Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
May 12, 2023
Ukraine Open Thread 2023-113

Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

Posted by: The Dolphin | May 13 2023 3:09 utc | 195

Pundits of all stripes waffle on about who will “win”.

People don’t know what winning means.
Just take the Cold War for example.
They celebrated the fall of the USSR.
Yet there the enemy stands:
Still the biggest nuclear power in history.
More economically powerful that ever.
More connected to the globe than ever.
As lethal as it was at it’s height in the 20th century.
What was won?
What was lost?
Who were the winners?
Did The Game ever end?
Who called it?

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 13 2023 4:02 utc | 201

Posted by: Clyde | May 13 2023 2:38 utc | 193

I posted this to show you just how unhinged and clueless some on here are. Get help.

Bye. Nice knowing you.
Not.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 13 2023 4:08 utc | 202

Going thru and repacking boxes of my old stuff, I picked up a book, Tao-Te-Ching by Lao Tzu. I randomly picked a page to read and landed on page 39, Book 1 Chapter 30 and had to share what I read:
Book 1
Chapter 30

(Of all the excesses, the most prejudicial, the most damnable, are those of weapons; war.)
A. Those who act as advisors to a prince should keep themselves from wanting to make war against a country. (For such action, calling for revenge, is always paid for dearly.) Wherever the troops stay, the land produces only thorns, having been abandoned by the farm-workers. Wherever a great army has passed, years of unhappiness (from famine and lawlessness) follow.
B. Therefore the good general is content to do only what he has to do (the least possible; moral, rather than material repression). He stops as soon as possible, guarding himself from exploiting his force to the limit. He does as much as required (to establish peace), not for his own advantage and fame, but from necessity and with reluctance, without any intention of increasing his power.
C. For each maximum of power is always followed by decadence. Making oneself powerful is therefore contrary to the Principle (the source of duration). He who is lacking on this point, will not be long in coming to an end.

All the best

Posted by: nathan in WA US | May 13 2023 4:28 utc | 203

It has seemed for some months conceivable an enlarged conflict field would likely be Poland and Germany. In the skies first, then God knows what quickly next.
Britain jumped line.

Posted by: Elmagnostic | May 13 2023 4:34 utc | 204

Posted by: nathan in WA US | May 13 2023 4:28 utc | 206

C. For each maximum of power is always followed by decadence. Making oneself powerful is therefore contrary to the Principle (the source of duration). He who is lacking on this point, will not be long in coming to an end.

Power Corrupts and Absolute Power Corrupts Absolutely.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 13 2023 4:38 utc | 205

We do not know for what reason the section of the front was abandoned, what kind of contingent was on the defensive there, and why, after a light shelling, the whole unit retreats, and does not hold the position. Usually as a result of just such a “retreat” people die even more.
https://t.me/rybar/46955
Posted by: Down South | May 12 2023 16:13 utc | 21
We don’t know the reasons for what we are seeing.
We do know that the current situation around Bakmuth looks an awful lot like the situation around Kharkiv last year:
– Ukraine piles up tens of thousands of troups along with tanks and artillery, for weeks on end.
– bloggers warn for weeks about a massive attack in the making, even predict (correct!!!) dates for the attack
– the Russian generals appear completely surprised, have nothing prepared, no defense lines to speak of, not nearly enough experienced soldiers, not enough ammo, no second, no third line of defense. The Russian military bureaucracy chose to instead NOT prepare for an offensive in the South, which, when it starts, will surise them equally.
(Suggestion to Putin: for the next round of mobilization, start by sending your generals and those clueless MoD- bureaucrats into the trenches. Right in front the next Ukrainian force buildup. So they see exactly what the Russian soldiers at the front see, before they die.)
Coming soon:
– for a couple weeks, optimists will speculate that Russia has prepared a trap which will spring when enough clueless Ukrainians have walked into it
– after losing Bakmuth and Donezk and Melitopol, they will start doubting their theories and instead argue that the new front lines are now easier to defend etc etc etc
– when the UK, pardon me, Ukraine, no sorry, terrorists, blow up the Ketsch bridge, this time for good, Putin will be furious and waste an awful lot of money blowing up some Ukrainian infrastructure that is completely irrelevant for the war. Instead of, say, bridges or railway junctions that would actually make it more difficult for Ukraine to move troups.
– winter freezes the Ukrainian attacks, Russia starts posting daily “successes” again – a barn blown up here, an oaktree destroyed there, fifty square meters of Marinka captured and another twenty Ukrainian soldiers killed, leaving Selensky with only 499980 for next year’s offensive.
Maybe its different this time. But April and May this year look an awful lot like August and September last year.

Posted by: Marvin | May 13 2023 4:40 utc | 206

@The Dolphin | May 13 2023 3:09 utc | 195
You say to me “do try to keep up,” but the admit you have no idea what is going on or what a win would mean. Russia has not taken Donbas yet, and there is no one honest with whom Russia can negotiate. The U.S. can’t be trusted WITH ANYTHING, even if they would negotiate. The rest of NATO simply follows U.S. demands. So I ask “where are we going and why are we in this handbasket?”

Posted by: Cesar Jeopardy | May 13 2023 4:53 utc | 207

Scorpion #3:47 utc | 201

Meanwhile, I continue to believe – or hope – that one of RF’s goals is to engender internal political turmoil in Western nations, principally Germany who at some point might push for proper sovereignty and join Belt and Road.

Poland first and maybe simultaneously the Baltic poodles would be my idea of a good BBQ. By then Germany might have realised its blunder and perhaps reconsidered its vassal relationship to the USA. Not holding my breath as this is a looooong process of unravelling the EU snake and then the NATO lizard. That reconfiguration is pretty much up to them as I doubt Russia has any intention of kinetic fuckery with them in the immediate term. Mind you Russia is likely receptive to accommodating much of their heavy energy form of engineering needs should they ask nicely, pay in Roubles, bypass any transport corridor via Poland, and integrate their manufacturing plant with Russian materials science research. Germany and a few others might shed their US bases too.
Perhaps Poland stands out as being in NEED of extraordinary persuasion but they could resolve their issues at the ballot box sooner rather than later. I personally don’t mind if they sink under the Baltic waves.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 13 2023 4:54 utc | 208

@The Dolphin | May 13 2023 3:09 utc | 195
You say to me “do try to keep up,” but then admit you have no idea what is going on or what a win would mean. Russia has not taken Donbas yet, and there is no one honest with whom Russia can negotiate. The U.S. can’t be trusted WITH ANYTHING, even if they would negotiate. The rest of NATO simply follows U.S. demands. So I ask “where are we going and why are we in this handbasket?”
Posted by: Cesar Jeopardy | May 13 2023 4:53 utc | 210
Not a good reader, are you? And dont you BLATANTLY MISQUOTE ME.
I DID NOT say I didn’t know what was going on. I DID say I couldn’t predict who would “win” according to my clearly explained criteria for what “winning” might actually mean for Russia … which was your original query,remember? The reason I put “winning” in quotes is because it has different connotations according to who uses it. So I tried to explain how Russia’s goals for “winning” have (and still keep) shifted.
Yes, do try to keep up. Bit hard if you’re a bit slow, though.

Posted by: The Dolphin | May 13 2023 5:11 utc | 209

Sigh!
1. Alleged Strom attack in LPR, probably fake. UK/US/France scaled down and did not repeat their strike against the Assad regime when Syrian AD took down all missiles and Russia threaten to take down launching vehicles.
2. Definition of a “Counter Offensive”
“In the study of military tactics, a counter-offensive is a large-scale strategic offensive military operation, usually by forces that had successfully halted the enemy’s offensive, while occupying defensive positions.
The counter-offensive is executed after exhausting the enemy’s front line troops and after the enemy reserves had been committed to combat and proven incapable of breaching defenses, but before the enemy has had the opportunity to assume new defensive positions. Sometimes the counter-offensive can be of a more limited operational maneuver nature, with more limited objectives rather than those seeking attainment of a strategic goal”. (Wikipedia)
The RF has NOT gone into a general or local “Offensive” for a “Counter Offensive” to take place.
3. Patriot took down Kinzhal. BS! Aegis ships and Aegis ashore couldn’t even track, must less shoot down Nth Korean Ballistic missile tests.https://militarywatchmagazine.com/article/radar-evading-ballistic-missiles-from-north-korea-aegis-air-defence-system-fails-to-track-new-projectiles
4. Kinzhal/NATO 200+ KIA. Not on any RF clobber list.
There’re many things I don’t know, but I’m certain there’s going to be less NATO proxies operating on the entire front line than there were today and that makes me happy.
This is the RF situation on the Front as of 11th May https://sputnikglobe.com/20230511/russias-special-military-operation-in-ukraine-and-how-it-is-progressing-1105665248.html

Posted by: Suresh | May 13 2023 5:18 utc | 210

People don’t know what winning means.
Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 13 2023 4:02 utc | 204
Exactly my point — unless specific goals are delineated … like the SMO vs AFU, and like Russia NOW has geopolitically against the Anglo hegemons. They were my points to @Caesar. Putin said it (paraphrased): “We only came in to do a little thing, but if you push us, well do more for longer”. Exactly where the end of “winning is”, noone knows. Lol.

Posted by: The Dolphin | May 13 2023 5:20 utc | 211

Turkey and its elections will be the place to watch in the near future. The gas hub deal with Russia to bypass nazi eastern Europe and the Anglo blockade there and western Europe can buy ‘Turk’ piped gas rather than Russian piped gas or expensive US LNG. There is also the matter of Turkey Syria moving towards normalizing relations which will make them allies against the US and its Kurd proxies. Also the matter of getting Nato ships through to the black sea.
I assume there will be at massive anglo effort at subversion and interference.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | May 13 2023 5:22 utc | 212

[211]
You float in a fact-free void. Germany cannot expel US bases because it has no right to do so. Those US bases closed in Germany were closed by U.S. – to consolidate Inman expanded base in Wiesbaden even after closing the old base which is now Europaviertel.
Germany has no majority government – and now no government can be formed without Greens which is why CDU will not damage Habeck though he is exposed for political corruption and Scholz is acting like von Papen trying to control Hitler
Germany is locked into doom-loop and industry is looking for the exit. US has irretrievably weakened Western Europe economically and politically and once US implodes it will leave Europe politically and socially destabilised

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 5:30 utc | 213

@ uncle tungsten 213
As in all life , disrespect has to be countered. If Nato Atlantacafantacists want to play war games with tin soldiers, they have to be disabused of their dreams, and no amount of China asking Russia to stop disabusing Atlantasatanists from playibg war games is going to stop Russia from enforcing some proper respect.
The idea that an evil and entirely self interested Empire thousands of miles away can satisfy European pangs of regret at losing their colonial power and influence is the wrong way of looking at life. Jeremy Corbyn understood that the being empire-free and trading fairly with the world is better by far than exploiting your own colonies OR becoming a colony of the US.
But the EU poodles wanted Empire and now they’ve got it and are being treated like a small African state lured into genocide.
Ukraine is merely the US empire responding to EU dreams of power with war in Europe.
As Corbyn wisely understood, the only way not to be used as toy tin soldiers by the new evil Empire of lies, is to relinquish your dreams of empire.
Something the Empire 2 British Tories are finding it hard to give up.

Posted by: Giyane | May 13 2023 5:31 utc | 214

[204]
War and winning are not reconcilable concepts. You fight war to survive by destroying the threats you perceive at whatever cost.
Britain fought two world wars and survived bankrupt and with huge debts and loss of territory. It gained nothing whatsoever – it left future generations economically poorer and subject to financial repression – U.K. had exchange controls 1949-1979 and you could not own gold or have more than £50 in foreign currency
Russia has to drive military threats from its borders by expanding the sanitary zone Stalin acquired after 1945 and making it a DMZ which should improve prosperity of nations not buying weapons on credit from US and S Korea
It then needs to have an umbrella protectorate over independent states formed from former USSR to secure its region

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 5:38 utc | 215

Perhaps Poland stands out as being in NEED of extraordinary persuasion but they could resolve their issues at the ballot box sooner rather than later. I personally don’t mind if they sink under the Baltic waves.
Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 13 2023 4:54 utc | 211
Well, my little thesis was predicated on the assumption that military kinetics will remain within Ukraine (as was). The regime changes will occur because of domestic cratering of the status quo opening the door to a wave of long overdue reforms. This will take time. Another reason why RF has no motivation to advance beyond the current oblasts who voted to join the Russian Federation. As long as the enemy is coming to them in the Donbass, or maybe soon probing towards Crimea, they can wage a war of attrition part of which involves military logistics and personnel on the ground, but most of which is more slowly playing out in the geopolitical non-military theater, i.e. more of an economic and cultural conflict. I don’t believe that RF has any interest in entering and conquering other nations with different languages etc. What they want is a multipolar world order with peace on her borders.
One irony here, seemingly, is that to unify the world first they have to divide it. The sanctions (aka trade war) now underway is basically cutting off the West from easy global pickings as the BRICS et alia nations increase their own internal trade flows. This will weaken the West considerably – though again these things take time – and thus (my thesis again) cause internal domestic cratering that will engender needed reforms. RF cannot make any of this happen in these many other foreign nations, but at least they can lead a coalition of those willing to isolate the West in order to immediately reduce their ability to dominate and meddle whilst simultaneously seizing the initiative in building a different international modus vivendi with well over half the world, moreover the part with the most resources and growth momentum, not to mention relative political stability and cultural cohesiveness. As far as I can tell, this is going extremely well and basically they have already ‘won.’ The only wild card is how desperately destructive the West is willing to get. (Another reason to keep the kinetics in Donbass, not advancing far but steadily wearing out resistance.)
Some Russian commenters are saying that the grumblings from Bahkmut etc. are significant indicating weakness in the Russian leadership, even traitors from their own Deep State networks etc. and there may be truth to that. Texas Bentley, though very loyal, has been extremely critical for over a year now, even more so of late reportedly, because he feels that RF has been dragging their heels all along (and states that the MoD reports are total BS), but again I don’t see how RF has any need or desire to advance too far because it might make an already huge front even more unmanageable than it already almost is – not to mention provoke more European states to up the ante and send in troops. But again, they have no territorial ambitions which will just bring more headaches. (Crimea to Vladivostok with its 11 time zones is enough!) This may well prove extremely frustrating to those on the ground in Donbass who naturally wish the front to push straight to Kiev ASAP and be done with it already.
I suppose the big schlusselpunkt is going to be whether or not Ukraine can mount a serious counterattack into Donbass, or more importantly Crimea, AND THEN BE ABLE TO HOLD any such advances and then later go further. This seems extremely unlikely right now, but time will tell. That said, if they cannot advance and hold such territories, the geopolitical siege warfare with continue its longer, slower grind and people on the ground in Donbass will continue to grind their teeth with frustration at Moscow’s slow grind approach.
This is probably going to take 10-20 years or some such, but what do I know? Except, as I often speculate here, the West is also working on the same agenda, namely their elites crashing their own nation states in order to Build Back Better. If this is indeed a Grand Coalition type play, then the whole thing might play out in only a few years. We shall see.

Posted by: Scorpion | May 13 2023 5:46 utc | 216

https://www.newsweek.com/ukraine-counteroffensive-invade-russia-capture-territory-putin-igor-girkin-1799866
A new person to this site and to trying to understand what it all means. ANy thoughts about this article’s claims?

Posted by: Questionperson | May 13 2023 5:50 utc | 217

Women are hypergamous, and always have been. It’s a fundamental truth of the relationship between the sexes.
Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 13 2023 2:33 utc | 192
Actually its a fundamental of the fact that there are classes in the first place and humans will do what they need to to survive in such a parasitic system. You don’t show much understanding of society or women in your rants.
As for presidents or any powerful men (or women) they abuse people in “lower classes” because they can and with impunity. it is about power and not primarily for sex.

Posted by: K | May 13 2023 5:52 utc | 218

⚡️🇷🇺🇺🇦⚔️ Battle for #Bakhmut – Situation at the End of 12 May 2023⚡️
▪️ Units of the Wagner PMC continue to dig into enemy defences in the western neighbourhoods of #Bakhmut: overnight, the stormtroopers managed to occupy several houses in the “Gnezdo” fortified area. Exactly two square kilometres of territory remain under the control of the enemy.
➖ All three strongholds – Nest, Constructor and Domino – are relatively small blocks of flats. The Ukrainian formations have equipped firing points in them, and when the PMC approach, they mine entrances and undermine the approaches.
▪️ In the afternoon, footage appeared confirming the retreat of the RF Armed Forces to the south of the #Berkhovskoye Reservoir. The fire control from the heights north of the Chasov Yar – #Khromovo road was lost, and the RF Armed Forces were taking up defences along the eastern bank of the reservoir.
▪️ In the evening, Ukrainian resources posted video of the counterattack by the 56th AFU Mechanized Brigade vs. the positions of the RF Armed Forces to the west of Dubovo-Vasilyevka. The footage depicts the fight and the retreat of a part of the Russian unit from the abandoned positions. The withdrawal of Russian units reported by PMC Wagner’s military correspondents takes place south of this point (we have marked it on the map), but there is no video confirmation yet.
📌 While Wagner PMC assault squads are digging into the western neighbourhoods of #Bakhmut, the RF Armed Forces units arriving on rotation are retreating to the 2nd and 3rd lines of defence. Ukrainian formations do not stop pressing on the flanks.
So far, the retreats have been in relatively small areas, which nevertheless came at a heavy price for the “Bandwagon”. But if the regular units do not consolidate and the configuration of forces on the front (as well as the approaches) does not change, the outcome of such regroupings could become even more deplorable.

https://t.me/sitreports/8565

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 5:53 utc | 219

⚡️🇷🇺🇺🇦⚔️ #Chronicle of the Special Military Operation for 12 May 2023⚡️
🔹 One of the Main Events in the SMO Zone was the missile strike on #Lugansk on Republic Day. To be honest, we are not sure that the strike was carried out by the Thunder-2 missile defense System. In the Ukrainian theater of operations, the United States and Great Britain are working on promising ways to break through the enemy’s air defence and defences in the face of the RF Armed Forces as part of a massive missile and artillery strike. And the use of air-based deception missiles is poorly connected with the use of OTRC (operational-tactical missile complex).
🔹 As for the fighting, in #Bakhmut, the PMC units continued to bite into the defence, while to the north, the units of the RF Armed Forces performed a “maneuver” and left the occupied lines.
🔹 And the Russian Aerospace Forces destroyed one bridge.

https://t.me/sitreports/8567

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 5:55 utc | 220

There are details on the impact in Lugansk.
Why was it concluded that this is a British storm? Not many options. Either the OTRK Thunder, or the Storm cruise missile, those are the missiles with sufficient range.
But Thunder, by virtue of its trajectory, rises high, and from this it is clearly visible for air defenses; Storm, on the contrary, goes low. Video with traces, apparently after being dropped from an airplane, the flight is still at an altitude, and a trace remains from the marching turbojet engine. After the rocket reached its standard low flight altitude, no traces were visible.
Well, plus the discovery in Lugansk of a decoy for cruise missiles, a regular decoy.
Based on this, we can conclude that training for these missiles has been ongoing for a long time, the delivery was also a long time ago, and yesterday’s mention of them was only a signal of readiness to use them. Therefore, the blow took place the next day, and again, the media component was also taken into account, a holiday in the LPR.
And accordingly, for sure, these missiles are part of the plan for the expected offensive. If yesterday, in fact, the softening of our positions and the search for weaknesses began, then at the decisive moment, we must be ready for mass launches of Storms. Including with decoys, for overloading air defense.

https://t.me/sitreports/8573

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 5:56 utc | 221

Children and their parents were taken from the front-line village of Krasnorechenskoye, which is located very close to the front line, to rest in Anapa.
Thanks to the energy and efforts of Anna Yuryevna, the military personnel who are on the Kremennaya-Svatovo line, the assistance of the Ministry of Defense, United Russia, the departure of the children happened and was successful. The departure was prepared for a month, taking into account all the risks.
In Krasnorechenskoye, the humanitarian situation is difficult due to the proximity of the settlement to the LBS. Kuznetsova has been engaged in this systematic work for a long time. Children and parents are taken out of places with a difficult humanitarian situation in the resort areas of Russia.

https://t.me/epoddubny/15933

We still took them out and the children and their parents will finally be safe and able to rest!
There is no communication with some villages, and it is extremely dangerous and difficult to get there. There are those who really need help, but it is extremely difficult to do this. Only our soldiers go there. They carry medicines, food, but every day from the side of the Armed Forces of Ukraine they fly to residential buildings. Of course, families with children have the hardest time there. Therefore, if there is a connection with the military, then we will arrange for families with children to go on vacation until the acute situation passes.
But there are situations when there is no way … There is simply no connection, and you can’t get there yourself. About one such territory and talked with Evgeny Poddubny. And he took it and went, brought the necessary information and we were able to start the work! Children with their parents were forced to be transported in small groups, in armored vehicles. There was no question of a bus, even if we wrote “CHILDREN”, the enemy would not care, he would hit the children too …
The road was not close, we drove to Rubizhnoye, whose residents were also helped to leave the territory for a while. It was they who finally dispelled the “horror stories” that were pumped up the people in Ukraine about the “terrible Russians.” Before leaving, they talked with their parents: “We were told that they would take you out and you would disappear forever!”
But now it’s all over. The children got on the bus and went to rest. The partners of our headquarters, the public organization “Healthy Fatherland” periodically send videos of how children travel, enjoy simple things, including eating normally. And we continue to work and thank everyone who helps!

https://t.me/wargonzo/12488

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 6:01 utc | 222

https://t.me/sitreports/8573
Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 5:56 utc | 224

I don’t think it is worth reading “the info” from the Telegram channels…:)

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 6:05 utc | 223

To Elmer Fudd @103
Look at this . This link contains information on the congenital abnormalities many blame on DU.
https://truthout.org/articles/fallujah-babies-birth-defects-blamed-on-us-weapons/
You would not want this stuff where your family lives.

Posted by: Judge Barbier | May 13 2023 6:06 utc | 224

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 5:38 utc | 218
Agreed fully. And what you describe in so many words as Russia’s goals/needs has been put most succinctly by Mearshiemer and Ritter as “A Whole New European Security Framework” which puts everybody at ease for a century or two. THAT is Putin’s goals for RF’s western side. The main force opposing that is the US.
It’s classic divide and conquer. So Putin and Xi are just mirroring that with the rising East plus the South against the old West. To me, that’s the Big Picture. Ukraine is just a pimple on a pumpkin.

Posted by: The Dolphin | May 13 2023 6:08 utc | 225

For example, “wargonzo” had re-reported a telegram post of another such Telegram “reporter” Anna KuZnetsoVa…and so on…They don’t have the real picture, might be just a part of it, and that part is so tiny…

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 6:09 utc | 226

“Explosions reported in Russian-occupied Luhansk”, shouts CNN, but it “forgets” to say that those two missiles were just shot blindly and fell on unused factory buildings quite far away from the centre of Lugansk. This heading is there for more than 12 hours now.
BBC, for example, doesn’t have much to say since yesterday…

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 6:15 utc | 227

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 5:56 utc | 224

we must be ready for mass launches of Storms. Including with decoys, for overloading air defense.

Ha ha ha @ “mass launches”. Watch them bleed out of production capacity in a few days.
Await the mournful complaints from western talking heads around how “we have runout of stocks of stormshadow missiles but are preparing production contracts for future …” …
The West and their artisanal weapons systems.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 13 2023 6:18 utc | 228

7 hr 52 min ago
“Ukraine successfully used the US Patriot air defense system, officials say.”
From CNN staff
This is what the people in the “west” is fed of…”officials say”

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 6:18 utc | 229

That’s the most infuriating actually, seeing people just move over and repeat the same old tripe week after week,
Posted by: Micron | May 12 2023 20:07 utc | 106
Micropenis is infuriated and projecting like a typical jew

Posted by: Mike | May 13 2023 6:19 utc | 230

It’s impressive that modern reactive armour can protect a tank so well. And yet, it seems like being inside that tank when the missile hit might be a truly unpleasant experience. Do the occupants really survive basically unharmed and able to continue?

Posted by: Boris Badenov | May 13 2023 6:34 utc | 231

Re: Euros or USA collapse first ?
The societal divisions in the US are so enormous that USA will collapse first in a Spanish Civil War scenario. (My guess)
Note, that most Americans live precarious lives with hardly any economic security. Only a minuscule percentage of Americans aren’t burdened with obscene amounts of debt. Even the supposed prosperous upper middle class in the USA are always teetering on the edge of insolvency. Social bonds on America are also weak, since society is so geographically mobile.
Revolutions don’t happen when the poor become further impoverished; revolutions happen when the middle class becomes improverished.

Posted by: Exile | May 13 2023 6:43 utc | 232

obscene amounts of debt.
Posted by: Exile | May 13 2023 6:43 utc | 235

That obscene debt is the other side of the ledger of fictitious capital.
Fictitious capital of the middle class was the target of Bernanke’s asset inflation policy.
The lower classes inability to meet their debt burden will collapse the value of fictitious capital and impoverish the middle class.

Posted by: too scents | May 13 2023 7:06 utc | 233

Women are hypergamous, and always have been. It’s a fundamental truth of the relationship between the sexes.
Posted by: LoveDonbass | May 13 2023 2:33 utc | 192
Actually its a fundamental of the fact that there are classes in the first place and humans will do what they need to to survive in such a parasitic system. You don’t show much understanding of society or women in your rants.
As for presidents or any powerful men (or women) they abuse people in “lower classes” because they can and with impunity. it is about power and not primarily for sex.
Posted by: K | May 13 2023 5:52 utc | 221

Thank you K. It’s so refreshing when someone succinctly cuts through the bullshit spew that makes up an unfortunate amount of the postings on this site.

Posted by: Drinky Crow | May 13 2023 7:10 utc | 234

Can people stop posting about something called “British Storm” or “Storm” ? It is BS.
The weapon is called “Shadow Storm” in UK and “SCALP-EG” in France and is made by MBDA
Ukraine has been sent the EXPORT version with 250km range – around 40 I think. That means France must have signed off on UK supplying them.
It can be used with Ukrainian aircraft ONLY because it is programmed on the ground and not from the cockpit so it needs only mounting pylons.
That means UK personnel must be programming targets into the missile in-situ

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 7:15 utc | 235

their elites crashing their own nation states in order to Build Back Better
You mean like Adolf Hitler and the Nazis destroying the German Reich so that the Federal Republic could be built in West Germany as the most prosperous and free German society in its history ?
Not sure that was his intent – but I suppose Adenauer who had been mayor of Cologne pre-Hitler did get to build his Rhineland Republic after 1949…………..
I don’t think “elites” believe anything they say – they chant mantras in the Temple of Money to keep their palms greased with silver …………since most Western politicians are trained lawyers they spout incantations without belief in veracity or meaning

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 7:21 utc | 236

Note, that most Americans live precarious lives with hardly any economic security. Only a minuscule percentage of Americans aren’t burdened with obscene amounts of debt. Even the supposed prosperous upper middle class in the USA are always teetering on the edge of insolvency. Social bonds on America are also weak, since society is so geographically mobile.
Posted by: Exile | May 13 2023 6:43 utc | 235

Agreed. But I found it helpful to note that officially about 1/10 of US Americans are millionaires (wealth, not income). Yes, it’s wikipedia and I can think of a bag of caveats but perhaps still good to know.
Never forget: we’re talking about the “indispensable nation”, the “city on the hill” and “God’s own country” (said by Obama, among many others). I’ve seen homeless beggars in the USA with little US flags on their shopping carts. As a German, I am thoroughly impressed by the level of indoctrination they’ve achieved.

Posted by: Konami | May 13 2023 7:30 utc | 237

@Paul Greenwood
“I don’t think “elites” believe anything they say”
Actually, I think the opposite is true; there are, of course, always cynics, but usually, people tend to believe their own ideology, even and particularly among the elites – and this can become a problem, because they get caught in their own propaganda and are not longer able to make pragmatic decisions. The current EU politics towards Russia is a good example: not matter how this war will end, the EU will be much weaker and poorer afterwards; maybe I am missing something, but I find it hard to explain the current madness with an secret ulterior motive; the frightening thing is that people like Baerbock indeed see the world as a manichean struggle between democracy and autocracy in which no compromise or long term modus vivendi is possible – with all the horrifying results.

Posted by: Confused | May 13 2023 7:34 utc | 238

[238]
It is a fire and forget missile, programmed before launch. Once launched, the missile cannot be controlled, its target information changed or be self-destructed. Mission planners programme the missile with the target air defences and target. The missile follows a path semi-autonomously, on a low flight path guided by GPS and terrain matching to the area of the target.[citation needed] Close to the target, the missile climbs and then bunts into a dive. Climbing to altitude is intended to achieve the best probability of target identification and penetration. During the bunt, the nose cone is jettisoned to allow a high resolution infrared camera to observe the target area. The missile then tries to locate its target based upon its targeting information. If it can not, and there is a high risk of collateral damage, it will fly to a crash point instead of risking inaccuracy.

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 7:37 utc | 239

Arestovich confirmed our information from the Office of the President that in the upcoming counteroffensive we will bet on psychological operations, the purpose of which is to demoralize the enemy.
The main stake in the counteroffensive of the Armed Forces of Ukraine is on the demoralization of the Russian army. If it can be achieved, then the forecasts about the Ukrainians reaching the borders of 1991 may come true this year, said Alexei Arestovich, a former adviser to the President’s Office.
But, if the Russians cannot be demoralized, then the war, in his opinion, will drag on. What does Zaluzhny say when assessing the counteroffensive that it is pointless to hope for a mass exodus.
“The main condition is a moral and psychological crisis in the Russian group, so that it, as they say, crumble. Because if it shows miracles of stamina and heroism, then it will be very difficult to fight them. And then we take the skeptical position of General Milli, who says that this year is unlikely,” Arestovich said in an interview with journalist Vasily Golovanov.
He goes on to describe how, in his opinion, the “demoralization strategy” could work if the Ukrainian army enters the border with Crimea.
According to Arestovich, if the Armed Forces of Ukraine approach the peninsula and start shelling it, “this should provoke a certain crisis within Russia,” and Putin will have to make a decision “either to escalate or de-escalate.”
If no decision is made in Russia, but they continue to fight in the same format, then Arestovich predicts the next few offensives of the Armed Forces of Ukraine (which other Ukrainian speakers recently spoke about, who called for not considering the planned offensive “decisive”).
Separately, it should be clarified that Zaluzhny is skeptical about assessing the effectiveness of the psychological component and offers more thoughtful operations.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17728

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 7:43 utc | 240

MI6 conveyed to the Office of the President a demand to fake contacts with Erdogan so as not to discredit future protests.
According to British intelligence, Erdogan is preparing fraud to win the first round of the presidential elections in Turkey, and this will cause mass protests.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17729

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 7:44 utc | 241

One of the reasons why Zelensky is delaying the counteroffensive is the awareness of the risks of negative scenarios. Now this has become an obvious factor for everyone, and a month ago, only political telegram channels wrote about it.
The level of Western support for Ukraine depends on the success of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, and in the event of a military failure, Kyiv will be pushed to negotiate with Russia. The Financial Times writes about this with reference to Ukrainian officials.
https://t.me/resident_ua/17360
In particular, to the deputy head of the Office of the President Andrei Sibigu. “This is a defining moment for us. The level of Western support depends on our success. The more we achieve on the battlefield, the more we get from partners,” he says.
More privately, Ukrainian officials use rhetoric they themselves describe as “extremely realistic and pragmatic.”
They admit that Ukraine is unlikely to be able to return all the lost territories, at least not this year, writes FT.
There are also fears that a failed counteroffensive could call into question further Western military assistance. In that case, Ukraine’s allies could also start pushing harder for peace talks with Russia.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17730

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 7:45 utc | 242

[241]
that people like Baerbock indeed see the world as a manichean struggle between democracy and autocracy
I think you refer to what psychologists call “Splitting” or “Black-White Thinking”. It is very prevalent in Germany, and German females are predisposed to Fanaticism – and even in the days of 1930s-1945 they were more fanatical than the men.
There is a particular need in people like Baerbock and indeed Truss to be “morally superior” and to be “right”. As a child for Truss it was CND with her mother at Greenham Common – later it was being an “adulteress” and then as a rabid Anti-Russian.
Baerbock is competing with Habeck to become Chancellor candidate in 2024 – btw they are currently working to change terms in Germany from 4 years to 5 years (voters will find out later)………..
Habeck is funded by Hewlett and Pew Foundations through Hal Harvey and Graichen is funded by Climate Foundation Europe and Mercador………..but Baerbock does not have a full deck even though she is infiltrating her cadres into whatever agencies she controls
What Germany has is what it had in 1933 when von Papen hosted Hitler in government – Scholz is hosting Habeck before they remove him and put CDU in power with Greens having yet more influence

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 7:46 utc | 243

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 7:43 utc | 243

Separately, it should be clarified that Zaluzhny is skeptical about assessing the effectiveness of the psychological component and offers more thoughtful operations.

He need not worry. Prighozin has proven to be the deadliest weapon of psychological destruction the West could hope for.
There’s an example of the truism that even heroes may live long enough to turn into villains.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | May 13 2023 7:59 utc | 244

Our source in the OP said that Syrsky reported to Zelensky about the heavy fighting in Bakhmut, in which the Armed Forces of Ukraine are still unable to turn the tide and we are forced to leave the blocks around high-rise buildings.
Yesterday, the enemy was able to take the first high-rise buildings, which complicates the situation, but allows the Ukrainian army to hold the line.
The commander of the ground forces considers it important to secure supply routes that will keep the high-rise buildings in Bakhmut for a few more weeks.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17731

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 8:08 utc | 245

The psy-ops that are supposed to accompany or perhaps be the main feature of the proposed Ukrainian Offensive seem laughable.
The Ukrainian armed forces say BOO and the Russians flee to Vladivostok?
Doesn’t sound very convincing to me, but what would I know? Only those in the arrogant Western leadership group would believe that tripe. It seems incredibly racist to think that that might be even possible.

Posted by: ZimZum | May 13 2023 8:15 utc | 246

“Officials: Russia tried to destroy US-made Patriot system in Ukraine” CNN’s newest headline.
And, somewhere inside CNN writes, “the large Patriot battery is a stationary system, making it possible for the Russians to zero in on the location over time.”
The thing is Russians would destroy the Patriot system in the Ukraine in time… 🙂

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 8:17 utc | 247

“US officials believe Russians picked up on signals emitted from the Patriot, allowing them to target the system using a hypersonic missile” CNN continues…
The thing is the Russians had not yet used the “Kinhzal”, the dagger…and, once they do, the Patriot system would be dead.
Ah, by the way, if the Patriot system is so good, why the buildings in Kiev get hit? And further away in the west, Lvov gets hit?

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 8:23 utc | 248

‼️🏴‍☠️Enemy first hit with Storm Shadow cruise missiles from Britain – Confirmed
Yesterday, to strike, the Nazis used a combination – one ADM-160B MALD anti-aircraft missile (made in the USA) followed by 2 cruise missiles at the target, the JCCC reports.
The information that the strike was carried out by the Ukrainian “Thunder” complex turned out to be incorrect.

https://t.me/RVvoenkor/44847
Photos of parts of the missile in the link

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 8:29 utc | 249

the frightening thing is that people like Baerbock indeed see the world as a manichean struggle between democracy and autocracy in which no compromise or long term modus vivendi is possible – with all the horrifying results.
Posted by: Confused | May 13 2023 7:34 utc | 241

Agreed on Baerbock but she doesn’t decide. Her world view is simplicistic to an extreme level but that’s why she has the job, part of which is to alienate the Eastern bloc (she’s really good at that: I have doubts if future German diplomats can fix what she’s destroying right now). However, Baerbock is only an agent, like Scholz, Biden etc. I am not telling you there’s a puppet master behind the scenes pulling the strings but I think it’s pretty obvious that these guys are not primary actors.
It’s looking grim for Germans, no question about that. Guess they will find a way to cope with the inevitable, it has happened before…

Posted by: Konami | May 13 2023 8:31 utc | 250

Those geniuses who come to this forum and laugh how slow Russia’s “progress” has been are convinced that this is in an invasion and a war of aggression and Russia’s success is measured by the square miles they conquer. That is the “philosophical” difference here. Even between the Kremlin and Prigozhin apparently. The Russians consider it a defensive operation and are thus not in a hurry to get anywhere. Yes, Russia did its best/or worse to create that it was doing something else by advancing towards Kiev in the beginning.

Posted by: Jonathan W | May 13 2023 8:33 utc | 251

Just woke up this morning done the usual MSM check then seen the headlines. Russia is retreating blah blah meanwhile the cocksucker has flown to Italy rather than be there to lead his troops. This narrative is perfect for the RF as even my Facebook of all places more sheep are waking up and cannot understand the MSM anymore. They have lost the plot. My wife spoke to a conscript from Poland on the border and there is huge anger in the polish army. They know exactley what is going on and the one name that comes up is the USA. This story narrative cannot keep running its course as people know it’s a lie. Even my
Mother says Nazi Ukraine now. So as I alluded to RF will love media spin meanwhile when it’s effort is over RF will deploy 1/2 million and run Ukraine out. How the MSM will sell defeat I don’t know but there is gonna be a lot of sad faces in the west. It is now 100% confirmed in my view this is the end game of Ukraine.

Posted by: Scot1and | May 13 2023 8:34 utc | 252

Enemy first hit with Storm Shadow cruise missiles from Britain – Confirmed
https://t.me/RVvoenkor/44847
Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 8:29 utc | 252

Utter BS!
What’s true is yesterday night, five cities in the Ukraine were hit, including Kiev.

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 8:36 utc | 253

Posted by: karlof1 | May 12 2023 22:03 utc | 141
Thank you Karlof I am dutifully reminded of the late great revolutionary Fidel Castro’s correct prediction some years ago and I quote ” The next war in Europe (after WW2) will be between Russia and Fascism, except that fascism will be called democracy “.

Posted by: Rick | May 13 2023 8:38 utc | 254

@ostro/256: It’s apparently the LNR itself that has reported it. I don’t know whether it’s true, but it’s also wrong to dismiss it completely at this stage.

Posted by: Verdant | May 13 2023 8:42 utc | 255

zero hedge has an article on senate hearings of hypersonic program. tried to post link and comment but it dissapeared . maybe it doesnt like that link. but the essence is USA talked up the program stating patriots took down a hypersonic from RF. i thought these guys have professional reputations that would stop them from actually swallowing the lies they might feed the citizens. but alas

Posted by: hankster | May 13 2023 8:44 utc | 256

The second strike by British long-range missiles on Lugansk. Today we arrived at the former building of the Academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs.
This is the rear of the actual Svatov direction, and therefore, the Office of the President, inflicting strikes on Lugansk, indirectly hints that the offensive of the Armed Forces of Ukraine will supposedly be from this flank.
Or vice versa OP wants to mislead. But, according to Luhansk, it will fly until enough air defense / electronic warfare is returned to this flank.
Otherwise, we are witnessing a positional war, which lasts from the beginning of 2023. Now the Armed Forces of Ukraine can sometimes get to the rear of the Russians. According to our information, these missiles were used in attempts to strike at the Donetsk direction (Mariupol, etc.), they were even sent to the Crimea, but there was a layered defense that shot them down, and Luhansk turned out to be a weak link in air defense cover. This is where the office hype comes in.
In other directions, British missiles have not yet passed the defense, but sooner or later they can pass, especially if there is a massive volley at one point. Bankova’s goal is informational and psychological, to sow panic among the opponent and inspire her army, plus promote sponsors’ toys.

https://t.me/legitimniy/15326

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 8:45 utc | 257

karlof1 | May 13 2023 1:42 utc | 188
Would you indulge me, please…what do you mean … “Then came Chicago”.
Can only plead ignorance, as I was too young to be cognisant of JFK/RFK; monumentous American news of course made it all the way here, even in the 1960s, but some of the nuance, details and background are lost in the mid-Pacific….

Posted by: Melaleuca | May 13 2023 8:45 utc | 258

It’s apparently the LNR itself that has reported it. I don’t know whether it’s true, but it’s also wrong to dismiss it completely at this stage.
Posted by: Verdant | May 13 2023 8:42 utc | 258

The keyword is “apparently”
The “storm shadow” has to be launched from a plane…

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 8:45 utc | 259

One down, two to go>
US State Department #3 Wendy Sherman resigns:
https://www.rt.com/news/576210-biden-china-architect-resign/
Xi hasn’t taken Biden’s calls for months. That is a clear failure of US diplomacy.
Project Ukraine is still in the balance, Russia appears to be doing its best to falter, but revenge could be a dish they prefer served cold.
Are Blinken and Nuland next to be shown the door? We can only hope.

Posted by: Et Tu | May 13 2023 8:49 utc | 260

“rezident”, “legitimny” and such like don’t have any direct info, neither does any war correspondent, so wait till what Lieutenant General Igor Konashenkov says something… 🙂

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 8:49 utc | 261

@ostro/262: Yes, that’s what makes me wonder. Converting their MiG-29 to use NATO weaponry is not a trivial task.
What’s somewhat interesting is a picture of remains of a MALD decoy missile found near the Lugansk factory that was hit – which is also air launched.

Posted by: Verdant | May 13 2023 8:55 utc | 262

Posted by: Et Tu | May 13 2023 8:49 utc | 263
They’re like black mold, extremely hard to get rid of.

Posted by: pretzelattack | May 13 2023 8:55 utc | 263

What’s somewhat interesting is a picture of remains of a MALD decoy missile found near the Lugansk factory that was hit – which is also air launched.
Posted by: Verdant | May 13 2023 8:55 utc | 265

The standard method is to wait 2-3 days, until the “info” is officially stated/verified. It is still a war…

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 9:00 utc | 264

@ostro/267: Which is what I do.

Posted by: Verdant | May 13 2023 9:07 utc | 265

This war is getting weirder and weirder. Now the Ukies are calling Prigozhin a liar and apparently defending the honour of the regular Russian forces. From The Telegraph:
Ukrainian Armed Forces Storm Battalion Commander ‘Rollo’ told CNN: “Prigozhin is a liar, because the first to flee were Wagner. It was his units that fled, and our success is not due to the fact that they fled but the fact that we conducted a planned assault by circumventing and cutting them off.
“Actually, the unit he is bad-mouthing fought to the end, his Wagners were the first to flee.”

Posted by: Jonathan W | May 13 2023 9:11 utc | 266

The standard method…

Posted by: Jonathan W | May 13 2023 9:13 utc | 267

@Verdant – 268
Even Izvestiya, Komsomolskaya Pravda is full of “storm shadow” info att the moment. Some even publish photos. But, Russian forces had downed this missile in Syria in 2018.
Or, otherwise, this “info” is used for some other reason, which we don’t still know. So, I wait…till Monday…

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 9:17 utc | 268

Psyops from the Jews? Well the standard method…

Posted by: Jonathan W | May 13 2023 9:19 utc | 269

@Posted by: Joe | May 12 2023 20:32 utc | 113
And it’s not comparable because the USA will lay waste to civilian populations without any hesitation, from the time they genocided American natives centuries ago until modern wars against Japan, Vietnam, or Iraq. Russia is clearly not doing this, and if they did then major cities in the Ukraine would have been nothing but craters last year.
And it should be remembered that this American doctrine of unlimited genocidal warfare doesn’t even bring victory, since the USA has never won a real modern war aside from the Pacific war against Japan (Americans just enjoy killing large numbers of people even if it has no strategic value because Americans tend to be sadistic monsters). Russia focuses on winning wars, not murdering millions of people for no reason. This seems to work because, unlike the USA, Russia wins wars.

Posted by: FVK | May 13 2023 9:37 utc | 270

Good news?
“There is no news of Ukrainian army commander General Oleksandr Syrsky, nor from General Valerii Zaluzhnyi, Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.
The Ukrainian Defense Ministry has denied rumors of their deaths”.
I live in hope.

Posted by: Suresh | May 13 2023 9:44 utc | 271

Z was turned down by the BBC but he is now in Rome speaking with the Pope and Meloni and President Mattarella.

Posted by: Jonathan W | May 13 2023 9:45 utc | 272

Re: collapse in USA ?
Indeed, 1/10 of American Households have a net worth over $1,000,000 and can be tallied as ‘millionaires’ which sounds like big secure wealth. It’s not. Typical upper middle class millionaire household assets/liabilities ledger :
Assets –
$2 million House
$1/2 million retirement Portfolio
$1/2 million other stuff
—————————
$3 million Assets
Liabilities
$1 million Mortgage
$1/4 mm 2nd Mortgage ( kitchen and bathroom remodel)
$1/2 mm College costs (2 kids)
$1/4 mm Car Loans or Leases
$1/10 mm Credit Cards
—————————
$2 million Liabilities
$1 mm Net Wealth (assets minus liabilities)
Wow ! This Upper Middle Class Household Are MILLIONAIRES !!! But wait there is a slight catch…..
What are their big ticket annual fixed costs ?
$75,000 Mortgage
$25,000 Property Taxes
$10,000 Health Insurance deductible
$25,000 Cars
$10,000 Home maintence landscaping
$15,000 Utilities, Cable, Telephone
—————————————-
$160,000 post-tax fixed costs !!!!
This household needs first to earn $320,000 gross income before they can pay for food. The upper middle class teeters on insolvency

Posted by: Exile | May 13 2023 9:48 utc | 273

Some further signs that this war is getting weirder and weirder: Z told the BBC that the counter-offensive will be delayed (and Z was nixed by the BBC). The very next day the Financial Times reported as its lede story: “Ukrainian counter-offensive takes shape with first gains around Bakhmut”. The third paragraph then states: “Kyiv denied that its counter-offensive was under way”.

Posted by: Jonathan W | May 13 2023 10:03 utc | 274

Verdant | May 13 2023 8:55 utc | 265
Not if they use the plane only as a carrier, targeting being done by nato troops somewhere on the ground. Or they’ve managed to add the electronics to program the missile. It doesn’t look complicated and no one cares if it doesn’t work perfectly. They only have a few Russian planes left so kamikaze is implied.
Russian forces had downed this missile in Syria in 2018.
Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 9:17 utc | 272

I don’t think there were any defenses placed in that area. The general staff seems to have no planning, not even in larger cities, not even when civilians are the weekly target. They only react very slowly or not at all.

Posted by: rk | May 13 2023 10:12 utc | 275

⚡️⚡️ Remember we wrote about how quickly the Lithuanian-Polish-Ukrainian brigade turned into a corps?
In the photo of the deputy commander of the 5th US Army Corps, Major General Adam Jox is already inspecting the headquarters of the Lithuanian-Polish-Ukrainian corps being formed in the city of Lublin. Naturally, we understand that an American general of this level is not engaged in military tourism, especially when he is one of the leaders of the ongoing Griffin Shock-23 exercise.
Recall that from May 8 to May 26, the 5th Corps of the US Army is conducting a major Griffin Shock-23 exercise in Poland at the Bemowo Piske training ground.
The NATO multinational corps “North-East” (Szczecin) and the NATO combat battalion group in Poland (1.2 thousand military personnel, Orzysz) take part in it. More than 3,000 servicemen from Poland, the USA, Romania, Great Britain and Croatia are involved in the training grounds near Poznan, Szczecin and Orzysz.

https://t.me/ZeRada1/13679

The creation of a joint corps is taking place within the framework of the Warsaw Union, as a pilot project, which should be further scaled up into a joint army of the two countries.
Negotiations between Prosha and Ukraine continue, now there is a discussion of the public part of the union, which should create a new state entity.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17732

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 10:18 utc | 276

Barflies – this watering hole needs a chanteuse; perhaps this young Russian gal singing the National Anthem in her car……
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=QYZgqIpftd0&pp=ygUTU2V4eSBSdXNzaWFuIGFudGhlbQ%3D%3D

Posted by: Exile | May 13 2023 10:25 utc | 277

This is probably going to take 10-20 years or some such, but what do I know? Except, as I often speculate here, the West is also working on the same agenda, namely their elites crashing their own nation states in order to Build Back Better. If this is indeed a Grand Coalition type play, then the whole thing might play out in only a few years. We shall see.
Posted by: Scorpion | May 13 2023 5:46 utc | 219
That’s what some Russian experts say. Russia shouldn’t be in a rush. Neither no one in Russia is interested in a frontline from Crimea all the way to the Barents sea. China Vs Taiwan, Iran Vs Azerbaijan if ever happen should redirect attention of the west in this conflict. Plus there is a possibility of a financial collapse of the west. Unfortunately, there are too many IFs at the moment.
I’d disagree with you about Russia not being interested in other regions though. I think if Russia gets what it wants in Ukraine, it might involve Transnistria and possibly Gagauzia or the whole of Moldova. The corridor to Kaliningrad region through Lithuania if things get bigger or just wipe all the Baltics off. Kazakhstan has all the chances to be involved too since it has a lot of British influence. Recently, one tiny group of ethnic Russians from Kazakhstan announced Petropavlovsk region’s sovereignity. Surely enough it was not mentioned by any big media but Kazakhstan has a high probability to get into conflict sometime in the future. At least Zhirinovsky predicted it. Life for ethnic Russians there only gets worse. You can see some Kazakhs wearing Azov badges in public. It’ll explode one day. But surely, if you mean Europe proper, Russia isn’t interested in that at all.

Posted by: Yuri | May 13 2023 10:28 utc | 278

https://simplicius76.substack.com/p/sitrep-51223-panic-ukraine-launches?utm_source=substack&utm_medium=email
Posted by: morongobill | May 13 2023 1:37 utc | 186
Not sure what Simplicius76 is trying to tell us, going on and on about the Russian guys getting killed and running away not being regular Russian troupes, but rag-tag volunteer groups.
Did the Russian MoD really throw away territory that Wagner captured in months and months of tough battles, with top-of-the-range soldiers, by not even bothering to install some MoD-troupes with enough experience to set up fortifications and, you know, actually hold the positions?
Instead of putting up some dummies that would have gotten blown away by the wind if some ukrainians hadn’t idled past and scared them away first?
Oh, and that ammunition Prighoshin requested: Wouldn’t it have come in handy had anybody bothered to deliver it? Even if not for Wagner, but at least for the russian army trying to hold positions?

Posted by: Marvin | May 13 2023 10:29 utc | 279

According to Italian media, the Ukrainian president has arrived in Rome. An Italian Air Force plane had taken Volodymyr Selenskyj on board in the southeastern Polish airport in Rzeszow near the Ukrainian border and brought him to the Italian capital, where it landed at the Ciampino military airport.
According to Corriere della Sera, Selenskyj was received by Foreign Minister and Deputy Prime Minister Antonio Tajani (Forza Italia) and Ukrainian Ambassador to Italy Yaroslav Melnyk. The visit to Rome was “an important visit for the coming victory of Ukraine,” Selenskyj wrote on Twitter
According to media reports, around 1,500 police officers and security personnel are being deployed to ensure that the state visit runs smoothly. Airports, train stations and the subway are being specially controlled. A no-fly zone has been set up over the city, including for drones. Snipers are positioned everywhere where Selenskyj is expected.
The pope as mediator?
The exact schedule of Selenskyj’s visit was not made public for security reasons, but the Vatican confirmed shortly before Selenskyj’s arrival that there would also be a meeting with the pope. This is expected to be the most important part of the visit.
Translated with http://www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)
https://www.spiegel.de/ausland/wolodymyr-selenskyj-in-rom-eingetroffen-a-97ad8d0e-dfd9-4fa6-9434-b12ec8b0ae71
.

Posted by: BonfireNight | May 13 2023 10:44 utc | 280

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 10:18 utc | 281
I’d be interested to know who plays the OPFOR and how they simulate the crushing weight of Russian artillery and operating under enemy air dominance and a hostile, near-peer, ISR environment. It’s not as though you can represent a credible threat by just recruiting some Arab speaking SF guys and have them inhabit shipping container villages anymore.
This then raises the second issue, regarding the efficacy of the Third Ukrainian Army, whose training the new corps? If the trainers do not have first hand experience of the environment, then those being trained will only have an approximation of what to expect, which can lead to a host of problems. Mobilised Russian units have the opportunity to experience the SMO’s unique characteristics without having to resort to the artifice of an ‘exercise’, and their training is delivered by instructors who have fought in the SMO. Another soft factor overlooked by those who focus on simplistic generalisations about a units combat efficiency.

Posted by: Milites | May 13 2023 10:45 utc | 281

War and winning are not reconcilable concepts. You fight war to survive by destroying the threats you perceive at whatever cost.
Britain fought two world wars and survived bankrupt and with huge debts and loss of territory. It gained nothing whatsoever – it left future generations economically poorer and subject to financial repression – U.K. had exchange controls 1949-1979 and you could not own gold or have more than £50 in foreign currency
Russia has to drive military threats from its borders by expanding the sanitary zone Stalin acquired after 1945 and making it a DMZ which should improve prosperity of nations not buying weapons on credit from US and S Korea
It then needs to have an umbrella protectorate over independent states formed from former USSR to secure its region
Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 5:38 utc | 218

I cannot agree more…
It is apparent that recently Ukie casualties now exceed 1500/day.
Ukie wounded are sent to abandoned, decrepit sanatoria where there is no care, no food, nothing on which to sleep, by their own government.
Ukie dead receive no survivor’s benefits.
Ukie religious faithful see their churches burned, their priests humiliated, imprisoned, and worse.
Meanwhile, the international sanctions war goes awry… RSA just summoned the US Ambassador to give him a tongue lashing over his claims WRT a Russian cargo ship. The US Congress is considering enacting a law to frustrate Syria returning from the cold… Georgia just ignored US / NATO pressure to stop direct flights between itself and Russia… KSA just exchanged ambassadors with Iran… Imran Khan’s arrest was ruled illegal…
I anticipate China working out a way for Argentina to nullify it’s IMF debt…
I anticipate China working out a way for it’s own chip makers to fill the void left by US pressure on Samsung to not ship chips to China.
China will work out a solution to the pending SE Asia rice crisis, via controlled releases of upstream water storage on the Mekong..
Russia/China continue to build and launch more naval vessels…
While NATO digs through the bowels of it’s arsenal, for crumbs to deliver to Ukraine, much of which never makes it to the front because it is destroyed in transit.
While NATO dribs and drabs launches of this and that “wonder weapon” providing Russia/China with practice in destroying/nullifying same….
While RosAtom fields reactors designed to burn spent nuclear fuel, converting what was waste into power.
While NATO goes “Green” and EV… regardless of the fact that sufficient power to run their economies is lacking..
Looks like a slow motion train wreck to me….
INDY

Posted by: Dr. George W Oprisko | May 13 2023 10:45 utc | 282

Posted by: ostro | May 13 2023 8:45 utc | 262 “The “storm shadow” has to be launched from a plane…”
Poland modified a SU-24 to fire the Storm Shadow. (This was reported to be underway last year.) After that Ukraine copied the modifications to other Su-24’s. Ukraine has been flying about 10-20 fixed wing missions a day since the beginning of the war. It is a fraction of what Russia fly’s but it’s still something.

Posted by: BB | May 13 2023 10:48 utc | 283

Our source in the OP said that the main task of the counter-offensive near Bakhmut is to regain control of the city, in order for the operation to be considered successful, we must surround Wagner’s positions along the perimeter.
Syrsky promised Zelensky that he would be able to free Bakhmut using the experience of the Kharkov counteroffensive, forcing the enemy to leave the city.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17733

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 10:51 utc | 284

“using the experience of the Kharkov counteroffensive”
Down South | May 13 2023 10:51 utc | 288
So their plan of success is depends on Russians leaving by their own will.

Posted by: rk | May 13 2023 11:01 utc | 285

“During today’s attack on Lugansk, the Armed Forces of Ukraine again used British Storm Shadow cruise missiles, – said LPR Colonel Marochko.”

Posted by: rk | May 13 2023 11:11 utc | 286

It seems to me that NATO is doing everything it can to make Russia the one to go on the offensive. New promised arms deliveries from England and Germany, constant terror attacks on civilians, repeated jabs at the Russian stockpile and a constant advance of the date of the Ukrainian offensive seem to be an attempt to make the standstill unbearable for Russia. But Russia backs off and retakes, in turn making it intolerable for NATO. “Bakhmut” is important to win for Russia,because when it fall, NATO has to act, I think. And myself am tired of those who, under the guise of care, downgrade the Russian action, as well tired of those who too quickly leave the boat that they just claimed was flying their flag

Posted by: ulfhp | May 13 2023 11:13 utc | 287

“Ukraine will run out of fighting men ?”
No they won’t as there are no such thing in Ukraine as mercenaries. They are NATO troops.
Poland has just created 300k. A lot of which are probably now in Ukraine. Nobody has even scratched the surface yet of how many NATO troops are actually in Ukraine. The figures on the Pentagon leak were a farce. The true figure could be over 100k. Who can tell you the actual figure ?

Posted by: Derek Henry | May 13 2023 11:14 utc | 288

Our source says that the attacks on Luhansk, the sabotage against two helicopters that have now been shot down on Russian territory, as well as the massive offensive on Bakhmut, are a demonstration before the meeting in Italy. Such a creation of a good informational background.
But at the same time, they gently remove from the mention in the media, getting into the hangar with equipment and the building where the manpower was located in Khmelnitsky. A blow in Nikolaev to the shops where they stored “toys” and also Kramatorsk, Zaporozhye, Chernihiv, Sumy regions, hitting the objects of the Armed Forces of Ukraine.
We see only one thing here, the rates gently began to rise …

https://t.me/legitimniy/15327

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 11:16 utc | 289

Exile @ 278
Will point out a couple you are likely aware of but that should be said aloud. The $2 million house is built of particleboard and plastic. In the mildest of downturns operating costs become impossible and all potential buyers vanish. Value of that house drops 50% in a heartbeat and that family is underwater. The cars get sold cheap, leased cars returned. They are stupid impractical expensive to maintain cars made only for bubble wealth. On and on. What currently looks like prosperity for at least a few per cent is quite fragile.
The landscaping costs you mention are normal to modest. That there are still idiots doing the 1/2 mil kitchen remodels is just amazing. There is a large class of construction workers dependent on that and many of them don’t know much about actually building or making things, just the specialized care and feeding of idiots with these pseudo-houses.

Posted by: oldhippie | May 13 2023 11:17 utc | 290

TASS:”Su-34 fighter jet crashed in the Bryansk region. This was reported to us by the emergency services.
“The Su-34 crashed near the Ukrainian border. The fate of those on board is being established,” the source said.
According to him, the circumstances of the crash are being investigated.
Earlier, a Mi-8 helicopter crashed in the Bryansk region. Two crew members were killed.”
⚡️ According to Mash – law enforcement is laying down a dragnet in Bryansk Oblast in a search for either a DRG or terrorist saboteurs working for the SBU.

https://t.me/DDGeopolitics/62473

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 11:19 utc | 291

https://www.kp.ru/daily/27502.5/4761968/
What’s Really Happening with Ukraine’s Counteroffensive: Armed Forces Movements, Zelensky’s Lies, and Harvest Time for Russia
Military expert Borzenko said that Zelensky is lying about the counter-offensive of the Armed Forces of Ukraine
Ukrainian President Zelensky has said that the widely publicized counter-offensive in the West is once again being postponed. Because – according to his version – more time is needed for preparation.
What is really happening? We talked about this on Radio Komsomolskaya Pravda in the program of Ivan Pankin and Igor Vittel with Alexei Borzenko, a military expert and deputy editor-in-chief of Literaturnaya Rossiya.
What is happening with the counter-offensive of Ukraine
THE LIE OF ZELENSKY
Why is Zelensky postponing a counteroffensive?
– Zelensky is lying. There is no postponement. There is a period of accumulation of forces and means before the offensive.
Are we tracking it?
– Yes. Before any offensive there is such a phase – the transfer of troops. Everything that has been accumulated for several months by the Armed Forces of Ukraine 200 kilometers from the line of contact is now being transferred to the line 40 kilometers away.
– Is this process painful for the Armed Forces of Ukraine?
– Certainly! There are warehouses from where the transfer of ammunition comes from. It’s all open now. We see it from space. And we strike at the columns that are moving towards the front line. Here in the Kharkiv region, “Leopards” were discovered.
– Harvest time?
– The enemy can be openly destroyed by missiles.
– Examples?
– The night of May 8-9, when we hit more than 60 targets. Basically, through the opened warehouses with ammunition, with equipment, with howitzers. There is an active phase of destruction.
– Why 40 kilometers?
– 30-35 kilometers – this is the limit of our artillery. This is already front, but not quite advanced. Now they are moving everything along this line. And the line of contact is 816 kilometers.
WHEN THE APU COUNTEROFFENSIVE BEGINS
– So when is the offensive?
– There are 5 days left. Maybe a week. When they have transferred everything, the offensive itself will begin.
– What are the obvious signs?
– The Nikolaev garrison, Odessa, Kharkov – they leave parts to defend Kyiv, and they rake everything else with a shovel and throw it in the direction of the offensive.
– What is their advantage?
– At the tip, a grouping of about 200, a maximum of 220 thousand. There is almost no one else to mobilize.
– And from Western Ukraine?
– There are other things. Since October, we have been digging into the ground and created a powerful line of defense, to a depth of 60 kilometers. And any offensive – they are no more than 30 km. Where, in what place they will cut in, try to rip open our defenses – it’s hard to say.
– Well, they’ll try to crash. – And what?
– At a distance of 5-10 kilometers, there may be a blow to the width of the line of contact. But they will get stuck.
– When will they stop?
– This is a golden time for our aviation. We can apply what we used in Aleppo in Syria, when they demolished quarter after quarter with the help of our strategists – Tu-160 (White Swan) and Tu-95.
RUSSIA’S RESPONSE TO UKRAINE’S COUNTEROFFENSIVE
– Enough bombs?
– There are a huge number of printed bombs in Crimea. And not only in the Crimea. These are FABs, KABs, five hundredths, thousandths, two thousandths. Even under the USSR, a huge number of them were stamped.
– They were made planners?
– Yes. These bombs don’t go off. They don’t get caught on radar. They do not have thermal kinetic energy, ejection. They are not seen when they fall.
– Here, ballistic missiles were also delivered to Kyiv
– Storm Shadow, cruise missiles, they hit 500 kilometers. Prior to this, the UK transmitted ATACMS. But the fact is that these Anglo-French missiles, 560 kilometers away, have been made since 1994. This is just the Anglo-French equivalent of the Tomahawk. How they work, I saw in Yugoslavia.
– And How?
– Storm Shadow missile is launched from aircraft. Comes out from a great height, then descends. Goes low profile. Before reaching the target, he makes a “candle” of 5 kilometers. And hits the target. She’s from the “fire and forget” section. It follows the GPS coordinate system.
– How to answer London, which supplied these missiles to Kyiv?
– We can close the Northern Sea Route for them – for all ships, both military and non-military. While the ships are moving. We even conduct them with our icebreakers. By the way, Britain turned out to be generally very dependent on all its neighbors. We just don’t use all the options that we could.
– In the end – will there be a counteroffensive next week?
– Yes, they are preparing to attack. Now the time is coming. The whole course of events in Ukraine will depend on how we react, how we destroy their units approaching the line of contact during the preparatory period, and how we carry out this operation of resistance to this offensive and retaliatory actions.

Posted by: Oblomovka daydream | May 13 2023 11:23 utc | 292

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 10:51 utc | 288
‘using the experience of the Kharkov counteroffensive’
Translation, trying to find a place where we out-number them 8-1 and where less than 400 para-military police, with little to no heavy weapons, are deployed.
Pithy comments, aside, it looks like their micro Kursk has initially suffered the same fate as it’s far larger forebear, with the Southern attack making modest progress but it’s northern counter-part stopped dead in its tracks, even though the much vaunted Western MBT’s seem to have been used. Again, past visions of Elephants foundering in minefields comes to mind, for some reason.

Posted by: Milites | May 13 2023 11:25 utc | 293

Exile @ 278
Another addition to your excellent comment. Back in 2008 I had a neighbor in my building who worked for a local high-end car dealership. When the bubble burst nearly all of the 12 cylinder German cars they had sold in the previous three years came back. The dealer did not attempt to sell those cars cheap. Maintenance pigs and only built for showing off. All of those cars were scrapped within a year. No way to even justify the cost of a parking space.
Much easier to operate an economy built on baubles than value.

Posted by: oldhippie | May 13 2023 11:28 utc | 294

ulfhp | May 13 2023 11:13 utc | 291
I don’t think nato wants a proper offensive from Russia. They want 10+ years of this. They’re escalating now because elections are coming in Russia. Terrorism, killing civilians for fun, some chemicals, some banned mines, maybe another ship or two sunk “by the brave Ukr army”. Then it’ll switch to low intensity war, high intensity terrorism. They will probably invade a part of former Ukr just to make sure at least half of it can’t be controlled by Russia and becomes nato. The idea that you can’t shoot anything you want at a nuclear Russia already is gone, thanks to the smo which had no results, no de-mil, no de-nazi, and thanks to a paralyzed government. They’ll sign Minsk 3 as soon as US lets them sign it.

Posted by: rk | May 13 2023 11:32 utc | 295

Our aviation group was ambushed.
To the guys of eternal flight, responsible for the border – a stalk in a point.
And yes, they launched rockets from the Chernihiv region, approaching almost tightly to the state border.

https://t.me/voenacher/44519

So, two Mi-8s, one Su-34, and probably another Su-25 are lost.
Let me remind you that quite recently, literally, for days, individual citizens informed us that the military correspondents were aggravating the situation, that there was no offensive, that the situation was normal, the enemy’s activity was standard.
And the military correspondents, they say, hurried with their assessments.
So it wasn’t they who hurried, it’s just an indicator that you can’t live in the past and think in terms of yesterday.
The modern offensive is not thousands of tank columns, led by General Von Bock with a monocle. It is exactly like that.
Lugansk yesterday, a blow to our Air Force today. Feeling the defense. Where it breaks. And strikes on the rear, infrastructure and aviation.
They said on the air a hundred times and wrote – the enemy has air defense, the enemy may have a weak air force, but long-range missiles will replace it.
There is no need to panic now. Conclusions must be drawn. Especially for those who believe that flight routes should not be changed so that the documents are not rewritten. Yes, there are.
Well, you need to prepare for the offensive even more seriously. Here it is, creepy.

https://t.me/wargonzo/12505

Posted by: Down South | May 13 2023 11:47 utc | 296

“The Russian Defense Ministry reported that on May 12, combat aircraft of the Ukrainian Air Force launched a missile attack on the Polypak polymer products enterprise and the Milam meat processing plant in Lugansk.
For the strike, the Storm Shadow aircraft missiles supplied to the Kyiv regime by the UK were used.
As a result of the strike, a fire started on the territory of Luhansk food and chemical enterprises.
There is destruction of nearby residential buildings. Civilians were injured, including 6 children.
The Su-24 plane, which launched a missile attack on Luhansk, and the MiG-29 fighter jet of the Ukrainian Air Force, which covered it, were shot down.”

Posted by: rk | May 13 2023 12:08 utc | 297

[278]
$25,000 Property Taxes
You forgot to mention how quirky Property Taxes can be in some states……….if you are in arrears they can seize your property and auction it away below market………or if someone comes and pays those arrears they can acquire title………..
It was once stated that nowhere on earth is Affluence less secure and one step away from Penury………….no maternity leave, no job security, and even at Investment Banker level the black bin liner can be on your desk on Monday morning for you to clear out
It also used to be 33% bankruptcies were due either to medical expenses or a serious car accident………..
Look at how many spinal injuries occur in USA annually from auto accidents………..

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 12:12 utc | 298

Data:
https://phoonglaw.com/comprehensive-guide-on-spinal-injuries-from-auto-accidents/

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | May 13 2023 12:15 utc | 299

Exile #278: Not trying to be a jerk here, but do you even live in the USA and if so have you ever lived outside of California or New York? Not that any of this is really material to the Ukraine topic, but…
Assets –
$2 million House try $500K
$1/2 million retirement Portfolio LMAO – No way. If I had $500K in my retirement accounts after the 2008 and most recent stock market fiascos, I’d retire right now. Most people have like $100K or less in their 40s and early 50s unless they are very high earners and have committed the maximum percentage allowable to their 401k/IRA since their late 20s. The median 401k value for people between the ages of 42-54 is $89K.
$1/2 million other stuff $500K on “other” (unnamed) “stuff”? Like what 4 late model Range Rovers and a boat? Nope.
—————————
$3 million Assets Try $1M max
Liabilities
$1 million Mortgage not unless they live in California or NYC. Again, more like $300K-$500K
$1/4 mm 2nd Mortgage ( kitchen and bathroom remodel)A $250K remodel? Come on. I know people who have had $1.4M homes remodeled extensively and it cost $125K max. The average is more like $40K and most people don’t do it that way at all. They do small projects over the years.
$1/2 mm College costs (2 kids) Paid for by the kids.
$1/4 mm Car Loans or Leases This is the real howler. You really think anyone “middle class” whether upper, middle or lower, has $250K worth of CAR loan debt? Again, what are they driving Ferraris, Mercedes AMG and Range Rovers x4?
$1/10 mm Credit Cards $7,400 is average US household credit card debt.
—————————
$2 million Liabilities Wrong. Way off.
$1 mm Net Wealth (assets minus liabilities)People can do their own math.
What are their big ticket annual fixed costs ?
$75,000 Mortgage on a $3M home maybe. On a $500K home it’s more like $36K/year at most.
$25,000 Property Taxes – in what state? the Red ones maybe where there is no state income tax
$10,000 Health Insurance deductible Probably accurate for a two income, two policy home. Probably underestimating it for families with multiple kids on the plan.
$25,000 Cars How does a family spend only $25K/year on $250K in car debt?
$10,000 Home maintence landscaping Maybe on a $2-3M home. Ours was $3,000/year on a 1/4 acre property including all maintenance and landscape contract before I bought a mower, string trimmer and leaf blower and started doing it myself.
$15,000 Utilities, Cable, Telephone Wut?? Telephone, assuming 3 persons in a household = $160/month. Utilities (gas, electric, Internet) = $250/month for a total of less than $5K/year. Maybe for an UPPER middle class McMansion type situation it gets closer to $10K.
All of which is to say that in some cases the upper middle class that lives beyond its means is even closer to illiquidity than your post would indicate, but that most of the actual middle class in the US is doing OK other than retirement savings (true worth/purchasing power) and other than if the housing market tanks leaving them underwater with no or little equity. I know a lot of relatively high rollers living in $1.3-2M homes and none of them have $250K in (combined household) automobiles so I’m not sure what you’re basing your information on.

Posted by: Tom_Q_Collins | May 13 2023 12:15 utc | 300