Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
December 21, 2020
A No Deal Brexit Is Now All But Certain To Happen

"Fog in channel. Continent cut off." is a famous headline that was once used in a British newspaper (or maybe not). It encapsulates the snobbish British attitude towards Europe. Some fog indeed arose in the channel today but a much denser cloud will arise from the waters on January 1.

The new variant of the SARS-CoV-2 virus now per-dominant in south England has give a sudden foretaste of the chaos that can be expected at Britain's borders 10 days from now when Britain will leave the custom union and common market with the EU.

It remains unclear how much the mutant virus will change the course of the pandemic:

Scientists, meanwhile, are hard at work trying to figure out whether B.1.1.7 is really more adept at human-to-human transmission—not everyone is convinced yet—and if so, why. They’re also wondering how it evolved so fast. B.1.1.7 has acquired 17 mutations all at once, a feat never seen before.
…
One reason to be concerned, [Andrew Rambaut, a molecular evolutionary biologist at the University of Edinburgh,] says, is that among the 17 mutations are eight in the gene that encodes the spike protein on the viral surface, two of which are particularly worrisome. One, called N501Y, has previously been shown to increase how tightly the protein binds to the angiotensin-converting enzyme 2 receptor, its entry point into human cells. The other, named 69-70del, leads to the loss of two amino acids in the spike protein and has been found in viruses that eluded the immune response in some immunocompromised patients.
…
In a press conference on Saturday, Chief Science Adviser Patrick Vallance said B.1.1.7, which first appeared in a virus isolated on 20 September, accounted for about 26% of cases in mid-November. “By the week commencing the ninth of December, these figures were much higher,” he said. “So, in London, over 60% of all the cases were the new variant.” Johnson added that the slew of mutations may have increased the virus’ transmissibility by 70%.

Christian Drosten, a virologist at Charité University Hospital in Berlin, says that was premature. “There are too many unknowns to say something like that,” he says. For one thing, the rapid spread of B.1.1.7 might be down to chance. Scientists previously worried that a variant that spread rapidly from Spain to the rest of Europe—confusingly called B.1.177—might be more transmissible, but today they think it is not; it just happened to be carried all over Europe by travelers who spent their holidays in Spain. Something similar might be happening with B.1.1.7, says Angela Rasmussen, a virologist at Georgetown University. Drosten notes that the new mutant also carries a deletion in another viral gene, ORF8, that previous studies suggest might reduce the virus’ ability to spread.

Some 40 countries reacted to yesterday's news of the new virus variant by stopping air traffic with Britain. France closed all transport links with the island. Britain depends on food from abroad and there were immediately fears about supply shortages:

UK supermarkets and supply chain experts warned of potential shortages of some products if the French restrictions aren't eased soon. The UK government held a crisis meeting Monday.

One major supermarket chain, Sainsbury's, said it had stockpiled enough produce to prevent Brits going without their Christmas dinners but warned of shortages of some fresh fruit and vegetables if the situation doesn't improve soon.

"If nothing changes, we will will start to see gaps over the coming days on lettuce, salad leaves, cauliflowers, broccoli, citrus fruit — all of which are imported from EU at this time of year," Sainsbury's said in a statement. "We hope UK and French [governments] can come to a solution that prioritizes immediate passage of produce and food."

The closing down of transport routes makes little sense as the horse has already left the proverbial barn. The B.1.1.7 mutant was first observed on September 20. As it is now prevalent in south Britain it has certainly already crossed the borders and reached other countries. If it really has an advantage over other variants of the virus by being more infectious it will in the end be found all over the world.

Britain has an excellent integrated surveillance system for virus variants. In about 5% of all Covid-19 cases in Britain the virus genome gets sequenced. Other countries sequence one in 1000 cases or even less. There is no way they could find and isolate all carriers of the new variant.

The proverbial fog that came down with the new virus variant is therefore likely to lift soon.

But a few days later the fog will arise again. Over the last days the chance of a hard no-deal Brexit on December 31 has mightily increased. Without a deal the easy transfer of goods from and to Britain will end. As new procedure have not been put into place the chaos that will cause will by far exceed anything we are seeing today.

Yves Smith sees little chance for a deal to still happen. Her opener is appropriate:

One has to wonder if all the bad karma that the UK incurred in its imperial days has finally come home to roost with a vengeance. The UK has found that the Brexit cliff edge arrived early thanks to a Covid cordon imposed by its trade partners, and as we’ll discuss soon, the real Brexit cliff is bearing down on the UK.

The last negotiations on Sunday about a deal that would allow Britain common market access have failed. There are at least two open issues. Fishing rights for EU countries in British waters is the more populist one. But the 'level playing field', which means that Britain has to stick to some EU rules if it wants free market access, is the way more important issue:

Because the Brexit deadline “wolf” has been cried one too many times, the press is under-reacting to the failure to come to an agreement over the weekend. This is an event horizon. It even resembles the way the real-life version is supposed to work, that there’s no obvious change when an object gets irrevocably sucked into the gravitational field of a black hole. The two sides are bizarrely still talking about a deal that now can’t get done in time as opposed to changing focus to what happens on January 1 and what can be done to ameliorate the damage.

In fairness, the EU now looks to be engaging in an empty exercise simply to preserve its claim that it didn’t leave the negotiating table. But Barnier would need a new mandate to do anything different, or at least some interim guidance from the Commission.

Nevertheless, the talks appear to be terminal even though both sides are still meeting. The headlines in the UK press are also making it sound as if fish, which to Brexiteers means EU intransigence, are scuppering the deal, when the critically important “level playing field” is still unresolved.

The EU can now allow Britain free access to its market and allow it to subsidize its companies or to lower working, health or quality standards. That would give British companies an unfair advantage over those within the EU. Barnier, the chief EU negotiator, has order not to move on the issue. But in the eyes of a Brexiteer a 'level playing field' means that Britain must follow EU rules and thereby does not have full sovereignty. Unless Boris Johnson makes a 180 degree turn and accepts the 'level playing field' clauses today, no deal will be made.

Anything negotiated beyond today can not be ratified by the EU parliament before January 1. Those who expect that the EU parliament will fudge the issues, and will let a deal pass without having sufficient time to look into it, misjudge the mood Brussels is in.

It's over. Brexit is done. Unfortunatelly done in a way that maximizes the damage it will cause.

Comments

Thanks for recommending that article by Larry Romanoff, Grieved (29), in the Unz Review. The sudden flare-ups of covid-19 around the world, at different times, is more than a little disturbing. On a different note, as alternative media stalwarts, MOA & TUR should be allies.

Posted by: Jeem | Dec 23 2020 1:37 utc | 101

There are increasingly genuine lunatics on this site, especially over the issue of Brexit, which few know anything about. Bevin’s “it was a very large majority that wished to leave” was outstanding in being away in la-la land. Virtually the only time there was ever a popular majority for Brexit was on 23rd June 2016, and recent opinion polls for more than a year, maybe two, have been consistently anti-Brexit but not by a lot. Why do you think Johnson chose an election a year ago? Because if he’d chosen a second referendum to confirm Brexit, he knew he would have lost.
In any case the whole creaky unwieldy structure is coming crashing down. Macron orders a closure of the frontiers for 48 hours, and Britain is on the edge of starvation. Two weeks and they would have genuinely starved. It’s that bad. The problem with vulture capitalism is that if you asset-strip everything as the Tories have been doing (since the time of Thatcher), there’s nothing left to stand up to a crisis, now a double crisis. No industry, no retail commerce (eg Arcadia), little agriculture or fisheries. Just hedge funds in the City who are going to short sterling when real Brexit finally comes in 10 days. Shorting as you know is an indirect form of asset-stripping; it’ll work fine to fill the Tories pockets for a month or two; and then what?
People don’t understand how Britain is fed (let alone works), neither Brexiters nor MoAers. 18,000 cross-channel truck movements per day, unchecked by customs, bringing in food and parts for the remaining factories. All that is about to get a permanent slow-down in 10 days time. and all funnelled through a limited number of ports, which are already semi-blocked up. You have to see the system in person to understand how astounding it all is. Customs checking will wreck the viability, but not absolutely.
As I said earlier, I’m increasingly convinced that Macron closed the frontiers for 48 hours as a demonstration, to try and get some sense into the heads of the revolutionary nutters who are unfortunatelly leading the British government, but I doubt he will succeed. Once the ideology of the revolution wins the fight, however unrealistic it is, reality doesn’t get much of a look in.

Posted by: Laguerre | Dec 23 2020 1:39 utc | 102

@ laguerre.. lets just take it one post or thread at a time…who in their right mind would vote for boris and yet they did! and didn’t he represent this same lack of concern for any of the implications of any of this here?? as for food security in the uk – to a good degree it is the same situation on the planet at present with agribiz and transportation lines all very vulnerable to interruption.. i never knew the uk people to eat vegatables anyway… that was my impression back when i travelled thru the area… fish and chips is the thing… maybe it has changed radically from when i was their.. and as far as i can tell macron is a part of this same system of money calling the shots… the powers that be were freaked out at the thought le pen could get anywhere near the halls of power, so they brought in this non entity macron… so if anyone is putting the screws to anyone it is the same extremely wealthy playing a game with one another to arouse more fear then is necessary here… how do you fit into this?? thanks…

Posted by: james | Dec 23 2020 2:03 utc | 103

For those who are advocating revoking the will of the English people and taking away their collective right to be lemmings towards their own doom, can you please explain to all of us racist, snobbish, backwater types why we should support a repeal of Brexit?
And please indictate why we should support the London-based technocratic elite that was almost unanimously in favor of staying in the EU over the little people spread out around the island who wanted to stick it to the little shits in the city.

Posted by: NemesisCalling | Dec 23 2020 2:14 utc | 104

Posted by: james | Dec 23 2020 2:03 utc | 104
“the powers that be were freaked out at the thought le pen could get anywhere near the halls of power, so they brought in this non entity macron.”
I’m afraid, James, that you too, far away in Canada from the action, are as unrealistic as some others here. Le Pen was never near power. She was comprehensively defeated in 2017, and even during the campaign, was forced to drop a Frexit policy like a hot potato, as a certain loser. It’s only (far right) Brexiters and Steve Bannon types who think otherwise, as suiting their ideology) but you attach yourself to them. Macron is in power because he’s quite good, ran an intelligent campaign, and most importantly his opponents discredited themselves, both Socialists (Hollande) and the Right (no-one wants Sarkozy back).
You are like even some (most) British government ministers (e.g., but not only, Raab) in failing to understand how dependent Britain is on imported food. The Brits are at this moment getting a nasty lesson, about to be made permanent in 10 days time. But it’s not only the food, it’s the just-in-time parts for the factories – the Japanese car plants in Britain have had to stop for lack of parts. Landrover production, an iconic British type owned by a nationalist Brexiter, is being exported to a plant in France.
Isolationist Brexitism is unworkable, but that’s what Brexiters (and some here) want.

Posted by: Laguerre | Dec 23 2020 2:57 utc | 105

#105 Nemesis Calling
There is no possibility of Brexit being “revoked” in the near or medium future, because there is no way the 27 European governments who currently make up the EU are ever going to allow Britain to rejoin the club on anything like the remarkably favorable terms you had before Brexiteers “won”. What you Brexiteers have “won” is a significant decrease in Britain’s wealth, power, and influence in the world, which in turn will lead to a drop in the standard of living for the great majority of Britain’s population. But the 0.1 percent of Britain will probably be unharmed by this.
Britain’s immediate future will involve the struggle to determine whether it becomes an economic and political satellite of the EU or of the US. Scotland and maybe Wales may break off from Britain over this question. Over the next 1 to 5 years, you might still eventually make a deal with the EU that allows you to keep at least parts of your current economy functioning (by allowing you to retain some access to European markets), in return for continuing to obey EU rules. Of course, becoming “rule takers not rule makers” to the EU will be utterly repugnant to many, so you may instead decide to retain your “freedom” to slash your environmental standards and worker’s salaries to the bone, in order to become more economically competitive. This might allow you to export more to the US and maybe even to some Asian markets, if you are prepared to meet at least some of their demands.

Posted by: Fnord13 | Dec 23 2020 3:07 utc | 106

re NemesisCalling | Dec 23 2020 2:14 utc | 105 more tosh! I’ve yet to see anyone here argue that brexit should be scrapped. It’s a farce, a three card trick pulled off by the englander elite, but like many others I don’t want to see it stopped, it is about time all the englander drongos woke up to their own stupidity. Karma is a bitch but I doubt there is a single little englander who doesn’t deserve what is going to happen to them.
My biggest concern is bucket loads of the racist petit bourgeois scum scarpering down to this part of the world to try and avoid the consequences of their stupidity.
Even now in the height of englander covidiocy they are whining bitching and moaning as they try to come here, upset that the few allowed in are subjected to quarantine. Just about every arrival caught trying to evade quarantine here has been an englander. I would ban the lot of them because like the white south africans who came here in the 90’s, their ignorant exceptionalism disrupts the balance of the bi-cultural co-operation that contemporary Aotearoa is based upon.
I have no doubt that the Scots, and maybe even the Ulstermen will separate from the union over brexit and that is much needed. The welsh are just as screwed now as they have ever been, they are simply too close to the south eastern heart of the englander elite base and their populations too intermingled to be able to have a clean break from england’s imperialism which has always been used to conceal the lie that is ‘the union’.
People who truly understand the history & geography of europe and its colonisation by the romans, the saxons and the vikings ought to know that the englander conglomeration of those elites dominated europe for more than 300 years by playing elements of continental europe against each other.
It took england , Prussia & Russia to defeat napoleonic france at the start of the 19th century just as Russia, France & england tried to take on greater Prussia (Germany) at the start of the 20th century.
It was Germany & France who had the two largest standing armies in europe and in the 20th century euro war england sided with the french army and failed. Now that Germany & France are on the same page, probably forever, right now england has no one to back it up once englander jingoism pushes europe into another war.
Amerika won’t go for backing england because the euro common market is not a market amerika can afford to lose.
Study the history of Russia, how it was settled by the Rus who were vikings outta Sweden who invaded Russia at the same time the Norsemen/Normans outta Denmark & Norway invaded western europe incl britain. How the Rus settled in what we now call Russia and defeated the black sea mob who had picked up Judaism from a few jewish exiles who escaped to black sea communities, then the black sea mob, invigorated by their new recruits swept north east to dominate the Ukraine and establish the Pale (since destroyed by A Hitler centuries later), became incrementally defeated by the Rus, it is possible to imagine that in a few years (alright decades), Russia and england both alienated from Europe, Russia by their old enemy Germany and england by their’s, France, will recognise their commonality and work together to resist the franco-germanic entity which the EU will now become.

Posted by: Debsisdead | Dec 23 2020 3:16 utc | 107

The key rookie mistake of UK is quite obvious: you can’t piss off EU without an alternative. The alternative is either the US – which would turn UK into a vassal like East Germany in 1960, worse than it was with the EU -, or Russia/China. Since British leadership is so bonkers as to openly antagonize the only economic bloc that would actually treat them fairly, they’re going to suffer a lot.
This, of course, is also true for any other Western country that wants to decouple from the uber-capitalism neo-liberal economic bloc that rules over America and Europe – their only path ahead is to jumo ship and side with Moscow and Beijing.

Posted by: Clueless Joe | Dec 23 2020 3:18 utc | 108

And Trump’s love affair with war criminals continues. He pardon’s all 4 of the Raven23, blackwater contractors. I believe 23 is the number of civilians they gunned down in Baghdad.
Pete Hegseth lobbied for them, he really loves war criminals. You can’t judge American soldiers EVER! Just Iranians for what we think they might do in the future.
This is why I will not miss Trump. Could you imagine how enraged the Iraqis must be?
1. 4 contractors shoot up 2 dozen people in your own capital.
2. You are not even allowed to try them, they get whisked away to the occupiers court system which is already going to go easy on them and the lord and master President pardons them and thanks them for their service.
3. The occupiers snarl at you and question your loyalty to Iraq since you were only born in Iraq, we the U.S. invaded, we know how to run your country.
I don’t know the facts of this case but we absolutely do not care about Iraq’s sovereignty. We are just going to shoot up their country whenever we feel like it and then take it out of their hands. We have no empathy.

Posted by: Christian J. Chuba | Dec 23 2020 3:26 utc | 109