Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
September 15, 2017
Afghanistan – U.S. Resolved To Repeat Failures

The U.S. military and political leadership is so devoid of learning capability that it does not fight multiyear long wars. Instead it fights one disconnected campaign after the other on the very same battlefield. Each of these campaigns will repeat the mistakes that previous ones made and will have the same outcome.

Thus we have seen several increases in troop numbers in Afghanistan. Each time such a surge happened under Bush, under Obama and now under Trump, the result was an increase in Taliban activity and success.

We have seen the use of local militia forces fail under Obama when these were called Afghan Local Police. The 20,000 men strong ALP was supposedly "trained" to hold land against the Taliban. But the local police groups turned out to be local gangs who, thanks to their "official" status, could rob, rap and kill people without fear of retaliation. The suppressed population then turned to the Taliban for relief.

The idea to create such a local force was so bad that it is time to repeat it:

The American military has turned to the [idea of a local militia] force as a potential model for how to maintain the Afghan government’s waning control — without too high a cost — in difficult parts of Afghanistan at a time when the Taliban are resurgent.
…
The size of the new force is yet to be finalized, but it could number more than 20,000, according to a senior Afghan official
…
While the senior Afghan official insisted that only the conceptual framework of the force has been agreed to, and that details were still being sorted out, several Western officials said that preparations were already underway to pilot the new force in southern districts of Nangarhar Province.

We can predict with confidence that a year from now those very same districts of Nangarhar province will again staunchly support the Taliban.

In 2001 the CIA and U.S. special forces kicking out the Taliban with the support of northern alliance war-criminals. Arial bombing based on partisan information continued for years. After their defeat the Taliban had given up on ruling the country. They offered to dissolve in exchange for amnesty and an end of the war. But the bombing, often on direction of some local wannabe strongman, continued. Many people not involved with the Taliban or any resistance were killed and maimed. Their communities called out for help. The Taliban revived and came back to fight the invaders.

For a while the indiscriminate, unaccountable bombing seemed to calm down. But the insurgency, once revived, continued. Time then to repeat and expand the scheme – if only under a different logo and in more countries:

The C.I.A. is pushing for expanded powers to carry out covert drone strikes in Afghanistan and other active war zones, a proposal that the White House appears to favor despite the misgivings of some at the Pentagon, according to current and former intelligence and military officials.

More indiscriminate bombing will obviously lead to more resistance and more war.

An argument can be made that the U.S. military and intelligence complex is willfully and systematically creating new enemies in Afghanistan and elsewhere to justify the continuation of its campaigns.

But that argument presume that there is sufficient intellectual capacity in the Pentagon and CIA to develop and follow such a design. Arrogance, bureaucratic inertia and lack of curiosity are the simpler and maybe more likely explanations.

Comments

Digging In for Next Decade, U.S. Expands Kabul Security Zone

the boundaries of the Green Zone will be redrawn to include that base, known as the Kabul City Compound, formerly the headquarters for American Special Operations forces in the capital. The zone is separated from the rest of the city by a network of police, military and private security checkpoints.
The expansion is part of a huge public works project that over the next two years will reshape the center of this city of five million to bring nearly all Western embassies, major government ministries, and NATO and American military headquarters within the protected area.
After 16 years of American presence in Kabul, it is a stark acknowledgment that even the city’s central districts have become too difficult to defend from Taliban bombings.

The center of Kabul and nearly all major thoroughfares will be blocked for most of the (already chaotic) traffic and hate for the occupation force will grow immensely.
Meanwhile – the U.S. can not get additional NATO forces for Afghanistan because NATO countries ask for a strategy. There is none and there is little interest to commit more forces without any timeframe or aim.
U.S., NATO still trying to map out Afghanistan strategy

With the military mission in Afghanistan primarily focused on training the Afghan military, the United States wants its NATO allies to take up the bulk of that role, freeing up U.S. forces to push closer to the front.
…
“There is still a lack of clarity which positions, which functions, to focus their contributions,” said Czech Gen. Petr Pavel, chairman of the NATO Military Committee. Speaking at a news conference here, Pavel added that the recently announced U.S. strategy provides a clearer picture of the way forward, but the alliance won’t make final troop decisions until another conference in October.

Posted by: b | Sep 17 2017 14:27 utc | 101

b | Sep 17, 2017 10:27:06 AM | 101
The U.S. in afghanistan is a failed venture; but they can’t give it up; too much treasure to grasp; which they’ll never get.
Lessons not learned; history not grasped…

Posted by: V. Arnold | Sep 17 2017 14:38 utc | 102

The strategy in Afghanistan is to keep the money flowing. Trump is a businessman, he understands that. The US NATO allies are apparently not in the cash flow. There’s a “lack of clarity” when it comes to cutting them in on the payments.
from the web: Congressman Thomas Massie blows the lid off the US subsidized opium trade and taxpayer funds flowing into the hands of the Taliban in Afghanistan. . .here . . .because war is a racket, a profitable one.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Sep 17 2017 15:29 utc | 103

Debsisdead@86 – Marginalized Sunni Pashtun and foreign occupation of their land ’caused’ the Taleban. Saudi Wahhabism exploits conditions where there are impoverished, oppressed Sunni – it did not ’cause’ the Taleban, nor were all Pashtun brainwashed into their cult. Wahhabism tainted the otherwise legitimate insurgency of the Taleban and turned other Afghanis against their governance. The Taleban stopped being about the Afghan people the second they declared a caliphate and enforced their religious apartheid state on all other Afghanis. Religious bigotry is NOT cultural to Pashtun or Sunni or Afghanis. Salafist Sunnis do not establish caliphates. ONLY Saudi Wahhabi adherents seem obsessed with dominating and controlling everyone else. Why is that?
Since 2015, the Saudis/UAE have decidedly turned against the Taleban because the Taleban are establishing relations with Iran. That effort is diametrically opposed to what the Saudis seek: armies of anit-Iranian Sunnis. The Taleban seem perfectly capable of throwing off the yoke of Saudi Wahhabism when it works against their interests. Why is the observation that it did have influence on the Taleban so incomprehensible to you?
Saudi Wahhabism has now turned into the Taleban’s enemy via al Qaeda and ISIS-K. Will you just as easily dismiss Saudi Wahhabi influence on the birth of al Qaeda and ISIS? Do you really see no connection between the spread of Wahhabism and militant extremists? Politicized Wahhabism was Saudi Arabia’s response to the growing influence of the Muslim Brotherhood in politics. It is religion usurped for political purposes by a corrupt clergy – a clergy that turns a blind eye to the egregious un-Wahhabi behavior of the obscenely-rich al Saud family. Everywhere a Saudi Wahhabi presence develops, dead Muslims follow. Why is that?

Posted by: PavewayIV | Sep 17 2017 15:57 utc | 104

104
Pakistan did not need Wahhabism to fuel religious fundamentalism there is an indigenous – formerly anti-British – sect of Deobandis
If you believe the above link from Wikipedia

Some 20 percent of Pakistan’s Sunni Muslims consider themselves Deobandi.[15] According to Heritage Online, nearly 65% of the total seminaries (Madrasah) in Pakistan are run by Deobandis, whereas 25% are run by Barelvis, 6% by Ahl-i Hadith and 3% by various Shia organizations. The Deobandi movement in Pakistan was a major recipient of funding from Saudi Arabia from the early 1980s up until the early 2000s, whereafter this funding was diverted to the rival Ahl al-Hadith movement.[16] Having seen Deoband as a counterbalance to Iranian influence in the region, Saudi funding is now strictly reserved for the Ahl al-Hadith.

Deobandis seem to be nationalist.
That is probably the reason Saudi Arabia has not got value for money in Pakistan/Afghanistan and there is now a threat called ISIS.
The trouble between Pakistan and Afghanistan is the Durand line which the US supported governement in Kabul does not recognize. I suspect Pashtun Taleban won’t either.
So it is not only Saudi Arabia that might not get value for money but Pakistan’s Secret Services, too.

Posted by: somebody | Sep 17 2017 18:59 utc | 105

add to 105
Statement of Taleban in support of Pakistan

A hardline religious scholar from Pakistan has said that the Afghan Taliban would support Pakistan against any kind of foreign aggression, Pakistani media reported on Thursday.
Maulana Samiul Haq, known as ‘Father of Taliban’, chief of his own faction of the Jamiat Ulema-i-Islam, said the Taliban has pledged to stand by the government of Pakistan in case of any aggressive design pursued by the United States against the country.
Different groups of Afghan Taliban after holding consultations sent a written statement to Maulana Haq, extending full support to Pakistan in case of an attack by the US or any other country, the reports said.
The Taliban factions have said they would fight for Pakistan like they had rendered sacrifices for their own country [Afghanistan].
The militant group has asked Pakistani political and religious parties to put aside their differences and forge unity among their ranks.

This is a nationalist statement, not a religious statement, and it is nationalist about two countries, not just one.
b. 101
This basically means that Kabul is not safe.

Posted by: somebody | Sep 17 2017 19:06 utc | 106

a historical letter from Afghanistan (extract):

“Every influence, every motive, that provokes the spirit of murder among men, impels these mountaineers to deeds of treachery and violence. The strong aboriginal propensity to kill, inherent in all human beings, has in these valleys been preserved in unexampled strength and vigour. That religion, which above all others was founded and propagated by the sword — the tenets and principles of which are instinct with incentives to slaughter and which in three continents has produced fighting breeds of men — stimulates a wild and merciless fanaticism. The love of plunder, always a characteristic of hill tribes, is fostered by the spectacle of opulence and luxury which, to their eyes, the cities and plains of the south display. A code of honour not less punctilious than that of old Spain, is supported by vendettas as implacable as those of Corsica. . . .. Then the Mullah will raise his voice and remind them of other days when the sons of the prophet drove the infidel from the plains of India, and ruled at Delhi, as wide an Empire as the Kafir holds to-day: when the true religion strode proudly through the earth and scorned to lie hidden and neglected among the hills: when mighty princes ruled in Bagdad, and all men knew that there was one God, and Mahomet was His prophet. And the young men hearing these things will grip their Martinis [British rifle], and pray to Allah, that one day He will bring some Sahib — best prize of all — across their line of sight at seven hundred yards so that, at least, they may strike a blow for insulted and threatened Islam.” — Winston Churchill, journalist, 1897, aged 23

Posted by: Don Bacon | Sep 17 2017 20:14 utc | 107

107
I would say the quote is imperial propaganda to justify killing the native.
This here is a report from the 1960’s hippie trail.

In Kabul you could stay at Sigi’s Hotel, a landmark on the Trail. Since the dollar or the D-mark went such a long way in 1970s Afghanistan, you could easily linger for weeks, getting high, feasting on cheap kebab or venturing out to the fantastic archeological sites that dotted the city and its environs. (True hippies especially enjoyed communing with the giant Buddhas carved out of a hillside in Bamiyan, a day’s drive away from the capital.) Then, when the time was ready, you could continue the journey all the way to Nepal, the El Dorado for recreational drug users. Still, Trail adventurers later recalled their sojourns in Afghanistan — easy-going, soporific Afghanistan — with particular fondness.
But they weren’t the only ones. The Westerners who actually lived in Afghanistan in the 1970s, on their tours of duty with the Peace Corps or European-sponsored development projects, loved the place for its laid-back exoticism. If you needed a bit of modern luxury, all you had to do was pop over to one of the foreigners’ clubs, which offered all the amenities, or pay a visit to the Hotel Intercontinental for a dip in its fine pool. And crime was minimal. An American high-school student whose father was doing a stint at the University of Kabul thought nothing of riding alone on the bus to Peshawar, across the border in Pakistan, for the weekend.

Posted by: somebody | Sep 17 2017 20:25 utc | 108

@ somebody
Each to his own, I read it as an ode to the people and their heritage, and their resistance to heathen outsiders. Sure, a bit over the top, but he was 23 at the time.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Sep 18 2017 1:08 utc | 109

Great discussion, thanks for all the links, info and comments.
It seems that the current situation is a continuation of opium wars with the same actor – British Empire – bu in disguise. The goals are the same: world domination, billions from opium, heroin, and now also opioid trafficking, destruction of the fabric of societies in the colonies and drugging them into easier submission. Add to that sending presently drug related offenders to privately run prisons for cheap labor benefiting the MIC.
Blocking OBOR, stealing minerals, plans for the Caspian oil pipeline are valid reasons too for maintaining the hell in AfPak.
Some people call it Great Game 2, and there is some rationale behind justified historically:
Massacre of British Army in Afghanistan in 1842
I believe it is also a continuation of the Russo-British war from 19. century, aimed also at blocking a land link between Russia and India (both BRICS).
Ghostship seems to find some sick satisfaction in defending not only SOHR but CIA people too, using some ludicrous arguments like vouching for those bastards that “they do not need any more money” as if he was one of them, or close. It’s preposterous that CIA could refrain from grabbing as much as they can, greed is their second name. And of course it’s a matter of control, and destroying the competition, not only the money. Hard data shows that only during the Taliban rule there was a dramatic drop, to almost null, in the opium growth in AfPak. Besides VoltaireNet writes, who is for everbody I think everybody much more of an authority than Ghostship (purposeful provocateur?), that the Taliban is destroying poppy crops protected by NATO, hence the war there. Thus the argument about Putin arming Taliban makes obvious sense – it would allow them to destroy all the NATO crops thus cutting immensely Empires profits and standing.
But I strongly support legalization of drugs, marijuana, and putting it under strict state control as the main weapon against the addiction epidemic, which will become far worse, because the global evil company is developing as we speak ever more potent, more addictive drugs to bu pushed soon on the world markets compensate fast for the terrible losses it suffered from Russia and her allies on the geopolitical arena.

Posted by: ProPeace | Sep 18 2017 4:17 utc | 110

The British are of course pleased:
Britain Should Commit More Troops To Afghanistan, Says Former Army Chief
UK to join Trump’s Afghanistan troop surge: Report
Keep in mind that some Pashtuns are savages, doing honorary killings (karo-kari) and raping boys (Bacha bazi).
Interesting read, as always, from Dean Henderson Afghanistan Part I: Fake Islamists, Heroin & The CIA

Though Western intelligence had earlier cavorted with Islamists in attacking nationalist movements in Iraq, Indonesia and Iran; it was in Afghanistan where they unleashed the full force of their young Frankensteins.
Afghanistan was founded in 1747 and ruled by a bloodline monarchy with rumored ties to the legendary Roshaniya – the all-seeing ones. In 1933 King Mohammed Zaher Shah took the throne, ruling the country in feudalistic fashion until deposed by his cousin Mohammed Daoud in 1973. [1]
In April 1978 Daoud was killed in a popular revolution led by socialist leader Nor Mohammed Taraki, who became President and embarked on an ambitious land reform program to help poor Afghan sharecroppers, who were traditionally forced to work land owned by the king and his cronies.
Taraki built schools for women who were banned from education under the monarchy. He opened Afghan universities to the poor and introduced free health care. When counter-revolutionary bandits began to burn down universities and girl’s schools, many Afghan’s saw the hand of the CIA. As the campaign of sabotage intensified, Kabul revolutionaries called on Soviet leader Leonid Brezynev to send troops to repel the bandits. Brezynev refused.
In 1979 pro-Taraki militants, convinced of a CIA destabilization plot, assassinated CIA Kabul Chief of Station Spike Dubbs. Indeed, in April 1979, a full seven months before the much-ballyhooed Soviet “invasion” of Afghanistan occurred, US officials met with Afghan warlords bent on overthrowing Taraki. On July 3, 1979 President Carter signed the first national security directive authorizing secret aid to Afghan warlords. Carter National Security Advisor Zbigniew Brzezinski said he convinced Carter that in his “…opinion this aid was going to induce a Soviet military intervention.”[2]
Taraki appointed Tabizullah Amin as Cabinet Minister in charge of land reform. Amin, who Soviet KGB Chief Yuri Andropov came to believe was a CIA deep cover agent provocateur, launched a brutal campaign of terror against political opponents. This turned world opinion against the Tariki government. Andropov believes the CIA had Amin infiltrate the Kabul government intent on discrediting the revolutionaries.
Taraki traveled to Moscow to consult with the Soviets on a strategy to get rid of Amin. The day he returned to Kabul, Amin had Taraki executed and seized power. A few weeks later CIA-backed warlords massacred dozens of Afghan government officials in the western city of Herat. The combination of these two events finally convinced Brezynev to send troops into Afghanistan. [3]
In December 1979 Soviet tanks rolled across the Panshir Valley, while KGB operatives stormed the Royal Palace in Kabul. They assassinated Tabizullah Amin and installed Babrak Karmal as the new leader of Afghanistan. Brzezinski now had the justification he’d been looking for to begin overtly arming counter-revolutionaries in Afghanistan. Though the Afghan conflict killed two million people, Brzezinski later boasted, “That (Carter’s secret directive) was an excellent idea. It had the effect of drawing the Russians into the Afghan trap.”[4]
CIA agents streamed into Peshawar in Pakistan’s Northwest Frontier Province. The city lay at the foot of Khyber Pass, the gateway to Afghanistan. Tens of thousands of Afghan refugees had flooded into Peshawar to escape the looming war. With help from the Pakistani Inter-Service Intelligence (ISI), the CIA scoured the refugee camps looking for modern-day Islamic fundamentalist Assassins who were prepared to intensify the guerrilla war on Kabul’s socialist government and now, to repel the Soviets from Afghanistan.
The Company found what it needed in Hezbi-i Isbmi, a force of feudal-minded Islamist fighters assembled and trained by the Pakistani military with CIA oversight. Their leader was Gulbuddin Hekmatyar, a fanatic who in the early 1970’s had ordered his followers to throw acid into the faces of Afghan women who refused to wear their burkhas. In 1972 Hezbi-i Isbmi murdered hundreds of left-wing students in Afghanistan then fled to Peshawar, where they escaped prosecution under the protection of the US-allied Pakistan military government. [5] The group was feared and despised by Afghans and Pakistanis alike, who viewed them as a terrorist organization.
Pakistan became the third largest recipient of US military aid in the world, behind only Israel and Egypt. Much of that aid was going to arm the mujahadeen who launched raids into Afghanistan, seizing large chunks of real estate. A pattern emerged.

Posted by: ProPeace | Sep 18 2017 5:00 utc | 111

109
It is the typical colonialist attitude to consider themselves ‘civilized’ and the native to have the “spirit of murder”, “treachery and violence”, “aboriginal propensity to kill”, “wild and merciless fanaticism” … and so on and so forth.
Churchill would hardly have described the British in these terms – this here is the independent’s list of the five worst atrocities of the British Empire
Among them ranks

Between 12 and 29 million Indians died of starvation while it was under the control of the British Empire, as millions of tons of wheat were exported to Britain as famine raged in India.
In 1943, up to four million Bengalis starved to death when Winston Churchill diverted food to British soldiers and countries such as Greece while a deadly famine swept through Bengal.
Talking about the Bengal famine in 1943, Churchill said: “I hate Indians. They are a beastly people with a beastly religion. The famine was their own fault for breeding like rabbits.”

There is one thing to say for the US attempt at empire (that has been contained by the Soviet Union, now Russia and China) – they dismantled the British empire.

Posted by: somebody | Sep 18 2017 8:04 utc | 112

111
Keep in mind that some Pashtuns are savages, doing honorary killings (karo-kari) and raping boys (Bacha bazi).
If you believe the independent raping boys was another crime the Taliban eradicated.

The Taliban had a deep aversion towards bacha bazi, outlawing the practice when they instituted strict nationwide sharia law. According to some accounts, including the hallmark Times article “Kandahar Comes out of the Closet” in 2002, one of the original provocations for the Taliban’s rise to power in the early 1990s was their outrage over paedophilia. Once they came to power, bacha bazi became taboo, and the men who still engaged in the practice did so in secret.
When the former mujahideen commanders ascended to power in 2001 after the Taliban’s ouster, they brought with them a rekindled culture of bacha bazi. Today, many of these empowered warlords serve in important positions, as governors, line ministers, police chiefs and military commanders.

Posted by: somebody | Sep 18 2017 8:37 utc | 113

Afgh. is occupied, it is not a ‘war’ >> many good comments lay it all out.
Comments on the ‘drug’ aspect.
Lea at 13. “Heroin” in the sense of heroin addiction and procurement of heroin through state pharmacies is legal in for ex. Portugal and Switzerland. In CH, it is considered more humane + cheaper (crime, homelessness, etc.) to maintain heroin addicts ‘in society’ by giving them free but controlled ‘dope’. This began during the AIDS epidemic – better to have ‘clean’ injections (free) than spread AIDS. I have been involved in one of the programs and can state that such efforts have, for about 1/3 or hopin’ 1/2 (numbers can’t be precise here) a liberating effect. (Over about 100 local addicts.)
Freed from the burden of procurement of an illicit substance at high cost (in cash to dodgy ppl hiding from all with danger to self), some addicts immediately take their lives in hand, and start cleaning themselves up, applying for jobs, getting in touch with family, which is always supportive, partners/children come out of the pit of despair, etc. About 1/4 or more return to work in 3 months (OK no unemployment in CH) and 1/4 ….give it up – all they needed was support, acceptance, and some vague heh dopey taper-off program. Cost? Negligible.
Plus, about 1/4 of addicts are just ordinary ppl who have Ok lives and don’t bother anyone, as they have well paying jobs, and affording them cheap / clean heroin is good. (see Hoarse at 18.)
Yes, it seems the US drug problem is caused by pharma marketing and advertising which is restricted in Europe. somebody at 15.
Yes, overall for pharma consumption, forbidding ads is a must. But. Mostly by docs prescribing, which is part of it all.… However, there is a factor not taken into account, and that is pain management. All over the “West” about 15-10 years ago there was a surge in opinion (science articles, directives to docs, guidelines, etc. etc.) that put forward that pain was not taken seriously enough, specially for ‘terminal’ patients who ‘deserved’ to be ‘free’ of pain, which was always underestimated, and not ‘treated properly’ for ‘fear of addiction’ – where that all sprung from idk, but i do know that many docs took this very seriously, and started to prescribe more (EU. Here it is possible to track the sum of prescription.) Obviously in the US it exploded.

Posted by: Noirette | Sep 18 2017 15:48 utc | 114

91
It leaks to remind you that you are huffing aerosolyzed antifreeze
that is neither absorbed, nor can be expelled by your lungs, so you
are essentially drowning yourself in ‘golden oil’, as is now being
reported in clinics, but not by the FDA which approved vaping.

Posted by: Chipnik | Sep 18 2017 15:51 utc | 115

59
Had the opportunity over the weekend to talk with two Americanized immigrants of one of America’s ‘just wars’.
First the younger complained the elder had ‘completely changed’ since leaving their home country, had enlisted even in America’s aggression in Iraq, and returned as a virtual walking, talking supremacist. The younger went further, and stated that ALL of their trupibe

Posted by: Chipnik | Sep 18 2017 16:17 utc | 116

59 cont’d
…all of their tribe had adopted American racist, exceptionalist views, openly mocking and disparaging Mexicans right to their faces (but not in English), as though these immigrants had wholly adopted American H8.
Then I had a surprise opportunity next day to talk to the Elder, how he escaped to America, tried to find work, was despised and spit on by American exceptionalists, until finally he joined the military, was even more despised and spit on, whilecdespising and spitting on Iraqis, until now (in my observation) he is virtually Joe the Plumber, despising and spitting on the values of The Younger.
Where did this come from? How does this transition happen? How is the H8 so deeply distilled through each generation of immigrants that Americans fervently embrace the Zionist party of Israel as a social model?!
Will the Dreamers one day despise and spit on the next wave of blue monkey-god Hindu immigrants, who will in turn despise and spit on the Grey Aliens, lol.
America ™ is a brand-name for a bubonic plague mind-rot. America never existed. There are no Americans.

Posted by: Chipnik | Sep 18 2017 16:28 utc | 117

>>>> Krollchem | Sep 15, 2017 9:39:59 PM | 28

The CIA may still be involved for the purpose of creating chaos via cut-outs, especially in Iran, and the CIS states.

I suggest that turning a blind eye to others’ drug operations in Afghanistan achieves the same purpose and provides deniability. If the drugs are going in the wrong direction, a few drone attacks will quickly see them going in the right direction.

As I pointed out yesterday, the CIA is only a part of the alphabet soup of gangster operations funded by US taxpayer dollars. Here is a more inclusive accounting:
http://www.zerohedge.com/news/2017-09-15/high-ranking-cia-agent-blows-whistle-deep-state-and-shadow-government
When General Smidley Butler stated “War is a racket” he could not imagine the current extent of the government racket.

Quite agree.
After the OSS used the Mafia in the Sicily landings, it should have done what the American government does to many of its erstwhile allies and wiped them out or at least thrown them to the wolves. That it didn’t speaks volumes. They were probably already thinking about the future and how useful the Mafia could be to the CIA in the fight against the Italian communists. Everything that the Mafia has done since in Italy (the Fascists had pretty much wiped out the Mafia) and the United States should be laid at the door of the OSS/CIA.
Similarly with the Wahhabist nutjobs in KSA, the OSS/CIA was happy to use them against the socialist/nationalist governments throughout the Middle East without a thought of what might happen because of their hatred of the West, so all the Islamic militant shit can also be laid at the door of the OSS/CIA among others. That Clinton was so willing to do so again in Libya and Syria after 9/11 demonstrates what an ignorant stupid person she was.
The CIA and all those other organisation are guilty of a great deal, probably more than you or I could ever conceive of or know about,but I just don’t think it currently runs the Afghan drugs trade and focusing on what it is not doing makes it easier for it to get away with what it is actually doing.

Posted by: Ghostship | Sep 20 2017 21:32 utc | 118

>>>> Krollchem | Sep 16, 2017 1:58:31 AM | 33

Looks like china is getting even for all the earlier CIA et al. drug running by releasing synthetic drugs such as Fentanyl and its derivatives

Currently China does quite well for drug deaths at 0.38 per hundred thousand, far better than the UK at 3.83 per hundred thousand. So I suspect it’s just generalised revenge on Anglos everywhere for the British Opium Wars in the 19th century. Although news reports do suggest that the Chinese government has made Fentanyl production illegal, perhaps they’re worried that the US death rate (6.96 per 100,000) could dramatically reduce demand for more high value consumer goods that China produces.
BTW, the idea that drug epidemics purely impact the United States is a bit wide of the mark – the United States is only third on the list. Estonia (10.15) and South Africa (8.36) lead and Iran (6.28) and Russia (5.50) are not far behind. If Iran and Russia who still both have good contacts in Afghanistan thought the CIA was running the Afghan drug they would make it public but they don’t because they can’t:

In the case of Afghanistan, the United States launched its operation there with international support following the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. The UN Security Council unanimously confirmed the US right to self-defence under Article 51 of the UN Charter. The US operation against the Taliban and al-Qaeda was supported by all countries. It’s another matter that after receiving the international approval, the United States and its NATO allies, which took over in Afghanistan, started acting rather inconsistently, to put it mildly. During their operation in Afghanistan, the terrorist threat has not been rooted out, while the drug threat has increased many times over. The drug industry prospered. There is factual evidence that some of the NATO contingents in Afghanistan turned a blind eye to the illegal drug trafficking, even if they were not directly involved in these criminal schemes.

ProPeace up page asks who people would rather believe, me or VoltaireNet. My reply, it’s not a choice between me and VoltaireNet but one between Sergy Lavrov and VoltaireNet. Sorry, but Sergy Lavrov wins every fucking time as far as I’m concerned.

. The late Chambers Johnson called this blow-back in his trilogy that you have probable read.

Yes. Read Inside The Company: CIA Diary back in August 1975 (I think) and even then I knew the CIA were duplicitous, evil, venal, vicious bastards, but I still don’t think the CIA is running the Afghan drug trade because these days they’re too bureaucratic and incompetent to hide their involvement for so long.

Posted by: Ghostship | Sep 20 2017 23:18 utc | 119

>>>> ProPeace | Sep 18, 2017 12:17:18 AM | 110

Ghostship seems to find some sick satisfaction in defending not only SOHR …….

If you spent some time looking at SOHR, as I have done, you would know that the easiest way to disprove the Washington narrative (Assad has killed hundreds of thousands of civilians, etc.) is to use the figures made available by SOHR to do so. Here is a link to the figures up to December, 2016, Perhaps you can explain how they actually prove the Washington narrative? I know they don’t.
For the claim that Assad has killed hundreds of thousand of civilians, the SOHR reports less than a hundred thousand dead civilians, and once you adjust the numbers to reflect the problems with the way that figure was calculated, it’s probably closer to fifty thousand.
Looking at the claim that this is a civil war rather than a proxy war – the number of foreign terrorist dead exceeds the number of Syrian opposition dead:
Dead Syrian opposition fighters: 50,606 – this also includes SDF dead which were mostly YPG.
Dead SAA deserters: 2,602
Total: 53,208
Foreign terrorists: 54,951
Total opposition dead: 108,159
Given the problems with male civilian dead in terrorist-controlled areas, the total number of dead Syrian opposition fighters is probably closer to 100,000
That the fighting has been predominantly the responsibility of the IRGC, Iranian-backed militias and Hezbollah – these made up less than 6% of the dead on the government side so assuming similar death rates, the government forces are overwhelmingly (~94%) Syrian and assuming the proportion of Alawites in the SAA/NDF/ militias is similar to that in the country, the total number of Alawite military dead is about 13,000 rather than the 100,000 dead claimed by many which would mean the SAA and associated militias are about 100% Alawite -clearly Al Arabiya is wrong which is not really surprising given that Saudi-owned.
SAA dead: 60,309
NDF/militia: 42,627
Total Syrian dead: 102,936
Iranian backed militias: 5,330 – no explicit count for IRGC
Hezbollah 1,387
Total foreign dead 6,717
Total government dead 113,652
There are problems with the SOHR figures. For instance, the difference between the ratios of male to female civilian deaths in government and terrorist controlled areas and the sources for the number of dead detainees.
So, the Western MSM makes claims about Assad and the Syrian government which just aren’t true, and the SOHR provides the facts to destroy those claims. What’s wrong with that? I agree that many of their incident reports are wrong but if their figures are correct and they seem to be far more so than other sources, I’ll take the figures and ignore the incident reports. This doesn’t mean I support or will defend everything SOHR claims.

Posted by: Ghostship | Sep 21 2017 12:27 utc | 120

>>>> ProPeace | Sep 18, 2017 12:17:18 AM | 110

………..CIA people too, using some ludicrous arguments like vouching for those bastards that “they do not need any more money” as if he was one of them, or close. It’s preposterous that CIA could refrain from grabbing as much as they can, greed is their second name. And of course it’s a matter of control, and destroying the competition, not only the money. Hard data shows that only during the Taliban rule there was a dramatic drop, to almost null, in the opium growth in AfPak. Besides VoltaireNet writes, who is for everbody I think everybody much more of an authority than Ghostship (purposeful provocateur?), that the Taliban is destroying poppy crops protected by NATO, hence the war there. Thus the argument about Putin arming Taliban makes obvious sense – it would allow them to destroy all the NATO crops thus cutting immensely Empires profits and standing.

I quite agree that the Taliban government had gone to very considerable lengths to wipe out opium production in Afghanistan, principally in Helmand Province reducing it to a level not seen in recent times, but that doesn’t mean the United States intervened in Afghanistan to protect it and that it bounced back to previous levels almost immediately after the Taliban government withdrew and before the US/ISAF/NATO entered Helmand Province supports that.
For my doubts that the CIA runs the Afghan drug trade, it’s not a choice between me and VoltaireNet but a choice between Sergy Lavrov and VoltaireNet:

In the case of Afghanistan, the United States launched its operation there with international support following the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. The UN Security Council unanimously confirmed the US right to self-defence under Article 51 of the UN Charter. The US operation against the Taliban and al-Qaeda was supported by all countries. It’s another matter that after receiving the international approval, the United States and its NATO allies, which took over in Afghanistan, started acting rather inconsistently, to put it mildly. During their operation in Afghanistan, the terrorist threat has not been rooted out, while the drug threat has increased many times over. The drug industry prospered. There is factual evidence that some of the NATO contingents in Afghanistan turned a blind eye to the illegal drug trafficking, even if they were not directly involved in these criminal schemes. Afghanistan is a separate case, although the current developments there, which are a result of the NATO operation’s failure, despite the carte blanche the bloc received from the international community, can be considered an unintended cause of managed chaos. In Iraq, Syria and Libya, this chaos was created intentionally.

Sorry, but Sergy Lavrov wins every time as far as I’m concerned over VoltaireNet. The Iranians and Russians suffer almost as much damage from drugs as does the United States – looking at the number of dead per hundred thousand of population, Iran and Russia are at 6.28 and 5.50 respectively while the US is at 6.96. The Iranians and Russians still have good contacts within Afghanistan, so both should have a good idea of what is happening in the drug trade in Afghanistan and good reason to take it down if they could. And if as you claim “the Taliban is destroying poppy crops protected by NATO”, don’t you think Lavrov would say so. Other reports suggest that the Taliban raise about 60% of their revenue from the Afghan drug trade so do you think they would destroy their major cash flow? So, no the CIA is not running the Afghan opium trade but merely turning a blind eye to it.

Thus the argument about Putin arming Taliban makes obvious sense…

So you prefer to believe the unsubstantiated claims of some idiotic American general over the Russians who have always denied supplying weapons to the Taliban. I would suggest that it’s you who is being the “purposeful provocateur” here.
Just for the record, I also agree with Sergy Lavrov that the United States intervened in Iraq, Syria and Libya to intentionally and wilfully cause chaos. I think he is being too generous and polite to the idiots in Washington by suggesting it’s managed chaos because the idiots are too incompetent to manage anything. I would also add Somalia, Yemen, and many more countries to the list where the Washington idiots have intentionally and wilfully caused chaos.

Posted by: Ghostship | Sep 21 2017 13:37 utc | 121