Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
June 24, 2022
Ukraine SitRep – Zolote Cauldron Closes – Lysichansk Blocked (Corrected twice)

[Corrected (twice) below]

In the last situation report about the war in Ukraine I discussed the situation near Lysichansk.

The Ukrainian leadership is still sending new units into the Lysichansk cauldron in the east. The Russians do not mind that. Their job is to "demilitarize" Ukraine. To enclose more troops in one swoop makes that easier.


bigger

The distance between the red Russian held area at the the top to the one at the bottom at the most narrow gap is a mere 15 kilometer or some 9 miles. There is only one open road running through it from west to east which is used for pushing resupplies to the Ukrainian troops in Lysichansk.

The map has since changed significantly:


Jun 16

Source: LiveUAmapbigger

What developed was first a smaller cauldron around Zolote at the bottom of the map.

Jun 18

bigger

This was a classic move done by the book.

Jun 20

bigger

Then a battalion of Ukrainian troops that was supposed to hold the villages in the upper area of the pocket retreated. Some say they were ordered to leave, others claim they mutinited. The later is more likely as these were amateur infantry from the Territorial Defense Forces who, without sufficient support, had been send to replace better troops that were ordered back.

Jun 22

bigger

The Russians on the eastern wing moved west to take 5 villages in one day along the pocket's northern border.

Jun 24

bigger

That put the lid onto the cauldron which immediately began to cook the estimated 2,000 Ukrainian soldiers who were inside.

The above maps are quite rough. A more detailed one from the Russian side shows that several towns within the Zolote cauldron have not yet been cleared.

Jun 24

bigger

In today's report the Russian Defense Ministry claims:

Successful offensive of Russian units towards Lugansk within 5 days has resulted in the liberation of Loskutovka, Podlesnoye, Mirnaya Dolina, Shchebkaryer, Vrubovka, Nyrkovo, Nikiolayevka, Novoivanovka, Ustinovka and Ray-Aleksandrovka.

Group of Ukrainian units has been completely isolated near Gorskoye and Zolotoye.

This pocket has encircled four battalions: 3rd Mechanised Battalion of 24th Mechanised Brigade, 15th Mountain Assault Battalion of 128th Mountain Assault Brigade, 42nd Mechanised Infantry Battalion of 57th Mechanised Infantry Brigade, 70th Battalion of 101st Territorial Defence Brigade, as well as an artillery group of 57th Mechanised Infantry Brigade, a group of Nazis from Right Sector organisation and a detachment of foreign mercenaries.

In total, the Gorskoye pocket has isolated up to 2 thousand people: about 1,800 servicemen, 120 Nazis from Right Sector, up to 80 foreign mercenaries, as well as over 40 armoured combat vehicles and about 80 guns and mortars.

41 servicemen abandoned their resistance and surrendered voluntarily just over the past 24 hours.

According to the prisoners, the encircled Ukrainian units are exhausted. The units are currently manned by less than 40%. Higher Ukrainian command has lost control over these units. Armament, munitions, fuel and other logistic supply is completely stopped.

Russian troops are straitening the Gorskoye encirclement by launching uninterrupted attacks at the enemy. Half of Zolotoye had been taken under control over yesterday.

Since this morning some 600 have additionally surrendered. The others will likely follow later today or tomorrow.

Also this morning the Ukrainian deputy commander for Luhansk province announced that the soldiers and foreign mercenaries who held out in the industrial area of Sevierodonetzk east of Lysichansk were told to retreat to Lysichansk. In fact a full retreat from Lysichansk further west seemed to be likely.

But that was no longer really possible for the 10-15,000 soldiers in and around the city as a bridge on the single road that leads to the west has been dropped overnight onto the railway tracks below.

Correction (19:00 utc) This sections was wrong and has been corrected. A bridge was bombed to cut the escape route from Lysichansk but it was a different one than I first wrote. That does not change the conclusion

Bridge marked in red – This map is of a different bridge.

bigger

This map is of the bridge that was actually destroyed. It is at the north-west of the Lysichansk refinery I discussed in the previous situation report.

Bridge marked in red

bigger

A Russian helicopter performed that mission and it now seems that there was a bigger landing of airborne troops west of the refinery.

Here is how the bridge is now said to be looking. Correction (17:30 utc): The picture does not show the bridge on the map.

Correction (19:00 utc) The picture is of the destroyed bridge but it was geo-located wrongly. But that the bridge on the map is now damaged was reported by a source that is usually correct. I still assume that it is in fact so. Again the map was wrong, not the picture of the bridge.

Sorry for this 'fog of war' confusion. The tactical effects of the incident mentioned below stays the same. [end of both corrections]


bigger

There are still side roads and dirt tracks that can be used but the whole area west of Luhansk is under Russian fire control. The long convoy that would be needed for a retreat can not pass without being severely molested.

The big Lysichansk cauldron has thereby also been closed. Despite the still necessary cleanup of the city and two or three small villages one can state that the former Ukrainian province Luhansk, now the Luhansk People's Republic, has been liberated from Ukraine. 

On the Russian side some 30-40 Battalion Tactical Groups (BTG) have been involved in the whole operation. Most of them can now resupply and rest to later be used elsewhere.

Comments

In response to Scorpion@270,
Cheers. I applaud your propensity for nuanced thinking, which is becoming increasingly rare these days.
As far as I’m concerned, you are right not to idealize Russia or Putin. Not because of any historic associations, but because it’s a mistake in principle to do so. Russia and its leadership are acting out of self-interest the same as everybody else, only they’ve arrived at the realization that long-term objectives of self-interest are more intrinsically valuable than short-term objectives. Coincidentally, the long view corresponds with behavioral principles that people generally find desirable.
Similarly to how a tenant might behave if he expects to live in an apartment for 2 days v.s 20 years. In the first instance, he needn’t worry about filth, repairs or good neighborly relations in doing whatever takes his fancy, whereas the latter case, on the contrary, requires care and consideration in all of his actions so as not to create additional obstacles along the way.
This is of course speculative, but it would make sense for a society, which has experienced several devastating periods of disintegration in short succession, to adopt a mode of behavior which prioritizes stability and responsibility. Conversely, behavior on the part of Western elites, which could be described as short-sighted self-interest, corresponds to the relative stability and prosperity which these societies have become accustomed to.
Western political elites leave their errors in judgement behind together with their posts, returning to well-paid positions and blissful ignorance; a prospect which is both their punishment for failure as it is their reward for serving out their term in full. As part of a wider conglomerate under the US umbrella, even a serious localized crisis isn’t an end to one’s career, ala Sakashvili — as long as one remains welcome in some part of this associated territory, it matters little what ruins are left in one’s wake elsewhere.
Putin was candid with his opinion, that the post-Soviet space wasn’t ready for Western-style governance, by which I assume he meant that which I described above, and that a careless attitude to politics in Eastern Europe carried with it significant risks to the region and even to the world at large. From arbitrarily drawn borders to competing historic identities and ethnic strife, there is no shortage of objective reasons for why this is so. But in order to glimpse that terrible potential, one needs to look far ahead into the future, while taking a strong stand for liberal democracy, come hell or high water, earns you brownie points in tomorrow’s newspaper.
I’ve enjoyed our conversation and wish you good luck.

Posted by: Skiffer | Jun 25 2022 17:50 utc | 301

Not from Sputnik:
Briefing of the Russian Defense Ministry. The main thing:
▪️The territory of the Azot plant is completely controlled by the troops of the People’s Militia of the LPR.
The entire left-bank territory of the Seversky Donets within the borders of the LPR came under the control of the People’s Militia of the LPR
The units of the People’s Militia of the LPR, with the support of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, completely liberated Severodonetsk, Borovskoye, Voronovo and Sirotino of the LPR

Posted by: Arganthonios | Jun 25 2022 17:57 utc | 302

Thank you. I tried several things but got nowhere. The Android solution works well and easily of course but on my Linux Gnome Laptop the only way is to copy something.
No doubt there IS another way, but finding it is tricky.
No big deal, was just curious. And thank you.

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 18:07 utc | 303

@ Scorpion re funny characters
Yeah, my experience with Linux (Mint flavor) is that you need to either (1) cut and paste, or (2) find the Special Character menu and click on the desired symbol that is available in the word processing software but not, of course, when one is filling out a form like this one on a website. Both options are tedious.
There is a third option, namely, reprogramming the software, but I’ve never bothered to learn how to do that.

Posted by: malenkov | Jun 25 2022 18:15 utc | 304

Paul Greenwood @ 274
But for slavery, the South would not have developed the wealth and political-economic system that allowed its elites to even think in the terms it did.
While I do not agree that the Civil War was only about slavery, to deny that slavery was the most important ‘given’ or fundamental underpinning of the political and economic system and the decisions of Southern elites, thus a main reason for the Civil War, begs disbelief.
To me, the political and economic arguments the South made are like the arguments made by the West now when they use democracy or freedom as the reason they oppose Russia. The real reasons are political-economic and the use of slaves provided most of the profit of the Southern elites.
State’s rights was a real argument, but take away slavery and that issue never appears.
Look at the Compromise of 1877, when Blacks were sold out for the benefit of white businessmen and propertied elites (northern and southern). Profit and power created a new system in the South that in many ways was worse for newly freed slaves. White people didn’t even have to ensure the well-being of freed slaves – they could be used with less care than before the Civil War.
No slavery equals no Civil War.

Posted by: Objective Observer | Jun 25 2022 18:18 utc | 305

@Scorpion 289
Caveat emptor. I’m not knowledgeable on this subject, but I consider it conceivable that not everyone in the Bolshevik party was earnest in their desire to “liberate the people”.
My gut tells me that – especially because of those bankster connections – the Bolshevik project might have been intended as a cheap labour scam. With a lot of flowery language, virtue signalling, and cheerleading, to get the people to put their hearts and souls into the task of developing that huge area. And of course recruiting true believers, to keep the movement energized.
Ostensibly for the welfare of the inhabitants, but secretly for the benefit of investors.
I don’t see the mechanics of that as being far fetched at all.

Posted by: Featherless | Jun 25 2022 18:24 utc | 306

Trotsky was only a Menshevik in the loosest sense-a member of the minority- after 1903. He regarded himself as a non aligned Social Democrat, neither Menshevik nor Bolshevik and promoting unity.

Posted by: bevin | Jun 25 2022 18:24 utc | 307

Various options for Character Map (WinDoze) are also available for Linux.
Ò – Ó – Õ – Ö – Ô
Пожалуйста

Posted by: Opport Knocks | Jun 25 2022 18:29 utc | 308

Opport Knocks | Jun 25 2022 16:38 utc | 283
I’ve got a riddle for you. Just came across the following sentence today when reading about WW1 on Wikipedia. So who said “To delay negotiations, there must be someone to do the delaying”? This sentence sort of rang with me, what with people wondering why Ukrainians aren’t working for a diplomatic solution, or at least an armistice.

Posted by: Scotch Bingeington | Jun 25 2022 18:31 utc | 309

Posted by: Soi | Jun 25 2022 17:21 utc | 290
Yes, in her Empire days UK was the greatest criminal of them all. You did a great job describing the endless machinations in the mix. Personally I regard them all as being basically both as good and as bad as each other so tend to resist narratives painting one side as angels and the other as devils.
Am having a hard time with the SMO because the West is so consistently and dysfunctionally psychotic/demented whereas Russia seems extremely sane and deliberate and in so doing is winning the information war (one of the most important fields these days) in ways that I think Andrea at the Saker just couldn’t perceive at first (maybe he does now after he’s had a break). He felt that the West was overpowering his team and became extremely discouraged. Well, after only 1-2 months it seems that a certain amount of judo has taken place, genius level in fact.
That said, I am still suspicious. Many people here voice narratives extolling both Russians and Soviets and demonizing Nazis and British. No big deal, that’s fine, except I wonder if such narratives will be driving the Russians still after the SMO? And the Chinese who bear a grudge against the West big-league. Are they going to keep being reasonable and humanitarian? Or is a bloodbath on the way with Whitey about to get slaughtered finally?
Only time will tell.
Bevin has opened my eyes to how vivid communism is as a present force in today’s world. I had mistakenly though it was left behind decades ago in that neither Russia and China were pure communist anyway and especially not after the 60s-70s. How wrong I was.
And karlof1 opens my eyes to the depth and consistency of the Russian (and extended Eurasian) game which appears deep and deeply principled. But I find their restored UN vision as expressed thus far sadly lacking in checks and balances details, i.e. what happens when things go wrong which they inevitably will. It’s fine to paint a utopian picture, all decent people can approve, but am not yet sure it is of any practical import and also am sure that they know that very well themselves, which begs the question: so what’s their plan actually? Until it is spelled out better it looks more like a big alliance in preparation for war.
China has practiced widespread strict lock downs. Maybe virus. Maybe war training. Russia is only using 10-15% of her forces. Maybe just not excessive, maybe getting ready for much more? Meanwhile European and US leadership keep sabotaging their own nation and people. Sheer incompetence? Quite possibly. But since EVERYTHING they do keeps going in the same direction, probably this is a coordinated intelligent process, not a random stupid one.
In any case, the world is indeed the sort of tangled web you described in your post although again I think the Brits were just part of a mess not the only bad actor therein. They are all bad actors and they are all lying to their people from beginningless time it seems.
Are Russia and China really breaking that mold and operating in an entirely new and thoroughly honorable way? It seems possible, but I cannot yet believe it based on how twisted things have been for so long.
And to your closing point about Jewish involvement: yes, it seems to me they are often thrust forward as the fall guys to keep their hidden masters identities out of public view. But that doesn’t make them innocent victims either!!! Also, they are no more monolithic than any other people. I read up a little on Russian revolution yesterday and learned how at some point there were two major Jewish Bolshevik factions trying to liquidate each other. I cannot keep up with all those stories in all those countries. What a mess!! (Just like today!)
I have respect for those who seem to be able to but am also leery that they have come down with a core version they believe in after which there is a lot of confirmation bias going on with subsequent analysis. And I find that people indulging in demonizing or scorning those with whom they disagree a little suspect. Are they so angry because they are in the right or are they angry because the differing view is regarded as a threat?
Ten close family members sitting around a table rarely agree about anything. This geopolitical stuff is quadrillions of degrees more multi-faceted. Determining what is going on demands that you pick a perspective from which to view things at which point you have taken a side. Perhaps this is why, ultimately, there are wars. The center can no longer hold and one extreme has to try to destroy the other before the whole sorry business starts all over again.
Big fleas have little fleas upon their backs to bite ’em;
And little fleas have smaller fleas and so ad infinitum!

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 18:32 utc | 310

I often hear that “the civil war was about slavery”. The implication (unstated but heavily implied) is that the North went to war with the South due to their refusal to countenance the continuation of this practice.
However, from what I have read in this thread, it seems that the primary issue was not slavery in itself but the secession of the Southern states who refused to abolish slavery due to the obvious economic implications.
Is that a fair assessment?

Posted by: eyeswideopen | Jun 25 2022 18:35 utc | 311

on my Linux Gnome Laptop the only way is to copy something.
No doubt there IS another way, but finding it is tricky.
Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 18:07 utc | 303

Have you ever wondered what the “AltGr” key does? Or maybe your laptop doesn’t have that key? Doesn’t matter.
The function you want is called compose. It is similar to overstrike on an old fashioned typewriter, where special characters are composed by striking two characters within a single cell space.
To access the feature on Linux Gnome open the “settings” application, go to the keyboard tab, and select “right alt” for the compose key.
To compose a character like ç you type in sequence “right alt” then “,” then “c”.
On many keyboards the right alt key will be labeled AltGr.

Posted by: too scents | Jun 25 2022 18:37 utc | 312

Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold;
Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world,
The blood-dimmed tide is loosed, and everywhere
The ceremony of innocence is drowned;
The best lack all conviction, while the worst
Are full of passionate intensity.
Posted by: Sushi | Jun 25 2022 17:42 utc | 300
Indeed. Interesting how the best are flummoxed whilst the worst are so certain of their cause. This is what I’ve been paddling through so ineptly myself….

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 18:38 utc | 313

I’ve enjoyed our conversation and wish you good luck.
Posted by: Skiffer | Jun 25 2022 17:50 utc | 301
Same here and thanks.
(It’s a relief not being threatened with being reported to the Men Upstairs minding the archives!!!)

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 18:41 utc | 314

There would also probably have been no Civil War if Lincoln had not sought to put down the “rebellion” with military force. The Upper South — Virginia, North Carolina, Tennessee, and Arkansas — had already decided against seceding, and only changed their minds after Lincoln called for troops.
A Lower South without the Upper South could probably not have been able to make a go of it, and might have had to sue for readmission. That was Seward’s policy. When the Virginia Secession Convention voted in March not to secede, Lincoln and the Union had won a great victory, which they then proceeded to throw away by calling up troops.

Posted by: Lysias | Jun 25 2022 18:42 utc | 315

ō
Ń
Ȏ
Aha!
Posted by: malenkov | Jun 25 2022 18:15 utc | 304
And to others:
At least on my Manjaro (Arch) system, I can download an application called Character Map and voila: all the special characters are there for easy copying. I used to have that on a different OS but just couldn’t find it here and stupidly didn’t think of searching for it in the repositories. 1 minute later, problem solved. Linux is neat that way but you do have to apply just a little intelligence to the problem. In my defense I did quite a few searches but none of them mentioned this little gem of a program. Whether it exists in other distributions I haven’t tried to find out, being the selfish fella I am!!
Thanks to all.

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 18:47 utc | 316

Posted by: Skiffer | Jun 25 2022 17:50 utc | 301
“… it would make sense for a society, which has experienced several devastating periods of disintegration in short succession, to adopt a mode of behavior which prioritizes stability and responsibility.”
I think this is a hugely important open question on which the fate of hundreds of millions now hangs.
Let us hope for the best whilst preparing for the worst!

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 18:54 utc | 317

So its your gut, Featherless@306, versus historical scholarship and archives around the world.
Full marks for originality however- the idea that the Bolsheviks were for cheap labour and sponsored by the banks is new.
‘Here’s a question though: given that the Bolshevik programme called for the expropriation of the land and capital how did they sell that to the banks, most of whom held billions of roubles in mortgages on land the Bolsheviks were helping the peasants to take without compensation, what did the banks gain by backing the Bolsheviks?”
Another question; Was Mao also an agent of the banks? Was the Chinese Communist Party also bankrolled by foreign bankers? What about Vietnam and Korea?
The real trolls on this board, and the probable agents of Security State organs are not the “Ukraine is winning” idiots but the people who constantly post stupid theories, many of them old Nazi and CIA tropes designed to demoralise and divide opposition, while claiming, no doubt sincerely, to know absolutely nothing but of having recently read a book making claims that only an idiot would believe.
The forces of reason are thus brought into constant conflict with people who know nothing about the subject but are undeterred from laying down the law on it. Scorpion who is happy to confess that he doesn’t know a Menshevik from a Bolshevik is nevertheless ready to assert that the origins of fascism lie in the reaction of honest people to the unprecedented terrorism, violence and mass sadism of the Bolshevik revolution.
He knows absolutely nothing about the history of the Civil War and the relatively ‘kid glove’ tactics the Bolsheviks- the popular party- employed against the Whites, who combined within their ranks every kind of racism and elitist contempt for the people, and acted accordingly. It was not the Red but the White side and its foreign backers who practised scorched earth, terrorist and brutal tactics.
It was out of the White reaction that fascism emerged after the war and the revolution. And its success depended in large part on the enormous financial and governmental backing it got for its brutality towards socialists, trade unionists and anti-imperialists.
The bankers did not back the Bolsheviks they backed the fascists and the public record could hardly be any clearer. They did not pay Trotsky and Lenin but they did pay Hitler and Mussolini. They did not invest in the Soviet Union but they did invest in Hitler’s Germany and Mussolini’s Italy, as well as Franco’s Spain and Horthy’s Hungary.
Lenin was not on the British payroll but both Hitler and Mussolini were. And why not? They were both promising to fight socialism, break strikes and oppose revolution. The programme of the fascists coincided almost exactly with that of the imperialist ruling class.
In other news 2+2=4

Posted by: bevin | Jun 25 2022 18:57 utc | 318

@ Michael | Jun 25 2022 17:36 utc | 299
thanks! we’ll see how it plays out…. i am unable to visit your telegram channel… cheers james

Posted by: james | Jun 25 2022 19:08 utc | 319

@Scorpion
I like your thought process. I’m really impressed with several of the new people here !
There’s a proverb : “2 Jews, 3 opinions.” Argumentative and Contentious.
In my experience with people in general, people like this are a real pain in the ass, and have contributed to a lot of my own personal misery.
Crocodiles sometimes eat other crocodiles.
It doesn’t make them any less dangerous to the rest of us.

Posted by: Featherless | Jun 25 2022 19:19 utc | 320

The bankers did not back the Bolsheviks they backed the fascists and the public record could hardly be any clearer.
Posted by: bevin | Jun 25 2022 18:57 utc | 318
So how come the Bolsheviks sent back all of Russia’s gold to the bankers?
Or is that fake news, you say?
( Also, am not sure if ‘the public record’ is always the best go-to source… but as you point out and I admit: I don’t know much about these things given how confused and confusing the public records tend to be, changing regularly from decade to decade as they often do…)

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 19:26 utc | 321

For me, it’s not about “the Jews”. But History ends up revealing a lot of information, if often belatedly. Someone on this thread mentioned that “the British” were the biggest architects of war in Europe. I certainly don’t dispute that. It’s not taboo to say it about that group. We all remember Voltaire’s quote. IMO I’d put both at the top of the World Criminal list, and USA on par with them.
Anyhow, my point wasn’t about that, but about how, in my experience, often argumentation is not used to do dialectics together (creative discussion), but to control people. And contentious people are often so, because they are irate in general, and hate to lose a pissing contest. So I’m very wary about argumentative or contentious people. Oh crap, now I’m stating the obvious.
Anyhow, my compass (BS detector) has improved my ability to detect whether someone is trying to engage in a creative process, or program/control me.
What was my point ? The British have their posh accent, to make their BS sound legit. The Jews (because of their whole IQ bell curve being 10% higher) are better in general at BS, and also better at Dialectics. Hence the 3 opinions for 2 Jews, meaning Lies and Power.
Unless I’m mistaken, the British and Jews have been cooperating at a high political level for a while.
I’m sorry for mentioning the Jews. I’m gonna go say 10 hail Mary’s now.

Posted by: featherless | Jun 25 2022 19:44 utc | 322

@bevin
Thank you for answering me. I promise I’m not a troll. I come here specifically to learn. So everything I said is just wacky nonsense ?

Posted by: Featherless | Jun 25 2022 20:06 utc | 323

Posted by: bevin | Jun 25 2022 18:57 utc | 318
How do you explain Lenin’s journey (some say with lots of gold) from Zürich to Scandinavia on a train, unharmed through the middle of warring Europe, with German soldiers on said train?

Posted by: Anonymous | Jun 25 2022 20:50 utc | 324

Just for the record I’ll add a short Austrian joke (in German, sorry, someone has to translate):
Zwei Wiener unterhalten sich: Hey, hast’s g’hört, in Russland gab’s a Revolution! – A’ge, wer soll’n des g’macht ham? – Na der Blank aus’m Cafe Zentral!

Posted by: Anonymous | Jun 25 2022 21:42 utc | 325

@ Anonymous | Jun 25 2022 21:42 utc | 325
Source: Die Tante Jolesch, oder Der Untergang des Abendlandes in Anekdoten. Read that one a long time ago. 🙂
Two Viennese in conversation:
–Hey, didja hear, there’s a revolution in Russia
–Go on! Who in charge of that?
–The guy who stiffed you in Cafe Central!
(Trotsky, so the story goes, left Vienna without paying his running tab there.)

Posted by: malenkov | Jun 25 2022 22:14 utc | 326

@ Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 19:26 utc | 321
i support bevins view @ 318.. . if you get a chance read margarat macmillians book ”paris 1919”.. it covers the attitude of the west towards russia at this key moment in time, quite well… Paris, 1919: Six Months that Changed the World

Posted by: james | Jun 25 2022 22:43 utc | 327

“How do you explain Lenin’s journey (some say with lots of gold) from Zürich to Scandinavia on a train, unharmed through the middle of warring Europe, with German soldiers on said train?” Anonymous@324
It has been explained many times: the German High Command, anxious to create chaos in Russia, allowed Lenin passage, eventually, to the Finland Station in Petrograd. It made a lot of sense from Ludendorff’s point of view- Lenin was a minor figure whose insistence that Russia should leave the war suited the Germans well. He was unlikely to come to power but he could lead an agitation for peace. There is no mystery about it.
If Lenin were alive today and calling for Peace in Russia would you be surprised if the NATO powers facilitated his return and ensured that he was out of the reach of assassins while travelling through their territory?
As to the gold, its the first that I’ve heard of it but it would not be surprising if, delivering Lenin to Petrograd they felt that he should have the wherewithal to publish a pamphlet or whatever.
Still I have never run across any evidence that Lenin did have any gold with him or that it came from any foreign/non socialist source.

Posted by: bevin | Jun 25 2022 23:40 utc | 328

“Someone on this thread mentioned that “the British” were the biggest architects of war in Europe. I certainly don’t dispute that. It’s not taboo to say it about that group…” featherless@322
Britain was the dominant world power between 1815 and 1914. During that period Europe, with a relatively few exceptions, was at peace. So Britain-accused of being the biggest architect of war in Europe- presided over the famous century of peace in Europe.
It did so, of course, because it was in the interests of the ruling class in London to promote trade, protect finance and maintain peace. It was good business. Maintaining the balance of power enable Britain, which barely had an army of any kind, to dominate the continent.
In fact Britain fought many wars in the century after Waterloo but not in Europe.

Posted by: bevin | Jun 25 2022 23:47 utc | 329

Scorpion:
“So how come the Bolsheviks sent back all of Russia’s gold to the bankers?” What do you mean by ‘sent back?”
A distant relative of mine, living in the south of England in the late seventies, had a lavatory in which the walls were papered with Russian bonds which were rendered worthless after October 1917. The banks lost billions as did hundreds of thousands of investors in France, the UK and elsewhere who had speculated in Russian stocks and bonds.
I imagine that any Russian gold reserves- times change!- in Paris or London in 1918 were not forwarded to the Bolsheviks. What did happen, in the 1920s was that Russia, more or less blockaded and boycotted by all the major powers and economies found that, in order to buy machinery or technical services, grain or medicines it had to trade in gold. And did so.

Posted by: bevin | Jun 25 2022 23:55 utc | 330

Thank you bevin, for helping me learn.

Posted by: featherless | Jun 26 2022 0:20 utc | 331

From the Jane English/C. Fung translation of the Tao:
Good weapons are instruments of fear; all creatures hate them.
Therefore, followers of the Tao never use them.
The wise man prefers the left.
The man of war prefers the right.
Weapons are instruments of fear; they are not a wise man’s tools.
He uses them only when he has no choice.
Peace and quiet are dear to his heart,
And victory no cause for rejoicing.
If you rejoice in victory, then you delight in killing.
If you delight in killing, you cannot fulfill yourself.
On happy occasions, precedence is given to the left,
On sad occasions to the right.
In the army, the general stands on the left,
The commander-in-chief on the right.
This means war is conducted like a funeral.
When many people are being killed,
They should be mourned in heartfelt sorrow.
This is why a victory must be observed like a funeral.

Posted by: FrankDrakman | Jun 26 2022 1:53 utc | 332

Posted by: bevin | Jun 25 2022 23:40 utc | 328
“As to the gold, its the first that I’ve heard of it but it would not be surprising if, delivering Lenin to Petrograd they felt that he should have the wherewithal to publish a pamphlet or whatever.
Still I have never run across any evidence that Lenin did have any gold with him or that it came from any foreign/non socialist source.”
It’s been a very long time since I read about such things but I seem to recall that Schiff in Brooklyn supplied the travelers with 20 million USD (an enormous amount in those days) so that once they got to Russia they had funds for publications and raising their numbers considerably. After the revolution succeeded they rounded up all the gold belonging to the Russian state and shipped it back to the banking consortium who backed them and who had arranged safe passage through Halifax, London, Berlin and Stockholm even though this was in the midst of a world war and many of the countries they went through were on opposing sides.
Of course, this could all be false news.
But also, it might not.
I have no memory of where I was reading this stuff but I will see if I can get lucky and find it (much has been scrubbed off the internet of late which used to be easier to find in the 90’s and 00’s.)
I am sincerely baffled that you regard the stories of Checka atrocities and later Stalin as false news. I didn’t realize that this was controversial presuming that the only issue might be the numbers given that many say it ranged from twenty to fifty million – truly staggering amounts.
I honestly think you have a whitewashed notion of the Russian Revolution perhaps out of your zeal for the communist cause but
a) I admittedly never studied it and
b) what little I read could have been false but
c) I don’t think so.
What do you think of Yuri Lena’s account in his Scorpion book? It is total rubbish according to you? It comes with numerous references….

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 1:56 utc | 333

Posted by: james | Jun 25 2022 22:43 utc | 327
Thanks for the recommendation. In a few months we’ll be moving up to a new place in goat country in clouds and mist where we probably won’t have electricity for quite a while and so no internet either. Perhaps I will spend a few months reading books. That one you recommended is on the list. Thank you.
That said, I might not want to go through all the ghastly business that went down in Europe so long ago.
I’d rather drink sake, and read Basho and make bokashi!

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 2:02 utc | 334

As it was in the interest of the ruling class in London up to 1914 to promote peace, so, in 1914, it was in their interest to promote war to prevent Germany from taking their place as the leading power.

Posted by: Lysias | Jun 26 2022 2:05 utc | 335

@ Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 2:02 utc | 334
lol.. you lead a good life! enjoy the sake and basho! the book covers the treaty of Versailles and more… it gives on a perspective on how russia was kept out of the western alliance – uk, usa and france..
how about some solo piano music from an armenian?
Tigran Hamasyan – An Ancient Observer (Live 2017-10-25 @ Bonn, Germany) (Audio)

Posted by: james | Jun 26 2022 2:07 utc | 336

Posted by: Oh | Jun 24 2022 15:58 utc | 24
Correction:
According to the Duran Duran,
“Don’t say a prayer for me now,
Save it ’til the morning after.”
Lol.

Posted by: Jon_in_AU | Jun 26 2022 2:29 utc | 337

@bevin
I went onto an old revisionist site (ihr) and found a little, but their emphasis is on German/WWII revisionism.
I found nothing resembling what I seem to remember reading a long time ago, certainly not about the gold. But two items did come up. The first is a mention of what Solzenitsyn said:
“Another major political phenomenon of the present time for which explanation and elucidation must be sought in the past is a massive Jewish exodus from the Soviet Union — a sharp reversal of the trend in 1917 and the years immediately following, when Jews from all over the Western world were streaming into Russia.
“Antisemitism is forcing the biggest exodus in 500 years,” cries a headline in the London Financial Times. According to Nathan Shcharansky, a much-publicized Soviet dissident now living in the West, Jewish families have been applying for permits to leave the Soviet Union at a rate of 2000 a day and the queue of would-be emigrants could be as long as one million. Other Jewish spokesmen have put the figure at anything between two million and four million.
There is no mystery about their reasons for wanting to leave; the Jews are being blamed for the Revolution and for the population massacres that followed.
Shcharansky said in an interview with the London Times:
This is something quite different from the street-level antisemitism of the past For the first time the Russian people have realized what an awful history they have had. It is no longer Solzhenitsyn saying there were 60 million victims of state terror; now conservative Soviet historians are estimating 40 million. So the Russians have found that it was their regime that destroyed all the cultural institutions, all the moral values, and every day they see it discussed on television, and their historians tell them, and new graves are discovered. And, of course, they remember who was Karl Marx, and someone is saying that the grandfather of Lenin was Jewish… It is mother nature that the scapegoat becomes the Jew.
What Shcharansky and other Jewish leaders find most disturbing about the new antisemitism, “no longer just street- level,” is the fact that it is to be found in intellectual circles. Here, he says, it takes the form of a debate around the question of Jewish responsibility for the years of Bolshevism.”
Now I included the context of the main paragraph of interest, namely the one mentioning the sixty and forty million figure. I really do believe that Solz. is a credible figure. Do you? Or is he a disinformation person in your opinion?
The second item was about money. This article mentions the 20 millions from Schiff: https://themillenniumreport.com/2018/07/the-nyc-and-london-banker-who-financed-the-bolshevik-revolution/
“In the February 3, 1949 issue of the New York Journal American Schiff’s grandson, John, was quoted by columnist Cholly Knickerbocker as saying that his grandfather had given about $20 million for the triumph of Communism in Russia. (To appraise Schiff’s motives for supporting the Bolsheviks, we must remember, that he was a Jew and that Russian Jews had been persecuted under the Tsarist regime. Consequently the Jewish community in America was inclined to support any movement, which sought to topple the Russian government and the Bolsheviks were excellent candidates for the task. As we shall see further along, however, there were also strong financial incentives for Wall Street firms, such as Kuhn, Loeb and Company, of which Schiff was a senior partner, to see the old regime fall into the hands of revolutionaries, who would agree to grant lucrative business concessions in the future in return for financial support today.)
When Trotsky returned to Petrograd in May of 1917 to organize the Bolshevik phase of the Russian Revolution, he carried $10,000 for travel expenses, a generously ample fund considering bthe value of the dollar at that time. Trotsky was arrested by Canadian and British naval personnel, when the ship, on which he was traveling, the S.S. Kristianiafjord, put in at Halifax. The money in his possession is now a matter of official record. The source of that money has been the focus of much speculation, but the evidence strongly suggests, that its origin was the German government. It was a sound investment.
Trotsky was not arrested on a whim. He was recognized as a threat to the best interests of England, Canada’s mother country in the British Commonwealth. Russia was an ally of England in the First World War, which then was raging in Europe. Anything, that would weaken Russia – and that certainly included internal revolution – would be, in effect, to strengthen Germany and weaken England. In New York on the night before his departure Trotsky had given a speech, in which he said: “I am going back to Russia to overthrow the provisional government and stop the war with Germany.” (A full report on this meeting had been submitted to the U.S. Military Intelligence. See Senate Document No. 62, 66th Congress, Report and Hearings of the Subcommittee on the Judiciary, United States Senate, 1919, Vol. II, p. 2680.) Trotsky therefore represented a real threat to England’s war effort. He was arrested as a German agent and taken as a prisoner of war.
With this in mind we can appreciate the great strength of those mysterious forces both in England and the United States, that intervened on Trotsky’s behalf. Immediately telegrams began to come into Halifax from such divergent sources, as an obscure attorney in New York City, from the Canadian Deputy Postmaster-General and even from a high-ranking British military officer, all inquiring into Trotsky’s situation and urging his immediate release. The head of the British Secret Service in America at the time was Sir William Wiseman, who, as fate would have it, occupied the apartment directly above the apartment of Edward Mandell House and who had become fast friends with him. House advised Wiseman, that President Wilson wished to have Trotsky released. Wiseman advised his government and the British Admiralty issued orders on April 21st, that Trotsky was to be sent on his way. (“Why Did We Let Trotsky Go? How Canada Lost an Opportunity to Shorten the War”, MacLeans magazine, Canada, June 1919. Also see Martin, pp. 163-164.) It was a fateful deecision, that would affect not only the outcome of the war, but the future of the entire world.
It would be a mistake to conclude, that Jacob Schiff and Germany were the only players in this drama. Trotsky could not have gone even as far as Halifax without having been granted an American passport and this was accomplished by the personal intervention of President Wilson. Professor Antony Sutton says:
President Woodrow Wilson was the fairy godmother, who provided Trotsky with a passport to return to Russia to “carry forward” the revolution… At the same time careful State Department bureaucrats, concerned about such revolutionaries entering Russia, were unilaterally attempting to tighten up passport procedures. (Antony C. Sutton, Ph. D.: Wall Street and the Bolshevik Revolution, published by Arlington House in New Rochelle, NY, 1974, p. 25)
And there were others, as well….”
So this shows the truly extraordinary level of support from very different sources, hardly any of whom cared a fig for communism, rather were bent on collapsing Russia.
I suspect the same thing is going on today: Ukraine is not about Ukraine or Donbass per se, rather it is being used as pretext for collapsing Western societies, much of it being coordinated, as in 1917 era, by seemingly disparate networks who are ostensibly on opposing sides. The more things change…..
This article goes into millions of Marks from Germany going into the Bolshevik coffers:
“Meanwhile, in 1921, in the democratic Weimar Republic the renowned social democrat Eduard Bernstein published in his party’s central organ Vorwaerts an article headed “A Shady Story.” In it, he related that as far back as December 1917, he received an affirmative answer from “a certain competent person” to the question of whether Germany had given money to Lenin.
According to his data, the Bolsheviks alone were paid more than 50 million German marks in gold. Later, this sum was officially mentioned during the session of the Reichstags committee on foreign policy. Responding to the accusations of libel from the communist press, Bernstein suggested that they sue him, after which the campaign instantly stopped.
As Germany was in a bad need of friendly relations with Soviet Russia, the discussion of this topic in the press ended abruptly.
Aleksander Kerensky, one of the Bolshevik’s chief political opponents, deduced from his own investigation of the case, that the sums received by the Bolsheviks before and after coming to power totaled 80 million German marks in gold (the equivalent of the present-day hundreds of millions, if not billions, hryvnias).
As a matter of fact, Ulianov-Lenin never even tried to conceal this from his party colleagues. Thus, in November, 1918, at the meeting of the All-Russian Central Executive Committee (a Bolshevist quasi-parliament), the Bolshevik leader said: “I am often accused of having carried out our revolution with German money; I do not deny it, but instead, with the Russian money, I’m going to carry out the same revolution in Germany.”
And he tried to do so, throwing away tens of millions of roubles. However, he failed: the German social democrats, unlike their Russian counterparts, saw which way the wind was blowing and managed to arrange for a timely assassination of Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg. This was followed by the disarmament of the “red guards” and physical extermination of their leaders.”
( Article: https://day.kyiv.ua/en/article/history-and-i/lenin-money-revolution )
Now I understand these snippets don’t constitute definitive proof of anything and I only searched for a few minutes. In reading through this material I remembered why I didn’t go further years ago. (I also never studied WWI in depth for the same reason.) It’s because to do the subject matter justice clearly I would need to spend at least a year if not much more. I do not wish to do that for personal reasons so prefer to remain ignorant of huge swathes of detail.
That said, I think some things are generally true, though admit I might be the victim of slick misinformation (for that is always the case with historical information no matter how respectable or widely read the source, let alone the controversial and not widely read ones). Namely:
The Russian revolution was funded by powerful western interests in both US, UK and Germany even though UK and Germany were at war.
After the revolution and during several different phases a huge bloodbath ensued involving the murder of dozens of millions, most of whom were Christian Russians and many of the organizers of the terror waves were Jewish.
And one point I have been making which some here feel is incorrect but I will say it again: this widespread takedown of a powerful nation which according to some accounts was the richest in Europe at the time, involving extreme mass murder of millions did not go unnoticed in Europe even if our histories today make little mention of it. Nationalism was in part a response to the threat of communism which openly wished to overthrow all monarchies, private property, religion and hereditary wealth, title and status. No doubt many approved of such goals, but I doubt many approved of butchery. So this is not meant to be a huge point or to make excuses for any excesses the later fascist regimes may have perpetrated but it does suggest that such things didn’t arise willy nilly or were the product of genetically caused racial hatreds and other silly self-serving theories. No, enmity was earned.
In sum, there was a concerted effort to collapse many different polities at once in the WWI – WW II period. The same thing seems to be happening now under cover of a kinetic war.
Second: tens of millions were murdered. Let’s hope the same thing is not in the cards, but with biowarfare against civilian populations in the mix these days, that possibility clearly exists, except now maybe billions not tens of millions. There is also the possibility of nuclear war. China has been practicing mass lock downs, maybe against covid, maybe for another reason.
Third, we must not be trapped or fooled by old stories, rather learn from them so as not to repeat the same mass
formation group psychosis which creates hell. We can and must find a way to do better. The problem of course is you can go back and back with enmity to the Chapter of Genesis. So ideally a new way forward must be found in which such ancient hatreds are not foundational. Most of us don’t feel any hatred for anyone, however all of us can be persuaded into it by skillful propagandists.
I am sorry I couldn’t find anything about the gold. Maybe it was a false story, but I just cannot remember the source. I saved many articles and online books but had a hard disk accident a few years ago and lost it all and now it’s much harder to find such materials plus I am now loth to try. I really don’t enjoy the subject matter. Indeed, will try to avoid raising it here any more. We are all entitled to our various opinions and since mine are not rock solid certain about these vast topics, there is no real need to keep chipping in with them.
All best..

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 3:51 utc | 338

oops. the first article with the Solzenitzyn quote: https://www.ihr.org/jhr/v10/v10p323_Benson.html

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 3:53 utc | 339

Barflys,
Regarding future peaceful secession of various U.S. States. ( Texas or California being most often suggested ) While peaceful secession would be the best solution, it’s not going to happen.
What is more likely for us is a horrific Spanish Civil War scenario. Spanish society was deeply divided along political NOT geographic lines in the decades before the actual fighting began. When the fighting finally did start ( due to a contested election BTW ), neighborhoods massacred other neighborhoods.
Study the social causes of the Spanish Civil War, then read a little about what happened at the local level. The parallels are striking.
The divisions in our society are not along clearly defined geographic lines. When the fighting does start, you will see skirmishes within Metropolitan areas. We’ll see poor suburbs attack wealthy suburbs. We’ll see pockets of besieged areas holding out far behind ‘enemy lines. There will be unspeakable atrocities.
There is still time to move. Better a couple of years too early than 1 day too late.

Posted by: Exile | Jun 26 2022 4:56 utc | 340

@scorpion 190
Hey, whoa there good buddy!
You know we are not supposed to talk about Stalinist purges, Mao designed mass murder,
and especially that thing in that square in Beijing, that may or may not have resulted in state ordered mass murder of protestors.
I’ll give you a pass this time, but tsk tsk.
Start pulling the rope the same way as everyone else here, comprendo?

Posted by: Cadence calls | Jun 26 2022 5:28 utc | 341

This sealing off of the area has enabled the evacuation of some 800 civilians and prohibited any possible escape for those (including foreign mercenaries) holed up in the Azot plant.
https://johnplatinumgoss.com/2022/06/26/the-last-days-of-the-azot/

Posted by: John Goss | Jun 26 2022 6:12 utc | 342

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 25 2022 18:07 utc | 303
On gnome: Search in your keyboard settings for the “compose” key. If you never heard of that, chances are good it is the right window key, but on a laptop you may have to set it to something else. Press and release the compose key, press and release “-“, press and release “o”, or Shift-O: ō, Ō
On my system, Mint, it is in controll-center, keyboard, second tab, should be something like “settings” or so, my language is german, Options, Position of compose key.

Posted by: TomD | Jun 26 2022 8:05 utc | 343

Posted by: Tard | Jun 24 2022 22:09 utc | 119
My brief answer to your question would be thst they have kompromat on ALL of the installed leaders in the EU. Remember the NSA/CIA bugging scandal? How far did it actually go, I wonder. We also know that Occupied Palestine was bugging the Outlaw US Government, which raises questions about the ultimate string-pullers.
I’m inclined to believe it is the Anglo-Zionist bankster cabal and associated crew running this whole shitshow out of their fear of SCO/BRICS/et al crushing their monopoly.
They (EU leadership) are all acting out their parts, in my opinion, because failure to comply would mean serious jail time or worse. It is the only explanation that makes sense, without invoking hypotheses about secret societies running the world.
Just my two penny’s worth.

Posted by: Jon_in_AU | Jun 26 2022 9:15 utc | 344

@Scorpion (303) re: special characters
On my Ubuntu PC my keyboard layout is set to an ‘Macintosh’ layout where the right Alt key (AltGr) plays the same role as the Alt/Option key on the Mac OS. It was already available with a fresh install, out of the box. I don’t know if any other Linux distros have this – what are you using?

Posted by: joey_n | Jun 26 2022 10:35 utc | 345

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 3:51 utc | 338
Quite interesting how the term “civil war” is studiously avoided in these posts.
Out of your curated account, one could take home the following impressions:
-White Russians barely exist at all, russian revolutionaries must have been punching a brick wall.
-Western powers were only ever funding revolutionaries, they had no involvement at all with the Russian Empire or White Russians (which didn’t exist!)
-Intervention during the civil war to the tune of 14+ foreign powers embroiled never happened, accordingly; since there was no “civil war” and White Russians dissolved into mist the moment Lenin popped out of a train.
-It is impossible that, at the very least, hundreds of thousands of subjects of the Russian Empire were fucking sick of World War One.
-It is impossible that, at the very least, tens of thousands of subjects of the Russian Empire were fucking sick of being second-class citizens or worse.
-Because, you know, a monarch is a “living, breathing embodiment of the spirit of a nation” with whom all subjects are in permanent psychic communion; this sustains the body and spirit on its own, regardless of the living conditions.
-By comparison, Lenin, being a pleb and an eighth of a Jew; cannot effect this succouring psychic sustenance for want of the requisite blue blood.
-Russian Jews must have come from Mars or maybe from Saturn, because they certainly were not Russian.
-Whatever happened during the civil war, which didn’t exist, was the handiwork of jewish bolsheviks.
🙄

Posted by: Arganthonios | Jun 26 2022 12:22 utc | 346

Posted by: joey_n | Jun 26 2022 10:35 utc | 345
At #316 I revealed that had found a program in Arch repositories called Character Map – I use Manjaro Gnome – and it’s all good now.
Have a Lenovo W530 with none of those special keys though am sure one could be assigned. Some OS’s come with that character program.

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 12:26 utc | 347

I’m inclined to believe it is the Anglo-Zionist bankster cabal and associated crew running this whole shitshow out of their fear of SCO/BRICS/et al crushing their monopoly.
Posted by: Jon_in_AU | Jun 26 2022 9:15 utc | 344
Me too, though my devious side worries that a deal has gone down and a multi generational fifth column has agreed to precipitate collapse of the West to usher in a new world order in return for which they get to be the ruling managerial class of a now techno-fascist controlled West with a subservient population.
I just read in Saker blog by Batyusha that ‘Nazi’ means any firm of White aggression going back millenia and the current war is about basically subjugating those peoples and their tendencies. The author is an Orthodox rector in Europe. So the pathocracy of the West is now infecting Saker blog. Who’s truly winning?

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 12:37 utc | 348

a new world order in return for which they get to be the ruling managerial class of a now techno-fascist controlled West with a subservient population.
Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 12:37 utc | 348
I fail to see your point because this is an accurate description of the present, not the future.

Posted by: Arganthonios | Jun 26 2022 12:49 utc | 349

Posted by: Arganthonios | Jun 26 2022 12:22 utc | 346
Some good points and yes, no mention of White Russians unless they were part of the 40-60 million murdered.
The accounts I picked up from the electronic ether might be revisionist disinformation masters like Solzenitsyn.
But your versions might be disinformation too. Ever considered that?

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 12:54 utc | 350

though am sure one could be assigned.
Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 12:26 utc | 347

Ŧḩé çōmṗösē kœỹ îṅċłúdėḑ ẇìŧħ Łìņųx.
https://help.gnome.org/users/gnome-help/stable/tips-specialchars.html.en
https://help.ubuntu.com/stable/ubuntu-help/tips-specialchars.html.en

Posted by: too scents | Jun 26 2022 12:58 utc | 351

Posted by: too scents | Jun 26 2022 12:58 utc | 351
Thanks. But unless I’m missing something this doesn’t work in Arch OS’s. The options don’t mention Compose Key anywhere that I can find though there is a Keyboard & Mouse in Settings. I prefer the Character Map option because I rarely use such characters and it’s just a simple copy paste job without having to look up or remember all those numbers.

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 13:07 utc | 352

I fail to see your point because this is an accurate description of the present, not the future.
Posted by: Arganthonios | Jun 26 2022 12:49 utc | 349
With respect, you lack imagination!

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 13:10 utc | 353

without having to look up or remember all those numbers.
Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 26 2022 13:07 utc | 352

That is the neat thing about compose. You don’t have to look up or remember anything. Just smash two characters into one space.

Posted by: too scents | Jun 26 2022 13:10 utc | 354

Thanks for the effort. Looks like you put in some real effort into your comment, unlike these other argumentative sabaki.
No, you don’t need to toe any line in the bar.

Posted by: Tom_12 | Jun 26 2022 13:13 utc | 355

With Roe v Wade overturned, Ukraine will be back page news in the states weeks. When it gets back to front page, people will say “what?”
Posted by: BroncoBilly | Jun 25 2022 14:26 utc | 254
—————————————————————–
As usual, timing is (almost) everything. This is so out in left field, so much from the Bazzaro World of DC Comics, that it seems to me it is deliberately designed to again, provoke domestic conflict and division, so people will not pay so much (or any) attention to the Ukraine or American internal problems. Helps great when the US is heading to insolvency with their many problems.
And how about the defeat in Ukraine when the empire has put so much wealth, resources, and propaganda into Ukraine the home of democracy and freedom…. how will the US natives digest that….
Imagine if these wokers were informed of the defeat of Ukraine and had no new 30 minutes of hate to distract them from that… imagine contemplating that with a clear and settled mind.
And to fire up the abortion hate again… just another nudge to a broken-up US and the culture wars there.
I guess I am just stating the obvious here…. sorry about that.

Posted by: Randolph | Jun 26 2022 16:08 utc | 356

“A million here, a million there. Pretty soon you’re talking real money” Sen. Dirkson in the 60s, talking about the US budget of those times.
Scorpion throws around numbers that top those 60s US budget numbers. I guess it must be inflation.
40 million, 60 million dead Christian Russians, slaughtered in the kind of torture porn ways that Lyudmila Denisova recently specialized in.
Odd that Russians still memorialize the 27 million slaughtered in WW2, but are blissfully uncaring of the far higher numbers slaughtered only a few decades before that. It’s almost as if it didn’t happen. Hmmm
That kind of human loss should have lowered the population of Russia dramatically, as happened in the 90s.
And yet, it didn’t.
And a million dollars seemed like a lot in the 60s, but the gullible think that Lenin and Trotsky were given millions earlier in the century? Sure, dudes.
I looked up the two sources Scorpion mentioned. One was born in the 20s, one in the 30s. Both had long careers in the USSR and died natural deaths when they were elderly. Odd that, if they were telling such tales. Apparently they didn’t tell those tales until after the USSR was destroyed and it became quite profitable to do so.
One had a very illustrious career which involved his traveling around the world, including a stint in the US when he snuck off to see Solzhenitsyn. Huh, I wonder if he got any tips about how to please the US oligarchs who run the country and like propaganda from “dissidents” from targeted countries. It seems more legit, doncha know.
Common sense and basic math should tell you that those stories are lies.

Posted by: wagelaborer | Jun 26 2022 18:58 utc | 357

Posted by: wagelaborer | Jun 26 2022 18:58 utc | 357
“Common sense and basic math should tell you that those stories are lies.”
I briefly looked for Russian population demographics but got nowhere. The figures cited – 40 & 60 million – were from the text excerpt, not mine. The lower one was from official Russian historians. And of course could all be lies, as with all history everywhere.
You do understand that if there were a wave of terror and many of those managing it were Jewish that considerable obfuscation of the historical record would be in the mix, right? Or is that too an unacceptable supposition?
I think some people are muddling their support for contemporary Russia with the 1920s Soviet days. We have seen in our lives how easy it is to manipulate entire populations, the inaginary/mental space being more important than physical territory perhaps at this point. People and their cultures change. Core characteristics remain (Russian VS Italian vs Chinese vs Aborigines etc – but attitudes and perceptions vary widely sometimes in only a decade or so.
Personally, am assuming that Russia today is very different from only 30 years ago, let alone 100. It seems to me that they are representing core western civilizational values and vision whilst the West has entirely lost their way.
That said, those crafty Eurasian behemoths might be pulling history’s greatest psyop! Though I doubt it. The strength and consistency of purpose evidenced is hard to fake. Something our Empire of Lies side used to but can no longer pull off – not even close.

Posted by: Scorpion | Jun 27 2022 13:25 utc | 358