Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
November 13, 2013
Open Thread 2013-24

News & views …

Comments

#99…
I really gotta agree with guest77 on this one. Foff is so hmmmlike, ya just hafta wonder. Is someone cloning a certain style of internet obnoxiousness? Seems every blog gets at least one of these cookie cutter jackasses.

Posted by: PissedOffAmerican | Nov 18 2013 1:56 utc | 101

Drunk again, huh?

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 2:02 utc | 102

None of what I said regarding the difference between the Red Army and the Wehrmacht in 1941 is even remotly controversial amongst people that actually have studied those events.
None of what neretva43 said regarding Zhukov is controversial either -Zhukov himself said the same things about his tactics.
Guest just chooses to deliberatly misinterpret in the fashion he has done because he has decided that he might appear to “win” by being dishonest

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 2:19 utc | 103

“None of what I said regarding the difference between the Red Army and the Wehrmacht in 1941 is even remotly controversial amongst people that actually have studied those events.”
Excepting spelling,foff, in which you are constantly making new inventions, nobody could ever accuse you of originality.
It is fairly obvious, since you have nothing new to say, that you simply hover around these threads waiting for an opportunity to insult or contradict.
The real question is why generally sensible people, including myself, bother to respond to your attempts to hi-jack discussions and prevent the great majority of thoughtful, serious critics of imperialist policy from reasoning together.
My guess is that the hasbara community, which is far wider than that sponsored by Israel, has reached the conclusion that, with apologies to Mr Godwin, the best way to deal with reasoned discussion of official criminality is to employ a few drunken stormtroopers to shout out obscenities and threats in the hope that what happened to Craig Murray’s, once valuable, website will wreck this one too.
And that would be a pity, because, on a few occasions in the past few years “b” and his readers have helped expose some attempts to impose dangerous lies on the public.
For anyone familiar with vernacular English of the UK variety it is unnecessary to point out the probable motives of a person posting under the name of foff.

Posted by: bevin | Nov 18 2013 3:10 utc | 104

Yes, how dare anyone contradict you. My bad.
As for insults, both you and guest handed out quite a few on this thread alone merely cos one or 2 people dared to state uncontroversial things which you didn’t like, about some events in 1941. Rather than address what was said you chose instead you invented a nazi-strawman and attacked that instead.
You and guest certainly do very quickly resort to Godwining whenever you are at a loss for a reply to what people actually say, rather than what you and guest wish to pretend they said
Obscenities and threats? Like mr pissedoffamerican above.

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 3:23 utc | 105

Attempt to bring POA into the Godwinning. Advantage foff.

Posted by: dh | Nov 18 2013 4:00 utc | 106

someone on guardian has been gloating on the *humanitarian* mission led by fukus , australia etc, in other words, the coalition of killing, while sniggering at china’s *miserable* performance. [*less than ikea*]
most fukusans seem to forget , conveniently perhaps, ph is china’s rival in the scs provocations orchestrated by the muricuns.
somehow they expect the chinese to fall over themselves to outshine the ph’s big bro, with its aircraft carrier groups prowling in the viccinity 24×7 ?
besides, china did fork out about 2m donation, which was increased many folds after it got all these stinging attacks from the ever waiting western propaganda rags.
in contrast, when china was hit by monstrous floods n devastating earthquake in the past, which were 10000 times worst than the haiyan disaster, muricca’s contribution never exceeded 100k , think abou it !
eg, in the 1998 once in a century deluge, the muricuns contribution was a whopping 50k, no kidding !
murica reckons itself as the self appointed *human rights champion* for the chinese, never a day goes by without some muricun taking up the cudgel for some poor sods *persecuted* by the tyrannical ccp.
but where’s this guardian of the chinese people when they need him most ?
often its countries like germany, which never, well seldom, deign to lecture the chinese on *human rights*, that is most generous in coming to the chinese aid. !
but u’ll never hear the likes of gaurdian, atimes , never mind nyt etc, calling uncle out for its awol ,which is nothing less than obscene
anyway, after i pointed out the muricun hypocrisy in this latest *humanitarian* extravaganza, the guardianite snorted at such *irrelevancy*, he never forget for a min reminding me this is a fukusa[ustralia] led mission, *lets see who r the more humane one* !
meaning china is less *humane* than the coalition of killing !
i couldnt help reminding him, old chap, *supreme international crimes* is the very antithesis to humanity ! [1]
well what do u know, the next time i refresh that thread, i was greeted by this msg
*this comment is removed for contraventing forum ethics* [something like that]
ethics, what ethics ?
hehehe
[1]
http://www.us-uk-interventions.org/index_frames.html

Posted by: denk | Nov 18 2013 5:59 utc | 107

I don’t even understand what foff is trying to say. In some ways he sounds like what bevin would call a ‘eustonite’ (ie a left imperialist), when he talks about (by implication describes most of us) as ‘left fascists’. But the underlying issue is not a new one: anti-imperialists will to some extent waive their own leftist ideals when looking at rather right-nationalist regimes which are at least resisting imperialism. My own logic for this is as follows: a small to medium sized nation which wishes to remain independent, to choose its own allies, etc, is necessarily regarded as a nuisance by the empire, which therefore places it under siege. Its natural reaction is to withdraw into a posture of right-nationalism. It becomes especially hostile to leftists in its own midst or among its supporters, because it sees them as trying to weaken its internal nationalist solidarity, which it regards as absolutely essential given that it is under siege from considerably more powerful, imperialist countries, and also noting that the imperialists have a well-recorded track record of using leftists (whether real or pseudo) as agents of division and demoralisation. So what such a country is saying (and this is what Nasser was saying, so many years ago) is: put your class war doctrines away for the duration, fellas, we have a siege to contend with, which means we must all pull together until it’s over. Equally, it wants to neutralise its right-wingers, the domestic fascists and religious maniacs, for the duration of the siege, for the same reason. And all this is quite reasonable. So we should just face the fact that that is what we are doing, and stop engaging in mutual moral blackmail about it.

Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Nov 18 2013 8:30 utc | 108

who’s pushing the sri lankans for a truth mission to investigate alleged war crimes in the civil war ,
none other than war criminal cameron !

Posted by: denk | Nov 18 2013 10:34 utc | 109

My comment about left fascists was directed at one individual. But “moral blackmail” is a good description of how certain people around here like to operate.
Some leftists are very like religious types, they try to bully opponents by pretending that they and their ideas/words are morally superior, and by implication their opponent must by morally inferior.
Hence bevin’s and guest’s constant resort to Godwin as as substitute for an argument. These people are more hypocritical than Opus Dei Catholics, almost as zealous as Evangelicals.

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 12:20 utc | 110

My comment specifically mentioned a lack of honesty and integrity. So “left fascist” applies to those that claim to be of the left and display those characteristics, like guest.

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 12:25 utc | 111

Instead of bouncing the accusation back and forth, why don’t you tell us what your political philosophy, your world-view, actually is, foff? And please don’t tell us anything about WW2, tell us what you think about world politics now. Tell us who or what you actually support, and why, just like I did, above. Then we’ll be able to see why, in fact, you are developing your various personal dislikes and disagreements.

Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Nov 18 2013 12:31 utc | 112

Regarding left fascism : juannie earlier said I’ve often heard it stated that “we become what we hate the most”
I suspect guest crossed that threshold a long time ago

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 12:39 utc | 113

“why, in fact, you are developing your various personal dislikes and disagreements.”
It’s the Godwin-ites who have decided to escalte this into an argument. Problem with the sort of rapid/rabid “escalation of rhetoric” against perceived enemies that the Godwin-ites engage in is: after “nazi” where does one go next? “Paedophile”?

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 12:46 utc | 114

Both left and right claim moral superiority. My philosophy is “beware those that claim moral superiority”

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 13:05 utc | 115

All of that makes you sound somewhat like a troll. Your stated purpose is destructive: to criticise other individuals, for their “claims of moral superiority.” You don’t have anything positive to offer. There’s no-one on here calling themselves Godwinites; your jibe refers to Godwin’s Law of Nazi Analogies. An argument about the WW2 Eastern Front in which one side accuses the other of betraying Nazi sympathies (by overestimating the scale of Germany’s early successes), and the other side accuses the first side of ‘Godwinism’ as a result, is an argument maximally personalised and of minimal informational content. And that is precisely the kind of argument trolls love to perpetuate endlessly, thereby crowding items of real interest out of the thread and putting off as many readers and visitors as possible. So stop it. Because if there is a general agreement that a troll is all you are, our esteemed host will make you go away.

Posted by: Rowan Berkeley | Nov 18 2013 13:51 utc | 116

An argument about the WW2 Eastern Front in which one side accuses the other of betraying Nazi sympathies (by overestimating the scale of Germany’s early successes), and the other side accuses the first side of ‘Godwinism’ as a result, is an argument maximally personalised and of minimal informational content.
you should be directing your comments at those that decided to maximally personalise it in the first place. No one forced the Godwin-ites to start Godwin-ising. That was their decision in the first place.

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 14:02 utc | 117

foff showing signs of desperation. New topic needed.

Posted by: dh | Nov 18 2013 14:46 utc | 118

especially for dh – unless they are man-in-the-middle-ing you, SSL still works, apparently
NSA Harvesting Contact Lists
A new Snowden document shows that the NSA is harvesting contact lists — e-mail address books, IM buddy lists, etc. — from Google, Yahoo, Microsoft, Facebook, and others.
Unlike PRISM, this unnamed program collects the data from the Internet . This is similar to how the NSA identifies Tor users. They get direct access to the Internet backbone, either through secret agreements with companies like AT&T, or surreptitiously, by doing things like tapping undersea cables. Once they have the data, they have powerful packet inspectors — code names include TUMULT, TURBULENCE, and TURMOIL — that run a bunch of different identification and copying systems. One of them, code name unknown, searches for these contact lists and copies them. Google, Yahoo, Microsoft, etc., have no idea that this is happening, nor have they consented to their data being harvested in this way.
These contact lists provide the NSA with the same sort of broad surveillance that the Verizon (and others) phone-record “metadata” collection programs provide: information about who are our friends, lovers, confidants, associates. This is incredibly intimate information, all collected without any warrant or due process. Metadata equals surveillance; always remember that.
The quantities are interesting: During a single day last year, the NSA’s Special Source Operations branch collected:

  • 444,743 e-mail address books from Yahoo,
  • 105,068 from Hotmail,
  • 82,857 from Facebook,
  • 33,697 from Gmail and
  • 22,881 from unspecified other providers….

Note that Gmail, which uses SSL by default, provides the NSA with much less data than Yahoo, which doesn’t, despite the fact that Gmail has many more users than Yahoo does. (It’s actually kind of amazing how small that Gmail number is.) This implies that, despite BULLRUN, encryption works. Ubiquitous use of SSL can foil NSA eavesdropping. This is the same lesson we learned from the NSA’s attempts to break Tor: encryption works.
In response to this story, Yahoo has finally decided to enable SSL by default: by January 2014.

Posted by: foff | Nov 18 2013 17:33 utc | 119

Thank you foff. I always did see it mainly as a job creation program.

Posted by: dh | Nov 18 2013 17:37 utc | 120

Congratulations to all Iranians, and especially to our Supreme Leader and all the centres of power and authority in Iran over their uncompromising stance over Iran’s inalienable rights:

“In what could be a way around the main sticking point in negotiations between Tehran and the six world powers, Iran has stated that other nations need not recognize its right to enrich uranium. The statement was made by Iran’s foreign minister.“

I was thinking about the exact translation of “bending over”…

Posted by: Pirouz_2 | Nov 18 2013 19:20 utc | 121

another one deleted by atimes
for reasons best known to themselves, the bandit territory ukus [1] seem to harbor some kind of pathological hatred for the chinese.
their litany of crimes is legend, opium war, yuan ming yuang [2], mcmahon line, tam, tibet , xinjiang r just some of the biggies. yet they have never apologised for any this barbarities, like their soul mate japanese, they’r utterly unremorsful n continue to screw the chinese at every opportunity until this day.
let the author n his ilks understand this,
nothing is more aggravating when some hypocrite from the bandit territory wag their tongue to lecture china on rule of law n all that jazz.
[1] *fukus* is taboo on atimes.

Posted by: denk | Nov 20 2013 4:44 utc | 122

scamoron on humanity, puke puke
http://www.globalresearch.ca/uk-prime-minister-covers-up-crimes-against-humanity-lectures-sri-lanka-on-crimes-against-humanity/5358657
is there no escape from this fukus tyranny — one moment they send drones to wipe out a wedding process, the next moment we’ve to suffer their bs sermons !
its not only from politicos like scamoron, whose hypocrisy is a given, there’s an army of such critters from where they come.
their fav buzzwords…*international community*, *human rights*, *rule of law* !
the other day at atimes, this fukusan was commenting on china’s *dangerous manipulation of nationalism* in the disputes with ph, jp etc.
the rule of thumb for these blowhards says in any dispute, china is always wrong !
soon enough, before long the bloke went into a tirade, *china’s claim in scs is not acceptable to the *international community** !
i dont even bother to argue the merits of china’s claim, this gem from andre vitchek shut him up for good !
*I want the world to talk about whether those countries responsible for such horrors should even be allowed to be members of the international community* !!!
http://dissidentvoice.org/2013/05/it-is-not-china-that-should-be-feared-it-is-the-west-3/
buhahahah
p.s.
heavy censoring at atimes
one more thing, atimes n diplomat operates as a tag team

Posted by: denk | Nov 21 2013 16:39 utc | 123