News & views related to the Ukraine conflict.
Please stick to the topic.
The current open thread for other issues is here.
|
|
|
|
Back to Main
|
||
|
September 8, 2022
Ukraine Open Thread 2022-148
News & views related to the Ukraine conflict. Please stick to the topic. The current open thread for other issues is here.
Comments
Yesterday (| Sep 7 2022 22:51 utc | 251) he was found to be linking to a Bellingcat shill’s twitter thread – https://www.bellingcat.com/author/jakubjanovsky/. Posted by: DocHollywood | Sep 9 2022 1:41 utc | 201 @DocHollywood | Sep 9 2022 1:41 utc | 203 Posted by: aquadraht | Sep 9 2022 1:59 utc | 202 Russia is losing in eastern Ukraine, and a loss in Kherson is inevitable where Russia is trapped. All modes of transport for the Russians across the Dnipro River have now been either destroyed or rendered impassable for motorized traffic, making proper combat service support impossible. Russia has moved its military headquarters south of the river, and the Kherson referendum has been called off. Posted by: Don Bacon | Sep 9 2022 2:00 utc | 203 Still waiting for my paycheque Aristodemos! Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 9 2022 2:03 utc | 204 Roger #113
I trust you are correct and that the kilometers of underground weapons storage in Kharkov are being emptied as we speak. What concerns me is the potential for a wave of ‘international brigades’ from the westies marching into Ukraine in support of this advance. Western hubris leads to insane decision making. Posted by: uncle tungsten | Sep 9 2022 2:13 utc | 205 @aquadraht and other decent people | Sep 9 2022 1:59 utc | 202. I agree with this assessment and believe there is no value in engaging him, so I ask this question in earnest of any good person reading it: is there no value in exposing his dishonesty to anyone? I don’t think of posting about his posts with the intent of highlighting the dishonesty (because as pointed-out, it’s sometimes buried in half-truths) as the equivalent of engaging him. But if I’m wrong, and that’s of no interest here, I’ll stop. Posted by: DocHollywood | Sep 9 2022 2:18 utc | 206 It was years ago that I totally gave up on CounterPunch… @Doc – once a troll is « unmasked », arguing with it is a complete waste. Mind you, we can learn, by observing, the different types of trolls. Some do « pilpul » which is the art of words to confound rather than elucidate. Posted by: Featherless | Sep 9 2022 2:22 utc | 208 Ukraine still has no air force and mechanized units without an air force are going to be chopped to pieces. Russia has a massive air and aviation force and they are deployed. I am sure that is the plan. It happened to the Southern offensive with relatively little air power used. Posted by: circumspect | Sep 9 2022 2:26 utc | 209 @Featherless | Sep 9 2022 2:22 utc | 208 Posted by: aquadraht | Sep 9 2022 2:29 utc | 210 It’s worth noting that the Ukrainian counteroffensives are being mirrored by something similar here. Never have i seen such persistence and I’ve been lurking here ten years! Posted by: Chevrus | Sep 9 2022 2:33 utc | 211 @TD #196, I find the Oryx lists to be excellent. That team has a lot of expertise in identifying vehicles (you’ll have to look elsewhere for bunkers/buildings). Some pro-RU channels have challenged them for showing more Russian losses, but Oryx & co. typically make a convincing case that their examples of “missed” Ukrainian losses are actually duplicates, i.e. an already-counted vehicle pictured from a different date or angle. And while they seem to pro-Ukrainian themselves, they put in the work trawling Telegram to find Ukrainian losses to document. Posted by: Yenwoda | Sep 9 2022 2:44 utc | 212 @ Don Bacon Posted by: Pobeda | Sep 9 2022 2:49 utc | 213 Chevrus@211 Posted by: aristodemos | Sep 9 2022 2:55 utc | 214 If anyone already posted this hypothesis, forgive me, I didn’t see it. Posted by: Eighthman | Sep 9 2022 2:57 utc | 215 Yentawoda @212 Posted by: aristodemos | Sep 9 2022 3:00 utc | 216 @aristodemos: Yeah I hear ya, and while everyone is entitled to their opinion it still annoys me that these Fuggin a holes just show up and act like they own the place . Posted by: Chevrus | Sep 9 2022 3:28 utc | 217 @ Featherless | Sep 9 2022 2:22 utc | 208 & aquadraht | Sep 9 2022 2:29 utc | 210: Posted by: DocHollywood | Sep 9 2022 3:29 utc | 218 @Pobeda | Sep 9 2022 2:49 utc | 213 Posted by: aquadraht | Sep 9 2022 3:31 utc | 219 @ Peter AU1 | Sep 9 2022 1:22 utc | 198 Posted by: james | Sep 9 2022 3:41 utc | 220 Hi all, Posted by: Patroklos | Sep 9 2022 3:53 utc | 221 @ Patroklos | Sep 9 2022 3:53 utc | 221 Posted by: james | Sep 9 2022 4:07 utc | 222 The Ukranian neo-nazis philosophy is restricted to the racist idea that Russians are undermenchen. Ukranian Nazism is like Israel in that it is completely surrounded geographically by a vibrant and mainstream European culture which embraces multi- ethnicity as a fundamental principle, in the same way Israel is surrounded by the multi-ethnic Muslims. Posted by: Giyane | Sep 9 2022 4:11 utc | 223 Eighthman | Sep 9 2022 2:57 utc | 215 Posted by: Melaleuca | Sep 9 2022 4:18 utc | 224 Has it been generally cloudy in the eastern Ukraine for the last week or so and Russian satellites and/or high altitude photo recon aircraft didn’t see a Ukie troop build up in the Kharkov area…? That seems to be a bit of a stretch. Posted by: DakotaRog | Sep 9 2022 4:19 utc | 225 The Indians will be hit with a lot of pressure to obey the oil price cap. Carrot and stick I’d imagine. Since the cap will likely be lower than what Indian currently pays, it will be hard not to cave. Only if and when Russia decides not to sell to them could they say they need to go back to the previous “at a discount” deal. Posted by: Simon | Sep 9 2022 4:43 utc | 226 Here is some fun, from Foreign Affairs
Apparently, I am a nihilist, but are we really sure that thats what nihilism is? Posted by: jared | Sep 9 2022 4:51 utc | 227 I agree with the statement that Ukraine will get the same amount of weapons if they are losing or if they are winning. The west – notably the USA – is not ready to stop regardless of the current state of affairs. And the USA has figured out they can give bigger and bigger weapons and they all get to the front and Russia doesn’t escalate. Posted by: Simon | Sep 9 2022 4:56 utc | 228 One of the best sources right now, second only to Rybar, is Erwan Castel. He calls a win a win, and calls a defeat a defeat. Posted by: Carlos Marques | Sep 9 2022 5:23 utc | 229 Posted by: jared | Sep 9 2022 4:51 utc | 228 Posted by: Exile | Sep 9 2022 5:30 utc | 230 Yesterday the origin of the term and the meaning of “troll” were discussed in the MoA. Very interesting, academic and high level discussion. Too complicated. Posted by: Grey Sparrow | Sep 9 2022 5:32 utc | 231 Oh, and Ukraine’s aviation is very active, aircraft (Su-25, MiG-29) and helicopters are helping their infantry and tanks advance. And that is completed with HIMARS and other MLRS and Howitzers in the back. Posted by: Carlos Marques | Sep 9 2022 5:46 utc | 232 Correction @232: Posted by: Grey Sparrow | Sep 9 2022 5:58 utc | 233 The last commander to attempt a 65 km push down a single road while leaving completely open and vulnerable flanks was named Montgomery. His operation was a resounding defeat. Posted by: Sushi | Sep 9 2022 5:59 utc | 234 John Pilger on how the war party silences dissent. Pilger was a Ozzie Vietnam journalist back when journalists busted their humps in the field. His reports are legendary. Posted by: Exile | Sep 9 2022 6:05 utc | 235 Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 9 2022 0:45 utc | 191 Posted by: Sushi | Sep 9 2022 6:07 utc | 236 The manic activity of the Ukrainian military in its death throes is coincidentally accompanied by manic troll activity on this blog asserting (while it is still possible to so assert) that this Kharkov offensive is the beginning of a real reversal in the progress of the SMO and an indictment of the Russian strategy. This offensive is a small snippet of fleeting and illusory success in a much bigger picture of Ukrainian failure. Russia is not going to lose the war. Ukrainian “success” would have been to build their country on its own merits, independently, inclusively, in peace with its historic neighbor and free of malign foreign influence, taking advantage of the natural gifts that had been bestowed to it. Instead, it chose to adopt a policy of division and hate and submission to false gods in the west who care nothing for them. Now, their idea of success is capturing a few towns and villages that they cannot hold just to say they did it. Beyond sad. Let’s see where things are in two weeks. Posted by: Activist Potato | Sep 9 2022 6:10 utc | 237 Sushi #237 Posted by: uncle tungsten | Sep 9 2022 6:29 utc | 238 Now across the West, the Queen’s death has pushed Ukraine out of the media! Posted by: Mo3 | Sep 9 2022 6:31 utc | 239 Posted by: Melaleuca | Sep 9 2022 4:18 utc | 224 Posted by: Ross | Sep 9 2022 7:01 utc | 240 Grey Sparrow
+1! Posted by: Zanon | Sep 9 2022 7:02 utc | 241 @MO3 Posted by: abrogard | Sep 9 2022 7:04 utc | 242 I think Brian gave the correct assessment,backed up by map data. It’s a propaganda stunt with no sustainable outcome. Liken it to Russias lightning thrusts in the initial stages. It won’t win Ukraine the war,but it could hasten the loss. Posted by: Bob | Sep 9 2022 7:05 utc | 243 Russians are not ready to die in this war. Posted by: mario2 | Sep 9 2022 7:11 utc | 244 Balakleya. Posted by: Stonebird | Sep 9 2022 7:11 utc | 245 @Peter AU1 Posted by: abrogard | Sep 9 2022 7:16 utc | 246 ANY FURTHER CONMENTS ON THIS? Will Schryver @imetatronink Posted by: Geraint ap Iorwerth | Sep 9 2022 7:48 utc | 247 So this “Oryx” being sited as a “source” here employs the same writers (story tellers?) as Bellingcat, which is known to be fed stories by MI6. We all know, per Zelensky, that “British military experts” planned the Kherson offensive. Posted by: unimperator | Sep 9 2022 7:55 utc | 248 abrogard | Sep 9 2022 7:16 utc | 247 Posted by: Peter AU1 | Sep 9 2022 8:01 utc | 249 Nothing Ukraine does or gains can be held without air or artillery parity let alone overwhelming inferiority so just breathe no strategic change here. Posted by: NewWorldDisorder | Sep 9 2022 8:24 utc | 250 The trolls are really getting desperate nowadays, posting fantasy to serve as copium for the realities. Ukraine is running out of Ukrainians and instead of advocating for peace they are waxing lyrical about imaginary victories. Posted by: DaVinci | Sep 9 2022 8:26 utc | 251 One of the single largest issues was failure to evacuate people out of the towns (Balakyeva). NATO is practicing ethnic cleansing with their ersatzgruppens in what they manage to capture. Of course they weren’t evacuated as no offensive was considered to happen. But the land will stay there always for people to come back later, after there is no more threat. Posted by: unimperator | Sep 9 2022 8:32 utc | 252 What our friends from the Ukrainian side kindly chose to ignore time and again: “Russia” isn´t doing much of the real fighting on the ground here, despite the media always proclaiming this – though they chose ignore the existence of the DPR and LPR anyway. Posted by: CM of Berlin | Sep 9 2022 9:13 utc | 253 Wow another trolley bus full of fug of warriers out last night! Supermaxxing the sugary Koolaid. It is funny. Such great PR word fest releasing. Posted by: DunGroanin | Sep 9 2022 9:40 utc | 254 The New Atlas has a good set of observations on the Ukrainian offensives, which I and many regular contributors to MOA tend to understand well also. Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 9:48 utc | 255 Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 9:48 utc | 256 Posted by: Greg Galloway | Sep 9 2022 10:03 utc | 256 Concerning the huge upsurge in troll activity coinciding with the Ukraine’s death spasm offensive, what do you expect? The US printed $billions to throw into the conflict but doesn’t have anywhere near that much actual military assistance that it can offer, so what do you think the money was spent on? Posted by: William Gruff | Sep 9 2022 10:36 utc | 257 As I recall Exile admonished us to consider the battle of Kursk in WW2 so I took the time to review an old favourite by StarmediaEN: Posted by: uncle tungsten | Sep 9 2022 10:47 utc | 258 @ DunGroanin 255 Posted by: Giyane | Sep 9 2022 11:34 utc | 259 Posted by: Greg Galloway | Sep 9 2022 10:03 utc | 257 Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 12:09 utc | 260 Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 12:09 utc | 261 Posted by: unimperator | Sep 9 2022 12:30 utc | 261 IF the Russian plan was to draw the UA out from their protected defensive lines into the open in large enough numbers to impact on the key objective of Kharkov city, especially perhaps the die hard units, it needed to be a very realistic, large scale and achievable. It had to be confirmed from NATO satellite and RC-135 etc watching and listening perspectives to such an extent that the UA unit commanders and SF were desperate to get at it and to be part of it. So, on the one hand it had to be militarily viable and on the other, if it could be timed to coincide with the 8th September Ramstein donors’ meeting it would irresistible to the top US/UK/Ukr politicians’ PR objectives. A slam dunk in other words. Posted by: JohninMK | Sep 9 2022 12:45 utc | 262 Since 2015 Nato has been sending silent recruitment “water cooler talk” getting soldies to move to Ukraine and become Ukrainian soldiers for that cheap living and high social status, at the same time they were broadcasting on the “news” that it was a Nazi safe haven. Posted by: OhhCanada | Sep 9 2022 12:52 utc | 263 Posted by: JohninMK | Sep 9 2022 12:45 utc | 263 Posted by: pretzelattack | Sep 9 2022 12:56 utc | 264 Ross | Sep 9 2022 7:01 utc | 241 Posted by: Melaleuca | Sep 9 2022 13:10 utc | 265 Posted by: unimperator | Sep 9 2022 12:30 utc | 262 Posted by: Blue Dotterel | Sep 9 2022 13:43 utc | 266 Here’s a great analysis, very uplifting. Posted by: Always_Z | Sep 9 2022 18:19 utc | 267 They certainly took the bait, if it was such and the Russians are moving in reaction today. Given that overwhelming capability, regardless of whether it was a dastardly Russian plot or not, it could never have been more than a short term operation. Another throwing of men and machines into the mincer. So sad. Me likee Big Serge. Posted by: Tony_0pmoc | Sep 9 2022 23:37 utc | 391 (ukraine thread) Posted by: watcher | Sep 10 2022 0:46 utc | 270 a bit of a history and language-use lesson Posted by: michaelj72 | Sep 10 2022 6:45 utc | 271 Agree on the list above with only caveat – roll batt insulation is dirt cheap at the building supply store; easy to lay in attic. Posted by: Exile | Sep 10 2022 9:06 utc | 272 Exile | Sep 10 2022 9:06 utc | 273 Posted by: arthur brogard | Sep 15 2022 9:44 utc | 273 |
||