Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
September 8, 2022
Ukraine Open Thread 2022-148

News & views related to the Ukraine conflict.

Please stick to the topic.

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Comments

“Yesterday, I posted the Oryx list update – 76 pieces of heavy equipment lost over 2 days, a remarkable quantity. Since then, an additional 45(!). We are talking about multiple battalions’ worth of equipment destroyed, captured, abandoned over 3 days:https://twitter.com/Rebel44CZ/status/1567990273803698176” – Yenwoda | Sep 8 2022 23:43 utc | 180

Yesterday (| Sep 7 2022 22:51 utc | 251) he was found to be linking to a Bellingcat shill’s twitter thread – https://www.bellingcat.com/author/jakubjanovsky/.
He’s linking to it again today.
It was a dumb move and a dead giveaway yesterday.
It still is today.
F

Posted by: DocHollywood | Sep 9 2022 1:41 utc | 201

@DocHollywood | Sep 9 2022 1:41 utc | 203
We all know that Yenwoda is a slimy smeary troll and bunghole peddling imperialist propaganda like Bellingcat or SBU (via MH17 “prosecutor”), and constantly spreading lies. But those lies are often enveloped in half truths, seducing to knee jerk contradict where his filth is not attackable, giving him a cheap success. Cunning tactic, and some already suspected that he is working for some imperial propaganda unit, be it at UK forces or elsewhere.
Best is to ignore.

Posted by: aquadraht | Sep 9 2022 1:59 utc | 202

Russia is losing in eastern Ukraine, and a loss in Kherson is inevitable where Russia is trapped. All modes of transport for the Russians across the Dnipro River have now been either destroyed or rendered impassable for motorized traffic, making proper combat service support impossible. Russia has moved its military headquarters south of the river, and the Kherson referendum has been called off.
So let’s stop putting lipstick on the pig.
As I recall b was against the full-on military reaction in Ukraine to US warmongering. He thought it wouldn’t be done, and shouldn’t be. But then it was done, and it’s failed. MOA is known for its reliance on facts not wishes and feelings. Let’s be honest.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Sep 9 2022 2:00 utc | 203

Still waiting for my paycheque Aristodemos!
Posted by: Moaobserver | Sep 9 2022 1:26 utc | 199
That is a major drawback with working for the anglo empire. Most ukroids are going to their graves or simply rotting on the battlefield without having received a paycheck.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 9 2022 2:03 utc | 204

Roger #113

Once this is all completed the Ukie forces will have thrown away their final reserves, and the Russians will have made significant gains in the Donbass. Then the Russians will retake all the ground gained by the Ukies and more. Then we will hear no more of these Ukie “successes”.

I trust you are correct and that the kilometers of underground weapons storage in Kharkov are being emptied as we speak. What concerns me is the potential for a wave of ‘international brigades’ from the westies marching into Ukraine in support of this advance. Western hubris leads to insane decision making.
If the 3rd Army does not manifest some radical action soon I will be surprised as the depletion and relocation of the UAF has been intense over the past two weeks. And before that as well. There is a pressing need to sweep west from Kherson and protect the Zap NPP, secure its energy generation to supply the east and grab another NPP just further west.
Time will tell. Plus the liberation forces of DPR LNR are in no hurry to die soon as there is a very good future emerging in Ukraine. Somedays I get impatient 🙂

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Sep 9 2022 2:13 utc | 205

@aquadraht and other decent people | Sep 9 2022 1:59 utc | 202. I agree with this assessment and believe there is no value in engaging him, so I ask this question in earnest of any good person reading it: is there no value in exposing his dishonesty to anyone? I don’t think of posting about his posts with the intent of highlighting the dishonesty (because as pointed-out, it’s sometimes buried in half-truths) as the equivalent of engaging him. But if I’m wrong, and that’s of no interest here, I’ll stop.
I welcome earnest input.

Posted by: DocHollywood | Sep 9 2022 2:18 utc | 206

It was years ago that I totally gave up on CounterPunch…
Posted by: aristodemos | Sep 9 2022 1:06 utc | 193
Me too. Even the bad comments here are better than all the drivel they put out in Counterpunch (at least last time I looked!).

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 9 2022 2:21 utc | 207

@Doc – once a troll is « unmasked », arguing with it is a complete waste. Mind you, we can learn, by observing, the different types of trolls. Some do « pilpul » which is the art of words to confound rather than elucidate.

Posted by: Featherless | Sep 9 2022 2:22 utc | 208

Ukraine still has no air force and mechanized units without an air force are going to be chopped to pieces. Russia has a massive air and aviation force and they are deployed. I am sure that is the plan. It happened to the Southern offensive with relatively little air power used.
It will happen again and again everywhere Ukraine make some gains into the plains. We still have over three months to winter. The only way they can demolish Russian mechanized units is with their limited artillery resources and face to face shootouts.
Not only that they are deploying their Iranian heavy strike drones as of a month ago according to Ukrainian sources.
Russians deploy Iranian drones into battlefield, Ukrainian government official says
That was just practice, now its real. An act of desperation by Putin. No, an act of destruction. What countermeasure do the Ukrainians have? It is a mad bloody adventure on their part and it will continue.

Posted by: circumspect | Sep 9 2022 2:26 utc | 209

@Featherless | Sep 9 2022 2:22 utc | 208
I tend to agree, but .. Mind that not everyone reads the comments regularly, so such distraction may have some success at some barflies. There is no fix rule how to deal with such kind of attacks. Rule of thumb would be: If the distraction may look superficially convincing, and you have good arguments and documentation to expose and refute it, go ahead. If you are angry and want to let some steam off, I am not worrying for the touchy soul of Yenwoda and his ilk, so if you feel so, go ahead as well :). Usually it is not worth the effort, sure.

Posted by: aquadraht | Sep 9 2022 2:29 utc | 210

It’s worth noting that the Ukrainian counteroffensives are being mirrored by something similar here. Never have i seen such persistence and I’ve been lurking here ten years!

Posted by: Chevrus | Sep 9 2022 2:33 utc | 211

@TD #196, I find the Oryx lists to be excellent. That team has a lot of expertise in identifying vehicles (you’ll have to look elsewhere for bunkers/buildings). Some pro-RU channels have challenged them for showing more Russian losses, but Oryx & co. typically make a convincing case that their examples of “missed” Ukrainian losses are actually duplicates, i.e. an already-counted vehicle pictured from a different date or angle. And while they seem to pro-Ukrainian themselves, they put in the work trawling Telegram to find Ukrainian losses to document.
One of their guys has also done work for Bellingcat, which I think is great but appears to be somewhat of a “third rail” around here. I think the case made by Bellingcat on MH17, Skripal poisoning, etc. is infinitely more convincing than what b has written at this site – some people will shape their entire worldview around whatever Russia’s MoD claims with *zero* evidence, but dismiss transparent sources/methods/evidence if the team producing them took money from NED once upon a time. Frankly it seems like a lame excuse to not have to engage with inconvenient truths, but just a heads up in case that is a deal breaker for you.
https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-documenting-equipment.html
https://www.oryxspioenkop.com/2022/02/attack-on-europe-documenting-ukrainian.html

Posted by: Yenwoda | Sep 9 2022 2:44 utc | 212

@ Don Bacon
Yes, let’s be honest. In the Kharkov front things are dire and I am very worried. But what you say about Kherson is BS nazi propaganda to save face their disastrous counteroffensive. If the Russians were done there, they would simply keep pushing. There would be no reason to stop. They did, because it is a complete failure. And the idea that Russians can’t work any supplying problems caused by the Kherson counteroffensive, when the front is currently “silent”, is rather silly.

Posted by: Pobeda | Sep 9 2022 2:49 utc | 213

Chevrus@211
If it looks like a troll, quacks like a troll, hangs out with a flock of trolls and lays eggs which turn out to be trolls, you can rest assured that there is intel money behind the deluge of trolls.

Posted by: aristodemos | Sep 9 2022 2:55 utc | 214

If anyone already posted this hypothesis, forgive me, I didn’t see it.
Was this Ukr. Kharkiv offensive based on mercenary/NATO volunteer forces being pushed to front lines?
ASB Military News talks about poorly supplied foreigners, some speaking English amidst confusion and lack of communication.
Did Ukr. patch a counteroffensive together with a loose foreign legion? If so, maybe they ran out of reserves and needed a quick victory for politics.

Posted by: Eighthman | Sep 9 2022 2:57 utc | 215

Yentawoda @212
How anyone can still repeat the lies about the downed Malaysian airliner by any other agency than a Ukie fighter jet after the aircraft was deliberately re-routed by air-control in Kiev is totally beyond my understanding. Even the Prime Minister of Malaysia insisted that the Ukies, U$$A and the farmer-hating Dutch government were behind the massacre of the innocents, in dire resonance with the 911 Inside Job.

Posted by: aristodemos | Sep 9 2022 3:00 utc | 216

@aristodemos: Yeah I hear ya, and while everyone is entitled to their opinion it still annoys me that these Fuggin a holes just show up and act like they own the place .

Posted by: Chevrus | Sep 9 2022 3:28 utc | 217

@ Featherless | Sep 9 2022 2:22 utc | 208 & aquadraht | Sep 9 2022 2:29 utc | 210:
Thank you.

Posted by: DocHollywood | Sep 9 2022 3:29 utc | 218

@Pobeda | Sep 9 2022 2:49 utc | 213
I fully agree. In fact, a military unable to force a river or continue supplies without 2 road bridges cannot seriously be called a military.
The ukrop even provided support for their dying forces over Ingulets pontoon crossings hourly destroyed by Russian airforce. And the Russians have 180km Dnyepr shore where they can ferry over. Impossible to cover by Ukraine with 16 Himars launchers where according to UA sources 60% are destroyed, captured, or dysfunctional. The Red Army forced the Dnyepr with 2 millon men without a single bridge.
Moreover, the railway bridge is rarely mentioned. The Hohols asserted after their first strike on Antonovsky bridge that they had destroyed it with a single Himars shell which is beyond ridiculous, and was disproven by photos. Since then nobody mentions that bridge.

Posted by: aquadraht | Sep 9 2022 3:31 utc | 219

@ Peter AU1 | Sep 9 2022 1:22 utc | 198
thanks peter. i am with you on all this.. cheers..
developing connection between india and russia as a consequence of the ukrainian dynamic..
Timely assertion of India’s strategic autonomy

Posted by: james | Sep 9 2022 3:41 utc | 220

Hi all,
Just checking in from work… what’s going on in Kharkov region??? Have the UA scored a hit? Talk of Izyum being retaken? Seriously? Any quick summary gratefully received…

Posted by: Patroklos | Sep 9 2022 3:53 utc | 221

@ Patroklos | Sep 9 2022 3:53 utc | 221
hi patroklos.. the picture is mixed at this moment .. better to wait for greater clarity from cooler heads… i am pretty sure b will be giving an update in the next day… lets say how he defines the developments.. i don’t get a clear picture from military channel or anyone, or else i would offer one.. cheers..

Posted by: james | Sep 9 2022 4:07 utc | 222

The Ukranian neo-nazis philosophy is restricted to the racist idea that Russians are undermenchen. Ukranian Nazism is like Israel in that it is completely surrounded geographically by a vibrant and mainstream European culture which embraces multi- ethnicity as a fundamental principle, in the same way Israel is surrounded by the multi-ethnic Muslims.
So Zelensky’s role is to force a cause for war , Racism, onto a general.population that is Liberal, and wants to join mainstream Europe.
What kind of motivation is that? Surely Ukranians can see through the lie, that fighting a war for racism is going to give them an entry card into mainstream Europe?
When will the penny drop that this feeble and fake cause is being cynically used by USUKIS to clear the land ready for privatisation. Do they not see that after Ukraine has been depopulation, the US Democrats who have been weaponising Ukraine will make splendid profits with Russia and China from the New train?

Posted by: Giyane | Sep 9 2022 4:11 utc | 223

Eighthman | Sep 9 2022 2:57 utc | 215
“……Did Ukr. patch a counteroffensive together with a loose foreign legion? If so, maybe they ran out of reserves and needed a quick victory for politics.”.
Hmmmm. Did Boorish Johnson Britz do this?
I’m going to use Lavrov’s appropriation of the western Liars and misdirects….
highly likely
~ it fits with the timeline of the Boorish departing PM.
Despite Truss being Boris with a comb, there’s a lot known within the PMO that’s not known within government. [ScoMo holding multiple portfolios during Convid, with the other appointed ministers allegedly blissfully unaware, being one of the more egregious examples].
There’d be a risk with a new Jim/Jane Hacker in the chair, that would “deeply concern” the Sir Humpreys who have been conducting this “nice little war”.
Truss is of course 10,000% “on board”. But she’s an idiot, and there’d be concerns she may say something stupid. Well, of course she’ll say something stupid, but …. say something stupid that should be concealed.
And. There’s frustration from the Western Powers that this whole dirty little bit of turning the “ruble to rubble” and regime changing Putin is taking way too long and turning into a rather Mad Max style decapitating boomerang.
The Britz set up a training program in Britain for the Ukies …. and some media has let slip that’s hasn’t yielded the fighting force they were anticipating.
What’s the next obvious step from training inexperienced Ukie troops in UK?
Retuning them to Ukraine along with their instructors.
The Brits, will of course, been certain they could single handedly defeat the “vodka-n#ggers”.
And the “style” of the Kherson Zerg-rush has a very Brit/Gallipoli/ [insert campaign disaster of your choosing here🔽].
The involvement of British special forces has been an open secret since 2014/5>>>
Mission creep is a thing. …

Posted by: Melaleuca | Sep 9 2022 4:18 utc | 224

Has it been generally cloudy in the eastern Ukraine for the last week or so and Russian satellites and/or high altitude photo recon aircraft didn’t see a Ukie troop build up in the Kharkov area…? That seems to be a bit of a stretch.
I can’t remember if it was Pobeda (the star of the night!) or someone else saying that it was thing that the Ukies had the most, infantry, that has made this attack a smashing success. Infantry without wheels or tracks don’t get very far. They sure as hell haven’t walked-ran 65 klicks in 3 days. Where were the Ukies stashing all this fuel to get their infantry that far past the former front lines?/ I suspect that the Russians pay very close attention to that logistic thread. Super Ukies at last!!

Posted by: DakotaRog | Sep 9 2022 4:19 utc | 225

The Indians will be hit with a lot of pressure to obey the oil price cap. Carrot and stick I’d imagine. Since the cap will likely be lower than what Indian currently pays, it will be hard not to cave. Only if and when Russia decides not to sell to them could they say they need to go back to the previous “at a discount” deal.
It would seem that Russia is in big danger in Kherson with the HIMARS (plus US intelligence or Turkish drone info) able to take out anything the Russians use to cross the river.
I saw a recent cellphone video taken in Romania of a military convoy rolling towards Ukraine. There were multiple HIMARS in the convoy. Ukraine likely got more than 16 from the USA. In the same way Ukraine shelled Donetsk city for 8 years, the HIMARS could be used to shell various cities of Eastern Ukraine for the next 8 years. Imagine if the USA starts giving them the extra long range missiles.

Posted by: Simon | Sep 9 2022 4:43 utc | 226

Here is some fun, from Foreign Affairs
The War Between Democracy and Nihilism
By Timothy SnyderSeptember/October 2022
Ben Jones

Russia, an aging tyranny, seeks to destroy Ukraine, a defiant democracy. A Ukrainian victory would confirm the principle of self-rule, allow the integration of Europe to proceed, and empower people of goodwill to return reinvigorated to other global challenges. A Russian victory, by contrast, would extend genocidal policies in Ukraine, subordinate Europeans, and render any vision of a geopolitical European Union obsolete. Should Russia continue its illegal blockade of the Black Sea, it could starve Africans and Asians, who depend on Ukrainian grain, precipitating a durable international crisis that will make it all but impossible to deal with common threats such as climate change. A Russian victory would strengthen fascists and other tyrants, as well as nihilists who see politics as nothing more than a spectacle designed by oligarchs to distract ordinary citizens from the destruction of the world. This war, in other words, is about establishing principles for the twenty-first century. It is about policies of mass death and about the meaning of life in politics. It is about the possibility of a democratic future.

Apparently, I am a nihilist, but are we really sure that thats what nihilism is?

Posted by: jared | Sep 9 2022 4:51 utc | 227

I agree with the statement that Ukraine will get the same amount of weapons if they are losing or if they are winning. The west – notably the USA – is not ready to stop regardless of the current state of affairs. And the USA has figured out they can give bigger and bigger weapons and they all get to the front and Russia doesn’t escalate.
Maybe this winter will get Europe to back off, but they seem powerless to the USA and Biden and Co. so it really isn’t their decision. The bigger issue is probably not the arms (which enrich the defense contractors), but the monetary support to keep Ukraine running. But that could be a lot worse if Russia has destroyed Ukrainian infrastructure the way the USA would have.

Posted by: Simon | Sep 9 2022 4:56 utc | 228

One of the best sources right now, second only to Rybar, is Erwan Castel. He calls a win a win, and calls a defeat a defeat.
«If, on the Kherson front, and despite some Ukrainian tactical successes, the Russian forces contain the Kyiv forces by inflicting heavy losses on them, on the Balaklaïa front, on the other hand, they seem to have been surprised by several enemy attacks carried out in the direction of of Balaklaïa and Kupyansk and which put this sector at the forefront of military news.»
There it is: incompetence.
Russians «have been surprised by several enemy attacks» in the Kharkov oblast, despite so many warnings of a possible counter-offensive there.
A terrorist attack in Moscow might cause surprise. A sabotage in Crimea might cause surprise.
But not this. This is just unacceptable.
If Izium falls, and therefore all SMO to liberate Donetsk Republic can no longer continue, Shoigu and Putin should resign.
After all, in UK, they also had to change the leadership in WW2.
Russia needs to take its Chamberlain out, and get its Churchill.
That is my view based on facts that pro-Russia Rybar is letting us know. This is my point of view, as an anti-NATO, a neutral towards Russia, and 100% pro-Donbass self-determined people.
How many Russians and allied soldiers died to take all that land in the Kharkov oblast, to make it possible to attack Ukrainians positions from the North side of Donetsk oblast?
All their lives were wasted, just so that Putin can continue to brag that a limited SMO is enough, and that Russia doesn’t even need to declare war nor use conscripts. Now this scandalous retreat is a direct result of that political decision (or maybe bad military intel given to the Kremlin, to make it look better than it was).
I just hope there’s still enough free speech in Russia to demand Justice.
I remember Lavrov’s words, when Ukrainians were successful in the first counter-offensive to re-take land around Kharkov city. Lavrov said it was unacceptable to lose those towns in such a way, specially after being so much time in the hands of Russians.
That was also my opinion.
So, to be coherent, if I agreed with Lavrov then, then now I demand that some heads must roll, figuratively speaking, of course.
And if Putin is too proud to make an extra effort and declare war and use extra troops and equipment to liberate Donbass faster instead of waiting for this kind of counter-offensives, then he must step down, or someone should show him the way out.
As someone summarized so well, Ukraine got more land in these 2 or 3 days, than Russia did in 2 months.
I wonder if pro-Russian propagandists (not to be mistaken with decent pro-Russian that like facts and reality) are going to talk about “tactics” or “cauldron” when Ukraine also starts taking settlements INSIDE the Donetsk oblast, north of the Seversky Donets river, where pontoons are needed, and theoretically there’s more than enough Russian artillery to stop them. In just 2 days, Defense Politics Asia already put 3 blue flags in that area South of Lyman.
If I keep coming here, is because I trust ‘b’ analysis, and the way he busts media’s and West’s lies.
That’s why I’m looking forward to the article explaining this HUGE Russian DEFEAT.
More from Erwan Castel:
«If Balaklaïa falls, even temporarily to the hands of Ukrainian forces, it will be Kyiv’s first major tactical success since February 24 and it is likely to accelerate a radicalization of Russian military operations in Ukraine, starting with a counter-offensive.»
Balakleya already fell. Rybar reported «Russian forces withdraw from Balakliya».
The next 2 settlements East of that also fell, and the fight is going on in Zalyman.
And to the North, it is humiliating that there’s now a video confirming Ukrainian troops reaching Shevchenkovo in USA’s M113s from the 1960s.
Wasn’t Russian army a modern one?
And to conclude, again with Erwan Castel:
«The main difficulty of the Russian General Staff, always forced to operate with the limited manpower characterizing any “special operation”, is that it cannot move many combat units among those deployed in the sector because the other secondary attacks carried out by the Ukrainians, north of Kharkov or on the side of Slaviansk and Seversk fix them on their positions. It is therefore necessary to resist, the time that come down from the North (and probably from Russia) sufficient reserves for a counter-offensive.»
«We can clearly see here that the prolongation of the conflict has reached a tipping point where the time taken in the conduct of Russian operations, which has allowed them to save their forces and to carry out a certain strategy of attrition, has also become profitable for the Ukrainians. who were able to reconstitute enough trained forces to resume an operative initiative here and there.»
That is also my conclusion. Russia got so arrogant and distracted by grinding cannon fodder in insignificant trenches in the middle of cereal fields, that Ukraine rebuilt a big enough army to re-take initiative and make the Russians run for their lives in other sectors.
And this Kharkov counter-attack was just with 9k men. If it is until the last Ukrainian, how many 9k waves are there left? Will Russia keep waiting fpor them all to be prepared?
If they take that bridge in Senkove over the Oskil river, then the Ukrainians just need to walk for 11 Km to reach Lugansk Republic. That will be the complete humiliation of Russia. It doesn’t even matter if *it’s just a photo op* like propagandists said about other Ukrainian advances that Russia was NEVER able to reverse in 5 months, specially in that area North of Kharkov, just a fez Km away from this Balakleya debacle. *fixing operation*… Yeah, right.

Posted by: Carlos Marques | Sep 9 2022 5:23 utc | 229

Posted by: jared | Sep 9 2022 4:51 utc | 228
Wow – plenty to unpack regarding that excerpt you posted. Simply stunning how the War Party tries to create a narrative that’s entirely at odds with reality.
The challenge is articles like this in heavyweights influencer publications inform journalists and politicians exactly what is today’s accepted party line.
Empire of Lies indeed

Posted by: Exile | Sep 9 2022 5:30 utc | 230

Yesterday the origin of the term and the meaning of “troll” were discussed in the MoA. Very interesting, academic and high level discussion. Too complicated.
Here at the MoA a simple and precise definition for “troll” would be: “the one who doesn’t have sand in his eyes”.
It is pathetic to see how certain stubborn idiots are incapable of acknowledging a crushing defeat largely pre-announced on dozens of pro-Russian Telegram channels. Temporary defeat? Maybe, but always a defeat. And if they continue with this sh*t they’ve done so far, more will come.
Russia, which was not able to – in 6 months! – putting an end to or even restricting the bombing of Donbass, now leaving behind people from the adjacent Oblast who trusted the supposed liberators and who will be tortured and massacred by the ukronazis
The Russian military command is not incompetent: it is criminal.
Russian military geniuses launched the SMO to prevent Ukraine from joining NATO. They managed, with 25-dimensional chess moves, for NATO to enter Ukraine. En masse.
But que sais-je? I am just a concerned troll…

Posted by: Grey Sparrow | Sep 9 2022 5:32 utc | 231

Oh, and Ukraine’s aviation is very active, aircraft (Su-25, MiG-29) and helicopters are helping their infantry and tanks advance. And that is completed with HIMARS and other MLRS and Howitzers in the back.
And Rybar also talked about some Su-25 and Ka-52 from Russia being taken down in the Kherson front. In a total of 2x Su-25, 1x Ka-52, and 1x Mi-24. Just in the last days. That’s what I call falling like flies.
And how’s that done? With brand new NATO anti-air defenses. Russia doesn’t even have air superiority (let alone supremacy) near the front lines?! At most, Russia has a Favorable situation in some places. And that’s it.
Let me summarize Russian advances in last 2 weeks: it got a village named Kodema (South of Bakhmut/Artemovsk), which basically consists of 2 parallel 1Km roads, with small houses, and 1 (ONE) big warehouse.
In the next 2 weeks, maybe PMC Wagner will try to get Mykolaivka Druha, which consists of 50 small houses and zero trenches.
And remember, it was to “take its time” capturing this kind of settlements, that Russia was *SURPRISED* with a 9k army capable of capturing 65 Km and all towns and cities in the way in the Kharkov oblast, that was in Russian hands almost since the beginning of SMO.

Posted by: Carlos Marques | Sep 9 2022 5:46 utc | 232

Correction @232:
“Russia, which was not able to – in 6 months! – putting an end to or even restricting the bombing of the Donbass, now leaving behind people from Karkov oblast who trusted the supposed liberators and who will be tortured and massacred by the ukronazis.
The Russian military command is not incompetent: it is criminal.”
Sorry.

Posted by: Grey Sparrow | Sep 9 2022 5:58 utc | 233

The last commander to attempt a 65 km push down a single road while leaving completely open and vulnerable flanks was named Montgomery. His operation was a resounding defeat.
That a NATO proxy army seeks the same brilliant defeat Montgomery obtained (it was a brilliant concept on the strategic level as it thrust a dagger into the heart of Germany; it was incapable of being realized on a tactical level) is perplexing.
If this were a board-game war, I would be quite happy to watch my opponent denude the Kherson sector to move the bulk of his military force into the woods Northwest of Izum. There is nothing in those woods of great value to me. Let the enemy rush to occupy the wasteland and consume his transport fuel and tank tracks, relocate his long range weapons and munitions, and all of the rations and supplies necessary to the survival of any army. Once he is fully committed to the Northeast woods, I will be free to march unopposed across the coastal plain to seize something of considerable value: Odessa, the entirety of the Black Sea littoral, creation of a link with the Russian population in Transinistra and sever a major NATO supply link running North from Romania.

Posted by: Sushi | Sep 9 2022 5:59 utc | 234

John Pilger on how the war party silences dissent. Pilger was a Ozzie Vietnam journalist back when journalists busted their humps in the field. His reports are legendary.
https://www.mintpressnews.com/john-pilger-silencing-lambs-how-propaganda-works/281884/

Posted by: Exile | Sep 9 2022 6:05 utc | 235

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 9 2022 0:45 utc | 191
Health doesn’t allow me to do anything other than sit and look at the walls.
Stay well Peter. You were missed in absentia.
Posted by: Melaleuca | Sep 9 2022 0:34 utc | 189
I see some are still being aggravated by the yenwoda (ADowney). I don’t know why.
What is a yenwoda?

Posted by: Sushi | Sep 9 2022 6:07 utc | 236

The manic activity of the Ukrainian military in its death throes is coincidentally accompanied by manic troll activity on this blog asserting (while it is still possible to so assert) that this Kharkov offensive is the beginning of a real reversal in the progress of the SMO and an indictment of the Russian strategy. This offensive is a small snippet of fleeting and illusory success in a much bigger picture of Ukrainian failure. Russia is not going to lose the war. Ukrainian “success” would have been to build their country on its own merits, independently, inclusively, in peace with its historic neighbor and free of malign foreign influence, taking advantage of the natural gifts that had been bestowed to it. Instead, it chose to adopt a policy of division and hate and submission to false gods in the west who care nothing for them. Now, their idea of success is capturing a few towns and villages that they cannot hold just to say they did it. Beyond sad. Let’s see where things are in two weeks.

Posted by: Activist Potato | Sep 9 2022 6:10 utc | 237

Sushi #237
Q What is a yenwoda?
A The raison d’etre for papier toilette

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Sep 9 2022 6:29 utc | 238

Now across the West, the Queen’s death has pushed Ukraine out of the media!
It seems that all the media and all so-called specialists of the strategy are happy that they no longer have to invent success reports as such!
Zelenski has landed from number 1 to number 20 in media in the last few days. And as I know this media, that will remain the case for at least 10 days!
Only the message “Ukraine conquered 700 km2 of land and cities back running on the treadmill at NTV (Germany) whether they 70 km” meant a 0 too much in wishful thinking?
.
All politicians in the EU are now happy not to be the focus of the press anymore, with energy plans, making up excuses, unrest in the country!
.
Conclusion : The Queen has done the West ( EU / USA ) a great favor to look for this very day to die !

Posted by: Mo3 | Sep 9 2022 6:31 utc | 239

Posted by: Melaleuca | Sep 9 2022 4:18 utc | 224
“Despite Truss being Boris with a comb, there’s a lot known within the PMO that’s not known within government. [ScoMo holding multiple portfolios during Convid, with the other appointed ministers allegedly blissfully unaware, being one of the more egregious examples].”
I’ll point out that Truss and Boris, and the UK Prime Minister’s Office (PMO), have nothing to do with whether ScoMo (as the former Australian Prime Minister was known) held multiple secret portfolios. I would fall over in astonishment if the UK PMO had any knowledge (or interest) in Scott Morrison’s constitutional games.

Posted by: Ross | Sep 9 2022 7:01 utc | 240

Grey Sparrow

“Russia, which was not able to – in 6 months! – putting an end to or even restricting the bombing of the Donbass, now leaving behind people from Karkov oblast who trusted the supposed liberators and who will be tortured and massacred by the ukronazis.
The Russian military command is not incompetent: it is criminal.”

+1!
Even though Russia hold some 15-20% percentage, the systematically attacks by Ukraine, for straight 6 months, the assassations, the attacks INSIDE Russia, in Crimea even in Belarus says alot about the incompetence by Russia!
Why did not Russia plan for a defense of Donbass already in february?
Why did not Russia set up a clear defense for Crimea already in 2014?
Per every day west sees this and just strengthen them that they can win this war by pouring more weapons to Ukraine to finish this off. Russia risks being humiliated if they are going to fail this bad.
Even RT had an article the other day that had the headline:
Dmitry Trenin: Six months into the conflict, what exactly does Russia hope to achieve in Ukraine?
https://swentr.site/russia/562349-moscow-is-aiming-ukraine/

Posted by: Zanon | Sep 9 2022 7:02 utc | 241

@MO3
what are ‘ridges’ ? And your post indicates the situation certainly is well advanced and serious for the allied forces. Izyum is under direct attack? Enemy forces are actually in contact?
Other matter:
I am told the fallen areas of allied control were manned by only such as border guards, not soldiers at all.
If true does this indicate an allied, more specifically ‘Russian’ lack of soldiers or does it indicate an allied lack of acumen in warfare – or both?

Posted by: abrogard | Sep 9 2022 7:04 utc | 242

I think Brian gave the correct assessment,backed up by map data. It’s a propaganda stunt with no sustainable outcome. Liken it to Russias lightning thrusts in the initial stages. It won’t win Ukraine the war,but it could hasten the loss.

Posted by: Bob | Sep 9 2022 7:05 utc | 243

Russians are not ready to die in this war.
The Ukrainians are ready.
Very simple.
Young Russians just want to be consumers, enslaved by the west.

Posted by: mario2 | Sep 9 2022 7:11 utc | 244

Balakleya.
Where did the Ukie troops come from?
Some say that Karkiv itself is now empty of defensive forces. Another variant is that they came from the Kherson “offensive”, ie redeployment of tired troops (Also unlikely because of previous losses, distance to cover from Kherson – and they would have had to cross the Dniepr further North. Would have been seen). Were they “secret” gangs of unused reserves.
They do not seem to be 50-60 year olds, or women and children.
OR, are their ranks “filled up” with NATO hangers-on, special forces, mercenaries and weapons specialists from various countries etc. UK; US etc.
Why was the action on several fronts designed to A) coincide with the NATO meeting on the 8th sept. B) suppress a possible “Exposé” of war crimes in Geneva (or NY – there is a bit of confusion about where this is to take place.). Timed with the attempted “takeover at ZNPP.
In any case the Russians (NY) have claimed NATO involvement in the onoing fighting and NOT only for the supply of weapons.
**
Conclusion; (Provisional). That we are moving into the next phase of the war, with NATO taking a direct part. THIS has been seen by the Russians for a long time. So that the direct threat is ALSO to Kalingrad (Belarus is moving troops towards the frontier), or any other front that the U’s (Uk,US, Ukie) have wargamed.
The Balakleya front is only one part of what is becoming a major push by the U’s. and is possibly why there is such a troll push to keep attention on Balakleya, (apart from the fact that they haven’t had much to write about for the last six months).
****
I think the Russians are gathering/reorganising. their forces for the foreseeable US,NATO v Russ phase.
The absence of Putin, Shoigu and Gerasimov, who are at Vostok-22. the other side of the planet, leaves a visible “gap” in the command structure, that some Zealots might want to take advantage of. Is this deliberate?
Even Poland is saying that they expect a war with Russia in the next three years.
*****
PS.
The BIG doddery daddy (the US,) is buying oil directly from India, to avoid their own sanctions. The energy crunch and financial manoeuvres now in the worrks, will potentially screw the NATO income base line,

Posted by: Stonebird | Sep 9 2022 7:11 utc | 245

@Peter AU1
the situation is much worse than that for the allies. check the military summary channel as of now. They are eastward all the way to the river. according to the russian map.
: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U2QOiMeaYYk

Posted by: abrogard | Sep 9 2022 7:16 utc | 246

ANY FURTHER CONMENTS ON THIS? Will Schryver @imetatronink
Increasing evidence of LOTS of foreign troops (US, UK, Swedes) involved in the ongoing Kharkov / Izyum counter-attack. This would explain their initial successes. But it also *significantly* raises the stakes for this battle …

Posted by: Geraint ap Iorwerth | Sep 9 2022 7:48 utc | 247

So this “Oryx” being sited as a “source” here employs the same writers (story tellers?) as Bellingcat, which is known to be fed stories by MI6. We all know, per Zelensky, that “British military experts” planned the Kherson offensive.
Story telling about bs seems to be the only thing the British know how to do.

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 9 2022 7:55 utc | 248

abrogard | Sep 9 2022 7:16 utc | 247
Russ has 1.9 million personnel in its standing military. Something over 1 million are combat troops. According to the pentagon Russia is using 140 BTG’s for the Ukraine operation. A BTG is anywhere from 600 to a 1000 troops. Allow 750 average. Grab a calculator, do math, eat popcorn. I would not like to be wearing a pair of ukroid boots. If Russian forces fall back, worse still. That becomes a kill zone where ukroids have no human shields.
The stated purpose of the second phase is to liberate Donbas. The Russians did not say what strategy they would use. It is becoming clear this is not about the defeat of the Ukraine military. It is about its extermination.
With that small force, the ukroids just keep on coming thinking victory is just around the corner. Same as Deir Ezzor. That small force is the bait and aviation with all manner of death and destruction are the jaws of the trap.
This is about about the defeat of the Ukroids. It is extermination. No different than the way Russia deals with islamic extremism.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 9 2022 8:01 utc | 249

Nothing Ukraine does or gains can be held without air or artillery parity let alone overwhelming inferiority so just breathe no strategic change here.

Posted by: NewWorldDisorder | Sep 9 2022 8:24 utc | 250

The trolls are really getting desperate nowadays, posting fantasy to serve as copium for the realities. Ukraine is running out of Ukrainians and instead of advocating for peace they are waxing lyrical about imaginary victories.
The Trojan horse manoeuvre at the ZNPP using the IAEA is now behind them, so guess what. New Harry Potter fantasies on myriad internet blogs…to achieve what?
Its stressful having to skim through the dross to find real dialogue

Posted by: DaVinci | Sep 9 2022 8:26 utc | 251

One of the single largest issues was failure to evacuate people out of the towns (Balakyeva). NATO is practicing ethnic cleansing with their ersatzgruppens in what they manage to capture. Of course they weren’t evacuated as no offensive was considered to happen. But the land will stay there always for people to come back later, after there is no more threat.
https://twitter.com/snekotron/status/1567980742994702337

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 9 2022 8:32 utc | 252

What our friends from the Ukrainian side kindly chose to ignore time and again: “Russia” isn´t doing much of the real fighting on the ground here, despite the media always proclaiming this – though they chose ignore the existence of the DPR and LPR anyway.
To large extend, it is the DPR and LPR armies who liberated and liberate their territory, quite a few of which might have “learned” the art of war only within the last 8 years and dire experience. Then there are Chechen “voluntaries” and PMC contract soldiers about. What they get from Russia is air and artillery support, which essentially does a lot of the obliteration of the Ukrainian forces. IMHO, the Russians themselves, bar that “run for Kiev”, have not spent any great force of their own ground troops thus far.
Whatever the Ukrainian have achieved within the last couple of days is, simply due to the fact of no airspace control alone, doomed to end in tears.
A week or so back, we heard that reinforcements are being sent to the front, was it 40k real Russian troops? We shall see what happens then.
In any case, so far Russia did its warfare as it wanted to be, with the odd deviation from the plan. Nothing Ukraine and its allies did has hindered that and I doubt that will change. What Russia`s real end game is remains anyone`s guess.

Posted by: CM of Berlin | Sep 9 2022 9:13 utc | 253

Wow another trolley bus full of fug of warriers out last night! Supermaxxing the sugary Koolaid. It is funny. Such great PR word fest releasing.
Yup these words have Russian SMO on the ropes all along it’s 1500km battle front!
Yup ,it’s all gone wrong for the Neanderthal Russkies, now the Natzos not so secret ‘professional’ sophisticated western powers killers are more openly , supposedly, in the front lines …
Well you see. Looks as the Straussian counter attack finally achieving its goal some 80 years after first failing !!!
Such Genius. Such Fire Power. Such Big Arrows .
I’ll wait for b’s superior analyses as always. Let this full bus of trolls go by without trying to fight onto it.
My Nazi saluting Queen is dead and her made son educated in a Nazi school is now a granddaddy in charge. Mad Lizzie will soon be visiting Kiev to snog ms Ellen Sky, lucky all these trained natzo killers are there to ‘protect’ her.

Posted by: DunGroanin | Sep 9 2022 9:40 utc | 254

The New Atlas has a good set of observations on the Ukrainian offensives, which I and many regular contributors to MOA tend to understand well also.
Basically, these “offensives” are PR campaigns to justify looting the Western (primarily US/UK) taxpayers to fund the MIC and some Ukrainian Oligarchs. In a week or two, the Kharkov offensive will go the way of the Kherson offensive, and Russia will continue on its way, perhpas, to an October surprise for NATO and Ukraine.
https://odysee.com/@LandDestroyer:8/ukraine's-offensive-coincides-with-us-3:f

Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 9:48 utc | 255

Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 9:48 utc | 256
Hope is cheap you’re free to spend it.
The Ukie Kupyansk thrust is not some kind of knee jerk reaction, it is a methodical blow. More to come. Beware western airstrikes. Kherson always was a diversion.

Posted by: Greg Galloway | Sep 9 2022 10:03 utc | 256

Concerning the huge upsurge in troll activity coinciding with the Ukraine’s death spasm offensive, what do you expect? The US printed $billions to throw into the conflict but doesn’t have anywhere near that much actual military assistance that it can offer, so what do you think the money was spent on?
I realize the trolling makes no sense from a rational perspective as it cannot change the outcome of the battle, but the USA is the land where delusion rules so from that perspective promoting delusion makes perfect sense. FUD and fantasies work for selling lifestyles, “identities”, and politicians, so why not wars as well?
Don’t fall for the FUD. You’ll just get stressed for nothing.

Posted by: William Gruff | Sep 9 2022 10:36 utc | 257

As I recall Exile admonished us to consider the battle of Kursk in WW2 so I took the time to review an old favourite by StarmediaEN:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y_bjuREfUbU
With two armies facing off totaling two million + there was one almighty battle that destroyed the German nazi force. The Germans were in full attack in Ukraine just east of Kharkov and it took a month to reverse and then Kharkov to be liberated as the nazi force retreated in rout.
We are only a few days in to this current ‘counter attack’ by the NATZO team.
I took a long peek and poke at Geroman and Slavyangrad at Telegram and there is much accusation and gnashing of teeth that the NATZO rump army bolstered with trained irregulars (read forces) from other western nations could have moved so far, so fast. Kharkov must have been stuffed full of these forces to have been ‘hidden’. Methinks the wailing and gnashing of teeth is premature and there is an abundance of Russian intel for the Russian Generals and so on to have a fair idea of what to expect.
Although there are reports of considerable/surprising number of NATZO forces on march and pushing forward, there are also reports of considerable losses and attrition of their armored brigades and reinforcements. They are fighting their way into a dangerous position should they suddenly encounter a major encirclement. If so expect the wailing and gnashing of teeth to vomit from Washington and the London rats.
IMO one should not leap to any conclusions or wave the various victory flags at this point. Time and locality and force capacity is with the liberation forces of Eastern Ukraine ably backed by Russia and its armor, soldiers and air support. Clearly the west is or already has delivered more of the previous weapons and some new varieties. And so this battle is an ideal place to demolish them and the NATZO army.

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Sep 9 2022 10:47 utc | 258

@ DunGroanin 255
I don’t think the Queen started working for the firm atvger coronation. The Nazi salute, out of the mouth of babes, to prove British sincerity, was probably a message to Germany that Britain was on Hitler’s side. They Queen works for the firm, on the Payroll. The firm.is evil and will continue to be evil, but the Queen herself was a remarkable woman, even though she did not manage to free herself from being Poster girl for the British Raj.

Posted by: Giyane | Sep 9 2022 11:34 utc | 259

Posted by: Greg Galloway | Sep 9 2022 10:03 utc | 257
I do not deal in hope. Unless, NATO fully joins in, the ukrainians cannot win (and they will not win even then. They are losers no matter what). They do not have the manpower to expend so cavalierly on these careless overextended “offensives”. Their weapon systems and supply chains will be ultimately decimated without airpower to support them. This should be obvious.
In any case, by the end of the weekend, we should know how things are likely to progress.

Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 12:09 utc | 260

Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 12:09 utc | 261
Nato has already joined by de-enlisting active personel and sending them as volunteers, then re-enlisting after they go back, counting towards their service time. Nato is as fully committed it can without declaring war.

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 9 2022 12:30 utc | 261

IF the Russian plan was to draw the UA out from their protected defensive lines into the open in large enough numbers to impact on the key objective of Kharkov city, especially perhaps the die hard units, it needed to be a very realistic, large scale and achievable. It had to be confirmed from NATO satellite and RC-135 etc watching and listening perspectives to such an extent that the UA unit commanders and SF were desperate to get at it and to be part of it. So, on the one hand it had to be militarily viable and on the other, if it could be timed to coincide with the 8th September Ramstein donors’ meeting it would irresistible to the top US/UK/Ukr politicians’ PR objectives. A slam dunk in other words.
This would be all about the lessor of two evils. We know that the Russian military strategy is very mathematical. This could have been where the algorithms at the Moscow MoD showed the best return of dead UA versus dead Russian UA citizens/military over the next few weeks.
They certainly took the bait, if it was such and the Russians are moving in reaction today. Given that overwhelming capability, regardless of whether it was a dastardly Russian plot or not, it could never have been more than a short term operation. Another throwing of men and machines into the mincer. So sad.

Posted by: JohninMK | Sep 9 2022 12:45 utc | 262

Since 2015 Nato has been sending silent recruitment “water cooler talk” getting soldies to move to Ukraine and become Ukrainian soldiers for that cheap living and high social status, at the same time they were broadcasting on the “news” that it was a Nazi safe haven.
That mixed with a massive online effort to find every racist they could has made Ukraine a dangerous place.
Russia is in deep water now

Posted by: OhhCanada | Sep 9 2022 12:52 utc | 263

Posted by: JohninMK | Sep 9 2022 12:45 utc | 263
maybe the idea behind it is to prime the US public for direct entry into the war. that would fit in with the increased propaganda offensive we see at MOA and so many other internet sites.

Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 9 2022 12:56 utc | 264

Ross | Sep 9 2022 7:01 utc | 241
You’ve completed missed the point.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Sep 9 2022 13:10 utc | 265

Posted by: unimperator | Sep 9 2022 12:30 utc | 262
NATO will need a little more than a handfull of “de-enlisted volunteers”. This has been standard practice it seems since the Armenian military sent “volunteers” to the Nagorno Karabagh war in the early 90s.
NATO will need to send air support, as well. Even NATO cannot win without it.
The fact is that NATO cannot win a war against Russia whether it declares it or not. NATO is only capable of provoking others to react in self-defense in order to claim the other the aggressor for it home audience. That way the corporate gangsters can continue to loot and exploit their simpering serfs.

Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 13:43 utc | 266

Here’s a great analysis, very uplifting.
https://bigserge.substack.com/p/ukraine-counterattacks

Posted by: Always_Z | Sep 9 2022 18:19 utc | 267

They certainly took the bait, if it was such and the Russians are moving in reaction today. Given that overwhelming capability, regardless of whether it was a dastardly Russian plot or not, it could never have been more than a short term operation. Another throwing of men and machines into the mincer. So sad.
Posted by: JohninMK | Sep 9 2022 12:45 utc | 263
Well said. We’ll know in a while what all this means but I suspect this was
a) a successful operation for Ukraine to lobby for more weapons and funds and
b) something which will end up in their achieving nothing other than more losses
c) both a) and b) suit RF just fine. The more the West funds Ukie operations, the less territory RF needs to take since the enemy is coming to them and they just wacamole them with artillery.
d) meanwhile the most important battle continues: winter in Europe with rapidly developing economic Depression the likes of which have not been seen in a century or more. With droughts, food shortages, supply chain nullification, a new disease (wait for it) this is going to make the 30’s look like a picnic!

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 9 2022 21:30 utc | 268

Me likee Big Serge.
“Operational Depth refers to the level of advance wherein the attacking force is no longer attacking the enemy’s frontline elements, but is instead directly assailing the enemy’s ability to sustain itself in combat.”
All armchair warrior barflies should memorize this definition. And apply it to the current situation which,again, is still fluid and not yet resolved. Time will tell.

Posted by: Scorpion | Sep 9 2022 21:54 utc | 269

Posted by: Tony_0pmoc | Sep 9 2022 23:37 utc | 391 (ukraine thread)
Hi Tony, if you bother to come here. Again sorry if i am telling stuff you already know but the following may help.
1. Check your windows. if you have thick curtains draw them. If possible put in a second layer. The air between acts as a cold trap, like insulation.
2. Put up pelments above all curtains. Blocks a lot of cold air. If cost is an issue use makeshift ones of boards and old blankets.
3. Pretty obvious but use door snakes everywhere
4. You might find using an electric fan useful IF it can be placed so as to blow warm air rising down again and spread the warmth through the room.
5. Once you have finished using the oven, leave the door open for as long as practical – heat spreads out.
6. Think about your own makeshift insulation. Put old or unused mattresses against the walls. Buy more bookshelves and place them against the walls. Put up pictures as many as possible. Place lounges against walls. Extra rugs on floors. At the risk of murder by wife, even old stacks of newspapers might help.
7. If you have an attic, fill it with old books, blankets, papers etc (careful of fire hazard of course). Wool is the best insulation you can have. Cotton is not bad. Fill old duvet covers with old clothes rags, blankets etc and stuff in the rafters. Again be careful of fire hazard. get an expert to check if necessary.
7. Clear vegetation on the south side of the house, to maximise the sun warming.
In making these suggestions I deny all liability if your wife kills you. again sorry if I am telling you the obvious.

Posted by: watcher | Sep 10 2022 0:46 utc | 270

a bit of a history and language-use lesson
https://caitlinjohnstone.com/2022/09/07/its-not-okay-for-grown-adults-to-say-the-ukraine-invasion-was-unprovoked/
It’s Not Okay For Grown Adults To Say The Ukraine Invasion Was “Unprovoked”
…..“Right now if you’re a respectable writer and you want to write in the main journals, you talk about the Russian invasion of Ukraine, you have to call it ‘the unprovoked Russian invasion of Ukraine,” Chomsky said. “It’s a very interesting phrase; it was never used before. You look back, you look at Iraq, which was totally unprovoked, nobody ever called it ‘the unprovoked invasion of Iraq.’ In fact I don’t know if the term was ever used — if it was it was very marginal. Now you look it up on Google, and hundreds of thousands of hits. Every article that comes out has to talk about the unprovoked invasion of Ukraine.”
“Why? Because they know perfectly well it was provoked,” Chomsky said. “That doesn’t justify it, but it was massively provoked. Top US diplomats have been talking about this for 30 years, even the head of the CIA.”
Chomsky is of course correct here. The imperial media and their brainwashed automatons have spent half a year mindlessly bleating the word “unprovoked” in relation to this war, but one question none of them ever have a straight answer for is this: if the invasion of Ukraine was unprovoked, how come so many western experts spent years warning that the actions of western governments would provoke an invasion of Ukraine?…..

Posted by: michaelj72 | Sep 10 2022 6:45 utc | 271

Agree on the list above with only caveat – roll batt insulation is dirt cheap at the building supply store; easy to lay in attic.
Regarding saving on Heating : my depression era grandparents ( born in the 1890s) heated their house this way:
1) close all doors between rooms
2) only heat family/living room and kitchen to a ‘comfy’ temperature, which for my grandparents was 62F/17C
3) Kitchen was always over warm from cooking
3) Bathroom heated to maybe 68f/20c
4) Bedrooms ‘heated’ to 50f/10c (yeah, feather beds and flannel PJs plus little cotton nightcap.
In my teens, I check these figures with a thermometer. – grandparents worn long Johns uppers and lowers all winter as a matter of course. What’s surprising is I always felt comfortable in this house. It was normal.

Posted by: Exile | Sep 10 2022 9:06 utc | 272

Exile | Sep 10 2022 9:06 utc | 273
here in Australia we had a few deaths from people installing bats in the attic. Apparently there’s possibly electrical hazards up there.
anything contemplating it should perhaps keep that in mind.

Posted by: arthur brogard | Sep 15 2022 9:44 utc | 273