|
The MoA Week In Review – Open Thread 2018-36
Last week's posts on Moon of Alabama:
Charlie Rowley, allegedly poisoned by a 'Novichok', has been released from hospital. There is no word of his whereabout.
[Meta remark: 519 comments – are you nuts? When am I supposed to read those?]
Adding;
A nice history piece with some surprising insights: Why Did the Dutch Give Up Manhattan for Nutmeg? Because the spice must flow …
Use as open thread …
Guerrero@44
Good question. I see Daniel gave a very good answer . Indeed hunter-gatherers were the best examples of a gift economy, or as Marx-Endahl called in Primitive Communism. The hunter’s status was not determined by how much of the kill he ate, but rather by what he brought back for others. Survival depended on the community working together
The neolithic revolution led to the turning point from primitive communism to class society as it was followed by private ownership and slavery, and inequality .
I will focus more on the more recent past and Western Civilization. Not an expert in this field by any means. However
during the so called Middle Ages the Christian Church was responsible for much of the gift giving, lets call it charity. People of means were expected to give tithes to the church, which then used the money to provide for the poor. This was also true in Jewish communities since both religions followed Mosaic Law which demanded the poor be taken care of,
Reformation led to a weakening of the church and with its emphasis on individualism , personal responsibility and labor, and its acceptance of usury. Dealing with poverty started to transition more to the state and more secular entities.
A major impact was social Darwinism in the 1800’s. A former Preacher named Sumner wrote a pamphlet in 1883 whose sentiments linger today. It was entitled “What Social Classes Owe to Each Other”. He insisted that the social classes owe each other nothing, synthesizing Darwin’s findings with free enterprise Capitalism for his justification. “According to Sumner, those who feel an obligation to provide assistance to those unequipped or under-equipped to compete for resources, will lead to a country in which the weak and inferior are encouraged to breed more like them, eventually dragging the country down. Sumner also believed that the best equipped to win the struggle for existence was the American businessman, and concluded that taxes and regulations serve as dangers to his survival”
Darwin himself felt that “social instincts” such as “sympathy” and “moral sentiments” also evolved through natural selection, and that these resulted in the strengthening of societies in which they occurred. In Descent of Man:
“The following proposition seems to me in a high degree probable—namely, that any animal whatever, endowed with well-marked social instincts, the parental and filial affections being here included, would inevitably acquire a moral sense or conscience, as soon as its intellectual powers had become as well, or nearly as well developed, as in man. For, firstly, the social instincts lead an animal to take pleasure in the society of its fellows, to feel a certain amount of sympathy with them, and to perform various services for them.”
Moving ahead to today and closer to home the US post WWII US economy was in some sense a gift community with up to a 90% tax rate and much more middle class charity in the community for the poor. It was not perfect by any means, especially in urban and extreme rural areas, but income inequality was a lot less than today. Strong unions gave corporations cost certainty and workers job security with be benefits. High income taxes reduced the demand for huge bonuses and salaries by CEO’s and owners so giving more to workers to grow the business for future capital gains (which were taxed at lower rates) was the priority
Moving into the 60’s Civil Rights and Social Welfare to eliminate poverty in the cities and rural areas took us to the door of Utopia, despite the civil unrest due to the CIA/MIC war in Vietnam and the assassinations of nationalist/civil rights leaders.
Entering the 1970’s with the Vietnam War winding down, relations with the Soviets and China improving, womens rights, creation of the EPA and Nixons talk of universal health care , and the CIA under attack the neoliberal elites backed by the MIC/CIA pushed Nixon out and the Neoliberal Globalists coup was completed
From 1975 till now its been a downward slide for equality in the US. Clinton gutted the Social Welfare System in 1996 and Trump will finish it off. Income inequality has never been higher
In Europe which was more devastated by WWII the European system placed more emphasis on a communitarian belief system. Social welfare in Europe tends to be more generous and more inclusive. Social benefits related to health care, housing, child care, employ- ment, and income support tend to be applicable to the entire population rather than limited benefits targeted to particular groups as in the US.
The neoliberal backed EU and its immigration policies is now seeking to dismantle many of these programs due to its fiscal austerity demands. Europe is following right behind the US
In 1944, “Vice President Wallace penned an article in the New York Times, “The Danger of American Fascism,” that warned about the growing right-wing movement in the United States — words that resonate today with the emergence of extremists like the Koch brothers, the Tea Party, and the ultra-conservative wing of the Republican Party. Wallace wrote:
The American fascists are most easily recognized by their deliberate perversion of truth and fact. Their newspapers and propaganda carefully cultivate every fissure of disunity… They claim to be super-patriots, but they would destroy every liberty guaranteed by the Constitution. They demand free enterprise, but are the spokesmen for monopoly and vested interest. Their final objective toward which all their deceit is directed is to capture political power so that, using the power of the state and the power of the market simultaneously, they may keep the common man in eternal subjection.”
He was prophetic
So where do we go from here to return to more equality and charity for the poor”
“Wallace told the Federal Council of Churches in 1933 that if the times would get more difficult “……they will be willing to join together in the modern adaptation of the theocracy of old.”
Christian morality and the Social Gospel formed the fundamental inspiration behind his speeches.
Not being religious myself but it seems we might want to return to the Middle Ages, or at least get back to where we were 70 years ago. Unfortunately Christian and Judaism seems corrupted beyond repair. The Christian Nation US and Jewish Israel for example have the highest poverty rates among OECD nations
I dont see a way back , and no way forward to Utopia. Greed and perhaps something more sinister seems to be here to stay.
Posted by: Pft | Jul 24 2018 1:08 utc | 105
|