Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
October 24, 2022
Ukraine Open Thread 2022-182

Only for news & views directly related to the Ukraine conflict.

Please stick to the topic.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Comments

AZ 🛰🌏🌍🌎
@AZgeopolitics
🇷🇺🇮🇷💥🇺🇦Newly appeared video of “Geran-2” swarm UAV’s being used days ago…

https://twitter.com/AZgeopolitics/status/1584574729129955328
Interesting to see how they use drone swarms to overwhelm AA.

Posted by: Down South | Oct 24 2022 16:11 utc | 101

AZ 🛰🌏🌍🌎
@AZgeopolitics
🇷🇺🇮🇷💥🇺🇦Newly appeared video of “Geran-2” swarm UAV’s being used days ago…

https://twitter.com/AZgeopolitics/status/1584574729129955328
Interesting to see how they use drone swarms to overwhelm AA.

Posted by: Down South | Oct 24 2022 16:11 utc | 102

Why is a sizable contingent of the 101st Airborne deployed to Romania. I can’t see any actual reason for it. Maybe its just another silly “training” exercise designed to keep the US public “nervous” before the mid-terms. (Those 28 who actually even know about it). What’s the game?

Posted by: HOGGY | Oct 24 2022 16:14 utc | 103

Down South | Oct 24 2022 16:11 utc | 101
Down South | Oct 24 2022 16:11 utc | 102
Are you using a Mac? I’ve noticed you double-post fairly often and I’ve heard macOS has a loose clipboard.

Posted by: sippy the shot glass | Oct 24 2022 16:16 utc | 104

There is the pesky theory that the 1945 bombs dropped on Japan were also dirty bombs.
Supposedly, a uranium based atomic bomb would leave the target area uninhabitable for centuries, yet those cities were rebuilt in 4 years.

Posted by: Opport Knocks | Oct 24 2022 16:18 utc | 105

Maybe RF intel picked up on something and wanted to head it off at the pass so to speak. Either way something big is coming up. Another thing that occurred to me is that thousands of Ukrainian soldier are getting trained out of country not because it’s so much better in say England or Poland, but because it has become hazardous to mass troops anywhere in Ukraine!
One has to wonder at the posturing in the form of deploying the 101st airborne to Romania…..

Posted by: Chevrus | Oct 24 2022 16:18 utc | 106

Have people seen Maria Butina’s OP-ED in RT?
She mentions “Three hots and a cot” like it’s a shibboleth for networking with American black culture. Reaching out to Angela Davis to build Russian/Black solidarity during a world war? Cringe.

Posted by: GoFast | Oct 24 2022 16:20 utc | 107

Posted by: sippy the shot glass | Oct 24 2022 16:16 utc |
Yes, I am using a Mac.
It annoys me immensely when it happens as I always refresh several times if I post and it doesn’t appear so that I don’t duplicate.
At least now I know why it’s doing it even though I can’t do anything about it.

Posted by: Down South | Oct 24 2022 16:21 utc | 108

@Opport-105: There is also a pesky theory that DU munitions that got pulverized in places like Fallujah are responsible for cancer and birth defects…..

Posted by: Chevrus | Oct 24 2022 16:22 utc | 109

Assuming a dirty bomb would still need facilities and an industrial electricity supply to manufacture:
Perhaps this would justify permanently shutting down the electrical supply to almost all of Ukraine?
By escalating the possibility of a nuclear bomb manufactured on Ukrainian territory the argument for complete termination of all energy supplies to industrial areas for nuclear processing becomes justifiable.
Perhaps that’s the real plan here …

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Oct 24 2022 16:24 utc | 110

I have to remind you that the airborne trannies were announced for Romania and other East European countries many months ago. A bit later, but still months ago, Macaron announced that some of his troops will go to Romania and other countries in the area. And they did go but wasn’t interesting for youtubers. Go search old news if you don’t believe me.

Posted by: rk | Oct 24 2022 16:30 utc | 111

Muthaucker
My wife is dying of hyperparathyroidism. It was caused by medical radiation. You really are one dumb motherfucker.

Posted by: oldhippie | Oct 24 2022 16:39 utc | 112

Have look at where the RF forces are between Nikolaev and Kherson today. https://ibb.co/Zgp43wB You’d notice that the RF forces are actually not that far from Nikolaev, ~25-30 from it. You can also notice that the city of Kherson is far away inside the Russian lines. There’s quite chance that RF forces might attack Nikolaev, rather than Ukr army advancing on Kherson.
Most probably, Zelly is trying his soldiers’ luck attacking Zaporozhe, that at least is across the river. Only, the RF aviation and artillery can mortally strike the attacking force quite far away. Zelly is doing all this to get Biden the midterm victory.

Posted by: Paulg | Oct 24 2022 16:41 utc | 113

Here’s a Tass article from a Russian Defense Ministry spokesman concerning the status of the SMO. It might well overlap with material posted on this thread by Down South, being that it would have taken too long for me to thoroughly compare the two sources.

Posted by: David Levin | Oct 24 2022 16:42 utc | 114

UK’s prime minister is an Indian. London mayor is a Pakistani. Both were born in the UK, while their parents were born in the former British colony, undivided at that time, as India and Pakistan. Times are changing for former colonial looters.
Yes. The country will more and more resemble the countries Sunak and Sadiq Khan sure as heck don’t want to live in.

Posted by: JackG | Oct 24 2022 16:52 utc | 115

marcjf #99
“Nothing seems to make sense to me. The lunatics appear to be running the assylum.”
I can only see nuclear escalation being an option if one adversary is sensed as being reluctant to enact the unthinkable. Mutually assured destruction (MAD) does require a fundamentally psychotic mindset. Yet MAD is the stable state of this stand off.
It just takes one adversary to suspect that the other is exhibiting signs of rationality for a perceived advantage to emerge.
I’m not sure how stable this situation can be in the medium term. If you’re psychotic you might envisage this as a normal state of affairs for your adversary over the medium term. If you’re not psychotic you might get a bit edgy after a while.
Its all so unstable that it might just be too difficult to game.

Posted by: Cyclops | Oct 24 2022 16:54 utc | 116

Yes. The country will more and more resemble the countries Sunak and Sadiq Khan sure as heck don’t want to live in.
JackG @ 115
How nice!
Glad to watch that happen to the colonial pirate/looter/bandit!

Posted by: Paulg | Oct 24 2022 16:55 utc | 117

@ HOGGY | Oct 24 2022 16:14 utc | 103
perhaps the 101 in romania sheds more light on the romanian defence ministers comments and resignation..

Posted by: james | Oct 24 2022 16:55 utc | 118

Living as I do in the USA,the lack of Neo-Nazi ceremonies and festivities here is troubling. Support the troops used to be a patriotic thing her. If you can’t show support for Zelenski and his stalwart butchers and, really, the whole administrative staff, what can I say?

Posted by: Elmagnostic | Oct 24 2022 17:00 utc | 119

My wife is dying of hyperparathyroidism. It was caused by medical radiation. You really are one dumb motherfucker.
Posted by: oldhippie | Oct 24 2022 16:39 utc | 112
Sorry to hear about your wife. Medical radiation and a radiological dispersal device (dirty bomb) are two different things. BTW only someone who can’t argue his point resorts to ad hominem attacks.

Posted by: Muthaucker | Oct 24 2022 17:01 utc | 120

All of this loose talk about a “dirty bomb” attack ignores the physics of nuclear fission and radioactive decay. Soon after detonation, the radioactivity of the fission products from even a moderate yield nuclear bomb is thousands if not millions of times greater than the radioactivity of any reasonable quantity of radioactive material that some imbecile might disperse with chemical explosives. Even so, the mass of shielding required to enable transportation and handling will result in a “bomb” about the size and weight of a main battle tank. The prolonged decay curve of a “dirty” bomb will be extremely easy to distinguish from the very rapid decay curve of fallout from a nuclear weapon. More importantly, measuring the decay curve in conjunction with analyzing the isotope ratios if individual elements will enable determination of how recently the fission or neutron capture events that creates the radioactive material occurred.
The bottom line is that unless the authorities are ignorant imbeciles, it is not possible to mistake the release from a “dirty bomb” for fallout from a nuclear explosion or even a nuclear fizzle. Unfortunately; the current handlers of America’s Senile Sock Puppet Biden are ignorant imbeciles as well as gratuitously dishonest.

Posted by: Elmer Fudd | Oct 24 2022 17:04 utc | 121

A dirty bomb could be anything, depending on the isotopes and quantities disbursed. I don’t remember many people dying from Fukashima pollution, although in a nuclear plant emergency, workers at the site are exposed to large doses of radiation.
More disturbing would be a dirty bomb filled intentionally loaded dangerous isotopes that are absorbed by the body like strontium or iodine and cause cancer later.
The worst case of widespread damage to human health I have read about is Fallujah. You can use scholar.google.com to look for papers (many are free access). There was a massive increase in infant mortality due to genetic mutations and cancers, most likely, due to the use of depleted uranium projectiles. These metals are left wherever they blew up and children encounter them, and it is possible that NATO and the USA will supply them.
The biggest risk of a “dirty bomb” is the triggering of world war. The biggest risk to human health is likely the US funded biolabs and the use of depleted uranium munitions.

Posted by: PP | Oct 24 2022 17:04 utc | 122

Re: PP (POST #122)
The hysteria over depleted Uranium used at Fallujah or anywhere else is drivel. The radioactively of any isotope is inversely proportional to its half-life. The longer the half-life, the less radioactive it is. With a half-life of over 4 BILLION years, the radioactivity of depleted Uranium is trivial. There are legitimate issues with chemical toxicity similar to that of Lead or Mercury, but it is nothing to shit your panties about.

Posted by: Elmer Fudd | Oct 24 2022 17:11 utc | 123

@rk
1
Quote “Russian Defense Ministry said they have information about the contacts of Zelensky’s office with representatives of Britain on the issue of obtaining technology to create nuclear weapons.”
I have been war ING Russia since 2007 about urgent need to kill England for its nefarious ability to destroy non Anglo World.
4th June, 2007.

President Putin is wrong when he says ( in Munich security conference 2007) that Russia should or will target the missile on Europe if america goes with anti missile defence plan in Poland in Europe.
]In fact it was not America but england which asked for ABM againstt Russia. BBC spy journalists were harassing presidential candidate Gore not to go ahead with Florida recount on ground” ally like britian want to conclude AMB deployment in Yorkshire as soon as possible so there should be no delay in govt. formation.” In other word accept fraudulent win of bush for sake of england !
Russia must target (rather than should) the nuclear missiles with multiple war heads against all ( including military instalations) of england because this cold war -like the one before- is being started by england for the benefit of english race only-.it is race war between the english parasite english parasite race versus the rest of the world-the sooner the rest of the world realizes that better it is for the world.
look how germany wes villified soon after fall of soviet union-look how russia is being vilified immediately after Putin made russia strong.
Russia’s “partners” understand only two things: the big wallet and the big gun, as satan understands only Saint George’s spear. Time is near.
-such is the evil propaganda of british spies inside america. .
Poland is nothing but a proxy for the british bastards.
It is no use targeting Poland -target the main villain which is england and the english nation which must be sorted out from the face of the world.
http://www.globalresearch.ca/new-world-order-the-founding-fathers/5445255
face 0f the evil.

Posted by: Sam | Oct 24 2022 17:11 utc | 124

“Only the defeated commit [war] crimes”, the British novelist John Mortimer wrote not long ago.
see helmers latest for more..

Posted by: james | Oct 24 2022 17:13 utc | 125

Posted by: PP | Oct 24 2022 17:04 utc | 122
Yes. Your last point is quite well taken.
The “dirty bomb” per se is going to be more or less dangerous depending upon how many tons of explosives it involves and how much and what kind of radioactive material is used.
But note that by the end of the Syrian operation the US was able to launch missile strikes to the resounding approval of most of the US populace and the entirety of the media class on the basis of the empty claim that Assad has used CHLORINE! I mean, if this much hysteria was able to be manufactured by the use of, gasp, CHLORINE, how much more do you think will be mustered by the claim that Russia has detonated a “radioactive bomb”?
I do not believe the aim here is to justify US military intervention. It is again to push further the isolation of Russia and to thereby achieve the economic destruction of the country. The danger is that Russia responds directly against US-UK decision-making centers. The US is betting that if Russia DOES respond it will respond against Kiev. This would actually benefit US interests as it would FURTHER isolate Russia and confirm all the intelligence reports dating back a few months that Russia was going to use a nuclear bomb. The US is betting that Moscow doesn’t have the balls to respond directly against UK-US targets. It’s a very risky bet.

Posted by: WJ | Oct 24 2022 17:13 utc | 126

Chevrus | Oct 24 2022 16:22 utc | 109

There is also a pesky theory that DU munitions that got pulverized in places like Fallujah are responsible for cancer and birth defects…..

It is not a theory. Hundreds of Italian NATO peacekeepers and Serbs have died/are dying from cancers caused by the radioactive dust which now poisons the ground and the water in areas of Serbia. Here is an extract of the press conference held by Zhao Lijian, the foreign Ministry spokesperson, on 10 June 2022

People’s Daily: Today marks the 23rd anniversary of the end of NATO’s bombing of the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia. After an international legal team filed lawsuits against NATO on behalf of 3,000 victims over the horrific consequences of up to 15 tons of depleted uranium bombs NATO dropped in 1999, NATO responded by saying it has immunity from prosecution. Do you have any comment?
Zhao Lijian: Twenty-three years ago, US-led NATO blatantly bombarded the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia for 78 days without the approval of the UN Security Council. In total, NATO dropped nearly 420,000 bombs weighing 22,000 tons, including 15 tons of depleted uranium bombs. Over 2,500 people including 79 children were killed and more than one million people became refugees as a direct result of the bombings. 
What is more heart-wrenching is that death and agony brought by the war lingered for generations till this day. As noted by experts, exposure to radiation emitted by depleted uranium bombs can show no symptom for years and depleted uranium bombs have long-term impact on the environment and human food-chain. In the 10 years after the bombing, about 30,000 people in Serbia developed cancer, among whom 10,000 died. According to the Institute of Public Health of Belgrade, by the end of 2019, the number of registered cancer patients in Serbia was as high as 97,000. A study of the Serbian emergency center shows that among children born in Serbia after 1999, many aged between one and five suffered from ectodermal tumors, many aged between five and nine contracted hematological malignancies, and there is a clear uptick in the morbidity rate of brain cancer among those aged between nine and 18. Besides, by May 2019, 366 Italian military personnel who participated in the NATO military operations have died of cancer, and 7,500 have fallen sick. 
However, till this day, the US — the country that sent military aircraft to drop depleted uranium bombs over Serbia and the inventor of this type of bombs as well as the only country that has ever used them — continues to deny that depleted uranium bombs can directly cause Gulf War syndrome and Kosovo syndrome. During the Gulf War, the US dropped far more depleted uranium bombs over Iraq. NATO is also trying to get away with it by claiming immunity from prosecution. Such moves by the US-led NATO are shocking. Neither the Serbian people, nor people elsewhere in the world seeking justice, will ever agree to this. The US-led NATO should earnestly reflect on its war crimes, and provide a reasonable explanation and compensations to the victims of depleted uranium bombs as soon as possible. NATO must also seriously learn the lesson and stop creating new turmoil and division across the world. 

Posted by: cirsium | Oct 24 2022 17:14 utc | 127

Not sure the neo-Nazis in Kiev will appreciate a brown leader of the UK government popping over for a visit a la Boris.

Posted by: Night Tripper | Oct 24 2022 17:16 utc | 128

Re: Opport Knocks | Oct 24 2022 16:18 utc | 105
you wrote “There is the pesky theory that the 1945 bombs dropped on Japan were also dirty bombs.
Whoever came up with such a “pesky theory” should take a look at the photo of the mushroom clouds over Hiroshima and Nagasaki, as well as the photos of those cities before and after being hit by US atomic/nuclear bombs. Do you really think a ‘dirty bomb’ could create such explosions and damage? And no, these cities were not subject to US firebombing raids, rather they were spared from such raids because they were being ‘saved’ for the atomic bombs, because the US wanted to see the effects on undamaged cities.

you also wrote “Supposedly, a uranium based atomic bomb would leave the target area uninhabitable for centuries, yet those cities were rebuilt in 4 years.
The atomic bombs that destroyed Hiroshima and Nagasaki were airbursts (this was done to maximize thermal and blast effects); their fireballs did not come into contact with the surface of the earth. Had they been ground bursts, their fireballs would have vaporized anything they came in contact with; immense amounts of soil and surface materials would have then been made highly radioactive, and produced huge amounts of fallout. The resulting high levels of radioactivity would have made the cities uninhabitable for a very long time.
As it was, many tens of thousands of Japanese died from radiation exposure to the fallout that came down as black rain following the detonation and subsequent firestorm that burned out the heart of the city.

Posted by: Steven Starr | Oct 24 2022 17:18 utc | 129

So much ignorance about toxicity of radioactive materials… looking at you, MFer.
The same radiactive material at the same quantity and same radioactivity can be completely safe and absolutely deadly depending on what form that material is in. This is particularly true about alpha and beta emitters – for example you can safely hold a chunk of metallic Plutonium 239 in your hand, and it feels warm due to radioactive decay. The alpha particles (He4 nuclei) it emits are stopped effectively by the outer layer of skin (dead cells). A few mg of Pu239 in the room as a fine powder, and you are dead from cancer because if you inhale a single dust particle, it will keep causing mutations in unprotected cells. Or take Cesium 137 – it’s dangerous mostly when ingested as it displaces calcium in bones and stays emitting radiation for years inside.
The dirty bomb pulverises and disperses radioactive materials, so they stay in the area in the form which is easily ingested or aspirated, and anyone not wearing proper rad suit and respirator (and following proper decontamination protocols when taking these off) runs a high risk of dying from cancer. The normal civilian life is impossible in the area for years or decades, depending on the level of contamination. There in nothing “psychological” about this danger.

Posted by: averros | Oct 24 2022 17:24 utc | 130

oldhippie | Oct 24 2022 15:07 utc | 76
precisely.
set it off near an orphanage for war vet kids and see how much size matters. hell, make a big bang with a conventional kitchen microwave and tell Amurkins Putin is poisoning the children (b/c we care so much about children), show some babies in incubators, orphan war babies struggling to breath and…
wait. memories…in the corners of my mind…will Hill and Knowlton still manage to fanagle a hefty “consulting fee” from USG for reworking the same script?
there’s also the issue of setting a precedent. since people don’t really know about DU, they’ll be shocked shocked SHOCKED to hear that there is radiological warfare going on already in this fine military establishment.
————–
Down South | Oct 24 2022 15:32 utc | 81
this kind of stuff works partly because people know zero history, even of things in their own recent lifetimes (e.g., Iraq).
and because people are conditioned not to trust their own senses. they can’t even correlate obesity to anything else about how they live, without “experts” running interference for industry and deluding people about how their knees got so gigantic. they can’t correlate the police state they live in w/foreign policy.
people gettin all apocalyptic and biblical these days…Ezekiel’s “valley of dry bones”? is that a useful image for the US? we are not quite there yet, since the rot is very contagious and the zombies are still moving and clawing and clutching and gnawing and gnashing. and have devoured all the brains long ago. somebody kick the dentures out of Biden’s dead mountain mouth already, please.
Petri Krohn | Oct 24 2022 16:06 utc | 100
thanks. analysis??? Americans will do some ANALYSIS before responding? hmmm…yeah…the point of all this dirty bomb talk is to create a situation in which no analysis will be possible that might induce a change of course, because of hysterical reaction. only one word will be allowed, and just long enough to start pressing some serious war buttons: REVENGE.
Elmer Fudd | Oct 24 2022 17:11 utc | 123
are you a cytopathologist working at the VA? cuz they don’t ever find DU to be a problem, either. funny, ain’t it?
burn pits are just piles of lead & mercury and such, right? no biggie. it was Saddam that caused your diabetes and malignant tumors, not that burn pit in the middle of your base.
funny how peoples’ cancers routinely get diagnosed w/o doctors having a clue or care what their patients are being exposed to. the patient is some cells in a dish, in fact.
and yes, I am referring specifically to America’s Heros, combat vets and their “care providers”.
but thanks for your input. remember to aim away from your own face, Elmer.

Posted by: rjb1.5 | Oct 24 2022 17:24 utc | 131

The US military arrived in Haiti to suppress anti-government riots on the island.
Naturally, everything goes without any “UN consents” and “international law”, it’s just that the United States wants to keep its man as president of Haiti, for this they will kill all political opponents of the country’s leadership and all leaders of the protesters in the coming days.
How brave is the US army!

Posted by: Paulg | Oct 24 2022 17:29 utc | 132

Evidently only billionaires and bankers are worthy to save humanity from billionaires and bankers. Good times!
Posted by: gottlieb | Oct 24 2022 14:32 utc | 61

To remove mice from a barn, one uses a cat, not other mice.

Posted by: anon2020 | Oct 24 2022 17:30 utc | 133

Night Tripper @ 128
The brown leader of the UK government won’t pop in the Ukraine anywhere near Zelly. He is brainier than Boris the clown and Truss the dumb, He won’t try to get the Zelly curse!

Posted by: Paulg | Oct 24 2022 17:32 utc | 134

“If the Europeans stop allocating money to Kyiv, then Ukraine will be left without salaries and pensions.” – Prime Minister of Ukraine Denys Shmygal.
This is always the case in the colonies, there is nothing to be surprised at, the metropolis always keeps its vassals firmly on a “leash”.

Posted by: Paulg | Oct 24 2022 17:36 utc | 135

Posted by: anon2020 | Oct 24 2022 17:30 utc | 133
“one uses a cat, not other mice.”
A cat like Stalin, Mao or Castro ..

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Oct 24 2022 17:37 utc | 136

The transcript of Lavrov’s presser after his Valdai Club appearance is now available. In it he’s asked about the dirty bomb issue and had this to say:

Question: Has the topic of Ukraine’s use of the “dirty bomb” been raised? In recent days, the Minister of Defense and the Head of the General Staff have been holding telephone conversations on this topic. Do you have any contacts planned on this issue?
Sergey Lavrov: Our information that provocations using a nuclear bomb may be planned in Ukraine is quite reliable. Detailed information indicating the institutions that may be involved in this was provided by Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu in his conversations with colleagues from the United States, France, Great Britain and Turkey. Our military departments have outlined other contacts. This issue will also be discussed in the UN Security Council today or tomorrow.
Unfounded refutations by Western colleagues that all this is fiction. They say that Russia itself plans to do something similar in order to later blame the Regime of Vladimir Zelensky – this is not a serious conversation. Some of the interlocutors offered to discuss the information we have at the professional military level. We supported this approach.

The Nazi pukes likely have control over this action, not Zelensky, which IMO means it’s more likely to happen. Which Western government is most likely in cahoots? My money’s on the UK.

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 17:39 utc | 137

Reuters – Russia could plan ‘dirty bomb’ pretext, Western countries say

Posted by: rk | Oct 24 2022 17:43 utc | 138

@ karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 17:39 utc | 137 with the Lavrov quotes about dirty bomb
It is interesting to see the UK showing its “residual” empire leanings. Is direction coming from King Chuck or the City of London Corp?

Posted by: psychohistorian | Oct 24 2022 17:46 utc | 139

On the deployment of parts of the 101st Airborne to Romanis, they are replacing their counterparts in the 82nd Airborne who were previously stationed there. They are there as an “ornament”.

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 17:46 utc | 140

@127: I used the word ‘theory’ in a somewhat sarcastic manner. I am well aware that women in Fallujah have been told to simply not bother to try to have a child due to so many horrible deformities

Posted by: Chevrus | Oct 24 2022 17:47 utc | 141

UK can’t pollute fertile land in Eurasia with impunity. If they pollute 4000km^2 in Nikolaev, then it would be fair to pollute 4000km^2 somewhere in the UK.
Posted by: unimperator | Oct 24 2022 13:36 utc | 32
It behooves one to identify and prosecute the responsible entities. Poisoning random locations and people is not Justice. As it is not justice to destroy a nation of people, families, that are in thrall to the governing elite.
We have come to learn, as per the Princeton study as one example, that the common rabble (myself included) have nearly no input as to government policy (in the US). This conclusion may, in some cases, be extended to other countries.
If you indeed do espouse one of the cardinal virtues- justice- then we must be clear which entities merit her attention.

Posted by: AParadiseLost | Oct 24 2022 17:49 utc | 142

I forgot who, but someone from high up in the Russian Federation made an excellent remark today:
‘Do not measure the width of our red lines.’
If that doesn’t sound as a dire warning, then I do not know what it is.

Posted by: whirlX | Oct 24 2022 17:53 utc | 143

Most of the problems of the modern world would have been avoided if Woodrow Wilson agreed to the Brest Litovsk treaty to recognize the territories Germany had won in 1917.
Donbass becomes part of the Duchy of Ukraine. End of story.
Woodrow Wilson bartered the future of humanity so the Poles and the Czechs (slovaks were mostly irrelevant back then) could have their own country, which turned into failed states almost immediately.
It is time to apologize for Wilson’s foulup, and re-ratify the Brest-Litovsk treaty again. How the Germans will treat the Poles and Czechs occupying German territories should not be USA’s concern.

Posted by: kulmthestatusquo | Oct 24 2022 17:58 utc | 144

karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 17:39 utc | 137

https://t.me/rezident_ua/14251
Resident
⚡️⚡️⚡️#
Our source in the OP said that the President’s Office is ready to create a dirty nuclear bomb to deter Russia. A headquarters has already been set up on Bankovaya Street with nuclear scientists and military personnel who are urgently preparing a group to develop nuclear weapons.
t.me/rezident_ua
/14251
846.1Kviews
Sep 28 at 00:21
https://t.me/rezident_ua/14355
Our source in the OP said that the President’s Office held a meeting with nuclear scientists and environmentalists on the nuclear threat track. Bankova is trying to find triggers that will force the West to seriously influence Russia, and not impose empty sanctions as was the case with the annexation of 4 regions.
392.7Kviewsedited
Oct 2 at 21:49

I have been reading this and the legitimate telegram channel for some time now and they have proved reasonably accurate. They would have to have the OK from MI6 for this bomb and I think is what was behind Ben Wallace’s sudden unscheduled trip to Washington a few days back.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 24 2022 17:58 utc | 145

karlof1 @ 140
Correct. I was in the 101 and deployed several times long ago. It signifies little more than a token training exercise.

Posted by: circumspect | Oct 24 2022 18:02 utc | 146

‘UK’s prime minister is an Indian’. NO. He is British but of East African Asian heritage. Mrs Sunak is Indian. Both have a joint fortune of £730m. Her father is worth £3.9. (net)

Posted by: Geraint ap Iorwerth | Oct 24 2022 18:02 utc | 147

In response to Paulg @ 56
Who cares if you wish the possible UK PM well? This is a Ukraine thread.
Posted by: Don Bacon | Oct 24 2022 14:43 utc | 65
Who cares what you think of the post you replied to incompetently (the wish was not Paul’s)? This is a Ukraine thread.

Posted by: StirThePot | Oct 24 2022 18:03 utc | 148

Obviously, Russia cannot expect Ukraine, Europe or US to deal rationally wish prospect of dirty bomb – they are busilly looking other way.
Is for Russia to make plans to ensure it would not provide a desired result.

Posted by: jared | Oct 24 2022 18:05 utc | 149

I think it’s most likely a matter of communication intercepts. Could be a prank, which is conceivable when you know someone is listening in on your communications, or it could be serious. Not something that needs to be taken into consideration in formulating an appropriate response. Western leaders have been informed of what that response is going to be and have characterized it as an escalation of the conflict in their collective statement.
The Ukrainians certainly have all the resources they need to make a dirty bomb with the potential of contaminating territory even outside their formal borders, but they don’t have launch-vehicles capable of delivering payloads with that sort of potential. Even with a suicide truck like on the Kerch bridge, I think it’s debatable on whether any long-term or large-scale contamination is achievable with conventional explosives. A cargo ship might do it, but the end results would be very difficult to predict. Maybe you’d get a radioactive cloud over Turkey, or a radioactive current sweeping past the Med, or the whole thing gets diluted out without raising any eyebrows.
Ultimately, I don’t understand what the objective would be. Obviously, even a dirty bomb detonated in the Kremlin, in Putin’s underpants, would be blamed on Putin and Russia and be described as an egregious escalation against Ukraine. But, couldn’t they do that with any actual Russian strike — just measure the radiation with a Democratic(tm) geiger-counter and call it a Russian dirty bomb and let their media circus do the rest? If the main goal is to use a manufactured incident to do some grand-standing while tugging on their vassals leashes, then there’s little reason to actually risk making Ukraine and neighboring territories uninhabitable. In fact, I think a real nuclear incident could be a step too far for leaders otherwise willing to pay lip-service to Western false narratives in a risk-free environment.
More likely, it’s an attempt at creating a credible deterrent — a self-destruct button to make Russia think twice about its objectives in Ukraine. The logic here isn’t half-bad, even if deeply cynical. If a Ukrainian defeat intrinsically means the detonation of a dirty bomb in Ukraine that contaminates most of its territories and kills its remaining civilian population, then Russian interest in a Ukrainian defeat becomes an unpalatable alternative. It would certainly fit the established trend of Ukraine using its own civilians as hostages to give itself an edge on the field of battle.

Posted by: Skiffer | Oct 24 2022 18:07 utc | 150

4 seismic events of unknown origin were recorded on October 20 and 21 near the Russian Primorsk and Vyborg, approximately in the area where the Nord Stream passes, reports the Finnish Seismological Institute.

Posted by: rk | Oct 24 2022 18:09 utc | 151

psychohistorian @139–
I’m being influenced by Larry Johnson on this issue. Maria Zakharova provides lots of info:

Of the most serious concern is the alarming information coming from reliable sources that the Kiev regime is preparing a provocation using an explosive device filled with radioactive substances, the so-called “dirty bomb”.
The purpose of such a monstrous provocation is obvious – to accuse Russia of using weapons of mass destruction. The Ukrainian authorities and their curators in the West expect that this will result in a powerful anti-Russian campaign, undermine the credibility of its partners in Moscow, and lead to the isolation of our country in the international arena.
According to our information, the Ukrainian side has already begun to implement the plan. In particular, the Eastern Mining and Processing Plant in Zhovti Vody and the Institute for Nuclear Research in Kiev are tasked with manufacturing such a bomb. We do not rule out the provision of assistance in solving this problem by some Western countries, which, according to reports, are negotiating with Ukraine on the supply of components for the “dirty bomb”. According to information available to Russia, the Kiev regime plans to detonate such a munition, disguising it as an abnormal operation of a Russian low-yield nuclear weapon, in which highly enriched uranium is used as a charge.
In this context, we would like to recall Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s irresponsible statements at the Munich Security Conference in February this year about Kiev’s claims to possess nuclear weapons, which would create real risks for Russia and international security. In general, it was about the possibility of revising the nuclear-free status of Ukraine, which would mean an attempt to acquire nuclear weapons to the detriment of the NPT regime. Given Kiev’s recent statements about the need for “preventive nuclear strikes” by NATO countries against Russia, this is categorically unacceptable and completely unacceptable. Moreover, earlier in the Ukrainian segment of the Internet there were already repeated calls to detonate a “dirty bomb” in Moscow. They even showed instructions for its assembly.
By all indications, the Ukrainian side is trying to play out a scenario similar to the provocation in Bucha, when they tried to baselessly accuse us of civilian casualties. Despite our repeated appeals, including to the UN Secretary-General, with a request to provide data on the victims and information about the circumstances of their deaths, we have not yet received any response.
We demand that the Kiev authorities and the Western sponsors who control them stop taking actions that lead the world to a nuclear catastrophe and threaten the lives of innocent civilians. It is foolhardy to ignore Russian warnings in this regard. It is dangerous to escalate things. The West should not measure the width of the “red line”. [My Emphasis]

As you read, Russia will have grounds to retaliate against any NATO nation it suspects of helping with such a provocation. That most recent provocations in Ukraine and Syria were backed by UK assets is why I primarily suspect MI6 but cannot rule out CIA as Larry suggests. As I wrote elsewhere on this topic, I agree with Maria that this provocation is designed as a message to RoW to persuade it to abandon Russia which until now its been very reluctant to do. The external help is needed to ensure the “disguise” of the bomb functions–that it has the fingerprint of Russian atomics, not one from another nation. It’s been suggested that the Outlaw US Empire possesses nukes recovered from a sunken Soviet sub and would employ material from them to provide such a signature. However, Russia will know what sort of signature those lost nukes had and if the signature is from them, then Russia will know who provided the aide and from where the material came from and that would likely prompt a hypersonic response.
So, as Larry suggests, the Military needs to make sure the spooks don’t get them killed.

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 18:10 utc | 152

They could launch dirty bomb into old Russia or into new Russia or set several off in area of Odessa during attack, for example.
The best response might vary.
I imagine a pre-emptive active would be off the table.
I think it is axiomatic that the US would preemptively strike civilian centers in same situation.

Posted by: jared | Oct 24 2022 18:11 utc | 153

averros & rjb, 130 & 131
Nice to see there are some who have a clue. Half the nuclear information on this thread is from outright agents, the part that comes from the welll-intentioned and totally misinformed is unfortunately normal. So long as all are in the dark it is far simpler to run these operations.

Posted by: oldhippie | Oct 24 2022 18:11 utc | 154

To understand the Ukraine-Russia war you have to understand the second world war.
To understand the second world war you need to read this article:
pre earth .net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=1175
REMOVE the spaces from the URL
You need to know that Hitler was a double agent.
There is also an informative article on the COVID SCAM on the same page.

Posted by: un censored | Oct 24 2022 18:12 utc | 155

Posted by: averros | Oct 24 2022 17:24 utc | 130
Nice try with the straw man argument. Just more psuedo-intellectualism. Pu239 and Cesium 137 are components of nuclear weapons. Nobody discounts the leathality of Pu239 and Cesium 137.
A dirty bomb is a mix of explosives, such as tnt, with radioactive powder or pellets. When the tnt or other explosives are set off, the blast carries radioactive material into the surrounding area. A dirty bomb works completely differently and cannot create a nuclear yield. Instead, a dirty bomb uses tnt or other explosives to scatter radioactive dust, smoke, or other material in order to cause radioactive contamination.
“The main danger from a dirty bomb is from the explosion, which can cause serious injuries and property damage. The radioactive materials used in a dirty bomb would probably not create enough radiation exposure to cause immediate serious illness, except to those people who are very close to the blast site.”
A dirty bomb is not a “weapon of mass destruction” but a “weapon of mass disruption,” where contamination and anxiety are the major objectives. Immediate health effects from exposure to the low radiation levels expected from a dirty bomb would likely be minimal.

Posted by: Muthaucker | Oct 24 2022 18:13 utc | 156

karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 18:10 utc | 152
the Ukr telegram channels Resident and Legitimate always talk of MI6 in relation to the presidents office, never CIA. Those channels have proved reasonably accurate in the time I have been reading them and they first reported on the making of a dirty bomb on Sep 28

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 24 2022 18:21 utc | 157

With a dirty Cobalt bomb the real fun starts when it gets into the groundwater system …

Posted by: Arch Bungle | Oct 24 2022 18:27 utc | 158

@Orgel 22
Have you ever read anything written by Marx, let alone studied what he said? How was Marx wrong about:
Capitalism’s chaotic nature and the boom bust cycle?
The rise of fictitious instruments?
The ongoing environmental catastrophe?
Mechanization, automation and AI?
Globalization of capitalism and the spread of the bourgeoisie?
Soaring inequality, reduced incomes, and rising debt?
Subservience to inhuman, sophisticated, unnatural and imaginary appetites?
Increasing regulation and the loss of the choice of how your time is spent?
Centralization and the spread of monopsony and monopolies?
The collapse of profits, incomes and employment?
The replacement of current economic systems.
And that is off the top-of-my head?

Posted by: Hermit | Oct 24 2022 18:36 utc | 159

@155 un censored
Investment bankers hate him. Learn how he makes $10,259/week working from home.
In order to understand WW2, you need to know that Stalin was a double-furry. (He dressed up as a leopard but secretly had a puma’s identity)

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Oct 24 2022 18:42 utc | 160

… then we must be clear which entities merit her attention.
Posted by: AParadiseLost | Oct 24 2022 17:49 utc | 142

Indeed. Let only those who approved of the act be dosed with the same contaminants and let it be known that, to this end, no expense will be spared.

Posted by: anon2020 | Oct 24 2022 18:44 utc | 161

@Greg Galloway 7
The denial of evidence, or inability to distinguish between fact (Russia has shared evidence that the Ukraine is conspiring to produce and detonate a radiological weapon with British assistance) and fiction (“I dont believe in that dirty bomb hype”) precisely accords with the definition of a psychosis, “mental disorder characterized by a disconnection from reality”.
Like most things, there are drugs for that.

Posted by: Hermit | Oct 24 2022 18:44 utc | 162

@ gottlieb | Oct 24 2022 14:32 utc | 61
“We must call in bad men to govern bad men.” George III about Henry Fox as his prime minister

Posted by: John Kennard | Oct 24 2022 18:45 utc | 163

Lots of discussion about the dirty bomb issue and righty so.
Here’s are two questions that I don’t see being asked / discussed anywhere:
1. Russian intelligence is obviously aware of the plan, but do they know the location where the bomb is being made?
2. Will Russia take pre-emptive measures to stop this bomb from being deployed? For clarity, I don’t mean phoning foreign defence ministries, complaining to the UN etc, I mean locate and physically destroy/disable the bomb.

Posted by: Jax | Oct 24 2022 18:45 utc | 164

All the talk of a dirty bomb is just more evidence that time is not on Russia’s side.
It’s “Show Me” time for the supposed Russian offensive and the supposed impact of the mobilization of 370k troops.

Posted by: Dan Farrand | Oct 24 2022 19:01 utc | 165

Peter AU1 @157–
Thanks for that info. In appraising this issue, IMO the Big Picture must be consulted. How can the Outlaw US Empire negate the attempt to form a New International Economic Order (NIEO) this time when the Multipolar World has the other three top economies–China, India, Russia–pushing for it along with the largest non-Western economic association–ASEAN? Same with disrupting the emerging Multipolar institutions BRICS, SCO, OPEC+, EAEU, and the many smaller, regional ones. IMO, events have already progressed to a point where undoing what’s been done is impossible (short of total nuclear war), and any further attempts at disruption will only increase the velocity of these two major happenings. Additionally, the West’s escalating weakness must be factored into the equation and the acts done by the Outlaw US Empire to facilitate that process–IMO, what the Empire did to Europe won’t be forgiven or forgotten by most Europeans, which will make a rapprochement with Russia and China inevitable. The Big Question: Do Imperial planners see/understand any of that or are they blinded by their hubris? More importantly given the topic: Do they really think they can gain an advantage or alter any of the above realities through such a provocation?
I must admit I don’t see any party gaining anything from such a provocation, which IMO is Russia’s position in their talks with the likely perpetrators.

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 19:14 utc | 166

@ karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 17:46 utc | 140
As a “red line,” easily run over in course of main-force operation but triggering greater involvement.
I’d expect the RF to run things around and past them, driving everyone crazy.

Posted by: John Kennard | Oct 24 2022 19:15 utc | 167

Perhaps, just perhaps, the dirty bomb Intel was either:
a) a false leak to determine who is sending Intel to the Russians
b) a diversion to distract the Russians
c) a pretext for the Russians to contact other militaries with a different message.
For a or b to be effective, the operation would have to have sufficient hard evidence of it being real.

Posted by: Opport Knocks | Oct 24 2022 19:16 utc | 168

Jax @164–
Try reading my comment @152.

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 19:16 utc | 169

Apparently, Ukrainians and the collective West would rather destroy Ukraine and themselves then be defeated by Russians.
That is also a way to win a war.

Posted by: marko | Oct 24 2022 19:18 utc | 170

Can We Avoid World War 3?
Tulsi Gabbard & Jeffrey Sachs talk about the the life and death situation of a possible World War III.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tjf-0ysmigw

Posted by: Babel-17 | Oct 24 2022 19:19 utc | 171

Liz Truss not handing over to Sunak immediately also makes me suspicious that something is up. They may be plotting to make the dastardly deed a fait accompli before he takes over. The question is will Sunak REALLY be PM or kept out of the loop in defence matters. I am not sure they are happy having him there, especially right now.
You would like to think that someone from Sunaks origins would not be a born psycho but as we have seen with Priti Patel and Suella Braverman sometimes they bend over backwards to prove they are in da club.

Posted by: DaVinci | Oct 24 2022 19:20 utc | 172

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 18:10 utc | 152
Agreed. My take:
1) We’ve been hearing “false flag” since before the war started. So far – zip, nada, zero. Except for things like Bucha and blowing up a few chemical warehouses to no practical effect, Ukraine hasn’t managed to pull off one false flag so far.
2) That said, it’s quite possible that this time the false flag is real, prepared by MI6 and the CIA and Ukraine, possibly by rogue elements of each.
3) If it does occur, I don’t believe Russia will target outside Ukraine because Russia still doesn’t want to start – or be blamed for starting – a war directly with NATO.
4) What Russia will almost certainly do, however, is decapitate the Ukrainian government, especially if any significant number of Russian soldiers are killed as a result of such a bomb.
5) The real question is: what will NATO do as the next step after accusing Russia of being responsible for the bomb, and then the Ukrainian decapitation? If the false flag was not prepared by rogue intelligence assets but with full knowledge by NATO leaders, then we must assume NATO will enter the war directly. They won’t have a choice not to. That alone could lead to a NATO collapse if it is seen by its members to be toothless. So they will enter the war or at least try to.
6) Then the real question becomes: does the Russia-NATO escalate out of control, or does Russian escalation dominance shut it down before it can escalate too far?
Just some things to think about…

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Oct 24 2022 19:24 utc | 173

I am in South Europe, Croatian seacoast.
In 2003, when the US invasion began on Iraq under false pretenses(like always) I was residing in Cairo for many years since. The heavy planes, bombardiers were flying above us, and it is the sound i have never forgot.
Tonight, about an hour ago, more or less, while drinking my tea on my balcony, I have heard this same menacing sound from our skies above, guess they are coming from Aviano or whatsoever and were flying eastwards. This sound I will never forget.
Very bad.

Posted by: ranger | Oct 24 2022 19:24 utc | 174

John Kennard @167–
IMO, Russia doesn’t want to enter any other nations unless it absolutely must. Russia’s capable of KOing the troublesome missile emplacements in Romania and Poland with hypersonics alone, which was mentioned well before Russia’s security proposals of last December. What Russia, China, India, and RoW want is to develop and modernize peacefully without any interference in any form as International Law provides. The Outlaw US Empire’s so-called national security policy doesn’t allow for any of that–Primacy must be kept at ALL COSTS.

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 19:25 utc | 175

Don’t expect much form Russia.
They are even afraid to continue destruction of energy facilities in Ukraine.
And that would be the fastest way to victory.

Posted by: marko | Oct 24 2022 19:26 utc | 176

@160 To really understand WW2 you have to realize that Stalin and Hitler were secretly married. It’s in a deleted passage from Churchill’s book.

Posted by: dh | Oct 24 2022 19:37 utc | 177

RSH @173–
Thanks for your reply. IMO, NATO doesn’t have the military might to do anything against Russia, and it certainly doesn’t have very many assets deployed close enough to Ukraine to provide any real help. As you note, Russia still owns escalation dominance. I stand by my comment to Peter. IMO, we’ll soon see just how good Russian humint or “illegal intelligence” assets are within Ukraine.

Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 19:40 utc | 178

re: Chevrus | Oct 24 2022 16:22 utc | 109 and cirsium | Oct 24 2022 17:14 utc | 127
The book, A Primer in the Art of Deception: The Cult of Nuclearists, Uranium Weapons and Fraudulent Science” is the best source I have found on DU and the “radiation safety standards” created by the nuclear health physicists.
In chapter 8, Are Uranium Weapons Made of Uranium?, the author, Paul Zimmerman, makes the point that “With the possible exception of a small number of workers in limited sectors of the uranium fuel cycle and some who are involved in the fabrication of components for nuclear weapons, no human being on planet earth receives acute internal exposure to concentrated uranium at levels comparable to those who inhale particles of DU. . . Using 360 nanocuries per gram as the specific activity of DU, this translates into 13,320 disintegrations per second per gram. To receive equivalent exposure to this gram of DU, you would need to take into your body 532,800 grams of soil.
In the chapter Scam Number One, Zimmerman analyzes the computational system developed for computing dosages from internal emitters and finds that it hides the high radiation doses delivered to individual cells or tiny clusters of cells by microscopic particles of DU (as well as other radionuclides) by averaging the dose over the entire organ system where the cells reside. While the formulas used to calculate dose employ “quality factors” that multiply the cellular impact of alpha particles by a factor of 20, this increase is negated when large quantities of tissue are used to average the exposure for the particular organ system involved. In other words, it is like multiplying by 20 and then dividing by a million.
Zimmerman has a list of 39 scams used by the nuclear industry to hide the dangers of internally absorbed/ingested/inhaled “low dose” radiation. I copy below his “Exhibit A” taken from this list:
“The entire system that has evolved to safeguard the welfare of humanity is ultimately grounded on
one fundamental idea: The essential feature of the interaction of radiation with biological systems
is the transfer of energy from its source to the medium in which it is absorbed, and the degree of
injury is proportional to the amount of energy transferred. When now queried by current
understanding, biology responds that this central idea is erroneous. The neat concept of energy
transfer is largely irrelevant to the biological response to ionizing radiation.

“The amount of kinetic energy transferred in each collision [between a charged particle and the
molecular components of a cell] plays no role in the production of radiation effects in mammalian
cells”. From Radiation Protection Dosimetry: A Radical Reappraisal (Simmons and Watt).
The biological effects of ionizing radiation cannot be adequately modeled by simply dividing the
quantity of energy by the mass into which it is deposited. That mode of thinking blinds one to the
reality of how biological damage is actually induced by radiation. A living system is made up of
cells. Impact on the functioning of these cells depends on how the energy is distributed in
relationship to critical cellular structures.

Zimmerman continues (in Exhibit D):
“The model used today by international agencies formulating safety for internal contamination by
radionuclides is essentially the same model, with updated modifications, developed during the
Manhattan Project, the Tri-Partite Conferences, and the meetings of the committees on internal
emitters of the NCRP and the ICRP. This model was developed prior to the discovery of DNA!
Since the 1950s, a revolution has taken place in biology. Entire vistas of cellular and molecular
biology, totally unsuspected by World War II physicists, have opened up for scientific exploration.
The rapid advancement in technology has created powerful tools for imaging cellular structures
and probing the mysteries of the molecular chemistry that orchestrates cellular processes.
Advances have been so profound that, today, microbeams can deliver individual alpha particles to
cells in vitro and the altered morphology of cellular structures can be determined by DNA
sequencing and correlated with functional aberrations. Over this amazing new world of
microscopic wonders and the deepening understanding of the cellular and molecular basis of life,
the ICRP, NCRP, NRPB, UNSCEAR, and BEIR, like Fascist dictators, inflexibly demand that their
archaic model of radiation effects be the basis for radiation protection. They tyrannize all
discussions on the biological effects of ionizing radiation, and are rigidly intolerant of allowing other
points of view from gaining a footing. Despite the fact that cellular response to radiation can now
be studied as never before, these “august” bodies of self-declared experts insist that radiation
effects can only be properly modeled as they were modeled in the early 1950s. This state of
affairs is despotic. The ruling paradigm on radiation effects maintains its supremacy by ignoring a
half-century of research in the biological sciences.

So when discussing the effects of a ‘dirty bomb’ or nuclear war, keep in mind that the long-term biological impacts of so-called “low dose” radiation from ingested/absorbed/inhaled particles may be much worse than the current radiation safety standards admit.

Posted by: Steven Starr | Oct 24 2022 19:41 utc | 179

I would draw the attention with this issue of a potential dirty bomb false flag and Nato entrance to the war – is all resulting out of the desperation of keeping the war running. The old Soviet stockpiles of tanks and fighters are nearly used up, and at this point in time it will get really expensive for Nato. There’s really no reason to assume they would perform any better, against Russian long range AD and AWACS and effective antitank weapons like Kornets. UAF also may have up to 400k casualties. Over 100 % of their GDP is funded by the EU and US.
They either have to swallow it and just let the house of card collapse, and accept Russia will just demolish all their equipment with cheap drones pretty much invisible to radars. Or they will go “all in” to avoid the potentially bad effects of admitting defeat. That is why it’s so dangerous.

Posted by: unimperator | Oct 24 2022 19:45 utc | 180

The Big Question: Do Imperial planners see/understand any of that or are they blinded by their hubris?
Posted by: karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 19:14 utc | 166

Always like your input, but youre overthinking this. It’s actually quite simple – so elementary that most either don’t understand or overlook its importance.
All it takes is one shot of that sweet banker money. Of course, bankers are not richer than states, so why would they need to borrow?
What happens of course is that the money is conjured out of thin air in the form of an iou. It has the same purchasing power as real money upon first use.
So why not commit if one can procure weapons & armies in which to possibly gain territories, resources and enough wealth to pay off the loan?
The problem of course is that another round of financing is required to create sufficient ‘money’ in which to pay the interest on the first tranche. Thus the perpetual cycle is born …
Now what happens when there are no longer easily acquired resources to drive economic activity which in term creates capital demand that once again is printed out of thin air?
See, the Satanic demons never explain that small detail in the fine print. And so it goes as each successive host is exploited until it’s time to find a new home.
Once the victim realizes what’s happened, it possibly realizes that it’s already lost. Once the difference between complete collapse and military defeat? None, so if these a micro chance of survival, why not risk all.
That’s what everybody is missing; it’s all Russia red line this, Russia existentional threat that.
But the situation with the country/alliance that is already a dead man walking seems to be ignored or characterized as crazy.
Not crazy, perfectly rational given all other possible outcomes. Like I said, our bed was made taking that first sweet intoxicating hit way back in 1913.

Posted by: B9k9 | Oct 24 2022 19:48 utc | 181

Slavyangrad 18:12
“White House: The US is taking reports of possible dirty bomb preparations seriously, but has yet to see evidence of preparation.”
Translation: Shogui in his phone calls on Sunday made cystal clear, that any nuclear accident happening on Russian soil would be treated as a nuclear attack against Russia, triggering the well known responses according to the military doctrin.
It is less than 100 seconds before midnight.

Posted by: MorePain4Cakes | Oct 24 2022 20:01 utc | 182

Biggest dirty bomb in the Ukraine is the stinking pile of shit they have for a President.
Cheers M

Posted by: sean the leprechaun | Oct 24 2022 20:02 utc | 183

Posted by: Elmer Fudd | Oct 24 2022 17:04 utc | 121
I have just one question about what you just said in your post. Will a dirty bomb 💣 kill the wabbet?

Posted by: Ed Nelson | Oct 24 2022 20:02 utc | 184

I dont get why anybody would take marx still seriously. Nothing happened the way he predicted it. Nothing.
Posted by: Orgel | Oct 24 2022 13:05 utc | 22
The three “great” jew visionaries of history are all equally fake, plagiaristic, subversive, damaging and laughably wrong: marx, freud and einstein.

Posted by: Jusses | Oct 24 2022 20:11 utc | 185

An new example of the unrelented hysteria that is frogging inside the heads of western governments. Today an anti-vaxxer + pro-Putin activist Jakub Netik was acquitted from trial by a Czech judge. He was brought to trial by the Czech government, who accuses him of ‘genocide’, because he openly doubted (on his FB page) the UA & MSM narrative with regard to what happened in Bucha near Kiev. The Czech government tried to get him for two years to prison (four years if he repeated his crime). They appealed immediately to the judge’s decision.

Posted by: Oblomovka daydream | Oct 24 2022 20:14 utc | 186

karlof1 | Oct 24 2022 19:14 utc | 166 “I must admit I don’t see any party gaining anything from such a provocation”
It has been my impression that UK is trying to take US into direct war with Russia. The 220 to 240 thousand strong Ukraine trained military at the start of the SMO plus all their heavy weapons are long gone – destroyed by a much smaller Russian force.
Biden saying Russia using tactical nukes in Ukraine left an open field for UK false flag. There may have also been some collusion by the faction in the US that Ehret termed the loyalists.
As an Australian I see two extremist factions in the US plus the overlap. There is the faction that is fanatical about destroying Russia before moving on to China and on the opposite side is the faction that wants detente with Russia so they can attack China. The overlap is those that want to attack Russia and China at the same time.
I we get through this changing of an era – the fall of the west and the rise of the east – without it going nuclear, I think Putin’s name will be there alongside Tzu and Clausewitz.
Some time in the last few years Putin said his intention was to make Russia so strong nobody would attack it. Any use of nuke or dirty bomb is an absolute red line for Russia. Shoigu talked to his counterparts in the last few days and now Gerasimov is talking to his counterparts. Those counterparts, even though many are political hacks, do I think have some inkling of the superiority of Russia’s next gen strategic weapons systems.
Interesting watching Europe and Nato now. Turkey vs Greece, Poland vs Germany ect. If we make it through without nukes, the war against Russia will end, likely in the northern hemisphere winter but Hudson’s decades of war will most likely be between the western/Nato states. Quite likely to be a lot of turbulence in the third world also – those countries that haven’t or haven’t been able to hedge against the collapse of the western economic system.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Oct 24 2022 20:18 utc | 187

The West and Ukraine dare to do anything, even unthinkable.
Russia doesn’t dare, Russia limits itself, has some moral restraints.
That is the difference making the victory of the West probable.
Posted by: marko | Oct 24 2022 14:30 utc | 59
Narko, are you a Finnish nihilist? You sound like one.

Posted by: Jusses | Oct 24 2022 20:20 utc | 188

Nato detonates dirty or low yield bomb in ukraine such as Nikolev, killing ethnic Russians. It will be used a pretext for Nato to capture odessa and enter the war. Nato believes thats Russia will not cross Nuclear threshold on NATO territories in respons and will sacrifice ukraine.
However Russia should immediately let USUK know that red line has been crossed, radioactive contamination will affect Russian terrorties.
In a tit for tat response Russia should take out Kiev with conventional weapons and fire a nuclear missile at Florida, a remote area of Florida to minimize civilian casualties and advise US of the same.
Then the escalation factor is with Nato to take world to Nuclear Armageddon or discuss peace terms with Russia.

Posted by: Jason Jackson | Oct 24 2022 20:22 utc | 189

I can’t see Ukraine dirty bombing itself in a false flag. U.S. intelligence will probably find out about it, and U.S. intelligence has thrown Ukraine intelligence under the bus recently, leaking that the Darya Dugina bombing was against their wishes to NYT. We’ll know and we’ll eventually kill the people involved, even if they don’t see a trial. Ukraine is doing well right now on the battlefield and received plenty of weapons, they don’t need a desperate ploy like a fake terrorism attack. Finally, the dirty bomb will contaminate soil and land for decades, people fear that stuff, and ultra-nationalists won’t contaminate their own land.
Makes no sense. It’s either a bogus story or the Russians are behind it. I don’t think Russia is going to dirty bomb Ukraine either though. It’s not going to help them out, but could easily invite U.S. direct involvement.

Posted by: GoFast | Oct 24 2022 20:29 utc | 190

The sad fact is that Western media consumers are trained via multiple repeated messages to accept whatever they’re told.
Brainwashing is just the repetition of messages.
Brainwashing is just the repetition of messages.
Brainwashing is just the repetition of messages.
They’ll be told that Putin set the bomb on purpose so he’d have an excuse to launch his nukes on international cities.
They’ll completely ignore the fact that this would lead to chain of events so devastating that there is no reason to setup a pretext. If Putin wants to nuke international cities he’s better off getting the surprise draw. But the western muppets won’t get it.

Posted by: Sideshow Bob | Oct 24 2022 20:34 utc | 191

Posted by: oldhippie | Oct 24 2022 12:51 utc | 18
«From the very beginning, going back to Dmitri Dontsov (1920s and taught in Ukrainian schools) the Ukrainians have prized fanaticism as a weapon.»
The ukrainian government has named a large number of streets, squares, plaques to celebrate notorious fascist criminals like Dontsov, Petliura, Bandera, instigators or executors of several massacres.

Posted by: Blissex | Oct 24 2022 20:35 utc | 192

Posted by: Don Bacon | Oct 24 2022 14:14 utc | 53
«It is not only Minsk II that is disregarded there is Security Council resolution 2202 (2015) supporting Minsk II.»
Another thing that is never mentioned is that the east German state was erased and its territory annexed by the west german state and NATO without any referendum or agreement, it has been called “re-unification” but it was done as an invasion and occupation (even if it was not resisted by the east germans) The referendum before the forcible annexation of east Germany was not done because the polls showed that:
* A large minority of east Germans preferred independence (perhaps even a small a majority), and a large majority wanted unified Germany to be neutral, not a vassal of NATO, which they regarded as no better than the Warsaw Pact.
* Most east germans wanted the annexation to be negotiated between the two governments, with a treaty between them, as obviously this would have resulted in much better terms for east Germany.
The model for many east germans might have been for Prussia (east germans) to return as an independent, socialdemocratic, neutral, prosperous country like Austria (south germans). for the USA that probably seemed like outrageous insubordination.

Posted by: Blissex | Oct 24 2022 20:38 utc | 193

The deployment of the 101st to Romania is an exercise in bluster, as evidenced by the report by the CBS journalist who has been embedded with the group. Hyping the proximity to Ukraine’s battleground with the commanding officer’s refrain that the outfit is “ready to fight tonight”, while wargaming based on observation of Russian tactics, the main “message” is clearly stated:
“For more than seven months, Russian troops have tried to push along the Black Sea coast into the Kherson region, aiming to capture the key Ukrainian port cities of Mykolaiv and Odesa. Their goal is to cut off all Ukrainian access to the sea, leaving the country and its military forces landlocked. That threat, so close to NATO territory in Romania, is why one of America’s most elite air assault divisions has been sent in, with some heavy equipment… while they’re there to defend NATO territory, if the fighting escalates or there’s any attack on NATO, they’re fully prepared to cross the border into Ukraine.”
https://www.cbsnews.com/news/ukraine-news-russia-us-army-101st-airborne-nato-war-games-romania/
I would say this story is meant to back up the latest NATO demands that Russia not seek to “escalate” i.e. no further advances. It may be a signal that NATO’s current redline is Odessa, while tacitly acknowledging that Ukraine has no hope of success in pushing back the current fronts.

Posted by: jayc | Oct 24 2022 20:39 utc | 194

Posted by: chunga | Oct 24 2022 14:06 utc | 47
It continues to amaze me that among western politicians, media and so forth, there isn’t a single, solitary pair of balls big enough to utter Minsk II.
It is mentioned sometimes, as an unequal treaty that colonial overlord Putin forced Poroshenko to sign with threats. Some interesting quotes as to that:
https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/vladimir-putin-turned-down-petro-poroshenko-offer-take-donbass-east-ukraine-1495181
Poroshenko made the offer during a peace summit in Minsk in February 2015, Putin reportedly told a senior member of the Russian Union of Industrialists and Entrepreneurs on 19 March. An anonymous source present at the closed door meeting revealed to Forbes Russian edition that Putin told the summit: “[Poroshenko] told me directly: ‘Take the Donbass.’ I replied: ‘Are you out of your mind? I don’t need the Donbass. If you don’t need it, declare it independent.'” Poroshenko reportedly asked Putin to take financial responsibility for the region, where the city of Donetsk called itself a ‘People’s Republic’ after the Maidan Revolution last year. Putin replied that the region was Kiev’s financial responsibility, as long as it remained part of Ukraine.
https://tfiglobalnews.com/2022/06/20/ukraines-new-masterstroke-against-russia-is-actually-ukraines-biggest-pro-russia-move/
Former Ukrainian President, Petro Poroshenko has admitted that the 2015 ceasefire in Donbas, which he negotiated with Russia, France, and Germany as president of Ukraine was indeed a distraction intended to buy time for Kyiv to rebuild its military. He made the remarks in interviews with numerous news outlets this week, including Germany’s Deutsche Welle television and Radio Free Europe’s Ukrainian unit.

Posted by: Blissex | Oct 24 2022 20:40 utc | 195

We are often told that the so-called A-10 Warthog ‘tank buster’ jets and M1 Abrams tanks use depleted uranium shells to penetrate and ‘burn up’ enemy tanks. But they are in fact used as explosives to demolish all sorts of targets. This narrative about ‘depleted uranium’ is just a big lie. If they were using actual depleted uranium we would not be receiving reports of people dyeing in large numbers from radiation poisoning. They are not using depleted uranium at all. They are actually using highly enriched uranium in the shells, which cause small nuclear detonations when they are compressed upon impacting hard targets. They really are ‘mini’-tactical nuclear bombs. Thus they produce enormous amounts of deadly radioactive dust which contaminates target areas for quite a while.

Posted by: blues | Oct 24 2022 20:44 utc | 196

ultra-nationalists won’t contaminate their own land.
Posted by: GoFast | Oct 24 2022 20:29 utc | 191
Haven’t you been paying attention? Zelensky’s jew government aren’t ukrainian nationalists and it’s not their own land. They’ll be happy to make part of it glow in the dark to make Israel number 2 (neo-khazaria), just like they were happy to kill a few million ‘little’ jews to make Israel number 1.
They can always put the goys in the glowing part after they separate them from their children and organs.

Posted by: Jusses | Oct 24 2022 20:46 utc | 197

«Transporting a dirty bomb in Moscow is already impossible! Probably the same in Belarus? At least in the west (Germany) no one transports a ratioactive load through cities unnoticed! At every intersection on busy roads, arterial roads are sensors that register any radiation»
That applies only to bombs made by CIA stooges in their kitchens. A government like UK or Ukraine I guess has the capability to create something that does not emit anything suspicious radiation (some weapons have minimal fissile materials, and there are legends that some have no fissile materials at all), and test them carefully with their own lab sensors before shipping them.
Regardless a “dirty bomb” even a kitchen one does not need to be exploded on Red Square (soon to be renamed “Bandera Square” after the siege of Moscow by the AFU), just “near” (even perhaps dozens of miles away) the target.
The sensors in cities are largely “security theatre”; some very paranoid people (e.g. thriller authors) suspect that in warehouses in many cities around the world there are weapons (not necessarily based on fission or fusion) very well hidden in anonymous containers by various governments waiting for the trigger sequence. “Ultima ratio regum”.
I have personally no idea whether this is technically possible and has been done, I am just reporting some wild speculations that however to me seems somewhat plausible.

Posted by: Blissex | Oct 24 2022 20:52 utc | 198

Jason Jackson 190

In a tit for tat response Russia should take out Kiev with conventional weapons and fire a nuclear missile at Florida, a remote area of Florida to minimize civilian casualties and advise US of the same.

Why bother with Florida if I can hit Washington DC instead. The rest of US citizens might even be grateful that somebody finally did it.
Can’t bring myself to say the same about London – there are quite a few nice people there I dont want to kill.

Posted by: grunzt | Oct 24 2022 20:54 utc | 199

Posted by: Blissex | Oct 24 2022 20:38 utc | 194
well I guess west germany didnt smell the trap, 30 years later maybe too late 😀
where there is no peace contract there is no law dont forget that;)

Posted by: Macpott | Oct 24 2022 20:57 utc | 200