Gaza, Ukraine, Syria, Iraq.
Other issues here please.
|
|
|
|
Back to Main
|
||
|
July 18, 2014
Current Issues
Gaza, Ukraine, Syria, Iraq. Other issues here please.
Comments
For whatever it is worth, my sense, after digesting as much of the coverage as I can from the last 24 hours, is, if we apply the cui bono standard, as we did during the Ghouta gas attack last August, is that this is a U.S./junta job. Even Power’s wording that the missile originated from rebel-held territory is similar to the administration’s claim last year that sarin-laden missiles came from Assad-controlled turf. Posted by: Mike Maloney | Jul 18 2014 18:21 utc | 1
The amount of wars happening at the moment is ridiculous. Basically everything from Iran to the Mediterranean is a warzone and then Ukraine as well. Localised wars all bleeding into each other and becoming one giant regional conflict. Posted by: Colm O’ Toole | Jul 18 2014 18:27 utc | 2 Here’s the fucking Guardian on how the pro-Russians are blocking access to the site with this fucking gem of a line:
Beyond the point addressing “ludicrous theories” – just fuck off, war criminals – it’s pretty amazing how the stories/propaganda so quickly shift the narrative from the reality of pro-Russians defending territory against a US-backed fascist junta to the intransigence of the “separatists” who just MUST let the fucking fascist war criminal whores have access to whatever the fuck they want to have access to. Posted by: JSorrentine | Jul 18 2014 18:29 utc | 3 Well, well, ONCE A FUCKING AGAIN the murderous war criminal whores renege on the own storylines: Posted by: JSorrentine | Jul 18 2014 18:34 utc | 4 if the airliner was shot down intentionally, then the cui bono issue must be considered Posted by: mistah charley, ph.d. | Jul 18 2014 18:38 utc | 5 JSore: Posted by: crone | Jul 18 2014 18:38 utc | 6 The fucking world fucking community seems fucking desperate to get a fucking cease fire. Maybe the fucking Ukie army really is in fucking trouble. Posted by: dh | Jul 18 2014 18:40 utc | 7 Trusting that we can all walk and chew bubble gum at the same time, I bring up Gaza. Posted by: crone | Jul 18 2014 18:52 utc | 8 The problem mistah charley @ 5 with the idea that Novorrosiya forces brought it down is that you cannot expect a ragtag militia member to be able to operate a SA-11. You need to have radar plotted out; you need to know particular codes, etc. It is not in a layman’s scope. Posted by: Mike Maloney | Jul 18 2014 18:52 utc | 9 It would not be to Russia’s advantage to either do the deed or assist others in doing the deed. Just as in “follow the money” ~ one can “follow the motive” ~ who stands to gain? Posted by: crone | Jul 18 2014 18:55 utc | 10 I agree, crone. I with you. There a lot of people though who are taking a nuanced view, saying that Ukrainian military aircraft shadowed the 777 into a Novorrosiyan hot zone, drawing the missile fire and downing the passenger jet. This might be. But I think the idea that Russia is responsible is not credible. Posted by: Mike Maloney | Jul 18 2014 19:04 utc | 11 Questions of “Cui Bono” have somehow been successfully smeared as a tactic of true conspiratards only, you really can’t even bring it up even on the most “progressive” of websites. They get all mouth-frothy. Posted by: L Bean | Jul 18 2014 19:06 utc | 12 Yesterday, in a news article from Sky News about the Malaysian plane, there was mention that the airliner disappeared from radar as it flew over the city of Kremenchuk in central Ukraine, southeast of Kiev. So to me, as a non-expert, it seems the plane wasn’t yet near rebel-held territory, although the forward momentum may have carried the debris further to the east. Posted by: Forgetful | Jul 18 2014 19:16 utc | 13 Could Putin’s plane have been the target? I can say that Putin’s plane and the Malaysian Boeing intersected at the same point and the same echelon. That was close to Warsaw on 330-m echelon at the height of 10,100 meters. The presidential jet was there at 16:21 Moscow time and the Malaysian aircraft – 15:44 Moscow time,” Posted by: harry law | Jul 18 2014 19:20 utc | 14 #9 Mike Maloney – there are degrees of skill between “complete novice” and “expert” – perhaps someone in the middle range was at the controls – good enough to target and fire the missile, not quite good enough to use all the “identify the target” bells and whistles Posted by: mistah charley, ph.d. | Jul 18 2014 19:21 utc | 15 re: Ukraine. If we accept the premise that EU/US/NATO accidentally fell into backing a poorly thought out coup, as I do, then the timeline speaks for itself. Posted by: cincop8 | Jul 18 2014 19:32 utc | 16 All of these false flags have had the objective of NATO intervention. Posted by: L Bean | Jul 18 2014 19:35 utc | 17 @ 15 Posted by: crone | Jul 18 2014 19:41 utc | 18 ETN has now retracted the independent confirmation of the source “Carlos” or @spainbuca Posted by: Alejandro | Jul 18 2014 19:41 utc | 19 Sorry here is complete email with sign. Posted by: Alejandro | Jul 18 2014 19:43 utc | 20 Mike M., Posted by: crone | Jul 18 2014 20:01 utc | 21 re: the downed airliner – Posted by: Prey4Justice | Jul 18 2014 20:07 utc | 22 El respeto al derecho ajeno es la paz. Posted by: Fernando | Jul 18 2014 20:07 utc | 23 Thank you, mistah charley @ 15 for the Gurdjieff aphorisms. You are right. the last one is a gem. As to the idea that there was someone at the controls of the missile battery that was good enough locate a 777 flying at 33,000 feet and hit it but not smart enough to recognize that it was a commercial aircraft, that’s the question isn’t it? One that applies both to the junta and the Novorrosiyans. Unless Flight 17 was intentionally downed to sow confusion and herd the reluctant Europeans to adopt more aggressive sanctions against Russia. Posted by: Mike Maloney | Jul 18 2014 20:09 utc | 24 @9 and @10 – ditto.. Posted by: james | Jul 18 2014 20:14 utc | 25 Who Ordered MH17 Flight to Lower Altitude? @crone #10: Posted by: Dr. Wellington Yueh | Jul 18 2014 20:21 utc | 27 Evidence Continues to Emerge #MH17 Is a False Flag Operation Posted by: crone | Jul 18 2014 20:26 utc | 28 The flight path of Malaysia Air Flight 17 Posted by: somebody | Jul 18 2014 20:27 utc | 29 Ukraine launched an extraordinary attack on Vladimir Putin tonight by accusing the Russian president of having the blood of one of the infant victims of flight MH17 on his hands by publishing a harrowing picture of the dead baby. Posted by: harry law | Jul 18 2014 21:12 utc | 31 @31 Posted by: Jon Lester | Jul 18 2014 21:19 utc | 32 @crone #27: Nobody heard the plane’s pilots Mayday!! calls? Surely one of them must have got a minute or two worth of Maydays out, unless they were killed outright. But Strelkov says the cockpit is mostly intact and the pilots dies on impact with the ground.. Furthermore, if it was a SAM, it was likely chasing the plane and struck its tail section, but would such a hit render the plane unflyable? The biggest question however is who deviated the plane from its historic flight pattern–was it a voice command or an electronic hijacking? The uploading of the AN-26 shootdown labeled as the boeing shootdown by the Ukies points a finger directly at them. And the cui bono answer is clearly Ukies/NATO, not Russia or Novorossiya. Apparently at the same time, there was a meeting of the Ukrainian Security Council being chaired by Poroshenko, which is likely where the order to shoot at the plane originated. And why just one missile given the odds of it being able to hit its target? Did one of the Ukie jets “accidentally” fire its cannons, realize its terrible mistake, and peal away? Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 18 2014 21:42 utc | 35 CNN Report: Did surface-to-air missile S-200 take down Malaysia Airlines Flight 17? I couldn’t find this earlier, when I was recalling having read about it. It was posted April 1st Posted by: crone | Jul 18 2014 22:13 utc | 37 If you want to see how the US political system is driving the media check out this from VOA. Posted by: Curtis | Jul 18 2014 22:23 utc | 38 Just remembered that with the Syrian false flag chemical weapons attacks, the Israelis claimed to have intercepted telecommunications too, which USG treated as a substantial part of the irrefutable evidence that the Syrian army was responsible. As I recall, in those recording the ostensible perpetrators expressed confusion too, having hit someone other than their intended targets. It is all from the same playbook. Apparently, CNN gave avoiding a weather system as the reason for the flight path diversion (July 17, 2014 – CNN Claims Storm Diverted MH17’s Course, But Shown To Be False Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 18 2014 22:27 utc | 40 It’s fine to theorize here at moonofalabama. But when we go out onto the mainstream comment sections, as I hope most of us are, I think we should take the high ground debate-wise with the following: ‘We don’t know what happened, so why jump to conclusions and accuse Russia when there is no hard evidence and only accusations? Like Putin and many others have said, let’s have an independent investigation, find out who did this if we can, and _then_ get angry at them and punish them.’ @Curtis #37: Here’s an example of how I’m ‘doing it’, just posted under that ugly, accusatory, warmongering Guardian editorial:
After the near countless times – just since the beginning of the GWOT, let’s say – that initial US/Zionist war criminal narratives have turned out to be nothing but complete and utter horseshit that run 180 degrees to reality, I waver between thinking that either average citizens/comment posters are so fucking retarded/brainwashed that there is no hope for humanity OR that the propaganda mechanisms have become so potent that said comments are nothing more than bots generating whitewash and hasbara. Posted by: JSorrentine | Jul 18 2014 23:13 utc | 45 Meant to be: Posted by: JSorrentine | Jul 18 2014 23:22 utc | 46 Clare Daly Condemns Israel’s Ongoing Massacre of Palestinians in Gaza Posted by: Tom Murphy | Jul 18 2014 23:40 utc | 47 For goodness sake, Strelkov admitted they shot down the plane when they thought it was a military aircraft. It’s the same tragic mistake the US has made before. You don’t need to make up fake conspiracy theories that it was a Ukrainian missile. Posted by: bob dole | Jul 18 2014 23:57 utc | 48 @JSorrentine #44: @48 Posted by: Massinissa | Jul 19 2014 0:22 utc | 50 @47 Posted by: green | Jul 19 2014 0:26 utc | 52 There are several black boxes and the two recovered so far are in possession of Strelkov and Co. Posted by: karlof1 | Jul 19 2014 0:33 utc | 53 Some Western media outlet, sorry forgot which, quoted DPR PM Borodai as saying the objects militia found were not black boxes. Posted by: green | Jul 19 2014 0:39 utc | 54 J Sorrentine at 44 and 45: @Massinissa #50: I don’t think this latest effort of the US to isolate Russia from the EU will fly… Posted by: crone | Jul 19 2014 0:51 utc | 57 It simply isn’t reasonable to expect Russia to counter US propaganda inside the US. That’s just too much to ask. It doesn’t mean they shouldn’t try, only that within the US it is obvious the USG point of view will be ever present and most of the public predisposed to view themselves as the good guys. So no need to loose heart over the DKos comments, frustrating as they are. Posted by: Lysander | Jul 19 2014 1:12 utc | 58 Who is the intended audience? That’s the cui bono. Set aside the massacre of 295 innocent human beings who could have been any one of us, who were the killed for? I say the American public, who despite everything still have residual faith in theirgovernment and the MSM. I’m with Jsorr 100 pct on what’s happening here. Posted by: Knut | Jul 19 2014 1:16 utc | 59 Johnny Cash – “One” Posted by: Paty Kerry | Jul 19 2014 1:24 utc | 60 wrt Gaza Posted by: crone | Jul 19 2014 1:32 utc | 61 Posted by: crone | Jul 18, 2014 9:32:14 PM | 59 @57 The important target for Russian Counter-propaganda is Europe. Which just so happens to speak English almost as much as their native languages these days. So having an English language alternative to American propaganda is of paramount importance. Posted by: Massinissa | Jul 19 2014 1:53 utc | 63 Here is latest from NYT, far down into a lede story:
There you go. It basically says it all, and from the “newspaper of record” no less, albeit buried at the bottom of the story: U.S. has no real proof (NYT even put “credible evidence” in quote marks); U.S. accepts at face Ukrainian denials that it had the same weapon systems in the area; and Obama used the downing of Flight 17 to hector the Europeans to get tougher on Russia. Posted by: Mike Maloney | Jul 19 2014 1:54 utc | 64 fairleft, I picked up the headline from Mondoweiss site Posted by: crone | Jul 19 2014 1:56 utc | 65 @Lysander #57: This false flag airliner takedown is a sure sign of increasing desperation by the hegemon. The Ukie goons are losing on all fronts. Things will likely escalate in the coming days. I pray the world survives the coming conflagration. Posted by: Jacobo Arbenz | Jul 19 2014 2:20 utc | 67 it takes canned goods to quickstart the next great power imbroglio? Posted by: Jay M | Jul 19 2014 2:27 utc | 68 Demian, the Dems are headed for the woodshed. I don’t think there is enough appreciation yet how much Obama’s dropping all pretense that he is sensitive to the peace wing of the party (a wing that cannot be discounted in the early going of the primary season) along with zero success delivering on economic justice issues as well as his pirouettes on immigration — how all this is going to hollow out the Dems going forward. I see a party in free fall. Posted by: Mike Maloney | Jul 19 2014 2:33 utc | 69 #62…”Ukraine denied that any of its forces had been involved, and American officials said they believed that denial.” Posted by: Colinjames | Jul 19 2014 2:35 utc | 70 Kiev is desperate because Kiev, by themselves, seem unable to crush the eastern separatists. Kiev, then, needs some way to pull western powers into the conflict on their side. So they shot down the plane and seek to blame it on the rebels. Posted by: Deke Solomon | Jul 19 2014 2:36 utc | 71 @Deke Solomon #69: Good old NATO ‘Warfighter” pork rations at 0:54 … slightly BBQ’s it seems … a little gas bottle explosion? Posted by: x | Jul 19 2014 2:48 utc | 73 Fairleft, you don’t know what I fucking do when away from this site so save your fake left “don’t be a nihilist” horseshit peptalk for the starry-eyed coeds that you probably woo with your vast knowledge of geopolitics. Posted by: JSorrentine | Jul 19 2014 3:10 utc | 74 Maloney – 67 —
It will probably take a few days (at least, one hopes) before it becomes clearer exactly how Team Obama plans to use this “fortuitous’ event in furtherance of their agenda … the things one hears … such as “Hopefully now Europe will see the light, banish their doubts and rally behind Obama” with special mention of Georgia and other low-hanging fruit, now considered possibly ripe for the plucking (since Putin is now “weaker”.) Posted by: Susan Sunflower | Jul 19 2014 3:14 utc | 75 Let us play make believe for a moment, shall we? It should not be too difficult, as news today is nothing but! Let say Vlad shot down the plane as a clear and unambiguous message to the EU; kill Russians and you will pay dearly! @56 Damien Posted by: sleepy | Jul 19 2014 3:57 utc | 79 from Pat Lang Posted by: crone | Jul 19 2014 4:13 utc | 80 Malaysian jet tragedy propagandized – Ron Paul Posted by: crone | Jul 19 2014 4:48 utc | 81 Russian Spring
Russian Spring
Question: At least someone had to fly the aircraft.
Posted by: Fete | Jul 19 2014 5:25 utc | 82 @HAHA #76: @81 Posted by: crone | Jul 19 2014 5:34 utc | 84 @81 @HAHA #83: on spanish ATC Carlos at kiev Posted by: brian | Jul 19 2014 6:12 utc | 87 @HAHA, read this to learn something you should know from history: http://www.geschichteinchronologie.ch/eu/D/1945-rheinwiesenlager/ENGL/001-basics.html Posted by: Robert | Jul 19 2014 6:15 utc | 88 @86 Brian, Posted by: Annon | Jul 19 2014 6:57 utc | 90 36 Posted by: chip nikh | Jul 19 2014 7:01 utc | 91 @84 Posted by: JSorrentine | Jul 18, 2014 11:10:08 PM | 72 @HAHA #90: @92 Judging from current storries in the British and the German press, now that USG has gotten the Ukies to shoot down MH17, USG is using that massacre to once more try to get EU countries to break with Russia. Let us see how that works out. Isnt it strange that neither Russia nor West/Ukraine could provide evidence what happend? The parties must have satetlites (and other intelligence) over the area? Posted by: Anonymous | Jul 19 2014 7:35 utc | 97 @94 It is my understanding that Merkel AKA (Nipples) lost control of her industrialists; they are not on board with the sanctions. This in combination with the obvious danger the Nazis pose to everyone, may seriously compel her to rethink their partnership with NATO and its adventures against Russia. Posted by: Anonymous | Jul 19, 2014 3:35:43 AM | 95 Posted by: brian | Jul 19 2014 8:06 utc | 100 |
||