News & views …
|
|
|
|
Back to Main
|
||
|
November 13, 2013
Open Thread 2013-24
News & views …
Comments
#99… Posted by: PissedOffAmerican | Nov 18 2013 1:56 utc | 101 None of what I said regarding the difference between the Red Army and the Wehrmacht in 1941 is even remotly controversial amongst people that actually have studied those events. Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 2:19 utc | 103 “None of what I said regarding the difference between the Red Army and the Wehrmacht in 1941 is even remotly controversial amongst people that actually have studied those events.” Posted by: bevin | Nov 18 2013 3:10 utc | 104 Yes, how dare anyone contradict you. My bad. Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 3:23 utc | 105 Attempt to bring POA into the Godwinning. Advantage foff. Posted by: dh | Nov 18 2013 4:00 utc | 106 someone on guardian has been gloating on the *humanitarian* mission led by fukus , australia etc, in other words, the coalition of killing, while sniggering at china’s *miserable* performance. [*less than ikea*] Posted by: denk | Nov 18 2013 5:59 utc | 107 I don’t even understand what foff is trying to say. In some ways he sounds like what bevin would call a ‘eustonite’ (ie a left imperialist), when he talks about (by implication describes most of us) as ‘left fascists’. But the underlying issue is not a new one: anti-imperialists will to some extent waive their own leftist ideals when looking at rather right-nationalist regimes which are at least resisting imperialism. My own logic for this is as follows: a small to medium sized nation which wishes to remain independent, to choose its own allies, etc, is necessarily regarded as a nuisance by the empire, which therefore places it under siege. Its natural reaction is to withdraw into a posture of right-nationalism. It becomes especially hostile to leftists in its own midst or among its supporters, because it sees them as trying to weaken its internal nationalist solidarity, which it regards as absolutely essential given that it is under siege from considerably more powerful, imperialist countries, and also noting that the imperialists have a well-recorded track record of using leftists (whether real or pseudo) as agents of division and demoralisation. So what such a country is saying (and this is what Nasser was saying, so many years ago) is: put your class war doctrines away for the duration, fellas, we have a siege to contend with, which means we must all pull together until it’s over. Equally, it wants to neutralise its right-wingers, the domestic fascists and religious maniacs, for the duration of the siege, for the same reason. And all this is quite reasonable. So we should just face the fact that that is what we are doing, and stop engaging in mutual moral blackmail about it. Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Nov 18 2013 8:30 utc | 108 who’s pushing the sri lankans for a truth mission to investigate alleged war crimes in the civil war , Posted by: denk | Nov 18 2013 10:34 utc | 109 My comment about left fascists was directed at one individual. But “moral blackmail” is a good description of how certain people around here like to operate. Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 12:20 utc | 110 My comment specifically mentioned a lack of honesty and integrity. So “left fascist” applies to those that claim to be of the left and display those characteristics, like guest. Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 12:25 utc | 111 Instead of bouncing the accusation back and forth, why don’t you tell us what your political philosophy, your world-view, actually is, foff? And please don’t tell us anything about WW2, tell us what you think about world politics now. Tell us who or what you actually support, and why, just like I did, above. Then we’ll be able to see why, in fact, you are developing your various personal dislikes and disagreements. Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Nov 18 2013 12:31 utc | 112 Regarding left fascism : juannie earlier said I’ve often heard it stated that “we become what we hate the most” Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 12:39 utc | 113 “why, in fact, you are developing your various personal dislikes and disagreements.” Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 12:46 utc | 114 Both left and right claim moral superiority. My philosophy is “beware those that claim moral superiority” Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 13:05 utc | 115 All of that makes you sound somewhat like a troll. Your stated purpose is destructive: to criticise other individuals, for their “claims of moral superiority.” You don’t have anything positive to offer. There’s no-one on here calling themselves Godwinites; your jibe refers to Godwin’s Law of Nazi Analogies. An argument about the WW2 Eastern Front in which one side accuses the other of betraying Nazi sympathies (by overestimating the scale of Germany’s early successes), and the other side accuses the first side of ‘Godwinism’ as a result, is an argument maximally personalised and of minimal informational content. And that is precisely the kind of argument trolls love to perpetuate endlessly, thereby crowding items of real interest out of the thread and putting off as many readers and visitors as possible. So stop it. Because if there is a general agreement that a troll is all you are, our esteemed host will make you go away. Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Nov 18 2013 13:51 utc | 116 An argument about the WW2 Eastern Front in which one side accuses the other of betraying Nazi sympathies (by overestimating the scale of Germany’s early successes), and the other side accuses the first side of ‘Godwinism’ as a result, is an argument maximally personalised and of minimal informational content. Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 14:02 utc | 117 especially for dh – unless they are man-in-the-middle-ing you, SSL still works, apparently
Note that Gmail, which uses SSL by default, provides the NSA with much less data than Yahoo, which doesn’t, despite the fact that Gmail has many more users than Yahoo does. (It’s actually kind of amazing how small that Gmail number is.) This implies that, despite BULLRUN, encryption works. Ubiquitous use of SSL can foil NSA eavesdropping. This is the same lesson we learned from the NSA’s attempts to break Tor: encryption works. Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 17:33 utc | 119 Thank you foff. I always did see it mainly as a job creation program. Posted by: dh | Nov 18 2013 17:37 utc | 120 Congratulations to all Iranians, and especially to our Supreme Leader and all the centres of power and authority in Iran over their uncompromising stance over Iran’s inalienable rights:
I was thinking about the exact translation of “bending over”… Posted by: Pirouz_2 | Nov 18 2013 19:20 utc | 121 another one deleted by atimes Posted by: denk | Nov 20 2013 4:44 utc | 122 scamoron on humanity, puke puke Posted by: denk | Nov 21 2013 16:39 utc | 123 |
||