Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
May 21, 2023
Ukraine Open Thread 2023-122

Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

Perhaps someone who speaks and reads can find out who this person is :Bipa Олійник. But he is truly a nasty piece of work as far as I can tell, he goes back to the Soviet era period.
The New Voice of Ukraine
Ukrainian intel intercepts Russian soldier boasting of killing 400 people in Kreminna, including women and children
Story by Bipa Олійник • 10h ago
During a conversation with a woman, he calls “granny”, the Russian war criminal brags that they went “on an assault” that night.
“Today, when we came in, we started whacking civilians and all the f***ers, just whacking everyone, just shelling the holy f*** out of them,” the soldier says.
“Granny, I’m telling you, we popped at least 400 people at night. … We also have machine gunners, and they mowed down everyone: children, women, men, locals, non-locals. They just mowed everybody down. We went into the houses and just shot them; we were just sick of everything. We were just given an order – guys, take Kreminna – and we just mowed it all down, gran.”
And who is the “New Voice”:
The New Voice is Ukraine’s new premier independent English-language news resource
providing Ukrainian coverage of the latest stories, analysis, and news.
The New Voice of Ukraine – YouTube
http://www.youtube.com/channel/UCBcX6l6oWL_PwzodIjANaLw/videos
Does anyone remember Tokyo Rose? So now we have a Russian Granny.

Posted by: Ed | May 22 2023 1:04 utc | 201

Eighthman #13:50 utc | 11
Even weirder than that is why westerners are becoming so fanatical about political ideologies (instead of money) while organized religion fades away. Do they think an afterlife rewards them for advancing LGBTQ ideas?
Social disruption creates opportunities, either for power or for money. That is why they want social disruption. The ideologies they push are about damaging the existing power structure, and thus creating opportunities for themselves. It goes all the way back to the Bible. Why did Babylonia exile Jews and move foreigners into the area? Why did the Assyrians ‘disperse’ the 10 tribes of Israel and move in outsiders? Why did both the Tsars and Joe Stalin move nationalities around? Why do they let followers of Islam into Europe? Why do we have an open border to Mexico? Why do we bring in non-conforming foreigners generally? The answer to all the previous questions is that they were and are efforts to break up the previous ethnic community, thus weaken the community, and thus make the locals easier to control.
The benefit of LGBTQ thing is an effort to weaken society and thus make it easier to govern, and thus to control. The assault on our real or imagined heroic past is the same thing. Regardless of whether there is anything special about American society or not, the idea that there is makes society stronger. So, that has to go. Traditional society has to be an embarrassment. And so on and so on. All the stuff we push now is self damaging to social cohesion.
It is all an effort to break up any common identity.

Posted by: Jmaas | May 22 2023 1:10 utc | 202

@mjc | May 22 2023 0:40 utc | 211
The following is an example of the type of “external kindling” which the people of Donbas received https://sputnikglobe.com/20230509/mariupol-residents-reveal-how-kiev-nazis-turned-sacred-may-9-victory-day-into-massacre-in-2014-1110164374.html

Posted by: cirsium | May 22 2023 1:14 utc | 203

@ ed 212
here is a wikipedia page on him.. you will have to use a translate page.. cheers james
Олійник Борис Ілліч

Posted by: james | May 22 2023 1:15 utc | 204

maybe a different person.. that one died in 2017…

Posted by: james | May 22 2023 1:16 utc | 205

[207]
George Robertson was a trades union official that Blair made Defence Secretary and the Americans made NATO puppet. Military Commander ??? ROFL
Probably a Freemason which is his connection to Dunblane
Otherwise a total nonentity

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 22 2023 1:18 utc | 206

ed
just propaganda bs… the world is awash in it..

Posted by: james | May 22 2023 1:22 utc | 207

English Outsider # 19:22 utc | 109

Sushi – has to be right. A query. What is the current mood in Ukraine? Is there a possibility that the war could be ended by a Ukrainian faction, backed by popular disillusionment, turning against the Kiev administration?

The governing nazi mafia might impede any good intentions exhibited by some other faction.
The only calculation the current SS elite might be considering is ‘how many choppers can fit on the USA embassy roof?’. I suspect the current US embassy roof is similar to that in Saigon as the USA seems incapable of learning the precautionary principle.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 1:25 utc | 208

logistics in danger . . .from Warrior Maven

(Washington DC) Tanks, rockets, artillery and ammunition are all being fast-tracked to Ukraine by boat, convoy and perhaps even airplanes to Europe, an intense and dangerous task taken on by thousands of Army soldiers with the 21st Theater Sustainment Command, a key part of Army Europe.
The logistics, sustainment and maintenance required for this task are simply massive, and US Army soldiers are moving supplies with the clear, real recognition that equipment lines could be attacked or sabotaged anytime.
Maj. Gen. James Smith, the Commanding General of the 21 Theater Sustainment Command, said his soldiers are trained to be ready for what he called “contested logistics,” meaning the possibility of an attack, ambush or saboteur intent on targeting weapons shipments.
“We always have to keep the context of contested logistics in mind.. We move with the sense that supply lines could be affected and we take that into consideration,” Smith told reporters.
Specific modes of transportation and routes or navigational details regarding the shipments to Ukraine are naturally not available for security reasons, yet the transport of critical weapons and supplies requires extensive collaboration between the US Army and its European allies.
“Our job is to get it from the port of debarkation to wherever we are going to transit into Europe and Ukraine. This is an opportunity to work alongside our host nations and allies. Host nation support is helping us move munitions,” Smith said. . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | May 22 2023 1:38 utc | 209

whirlX, are you and Mr. Karlof1 on the same page? Because I can’t tell from your comment. Karlof1 is stating that Putin never “…Putin NEVER announced that he activated the “PERIMETER.” Are you in agreement?
—————————————————————-
The RT report provides no direct quote. TASS’s Report has a little more meat but no statement by Putin nor any mention on the activation of Perimeter.
Usually it’s the trolls spreading misinformation; this time that’s not the case. Please stop.
Posted by: karlof1 | May 21 2023 22:36 utc | 187
Posted by: Ed | May 22 2023 0:28 utc | 205

Putin’s speech is transcribed in post #249 by Sushi on May 20. See the link below and check #249. It would have been good to include audio/video link to the speech itself. Not sure if this represents the real speech by Putin. https://www.moonofalabama.org/2023/05/bakhmut-has-fallen-artyomovsk-has-been-liberated-/comments/page/3/#comments

Posted by: BD | May 22 2023 1:42 utc | 210

WANTED!
The following individuals…
ICC Criminal Court Judge and Prosecutor, Khan Karim Asad Ahmad and panel members Tomoko Akane, Rosario Salvatore Aitala and Sergio Gerardo Gerardo Godinez
Charges include: 1) For issuing an illegal arrest warrant for Vladmir Putin, President of the Russian Federation. 2) For wrong doing in the International Criminal Court
Russian Federation

Posted by: HERMIUS | May 22 2023 1:51 utc | 211

Meanwhile…
It appears Dnipro is having missile impacts tonight/early morning there.

Posted by: BroncoBilly | May 22 2023 1:56 utc | 212

Zalhuzny.
Twitter says:
>…”Zaluzhny has allegedly been found (left). He appeared on the video call. His last public appearance from April (right).
https://twitter.com/OlgaBazova/status/1660297119175933955
Twitter Comments:
§ “The biggest questions that I have are:
He couldn’t show up for a VERY important call with NATO in the middle of the most crucial phase of the conflict, but he found the time to show up for some mundane Day of Science event in Odessa?
When you are losing Bakhmut, which Zelensky proclaimed was the most important battle of this whole conflict, but you’re nowhere to be found as Commamder-in-Chief in the middle of it? /serious doubts”
§ “Looking at the video, it’s really difficult to say if it’s a truly recent vid or perhaps a vid from last year’s conference being posted now. But, it’s hard to believe that he didn’t join the call with NATO officials and found time to blabber at some shindig in Odessa.”
§ “Given today’s live deepfake technology this proves nothing.
> And thus “allegedly”.
§ Blurred background – hospital ?
Bakhmut falls yet he has time for this
Smiling on the day Bakhmut fell?
Bit weird
§ Rybar in English
>…”Schrödinger’s Zaluzhny – The AFU Commander-in-Chief finally appeared on video at a conference for Science Day. There were rumors that Zaluzhny was killed or seriously wounded, possibly on May 8 during a Kinzhal strike on a bunker in Mezhirichi.”
https://twitter.com/rybar_en/status/1660328815753609216
The vid: Jump to :44sec
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qXCkzVA0hBY
>…Comments are turned off [😂]

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 2:17 utc | 213

Sure it is doubled posted BUT this needs to seen, even for B
I write this in the knowledge that the following DID occur. Missile strike on Khmeknytsyi on the 14th may 2023 did blow up a large ammunition storage ( dump) By all accounts to readings in Poland, which have been either taken off line or EU calibrated for disinformation. So large reading of Depleted Uranium and get this, thousands of TONNES of Depleted Uranium up in Uranium dioxide smoke, which plumed all over Western Ukraine Lvov and Eastern Poland including Warsaw, which was captured by detectors. So when depleted uranium explodes it turns into Uranium diode a small particle 3 microns and/or gas which is easily carried by the wind. The following video shows a eccentric world expert who gives the health outcomes of inhaling such a particle. Now what can’t be said their was no explosion, many videos testify to it. Also The reading obtained by the expert show it was depleted Uranium. No other way to see it.
https://www.bitchute.com/video/iSPw64WMPumB/
One has to say this effect will even impact Western Europe with distance from Khmelnytsyi being mediated by winds/distance from explosion. I believe this will have devastating impact on Poland population, your thoughts would be appreciated.

Posted by: Col from OZ | May 22 2023 2:21 utc | 214

@Melaleuca | May 22 2023 2:17 utc | 226
In the course of a missile attack on military infrastructure facilities in the Dnipropetrovsk region, this command post was struck by a precise hit by a Russian cruise missile. As a result, a large number of high-ranking Ukrainian military personnel were killed and wounded, including General Zaluzhny. . .here

Posted by: Don Bacon | May 22 2023 2:28 utc | 215

There are many of us simply astounded by the breadth, depth and intense persistence of outright lies pumped out by the West about this war. Deception has always contributed to success in war but somehow what we are witnessing seems unprecedented. And we are left wondering why so few notice it when it gets exposed on a daily basis. How does it work?
Give people an attention span of microseconds (while enslaved to smart phones) and before you can say, “Look ! A squirrel !”, you’ve got them. Critical reflection evaporates.
And then they just ape the reality. Did Ukraine lose 100K at Bakhmut? No, that was the Russians. Did Patriots get blown up? No they shot down Kinzhals. Take whatever negative fact emerges and flip it glibly and the situation is covered. Hey, I remember that bad stuff you mentioned was actually about Russia, right? This is straight out of ‘1984’. We were always at war with Oceania.
The truly stunning end of this culture of ubiquitous falsehood may come as a shockwave even to “experts” as Russia wins, western economies collapse and national social cultures shrivel up as a Grand Surprise. If nearly everyone is deluded, how could it be otherwise?

Posted by: Eighthman | May 22 2023 2:29 utc | 216

Don Bacon | May 22 2023 2:28 utc | 228
Euroweekly. Weren’t they the ones that broke the Profumo scandal? LOL

Posted by: TRDtherealdeal98@gma | May 22 2023 2:33 utc | 217

@Eighthman | May 22 2023 2:29 utc | 229
what we are witnessing seems unprecedented
Not really, leading to the rule: If a government spokesman says something, believe the opposite.

Posted by: Don Bacon | May 22 2023 2:37 utc | 218

Posted by: Eighthman | May 22 2023 2:29 utc | 229

If nearly everyone is deluded, how could it be otherwise?

The leaders know it for sure!
You / we should just not know it

Posted by: theo | May 22 2023 2:37 utc | 219

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 0:40 utc | 211
i think you have no evidence for any of this.

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 2:49 utc | 220

Wagner lost six million soldiers in Bakhmut.

Posted by: Wokechoke | May 22 2023 2:54 utc | 221

All things come through God and Christ.
The Christians will be victorious.

Posted by: Theodore Roosevelt | May 22 2023 2:57 utc | 222

A Russian top official claimed on Friday that a radioactive cloud is moving toward Western Europe, but the Polish Press has no such news.

Posted by: Don Bacon | May 22 2023 3:03 utc | 223

⚡️🇷🇺🇺🇦⚔️ War Map and the Situation on the Fronts in the Evening of 21 May 2023; pub. 00:05⚡️
⚡️ The Russian Army is targeting AFU facilities in 404. Missile strikes have been carried out on targets in #Kharkov region, allegedly destroying a temporary deployment point of the Kraken Battalion (banned in the Russian Federation). There are “Geraniums” operating in #Odessa region and several incursions have been recorded. In addition, our forces are covering militants’ positions in #Pologi district of #Zaporozhye region with KABs.
⚔️ The Situation on the Fronts over the past Day:
🔹#Svatovo – #Kremennaya Direction:
▪️ The Russian army advanced in the areas of #Belogorovka and #Nevskoye. Also ours attacked in the vicinity of #Makeyevka and #Stelmakhovka.
🔹#Artyomovsk (#Bakhmut) Sector:
▪️ The mopping up of the western outskirts of #Artyomovsk continues. Fighting is ongoing in the areas of #Krasnoye and #Khromovo, where retreated militants have gained a foothold.
➖ Meanwhile, the AFU command continues to “defend” the city despite its complete surrender.
🔹#Donetsk Direction:
▪️ Russian army fighters stormed (storm, cause not completed) #Avdeyevka from the south, east and southwest. Also ours attacked in the areas of #Steponoye (#Petrovskoye) and #Kamenka. There is fighting north of #Krasnogorovka and in the western part of #Maryinka.

https://t.me/sitreports/9018

Posted by: Down South | May 22 2023 3:07 utc | 224

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 3:04 utc | 237
i disagree, you made several specific claims and haven’t provided any evidence for any of them.

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 3:11 utc | 225

What’s worse than constant lies by western governments? (about Ukraine and all else)
Putting no effort into lying. Making it glib, uncaring, predictable, often automatic. To the point of being insulting.
Look at Jake Sullivan and his ‘how we defeat China’ speech. And this guy is in charge of national security? Does he think China can’t understand simple English?
They’re lying without even trying.

Posted by: Eighthman | May 22 2023 3:16 utc | 226

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 3:13 utc | 240
Kiev has claimed from the first that Russia was interfering with Donbass. hardly an admission against interest for a pro Kiev site to claim the same. useful distraction from losing on the battlefield, though.

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 3:18 utc | 227

Zhuluzny MIA since 8-10 May
Artyomovsk is liberated 20 May
Maybe something Russian is planned 30 May”
NATO exercise called “Air Defender 23” 12 to 24 June

This is now the looming Russia-attack threat of the Ramstein “exercises”; these are scheduled to run from June 12 to June 24. Japan is one of the non-member state NATO “partners” officially acknowledged to be participating; the Ukraine is not mentioned in the NATO press releases.

Zelensky is en route to…?
Is there enough time for NATO to bang nazi heads together and work out one or even TWO successions? AND present this as a stable, nothing to see here, ‘government’?
Japan flying aggressive fighters about in the NATO camp west of Russia and simultaneously based east of Russia and on China’s border.
Nato is sending an expeditionary naval force to sort out that mean China ownership issue with its island province Taiwan.
Now who is the aggressor here? Who is escalating the conflict?
Is the Republican impeachment team moving ahead with the Biden Crime Family agenda – or has it ‘slipped away’ for now.
So many questions, so little popcorn. sigh.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 3:26 utc | 228

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 0:40 utc | 211
I think the level of popular support in the Donbas for armed uprising *may* have been a minority for at least the first few months, suggesting a need for external kindling.
The first act generating popular support in the Donbass for armed uprising WAS a ground strafe attack by a UAF Frogfoot against the civil administration building in Slaviansk after Russian speaking citizens dared to voice their displeasure with the overthrow of their duly elected government in Kiev, and the ascension of AZOV thugs to power.
Eight citizens lost their lives on the building steps due to Frogfoot cannon fire. I can attest to this fact as video of the attack, filmed from the windows of an adjacent high rise was posted to YouTube (since disappeared). You could observe the cannon fire shred treetops in the adjacent park as it marched across the park toward the bunched civilians. Additional footage showed the deceased crumpled on the steps, the blood still spilling down.
A second event generating great popular support was the massacre of Russian speaking Ukrainians in Odessa. Contemporaneous footage of this event was also viewed by me on YouTube. It included scenes recorded inside the fire gutted administration building. One image still haunts me. This was a human form, charred and black, coils of telephone cord wrapped round her neck to suffocate her, her body positioned with legs spread so as to make evident what took place shortly before, or after, her murder. Having handled burn victims in a prior occupation I can attest it would be impossible to position a burned body in this way after the fact – the tissue would simply flake away and the remains crumble to dust.
None of this footage would today be permitted on YouTube. There was no need for “external kindling” of dissent. All of the critical provocations were delivered by the US endorsed government of the day.
I am not a Ukrainian and have no degree of attachment to Ukraine. But I urge President Putin to do all that is within his power to bring the guilty to justice and ensure these inhuman acts are recorded for posterity.

Posted by: Sushi | May 22 2023 3:46 utc | 229

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 3:21 utc | 245
what revolutionary government?

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 3:53 utc | 230

Just as scary as the prospect of an all-out nuclear war is the capacity of Western MSM to lie. It is happening on a massive scale and happening right now.

Posted by: Jonathan W | May 22 2023 3:54 utc | 231

Jmaas # 1:10 utc | 213

It is all an effort to break up any common identity.

Indeed it is:-
Thatcher made an artform of social fragmentation, of social product destruction, of ruination of common identity. She sold as much social solidarity service as she could jettison into the hands of singular, oligarchic possession.

and so they are casting their problems on society and who is society? There is no such thing! There are individual men and women and there are families and no government can do anything except through people and people look to themselves first.

And refuted here.
Many religious orders perpetuate this nonsense by maintaining that there is only ONE community within their worshipful deity and all others are cast out, detestable, excluded, possessed of evil and evil intentions. And so on.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 3:58 utc | 232

Eighthman #3:16 utc | 242
“They’re lying without even trying.”
It is almost as if Pompeo’s boastful admission grants licence to overt lies.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 4:06 utc | 233

China should help Russia fight the common enemy at times of need. Otherwise China will not have any support when NATO and QUOD attack it soon. Optimistic observers put it to 2026. China’s lack of support for Russia won’t be forgotten in just 3 years.

Posted by: Jason | May 22 2023 4:08 utc | 234

Wokechoke #2:54 utc | 234
Wagner lost six million soldiers in Bakhmut.
Doing better than last time then;)

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 4:11 utc | 235

Ukraine has only a few functioning airports. Russia should target all of them. That should give Russia air supremacy over Ukraine.
NATO air drill in late June is a good opportunity to monitor them and identify airports they use, facilities they house, roads and bridges around them.
These should be busted in a war.

Posted by: Jason | May 22 2023 4:12 utc | 236

the ascension of Azov thugs to power in February 2014 preceded March 2014. initial kindling.

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 4:14 utc | 237

mjc | May 22 2023 0:40 utc | 211
This article by Jaques Baud who was working with NATO in the Donbass region at the time gives a good perspective. He says that he was looking for Russian interference and did not find it.
https://www.globalresearch.ca/the-military-situation-in-the-ukraine/5778420

Posted by: ZimZum | May 22 2023 4:20 utc | 238

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 3:13 utc | 240
Atlantic Council press releases? That’s seriously like quoting Goebbels if he was asked to provide information on how WWII unfolded.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | May 22 2023 4:22 utc | 239

Col from OZ #2:21 utc | 227

I believe this will have devastating impact on Poland population, your thoughts would be appreciated.

Thanks for post and the link but this one works as I chopped off the / at end of yours as it seems bitcute URL copy includes that and it renders probs.
https://www.bitchute.com/video/iSPw64WMPumB
My first though was King Charles has to face his first large scandal as King. He has form.
Secondly all that grain just planted and fresh rained might be troubled until they blend it at harvest time with clean Russian grain to reduce the
radioactive problem below threshold. Then sell it as chicken food or cow pellets and deliver to … USA or some unregulated country like Egypt, Sudan?
Or maybe never sell grain again from that soil and sow tree crops instead that will mature as the radioactive particles bind in the soil over ?how many years?
The fallout needs some better detailed mapping before one can dismiss Germany or Chech Republic from that receiving end. I looked at winds on Ventusky at the time and they could have travelled SW.
Like mad cow disease and the tainted animal feed, you can bet there will be some mighty shifty shenanigans in the EU.
The UK and Zelensky have some mansplaining to do but I wont put my drink down waiting for their response.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 4:31 utc | 240

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 4:24 utc | 262
Bellingcrap uses “open source” imagery too. Have you looked at Google Maps recently where Crimea is concerned? Again though, who cares if some Russian assistance units were in the Donbass which is right on their border, was threatening to join NATO, develop nukes and was embroiled in a civil war of NATO’s creation? What would the US have done if it were Mexico and Russia-or-China? Give us a break already.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | May 22 2023 4:49 utc | 241

Also the Atlantic Council is on record predicting there would be NO SMO in February of 2022. LOL.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | May 22 2023 4:49 utc | 242

Do wonder if S-300 systems have pre-programmed Foe ID such as F-16 signatures integral. Might it be possible to get Ukrsinisn S-300 to shoot down F-16 over Rimania or Poland ?

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 22 2023 4:51 utc | 243

Posted by: HERMIUS | May 22 2023 1:51 utc | 224

Charges include: 1) For issuing an illegal arrest warrant for Vladmir Putin, President of the Russian Federation. 2) For wrong doing in the International Criminal Court

Just had the best idea for t-shirt merch ever …

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 4:54 utc | 244

mjc | May 22 2023 4:03 utc | 251
Was the first shot of the upcoming Ukrainian civil war just fired?
March 26, 2014
https://thesaker.is/was-the-first-shot-of-the-upcoming-ukrainian-civil-war-just-fired/
Extracts:
§~ 8) The upcoming (in May) presidential elections are going to head for disaster in one way or another: there is simply no way, no way at all, that the current regime would – or even could – organize even minimally decent elections.  
They cannot let Milkail Dobkin run or, if they do, they would have to dramatically “correct” the number of votes he will get. 
They probably cannot let Iarosh run either.  Dobkin, being under house arrest, could not run a normal campaign either way, as for Iarosh, he might be the next to be assassinated by the SBU/cops. 
No matter what the modalities or he outcome, the next presidential elections will be a farce which most people will simply not accept. 
The resulting “President” and government will have zero legitimacy. {[Poroshenko won]}
§~ 10) Last, but not least, there is already overwhelming evidence that the revolutionary regime is lying about the circumstances of the death of Aleksandr Muzychko who appears to have been executed by a special SWAT unit. 
The order to kill him apparently was given or, at least, approved, by the CIA station in Kiev who, according to many reports, is basically running the revolutionary government from the 4th floor of a building in central Kiev.
§~ …… “triggers a crisis between the pro-US oligarchs and the neo-Nazis which would allow the former to try to get rid of the latter in the name of “democracy” and “anti-Fascism”, hence something which would not only be applauded with both hands in the West, but also give the oligarchs some anti-Nazi credentials and thus help to erase from the collective memory of the TV-zombified morons the fact that this regime only came to power thanks to the violence meted out by these neo-Nazis.
§… The bad news is that the Russian military does *not* want to intervene in the Ukraine. 
At the very best, the Kremlin might be forced to move the Russian military into eastern and, possibly, southern Ukraine to protect Russian-speakers from the violence resulting from a breakup of the Ukraine, but that would be an option of last resort as the Kremlin fully understands that the imbeciles in charge of the major powers in the West could do something truly stupid in reaction to such a Russian move. 
Thus, from the Russian point of view the best solution is by far, and I have said that many times here, to have a more or less stable, more or less prosperous, more or less “not anti-Russian” and independent Ukraine as a good neighbor.
When Putin told the Russian Federal Assembly and the rest of the world in his historical speech that Russia did not want to occupy or annex the Ukraine, he was not lying to cover up an imminent invasion, or trying to appease the West or showing how generous and good the Russians are – he was stating a basic reality of Russian pragmatic self-interest: Russia neither needs nor wants the Ukraine, especially now that it got Crimea back. 
What Russia does not want is a neo-Nazi Ukraine with NATO bases.
So if the Empire’s leaders had any common sense at all, they would understand the basic truth that this is not a zero-sum game and that Russia’s interests are quite compatible to the West’s as long as the West gives up its crazy idea of setting a neo-Nazi regime in Kiev surrounded by NATO bases. 
That crazy shit Russia simply will not accept. 
But an independent Ukraine?!  Of course – please, they will even help pay for it as long as it avoids a much more dangerous outcome resulting in a civil war.
Alas, all the signs are that Obama and his EU minions are just not going to accept anything short of a total victory – thereby securing their own total defeat, but at the cost of a complete destruction of rump-Ukraine and a horrible predicament for the people of the Ukraine.
§~ Short of a miraculous change of mind of the AngloZionist plutocracy, the bullets that killed Muzychko might well have been the (CIA’s) match which will start a fire capable of burning down what is left of the Ukraine.
*= mjc
Some of us, here and at percipient (but now defunct blogs), have been observing the USNATO instigated Ukraine/ Russian war for almost a decade now……
I know I’m now jaded and exhausted, having spent 8 or more years “explaining” to Rip Van Winkles, who just woke up, the how, why and who of the Maiden and events since 2014.
If you really are genuine in wanting insight into the spore of the SMO, start here, @bar MoA, and read the 2014 archives.
Read The Saker Archives of 2014- 2020 (after about then he lost the plot)
Read RH Ausländer. “An Incident on Simonka”. And also, “Sevastopol: The Third Defence”.
Ausländer lives in Crimea and took part in The Resistance. He was a sporadic, but always enlightening poster at The Saker. He always had first hand info on what was actually happening there 2014-2021. (He stopped posting for opsec reasons, I think).
As a Crimean resident Ausländer left readers in no doubt the rejection of the illegitimate Ukrainian government was organic and in response to the violence inflicted by the CIA-Ukrainian government on its Crimean citizens.

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 4:55 utc | 245

Posted by: Jason | May 22 2023 4:08 utc | 254

China should help Russia fight the common enemy at times of need.

This is the kind of nonsense that leads to world wars.
Ukraine is not a *common* enemy of China and Russia.
But if China were to get *directly* involved it certainly would become one …

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 4:57 utc | 246

Do wonder if S-300 systems have pre-programmed Foe ID such as F-16 signatures integral. Might it be possible to get Ukrsinisn S-300 to shoot down F-16 over Rimania or Poland ?
Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 22 2023 4:51 utc | 266

Out of range unless shooting from Belarus into Poland.
Also, even S-400 right on the Belarus border cannot close the sky over the whole of western Ukraine — the range is 400 km and that still leaves a narrow safe zone along the Romanian border.
It’s a damn large country…

Posted by: shadowbanned | May 22 2023 4:58 utc | 247

Posted by: Sushi | May 22 2023 3:46 utc | 247
This video , if it exists, is crucial to determining who truly holds the moral high ground in this conflict.
If it can’t be uploaded on YouTube it can certainly be sent to Bitchute.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:01 utc | 248

@Melaleuca | May 21 2023 23:23 utc | 191

No apologist for Stoltenberg.
Yet. There was not a single armed security guard on the island.
Why would there be?
Why would anyone expect there to be armed security for a teenager holiday camp?

Ask the police, who trained for this exact scenario in this precise location the days before, as it was reported in Norway’s largest newspaper Aftenposten (long since erased). By the way, Stoltenberg referred in a speech in 2018 to the shooters on the Utøya Island in plural form, even though supposedly ‘Breivik’ killed 69 of Stoltenbergs younger party members (who the day before called for a boycott of Israel) all by himself.

Posted by: Norwegian | May 22 2023 5:02 utc | 249

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 4:55 utc | 268

§… The bad news is that the Russian military does *not* want to intervene in the Ukraine.

That’s the good news. Pull an Uncle Sam and let them bleed themselves out …

Alas, all the signs are that Obama and his EU minions are just not going to accept anything short of a total victory

Kind of like they did in Afghanistan …
Posted by: Theodore Roosevelt | May 22 2023 2:57 utc | 235

The Christians will be victorious.

They’ve been victorious for a thousand years and that’s why Satan is the God of this world.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:07 utc | 250

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 5:01 utc | 272
I can’t see microscopic text on this screen but they aren’t “tools” they are standard 30 year old HTML tags. Come on.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | May 22 2023 5:11 utc | 251

Ukraine is not a *common* enemy of China and Russia.
But if China were to get *directly* involved it certainly would become one …
Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 4:57 utc | 269

You sure you really know what the Banderites think about yellow people with epicanthic folds?
The following is a real quote, and not even a recent one, but from 2014:

“we are waging a war against the Mongoloid race in fascist Russia that are like locusts creeping towards Ukraine, seeking to destroy our nation”

Which isn’t a random outburst — in fact a core tenet of Ukrainian nationalism is that Russians are subhumans because they are not real Slavs but mongrels mixed with various Finno-Ugric and Mongoloid barbaric hordes.
The contradictions should of course be obvious:
1) There is genetically no difference between people in Bryansk and those in Kiev
2) There are literal siblings fighting on different sides of the war
3) If Finno-Ugric people are subhumans, are the staunch Ukrainian allies in Estonia and Finland aware of that view? Or is it only Russians with Finno-Ugric heritage that are subhuman?
4) If “mongoloids” are subhumans, has anyone told South Korea, Taiwan and Japan about that?
Then there is that minor issue about Nazis and communists which maybe, just maybe has some relevance to the PRC and who rules it.

Posted by: shadowbanned | May 22 2023 5:11 utc | 252

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 4:08 utc | 253
oh a “survey”. never mind the history of Ukraine neo nazis persecuting russian speakers, you have a survey. and you quote Atlantic Council and Bellingcat sources to “reluctantly conclude” that Baud is lying. we weren’t born yesterday, and we’ve seen this act of yours before.

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 5:14 utc | 253

Norwegian | May 22 2023 5:02 utc | 274
Ask the police, who trained for this exact scenario in this precise location the days before, as it was reported in Norway’s largest newspaper Aftenposten (long since erased).
The incident is a knowledge gap for me. I’ve gleaned it’s Norway’s “Port Arthur” [Tasmania/ mass shooting / weird shit with more anomalies than answers].
Port Arthur initial reports had two shooters… quickly reduced to the low-IQ guy they jailed without trial. (A trial would be toooo stressful for the victims. Apparently.) It also meant the many anomalies and contradictions and eyewitness accounts need never be addressed.

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 5:17 utc | 254

Posted by: shadowbanned | May 22 2023 5:11 utc | 277

You sure you really know what the Banderites think about yellow people with epicanthic folds?
The following is a real quote, and not even a recent one, but from 2014:

So you’d like the entire Ukraine, including non-Banderites to be converted to the same ideology?
You think it’s a win for China if millions of Ukrainians with good will towards China now embrace Bandera?
What happens when villages of people who’ve never had a negative thought against an Asian get flattened by Chinese weapons?
You’d like to pump adrenaline and fuel into the relatively limp efforts of the neocons to start a kinetic war against the PRC?

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:22 utc | 255

So you’d like the entire Ukraine, including non-Banderites to be converted to the same ideology?
Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:22 utc | 281

By 2050 or so that will indeed happen if Ukrainian statehood is not erased from the face of the planet. Nobody has any intention to tolerate non-Banderites on that territory

Posted by: shadowbanned | May 22 2023 5:25 utc | 256

Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:07 utc | 275
I thought I’d made it clear I was extracting directly from Saker’s 2014 piece…
——-
Since Day 1, there’s been An Argument that Russia should have stepped in immediately and just sorted shit out.
And here today we have a New Arrival pushing the case that Russia did just that…

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 5:28 utc | 257

Posted by: shadowbanned | May 22 2023 5:25 utc | 283

By 2050 or so that will indeed happen if Ukrainian statehood is not erased from the face of the planet.

Nice argument you’ve made for pre-emptive warfare there.
What next? A vindication of Bush, Obama, Clinton, Blair?

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:36 utc | 258

surveys are often not useful even if the outfit conducting them is legitimate.and once again, you’re playing coy with sources and cites. i think the troll community is in disarray after Ukraine’s major loss, not sure what narrative line to take.

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 5:36 utc | 259

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 5:28 utc | 285
Excuze me. I blame the covid and your crappy formatting.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:36 utc | 260

Re: A three front war
Von Der Leyen is pushing secondary sanctions on China. As a junior partner of the War Party, VdL is the perfect person to promote this dangerous provocation.
The War Party is actively driving towards a 3 Front War against Russia, China, and Iran simultaneously.
Watch this space

Posted by: Exile | May 22 2023 5:37 utc | 261

you claimed Russia was lying and Ukraine was not. you claim Baud is lying and Ukraine is not. you use Bellingcat and the Atlantic council as sources. you’re discrediting yourself, and I for one don’t know why you are so keen on that. like i said, i think the bellingcat/atlantic council troll community is disorganized, and they aren’t sure what line they want to push yet.

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 5:49 utc | 262

Posted by: mjc | May 21 2023 23:38 utc | 195
Not a studious Russia-watcher but this is what I know:
There were anti-Maidan protests throughout east Ukraine in late 2013 and 2014. After the coup, and the return of Crimea, many east Ukrainians figured they too would be accepted into Russia if they held referendums. Local administrative and govt. buildings were seized; Russian nationalists and relatives of Ukrainians crossed the border to help the process. There is no indication of Kremlin involvement.
Later as the indiscriminate ‘anti-terrorism operation’ was launched the Russian govt founded ‘Wagner group’ in Lugansk as a legal way to feed in advisors and trainers to help the locals resist. Donbass residents refer to this euphemistically as the ‘North Wind’ which blew away the ukro-nazi army.

Posted by: Browser | May 22 2023 5:54 utc | 263

Nice argument you’ve made for pre-emptive warfare there.
What next? A vindication of Bush, Obama, Clinton, Blair?
Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:36 utc | 286

Take it easy with the strawmanning.
The US has never fought a defensive war in the last couple centuries. All its interventions were in far away places on the other side of the globe, or it waged wars of conquest against neighbors that were culturally and ethnically completely foreign (the natives, Mexico, Hawaii, Philippines, Cuba, Puerto Rico, etc.).
Ukraine minus Galicia is core historic Russian territory that ended up independent and in these particular borders through an unfortunate series of historic accidents, but that doesn’t change the fact that it is core historic Russian territory. Independence was tolerated as long as it was not a threat to Russia, but once NATO moved in, it could no longer be tolerated — Russia is defending itself from invasion in this case, we are not talking about needless “pre-emptive war”.
The closest historic equivalent to this war is the US Civil War. Imagine Lincoln had been stopped by an international coalition because he had no right to start a war of conquest on the South? What would the US be like today?
P.S. In retrospect this was a huge geostrategic blunder on the side of the major European powers at the time. Including the Russian Tsar who sent ships to prevent a British intervention on the side of the South. They should have all made sure the South became independent and then pumped it with weapons, to make sure the US is never a continental superpower and is always bogged down in an internecine conflict. The way it was done to India with Pakistan. It should have been pretty obvious already then where things were heading in the long term, but apparently nobody had the vision to see it. Now we see how the US is repaying the favor…

Posted by: shadowbanned | May 22 2023 5:57 utc | 264

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 4:08 utc | 253
and by most you mean the vast majority. misleading. and i hope by “working through it” you don’t mean you’re researching more from Bellingcat and the Atlantic Council.
here is something for you to work through, how did Crimea become a part of Ukraine in the 1990’s when it tried to declare independence?

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 22 2023 5:59 utc | 265

I actually was rather content with what NATO did way back then in 1999.
Posted by: whirlX | May 21 2023 20:08 utc | 128
I cannot believe that you believe this BS story. I thought you were more sensible.

Posted by: RB | May 22 2023 6:03 utc | 266

@Melaleuca | May 22 2023 5:17 utc | 280

Port Arthur initial reports had two shooters… quickly reduced to the low-IQ guy they jailed without trial. (A trial would be toooo stressful for the victims. Apparently.) It also meant the many anomalies and contradictions and eyewitness accounts need never be addressed.

Surviving witnesses on the day reported several shooters. The police image of the alleged lone Breivik on the island did not resemble very well the image of him in the trial that was held the year after.
An extremely compressed version of the alleged events is that ‘breivik’ rented a farm at Åsta (~160 Km north of Oslo, near the Rena military camp). He supposedly there created a fertilizer bomb and put it in a rented van. On the big day, he supposedly drove the van to the Government house (I know the exact place because a family member worked in the department of Finance) and blew it up almost 911 style, killing ~8 people (it was a slow Friday afternoon). The government had wanted to demolish the building before. Lots of theatrical injuries on the sidewalks, many details skipped. Then he supposedly used another car parked nearby and drove another 40 Km to Utøya, took the ferry to the island where Stoltenberg’s Labour Party holds its political summer camp every year and where both Stoltenberg and former PM Gro Harlem Brundland (WHO) were scheduled to speak, but were not there during the shootings. He then allegedly proceeded to kill 69 of Stoltenberg’s party members, some of which had banners calling for boycott of Israel’s handling of Palestinians.

Posted by: Norwegian | May 22 2023 6:11 utc | 267

About Zaluzhny Schrödinger
Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of Ukraine Zaluzhny finally appeared in public at a video conference on the occasion of Science Day. For a long time there were rumours that he was either killed or badly wounded. We believe that it could have happened on May 8 during an attack on the bunker in Mezhirichi with two “Daggers”.
And now a video with Zaluzhny appeared on the Web. True, after it there are more questions than answers.
No, we have no doubts about the sincerity of the video: at first we thought it was some kind of processing through neural networks / swap face. Zaluzhny’s speech corresponds to the theme, he himself looks haggard, and the smeared background can be an office somewhere on the ZKP. Well, or a hospital ward.
But two questions arise: when was the video recorded and why did Zaluzhny owe his first public appearance to Science Day ?
It is very strange that there was no announcement of the event against the background of rumours in the media. The video was centrally uploaded yesterday via Odessa Telegram channels, and the primary source is the National University “Odessa Law Academy”. By the way, the rector of the academy, Sergei Kivalov, has been a good friend of Zaluzhny for many years.
The video was published on the YouTube channel of the university on May 19, but it is strange that, against the background of rumours about the death of the commander-in-chief, large Ukrainian media did not distribute it, and this was entrusted to local Odessa nets without much scale.
The video gained the greatest popularity thanks to Russian Telegram channels, where it was uploaded via feedback bots.
The reaction of the audience at the event also looks strange, which seems to be absolutely not interested in what is happening, despite the fact that, in fact, one of the first persons of the non-state Ukraine is speaking.
@rybar
Two Majors

https://t.me/sitreports/9030

Posted by: Down South | May 22 2023 6:23 utc | 268

The disappearance of Zaluzhny, the further escalation of the conflict by London, and the media activity of Budanov – does this have a connection?
There is no doubt that something is wrong with the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. The inability to provide at least some evidence of his health makes Kiev suffer great reputational losses. But is everything so unambiguous and is Bankovaya saddened by the loss of De Gaulle of the Farmer’s Spill?
Recall that for a long time, there has been a struggle between London and Washington for influence over the office of the president, while traditionally the Ministry of Defense was an independent patrimony of the States. There was even an opinion that Zaluzhny, controlled by the White House, was seen as an alternative successor to Zelensky. At the same time, the American media have for a long time sculpted a national hero from an amateur to chat with girls on Instagram.
Now that Zaluzhny is probably injured, and seriously, there are many theories about how this happened. According to many sources, he became a victim of an artillery (or missile) attack by the Wagners on Chasov Yar. The fact of an attempt to eliminate the commander-in-chief is not denied by Yevgeny Prigozhin, but he does not disclose the details and results of the operation. Thus, we can say that the location of Zaluzhny was most likely leaked. And here, recalling the old “games of Kiev thrones”, the question involuntarily arises: who benefited from this drain?
Zelensky, led by Yermak and London, had a different view of the defense of Bakhmut from the general. If the president demanded to fight to the last Ukrainian, then Zaluzhny insisted on withdrawing. By the beginning of May, it became obvious that Bakhmut would fall, and against this background, the commander-in-chief could receive very high political points, which did not suit either Zelensky or London.
The British have long made no secret of the fact that their “specialists” are working on the front line, and in the event of trips to the front line of Zaluzhny, they would probably know about them. It is not difficult for the British intelligence services to leak the coordinates of the general to the Wagners through third parties.
It is noteworthy that at the same time, Britain begins to actively get involved in the conflict and play to raise the stakes – statements about assistance in the supply of F-16s, the use of Storm Shadow, and other similar actions by London at the time of the mysterious disappearance of Zalugny are very similar to attempts to seize the initiative in management Ministry of Defense of Ukraine.
It is obvious that the Americans, having lost their main trump card in this battle, hastily began to look for a replacement. And a powerful media wave aimed at forming a new national hero from the head of the GUR Budanov is just part of this concept of finding a replacement for Zalugny. Budanov is an exceptionally pro-American figure, although he is often presented as an MI6 agent. It is possible that the daring ambush on Russian aviation in the Bryansk region was a kind of revenge for the neutralization of Zaluzhny.
Naturally, the above is only one of the possible conspiracy theories that justify what happened. However, there is no doubt that after the loss of Bakhmut and Zaluzny, very turbulent times are coming for the office on Bankovaya.

https://t.me/Slavyangrad/47218

Posted by: Down South | May 22 2023 6:26 utc | 269

shadowbanned #5:11 utc | 277

Then there is that minor issue about Nazis and communists which maybe, just maybe has some relevance to the PRC and who rules it.

Thank you – nice post. I fully agree.
A black South African and a Chinaman walk into a bar full of banderites to talk peace with Slavs… :/ The outcome is unlikely to be fruitful.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 6:38 utc | 270

HERMIUS #1:51 utc | 224

WANTED!
The following individuals…
ICC Criminal Court Judge and Prosecutor, Khan Karim Asad Ahmad and panel members Tomoko Akane, Rosario Salvatore Aitala and Sergio Gerardo Gerardo Godinez
Charges include: 1) For issuing an illegal arrest warrant for Vladmir Putin, President of the Russian Federation. 2) For wrong doing in the International Criminal Court

Excellent news. The countries that appointed them should revoke their standing and appoint fresh judges or perhaps avoid the pox ridden kangaroo court altogether.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 6:53 utc | 271

I really liked “Sushi’s” comments. So much so I will steal some of it for an article on my Substack newsletter, News Forensics. Ummmm….with credit, of course.
#1 “The victor always writes history (WWII is an exception to this aphorism).” More correctly, “Losers don’t write history”. Winners write history for themselves – not necessarily for the whole team. So the US wrote history– really, a form of cultural propaganda — for the US. The USSR wrote its version for itself. But uniquely, when the USSR collapsed Russia had to look at the facts of its history, pimples and scars and all. So their “history” is more honest and less self-serving of of its elites. Thank you Sushi.
#2 “In February 2020 the US sought to provoke a RF attack on the fortified bunkers of the UAF fronting the Donbass. Evidence is found in the OSCE documentation of an increasing weight of UAF artillery fire on the civilian population, weekly Biden pronouncements on the imminence of RF attack, and Western contempt for repeatedly voiced RF security concerns. ” Russia wisely did not allow itself to be suckered. NATO had built what I have called in my writing a “maginot gird” – fortifying villages and towns against direct Russian assault – a kind of “net” in the case of direct attack.
#3 RF responded to the Western provocations with a hasty attack on multiple axes including a critical airborne landing at Hostomel airport outside Kiev. The intent of these attacks was to: 1) Confuse the UAF as to RF intentions; 2) Force the UAF to abandon their planned offensive and switch to a defensive response, repositioning all their forces to do so; 3) Make clear Russia’s intent to act on its voiced security concerns and its intent to defend itself against further NATO encroachment (UN Article 51 right to self defence); 4) Drive 404 toward negotiations.
Objective 1,2, and 3 were achieved. Objective 4 failed and the RF found itself under increasing pressure as UAF mounted its defensive response to the RF initiative. Russia was forced to acknowledge its the economy of force attack was inadequate in the face of well trained and equipped UAF forces.
Here I disagreed — SLIGHTLY only. The Russian attack as not “hasty”; it had been planned. It was mobile, maneuver combat — which inevitably resulted in losses but was worth it insofar as UAF– then the largest, best equipped NATO army, outnumbering the Russians 3:1 lost a huge chunk their airforce and armor–most important of all — mobility. They then hunkered down in their Maginot Grid. The Russians could not launch frontal assaults. But they could attrit. And with the failure of negotiations and the US doubling down — they knew the “war” was not with Ukraine but with NATO and would take a lot longer. IMO.
Bakhmut (Artyomovsk) was important because it was a keystone of the UAF “Maginot Grid”. But it also revealed the weakness of such static strategies. A fortified town can become a prison for the defenders, a killing field for the attackers.
Well done Sushi! Look forward to more posts. Thanks also to many others here.
My recent post on Bakhmut: https://julianmacfarlane.substack.com/p/prigozhin-and-war-theater

Posted by: julianmacfarlane | May 22 2023 6:56 utc | 272

Proof of Russian forces in eastern Ukraine in 2014: Armata tank seen with Buk launcher that shot down MH-17.
Proof of Russian forces in eastern Ukraine in 2014: Yars strategic missile TEL seen with Buk launcher that shot down MH-17.
There is your “open source photographic evidence”, barfingcat.

Posted by: William Gruff | May 22 2023 7:02 utc | 273

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 6:17 utc | 304
Just scraps of information and speculation from here and there. I recall Chechens fighting in Donbass ’14/15 and they were associated with ‘North Wind’.
Here is Scott Ritter, who has a lot of Russian sources, opining on Wagner-
https://youtu.be/watch?v=rX19LkcUZlc
https://yewtu.be/watch?v=rX19LkcUZlc

Posted by: Browser | May 22 2023 7:04 utc | 274

Will the Armed Forces of Ukraine counterattack on Donetsk? Do they want to turn Donetsk into Mariupol and Artemovsk?
On the night of May 20-21, a large consignment of armored vehicles of the Armed Forces of Ukraine and NGU drove into Avdeevka through the Kurakhovo railway station. During the last 72 hours, wave after wave of enemy manpower arrived in the specified city, incl. and personnel of the so-called. “assault brigades”. In addition, there is a sharp increase in tanks and other military vehicles of Ukraine on the territory of an old brick factory in Krasnogorovka.
They dug underground passages to Donetsk and infantry will pass through them? Which will capture high-rise buildings?

Posted by: mishin05 | May 22 2023 7:17 utc | 275

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 5:00 utc | 271
I think one consequence is that, on this point, the Russian government has been lying, including to the UN, and the Kiev government has been telling the truth.
. . . the ATO wasn’t just an excuse for ethnic cleansing. I think it was that as well, but it was also a genuine response to a covert, low-intensity Russian invasion in support of one side of a Ukrainian civil war.

If you have these beliefs then why are you in the bar asking for evidence? Your mind is made up. You know what is true and not true. You neither need, nor can benefit from, any of our contributions.
To be blunt, you are a fraud. Take your solipsism elsewhere.

Posted by: Sushi | May 22 2023 7:23 utc | 276

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 22 2023 5:01 utc | 273
The videos were viewed by me within days of the events in question. This was the YouTube of ten years ago. There were no YT “minders,” no YT content policies that I remember, and YT Downloaders were not yet a thing.
I regret not having made screen captures. This is how history is shaped. A private entity can eliminate evidence and create bias in the historical record. A pity about the “Don’t be evil” corporate motto.

Posted by: Sushi | May 22 2023 7:34 utc | 277

John Helmer has some very worrying theories on the upcoming Air Defender NATO exercises:
https://johnhelmer.org/bravado-before-capitulation-will-russian-defeat-of-us-patriot-missile-be-followed-by-ukrainian-f-16-attack-during-the-nato-air-defender-23/
Dreizin shares some thoughts on F-16’s:
https://thedreizinreport.com/2023/05/21/the-f-16s/

Posted by: Et Tu | May 22 2023 7:34 utc | 278

Posted by: UWDude | May 22 2023 6:53 utc | 312
Sorry Dude. I have not followed this argument but to an outsider your posts come across as frothy mouthed slander and mjc comes across as measured and reasonable.

Posted by: Tim | May 22 2023 7:42 utc | 279

So where is the contamination cloud now.
Or isn’t it important.

Posted by: Mark2 | May 22 2023 7:46 utc | 280

I surely hope Helmer is wrong.
If previous events are anything to go by, and presuming if Helmer knows/thinks NATO is planning something nefarious, then so does Russia’s MoD.
Which means, just as they have before with alleged false flag nuke attacks and other such provocations, they usually preempt it by announcing it to the public and follow it up with military to military communications aimed to deescalate and prevent the unthinkable.
I’d say in the time between now and June 12 when the operations begin, that will be the one thing to look out for.

Posted by: Et Tu | May 22 2023 7:47 utc | 281

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 5:25 utc | 282
How else should I try to learn if an overall majority of Donbas residents favoured armed uprising in March-April 2014?
Examine the vote in the last election according to language preference and place of residence. You will find the majority of the population voted for the candidate running on a platform of “peace.”
That was Mr Z who has since terminated elections, the political opposition, the free press, the right to express an opinion, and has sent 300,000 of his electorate to their deaths.
And this is the NAZI SOB that you seek to exonerate, the coke addled impresario you believe to be the fount of all truth?

Posted by: Sushi | May 22 2023 7:48 utc | 282

Our source in the OP said that Syrsky is again convincing Zelensky of the attractiveness of his plan, which should allow the Armed Forces of Ukraine to surround the city, and then the Russian troops will leave it.
The commander of the ground forces is confident that Wagner’s withdrawal will allow him to quickly take the enemy’s positions, which means that the counteroffensive must be continued after the rains.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17906

Posted by: Down South | May 22 2023 7:50 utc | 283

Russian ship delivered weapons to South Africa, not the other way around:

The contents of containers offloaded at the South African military’s Simon’s Town naval base by a Russian cargo ship — the Lady R — included “armour-piercing incendiary shells” and machine guns suitable for mounting on aircraft.
This is according to the Sunday Times, which said it had been informed of this by a “highly placed government source.”
It said the source was not authorized to speak to the media and therefore wished to remain anonymous.
The delivery of this shipment sparked diplomatic controversy between South Africa and the United States when US Ambassador Reuben Brigety told reporters the arms transaction had involved South Africa supplying weaponry to Russia.
However, South Africa has insisted no permit had been issued for supplying arms to Russia.
Brigety has since apologized for any “misimpressions” his allegations have caused — but has not officially withdrawn them.
Lady R shipment
Citing its source, Sunday Times reported that the order for these weapons had been placed before the Covid pandemic.
They were reportedly procured from Rosoboronexport — the Russian state entity that exports military hardware, services, and technologies — and the transaction was approved by the National Conventional Arms Control Committee (NCACC), which oversees weapons sales in South Africa.
Armscor was given a permit for this transaction, which had to be renewed three times due to delivery delays.
“It is routine that a permit can be renewed, but, obviously, conditions that existed when it was renewed must not have changed,” said the source…

Posted by: Mike Hampton | May 22 2023 7:51 utc | 284

UWDude | May 22 2023 7:16 utc | 321
…”I further think Putin lied about helping Donbass
FWIW. I don’t think he helped, and thus, didn’t lie.
My understanding is the Eastern Ukraine/ Russian border, up to 2015-16 was more porous and open than the current U$ Mexican “border”.
That is, Ukrainians and Russians moved back and fro with ease. Russians lived in “Ukraine” and Ukrainians lived in Russia. Family members lived either side of this nominal boundary. No body really cared.
Once the illegitimate CIA-Ukrainian government began an extermination against its Russian speaking, Russian sympathetic citizens, then the issue of nationalism grew in importance.
Ukrainians and Russians in Russia began to help their Ukrainian and Russian family and friends in Ukraine.
The Kremlin did fuck all, and this greatly angered the Russians in Ukraine and the Russians in Russia neighbouring the Donbass.
Minsk 1+2 were supposed to resolve the issue and get Putin off the hook… he really didn’t want to get involved.
USNATO of course DID want to escalate… and eventually the killing of Russians in Ukraine became a white hot issue…. And then, in February 2022, at the Munich Security Conference Zelensky said Ukraine would be reactivating it’s nuclear capability.
That lit a fire under Putin’s arse.
And here we are.

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 7:52 utc | 285

Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 3:04 utc | 237
The claim that after Bandera/OUN political movement took over in Kiev, after Odessa terror, after the killing of Mariupol policemen and tanks on the streets, after making the Russian language illegal, the Donbas people needed kindling from Russia.

Posted by: RB | May 22 2023 7:56 utc | 286

Mark2 | May 22 2023 7:46 utc | 326
So where is the contamination cloud
What “contamination” cloud.
There’s no contamination cloud.
Why would there be a contamination cloud?
The BBC CNN has not reported any contamination cloud.
So. There’s obviously no contamination cloud.
You… might *think* blowing up a depot of depleted uranium might lead to a contamination cloud.
But, you wouldn’t want to be considered a conspiracy theorist, right?

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 7:56 utc | 287

Posted by: MJC | May 22 2023 5:27 utc | 284
I support Russian Federation military support for the LDNR militias during Baud’s tenure. That support does not conjure up little green men on the ground in Donbass.
You are a non-sequiter and if I was a true “humanist” I would beat you with a stick. People such as you are more dangerous than you know.

Posted by: Sushi | May 22 2023 8:00 utc | 288

Col from OZ #2:21 utc | 227
Further thoughts after checking out the Chris Busby interview
https://www.bitchute.com/video/iSPw64WMPumB
The Polish and German people are extreme foolish to ignore this but I am sure they will be attacked, gaoled, cancelled and probably gagged and prosecuted in closed courts through the new pandemic health provisions for sowing denialism.
All the state need do is roll out a couple of scientists as paid shills to say “all is good, all is safe” then they will unleash silencing laws on deniers.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 8:02 utc | 289

Interesting ?
Official reason why Ukraine has NOT launched an offensive yet:
Zelenski as commander-in-chief of the army is out of the country !!!!
.
No offensive can take place without the commander-in-chief because ONLY HE has the authority to command….
Should you laugh now?
Zelenski avoids coming back to Ukraine under any pretext….
Cowardice… or calculation, more likely the latter.
Calculation to buy time, time for possibly F16, time for French/English cruise missiles?
Time to possibly use the NATO maneuvers?
Putin made it clear:
Start any delivered F16 from Poland or Romania to fight in the Ukraine..these airfields are targets!
.
But no matter: Zelenski is currently avoiding Ukraine like the devil avoids holy water… always finding new reasons to stay away…
Even media in the West are now noticing this….

Posted by: mo3.1 | May 22 2023 8:03 utc | 290

@ Sushi
I want to type: “I love you, sushi”. But that would be silly and inappropriate, and would probably be misconstrued, especially on an anonymous internet blog such as this.
So I wont.

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 8:06 utc | 291

@Posted by: mjc | May 22 2023 6:37 utc | 310
Nobody here has to help slow people like you figure anything out, loser. If you lack critical thinking abilities, then keeping up with current events just isn’t for you. Stick to drawing with chalk on the sidewalks or eating jello.
Nobody cares about your “morality” either. Westerners like you are losing. You and your culture will be extinct by the end of this century. Your fake hypocrite morality will go extinct with you.

Posted by: FVK | May 22 2023 8:08 utc | 292

President Joe Biden said Sunday that Ukraine President Volodymyr Zelenskyy assured him personally he won’t use F-16 fighter jets to attack Russian territory.

Posted by: shoplifter | May 22 2023 8:13 utc | 293

Melaleuce @ 334 Thaaank yooou
At least I know there’s a few people out there with a pulse ! Your right it’s …..
The dog that didnt bark.
Maybe Vladimir Putin didn’t speak loud enough for them to here.
And I don’t mean by words.
Maybe were 2 or 3 steps into nucular war, and the wise old elephants of MOA have become so lacking in agility of mind that their to slow to realise the true import.
Thank Col of Aus for me next time you see him. The guys my hero.
And for every one else…..
Wake the fuck uuuuup.

Posted by: Mark2 | May 22 2023 8:14 utc | 294

Chris Busby has a web page:
https://greenaudit.org/
He has not published any of his Khmelnytsky thoughts there yet and is considering a utoob report.
and a facebook page but I don’t go there.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 8:15 utc | 295

Posted by: julianmacfarlane | May 22 2023 6:56 utc | 314
I really liked “Sushi’s” comments. So much so I will steal some of it for an article on my Substack newsletter, News Forensics. Ummmm….with credit, of course.
Please credit b and the MoA bar. This is an irascible community dedicated to some semblance of truth finding and I believe we all feel in debt to our gracious host.

Posted by: Sushi | May 22 2023 8:21 utc | 296

Melaleuca #8:06 utc | 338
re Sushi love fest… seconded

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 22 2023 8:21 utc | 297

Mark2 | May 22 2023 8:14 utc | 342
Putting the fusion into your fish n chips
>… A massive fish die off (including beavers) in rivers in the proximity to the depleted uranium depot explosion….
https://t.me/iEarlGreyTV/5578

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 22 2023 8:22 utc | 298

Posted by: julianmacfarlane | May 22 2023 6:56 utc | 314
“The victor always writes history (WWII is an exception to this aphorism).”
This references the fact the German military high command, those not executed after Nuremberg, were hired by the US military to learn details of their operational doctrine and how to battle the Soviets.
The Wehrmacht elite used this platform to write self-serving history blaming Hitler for every failure and exonerating themselves while obscuring the exact nature of their crimes against humanity.
It was not until the collapse of the Soviet Union that the Russian archives became available to researchers such as David Glantz who has since written a revisionary history of the Ost Front in a series of volumes.

Posted by: Sushi | May 22 2023 8:31 utc | 299

Melaleuce and uncle tungsten
Count me in on the love fest re Sushi
Agility of mind.
Regards the dead fish…
This is the sort of impotant detail we should be tracking down.
For sure we won’t be able to trust the official monitors.
It’s for the good we have eyes open not closed.
Basicaly my scaremongering is deliberate, necessary. And urgent.
Alot of good folk here have become conditioned and lost the sharp edge.
Maybe MOA needs rotation of its troops perhaps.

Posted by: Mark2 | May 22 2023 8:36 utc | 300