Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
February 21, 2023
The Buildup To War In Ukraine – Monday, February 21, 2022

Around noon of Monday, February 21 2022, the Donetsk News Agency reported of unprecedented artillery attacks on the Donbas republics:

The tensions along the line of contact in Donbass heightened over the last 24 hours, both DPR and LPR Missions to the JCCC report.

In the DPR, 730 explosions of Ukrainian projectiles were recorded, the enemy is using large caliber mortars and artillery cannons. A similar situation is obsereved in the LPR, where 674 explosions of Ukrainian shells were reported over 24 hours.

The Republics have suffered military and civilian casualties.

Key infrastructure objects have sustained damage. More than 1,000 customers are without power, a major ventilator was off in the Skochinskogo coal mine, prompting staff evacuation.

At around 18:50 local time the DNA reported that the Donetsk People's Republic and the Luhansk People's Republic had asked the president of Russia Vladimir Putin to recognize the republics as independent states:

"On behalf of our people we ask you to recognize the DPR as an independent, democratic, social state under the rule of law," the DPR Head Denis Pushilin said.

"I ask you to recognise the sovereignty and independence of the Lugansk People's Republic", the LPR Head Leonid Pasechnik said.

They both asked to consider the possibility of signing an agreement of friendship and cooperation between Russia and the LPR, including the cooperation in the sphere of defence.

Putin has a degree in law and is generally unwilling to bend or break it. The request by the Donbas republics are part of a process that will make a Russian intervention on their side legally consistent with the Charter of the United Nations and international law.

The Russian president held a Security Council meeting. It opened with his summary of previous events that had led to the situation:

A peace plan was drafted during the negotiating process called the Minsk Package of Measures because, as you recall, we met in the city of Minsk. But subsequent developments show that the Kiev authorities are not planning to implement it, and they have publicly said so many times at the top state level and at the level of Foreign Minister and Security Council Secretary. Overall, everyone understands that they are not planning to do anything with regard to this Minsk Package of Measures.

Nevertheless, Russia has exerted efforts and still continues to make efforts to resolve all the complicated aspects and tragic developments by peaceful means, but we have what we have.

Our goal, the goal of today’s meeting is to listen to our colleagues and to outline future steps in this direction, considering the appeals by the leaders of the Donetsk People’s Republic and the Lugansk People’s Republic on recognising their sovereignty, as well as a resolution by the State Duma of the Russian Federation on the same subject. The latter document urges the President to recognise the independence and sovereignty of the Donetsk People’s Republic and the Lugansk People’s Republic.

After the Security Council meeting Putin had a phone call with the German chancellor Scholz and the French president Macron to inform them of the results:

Vladimir Putin informed the leaders of the outcomes of the expanded meeting of the Security Council of the Russian Federation, which reviewed the current situation around Donbass in the context of the State Duma’s resolution on recognising the Donetsk and Lugansk People’s Republics. Today the leaders of the DPR and the LPR also requested the recognition of their sovereignty in connection with the military aggression of the Ukrainian authorities and massive shelling of the territory of Donbass, and the resulting civilian suffering.

In view of this, the President of Russia said he intended to sign a corresponding executive order soon.

The President of France and the Federal Chancellor of Germany expressed disappointment over the developments, while also indicating readiness to continue contacts.

At around 22:30 local time Putin held an address to the nation which was televised on public TV. It notices that large parts of today's east and south Ukraine as well as Crimea were previously parts of Russia that had been attached to Ukraine by Lenin (1922) and Khrushchev (1954). Additionally Stalin had attached Polish areas that to Ukraine after the Second World War.

He then review the plundering of Ukraine's richness after its independence, the rise of its 'nationalists' and the terror campaign they unleashed after the U.S. financed Maidan coup.

He noticed the build up of the Ukraine army, trained and armed by a continuous stream of NATO forces. Meanwhile NATO created new infrastructure that threatened Russia while the U.S. withdrew from several Arms Control treaties:

Today, one glance at the map is enough to see to what extent Western countries have kept their promise to refrain from NATO’s eastward expansion. They just cheated. We have seen five waves of NATO expansion, one after another – Poland, the Czech Republic and Hungary were admitted in 1999; Bulgaria, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Romania, Slovakia and Slovenia in 2004; Albania and Croatia in 2009; Montenegro in 2017; and North Macedonia in 2020.

As a result, the Alliance, its military infrastructure has reached Russia’s borders. This is one of the key causes of the European security crisis; it has had the most negative impact on the entire system of international relations and led to the loss of mutual trust.

He describes the situation in Donbas under steady shelling and concludes:

Russia has done everything to preserve Ukraine’s territorial integrity. All these years, it has persistently and patiently pushed for the implementation of UN Security Council Resolution 2202 of February 17, 2015, which consolidated the Minsk Package of Measures of February 12, 2015, to settle the situation in Donbass.

Everything was in vain. Presidents and Rada deputies come and go, but deep down the aggressive and nationalistic regime that seized power in Kiev remains unchanged. It is entirely a product of the 2014 coup, and those who then embarked on the path of violence, bloodshed and lawlessness did not recognise then and do not recognise now any solution to the Donbass issue other than a military one.

In this regard, I consider it necessary to take a long overdue decision and to immediately recognise the independence and sovereignty of the Donetsk People's Republic and the Lugansk People's Republic.

I would like to ask the Federal Assembly of the Russian Federation to support this decision and then ratify the Treaty of Friendship and Mutual Assistance with both republics. These two documents will be prepared and signed shortly.

After the speech Putin signed documents recognizing the independence of the Donetsk and Luhansk republics:

The President of Russia signed the Executive Order On the Recognition of the Donetsk People’s Republic and the Executive Order On the Recognition of the Lugansk People’s Republic.

Vladimir Putin and Head of the DPR Denis Pushilin signed a Treaty of Friendship, Cooperation and Mutual Assistance between the Russian Federation and the Donetsk People’s Republic.

The President of Russia and Head of the LPR Leonid Pasechnik signed a Treaty of Friendship, Cooperation and Mutual Assistance between the Russian Federation and the Lugansk People’s Republic.

The treaties of Friendship, Cooperation and Mutual Assistance included mutual defense agreements.

While the 'West' calls Russia's action in Ukraine 'unprovoked' the long list of NATO actions that Putin included in his speech prove that Russia's action was certainly provoked.

The 'West' also likes to call the Russian intervention in Ukraine 'illegal'. However, Russia recognized the two republics just like the 'West' recognized Bosnia and a part of sovereign Serbia as an independent Kosovo. Unlike in the Donbas republics there had never been a referendum in Kosovo that supported such a step. But the 'West' had even found an international court that (barely) legalized the Kosovo case. There can thus be no argument that the steps Russia took in recognizing the republics were in any way illegal.

The common self-defense treaties Russia and the republics signed are not fully consistent with Article 51 of the UN Charter as those republics  were not (yet) UN members. But they closely followed that articles spirit:

Nothing in the present Charter shall impair the inherent right of individual or collective self-defence if an armed attack occurs against a Member of the United Nations, until the Security Council has taken measures necessary to maintain international peace and security.

The case of Russian support for the Donbas republics was thereby made as legal as they possibly could be made.

The OSCE Special Observer Mission at the ceasefire line in southeast-Ukraine reported of Monday, February 21 2022.

It was the worst day ever.

In Donetsk region, the SMM recorded 703 ceasefire violations, including 332 explosions. In the previous 24 hours, it recorded 579 ceasefire violations in the region.

In Luhansk region, the Mission recorded 1,224 ceasefire violations, including 1,149 explosions. In the previous 24 hours, it recorded 333 ceasefire violations in the region.

After a high number of ceasefire violations and explosions on Saturday, February 19 2022, the following Sunday had seen a reduction of incidents. Monday however proved that this was not a trend. While the numbers of ceasefire violations were 10% less than on the previous Saturday the number of observed explosion increased by 20% over Saturday.


bigger

The map shows ceasefire violations in yellow, orange to red colors. By far the most now appear on the side of the Donbas republics. The source of most of the ceasefire violations, like noise of shooting or explosions recorded by cameras, drones or heard by the observers, is listed as 'undetermined'.

The map shows explosions, as small black dots, on both sides of the ceasefire line. While only a part of the hundreds of explosions were located and marked on the map a count of the black dots shows that a great majority of those happened on the side of the Donbas republics. I count 92 impacts marked on the Donbas side and only 16 on the government controlled side of the ceasefire line.

This was no longer an artillery duel or exchange of harassment. From a military standpoint this now clearly looked like artillery preparations for an attack along roads that could then be used as future lines of attack for a mechanized force.


bigger

Comments

Posted by: bevin | Feb 22 2023 2:20 utc | 82
Why would you think Hollande and Merkel signed the Minsk Accords in good faith, when they both came out and say otherwise? No really, I really want to know your thoughts.
I take them at their word in this instance , and my take is that they knew they were trying to fool Russia as they knew they were satraps of. Washington. Lackeys…

Posted by: Brother Ma | Feb 22 2023 7:03 utc | 101

Posted by: A.z | Feb 21 2023 18:30 utc | 21
«the intensification was not about launching an attack it was more venting of rage at Russian recognition of dpr and lpr […] For me atleast at 24th February Ukrainian state itself had no intention of waging war again dpr and lpr»
For you a storm of bombing against civilians is just “venting” but not an “attack” and never mind an “intention of waging war”, which therefore makes the counter-attack of the LPR and DPR with the support of their allies an “unprovoked aggression” by the people of the Donbas against the peacefully venting people of Greater Ruthenia :-).
I guess that if the RF bombed in the same way Warsaw then for you it would not not be an “attack”, but just “venting” against polish hostility to Russia without any “intention of waging war” against Poland.

Posted by: Blissex | Feb 22 2023 7:25 utc | 102

For the record:
– Lenin (as part of Soviet creation wars) added eastern provinces to Ukraine in the 1920s, previously Russian imperial territory
– Stalin (as part of WW2) added the far western provinces (including Lviv), previously Polish territory
– Stalin (on recommendation of Khruschev) also added the “southern” province of Chernivitsi aka Cernauti aka Northern Bukovina, previously Romanian territory
– Stalin (also Khruschev’s initiative) also gave parts of Bessarabia to Ukraine (today’s Odessa oblast), previously also Romanian territory, but before that, Moldovan and then Russian imperial territory
– Stalin (part of WW2) also seized Transcarpathia and added it to Ukraine, previously A-H or Hungarian territory
In other words, the really hardcore anti-Russian Nazi areas of (today’s) western Ukraine were added by Stalin while the most pro-Russian areas of (today’s) Ukraine were added by Lenin.
And, of course, we all know that once Khruschev ascended to power after his mentor’s death, he transferred Crimea to Ukraine as well.
Long story short, there are close to 1 million ethnic Hungarians, Romanians, Bulgarians, and Moldovans inside Ukraine’s official borders today that were added to Ukraine BY FORCE without a single vote, referendum, et al.
Also, I’m not the same “Sam” as the other commenter here, so I think I need to get a different name 🙂

Posted by: Sam | Feb 22 2023 7:58 utc | 103

– Stalin (as part of WW2) added the far western provinces (including Lviv), previously Polish territory
Don’t look too closely at the land deeds……….Poland annexed this area in 1349 and lost it in 1772 to Austria-Hungary. It was German-language region.
Poland cut deals with Ukrainian Nationalists in 1920 renouncing these areas if Ukrainians would fight Stalin ………..
League of Nations gave Poland a Mandate over Galicia 1923 but Poland failed to honour the conditions attached – anyway Hitler liked it too………
Stalin had agreement of FDR – Biden’s predecessor in Dems to incorporate Lwow into USSR and have Ukraine with its own separate seat at UN as Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Feb 22 2023 8:50 utc | 104

Posted by: Brother Ma | Feb 22 2023 7:03 utc | 104
Why……oh why……do you not look at German Foreign Policy since 1870 ???????
What is it in German History that makes you think Merkel and Berlin were not pursuing OWN objectives in Ukraine and leveraging US support ?
Is it that American Narcissism that makes people think everyone dances to US tunes ? Germany has more history in splitting Ukraine from Russia than ANY other nation………it tried in 1918 and it tried in 1941…….and it tried in 1991 and in 2014.
Go look at Tymoschenko and who got her out of prison and to Berlin – just as Berlin got Navalny into Berlin……..look at the Klitschko brothers and how Merkel funded them…….look at Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung.
https://www.kas.de/de/web/ukraine
https://deutsche-wirtschafts-nachrichten.de/2015/05/03/mit-deutschen-steuergeldern-adenauer-stiftung-mischt-in-der-ukraine-kraeftig-mit
03.05.2015 01:47
Vitali Klitschko gilt als politischer Ziehsohn der Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung. Die CDU-nahe Organisation spielte beim Sturz der Regierung Janukowitsch eine Schlüsselrolle. Finanziert wird die Adenauer-Stiftung größtenteils durch den Steuerzahler. Über die Zuteilung der Mittel entscheidet der Bundestag. Was genau mit den Steuergeldern der Deutschen in der Ukraine geschieht, ist nicht klar.

Die Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung ist eigenen Angaben zufolge seit 1994 in der Ukraine aktiv und hat dort mehr als 500 Projekte begleitet. Sie baute auch Klitschkos Partei, die „Ukrainische Demokratische Allianz für Reformen“ (UDAR), durch gezielte „logistische Hilfe“ und Schulungen mit auf. Die pro-europäische Partei hat es sich zum Ziel gesetzt, die Ukraine schnellstmöglich in die EU zu integrieren. Eine direkte Finanzierung durch die CDU-Stiftung streitet Klitschko jedoch ab. Er finanziere seine Partei vorwiegend durch Einnahmen aus Boxkämpfen.
Am Sturz der Regierung Janukowitsch war die CDU-nahe Organisation maßgeblich beteiligt. Als Janukowitsch seine Unterschrift unter das EU-Assoziierungsabkommen verweigerte, forderte die Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung, „eine klare Botschaft aus Deutschland und Brüssel an Kiew“ zu senden. Sie unterstützte folglich alle Oppositionsparteien, die sich zu dem Abkommen mit der EU bekannten. Neben Klitschkos UDAR und Jazenjuks Vaterlands-Partei zählte die Adenauer-Stiftung im Juli 2013 auch die rechtsextreme Swoboda-Partei zu den drei „demokratischen Oppositionsfraktionen“, obwohl diese „ihre Anlehnung an die nationalsozialistische Ideologie der NSDAP nie verborgen hat“.
Es ist nicht das erste Mal, dass die KAS rechtsnationale oder rechtsextreme Parteien unterstützt, wenn es der Durchsetzung der eigenen politischen Ziele dient. So berichtete die Junge Welt, dass die Adenauer-Stiftung mit den rechtsradikalen „Grauen Wölfe“ in der Türkei kooperierte. Und auch in Honduras bildete sie die rechtskonservativen Unterstützer des Militärputsches aus.

It is really time people;e on this thread woke up and started understanding this is not reluctant Germany (the population – yes) but the Elites are in lockstep seeking Revenge for TWO failed attempts to subdue Russia………
Germany was freed from its chains by Gorbachev and Scheverdnaze – and Yeltsin gave away everything…………..US is simply frightened Merkel was upstaging USA by signing deals with China as EU largest trade partner

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Feb 22 2023 8:59 utc | 105

Meine Meinung:
Die Anerkennung war völlig legal, und das einfach deshalb, weil sich die Bevölkerung der Republicken nie der Staatsgewalt, die jedenfalls zwischen Februar 2014 und dem 25.05.2014 (Präsidentschaftswahlen) jedweder Legitimität entbehrte, unterworfen haben.
Das mußten sie auch nicht, und an den Wahlen, die im Hinblick darauf, ob sie denn auch hinlänglich “frei” waren, zumindest fragwürdig erscheinen, haben sie nicht teigenommen.
Die Minsker Vereinbarungen waren in diesem Zusammenhang ein, jedenfalls auch völkerrechtliches, Verfahren, in desssen Folge die Anerkennung der Legitimität der Kiewer Staatsgewalt durch die Bevölkerung des Donbaß erst wieder hergestellt werden sollte.
(DeepL)
My opinion:
The recognition was completely legal, simply because the people of the republics never submitted to state power, which lacked any legitimacy between February 2014 and 25 May 2014 (presidential elections).
Nor did they have to, and they did not take part in the elections, which seem at least questionable in terms of whether they were sufficiently “free”.
In this context, the Minsk agreements were a procedure, at least under international law, in the wake of which the recognition of the legitimacy of the Kiev authorities by the population of the Donbas was to be restored.

Posted by: Humml | Feb 22 2023 9:11 utc | 106

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Feb 22 2023 8:59 utc | 109
I agree with you! I never said Germany was saintly , and frankly that is why I say that Merkel and Hollande (follower loser) were lying through their teeth. You misunderstood me, as I do believe Germany is a malign influence in Europe , and always has been. It has always hated Russia and Yugoslavia for being better warriors and people than themselves.
I’m not USA-ian. I am Australian.

Posted by: Brother Ma | Feb 22 2023 9:17 utc | 107

james@85-The Guardian has become a voice piece of the the Brit intelligence agencies since about 2015. Russbridger the then editor caved into demands from the intelligence services to disclose details of Wikileaks. Kath Viner, if ever a patsie for the intelligence services, replaced him as editor and from then on the now MI5/6 controlled shit-sheet plays the role of appearing to be the alternative voice of progressive UK but in reality, it nothing but a bulletin for zionist and UK government propaganda. It publishes no criticism of Palestine’s occupier’s actions whatsoever and was the leading publisher of anti-Corbyn invective.
Don’t touch with a bargepole.

Posted by: Vragtes | Feb 22 2023 9:37 utc | 108

Posted by: Vragtes | Feb 22 2023 9:37 utc | 112
Guardian was a loss-making paper employing children of titled and very affluent trust-funds. It covered its losses through ownership of Automart then Auto-Trader which spun off cash. They sold it to Apax for £600 million in 2014 which is why they are still afloat.
It has Jonathan Freedland resident Zionist plus children of Communists like Martin Kettle, Polly Toynbee (university dropout) and assorted well-connected opinionated types who presumably send in copy from their country cottages……..
You are right it was rolled over and is frankly unreadable. After looking at its pages you feel you need to shower

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Feb 22 2023 9:57 utc | 109

Posted by: Vragtes | Feb 22 2023 9:37 utc | 112
The problem with slagging off the Guardian, which is justified, is that there are no British MSM which are better. It is a least-worst case.

Posted by: laguerre | Feb 22 2023 10:03 utc | 110

laguerre @114 posted:
“The problem with slagging off the Guardian, which is justified, is that there are no British MSM which are better. It is a least-worst case.”
You could be right but it still leaves print on one’s arse when wiping-its only real useful function nowadays.

Posted by: Vragtes | Feb 22 2023 10:26 utc | 111

@ Paul Greenwood 109
Merkel snd Berlin were… supporting own ( German ) objectives , and leveraging US support…
I confess I hate politics, and here you show us why I hate the total hypocrisy of modern politicians. The word leveraging already has associations with the word used for banking interest, taking profit for lending money. Here it means trying to get something deceitful, viz weakening Russia, by perfidiously signing an international Peace agreement in bad faith.
I think you are right and that President Putin understood it as you have explained it. That two senior leaders of the EU were abusing the UN, the forum for World Peace, in order to foment war. Putin’s response clearly states that the objectives of the SMO were not only to deal with Ukraine, but also to deal with the entire negative attitude of the West to Russia.
Merkel and Hollande were prepared to leverage the nuclear superpower in a petty game of regional politics. That is unforgiveable. France and Germany should prosecute both of them for bringing nuclear war to Europe and for acting in bad faith.
If they are not prosecuted, then their respective countries agree with their stupid and irresponsible games, and Russia will have to pursue their complaint at the UN or by force.
I hadn’t understood this before , so thanks for your ( rather forcefully ) making the point.

Posted by: Giyane | Feb 22 2023 10:33 utc | 112

Posted by: Vragtes | Feb 22 2023 9:37 utc | 112 & 115
Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Feb 22 2023 9:57 utc | 113
Posted by: laguerre | Feb 22 2023 10:03 utc | 114
At the risk of causing even more topic drift (apologies to other barflies), in my view the state of the British MSM is a reflection of the wider state of the British body politic.
Looking across the entire political spectrum here, all I see is a series of interchangeable technocratic nonentities (a malign version of Pratchett’s Interchangeable Emmas), so the MSM merely becomes a series of interchangeable technocratic mouthpieces.

Posted by: West of England Andy | Feb 22 2023 10:38 utc | 113

re: bevin | Feb 22 2023 2:33 utc | 86
Sorry to be so late getting back to you but I’ve had a coupla things to do – plus when I tellya yo’re likely to think I’m a idiot for not expressing it better in the first place just cos I thought it was obvious which it clearly isn’t, I tend to get a bit lost in jargon sometimes. A nym is somewhat ancient internet slang for a handle, a name.
I keep things constant around sites I consider matter, but out there in the world where wipe arse fishwraps like the guardian are concerned I don’t care who says something, what is said is more important so I change up & down.
There is a lot more than that and yeah I need more effective hobbies but nevertheless testing out these low lifes derpy and highly unoriginal efforts can be diverting now & then. It is important to remember that most of these scum are even less able than the bumbling officialdom of 50 years ago.

Posted by: Debsisdead | Feb 22 2023 10:47 utc | 114

Posted by: bevin | Feb 21 2023 21:51 utc | 50

Can anyone offer an explanation?
I have been trying to post a lengthy piece on this thread this afternoon. On each occasion it has appeared in preview with the “Your Comment has been posted. Post another ..” message. But it has never appeared. There are no links in it.
(…) I do worry that this might be happening to others.

I’ve had the same happening to me when trying to post a short text containing three links for Orgel to pick up. It said “your comment has been posted…” but that was a lie. Shorter posts were accepted and it finally turned out the links were to blame. I modified them in ways that prevented them from being reckognized as links on the preview screen, and thus finally succeeded in posting my text.
Your case is the same, except that links do not seem to play a role.
One thing that could be tried is to determine which half of your text contains the problem, then, which quarter of the text, and try to narrow it down until you have something small than can be characterized. Good luck, if you wanna embark on this journey…

Posted by: grunzt | Feb 22 2023 10:54 utc | 115

Paul Greenwood | Feb 22 2023 9:57 utc | 114
I always assume when MI5/6 raided the Guardian offices re Wikileaks, and took away their computers, that they found (or planted) things which could be held over the Guardian – kompromat of some kind.
Ever since then Guardian has toed the line. No more Assange, Craig Murray or Greenwald, just Freedland and Behr.

Posted by: YetAnotherAnon | Feb 22 2023 13:06 utc | 116

Brother Ma@105
I’m just guessing, of course. But it makes sense to me that Merkel and Hollande imagined, or deluded themselves, that they were engaged in diplomacy, until, years later they learned, by reading about it, that they had merely been used. As they always were in such matters by the United States. In the end nothing NATO does matters unless the Pentagon/CIA allow it.
Debsisdead@119
Thanks for the reply. I’m so ancient and idle and I missed the early internet days and I’m a Know-Nothing not just on names but on simple maintenance measures. I admire your persistence and strong stomach in taking guerrilla action against the Guardian. I have always known that The Telegraph and The Times were Tory rags run in the interests of the enemies of mankind, but watching the Guardian lead the campaign against Palestinians, the wretched people of Gaza and the giants of courage in Jenin for example was too much. Kettle, who makes a living insulting his dead father and Polly Toynbee, Freedland, Harding and the rest of them are, unfortunately, fairly typical of the disgusting intellectual caste in Britain- there is nothing they won’t do for a lot less than pieces of silver. What they did to Assange however shows that they aren’t racists- they lynch anyone the boss tells them to.
grunzt@120 Thanks for your help. I’m beginning to think that my computer was messed up in some way. In the end I posted it in bits and pieces-most of it anyway.

Posted by: bevin | Feb 22 2023 15:45 utc | 117

@ Vragtes | Feb 22 2023 9:37 utc | 113
thanks vragtes…. and others who chimed in… it is much like other countries in the west at this point…

Posted by: james | Feb 22 2023 15:49 utc | 118