Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
September 29, 2022
Liz Truss Is Already The Bad Prime Minister Everyone Expected Her To Be

When Liz Truss was 'elected' as Prime Minister by 0.6% of all British voters I expressed some sorrow for a once great Britain:

Liz Truss is less competent than Boris Johnson but at the same level when it comes to lying. She also has no empathy. In the end she will look worse in office than Johnson did.

The damage of the Brexit disaster is still getting worse. The energy crunch, caused by the economic war waged against Russia, is tearing the country apart. […] The National Health Service is turning patients away for lack of resources.

Truss will worsen all that.

But the billionaires and banksters of the City of London will still applause her for lowering their taxes.

With the election process rigged for the Tories and the Labour leadership held by the hapless and vindictive Keir Starmer there is little chance for regime change in Britain. When Truss falls the premiership could even go back to Boris Johnson.

Just three weeks later and we may already be there.

Liz Truss and her chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng are libertarians who believe that the state's function should be as small as possible.

On August 5, before Truss was 'elected', the Official Monetary and Financial Institution Service, a think tank, had predicted what was soon to happen:

If she wins, and enacts her promise of immediate tax cuts, the only safe prediction is that sterling will crash. The pound’s fall on 4 August – after the Bank of England raised its headline rate to 1.75% and warned of 13% inflation and a protracted recession – delivers a taste of things to come.

Britain’s combination of economic downturn and inflation is likely to be as severe and possibly as long lasting as in the 1970s. Truss’s policies are likely to make it worse. The idea of a bonanza amid stagflation is not just bold; it is foolhardy.

Thatcher’s record shows she was determined to inflict pain before rewarding the punters with tax cuts. Upon taking office in 1979, Thatcher’s government doubled the rate of value added tax to 15% from 8%. She believed, rightly, voters had to accept hardship as a prelude to facing up to economic reality.

If Truss becomes leader, she would follow the opposite course, with a pliant chancellor (perhaps Kwasi Kwarteng, the present business secretary) carrying out her bidding. Truss’s policy on tax cuts would prolong the often bizarre nature of Johnson’s three year rule.

As soon as the deceased queen was buried Truss went to work. Chancellor Kwarteng announced a 'mini-budget' that will lower taxes for people with high incomes while increasing the deficit to cover the promised energy cost subsidies:

It would be an understatement to describe Truss’s budget initiatives as bold. Last week, she announced the largest U.K. tax cut in 50 years, including a payroll tax cut and a reversal of a planned increase in corporate taxes. The estimated cost is $50 billion. This tax cut comes on the immediate heels of extraordinarily generous energy subsidies to households and businesses, at an estimated cost of $150 billion.

According to the National Institute of Economic and Social Research, the new budget initiatives will cause the U.K. budget deficit to balloon to 8% of gross domestic product next year. At the same time, the public debt will soon exceed 90% of GDP.

As soon as the 'mini budget' was announced the British pound sterling tanked. This not only against the overvalued U.S. dollar but also compared to the rather weak Euro.


bigger

Interest rates on British government bonds (Gilts) increased sharply.


bigger

After two days the British central bank, the Bank of England, had to intervene to prevent a Lehman like crisis that would have killed many British pension funds. The bank, which had just increased its interest rate to tighten money supply, reverted to quantitative easing by buying gilts in the open market. This will further increase the already runaway inflation.

The lower pound sterling with further increase energy costs. Many British homeowners have mortgage with flexible interest rates. They will get devastated by all of this.

Today Liz Truss gave a round of radio interviews.

Another Angry Voice @Angry_Voice – 11:49 UTC · Sep 29, 2022

Liz Truss getting absolutely ruined on local radio this morning
A thread, with credits

Truss could not answer even basic questions about her budget and its consequences.

The British government received a lot of criticism over its move. Not because the IMF or other commentators think it is general bad what Truss and Kwarteng try to do but because it created uncertainty and trouble in the markets.

Adam Tooze writes that Truss and Kwarteng probably intended to create market jitter because it will help them to push for their real aims:

I am not sure that Kwarteng and team intended to produce a crisis that will supercharge their drive to slash public spending. But cutting government spending is clearly their plan. They have effectively said as much. And we should expect them to exploit the situation to pursue that goal and be braced for that.

On October 6 the Tory will have their yearly party conference. It may well become a challenge for Truss and one can not exclude that the party will simply dump her for the chaos she created.

Boris Johnson may be back as Prime Minister sooner than anyone expected.

Comments

Brexit: a vote by people wanting more say in how their lives are run, and feeling more and more like strangers in their own land. Pity it was sold by liars, who are still in power, stealing as much as they can get their hands on.
Truss et al didn’t start the collapse, but their shaky hands pushed it over.
Reality is what doesn’t go away when you stop believing in it. The economy is energy. Peak oil was in 2018, and we are on the decline, and there isn’t enough North Sea oil and gas to prop up fantasy economic theories like in the 80s, and there isn’t any wiggle room with interest rates and debt like there was in the 90s.
We are headed for the biggest crash since the 13th century.
MMT is more fantasy. If you print money, that gives you a claim on goods or energy that you would only be able to access in the future if you saved up. It is stealing from the future. Clawing inflation back with tax doesn’t mean squat because the goods and energy are already there.
God help us all.

Posted by: Benn | Sep 30 2022 10:58 utc | 101

if you are still unable to see the beauty of this big and bloated machine, you are in denial.
show me an actor who can play the idiot better than G.W.Bush. political class, media, alternate-media… in perfect synch, playing their parts beautifully. blinded by details, we are unable to see the big picture.

Posted by: brexitquestion | Sep 30 2022 11:16 utc | 102

Morons here who believe BrexShit was some kind of popular revolt are dumbasses who believed in Santa Claus, tooth fairy and every little fairy tale of propaganda, mass hallucination, Pavlovian action, flat Earth ism, the holy book , heaven and hell, divinity of royalty , god and think governments have to tax first to spend !
They really are thick as shit and think they MAKE the MONEY they EARN by their WORK.
These simple lies and self delusional certitudes makes them believe that the Country is in some way theirs and they have a greater interest in it.
BrexShit was a con.
It was done to save the City from a level playing field and from a Court it could not control and Laws it couldn’t exceptionally ignore.
Political Austerity was the stick to make people believe that austerity was caused by EU membership.
Along with dog whistle racism against migrants.
The carrot of some fairytale sovereignty and greater share of the pie.
There was postal vote fraud to deliver the lie of BrexShit as evidenced by the suspiciously high turnout in some areas which pushed the vote in that direction.
There is no transparency about these postal votes because they were run by a private company, foreign owned and no records are released. It is how Western Elections are skewed this century. They are not transparent, they are a joke, compared to the plebiscite just carried out in the now independent republics of Ukraine.
Just look at the exponential rise in postal vote share this century.
Morons still believe they actually got one over on the State as they run around with a bloody hole in the middle of their face where they cut off their noses and show off how they spite their EU identity face.
Liz fucking Truss and her fuckbuddy Posh Boy Kwarteng are from the same Brittannia Unhinged book group nurtured from the 80’s. To destroy the ever closer Union, to destroy the unifying Euro that challenged the City and the petrodollar hegemony. And would have made a secure and prosperous peace on the EurAsia land mass – completely isolating and nullifying centuries of Obsessive Imperial invasion and capture of resources and enslavement of peoples for the very very few Financiers and Ancient Slave Owner, Robber Barons and their mercenary praetorian thugs.
They are who fermented BrexShit to bring down the EU and BrexShitheads really really believe it was all their own idea!!! There are many within the EU who are placed to bring down that demise as there are many Kipperish parties which arose like mushrooms from nowhere with obscure funding and social media algorithms.
They have been played for the suckers they are
I bet they delude their children with the same fairy tales of a Santa and now even hallowe’en , which are wholly invented commercial sales campaigns born of the Mad Men.

Posted by: DunGroanin | Sep 30 2022 11:23 utc | 103

Astonishingly, opinion polls show Labour to be +33 points ahead of Conservatives
they have been consistently 10 points ahead on average since December.
i would really hate to think that Labour might take this (+33 point lead) to be indicative
of any popularity towards themselves. they would be delusional to think so
ps it is not Sterling that is in crisis, yet (although that may very well change and soon).
its the Gilt/market
that is in turmoil. 10 year gilt yielld has moved from 2% to 4.5% since early August, in statistical terms it is off the charts, to coin a phrase.

Posted by: chris m | Sep 30 2022 12:04 utc | 104

Now would be the perfect time to launch a new party. Just copy what Meloni did. While you may not win even a small %shift will allow you to force policy changes. As pointed out it not a pro labour shift,but rather an anti government protest. That leaves a 23 % potential vote share up for grabs.

Posted by: Bob | Sep 30 2022 12:31 utc | 105

“As soon as the deceased queen was buried Truss went to work.”
Tautological…..they could hardly have buried her had she been alive.

Posted by: Guy Thornton | Sep 30 2022 13:00 utc | 106

Truss appears to be very stupid but who knows how clever are those behind her? Part one of the wrecking operation has proceeded according to plan complete with collapse of the pound and a huge propping of the pound by the BoE amounting to QE. This was not because the markets were not happy with the principles of small government just the fact that the tax giveaway was not costed. The masterstroke will follow because Truss’ chancellor next move will be to appease the market by drastically reducing expenditure on social security and the objections to this will be drowned by the endorsement from the markets and the pound rallying. Let’s wait and see.

Posted by: Orage | Sep 30 2022 14:00 utc | 107

@ 31 albagen
Truss can press as many buttons as she likes but if the US doesn’t provide the security code, she may as well be playing with a remote control.

Posted by: duplicitousdemocracy | Sep 30 2022 14:16 utc | 108

This will be the trend across all of Europe over the next decade, as the continent is gutted in futile attempt to prop up America’s neoliberal Leviathan. Slash public works and services, crater industrial capacity, attempt to brain drain whatever talent Europe has towards the USA. That is Europe’s future. Nothing but a farm for wall street.

Posted by: FVK | Sep 30 2022 14:26 utc | 109

Liz Truss and her chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng are libertarians who believe that the state’s function should be as small as possible.

I am not sure that Kwarteng and team intended to produce a crisis that will supercharge their drive to slash public 7spending. But cutting government spending is clearly their plan. They have effectively said as much. And we should expect them to exploit the situation to pursue that goal and be braced for that.

I don’t know how anyone can claim the Truss and Kwarteng are “libertarians” if they’re spending £200B on subsidising energy use, and allowing the “independent” BoA to bail out pension funds
Much as I dislike Truss, the UK faced staflationary economic collapse if they didn’t subsidise energy prices. Most businesses would have gone bankrupt, there’d hve been massive unemployment and people dying of hypothermia in their homes because they couldn’t afford to heat them.
The optics of (some of) the tax cuts are very bad (bafflingly tone deaf in fact). They should have raised the tax on incomes over £150k to 50% (rather than reduce it to 40%) to pre-empt Leftist demagoguery, but cut corporation tax to 15% to attract more FDI (corporation taxes are a disaster economically, and if you don’t understand why, then you shouldn’t be commenting on tax policy). But as politically offensive as the tax cuts are, in terms of affecting the GBP exchange rate, interest rates and inflation, they’re insignificant. The energy crisis and subsidies are what will really hammer the pound (and currencies of all countries reliant on external sources of energy sourced at market rates and paid for with USD).
But the real problem in the UK is the so-called Conservatives embracing useless Green energy virtue-signalling and sanctions of Russian energy. And propping up the Ukrainain neo-Nazis in an attempt to destroy Russia.

Posted by: Observer | Sep 30 2022 14:38 utc | 110

#106
Mate, Truss is a fall guy (fall gal?). Clear as day. Neither BoJo the clown nor Sunak are dumb enough to want to get caught into the crapstorm coming in the fall and winter, between inflation, employee crisis, supply crisis, financial crisis, the strikes, what is shaping up to be one of the coldest winters on record at the same time as energy costs are going into high orbit, and a lot of other stormfronts coming up to form possibly the most massive economic, social and political hurricane ever seen in the UK since WW2.
Who would be so vain, stupid and petty to rush to catch the red-hot potato that everyone’s been dodging, and be at the center of attention for a while?
Liz Truss.
The only mammal available to be so abysmally incompetent and unprepared for the job to not realize it is a trap and spells doom for her career.
She will get all the blame for the disastrous situation the UK will find itself in by Christmas at the latest.
She will become a political pariah (actually she’s already well on the way there).
The best she can aspire to do, in the next few weeks, is change her name, get a facial reconstruction surgery and flee to the Falklands.

Posted by: SumGuy | Sep 30 2022 14:50 utc | 111

Observer @ 109.
It’s quite possible that the Conservatives, some of them anyway, would love to scrap the Green energy plan. But imagine the demonstrations if they tried.
And if they suggest making a peace deal with Russia they would be called a bunch of Neville Chamberlains.

Posted by: dh | Sep 30 2022 14:50 utc | 112

It is always the case that between the Labour and Tory conferences there is always a swing towards Labour which is wiped out after the Tories have featured exclusively in the press.
It is a function of the abysmal attention span of Joe Public.

Posted by: Pancho Plail | Sep 30 2022 14:53 utc | 113

Posted by: Jannie | Sep 29 2022 18:21 utc | 15
Indeed. Maybe transport -like of old -all the Conservative powerbrokers . Pity Australia isn’t a penal colony anymore…

Posted by: Brother Ma | Sep 30 2022 15:39 utc | 114

Two very nice articles very much in keeping with B’s analysis on the decline of Britain before and during the rise of Liz Truss. Much more details to add to his excellent article!
“Liz Truss and Britain’s 0.17%Democracy”
https://watchingromeburn.uk/news/liz-truss-and-britains-0-17-democracy-monocracy/
and… Britain’s Special Relationship and the American Virus
https://watchingromeburn.uk/news/britains-special-relationship-and-the-american-virus/
This is what a country gets from following the American economic. political and social model down the tubes. Britain and th pound are finished. Next up… The EU and the EURO then the US and tjhe dollar. A reset I can totally support.

Posted by: Don Stevens | Sep 30 2022 15:57 utc | 115

Posted by: Some Random Passerby | Sep 29 2022 21:54 utc | 51
Random? What do you term core jobs? Builders /carpenters ? Service industry, like Bank tellers, barbers? Government/insurance clerks?

Posted by: Brother Ma | Sep 30 2022 16:00 utc | 116

Re: The discussions about Truss; Britain isn’t a democracy and never was. First past the post voting guarantees minority rule. FPTP does for the British boss class what the Acerbo Law did for Mussolini, which is why you won’t find tanks on lawns or the SA watching people to make sure that their ballots are for the right partei (in both senses of the word). The point is that you shouldn’t blame British voters for anything but casting a vote in a fascist system; notice thought that the abstainers have accumulated more votes than the partei that formed a government in most if not all of the elections since 1997.

Posted by: Squeeth | Sep 30 2022 16:04 utc | 117

add that “think” tank to the recent – and very odd – spate of people blowing thatcher. that’s like all the paleo dorks who think “things sure were great under reagan…what happened?”
bojo isn’t coming back. he was always in over his head and his popularity at this point (outside of the dead eyed financial sector patrick batemans in london) is roughly that of cholera and child abuse.
once truss is out it’ll be starmer or some other stuffed suit/placeholder. the office of PM is just “weekend at bernies” at this point. hell, the whole UK government; i’m surprised they didn’t just taxidermy liz and prop her up on a balcony somewhere. truss is just really bad at pretending the proles matter and have any say in their sad fog breathing lives.

Posted by: the pair | Sep 30 2022 16:16 utc | 118

Well, if people like you had been a little circumspect in your criticisms, maybe we would have let you krauts keep your (empty) russki pipelines. Too late now.
And don’t even think about restarting those merkelized reactors.

Posted by: Alen Dulles | Sep 30 2022 16:41 utc | 119

“Liz Truss and her chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng are” members of the Conservative Party of the UK

Posted by: sln2002 | Sep 30 2022 18:02 utc | 120

@brexitquestion, #104:
Even if we saw the big picture since GWBush times, what exactly could we have done???

Posted by: Oriental Voice | Sep 30 2022 18:18 utc | 121

Trillion pound question: Can Captain Lizzy (Borden) Truss navigate the ill-fated SS Great Britain through the treacherous Wiemar Bank Reef?/s

Posted by: Bad Deal Motors On | Sep 30 2022 22:36 utc | 122

Squeeth [119]
You know little. FPTP is a constituency-based system which means ALL seats are directly elected and is not how other countries operate.
In N Ireland a rigged PR system is used to dilute Protestant votes. In Scotland a different PR system is used to ensure SNP dictatorship and in Wales similar. London Mayor US elected on different PR system
Germany is dominated by minority fanatics of Greens without whom no Coalition is possible because of terrible German system. There are now the most parties in Bjndestag since Weimar Republic. In Thüringen Merkel had the election of PM overturned because she did not like the result and since elf tuins cintjnue to be postponed
There are no majorities in most German states and voters are disenfranchised
So-called Media Democracy is simply Oligarchy with puppets

Posted by: Paul Greenwood | Oct 1 2022 6:39 utc | 123

“…United States is practically pushing Europe toward deindustrialisation in a bid to get its hands on the entire European market…
This is only half the picture. Companies in energy intensive sectors simply move out. Bye-bye for jobs, know-how, capital. Where to? USA and… CHINA! German investment in CN has never been so high as these days. That’s not what the USA want. The capital streams still need to be directed now that the gates are open. More sanctions, more sabotage ahead.

Posted by: OttoE | Oct 1 2022 16:10 utc | 124