several posters have speculated that the $6.2B the Pentagon miraculously found under the sofa cushions was somehow diverted to bribe Prigo.
I find that highly likely to be overcooked BS.
1. If the CIA wanted to do this, they’d use a covert slush fund, not announce it across the airwaves in such an easily deduced way.
2. The way it works with surplus is like this: some dude in the bowels of the Pentagon with a spreadsheet gets told to slap a valuation on some surplus gear, maybe a Bradley built back during the 90’s. The spreadsheet has some formula, maybe factoring in depreciation, cost of materials, labor, etc. Say its $250M for 100 Bradleys – a completely arbitrary number that could be wildly wrong.
Then Pudding-for-brains or Stinkin’ Blinken announces $250M worth of Bradleys in an aid package. No new treasury funds are needed – this is from existing stock that are simply valued at an arbitrary number, albeit with some degree of accounting magic.
Again, no new money has to be borrowed or printed into existence, yet. This is a pure accounting exercise.
Then, some weeks later, the Ukraine pisses away those Bradleys and they get turned into steppe-scrap. Whoops, now they need replacements. But the budget for them was already set – an arbitrary number, but one that the Pentagon wants to stick to, in order to look less like they’re spending funds willy-nilly.
The dude in the Pentagon is told to open the spreadsheet, and change a fudge factor somewhere in the Excel formula. Suddenly, 100 Bradleys from the year when Clinton was getting a BJ from an intern are only valued at $200M.
Voila, $50M freed up to send moar!

Posted by: Ghost of Zanon | Jun 27 2023 18:14 utc | 12

note Rolo Slavskiy might speak Russian, but his primary goal will be to adavance a narrative that promotes his ethnic group’s intetests.
It’s interesting that all of a sudden Rolo Slavskiy is being heavily promoted here. Hmmmm

Posted by: Exile | Jun 27 2023 18:15 utc | 13

I think Annalena Baerbock would be perfect for the new NATO chief (lol)

Posted by: Perimetr | Jun 27 2023 18:18 utc | 14

“Western nations must have helped businessman Evgeny Prigozhin organize his brief insurrection last week, according to Viktor Zolotov, commander of the National Guard of Russia… the senior official expressed certainty that the mutiny ‘was inspired by Western special services, because, as they said, they knew about it several weeks ahead of time.’”
Neocons will double down, triple down and quadruple down:
https://jamesburrillangell.substack.com/p/strange-diplomacy-victoria-fck-the

Posted by: Doim | Jun 27 2023 18:20 utc | 15

No discussion of Larry Johnson’s theory yet ?
https://sonar21.com/was-prigozhins-mutiny-a-western-intelligence-op-derailed-by-russias-spies/
It’s not a long piece but the tl;dr is that Prigozhin was a ‘double agent’ who was playing the West + Ukraine’s intelligence agencies into thinking they had a genuine coup leader. Larry was also on Napolitano’s show today, speaking to his theory.

Posted by: Hot Fuzz | Jun 27 2023 18:22 utc | 16

Comment by sln2002 | June 25, 2023 at 15:54While the 4B ruble triple agent Prigozhin debriefed Putin and Lukashenko, this happened. Belarusian opposition leader Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya [alias Svitlana Tykhanovskaya alias Svetlana ] has called on Belarusians to not let an opportunity to save Belarus go to waste….
RT, 27 June 2023,”Belarusian opposition was ready to stage armed coup amid Russia crisis – Lukashenko”

Lukashenko said on Tuesday that his opponents had started “buzzing with activity” when Wagner launched its mutiny in the neighboring country last week [24.06.23]. “But it was a false start,” he added.
The opposition “has already published its appeals and plans… that they are also ready to implement the scenario of an armed rebellion in Belarus,” the president claimed. “They’re trying to demonstrate at least some results to their curators abroad.”
“When the events in Russia were happening, I gave all the orders to put the army on full combat alert,” Lukashenko said, adding that the same was true for the police and the special forces….

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 27 2023 18:25 utc | 17

No discussion of Larry Johnson’s theory yet ?
Posted by: Hot Fuzz | Jun 27 2023 18:22 utc | 15
————-
Well, Larry is good at writing (in his blog), but what does he know about Russia and Russians…being an American?

Posted by: ostro | Jun 27 2023 18:31 utc | 18

>Posted by: Exile | Jun 27 2023 18:15 utc | 13
Agreed. It’s hard to take someone seriously who’s posts usually start with a variation of this:
>Literally everything is occurring as I said it would, folks. It’s eerie, actually. I’ve got chills running up and down my spine now and you should too. It must be all the spice melange (kratom and nicotine) I’ve been imbibing gifting me the powers of prescience (and belligerence).
>All the people in the comments section or Twitter who were arguing with me these last days, only to be proven wrong, again, continue to reaffirm and strengthen my disdain for the masses. Your stupidity and swine-like ingratitude towards Rolo only strengthen my resolve to drive the truth deeper down into your throats as you gurgle in protest with each post. The simpletons should realize by now that they have literally no chance and no business going up toe-to-toe against me in the future. Look, I have autism and if I add up my math and reading section scores from the SAT, it comes out to me having a *154+ IQ, so you’re just not going to be able to out-analyze me, bro. Give it up already. Also, if you are unable to pick up and run with the logic that I lend out to you or make use of the hidden Slavlands lore that I reveal for my beloved Stalkers behind the paywall, just start pretending that I am a priest or a celebrity or yer mum or whatever other authority personality that you are accustomed to obeying unquestioningly.
Or, in other word, the dude is batshit crazy.

Posted by: Pudding | Jun 27 2023 18:32 utc | 19

RT reports in very few lines RF’s position.

1. Prigozhin is a traitor
Putin unequivocally condemned Prigozhin’s actions, describing them as “treason” motivated by “inflated ambition and personal interests.”
Speaking on Saturday before Prigozhin called off the rebellion, Putin said the mutiny came as Russians are “fighting for the lives and security of our people, for our sovereignty and independence” against the entire Western bloc.
The uprising was “in essence a betrayal of our people, of the brothers in arms that are fighting on the front line. It is a stab in the back of our nation and our people,” Putin declared.
2. Russia avoided civil war
Putin compared the situation to what Russia had faced in 1917, when two revolutions happened months apart amid World War I. Victory in that conflict had been “stolen” from the Russian people, the president claimed.
“Intrigues, quarrels, political machinations behind the back of the army and the people led to a great disaster, the destruction of the army and the dissolution of the state, the loss of a large swath of its territory. Ultimately, to the tragedy of the civil war,” Putin said in the same speech on Saturday morning.
In an address to the nation on Monday, Putin said the country’s foreign enemies had hoped Russian society would “be split asunder and drown in a bloody feud.”
On Tuesday, Putin thanked the Russian military and security personnel involved in the response to the crisis for preventing a new civil war.
3. Wagner troops were deceived
Putin described Wagner troops as victims of Prigozhin’s deception, rather than his accomplices. They were heroes because of the sacrifices they made in the Russian military operation in Ukraine, the president added.
“An overwhelming majority of the fighters and commanders of the Wagner Group are patriots of Russia too, who are loyal to their people and the country,” Putin stated in his speech on Monday.
He said he had personally ordered “steps to avoid major bloodshed” and had given the insurrectionists time to reconsider their actions, which they did. Wagner troops “stopped at the last line,” Putin stated.
4. Military pilots killed during insurrection
While Prigozhin’s mutiny did not escalate into widespread bloodshed, his troops did kill several Russian military pilots. They died “confronting the mutineers,” Putin said on Tuesday.
“They didn’t falter and carried out their orders and military duty with honor,” the Russian president declared as he announced a minute of silence to commemorate the fallen officers.
5. Russia reacted by showing unity
The Russian people reacted to the crisis by showing unity, Putin assessed in the same speech on Tuesday. Ultimately, this consolidation “played the decisive role” in the resolution of the crisis, he said.

Posted by: whirlX | Jun 27 2023 18:33 utc | 20

Anyone heard of the whereabouts of Prigozin, or his closest gang members?

Posted by: ostro | Jun 27 2023 18:37 utc | 21

HAL TURNER- just reported Russians will transport back to MOSCOW diplomatic corps..hmmm airplane is on the way to Distict(of)Crimes…from Moscow

Posted by: sejmon | Jun 27 2023 18:39 utc | 22

Posted by: Hot Fuzz | Jun 27 2023 18:22 utc | 15
Some of us still think it was a psyop. I for instance. Still no photos of bodies, still no witnesses to say they saw the helicopters and planes be shot down and saw bodies, still no record of even one Wagner even wounded by a Russian trooper. Seen Putin go to a funeral? Any mothers, wives or children crying on TV? Also the Rosguardia director is still talking with honour on websites, rather than be in chains ( his units supposedly gave up in Rostov).
What matters is that it is a net benefit to Russia as I mentioned in my previous posts here.
Posted by: Exile | Jun 27 2023 18:15 utc | 13
Someone here said his Russian was poor and inconsistent with him being a Russian or Ukrainian or even born overseas with Russian/Ukrainian parents. UK psywarrior? Anyway, I do read him every so often. I like his audacity, but not his conclusions.

Posted by: Boy | Jun 27 2023 18:41 utc | 23

@ ostro | Jun 27 2023 18:31 utc | 17
Well, Raymond McGovern is also an American, but he does know a lot more about Russia than many Russians do. And his Russian, as a foreign spoken language, is very good.
Larry is not a Russian expert, as he is more versed in Central America and counterterrorism. But he is a very good analyst.
Both have some added value there.

Posted by: whirlX | Jun 27 2023 18:41 utc | 24

Hot Fuzz | Jun 27 2023 18:22 utc | 15
Wagner is a GRU creation and it’s funded by the Russian government. Putin was not only a KGB agent he ran the East German station during the cold war … he is no desk jockey.
I can’t imagine Putin and the GRU being so naive as to put an ex.con in charge of a 50,000 man army without at least one loyal agent ready to put a bullet in his head if he took one step off the reservation.
You would have to believe either Putin and the GRU are completely inept, incompetent and impotent or Prigozhin is playing a part in a piece of theater. it would be far easier to pull off Prigozhin dying in a training accident or slipping and falling out a window and replacing him than going through this whole ‘march on Moscow bullshit which the Russians could have stopped any time they wanted by simply mining the roads in front and behind Prigozhin’s convoys.
The GRU are the agency responsible for military deception. Russia has a long tradition of complex military deceptions and psyops. All of us Russian history nerds have been waiting to see in what form “maskirovka” comes in in the age of NATO ISR … I think we may have seen it.

Posted by: HB_Norica | Jun 27 2023 18:45 utc | 25

@12
the us pentagon scarcely insects the bradleys they bought 30 odd years ago for meeting the spec ordered, and never fully tested
this is why no auditor will pass the pentagon’s asset accounts.

Posted by: paddy | Jun 27 2023 18:50 utc | 26

On what is the effect of negotiations.
Ukraine has rejected negotiations and even broke out of them even though they had good terms. The reason was the promise from the West that they will stand by them militarily no matter the cost. This of course gives a huge morale boost and justifies in front of the populace all subsequent actions such as economic and social hardship, mobilization and huge losses on the front. It is internally tolerated because they are never going to negotiate. Hence, an “all or nothing” narrative is used for garnering the needed popular support. This is effective for the Ukrainian side and may win the war for them. In other words, negotiations – even the smallest hint – and the winning narrative will be gone.
Russia went in in the first place with negotiations in mind. They wanted to use “military technical” means as a way to force an agreement to protect Ukrainian Russians from discrimination by the NATO-instigated nationalist Ukrainians and to achieve a better strategic position against an ever agressive NATO. But they failed in this and since the summer are now on an increasingly defensive path. Such strategy has no clear goal, does not solve the problems of the russian citizens nor is there a victorius narrative to support their actions. The Russians will always talk if any hand is outstretched and try to end this asap, even on worse terms than the original ones (because of intrinsic humanism and honesty). By itself such a strategy admits that they are the invaders. Waiting for the West to exhaust itself is also not a grand winning strategy. This of course affects troop morale negatively and creates a need to compensate for it via other means. In other words, the Russians lack a narrative that will equalise the societal support with the one on the Ukrainian side. The support of China at the beginning was a positive booster but that has gone in recent months. The support of the RoW has also become less warm. The West is not tiring itself, even more: economic booms are happening in front of very high inflation and the populace is almost monolithically in support of NATO.
These strategically lacking issues are of course exploited by their opponents but also by themselves come up once in a while. The Prigozhin episode underscored the stress in the Russian society that has built up due to a lack of a well motivated reason why are they doing this in Ukraine at the moment and what will be the end goal that benefits Russian society more than not doing it. The humanitarian honest reasoning and patriotism is too abstract and goes only so far. They need to get winning and show to everyone and most of all themselves that they are on the right side of history.
Unfortunately I dont see that the Russian state has learned from the last half year how construct a strong narrative, a story, of intrinsic motivational character like the one the Ukrainian side has. This may cost them the war at some point, even though they have all the prerequisites to win it. I hope I am wrong and that having the moral high ground is enough but I am afraid that is so only in Hollywood movies. It reeks of the way the dissolution of the USSR was handled when social pessimism completely overwhelmed many decades of building a society.

Posted by: alek_a | Jun 27 2023 18:50 utc | 27

I think Larry Johnson – like many people including commentators here and b – is at least partially correct in his overarching theory about the “coup” or “mutiny.”
Also I read comments under his short article and found some that echoed my own theory about the destroyed aircraft, including ones that were destroyed while sitting on the ground and the one video-verified shoot-down of the large intel gathering turboprop/converted airliner. IMO it is that loss of aircraft and personnel that Putin (truthfully) refers to in his speeches after that day and Prigozhin – TMK – only admitted that SHOOT-DOWN and loss of life. Other references, IMO, were to aircraft and materiel destroyed while idle. I will refrain from using the term __________ moving forward here, but I offer my assurances that my use of the Russian language term was out of respect for the Russian military and their ability to pull off elaborate operations that simply are NOT what they seem on the surface. As with any real-world situation, of course various aspects are TRUE. But Prigozhin wouldn’t be alive much less a free man at this point if the main allegations circulated mainly to WESTERN audiences were true.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 18:51 utc | 28

https://sonar21.com/was-prigozhins-mutiny-a-western-intelligence-op-derailed-by-russias-spies/#comment-138359
Dropshot American Plan for War with the Soviet Union, 1957 Vol. III
I first read it many years ago, but at the time was more interested in the operational issues of how it was anticipated the war would be fought in 1957.
Re-reading it, I am struck by the US war aims as expressed in it:
16. Establish Control and Enforce Surrender Terms in the USSR and Satellite Countries (in the Event of a Possible Early Capitulation of the USSR During Phase I)
a. Analysis In order to ensure compliance with our national objectives, the Allies would have to occupy selected areas of the USSR and her satellites and establish some form of Allied control in each of those countries. A method of control under the conditions which would exist in the event of early capitulation, affording maximum control with minimum forces, might be to occupy selected bridgeheads in the USSR and other selected centers which would serve as bases for projection of control in both the USSR and her satellites. It is considered that the greater portion of control forces should be in bridgehead areas with minimum forces in the interior.
Areas selected as centers of control in the USSR should be urban areas which are of strategic importance such as the following: political and administrative centers, communication centers, major seaports or naval bases, oil-producing or refining centers. Areas selected in the satellites as centers of control should be the various capitals and certain key seaports and urban areas. Centers of control in the USSR should be grouped into larger regions of responsibility.
It is considered that the basic element of control should be exercised by ground forces based in and operating from the control subcenters. The most suitable control unit readily available would be the division augmented by additional motor transport to give it increased mobility. On this basis, a total of thirty-eight divisions is estimated to be the minimum requirements for the control centers shown on the map referred to above.
Since the means of control envisaged would in reality be a skeleton occupation, it is considered that a high ratio of air-force units would be desirable in order to bring visible evidence of Allied strength before the Soviet and satellite people. These air-force units should be organized, disposed, and controlled on a broader regional concept than the ground forces in order to assure flexibility and maximum effectiveness with the minimum of forces in assisting and supporting the ground forces.
On this basis five reinforced tactical air forces, each consisting of approximately five to six combat groups and one troop-carrier group with an attached assault or glider squadron, should be assigned the following regions of responsibility: western USSR, Caucasus-Ukraine, Urals-west Siberia-Turkestan, east Siberia-Transbaikal-maritime (including Korea) and the European satellite area. Ground and air forces would be provided from forces released from other tasks and should be moved to selected centers of control by the most feasible and rapid means available in each case. Logistic support would be mainly by sea transport and railroad, augmented, especially in the initial stages, by air transport. It is recognized that tremendous logistic problems would exist in the supply of Allied control forces, particularly those destined for areas deep in the USSR. Allied troop-carrier and air-transport units would be strained to the utmost in providing airlift. A considerable period might elapse before full complements of Allied ground and air forces reached all control centers, but every effort should be made to reduce this time to the minimum, even though capitulation had already been obtained.
A carrier task force should be provided in each of the Baltic and Black seas to provide a reserve striking force and to serve as a psychological factor to impress the Soviet and satellite peoples.
A reserve of divisions, fighter and bomber groups, and troop-carrier units should be earmarked by the Allies when released from other tasks to be available for re-enforcement of the control forces if required. The size and composition would be dependent upon the situation existing at the time.
The forces required for this course of action, with the possible exception of those required for airlift, could be made available from those which have been developed for the other courses of action in Phase I. The balance of forces then in existence should be retained operational in reserve until full control of the USSR and her satellites is established and until the situation in Southeast Asia and the Far East has been clarified.
United States Department of Defense. Dropshot: American Plan for War with the Soviet Union, 1957 (pp. 45-46). Unknown. Kindle Edition.
Elsewhere in Dropshot, though not in the Vol 3 on Kindle, the aim of breaking up Russia in order to ensure it would never be powerful enough to oppose the US is explicitly stated as a war aim.
The war aims of this plan were delusional. Russians would never accept foreign occupation, the US could never mobilise enough forces to effectively occupy Russia.
But More! I had though the plans to defeat and break up Russia were a relatively recent neocon innovation. NO, HELL NO! Dropshot was drafted in 1957, 66 years ago, and was the outcome of up to 10 years of planning, thus the plan to break up Russia is probably at least 75 years old and has permeated all US “strategic” thinking about Russia since then.

Posted by: Dropshot | Jun 27 2023 18:56 utc | 29

No discussion of Larry Johnson’s theory yet ?
Posted by: Hot Fuzz | Jun 27 2023 18:22 utc | 15

Larry Johnson’s theory is absolutely idiotic, as is Scott Ritter’s theory that Prigozhin mounted an honest-to-God, Western-backed coup attempt. The Duran boys, along with Big Serge, have glommed onto the position that Prigozhin had let his ego get to him and was throwing a fit about his Wagner organization (and therefore his business interests) being sidelined. This idea is also absurd.
The truth of the matter is that Prigozhin, like Razin and Pugachev before him, was giving voice to the repressed concerns within Russian society by assuming the role of the brigand-hero which is a deep rooted archetype within Russian cultural memory. This does not mean Prigozhin’s actions are excusable, it just means that some of the concerns he expressed in his characteristically bombastic manner were indeed rooted in the truth.
Russia and the MoD need to stop the slow roll through Ukraine and wrap this thing up already. I understand the logic behind playing it cautious. I understand the need to preserve Russia’s regular forces in case of NATO escalation, and I understand that Putin is playing a long game with his global partners, getting the BRICS and the Global South to see Russia as a reliable party.
However, there is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to playing it safe. If you play it too safe, you are simply giving the enemy time to play the odds. Even a weak enemy like Ukraine might get in a lucky strike if you give him enough chances, so it makes sense to finish him off when you can. Furthermore, there is a legitimate desire on the part of many Russians to to see their people protected and their fallen revenged. They want to see and feel a decisive victory between their legs, and those desires should not simply be dismissed. Emotion plays a role in human life, and Russians have put up with a lot already.

Posted by: Intelligent Dasein | Jun 27 2023 18:58 utc | 30

Well, from where I’m sitting, Jake the Snake’s press conference today tells me that the USA are throwing the UK under the Bus. I believe Pregozhin was helped by the UK Govt. Russian fighter jets scrambled to escort an RAF recon ‘plane flying over Crimea. Ben Wallace is obsessed with Crimea, truly obsessed. The UK is isolated. With the USA literally throwing them under the Bus, our Govt needs to really stop and think what they are doing interfering big time in Ukraine. We are going to suffer here in the UK because of it. Russia has a right to retalliation. I’m seriously considering moving to Africa next year, I won’t name it but a highly stable country in Africa.
I want no part of this NWO, of slavery, of surveillance and all that comes with it. I want to live a free life with good friends, in a civilised country that has a Govt that actually puts the people first. has intelligent Presidents/Prime Ministers and who invest in their own country’s needs rather than pander and kow tow to the USA.
God Bless Mother Russia and President Putin and the Russian Citizens and civic officials and institutions who stood firm against Traitor Pregozhin. May he rot wherever he is.

Posted by: Jo Dominich | Jun 27 2023 19:00 utc | 31

Posted by: HB_Norica | Jun 27 2023 18:45 utc | 24
Agree, at least in that you’re open minded and distrustful of the press(titute) narrative we are fed.
IMHO the willingness and almost compulsive urge of people here in the West to write down what happened on Saturday and Sunday as exactly what the simple, official explanation disseminated said happened is part and parcel to a profound lack of the ability to delay gratification and/or inability to accept that a straight forward Netflix denouement wasn’t handed to them neatly buttoned up and easy to mentally process. And the opposite of that mindset in a sort of horseshoe arrangement is the Qanon ultra-conspiracy which also makes it easier for some commentators to “explain” what happened. In that scenario, every aspect of a complex psyop was played perfectly and without a hitch. The truth – as always – lies in the “middle” and as with other major events of the modern era, we likely won’t know all of the details for a long time, if ever.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 19:00 utc | 32

Ostro no. 20
“President Alexander Lukashenko, who quelled the feud between the Wagner Group and Russia, confirms that mercenary chief Yevgeny Prigozhin has arrived in Belarus.“We offered them one of the abandoned military bases,” Lukashenko says, referring to exiled Wagner fighters who have been invited to live in Belarus under the deal he brokered.”
Aljazeera

Posted by: ThusspakeZarathustra | Jun 27 2023 19:01 utc | 33

The tell that this was aa CIA op was Blinken’s repeated emphasis that this was an “internal” Russian affair and US respects Russia’s “internal affairs.
The Blinken emphasis was later repeated by Biden’s open denial: “No US role” a story I which US media repeated the “internal” slogan.
The “internal” slogan is serving exactly the same propaganda purposes as the term “unprovoked” did.

Posted by: bill wolfe | Jun 27 2023 19:01 utc | 34

This makes no sense to me: https://www.rt.com/russia/578777-lukashenko-belarus-wagner-coup/
Perhaps I’m not reading between the lines, but how does this scenario seem remotely plausible? Belarussian opposition was activating a coup attempt while Prigozhin engaged in his own (assumed real) coup (or “mutiny”) attempt in Russia. Lukashenko negotiates the end to the Russian coup while his people put down the one in Belarus. Luka and Belarus then welcome the (assumed real) coup attempt in Russia after putting down their own coup. I mean, c’mon – Really?

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 19:10 utc | 35

Prigozhin’s stunt has put wind back in the sails of western maniacs who want to escalate the matter even more and to sow doubts in the minds of those who would align with Russia.
I’m not buying any of these theories that Putin would go along with such a thing unless he’s a complete fraud and I don’t think he is.

Posted by: chunga | Jun 27 2023 19:10 utc | 36

Or, in other word, the dude is batshit crazy.
Posted by: Pudding | Jun 27 2023 18:32 utc | 18
Totally!

Posted by: RB | Jun 27 2023 19:11 utc | 37

^^^…welcome the leader of the (assumed real) coup attempt in Russia….^^^

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 19:11 utc | 38

Posted by: Intelligent Dasein | Jun 27 2023 18:58 utc | 29

The truth of the matter is that Prigozhin, like Razin and Pugachev before him, was giving voice to the repressed concerns within Russian society by assuming the role of the brigand-hero which is a deep rooted archetype within Russian cultural memory.

That argument has a lot of meat to it, Prigozhin’s alma mater was the slammer and his language makes honor to it, Luka admitted that for the first half hour the whole conversation was plain blasphemies, the language that the regular Ivan understands quite well. And for true Russophiles, the respect or love that you may have for that country should not blind anybody, there are lots of problems that need to be solved together with the big one, the whole west salivating when they see a map. One huge problem, the defense minister son in law, highly offensive, especially if the fate of Stalin’s son is remembered.

Posted by: Paco | Jun 27 2023 19:12 utc | 39

Well, Raymond McGovern is also an American, but he does know a lot more about Russia than many Russians do. And his Russian, as a foreign spoken language, is very good.
Posted by: whirlX | Jun 27 2023 18:41 utc | 23
————
My Russian, I’m sure, is better than McGovern’s. I’ve rarely heard a well spoken, that is, in Russian, American with a Irish surname. They simply can’t get rid of the accent…and, thinking.
But, I don’t claim that I know Russia better than Russians…but, many Russians, after a few days, call me a native, which I take as a honour.

Posted by: ostro | Jun 27 2023 19:13 utc | 40

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 19:10 utc | 34
————–
I suppose, it is an exile in Belarus, rather than be free…

Posted by: ostro | Jun 27 2023 19:17 utc | 41

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 19:10 utc | 34
—————-
It is quite normal for Belarus to help out. If Russia crumbles, it is death for Belarus. Catch?

Posted by: ostro | Jun 27 2023 19:19 utc | 42

Folks more knowledgeable than I will /do poo poo Larry’s post that what we saw was a sting. They also reject the idea that lots of US $$ was transferred to foster this coup.
But consider: From reports of how the CIA promotes color revolutions (and have for many years), Larry’s scenario is plausible.
The fact is that both issues are being discussed (true or provable is not a consideration) Folks (like me scratch their heads and say – hmmmmm – maybe?
Please do not misunderstand – I am talking about winning the war of words – This recent ‘coup’ has made the news world wide – and IMHO the USofA did not come out as a winner – nor did the Bidenites.
Q: how does the CIA (or DOD or??) PROVE that it did NOT participate in any way in the coup? The more they deny the worse it looks for them.

Posted by: ms idaho | Jun 27 2023 19:19 utc | 43

I have a crazy idea. Let’s say that NATO attempts to topple Uncle Sasha in Minsk and in retribution Wagner attacks Lithuania in Suwalki corridor towards Kaliningrad. That should trigger NATO’s Article 5. But Wagnerites are now fighters for democracy in the eyes of Washington and they are now outlaws in Russia. NATO can’t attack Russia as Russia is not part of that fight even though RUS citizens armed with RUS heavy weapons and ammo are attacking NATO. Smart or crazy? Let’s hope that it is not going to happen in July.

Posted by: J_Schneider | Jun 27 2023 19:22 utc | 44

Posted by: ms idaho | Jun 27 2023 19:19 utc | 42
Posted by: J_Schneider | Jun 27 2023 19:22 utc | 43
——
The guessing game is on…and let it go on… 🙂

Posted by: ostro | Jun 27 2023 19:27 utc | 45

Posted by: ostro | Jun 27 2023 19:19 utc | 41
I completely understand that part and have no doubts that Luka played a moderator role in ramping down whatever the heck Prigozhin was really doing/trying to do. Note, however, that I’m leaving open the possibility that it was in fact “role playing” on the part of himself, Prigo and even Putin for some aspects of the failed “mutiny”…I no longer prefer to call it a “coup” attempt.
Frankly, we’re all just speculating and have nothing more to go on than what 1) we’re able to ascertain from western media sources and 2) what is said by Putin, Luka and Prig and what appears in Russian media (not counting RT here, more so referring to TASS and Interfax). I guess we’ll have to wait and see how this “exile” goes. He’s not the type to remain silent for very long, so if we don’t hear from him for a span of a couple of months, it’s possible he’s no longer with us.
I wish MoA and other sites where people dedicate so much time to talking about this war had more commentators actually on the ground in Russia. I know we’ve got some Russian speakers and ex-pats, but we’re missing an authentic man-on-the-ground perspective that might obviate some of this (often wild) speculation (including my own).

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 19:29 utc | 46

This author is new to me, but he puts out some interesting theories.
https://sonar21.com/a-working-theory-on-prigos-coup/
In particular I think he’s correct about the ammo complaints.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 19:33 utc | 47

@ Hot Fuzz | Jun 27 2023 18:22 utc | 15
Yes. Larry follows the CIA field manual logic, that he is using in his analysis.
A typical set-up according to the field manual:
Pryggo attracted MI6/CIA’s attention by open his mouth wide some month ago, showing a lability and a distrust in current RF military, attacking left and right. What is a better material to lure one onto the Western no-money-issue side, than Pryggy? Of course, that he got approached by and via…one enthusiastic operative never misses such a chance.
How and what happened with Pryggy, playing a double-agent, is chewed here and everywhere from all the sides.
I have the impression that PTSD has been struck Pryggy badly and he appears very traumatised, and that is recognized by many in RF’s army top people.
However, I suspect that this is not yet over, and it’ll linger some time until services assigned to it come to the bottom of the things.
We do not know yet who else is involved, but I doubt that top people have any doing in it.
Larry is mostly right in what he assesses, but he doesn’t go too deep.
After all, he is writing a blog and not situation assessment in-depth analysis.

Posted by: whirlX | Jun 27 2023 19:39 utc | 48

Lukashenka also revealed some details of the negotiations that took place on Saturday.
“It took me a long time to convince him. And at the end I said, “You know, you can do whatever you want. But don’t take offense at me. The brigade is prepared for transfer to Moscow. And, as in ’41 (you read books, an educated, intelligent person), we will defend Moscow. Because this situation is not only in Russia,” Lukashenko said.
————-
“There is a lot of talk and chatter now: “Wagner, Wagner, Wagner.” People don’t understand that we are also pragmatic about this. If their commanders come to us and help us… Experience. Listen, they’re on the front line — assault squads. They’ll tell us what’s important right now. That’s the last time Putin told me: counter-battery struggle, it’s impossible without it. Drones. They’ve been through it. They will tell you about the weapons: which worked well, which did not. And tactics, and weapons, and how to attack, how to defend. It’s priceless. This is what we need to take from the Wagnerians,” Lukashenka noted.
At the same time, he said that “there is nothing to be afraid of them,” because the Belarusian authorities “keep their eyes open.”
————-
Didn’t hear anything about Prigozin’s future, though.

Posted by: ostro | Jun 27 2023 19:46 utc | 49

>One huge problem, the defense minister son in law, highly offensive, especially if the fate of Stalin’s son is remembered.
>Posted by: Paco | Jun 27 2023 19:12 utc | 38
Absolutely, something is deeply wrong if the head of the MoD’s daughter showcases a lavish western lifestyle in Dubai and her husband’s public support of Ukraine war propaganda goes unchallenged.

Posted by: Pudding | Jun 27 2023 19:55 utc | 50

@ Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 19:33 utc | 46
tom… karlof1 shared the link here at moa yesterday… i see moa is talking about it earlier in this thread with the hot fuzz post.. i think its a pretty good theory as far as theories go.. larry johnson used to post at pat langs site.. i go to his site from time to time..

Posted by: james | Jun 27 2023 20:33 utc | 51

Absolutely, something is deeply wrong if the head of the MoD’s daughter showcases a lavish western lifestyle in Dubai and her husband’s public support of Ukraine war propaganda goes unchallenged.
Posted by: Pudding | Jun 27 2023 19:55 utc | 49
############
IME, women exposed to Western thinking tend to make terrible decisions when it comes to men.
The West regularly casts Russia as a totalitarian dictatorship, and here we have a pardon for Prighozin, and Shoigu’s daughter cavorting with a degenerate and dissident thinker.
Maybe ol’ Vlad is a soft touch after all.

Posted by: LoveDonbass | Jun 27 2023 20:33 utc | 52

The media chattering classes in France have been going on ad nauseam about the ‘coup attempt’ for the last five days. Most of it is sheer Lalaland, along the lines of b.’s eight identical commentators. I’ve learned two valuable facts, however: 1) Nobody actually knows anything; 2) You are not allowed to say anything positive about Putin.

Posted by: B. Wildered | Jun 27 2023 20:33 utc | 53

tom
i see that is larrys post from today… i rate it so so.. throw it in the pile with all the rest of the speculative talk..

Posted by: james | Jun 27 2023 20:37 utc | 54

“Cet auteur est nouveau pour moi, mais il propose des théories intéressantes.
https://sonar21.com/a-working-theory-on-prigos-coup/
En particulier, je pense qu’il a raison en ce qui concerne les plaintes concernant les munitions.”

Diriez vous que Prigojine agit comme Zelensky et Nuland ?
Boris Berezovski, Mikhaïl Khodorkovski et son collègue Vladimir Potanine,Roman Abramovitch, Arkadi Rotenberg,…
https://www.liberation.fr/grand-angle/2003/11/10/la-saga-des-oligarques_451256/
https://www.forbes.com/sites/giacomotognini/2023/06/24/billionaire-oligarchs-jets-flee-moscow-as-putins-regime-plunges-into-crisis/
Cherchez le fil conducteur…

Posted by: christophe nicolas | Jun 27 2023 20:43 utc | 55

I keep reading that “8,000” Wagner men are moving to Byelorussia but is this verified? My understanding is that a camp for 8,000 is being set up [not has been set up] but as of yet no one actually knows how many Wagner troops will go – and how many will move to the Russian military proper or even “go home”. Or is the choice thing another bit of deliberate misinformation?
It looks like of the c 25,000 Wagner troops [is that number even correct?] only a very few were in on the “coup” and of the few thousand who were actively involved, the majority seemed to have been duped by Prig. Hence the leniency shown and the successful attempt to resolve this with minimum bloodshed.
And in 4D chess terms, if Russia wanted Wagner in Byelrussia, why stage an elaborate psyop? Why not simply move them there? They are designed to be deployed abroad.
I still stand by my analysis that this was a coup and probably western backed or at least encouraged – though am less certain of this having read 5,000 comments and articles on the whole affair! However why is Prig still breathing? That may have been the short term price of shutting this thing down in 22 hours. However I’d say – if my analysis is correct – he doesn’t need to worry about saving up for a pension.

Posted by: marcjf | Jun 27 2023 20:45 utc | 56

Posted by: james | Jun 27 2023 20:37 utc | 53
At Larry’s site, but by a different author who I’d not seen before. And as far as things go, yeah it’s so-so, but at least he qualifies it at the beginning and end thusly:
“I have no idea if this is the correct interpretation of events or not. It’s just idle speculation, but who knows…”
Which is pretty much where I’m at right now, lol. Only time will tell, but we have no idea how much it will tell.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 21:07 utc | 57

My two cents from Moscow in this podcast with Ben Toth – no, the Wagner feud wasn’t a “psyop”, it was real. I also don’t think NATO or Ukraine had any knowledge of the coup attempt beforehand.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AxTGo_Tuz-g

Posted by: Ian Kummer | Jun 27 2023 21:07 utc | 58

B. Wildered no. 52
Right on both counts.

Posted by: ThusspakeZarathustra | Jun 27 2023 21:12 utc | 59

LoveDonbass @ 51

Maybe ol’ Vlad is a soft touch after all.

Until proven otherwise I will give Putin the benefit of the doubt and assume he is a Human Being:
Little Big Man (1970)

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Jun 27 2023 21:12 utc | 60

Marcjf no. 55
Nothing is confirmed of course but apparently the Wagner contingent and their leader are being housed in an abandoned military base in Belarus.

Posted by: ThusspakeZarathustra | Jun 27 2023 21:20 utc | 61

LightYearsFromHome no. 59
Great exerpt. Thankyou

Posted by: ThusspakeZarathustra | Jun 27 2023 21:27 utc | 62

I see the Prigozhin thread has migrated to this one–again. An interesting interpretation of Putin’s four recent speeches–The overall Russian audience was urged to understand that just because life seems normal in cities and towns far removed from proximity to Ukraine all of Russia is facing an existential crisis, that Russia’s Western enemies mean it suffer very substantial harm. So, part of the Prigozhin “trick” was to shake Russia by its shoulders and awaken all of it to the genuine danger it faces. Putin also knows that at some point he’ll need to tell Russians why Prigozhin was allowed to go to Belarus after causing the deaths of thirty or so helo pilots and crew. In Putin’s second address today, which I provided translated transcripts of at the previous Ukie open thread, while talking about that enemy he cryptically said, “He’s already trying to do it – I’ll tell you about it later-but it’s not working,” that IMO was Putin acknowledging there’s more to be said about the event but it can’t be revealed now.
So, what is happening in Ukraine? I assume the clobbering continues. What’s happening in the Kharkov region? Johnson reported an incident where a Ukie officer fragged his own troops for not getting off their butts that was caught on video.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 27 2023 21:28 utc | 63

#39 ‘My Russian, I’m sure, is better than McGovern’s. I’ve rarely heard a well spoken, that is, in Russian, American with a Irish surname. They simply can’t get rid of the accent…’
I’m not sure that makes any difference. he did study Russian history language and culture for many years.
He is the only Western commentator to pronounce Putin’s name accurately.
I take him seriously.

Posted by: scepticalSOB | Jun 27 2023 21:35 utc | 64

Lukashenko’s speech on Pul Pervogo describing the events of Friday – interesting, perhaps even entertaining. Is there a transcription somewhere?

Posted by: Passerby | Jun 27 2023 21:36 utc | 65

ostro – I know many people who speak English as a second language and retain an accent throughout their lives. It doesn’t have much to do with how fluent they are. Some possess vocabularies greater than mine. Accent is not a great way to judge someone’s knowledge of a language. Even different regions of English speaking countries have different accents and terminology.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 27 2023 21:48 utc | 66

Large hit in Kramatorsk. In this video they are speaking to a wounded man in English—and the man aiding him appears to have a Rangers 3rd Battalion tattoo.
(graphic)
https://twitter.com/squatsons/status/1673803675062657025?s=46&t=iQi7fB-06urmjYsPOJ0ITw

Posted by: Gengar | Jun 27 2023 21:51 utc | 67

The situation at Antonov bridge worries me. It begins to look like Balaklia breakthrough in september 2022. The fact that Russians are unable to retain control of this small section tell a lot of the real capacity of their army. Wasn’t the Dniepr to be considered as a insurmountable barrier, which explain Kherson was abandoned ? Why don’t they use some FOAB on this ? Or an Avangard ? This situation could be even dealt with a small tactical nuke, that Putin won’t use for – u see – the LAW doesn’t allow this.
Our enemies, NATO included, don’t give a dam of these. They mean business with this war, like exploding their dam or using chemical weapons, and i don’t understand why we don’t make the same. In fact, we are going to lose this war because of Russia’s legalism.

Posted by: America is defeated | Jun 27 2023 22:05 utc | 68

Ian Kummer | Jun 27 2023 21:07 utc | 57
Agreed, nobody knew. A simple explanation is that Wagner PMC had reached dangerous levels of force over the times, threatening RF’s state monopoly of power. I see an analogy to Germany’s situation in 1934 (coincidence, 3 days, end of June), when the SA, NSDAP’s brown shirt paramilitary, had grown too strong for Hitler’s and his inner circle’s taste. SA was “pruned” (leadership murdered) in the Night of the Long Knives. Russia’s approach in 2023 appears somewhat more civilized: They decided to force all PMCs into contracts. Kadyrow agreed around two weeks before the Wagner coup. Prigozhin, apparently seeing his control over his empire dwindle, snapped according to his short temper. – Neither double, triple or whatever agent and three-letter agency involvement is needed to explain this inner-Russian purge.

Posted by: OttoE | Jun 27 2023 22:06 utc | 69

scepticalSOB no. 63
“He is the only Western commentator to pronounce Putin’s name accurately.”
I agree. And what does an Irish surname have to do with the way you speak Russian. (Or any other language)

Posted by: ThusspakeZarathustra | Jun 27 2023 22:09 utc | 70

-> ostro
-> scepticalSOB | Jun 27 2023 21:35 utc | 63
I’m not sure that makes any difference. he did study Russian history language and culture for many years.
Ray was a Russian language and history teacher in a high school, when there were a few ones in that period, that is why he ended up with CIA.
His Russian is better than any non-Russian Slavs speaking Russian.
He has no accent. Also, his German is good, with a proper pronunciation.
I know also know few older East Germans that speak flawless Russian.
So the point is one cannot judge how good someone speaks by nationality. It requires a good ear, and a lot of practice.

Posted by: whirlX | Jun 27 2023 22:28 utc | 71

Posted by: Neofeudalfuture | Jun 27 2023 17:35 utc | 6 ” but maybe ukraine will be able to expand the bridge head”
Yeah, to the next bridge a few kilometers away. That bridgehead is only sustainable by Ukraine if they keep the number of soldiers down to a handful of hundreds. I think it is mostly to make it more difficult For Russia to hit the city of Kherson.

Posted by: Tim2 | Jun 27 2023 22:28 utc | 72

Hmmmm
Posted by: Exile | Jun 27 2023 18:15 utc | 13
Right. Rolo Slavskiy makes a lot of statements including many opinions. It sounds like a NYT piece. First time I listen to him. Then I saw his articles published on unz.com and Unz was the first to point out some factual error in one of his pieces. So I need to find some way to double check what he says. Time will provide the answer eventually.

Posted by: Richard L | Jun 27 2023 22:33 utc | 73

I decided to hunt around Twitter to see what might appear. A hotel housing Ukie officers and Mercs was hit in Kramatorsk. Video posted at My Lord Bebo shows lots of troops wearing web gear, injured with 5th Ranger’s tattoos, and a soldier applying first aid wearing a helmet with a US flag attached to it. Audio suggests English being spoken is that of American Mercs or NATO on TDY.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 27 2023 22:35 utc | 74

More on Kramatorsk:
https://t.me/NovichokRossiya/34670
The enemy is preparing to throw large forces into a new offensive wave for the NATO summit…
https://t.me/NovichokRossiya/34668
No question there is a surge happening right now, counter offensive is far from over, Ukraine seems to have infinite men and resources, funny how the UKR calls Russians orks, for anyone familiar with TLOTR it’s exactly the opposite, in every way.
The west is not running out of weapons and ammo and from Kramatorsk images seems mercs aplenty, this is not ending soon. IMO the Russians will escalate soon, they’ll have no choice, the USA plan is definitely to wear down Surovikin’s defensive system at all cost, no price too high, they’ll keep at it till they break through in “Osgiliath”. So what’s RF’s next move?

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Jun 27 2023 22:36 utc | 75

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 27 2023 22:35 utc | 73
It wouldn’t be surprising if there are 50k Nato troops scattered all over the front. That in conjunction with the Zelensky’s Total War announcement means that men won’t be running around anytime soon. RU will be forced to give ground here and there.

Posted by: unimperator | Jun 27 2023 22:57 utc | 76

I may have missed it but I have seen no reference to Indian Punchline today. And Bhadrakumar’s take strikes me as being the most interesting that I’ve seen.
He puts the ‘coup’ in the context of the 100 year plus war that US capitalism has been waging against Russia- and Russia’s reaction as all of a piece with its constant awareness that there are always attempts to subvert and weaken it.
Specifically he links the nine hours wonder in Rostov with last year’s coup attempt in Kazakhstan and Russia’s swift squelching thereof.
It has been obvious to all here that, for several months now, the CEO of Wagner has been going off the rails: nobody anywhere gets away with the sort of nonsense that Proghozin has been pouring out into the media, unless the object of his increasingly unhinged attacks wants them to continue. He was being fed as much rope as needed not just to hang himself but others too.
And that is what is interesting- who were the ‘others’? Was he in touch with Ukrainian Nazis? Was he in touch with their NATO sponsors? How many others in Russia were involved?
In normal circumstances he would have been shut up- appeased, jailed, removed from social media, cashiered and replaced or dealt with in some other appropriate manner- as soon as his strike breaking in Bakhmut began. Instead he was given his head, encouraged to say more. And eventually allowed to go into what one assumes is secure exile/house arrest, from where he can be brought back to Russia to supply the missing pieces when the puzzle is assembled.
Which may or may not become public knowledge.

Posted by: bevin | Jun 27 2023 22:59 utc | 77

There will be no peace treaty, given the way that Putin and Russia were played with respect to the Minsk treaties…No one trusts the US any more, and the hardliners seem to have new clout after recent events..Russia will end this thing in the next year, or Putin will be out…

Posted by: pyrrhus | Jun 27 2023 23:10 utc | 78

My two cents on the Prigs’ Maskirovka angle are in:
1 – Motive. Paul Damascene came up with the notion of putschists trying to seize a nuclear-armed airfield. Now that is a point, and it gives sense to a possible mission which tries to smoke out the rats in Russia’s own ranks.
2 – Means. I certainly deem Moscow, as well as Putin himself, prepared to lie with a straight face; especially at a time of war. Maybe they’d prefer not to, I can’t tell – but they apparently do – ? ? – – I note that the “downed aviation” theme resembles the 9/11 airliner crash in Pennsylvania, fwiw. And Wagner getting a leftover military base in Belarus, as Lukashenko apparently offered, is quite the gift for such a rogue troupe, isn’t it? Now surely this needs a more solid argument to be convincing, but I don’t really have one that goes beyond pointing out the recent theatrics, including the drone incident, and that interesting law against a revisionist version on the beginnings of the great war in 1941 (the Suvorov-Schwipper hypothesis that was discussed in last week’s open thread).
So it’s a speculation.

Posted by: persiflo | Jun 27 2023 23:15 utc | 79

This is a response to a comment in a previous thread. I’ve repasted the comment below.
Ok, and what to you think are the respective strategic political motives for both parties, NATO and RF to this war?
Please don’t come with abstract humanitarian reasons, they belong into the sphere of propaganda. I want to hear real substantial state interests for both (!) sides on which you base your judgement/evaluation of this war.
Posted by: Arminius | Jun 27 2023 13:59 utc | 262
This is not sophisticated analysis. It’s just my opinion. Short answer is, main driver here is the Russian-Ukrainian conflict; NATO is secondary. What has made the war go on is that the Ukrainians are willing to fight. NATO and in particular the United States have been largely reactive. They don’t have a grand plan. And I don’t know what the Russian plan at the moment is. Not sure they have one, beyond hoping that, as Mr. Micawber would say, something will turn up.
Going into the war, Russia either wanted Ukraine to cease to exist or to be thoroughly integrated into the Russian sphere, and Ukraine wants to be integrated into the West. I think they’re really more interested in the EU than NATO, ultimately; they’d like the same kind of standard of living the Poles have achieved over the past 30 years, and they think getting integrated with Europe is the way to get there. But they’ve decided they can’t have the EU without the military umbrella. On the other side, Russian fear of NATO expansion is genuine, heartfelt, and understandable.
Claims that Ukraine is Nazi, or that Maidan was an American coup, are just propaganda IMO. And as Prigozhin admitted, Ukraine wasn’t trying to genocide the Donbass. Nor has the United States been executing some kind of master long-range war plan against Russia since 2014. NATO was definitely trying to upgrade Ukraine’s army between 2014 and 2022, but nothing the Ukrainians received before the Russian invasion gave them any kind of offensive capacity, especially against Russia.
War came in 2022 because Putin chose it. I think he expected a swift Russian conventional triumph, and I know that informed people in the West expected the same thing. Some barflies and some Western commentators have said that the US expected to fund a guerilla insurgency after the inevitable Russian conquest, which would have been cheap. I’m sure that’s right. The United States offered to evacuate Zelensky right after the invasion began. But…the Russian army turned out to be a lot less competent, and the Ukrainians a lot more motivated, than anyone expected. And Zelensky, with his “I need ammo, not a ride,” and the Ukrainians, with their brave initial resistance to a much better armed and equipped adversary, captivated popular opinion in the West. You don’t want to hear about humanitarian stuff, and that’s fine, but you have to understand that Russia’s invasion inspired deep, genuine popular revulsion. Which manifested itself in some shameful, silly ways, like kicking Russians out of performing arts groups if they wouldn’t denounce the war, but it also manifested itself in a lot of political pressure. Every day for months after the war began, the question from across the political spectrum in the United States to Biden was, “why aren’t you doing more for Ukraine?” And weapons began to pour in. There was a debate whether NATO should try to impose a no-fly zone in Ukraine – I’m sure that was warmly discussed in here. Luckily that idea was, uh, shot down, but it gives you an idea of what public opinion was like at the time.
I think after the initial Ukrainian successes there was a period of euphoria, a belief that the Russians might just give up. By summer 2022 it was clear that wasn’t happening, and people realized that the shift of the war to the East and the shift to a more static, artillery-heavy war was to the Russians’ advantage. And like everything in the politically dysfunctional United States, the conflict eventually became culture-war and partisan fodder. But don’t be fooled: supporting Ukraine, including with weapons, remains the majority view in the US. If inflation had continued the way it was going, maybe support would have eroded more, but it didn’t.
The main thing that has changed in terms of NATO support is that the lethality and cost of the weapons has increased, and now includes MBTs and F-16s. Why? Not sure, but several possibilities. One is probably impatience. This war means a lot more to Ukraine than to Russia, but it means a lot more to Russia than it does to the West. Another is a belief that, despite the gibes about fighting to the last Ukrainian, you don’t just want to help Ukraine continue to fight a defensive battle on the current lines. You have to help them to win, or at least persuade the Russians to seek peace on acceptable terms.

Posted by: zinjanthropus | Jun 27 2023 23:15 utc | 80

Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Jun 27 2023 22:36 utc | 74
Keep on doing what they’ve been doing, Ukraine have only dented the forward defensive screen, which probably was expected to fall back after D+3-4, not still be fighting on D+20. No, Ukraine do not have infinite reserves, they are burning through the troops who should have been committed to assaulting, breaching and exploiting the first main defensive line. They probably have committed the bulk of their operational reserves and are heavily dipping into their strategic reserve. Why is this important? It means when, not if, they come close to reaching offensive equilibrium they are very vulnerable to any Russian counter-offensive, or more likely offensive. Secondly, the longer the Ukrainians maintain the offensive tempo the more their forces suffer attrition (critical with regards to their parlous recovery and repair capabilities) exhaustion (this isn’t an RTS with a replenishing fatigue bar) and ammunition shortages.
If this was LOTR the forces of Mordor are still battling outside the Black Gates; however, analogies aside, referring to your opponent as sub-human is probably one of the stupidest psychological moves one can make as it is ultimately self-defeating.

Posted by: Milites | Jun 27 2023 23:16 utc | 81

After 20 days of mayhem a few fields and barns have been captured. Not one major settlement or defensive line. Berletic of the new atlas expected that at least one defensive line would have been breached by now.

Posted by: Oh | Jun 27 2023 23:25 utc | 82

Personally, I’m half expecting that there will now be an increase in pressure on Ukraine to ratchet up its attacks, both in intensity and range.
Because in the West they might be feeding into their abomination of a calculus a combination of their hopes and desperation driven needs that have been distilled down into an equation, and the resulting Garbage In Garbage Out is being held up high as a rationale for going all in on “taking out Putin, now that he’s been weakened”.
In the corridors of power of the West, that could be what passes for a military strategy.

Posted by: Babel-17 | Jun 27 2023 23:31 utc | 83

Incidentally Prighozin was sounding off about corruption and people dipping their beaks at the MOD, whereas it appears he was one of the main participants with contracts which he was fearing to lose.

Posted by: Oh | Jun 27 2023 23:36 utc | 84

US Army Rangers Third Battalion merc hit in Kramatorsk?

An interesting tattoo on the arm of one of the “tourists” from the Kramatorsk strike earlier today.
https://t.me/DDGeopolitics/71086

Today there was a strike in Kramatorsk and let me just say that’s a lot of English for eastern Ukraine.
Most are saying foreign mercenaries.
https://t.me/CyberspecNews/34529

Posted by: SattaMassaGana | Jun 27 2023 23:37 utc | 85

Posted by: zinjanthropus | Jun 27 2023 23:15 utc | 79
You make the following fallacies:
-Ukraine is a monolithic state
-“Ukraine” is willing to fight
-Nato has no plan or participation in Ukraine
-Russia has no plan
-Ukraine’s ATO didn’t try to genocide RU ethnics
-Zelensky is an independent actor
-“Biden” is an independent actor
-Maidan was all natural occurrence
-The western “opinion” is natural occurrence
What can I tell you.
Ukraine is not monolithic, it’s divided into ethnic RU speakers on one side, and Galician banderists on the other side. The US state department coup gave power to the latter, which started persecuting the former. In 2014-2015 there were a lot more referendums to gain independence/join RU which Putin disregarded, excluding Crimea.
Ukraine is willing to fight? Zelensky says there are endless queues to the enlistment office. The truth is people dragged off the street or resorts and thrown into the back of an unmarked van by lawless thugs. Contrary to what western pundits think, it is AFU using human wave tactics, very well seen now on Zaporozhye fronts and elsewhere. They use conscripts to fill in the gaps and buy time so they can train a few extras in Nato countries, which can potentially hold coherency together for a while longer.
AFU is 100 % Nato proxy. Some Nato general in UK or US makes or their plans and goals, Nato arms and trains everything. AFU buys time in the front with pre-mentioned conscription method who are thrown to the front to fill in the gaps.
Russia plan is debatable, no one really knows what’s going to happen, but most likely AFU/Ukraine will get completely crushed within a few years time along with everything Nato decided to commit there.
Arestovich, Zelensky’s advisor said the Ukraine (Kiev regime, controlled by Mrs. Nuland from the US state department) ATO operation was 100% illegal under both Ukrainian law and international law. Since they bombarded randomly Donbass and Lugansk population centers with the aim of creating terror and chaos probably with the purpose of ethnic cleansing due to hatred of Galician Banderists toward eastern Ukrainian ethnic Russian people and on the other hand due to US strategy of proxy-provocation.
Zelensky is 100% under US state department or UK control. If the entire budget of Ukraine comes from either US or its vassal EU, and all the other funding and arms. You think they are doing it just because?
You say “Biden” says this or that. Everything was preplanned and Biden decides nothing, it’s all his neocon pals that are actually ex Obama officials.
Maidan was a US funded and organized color revolution, organized by US think tanks, NGOs and pre-installed opposition. It was EXTREMELY violent at that. Similar color revolution attempts have been dismantled in Belarus and Kazakhstan.
The western opinion is just a circle jerk of western MSM and western think tanks. They present what they are told to present. The western media is 100% non-independent nowadays.

Posted by: unimperator | Jun 27 2023 23:41 utc | 86

ostro # 18:37 utc | 20

Anyone heard of the whereabouts of Prigozin, or his closest gang members?

I will let you know after my next zoom chat with my Palestine buddies 😉

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Jun 27 2023 23:44 utc | 87

unimperator | Jun 27 2023 22:57 utc | 75–
Thanks for your reply. All those men running around with their web gear on but without anything else I found rather odd, but it does tell us what sort of troops they are–Front Line Troops, not instructors or rear area MFs who don’t wear that gear cause it gets in the way of them performing their duties. So as assumed, Kramatorsk is an assembly area that Russia will only target with similar precision strikes since the town’s also full of civilians as the vids also showed.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 27 2023 23:47 utc | 88

to zinjanthropus | Jun 27 2023 23:15 utc | 79 …
That “analysis” is such overall cobblers — though carefully contrived — as to not be worth refuting point by point. A rehashed compendium of NATO propaganda and denials throughout (at least) this century. Next time, do ask Wallace, Ellwood, Cleverly, Blinken or whoever for a more original script.

Posted by: Cynic | Jun 28 2023 0:00 utc | 89

@ unimperator | Jun 27 2023 23:41 utc | 85
thanks for that, although i am not sure if it is possible to convince someone who is so thoroughly brainwashed..

Posted by: james | Jun 28 2023 0:01 utc | 90

When officials in Washington, even the highest ones, hand out to the public statements about events in Russia and Ukraine which are not true, which are in fact outright nonsense, which they must think serves some purpose, do they believe in the nonsense they are selling?
— Russia is crumbling, civil war has begun, Ukraine is winning —- etc.
If they do then it is hard to understand how they have achieved high office since they are so stupid. However some DO realize what they are saying is contrary to reality. Obviously they are expecting personal reward for their duplicity.
are they all so depraved? I am inclined to think so.

Posted by: medo | Jun 28 2023 0:06 utc | 91

I visited Rybar for the first time to see what it had to say about the current situation. Lots of positional battles as a result of the big push made in tandem with Prigozhin’s revolt that have resulted in a few very small gains likely at great cost as usual. More evidence that those hit in Kramatorsk were USA Rangers. That’s all for now.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 28 2023 0:07 utc | 92

Posted by: unimperator | Jun 27 2023 23:41 utc
Thanks for that excellent and brief summary in response to one of the barfleas. Its important to repeat the history of events like that.

Posted by: Wisco | Jun 28 2023 0:08 utc | 93

Posted by: unimperator | Jun 27 2023 23:41 utc | 85
Thank you.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | Jun 28 2023 0:23 utc | 94

Posted by: Richard L | Jun 27 2023 17:53 utc | 9
“Rolo Slavskiy” is a CIA shill like 99% of “Russian nationalist” etc. media.

Posted by: Ree | Jun 28 2023 0:25 utc | 95

bevin@76 …the US proper, never had a beef with Russia, in referencing the US Vulture Capitalists perhaps the reference is to the buck toofed Plymouth Rockers from across the pond. Now they have a beef with Russia.
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Jun 28 2023 0:25 utc | 96

I see barflies/barfleas continue to misrepresent the context of the Ukraine SMO
Humanity is in a civilization war between the God Of Mammon cult with its zombie acolytes and the growing China/Russia axis.
To Russia, the SMO is existential. To most of the 101st chairborne I read here, the Ukraine conflict is about Hollywood lipsticked Western values and Rules Based Order localized to Ukraine and the EU.
Putin has made it clear that the goals of the Ukraine SMO are focused on taking down the bully of empire. The same bully that is threatening China and all those other nations that don’t abide the bully’s ways.
Russia’s methods are slow and methodical which is in existential conflict with the Might-Makes-Right approach of empire…..if empire doesn’t nuke or bio-chemical us all to death THE MEEK SHALL INHERIT THE EARTH!
Get use to it. Human merit will replace inheritance as key to social leadership

Posted by: psychohistorian | Jun 28 2023 0:34 utc | 97

bevin # 22:59 utc | 76

I may have missed it but I have seen no reference to Indian Punchline today. And Bhadrakumar’s take strikes me as being the most interesting that I’ve seen.

Thank you, I am not surprised by Bhadrakumar’s assessment and informed surmise. It was indeed a good read and I found his link at the very conclusion to be equally informative of the real circumstance in the UKraine:

But, not for long. For, what lies ahead is the manifestation of the steely resolve of the Kremlin — and Putin himself — to seek an all-out military solution to the Ukraine crisis. Putin declared last week — most likely in anticipation of the storm brewing on the horizon — that the war will be over when no Ukrainian army will be left on the battlefield, or NATO weapons.
Read the official transcript of a videoconference that Putin took last Thursday, in the immediate run-up to Prigozhin’s coup attempt, with the full quorum of the Security Council (post-Soviet Russia’s ‘Politburo’), which gives a flavour of the mood in the Kremlin and will provide some clues to what to expect on the battlefields of Ukraine, going forward. It is a huge signal in advance to the “collective West” that nothing will be forgotten.

This short public introductory extract from their proceedings gives an insight to the detailed analytical approach they are taking and the closing words from Putin emphasising caution until the majority of the UKraine arsenal including western weaponry is exhausted.
Just as with Prigozhin so with Ukraine, they watch and listen, they research and accumulate data. They consider their intelligence and historic data of arsenal contents from all of the soviet states from pre 1990’s. Clearly Russia has a formidable intelligence and diplomatic capacity stretching well into the past and informing their current strategy for intended victory today.
And they are not about to waste the effort given by their dead and maimed soldiers and citizens in the past ten years and particularly 500 days.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Jun 28 2023 0:48 utc | 98

i read indian punchline yesterday… i suppose i assume others keep up and read these types of websites, but i am probably wrong..

Posted by: james | Jun 28 2023 1:00 utc | 99

psychohistorian # 0:34 utc | 96

THE MEEK SHALL INHERIT THE EARTH!
Get use to it. Human merit will replace inheritance as key to social leadership

🙂 Indeed THE MEEK HAVE INHERITED THE EARTH
and right now they are clearing out the fraudsters who tried to steal their inheritance. I get that it is an ongoing process but Prigozhin is now stuffed, so there is progress.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Jun 28 2023 1:00 utc | 100