Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
May 4, 2012
Chen Guangcheng And The Evangelical Anti-Abortion Movement

Peter Lee aka China Hand has a good piece with a lot of background on the Chen Guangcheng drama at ATOL. The local rabble rouser Chen had a good deal. He left from the U.S. embassy with a promise that he would be able to study at a place away from the local security apparatus that was bothering him and his family. He then suddenly changed his mind and asked for asylum for himself and his family in the United States.

At his blog Lee adds:

Looking at today’s shenanigans, and Chen’s metamorphosis from brave legal activist to handwringing exile in waiting, I have the distinct impression that people invested in the current freedom fighter vs. tyrant polarity prevailed on Chen to blow this deal up.

It wasn't the confused and frightened man's idea to change course. That definitely came from the outside.

The involvement and of China Aid, which is an evangelical ministry in Texas run by one Bob Fu, and the Chinese lawyer and member of the Chinese Christian Rights Defence Association Teng Biao point to the deep involvement of the right-wing evangelical anti-abortion movement in the United States. The movement has certainly no interest in calming the case down. It would rather burn Chen than miss this opportunity to hit against China as well as this administrations policies.

It was this Teng Biao who in a phone call convinced Chen Guangcheng to change his mind after he left the U.S. embassy and to then suddenly ask for asylum in the United States:

Teng Biao: Oh, it's Guangcheng! How are you? I haven't seen you in a few years now!

TB: Many netizens are out there at the hospital to meet you, but they must all have been blocked. If I were in Beijing, I'd probably be blocked from visiting you to. I'll try to find some way of meeting you. I heard you're going back to school to study, where will that be?

CGC: Yes, but I haven't decided where.

TB: Guangcheng, you absolutely must not do this. It's going to be very dangerous for you to stay on in China. Seriously.

CGC: [Silence]

TB: I heard one of the guards watching over you was detained, the one that helped you escape. Is this true?

CGC: Nobody helped me escape. I escaped by myself.

TB: I suggest you get back to the embassy ASAP.

CGC: That's not possible now.

TB: Is the embassy not allowing you back? Or is the Chinese government not allowing you back?

CGC: I…

TB: Guangcheng, even if you told the embassy you won't ever go back, there's still time for you to change your mind, and it would be totally understandable. Please reconsider this whole thing. You know — Kegui, Chen Hua and everyone at home is in a very dangerous situation. Pearl's been taken away. Even if you're not considering this for yourself, then at least for your family and for those that tried to help you, you should try to get back to the embassy and make your way to the US. If this thing hangs in the balance, it's going to be very dangerous for everyone. We understand that you don't want to leave that you want to stay behind and try to do something. But you need to understand that if you stay behind, there'll be nothing you can do. Even if you don't work on any sensitive case, life will be bad enough if you're trying to do your own thing, you'll meet obstacles everywhere. Some of our friends have faced harrassment even trying to run their own little business. You've done way too much for human rights in CHina, you've made too many sacrifices. We don't want you to sacrifice or give more of yourself. Please reconsider.

CGC: I understand.

To me this call is a manipulation of one rather naive mind by someone who has an interest in steering up more conflict.

There was a congressional meeting yesterday which was obviously planned to push the case:

The Capitol Hill hearing was set up by a commission formed to monitor China's human rights record. The Congressional-Executive Commission on China is led by two Republicans, Christopher Smith of New Jersey and Frank Wolf of Virginia.

Also testifying was Bob Fu, a Chinese-American pastor and rights activist who was in touch with Mr. Chen during his flight last week from his home.

Does the "in touch during his flight" and Teng Boao's mentioning of a bribed guard mean that the whole "flight" was organized by China Aid?

Christopher Smith of New Jersey is a radical anti-abortion legislator as is Frank Wolf. Chen's original cause was to fight against forced abortions in China which are in some cases still used by local administrations to implement China's one-child policy. (Is ist somewhat tronically that Chen has two children?)

At the congressional hearing China Aid boss Bob Fu phoned up Chen in his Beijing hospital at some 3:00 am local Beijing time. The phone was then held to a microphone so the whole committee could hear him:

In his telephone testimony to Washington, Chen wasn’t asked his opinion of American authorities’ actions. But he did say that he’d like to meet U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton, who is in Beijing for a previously scheduled high-level meeting on a variety of issues, and “thank her face to face.”

Apart from those evangelical folks who turned Chen's plans around to embarras the Obama administration the Chinese state will also like the current situation. To have the Obama administration under pressure during the current U.S.-China Strategic and Economic Dialogue will be helpful. China can now show a friendly public face by offering Chen to study abroad while quietly asking the Obama administration to pay a price to end the affair. "Do you really want to sell those F-16 fighters to Taiwan?"

Comments

I haven’t got my head around the full implications of this story, yet.
Fwiw, Lateline covered it from a couple of angles this evening including an interview with Fu, which was disrupted by a satellite glitch, causing the (delayed) 2nd half to be listed separately as Part 2.
http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/
I didn’t bother posting specific links to each story bcs it’s Friday and the Lateline home page won’t change until late Monday evening – 48 hrs or so.

Posted by: Hoarsewhisperer | May 4 2012 19:13 utc | 1

what Fu says here
http://www.abc.net.au/lateline/content/2012/s3496115.htm
all the activity being in China
is different from what he says here
http://www.texastribune.org/texas-politics/texas-political-news/help-from-midland-in-chinese-dissidents-escape/
i.e. him running a dissident network in China

Posted by: somebody | May 4 2012 20:03 utc | 2

so many dark points in the story of his detention and escape …
an hypothesis is that China Aid and others organized everything expecting a crisis between Us and China to automatically develop once they managed to bring Chen inside the Us embassy;
instead, Us and China found a reasonable compromise, which Chen was glad to adhere to (he didn’t want to leave China, at that moment);
so China Aid had to intervene again towards Chen, but the ploy had been foiled, and now everything looks so messy …

Posted by: claudio | May 4 2012 22:32 utc | 3

Teng Biao gives away the name of the enabler of the escape in his phone call to Chen … incredible!

Posted by: claudio | May 4 2012 22:34 utc | 4

This problem seems to be resolved — Chen will be going to NYU as a visiting scholar. The Chinese FM seems to have signed off on this.
But it has been a strange story. My conjecture is that those Christian fundies in Texas have been trying to embarrass the Obama administration and have been manipulating Chen to that end. This escape to the US embassy was probably coordinated to happen during Clinton’s visit for maximum exposure.

Posted by: ToivoS | May 4 2012 22:43 utc | 5

ToivoS @ 5
Righ on!

Posted by: Alexander | May 4 2012 22:49 utc | 6

bob fu’s chinaid is another ned funded destabilisation outfit
he organised a vast network of *underground churches* in china
now christianity n all other religions are legal in china
they wont lock u up for merely chanting christian bs
why’d chinaid set up these *underground* network, which is illegal, to
preach ?
the only reason i could think of is they use it as a conduit to spread
subversive anti commies *democrazy* propaganda, mixed in with their religious bs.
this would be difficult in government sanction churches, which is
probably monitored for such activities
like the ned funded flg cultists, tibet, xinjiang *activists*, they look up for every opportunity to undermine n embarrass china
one of their recent prank is sending in a priest to vandalise a hotel during the 2008 olympics
http://tinyurl.com/89k5sam

Posted by: denk | May 5 2012 3:53 utc | 7

alexanda
all these *ngo*s are beholden to the ned
which answer direct to the state dept
they wouldnt do anything to upset their paymaster
this is just the latest episode of fukus demonisation campaign imho
it follows a very familiar pattern by now
every time fukus send someone to beijing trying to pry more concession from ccp in financial or foreign policy
they would orchestrate such stunts to leverage on the chinese as bargain chips
if event appear to go out of hand
may be someone screwed up

Posted by: denk | May 5 2012 5:24 utc | 8

denk, the US is not a monolith
http://www.haaretz.com/news/diplomacy-defense/ehud-olmert-right-wing-americans-thwarted-israeli-palestinian-peace-accord-1.428324
“Olmert told Amanpour that he was working toward a peace agreement in 2008, knowing that this would mean handing over East Jerusalem to the Palestinians. “But I had to fight against superior powers, including millions and millions of dollars that were transferred from this country (the U.S.) by figures which were from the extreme right wing, that were aimed to topple me as Prime Minister of Israel. There is no question about it.”

Posted by: somebody | May 5 2012 7:53 utc | 9

A week after me the NYT gets to the gist of the story: Echoing Out of Texas, Chinese Voice of Dissent for Religious Freedom

His organization, ChinaAid, is at the crossroads of a growing movement among American Christians agitating for religious freedom in China and the wider dissident network inside the United States, as well as members of the underground church in China trying to practice their faith in a hostile environment.

But some critics say that Mr. Fu’s high-profile role as an advocate for religious freedom is a double-edged sword. It has raised awareness of human rights abuses. But his close association with Republicans and evangelical Christians, the critics say, risks stoking China’s fears that foreign forces are plotting to subvert the ruling Communist Party.
“Bob’s heart is in the right place, but sometimes in his zeal to bring attention to his cause he gets sucked up into the partisan maelstrom of Washington,” said one American human rights advocate who works closely with ChinaAid and spoke on the condition of anonymity because he did not want to offend Mr. Fu.

Posted by: b | May 13 2012 6:30 utc | 10