Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
June 29, 2022
Ukraine Open Thread 2022-99

Only news & views related to the Ukraine conflict …

The current open thread for other issues is here.

Comments

Zakharova’s weekly briefing has this on the Kaliningrad situation:

Official representatives of the European Union promised to prepare legally binding “recommendations” of the European Commission as soon as possible to resolve the situation artificially created by Brussels related to the restriction of Kaliningrad cargo transit. According to available information, Vilnius is studying these proposals. He emphasizes that he does not intend to succumb to the alleged pressure exerted on Lithuania by Russia. I don’t understand who is putting pressure on whom. We are only reading the news from Lithuania and Brussels. In this regard, Lithuanian Foreign Minister G. Landsbergis’ statements that “Russia should not get a diplomatic victory on the issue of sanctions” are indicative. Then we need to be more consistent and frank to the end. If you are talking about victories, then it is necessary, gentlemen of Brussels and Lithuania, politicians and officials, to declare that you have unleashed a war. Or did we misunderstand you?
The Lithuanian politician is not able to understand the main thing – there can be no obstacles to communication between the two parts of Russia in principle.
We are closely monitoring the development of the situation, commenting on it at the request of the media and in the course of receipt of materials.
We reaffirm that the Russian side is preparing retaliatory measures that are painful for Lithuania, which will be applied if the situation with the Kaliningrad transit does not normalize. But we hope that common sense will still be shown by the “partners”. Although this situation does not apply to any partnership. [My Emphasis]

IMO, Russia understands perfectly well, and it’s the EU nuts who have no idea what they’re doing or opening themselves up for.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 20:42 utc | 101

Posted by: JB | Jun 29 2022 20:27 utc | 93
Show me standards of evidence by country
–preponderance (jury | no jury)
–reasonable doubt (jury | no jury)

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 29 2022 20:43 utc | 102

It’s better described as a campaign of terror against a population to force it to give up its cultural identity, values and historical memory.)
Posted by: S | Jun 29 2022 17:33 utc | 43
A true tragedy in every sense of the word. Whilst the cynics and skeptics see the picture of the evils of country 404. The general public will never see these pictures unless by sheer accident.
For example a brave German female reporter working east of the battle line Ms Alina Lipp. Is being charged by the German legal system of supplying non local consensus information………

Posted by: Bad Deal Motors On | Jun 29 2022 20:47 utc | 103

All the US troops in Poland, ships in the Mediterranean, and planes in the UK are sitting ducks for hypersonic missile volleys of 4-6 missiles per target. This Rambo posturing only impresses girl scouts anymore.

Posted by: Tom Huck | Jun 29 2022 20:53 utc | 104

@102 Cont’d–
From the Q&A:
“Question: You have already spoken about Kaliningrad transit. My question lies in a slightly different plane. Former Latvian Interior Minister Maris Gulbis said that the restriction of transit to the Kaliningrad region is a signal to Russia that Europe and NATO are ready to take it away. How would you comment on this provocative statement?
“Maria Zakharova: It seems to me that Russian statesmen have already commented on this, and they have done it very succinctly. In my opinion, this is said from some kind of ‘ill health’. I am sure that these people are saying this for provocative purposes. Perhaps they themselves do not understand the scale of what they are doing, but this activity has always been called a provocation. This is the hallmark of the Western mentality. I can hardly find a historical period that would not be marked by provocations by Western regimes. Even if we take recent history, there are plenty of examples when everything that happened in the world was connected with the provocative activities of the West. This is their characteristic feature for various reasons. I can’t list them all for you now, because it will take a very long time. But I would like to stress once again that provocation has long been part of the state policy of Western regimes.” [My Emphasis]
As I recall, the firepower based in Kaliningrad alone is enough to take out all major European decision making centers. Clearly as I’ve previously posited, these provocations are ordered from Washington, and Russia has told the Bidenites that Russia knows that and thus Washington’s not immune–and Russia doesn’t need to employ nukes to devastate any major city.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 20:58 utc | 105

“Army’s 101st Airborne Division from Fort Campbell, Kentucky, to Europe in 80 years.”
Putin’s and Shoigu’s pants are trembling!

Posted by: Milos | Jun 29 2022 21:00 utc | 106

100
China should tell the Chinese to no longer buy Teslas…

Posted by: Nico | Jun 29 2022 21:04 utc | 107

ostro #40
A moment might come soon when NATO will realise its doom is nigh unless it negotiates the non aggression pact offered by Russia. Already it appears to be an abject failure led by fools. Same for the EC/EU. When a loud uproar is heard from the European people who come to the above conclusion, I expect we might see ‘leaders’ fall.
There is a chance that the people will not see this reality or be permitted to protest it and NATO and EC/EU will stagger into a superb debacle. It will be economic ruin for the people of Europe yet again.
Does Easter Ukraine harvest good popcorn?

Posted by: uncle tungsten | Jun 29 2022 21:09 utc | 108

As I have noted here before – like every crime, it has two elements: a prohibited act, and a legally defined mens rea [the ever present psychic defense LOL!]
Posted by: JB | Jun 29 2022 19:38 utc | 76
What happended to these two elements–findings of fact, findings of law? ICJ or ICC? You do know, UA started running parallel complaints the day after the SMO began. Do you suppose that “legal strategy” has anything to do with venue shopping for sympathetic jurists like Joan E. Donoghue and ICC prosecutors?

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 29 2022 21:09 utc | 109

We reaffirm that the Russian side is preparing retaliatory measures that are painful for Lithuania, which will be applied if the situation with the Kaliningrad transit does not normalize.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 20:42 utc | 102
————————————————
That’s dip-speak, but she actually had given a warning. The decision will be taken by someone else authorised to do that, and we’d know about that, after the action taken. Guessing game in on!
My guess: Klaipeda will be blocked, electricity cut off, Vilnius either surrounded/overtaken, all Lithuanian/foreign military bases hit.

Posted by: ostro | Jun 29 2022 21:09 utc | 110

all the US troops stationed in Germany, Italy, Spain, the UK, Norway and Belgium
all the more US combat teams and airborne divisions deployed into Europe
all the Nato cruise missiles ready to launch against Russia
all the CIA and MI6 special forces operating in the Ukraine
all the big bad destroyers moved into the Mediterranean Sea
all the strengthening of US and NATO interoperability across the entire eastern flank, and the F-35 squadrons to the UK….
won’t put The Empire back together again

Posted by: michaelj72 | Jun 29 2022 21:17 utc | 111

Posted by: Pagan | Jun 29 2022 19:52 utc | 80
“I am of the opinion that if the Ukrainian leadership had any illusions of stopping the Russians by giving up Donbas they would have made some move to at least explore that option. I believe they have no such illusions, they are aware that their best chance to stop the collapse of the country is right there at the Line of Contact, where they have fortifications and where they have accumulated men and arms and where they can use local population as human shields. Such “favourable” conditions do not exist in the rest of the country. To conclude, I think that the intransigence of the country’s leadership is a sign that they know this is an all-or-nothing battle.”
If Russia’s goal in Ukraine is to enlarge Russian territory, Putin has a funny way of going about it. In 2014 the DPR and the LPR (the Donbass region) voted to leave Ukraine and become a part of Russia. For nearly 8 years Putin refused to honor their vote and instead worked with certain EU countries to implement the Minsk agreements l and ll. During this time, the US and NATO were training Ukraine forces and shipping a multitude of weapons into Ukraine all while Russia looked on. Yes, at this point, Russia will be slow to give up Eastern and Southern Ukraine paid for with the blood and treasure of the Russian people. But there was a time early on in the conflict when Elensky could have retained most of Ukraine by agreeing to Russian terms about being natural with NATO and removing neo-Nazis from the government and the Ukraine military. The DPR, LPR, and Crimea would have remained within Russia’s orbit. I don’t think that Russia has any desire to own Western Ukraine, why should it. Western Ukraine is a shit hole.

Posted by: Ed Nelson | Jun 29 2022 21:18 utc | 112

@ SCC | Jun 29 2022 18:22 utc | 55
I scanned that link to my area and recognized that the image given was pre 2020 based on local developments. There is probably some way to access more recent aerial surveillance google maps but that is beyond my ken. That one is pre 2020.

Posted by: suzan | Jun 29 2022 21:23 utc | 113

Joe6pack | Jun 29 2022 16:45 utc | 21
Hahaha! Even that would be better that being subject to the Rentier Capitalist Oligarchy…As they know by now: they were hollowed out not long ago by such vampires.

Posted by: donten | Jun 29 2022 21:23 utc | 114

Maybe, Belarus needs a sea border, so Lithuania can be annexed…

Posted by: ostro | Jun 29 2022 21:27 utc | 115

@Posted by: Nico | Jun 29 2022 21:04 utc | 108
One of the biggest shocks for Tesla will be its falling market share in China as a myriad of local competitors are starting to eat its lunch with a mix of features and luxury (and reliability and cheaper insurance and maintenance) at significantly lower prices. First-mover advantage has left the station for Tesla in China, which will not have a new model out until well into 2023 while Chinese manufacturers are bringing out new model after new model. The model 3, and even the Y, will start looking long in the tooth to Chinese consumers pretty soon.
The Chinese EV manufacturers will also be eating the German Chinese car market share (nearly all ICE), up to a third of the sales of VW, BMW, Mercedes, Audi etc. are in China. With a lack of affordable natural gas helping to shut down their factories in Germany, the coming winter will be a hard one for German car manufacturers; as well as for other industries competing with a China that has cheap Russian and local natural gas and coal.
New Tesla Model 3 rival 700km range $26,800 Shenlan SL03
China’s EV market hits 31% – over 50% of all EVs worldwide
The Ukraine conflict just keeps on giving to Russia and China, while exacerbating the lack of competitiveness of European industry.

Posted by: Roger | Jun 29 2022 21:30 utc | 116

#90, Scorpion: thanks,
kabuki? absolutely!
I am beyond astonished that this clown is still in office, allegedly making war making decisions (see susan rice, valerie jarrett, obumer and giggles harris) but it speaks to the the utter rot, uselessness, and corruption of the uniparty.
Now they are talking about “limited” nuclear war, attempting to plumb the depths of utter stupidity.
I doubt if Shoigu is too concerned about a few thousand 101 Airborne troops but it does ratchet up the ante.

Posted by: Thomas | Jun 29 2022 21:36 utc | 117

ostro @116–
Belarus was gifted a significant portion of the port of Bronka, which is at St. Petersburg, which Lukashenko discussed with Putin during their meeting on the 25th.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 21:41 utc | 118

@ librul # 2
Empire To Expand NATO In Response To War Caused By NATO Expansion (Caitlin Johnstone)
With the expansion of NATO’s partners and geographic scope, I’m going to trademark Panthalassa Treaty Organization (PATO). That should get me a little bit of dough.

Posted by: Leuk | Jun 29 2022 21:46 utc | 119

If Russia’s goal in Ukraine is to enlarge Russian territory, Putin has a funny way of going about it.
Posted by: Ed Nelson | Jun 29 2022 21:18 utc | 113
I do not think that the goal of SMO is to “enlarge Russian territory” as you say. Russia insisted on Minsk agreements because it did not want Ukraine broken up. That is true even today. Ukraine broken up into pieces may be more difficult to manage than Ukraine in its present borders under a new pro-Russian government. Russia recognized Donbas republics’ independence to give legal cover to its intervention, but I would not be surprised if it negotiated that they remain in new Ukraine. Yes, it is a tall order, but from the perspective of Ukraine politics in the future pro-Russian regions would be a much needed balance to the regions not so inclined.
You also said “In 2014 the DPR and the LPR (the Donbas region) voted to leave Ukraine and become a part of Russia.”
At the time they wanted independence, and Russia did not want to break up the country. They may have wanted to join Russia but that would have put them both in an impossible situation internationally. Crimea was different but still there was an uproar.

Posted by: Pagan | Jun 29 2022 21:46 utc | 120

Posted by: Roger | Jun 29 2022 21:30 utc | 117
Automotive News [MAJOR MARKET] is a trade rag I bookmarked a little over a decade ago. Periodically, I check AutomotiveNews EUROPE and AutomotiveNews CHINA, because MSM feature stories never accurately report the industry tech, sales, marketing. Go browse, but know this, it won’t be easy to fill knowledge gaps even if you’re a casual Big 3 annual report reader.
So what I’m saying is, China JV dev with US, EU manufacturers leap consumer passenger and fleet EV and “hybrid” volume production befor Obama left office or Eloon secured P&E in mainland. Over the years surfing anglo-american innerboob medium, I am confident that < 80% of chatter have a clue that China's massive domestic EV/HEV adoption and export is precisely what motivates belated NATO-allied trade sanctions (tarriff, quota, MSM bigotry). This cycle is Japan imports v USA 1970s, 2015 PV imports v Made in USA all over again. NATOstan ideologues truly kick gift horse in mouth 24/7; they do not care that low-overhead frees “advanced economy” HH cash flow L/T; and they do not want to cooperate.

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 29 2022 22:17 utc | 121

You also said “In 2014 the DPR and the LPR (the Donbas region) voted to leave Ukraine and become a part of Russia.”
At the time they wanted independence, and Russia did not want to break up the country. They may have wanted to join Russia but that would have put them both in an impossible situation internationally. Crimea was different but still there was an uproar.
Posted by: Pagan | Jun 29 2022 21:46 utc | 121
This is pure speculation of course but: my guess is that up until the beginning of the SMO Russia was open to friendly relations with the West albeit by the end of 2021 they pretty much knew it was hopeless as their firm push for a clear accord was rebuffed.
That was then. This is now. And now is a new paradigm. I believe that Russia and China are going ahead with divorcing from the West, at least for the foreseeable future. So part of the Ukraine campaign is to rid Russia of hostile aggressor on her borders and have a nice large buffer state between NATO countries and Moscow on that front. How much of Ukraine gets reconfigured remains to be seen. If things escalate to include NATO involvement, then surely all of Ukraine will be forcefully occupied and the three little Baltics probably too. Finland and Sweden will not be allowed big missile silos. And so forth.
The other and more important part is the geopolitical sphere where the intention is to so weaken the West that they can no longer be any threat militarily but above all they will no longer exert any moral or financial leverage over Eurasian rise (and many other ‘Global South’ partners). This latter is now the goal and everything aligns to that end at this point.
It’s going to be a long, hard winter in the West. If there are not major riots this summer, just wait until next!

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 29 2022 22:20 utc | 122

@ 55 SCC
Do you believe they put a man on the moon?
Alfred Hitchcock’s coming out of retirement to direct the movie ‘Our Man In Odessa’.

Posted by: WTFUD | Jun 29 2022 22:28 utc | 123

The probable experiences of Europe this winter remind me of the UK “Winter of Discontent” which lead to the thrashing of the Labour Party and a major change in UK politics that has lasted decades. Perhaps this winter of discontent will produce a thrashing for the US-puppet parties and a replacement with something else.
If only Jim Callaghan the British Labour PM had called the election in the Autumn of 1978, before the Winter of Discontent, Thatcher may never have happened …. would also have helped if he hadn’t engaged with the IMF just before the North Sea oil revenues were about to flood in.
Secret History: Winter of Discontent

Posted by: Roger | Jun 29 2022 22:30 utc | 124

“I believe that Russia and China are going ahead with divorcing from the West, at least for the foreseeable future.”
Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 29 2022 22:20 utc | 123
Agree completely. How can they have a normal relationship with Western nations behaving this way. I often think that the craziness displayed by EU, US, and NATO officials may be intentional (which does not make them any less imbeciles) in order to rebuff any potential normalization of relations with Russia and China.

Posted by: Pagan | Jun 29 2022 22:31 utc | 125

@ptb #4
I’m surprised that everyone is taking this as Lithuania taking orders rather than them doing something dumb and escalatory on their own like Poland has done repeatedly to the point that they’ve been publicly dressed down by Blinken.
It’s entirely possible given the prevailing attitudes and hysteria among Lithuanians.

Posted by: Altai | Jun 29 2022 22:35 utc | 126

the gross incompetence of the Soviet years.
Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 17:18 utc | 39
Yeah those bloody Soviets winning WW2 and all, defeating the Nazis, how grossly incompetent!
Relative to Stalin, I’ve heard Putin express heartfelt gratitude for his leadership in WW2.
Western projection of hate towards the soviets is something that i find particularly distasteful. Is hating Stalin more to do with him winning than his reprehensible behaviour? Is it irksome that Communists won the biggest war in modern history?
By most standards the Soviets were the opposite to incompetent, they saved their country from colonization. And that my friends is what I believe most Russians remember about Stalin and what Putin insists on reminding them in patriotic addresses. The soviets got a lot right and a lot wrong. Its is not black and white not is Russia’s relationship to Communism.
Russia’s two besties are not Capitalist. Interesting times.

Posted by: K | Jun 29 2022 22:37 utc | 127

“I was on both sides of the iron curtain in the 70s, 80s and 90s to have look at NATO of those days…NATO absolutely feared the USSR (and the Warsaw Pact) those days…” ostro@40
That was not my experience, which was based entirely on talking with military and political people in the UK, US and Canada. None of them was concerned that the Soviet Union would attack. They knew that it would take considerable provocation to elicit any military response from them. Most of them had the brains to respect the power of the USSR and the need to prevent any confrontation. Sensible people were extremely worried by the cruise missile and ABM crises of the early eighties. It was felt that there were madmen in Washington and in its pay who might act in such a way as to make war inevitable.
NATO as I said above, pretended to fear the USSR but only in order to frighten their own populations into going along with expensive arms budgets and the diversion of wealth from peaceful social purposes to military waste.
Now those idiots appear to be in charge. But my guess would be that the real powers in the Pentagon, for example, regard the neocon hawks and their intellectual cheerleaders with contempt

Posted by: bevin | Jun 29 2022 22:42 utc | 128

First World problem in a word
400 years later, ROW be like, I’m tired of “negotiating.” I’m done with you. WHO is with me?

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 29 2022 22:44 utc | 129

Posted by: James Cook | Jun 29 2022 19:18 utc | 71
Posted by: polarbear4 | Jun 29 2022 19:54 utc | 82
Posted by: Thomas | Jun 29 2022 20:09 utc | 86
All these moves are meaningless. Russia can counter all of them in the event of a war with NATO. I’m not saying Russia wouldn’t take some hits, but thirty NATO war games show NATO losing against Russia despite being given the initial advantage. Short of nuclear weapons, NATO can not win against Russia.
As I said in an earlier thread, so what if NATO moves in another 300,000 troops? They’re still outnumbered and outgunned by Russia. And Russia can simply mobilize their 2 million reserves. Over to you, NATO… Finally, of course, there are the hypersonic missiles that NATO simply can not defend against, which, from Russia, can neutralize every NATO and US ship in the Med.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2022 22:52 utc | 130

“…everyone is taking this as Lithuania taking orders rather than them doing something dumb and escalatory on their own …”
Posted by: Altai | Jun 29 2022 22:35 utc | 127
Lithuania is a vassal state and a very minor one. Vassal states have no agency in international arena and cannot act independently, because any unapproved action may embarrass or even endanger their allies and masters. Such behaviour cannot be condoned even if undertaken by a more important vassal.

Posted by: Pagan | Jun 29 2022 22:55 utc | 131

K @128–
Sorry, should have been more specific in my criticism. Gross mismanagement of the political-economy during the Soviet years that enabled the Rape of Russia during the 1990s.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 22:56 utc | 132

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 29 2022 22:20 utc | 123

… the intention is to so weaken the West that they can no longer be any threat militarily but above all they will no longer exert any moral or financial leverage over Eurasian rise…

As an American in my late 70s, I have given up believing the military industrial complex will bankrupt my country and thereby put war out of business. They just keep PRINTING MONEY for war, for harm, for terrorism, for atrocity. The American people have no way to stop them, no means with which to pull the plug. War is a private industry with its own printing press, its own insatiable financial fueling machine, with responsibility and answerability toward no one.
My feeling is that the Russian government understands this and that they, and the other countries in which labor and resources create actual value, know they have to fight militarily to stay alive, on top of having to provide resources to the rest of the world. The United States has become a military industrial dictatorship, a war machine with no mind.

Posted by: Linda Wood | Jun 29 2022 23:08 utc | 133

@ Posted by: Altai | Jun 29 2022 22:35 utc
>> (a) on their own like Poland has done repeatedly to the point that
>> (b) they’ve been publicly dressed down by Blinken.
(b) implies (a). But it does not prove it.

Posted by: dfg | Jun 29 2022 23:14 utc | 134

@ Down South | Jun 29 2022 17:00 utc | 28
@ ostro | Jun 29 2022 17:08 utc | 33
@ JulianJ | Jun 29 2022 17:10 utc | 35
@ Nico | Jun 29 2022 17:35 utc | 44
@ karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 17:41 utc | 45
& @ Anyone else speculating about anti-satellite weapons.
As already suggested by Nico (44) simple fragmentation bombs could be absolutely devastating to satellites. At orbital speeds, collisions even with quite pieces of debris are very destructive. Worse still, each collision is liable to create yet more fast-moving debris, potentially creating a cascade of collisions which could wipe out everyone’s satellite networks and make space unusable for decades to come. No science fictional weaponry is required.
There is already so much stuff up there that some scientists are concerned that a catastrophic cascade of collisions might already be a real possibility, and that is without deliberate acts of warfare. There was an episode of PBS spacetime devoted to the subject….
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LkeTk-Fi_c8

Posted by: MarkU | Jun 29 2022 23:18 utc | 135

I have almost the same comment as yesterday: here is a link to the main store at the ‘mall’. https://www.google.com/maps/place/Amstor/@49.0702474,33.4247481,513m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m7!3m6!1s0x40d75322b00163bb:0x9981e1c6d335dd9c!8m2!3d49.0702474!4d33.4247481!9m1!1b1
Yesterday it implied that the ‘mall’ was operating at certain hours. The day before that, according to a post on MOA, it showed Closed. Today, it shows Closed again. Some outfit is playing with the implications of that info, but they didn’t bother to look at the Reviews section in the lefthand column. Sort by Newest – latest reviews show “4 months ago”, and there are many such listed. Then it starts with “5 months ago” reviews. The ‘mall’ quit operating in early March…

Posted by: paul spencer | Jun 29 2022 23:25 utc | 136

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Jun 29 2022 20:39 utc | 101
“DPR publish their losses so a rough idea of losses to Russia LDPR side can be judged from from.”
From Interfax back on March 2nd:

MOSCOW, March 2 (Reuters) – Russia’s defence ministry said on Wednesday that 498 Russian soldiers had died in Ukraine and another 1,597 had been wounded since the beginning of Moscow’s military operation there, Russia’s RIA news agency reported… The ministry also said that more than 2,870 Ukrainian soldiers and “nationalists” had been killed and about 3,700 wounded, according to Interfax.

So at that time, seven days after the war started, when Russia was running a fast advance all over Ukraine and allegedly getting ambushed frequently, they had essentially 2,000 casualties, dead and wounded, compared to Ukraine’s 6,000 dead and wounded. That’s a ratio of 3:1 in Russia’s favor. But it’s a fairly high rate of casualties in my view for a week (although acceptable given the scale of the operation.) If it continued for the following month, then Russian losses would have been in the area of 8-10,000. If the 3:1 ratio held, the Ukrainian losses would have been 24,000 or so – which is about what Russia estimated at that time IIRC, whereas Rybar was estimating 40,000 IIRC.
Then the war changed and Russia consolidated its forces, albeit along a long front line, and resorted to classic Russian tactics: advanced until resistance met, pull back, shell everything, check for resistance and shelling what’s left, then send in tanks and infantry to mop up. Rinse and repeat. Also note that Russia was launching large numbers of missile and air attacks, which, as I’ve mentioned before, invariably cause numerous Ukrainian casualties at little risk to the Russians. At one point a couple months ago, Russia was launching over 1,000 missile strikes a day at “concentrations of manpower and equipment”. These days it’s about a third of that.
As you say, the LDNR and Chechyans and Wagner are doing ground fighting (with some Russian units, of course.) As I mentioned before, based on the DPR reports, I think ninety percent of the Ukrainian casualties are caused by Russian artillery, air and missile strikes. So while the Ukrainians are losing a thousand men a day, the rest of the Allied forces are losing maybe 100 – and Russia forces losing the least as they are behind the front manning the artillery, driving tanks, etc. Of course, everyone takes some hits, but the ratio of losses between Ukraine and Russia is likely now 10:1 instead of 3:1.
And the total is perhaps five-ten percent of Russia’s committed forces (including the allied forces), whereas Ukraine’s is half their previous contract army.
Of course, all estimates are unfortunately bullshit, but it’s the best we can do. The overall point is that Russia is in no danger of losing, and Ukraine has zero chance of winning.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2022 23:27 utc | 137

Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2022 23:27 utc | 138
That’s very similar to my estimates. Somewhere between 3-1 and 5-1 in the first phase, 10-1 or better in the second phase.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Jun 29 2022 23:32 utc | 138

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 29 2022 22:52 utc | 131
I wish like hell you and many others (including Martenov) would cut out the absurd hubris. It is as stupid as that of the yanks and almost (this is very hard) as stupid as that of the UK.
Absolutely no war is predictable. There are things like blind luck or natural disasters that can swing the game around.
Sure on paper and in trials, Russia would win against NATO but it is never a sure thing, always a big risk and only a fool encourages such potentially catastrophic actions.
My impression is that Russia will only act when pushed, ie when no other realistic options are available. This too has risks but less that those of acting too hastily.
Thing is that Russia HAS taken some big hits in the SMO. it will recover, but it is stupid to ignore them.
First was of course the failure of the diplomatic approach. One can only assume that it was US/NATO hubris ie certainty they would win the war that led them to reject what was a win/win offer by Russia. Whatever the reason it was a diplomatic loss by Russia.
Second was the partial failure of phase one of the SMO. There was of course tremendous success in the South – Kherson and Zaporizhia. However the Kiev convoy and northern incursions were NOT a success. It is stupid to put lipstick on this pig. Sure I think the Russian objective was a very quick war, Kiev negotiating, no NATO in Ukraine, independence for the two breakaways, Crimea secure. They never intended to capture Kiev but this second part was a failure, like it or not. There was a problem with the convoy to Kiev. Not sure what it was but Russia took some hits. Unfortunately for Ukraine, this only added to the US/NATO hubris and the belief that they could win the war ie drive Russia out.
Third was the loss of the Moskva. Again no use putting lipstick on this pig. It was/is a loss. It must have set back plans for Odessa a long way.
So if a full on NATO war breaks out triggered by Lithuania, yes probably Russia will win, delivering big hits to Europe, but the word is probably not certainly.

Posted by: watcher | Jun 29 2022 23:41 utc | 139

From the latest ISW assessment report:
“Russian forces continued offensive operations in and around Lysychansk”….
“Russian forces continued offensive operations east of Bakhmut”….
“Russian forces continued offensive operations northwest of Slovyansk”….
“Continued Russian offensive operations around Kharkiv”….
Of course, as far as Fat Freddie Kagan is concerned all this is evidence – nay, proof! – that the Russians are just foolishly continuing their head-long rush towards their fateful “culmination point”, after which they will fall over exhausted and the Ukrainian military will march on Moscow.
Just you wait. Any day now. Annnnnnny day.
Meanwhile, over in cloud-coo-coo-land, Pat Lang is fantasizing about Putin being assassinated by his inner core of Nikolai Patrushev, Alexander Bortnikov and Sergei Shoigu.
Or some combination therein, it’s all a bit unclear as to motive.
He is inclined to believe this because, you know, wish-fulfillment is the American way nowadays, innit?

Posted by: Yeah, Right | Jun 29 2022 23:43 utc | 140

RSH @131–
Concur. As we’ve seen with Russian artillery and missile marksmanship, any opforce is going to get clobbered wherever it sits–to survive, you must remain in motion, but that’s only versus the above weapons. NATO won’t have air superiority and thus even movement isn’t good enough, although it does slightly improve your chance to survive. Recently, the Outlaw US Empire’s DoD lowered enlistment standards for all branches because it can’t recruit willing cannon fodder or even administrative types–no more GED or HS Diploma required and related dropping of ASVAB scores for cannon fodder MOSs. AF and USN would be different as they need smarter people, although the lower standards are for them too. But war versus Russia will mostly be a land war and that means Army and AF. I suspect most NATO national forces are no better than US. And IMO, most members of those militaries never thought they’d ever have to fight Russia. Oops!
Then there’s logistics. How many transport and supply ships can NATO muster and can a supply line from North America to Europe be maintained when subs aren’t needed any longer to destroy convoys in the usual manner? How long did it take to fully garrison Saudi Arabia prior to Gulf War 1, several months using ships that no longer exist? Fuel to remain mobile will be rather difficult to accumulate or import. Russia of course enjoys inner lines of communication and supply. And for Russia, the fight is existential whereas for NATO nations it isn’t, although their colonized government will try to argue otherwise.
And as I mentioned above, Russia can inflict serious damage on the Outlaw US Empire without using nukes. Taking out the major East Coast Navy bases and commercial ports would stop the flow of supplies and reinforcements. Plus, IMO the attempts to dehumanize Russia and blame it for all ills has failed, so the public is unlikely to support such a war. And if the mainland USA gets hit, IMO a political crisis will be triggered, particularly if Wall Stret gets targeted as it should.
IMO, Russia can easily destroy Outlaw US Empire-based C&C nodes, key logistics infrastructure and selected political targets (Wall Street) using its non-nuke hypersonics, all in 20 minutes. I know it has that capability, the only question is if it decides it’s worth risking a nuclear response, which Russia may be perfectly capable of defending against. And I wonder how many on the JCoS have pondered all of the above.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 23:44 utc | 141

Posted by: Dodgy Bodger | Jun 29 2022 20:39 utc | 100
preposterous. That UN complaint is 404. Besides, erryone knows neither thr RF nor CN are capable of extra-terrestial transportation. And even if they were, we all know the fact that they stole NASA IPR is a crimes against humanity subject to international law–as soon as the docket clears all the African AUTHORITARIAN criminals. Furthermore, Eloon is gonna replace Roscosmos ISS modules any.day.now. on the way to colonizing Mars with high-net worth indivijools.

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 29 2022 23:47 utc | 142

Posted by: Linda Wood | Jun 29 2022 23:08 utc | 134
“My feeling is that the Russian government understands this and that they, and the other countries in which labor and resources create actual value, know they have to fight militarily to stay alive, on top of having to provide resources to the rest of the world. The United States has become a military industrial dictatorship, a war machine with no mind.”
Thank you for your reply. Very well said – the whole post. I agree that the Russians – AND the Chinese and many others – are very well aware of this. And either they are prepared to go toe to toe with the West in any way shape or form needed. But I also strongly suspect that a deal has already been done or will soon be in the works wherein there is a divorce leaving the West to its own devices and run by their own elites. The deal? Those Western elites have to give up on trying to control the rest of the world. Ain’t gonna happen.
This means there is also a possibility that the current conflict is semi-managed so that the Western elites get what they want: collapse, after which they can put together their techno-fascist DavosMan dystopia. Eurasia is happy to give them this opportunity especially after all the violence and turmoil they created in Ukraine when they thought they could win.
But if no deal has been made like I am imagining, then maybe the Western elites will be tempted to use a Sampson option in which case Eurasia will have to be ready. (That’s why I suspect a deal has been done: they have said to Eurasia something along the lines of: ‘look, we control the West, especially the military-industrial-political aspects. If you don’t give us a bone here we will exercise the Sampson option, don’t think we won’t. But if you give us the run of the West once our Reset is done and dusted, we can ensure that you don’t have to worry about escalation to nuclear. No way, ain’t a-gonna happen! So what do you say?’
With a deal on the table like that, why wouldn’t Eurasia go along? They are ready for some great resetting too – new financial system, new alliances, new technologies, new civilization and so forth. They’ve got a bright exciting future to build together. The only problem is the goddamn Hegemon armed to the teeth and run by fanatics, many of whom hate anyone else getting ahead or, more likely, not obeying and worshiping them. So the Hegemon has realized that M.A.D. is not a consummation devoutly to be wished and they don’t have the power any more to prevent Eurasian Rise. So now there is a dance; a little war; a little economic depression; a little famine; one more plague; and then a Brave New techno-fascist World.
And they all lived happily ever after, except for all the enslaved Europeans with chips in their arms, but hey: at least they get Universal Basic Income and lifetime Netflix subscriptions!!
The more negative fantasy along these lines is that the Eurasians will be just as ruthless managers of a techno-fascist regime. Maybe they go along with population reduction and forced medical procedures and who knows what.
Time will tell.

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 29 2022 23:49 utc | 143

paul spencer | Jun 29 2022 23:25 utc | 137
Imediatly after the event, google maps had that Amstor as Permanently closed. That has now been changed to Temporary closed.
Only men in the initial videos rather than women children and older people that would normally be seen at a shopping center. I am guessing all those men, a number in full military kit came from the plant behind the mall.
At or near the rear right corner of that mall was something the powers that be did not want us to see. Early drone footage carefully avoided that area which is where the blast occurred.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Jun 29 2022 23:50 utc | 144

watcher @140–
You assume the US Mainland won’t be involved. IMO, that’s a big mistake. The US Mainland currently is a very soft target as it has zero defenses against the weapons targeting it. And its military, economy, public, and political leadership are in no condition to wage a war against Russia.
Linda Wood @134–
I very much sympathize with your POV, but paper dollars don’t work very well in a modern war. Look at what little all the trillions already printed have provided us with–a military according to the Heritage Foundation that’s merely mediocre and mostly under repair and unusable.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 23:58 utc | 145

Posted by: Dimitri Xi Jones | Jun 29 2022 19:46 utc | 79
Public opinion well, Dutch mainstream media is acting like stenographers for Zelensky
Whatever the UK military says about Ukraine is presented as neutral and unbiased.
Everybody still remembers MH 17 of course and there is a trial in progress against some folks that are accused of transporting the SAM from A to B. They are charged with 298 counts of murder and the prosecutor demanded a life sentence, trial wil resume in September. Suspects are no where to be found.
Some small new public broadcaster that broadcasts couple of hours per week on government TV just got a fine for spreading fake news because they sad NATO expansion caused the war in Ukraine
Poeple are pissed off of course because we got 10 % inflation now, but according to polls they will still vote for the same politicians that got us into this mess.
I only voice my opinion on the war to friends and family, never to strangers , never at work, But then at work folks don’t talk about the Ukraine any more, they did the first couple of weeks but now they don’t. At my Job we drive a bunch of cars and motorcycles and well what we do talk about all the time is gas prices of course
I dont see that many Ukranian flags on houses or buildings where I live, seen like maybe 5.

Posted by: Jimmy | Jun 30 2022 0:01 utc | 146

by: mundanomaniac | Jun 29 2022 20:36 utc | 97
The rudeness and ignorance of ^ this person who only hijacks thus site to promote his own.

Posted by: Melaleuca | Jun 30 2022 0:01 utc | 147

Linda Wood @134–
I very much sympathize with your POV, but paper dollars don’t work very well in a modern war. Look at what little all the trillions already printed have provided us with–a military according to the Heritage Foundation that’s merely mediocre and mostly under repair and unusable.
Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 23:58 utc | 146
Also: it is doubtful that US has the industrial capacity along with access to raw materials any more – and especially so if their USD depreciates considerably making those materials far more expensive. As far as I can tell the West is played out. They know it and there is a collapse plan after which a reboot with entirely different rules and expectations (probably featuring drastic declines, restrictions, reductions, limitations etc.). But we’ll find out one way or another.
But any day we choose we can wake up, become sane, stop being demons and join the human race as cheerful, productive can-do people. Stranger things have happened…

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 30 2022 0:03 utc | 148

Only the US believes it can wage war without loss, and that’s because it’s well-practiced at hiding those losses. For example, US casualties in Iraq and Afghanistan don’t count contractors, who made up a large proportion of forces during the insurgency phases of both conflicts.
Russia never thought it would get Kiev. It hoped it might get Kharkov. And Kiev wasn’t to pin reinforcements going to Donbas, it was to distract the whole world from Russia’s primary strategic objective in Phase I: the Azov coast completely and a secure land bridge to Crimea. Phase II is liberation of the Donbas and degradation of the Ukr army. Phase III will primarily be about Odessa. And that’s because if Odessa isn’t taken, the US/UK will finish that naval base and essentially nullify Russia’s warm water port. Sevastopol will be in missile range; the ability blockade the Black Sea with even a relatively small naval force from NATO is real.
Kharkov in Phase III to, but I imagine less of a priority and more waiting for it to fall be squeezing slowly. Stopping at the Dnieper doesn’t much change the missile flight time, but I’d bet dollars to doughnuts that once Odessa falls the US/UK will abandon Ukrainians faster than you can stab a Kurd in the back. (Not expressing an opinion on the Kurds, just their history with the west.)

Posted by: Lex | Jun 30 2022 0:05 utc | 149

Lithuania is a vassal state and a very minor one.
Posted by: Pagan | Jun 29 2022 22:55 utc | 132
No. Lithuania is not a vassal state. Lithuanis is a sovereign state. Name just one “mandate” or “mechanism” that compels its government to enact any public project contrary to its constituents’ instructions.

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 30 2022 0:08 utc | 150

bevin @ 129
Well written, those were much cooler times than today. Lithuanian appears to be the perfect place for NATO to escalate. It is no great loss to them and Russian retaliation will speed up their ability to build out a force.
The can pound their chests and rally around their 2 percent to build up their arms supplies. It would be something that would solidify NATO into an increased state of readiness.
The other day on Russian television a retired general basically said they could turn Western Europe into an icicle in short order. All they need to do is calibrate a few ports and LNG facilities. No more oil, gas, diesel, or natural gas for you.
All bets are off now, war is coming.

Posted by: circumspect | Jun 30 2022 0:15 utc | 151

@127 Altai
I hope so, but am skeptical.
I feel like it’s just a variation on the “good cop / bad cop” hustle. So the bigger power (the US with PL, or the EC with LIT) can stay a step removed and have a fig leaf of oh-we-didn’t-really-mean-it, if it all goes to shit… while still enjoying what they reckon is the benefit of more risk being taken.

Posted by: ptb | Jun 30 2022 0:16 utc | 152

Posted by: Roger | Jun 29 2022 21:30 utc | 117
Germany demise will be good news #1 for the French, #2 for the Brits.

Posted by: Greg Galloway | Jun 30 2022 0:21 utc | 153

watcher | Jun 29 2022 23:41 utc | 140
First phase was a partial failure by Russia. That would have to compared to their stated objectives for phase one. Do you remember or have a link of those objectives?
To me looking at the first phase – Two nuclear sites, one containing according to the west 30 tons of plutonium and 40 tons of enriched uranium three or more bio weapons sites with a treasure trove of documents, Azov nazis plus nato locked in Mariupol, All of Kherson securing Crimea water supply, land bridge to Crimea, and last but not least, 50% of Luhansk oblast.
Take note of when Russia pulled back its forces threatening Kiev. It was only when Mariupol was securely locked in, when no forces could break in or break out that Russia withdrew its forces in the north. Threatening Kiev and Kharkiv, Ukraines two biggest cities tied up a large number of Ukraine forces.
Russia accepted casualties for huge gains in that initial phase. Second phase is at a different pace different tactics. Its now a bit of practical work experience for its military that if it wishes to can continue indefinitely.
The old saying don’t interfere while your enemy is making mistakes. The longer the war goes on in Ukraine, the more mistakes the US west will make. The big picture is in what karlof1 posts here.
Ukraine is essentially a sideshow/glittery object/polished turd in the bigger contest. Russia vs the senile warmongers of the west.

Posted by: Peter AU1 | Jun 30 2022 0:22 utc | 154

karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 23:58 utc | 146
yeah, wait until they hit a shopping mall in Wobbleville, SC or Val Dosta, GA…or until one is staged, to keep the peeps raged out. a psyop against a homeless pop camping out in a Wal Mart parking lot could be a real two-fer for the PTB’s…and for information management, just tell people a russian missile hit one or some of the port a poopies in said shopping center parking lot, and you’ve got instant control of the area, and control of media coverage, w/this toxic airborne event + chemical spill you just staged…
does a country facing an ‘existential threat’ from a foreign foe stage a massive domestic conflict, really over nothing thanks to contraception, unless that foreign threat is bullshit, a PR scam like the abortion “debate” itself?

Posted by: rjb1.5 | Jun 30 2022 0:23 utc | 155

In Krivoy Rog, they want to make Biden Street instead of Pushkin Street.
▪️Boris Johnson Street instead of pilot Vodopyanov Street
▪️John McCain Street instead of Armavir.
Deja Vu Kosovo and Bosnia. In Sarajevo and Pristina street names Clinton, Albright,….
Everything reminds me Nato aggression against Serbia.
SAME PLAYBOOK!
What we ve learned from Nato aggression vs Serbia?
NEVER EVER SIGN ANY CEASEFIRE or AGREEMENT! ITS ONLY A TRAP! THEY WANT TO BUY TIME!
MILOSEVIC HAS ALWAYS FALLEN AGAIN AND AGAIN INTO THESE PEACE TRAP.
As a reward for his cooperation the new serbian traitor government has brought him to The Hague

Posted by: Chessmaster | Jun 30 2022 0:26 utc | 156

Pepe’s been busy! I highly suggest his latest, “You’re either with us or you’re a ‘systemic challenge'”. An important part of the Big Picture:

Yet the notion that “ideas and projects originating in the illiberal West continue to shape global politics” is nonsense, as Xi in fact is inspired by Mao as much as Putin is inspired by several Eurasianist theoreticians. What’s relevant is that in the process of the West plunging into a geopolitical abyss, “Western liberalism has itself become illiberal.”
Much worse: it actually became totalitarian.

More:
“Fabio Vighi has brilliantly outlined how ‘the purpose of the Ukrainian emergency is to keep the money printer switched on while blaming Putin for worldwide economic downturn. The war serves the opposite aim of what we are told: not to defend Ukraine but to prolong the conflict and nourish inflation in a bid to defuse cataclysmic risk in the debt market, which would spread like wildfire across the whole financial sector.'”
Yes, the FIRE sector indeed needs a fire to burn itself out of existence.
But as Pepe himself admits, so much of what just transpired at the G-7 and NATO Summits has been seen and written about before and borders on being no more than a rerun. What’s all new and exciting is all in Eurasia and Global South. The West shrieks that it remains relevant, but nobody is listening anymore.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 30 2022 0:26 utc | 157

i know all you folks are pretty serious about all this, but i found this rt article that seemed to sum up some of the major differences between the west and russia here… on the one hand you have comedians in positions of power and on the other you have an intelligent, thoughtful person leading russia! the differences couldn’t be more stark.. this is what we are probably dealing with on the war front as well… leadership by bozos, verses leadership by an actual leader.. now, maybe i am being a bit too cynical on the western leaders here, but from everything i see – i think richards hubris may not be as dramatic as suggested above… in fact – richard might actually be closer to the reality on the ground – which is always an impossible thing to figure out either way, until much later…
Vladimir Putin comments on Boris Johnson’s remarks……………
Speaking to journalists in Turkmenistan on Monday, Russian President Vladimir Putin responded to questions about several recent remarks from British Prime Minister Boris Johnson. During the latest G7 summit, the UK leader joked that his allies should take their clothes off for the photoshoot – to show that they are “tougher than Putin.”
“I don’t know how they wanted to undress, waist-high or not, but I think it would be a disgusting sight either way,” the Russian president quipped. “Everything should be harmoniously developed in a person, both the body and the soul. However, in order for everything to be harmonious, one has to abandon excessive drinking and break other bad habits, start exercising, take up a sport.”
Johnson’s another recent remark suggested that what he described as a “macho war of invasion” in Ukraine would not happen “if Putin was a woman, which he obviously isn’t.”
The Russian leader responded: “I just want to remind you about the events of modern history, when Margaret Thatcher made a decision to launch military action against Argentina over the Falkland Islands. Here’s a woman, deciding to launch military action. Where are the Falkland Islands and where is Britain? And this was dictated by nothing but imperial ambitions.”
“So coming from an acting British Prime Minister, this is not exactly a correct remark in regards to what is happening today.”

Posted by: james | Jun 30 2022 0:27 utc | 158

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 29 2022 23:58 utc | 146
No I was not really assuming the US mainland would not be involved. I was perhaps hoping it would not go nuclear. My gut feel is that a strike on the US mainland would make the war go nuclear, and Russia may well baulk at that.
More to the point I was just saying do not be over optimistic. Things go wrong.
Yes i think if there is any serious attempt by NATO to take out Karlingrad, then yes a strike on the US homeland is likely – probably the Pentagon, but perhaps more symbolically, CIA headquarters. Much, much less likely to cause nuclear retaliation, given how many people in the USA hate the organisation.
Anyway I am hoping that wiser heads prevail and the Karlingrad thing blows over.

Posted by: watcher | Jun 30 2022 0:27 utc | 159

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 29 2022 18:01 utc | 52
This raw fish is having great difficulty with reality.
Ukraine has forced conscription of everyone from age 18 to 60, male or female, blonde, disabled or not.
Yet when 1,000 Ukrainian citizens are found out shopping when they should be enlisting, going to 1 day boot camp, and then straight into the trenches of the Donbass, the world erupts in great indignation.
Why is this?
Under the laws of Ukraine can you not be shot for failing to obey the forced conscription law? Does not Z have the authority to put 1,000 shoppers a day up against the wall? Is this not a great waste of scarce NATO resources?
Does not one RF missile save the Z regime thousands of NATO bullets?
If the draft evaders are not shot in the mall is it not true that they will get their 6.5 hours of basic training, learn which end of a rifle is the bad end, how to eat cardboard chicken, and live in a grave trench for 3 days before the incoming artillery strike makes drying your socks completely unnecessary?
Why is that when the citizens of Ukraine are dispatched by the Z regime this is a great heroic event, but to be killed by the Z forces is totally immoral and repugnant to all the citizens of the world?
Do the dead really have a preference one way or another?
The only way I can cope with these issues is by channelling my inner Joe Tzu.
The art of war lies in graduated response
Never go senile all at once.
Joe Tzu

Posted by: Sushi | Jun 30 2022 0:28 utc | 160

< a href="https://www.robert-schuman.eu/en/eem/0183-referendum-on-the-european-union-in-lithuania-10th-11th-may-2003"10/05/2003 - Analysis

“I support Lithuania’s membership of the European Union.” This is the sentence that appears on the ballot paper that the majority of Lithuanians should place in the box on 10th and 11th May when the European referendum takes place in this Baltic State the population of which has always supported the country’s integration into the Union

Irish Times

Lithuania’s 91% Yes vote for joining EU a signal to others
LITHUANIA

Why you gonna argue a nearly a decade later that Lithuanians did not voluntarily elect to join an international Single Market treaty signifies “vassalage”? Do you not understand WHY people incorporate? Ot are you certain that the peoples of Lithuania could yet accomplish their goals alone?

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 30 2022 0:29 utc | 161

@144 Scorpion
I don’t think they’re organized enough, or united enough, to pull something like that off.
There might be factions in the Western power structure who would go for what you say, but there are also balls-to-the-wall hegemonists, true-believer-exceptionalists, and neocon-aka-idiot-imperialist types. And they all rose to power thru their skill in sabotaging each other (not to speak of foreign rivals and sometimes partners too).

Posted by: ptb | Jun 30 2022 0:32 utc | 162

Posted by: Lex | Jun 30 2022 0:05 utc | 150
Pretty much fully agree. Kharkov was a disappointment I am sure. But Kiev was always going to be the basis for some sort of negotiation, not occupied. At least it was when the intent was to still have an independent Ukraine- Russian sympathetic perhaps but still independent. Not sure that is still the plan.
I guess I will not say Russia has won or is winning until Odessa is taken. Without Odessa, the war will be a long one of attrition, and even if there is a negotiated settlement, it will start up all over again in 5-10 years.

Posted by: watcher | Jun 30 2022 0:35 utc | 163

Posted by: watcher | Jun 29 2022 23:41 utc | 140
You’re clueless. Not surprising, since I’ve dealt with your BS before. A master of hand-waving and not much else.
In particular, describing the rejection by the West of Russia’s treaty proposals as a “diplomatic failure” is risible. That was a failure by the West. Russia offered them a way out, fully expecting the West wouldn’t take it, which is why Russia spent 2021 preparing the Ukraine war in parallel with the development of those proposals.
Moskva had nothing to do with any Odessa invasion, which, as long as the area was mined, was never in the cards. Not to mention we still don’t know what actually happened to the ship, as the one apparently valid pictures does not show missile damage according to most analysts. So it could have been a mine or could have been what the Russians said: a fire and armaments explosion.
And the Kiev gambit has been debunked so many times only a moron like you would still bring it up.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 30 2022 0:35 utc | 164

Hostilities between NATO and Russia will not ease. NATO is modernizing weapons. Russia cannot match the dollars. Way too much. Instead Russia must restore its biological weapons program. USA has already done so.
North America is isolated from the rest of the world. Any serious biological event there won’t affect most humans (95 percent) as much. It will also force other US lackeys to cut close ties which will allow progressive powers to dominate.
The same cannot be done to Russia.

Posted by: Jason | Jun 30 2022 0:36 utc | 165

Posted by: james | Jun 30 2022 0:27 utc | 159
“the UK leader joked that his allies should take their clothes off for the photoshoot – to show that they are “tougher than Putin.””
I’d like to see fat-boy Johnson go up against high-ranked judo black belt Putin. LOL

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 30 2022 0:39 utc | 166

In Krivoy Rog, they want to make Biden Street instead of Pushkin Street.
▪️Boris Johnson Street instead of pilot Vodopyanov Street
▪️John McCain Street instead of Armavir.
Reminds me Kosovo and Bosnia. In Sarajevo and Pristina street names Clinton, Albright, Kohl, Joschka Fischer,…..
SAME PLAYBOOK like Nato aggression vs Serbia.
What we ve learned from the Serbian theatre?
NEVER EVER SIGN ANY AGREEMENT OR CEASEFIRE! ITS ONLY A TRAP!
Milosevic has every time fallen into Nato trap. He was so stupid naive.
As a reward the new western installed government has brought him to The Hague.

Posted by: Chessmaster | Jun 30 2022 0:39 utc | 167

rjb1.5 @156–
You mean something like 911? How long did that saga last? Most of the day, yes? I’m talking something extremely devastating that will be over in a few minutes leaving between a dozen to 16 smoking piles of twisted metal, cement and other rubble that will decapitate the US government, its Neoliberal Parasite Center, and its strategic East Coast military and commercial ports without generating any radioactive fallout with very little damage to civilians and their infrastructure. That’s what war with Russia means for the Outlaw US Empire–Defeat.

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 30 2022 0:39 utc | 168

“I don’t know how they wanted to undress, waist-high or not, but I think it would be a disgusting sight either way,” the Russian president quipped. “Everything should be harmoniously developed in a person, both the body and the soul. However, in order for everything to be harmonious, one has to abandon excessive drinking and break other bad habits, start exercising, take up a sport.
Posted by: james | Jun 30 2022 0:27 utc | 159
Hilarious and true, Thanks James 🙂
Putin is a man of self discipline and spiritual balance as well as having an orientation of service. Rare indeed and as usual Boris is a joke.
Western leaders devour everything and sacrifice nothing therefore they have no character or moral compass.

Posted by: K | Jun 30 2022 0:42 utc | 169

@ Sushi | Jun 30 2022 0:28 utc | 161
brilliant!! and very good for a raw fish too, i might add! but then i always did love sushi!

Posted by: james | Jun 30 2022 0:43 utc | 170

@ K | Jun 30 2022 0:42 utc | 170
thanks k… and i like how you challenged karlof1 on that quote which he had to clarify afterwards… cheers.

Posted by: james | Jun 30 2022 0:44 utc | 171

Jason @166–
The two ponds don’t protect the Outlaw US Empire’s mainland anymore. In fact, as I’ve commented above several times, the mainland is a very soft target that’s essentially undefended. The Neoliberal Parasites need to wake up to that reality. They don’t hold a winning hand, nor can they outdraw their opponents. Reality says they’ve already lost. But they’re clearly blinded by their pleonexia–“the insatiable desire to have what rightfully belongs to others.”

Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 30 2022 0:55 utc | 172

@170 I’m not sure I really need to see Ursula van de Leyden topless. But I thought it was very crafty of Boris to turn the Ukraine situation into a gender issue.

Posted by: dh | Jun 30 2022 0:55 utc | 173

I’m re-posting something from yesterday’s thread with the initial link included – seriously…it’s worth reading…just open the link and click on the pdf – CIA planning doc about Ukraine from 1957.
CIA Doc – Resistance Factors in Ukraine
I have been reading the sections where the CIA analyzes the parts of Ukraine which oppose/support the USSR/Russia. The CIA (thus the US government planning apparatus) clearly knew (and knows) that the entire southern (Odessa to Kherson) and eastern parts of Ukraine (Donbass) are either culturally Russian, ethnically Russian, or supports the Russian (USSR back then) government. The document also clearly shows that the CIA was planning operations for western Ukraine at that time and this probably connects to the ‘stay behind’ operations connected to Operation Gladio (I’ve just purchased a few books about this topic).
Also, I was just listening to the Multipolarista podcast where I learned about this interesting article from January 2022 re: CIA/US planning and involvement in preparation for war with Russia pre-SMO. Another interesting read.
Link to article re: CIA in Ukraine pre-SMO
Cheers!

Posted by: Objective Observer | Jun 30 2022 0:56 utc | 174

North America is isolated from the rest of the world. Any serious biological event there won’t affect most humans (95 percent) as much.
sorta like how N. America was able to withstand the spread of the last few virus pandemics. There’s no nation isolated enough (N. Korea included) to be immune from the gnarly pathogens cooked up by the white-coated sociopaths working for the even more sociopathic global elite.

Posted by: Milton | Jun 30 2022 0:56 utc | 175

Posted by: sln2002 | Jun 29 2022 23:47 utc | 143
I am sorry 4 404 try…
https://www.unoosa.org/res/oosadoc/data/documents/2021/aac_105/aac_1051262_0_html/AAC105_1262E.pdf

Posted by: Dodgy Bodger | Jun 30 2022 1:01 utc | 176

Posted by: Sushi | Jun 30 2022 0:28 utc | 161
“The only way I can cope with these issues is by channelling my inner Joe Tzu.
The art of war lies in graduated response
Never go senile all at once. Joe Tzu”
Like I said earlier: A Master!!
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
I wandered lonely but still proud
The secret service wave a shroud
Screaming something very loud
Drowned out by yonder mushroom cloud!
Spontaneously Composed Doggerel by
Hilarious Joe Belloc
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 30 2022 1:17 utc | 177

karlof1 | Jun 30 2022 0:39 utc | 169
sorry, i don’t think russia is dumb enough to attack the US at all at this point, certainly not at some random shopping center. were such an attack to occur, it would undoubtedly be a “white helmet” affair, whose sole purpose would be to keep enflamed the baseless hysterical war passions of a gullible populace that is already tiring of the latest in atrocity theater from Ukraine. (and, with such a stage managed affair, why not take out the garbage, the human refuse piling up in our shopping mall parking lots, at the same time? i probably shouldn’t be giving our leaders any ideas…)
but, based on the ongoing detailed analysis provided by you, the host, rsh, et al, “winning the war” is no longer possible. and they know it. so what’s the game, and how to keep it running? probably others, but i thought of two reasons:
one, the war wastes a lot of money, and, for the US audience on the other side of the planet, can be made to disappear in a way that it cannot in e.g., Germany, Poland, etc. partly, w/the purchase of toys like the F35, such waste is a kind of “tribute” to the hegemon, as people have noted. much easier in the US to blame it all on Russia than in countries which, by proximity, have more skin in the game.
two, the war enables the further “command and control” militarization of society and authoritarianism, as western societies strain, groan, creak and likely collapse under the bloat of corruption and dysfunctionality. that airsuit that holds Baron Harkonnen aloft is about to deflate or run out of gas, leaving a beached diabetic baby whale with no diapers or bottle floundering and flopping around. but, until then, domestic control, austerity, totalitarianism, is in. the constant external threat justifies the regime of oppression, wherein something like going on strike at Amazon or even reading “the Idiot” become “aiding and abetting” the enemy.

Posted by: rjb1.5 | Jun 30 2022 1:19 utc | 178

@S 43
According to the UN Convention on Genocide, which is definitive, Genocide can indubitably target cultural groups.

Article II
In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with
intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
(a) Killing members of the group;
(b) Causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group;
(c) Deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its
physical destruction in whole or in part;
(d) Imposing measures intended to prevent births within the group;
(e) Forcibly transferring children of the group to another group.

Posted by: Hermit | Jun 30 2022 1:26 utc | 179

Posted by: DutchZ | Jun 29 2022 16:49 utc | 22
“If voting made any difference, they would’t let us” (as old as the idea of democracy)
This applies to some countries at least. It’s a pretty big list.

Posted by: Tard | Jun 30 2022 1:53 utc | 180

Richard Steven Hack @131
well that makes me feel better. :o)
i hear conflicting news on how many trained troops there are. iirc, putin recently started a mobilization/training program.
i do believe that russia has the advantage of fighting with her heart and soul, as she has captured so many of ours. and that gives her a huge advantage.
ukraine and nato are fighting out of hate and entitlement and greed.

Posted by: polarbear4 | Jun 30 2022 1:59 utc | 181

Linda @134
well said!

Posted by: polarbear4 | Jun 30 2022 2:02 utc | 182

Lithuania is contemptible. I cannot respect a nation that hates Russia more than it cares about its own people. They cling to sanctions on Kaliningrad even after the EU says they don’t have to. They do – or try to – deny fertilizer shipments from Belarus – that hungry people need elsewhere.
Their inflation rate is about 16%. They are literally a dying nation as young people emigrate and their birth rate is awful. When a depopulated aging country with a bad economy is willing to injure its own people in service to the US/EU, how can it be anything other than a vassal?

Posted by: Eighthman | Jun 30 2022 2:09 utc | 183

There might be factions in the Western power structure who would go for what you say, but there are also balls-to-the-wall hegemonists, true-believer-exceptionalists, and neocon-aka-idiot-imperialist types. And they all rose to power thru their skill in sabotaging each other (not to speak of foreign rivals and sometimes partners too).
Posted by: ptb | Jun 30 2022 0:32 utc | 163
Well – obviously – am out on a limb speculating. But the sheer stupidity is becoming suspicious. If they were just stupid but trying to do well then some things would be so-so OK and others would tank. But for a while now everything they do – at least in the US – is all wrong every time. It smacks of coordination.
And look at Europe: every single leader at the same time agreeing in lockstep to overwhelmingly stupid and terrible policies. Since when do European leaders agree on anything? Never. Again, it smacks of coordination.
And take Russia-China. Right now what do they want? Do create a new system free of Western interference to which end they want nothing better than US-EU weakness or worse. And US-EU is giving them what they want on a platter! Coincidence or happenstance? Possibly. But really, everything is so consistently following the same vector….
As to your possible list above: take away the hegemons and the rest are probably the ones. But also hegemons can change: if the name of the game is no longer capturing Eurasian countries but exploiting home-grown populations in a new techno-fascist regime, they might feel fine being the Titan-Lords of such a dystopia with captive populations to toy with.
Anyway, I guess we’ll be finding out in the next 6-36 months, eh?

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 30 2022 2:20 utc | 184

@ Don Bacon, 23
@ nook | Jun 29 2022 18:12 utc | 54
@ | Jun 29 2022 18:22 utc | 55
Regarding those pics, the NYT picture has camouflaged the damage to the factory by carefully manipulating the angle the picture was taken.
If one looks directly back from the mall, one can see a small pink-and-white building with a dirt yard behind it. There appears to be debris in that yard that hasn’t yet been removed. Correct me if I’m wrong, but doesn’t the long building behind that one have a lot of roof damage to it? That building runs diagonally behind the building with the facade at the entrance, painted pink-and-white off to the left.
It’s my guess that’s where the missile landed, and we can’t see the damage to the factory because it’s being hidden by that pink-and-white building. The entire area appears to slope downwards not-too-gently away from the shopping mall–the larger pink-and-white building with a facade is clearly at a lower elevation than the factory sections in front of it.
That’s my best guess as to why we can’t see any damage in the photo. Also, it appears that the video of the damage shows a few of the buildings that can be found at the rear of that section of (what appears to be) the warehouse. I believe that the buildings in the video more-or-less match what can be found on the aerial view to the rear of that building–buildings which are mostly hidden in the NYT picture.

Posted by: Pacifica Advocate | Jun 30 2022 2:27 utc | 185

democracy: governance by the people
Outcome of Ukraine war will determine long-term American security, senators attending NATO summit say

Two members of the Senate NATO Observer Group vowed Wednesday to keep the American public engaged with the war in Ukraine despite inflation and other domestic challenges, linking the outcome of the conflict to long-term national security.
Thom Tillis, R-N.C. . .“[People] need to understand that Vladimir Putin is playing a chess game,” Tillis said at a forum in Madrid. “He’s trying to reestablish an empire, and it only starts with the success in Ukraine and it continues. So yes, to that constituent of mine in North Carolina, [Ukraine] may seem an ocean away, but they’re not. And every time we turn our backs, we live to regret it.”. . .here

These “wise men and women,” these senators, know better than their constituents that war is necessary. Most Americans probably don’t give a hoot about Ukraine, or even know or care where it is. The senators expect their constituents to follow their wise senatorial counsel, aided by the MSM of course, when it should be the other way around, with senators representing constituents.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Jun 30 2022 2:37 utc | 186

@ La Bastille | Jun 29 2022 20:38 utc | 99

More video from the Shopping Mall
Today French TV LCI was in the Kredmash factory. Just have a look at the first 2 mn. The “mall” is really close from the factory, was hit on northeast corner [or railways]
French TV conclusion is that the first missile hit the factory and the second one probably missed a few meters.
French LCI :
https://youtu.be/XE26ZH-SX3

Do you have another link to that footage, La Bastille?
YouTube has already taken it down. Perhaps there’s something on Rumble?

Posted by: Pacifica Advocate | Jun 30 2022 2:43 utc | 187

Posted by: polarbear4 | Jun 30 2022 1:59 utc | 182
“putin recently started a mobilization/training program.”
Russia does mobilization – or perhaps conscription might be a better phrase – programs twice a year. New conscripts undergo up to eight months of training before being sent to designated units. Mandatory conscription lasts for 12 months, after which the soldiers can join Russia’s two million-strong military reserves.
Also, under Russian law, conscripts can’t serve outside Russia’s borders (presumably unless there is a general war mobilization), although allegedly some did end up in Ukraine where they were pulled out after it became public knowledge.
In short, it has nothing to do with the progress of the war.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 30 2022 2:52 utc | 188

When you have been beaten in battle by your enemy, refocus your efforts against your allies. That way, now where did I leave my pants?
~ Joe Tzu

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Jun 30 2022 2:53 utc | 189

Are we STILL discussing the shopping mall, which has already been adequately explained? Some people have a lot of free time.
It might be better spent by viewing Mercouris’ latest video, in which along with an update on the Donbass situation, he discusses Erdogan’s approval of Sweden and Finland being admitted to NATO, the history of Swedish and Finland “neutrality” – which doesn’t exist – and also the “Russian default” and the insanity of the “oil price cap” which apparently the idiots at the G7 want to apply to all oil-producing countries, which is even more insane.
Russia Traps Ukraine Troops in Lysychansk, Turkey Drops Veto on Sweden Finland-NATO, Russia Unfazed
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSPvz4LuoSw

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 30 2022 2:57 utc | 190

Remember, the journey of a hundred shuffling steps to the bathroom begins with a stumble.
~ Joe Tzu

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Jun 30 2022 2:58 utc | 191

@Richard Steven Hack #138

As you say, the LDNR and Chechyans and Wagner are doing ground fighting (with some Russian units, of course.)

Russian MoD has denied that Wagner mercenaries are fighting for Russia in Ukraine, understandable given Russian statements on Western mercs. What evidence is there that they are indeed fighting for Russia in Ukraine?

Posted by: Kingsmeg | Jun 30 2022 3:07 utc | 192

When meeting your adversary in negotiations, do not show fear and remember to bring two pairs of shorts.
~ Joe Tzu

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Jun 30 2022 3:22 utc | 193

Reality says they’ve already lost. But they’re clearly blinded by their pleonexia–“the insatiable desire to have what rightfully belongs to others.”
Posted by: karlof1 | Jun 30 2022 0:55 utc | 173
That reminds of a quip attributed to Reagan, but it could have been just a joke about him: Allegedly he said “What’s our oil doing under their sand?”

Posted by: Pagan | Jun 30 2022 3:22 utc | 194

The Russian leader responded: “I just want to remind you about the events of modern history, when Margaret Thatcher made a decision to launch military action against Argentina over the Falkland Islands. Here’s a woman, deciding to launch military action. Where are the Falkland Islands and where is Britain? And this was dictated by nothing but imperial ambitions.”
Posted by: james | Jun 30 2022 0:27 utc | 159

Yes, Putin sometimes gets things wrong. In the subsequent referendum in the Falkland Islands, only 3 people voted to join Argentina. A better result than even Crimea. So Thatcher was acting under a valid Responsibility to Protect requested by the descendants of Brits, like the descendants of Russians in Donbass.
Find better examples VVP, there are lots out there.

Posted by: Opport Knocks | Jun 30 2022 3:24 utc | 195

Posted by: Kingsmeg | Jun 30 2022 3:07 utc | 193
I have no idea. It just seems to be the consensus on Telegram channels. In any event, by some accounts the number ranges from 300 to 1,000, so they’re not particularly significant, if they are there.

Posted by: Richard Steven Hack | Jun 30 2022 3:31 utc | 196

Posted by: Kingsmeg | Jun 30 2022 3:07 utc | 193
I have always thought the Wagner Group is a private mercenary force which may include some Russians but which is not connected to the Russian government. I think this because our media sources imply that it is run by the Russian government, and because our media sources lie about the Russian government, I think Wagner may be run by the CIA. Or it may be a private group run by oligarchs of any country. But I believe the Russian government because their credibility is sound.

Posted by: Linda Wood | Jun 30 2022 3:50 utc | 197

We’re not following the same Telegram channels then.
And I don’t know what use a bunch of mercenaries (aka terrorists) would be on the front lines of an artillery shoot-out.
I’m not saying they aren’t there, but I have seen obviously fake Ukie propaganda trying to prove they are, and I read the denial by the Ru DoD saying they aren’t.

Posted by: Kingsmeg | Jun 30 2022 3:51 utc | 198

@scorpion #90
“I’m not sure I buy it. I can’t help but suspect that this entire thing is political kabuki…”
Yeah, for sure. Always more under the table than over the table. What I am watching is the huge shift underway to appeal to conservative elements of the US, reversing abortion rights, reinstalling prayer in schools, why so much and why all of a sudden?
A distraction from the war?
A distraction from something else?

Posted by: HelenB | Jun 30 2022 3:54 utc | 199

fyi, a well worth while thread, and here are a few snippets
from Will Schryver’s
Observations on the Ukraine War, 2022-06-28
https://twitter.com/imetatronink/status/1541780685937332224
“…..But it is irrelevant. Because, since no later than the Korean War, the US has not faced a peer or near-peer adversary in a high-intensity conflict. The US military has not been, for almost three-quarters of century, truly tested “under-fire”. This is an indisputable fact.
The US has measured its battlefield mettle, for decades, against brave sandal-shod men with AK-47s, RPGs, and a certain savoir faire for constructing IEDs. But they have *never* faced anything like Russian artillery or missiles. Not even in Hollywood movies or video games….
….They deluded themselves into believing the Russians lacked: strategic and logistical acumen, a sufficiently well-trained force, and – arguably the biggest miscalculation of all – sufficient stockpiles of ammo to conduct a protracted high-intensity conflict….
…In short, I have come to believe the US/NATO actually persuaded themselves that this “Mother of All Proxy Armies” they built in Ukraine seriously had an excellent chance to soundly whip the Russians in a battle situated on their borders.
In other words, they not only grossly underestimated their enemy, but they ignored centuries of history that they somehow convinced themselves had no relevance to their 21st century aspirations to defeat Russia militarily and take a great spoil of its resources.
Even more revealing is that once-vaunted and universally feared US/UK weaponry – almost all of it rather antiquated – has proven to be far less “game-changing” than the pea-brained strategists in Washington and Whitehall mistakenly believed.
Javelins, NLAWs, and Stingers have been exposed as effectively useless against their intended targets. M-777 howitzers break down after just a few fires. GPS-guided “precision” munitions are routinely jammed by Russian EW counter-measures.
…..What sober military men in potential adversary countries across the globe see is that Russia has, with one hand tied behind its back, eviscerated the massive, relatively well-armed and well-trained Ukraine military. The US intimidation factor has been forever compromised…..
…More concerningly, the Chinese have been watching all of these developments with great interest. They are almost certain to be emboldened to act decisively to secure their sphere of influence in the emerging multipolar world. Great dangers now await in east Asia.”

Posted by: michaelj72 | Jun 30 2022 3:59 utc | 200