To all of us some contemplative, hope- and peaceful holidays. May the walls come down.

Picture courtesy of the Bethlehem Association
Use as open thread …
|
|
|
|
Back to Main
|
||
|
December 24, 2013
Have Some Nice Days …
To all of us some contemplative, hope- and peaceful holidays. May the walls come down.
Use as open thread …
Comments
@ Parviziyi
Really? Your saying that some civilians in areas seized by ISIS, praise the group, while surrounded by ISIS goons? Tell me, what do you think would happen to those guys if they condemned ISIS in front of them. This is about as heavy handed as asking those abducted nuns if they are happy while surrounded by their kidnappers. Posted by: Colm O’ Toole | Dec 27 2013 14:23 utc | 101 I can’t read most of the recent posts as someone must have linked to a very long url… Posted by: crone | Dec 27 2013 14:37 utc | 102 I love this blog, but the format of the comments sucks big-time. Posted by: PhilK | Dec 27 2013 14:55 utc | 103 This is about as heavy handed as asking those abducted nuns if they are happy while surrounded by their kidnappers. Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Dec 27 2013 14:56 utc | 104 Had missed that the slimy george clooney support the rioters in Ukraine. Posted by: Anonymous | Dec 27 2013 15:17 utc | 105
Posted by: somebody | Dec 27 2013 16:02 utc | 106 @ Colm O’Toole #98, Hoarsewhisperer #101: You didn’t take the time to watch the video of the people being interviewed on the street in Aleppo. Here’s the link again: http://eaworldview.com/2013/10/syria-spotlight-winning-hearts-minds-aleppo-think-islamic-state-of-iraq/ . In the video interviews, the people speak in Arabic and subtitles are provided in Russian, but you don’t need to understand Arabic or Russian to be able to see from the visuals that the people are volunteering their own opinion in all good faith and sincerety. The context in which they’re interviewed is that they’ve voluntarily turned up for a religous-themed street event during Ramadan last August in Aleppo city. Also the particular interviewee who I quoted at #96 exudes Salafi-ism in all his appearances — he’s in the video from time 3:35 to 3:55. You are making a terrible mistake when you put him or any of the others into comparison with nuns. Weddings, funerals, they didn’t get that in the drone world it’s forbidden to move in a group? Posted by: Mina | Dec 27 2013 17:36 utc | 108 @ Colm O’Toole #98, Hoarsewhisperer #101: The Salafi-looking interviewee is in the video at time 3:26 to 3:53. As another item on the same lines of thought, there’s a Wahabbi-looking guy at time 1:05 who says: “May God bless the Mujahideen [armed rebels] who came to us from faraway lands, it doesn’t matter which lands, from Islamic countries, whether that’s Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, we are all brothers before Allah!” http://eaworldview.com/2013/10/syria-spotlight-winning-hearts-minds-aleppo-think-islamic-state-of-iraq/ . Video is also at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OBXe4soflVE . re 62. Gülen is a deep Turkish movement, difficult to handle for Erdogan, but not a puppet of the CIA. Posted by: alexno | Dec 27 2013 23:04 utc | 110 There are some interesting observations in this Guardian piece. Posted by: bevin | Dec 27 2013 23:23 utc | 111 Parviziyi @ 104. Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Dec 28 2013 4:00 utc | 112
There are many obvious reasons to assume Gulen is a puppet of the CIA, starting with a 2009 interview with Sibel Edmonds that contained the following exchange:
Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Dec 28 2013 6:24 utc | 113 The hostile takeover of the USSA by the Israeli 5th column is nearly complete. Posted by: john francis lee | Dec 28 2013 7:11 utc | 114 syrian Druze converted to wahhabism…new suicide bomber material? #subversion Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 7:29 utc | 115 the “rebels” have become “popular” with pro-Assad Syrians. Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 7:31 utc | 116 ‘it doesn’t matter which lands, from Islamic countries, whether that’s Jordan, Saudi Arabia, Iraq, we are all brothers before Allah!”…’ Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 7:33 utc | 117 Posted by: Parviziyi | Dec 27, 2013 8:27:50 AM | 96 Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 7:45 utc | 118 @96 Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 7:57 utc | 119 for 111 and the saudi preacher, just to reiterate, saudis dont allow preaching by non sunnis in their country, christians are beyond the pale let along anyone else Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 8:01 utc | 120 from Hands off Syria: Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 8:11 utc | 121 107 Alexno – yep. The US cultivate him though.
Talking about charter schools and Obama’s preference … Posted by: somebody | Dec 28 2013 8:54 utc | 122 are saudi men the problem? some may be the solution Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 8:57 utc | 123 Excuse me, somebody (#118), but your lengthy quote from Claire Berlinksi is a classic piece of manipulative bullshit. We are supposed to believe that because the author disparages the USA, she is “one of us” and can be trusted when she tells us that Gulen does not work for the CIA. And who is the author? “Sshe is a senior fellow for Turkey at the American Foreign Policy Council and a Manhattan Institute scholar.” Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Dec 28 2013 9:46 utc | 124 Come to think of it, the discussion in that Berlinski article of the Sledgehammer trials makes quite good sense: as I said, the evidence was forged or in many cases non-existent, but that doesn’t mean the Sledgehammer and the earlier Ergenekon conspiracies in the Army and the security services weren’t real. What it means is, just as Sibel Edmonds has explained at length in many posts and interviews, is this: up until a certain point, roughly marked by the Susurlik affair, the CIA had a classic Gladio type of operation, a “deep state” hard right coup apparatus within the Army and secret services that could take over in the event of a dangerous win at the polls by Left parties, and that in the meantime could stage false flag incidents to discredit the Left. This is the same Gladio pattern well-known across Europe. But, as Sibel explains, after that point in time the CIA phased out the old networks and moved to a new system, which she calls “Gladio II”, based on islamist networks. Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Dec 28 2013 10:35 utc | 125 The army ambushed and killed dozens of terrorists affiliated to Jabhet al-Nusra between the areas of Maaloula and al-Qastal. Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 11:25 utc | 126 This is the same Gladio pattern well-known across Europe. But, as Sibel explains, after that point in time the CIA phased out the old networks and moved to a new system, which she calls “Gladio II”, based on islamist networks. Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 11:28 utc | 127 Sibel’s most comprehensive expositions of the “Gladio II” theory are here and here. Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Dec 28 2013 11:42 utc | 128 Damnit, my reply went into the spam hole because it contained two links. These are the two major expositions Sibel gave of the Gladio 2 theory. Here they are separately: Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Dec 28 2013 11:45 utc | 129 Erdogan doesnt like protests or rebels in turkey!!!tho he supports them in syria Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 13:09 utc | 131 how to defeat takfiris Posted by: brian | Dec 28 2013 13:13 utc | 132 Hoarsewhisperer #109: The video shows that the rebel organization “Islamic State in Iraq and Syria” (“ISIS”) is NOT popular in Aleppo city. To repeat: the video was produced by ISIS; it consists of selected interviews with a half a dozen Aleppo city locals who are not members of ISIS; the interviewees express support for ISIS’s goals (yawn); two of the interviewees indicate that the ISIS rebels are predominantly non-Syrians (interesting). It implies that ISIS has not been able to recruit rebels among the locals in the neighborhoods in Aleppo that ISIS controls. re RB 113 etc
You are too much into conspiracy theory here. ‘In contact with’, ‘allied to’, ‘funded by’ is not the same as ‘puppet’. Gülen is a genuinely independently powerful organisation, which may be profiting from CIA support. But the CIA is not running the show. Gülen’s policies are not pseudo-American, very Turkish, rather. Posted by: alexno | Dec 28 2013 15:36 utc | 134 You presumably think that using the expression ‘conspiracy theory’ puts you into some sort of ‘adult’ category as a ‘thinker’, but actually you’re just being obtuse. You wind up with a meaningless claim about ‘national character’, always the last refuge before religion of the scoundrel, though you may just be a fool. My judgment about you and your train of thought is the same as my judgment about most of what everybody in the ‘official’ world says: they’re either fools or crooks, and so are you. Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Dec 28 2013 16:37 utc | 135 Alright then, here are some words from the wise:
Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Dec 29 2013 8:51 utc | 137 I suspect that all the prattle about ‘uniting’ the Syrian opposition jihadis is so extraordinarilly stupid that it’s probably true. It’s a 24 carat, solid gold way to guarantee that the SAA wins. Sorry I can’t explain why, but I’m convinced that US/NATO/Saudi’s military “geniuses” really are too fucking stupidly self-obsessed to figure it out for themselves. Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | Dec 30 2013 3:58 utc | 138 Well hope and peace and love or whatever. Happy Holidays and a Great New Year to all. Posted by: Noirette | Jan 1 2014 18:03 utc | 139 |
||