Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
April 29, 2023
The Last Hurrah

ZubuBrothers has a piece that reports about a talk given by the Chief of the General Staff of the Polish Armed Forces General Rajmund Andrzejczak:

Andrzejczak said that the situation doesn’t look good for Kiev at all when considering the economic dynamics of this conflict, with him drawing particular attention to finance, infrastructure issues, social issues, technology, and food production, et al. From this vantage point, he predicts that Russia can continue conducting its special operation for 1-2 more years before it begins to feel any structural pressure to curtail its activities.

By contrast, Kiev is burning through tens of billions of dollars’ worth of aid, yet it still remains very far away from achieving its maximum objectives. Andrzejczak candidly said that Poland’s Western partners aren’t properly assessing the challenges that stand in the way of Ukraine’s victory, including those connected to the “race of logistics”/war of attrition” that the NATO chief declared in mid-February. Another serious problems concerns refugees’ unwillingness to return to their homeland anytime soon.

As Andrzejczak himself admitted, “We just don’t have ammunition. The industry is not ready not only to send equipment to Ukraine, but also to replenish our stocks, which are melting.” Considering that Poland is Ukraine’s third most important patron behind the Anglo-American Axis, this strongly suggests that all other NATO members are struggling just as much as it is to keep up the pace, scale, and scope of support, if not more since many are a lot smaller and thus less capable of contributing in this respect.

Accordingly, this observation means that Kiev’s upcoming counteroffensive will likely be its “last hurrah” prior to resuming peace talks with Russia since the West won’t be able to keep up its assistance for much longer. Andrzejczak seems keenly aware of this “politically inconvenient” fact, hence why he wants his side to give its proxies as much as possible until the end of that operation in the hopes that they can then be in a comparatively more advantageous position by the time these talks recommence.

I agree with the General's analysis.


bigger

Bakhmut/Aryomovsk is to 90% under Russian control and the rest will be captured during the next few days. Ukrainian losses in the city must have been huge. The Ukrainian troops who try to escape from the city immediately come under artillery fire. The latest daily Russian clobber report counts 575 'enemy losses' in Bakhmut over the last 24 hours for a total of 815 along the whole frontline. This is the largest number reported over the last two months.

Holding onto the city at all cost was in my view the wrong decision. A more mobile defense would have cost more land but also would have had much fewer losses than occurred in those static positions under strong artillery fire. As Ukraine is geographically big but has relative few mobilizable soldiers it would have been better to trade land its for time and not its soldiers.

The defense of the lowland city cost the Ukrainian army dearly as it eroded its material and human reserves. Those will be missing to patch the holes in the front line when that long announced 'last hurrah' counteroffensive fails to make any serious gains.

Comments

” Oh aye, and I suppose Ukraine can keep troops in the field to get killed multiples to 1 against the Russians. With a moribund economy and unreliable donors forever?
Posted by: Urban Fox | Apr 29 2023 22:17 utc | 115 ”
That statement is worthy of a five year old complaining about other children to his mother.
” But what about the other kids Mom !! ”

Posted by: Deplorable Commissar | Apr 30 2023 6:22 utc | 201

Erelis | Apr 30 2023 6:09 utc | 196
Or until 2024, elections time in Russia. Putin didn’t say yet if he’ll take part and he may not win anyway. by that time they’ll be at 60-80k dead, including civilians, with medium or long range missiles in Ukr hitting distant targets and zero results after two years. So I expect that the war is only starting now, and terrorism will increase a lot to finish the regime change

Posted by: rk | Apr 30 2023 6:34 utc | 202

Goooooood morning world.
Todays sermon is just for BrexShitheads amongst us.
The rest of the bar can slumber on.
Voting to Remain in the EU, in 2016 is what is being addressed here by the poster who got my ire before bedtime last night but I refrained from posting as was late and wanted to read again and rewrite if necessary. Having woken up early and re-assessed my rant and the post I have decided to post it as stands.
“Why oh why would anyone vote for that ? Utter madness and stupidity.”
Posted by: Julian | Apr 29 2023 17:12 utc | 19
So, Julian – be seated, let’s us begin.
Given that most of the BrexShitheadery was based on Austerity imposed since the banking crises of 2008 and people were being told they were poor because of EU migrants coming over here and taking jobs for cheap wages …
Basic dog whistle racism. Same as we have been subjected to ever since with Covid and now Ukraine.
There has been no increase in wages. Austerity still continues. Most Eastern Europeans have left and not many are coming
So it was mostly BIG lies, with a very little bit of truth.
Also many voters did it because they wanted to give the government a bloody nose- many admitted to not expecting the vote to go that way based not only on polls but what many people they knew were voting!
They were all surprised as the votes reported early were in line with these polls until about 2 am when Sunderland reported a big swing! And what’s more important a large turnout!
The rest of the night these results were repeated mainly in the urban industrial towns many with diaspora communities, mostly traditional Labour areas delivered by community leaders.
One thing they all had in common was the exceptionally high turnout which wasn’t actually turnout at polling stations but a massive number of postal votes! A previously unseen method of voting by most people. Any turnout approaching 70% was exceptional any over that and being over 75% is ludicrous and unlikely. In ANY election or Referendum in a advanced voting democracy.
These turnout and postal vote numbers swung the expected polls to the majority of 1 in 33 votes that made BrexShit be declared at 6 am.
The stupidity and madness of BrexShit is only just being felt by the majority who had freely travelled several times a year to frolic in the EU without passport stamping, form filling and ability to take and return with unlimited amounts of booze and cigarettes.
This Easter was the first time they had experience of the brave new world of queuing for 24-48 hours.
This summer is going to be a doozy.
In the meantime the NHS is not suddenly improved by the undelivered promised £billions extra, food prices are through the roof and now there is no easy driving to holiday homes across Europe!
Yup the other shoe has dropped and there is mass regret at thinking they made the wrong choice! There is nothing like repenting at leisure after acting in haste. Eh?
But as I say , they are gaslighted into believing they did that , when it was actually ballot box stuffing with postal vote frauds in the dense urban areas.
So Julian what connects this to the SMO?
Well some of these workers coming here to take jobs were Ukrainian- even as they weren’t in the EU themselves. 25 years ago there used to be Russsians too amongst the Eastern and Central Europeans (as well as many other parts of the world who were arriving here in London to do whatever shitty job they could – but that is another story).
Now – there haven’t been Russians for the last 20 years ( or Chinese btw) except as bonafide students and tourists. The ‘cheap’ labourers were being flown in weekly to man the massive building sites and cranes across London through Covid! The Poles have gone home because there is now plenty of ‘investment’ taking place there and we, we in the U.K. can’t get a builder to do any repairs on our homes, we can’t get any bar and restaurant staff as all the cute young boys and girls of the EU can’t get here and work so we are screwed , worse we can’t get nurses and care workers to be paid a pittance to wipe our elderly in the lie homes for a pittance – the government quality of life has plummeted and it’s still dropping like a stone.
London is dying. Our young in the poor regions of the country aren’t coming anymore as the cost of living is too high and they would rather sign on and survive in their BrexShit country ever more deader towns than suffer more in the Capital.
All because these who were persuaded that BrexShit was a solution to their politically imposed Austerity regime. Where it was actually a move to protect the Old City , destroy the level playing field and stop the EU-EurAsia mutual economic security union from progressing. By way of a , Pavlovian conditioning of critical thought in the populace of Covid and ‘expert’ worship, the bread and wine belief of Vaxxing passports and the ensuing proxy natzo war against the multilateralists.
That Julian, and deluded BrexShitters, and yes, unwary idealistic Remainers and everyone Apathetic else – has been the ‘All our Plans’ of the DeepShits who twice stopped the Corbynites stopping them – for at least the last 15 years since the 2008 Banking Crash ; il
They’re massive amounts of MagikMoney printing LastHurrah of their control of the Collect Wastes World Finances which has no intention of ever controlling
It is culminating now and reaches its deceitful stinking zenith with the crowning of the latest Big Stinking C3poo – King Charles the Turd next Saturday. As they celebrate their great last boot filling plunder expecting to escape into the future by shapshifting again.
If we let them.
The fall will be mighty, fast and furious and we the majority of peoples will be rained on by its hard rains for generations. And this time we won’t be able to blame just the migrants and the EU, but the Chinese, Russians and all who join them in their war to free the majority of humanity., including all of us that buy into their grand old and new Narratives.
Amen.

Posted by: DunGroanin | Apr 30 2023 7:00 utc | 203

186 assad must go so Genie energy (board of directors is eye watering) can easily start extracting from the Golan before its was even stolen later on . ahh sovereign integrity and all. yes the competing pipes and israel didnt have theirs all sorted.

Posted by: hankster | Apr 30 2023 7:11 utc | 204

Narrative: change underway
Whisper it: Ukraine may no longer be winning
https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/04/28/whisper-it-but-ukraine-may-no-longer-be-winning/
https://archive.is/MlydF
Posted by: Melaleuca | Apr 29 2023 22:17 utc | 116
The article raises the interesting question on how to define “success” for a possible Ukrainian offensive.
Spoiler: the suggested options are several light years away from Selenskys and NATO’s stated goal of kicking Russia out of Donbass and possibly Crimea. Which, by the way, would not solve Ukraine’s problem of being threatened by a neighbour with a mighty army and more than 7000 nuclear war heads.
The TELEGRAPH, it appears, would settle for Melitopol. Possibly Mariupol. And perhaps a route to the Asow sea.
And then?
US, EU and NATO are scraping the bottom of the barrel to find 100 tanks for the current offensive. They are about to run out of ammo for air defense, and won’t have a lot artillery shells left after the offensive.
Putting a big question mark behind next year’s offensive, to go east or west from Melitopol or Mariupol. Assuming they capture them in the first place. And won’t be kicked out again: how do you defend a narrow corridor?
Especially if DiMA is right and Russia brings their Navy into the Asow sea, to pound on the Ukrainian army and their NATO toys from the water?
What would success look like for the Ukrainian offensive?

Posted by: Marvin | Apr 30 2023 7:23 utc | 205

Don’t you get it? In Bakhmut, Putin is meat grinding Ukrainian military, Zelensky is meat grinding the Ukrainian antisemitism there.
Antisemitism in Ukraine

Posted by: Nomad | Apr 30 2023 7:36 utc | 206

@19, 51, 52
I thought at the time in non critical thinking, in other words I had zero idea what was going on in the bigger picture. Only recent I’ve figured out how things have worked and realize that the MSN is the biggest problem. Most people have to be told a story and that is the belief , I thought like that for over 40 years, only the last 2-3 years have I to say the least awakened. I did not vote on EU debate but I did think at the time staying would be best. Again does the UK leaving have any tie in to the west plan , except it did not work.

Posted by: Scot1and | Apr 30 2023 8:10 utc | 207

@Suzan, #175:
Thanks for the anecdote on Yeltsin/Putin, one that proved to have a monumental historical consequence :-).

Posted by: Oriental Voice | Apr 30 2023 8:25 utc | 208

🧩The question is not whether nuclear weapons will be used, but who will be to blame/accused of this
The New York Times writes that the States gave us radiation detectors to detect nuclear explosions.
According to the publication, the goal is that if Russia uses nuclear weapons on the territory of Ukraine, then Moscow’s responsibility for this could be proven.
“Radiation sensors will be installed throughout the region and will have the ability to obtain data on the size, location and consequences of any nuclear explosion.”
In addition, the article states that the deployed sensors will deprive the Russian Federation of “any opportunity to use nuclear weapons in Ukraine without attribution.”
The probability of using tactical nuclear weapons in Ukraine has increased manifold.
In the event that the United States fails to achieve a Zelensky truce before the presidential elections at home, on the contrary, they can escalate. Both operations under a false flag are possible, as well as significant strikes on the territory of the Russian Federation in order to provoke a nuclear response☝️

https://t.me/ZeRada1/13452

Colleagues, you are right that the Western lobby’s contingency plan for the Ukrainian crisis is the maximum increase in stakes in a game where the “nuclear case” is most likely to be bidding. And not necessarily, Russia will have to strike. For this, there is a “third party”, or such “unknown snipers from the Maidan”, who will detonate a dirty nuclear bomb or create another provocation, and the culprit will already be predetermined.
It’s not just that, now, the United States is transmitting these sensors. Most likely – this is a strategic move ahead of the curve. They form in the society confidence in the future statements of Ukraine and accusations of the Russian Federation.
A nuclear catastrophe, an explosion, a tragedy, and a direct “absentia” accusation of the Russian Federation of this inhuman step against the security of the whole world. Imagine what a trump card this is for Biden and the United States in their game of completely isolating Russia and forcing the Kremlin to abandon its alliance with Beijing. Or Beijing to abandon the alliance with Russia, as well as other states that still trade and conduct international and other relations with the Russian Federation. Plus, Biden will save himself and his rating before the US elections.
Add to all this the news that London is ready to buy long-range missiles (500 km) for Ukraine, just enough to hit all military bases in the Crimea or towards Moscow. To create the necessary background, allegedly the Russians themselves, in retaliation, gasped at the conditional Nikolaev or the conditional Dnieper, with a “mini” nuclear bomb (the name does not matter, which city will not be sorry for the partners, that one will be sacrificed).
By the way, on October 25, 2022, we already got inside about this, writing that a dirty nuclear bomb already exists in Ukraine, but Kiev or foreign mercenaries use it not against Russians, but against their own citizens in order to create a world tragedy.
Take care of yourself, but rather think about how to leave the country …

https://t.me/legitimniy/15234

Posted by: Down South | Apr 30 2023 8:39 utc | 209

Our source in the OP said that the Main Intelligence Directorate is preparing a series of operations on enemy territory in order to shift the focus from Bakhmut, who is being held with the last of his strength, while losing several blocks a day.
The Office of the President gave the go-ahead for complex operations in the Moscow region on thermal power plants, fuel tanks, airports and military-industrial complex plants.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17521

Posted by: Down South | Apr 30 2023 8:40 utc | 210

Today, CNN published all of Zaluzhny’s fears that affect the success of the counteroffensive, which he expressed to Zelensky at the headquarters:
• Fortified defense complex built by the Russian Federation in 6 months, which is well equipped and mined.
“Breaking through will be a huge challenge. Layers of anti-tank ditches, barriers, minefields and trenches have been erected for hundreds of miles along the winding southern front.”
• The absence of a moment of surprise, any advancement of columns of equipment from Zaporozhye will be tracked before entering the battle, which means there will be no effect of surprise.
“Ukrainian officials have acknowledged that, unlike the surprise capture of most of the Kharkiv region last September, they may lack the element of surprise in any larger counteroffensive.”
The danger is that the counter-offensive could turn into a “division-level battle that turns into a series of platoon clashes” in which the Armed Forces of Ukraine get bogged down.
• The Russian Federation retains an air superiority that “may be critical to slowing down Ukraine’s advance.”
It is worth adding the negative consequences of the failure of the counteroffensive and then we get the risks that any manager / leader considered dangerous for him to get involved in an adventure.

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17522

Posted by: Down South | Apr 30 2023 8:42 utc | 211

The defeat of Ukraine will make it the strongest country in the world.
This statement was made by the commander of the Ukrainian troops in the Kharkiv region, Sergei Melnyk, answering the question of what will happen to Ukraine in five years.
According to him, in this matter, Ukraine should be equal to Germany, which lost in World War II, but managed to recover.
Did we get it right? The military does not believe that the counteroffensive will be successful? But what about those colossal losses in Bakhmut and not only?! What is all this for, if you yourself do not believe in anything ??

https://t.me/rezident_ua/17523

Posted by: Down South | Apr 30 2023 8:46 utc | 212

“So any Tips Gow to deal with it all. 6 cap song medals and all I know now is it’s all been a lie.
Posted by: Scot1and | Apr 29 2023 17:04 utc | 13”
Same here. Royal Navy followed by 15 in the police. Now in Finland with my family.
I can only recommend living a good life with your spouse. Have kids and raise them well. Maybe our children can rebuild if we train them right.

Posted by: Wazdaka | Apr 30 2023 8:53 utc | 213

Nothing to see….it’s just an *exercise* /(drill/ dummy run):
Few of us are convinced by “coincidences” anymore, right. ? Right?
§_ U$ announces they are expecting a probable nuke detonation in Ukraine.
§_ Conducts a nuke test “training exercise” on the at the same time.
Just a “coincidence”, right?
@FBI Houston

A large-scale, multi-agency nuclear incident TRAINING EXERCISE will take place May 1-5 in southeast Houston and Harris County. The training exercise will NOT pose risks to area residents.
Please do not be alarmed by training-related activity. @HoustonOEM
The training exercise will take place from in and around NRG Park/SH 288 to SH 146 to I-10 E to Hwy 225 and in and around Ellington Field.
Please do not be alarmed by training-related activity, including presence of military personnel/aircraft and people in protective equipment.
https://twitter.com/FBIHouston/status/1652314301552635907

And:
HahahaHal Turner: https://halturnerradioshow.com/index.php/en/news-page/world/foreign-ministry-u-s-directly-killing-russians
Also:
Something else not noticed while “we” are distracted by the plummeting sales of a beer company, or the plummeting ratings of a Faux news corporate…..
Authorization for Use of Military Force of 2001
§§| April 27, 2023
https://www.whitehouse.gov/briefing-room/presidential-actions/2023/04/27/message-to-the-congress-on-executive-order-on-authority-to-order-the-ready-reserve-of-the-armed-forces-to-active-duty-to-address-international-drug-trafficking/
Executive Order on Authority to Order the Ready Reserve of the Armed Forces to Active Duty to Address International Drug Trafficking

By the authority vested in me as President by the Constitution and the laws of the United States of America, including the National Emergencies Act (50 U.S.C. 1601 et seq.), and in furtherance of Executive Order 14059 of December 15, 2021 (Imposing Sanctions on Foreign Persons Involved in the Global Illicit Drug Trade), which declared a national emergency to address the unusual and extraordinary threat to the national security, foreign policy, and economy of the United States posed by international drug trafficking, it is hereby ordered as follows:
Section 1. Emergency Authority.
To provide additional authority to the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Homeland Security to respond to the national emergency declared in Executive Order 14059, the authority under section 12302 of title 10, United States Code, is invoked and made available, according to its terms, to the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Homeland Security.
The Secretaries of the Army, Navy, and Air Force, at the direction of the Secretary of Defense, and the Secretary of Homeland Security with respect to the Coast Guard when it is not operating as a service in the Navy, are authorized to order to active duty such units and individual members of the Ready Reserve under the jurisdiction of the Secretary concerned as the Secretary concerned considers necessary, consistent with the terms of section 12302 of title 10, United States Code.

Q: Ready reserve is any service member can be call back to active duty for up to 6 years?
Also: Flight crews have already had contracts extended (isn’t that is essentially mobilization by stealth)?
Mexico. Wants to join BRICS.
Mexico, might find itself Occupied if it continues ….. ?

Posted by: Melaleuca | Apr 30 2023 9:23 utc | 214

. . .my basis rule: If the government says something, assume that the opposite is true.
Posted by: Don Bacon | Apr 29 2023 18:08 utc | 42
NATO claims they lack ammo. Understand they got a good supply of it and Ukro push is coming soon.

Posted by: Greg Galloway | Apr 30 2023 9:37 utc | 215

@Longhorn | Apr 30 2023 3:12 utc | 170
“Yes. That said, having 5000+ nuclear warheads makes you impervious to attack. So the idea that Russia was threatened by NATO expansion is bullshit. That was the excuse for the territorial grab.”
Blah! blah! blah! Your type of logic was refuted several times in the past I seem to recall. America sure was threatened when Russia put a few missiles in Cuba. Now America wants to put missiles in all the new NATO territories. Unacceptable, America had better gets its arse back to its side of the Atlantic before Russia kicks America’s arse all the way back to America’s side of the Atlantic. Its not a matter of the mass media, the social media, logic or so-called European sovereignty, but simply a matter of tanks, planes and artillery shells.

Posted by: gT | Apr 30 2023 10:03 utc | 216

karlof1 | Apr 30 2023 1:25 utc | 159

The socio-political situation within Europe is very unfavorable for most NATO governments and will only worsen

Which is exactly the point I am making. NATO has neither capacity nor appetite for a protracted ground struggle. An outrageous last act of carnage and destruction is inevitably becoming – in some minds – its best and cheapest option to emerge ‘victorious’; with the risk such an escalatory act would directly set up ww3 being one they increasingly seem willing to take. Is it that lingering shock and awe mentality, or do they sense Kremlin division and weakness at the top?
Putin’s ponderous and ill defined SMO timetable has allowed even a depleted UkraNATO back into the game on several occasions, much to the chagrin of the likes of the DPR/LPR militias and even Yevgeny Prigozhin who has been openly asking to be given control of the RF forces in the north and south. His recently stated aim is to push UkraNATO 300km back west from the Dnieper thus placing the Donbas out of range of all but the most determined long range missile attacks on its civilians.
Putin on the other hand prefers to make speeches at trade events. In much the same way it took him 8 years to wake up and actually recognise the DPR and LPR, and meaningfully respond to the deadly struggle they had been involved in since 2014.
UkraNATO should be terrified of Russia, and the fact minor NATO states are yapping to be let off the leash to somehow savage Moscow’s ankles arguably says more about the Kremlin’s conciliatory attitude than NATO’s unabashed expansionism.

Posted by: B.F.Finlayson | Apr 30 2023 10:19 utc | 217

There will be no negotiations of any kind to stop the war. The West will see to that. Once the Russians smash the coming counter offensive, NATO/US will do something stupid and very escalatory to continue the war.
Posted by: Erelis | Apr 30 2023 6:09 utc | 196

You are right.
Unfortunately, the nuclear escalation is the only possible outcome in this situation.

Posted by: Srbin | Apr 30 2023 10:26 utc | 218

Scorpion | Apr 29 2023 21:31 utc | 98
That’s very good advice to Scot1and, which has been reitertated by Wazdaka | Apr 30 2023 8:53 utc | 214.
I think it was uncle tungsten that suggested that we are in a time when everyone has to choose a side. It seems to me that the choice is an internal one and that Scorpion and Wazdaka provided insights for that direction of travel. Liberty, Equality and Fraternity is a quaint eighteenth century notion that could come back into fashion over the next twenty years.

Posted by: Lantern Dude | Apr 30 2023 11:00 utc | 219

Posted by: karlof1 | Apr 30 2023 1:25 utc | 159
Good synopsis, too many here fail to see the difference between strategy and tactics, and get tied up in the latter. Agree, no nukes are planned although some sort of nasty false flag is possible. This is a war of economics, ideology and kinetic, one area may advance differently to how the audience likes but it is probably to enhance the other areas.

Posted by: Organic | Apr 30 2023 11:05 utc | 220

Suzan @ 175, Oriental Voice @ 209:
Another anecdote about Vladimir Putin is that in 1989 he defended the KGB office where he was stationed against a crowd of looters in Dresden (in the then East Germany) armed only with a pistol.
Apart from that, he was not great at recruiting foreign students at the nearby university into working clandestinely for the KGB. A person like that needs to be very sociable and good at chit-chat and making small conversation, and that wasn’t Putin’s style at the time.

Posted by: Refinnejenna | Apr 30 2023 11:05 utc | 221

@ Julian | Apr 30 2023 4:55 utc | 183 & @ Lone Druid | Apr 29 2023 18:47 utc | 60
I think the recent DiEM25 proposal (Yanis Varoufakis et al) is an eminently reasonable one.
Varoufakis & Co. are not positive players and are on the wrong side of the history. Mostly well oiled saloon leftists, with a very twisted neoliberal ideas made to sound progressive, basically a justified core foundation for the mainstream narrative.
Kind of a EU “leftist” political “Bellingcat”, if you will.
They all, and also including confused Zizek, jumped on board of compliant anti-Russian pro Ukrainian stay-with-the-West strategy.
Thus wrecking and exposing their false “revolutionary” posture.
They silenced themselves, conformists as they are.
Insulting RF and their leadership doesn’t help Varoufakis & Co. to have any fair say in what is happening on any stage, as being pro-Assange is just not enough.

Posted by: whirlX | Apr 30 2023 11:14 utc | 222

@Karlof1 167
For those who would like to delve into these competing theories Pankaj Mishra‘s ‘Age of Anger’ is a wonderful place to jump in.

Posted by: Valerie Swales | Apr 30 2023 11:15 utc | 223

IMO, unconditional surrender by the Ukraine is the best idea.
Ukraine can then be dismembered with neighboring western countries getting whatever pieces of land they think they lost in former conflicts.
There can be no Black Sea access for this area.
The eastern and southern areas including Odessa and up to Moldova can return to Russia.
No ships, no military components, no NATO, no EU – neutrality and growing good crops on any land not contaminated by the UK depleted uranium.
The word similar to Ukraine which my computer refuses to type – the word is from old Russian and means “border area” – is sufficient to describe what this area the size of Texas is – a border area of Russia.
and so it shall return and remain IMO if any of us want to escape the insane racial policies of the nazis.

Posted by: a lurking reade | Apr 30 2023 11:53 utc | 224

Posted by: Lone Druid | Apr 29 2023 18:47 utc | 60
What a stupid, pro-nazi text.
Obviously many people don’t understand the meaning of the words demilitarisation and denazification.
Is it so difficult to understand that the war did not begin on the 2022.02.24 and that the people of 4 oblasts voted to be part of the RF?
They call themselves democrats, but refuse that people can decide about leaving a nazi State.

Posted by: Quo Vadis | Apr 30 2023 11:56 utc | 225

What would success look like for the Ukrainian offensive?
Posted by: Marvin | Apr 30 2023 7:23 utc | 206
Any destruction is considered success for nato/US, as it was since 2014. The most valuable target would be an npp, preferably ZNPP which should hit Crimea too, but one in Russia would be as good. DU filling Donbass and Crimea is another favorite. If such “success” cannot be obtained, they will blow up a dirty bomb or one of the other Ukr npps, even if that would spread towards Poland, and say Russia did it because they can’t win the war. Also possible that small nukes (invented by Trump, if you remember, the first president to send weapons to Ukr to kill Russians for fun) were placed everywhere and that would explain why Russia pretends to fight using only 5 soldiers, trying hard not to win anything. Or they’re just stupid. Anyway, Xi’s piss plan, as absurd as Lula’s piss plan, was his way of saying that he’s afraid he’ll lose cheapest energy from Russia, many billions from Ukr reconstruction, which will never happen if there’s radiation damage, and Taiwan too. At least Indians are more direct, they resell everything back to EU so nato has no problems with resources.

Posted by: rk | Apr 30 2023 11:57 utc | 226

An interesting result of this war so far….
Top 10 Countries in Europe by Size.
1. Russia – 17,098,246 km² (6,601,670 mi²)
2. Ukraine – 603,500 km² (233,000 mi²)
3. France – 543,940 km² (210,020 mi²)
4. Spain – 505,992 km² (195,365 mi²)
5. Sweden – 450,295 km² (173,860 mi²)
6. Germany – 357,114 km² (137,882 mi²)
7. Finland – 338,425 km² (130,667 mi²)
8. Norway – 323,802 km² (125,021 mi²)
9. Poland – 312,696 km² (120,733 mi²)
10. Italy – 301,339 km² (116,348 mi²)
Russian claimed/occupied (Since 2014):
Crimea: 26,100 km² (10,100 mi²)
Donetsk: 26,506 km² (10,234 mi²)
Luhansk: 26,673 km² (10,299 mi²)
Top 10 Countries in Europe by Size.
1. Russia – 17,098,246 km² (6,601,670 mi²)
2. France – 543,940 km² (210,020 mi²)
3. Ukraine (without Crimea, Donetsk & Luhansk) – 524,221 km² (202,367 mi²)
4. Spain – 505,992 km² (195,365 mi²)
5. Sweden – 450,295 km² (173,860 mi²)
6. Germany – 357,114 km² (137,882 mi²)
7. Finland – 338,425 km² (130,667 mi²)
8. Norway – 323,802 km² (125,021 mi²)
9. Poland – 312,696 km² (120,733 mi²)
10. Italy – 301,339 km² (116,348 mi²)
Russian claimed/occupied (Since 2022):
Kherson: 28,449 km² (10,984 mi²)
Zaporizhzhia: 27,169 km² (10,490 mi²)
Top 10 Countries in Europe by Size.
1. Russia – 17,098,246 km² (6,601,670 mi²)
2. France – 543,940 km² (210,020 mi²)
3. Spain – 505,992 km² (195,365 mi²)
4. Ukraine (without Crimea, Donetsk, Luhansk, Kherson & Zaporizhzhia) – 468,603 km² (180,893 mi²)
5. Sweden – 450,295 km² (173,860 mi²)
6. Germany – 357,114 km² (137,882 mi²)
7. Finland – 338,425 km² (130,667 mi²)
8. Norway – 323,802 km² (125,021 mi²)
9. Poland – 312,696 km² (120,733 mi²)
10. Italy – 301,339 km² (116,348 mi²)
So as things stand at present, Ukraine is only the fourth largest country in Europe by area – behind Russia and now France & Spain.
If much more of Ukraine is removed it will soon drop below Sweden and perhaps even Germany, Finland & Norway…..
I’m sure France wouldn’t mind moving up to be the largest country in Western & Central Europe – that sounds like something Macron would love.

Posted by: Julian | Apr 30 2023 12:10 utc | 227

The word similar to Ukraine which my computer refuses to type – the word is from old Russian and means “border area”
Posted by: a lurking reade | Apr 30 2023 11:53 utc | 225
My mind keeps reading “Украсть”…

Posted by: Catilina | Apr 30 2023 12:11 utc | 228

Posted by: Julian | Apr 30 2023 12:10 utc | 228
More interesting by far is to compare the area Russia brought under its protection with just 200,000 troops to the land area of the United Kingdom or Germany.
Then to contrast the area of Ukraine with that of Afghanistan or Sudan or Iran – places where the USA fancies its chances………..and failed.

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Apr 30 2023 12:30 utc | 229

karlof1@167
Crooke seems to make a curious omission.
Friedrich List came upon his economic natinalist theories in the United States. As a young legislator and academic (Tubingen) in Wurtemberg he offended the authorities and fled the country. Eventually he agreed to emigrate to the US. It was there he learned of the “American System”, and of Hamilton’s policies.
Most importantly he was influenced by Henry Carey, the son of Philadelphia printer, Matthew Carey (famous for his long running feud in the 1790s with William Cobbett.)
Crooke talks of the Anglo American ideas of Free Trade. But historically the US was generally (the South, with its ties to Manchester, was an exception) opposed to Free Trade, developed its ‘infant industries’ behind a tariff wall, and claimed that the American System was what kept working class wages so high (the origins of the ‘middle class’ workers).
List improved upon the system that Henry Clay promnoted and worked to get Germany to adopt it-the Zollverein being one of its fruits. Japan also modelled its rapid industrialisation on List’s ideas.
Currently, of course the US has adopted, along with imperialism, the Free Trade that demands global hegemony to work. It was Sir Walter Raleigh who put it best: “For whosoever commands the sea commands the trade; whosoever commands the trade of the world commands the riches of the world, and consequently the world itself..”

Posted by: bevin | Apr 30 2023 13:17 utc | 230

Posted by: Julian | Apr 30 2023 5:07 utc | 186
I think the main reason the US wanted to overthrow Assad was to interdict the overland supply route from Iran to Hezbollah in Lebanon. Hezbollah is the only neighboring army which has defeated the Israeli forces.

Posted by: Antiwar7 | Apr 30 2023 13:46 utc | 231

Antiwar7: Real life is messy, and I doubt there was any one “main reason”; there were in fact several: the oil/pipeline matter; the elimination of an erstwhile torture ally; dislodging Russia from its bases in Tartus and Latakia; support for Israeli theft of Golan resources; support of Wahhabi terrorism over secularism. No doubt I’m forgetting other main reasons.

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 30 2023 14:12 utc | 232

Re: Posted by: Antiwar7 | Apr 30 2023 13:46 utc | 232

I think the main reason the US wanted to overthrow Assad was to interdict the overland supply route from Iran to Hezbollah in Lebanon. Hezbollah is the only neighboring army which has defeated the Israeli forces.

This is another valid possibility to consider. The fact is there were a multiplicity of reasons.

Posted by: Julian | Apr 30 2023 14:26 utc | 233

Spot that Nazi … C’mon let’s play with Mark Sleboda
https://marksleboda.substack.com/p/spot-that-nazi?
Brian Berletic on Critical Hour [shout out to MoA, 14 mins]
The Critical Hour: Growing Doubt Over Ukraine’s Offensive + US Difficulties Recruiting New Soldiers
@Antiwar7 #232
Other reason was to build a gas pipeline from Qatar through Syria to service Europe thus impacting Russian gas supplies to Europe. Didn’t work – so they blew up NS2 – and are still stealing Syrian oil and in situ in East Syria.
Russia, of course, had one big reason to protest its leased Naval base and Airport on the Syrian Med which the fall of Assad would have threatened … life in West Asia can get a bit complex at times … Enter China – and all changes – next big one is Erdogan which US would like to topple …
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d0hYnUbxrVE

Posted by: Don Firineach | Apr 30 2023 14:38 utc | 234

Re: Putin shooting an attacking wild boat during a outdoor dinner
Reminds me of Czar Alexander after a failed assasination attempt grabbing a policeman‘s horse and capturing the assassin all by himself.

Posted by: Exile | Apr 30 2023 14:51 utc | 235

“It has taken Russia 8 months to capture one town in the Donbass and they still have not done it…”
Posted by: Longhorn
Are you Mr. Podoliak himself? This site provides an excellent explanation as to why and how the Russians care about their soldiers while your Jewish Fuehrer Zelensky has been sending the Ukrainian youth to sure death in “meat grinders.” Ziocon/Banderite shills are certainly outraged that the Nazified cannon fodder “does not perform” as ziocons/neocons expected.
Pity Ukrainian mothers, wives, sisters, beloved girlfriends… Pity maimed and dead Ukrainian boys and girls, the victims of Straussian “full spectrum dominance” idiocy that gave its stinky rotten fruit in kind of the Notification of Ukraine. The loss of sovereignty by Ukraine to the Talmudized US shows its horrific consequences.

Posted by: Cerena | Apr 30 2023 15:01 utc | 236

Posted by: Cerena | Apr 30 2023 15:01 utc | 237
Bravo.

Posted by: Mexicana | Apr 30 2023 15:13 utc | 237

having x000+ nuclear warheads makes you impervious to attack.
Let’s test that theory…. With Russian nukes in, oh, say, Cuba?
Mexico? Puerto Rico? Haiti?
Posted by: Melaleuca | Apr 30 2023 3:59 utc | 174
Your counter-argument is a propaganda-fueled straw man. There were no nukes on the border of Russia when Putin began the SMO.

Posted by: Longhorn | Apr 30 2023 15:46 utc | 238

Posted by: Cerena | Apr 30 2023 15:01 utc | 237
Lots of repeated propaganda in your reply, yet you never refuted my comment. Fail.

Posted by: Longhorn | Apr 30 2023 15:49 utc | 239

Longhorn’s 3 letter agency training showing through “Accuse the opposition of doing what your doing, over and over”

Posted by: SwissArmyMan | Apr 30 2023 15:58 utc | 240

Meh. Accept and ignore the impotent trolls yapping away. No one’s going to change their agenda and, therefore, no one will change their opinions as stated. You can lead jackasses to water but you can’t make them think.
Indeed, pity them. They’ll be unemployed and their cities and towns will be further ruined thanks to generations of decisions by the gangsters who rule them until their neighbors fight each other because they weren’t smart or brave enough to challenge authority before they lost it all. If you insist on engaging them, appeal to them to visualize the alternative futures and where they see them and their families in it. Bankrupt from medical bills? Morbidly obese from Frankenfood? Watching obvious bullshit like Fox without Tucker or CNN or Madcow? If they think about the shitshow they support, maybe they’ll spend their off-hours learning a trade that survives their regime.

Posted by: natokraine | Apr 30 2023 16:56 utc | 241

A friend of mine died in Bakhmut about a week ago. The choice to claw on to a lost city yielded a tremendous loss of life and labor; lives thrown to the wind. May peace talks come swiftly.

Posted by: Elijah SR | Apr 30 2023 17:56 utc | 242

Now, when Putin, as you say “boasted” (I doubt he said it): “don’t they know I could take Kiev in two weeks?”
Posted by: Ed | Apr 29 2023 21:42 utc | 102

https://time.com/3259699/putin-boast-kiev-2-weeks/

Posted by: Jean-Bapt. Moquelin | Apr 30 2023 18:35 utc | 243

Putin famously boasted: “don’t they know I could take Kiev in two weeks?”
So famous, you’ll have a source for that, right?

Yes.
https://time.com/3259699/putin-boast-kiev-2-weeks/

Posted by: Jean-Bapt. Moquelin | Apr 30 2023 18:43 utc | 244

And Time has such pristine sources, half a notch above unnamed government officials.

Posted by: SwissArmyMan | Apr 30 2023 18:51 utc | 245

One thing I’ve never understood is why Russia doesn’t hit the equipment/artillery/tanks as soon as they cross the polish border? Wouldn’t some long range missiles be able to destroy the deliveries in transit right after they cross?

Posted by: James c | Apr 30 2023 19:33 utc | 246

Posted by: Longhorn | Apr 30 2023 15:46 utc | 239
yeah the US had not gone that far yet, he did not want the ienvitable us nukes on his border, hence the SMO.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Apr 30 2023 19:42 utc | 247

What’s the big deal? Sure, Russia COULD have taken Keeve in two weeks.
It’s just that it’s that Russia knows it’s in her best interests to draw it out a bit.

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 30 2023 19:54 utc | 248

IIRC the Cuban Missile Crisis ended when nukes were withdrawn from Cuba and Turkey.
That didn’t last long, of course; the US has had nukes st Incirlic for quite some time now.
Maybe it’s time for Russia to put some nukes in Cuba again? or better, Mexico?

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 30 2023 19:57 utc | 249

Maybe it’s time for Russia to put some nukes in Cuba again? or better, Mexico?
Please don’t give the Neocons/RINOS/Dems the damn excuse they need to invade Mexico. They are already chomping at the bit to do this.

Posted by: LGB! | Apr 30 2023 20:10 utc | 250

LGB!: You have a point there. Of course any stationing of nukes would have to be preceded by a mutual defense treaty between Russia and Mexico.

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 30 2023 20:21 utc | 251

Malenkov – If US doesn’t get out of NATO and Europe, I don’t see how anyone could fault Russia and Mexico for buddying up. My preference would be to leave europe and Africa to the Russians, North and South America to the US, and Asia to China, but we don’t get to vote for our leaders here anymore. I think there would be less wars if all the great powers just stuck to their own damn continents.

Posted by: LGB! | Apr 30 2023 20:28 utc | 252

LGB!: I see your point, but since we all know that the USA has been pretty horrible to Latin America, I can’t imagine the Latin Americans signing on with anything resembling enthusiasm.

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 30 2023 20:49 utc | 253

What’s the big deal? Sure, Russia COULD have taken Keeve in two weeks.
It’s just that it’s that Russia knows it’s in her best interests to draw it out a bit.
Posted by: malenkov | Apr 30 2023 19:54 utc | 249

Exactly. Twist ’em up by telling ’em you can do it. Then wind ’em up a bit further by telling ’em they’ve taken what you said “out of context”.

A Kremlin foreign policy aide commented today (2 September) Putin’s statement with the Russian Itar-Tass news agency.
He didn’t deny that Putin had said the Russian army could capture Kyiv within two weeks, but said the words were “taken out of context”.
“It was taken out of context and had a totally different meaning,” Yuri Ushakov was quoted as saying.
In any case, the disclosed exchange clearly illustrates that EU leaders do not know how to handle Putin, and that there is no consensus on how to deal with him.

https://www.euractiv.com/section/europe-s-east/news/putin-i-can-take-kiev-in-two-weeks-if-i-want/

Posted by: GT Stroller | Apr 30 2023 20:55 utc | 254

Malenkov- well I guess we can’t always get what we want. Probably Japan and Australia won’t be none too enthusiastic about being under China’s wing, nor Poland under Russia’s, but in the long run, it’s just better for world peace. We are all gonna have to compromise if we are gonna move forward.

Posted by: LGB! | Apr 30 2023 21:10 utc | 255

LGB!: But can’t we put Latin America under Russia’s wing? Yeah, there’s distance, but Moscow has been lending a hand to their liberation movements for more than half a century.
As for Poland, Japan, and Australia: Your scenario serves ‘em right. 🙂

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 30 2023 21:15 utc | 256

I think there would be less wars if all the great powers just stuck to their own damn continents.
Posted by: LGB! | Apr 30 2023 20:28 utc | 253

I’m certain that everyone on the continent of South America would agree!

Posted by: GT Stroller | Apr 30 2023 21:17 utc | 257

Perhaps South America could be under Brazil’s wing, and Africa could be under either Nigeria’s or South Africa. I think probably the more polarity the better. Too many Americans don’t want to see Russians or Chinese in the Western Hemisphere, similar to how Russia doesn’t want Americans in Europe or the Chinese don’t want the Americans in Asia.

Posted by: LGB! | Apr 30 2023 21:26 utc | 258

As for Poland, Japan, and Australia: Your scenario serves ‘em right. 🙂
lol, can’t disagree with you there, but remember, the point and purpose of multi-polarity is not about serving anyone right or giving them their just desserts, but rather about lasting world peace. Compromises necessarily have to be made.

Posted by: LGB! | Apr 30 2023 21:29 utc | 259

LGB!: Of course, if Lula survives the inevitable coup attempt, he could, with Argentina and a few others, establish their own regional sphere of influence. Dare we hope?

Posted by: malenkov | Apr 30 2023 21:36 utc | 260

The Russians made a lot of mistakes btwn 2014 till the Kherson pull back.
Posted by: LightYearsFromHome | Apr 29 2023 23:36 utc | 141
———————————————–
What looks like mistakes to you are simply facts on the ground. For example, “the Kherson pull back” as you called it was a tactical decision, made to preserve troops, supplies, and weapons to fight another day on better terms for Russia.
Now Zelensky’s decision to stand and fight in Bakhmut (soon to be Artyomovsk) to the last man was a mistake.

Posted by: Ed | Apr 30 2023 21:58 utc | 261

Posted by: Ed | Apr 29 2023 21:42 utc | 102
Well, Ed, they did fight their way into Kyiv, making it to the zoo.
Posted by: Response2 | Apr 30 2023 1:33 utc | 161
——————————————————
Yes sir Mr. Response2, you are correct, the Russians went to the zoo and fed the MSM monkeys a military feint, i.e. an attack designed to draw defensive action towards the point under assault. It is usually used as a diversion to force the enemy to concentrate more enemy manpower in a given area in order to weaken the opposing force in another area.
Unlike a related diversionary maneuver, a feint involves actual contact with the enemy.
This was pointed out buy the Russians and others after the event was completed, but you know how the lying MSM is, they lie when the truth fits better.
https://time.com/3259699/putin-boast-kiev-2-weeks/
REPORTS emerged Tuesday that Russian President Vladimir Putin said he could take control of Ukraine’s capital city in as little as two weeks, a remark that escalated already pitched tensions between Russia and the West in the lead-up to NATO’s summit in Wales (2014).
Putin made the incendiary comment in A PHONE CONVERSATION with European Commission President José Manuel Barroso, [and] ACCORDING TO Barroso’s ACCOUNT, published by Italy’s La Repubblica on Monday [????].
“The Kremlin did not deny that Putin made the statement, but insisted it was taken out of context.”
Mr. Response2, you know how things get taken out of ACCOUNT. You know like when the Obama / Biden Administration staged a bloody coup that ousted the legitimate elected government in Ukraine, but the MSM called it “a revolution” rather than ” a bloody coup against an elected goverment that wasn’t acceptably kissing the US ass.” It is easy for such things to be taken out of context.
https://www.euractiv.com/section/europe-s-east/news/putin-i-can-take-kiev-in-two-weeks-if-i-want/
(ditto)
https://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/03/world/europe/ukraine-crisis.html
(ditto)
Truely Mr. Response2, I would find some better sources, the MSM have proven that they follow a narrative not the facts or the truth.

Posted by: Ed | Apr 30 2023 23:10 utc | 262

Now, when Putin, as you say “boasted” (I doubt he said it): “don’t they know I could take Kiev in two weeks?”
Posted by: Ed | Apr 29 2023 21:42 utc | 102
https://time.com/3259699/putin-boast-kiev-2-weeks/
Posted by: Jean-Bapt. Moquelin | Apr 30 2023 18:35 utc | 244
Putin famously boasted: “don’t they know I could take Kiev in two weeks?”
So famous, you’ll have a source for that, right?
Yes.
https://time.com/3259699/putin-boast-kiev-2-weeks/
Posted by: Jean-Bapt. Moquelin | Apr 30 2023 18:43 utc | 245
————————————————————————–
You realize that you are talking out of both sides of your mouth. I dealt with this issue above at #246. I still have NO reason to believe a word of it, but if the comment is true, it was made in 2014 after the Obama/ Biden/ Nuland bloody fucking coup. At that time, before the US and NATO took control of the UAF, I am sure it was a well confirmed fact. But this has nothing to do with the present-day SMO or the US/NATO proxy war between Russia and the US.
If you would have said that Putin said this in 2014, I would have agreed with you and Putin. Most of the Ukraine military would have supported Russia in 2014, or at least opposed going to war with Russia.

Posted by: Ed | Apr 30 2023 23:32 utc | 263

James c | Apr 30 2023 19:33 utc | 247
Long range missiles are expensive bomb systems and a few tanks are too small a target. Long range missiles are also in transit longer and more vulnerable for NATO to target and bring down.
This article helps explain Russian strategy and adaptations.
https://eurasiantimes.com/ukraine-war-russian-bombers-fire-cruise-missile-for-battlefield-interdiction-after-limited-success-with-infra-attacks/

Posted by: olaf22 | Apr 30 2023 23:53 utc | 264

Anyone confused about how much territory Russia has taken over can see the new border on the institute for the study of war timelapse map. It shows that the new border has remained stable for 5 months.
https://storymaps.arcgis.com/stories/733fe90805894bfc8562d90b106aa895

Posted by: olaf22 | Apr 30 2023 23:54 utc | 265

LGB! | Apr 30 2023 23:57 utc | 268
I am merely supplying facts that might help readers with their opinions and speculations.
What’s your point?

Posted by: olaf22 | May 1 2023 0:29 utc | 266

Starting seeing Ukrainian refugees working in the rest area stops on Penn Turnpike. They are losing their young people in more ways than just casualties.

Posted by: John | May 1 2023 0:57 utc | 267

LGB! | Apr 30 2023 23:57 utc | 268
I am merely supplying facts that might help readers with their opinions and speculations.
What’s your point?
Posted by: olaf22 | May 1 2023 0:29 utc | 269
—————————————————-
So, olaf22, you see the war as a fight for territory. Most of the territory where the people have voted to leave Ukraine has been taken. But unless Russia (including the new Russians) cannot have security until the fascist Neo-Nazis Ukrainian military is reduces to nothing more that police and border guards.
The war ends with either peace agreements cast in stone which includes a nutural Ukraine excluded from the NATO Bloc) or an exceedingly lengthy process at the Russian meat grinder.
The issue of territory was decided in 2014 when the Obama/ Biden/ Nuland decided that democracy in Ukraine is not a requirement.

Posted by: Ed | May 1 2023 1:34 utc | 268

I’m wondering if the Zelensky phone call with Xi in China is a sign that China might pull another diplomatic coup by brokering a Peace … I can imagine that China might want to “ move” into Ukraine from their powerful economic side and stop the carnage… And again show who’s really taking charge and changing the world…. Just thinking

Posted by: Bill Ziebell | May 1 2023 5:52 utc | 269

Pretty sure I’ve seen variations of this post for the past few months.
Just another uncritical swallow of government data.

Posted by: Old Fart Legion | May 1 2023 5:57 utc | 270

A late comment/opinion…
The Polish general is only an example among the latest in an endless “good cop, bad cop” act being put out by “the west”. It is not relevant and it doesn’t matter; a cacophony of noise in the deep thick fog aiming to deceive and still stubbornly clasping on to key “western” delusions, most of all the ideas of their own importance and value.
I doubt the world and Russia is fooled nor cares.
I expect “the west” will escalate using any lie and false flag they can think of and “taboo” weaponry such as nuclear, biological, and chemical weapons, and then pile on with prepared “deniability” and “proofs” pointing the finger at the victims.
UK DU ammunition is said to already have been delivered and US/DoD new bio-labs are said to be back up in remaining parts of ex-Ukraine and the money and propaganda is still flowing freely.
At least in public not a single de-escalating move of any importance has come out of “the west”, none whatsoever that I am aware of, none whatsoever that I’ve seen anyone mention (and any “western” taunts of hypothetical negotiations —rare as they are— do not count in the slightest; as pointed out they’re due to ulterior motives).

Posted by: Sunny Runny Burger | May 1 2023 18:07 utc | 271

Posted by: Ed | Apr 29 2023 21:00 utc | 92
1. I would have negotiated with Putin but would not have given into his threats. I am against war in all its forms. Having said that, I am also against dictators…both Biden and Putin.
——————————————————————————
who was threating who? Was Russia moving towards Germany or France. Or is it the other way around? Do they let high school dropouts hang around the military for 4 years, when they can’t answer a simple question?
2. Yes. That said, having 5000+ nuclear warheads make you impervious to attack. So, the idea that Russia was threatened by NATO expansion is bullshit. That was the excuse for the territorial grab.
Posted by: Longhorn | Apr 30 2023 3:12 utc | 170
—————————————————————
Exactly what territorial grab are you talking about? Could it be Noth Korea, Vietnam, Loas, Kosovo and Serbia, or was it Iraq (WMD and bull that bullshit.) Oh yes it was Serbia, Guatemala, Nicaragua, and let’s not forget CUBA for Christ Sakes. Then there was Libia and Syria. Remember when Hillary Clinton allowed a right-wing haunt to steal a poplar election in Honduras. And finally, let’s get to the point Longhorn foghorn, did you salute smartly and proudly when The Obama, Biden, and Nuland organized a bloody coup against the democratic wished and election by the majority of the people of Ukraine in February 2014.
You say you spent 40 years in the military or working for the military, and you didn’t learn shit about deocracy,

Posted by: Ed | May 2 2023 4:03 utc | 272

Longhorn doesn’t oppose Biden. Indeed he’s probably never disagreed with Biden on any substantive issue. Biden was in favour of destroying Iraq, Libya, Afghanistan etc. He even helped to destroy South Africa and Rhodesia.
Classically Dictators reflect the will of the broader public anyway. Dictatorial power was an emergency measure given to a Consul for a year. They called Caesar a dictator but he was wildly popular in Rome and his only enemies were oligarchs in the Senate.

Posted by: Wokechoke | May 2 2023 4:17 utc | 273

Posted by: Piotr Berman | Apr 29 2023 22:28 utc | 123
wait, do you think the 2A is one of the Commandments!?!?

Posted by: Old Fart Legion | May 2 2023 5:42 utc | 274

The important question for Ukraine is how to lose the war.
The worst outcome would be winning.
https://thelonghillinstitute.substack.com/p/the-important-question-for-ukraine

Posted by: Richard Morchoe | May 2 2023 12:22 utc | 275

Kevork Almassian interviews:

“Patrick Henningsen, founder of 21st Century Wire joins Kevork Almassian to discuss Seymour Hersh’s investigation on the Nordstream bombing with new facts published by Freddie Ponton that support the findings that the US carried out the operation against the Russo-European pipelines.

Lots of meticulous detail discussed in this thirty minute utoob.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | May 3 2023 2:51 utc | 276