Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 24, 2022
Ukraine Open Thread 2022-234

Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Please stick to the topic. Contribute facts. Do not attack other commentators.

Comments

Posted by: Snowleopard | Dec 25 2022 23:01 utc | 202
It is completely possible to run 24/7 with a basic workweek of 40 hours x 5 days.
Sorry inadvertent deletion. s/b
It is completely possible to run 24/7 with a basic workweek of 40 hours, ie. 8 hours x 5 days.

Posted by: Snowleopard | Dec 25 2022 23:10 utc | 201

Posted by: Snowleopard | Dec 25 2022 22:31 utc | 200
Do you have any other examples of someone pretending to be stupid on such a grand scale?
Bush Jr is hard to accept, he really was that stupid but your notice of the pass he got does ring true.

Posted by: SwissArmyMan | Dec 26 2022 0:19 utc | 202

Posted by: DakotaRog | Dec 25 2022 19:08 utc | 187
That was informative and interesting, thank you.

Posted by: Babel-17 | Dec 26 2022 0:33 utc | 203

Donbass Lives Matter | Dec 25 2022 20:13 utc | 191
There has been video of latest model T-90’s at mobilized training camps for some time. Now there is also video of Amarta tanks at the training grounds. 150,000 of the mobilized still in training. Those tanks are not for defensive/ static line warfare. When the time is right they will roll over the nazi Ukrainians and nato mercs in the Donbas. Perhaps hey will go further but I think not. Other egions are not as heavily ethnic Russia/pro Russian as the four regions that are now part of Russia. Anywhere that has a significant anti Russia minority leaves Russia open to sabotage ect.
Russia is now in the process of moving from a peace time military to a war time military. War at this scale brings out problems that don’t show up in peace time exercises. Looking at attrition ratios, Russian military have performed well but I have seen there are problems with mid and lower level bureaucracy. Putin is now directly overseeing a transformation. I think infantry, artillery, tank forces will be brought up to something like the quality of Russia’s special forces in terms of equipment and training.
Russia is fighting Nato, Ukraine simply the battlefield. When Nato canot dent Russian defenses, it turns its guns on the soft targets – the civilians. Since the start of the SMO, all civilians have had a free ticket to Russia, either as refugees for the duration or permanent residents. We see the tragedy of Nato shelling of Donbas towns and cities. Why are the wives and children not sent back to somewhere beyond the range of Nato shelling? I know if I had a young family in a war zone that is the first thing I would do.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Dec 26 2022 1:06 utc | 204

indian punchline from today –
Ukraine war tolls death knell for NATO
Posted by: james | Dec 25 2022 16:49 utc | 181
thanks James. very good article.

Posted by: migueljose | Dec 26 2022 1:23 utc | 205

“Russia is fighting Nato, Ukraine simply the battlefield.”
That’s right.
The narrative that Russia is fighting Ukraine is a propaganda narrative peddled by the American and Western unfree press–not to mention the fake alternative media or anti-establishment “critics.”
Russia is fighting NATO. And NATO is an American meat puppet that the USA hides behind to give the illusion of “international consensus.” As such, NATO is just a variation of the assorted Coalition of the Killings that the Americans love to courageously cower behind.
And all the bean-counting about how many Ukie troops or potential cannon fodder units that Ukraine can scrounge up is also likely a piece of related disinformation. It obscures the reality that many military personnel fighting in Ukraine are not Ukrainian but include “unofficial” military from America, Poland, Britain, Canada, and other NATO shit states.
Ukraine is not the enemy.
Ukraine is the theater of operations.
America and its NATO proxy are the enemy.

Posted by: ak74 | Dec 26 2022 1:57 utc | 206

Hi, first comment here and obviously you all follow this in more depth than I do. But I was watching an interview with Col. MacGregor and he recommended a recent interview with a Senior Ukrainian general by “The Economist”.
I can’t find the transcript. Does anyone know where I can find a copy
Btw name is Valerii Fedorovych Zaluzhnyi, Aka The Iron General aka: The Ghost of Kiev’s uncle.
If someone could help find it, Merry Christmas.
To the rest of you, enjoy that lump of coal Santa left you.

Posted by: TheFeebleClone | Dec 26 2022 2:35 utc | 207

@206 Peter AU1 | Dec 26 2022 1:06 utc – “When the time is right [Russian tanks] will roll over the nazi Ukrainians and nato mercs in the Donbas. Perhaps they will go further but I think not.
Amarynth, who did such great work at the Saker site while he was on sabbatical, and who now has her own site, offered a lovely thought the other day:

“There is much discussion on where Russia will stop in the Ukraine? You know what I think? Russia might just decide to stop at the site of the original Berlin Wall right in the middle of Germany.”

That was from her very good geopolitical retrospective of this year:
Transformative Z..oomerangs of 2022
~~
Okay, no one really expects Russia to go all the way to Berlin – although during one of Germany’s recent moments of pettiness there was a Russian official who reminded Germany that Russia did know the way there.
We always said that NATO should be grateful that Russia was only demanding a return to 1997 borders, and not to 1989, when the Berlin Wall came down. Of course, that was the first offer, and the terms of subsequent ones from Russia always get harder.
I don’t think Amarynth really believes a physical offensive all the way to Berlin either, but I think the real point is that the psychic force of the posture that Russia is still building will be such that all of Europe can imagine that scenario – that all of the western world will finally see that Russia is prepared to roll over all of it unless it settles down and quits the fuckery.
And there will be no doubt of Russia’s physical capability to do this and her spiritual resolve to do this if compelled.
~~
And especially since the nuclear spear-tipping of Belarus last week, already the overall posture of Russia has moved farther west than Ukraine’s borders.
So, it’s a whimsical point from Amarynth, and not to be taken strictly literally, I think – at least, not today. But to be taken viscerally literally, by Europe, I think, is where we’re headed. And it may take Russia a year or two to build that ultimate posture, but when it’s built, no one in Europe or NATO will have the slightest doubt that the EAST is off-limits to the west, except with Russia’s approval.
Even the neocons will accept defeat there, or at least admit to being thwarted and stymied for ideas. I think Europe is about to be faced with the serious fear it used to feel at the sheer scale of the USSR, not so much from the threat as from the incredible scale of the opponent.
We will yet see the bully stopped and begin to tread softly, as it walks in the shadow of a big stick. I have no doubt that Russia will succeed, and it will be fascinating to watch. And the Rest of the World will be watching too.
Merry Christmas 🙂

Posted by: Grieved | Dec 26 2022 2:47 utc | 208

@209 TheFeebleClone | Dec 26 2022 2:35 utc – “If someone could help find it, Merry Christmas.”
I found the whole story on a site called Moon of Alabama:
Ukraine – What Its Military Leadership Says [Dec 15, 2022]
Funny name for a website but I hear they’re very good.
Merry Christmas to you too 🙂

Posted by: Grieved | Dec 26 2022 2:57 utc | 209

Latest New Atlas (Brian Berletic) video with Carl Zha and Mark Sleboda, one hour 22 minutes:
Russian-Chinese Ties vs. US Aggression w/ Carl Zha & Mark Sleboda
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALE6S_MmVew

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Dec 26 2022 3:05 utc | 210

Grieved | Dec 26 2022 2:57 utc | 211
I am not religious and you are Buddhist but western Christmas is a good time to catch up with relatives and friends. A merry Christmas to you and everyone here.
Russia I think will march on Berlin psychologically. What I see as a coming Russian tank offensive in Ukraine will I think knock all the viagra out of the European pedophiles.
ak74 | Dec 26 2022 1:57 utc | 208
Thanks for the reply. It adds to my thoughts.
………….
An overall thought of mine is Russia lives in a pragmatic relist world fully versed on history.
Here in the west we seem to live in some twilight zone far removed from reality.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Dec 26 2022 3:57 utc | 211

“An overall thought of mine Russia lives in the pragmatic realist world…” Your thought looks more like the dumb n’ dumber’s world. you’re telling Russia should simply abandon trillions worth of natural resources for what ? Having gone through all this war and sanction’s damage, just so when the opportunity to acquire huge swaths of land perfect for agriculture plus huge amounts of all sorts of resources, leave and pass on that ? (also leaving the pro-Russians in places like sumy, krivoi rog and Odessa out) there is nothing “pragmatic or realistic” about that, just stupid.

Posted by: Phariah | Dec 26 2022 4:16 utc | 212

Phariah | Dec 26 2022 4:16 utc | 214
You picked the correct username. The only thing in your comment that is accurate.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Dec 26 2022 4:19 utc | 213

“the only thing accurate…” You’re truly stupid , given you dont know even basics about Ukraine geography ( let alone history)

Posted by: Phariah | Dec 26 2022 4:21 utc | 214

@ Grieved | Dec 26 2022 2:47 utc | 210 with the civilization war level comment…thanks
You, I and everyone paying attention knows that Ukraine is proxy for a bigger conflict with strange lies and posturing around “no boots on the ground” sort of shit. I expect the physical boundaries of the Ukraine focused conflict to expand if Russian demands are not met and the attacks on Russia itself grow.
When does it get out of hand? Its been out of hand since 1971 when the global money mafia pulled the value rug out from under global money. I believe a new value based global money system managed by sovereign nations is coming to replace the private jackboot of the US dollar. I continue to posit that the birth of the new money system will be the knockout blow to the bully of the West
Does it go nuclear then? I somehow doubt it. I think folks are being prepared for the evolution

Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 26 2022 4:44 utc | 215

Posted by: Snowleopard | Dec 25 2022 23:01 utc | 202
Back in my younger days I used work on the docks during hake (whitefish) season.
We ran two 12 hour shifts, 7 days a week with every other Sunday off.
Sundays were clean up and maintenance day.
The seasons were 3 or 4 months long.
This is pretty common in agriculture work. For manufacturing, not so much, except in situations where the industry is trying to produce lots of good in a short amount of time.
Three 8 hour shifts, seven days a week is far more common, though.

Posted by: Haassaan | Dec 26 2022 4:57 utc | 216

Phariah | Dec 26 2022 4:21 utc | 216
Austro German nazi Galicia is not Ukraine’s history. Yet in just a few years since the US/UK takeover of Ukraine, they have been able to spread that idiocy to a good portion of the population. US learn’t its lesson in Syria when Russia separated militias from ISIS and al Qaeda. In Ukraine they have nazi punisher units to prevent regular troops/conscripts from surrendering or retreating. They will all be killed or maimed. Nazi Ukraine is no different to the ISIS caliphate. Cannon fodder for the west that Russia will destroy. It is a tragic thing when so many allow themselves to be brainwashed. It reminds of the pied piper leading the little children away.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Dec 26 2022 5:06 utc | 217

PeterAU1@206, i too have wondered why the vulnerable haven’t left or weren’t taken, forcibly loaded onto the waiting buses… but a friend of larch’s used to post on the saker, sometimes even now larch will post his conversations with auslander. after reading & re-reading his comments & now those few shared…i believe it’s really a matter of what happens in those moments when we find ourselves up against it & in that moment we must choose–stay & fight no matter what or go, re-group & do what we can to keep on going on. circles we worry like a worn bead given the war this war is existential for us all.

Posted by: emersonreturn | Dec 26 2022 5:48 utc | 218

@ RHS
I don’t know whether there’s any point trying to avoid some streaming services to use others hosted in the same jurisdictions. In case it matters, here’s that video on rumble.
Latest New Atlas (Brian Berletic) video with Carl Zha and Mark Sleboda, one hour 22 minutes:
Russian-Chinese Ties vs. US Aggression w/ Carl Zha & Mark Sleboda
https://rumble.com/v22e9f5-russian-chinese-ties-vs.-us-aggression-w-carl-zha-and-mark-sleboda.html

Posted by: wot wot | Dec 26 2022 6:18 utc | 219

The cause of this conflict can be debated, but the combatants are clear. The western hegemonic elites are infected with the disease of exceptionalism, and are unable to see the wood for the trees. The notion of democracy has crumbled to dust in front of our eyes and the masks have come off.
When nation states call for war instead of peace negotiations, then we know they have been infiltrated by the
shareholders of the MIC. As for the Russians, i think Mr Putin summed it up with his boyhood days experiences, “When you know a fight is inevitable, strike first”. Ukraine was finished the day the SMO started, now the fight is for all the marbles…we live in dangerous times.

Posted by: Genesisaker | Dec 26 2022 6:49 utc | 220

Translated from Russian FYI:
ПЕРЕХВАТ (Z) (Intercept (Z)) (Open/Public TG link)(Nine(9) referenced Situ maps)

Frontline report for the morning of 26.12.2022⚡️
Russian artillery is working hard in the Zaporozhye direction. Let’s go from west to east. Kamenskoye, Stepnoye, Malye Shcherbaki, Orekhov, Novodanilovka, Malaya Tokmachka, Belogorie, Charovne, Dorozhnyanka, Krasnoye and the unmade Malinovka are under attack. The AFU does not make similar responses. Why is the AFU relatively “silent”? Hardly because of the lack of ammunition. We will not elaborate on this topic further at this point. (Fig. 1)
The same situation is in the area of Ugledar. Russian artillery is working on the town. Bolshaya Novoselka and Prechistovka are also under fire. Also, we will not assess these events. (Fig. 2)
On the Donetsk front, Russian troops are again attacking near Novomikhailovka. They are also conducting assault actions in the city limits of Marinka. They slightly advanced near Nevelsky. They are trying to do the same in the direction of Pervomayskoye, Vodyanoye, from the direction of Opytne to Krasnogorovka and in the area of Kamianka. The Armed Forces of the Russian Federation continue to attack Alexandropol. There the H-20 highway, one of the key logistical routes for the AFU supply in Donbass. (Fig. 3)
Bakhmut area: an attack by the Wagner PMCs near Klescheyevka, shelling of the city itself, and counterattacks on the eastern outskirts. Soledar: again an attempt to cover Bakhmutskoye and offensive actions from the direction of Yakovlevka. (Fig. 4)
In the Luhansk direction Russian troops intensified. Attack near Krasnopopovka and Ploshchanka. Artillery is firing on Makiivka behind Ploshchanka. To the north – an attempt to move in the direction of Stelmakhivka and near Novoselovskoye. Even further north is an interesting option. There is an attack by the Russian army near the village of Liman First. This could create problems for the AFU bridgehead on the right bank of the Oskol River near Dvurechnaya.

Posted by: Outraged | Dec 26 2022 8:06 utc | 221

‘Big war is back’:
Of course, the Armed Forces of Ukraine are experiencing a number of problems. Among them are high losses, a low level of training, an extremely strong attrition of the military personnel of some units, as well as a lack of weapons and ammunition,” an unnamed military adviser from one of the Western countries quoted the publication as saying.

Financial Times (Paywalled)

Posted by: Outraged | Dec 26 2022 8:44 utc | 222

@79 : Hummm … better not fall in China grips :
“In contrast, only a small portion (21%) of the money that China gives to other countries can be considered as traditional aid. And the rest of that money? The “lion’s share” of that money is given in commercial loans that have to be repaid to Beijing with interest. ”

Posted by: murgen23 | Dec 26 2022 8:54 utc | 223

Translated from Russian FYI:
Операция Z: Военкоры Русской Весны (Operation Z: Russian Spring Warcasters) (Open/Public TG link)
(Referenced map at above link)

The map of a “dismembered” Russia in the office of the head of the Ukrainian Ministry of Defense was shown by Ukrainian propagandists
▪️Russia is divided there into territories “given” to Ukraine, a certain CAR (apparently “Central Asian Republic”), a number of territories near China are marked with a red “K”, the Kuril Islands are given to Japan, Kaliningrad to Germany, and the northern territories to Finland.
▪️Kiev reporters noted the Kursk and Belgorod oblasts, as well as parts of the Kuban, that were assigned to Ukraine and asked Budanov whether this was “the next stage after the 1991 borders,” to which he responded evasively that anything was possible.

Posted by: Outraged | Dec 26 2022 10:10 utc | 224

I expect the physical boundaries of the Ukraine focused conflict to expand if Russian demands are not met and the attacks on Russia itself grow.
Posted by: psychohistorian | Dec 26 2022 4:44 utc | 217
That was what everyone expected months ago related to Donbass borders but it was based on nothing real. The army was and still is too tiny to even prevent the attacks in Donbass or Belgorod. They can’t buffer even 100km around those regions, who is going to expand out of Ukr borders? Soon Poland with troops and US with bases will move in, they only wait for more Russian losses to add (total, including civilians) to create a bigger propaganda effect on Russian population. US won’t fight anyone, just repeat Syria and proxy terrorists, nazis and slaves like Poland. Turkey also complains about a lot of pressure from nato to open the Black Sea to nato ships. They can’t keep it closed forever anyway, surely not long enough for Baldie to win his artillery duels.
Saratov base was hit by drone attack today, 3 soldiers dead. Targets were the nuclear bombers. Remind me again how well trained are the Russian generals.

Posted by: rk | Dec 26 2022 10:13 utc | 225

TASS, December 26 – 4,400 civilians have been killed in DPR, including 132 children, since Feb 17. 3,956 people, including 249 children, were injured during this period.

Posted by: rk | Dec 26 2022 10:36 utc | 226

In contrast, only a small portion (21%) of the money that China gives to other countries can be considered as traditional aid. And the rest of that money? The “lion’s share” of that money is given in commercial loans that have to be repaid to Beijing with interest. ”
Posted by: murgen23 | Dec 26 2022 8:54 utc | 225
Obviously IMF, that is the US and EU give money to the global south for free. 100%. No need to repay.

Posted by: RB | Dec 26 2022 10:46 utc | 227

Translated from Russian FYI, MOD Summary Dec26:
ПЕРЕХВАТ (Z) (Intercept (Z)) (Open/Public TG link)

Summary by the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation on the progress of a special military operation on the territory of Ukraine (26 December 2022)
The Armed Forces of the Russian Federation continue to conduct a special military operation.
💥 In the Kupyansk direction, up to 20 Ukrainian soldiers, an infantry fighting vehicle and two vehicles were destroyed as a result of a concentrated fire strike on the accumulation of AFU manpower and equipment near the settlement of Kislovka, Kharkiv region.
💥 In the Krasno-Limansky direction, Russian artillery fire hit AFU units in the areas of Makiivka and Nevskoye settlements of the Lugansk People’s Republic, as well as Terny and Torskoye of the Donetsk People’s Republic.
◽️ In addition, a Ukrainian sabotage and reconnaissance group and an AFU mortar team were destroyed in the areas of Stelmakhivka and Chervonaya Dibrova in the Luhansk People’s Republic. The losses of the enemy in this direction amounted to more than 30 Ukrainian soldiers, two armored combat vehicles and two pickup trucks.
💥 In the Donetsk direction, Russian troops continued successful offensives, during which they occupied advantageous lines and positions. More than 35 Ukrainian servicemen, including five senior officers, were killed as a result of a strike on the command post of the 80th Airborne Assault Brigade of the AFU near Kramatorsk, Donetsk People’s Republic. Total losses of the enemy during the day in this direction were up to 100 servicemen, four infantry fighting vehicles and eight vehicles.
💥 On the South Donets direction, artillery fire and active actions of Russian troops defeated AFU units in the areas of Vladimirovka, Ugledar, Novodonetskoye and Novoselka settlements of the Donetsk People’s Republic. More than 40 Ukrainian servicemen, two armored combat vehicles and three pickup trucks were destroyed.
💥 Rocket troops and artillery hit 63 AFU artillery units in firing positions, manpower and military equipment in 79 areas. In the areas of Elizavetovka and Slovyansk settlements of the Donetsk People’s Republic, temporary deployment points of the 72nd mechanized brigade of the AFU as well as foreign mercenaries were hit.
💥 Two Ukrainian Grad multiple rocket launcher vehicles were destroyed during counter-battery warfare in the areas of Pervomaiskoye in the Donetsk People’s Republic and Kamyshevakha in the Zaporozhye region.
💥 Three Ukrainian D-30 howitzers were destroyed near Torskoye, Vodyane and Maryinka settlements of Donetsk People’s Republic.
💥 A US-made M777 artillery system, which was used for shelling residential areas of Donetsk city, was uncovered and destroyed near Georgiyivka settlement of Donetsk People’s Republic.
💥 Two US-made HIMARS multiple rocket launchers, two Gvozdika self-propelled howitzers, five D-30 howitzers, as well as three units of special vehicles were destroyed near Kramatorsk, Donetsk People’s Republic.
💥 Anti-aircraft defense forces destroyed seven Ukrainian unmanned aerial vehicles in the areas of Kreminnaia, Luhansk People’s Republic, Chervonoye, Kuteynikove, Kropivnitske, Donetsk People’s Republic and Zmievka, Kherson region, overnight.
◽️ In addition, two HIMARS multiple rocket launchers were intercepted in the areas of Rubezhnoye and Krasnorechenskoye of the Luhansk People’s Republic, as well as two HARM anti-radar missiles near the settlement of Bayrak of the Donetsk People’s Republic.
📊 In total, since the beginning of the special military operation destroyed ((+?) over preceding 24hrs):
– 352 aircraft,
– 192 helicopters,
– 2,731(+5) unmanned aerial vehicles,
– 399 anti-aircraft missile systems,
– 7,249(+9) tanks and other armoured combat vehicles,
– 944(+4) multiple rocket launcher combat vehicles,
– 3,719(+11) field artillery guns and mortars,
– 7,765(+18) pieces of special military vehicle equipment.

Comment:
Though the claimed destruction of 399 anti-aircraft missile systems has not changed for some time, the regular routine destruction of S-300/Buk AD batteries radars, which cannot be replaced or repaired(no parts)(ex-soviet manufacture), routinely renders affected AD batteries non combat-effective regardless (Kill equivalent).
15 total Arty pieces destroyed in only 24hrs (4 MBRLS & 11 Tubes) is a significant ‘uptick’ compared to the norm. In particular qty x 9 (2 HIMARS, 2 Gvozdika SPGs & 5 D-30 howitzers) in vicinity Kramatorsk alone.
IF sustained over the coming 5-10 days, in isolation, a likely indicator of targeted enemy fires(Fire Support) destruction & suppression, preparatory to significant offensive Op/s.

Posted by: Outraged | Dec 26 2022 11:51 utc | 228

Hitting bases deep inside Russia will become an increasing problem that is almost impossible to solve. As the West pours even more resources in combat and having the Ukrainians as a shield of plausible deniability, I dont see how the Russians can solve this.
Maybe alerting the international community, with evidence, that the West is aiding and abetting these terrorists. There is very probably a local component to it, aside from recon via Western assets to defeat the local security around these bases.
Maybe there are technical means to do it, but I dont see them (low flying cheap drones guided though radar gaps + local help).
The best bet is capturing the terrorists and obtaining evidence of Western involvement. Then Russia can fly their own drones over Western capitals just to scare them. As NK did today.

Posted by: alek_a | Dec 26 2022 12:33 utc | 229

IF sustained over the coming 5-10 days, in isolation, a likely indicator of targeted enemy fires(Fire Support) destruction & suppression, preparatory to significant offensive Op/s.
Posted by: Outraged | Dec 26 2022 11:51 utc | 230
Maybe time to stop playing footsie? Well, it is a new year coming. Everybody will be trying to get things started right. Yeah, I have to think so.

Posted by: Bemildred | Dec 26 2022 12:56 utc | 230

Posted by: Outraged | Dec 26 2022 10:10 utc | 226
▪️Russia is divided there into territories “given” to Ukraine, a certain CAR (apparently “Central Asian Republic”), a number of territories near China are marked with a red “K”, the Kuril Islands are given to Japan, Kaliningrad to Germany, and the northern territories to Finland.
C.A.R … That reminds me of the original “Central African Republic”, and probably a foreshadowing of the kind of hellhole they’d like to turn Russia into.

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Dec 26 2022 13:07 utc | 231

alek_a @ 231
Russians are more sophisticated and long-term in their thinking than the NATO decision makers, which I believe works against them. Sometimes, if a bully shoves you, you need to shove back. If “Ukrainian” drones are attacking Russian bases, then “unidentified” drones need to attack NATO assets directly. Do the Russians understand that they are facing a bunch of narcissistic sociopaths? When dealing with sociopaths, timidity is often more dangerous than retaliation!

Posted by: Donbass Lives Matter | Dec 26 2022 13:35 utc | 232

Alek_a@231
>>Hitting bases deep inside Russia will become an increasing problem that is almost impossible to solve. As the West pours even more resources in combat and having the Ukrainians as a shield of plausible deniability, I dont see how the Russians can solve this.
The real problem is NATO-countries thinking they can get away with what Russia can and will see as terrorist attacks against their territory, with a Ukrainian smugly rejoicing “unfortunate smoking accidents” and advising Russian civilians to stay clear.
How will NATO react when “unfortunate smoking accidents”start to happen on NATO bases? How will NATO react when NATO ships get in trouble due to “rough waters”? And what Genius thinks it is a good idea to launch missiles and Drones against Engels air base? Strikes against nuclear capable aircraft that could be seen as trying to disable Russia’s nuclear cability? Strikes that would, a few years back, have been likely to trigger a nuclear strike by Russia!
We have a war in Ukraine because the NATO-Geniuses thought that Russia would not react, no matter how much we provoke them. Now some people think they can have fun by poking the bear some more.
Are they desperate? Are they complete idiots? Or do they want to trigger World war III?

Posted by: Marvin | Dec 26 2022 13:49 utc | 233

Austro German nazi Galicia is not Ukraine’s history. Yet in just a few years since the US/UK takeover of Ukraine, they have been able to spread that idiocy to a good portion of the population. US learn’t its lesson in Syria when Russia separated militias from ISIS and al Qaeda. In Ukraine they have nazi punisher units to prevent regular troops/conscripts from surrendering or retreating. They will all be killed or maimed. Nazi Ukraine is no different to the ISIS caliphate. Cannon fodder for the west that Russia will destroy. It is a tragic thing when so many allow themselves to be brainwashed. It reminds of the pied piper leading the little children away.
Posted by: Peter AU1 | Dec 26 2022 5:06 utc | 219
Best description yet Peter. Russia is faced with a hostage situation where many of the hostages have embraced their nazi leaders while others on the front lines are being shot for desertion. Hence, Russia’s hesitation.
Appreciate your posts and work on the biolabs. Thank you

Posted by: migueljose | Dec 26 2022 14:08 utc | 234

Posted by: Marvin 235
“We have a war in Ukraine because the NATO-Geniuses thought that Russia would not react, no matter how much we provoke them. Now some people think they can have fun by poking the bear some more.” The West/NATO thinks like that because they are megalomaniacs, among their many psychopathologies. They never even had a Plan B just in case Russia did not back down. They are just now trying to process a Plan B, and it doesn’t include admitting that their are limits to their power and they got Russia all wrong.
“Are they desperate? Are they complete idiots? Or do they want to trigger World war III?” All of the above. Some of them still think that a nuclear war can be ‘won.’

Posted by: Mike R | Dec 26 2022 14:18 utc | 235

They are not idiots, but they are narcissistic sociopaths. People commonly believe that sociopaths are just really selfish, amoral individuals, but they’re actually much worse. They love taking risks, the more dangerous the better. And unfortunately, once one of them targets you, you cannot simply play defense indefinitely.
If you want to understand the psychology of the NATO decision makers, read this article: https://www.choosingtherapy.com/narcissistic-sociopath/ . Everything will make sense.

Posted by: Donbass Lives Matter | Dec 26 2022 14:40 utc | 236

@ Posted by: Peter | Dec 24 2022 15:52 utc | 19
How amusing more scrap steel.
The average life of a country 404 MBT tank on the eastern front. On a good day twenty-four hours. On a bad day two hours!

Posted by: Bad Deal Motors On | Dec 26 2022 14:53 utc | 237

Greetings fellow barflies
Once again, the Engels base, located just one hundred kms from Moscow, is targeted with a low flying drone causing the death of three technicians on the base.
I cannot fathom how a low flying drone can travel undetected over a 600 kms run into hostile territory.
Admitting it is turbofan powered, maximum speed at low altitude would be a tad below 900 Km/hr.
One full hour if a direct flight, uncomplicated by navigating around ADs.
Plenty time for some soul on the ground to call a defense center and alert to an incoming missile.
Plenty time to scramble a few fighters to intercept the bitch.
Russia possesses AWACS that can detect low flying objects. Are they all sleeping at the same time?
All this points out to either complicity somewhere along the chain of defense, Or incompetence?
Unless, unless the drone is flown from Russia itself, closer to the target.
Then, what is to prevent the crazy Brits from purveying some nukes to the crazier Ukies that will fit on this very unstoppable drone? There are US artillery shells that will fit the purpose.
The RF is not dealing seriously with this treat, I am afraid that some of the billions the US has sent to Ukraine have been used to bribe key actors in this scheme.
I mean, not even one SU30 or 35 aloft to face any unknowns and fill the fixed defense gaps?
What about giving a bloody nose to the enablers, basking in the comfort of their cocoons?

Posted by: CarlD | Dec 26 2022 14:56 utc | 238

Posted by: alek_a | Dec 26 2022 12:33 utc | 231
Not only did the NK drones fly over Seoul unhindered, but South Korea had three Patriot systems that supposedly didn’t fire a shot. In addition , a South Korean fighter was also seen to crash with both pilots in hospital. At the time of the article, we weren’t told why the pilots are in hospital, nor why the plane crashed. Did the NK drone(s) shoot it down?
Posted by: rk | Dec 26 2022 10:13 utc | 227
Turkey can at least use the fig – leaf of a treaty and international law – Montreux Convention for the Straits. If the USAans keep pushing Turkey it at least shows they are willing to break more treaties when it doesn’t suit them . Also ,bombings were all over Russia in WWII and it still won. London also experienced the “ Blitz” ,admittedly for much shorter length of time but won. Korea was bombed into the ground and NK still won to status quo ante . You can survive bombing, it comes down to the level of pain the people will endure .

Posted by: Brother Ma | Dec 26 2022 14:57 utc | 239

Nato wants a big war, they are trying to make Russia “start” it. Russia for the most part has managed to avoid this situation. The last thing the Russians want is a war against 10x it’s population.
Right now the cost of the war is a massive drain on the west and fairly controlled.

Posted by: OohCanada | Dec 26 2022 15:28 utc | 240

The Oliver Stone – Vladimir Putin interviews from five years back are 3 hours 36 minutes and I’m not reviewing all of it to give an exact link. It is all worth listening to.
One thing Putin said was Ukraine is still divided by WWII. Every family in every village knows who had a grandparent who fought onside with the Nazis, everyone knows who lost half the family in battle with the Nazis. And it would never end until scores were settled. He had no interest being involved in that.
He is involved now. That is how this ends. When Russia secures entire territory of Ukraine there will be a bloody settling of scores. When that is concluded the terrorist attacks will stop. The terrorist attacks will slow when West has trouble financing them. They will end when Ukraine is soaked in blood. West is doing everything possible to see that it goes that direction.

Posted by: oldhippie | Dec 26 2022 15:39 utc | 241

I cannot fathom how a low flying drone can travel undetected over a 600 kms run into hostile territory.
Posted by: CarlD | Dec 26 2022 14:56 utc | 239
What makes you believe that?
Many here think that Russia is operating in Ukraine with one hand behind its back as it doesn’t want to expose its true capabilities and systems due to the potential risk of NATO doing something stupid.
Allowing these missiles through and only downing them with SHORADS at the airfield could be part of that strategy. Why allow the US Global Hawk over the Black Sea, or other INTEL assets, to ID their medium and long range SAM systems’ frequencies and locations? The unfortunate loss of a few servicemen at Engels is, in the scheme of things, is neither here nor there.
Plus no doubt there are idiots out there who now believe that if a crappy old Soviet cruise missile can get through them ‘modern’ US missiles will have home runs. Probably the same lot who think that the effectiveness of Ukrainian AD against RuAF aircraft would not apply in reverse were Russia, with its updated+ versions of those systems, faced with incoming NATO aircraft.

Posted by: JohninMK | Dec 26 2022 17:00 utc | 242

Armed conflicts. Combat operations, Reports from the militia of Novorossiya. Latest reports from the DPR and LPR fronts
Since December 15, the AFU reinforcements have lost about 1.2 thousand people killed and seriously wounded in Bakhmut. According to the Military Chronicle, the largest losses were suffered by units deployed to Artemivsk from the southern direction.
The largest number of dead and seriously wounded was recorded in the reconnaissance company of the 24th AFU Brigade, the 34th and 17th motorized infantry battalions of the 57th infantry Brigade, and the 9th, 10th and 11th territorial defense battalions of the 59th separate motorized infantry Brigade.
AFU reinforcements suffered losses at the positions of the 30th and 54th brigades in the southern suburbs of Bakhmut-Opytne and Kleshcheyevka. After the arrival of the Ukrainian infantry on the positions targeted and partially destroyed by artillery fire, which are under the supervision of the Wagner PMC, the APU used a barrage tactic using 152 mm Hyacinth-B howitzers.
The 1st, 2nd and 3rd battalions of the 62nd mechanized Brigade from the 4th Army Corps of the AFU Reserve also suffered heavy losses. These units came under a barrage of artillery from the Wagner PMC during an attempt by the Ukrainian Armed Forces to counterattack in the area of Kurdyumovka and Ozeryanovka, 20 km south of Bakhmut.
The situation is particularly difficult in the 59th Brigade of the Armed Forces of Ukraine. In just three days, from December 23 to 26, the unit lost about 185 people killed and wounded. A reconnaissance company of the brigade and a self-propelled division with howitzers “Gvozdika” of 122 mm caliber were almost completely destroyed.
On December 24, due to the impact of 300-mm Smerch complexes, the brigade lost the control point of an artillery reconnaissance battery with the American AN/TPQ-37 Firefinder counter-battery radar and the Starlink satellite terminal in the Ivanovsky area (a southwestern suburb of Bakhmut). After that, the headquarters structures of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in this area switched to data exchange via the Iridium PTT (Push-To-Talk) system, which complicated and slowed down the exchange of information and counter-battery warfare in this area.
The destruction of the AN/TPQ-37 counter-battery radar also made it difficult to use the 155 mm TRF1 French howitzers deployed near Bakhmut. Due to a lack of intelligence, the Ukrainian artillery was unable to conduct targeted fire for several days and twice hit the positions of the 54th Brigade of the Armed Forces of Ukraine in the south-east of Artemivsk.
The Bakhmut garrison of the Armed Forces of Ukraine suffers heavy losses on the first and second lines of defense, where, in addition to the orchestra artillery, T-80BV/BVM “jet” tanks are very active. According to the Military Chronicle, the Ukrainian infantry in this area suffers from a shortage of anti-tank grenade launchers and gradually loses the ability to deal with the rapid breakthroughs of tanks in the depth of defense at a speed of 60-70 km/h.
According to AFU radio intercepts, the infantrymen left on the first two lines of defense are dying without weapons and cover, while the reserves inside Bakhmut are working on a plan of action in urban battles in case the front collapses. The AFU reserves are forced to prepare fortifications inside the city for the fall of the defense around Bakhmut manually due to a shortage of engineering equipment, which the Military Chronicle reported earlier.
Source: life.ru
See also (in Spanish) https://guerraenucrania.wordpress.com/2022/12/07/la-batalla-por-artemovsk/

Posted by: JohninMK | Dec 26 2022 17:15 utc | 243

Posted by: CarlD | Dec 26 2022 14:56 utc | 239
Think of it in the opposite way. How easy will it be to defeat the security of a random US nuclear base using local support to guide a low-flying long-range drone which can be fired from within or from, say, Mexico? Let it fly through unoccupied areas only to reveal itself on terminal approach?
The US also has large swathes of unmonitored border, unoccupied areas and/or areas without radar coverage. The routes frequently used by drug cartels and smugglers.
Compare this to the current Russian base attack and you know how it could have happened.
The difference here is that US recon assets, space based, monitor radar signatures and discover routes that have low probability of interception. It is this help which makes it possible for “Ukraine” to strike nuclear bases deep in Russian territory.
There is a way to significantly cripple low-orbit satellite assets (like starlink) but it will mean that noone can use those orbits for hundreds of years. As I see it, this will happen sooner or later since escalation has been pretty linear up to now and I see no side letting up.

Posted by: alek_a | Dec 26 2022 17:29 utc | 244

by: JohninMK | Dec 26 2022 17:00 utc | 243
„…….part of the strategy….“
u mean same strategy like with the first german drone Mathias Rust?
Hahahaha man u made my day )))))
„…loss of servicemen….is in the scheme…“
Due to 5D MOD, Three soldiers were killed from falling drone parts…….crazy……so ridicolous

Posted by: Ćevapčići | Dec 26 2022 17:31 utc | 245

JohninMK 243
The idiots out there seem to reckon that the SAMs are mobile and their location and configuration can change very quickly.
Therefore, unless NATO were going to strike at that moment the exact location of said defenses is useless.
I see no reason to put these valuable lives and bombers in harm’s way.
If the RF want to hide its assets, it should borrow a page from the Iranians and do away with the Golden Hawk, just like they did three
years ago.
I see no reason why these birds are allowed to fly over the Black Sea while spying for the enemy.

Posted by: CarlD | Dec 26 2022 17:34 utc | 246

@ Bemildred | Dec 26 2022 12:56 utc | 231
It appears the 9 were congregated at a near rear area AFU workshop for repair/maintenance. So, maybe not.
@ Arch Bungle | Dec 26 2022 13:07 utc | 232
Yes, CAR & RoC & DR Congo along with the coup & execution of Patrice Lumumba & the assassination of Dag Hammarskjöld (Sec-Gen of the UN).
Cannot let all that immense wealth above & below the ground, be denied the walled ‘Garden’, by inconveniently resident ‘Barbarians’. 🙁
@ JohninMK | Dec 26 2022 17:00 utc | 243
Indeed.
RF must keep its full capabilities, its ‘powder dry’, in reserve, re possibility of US/NATO becoming or being declared open belligerents to the conventional conflict. The Ukie Theater & RF/Belarus is an enormous 24/7 ISR fishbowl since Feb2422. Beyond time for RF to start ‘dropping’ encroaching unmanned surveillance drones ?
The constant destruction of the AFUs US supplied AN/TPQ-37 counter-battery radars progressively, week-in-week out, further diminishes AFU offensive & defensive counter-arty fires. Yet another US war stock materiel one doubts is in serial production re replacements nor mass quantities in arsenal holdings.

Posted by: Outraged | Dec 26 2022 17:49 utc | 247

I see no reason why these birds are allowed to fly over the Black Sea while spying for the enemy.
Posted by: CarlD | Dec 26 2022 17:34 utc | 247
Beyond time for RF to start ‘dropping’ encroaching unmanned surveillance drones ?
Posted by: Outraged | Dec 26 2022 17:49 utc | 248
I agree with you both but Putin is clearly a stickler for the law and they very carefully fly well within international airspace. Dropping a Global Hawk would be viewed by the US as an attack on them and an excuse for God knows what.
The Iranian dropping one was not comparable as their Global Hawk was in their airspace, as was the ISR aircraft near it, which was very sensibly ignored, there being a huge difference between a drone and a maned aircraft. Hence no US reaction.

Posted by: JohninMK | Dec 26 2022 20:44 utc | 248

@ JohninMK | Dec 26 2022 20:44 utc | 249
In airspace violation or not, over 10 months of ‘plausibly-deniable'(not) Ops(US/UK) resulting in loss of numerous Russian lives, damaged Black Sea Fleet vessels, damaged Strategic Nuclear Bombers, Nordstream pipelines, Kerch bridge, assassinations, terrorist & sabotage attacks inside RF proper ?
Dropping ‘unmanned‘ ISR drones(all ?) as an explicit ‘warning’, simply does not compare, & is likely an inevitable event. The warnings have been numerous.
What can US/NATO do that they have not already been doing covert op wise ?
US/NATO is in no state nor prepared(logistics) for entry as belligerants. All academic in any case. RF has shown truly remarkable restraint re continual deliberate provocations, IMO. Foolhardy & inadvisable to continue poking the bear …

Posted by: Outraged | Dec 27 2022 12:51 utc | 249

@ JohninMK | Dec 26 2022 20:44 utc | 249
Dropping a Global Hawk would be viewed by the US as an attack on them and an excuse for God knows what.
I think until this happens and RF applies serious blinding EW on those assets, including those over the Black Sea, Baltic, along the Western Ukrainian and Belarus borders, RF military will always have to improvise and play hide and seek.
Being tapped in and listened on RF is never going to achieve a surprise momentum and the upper hand over the whole theatre.
3-4 AWACS transmit the 24/7 real-time data to Ukrainian Army, while running the drone ops from afar and in a safety of a given airspace should simply not be taking the place.
That also concerns satellite sensing, data downlinks etc.
I understand that it is not so easy, but it is doable and very necessary.
Cynicism of US and NATO of repeating the mantra that they are ‘not involved and will seek not to get involved’ is appalling.
So it just might be that neutering those assets would be the right answer and a precise warning for crossing all the possible red lines that US and NATO trampled over ever since.
And NATO/US will do nothing, because RF can up the ante very quickly, by targeting spread and a lot better definition of ‘the decision centres’ if that is not clearly understood by NATO/US.
I do not think that NATO/US can up the ante militarily, except doubling down on provoking, poking and being derogative even more towards RF in their media.
When GH (Forte6-10) and AWACS start ‘falling off the sky’ we will know that war really started at its earnest.

Posted by: whirlX | Dec 27 2022 13:44 utc | 250

It is a physical impossibility for Ukraine to defeat Russia, short of the West deploying nuclear weapons. Always was, always will be. Anyone who thinks otherwise is delusional.
Some of the deluded are making a lot of money. Overtime for American defense workers. Defense lobbyists are not getting days off. People making the money don’t care that people on the other side of the planet die.

Posted by: K-Dog | Dec 27 2022 21:39 utc | 251