Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
February 7, 2023
NYT On Ukraine – Real Reporting, Propaganda For Balance, Ominous Warning

Th New York Times is putting itself in a twist with its current reporting on the war in Ukraine.

Last months Ukraine was winning the war – at least in 'western' media. But this week the NYT's man on the ground reports the opposite:

Outnumbered and Worn Out, Ukrainians in East Brace for Russian Assault

Exhausted Ukrainian troops complain they are already outnumbered and outgunned, even before Russia has committed the bulk of its roughly 200,000 newly mobilized soldiers. And doctors at hospitals speak of mounting losses as they struggle to care for fighters with gruesome injuries.

The first stages of the Russian offensive have already begun. Ukrainian troops say that Bakhmut, an eastern Ukrainian city that Russian forces have been trying to seize since the summer, is likely to fall soon. Elsewhere, Russian forces are advancing in small groups and probing the front lines looking for Ukrainian weaknesses.

The efforts are already straining Ukraine’s military, which is worn out by nearly 12 months of heavy fighting.

Losses among Ukrainian forces have been severe. Troops in a volunteer contingent called the Carpathian Sich, positioned near Nevske, said that some 30 fighters from their group had died in recent weeks, and soldiers said, only partly in jest, that just about everyone has a concussion.

“It’s winter and the positions are open; there’s nowhere to hide,” said a soldier from the unit with the call sign Rusin.

At one frontline hospital in the Donbas, the morgue was packed with the bodies of Ukrainian soldiers in white plastic bags. In another hospital, stretchers with wounded troops covered in gold foil thermal blankets crowded the corridors, and a steady stream of ambulances arrived from the front nearly all day long.

"We ca not let that defeatist piece stand alone," said the editor and turned to the dimwits of the British Military Intelligence to get some 'balance':

Moscow’s forces are advancing only a few hundred meters a week, U.K. intelligence says.

As Russia makes slow, bloody gains in a renewed push to capture more of eastern Ukraine, it is pouring ever more conscripts and military supplies into the battle, Ukrainian officials say, although it remains far from clear that Moscow could mobilize enough forces to sustain a prolonged offensive.

But Britain’s defense intelligence agency said on Tuesday that Russia had been trying to launch “major offensive operations” since early last month, with the aim of capturing the rest of the Donetsk region, which includes Bakhmut. But it had “only managed to gain several hundred meters of territory per week,” because of a lack of munitions and maneuver units, the agency said in its latest daily assessment of the war.

“It remains unlikely that Russia can build up the forces needed to substantially affect the outcome of the war within the coming weeks,” the agency concluded.

One wonder what 'outcome of the war' those folks are dreaming of.

The reports from the ground leave no doubt on who is winning. Even the op-ed pages of the NYT now acknowledge it:

The problem is that Ukraine is losing the war. Not, as far as we can tell, because its soldiers are fighting poorly or its people have lost heart, but because the war has settled into a World War I-style battle of attrition, complete with carefully dug trenches and relatively stable fronts.

Such wars tend to be won — as indeed World War I was — by the side with the demographic and industrial resources to hold out longest. Russia has more than three times Ukraine’s population, an intact economy and superior military technology. At the same time, Russia has its own problems; until recently, a shortage of soldiers and the vulnerability of its arms depots to missile strikes have slowed its westward progress. Both sides have incentives to come to the negotiating table.

The last sentence is wrong. Russia has no incentive to negotiate now. It no longer has a shortage of soldiers and its ammunition points have been dispersed and camouflaged to protect them from Ukrainian HIMARS attacks. Russia keeps grinding the Ukrainian army into the ground and is ready to attack further.

But the piece then makes a correct point. The U.S. would not allow any negotiations:

The Biden administration has other plans. It is betting that by providing tanks it can improve Ukraine’s chances of winning the war. In a sense, the idea is to fast-forward history, from World War I’s battles of position to World War II’s battles of movement. It is a plausible strategy: Eighty years ago, the tanks of Hitler and Stalin revolutionized warfare not far from the territory being fought over today.

But the Biden strategy has a bad name: escalation.

With whom is Russia at war — Ukraine or the United States? Russia started the war between Russia and Ukraine. Who started the war between Russia and the United States?

Many Americans cannot resist describing Mr. Putin as a “barbarian” and his invasion of Ukraine as a “war of aggression.” For their part Russians say this is a war in which Russia is fighting for its survival and against the United States in an unfair global order in which the United States enjoys unearned privileges.

We should not forget that, whatever values each side may bring to it, this war is not at heart a clash of values. It is a classic interstate war over territory and power, occurring at a border between empires. In this confrontation Mr. Putin and his Russia have fewer good options for backing down than American policymakers seem to realize, and more incentives to follow the United States all the way up the ladder of escalation.

That is indeed the case. Russia does not want to escalate. But when the U.S. does escalate, then Russia will do it too.

Comments

Posted by: Anthony | Feb 8 2023 13:52 utc | 292
Thank you. Hear hear. Well said.

Posted by: Mexicana | Feb 8 2023 15:18 utc | 301

@ cranked | Feb 7 2023 19:22 utc | 56
your instruction how to”plug in link to article ad hit save and wait to load. Easy” — it is not easy for an analphabet like me. You sound like the ‘computer guy’ from an old SNL skit, who tells the people, how incompetent they are..

Posted by: fanto | Feb 8 2023 16:54 utc | 302

Posted by: barstool | Feb 7 2023 19:23 utc | 57
Do you often struggle to count to ten?
Posted by: Crypt | Feb 7 2023 22:42 utc | 117
Haha. Curiously we have ten fingers, ten toes.

Posted by: RB | Feb 8 2023 17:46 utc | 303

I suspect that the US will lose the war against Russia in Ukraine because the same reason as it lost the Vietnam war and Afghanistan war, namely DISTANCE!!!. Ukraine is close to Russia and the US is far away. Hitler did not understand it and the US nether. DISTANCE IS EXPENSIVE in money and human los

Posted by: Jan Czekajewski | Feb 8 2023 18:15 utc | 304

Posted by: Opport Knocks | Feb 7 2023 20:41 utc | 83
There seems to be no contradiction between your belief that the metric system is appropriate for scientific work and his belief that the imperial system is appropriate for everyday life.
In terms of division, the duodecimal system is the best, but it’s a different system than the decimal system we’re used to.
Maybe we should abolish the decimal system and use the duodecimal system instead.

Posted by: Colin | Feb 8 2023 18:35 utc | 305

The audience between the King and President Zelensky will take place at Buckingham Palace this afternoon.
(What’s he going to offer)

His kingdom for a whore?

Posted by: LGB! | Feb 8 2023 18:58 utc | 306

I like Sy Hersh.
This does not mean I believe anything he says. Imagine that, a critical reader.
Hersh fell out of the golden circle when he published his Kennedy book, The Dark Side of Camelot. All the Kennedy groupies and fans dropped him cold and he never recovered.
I listened to a radio interview he did for the book. Pretty sure it was Pacifica, most likely Ms. Goodman. Contrary to what many believe it is not possible to walk into Alfred Knopf and get them to publish slander libel and gossip. His editor asked him how in hell she could fact check the text. He asked his editor who would know such things. She thought and answered “Family.” He told her to ask them. Which she did.
I am pretty every word of that book is fiction. Fiction the family wanted out in public. Hersh complied, he was likely rewarded. It ended his career.
Listen to sources. Evaluate sources.

Posted by: oldhippie | Feb 8 2023 19:02 utc | 307

oldhippie essentially repeats a point RSH made earlier: trust nobody’s word on nothing, not never, not even saintly Seymour. But wow, barflies, this is one heckuva read, I’m thinking:
https://seymourhersh.substack.com/p/how-america-took-out-the-nord-stream
Quite rich in illuminating logistical details, we must say. Whether or not you accept such details as plausible, it’s interesting that someone as connected as Sy Hersh has been deployed as the venue for this message.
Probably not entirely truthful, but certainly meaningful. For my part, I read this release (nearly simultaneous with Biden’s State of the Union address, notable for only slightly mention of Ukraine) as an ominous escalation. I don’t like Hersh’s tone one little bit, no longer trust him in the slightest, and find it scary: this game he’s playing with the selective truthfulness of some US officials.

Posted by: Aleph_Null | Feb 8 2023 19:24 utc | 308

jared | Feb 8 2023 1:32 utc | 166

What would Gengis do?

Aaargghh ! Don’t go there ! They invented paper money as a more efficient system of looting !
Oh, wait …

Posted by: Sarlat La Canède | Feb 8 2023 21:12 utc | 309

Jerry | Feb 8 2023 2:42 utc | 184

The Binary Cupid Shuffle
Now
Rotate Left, Rotate Left, Rotate Left, Rotate Left;
Now
Rotate Right, Rotate Right, Rotate Right, Rotate Right;
Now
Carry Clear,Carry Clear, Carry Clear, Carry Clear;
And
Give Me Another Byte, Give Me Another Byte

Brilliant !

Posted by: Sarlat La Canède | Feb 8 2023 21:17 utc | 310

Jan Czekajewski | Feb 8 2023 18:15 utc | 305

I suspect that the US will lose the war against Russia in Ukraine because the same reason as it lost the Vietnam war and Afghanistan war, namely DISTANCE!!!. Ukraine is close to Russia and the US is far away. Hitler did not understand it and the US nether. DISTANCE IS EXPENSIVE in money and human los (sic)

Not “distance”, perhaps “reach”…
Ogadai, Timur, Rome itself rarely had problems with “distance”..
Famously, the Carthaginian Hannibal made it through Gaul from ,err, ‘Spain’, but he only progressed by asking permission from the matriachal councils along the way.
These were, of course, destroyed by the boch, oops, sorry, romans after the conquest by our lad Julie !

Posted by: Sarlat La Canède | Feb 8 2023 22:43 utc | 311

@Pacifica_Advocate #206
Here you go:
Economists Radhika Desai & Michael Hudson explain multipolarity, decline of US hegemony
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6adqdNCSVhU
Posted by: Don Firineach | Feb 8 2023 9:16 utc | 242

Thank you for that link, Don, but that’s not actually the interview I was referencing. This is it, here. You can find the relevant bits at a back-and-forth between Ms. Desai and Mr. Hudson at 23:17~39:20–the back-and-forth is actually quite important, because the details of what they’re saying come out in the interaction–and then in a small bit by Ms. Desai at the end, at 47:55~49:05.
It goes into the real reasoning and effects of the lend-lease program and how that program is, rather than helping Ukraine “liberate itself, instead being used to enslave the Ukrainian economy to US financial/rentier interests. At another part of the talk (outside the scope of the times I mention, IIRC) the example of Great Britain in WWII is used, and how the US used lend-lease to shift the use of British Sterling to the US Dollar thus bringing an end to the Empire of Great Britain.
The rough outline i took away is as I mentioned above: US financial institutions are taking over the basic commodity markets and will extract the wealth from Ukraine by using their profits from those industries to pay off US investors, who will–of course–then reinvest their profits in those corporations which are stripping Ukraine of its commodities. None of that wealth will be shared with the Ukrainian people, who will essentially be wage-slaves to US corporations, no longer in possession of their land, mineral rights, or even basic agriculture.

Posted by: Pacifica_Advocate | Feb 9 2023 3:34 utc | 312

@ SG 301
You are more likely correct. There is no way to flatten the middle part of such a long stretch without distortions… Kind of a similar to underwear – tight edges with so much to cover. Yet an African continent is in the same situation – so there is a valid comparing point.

Posted by: Alex Vadim | Feb 9 2023 5:05 utc | 313

test

Posted by: alx west | Feb 9 2023 5:23 utc | 314