|
The Reconnaissance Strike Complex
The Reconnaissance Strike Complex Lester Grau and Charles Bartles – May 30, 2018
The Soviet Union, and now Russia, have long worked on the development of twin concepts for the detection and assured destruction of high-value targets in near-real time. The Reconnaissance Strike Complex (разведивательно-ударный комплех-RYK) was designed for the coordinated employment of high-precision, long-range weapons linked to real-time intelligence data and precise targeting provided to a fused intelligence and fire-direction center. The RYK functioned at operational depths using surface-to-surface missile systems and aircraft-delivered “smart” munitions.
It took some time for the Russian reconnaissance-strike-complex to improve its reaction time. But it now seems to be quite fast.
First the reconnaissance element:
The Ukrainian Air Force Formed A New Strike Squadron—By Arming Reconnaissance Bombers With British Cruise Missiles Forbes – May 28, 2023
Working closely with the United Kingdom, the Ukrainian air force has equipped at least some of the recon section—which flies two-seat, supersonic Sukhoi Su-24MRs from the regiment’s base in western Ukraine—with British-made Storm Shadow cruise missiles. … All the pre-war bombers and recon planes—as many as 16 of the former and nine of the latter—belonged to the 7th Bomber Regiment at Starokostiantyniv air base.
In a year and three months, the regiment has written off at least 17 Su-24s. Victims of Russian air-defense missiles, mostly. … It’s that simplicity [of the conversion] that apparently allowed the Ukrainian air force and its British supporters to form what amounts to a new long-range strike squadron—eight or more Storm Shadow-armed Su-24MRs—inside the battle-battered 7th Bomber Regiment … in just three months’ time.
After reading yesterday's Forbes piece about Storm Shadow launching airplanes stationed at the Starokostiantyniv air base the commanders at the operation center of the Russian Special Military Operation, decided to have them destroyed.
The strike:
Russia Hits Military Facility In West Ukraine, Damaging Planes AFP – May 29, 2023
A Russian strike hit a military facility in western Ukraine, damaging five planes, while Kyiv repelled another large volley of overnight air strikes, authorities said Monday. … In the western city of Khmelnytsky regional authorities said Russian troops attacked a military facility overnight.
In a rare admission of the damage, they said "five aircraft have been put out of action."
Work was underway to localise fires at fuel and lubricant warehouses, the statement said.
The Starokostiantyniv air base is some 40 kilometers north of Khmelnytsky.
Posted by: Biswapriya Purkayast | May 30 2023 4:30 utc | 125
Yeah Zelly concerned about lives. I’ll just leave this one here. They really seem inable to comprehend the disaster and why the slaughter will accelerate (due to force balance shifting even more in disadvantage of UAF).
“What is important to understand about the losses of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in Artyomovsk: analysis of the military chronicle
On May 20, the end of the battle for Artyomovsk was announced. The city came under the control of Wagner units, and the Armed Forces of Ukraine withdrew from all fortified areas to the suburbs in the Artyomovsky direction. During the 224 days of the battle for Artyomovsk, the Armed Forces of Ukraine have lost a significant part of their units, which cannot be restored at the moment.
What forces did the Armed Forces of Ukraine have before the start of the Bakhmut meat grinder
Before the active phase of hostilities in the Artyomovsky direction, the garrison of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in the city consisted of several dozen units. The brigades and battalions of the Armed Forces of Ukraine that survived the battles retreated after the defeat near Severodonetsk, Lisichansk, Popasnaya and Svetlodarsk. The total number of all units around Artemovsk and in the nearest settlements by the end of July – beginning of August 2022 was approximately 35-40 thousand people, and after the retreat from Soledar and the transfer of reserves, the grouping increased, presumably, more than twice, to 85- 97 thousand
What influenced the losses of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in Artyomovsk?
The main reason for the heavy losses of the Ukrainian armed formations was the forced tactical situation, when the mass of heterogeneous units were forced to fight for a long time in a limited space. As a result, they were unable to maneuver freely or covertly, and their supply routes were stretched out and subjected to surveillance and fire.
Also, the increase in losses was affected by the numerical superiority in artillery and means of RER and EW among the units of the Wagner PMC and the RF Armed Forces. According to the Military Chronicle, the intensity and density of fire from the artillery of the PMC “Wagner” and the forces of the Eastern Military District in some sectors of the front in the Artyomovsk region were 20-40 times higher than in other directions.
Which units suffered the most losses?
According to the Military Chronicle, the 30th, 62nd, 53rd, 92nd and 93rd mechanized brigades of the Armed Forces of Ukraine suffered the greatest losses in the battle for Artyomovsk. In most units of these formations, the level of irretrievable losses (killed + seriously wounded) exceeds 50%. However, the territorial defense units suffered the biggest losses. After the retreat from Artyomovsk to the area of Krasny (Ivanovsky) and Chasov Yar, irretrievable losses (killed and seriously wounded) in the 112th, 116th, 119th, 122nd and 241st troop brigades are estimated at 63-66%.
The total number of Ukrainian troops deployed against Wagner PMC in Artyomovsk is 34 brigades. Three artillery, 12 mechanized and motorized infantry brigades, four airmobile brigades, six assault brigades and nine territorial defense brigades.
What are the losses of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in Artyomovsk in numbers?
Preliminary figures for the losses of the Armed Forces of Ukraine are 50-55 thousand killed and about 70 thousand wounded. However, most likely, these data will be revised for several reasons.
Firstly, for nine months in a limited space there was a classic artillery war in the spirit of the First World War and the Great Patriotic War. The experience of two world wars shows that the ratio of irretrievable losses to sanitary (killed to wounded) almost always ranges from one to three to one to five.
With 50 thousand killed, the number of wounded of the Armed Forces of Ukraine should be in the range from 130 thousand to 150 thousand. At the same time, some of the wounded will not be able to return to duty due to the severity of injuries, injuries and other reasons. Also, a number of the wounded subsequently died in hospitals.
It is noteworthy that a significant part of the units of the Armed Forces of Ukraine destroyed in the battle for Artyomovsk are well-trained and equipped formations.”
————————-
What needs to be understood about AFU casualty figures in Artyomovsk.
1. The AFU suffered monstrous losses at Artyomovsk. The 72,000 Ukrainian (and not only) military personnel dead includes not only enlisted personnel, but all – tankers, artillerymen, reconnaissance personnel, signalers and all those who fought in this area and were liquidated. It is not yet clear how many of them are mercenaries, even approximately.
2. For the 72 thousand killed there are about 200 thousand wounded of varying degrees (with a ratio of one to three). Most of the wounded will never return to action, and therefore will not be able to increase the combat effectiveness of the AFU.
3. Ukraine’s entire pre-war army numbered about 230,000 men, and Artyomovsk destroyed its asset, its best personnel, which cannot be replenished in the foreseeable future.
4. Together with these cadres, the reserves that the AFU was preparing for an attack in the Donetsk direction were burned. Without a grouping of 200,000 men, no large-scale offensive is possible.
5. Now another problem has arisen: a shortage of junior and mid-level commanders, without whom combat management, even under current conditions, will be seriously hampered.
@ukraine_watch
Posted by: unimperator | May 30 2023 4:57 utc | 107
@ Richard Steven Hack | 120
The only value of a nuke to Ukraine would be to bomb Russians, not themselves. Using it as an excuse to launch a NATO attack is pointless….
You’re missing the point why such a false-flag would be useful: controlling the news narrative and building a historical justification for American righteousness in its war of aggression against Russia.
5th Generation Warfare is all about building a propaganda narrative that will direct/distort public opinion, thus creating a moral imperative that may be used to diffuse and discredit any potential public movements that would oppose the aggressors who are responsible for the warfare. That’s the whole Neocon “We create reality” mentality.
Ukraine shot down a civilian airliner from a third country–Malaysia, which was totally uninvolved in any of the regions’ hostilities–and literally murdered hundreds of innocent civilians. The US and NATO have steadfastly supported and defended the Ukrainians by insisting that it was actually Russia that shot that airplane out of the sky.
Detonating a tactical nuke in what is now a mostly uninhabited part of Ukraine–and if it is inhabited, it is inhabited by Russian sympathizers–as an Area Denial tactic is certainly not beyond the realm of the possible. Doing so and then blaming The Russians for it would be the new USS Maine/Lusitania/Reichstag Fire/Gulf of Tonkin incident that would build public support for full-on war, this time against Russia.
Operation Northwoods was precisely such a plan: create a massive incident on some US military facility (probably Gitmo, but it could have just as easily been done on the mainland somewhere) and then blame it on the Cubans to build public support for war with Cuba.
From the NATO website, this is official:
Air Defender 2023 involves Air Forces from 24 Nations and 220 aircraft. The German Air Force ensures command and control of air operations during the exercise. It will be combined in time and space with the German-led Multinational Air Group Exercise (MAGDAYS 23) and linked to two NATO exercises (RAMSTEIN DUST 23 and RAMSTEIN GUARD 23).
“Our goals for this largest deployment exercise since the foundation of NATO are comprehensive,” said Lieutenant General Ingo Gerhartz, Chief German Air Force. “We want to demonstrate the agility and swiftness of Air Forces as a first responder and showcase NATO Air Power.
So your assertion that there isn’t going to be a massing of air force and ground force power practically on the borders of Russia/Ukraine is false. 220 air craft are currently being prepared for a live-fire exercise; a huge amount of materiel and troops are currently mobilized in Poland, as well. Germany is mobilizing its ground forces for other live-fire exercises that will be taking place at the same time.
Yes, I think it would be folly for NATO to attack Russia; but Germany and Turkiye have nukes, and the US has already stated that it’s willing to use them on the battlefield as offensive weapons. I don’t think that NATO would be foolish enough to initiate a full-on nuclear war by using them, but then again I didn’t think the US/NATO would be foolish enough to provoke a war in Ukraine, either.
If a nuke goes off in Ukraine then the corporate media will doubtlessly broadcast the news and insist that the Rooskies did it because…”How on earth would Ukraine allow such a weapon to be used on its own territory for a false-flag event? Obviously the Russians were losing ground during the Ukrainian offensive and felt they needed to resort to nuclear weapons!”
That event then opens the door for the US to start using its own nuclear arsenal, as well as whatever other nasty things it has: chemical and biological WMDs, for instance. It also allows the US and NATO to go into full mobilization for war against Russia.
The Ukraine is already guilty of initiating several false-flag events during the last 10 years and this one would be a relatively small hit for them: remember, Chernobyl is on Ukrainian territory and that was a much scarier and destructive catastrophe than would be a tactical nuclear hit on territory inhabited by ethnic Russians that Ukraine is going to lose anyway if they don’t do something like this.
2) That would immediately result in Ukraine’s annihilation, conventionally or otherwise. And since the US would be behind it, Russia would probably take down a good portion of NATO as well.
A tactical nuke detonated in Ukraine is not an attack on Russia. So no: that would not “immediately result in Ukraine’s annihilation,” for the simple reason that Russia would initially protest and insist it hadn’t used nuclear weapons for the simple reason that any kind of immediate response by Russia would turn international opinion to automatically presume that yes, Russia had initiated the use of nuclear weapons. Then they’d essentially have the entire planet against Russia.
3) As I’ve said, there is no NATO option to attack Russia short of a full-scale nuclear first strike or attempted decapitation strike. We know how that ends.
I agree with you insofar as I do believe that Russia can take on all of NATO and win. But there’s the problem: the entire premise during the Cold War–and I got this from several military people who attended the military colleges (Annapolis, West Point, USAF Academy)–was that NATO would overrun Russian ground forces and push any invasion force back to the borders of the Soviet Union and then would be the time “the Russians” would start to use nuclear weapons.
Well, we’ve got something like that in reverse, now: the Russians are clearly poised to overrun all of Ukraine and push right up to the borders of Poland, Romania, and Slovakia, with just 357 miles (574 km) separating the border of Ukraine from the border of Germany–and of course, except for Poland and perhaps Germany the military capabilities of every country on that list is next to nothing.
4) Using a nuke to “cut off a transportation hub” would not stop a Russian attack from anywhere else and probably not Belarus.
Nuclear fallout from a tactical device is a very effective area denial weapon and, if detonated in the right place, would certainly hobble any effective maneuvers out of Belarus and in the Kharkov region. Also, such an event wouldn’t provoke Russia to change its order of battle and rush in on a full-scale offensive. The Russians are waiting for this offensive to develop so they can, from their currently quite secure positions, systematically annihilate whatever’s sent at them–then they will attack.
A tactical nuke set off in Ukraine would simply be one more war crime they’d add to the list they’re developing and would certainly be something they’d prosecute internationally.
5) Ukraine “hurtling” to Russian lines would run into the 500-750,000 troops Russia has poised to enter the war. It would simply be the “Ukraine counteroffensive” which is doomed to failure, as everyone expects.
A Ukrainian offensive that’s supplemented with NATO troops (Poland, for instance) and materiel coupled with 220 fully armed attack jets and bombers would certainly be a difficult threat for the Russian forces to cope with. Those “700,000 Russian troops” you speak of are spread out across a 150 mile front. Hobbling maneuvers to resupply and strengthen the lower portions of the line while pounding at the center with everything available may well be capable of overrunning a section of the line to allow a flanking attack southwards.
There are certainly some minds in NATO and the Pentagon who believe such an attack could succeed. The big question is, of course: how does NATO persuade its population that such an attack is necessary when, as we can all see, most folks just don’t believe in the necessity of this war?
A false-flag tactical nuke fits that bill perfectly, and Biden’s administration has already made it official policy that yeah, it’s OK to use nukes even if they haven’t been used yet.
Your estimation of the wisdom of the NATO and US leadership is much higher than mine. I share the worry of Gilbert Doctorow that the US would be perfectly happy to see most of Western Europe destroyed in a conflict that allowed the US elite to continue on as world hegemon for another 70 years.
Posted by: Pacifica Advocate | May 30 2023 5:44 utc | 111
Posted by: Pacifica Advocate | May 30 2023 5:44 utc | 112
“You’re missing the point why such a false-flag would be useful: controlling the news narrative and building a historical justification for American righteousness in its war of aggression against Russia.”
And what good is that if the end result is Ukraine is annihilated – and perhaps a good portion of NATO as well?
Not to mention that almost no one outside the West would believe it. If the West believes it, who cares?
“would build public support for full-on war, this time against Russia.”
Again, what good would that do if Russia then destroys Ukraine. The scenario stated is 1) tactical nuke for minimal effective results against Russia; 2) Ukraine then launches a counter-offensive – which is then annihilated because Russia is pissed off by the nuke.
You now add:
3) NATO goes to war with Russia.
4) ???
5) Profit!
“Air Defender 2023”
You apparently did not bother to read my post analyzing these upcoming NATO exercises. No, they do not encroach on Ukraine, Crimea or Russia proper. They also are not designed to be coordinated into some kind of attack on Russia, regardless of whether a nuke is detonated. That is not how air operations are planned and conducted. So this and the rest of the NATO exercises are completely irrelevant.
“Germany and Turkiye have nukes”
I highly doubt either of them would be willing to allow the US to authorize use of nukes from their territory, especially Turkey, based on the flimsy scenario you outline. But again, even if they did, the end result is WWIII.
“A tactical nuke detonated in Ukraine is not an attack on Russia. So no: that would not “immediately result in Ukraine’s annihilation,” for the simple reason that Russia would initially protest and insist it hadn’t used nuclear weapons for the simple reason that any kind of immediate response by Russia would turn international opinion to automatically presume that yes, Russia had initiated the use of nuclear weapons. Then they’d essentially have the entire planet against Russia.”
You just said the West would immediately assume Russia used a nuke, while Russia would be quite clear that they did not. Russia might issue a protest, but that would be followed up by a direct attack on whatever “decision center” authorized use of a nuke in Ukraine, whether or not directly against Russian forces. That attack would likely be delivered using conventional stand-off weapons, not nukes, so Russia will have clearly established that it was not at fault for whatever nukes was employed.
Furthermore, all nukes can be identified by their “signatures”. A significant portion of the world would be analyzing the signatures of the weapon used. It would not take long before various nations, especially China, concluded that the nuke was a US nuke.
“the entire premise during the Cold War–and I got this from several military people who attended the military colleges (Annapolis, West Point, USAF Academy)–was that NATO would overrun Russian ground forces and push any invasion force back to the borders of the Soviet Union and then would be the time “the Russians” would start to use nuclear weapons.”
First of all, the fact that you get this crap from military people reinforces Martyanov’s point that the US military is clueless.
During the Cold War it was absolutely assumed that NATO would barely be able to hold the line against a Soviet invasion until the US was able to respond with an air and sea lift of the majority of its forces from the continental US to Europe. The only use of nukes would be authorized if that line didn’t hold, or, of course, if the Soviet Union unilaterally used them first.
That was then, this is now. The US would not have the capability to do an air-sea lift rescue of NATO because Russia would use its stand-off weapons to interdict Europe’s ports and airfields, while the Russian navy would interdict US navy responses.
I remind you that according to articles I’ve seen, there have quite a number of NATO war games that have established that NATO has next to zero change of winning a war with Russia without resorting to a full-scale nuclear attack.
“if detonated in the right place, would certainly hobble any effective maneuvers out of Belarus and in the Kharkov region.”
Which, because you specify it is not used directly against Russian troops (which is the only effective way it can effect Russian forces), will not prevent Russia from using the half-to-three-quarters of a million troops it already had available all across eastern Ukraine and on the Russian border to deal with the issue.
We don’t even know whether there are any significant forces in Belarus. Macgregor keeps talking about 150,000 but he’s never produced any evidence, and I can’t find any evidence for that on open sources.
So your whole “area denial” speculation is essentially meaningless. Forgive me if I suspect that’s thrown in to make your scenario more plausible. It doesn’t.
“Also, such an event wouldn’t provoke Russia to change its order of battle and rush in on a full-scale offensive. The Russians are waiting for this offensive to develop so they can, from their currently quite secure positions, systematically annihilate whatever’s sent at them–then they will attack.”
NOT IF THERE IS A NUCLEAR DETONATION! Plans change, then!
“A Ukrainian offensive that’s supplemented with NATO troops (Poland, for instance) and materiel coupled with 220 fully armed attack jets and bombers would certainly be a difficult threat for the Russian forces to cope with. Those “700,000 Russian troops” you speak of are spread out across a 150 mile front. Hobbling maneuvers to resupply and strengthen the lower portions of the line while pounding at the center with everything available may well be capable of overrunning a ection of the line to allow a flanking attack southwards.”
Sigh. You really are clueless in military matters. Guess what? Where are those Polish troops coming from? Fucking Poland, right? How many miles do they have to cross to engage Russian forces? I’ll wait while you find a map. How about US forces? You think the 82nd Airborne is going to climb into helicopters, fly to eastern Ukraine and engage the Russians?
“Your estimation of the wisdom of the NATO and US leadership is much higher than mine.”
No, it’s not. I’m perfectly well aware that imbeciles run the US and Europe. But the crap you’re talking about is completely outside their competence. That’s the point I’m making.
Jesus Christ, go back to watching “Top Gun” and “Full Metal Jacket”, and leave this nonsense alone.
I’m done talking to you tonight – or ever. Babble this crap to some of the other morons here who no doubt eat it up.
Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | May 30 2023 6:23 utc | 118
Opening remarks by the Minister of Defense of the Russian Federation at a thematic conference call, May 30, 2023
First about the progress special military operation.
Russian troops continue to apply effective fire damage to the enemy.
Only for this month its losses amounted to more sixteen thousand military personnel, sixteen airplanes, five helicopters, 466 unmanned aerial vehicles, more four hundred tanks and other armored combat vehicles, 238 field artillery and mortars.
In addition, intercepted and destroyed 196 rockets «Haymars», sixteen rockets « Harm » and 29 long-range cruise missiles « Shadow Storm ».
Despite significant losses APU, Western curators continue to demand from the Kiev regime to move to large-scale offensive actions.
Deliveries are growing Ukraine equipment and weapons. We track volumes and routes of supply and upon identification strike.
Large Western weapons depots destroyed in recent days in Khmelnitsky, Ternopol and Nikolaev, hit the American anti-aircraft missile system «Patriot» in kiev.
Military support of Ukraine is only drags out hostilities, but can not affect source special military operations.
Using NATO weapons, Kiev authorities continue to apply attacks on social facilities, conduct terrorist attacks against peaceful Russian citizens.
Our Armed Forces as much as possible react harshly on actions of Ukrainian militants.
So, May 22 during the counter-terrorism operation in the belgorod region eliminated from above 70 Ukrainian saboteurs, automotive and armored vehicles. The remnants of the nationalists were thrown away to the territory of Ukraine, where fire was inflicted on them.
This morning, the Kiev regime implemented terrorist act in the Moscow region. I note on civilian objects.
In her was involved eight unmanned aerial vehicles of an airplane type.
They are all shot down.
In moscow three drone suppressed electronic warfare, lost control and deviated from the intended goals.
Still five – shot down in the Moscow Region with an anti-aircraft missile-gun complex « Pantsir ».
I want to note that during a special military operation, our military personnel operate selflessly, decisively, showing mass heroism, persistence and courage.
By decision of the Supreme Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces 155th Marine Corps Awarded the order of Zhukov.
Honors « Guards » assigned 291st artillery brigade, 55th separate helicopter Sevastopol Kutuzov order shelf and 50th self-propelled artillery regiment.
I want to emphasize military doctors, which, often risking their lives, save our military personnel, provide help civilians.
More 75% medical service specialists received combat experience in the zone of special military operation.
By decree of the President of Russia, the Central Military Clinical Vishnevsky hospital awarded Order of Alexander Nevsky.
Congratulations to our colleagues.
Let me remind you that earlier Order of Alexander Nevsky was awarded Kirov Military Medical Academy.
Further. First of June in the Armed Forces begins summer training period.
It preceded thorough preparatory work. Conducted from above two and a half thousand events.
During study main efforts will focus on training personnel and governing bodies, combat slacking newly formed associations, formations and military units.
Planned to prepare and conduct teachings of different scales.
Much attention will be paid to joint learning with CSTO peacekeeping forces, joint anti-terrorism exercise within « SMOA plus ».
The implementation of planned activities will allow ensure required level of readiness army and navy, task execution to protect national interests and respond effectively on changes in the military-political situation.
The thematic part of today’s conference call.
First, consider how the United Shipbuilding Corporation fulfills the state defense order repair with modernization heavy atomic missile cruiser « Admiral Nahimov ».
The corporation is building and repairing 62’s ships in the interests of the Navy.
May 13th transferred to the Navy corvette « Mercury ».
Work on five submarines and six surface ships are in the final stages.
Modernization of the missile cruiser « Admiral Nahimov » involves equipping it modern new high-precision weapons equipment long range including hypersonic missiles « Zircon ».
Ship sea trials scheduled at the end of 2023.
After commissioning cruiser will continue to perform tasks as part of Northern fleet.
Today we will outline measures that will allow complete upgrade cruiser by the end of 2024.
We will also discuss the issue at the meeting safety in the Armed Forces.
During a special military operation, they improve methods of application aviation. Digested new technique and means of destruction.
Often changing environment and use adversary of various kinds weapons of western production require us rapid response on emerging threats.
In this regard, we we use new approaches to the training of aviation personnel, implement in the educational process received combat experience, we are improving evaluation criteria combat training events and safety of flights.
The events allowed in the first half of the year current year practically exclude accident due to the so-called human factor.
Work continues on commissioning innovation system collection, processing and communication of information about aviation events.
We plan to connect to it in the near future federal executive bodies, operating state aircraft.
Today we will let us down work results safety in the first half of the year and outline the actions to reduce accident rate aircraft.
Posted by: opening remarks | May 30 2023 13:46 utc | 175
|