|
Open Thread 2014-09
(busy …)
Your news & views …
Natalia Polkonskaya interview 11 march 2014
http://youtu.be/kAQonPZOTvM
Google translate. TV Crim (~11 May 2014)
Hello, dear friends . End long after the holiday weekend. I hope you’re well rested. Well, well ahead of us working week . Rather uneasy . Because the preparation for public Crimean referendum . Well, today we’ll talk a little bit about something else. We recall the recent events on the Maidan in Kiev. All that happened there . Well, we all saw it here, from the Crimea. Not all were there , not all . That’s it. But Natalya Poklonskaya employee of the General Prosecutor’s Office , Counselor of Justice today in our studio . And we will hear her point of view. Hi Natalia .
– Hello.
– You worked there in the General Prosecutor’s office to anyone , I’m sorry ?
– At the senior prosecutor of the 4th cupola . This General Directorate for Supervision of the law during the pre-trial investigation of criminal proceedings , which shall be exercised by the police. And indeed, everything that happened in the Maidan , it was awful. This is something that did not allow the Crimea.
– But you were not there.
– Yes , right on Independence in armed clashes and fighting I was not. But I lived there , I worked there and heard every five minutes under the windows of his office , as the ambulance went and drove the corpses , drove victims who survived.
– But it all began , in other words, quite peacefully .
– Usually begins .
– Peacefully . I would like you to talk about it in terms of the prosecutor of the prosecutor . Everything was within the law ?
– Here now I officially declare as public prosecutors as someone who watched it all and seen as a citizen of Ukraine, which took place in Ukraine unconstitutional coup . Armed seizure of power . This is not a peaceful demonstration , which all so fiercely and valiantly says and says to this day for some reason . I do not understand what a peaceful demonstration ? She was not on February 18 or January 19. And at such festivals that …
– You are already talking about the highlights of the days when it really turned into a military phase.
– Yes, indeed. Because these are the events that are stored separately. And those are the culminating days, which will remain in memory forever. This flowering of Nazism. Nazism is one from which we have saved our grandfathers , grandmothers , who with their blood watered the earth , so that we in a tranquil setting in a quiet life in a peaceful life with a clean -air living . And now at the level of government, the present government of Kiev all encouraged. Nazism leveled just as some heroism , heroism .
– In what way? Where there Nazism ?
– The fact that currently has the Verkhovna Rada (Supreme Council of Ukraine) adopted , accepted , and is under consideration in the Verkhovna Rada of the law on the liberalization of the “right sector.” Who is the ” Right sector” ? All of you, all the citizens , all the people who live in Ukraine and not only outside of Ukraine , all seen , all watched on television , many watched from their windows , including I saw people running with shields with some guns , shooting at our soldiers , who were unarmed , who stood on the protection of public order . They all have one slogan and one flag – black and red. This flag Bandera.
– Please tell me we have in Ukraine banned black and red flag ? Yes, this flag Bandera.
– Well , now , as I understand it , it will soon be the flag patriotic spirit of Ukraine.
– You know , Natalia, it all happened yesterday and not February 19. We have put years Bandera monuments , quite explicit , well, so to speak, the documentary Hitler’s accomplice . That’s understandable. But this one did not oppose . And including the prosecutor’s office , right?
– No, why ? Previously, prosecutors , to behold such a radical breakthrough in our power once demolition sites, monuments , even our soldiers , our soldiers , our heroes bring cases are investigated . The attitude of the people was completely different – not the same as now . Now pull down a statue of Lenin – is heroism.
– Yes, it’s prowess. This is true .
– Now discourage hand monument to soldiers who died for us, dear compatriots , dear Crimean’s , those warriors who died for us , the fact that just unceremoniously brazenly destroyed. And as we can safely look at it ? I did not understand . It’s just inside .
– Natalia , I’m sorry , but these emotions that you say , they are quite clear to us . But then immediately , and a question for you . And what about you , where you , the prosecutor , Attorney General of the country?
– Prosecutor General’s Office in the country contributes information ERDR and tries …
– It’s that, sorry ?
– This is the Unified Register of pre-trial investigations . And , apparently , is investigating the case properly oversee the investigation of these cases . But again , that’s all these facts , which were committed by the government, by the present , I believe that an illegitimate government , which came through the blood. That soldier that blood , that blood that ordinary citizens who suffered purely coincidental . They welcome it . They indulge , they just indulge nationalism , Nazism . That this banderskomu Nazism . Look who we have running for president. This is the man who is on the international wanted list. This is the man who calls to murder, to weaponry .
– You’re talking about Dmitry Jaros ?
– Yes, I ‘m talking about Dmitry Jaros . Those who had brought this army , the one who cried on the Maidan, not afraid of anyone .
– You know, yes, indeed . But we want to know the legal assessment of his actions . We want to know how to relate to his appeal to his appeals to various armed actions. Here’s how to include law enforcement agencies ? After all, they have to react .
– Should and must respond . Obliged . But for myself, I made a choice and do not support the present regime in Kiev. Work in the General Prosecutor’s Office I will not .
– So you ‘re saying that just the Prosecutor General is quite loyal to this ?
– I do not want to say anything about this, because the Prosecutor General are working quite adequate and very competent staff and wise , my colleagues , whom I respect. But what happened , the people who came to power and now instruct and guide our country , directly in Kiev, I do not support them . So stay in Kiev and the General Prosecutor’s Office I will not. Regardless, I ‘m sorry, regardless of whether I stay unemployed , I will work , but keep this one Nazism does not allow me my conscience . Look at me the same way and look at you all your grandfathers who died . Those soldiers are patriots who died. And those soldiers , who were standing on the Maidan and human shield to not skip this ” Right sector” , these radicals crazy , you know. Conscience will not let me .
– And your colleagues , Natalia, in the Attorney General’s Office allows conscience?
– To this question I can not answer . Many colleagues, I , again , I will repeat , but worthy . And they have their own reasons , its reasons , its argument . Therefore, this issue should be set directly to each person . I – no. I do not want to take this position .
– Natalia, these days, in those days of February than the Prosecutor’s Office , where there were fights when militiamen burned when fire to the building and seized them, when, in fact , simply looted the stores that were in these streets , and so on, what worked prosecutors ?
– The prosecutor’s office did not sleep . The prosecutor’s office during the day and night was in the workplace. And just experienced, and perhaps even more.
– But she had to act , except experiences?
– No, we’re going to constantly information . Just in those days such a huge work has been done , this is a crazy amount of work .
– And what exactly ?
– Registration in the Unified Register endless pre-trial investigations . It is directly on those procedural “kerivnitstvo provadzheniyam” (ukr. leadership in the proceedings) that have been instituted . This again , we remember the last amnesty , which the Attorney General Victor P. Pshonka launched into action and which have not kept our opposition and our invaders administrative buildings. Restrained the former government , and well, and so it happened , we all watched these spontaneous events . But all this is , again, a lot of work . prosecutors and day and night fixed , who, when, where, what relieved that captured again. This criminal case is endless investigations , this endless instructions directly involved and investigative actions . Again, all of this was carried out in this mode …
– But not where these events took place ? No ?
– No, just on Independence we are. We were working at their jobs . Duty . Duty , night shifts were . These are the guys who “Berkut” , internal troops , and they were next to us . And we all saw it . And all cooked and everything worked , and all hoped that there will be bloodshed, such as have been approved.
– Legal assessment can find it here ? Here you can see how to perform their professional duties and duties to the police in the face of “Berkut” . And you see that with them here makes this crowd . Well, some misunderstanding arose Management Action why let burn and kill policemen and nothing happens ? And they forbid simply shifted . They were just standing wall and fell when they were killed .
– This is something extraordinary . It is impossible to explain reasonable words. At me it just does not fit in my head , as cannon fodder soldiers put these 19 -year-olds . I’ve still want to emphasize , I in Kiev, there as in Kiev, there is now the heroes – this “heavenly hundred .” Yes, people died. People have died . But these are the soldiers who were they not heroes in Kiev. About them for some reason everyone forgets . And the MVDshny(police) hospital where were treated to this day being treated soldiers , 19 -year-olds from the Internal Troops, I came to them . And I want to say to express my gratitude to those doctors who are really in good faith and are concerned , I saw it with my own eyes , as they relate to these guys , how they are treated . And these guys are in this hospital . Mom can not come because my mother does not have such funds to rent an apartment in Kiev. And there are some guys , they 19 years . And when I was in the hospital and talked to one of the internal troops , I will not specify the name of this young man, he’s 19 years old, he is from Dnepropetrovsk, he serves in the army four months. Of these three months was at Maidan . He ‘s broken hand , he is still on treatment. He told me with frightened eyes said one thing: ” You know me as never before in life, no one beat .” This 19 -year-old guy.
– Yeah, just do not understand the actions of the leadership , which has exposed young children and did not give them anything to do. Even , in fact, be protected . They just stood there . Do not you think it strange ? Why is this happening ? Have you discussed this in the prosecutor’s office , at least among colleagues , so why allow people to kill ?
– This, of course , discussed with colleagues and prosecutors , prosecutors and beyond . And only one hope : that now, but tomorrow it will change . That’s tomorrow these guys will protect us . That’s tomorrow. But there was one mistake : these have already made radical forces in Kiev . And in Kiev mood completely different people . When I arrived for their belongings in Kiev , all the people of Kiev , whom I met – taxi drivers – they empathized with me . They say, and where are you from ? I say, from the Crimea. Oh dear , so you took the same ! I say yes we have not captured . This , folks, you have captured . In Crimea – this will of the people.
– That is a big part of Kiev ‘s now create a mood ?
– Yes .
– But this is a zombie people.
– It’s a zombie . This zombie . They are all under some hypnosis. That really changed the concepts of good and evil. People forget , people have forgotten their history . And who has not forgotten , he pretends : okay , well that went . What’s done is done , we are now living . The main thing is that there was no war. This is wrong.
– This is wrong , I agree.
– Crimean’s , this is wrong .
– There are things that can not be justified by the fact that as long as there was no war . Well , maybe a former employee ?
– Apparently, the former already . As I expressed my position and I ‘m not afraid of her . And let me prosecute. I do not do the crime and do not perform .
– You are officially retired , or you just left Kiev – and everything ?
– Officially, I do not dismiss . I , apparently , had already fired. So I understand that.
– Here in this as you .
– And give of his actions . Back there , I will not.
– And who now heads the Prosecutor’s Office ?
– Prosecutor’s Office of Ukraine , the Prosecutor General of Ukraine – it Mahnitsky . The fact that he was introduced to us as … he worked for two and a half years as an investigator in the prosecutor’s office in Lviv region , somewhere out areas. I do not know .
– That is, as a colleague you do not know ?
– No, I do not know him as a colleague . Here’s why … So be described as a man with whom she worked a certain period of time , I can not.
– Well, obviously .
– Well, he has not the Attorney General .
– He . about . ?
– He was acting . And by the way , again, for the first time as it is so in our country, it turns out, I do not know what is the legal field that Acting President shall appoint an Acting Attorney General . It somehow does not fit , too, especially in the legal field . Similarly , as a peaceful demonstration that killed our soldiers. When February 18 corpses fell one by one. And no one saw . And the power that now runs our country , they stood on the Maidan and screaming . The same minister , no, not the minister , chairman RNBU yes, chairman RNBU , his voice at me still rings in my ears .
– It’s you …
– He shouted very loudly : “left hundreds – right, right a hundred – to the left .”
– Chop ?
– Chop , chop , yes. This is also all heard .
– Well, yes, that is the head of the military part of the square. Yes, he really led here by these armed groups .
– He stood on the Maidan , and pointed out that’s what I heard, and pointed out how much is a hundred .
– Fighting .
– Yes, to fight ! How’s that? It is in the legal field ? Tell me, dear citizens , Ukrainians, Crimean people , what is the legal field? When killed, I repeat , I’m sorry , our soldiers were killed when the center of Kiev came with torches, torches . Ahead portrait of Stepan Bandera , beat beautiful hotels, which are located in the center of Kiev . And something happy . What joy , tell me? World turned upside down simply . This is not the Nazis ?
– Hello , please speak . Listening to you , call.
– Good evening. My name is Sergey. I have to Natalia a question. Natalia, you are ready to take the oath to serve the people of the Crimean Crimean people benefit ? And the second question . How you treat your fellow prosecutors and police Crimean who still has not given such an oath of allegiance to the Crimean people to him?
– Thanks for the question . I , you know, I want to express my gratitude to the Government of Crimea for the fact that they had the courage , patriotism and packed up , not left somewhere abroad , well, as many do – to get away from the country and live in peace with beautiful decor – and stood up for us, for the people. And here I saw that the hope that here, here, people seem to do well , people got up , people defend their point of view , well done , not traitors .
– But most importantly, the people rebelled against Nazism , which is now in rampant throughout Ukraine.
– In the revelry . You understand. This is not a power struggle , this is real Nazism . And to answer your question , thank you very much , I guess I think that’s an honor to take the oath of service to the protection and service of the Crimean people, with such leaders, with leaders such as these . Because that’s my word , they are great . I did not expect that our rulers … And to answer the second part of the question about the Crimean colleagues , prosecutors , you know , they probably would have cost to go to Kiev and see the glory of God, the hours can not be returned , but a little would they survived and pobyli in that situation and seeing when nobody hears you , when the world turns just flipped all the concepts , they can not do anything . People here , prosecutors , my colleagues , they have not experienced it. They are waiting , waiting for something.
– For them it is just a change of government.
– For them it is a change of power either, I do not know how to call it , or a scary movie on TV. Maybe someone does not understand me and support of my colleagues . Every point of view is the right place to be. But , nevertheless , my dear colleagues , you just as prosecutors are obliged to review all this , review all the subjects , it is all true , it’s life, this is not a movie .
– Natalia, I think, if ordinary citizens , Crimean’s , understand and see that it is really a specialist lawyer should it be more sharp-sighted vision and understand what was happening. Hello?
– Hello. Tell me, please , so many people are concerned about the citizens who are at the moment , for whatever reasons, in conclusion , if they can , if they Crimean’s , to vote in the referendum ? And in the future , on what legislation will be various legal proceedings ?
– Thanks for the question . Tomorrow will be a co-ordination meeting , likely to be . And I think that the concerned officials will take appropriate decisions about the legal and law on which the future we will live. I do not know for sure what laws we live . This will show all the referendum . This free will of our people, to which they are entitled. And what is now referred to us all on TV , our great politicians who came through blood and call us back to the Crimean people are calling for criminal liability and frighten , scare , that you have no right to free expression – do not believe . Citizens Crimean’s , you have every right to their free will. Usurp power , no one can .
– Natalia, tell me about that … to clarify the question the viewer . Society can not live in a vacuum legal means still valid now that the legal framework and the laws that exist. They still keep the society within certain . And how it will be reviewed – it’s like you said , will soon have , in fact , the future . Well, here , in particular, after the referendum . I understand . I apologize . We call.
– Hello. Natalia, I want to thank you. Because you are very brave . You came on TV, you’ve gone with your work, you threw everything in Kiev. Still, it’s too scary – and come here so declare their position. There still sit very big people and they have a very great opportunity as it is something you do.
– Got it.
– I want to thank you very much . You are a very good woman .
– Thank you.
– It’s still just words of encouragement . And they , of course …
– Thank you . I think it’s long , it is the cry of the soul. Good people, it’s wrong – what happened in Kiev. This is not a change of government , that, you know , I can not describe such terrible words , well , for me it was like this: when it is out of the ashes , from hell, from hell just got out demons, and there held their fights. It was so . Neither day nor night of rest was not. That night battle drums as the Indians know, constantly beating drums . I do not know what they were drinking , what they ate , but they did not get tired . I could not sleep at night . And other people who were in the center, the same. This battle drums .
– You live near the center ?
– Yes, I lived on Rybalsky . It’s not far . Nevertheless , if it is not … under the nose , it is not under the window I had. But I heard it . This endless fumes of these wheels , the rubber , black soot in the throat worth . These cries. Of course , they are free milk distributed in the Maidan , to remove harmful substances . Here is a change of government . These are the people to come now .
– Yes . Listen . Hello , you say .
– Hello . Hello I want to tell your guests to her eyes never driven , and that she was lying too much. As a psychologist present .
– And besides , you can say something else , what you do not like ? Hung up.
– Well, the person’s opinion , it is , a little , perhaps, takes a different view .
– Yes, of course .
– Well, it also has a right to exist .
– Well, I guess you’re right to say that many people would have revised his views on current events , if there have visited and seen. While many , not many , and those who adhere to the support of past events in Kiev, they believe that it was a bright evrorevolyutsiya . And here we are , Ukraine closer to Europe, to the European values . That think so. Therefore, here there are such opinions . You mentioned , Natalia, on that great work, which led prosecutors in these months . That this work will that be? Does anyone need it now ? It seems to me that no one will be nobody there to judge. It all goes to the archive at best, if not will be thrown .
– Well, I think , and the audience , and you’ve all seen the conversation , well, he himself name-calling Bellamy Muzychko .
– White Bellamy .
– Yes, Bellamy Bily as he spoke with prosecutors and with a gun to come to a meeting of the district of the city administration , the session.
Yes, we’ve all seen it .
– And too well on the Internet saw slogans and appeals Dmitry Yarosh , who we have a presidential candidate . Well, you know, they are not afraid . They are not afraid even that. Why, how can you then how can you call it? What responsibility do you say?
– Good. You Natalia, gave us , actually, Crimean’s food for thought for those who have not been there , but it’s only seen on television. But that was the point of view of Natalia Poklonskaya , employee , former employee of the General Prosecutor’s Office . Thank you came to us . Welcome .
– Thank you.
– Thank you , dear friends . Goodbye
Posted by: brian | Apr 4 2014 11:23 utc | 131
It has become obvious that “somebody” nearly desperately tries to outcast claims that the coup was done by CIA assets and agents on direct order of the State Department (97, 119). Especially he removes Parubij from the firing line, therefore lining him in a broad, generic accusation against “organizers of Maidan” tolerating right wing extremists.
And “somebody” is outright lying indeed. Yesterday again I indicated the interview to him in which Yakumenko took account of the disloyalties within SBU, its CIA- and “Pravy Sector” connections, while “somebody” claims, he did not and tries to insert the dogma of SBU being either loyal or not and nothing in between.
Therefore I cite this passage here:
Q: Is it true that Nalivaichenko allowed the CIA agents to work in the Security Service building?
AY: Yes, that?s true. He also handed personal files of his own employees over to the CIA agents to study. But their mission was interrupted by an armed coup. The Maidan does not appoint these people; rather, it?s the US that does it. It?s enough to look at the newly appointed officials: Parubiy, Gvozd, Nalyvaichenko are all people who followed somebody else?s orders, the orders of the US, not even Europe. They are directly linked to the American intelligence. They sought to delay the negotiations and prevent the incumbent president from striking a deal with Russia and Russia from helping to prop up the social and economic order in Ukraine. After that they were planning to depose the president and integrate Ukraine into Europe, using Russian money. Who was troubled by the victory of the EU and the pro-integration forces? Only the US. It was the only country concerned over a possible alliance of Europe, Russia and Ukraine.
They?d been doing it ever since Yushchenko was president, and we couldn?t get rid of them. Once we started to put pressure, they relocated to Poland, Latvia and Lithuania. The most interesting part is that many regional governments spent budget money to pay for the so-called vyshkoli, i.e. training camps for militants to fight with various types of weapons.
All the orders were given either by the US embassy or by Jan Tombinski, a Polish representative who worked in the EU mission in Kiev. Poland played an invaluable role in the coup. It has always dreamt of restoring its former power and the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth.
Ever since the Maidan kicked off, our security service registered a dramatic increase in diplomatic correspondence coming in to various Western embassies in Kiev. There is one more mystery. Straight after this influx of correspondence we saw some foreign money at the Maidan and in Kiev exchange bureaus: the new, re-designed US dollar bank notes.
Q: So they were bringing in cash?
AY: Yes. Poroshenko, Firtash, Pinchuk ? they all poured money into the Maidan. With all their assets in foreign banks, they found themselves trapped. So they had to follow orders from the West. All they were supposed to do was back the Maidan; otherwise they would have lost all their assets. They were thinking about their money rather than their own country. Unfortunately we couldn?t prevent the casualties, the people, mainly those who had come from the Western regions, were sent into the line of fire. The Maidan militants had left the barricades after the sniper fire started.
I can’t see but one inconsistency and one omission.
The inconsistency:
Poroshenko, Firtash, Pinchuk ? they all poured money into the Maidan. With all their assets in foreign banks, they found themselves trapped. So they had to follow orders from the West.
No. That is a typical conspiracy theory of a spook 🙂 In a divided society like in Ukraine it is fundamental, that an oligarch (and oligarch-affiliated politicians) have to play on all sides to come to the first ranks and stay there. That’s even a security prerequisite, a life-insurance. This is valid for Janukowitch as well!
The omission:
“Somebody” hinted at it in his dishonest way with the claim:
“Yakumenko has to explain how come the Ukrainian Security Service under his leadership could not prevent the takeover of the government by a small group of armed individuals.”
This actually was exhaustively done by Yakumenko, who reported, he couldn’t send in his men to uproot the sniper positions because they would have come under fire from all sides by Parubijs men, by the bulk of “Maidan self-defense” forces. So it was either a full-fledged live-fire clampdown or let it happen.
But Yakumenko does not tell, why he didn’t record and document all this and came up with it the right time. And he does not tell why “let it happen” became giving way to the coup. Because this was, that happened. Janukowich and Yakumenko fled and in a Mafia-like semi-state like the Ukraines this means breakdown of the top institutions.
Well, you can judge by the result: Janukowich and Yakumenko were taken out of Ukraine by the RF and also Yakumenko’s account of events and circumstances, that is now taken out of the equations by FM Lavrov.
And it was taken out of the equations before, by His Majesty himself, Vlad Putin, who at the big press-round answered the very same question, “Somebody” posed dishonestly, in a way that was not quite so dishonest:
“Well, I think it was a revolutionary situation.”
Then Putin listed a lot of conditions and circumstances that in his opinion (and quite plausible) made up for this “revolutionary situation” still holding on calling it a coup. This is the honest way to put things if you want to skirt telling all of it. And it allows the conclusion: There was a kind of concluded action (can it be put this way?) by Putin and the “Weimar Triangle” to handle it this way.
Of course this way the coup allowed some of the fish to break loose from the rods or at least they were given more thread, more room to manoeuvre, and of course the guys who pulled the strings tried to conceal their hands at best from each other. We know, the Crimea – Coup came as a surprise for the western actors.
Okay.
Now the narratives of the main actors tend to convene in a way that will serve as a more or less comfortable background for continuing the power-games within and outside Ukraine, because it avoids sharp confrontations and escalation at the expense of third class players and useful scapegoats within Ukraine.
It could be estimated, this will be good for masters and slaves, the latter heavily depending on the masters decisions about “war and peace” (it’s war all the times, but with changing intensity!). But this reasoning is flawed, because it implies, the masters making themselves dependent of what the slaves wish and think, and we know, this is not the case. It’s the other way round: We got a situation with most of the slaves nearly unconditionally siding with their masters and the limits of this loyalty pushed back to the point where it is about to live or to die. That gives the masters all the freedom to act they need.
On the other side we know, that of the roughly one dozen factions involved in the Ukraine power-play there is only one, that tries to escalate the situation towards war, let’s call it the “chaos – faction”, and those people know, they will fail. They are used by all the other factions in different ways and for them it is not about winning, but about keeping a most heavy hand in the hot spots. Perhaps at best with low intensity warfare within Ukraine and spilling over to Belarus, but this is speculation. But we know with certainty, that the convening narratives of the Institutskaya massacre partly hides and lessens the hand the US “Chaos Faction” had in it and covers their most active and prominent agents: Parubij and Yatseniuk. (It is even tried to make Klitchko a scapegoat (who very probable was informed, but not involved) to put him finally aside – as wished by Nuland!)
This is only one, but a fully sufficient reason to judge: No, sticking to this kind of narratives is absolutely detrimental to the slaves, to the Ukrainian people and especially to the seriously rebellious people of Maidan, who tried to stand up for their interests.
Also we can judge, “Somebody” acts in favour of the “Chaos Faction” even in case he believes acting in favour of one or two factions of the ruling masters of the RF.
So, if I was the master of this blog, I would ban him. Not because of his opinions and not because he might be paid for what he does, but for the methods and techniques he applies to influence the discourse, which under the given circumstances are impossible to overcome by inserting them in the discourse. This would require a teamwork of people equally skilled as him and with a similar amount of worktime to spend on it. This is unacceptable.
So, please, simply ignore him.
Posted by: TomGard | Apr 4 2014 14:38 utc | 135
|