Moon of Alabama Brecht quote
January 6, 2012
Who Is This Faris al-Banna?

Joseph Fitsanakus of Intel News writes:

One of Mauridania’s leading daily newspapers, Al-Huriyeh, says that the spy ring, which allegedly consisted “businessmen and activists [from] several Arab nationalities”, was uncovered following the arrest of one of its members, identified as Fares al-Banna. A Jordanian citizen of Palestinian extraction, al-Banna was arrested for larceny, which eventually lead to a warrant issued for searching his premises. Upon searching his house, authorities reportedly found a handwritten letter, addressed to the Ambassador of the United Arab Emirates in Mauritanian capital Nouakchott, in which al-Banna claimed had been recruited by Israeli intelligence agency Mossad. In the letter, al-Banna also claimed that he had participated in the January 2010 assassination of Hamas weapons procurer Mahmoud al-Mabhouh in Dubai. The letter also alleges that al-Banna helped Mossad carry out a bombing of Ethiopian Airlines flight ET409, which blew up in mid-air on January 24, 2010, five minutes after taking off from Beirut’s Rafiq Hariri International Airport, en route to Addis Ababa. Al-Huriyeh reports that al-Banna’s letter suggests the Mossad blew up the plane in order to kill one or more Hezbollah targets who were on board.

There is a minor issue with that report in that the plane did not blew up. According to the Lebanese investigation progress report (pdf) from February 10, 2011 the plane did not "blew up" but ditched into the sea after some very unusual maneuvering.

The [flight] recorders data revealed that ET 409 encountered two stick shakers respectively at time 00:40:01 for a period of 29” and at 00:40:56 for a period of 26”. 10 “Bank Angle” warnings were registered between 00:38:41 and 00:40:54; an over-speed clacker was also registered from time 00:41:25 till the end. The maximum registered AOA was 32° at 00:40:14, maximum registered bank angle was 118° Left at 00:41:14, the maximum registered speed was 407.5 knots at 00:41:28, the maximum registered G load was 4.412 at 00:41:28 and the maximum registered nose down pitch value was 63.1° at 00:41:16.

There is no discernible reasons why the pilots might have made these maneuvers. So this may have been an accident in bad weather, sabotage on the plane or something else. The discussion of the incident at the Professional Pilot Rumor Network is inconclusive.

The plane crashed on 25 January 2010.

Moon of Alabama reader Juan Moment pointed me to three videos one Faris al-Banna uploaded to youtube shortly after the incident on February 14 2010 and February 19 2010.

The first one (53 views as of now) shows photos from two men in an office and then of one man standing in a harbor with probably oil installations in the background. He seems to looks quite similar to the one pictured along the Al-Huriyeh piece.

The second (16 views) just show the relevant man filming himself saying nothing with some Arabic background music. In the third video (32 views) the man talks quite earnestly into the camera in Arabic, then turns up some music, then talks again.

The youtube user Faris al-Banna has no other videos. Only those three he uploaded three weeks after the plane crash in Beirut. We do not know for sure if he is the same Faris al-Banna as the man in the Mauredania spy-case though judging from the newspaper picture it could be him.

Neither Juan nor I understand Arabic and we do not know what the man in the video says. It could be a message to a lover or something else. Maybe on of the readers here knows Arabic and will let us know?

Comments

Interesting –Israel spy network in Mauritania, the Emir of Qatar visiting there today, and this place seems a long way from anywhere, especially Israel and Qatar, over in west Africa fronting on the Atlantic Ocean.

Posted by: Don Bacon | Jan 6 2012 4:40 utc | 1

Thanks b for following this story. I am rather curious what he is saying in the videos he recorded weeks after the assassinations. He seems tense and for some reason I get the feeling he has indeed a heavy conscience.
On this web dating service Faris al-Banna states he would like: to be famous man ………. and to help other to have good life. Well, should the story check out he managed to reach his first goal.

Posted by: Juan Moment | Jan 6 2012 5:39 utc | 2

All this talk of blown up planes. The subject is an anathema to those who fly, but it gets old and perhaps is dead to some of us, but they keep it fresh, so the PTB catapult the fear given any change. It keeps resurrecting at auspicious times. I don’t know who Faris al-Banna, is, maybe he’s every man, but I know who this is…
Bragg soldier stopped twice for ordnance in luggage:

A Fort Bragg soldier charged with having explosives in his carry-on luggage at a Texas airport was stopped earlier at Fayetteville Regional Airport when security screeners found a military grenade in his bag, according to the FBI.
Trey Scott Atwater, 30, was stopped at security at the Midland International Airport in Texas on Saturday after a Transportation Security Administration officer spotted a suspicious item in a carry-on bag during X-ray screening.
According to an FBI affidavit in the case, the material was C-4 plastic explosive. Officers found no detonator, meaning there was no way to ignite the explosive.
Atwater flew out of Fayetteville on Christmas Eve, and security there detained him after finding a military smoke grenade in the bag, the FBI affidavit states. TSA agents in Fayetteville didn’t see any C-4 in the bag at the time, according to the affidavit, and they allowed Atwater to continue on the flight to Midland after confiscating the grenade and admonishing him.

He is America.
when was the last time you were allowed to fly after having plastic explosives material and a grenade confiscated? and being “admonished”? hahahahaha…uh, hahahahaha..
It’s not the hysterical laughter and simultaneous tears that bother me, it’s my inability to stop.
Meanwhile:
TSA Admin John Pistole said on Today Show this morning that “Children 12 and under are not going to undergo the ‘enhanced pat down’,” but in Charlotte a 6-year-old was patted down in tears, and dad was admonished against comforting his kid.

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Jan 6 2012 5:53 utc | 3

More to the topic…
Faris al-Banna’s vids are gone

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Jan 6 2012 6:35 utc | 4

@Uncle – not so

Posted by: b | Jan 6 2012 7:32 utc | 5

Whew, but just in case, as it would have not surprised me at all if the vids would have been pulled, I have downloaded them.

Posted by: Juan Moment | Jan 6 2012 8:06 utc | 6

B – You need to recruit some Arabic speakers, or rather a number of them, from different areas. Your digging is deep, and you need to understand what you might find. Arabic is no more ‘a’ language than Latin, Portuguese and Romanian are ‘a’ language. Even the high register MSA might need interpretation, in these contexts.

Posted by: Anonymous | Jan 6 2012 8:54 utc | 7

@3 this was no simple GI this was a person from the 7 Special Forces Group, Task Force 373.
This is a good follow up on this site
Trey Scott Atwater – 7th Special Forces Group, El Salvadorian Death Squads, and Task Force 373

Posted by: hans | Jan 6 2012 9:51 utc | 8

Weird, sorry guys…

Posted by: Uncle $cam | Jan 6 2012 9:59 utc | 9

schticky names sound funny when repeated in serious reporting. “Moon of Alabama reader Juan Moment pointed me to three videos…” Interesting story certainly, it will be interesting to bookmark this in the ole memory hole.

Posted by: scottindallas | Jan 6 2012 14:38 utc | 10

My Magrebi Arabic expert should be back in a week. If you need translation help. That said, this isn’t her bailiwick–she’s not into politics at all. So, she won’t be rushing to translate, but give a day and she could turn it around for you.

Posted by: scottindallas | Jan 6 2012 14:45 utc | 11

I am a native Arabic speaker. There is no information content in those youtube vids. I can confirm b’s conjecture; the only video were this chap talks amounts to a lame message apologizing to an unnamed lover who had evidently dumped him and reaffirming his love. My sense is that the person in those videos simply shares the same name, which is not exactly unique, as the person identified in the report from IntelNews.

Posted by: Arab-AmericaninOhio | Jan 6 2012 15:43 utc | 12

Fares (Faris, Fars, etc.) al Banna (Al-Banna, al Bana, Albanna, etc.) is an extremely common name, comparable in a way in the W to John Robertson, William Smith, Charles Jones.
The US (and the EU poodle) deliberately mix up Arabic names, with multiple ppl matching some ‘terrorist’ garbled name. So 3 year olds can’t step on planes because of ‘security.’ An easy way to intimidate, punish, control, dominate, frighten.
The upshot is that is very difficult to identify one particular person.
The confusion is also responsible for the 9/11 terrorists are still alive story – all except one are homonyms of one sort or another. The PTB encourage the muddle, and I imagine, sit and laugh.

Posted by: Noirette | Jan 6 2012 16:50 utc | 13

Letter to his love that he left because she deserves better than him, he also asks her to forgive him. and then the song starts.
the song is a love song and very emotional.
he end by saying, he hope this message reaches her. he hopes she is happy.,, and theen he directly addresses her: “take care of yourself”.

Posted by: Haki | Jan 6 2012 18:34 utc | 14

Thanks for that Haki and Arab-AmericaninOhio, appreciated.

Posted by: Juan Moment | Jan 7 2012 5:52 utc | 15

@Arab-AmericaninOhio @Haki
Thanks to both of you.

Posted by: b | Jan 7 2012 8:12 utc | 16

the photo used in the article does resemble the guy in the videos. the letter doesn’t make sense tho. who writes a letter identifying himself as working for the mossad and carrying out assassinations? no sense.

Posted by: annie | Jan 7 2012 21:19 utc | 17