|
The Space Race: Technical Facts vs Popular Narrative – by Gordog
by Gordog
lifted from a comment
A little while ago, commenter Karlof1 asked me about the space race, the Apollo Program, and the role of Nazi scientists recruited under Operation Paperclip.
This is a fascinating subject that has also been severely distorted by the American narrative.
What prompted Karlof's query was my earlier, and somewhat lengthy technical discussion of today's state of space technology, where the media narrative is that the US is greatly advanced, due mostly the 'exploits' of Space X—when in fact the situation is quite the opposite.
The US is far behind important core technologies like advanced rocket engines and space station tech, both of which it acquired from Russia. China has similarly acquired nearly all of its core space technology from Russia, but has built impressively on that technology transfer—including developing its very own space station tech, and its own advanced rocket engines.
During the 1990s, many important Russian industries were on the verge of collapse due to the disintegration of the USSR. Hence there was something of a firesale of Russian space tech, something that would have been considered unthinkable previously. The Chinese acquired their entire manned program, Shenzhou, lock, stock and barrel through direct technology transfer from Russia, resulting in the first Chinese man in space in 2003.
The US similarly bought its way into the Mir2 space station that was already built, but not yet launched, abandoning its own effort to build an indigenous station to rival Mir—the Freedom space station that was killed on the drawing board. Those Mir2 modules, now known as the Russian Orbital Segment, would become the functional core of the ISS.
The US also acquired advanced Russian engines and key engine technologies, mostly the RD180, which is in fact the undisputed workhorse for both high profile Nasa missions [such as the current mars rover mission], and the US Space Force, which launches nearly all of its mission-critical payloads on the Russian engines.
Other Russian engines, including the RD190 and even the 1960s era mothballed NK33s were also bought up and pressed into service by the US. That the Russians possessed this advanced engine technology was completely unknown in the west until the 1990s, which had regarded the 'closed-cycle' technology as technically 'impossible.'
So let's take a look back to the 1950s, when spaceflight was first achieved. This was an exciting era, and there is much to discuss here, so I will leave the Apollo story for another time.
By the latter stages of Word War 2, the Germans were the undisputed leaders in rocket technology. The V2 rocket, which was used to bombard London, was a hugely impressive piece of engineering for the time.
Russia, whose rocket technology in the 1930s was considered comparable to the Germans, had fallen behind. But the country did develop smaller, albeit usable rocket engines, for instance the experimental Bereznyak-Isayev BI1 interceptor aircraft. The US really had no rocket engine technology to speak of during this era.
But the US would import most of the German rocket engineers, as well as some working copies of the V2 itself. This would provide a strong base to build on, not just for the space race a decade later, but also the far more important race for strategic weapons, namely the intercontinental ballistic missile.
A quick tale of the tape on the V2: It had a mass of 12.5 metric tons, and a thrust of about 25 tons, from a single engine burning alcohol and liquid oxygen. It could reach a speed of 3,500 mph, and a flight range of about 300 km. Incredibly, over 3,000 of these were built during the war!
Von Braun and over 100 key V-2 personnel surrendered to the Americans, and many of the original V-2 team ended up working at the Redstone Arsenal. The US also captured enough V-2 hardware to build approximately 80 of the missiles.
The Soviets captured the V2 manufacturing facilities in Eastern Germany and used some of the remaining German engineers and technicians to build 30 V2s of their own by 1946.
The following year, a group of these engineers were transferred to Russia to work under the direction of Sergei Korolev, on the R1 missile, a copy of the V2, but built using Russian industrial plants.
This was quickly followed by the substantially improved R2, which first flew in 1949, and featured a number of key design improvements. R2 achieved double the V2's range, and a much higher speed of nearly 5,000 mph.
By 1953, the Russians started on what would become the world's first ICBM and also the world's first space launch vehicle—the R7 'Semyorka' rocket.
This was a huge leap forward in rocket technology. The R7 first flew in 1957 and launched Sputnik, the first satellite in earth orbit, later that year. It was also the launch vehicle for the first TWO humans in space, Yuri Gagarin in April, 1961 and Gherman Titov in August of the same year.
In the meantime, the US launched its first 'astronaut,' Alan Shepard on a suborbital 'spaceflight' atop a Mercury-Redstone rocket that was basically a slightly improved V2, comparable to the Russian R2 of a decade earlier.
In this photo from 1961, we see the Mercury-Redstone rocket that carried Shepard on America's first 'spaceflight' [more on that in a moment]. Joachim Kuettner, the Mercury project manager, and former V2 engineer is seen at left. 'Astronaut' Gus Grissom is sixth from left.
The size difference between the Mercury Rocket and the Russian Semyorka is obvious. With a mass of 30 tons, it was barely one tenth the mass of the R7. The latter's thrust of over one million pounds was more than TWELVE times the power of the single engine Mercury rocket with its 78,000 pounds of thrust!
Crucially, the single-stage Mercury could only reach a speed of about 5,000 mph, less than one third of orbital velocity of 18,000 mph [8 km/s].
A little basic physics to explain what 'space flight' really means. In short, it means achieving orbit, which is a function of SPEED, not altitude.
To understand this, a spacecraft must generate enough centrifugal force to overcome the earth's gravitational pull. When the spacecraft's centrifugal force is exactly equal to the earth's gravity, the spacecraft will continue orbiting the earth indefinitely, just as the space station stays aloft [provided it is high enough above the atmosphere that collisions with few and far between air molecules don't slow down its speed, which will cause it to descend, and require an engine burn to speed back up].
A good way to visualize this equilibrium of forces is with the Olympic hammer throw. As seen here, the athlete swings a metal ball attached to a length of cable he is holding. As he swings it around, the centrifugal force builds up and wants to hurl that ball off into space. But the cable is like the force of gravity keeping it from spinning off. The two forces are in exact equilibrium, until he lets go.
The only difference with an orbiting spacecraft is that the earth's gravity never lets go! Once equilibrium is reached the two opposing forces are equal and opposite, as per Netwon's Third Law. And since centrifugal force is a function of speed, it is necessary to reach a speed of about 8 km/s [18,000 mph] to counter the earth's gravitational acceleration of 9.8 meters per second squared.
[Here is the math: centrifugal force = mass x velocity squared, divided by radius of the circular motion. Since the radius of the earth is about 6,400 km, and we assume a unit mass of 1 kg, then it is a simple matter of algebra to solve for speed: square root of (earth's radius in meters x acceleration of gravity), which gives…square root of (6,400,000 m x 9.8 m/s^2) = 7,900 m/s, or ~8 km/s]
I am dwelling on this because it is important to understand what actual spaceflight means. Simply flying to any given height above the atmosphere is not spaceflight—anymore than a ski jump is 'flying.'
Similarly, feeling weightlessness also does not require actual spaceflight. Astronauts regularly train on large commercial jets that have had their interiors removed and the pilots fly the airplane in a ballistic arc that provides up to several minutes of zero g flight inside the cabin training space. In fact, you can have several seconds of zero g flight in a little Cessna student training aircraft!
So let's continue with the relevant stats for the first American 'spaceflight' of Alan Shepard. His 1961 flight aboard that Mercury rocket [a souped up V2] covered a total distance of 263 miles over the ground! While staying aloft for a grand total of 15 minutes!
Now compare that to Gagarin and Titov's real spaceflights, Gagarin making a complete orbit of the earth in about 90 minutes, which is 25,000 miles, almost one hundred times greater than Shepard's distance flown. Titov Orbited the earth 17 times in 25 hours aloft just a few months after Gagarin—covering a distance of 425,000 miles!
Obviously the US has been willfully deceiving folks about what spaceflight means for all of these decades.
And they have been doing it because they desperately wanted to show they could 'match' the Russians by sending a man into 'space.'
And the reason they could get away with this is because they knew that the majority of folks simply don't have any knowledge of physics.
It is a cynical charade that plays upon the public's lack of understanding!
It was only John Glenn's 1962 flight aboard a much more capable rocket, the Atlas, which put the first American in space. He flew three orbits, covering a distance of 75,000 miles in about four hours aloft.
This was in fact an incredibly daring feat, considering the shortcomings of the early Atlas rockets. This was also the first US ICBM. It was far less capable in both mass and thrust than the Soviet R7, and could only carry a fraction of the latter's payload. More importantly, it was prone to spectacular explosions.
After watching an Atlas ICBM explode shortly after launch, Mercury astronaut Gus Grissom remarked "Are we really going to get on top of one of those things?"
The numerous failures led to Atlas being dubbed an "Inter County Ballistic Missile" by missile technicians…
An 'inter-county' ballistic missile? Why not?…considering the first American 'astronaut' Shepard made an inter-county 'spaceflight.'
But hats off to John Glenn, who showed remarkable grit to fly one of these things at this stage in the game, where the Americans were clearly desperate to keep up. Glenn flew into orbit again at age 77, aboard the Shuttle STS95 mission.
What is clear to this point in time is that both the Russians and US piggybacked off the German V2 technology. The big difference in results was due to the Russians having their own, indigenous rocket capabilities that were not that far behind Germany.
The impressive Soviet buildup of higher education was perhaps the key, which built greatly on top of already world-leading institutions like the Bauman Moscow State Technical University, which pioneered the use of deep practical education in concert with industry, alongside the classroom theory. This influence was in fact adopted back in the latter 19'th century by MIT and other American technical universities.
During the Stalin era, 'Baumanka' founded more than 70 technical universities in the USSR. Among them some of the more storied names in specialist fields like rocketry, aviation [TSAGI] and many more.
I will leave the story at this point, but perhaps some interesting and hitherto unfamiliar aspects of the early space race have been presented.
There is still much more ground to cover before we get to the moon race, but it is worth noting that the R7 Semyorka evolved into the Soyuz launch vehicles, which have made nearly 2,000 spaceflights to date and are still carrying cosmonauts and astronauts to the space station.
There are many interesting technical details here, as the engines on the Semyorka-Soyuz are remarkably similar to the original V2. The Russians simply refined this basic engine technology and literally perfected it. However, the advanced closed-cycle engines would come along later, for larger and more demanding launches.
By comparison, the US space program was far more discontinuous. Neither the V2 nor the early Atlas technology was ever refined or taken to its logial evolutionary limit. The same was true for the Saturn V of the Apollo program, which was abandoned after just 13 flights. And so on down the line.
There is still lots of very interesting technical discussion engines to explore. And engines are of course the heart of any spacecraft—in the same way a turbojet engine is the beating heart of an aircraft.
Well, it has been suggested here that Gordog has ‘sadly’ joined the mudslinging.
I’m not going to dwell on this, because the point of my writing comments on this website is certainly NOT to engage in stupid games. But I will just point out that I have for the last several hours been going through my home copy of Orbital Mechanics for Engineering Students.
I am doing this so, I guess, for the reward of getting suckerpunched by some blowhard who has zero impulse control. Yeah, maybe I should just turn the other cheek, and continue spending my Sunday poring over physics texts—in the hope that I may be rewarded with yet one more volley of name-calling.
But I know there are lots of good folks reading this who want some REAL INSIGHT into what is going on with this SpaceX nonsense.
Now obviously I am not going to write the book-length monograph that is required to fully silence any and all psycho blowhards [if that is even possible, lol—especially when dealing with Musk-addiction!]
But I will bring the subject to a close that is perfectly adequate and acceptable to the reasonable folks here, who are in the vast majority—and many of them obviously knowledegable and many more also good logicians, as is plain from reading the comments.
Now the impulse-lacking blowhard, in all of his name-calling has raised a question that should be addressed. I pointed out just a very basic sketch of what happens when you try to send up enough propellant with your payload, so you can retroburn your way back in.
Now the objection raised was literally this: ‘so what!’
The implication, of course being, that we have simply DOUBLED our payload, as in that silly example, and we are still sending 100 tons of payload up there, along with 100 tons of fuel to get us back down!
And here is the physical reality: The amount of fuel required to get ANY given amount of payload back down to earth by retroburning is going to be WELL over 90 percent. The commenter Jinn noted this already, but here is the math.
I have highlighted the relevant equation, which lets us ‘compute the amount of propellant required,’ in the words of the text.. But we are coming back down, so what this exact equation will compute will be the mass fraction—that is the total mass of the spacecraft other than propellant.
So let’s work this out real quick: I will use 7,900 m/s as the orbital velocity, since that is what Curtis prefers in his text—and this is due to the additional energy, namely potential energy, that is required to also reach orbital height.
This is of course a small fraction of the KINETIC energy required to reach orbital speed, but I left that out for simplicity in my initial discussion.
Gravity is still 9.8 m/s^2, and specific impulse is 300 s, and ‘e’ is the exponent function of the right hand term.
So propellant fraction = 1 – e[-delta v / (ISP x g)] = 0.068
That’s right, everything except 0.068 [also known as seven percent] will be propellant.
And propellant will be 93.2 percent!
It should be noted that no spacecraft has ever been made that could be this light, and still survive the forces that spacecraft have to endure!
And let’s see just how much propellant we are going to have to carry up there for our 100 ton ‘starship’
This is the easy peasy math part, lol! The inverse of 0.060 = 14.7
So we need 14.7 kg of ‘retroburn’ propellant for each kilogram of total spaceship we have sent up there—that includes the spacecraft structure, astronauts, supplies, everything!
Yes, I do agree with impulse-control blowhard that 100 tons should be perfectly adequate.
This will require only ~1,500 TONS of total payload sent up to a speed of 18,000 mph.
Piece of cake! That will only take about what 800 thousand ‘raptor’ engines?
Yeah, let’s take Mr Polite’s word for it. It’s going to happen this year, just you all wait and see!
But I will stop here for now. I will only add this: note that at the top of that textbook page linked to above, the author notes that the simplifed expression for the rocket equation is ‘at best’ a rough approximation.
This is because it neglects important parameters like air drag, and also the tilt of the spacecraft from the vertical, which means only a part of its thrust is actually countering gravity.
What that means, is that this simplification WORKS AGAINST the performance numbers we compute here in our simplified way. Whatever we compute for SpaceX [I will get to that, for the decent folks here], is going to be way optimistic for reality. That includes the IMPOSSIBLE mass fraction we just computed above.
Here is the full rocket equation with the drag and flight path angle terms included, which I have highlighted.
Note that those drag and flight path angle values are shown in integral form—and also note that these CANNOT be computed by closed-form mathematical analysis. It is just too complicated. It requires ‘numerical’ methods, which are estimates performed by things like finite element software.
I apologize in advance to any impulse-control blowhards for simplifying to ‘wikipedia’ level. I know I should try harder, turning other cheeks and all—and heck even going to my colleagues who are proficient at running high end physics sim software.
Anyway, it’s just Gordog’s ‘spare’ time, right? No worries! Glad to have provided a face for a mudpie—and look forward to a few more.
I know, a little sarcastic.
But I will put in the time to bring a thorough understanding forward here, which will include doing up an actual math analysis of a Falcon 9, since its characteristics are known [well, sort of—but that’s a whole ‘nother story, lol!].
Because I know that decent people appreciate it. And that’s the folks I am writing for.
Posted by: Gordog | Jul 11 2021 19:46 utc | 228
In response to William Gruff@237,
The costs (I included an excerpt from the table above) are very telling. How can SpaceX be selling launch services for half to a third what the competition is and still be turning a profit if the turnaround costs for their launchers are anywhere near the cost of manufacturing the launcher new?
In a hypothetical scenario where this is the case, their funding would obviously have to come from somewhere else. Selling at a loss isn’t unthinkable or even irrational, provided there’s a clear objective behind it. Now, I’m not claiming that this is the case with SpaceX, only that B does not have to follow A — in particular, there’s no reason that I can see where the pricing of their launch services is pegged strictly to turnaround costs.
Secondly, unless I’m missing something, there’s no surface level correlation between asking price and cost or asking price and utility. If I’m selling a house for 100.000$, that does not imply there’s 100.000$ of value in the construction cost of that house, or that it’ll provide the new owner with 100.000$ worth of utility. If my priority is to increase my market share and less so to profit from each individual sale, I’ll certainly have a reason to consider selling at a net loss.
Third, although they may be competitors in the international market, domestically developed launch platforms have a multitude of advantages on their respective domestic market. The insinuation was, appropriately, that China would seek to imitate SpaceX methods rather than employ their services directly. But it makes sense to ask, why waste resources on building your own rather than employing SpaceX directly, if it provides the same service at a third of the expense? Or in other words, turning the argument on its head, how can SpaceX competitors turn a profit with disposable platforms at three times the cost p. launch?
Among other things, it also makes sense to question what the dollar denominated launch costs presented in the study actually represent — is it a representation of the material cost of launches, i.e a money equivalent expenditure of effort on the part of the bureau? Is it simply the rate which they feel comfortable in charging for their services? I was not able to clarify this from perusing the Launch Cost Analysis paper, only the statement that the costs presented were averages of the entire launch history of the specific platform and excluded supplementary costs such as insurance.
Additionally, are the bureaus desperate for outside funding or comfortably subsisting on government contracts? Such questions, I think, have a more immediate impact on any price disparity than the presumed value of reusable platforms.
William Gruff@239,
The price for a Falcon 9 launch varies depending upon new/used and recovery/no recovery, so it seems like some objective factors relating to the costs going into the launch are considered.
Well, it wouldn’t be definitive, but it would certainly support your argument if a new Falcon 9 launch without recovery was priced in the same range as other launch vehicles in the same weight category.
Posted by: Skiffer | Jul 11 2021 22:37 utc | 242
Peter, yes…recovering second stage is a pipe dream, just like this starship / flying dustbin, lol!
Btw, about my #228, where I mentioned that full payload for a 100 ton spacecraft would be 1,500 tons, with over 90 percent of that being propellant required…
Well, I’m just going to mention total rocket mass at launch for a science fiction rocket that is going to hurl 1,500 tons to 18,000 mph orbital velocity.
The best we can do is about four percent payload. Musk’s Falcon 9 has never carried that big of a payload fraction! He hasn’t even done THREE PERCENT.
[I’m still planning to do an analysis on Falcon 9, where we at least have some sketchy and half-believable data, lol; Did I mention secrecy and ‘fudging’ and ‘alternative facts’ is a very large part of the Musk MO?]
So getting back to launching a ‘starship’ that’s going to ‘retroburn’ from orbit. With four percent payload, it means our total mass to payload mass ratio is 25!
Multiply 25 by 1,500 tons to get the launchpad mass of the rocket. That’s 37,000 TONS, about 12 Saturn V’s.
Yeah, that’s what retroburning back a 100 ton spacecraft comes out to. Maybe Musk can invent a new kind of launchpad while he’s at it? Not to mention the 100 MILLION pounds of engine thrust at liftoff? [That would require 200 ‘raptor’ engines, if we are to believe the claims that each one makes 500,000 pounds.]
But look, even if we scale that returnable, retroburning spacecraft down by a factor of 10, so ten tons. It still means 150 tons payload, which has never been done. And a rocket mass of 3.75 million tons, bigger than Saturn V.
And that 10 tons of actual spacecraft would be just a bit bigger than the size of a 7.2 ton Soyuz that carries three people to the space station. Yeah, that’s a real ‘gamechanger’ right there, lol! Use a Saturn V to launch a Soyuz. Brilliant!
And about landing that second stage of a Falcon 9 back. Some people will tell you that they are supposedly ‘testing’ that now, lol!
Those only weigh four tons empty. Although they would need to weigh 60 tons with enough propellant to do that…which means the Falcon 9 would need to be about five times bigger etc etc.
Thanks for that graph—1,700 m/s is about 3,800 mph. But here is the key to the whole thing. It comes to a complete STOP, zero UPWARD velocity, before gravity pulls it back down and it speeds back up. That is why it is possible to do this landing.
This graph is obviously Total velocity, because remember the rocket is tilted in the ascent, progressively more as it climbs, because it needs to get into a circular orbit in order to generate the centrifugal force needed for orbit.
So we see that this graph actually never goes down to zero speed, which is obviously impossible if we are talking about VERTICAL speed only. So 1,700 m/s is a combine vertical and horizontal vector speed.
After its apogee, it frefalls and reaches a maximum speed in freefall of about 1,300 m/s by the looks of it, before turning on the retroburners and running those for about a minute and a half or so.
So the deceleration from retroburn starts at only 1,300 m/s [2,900 mph]. This is a fraction of orbital velocity of ~8000 m/s
And we note that kinetic energy goes up by the SQUARE of speed [KE = m x v^2 / 2]. It means that reentering from orbit at nearly 8 km/s you will have nearly 40 times the kinetic energy. [(8 km/s / 1.3 km/s)^2 = 6.2^2 = 39]
That’s the whole key right there. Nearly 40 times more ENERGY to dissipate.
This is nearly two orders of magnitude difference. Yet, the Musktards think it’s all just the same deal, lol!
Also I see some are repeating the urban legend that all the ‘scientists’ were saying the landing back of that first stage supposedly couldn’t be done.
Well, actually that’s not true. The tail-landing of rockets idea has been around since the beginning of rockets. No serious rocket engineer would say it couldn’t be done.
They might have said, ‘what’s the point’—and they would probably still be right, if we had a clear picture of how much corporate welfare Musk is getting.
Btw, here’s another excellent video by this Thunderfoot fellow, from just two weeks ago: the Vaporware King, lol!
Posted by: Gordog | Jul 12 2021 3:00 utc | 247
@Gordog #165:
As for retro-burning to slow down. This can only work AFTER the craft has slowed down to a quite LOW SPEED first.
Can you please explain why?
You would need the SAME amount of fuel coming down, as going up! […] Now it is obvious that if you are going to burn fuel to slow yourself right back down from 18,000 mph to zero mph, you will burn EXACTLY THE SAME AMOUNT OF ENERGY.
Wait, but doesn’t the rocket have less mass after spending the fuel to accelerate, meaning it now needs less fuel to decelerate?
Tsiolkovsky’s rocket equation is the basic physics of all spaceflight, that governs this.
Yes, and when we apply the Tsiolkovskiy rocket equation to this situation (ignoring the atmosphere), we get
Δv = vₑ ⋅ ln(m₀ / m₁) = vₑ ⋅ ln(m₁ / m₂) , i.e., m₀ / m₁ = m₁ / m₂ ,
where m₀ is the starting mass, m₁ is the mass after the rocket has accelerated to orbital speed, and m₂ is the mass after it has decelerated back to 0 (dry mass). It then follows that (m₀ − m₁), i.e., the amount of fuel spent speeding up, is (m₁ / m₂) times greater than (m₁ − m₂), i.e., the amount of fuel spent slowing down:
m₀ − m₁ = m₁^2 / m₂ − m₁ = (m₁ / m₂) ⋅ (m₁ − m₂) .
So, no, according to the Tsiolkovskiy rocket equation, you would need less fuel coming down, not “the SAME amount of fuel” (again, ignoring the atmosphere). If you now account for the atmosphere, you need even less fuel.
I know, even experts make rookie mistakes, but since you have taken it upon yourself to educate the bar on aerospace matters, you have to be more careful with your statements, especially when using all caps.
Now, what you were probably trying to say is that the rocket equation precludes the creation of a “single-stage-to-Earth-LEO-and-back” chemical rocket based on known chemistry (ignoring the atmosphere). Assuming Δv = 9 km/s (no atmospheric drag) and vₑ = 3.05 km/s (best-in-class rocket engine RD-180, at surface level), we get:
m₀ / m₁ = m₁ / m₂ = e^(Δv / vₑ) ≈ 19.1 ,
giving us the dry mass—the mass of engines, tanks, landing legs, etc.—of just 0.27% of the launch mass, which is impossible.
But, of course, Starship is not a single-stage rocket: it is the second stage launched on top of the first stage, Super Heavy. And our planet has an atmosphere, allowing the use of aero-braking. So the limitations placed by the simplest form of the rocket equation do not apply.
What you are suggesting has zero connection to the reality flight physics.
I haven’t suggested anything. I merely noted that there are two stages, not one, that the second stage, Starship, has two pairs of wings, and that it will have a thermal protection system installed for the atmospheric reentry test flight. These are not suggestions, these are facts. I then asked you a question: are you sure there’s no way this configuration could work? Which is a reasonable question to ask, because it’s very similar to the configuration of the Space Shuttle, which, as we all know, worked.
So yes, starship reentering the atmosphere at 18,000 mph is most definitely a physical impossibility, in every sense of the word!
You probably meant to say that it is physically impossible for it to survive such reentry. You strike a very authoritative tone, but your statements are not very precise.
Again, if you know even the basics of aerodynamics you know that a cylinder has only HALF the drag coefficient of a flat surface. It has no chance to do anything but to burn up.
No chance to do anything? Another incorrect statement. Doing half of something is not the same as doing nothing. The cylinder will aero-brake, just less than a flat surface would. Also, if a cylinder is thick enough, it won’t burn up.
Those ‘wings’ don’t have nearly enough surface area to accomplish the amount of braking that is required from 18,000 mph. Look at the surface area of the Shuttle underside, like in this cfd image.
Okay, so your educated guess, as an expert, is that these two pairs of wings, or canards, or whatever you want to call them, are not enough to slow down Starship sufficiently. Of course, you haven’t actually run the numeric simulations. I’m pretty sure SpaceX’s engineers did. But if live tests show that they’re wrong and you’re right, what’s to prevent SpaceX from simply increasing their size, or replacing them with a delta-wing attached to the side?
The heat shielding on the bottom of that craft was an ENORMOUS scientific and engineering undertaking that took many years. This flying dustbin has ZERO heat shielding of any kind, lol!
Yes. And NASA will share the results of this enormous undertaking with SpaceX, just like they shared their know-how to help it build Crew Dragon. And SpaceX won’t have to pay for it, because a decision has been made to subsidize SpaceX. The Starship prototypes built so far didn’t have the heat shielding installed because they were built for low-altitude flight tests.
Look, you can drink the Musk koolaid if you prefer…
I don’t drink anyone’s Kool-Aid—neither Musk’s nor yours. Our discussion is about the technical aspects of the Super Heavy/Starship launch system. Musk has nothing to do with it.
…but his supposed ‘orbital flight’ is either going to be suborbital, or the whole thing is just going to burn up.
I actually agree with you on this. I too think that the first atmospheric reentry test flight will result in Starship burning up. I don’t think the termal protection system will work on the first try. However, they will collect detailed test flight data, the system will be improved, and eventually they will get it working. Because if it worked on the Space Shuttle, why can’t it work on Starship?
What little they have said is that it is only going to go as far as Hawaii and splash down in the ocean, lol. So that’s no ‘orbital’ flight.
Yes, that’s an orbital flight. They’re launching from Texas eastwards towards Hawaii. You can see the trajectory in their filing with the FCC.
Like the guy in the video says. Musk can go ahead and ‘evolve’ that flying dustbin into a proper Shuttle-like reentry vehicle, which will take many many years and billions of dollars.
That is exactly what SpaceX will do. They will keep iterating until it survives reentry and lands. I thought you were saying the concept of Starship was “physically impossible”? Now you’re saying it will take time and money? That’s a completely different position.
And then he might as well put wheels on it, so it can glide in without any fuel, and without eating into the already precious payload to begin with.
Won’t work on Moon and Mars, which they eventually want to go to.
Posted by: S | Jul 13 2021 12:38 utc | 283
To the commenter S, who hasn’t bothered actually reading my subsequent comments in this thread.
About That ‘flight plan’ with the FCC for the ‘orbital’ flight of ‘starship.’
The distance from Texas to Hawaii, flying eastbound, is about 25,000 km. The flight duration stated in that ‘document’ you linked to gives a total flight time of 5,400 seconds, which is exactly 1.5 HOURS.
The second stage engines cut off at 520 seconds, at which point it will have reached its maximum velocity. If we subtract that, plus another 500 seconds for descent, it leaves ~4,400 seconds of ‘orbital flight to cover 25,000 km.
That’s an ‘orbital’ velocity of 5.7 km/s, which is actually NOT orbital velocity. It’s short by more than 2 km/s, or about 30 percent slower.
In simple terms, that ~4,400 seconds of flight time at ‘orbital’ velocity is exactly 73.3 MINUTES of flight time, to cover 25,000 km.
By comparison, an actual orbital flight at 7.9 km/s will make a complete orbit of the earth’s 40,000 km circumference in a time of 84 minutes.
Maybe you could explain the difference? So that we can take your word for it that this is indeed an ‘orbital’ flight. [Which doesn’t actually make even a single orbit?]
Also note we have not accounted for the distance flown over the ground in those 1,000 seconds of ascent to maximum velocity, and descent from there—which are going to be substantial, and would be subtracted from the 25,000 km total distance.
Even if the average speed of those ascents and descents is 2 km/s that still cuts the flight distance of that ‘orbital’ segment to at most 23,000 km.Which drops the ‘orbital’ velocity down to 5.2 km/s.
Orbital speed, again, is 7.9 km/s.
Btw, if you have any solid information on key numbers for that contraption, like the mass of that ‘starship’ payload and, crucially, the mass of its fuel carried, I would appreciate hearing it.
Also the mass of that booster stage, fuel mass, number of engines, total thrust etc.
From that ‘document,’ under ‘flight profile’:
The Orbital Starship will continue on flying between the Florida Straits.
It will achieve orbit until performing a powered, targeted landing approximately 100km (~62 miles) off the northwest coast of Kauai in a soft ocean landing.
Mmmhmm. And the particulars of the machine are all top secret of course?
As for your comments about my comments about aero-breaking.
Perhaps I should just devote the next month or so of my ‘spare’ time to make the technical particulars of atmospheric reentry understandable for the layman?
Surely you must realize the enormity of the subject of atmospheric reentry. Yet you say things like:
No chance to do anything? Another incorrect statement.
Doing half of something is not the same as doing nothing.
Okay then. Perhaps YOU could go ahead and explain how atmospheric reentry works? If you don’t mind?
Posted by: Gordog | Jul 13 2021 16:33 utc | 295
@Gordog #295:
To the commenter S, who hasn’t bothered actually reading my subsequent comments in this thread.
That is true. I only had time to respond to your comment #165 that I took as your answer to my comment #162. I will try to catch up with the rest of the thread.
The distance from Texas to Hawaii, flying eastbound, is about 25,000 km.
SpaceX Launch Facility at Boca Chica Village, Texas is located at N 25.99822, W 97.15732. I have used the third image of the trajectory from the FCC application and Google Maps’ satellite view to estimate the splashdown point to be at approximately N 23, W 160. Plugging these into NOAA’s Latitude/Longitude Distance Calculator, I get 6301 km. Since the Starship is flying eastbound, the distance is then approximately 40075 − 6301 = 33774 km.
If we subtract that, plus another 500 seconds for descent, it leaves ~4,400 seconds of ‘orbital flight to cover 25,000 km.
That’s an ‘orbital’ velocity of 5.7 km/s, which is actually NOT orbital velocity. It’s short by more than 2 km/s, or about 30 percent slower.
33774 km / 4400 s = 7.68 km/s
Maybe you could explain the difference? So that we can take your word for it that this is indeed an ‘orbital’ flight.
Yes, I can explain it. The explanation for the difference is that you are sloppy in your calculations and statements.
Btw, if you have any solid information on key numbers for that contraption, like the mass of that ‘starship’ payload and, crucially, the mass of its fuel carried, I would appreciate hearing it.
See the Wikipedia article and the product page on SpaceX’s website (click left/right arrows to view more specs).
Surely you must realize the enormity of the subject of atmospheric reentry. Yet you say things like:
No chance to do anything? Another incorrect statement.
Doing half of something is not the same as doing nothing.
You said that the drag coefficient of a cylinder is half that of a flat surface. That must mean that the aero-braking is still happening, just not as efficiently as in the case of a flat surface. So the cylinder is actually doing something, and it is incorrect to say that it has “no chance to do anything”.
Of course, as I’ve already mentioned twice, it’s not just a cylinder, there are two pairs of wings/canards. And there’s a thermal protection system: you can see the tiles installed on one of the Starship prototypes in this video.
You still haven’t addressed my main point: how can it be “physically impossible” for Starship + Super Heavy to do what the Space Shuttle + an external tank + SRBs did?
Posted by: S | Jul 14 2021 3:45 utc | 300
|