Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
May 6, 2023
Ukraine SitRep: Bakhmut – Prigozhin – Counteroffensive

Some 10% of Bakhmut/Aryomovsk, with two distinct areas, are still in Ukrainian hands.


bigger

The northern area consists of single dwellings amongst gardens and trees. The southern area is full of high-rises with little green in between.


bigger

Yesterday the head of the Wagner mercenaries Yevgeny Prigozhin published a video. Standing in front of a number of dead corpses he publicly attacked the Russian minister of defense over an alleged lack of ammunition. He claimed that it had caused those casualties. A day before those troops had tried to further penetrate the upper area and got caught in an ambush. Bad for them but not a cause of serious concern.

'Western' media like to see such Prigozhin tirades as a sign of infighting within the Russian military apparatus. I have long stopped to listen to Prigozhin. Militarily the Wagner troops are just a part of the Russian army and under its command. Prigozhin's concern is marketing for his Wagner enterprise and for the large share he receives from the monthly bill his company sends to the Russian Ministry of Defense. Politically there is no roll for him.

That his claims of lack of ammunition had been just a show was proven some 12 hours after he published his video.

Here are drone shots of the Bakhmut high-rises still in Ukrainian hands after the received a visit by incendiary missiles.


bigger

The same view in infrared. The white spots are burning hot.


bigger

Video of the attack can be seen here and here.

So there is your lack of ammunition. Anything that was outside of the high-rises, trucks, soldiers and supplies, was likely destroyed.

Prigozhin troops have been in the fight for quite some time. They need some rest and will soon move out. The Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov admonished Prigozhin for his public stunt. If needed his troops will replace the Wagners and finish the Bakhmut fight. Meanwhile the attention will move to a different front.


bigger

The long announced Ukrainian counter-offensive will probably start on Victory Day, May 9. One axis of the attack will be in the Zaporizhia region towards south in an attempt to reach the sea. But the first important aim is likely the retaking of the Zaporizhia Nuclear Power Plant near the city of Enerhodar south of the Dnieper basin. Its economic importance to Ukraine is immense as it can easily sell the electricity the six reactors generate to Europe. There is little other income the Ukraine still has.

The Russian military has asked civilians in 17 towns within 50 kilometer (30 miles) of the current frontline to evacuate the area. The Russian army has also prepared defense lines and moved reserves to the south of the region.

The success of the Ukrainians will depend on the gadgets its 'western' supporters have supplied it with. We may see some unexpected weapons or longer range missiles in the field. There is likely also some new bridging equipment that will help with crossing the Dnieper in the Kherson region for a secondary axis. A third axis, or perhaps a diversion, in the northeast towards Soledar is also possible.

The first days of the new fight will be confusing with lots of false claims and propaganda from both sides. We will all have to sit back and wait until the fog of war rises enough to paint a picture of the new situation.

Comments

Posted by: Greg Galloway | May 7 2023 10:10 utc | 306
It’s not propaganda among the chattering classes that’s going to change the UK.
It’s chattering teeth among the fuel impoverished that will cause a political upheaval.

Posted by: GT Stroller | May 7 2023 10:39 utc | 301

OohCanada | May 7 2023 10:19 utc | 308
The Russians stole Crimea… from what. Nazism? Genocide? US had building tenders put out for Sevastopol. The killings at the trade union building in Crimea had already occurred.
Crimean’s were not interested in becoming crispy critters in a nazi BBQ.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | May 7 2023 10:42 utc | 302

Odessa not Crimea…

Posted by: Peter AU1 | May 7 2023 10:43 utc | 303

Posted by: Greg Galloway | May 7 2023 10:31 utc | 310
The Kremlin does not like the Donbass rebellion and has fought it from day one (oligarchs vs commies). Now trying to swallow it and digest it.

Whilst feeding the ‘independent republics’ militias to the frontline of the slowSMO.
Cynical isn’t it?

Posted by: GT Stroller | May 7 2023 10:44 utc | 304

A reasoned and detailed discussion of the Prigozhin interview with WarGonzo and a critique of certain utoob commenters by The Slavland Chronicles.
Here are the significant points made by Prigozhin in this volatile interview.

General Mizintsev was fired because he gave too much ammo to Prigozhin
But, also, it could be the complete opposite and actually the two hated each other
Prigozhin might be getting too big for his britches and becoming a loose cannon
And that’s about it. That is his entire summary of the Prigozhin interview.
But here are the relevant points that Prigozhin brought up that I reported on:
The SMO proved that the Russian army is totally demoralized, unorganized, untrained, undisciplined and unprepared
The MoD routinely lies about realities on the battlefield even about Wagner’s operations
The military command gives bizarre orders to its men
There is no real leadership in the army
Russia has the resources to win, but the leadership keeps the resources away from the people who need it on purpose
Lower level officers are pressured to lie to higher-ups because everyone will get in trouble if they don’t
Mentally-ill people in the command believed in saving funds and supplies for a later attack, but this decision was eventually reversed
Prigozhin says he knows where the supplies are being kept, there are enough supplies to fight another half-year
MoD Deputy in charge of supplies Aleksei Krivoruchka has to be fired
On paper, the Russian Army has soldiers on Wagner’s flanks, but they are not there in reality
Prigozhin believes this is a political sabotage campaign directed at Wagner
Wagner has been cut-off from supplies. Their representatives are sitting 4 days in line to get an appointment from the bureaucracy
The KGB stands for Club of Senile Grandpas (in Russian this acronym works) or the Club of Emotional Midgets
The KGB hates Russia. All their mistresses live good lives in the West so what do they care about the war. They demand that the officers lie to them and only tolerate nice-sounding lies.
The Russian army has been transformed from the world’s second-best army into one of the worst – Russia cannot even deal with Ukraine
Russia’s defenses won’t hold if supplies are not released to the soldiers
Prigozhin reaffirms that political intrigue is what prevents the release of these supplies
Prigozhin wants to launch a federal investigation into the corrupt officials responsible for this and the blood that they have on their hands
Prigozhin keeps a list of the thousands of Russian deaths caused by the MoD
Poor medicine leads to more deaths
Bakhmut could have been taken if Shoigu had given them their supplies
Wagner might have to retreat unless they don’t get supplies
Time to tell the truth and stop lying to the Russian people
Wagner’s intelligence says that they have spies, satellites, the whole works and according to their information, the Ukrainian threat is very real and can reach the Russia-proper border with the forces that they have
Wagner takes the opinions and analyses of their soldiers seriously, the Russian Military, in contrast, treats its soldiers like trash
Interviewer: “are you a demoralization agent?”
Prigozhin: the Russian people need to know because they will have to pay in blood for this. The bureaucrats will simply flee to the West. They are the ones afraid of the truth
Prigozhin asks why Russia continues to sell oil to the West through India? Says this is treachery. The elites in Russia are in secret negotiations with the Western elite. [A word-for-word Strelkov talking point].

He then gives his blunt assessment:

Now, compare and contrast and ask yourselves: did you hear any of these points brought up in Mercouris’ analysis of the interview? Would you say that Mercouris provided an accurate or thorough overview of the main topic of his talk if he did not include any of the main points that Prigozhin brought up? Because it seems to me that Mercouris appeared to be giving an overview of this bombshell interview and yet did not even address any of the absolutely INCREDIBLE allegations that Prigozhin lobbed at the MoD, the FSB and the oligarchy.
There is something strange going on here, folks. A conspiracy of silence, perhaps.
I have to ask: is this deliberate? Does Mercouris not speak Russian and so missed all the important bits about treachery, sabotage, imminent catastrophe? Or did he think that this wasn’t relevant or interesting enough to report on?
Another question that I have for these people is why they do not simply work for Russian state media? I mean, their talking points are identical to Russian state media. How anyone can call them an alternative media project then can only be explained by a complete misunderstanding of terms. Yes, Russian state media is an alternative to Western state media, but is it “alternative” in the sense that it presents a non-state-affiliated point of view?

The report is comprehensive and includes the Mercouris utoob report.
Here is Pepe Escobar’s report at Strategic Culture following that interview .

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 7 2023 10:49 utc | 305

Whilst feeding the ‘independent republics’ militias to the frontline of the slowSMO.
Cynical isn’t it?
Posted by: GT Stroller | May 7 2023 10:44 utc | 314
Embrace who you cannot kill.

Posted by: Greg Galloway | May 7 2023 10:55 utc | 306

uncle tungsten | May 7 2023 10:49 utc | 315
We wait and watch. Everything has been going bad for Wagner since the west first talked about pulling out of Bakhmut.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | May 7 2023 10:56 utc | 307

Posted by: OohCanada | May 7 2023 10:19 utc | 308
I suggest you read a History of Crimea from at least 1783……..your assertions contain factual inaccuracies and historical aberrations

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 7 2023 11:17 utc | 308

The SMO proved that the Russian army is totally demoralized, unorganized, untrained, undisciplined and unprepared
The MoD routinely lies about realities on the battlefield even about Wagner’s operations
The military command gives bizarre orders to its men
There is no real leadership in the army
Russia has the resources to win, but the leadership keeps the resources away from the people who need it on purpose.

You mean there are wars where such things do not happen ?
I am astounded. I have not seen great historical examples of it being otherwise………then again all human endeavour is bedevilled with human agency

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 7 2023 11:19 utc | 309

crispy critters
Not sure you refer to Odessa but those people did not die in a fire……..
They were murdered – by gunshot and a pregnant woman was strangled with an electrical cord at a desk
The fire was set to cover the evidence of the crime
Those who escaped from windows were clubbed to death outside

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 7 2023 11:22 utc | 310

Stalin went AWOL for a long time when Germany invaded the Soviet Union. When he did return to command he kept insisting that the remaining infantry and tanks be hurled into wasteful attacks against well positioned Germans covered by the Luftwaffe. The Russian troops were annihilated in suicidally reckless assaults that barely grazed German units.
@Posted by: Inkan1969 | May 7 2023 2:34 utc | 198
Nobody who cares about the lives of people would ever say they need a Stalin, under any circumstance. The Soviets didn’t need any Stalin to win WW2. They were motivated to defend their homeland and themselves against an enemy devoted to annihilate them. They didn’t need a totalitarian despot to motivate them.
Without the mass industrialization of the USSR driven by Stalin in the 1930s the USSR would not have stood a chance, it would have been a rerun of WW1 with the same outcome. I agree that Russia does not need a Stalin, Putin is doing a good job given the circumstances, but there is no need for ridiculous historical revisionism.
Posted by: Roger | May 7 2023 2:49 utc | 209
Russia could have done without Stalin on several levels. Not that Trotsky would have been better. The who,e Revolution was a disaster.

Posted by: Wokechoke | May 7 2023 11:29 utc | 311

@Peter #312
Russia took Crimea before the trade Union thing unfolded, they also funded and supported a group that were killing Ukrainians.
It does not make what unfolded in Odessa okay but it does help explain why a few idiots thought they were dealing with Russian spies.
The west and Nato decided to flood the place with Nazi idiots to use as cannon fodder, most Ukrainian people have their own problems and want nothing to do with this poop sandwich.
Ukraine is allowed to build whatever it wants for whomever they want, that does not give anyone the right to murder them.
Do I understand why Russia is doing what they are doing? Absolutely. But I also understand why Ukraine is fighting back.
This isn’t the “good fight” it’s greed and a power struggle.

Posted by: OohCanada | May 7 2023 11:29 utc | 312

In response to karlof1@155,
Johnson’s closing argument isn’t internally consistent, since it is premised on juxtaposing narratives which the author clearly believes are fictitious. If you have supposed Kremlin-backed subterfuge about ammo shortages on one hand, and Western narratives of Russian authoritarianism crushing all dissenting voices on the other, using either one to support the other breaks the argument by validating what is presented as a false claim.
Basically, Larry ends up arguing either that Russia actually does silence all criticism (at least, that Prigozhin’s statements should warrant that sort of response) or that Prigozhin’s statements are true, and not part of a concerted disinformation campaign. I’m surprised a smart guy like Larry would set himself up like that.
Personally, I think this information campaign is part of an effort to restructure the armed forces chain of command even further. Perhaps it has less to do with Prigozhin himself and more to do with individual ambitions of combat officers concerning the ministry of defense, or perhaps conceptual disputes regarding structural dogma in the mod bureaucracy.
I don’t believe a relocation of the Wagner PMC’s to Africa warranted this sort of incendiary media campaign, nor that it somehow influenced Ukrainian troops to ignore battlefield realities in favor of constructed narratives. This media campaign seems to me to have been designed to influence Russian society first and foremost, in order to create public pressure as a resource to tip the scales in some sort of argument with the ministry of defense. What that argument concerns and whether a compromise or concession will be achieved as a result of this is a different story, but I interpret this as a matter of political, not military, utility.
Also, as a side-note, Khodorkovsky and others like him, who maintain or act as fronts for rather limited internet-based influence operations, are shrewd or stingy with money and are thus concerned with getting the most out of their investments. For this reason, paid commentators are kept fairly sparse in low-impact seasons, and then get ramped up during high-impact seasons.
9’th of May is fast approaching, as is the Ukrainian offensive, allegedly. We’ve had a rather lame drone-strike on the Kremlin, a few strikes on oil facilities, a couple of bomb assassination attempts in short succession, almost daily drone-related news — this is now an opportune moment to demoralize those who support Russian objectives in Ukraine and internationally, both in the Russian segment of the internet and in the relatively few other segments that have a more somber view of geopolitics.
Simply put, expect more paid-for commentary wherever comment-sections haven’t yet been locked or regulated to death. Not to imply that anyone here at the bar is getting paid to present news and views which aren’t their own, heaven forbid. Even the friendly milf-lady is sharing herself out of the kindness of her heart, I’m sure.

Posted by: Skiffer | May 7 2023 11:37 utc | 313

Deplorable Commissar is right. Nazi or National SOCIALISM is not an appropriate term. We should talk about NALI instead of NAZI, with the LI of (neo)liberalism. The West Ukrainian extremists call themselves “integral nationalists”. That was developped by Dontsov (1883-1973) even before the term “fascism” was coined in Italy. Hitlers national SOCIALISM was socialist in the sense that there was free health care, invalidity benefits, old age pensions for Germans. In 404 nothing of that sort anymore: zero contract hours, unexisting social security, commodification of everything (soil, water, human blood, organs, surrogate mothers, child traficking..), massive looting of assets by foreign predators. The Iranian journalist Mazaheri calls it NALI, combination of “extreme NAtionalism” and “neoLIberalism” in its degenerate late phase.

Posted by: Teraspol | May 7 2023 11:37 utc | 314

308.
Crimea was illegally annexed by Ukraine in 1995 against the will of the population.
It’s find to have an opinion but let’s be clear it’s not one supported by facts.
I also like making things up. I shot down a Kinzhal today with my slingshot.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | May 7 2023 11:44 utc | 315

Posted by: OohCanada | May 7 2023 11:29 utc | 322
Current Ukrainian regime is clearly undemocratic.
Election were held while 8 Million ukrainians disenfrenchised (Crimea Lugansk, Donetsk oblasts)
Now there’s only one party in Rada.
If one removed Lvov, Lutsk, Chernovitsi oblasts which were forcibly added to Ukraine SSR in 45, you would find some rump Ukraine remaining which is divided between russian as mother tongue people and ukrainian dialect as mother tongue roughly in the middle.
This makes good for some civil war in which for the sake of obvious interests NATO as well as Russia support sides.

Posted by: Greg Galloway | May 7 2023 11:45 utc | 316

322.
Incorrect again. The Nazis you apparently support because Russians are bad mmkay have been murdering eastern Ukrainians since 2014.
Your view is incorrect and unsupported by facts. Historians of the future aren’t going to be writing the NATO story you are selling here, but what actually happened.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | May 7 2023 11:46 utc | 317

The most telegraphed offensive in history is about to begin. An offensive without air superiority into the teeth of dug in Russian defenses. What could go wrong….
Posted by: JustAMaverick | May 6 2023 18:54 utc | 46
Just watched an analysis from German TV including an ex-general who went on and on about how well the Ukrainians did in Kherson and that a similar scenario might unfold in the South … without mentioning that a) the Kherson area defense was minimal – and the attack effectively caused the part-mobilization, which has now come to bear fruit and 500k soldiers are not at the frontiers. So not only that, but b) also that the southern areas have by now been prepared by trenches, mines, equipment, and staffed. And even worse, for an army general, he c) fully ignored the fact that Russia has full air power over the battle terrain and no matter what wonder-tanks and APCs Ukraine is throwing into the fray, they will be food and drink to glide-/bombs, drones, missiles, and air strikes. It’s not that Russian has no recon drones and satellites ready and watching …

Posted by: CM of Berlin | May 7 2023 11:47 utc | 318

Posted by: Teraspol | May 7 2023 11:37 utc | 324
Should be called XNALI for extreme…
Or even easier : “Piracy”.

Posted by: Greg Galloway | May 7 2023 11:49 utc | 319

Also it should be noted Ukraine is deeply Nazi. The OUN that the CIA has been funding since the end of WW2 has at its core a Nazi ideology.
Believe whatever you want, but you don’t have a right to your own facts. Truth is not subjective.
Why don’t you look up the Nazi Ukrainian monument in Canada dedicated to the Galician division.
You might learn something, eh.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | May 7 2023 11:50 utc | 320

@ paul greenwood.. thanks for your posts, especially the one @ 300..
@ passerby..
typepad is not set up to allow this option.. it has been mentioned here for years..

Posted by: james | May 7 2023 11:52 utc | 321

Teraspol: Good enough, although you succumb to the fallacious notion that there was anything meaningfully socialist in the Third Reich’s “national socialism.” Health insurance, pensions, etc? All implemented by Bismarck to take wind out of the sails of the socialist movement.
It’s true that one prominent Nazi had socialist leanings. That was Ernst Röhm. He and his gang were murdered because of it (and to make the likes of Krupp and IG Farben happy)—treason and gay sex were just the pretexts.
Nazi socialism can be summed up in various halfhearted KdF projects, the most notable of which were some North Sea resort monstrosities and the much-promised-and-never-delivered KdF-Wagen, which with a dew tweaks was mass produced postwar as the VW Beetle.

Posted by: malenkov | May 7 2023 11:55 utc | 322

Then you have the realization our governments are funding the Nazi side of this civil war as undeclared participants and…that leads to many other pessimistic insights.
I myself have decided our governments are traitorous cretins in thrall to the United States.
But do go on believing we are fighting the good fight shoving our snout into a bloody civil war. Im mean we are virtuous good guys over here amirite?.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | May 7 2023 11:56 utc | 323

@ 330 doc 11..
you are right.. maybe someone can pull up the pic of crystia frreland in front of the oun flag which had been shown on cbc, until they took it down… optics being everything….

Posted by: james | May 7 2023 11:56 utc | 324

Per Intel Slava Z all roads to Artemovsk are cut off. Only access is across a wide open field under fire.
Prigozgin says he has been promised everything Wagner needs.

Posted by: Mary | May 7 2023 12:32 utc | 325

prigozhin. says”…………as the stomach turns….. a soap opera coming your way, lol..

Posted by: james | May 7 2023 12:42 utc | 326

@Julian #355
Your neighbor stealing your beach front property because it was his in the past is going to piss a lot off people off. The majority does not want war and could care less about who owns what. But the majority does not rule.
Russia lost a major trade partner and all it’s influence in Ukraine so it kicked in the door and started looting

Posted by: OohCanada | May 7 2023 12:42 utc | 327

Posted by: CM of Berlin | May 7 2023 11:47 utc | 328
Just watched an analysis from German TV including an ex-general who went on and on about how well the Ukrainians did in Kherson and that a similar scenario might unfold in the South … without mentioning that a) the Kherson area defense was minimal – and the attack effectively caused the part-mobilization, which has now come to bear fruit and 500k soldiers are not at the frontiers. So not only that, but b) also that the southern areas have by now been prepared by trenches, mines, equipment, and staffed. And even worse, for an army general, he c) fully ignored the fact that Russia has full air power over the battle terrain

They get away with this because people have no clue. I know people (we probably all do) who whole-heartedly believe that “Ukraine is winning”. I’d like to say that it will be interesting to watch how the narrative is going to change… but we’ve seen that often enough, and it won’t be interesting. Ukraine simply and quickly replaced by something else.
This has probably been mentioned before on MoA but can’t hurt to do it again: tomorrow is the day of victory/liberation/capitulation/shame in Germany, depending on your values (liberation for me). Last year, German authorities forbade showing Russian and Ukrainian flags; I don’t know if the Soviet banner was allowed. This year, Russian is verboten, Ukrainian allowed. Looks like it won’t be too long until “Red Army liberated Germany” is officially (as in: speeches, school books) replaced by “Red Army teamed up with Wehrmacht and occupied/pillaged/raped Eastern Europe; US & Allies liberated Europe and Auschwitz”. And people I know and like get distracted and sedated with the coronation nonsense.

Posted by: Konami | May 7 2023 12:43 utc | 328

335, 339 — UNDRIP belongs in your conversation
MK Bhadrakumar just posted a stunning Tweet regarding Prigozhin:
https://twitter.com/BhadraPunchline/status/1655114792443543553
Makes me wonder where Kadyrov and the Chechens fit in all that?

Posted by: Bruised Northerner | May 7 2023 12:51 utc | 329

Karlof1 @113
Thanks for your very thoughtful reply.
I wonder if you have any additional thoughts on the inclusion of this term ‘EuroPacific’…?

Posted by: Paul Damascene | May 7 2023 12:56 utc | 330

Ukraine is finished without direct NATO intervention, Mr. Lackey. The question is how fast, not if.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | May 7 2023 12:57 utc | 331

339.
Your postings are the quivalent of a child sticking his fingers in his ears and shouting I can’t hear you.
Everyone knows the narrative you are spinning, it’s the deceptive one of half truths and outright lies peddled by the media since 2021. A apparent collective case of amnesia has fallen over Western media..how convenient.
What I am telling you is not mere assertion – as you have done – but cold hard truth like a concrete floor.

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | May 7 2023 13:00 utc | 332

Such a tortured world is in the west, convoluted and outright crazy nowadays…
We do not not know about the daily logistics of SMO, only what we are about to glimpse from MSM and then interpretations ( big question-marks there). I am grateful to b. and especially karlof for trying to reveal us the bigger picture.
Here is the movie by Stone about the recent re-starting of all this, Ukraine on fire:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IwZApPCFXIc
Some time ago I watched the docu about Putin, it was named ‘The Statesman’, can not find it anymore, guess it was scrubbed.
Pity.

Posted by: stranger | May 7 2023 13:00 utc | 333

Just watched an analysis from German TV including an ex-general who went on and on about how well the Ukrainians did in Kherson and that a similar scenario might unfold in the South … without mentioning that a) the Kherson area defense was minimal – and the attack effectively caused the part-mobilization, which has now come to bear fruit and 500k soldiers are not at the frontiers. So not only that, but b) also that the southern areas have by now been prepared by trenches, mines, equipment, and staffed. And even worse, for an army general, he c) fully ignored the fact that Russia has full air power over the battle terrain and no matter what wonder-tanks and APCs Ukraine is throwing into the fray, they will be food and drink to glide-/bombs, drones, missiles, and air strikes. It’s not that Russian has no recon drones and satellites ready and watching …
Posted by: CM of Berlin | May 7 2023 11:47 utc | 328

That isn’t even correct.
It was eastern Kharkov region where the Russians didn’t have adequate defenses. Kherson they could have held if they wanted to — they had only lost about 10 kilometers in the north of the region, which was indeed because of inadequate manpower, but that did shorten the front and helped with the manpower issue, and when they pulled out Ukraine was still very far away from Kherson city itself. Ukrainian armor was being straight up genocided there by the regular Russian army. It could have been defended for a very long time, and this was before they even rolled out the glide bombs.
But again, the effort was not even made.
This is the fear here — yes, Russia can defend the Zaporozhye if it wants to and steamroll the Ukies. But what kind of treason has the political leadership committed this time that will result in another goodwill gesture and a retreat without a fight? We have no way of knowing.
Remember that on the 11th Ukraine and Russian will be negotiating over the ammonia export that goes through the pipeline from TogliattiAzot to Odessa. How are you going to sit on the same table with the people who just attacked the Kremlin and are about to launch a large-scale offensive against Russian territory over something so pedestrian as ammonia exports???
That tells you all you need to know about where things stand.
P.S. I used to be sneeringly dismissive of the various Western military bozos claiming how the Ukrainians will inflict defeats on Russia, recover Kherson, etc. But them Russia just retreated without a fight, and they turned out to be correct. So if the same people are claiming they will recover Crimea, that is to be taken seriously. Of course they have no chance to do it militarily in a real serious confrontation. But is there going to be one, or are there going to be more acts of treason?

Posted by: shadowbanned | May 7 2023 13:12 utc | 334

Your neighbor stealing your beach front property because it was his in the past is going to piss a lot off people off. The majority does not want war and could care less about who owns what. But the majority does not rule.
Posted by: OohCanada | May 7 2023 12:42 utc | 339

The Ukraine/Russia relationship right now is like that between the drug addict son who has sold all the jewelry, furniture, and appliances in the house to support his habit and is now beating up his parents trying to extort them to sell the house so that he can buy heroine for another couple years.
Which is an analogy that hits particularly hard in the former USSR because precisely that happened to many thousands of families in the 1990s…

Posted by: shadowbanned | May 7 2023 13:15 utc | 335

an ex-general
Firstly it is better to say “retired general” or “General a. D.” rather than “ex-general” which suggests he has been ‘cashiered’.
Secondly – German generals are a Waste of Time. They have zero combat experience and have simply served on NATO committees and wined and dined.
Please assure me you did not watch General a.D. Kather……….if you did go and read his resume……….he is a desk jockey

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 7 2023 13:21 utc | 336

The only way Ukraine can sever the land bridge to Crimea is to blow up the ZNPP. They are installing radiation monitors in advance. Russia is evacuating the area. People on every side of the fight are trying to prevent this from happening, we will see if they succeed.

Posted by: R Rodina | May 7 2023 13:24 utc | 337

If a Wagner soldier is killed in action, who pays for the family of the deceased; the Russian State or Wagner?
Is Wagner financially impacted by high losses?
As a business Wagner has to take into account finance as well as morale and human feelings for fallen friends.

Posted by: CitizenSmith | May 7 2023 13:34 utc | 338

Ed | May 6 2023 23:03 utc | 143

I am particularly concerned for “b” because Germany is of particular concern on this matter.

I share your concern. Uncle Sam has a watchful eye on what information we are fed, much more so in Germany than in other European countries. Remember how Germany blocked RT’s attempt to establish a German language TV channel, while France had long received their own channel (during the time before the SMO). Germany’s audiences are kind of lazy, so the language barrier is crucial, and the CIA is including that in their calculations. This may have protected MoA so far. But even here, you are being shielded from certain bits of information, even if they are well known in the Anglosphere. Post about them, and watch your post getting deleted.

Posted by: grunzt | May 7 2023 13:34 utc | 339

The Ukraine/Russia relationship right now is like that between the drug addict son who has sold all the jewelry, furniture, and appliances in the house to support his habit and is now beating up his parents trying to extort them to sell the house so that he can buy heroine for another couple years.
Posted by: shadowbanned | May 7 2023 13:15 utc | 347

That’s funny, I made the same point three days after the war started.
https://www.unz.com/isteve/so-whats-happening-in-the-war-are-your-predictions-coming-true/#comment-5200799

That’s enough already with the glowing reports of Ukrainians mounting an heroic resistance to Russian invasion, fighting like lions, embarrassing Putin, and so on and so forth. This is all absolute nonsense.
The Western news media spent the last 2 years telling us that Covid-19 was a deadly disease that threatened everybody, that masks and social distancing work, and that the vaccines were safe and effective. This was all an absolute lie. The same Western media spent 4 years telling us that Trump colluded with Russia to steal the 2016 election. This was an absolute lie. Now that media is telling you that Putin is getting the fight of his life from plucky Ukrainian patriots. Don’t you believe it.
Ukraine is doing the same thing it always does. It antagonizes the crap out of Russia and bitches until it gets the consideration it wants, meanwhile counting on Russian patience, Russian maturity, and Russian money for its very existence.
Ukraine is Russia’s kleptomaniacal, meth-addicted girlfriend who steals and pawns Russia’s stuff, and threatens to call the cops (NATO) on him and report him for domestic abuse if he does anything about it. This time Russia said, “The cops are too busy watching trucker convoys to send a car out, and I just beat up your drug dealer and sent him to the hospital. So get your things, I’m taking you to your mother’s.”
Russia is taking it slow in Ukraine right now because Russia has no intention of harming Ukraine or Ukrainians at all. Russia is just trying to expel the foreign interests, NGOs, oligarchs, kleptocrats, and agents provocateurs that have penetrated Ukraine and turned it into a hostile base—“denazification.” It must be incredibly frustrating for Russia to endure the potshots and cockcrowing coming from the Ukrainian military and the Western media, but Russia is taking the higher road here and will prevail.

Posted by: Intelligent Dasein | May 7 2023 13:35 utc | 340

“..The Ukrainian people hate Russian people because the Russians stole Crimea in 2014 and have been funding a rebellion in the east ever since. Thinking the people of Ukraine have been tricked or brainwashed is way off base…” OohCanada@308
There is nothing ‘different’ about this opinion, it comes straight from the CBC and the Globe. You are simply repeating the half truths and lies that pass as wisdom in Ottawa.
Read the current Covert Action article on Capitalism in Ukraine, it is based on an interview with a journalist who was there, watched what was happening and understands what has been, and still is, going on.
It is shameful enough for Canadians to be associated with the cowards and trimmers in the political sphere, spare us the humiliation of being associated with silly and uninformed opinions.

Posted by: bevin | May 7 2023 13:39 utc | 341

As long as the Russia/Ukraine conflict is actively underway, the US and NATO cannot pivot to Taiwan. If they try pivoting to Taiwan, Russia can quickly escalate and overrun Ukraine as well as Lithuania, Lativa and Estonia. Therefore, going slowly and forcing the West to support Ukraine ultimately drains the West and prevents it from focusing fully on Taiwan.
As a result, China almost certainly helping Russia quietly and in the shadows. They share a long border which can easily be used to smuggle goods, and China is probably supplying North Korea with items that are then transferred to Russia.
In addition to this, Ukraine is now being forced to go on the offensive to retake the territory that Russia has annexed. As a result, the Ukrainians will continue to send droves of men into the jaws of death, as they get mowed down by Russian artillery.
It is quite clear that there is no timetable on the Russian side, and that this will probably go on for years, possibly decades, turning Europe into a warzone reminiscent of Syria, Iraq, Lebanon, Yemen etc.

Posted by: Augustus Caesar | May 7 2023 13:45 utc | 342

349 Blowing up the ZNPP and causing massive radioactive contamination.
This would be a very popular move with the German Greens and others of a similar ilk.
Removing nuclear power as an alternative to fossil fuels would have a Huge impact.
The German Government would love it. Spike Russia’s nuclear industry and strike a telling blow for the `green loonies.

Posted by: CitizenSmith | May 7 2023 13:45 utc | 343

@ ohh canada and bevin
does ohhcanada know many here, like bevin and i, are canucks? you would haveto be a real ignoramus to believe anything cbc says about russia ukraine.. may as well listen to the oun flag draped crystia freeland, to here it from a 3rd generation nazi symapthizer…. whatever you do ohhcanada, please cease and desist.. you make canucks look more ignorant then we generally are.. get out in the world more and seek alternative views, as you appear to be doing by coming to moa..

Posted by: james | May 7 2023 13:46 utc | 344

i am seeing hints here and there: Turkey may be about to deliver its s-400 to Ukraine? The election outcome in Turkey may be very important to the outcome in Ukraine. Anyone else seeing such unbelievable stuff?

Posted by: snake | May 7 2023 13:49 utc | 345

@Downsouth 22
That is why Britain must be attacked and English nation destroyed to save Russia and world, otherwise coward English will go on plotting wars for others to fight on british behalf.
Quote “Our source in the OP said that in the General Staff, when preparing a counteroffensive, they are focusing on the capture of Energodar and the Zaporozhye nuclear power plant.
The operation is being developed by British intelligence and the SBU so that the details remain classified until the last moment. ”

Posted by: Sa. | May 7 2023 13:54 utc | 346

“..There is no effective revolutionary movement in Russia the way there was during World War I…”
armalyte@256
There were lots of revolutionaries, many left over from 1905, and a long and rich tradition of revolutionary thought and action in Russia during the war. But the Bolsheviks were in shambles, the leader of their Duma caucus a police agent, most of the leaders scattered around the world, deep divisions in the party among very small membership.
What Ukraine has that Russia had then are the conditions under which people are driven to conclude that the only way out is a revolution. It was at that point that the genius of Lenin evidenced itself- despite the Bolsheviks, who remained for some time committed to a non-revolutionary, bourgeois reformist agenda.
The Bolsheviks of October bore very little relationship to the Bolsheviks of April, just as the Communists of 1918 bore very little relationship to those of 1932.
Deplorable Commissar@245
You don’t do English do you? ‘Dribble’, when you mean drivel, ‘tenants’ where you mean tenets.
No harm in that and your English is much better than my Estonian, or whatever it is that you speak. But come clean- you challenge us to define Nazi achievements, because you long to do so yourself, but lack the courage to do anything more than hint at.
So you are a Nazi-tell us why and what it is that they achieved. And for who they achieved it.
When you reveal yourself and your affiliations you will be able to drop the slightly hysterical aggression and the affected education.

Posted by: bevin | May 7 2023 14:09 utc | 347

Of course the Russian MoD is full of incompetent and corrupt officers. It’s a Ministry of Defense. The DoD is no better, and even a brief scanning of military history will show that this the rule not an exception.
Whether Russia can/will clean it up is the question worth asking. But shy of implementing the blogger calls to start executing people we won’t see it. The primary problem with Martynov is his unfounded belief that the Russian MoD is immaculate. It has done some amazing things in the last 15 years or so, like rearming right under the noses of US intelligence and significant technological advances. But those don’t mean that it’s immune from bureaucratic bullshit. Every single major corporation and government agency across the globe is susceptible to these things. A belief that the Russian MoD is immune is fantasy.

Posted by: Lex | May 7 2023 14:16 utc | 348

OhhCanada, Canadian news is simply awful. Example: If ever Putin or Xi are “quoted” by one of the many think tank propagandists we see in papers and television media claiming an outrageous things, go dig up the full quote from their embassy website. Their words will likely be twisted. It is embarrassing.
Our country used to be a diplomatic force. We would have been active helping find solutions to this mess in Trudeau Sr.’s day. Now our government and media are shameless lackeys to US State ideologues content to cheer on war.
We live in a new dark age, and the vast majority of Canucks don’t realize it.
People here are far far more informed.

Posted by: bobzibub | May 7 2023 15:06 utc | 349

Posted by: Steven Starr | May 6 2023 17:48 utc | 18
I cannot agree with you more. I am very concerned.

Posted by: lex talionis | May 7 2023 15:13 utc | 350

Posted by: Exile | May 7 2023 6:38 utc | 248

and pliable leadership is installed facilitating a breakup of the RF into mini-states facilitating a return to the 1990s easy pickings for Wall Street

That would certainly do the job.
However, the sheer number of people that would have to be purged in order install “pliable leadership” will probably result in a nuclear holocaust before things get to that point.
I think the Russians have learned from The Collapse: It’s everyone’s neck on the line this time around …

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 7 2023 15:21 utc | 351

I agree with another commenter here. IMO Prigozhin is probably not getting as much ammunition as he would like. From Prigozhin’s point-of-view, if he had more ammunition, he could lay down more suppressive fire and save more of his men’s lives. I believe that’s real. From the MoD’s point-of-view, they’re managing an armed conflict that’s been going on for over a year with a 900 mile long front with multiple hot zones. I’m sure they have some difficult choices to make regarding how to distribute ammunition to commanders. I think both sides can improve their performances. I think the MoD, for its part, can do a better job in the future to let Prigozhin understand the reasons why he’s not getting all the ammo he requested. And Prigohin, for his part, should stop publicly criticizing his commanders. That respectful discussion should always be held privately.

Posted by: Mountain_Stream | May 7 2023 16:30 utc | 352

Andrey Morozov on ammo hunger and other stuff:

Well, about the “special one”. Let’s leave aside the situation with Prigozhin per se. If a private contractor accepts the penalties that follow such a “breach of contract”, or he considers the existing situation as falling under one of the clauses of the contract that allows him to withdraw from the agreements without such penalties, then why not? Or not to withdraw, but to blackmail the client with such a withdrawal? He’s a private contractor. He can afford it.
Let’s talk about the “ammo hunger” itself, as a result of which the entire military sports of artillery ammo blanket tug of war between Russian Armed Forces and the private contractor began. The private contractor, who has an option of publically bargaining using the corpses of his soldados and is sufficiently “free from any prejudice” to just do it, had every chance of winning and it seems that he has won in the end—they’ll give him the ammo. And the business will be good again.
(Of course, any LNR/DNR People’s Militias brigade commander, whose artillery hasn’t been getting ammo in quantities comparable to Wagner’s for a long time and is getting laughable crumbs, any such brigade commander, whose people are taking part in “meat assaults” without the necessary artillery support, are capturing positions with much blood and then are retreating from them because Ukrian artillery is pounding them into dirt without punishment, any brigade commander taking his KIAs from Maryinka, Avdeyevka or Belogorovka, putting them in front of cameras and demanding “give us ammo or we’ll leave”, would immediately go the “basement” [be arrested — S].)
So, about the “ammo hunger”. About eight months after it began we have come to a point when this phenomenon can no longer be silenced. Do we expect that now, when this “hunger” is finally being publicly acknowledged, “political workers” such as Shurygin, who a year ago have been telling us how great our artillery was working “ramming through the Ukrainian defenses” (while the majority of that artillery was successfully ploughing the fields without proper fire correction and comms), will weigh themselves on the nearest tree branch? No, we don’t. Do we expect that those people among country’s leadership who were building the much coveted “holy 1913” without realizing that it will be followed by 1914, 15, 16 and 17, will do so? No, we don’t. Will we help them in this? Meaning, in weighing themselves on the nearest branch? Will we help in this endeavour those who were actively denying reality and those who were fed this denial of reality, inducing them into a state of command-administrative deprivation? No we, won’t. We are busy people.

Posted by: S | May 7 2023 16:35 utc | 353

Cont’d from #356:


We are busy. We are trying to find where we can buy MPLs [Soviet/Russian military standard issue small infantry shovel — S] and “dugout Fiskars” on the cheap, because… because people from one of Southern Military District units fighting in the DNR came to us and told us what they were told by their logisticians—the storage facilities are out of MPLs, those famous “sapper’s shovels” that the Red Army, as everybody knows, can use to chop up any enemy and their Leopards. They are out of small shovels, and soldiers who are taking part in “meat assaults” are requesting those from logisticians so they can dig in in captured positions. Because it’s pointless to take shelter in locations that were previously occupied by Ukrops—Ukrian artillery, which has the exact map of those positions, will blow them away. And it’s better to do this digging with something more convenient than a steel helmet, praised by war correspondent Sladkov. What can the servicemen do? With one hand, they are taking large BSL-110s [big infantry shovel — S] and maiming-shortening them, and with other hand, they go to the volunteers.
So yesterday I have contacted Vova Grubnik’s suppliers in Moscow right from his storage facility in Donetsk and we were trying to find where we can get short “Fiskars”. And I asked him, when the cargo arrives, to not send it all to the front, but set aside a few pieces as samples. So we can set up production.
Convenient and sturdy compact soldier shovels and picks that don’t break in Donbass ground—I think that volunteers will be able to produce those alright.
But what to do with ATGMs and tank gun barrels, I don’t know. Because after many months of ammo hunger and HUSHING IT UP, the tanks’ gun barrels are worn out by constant firing of HE fragmentation shells from closed positions instead of howitzers and self-propelled artillery, and the ATGMs have become the infantry’s main replacement for the artillery that is missing from the battlefield.
And tanks and experienced anti-tank specialists with fresh ATGMs are the only forces that can really stop an armor–tank fist during a breakthrough, after the first line of minefields has already been passed by the enemy.
In summary, the scale of the impending disaster is already largely clear to experienced people.
Therefore, let’s stop worrying and let’s find the button shovels. [A reference to a scene from the popular 2008 Russian comedy Den’ radio (Radio Day). The key line in the scene is: “Can we find the button? Sh-sh! We’re speaking theoretically! Yes, we can. And about the Ministry of Defense, we can’t do anything. Therefore, we should search for the button.” — S]

Posted by: S | May 7 2023 16:36 utc | 354

Please, What does the “t.me/bakhmut_2022” watermark on incendiary attack videos mean?

Posted by: Humberto Borges | May 7 2023 16:40 utc | 355

Cont’d from #357
I had to split my translation of Morozov’s post into two parts because Typepad wouldn’t let me post it otherwise. Morozov’s original post (coincidentally, also in two parts, but split differently) can be found here: 1, 2.

Posted by: S | May 7 2023 16:45 utc | 356

re: lex talionis | May 7 2023 15:13 utc | 353
Thanks, I was hoping someone noticed my post.
I see that Zero Hedge has an article today: ‘Mad Panic’ As Towns Near Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Plant Evacuated Amid Stepped-Up Ukrainian Shelling
An excerpt from the article:
Director of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Rafael Grossi described that the situation “becoming increasingly unpredictable and potentially dangerous.”
He called for stability and protection of Europe’s largest nuclear site. “I’m extremely concerned about the very real nuclear safety and security risks facing the plant. We must act now to prevent the threat of a severe nuclear accident and its associated consequences for the population and the environment,” Grossi said.
The issue is a Ukrainian counteroffensive may have started in the city, given the significantly ramped-up shelling. Regional Russian head Yevgeny Balitsk said Friday that “in the past few days, the enemy has stepped up shelling of settlements close to the front line.

In the event of all-out war, nuclear power plants become pre-positioned gigantic radiation dispersal devices. Spent fuel pools contain some of the largest concentrations of high-level radioactivity on the planet.

Posted by: Steven Starr | May 7 2023 16:49 utc | 357

re: lex talionis | May 7 2023 15:13 utc | 353
Thanks, I was hoping someone noticed my post.
I see that Zero Hedge has an article today: ‘Mad Panic’ As Towns Near Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Plant Evacuated Amid Stepped-Up Ukrainian Shelling (MoA scrubs my post if I include the link).
An excerpt from the article:
Director of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) Rafael Grossi described that the situation “becoming increasingly unpredictable and potentially dangerous.”
He called for stability and protection of Europe’s largest nuclear site. “I’m extremely concerned about the very real nuclear safety and security risks facing the plant. We must act now to prevent the threat of a severe nuclear accident and its associated consequences for the population and the environment,” Grossi said.
The issue is a Ukrainian counteroffensive may have started in the city, given the significantly ramped-up shelling. Regional Russian head Yevgeny Balitsk said Friday that “in the past few days, the enemy has stepped up shelling of settlements close to the front line.

In the event of all-out war, nuclear power plants become pre-positioned gigantic radiation dispersal devices. Spent fuel pools contain some of the largest concentrations of high-level radioactivity on the planet.

Posted by: Steven Starr | May 7 2023 16:51 utc | 358

The Ukrainian people hate Russian people because the Russians stole Crimea in 2014 and have been funding a rebellion in the east ever since. Thinking the people of Ukraine have been tricked or brainwashed is way off base.
When Prigozhin complains about ammunition, the Russians unleash hell.

As I said earlier… The Bakhmut operation is a “killing field” for the express purpose of destroying Ukraine’s 4th army…. Prigohzhin’s latest was a sucker punch… The Ukies fell fot it.
As for your Crimea stolen nonsense….. The Russian federation is the successor state to the USSR… as such it has suzeranty and hegemony over the entirety of the FSU… Thus Russia cannot steal any part of the FSU… it owns it…
As for Ukie title to Crimea… the Crimeans voted in plebicites in 1990 before the Ukraine was set up, to return to Russia… The Ukies invaded Crimea and took it at gun point…
Furthermore, Ukraine is a NATO puppet state,…. bought and paid for by Vicki Nuland’s $5 billion USD… for the express purpose of getting the USN a base in Sebastopol…
In claiming what you claim… you distort history… thus you are a NATO troll…
FYI… The baltic states and Moldova and Poland have threatened anyone who celebrates the 9 May victory over the Nazis with massive fines…. Were I the Stavka… I’d nuke any capital of any country, NATO or not which denigrates the 9 May victory… I’d Nuke Norway into oblivion for destroying Nordstream… I’d nuke all US refineries… ditto…
Then… I’d say… “feel lucky punk??? Go ahead and make my day!!”
INDY

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | May 7 2023 16:54 utc | 359

@Humberto Borges #358
It’s the URL of the Telegram channel Бахмут (Bakhmut). You can paste it in the address bar of your web browser and read the channel without installing the Telegram app (click “Preview channel” link).
Each Telegram channel has two names: the displayed name (in this case, Бахмут) and the URL name, which can’t use non-Latin letters (in this case, bakhmut_2022).

Posted by: S | May 7 2023 16:56 utc | 360

@ 360 steven starr,
i noticed your earlier post and this one too…
this nuclear power plant has been an ongoing major concern for some time.. i don’t know what anyone can say to help alleviate these concerns.. perhaps if the western press was to address the glaring inconsistancy of the idea of russia firing on its own position, this would help, but given the intensity of the war propaganda – the bombing of nordsteam is another obvious example- i can’t see the western msm changing tack here.. thanks for your posts..

Posted by: james | May 7 2023 17:19 utc | 361

Paul Damascene | May 7 2023 12:56 utc | 333–
Euro-Pacific: A holdover term from the Age of Plunder that describes the several Plantation Nations and remaining Colonies yet having internal contradictions. Is Tahiti Tahitian or French for example. Australia can still be considered a penal colony given its lack of independence. Guam is completely captured by the Outlaw US Empire but Filipinos still resist attempts to force them back to servitude as Marcos flirts with the treatment given his father. Singapore is an oddity defying any classification aside from Singapore. Australia could become the same to Asia as the UK is to Europe–an unsinkable reactionary base that cannot rid itself of its geoeconomic dependence on the greater region it resides within. As a term, its heyday has passed as is being replaced by Asia-Pacific. One hundred years from now, Australia and Hawaii will be the only remaining vestiges of the Age of Plander, and the term Euro-Pacific will be gathering dust inside the OED.

Posted by: karlof1 | May 7 2023 18:24 utc | 362

Singapore is an oddity defying any classification aside from Singapore.
Posted by: karlof1 | May 7 2023 18:24 utc | 365

Singapore is the only country in Asia with a AAA sovereign credit rating from all major rating agencies. It is a major aviation, financial, and maritime shipping hub, and has consistently been ranked as one of the most expensive cities to live in for expatriates and foreign workers. Singapore ranks highly in key social indicators: education, healthcare, quality of life, personal safety, infrastructure, and housing, with a home-ownership rate of 88 percent. Singaporeans enjoy one of the longest life expectancies, fastest Internet connection speeds, lowest infant mortality rates, and lowest levels of corruption in the world.
Its contemporary era began in 1819 when Stamford Raffles established Singapore as an entrepôt trading post of the British Empire. In 1867, the colonies in Southeast Asia were reorganised and Singapore came under the direct control of Britain as part of the Straits Settlements. During World War II, Singapore was occupied by Japan in 1942, and returned to British control as a separate Crown colony following Japan’s surrender in 1945. Singapore gained self-governance in 1959

Posted by: GT Stroller | May 7 2023 18:46 utc | 363

Russia could have done without Stalin on several levels. Not that Trotsky would have been better. The who,e Revolution was a disaster.
Posted by: Wokechoke | May 7 2023 11:29 utc | 314
Trotsky would have been better. He was the founder of the Red Army and led the successful effort to defend the revolution during the civil war. After Stalin ousted Trotsky, Stalin began eliminating the officer corps that had been established by Trotsky. Had Trotsky seen Stalin sneaking up behind him and taken action World War II may have ended sooner, or never even happened at all, in my humble opinion.

Posted by: Chas | May 7 2023 19:06 utc | 364

Chas: Neither of the two was ideal. This much said, I don’t know how a Trotskyist USSR would have withstood the Nazi war machine without a highly developed industrial base, having devoted too much of its energies promoting European revolutions that would only have failed.

Posted by: malenkov | May 7 2023 19:14 utc | 365

Conspicuous absence of comment re the claimed Patriot kill of a Khinzal — false flag is possible but risky as if the Patriot (alleged) missed the target missile, it would seem that the target would fall on a populated area of Kyiv …… apologies for the wild speculation, but I felt the subject should be broached.

Posted by: chet380 | May 7 2023 19:18 utc | 366

It’s hard to imagine a “conspicuous absence of comment” regarding imaginary events. Unless you’re infatuated with the Ghost of Keeve, I guess.

Posted by: malenkov | May 7 2023 19:24 utc | 367

Malenkov —
The loud explosion in the sky was witnessed by independent journalists, so not imaginary.

Posted by: chet380 | May 7 2023 19:31 utc | 368

Loud explosion of what exactly, Chet?

Posted by: malenkov | May 7 2023 19:47 utc | 369

371.
There was no Kinzhal shooot down. I alluded to it wittily earlier. Pats self on back.
Maybe what the bright flash they saw was when they shot down their own hacked Bayraktar? That’s just embarassing, eh

Posted by: Doctor Eleven | May 7 2023 21:38 utc | 370

Doctor Eleven: Yeah, I notice that “Chet” has grown silent. Pity.
BTW I don’t know if you’re new here—I just started noticing your comments a few days ago—but I really like your style. And content too, of course.

Posted by: malenkov | May 7 2023 22:18 utc | 371

Karlof1 @365
Thanks for this. I had had a completely different understanding, entirely based on conjecture.

Posted by: Paul Damascene | May 8 2023 0:17 utc | 372

Trotsky would have been much like Zelenskyy who comes from the same area in The Ukraine. The two might even be distant cousins. A constant pain in the doing a Chabathon for Christian blood and treasure.
The best thing would have been a military coup in 1936 lead by Marshall Tukhachevsky instituting something like a Crowellian Republic.

Posted by: Wokechoke | May 8 2023 0:29 utc | 373

The Russians can dump CBU and 1000lb bobs on anything that looks a little suspicious. It will be tough fo rthe Ukies to concentrate anything if they are getting rained on with mix of floating bomblettes and big detonations from a storm of dumb bombs.

Posted by: Wokechoke | May 8 2023 0:33 utc | 374

Many comments criticizing Gonzalo Lira for staying in Ukraine and endangering himself and his family. Feel free to correct my fuzzy memory, but I recall Gonzalo Lira implying he couldn’t leave Ukraine because he was on the equivalent of house arrest/probation pending court appearances following his original arrest and release last year, and as a condition of his release he was prohibited from publicly disclosing the details of his case. I also recall him saying his former wife and children left Ukraine last year.

Posted by: Willow | May 8 2023 1:38 utc | 375

@ 378 willow
that sounds correct..
signapore…..
unique situation because it is a ‘city-state’.. it has been used by the british, and now mainly china, as a finacial capital.. it has an unique set up which explains the numbers..

Posted by: james | May 8 2023 6:56 utc | 376

“I challenge anyone here to list the basic tenants of National SOCIALISM. ”
In practice, fascism is not a fixed ideology, but a style with big stress on hatred and glorifying violence. To capitalize on the typo (tenets != tenants), I would say that while tenants have some importance, the key question is: who are the landlords?

Posted by: Piotr Berman | May 8 2023 12:36 utc | 377

Much thanks to:
Karlof
bevin
Melaeluca
Enlightening posts , thank you, I have learned a lot.
And learned to avoid the idiots who have an ego issue to fight about, so irrelevant in this quagmire.

Posted by: stranger | May 8 2023 17:43 utc | 378

I have posted ‘The Ukraine under fire’ previously on this thread.
However the docu about Putin named the ‘Statesman’ seems to be erased. Any help?

Posted by: stranger | May 8 2023 17:47 utc | 379

What “AmmoDude” is missing (“It’s foolish to suggest that Russia can fight …”)
is that the US et al. do not have an infinite supply of $$$, and in fact, are
*very* close to bankrupcy. It is unlikely to find enough “True Believers” willing
to foot the tax increases necessary to wage a war on the other side of the Wierld
against folks who have more that sticks and stones to fight back with.
There’s an unpleasant description used in Warshington, London and Paris for these
sorts of wars but I’m afeared there’s a shortage of N*rs to Bash in Russia.

Posted by: Fubar El Haq | May 9 2023 20:09 utc | 380

Oh, wait. That shud b ArmoDude not AmmoDude.
Dhu

Posted by: Fubar El Haq | May 9 2023 20:35 utc | 381

Twitter: “@Navsteva’s account has been withheld in Germany based on local law(s).”
freeze peach -.-

Posted by: axl237 | May 11 2023 6:54 utc | 382