|
Afghanistan – U.S. Resolved To Repeat Failures
The U.S. military and political leadership is so devoid of learning capability that it does not fight multiyear long wars. Instead it fights one disconnected campaign after the other on the very same battlefield. Each of these campaigns will repeat the mistakes that previous ones made and will have the same outcome.
Thus we have seen several increases in troop numbers in Afghanistan. Each time such a surge happened under Bush, under Obama and now under Trump, the result was an increase in Taliban activity and success.
We have seen the use of local militia forces fail under Obama when these were called Afghan Local Police. The 20,000 men strong ALP was supposedly "trained" to hold land against the Taliban. But the local police groups turned out to be local gangs who, thanks to their "official" status, could rob, rap and kill people without fear of retaliation. The suppressed population then turned to the Taliban for relief.
The idea to create such a local force was so bad that it is time to repeat it:
The American military has turned to the [idea of a local militia] force as a potential model for how to maintain the Afghan government’s waning control — without too high a cost — in difficult parts of Afghanistan at a time when the Taliban are resurgent. … The size of the new force is yet to be finalized, but it could number more than 20,000, according to a senior Afghan official … While the senior Afghan official insisted that only the conceptual framework of the force has been agreed to, and that details were still being sorted out, several Western officials said that preparations were already underway to pilot the new force in southern districts of Nangarhar Province.
We can predict with confidence that a year from now those very same districts of Nangarhar province will again staunchly support the Taliban.
In 2001 the CIA and U.S. special forces kicking out the Taliban with the support of northern alliance war-criminals. Arial bombing based on partisan information continued for years. After their defeat the Taliban had given up on ruling the country. They offered to dissolve in exchange for amnesty and an end of the war. But the bombing, often on direction of some local wannabe strongman, continued. Many people not involved with the Taliban or any resistance were killed and maimed. Their communities called out for help. The Taliban revived and came back to fight the invaders.
For a while the indiscriminate, unaccountable bombing seemed to calm down. But the insurgency, once revived, continued. Time then to repeat and expand the scheme – if only under a different logo and in more countries:
The C.I.A. is pushing for expanded powers to carry out covert drone strikes in Afghanistan and other active war zones, a proposal that the White House appears to favor despite the misgivings of some at the Pentagon, according to current and former intelligence and military officials.
More indiscriminate bombing will obviously lead to more resistance and more war.
An argument can be made that the U.S. military and intelligence complex is willfully and systematically creating new enemies in Afghanistan and elsewhere to justify the continuation of its campaigns.
But that argument presume that there is sufficient intellectual capacity in the Pentagon and CIA to develop and follow such a design. Arrogance, bureaucratic inertia and lack of curiosity are the simpler and maybe more likely explanations.
>>>> ProPeace | Sep 18, 2017 12:17:18 AM | 110
………..CIA people too, using some ludicrous arguments like vouching for those bastards that “they do not need any more money” as if he was one of them, or close. It’s preposterous that CIA could refrain from grabbing as much as they can, greed is their second name. And of course it’s a matter of control, and destroying the competition, not only the money. Hard data shows that only during the Taliban rule there was a dramatic drop, to almost null, in the opium growth in AfPak. Besides VoltaireNet writes, who is for everbody I think everybody much more of an authority than Ghostship (purposeful provocateur?), that the Taliban is destroying poppy crops protected by NATO, hence the war there. Thus the argument about Putin arming Taliban makes obvious sense – it would allow them to destroy all the NATO crops thus cutting immensely Empires profits and standing.
I quite agree that the Taliban government had gone to very considerable lengths to wipe out opium production in Afghanistan, principally in Helmand Province reducing it to a level not seen in recent times, but that doesn’t mean the United States intervened in Afghanistan to protect it and that it bounced back to previous levels almost immediately after the Taliban government withdrew and before the US/ISAF/NATO entered Helmand Province supports that.
For my doubts that the CIA runs the Afghan drug trade, it’s not a choice between me and VoltaireNet but a choice between Sergy Lavrov and VoltaireNet:
In the case of Afghanistan, the United States launched its operation there with international support following the September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks. The UN Security Council unanimously confirmed the US right to self-defence under Article 51 of the UN Charter. The US operation against the Taliban and al-Qaeda was supported by all countries. It’s another matter that after receiving the international approval, the United States and its NATO allies, which took over in Afghanistan, started acting rather inconsistently, to put it mildly. During their operation in Afghanistan, the terrorist threat has not been rooted out, while the drug threat has increased many times over. The drug industry prospered. There is factual evidence that some of the NATO contingents in Afghanistan turned a blind eye to the illegal drug trafficking, even if they were not directly involved in these criminal schemes. Afghanistan is a separate case, although the current developments there, which are a result of the NATO operation’s failure, despite the carte blanche the bloc received from the international community, can be considered an unintended cause of managed chaos. In Iraq, Syria and Libya, this chaos was created intentionally.
Sorry, but Sergy Lavrov wins every time as far as I’m concerned over VoltaireNet. The Iranians and Russians suffer almost as much damage from drugs as does the United States – looking at the number of dead per hundred thousand of population, Iran and Russia are at 6.28 and 5.50 respectively while the US is at 6.96. The Iranians and Russians still have good contacts within Afghanistan, so both should have a good idea of what is happening in the drug trade in Afghanistan and good reason to take it down if they could. And if as you claim “the Taliban is destroying poppy crops protected by NATO”, don’t you think Lavrov would say so. Other reports suggest that the Taliban raise about 60% of their revenue from the Afghan drug trade so do you think they would destroy their major cash flow? So, no the CIA is not running the Afghan opium trade but merely turning a blind eye to it.
Thus the argument about Putin arming Taliban makes obvious sense…
So you prefer to believe the unsubstantiated claims of some idiotic American general over the Russians who have always denied supplying weapons to the Taliban. I would suggest that it’s you who is being the “purposeful provocateur” here.
Just for the record, I also agree with Sergy Lavrov that the United States intervened in Iraq, Syria and Libya to intentionally and wilfully cause chaos. I think he is being too generous and polite to the idiots in Washington by suggesting it’s managed chaos because the idiots are too incompetent to manage anything. I would also add Somalia, Yemen, and many more countries to the list where the Washington idiots have intentionally and wilfully caused chaos.
Posted by: Ghostship | Sep 21 2017 13:37 utc | 121
|