Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
November 9, 2015
No, This Is Not The Anti-Syrian Twitter Campaign

Via Club des Cordeliers we find an army of Twitter bots which is, on first sight, spreading negative propaganda about Syria.

These robots, hundreds or thousands of them, are artificial Twitter accounts which tweet every few minutes around the clock. They seem to be programmed to recite single short sentences on Syria. Many of these accounts add the hash-tag #NaturalHealing to their tweets.

Currently a search on twitter for "syria's media outlets" produces a long list with similar tweets:


bigger

The tweets are all the same basic sentence: "Nearly all of Syria's media outlets are state-owned, and the Ba'ath Party controls nearly all newspapers." with some of them attaching the "#NaturalHealing" hash-tag. A Internet search for that sentence points to the Wikipedia article on Syria as the source. A closer look at several of these bot accounts and their tweets shows that this is a recurring phenomenon.

It is thereby somewhat dubious that these bots were hired for anti-Syrian propaganda. They just quote random sentences from the Wikipedia entry on Syria which have no specific propaganda value like:

Cami Vestal ‏@CmVstl530 1h1 hour ago
#NaturalHealing The Abbasiyyin Stadium in Damascus is home to the Syrian national football team.

Other tweets these robot accounts currently put out are from the Wikipedia entry of Richard Nixon, the Wikipedia entry of the city of Manchester in England, the entry on Academic dress and several others. None of which have of course anything to do with "natural healing" but also nothing to do with anti-Syrian propaganda interests.

All the robots have English sounding names, have the registered country USA and the attached photos of their personalities are mostly attractive and young Caucasian people. The quoting of Wikipedia articles and endless retweets of other bots in that network are just fillers to make these accounts seem "alive" and to then use them to deliver paid-for advertising for health related products.

I have some reason to believe (but can not prove) that this bot army is run (or rented) by the British company Marketing Runners which says it is:

Assisting Businesses and Individuals to Increase Their Online Presence, Generate Leads, and Discover Opportunities.

The Twitter account of Marketing Runners has some unbelievable 83,500 followers of which 99.9% are likely artificial. Marketing Runners is registered by Ad Easy Ltd, Kemp House, 152 City Road, London, UK which is run by one Derin Cag. Cag is involved in various "new media" marketing companies in London.

So while this on first sight seemed to be an anti-Syrian campaign a deeper look shows that it just a run-of-the-mill marketing scam. Its twitter bots are programmed to put out quotes from various Wikipedia articles to make them look "human", attractive and seemingly alive.

All of which does not mean that there are no anti-Syrian campaigns on Twitter and elsewhere. There surely are. But those I have come across are run more intelligently. They use sock-puppets, dozens of fake Twitter and Facebook accounts with similar propaganda but run by one human or a human group. Such accounts are better individualized with more specific content that random Wikipedia quotes. In March 2011, just in time for its Syria campaign, the U.S. military purchased software that helps running such sock-puppet armies. Unfortunately they are hidden and hard to detect.

Comments

Moon,
Brilliant absolutely brilliant.
I read your blog every day and always enlightened and never disappointed.
Thank you
TomV

Posted by: TomV | Nov 9 2015 12:06 utc | 1

Thanks for the info. Could it also be said that about the western press? Propaganda for one view or another? What a dastardly thought. Gonna get fooled again?

Posted by: Norman | Nov 9 2015 12:10 utc | 2

You’re right, such robot system could be very well expanded to pick sentences from anti-Syrian press (Saudi, Turkish or the new SOHR outlet) and spread it on twitter.
It could also be used by pro-Syrians etc..
All could be a plot to swamp Twitter with garbage so as it may loose whatever credibility it still has. The “Freedom of expression” is now transformed into the “Freedom of manipulation”

Posted by: virgile | Nov 9 2015 12:59 utc | 3

“But those I have come across are run more intelligent.” My high school English teachers would insist on adding “-ly” to “intelligent”.
On the other note, the system of state press ownership seems more efficient than bribing and intimidating private corporations, which is a popular model in more free countries like Turkey (Russia seems to be a role model, although the approach was not invented there, it is just that Putin seems more thorough at anything he does).

Posted by: Piotr Berman | Nov 9 2015 14:30 utc | 4

“Nearly all of Syria’s media outlets are state-owned, and the Ba’ath Party controls nearly all newspapers.”
We can say the same about USA : “Nearly all of United States’ media outlets are state-biased, and the AIPAC controls nearly all newspapers.”

Posted by: Everett | Nov 9 2015 14:52 utc | 5

This is likely just seeing the tip of what is now a gargantuan disinformation apparatus.
Engaging some google searches on the subject of Syria yields some confusing results.
I don’t have the time to investigate this further
However, I am trying to find info on Pulse Media Group–its funding and alliances.
Any help would be appreciated.

Posted by: Steven Hunt | Nov 9 2015 15:40 utc | 6

One of the problems with all of these social networks is they have no incentive to remove fake accounts. What would happen to Twitter or Facebook’s share price if they publicly announced they had purged 50% of their active accounts because they were bots?
Better for them to endlessly repeat ‘more than a billion people use Facebook every month!’ or ‘300 million people actively use Twitter!’ and turn a blind eye to the scammers, the astroturfers, and the propagandists. The side benefit of allowing all of this fraud is you can trumpet your shockingly rapid user growth and cash out your stock options.

Posted by: WG | Nov 9 2015 16:12 utc | 7

Derin Cag can be contacted via e-mail at: info@richtopia.com
linkedin, twitter, facebook – all bullshit sites where you have to suspect bullshit.. 5% relevance, 95% bullshit.

Posted by: james | Nov 9 2015 17:14 utc | 8

An Apachi attack helicopter follows Islamic state over 100 vehicle convoy from Iraq into Syria
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KFFb5E22TvE

Posted by: harry law | Nov 9 2015 18:31 utc | 9

Well, this brings up a lot of possibilities.
There may be some obscure steganographic info in the tweets:
“steganography
“Hiding a secret message within a larger one in such a way that others can not discern the presence or contents of the hidden message. For example, a message might be hidden within an image by changing the least significant bits to be the message bits.” – Some MIT Professor
So a picture of some girl could contain a message that maybe doesn’t even need to be encrypted since no one would know it was there to begin with.
Or let’s say that some French version of the NSA wants to hide stuff from the rest of the world by overloading everyone else with meaningless data. It could know how to avoid vacuuming up its own garbage while everybody else would need to try to sift through it all.
You may sometimes hear that some “agencies” are detecting increased “chatter”, so somebody must be up to something. Real intel operations simply chatter garbage constantly, so when they send out real info, the bandwidth rate remains steady. Another reason for putting out garbage info.
The possibilities are endless.
Maybe this guy could help:
Schneier on Security
https://www.schneier.com/about.html
I looked up the domain associated with the email address provided above by james, and it goes to a very interesting and informative blog. But it’s also a PR business:
RICHTOPIA
http://richtopia.com/services
TWITTER GROWTH MANAGEMENT
** We will dramatically grow your Twitter following with specific users who you can easily transform into new customers. Growing your business or connecting to more people like you! Under your guidance, let us do the legwork while you focus your energy on connecting with customers and targeted followers.
We have provided 300,000+ Targeted Followers (Examples: @RichTopiaCom and @DerinCag)
We have made 1,500+ Hashtags Go Viral
We have created 900+ Opportunities (From speaking engagements and new clients to joint ventures and radio interviews)
I avoid “social media”. And won’t even bother to post on Google’s Blogger sites.

Posted by: blues | Nov 9 2015 18:42 utc | 10

As already mentioned, this is a plan to overwhelm and replace any truth that the people might want to seek out.
Could you imagine how soon online social media bots will soon vastly outnumber real human beings using social media? It’s horrifying. The truth of reality will be so much harder to find online going forward and that is exactly the plan.
We’re currently not even close to bot propaganda overwhelming all kind of media, and that scares me shitless.
I wonder how people will react in The future? Currently With YouTube bots reading the news for eg, with a terrible voice over of a robot, it’s a bit too obvious how fake it is, but with text like in Twitter, it’s less obvious. But they will get a lot better at this shit.
It’s also a despicable plan to undermine the humanity of people of the world who are in the crosshairs of the evil US Empire, so to be easier to be attacked and/or killed.
It’s sort of like the Stuxnet virus in its occasionally inaccurate targeting. It might have an intended target, but it can also spread to other places not related.

Posted by: tom | Nov 9 2015 19:26 utc | 11

a little OT, but I must say that Russia’s philosophy on war reporting is amazing.
Syria’s media and sitreps were spotty until last month. Now everything is practically real-time with multiple sources of media

Posted by: bbbbb | Nov 9 2015 20:01 utc | 12

Twitter and Facebook are to the internet as finance is to the economy … a huge gaming operation that parasitizes and cripples its host.

Posted by: jfl | Nov 9 2015 20:32 utc | 13

I think there’s a way to use social media without getting totally sucked in. Kinda like drinking without getting drunk. I don’t even have an iphone myself but b clearly knows his way around twitter.

Posted by: dh | Nov 9 2015 20:51 utc | 14

There are a whole bunch of services where you can buy followers. I don’t know how they work but I often get followed by some account that has info in the bio section about guaranteed 5,000 followers, etc.
I’ve also seen things about analysis tools that determine whether a Twitter account is a real person or a bot. So I assume there are tools out there with algorithms that determine that. There are other tools like “Klout” that create metrics that determine how powerful or valuable your Twitter account is — how much of an influencer you are and some such. No doubt there are marketing agencies that have services that try to get to the most influential Twitter accounts, and try to sell their customers on their ability to do more effective marketing.
It’s all getting overwhelming. There is so much money in marketing and frankly, I don’t think the money for these marketing tools are only coming from companies. There is a definite common ground between corporations and intelligence agencies when it comes to collecting information and profiling individuals, groups, population. And we know from the Snowden docs that intelligence agencies also have strong interest in “shaping opinion” and influencing people via social media.
It would not surprise me if there was some govt money going into research and development of big data and marketing tools for social media. That would explain where the abundance of money is coming from for marketing tools that are so godawful and ineffective (and has been so for a long time now). It seems much more innocent to collect data on people for marketing purposes than for intelligence profiling.

Posted by: gemini33 | Nov 9 2015 21:42 utc | 16

@16 gemini – as b’s link on the bottom of the article outlines – “U.S. Military Launches Spy Operation Using Fake Online Identities” and they have bozo’s like derin ceg with probable fictitious names running them too! this is all a given.. they are competing with ISIS for the head whackjob roles, on and off the internut..

Posted by: james | Nov 9 2015 22:24 utc | 17

Why would predominantly young white Anglo Americans with twitter accounts care so much about Syria? They are obviously fake bots. I doubt they even know where Syria is on the map but they are not real. Twitter, Facebook, Google and others like them are all propaganda and surveillance tools by the USA military industrial complex (MIC) and spy agencies.
These propaganda tools including the US news media and other media spend endless amounts of time demonizing Putin as well. If you tell a lie over and over enough then many people believe it.

Posted by: MarkB | Nov 9 2015 23:29 utc | 18

This reminds me of ROMAS/COIN or whatever it’s called in its newest version.

Posted by: yellowsnapdragon | Nov 9 2015 23:43 utc | 19

This doesn’t even seem like a very sophisticated effort. I saw this today coincidentally:
https://github.com/ryankiros/neural-storyteller
Its a program can look at an image and “write a unique story” about it. If they can do that with images and video, they can do it with text. Certainly training the computer with different personalities, likely we’d not even be able to detect wether poster is real or fake – especially on sites like YouTube and ZeroHedge where the general tone is disconnected one-liners.
The internet is becoming a trash bin. From companies like Uber and AirBnB who are using small techno-gimmicks to eat up whole industries at the expense of workers and citizens, to propaganda crap like Twitter, to the ability to divide and direct news pushing different groups into conflict – not to mention the fact that by now anyone who has used it has a dossier created on them from everything from political leanings to personalities – its the biggest social engineering effort ever created.

For every site like MoA getting 10,000 visits a day, all the big boys like the NYTimes are still getting 200,000,000. It’s value as a forum for ideas is far outweighed by its power to trick and (if need be) coerce.
Ultimately, its very bad unfortunately. Its any neo-liberal/fascist state’s wet dream. Which is probably why most of the world treats it as the danger it certainly can be (and believe me, if the USA was on the receiving end instead of the giving – it’d be doing the same).

Posted by: guest77 | Nov 10 2015 0:51 utc | 20

The only good news to come from all of this may be that foff and WayOutWest are replaced by software and have to get real jobs someday.

Posted by: guest77 | Nov 10 2015 0:59 utc | 21

We all, now, live in a world that is mostly PR and Marketing.Guess we should get used to the BS, continue to search for the “truth”, and maybe, just maybe, you’ll meet some fellow human being even interested in sharing notes. Thanks b, and all.
guest77 @ 21: Agreed. Robot trolling, wonderful!

Posted by: ben | Nov 10 2015 1:47 utc | 22

P.S…And all in the name of capturing market share.
As Chipnik often says: ” Its just business, get over it.”

Posted by: ben | Nov 10 2015 1:52 utc | 23

@16 gemini ‘It would not surprise me if there was some govt money going into research and development of big data and marketing tools for social media. ‘
They don’t have to … they’ve got CISA 2015. They’ve privatized the NSA … from big government’s point of view : hands-off, deniable, more competent spies and trackers … from big corporate’s point of view : no-tell, immunity, and all those ‘national security’ dollars will be in ‘private’ (their) hands – as soon as they develop the payment methods. Cost+ no doubt. That’ll be ‘secret’ too. National security.
The Libertarians at Google, Facebook, Twitter and the rest ‘hate big goverment’ – they still don’t control it 100% … love big corporate – they do control it, 100%.
Having ‘the dirt’ on everyone on earth coupled with immunity from prosecution for using it is a very profitable thing to have.
Guarantees the passage of TTP, for instance. National Security has been overtaken by Corporate Security.

Posted by: jfl | Nov 10 2015 1:59 utc | 24

Thanks, b. In the Good Old Days I occasionally pondered, briefly, the Whys and Hows of blogs which required a Commenter to faithfully reproduce a string of random letters & numbers before the comment was approved for posting by the resident anti-troll Bot. I couldn’t get my head around the idea that an automated Troll Bot could dream up a plausibly intelligent comment. This post throws some light on that mystery.
Does this mean that Wayoutwest is usually just a Comment Bot programmed to plagiarise Reuters, Debka, INN, NYT and Wapo, instead of Wikipedia?

Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Nov 10 2015 4:15 utc | 26

Posted by: ben | Nov 9, 2015 8:52:55 PM | 23
Hello, first post ever here. Ben, that quote is part of a longer one reported a few years back, about yet another home invasion/takeover of some elderly Palestinian’s ancestral property. It appears to have been erased from the internet and I couldn’t say exactly where I read this, but I remember it very well. It was reported to have been said by the female half of a couple who had just taken possession of the land, to the elderly man: “We won, you lost, it’s just business, get over it. Now GET OFF MY LAND!”

Posted by: mena | Nov 10 2015 5:00 utc | 27

I quite enjoy the setup on this sight….it’s oldschool. No bots. And nobody moans about the setup… I’m getting old.

Posted by: Dan | Nov 10 2015 6:57 utc | 28

Twitter and social media etc. are being severely mis-used. To put it mildly. (See Steven at 6, this is an ex.)
France. Manuel Valls (PM) tweeted a few days ago “I will see to it that nobody suffers from this problem, this legislation.” He is governing by tweet! He was refering to a tax-measure (brought in by the Sarkozy Gvmt. but not scotched by the Socialists, which has hit a certain cat. of pensioners so hard that they will, literally, starve. Between 250 and 500K of them.)
Then today I was subjected to France Culture (radio) from 7 am to 9 am (news, news, more news, and I kept track.) The main item was the Russian Doping Scandal which was mentioned, in full (5x same tape, 1x partial with commentary), total 6 times, and each time for longer in minutes than any other item. Only two other items were offered 2x: Portuguese Gvmt, and an internal F matter concerning schooling. Oh yeah and the death of Glucksman had 2 brief mentions as well. (later in the day they went on aout how fantastic he was.)
The story about the Russian Doping Scandal had as reference only a German TV show, the Daily Beast (!), and an “vital report” which was not otherwise specified.
Anecdotal, for sure, but the stew of propaganda, misinformation, and manipulation is simply mind-boggling. France Culture is Gvmt. owned and paid for; the media types who work there are ‘priviliged’ – tax breaks and the like.

Posted by: Noirette | Nov 10 2015 13:21 utc | 30

b, that huffpo piece is outdated. As I alluded to the Cannonfire blog, beyond operation Mockingbird and Cass Sunstein, the laws have changed and Metalgear can and is pointed at the American people.

Posted by: Shadow Nine | Nov 10 2015 13:28 utc | 31

@30 Ah yes, the Russian Doping Scandal. As if we should all forget Lance Armstrong – who took doping and cheating to such shameless levels that it really boggled the mind. And that he still managed to maintain respectability in the US media.

Posted by: guest77 | Nov 10 2015 14:04 utc | 32

H@26
I see you’re still butt-hurt by my quip about your gelded existence as a subject of your Queen and her not allowing you to play with dangerous weapons. Striking out at me because of your weakness and impotence in form or function is expected and I almost sympathize, but not quite.
Just as you are led by the nose by your Royalty you seek to follow what you are told to believe about Syria, it’s easier and more familiar to let others do your thinking for you.

Posted by: Wayoutwest | Nov 10 2015 17:09 utc | 33

guest 77, the thing is, when anyone in F turns on the radio to the ‘sorta upper class’ France Culture to hear the news, it is around 80% probability (with the repetitions) that the first / important item they hear, maybe even the only one they will listen to, is the Russian Doping Scandal. I’m sure, as certain as can be from the outside, F Cult. has the timing worked out.
Lance Armstrong what a sleaze.

Posted by: Noirette | Nov 10 2015 18:59 utc | 34

@34 – Amazing how far even proud France has slipped into becoming a gross replica of US media culture.

Posted by: guest77 | Nov 11 2015 0:31 utc | 35

mena @ 27: Thanks for that. Always nice to know the quotes origin. It does seem to fit what’s going on in the world today,IMO, Multi-National corporations fighting to control Global market share, using the “GWOT” (Global War On Terror), as an excuse to invade and dominate resource rich foreign countries.

Posted by: ben | Nov 11 2015 4:28 utc | 36

Posted by: Wayoutwest | Nov 10, 2015 12:09:14 PM | 33
Butt hurt, moi? Not at all (I think I generally dish out more than I cop).
And as ‘they’ say, you can’t win ’em all.
Your Queen quip was almost clever and probably earnt you a stay of execution for being WoW and “not very funny.”
The comment to which you object was a spontaneous invitation to ambush yourself.
So thanks very much for #33.

Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Nov 11 2015 12:56 utc | 37

guest 77, it is incredible. Dead thread so…
France. Here is Myriam El Khomri, *Minister of Labour*. Obviously a ‘diversity’ appointment.
http://tinyurl.com/p3j3gg7
The video (one doesn’t even need to understand the language) shows her responding to the question of how often a certain work contract, the CDD (there are two main types of work contracts in F, the CDD and the CDI, see link below for a summary explanation for expats) can be renewed.
She doesn’t know.
She is not, believe me, fudging because of dire complications or unadmitted violations. E.g. as in what would come out as: “Well officially the CDD is renewable twice but it’s often more on the ground but that is a problem I can’t address right now” / “Well as you know this question is very controversial for the moment as legislation is pending, we are trying etc. etc.”…Nothing like that.
At the end of the interview, she flat out admits she doesn’t know.
The second most common work contract in France, and she, Minister of Labour, doesn’t know for how long it can last. In F, 7-12-year-olds know these regulations. Their FOOD, clothes and vacations, depends on the type of work contract (of parent/s), and they can access the internet.
Jen Psaki is a brilliant genius lovely spokeswoman in comparison.
http://www.thegoodlifefrance.com/cdd-and-cdi-employment-contracts-in-france/
There are increasing voices predicting civil war in France. Not just crazy individual bloggers, but mainstream types. Won’t happen anytime soon but the rumblings are increasing.

Posted by: Noirette | Nov 11 2015 16:29 utc | 38